ML20212J238
| ML20212J238 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Hatch  |
| Issue date: | 05/31/1986 |
| From: | BECHTEL GROUP, INC. |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20212J149 | List: |
| References | |
| TAC-11158, NUDOCS 8701280113 | |
| Download: ML20212J238 (125) | |
Text
'
- -N..
. ,,._ 4 ~_ 3 ENCLOSURE 1 -
u;. : ..- ,-s...., .- c,,
.~ **
N
" 'UN 3 ,
' .(
. y:. s.
. 20 986_ 1 NMEAR SAf((ypyg g;ggffg .
- E. l. HATCH -
n NUCLE R POWER PLANT '
I UNITS 1 AND 2
- GeorgiaPower A , ,
l_ <~ ~~m aywa.m _
REPORT ON SETTLEMENT OF MAJOR PLANT STRUCTURES g FOR -
GEORGIA POWER COMPANY l SOUTHERN COMPANY SERVICES BY -
! BECHTEL POWER CORPORATION GAITHERSBURG, MARYLAND E' -
- .= u b 4
,- c. r, ;@c:
., f, , s 3 , ., ., ,
l .' ' ,
,',.Y' ' -
- 1 --
g= - , g 4 9
( " #
.#$ k 6 g f w fg .- -s .
. 2 .,. , Y. . : . , ' _., ~ l 5 . ,. c . . ,, .
. , y,,. , . . . MAY 1986 'f. ..
~-
- x. , , .
, I, 4 's '[ y * ' Vd N '
'q.,.'- g; ? n,k ) 7 , (. ,,
. g' , g*j a, [. , .
T .: 3 s
.3 '
. / . .' g.. x,,. , , ; ,. < --
.x w w M % ' . ..
,g8%c.
- , , ..f ~. i ,.,
B+*[e . *
. .- 't.
..y p ,. ,~,
( [,);,;'E'[. *
', - . .(,.I'/.h.\ . h:[ $ I' . ' ? ' .* U .
., . :,. ~p m .
, . w . .g e..vc .
~ : . . thi- le-
.0_ ?g 5 ' , ;;*4 , , y,,:* [^l. l
'. n
'.c i,'l.e.{.' \ . h,. s.$ h,'**7 -
- Q:7;
,, ,.,: s. ,
~
, , := *
.. --g -
.g - ,
r .. .
j ..
.E_ .f,:2 j~~- a . a - ..t , J .~s-_ ....._.. ..___ :-....-___.._,_
~
- k. .
1 E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR POWER PLANT
, UNITS 1 AND 2
?
REPORTONSETiLEMENTOF MAJOR PLANT STRUCTURES FOR
. GEORGIA POWER COMPANY n.
SOUTHERN COMPANY SERVICES
.1
". BY BECHTEL POWER CORPORATION GAITHERSBURG, MARYLAND W
. 1
.~ .
TABLE OF CONTENTS
~ '
PAGE
- 1. 0 INTRODUCTION AND SCOPE 1
- 2. 0 PREDICTED SETTLEMENT 2 3.0 SETTLEMENT MONITORING DATA 3 4.0 TOTAL SETTLEMENT 3
- 5. 0 DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENT ACROSS STRUCTURES (TILT) 5
- 6. 0 PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENT 7
- 7. 0 FREQUENCY OF READINGS 8
- 8. 0 ACCURACY OF READINGS 9
- 9. 0 TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION 3/4.7.8 10
10.0 CONCLUSION
S AND RECOMMENDATIONS 12 REFERENCES 15 I
4 6
h y
I
TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued)
TABLES t
TABLE 1: PREDICTED AND MEASURED TOTAL SETTLEMENTS TABLE 2:
SUMMARY
OF DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS ACROSS STRUCTURES TABLE 3:
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND SOIL
- - TABLE 4:
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS
- DIESEL GENERATOR BUILDING AND SOIL
. TABLE 5:
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS MAIN STACK AND SOIL TABLE 6:
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS INTAKE STRUCTURE AND SOIL 6
TABLE 7:
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS e
REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND RADWASTE BUILDING HNP-2 TABLE 8:
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND CONTROL BUILDING
, TABLE 9:
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND TURBINE BUILDING HNP-2 TABLE 10:
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND REACTOR BUILDING HNP-1 b
o
).
b e
b r
, 11 '
t
s- .
e.
TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued)
FIGURES -
> F5GURE 1: POWER BLOCK BENCHMARK AND PENETRATION LOCATIONS FIGURE 2: BENCHMARK AND PENETRATION LOCATIONS FOR OFFGAS STACK, 3 INTAKE STRUCTURE AND DIESEL GENERATOR BUILDING s FIGURE 3: REACTOR BUILDING UNIT 1 BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 4: REACTOR BUILDING UNIT 2 BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 5: RADWASTE BUILDING UNIT 1 BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 6: RADWASTE BUILDING UNIT 2 BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 7: TURBINE BUILDING UNIT 1 BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 8: TURBINE BUILDING UNIT 2 BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT
> FIGURE 9: O CONTR'L BUILDING BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 10: DIESEL GENERATOR BUILDING BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT .
FIGURE 11: INTAKE STRUCTURE BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT l
FIGURE 12: OFFGAS (MAIN) STACK BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT i
FIGURE 13: REFERENCE BENCHMARK LOCATIONS 4
e e
(
iii L
L
+
~.: ............-.w.~........- ,- -
..w.....-.....,
TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued)
- f. .
( APPENDICES APPENDIX A: TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION 3/4.7.8, SETTLEMENT OF CLASS 1 STRUCTURES 3 APPENDIX B: SETTLEMENT DATA - REACTOR BUILDING UNITS 1 AND 2 APPENDIX C: SETTLEMENT DATA - RADWASTE BUILDING UNITS 1 AND 2 2
APPENDIX D: SETTLEMENT DATA - TURBINE BUILDING UNITS 1 AND 2 APPENDIX E: SETTLEMENT DATA - CONTROL BUILDING AND DIESEL GENERATOR
. BUILDING APPENDIX F: SETTLEMENT DATA - INTAKE 6TRUCTURE AND OFFGAS (MAIN)
STACK O
l-
. 4 4
4 6
i
( ,
I iv r
..m_.,. .~.......~..._.
h" k$ d-EXECUTIVE
SUMMARY
~
i All available information and measurement dat.a on the iled, and toring of E. I. Hatch Nuclear Power Plant structures were com the data plotted and analyzed.
dies r re the Final Safety Analysis Report, and previous related stu reviewed as part of this comprehensive study.
d P,
The results show that the butidin.g settlements l have The essentially sto several years ago, and are all below the predicted maximum Based on va ues.
p dif ferential settlements are also below the allowable limits.for the past the conclusion of no significant building settlement i tion 3/4.7.8 years, it is recommended that the current The outlineTechnical contained Specif ca be replaced with a Plant Operating Procedure. this recommended within this report is intended to serve as a basis for I
' change.
3 s
F h.
e O
.i 1
l.
. f
' . ' ' l.
,4 f '.
,l
. {
. nry,, ,.
.< , .r , u: ;> .
- - - - r .- ~. .. ,
l I
~
l l 1.0 IgTRODUCTIONANDSCOPE I
~
As(requiredbyTechnicalSpecification3/4.7.8, entitled l
" Settlement of Class 1 Structures," Georgia Power Company (GPC) is committed to monitor total and differential settlements of I
all Class 1 structures'at E. I. Hatch Nuclear Plant Unit 2 (HNP-2). The technical specification was issued in 1978 and l has included the monitoring of not only the Unit 2 Class 1 structures but other major plant structures. The structures included are listed below:
o Reactor Building, Units 1 and 2 l
o Turbine Building, Units 1 and 2 l
0 Radwaste Building, Units 1 and 2 j -
o Control Building *
\ -
L o Olesel Generator Butiding o Intake Structure i
o Offgas (Main) Stack The technical specification, which is included as Appendix A, outlines the monitoring and the resulting potential action requirements for the Class 1 structures.
The major structures at Plant Hatch were constructed in the l early to mid-1970's, with commercial operation for Unit 1 and Unit 2 being December 1975 and September 1979, respectively.
Since the start of commercial operation, the measured settle-ments of all structures have stabilized to nearly constant I values. In light of this, the purpose of this report is to perform a comprehensive review of the technical specification 1
i
'E E
EXECUTIVE
SUMMARY
i t-All available information and measurement data on the settlement moni-toring of E. I. Hatch Nuclear Power Plant structures were compiled, and the data plotted and analyzed. .The applicable Technical Specif.ication, the Final Safety Analysis Report, and previous related studies were reviewed as part of this comprehensive study.
8 The results show that the building settlements have essentially stopped several years ago, and are all below the predicted maximum values. The I differential settlements are also below.the allowable limits. Based on the conclusion of no significant building settlement for the past several t years, it is recommended that the current Technical Specification 3/4.7.8 be replaced with a Plant Operating Procedure. The outline contained within this report is intended to serve as a basis for this recommended change.
8 .
8 I
i l
I I
l I
5 E
TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued) l APPENDICES APPENDIX A:
E TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION 3/4.7.8, SETTLEMENT OF CLASS 1 STRUCTURES APPENDIX B:
SETTLEMENT DATA - REACTOR BUILDING UNITS 1 AND 2 APPENDIX C:
SETTLEMENT DATA - RADWASTE BUILDING UNITS 1 AND 2 APPENDIX D:
SETTLEMENT DATA - TURBINE BUILDING UNITS 1 AND 2 APPENDIX E:
SETTLEMENT BUILDING DATA - CONTROL BUILDING AND DIESEL GENERATOR APPENDIX F:
SETTLEMENT DATA - INTAKE STRUCTURE AND OFFGAS (MAIN)
STACK I
I i I
I I
1 l
1 fv
8 TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued)
~
FIGURES FIGURE 1:
POWER BLOCK BENCHMARK AND PENETRATION LOCATIONS FIGURE 2:
BENCHMARK AND PENETRATION LOCATIONS FOR OFFGAS STACK, INTAKE STRUCTURE AND DIESEL GENERATOR BUILDING FIGURE 3:
REACTOR BUILDING UNIT 1 BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 4:
REACTOR BUILDING UNIT 2 BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 5:
RADWASTE BUILDING UNIT 1 BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 6:
RADWASTE BUILDING UNIT 2 BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 7:
TURBINE BUILDING UNIT 1 BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 8:
TURBINE BUILDING UNIT 2 BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 9: CONTROL BUILDING BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 10: DIESEL GENERATOR BUILDING BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 11: INTAKE STRUCTURE BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 12: OFFGAS (MAIN) STACK BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 13: REFERENCE BENCHMARK LOCATIONS I .
1 I
t fff I
f fI i 5 ,
TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued)
TABLES TABLE 1: PREDICTED AND MEASURED TOTAL SETTLEMENTS TABLE 2:
SUMMARY
OF DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS ACROSS STRUCTURES TABLE 3:
E
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND SOIL TABLE 4:
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS I DIESEL GENERATOR BUILDING AND SOIL TABLE 5:
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION. DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS MAIN STACK AND SOIL TABLE 6:
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS INTAKE STRUCTURE AND SOIL TABLE 7:
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND RADWASTE BUILDING HNP-2 TABLE 8:
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND CONTROL BUILDING TABLE 9:
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND TURBINE BUILDING HNP-2 -
TABLE 10:
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND REACTOR BUILDING HNP-1 8
I E .
E 8 '
E 11 1
g -a 4
E I
TABLE OF CONTENTS k PAGE
1.0 INTRODUCTION
AND SCOPE 1
- 2. 0 PREDICTED SETTLEMENT .
2 3.0 SETTLEMENT MONITORING DATA' 3
4.0 TOTAL SETTLEMENT 3
S.0 DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENT ACROSS STRUCTURES (TILT) S 6.0 PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENT 7
- 7. 0 FREQUENCY OF READINGS . 8 8.0 ACCURACY OF READINGS 9
9.0 TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION 3/4.7.8 10
10.0 CONCLUSION
S AND RECOMMENDATIONS 12 REFERENCES 15 I
I l -
E l
i
, ,. 4 5 4 -: Q4J50-.. ' -
. ~ . . ,
l E
I E
- f. ~
il l
l E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR POWER PLANT UNITS 1 AND 2 5
E -
REPORT ON SETTLEMENT OF I MAJOR PLANT STRUCTURES I FOR
. GEORGIA POWER COMPANY SOUTHERN COMPANY SERVICES BY BECHTEL POWER CORPORATION GAITHERSBURG, MARYLAND E l 5 MAY 1986 5
5
.E _ . .
-a-
... . . . . . . . . .. .. d4 : ' -
..~. . .
[ ,in conjunction with the settlement measurements recorded to r
jateforeachstructure. In addition, it will be deterteined if thanges can be made to Technical Specification 3/4.7.8, while continuing to assure that plant safety and operations are maintained. The following items will be addressed:
r.-
o Total Settlement o
Differential Settlement Across Structures (Tilt) o Penetration Differential Settlement (Between adjacent structures and between structures and soil) o Frequency of R6adings o Accuracy of Readings '
o Technical Specification 3/4.7.8 l 2.0 PREDICTED SETTLEMENT Settlement predictions were made for the structures under con-sideration. Generally, the prediction util'ized stress values calculated in accordance with the Westergaard theory and considered stress overlap from all nearby founbations. Struc-tural dead loads plus live loads were considered in the stress calculation. The soil compressibility characteristics were
( cetermined by one-dimensional laboratory consolidation tests.
't Details of the settlement estimate are given in the Final p Safety Analysis Report (FSAR) Section PA.5.3, Reference 1.
li Table 1 presents the predicted total settlement for each structure under consideration.
4 1
g.
l 2
S
- 3. 0 SETTLEMENT MONITORING DATA
{ p I
i
, fheconclusionsandrecommendatio'nsofthisreportarebasedon lettlement monitoring data supplied by GPC and information contained in the FSAR Section 2A.5.3. In most cases, information
( from these two sources provides a complete record of settlement for each structure, except for the following:
I e
o Reactor Building Unit 2 li and 1974 no data was available for 1973 r>
o Turbine Building Unit 1 - no data was available for 1972 and 1974 o
Control Building - no data was available for 1972 o
Diesel Generator Building - no zero readings were available for the NE and NW benchmarks o Radwaste Building Unit 1 no data was available for 1972 s
o Intake Structure no data was available prior to mid-1978 A
In all cases, however, sufficient information is available to
[. determine settlement trends and maximum settlement for each p
structure and to determine what future course of action is
,, required.
>>+
4.0 TOTAL SETTLEMENT 1
Measurements of structure movements w: e, in most cases, made h
once each month during construction and have been made twice a 9
year since each structure has been completed. The measurements 7 are currently being made on four settlement benchmarks established g
on each structure, except for the Offgas (Main) Stack where there are only three benchmarks. Figure 1 shows the relative
?
i
% 3 N
y--
I locations of each benchmark on the power block structures, r
' --while Figure 2 shows the relative locations of each benchmark k
- .for the Offgas (Main) Stack, Diesel Generator Building r.d lIntake Structure.
8 The tabulated total settlements for each structure are given in ,
Appendices B through F. The values were determined by subtrac-ting the survey reading for a given date from the total set-q 6;
tlement reference elevation established near the start of construction. However, in some cases (generally prior to 1975), only the measured settlements were provided in the supplied data. Further, where tabulated survey data were not
( available, settlement figures from the FSAR were used to 1
I
{ estimate the movement of a particular benchmark.
rr Several assumptions and adjustments to the reference elevations l L
were made in order to determine the actual benchmark movement.
For example, referring to Appendix B, the reference elevation f
I for the southwest marker of the Reactor Building Unit 2 was
' 130.002 feet. On January 15, 1980, the survey reading indi-cated the southwest marker had settled a total of 1.884 inches (0.157 feet) since the beginning of settlement monitoring. On the same day, a new settlement benchmark was established. The surveyed elevation of 129.859 feet for the replacement bench-s mark was adjusted to 130.016 feet (129.859 + 0,.157) to account j for the. settlement which had already taken place.
Subsequent
' readings were then compared directly to the new established
' reference elevation of 130.016 feet. Details of these assump-tions and adjustments are given in Appendices B through F.
Settlement versus time curves for each structure, prepared from the data contained in Appendices B through F, are presented as Figures 3 through 12.
Common vertical and horizontal scales were used for each plot for ease of ccmparison of relative amounts of movement with respect to time.
4 .
4,I The ratios of the measured settlements (both historical maximum
~and as of July 1985) to the predicted settlements are shown in Table 1. The ratios are highest'at the Unit 1 Reactor and Turbine Buildings and the Control Building. All three of these structures were completed during the early construction stages ,
at riant Hatch. The ratios for the Unit 2 structures are lower -
due to higher predicted Unit 2 settlements, and because Unit I structures partially prestressed or preloaded the soil beneath f*, the Unit 2 structures prior to the start of Unit 2 construction and settlement monitoring.
As shown on Figures 3 through 12, the settlement curves have flattened out, indicating th5t no measureable settlement of any structure has occurred for at least the last seven years. It is believed that the slight cyclic movements taking place are due to the inherent variations associated with optical survey, including seasonal variation with temperature. These curves demonstrate that the structures have essentially completed
- 1. .
their settlements, and that the measured settlement values will not reach the predicted values. -
5.0 DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENT ACROSS STRUCTURES (TILT) -
Differential settlement across buildings will only be con-s.
sidered for those structures referenced in theiE. I. Hatch Nuclear Plant Unit 2 (HNP-2) FSAR, Section 2A.S.3.2. Those structures are:
o Reactor Building Unit 2 o Radwaste Building Unit 2 o Turbine Building Unit 2 o Control Building l
b 5
z ..~. _ J
-- - - - - ~
F -
i r o Diesel Generator Building i
- k. .
g Offgas (Main) Stack i r :
a, o Intake Structure PW a Details of the criteria used to establish the allowable differ-ential settlement across each structure are not discussed here.
? but can be found in FSAR Section 2A.5.3.2.1, and in Reference 2.
ry To determine the actual differential settlements, tilt reference
[. elevations have been established for the settlement benchmarks
, , in each building. The term 'Itilt reference elevation" used here is the elevation which can be compared with current survey elevation readings to indicate the existing degree of differential f settlement across the structure. These tilt reference elevations 3*
are based on the survey readings taken at or near the construction 7 completion date of each buf1 ding. This date corresponds to the L time when the structure is assumed to be properly aligned, both with respect to itself and to any adjacent building. ' Existing
(, differential settlement across the structure will be measured from this reference date and compared with the allowable h
sr values.
['d Using the tilt reference elevations and the latest survey values, the settlement of each benchmark from the reference 3 date to the present time can be determined. A comparison of the settlement values of any two benchmarks within a building provides the differential settlement or tilt between the k
benchmarks.
A comparison of the existing and allowable differential settle-ments is shown in Table 2, along with the reference date (approximate completion date of each structure). The results indica ~te that there has been little differential settlement to date and that the existing tilt is well below the allowable.
6
=
l l
- urther, by examining the settlement u rves (Figures 3 through 2), it is apparent the differential settlement across all B '
tructures will not significantly change in the future, as each structure has reached an equilibrium point and no additional measureable movement is expected.
6.0 PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENT Penetration differential settlements for those structures 5 referenced in the FSAR Section 2A.S.3.3, will be considered here. The structures considered are the same as listed in I Section 5.0. The only exceptions are the penetrations between ,
each Reactor Building, which will also be addressed. I Details of the criteria used to establish the allowable differ-ential settlement for the penetrations are not discussed,here, but can be found in FSAR Section 2A.5.3.3.1 and in Reference 2.
I Differential settlements of the penetrations since installation were measured by assuming the settlement of the penetration to be the same as the settlement of the nearest benchmark. For each penetration exiting from the structure into the scoil, reference was made to the appropriate value of settlement given l
in Appendices B through F. This value of settlement was compared to the latest (July 1985) movement of' the benchmark
, (either up or down), which had occurred since the date of pene-tration completion. If no reading was taken for a benchmark cn the completion date, then the previous reading was used as the I reference value. It should be noted that the maximum movement is not necessarily the movement that occurred between the penetration completion date and the present reading. This is ,
l because the settlement pattern of all of the benchmarks is, at
, present, nearly level, with dips and peaks due to inherent I
survey error and thermal expansion and contraction of the structures. As a result, the maximum settlement frequently occurs in one of the dips measured prior to the present readings.
7 B
f For penetrations passing between adjacent structures, the pettlementofthebenchmarksclosesttothepenetrationonboth structures must be considered. The settlement values of the two benchmarks from the penetration installation date to present are compared to the latest (July 1985) mcvement. A review indicates that maximum differential settlement does not necessarily occur on the most recent date for the reasons stated in the previous paragraph.
{*?
The ratios of the maximum measured settlement to the allowable rv settlement for the penetrations have been calculated and are 6.
presented in Tables 3 through 10. These tables show that all
^
of the measured settlements are presently well below the allowable values, with the large majority being less than n 20 percent of the allowable. These low ratios reflect two related f. actors: first, the majority of the penetrations have bees, installed since late 1976; and second, building settlement r values since late 1976 have been very small.
t n Examination of the settlement curves on Figures 3 through 12 shows that the differential settlements at the penetrations have not changed significantly in the last seven years. Since the curves indicate that the structures have essentially completed their settlement, this pattern of "no change" is r,
expected to continue in the future. I u
, 7.0 FREQUENCY OF READINGS
, Presently, the benchmarks are being surveyed twice a year,
. except when the benchmark is temporarily blocked by equipment or if radiation is high, as in the case of the Offgas (Main)
?
Stack. Generally, the readings are taken near the beginning of i
the year, in January, and in the middle of the year, in July.
r This monitoring pattern has resulted in what appears to be u small cyclic temperature fluctuations.
d' 7, 8 L
T 8.0 ACCURACY OF READINGS The settlement values are determined by measurements which are kompared with known elevations at established onsite reference k,
O benchmarks. The locations of the reference benchmarks are shown on Figure 13. The elevations of the reference benchmarks were originally established from a United States Geological Survey (USGS) benchmark in Toombs County. The reference benchmarks are situated in the yard in such a way as to avoid k
accidental displacement and facilitate the settlement surveys of the Class 1 buildings. They are far enough away to avoid
~
settling with the buildings. Precautions were also taken to P
provide proper soil and anchorage conditions to ensure the stability of the benchmarks. However, there appears to be no procedure for periodically checking the elevations of the reference benchmarks.
[T. .
!,. Plant operating procedure 42SV-SUV-014-2 established a detailed method for monitoring settlement of Class 1 structures for HNP-1 and HNP-2. A series of special drawings was prepared to
{"'
clearly locate the benchmarks and establish a fixed survey route. These drawings are referenced in the procedure. The
- fs ,
acceptance criterion for closure error is 0.005 foot. The 6
procedure establishes as much consistency as possible from one survey to the next in order to make any change;or abnormality immediately apparent. However, even with tight controls, survey " errors" and variations are inevitable. These can be divided into three categories:
f .
o Instrumental errors o Personal errors o Natural variations T
9 I
F .
Ideally, the plant operating procedure eliminates the instru-
~ hntal and personal " errors" through a system of checks and I-plances. The natural variations, however, are unpredictable.
re Surveying experience indicates the variations associated with
.L optical leveling can be as high as 11/8 inch (Reference 3),
(, which is about the level of accuracy that can be expected for a
.s first order survey traversing about 1/4 mile (Reference 4).
Most of this is more than likely due to natural " variations,"
such as temperature fluctuations, that occur during the survey.
- ? 9. 0 TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION 3/4.7.8 In order to understand the development and implementation of the technical specification, a brief chronology of significant events is given below:
L o June 13, 1978: Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) issued F the Plant Hatch Unit 2 Technical Specification for Monitoring Building Settlement 3/4.7.8.
7
. o June 15, 1978: GPC requested Bechtel to ". . . investigate the potential significance of building settlement and 3
s' review the specification that the NRC issued . . ."
o November 1978: Bechtel issued a report entitled, " Proposed Technical Specification, Settlement of Category I Struc-tures," as an outgrowth of the June 15, 1978 GPC request.
o December 1, 1978: GPC transmitted to the NRC the proposed changes to Technical Specification 3/4.7.8.
o March 30, 1979: NRC requested additional information re-garding December 1, 1978 GPC submittal.
o July 20, 1979: NRC requested additional information re-garding December 1, 1978 GPC submittal. l 10 l l
F o August 14, 1979: GPC responded to March 30, 1979 NRC request.
, 5 October 8, 1979: GPC responded to July 20, 1979 NRC
, request.
d o September 27, 1982: GPC proposed to the NRC deleting Technical Specification 3/4.7.8 and a withdrawal of sub -
mittals on that subject.
,,, o December 7, 1983: GPC outlined to the NRC a procedure to L, be used for continuation of settlement monitoring via a Plant Operating Procedure'.
s.
o May 4, 1984: GPC reported to the NRC a possible error in 7 the December 7, 1983 submittal and discrepancies between t-the FSAR and Technical Specification 3/4.7.8.
r i o October 1985: GPC requested that Bechtel review the set-n tiement issue, including all submittals to the NRG on building settlement, and recommend changes needed to Technical. Specification 3/4.7.8, if appropriate.
('
o December 18, 1985: GPC reported to the NRC that the
[s December 7, 1983 submittal was incorrect. iThe correct L3 information was supplied.
e o April 4, 1986: GPC reiterated the September 27, 1982 !
submittal to delete Technical Specification 3/4.7.8 and monitor building settlement via a Plant Operating Procedure. l fB The original technical specification, which was initially reviewed in 1978, is the same Technical Specification 3/4.7.8 still in use today and given in Appendix A. The only difference between the two is that the original 1978 version gave an allowable differential settlement of 3/4 inch for all structures, i
11
f r whereas the current version does not give allowable differential ettlement values. GPC has initiated action with the NRC to .
[esolvethisdifference. Further', GPC has committed to monitor n Building settleraent in accordance with provisions given in the y FSAR, Section 2A.5.3, via a plant operating procedure rather than a Technical Specification.
fr o It must be emphasized that whether or not differential settle-y ment is addressed in the Technical Specification, it does not alter the fact the structures are not settling and are not y expected to settle in the future. It is for this reason that 4 the Technical Specification can be eliminated.
ro
10.0 CONCLUSION
S AND RECOMMENDATIONS u.
The settlement curves on Figures 3 through 12 demonstrate that the structures under consideration are not settling and have q not been settling for at least the last seven years. In every case the measured total settlement (Table 1) for each structure is less than the predicted value. The small movements that have taken place recently appear to be due to temperature fluctuation and the inherent variation in optical surveys..
[f: '
Further, no appreciable tilt has occurred in any of the struc-tures. In all cases, the ratio of measured differential
{s settlement to the allowable differential settlement (across y structures) is less than or equal to 30 percent (Table 2). The L ratio of the measured differential settlement to the allowable
, differential settlements (for penetrations) is less than or equal to 53 percent (Tables 3 through 10). In summary, the structures have experienced all of the appreciable settlement that is expected to occur, and any remaining measured movement f will be due to survey inaccuracies and/or temperature fluctu-
$ a4. ions.
In conclusion, from a purely geotechnical standpoint, Technical Specification 3/4.7.8 can be eliminated in its entirety and i 12 m
~
PW settlement monitoring of the structures can be accomplished brough a Plant Hatch Operating Procedure, t'is recommended that the new procedure address not only total
, settlements, but differential settlements as well. The basis for the plant operating procedure is the December 1,1978 submittal from GPC to 'the NRC, Reference 5, with some minor revisions. Note that the provisions in Reference 5 are the
'f same as those in Reference 2 and in Section 2A.S.3 of the FSAR.
N '
The recommended criteria to be used to evaluate the settlements 2 are as described below:
u
?-
A. Surveillance Requirements' The surveillance requirements for all settlement benchmarks shall be once a year, except when an unusual meteorological b
or seismic event occurs, in which case the structures r should be surveyed as soon as possible. The existing s surveillance requirements 4.7.8 a and b of Technical
,, Specification 3/4.7.8 should be deleted in their entirety.
s B. Total Settlement h
The total settlement of each structure shall not exceed the predicted values given in Table 1. If theitotal settlement of any structure reaches the predicted settlement given in Table 1, GPC site engineering should notify GPC corporate
, engineering for resolution.
[ C. Differential Settlement Across Structures
% The differential settlement across structures shall not f exceed the allowable values given in Table 2. If the differential settlement across any structure exceeds 75 percent of the allowable settlement value given in Table 2, 13
m .. ..
GPC site engineering should notify GPC corporate engineering for resolution.
Penetration Differential Settlement Between Structure and f Soil The penetration differential settlement between structure and soil shall not exceed the allowable values given in
? Tables 3 through 6. If the penetration differential settlement between structure and soil exceeds 75 percent of 2- the allowable values given in Tables 3 through 6, GPC site s.
engineering should notify GPC corporate engineering for resolution.
r s.
E. Penetration Differential Settlement Between Adjacent N '
Structures b
p The penetration differential settlement between structures s shall not exceed the allowable values given in Tables 7 t
through 10. If the penetration differential settlement between adjacent structures exceeds 75 percent of the allowable values given in Tables 7.through 10, GPC site engineering should notify GPC corporate engineering for resolution.
f, 1 Lt further, it is recommended that provisions be incorporated in y
the procedure to check the elevations of the reference bench-
, marks, shown on Figure 13, at least once every 5 years or if it is suspected that damage to the reference benchmarks has occurred.
14
.. . i F
t
. REFERENCES
[
- 1. Final Safety Analysis Report (FSAR) Update, E. I. Hatch Nuclear 3
Plant, Unit 2, Georgia Power Company.
- I 9
- 2. Proposed Technical Specification, Settlement of Category I Struc-r
.* tures, E. I. Hatch Nuclear Plant, Unit 2, Bechtel Power Corporation, November 1978.
v, a- 3. Lewis, M. R. , and A. Sanver, Foundation Movement Monitoring of r, Heavy Structures - A Case History," International Conference on Case Histories in Geotechnical Engineering, University of Missouri-Rolla,
't Rolla, Missouri, May 1984.
- 4. Merrit, Frederick S. , " Standard Handbook for Civil Engineers," New
~
York: McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1968. -
~
- 5.
Letter from C. F. Whitmer (GPC) to Director of Nuclear Reaclor
.. Regulation (NRC), dated December 1, 1978.
m mb
+ e i
N' b
w e
4 Y
k I -
L 7 15 L
'N-R F 4
N e
t .
l -
i 6
b TABLES T,.
7-t .
e 5O' S
bo P
L i
6 9
k l
m I.
~
TABLE 1 PREDICTED AND MEASURED TOTAL SETTLEMENTS RATIO OF MEASURED SETTLEMENT-INCHES 1 TO PREDICTED-%
MEASURED
, STRUCTURE PREDICTED MAXIMUM TO DATEz MAXIMUM TO DATE2 i Reactor Building Unit 1 3.1 2.8 2.6 90 84
, Reactor Building Unit 2 4.5 2.0 1.7 44 38
, Turbine Building Unit 1 1.5 1. 2 1.2 80 80 Turbine Building Unit 2 2.0 0. 3 ---
15 --
Radwaste Building Unit 1 1.5 0.8 0.6 53 40 Radwaste Building Unit 2 3.5 - 0.5 0.3 14 9 Control Building 2.0 1. 5 1.5 75 75 Diesel Generator Building 2.0 1. 0 1. 0 50 50
? Offga: (Main) Stack 2.0 0.4 0.3 20 15
. Intake Structure 2.0 1.44 1.44 70 70 b
5 i
.! \
l 1
I
. 1 7,
>' 1 Settlements are reported to the nearest 0.1 inch.
2 July 1985 reading.
f aAll measurements are currently indicating heave.
( 4 Measured settlements are estimates only, since complete records do not exist prior to July 1978.
T y
?
r--
TABLE 2
~
}.
SUMMARY
OFDIFFERENTIALSETTLEMENTSACROSSSTRUCTURES
. (
d DIFFERENTIAL RATIO 0F BETWEEN SETTLEMENT MEASURED
- REFERENCE DIRECTION BENCHMARK INCHES 2 TO ALLOWABLE STRUCTURE DATE OF TILT' NUMBERS 1 ALLOWABLE MEASURED 3 PERCENT Reactor 5-76 N-S 1 and 2 0.40 0.00 0 T. Building N-S 3 and 4 0.41 0.02 5 Unit No. 2 E-W 1 and 3 1.67 0.12 7 E-W 2 and 4 1.61 0.10 6 7 Radwaste 10-75 N-S 5 and 6 1.85 0.28 15
. Building N-S 7 and 8 1.92 0.30 16 Unit No. 2 E-W 5 and 7 1.58 0.01 1
{ E-W 6 and 8 0.96 0.04 4 Control 1-75 N-S 9 and 10 1.00 0.08 8
, Building N-S 11 and 12 0.95 0.18 19 E-W 9 and 11 3.01 0.22
{~ E-W 10 and 12 3.46 0.12 7
3 7 Turbine 5-76 N-S 13 and 14 2.69 0.23 '9
[' Building N-S 154 and 16 2.46 0.29 12 Unit No. 2 E-W 13 and 154 2.96 0.19 6 7.; E-W 14 and 16 3.37 0.13- 4 s- Diesel 1-75 N-S 17 and 18 5.09 0.11 2 Generator- N-S 19 and 20 4.73 0.22 5 n ,
Building E-W 17 and 19 2.47 0.43 17
- , E-W 18 and 20 2.47 0.11 4
- r. Offgas 10-74 N-S 21 and 22 0.44 . 0.13 30 (Main) E-W 21 and 23 0.55 O.08 15 Stack E-W 22 and 23 0.50 0.05 10 Intake 10-74s N-S 24 and 25 2.50 0.24 10
- Structure N-S 26 and 27 2.50 0.08 3 E-W 24 and 26 0.65 0.04 6 r E-W 25 and 27 1.25 0.12 10 d
d 2 Refer to Figure 1 for benchmark identification.
2 Reported to the nearest 0.01 inch.
3 As of July 1985.
7
- 4No current survey data are available for benchmark 15; used last available cata, January 1979.
5
,, Actual benchmarks used were established in July 1978.
2 o
M7 it
P5 TA8LE 3 m
..}'
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS
, [ REACTOR 8UILDING HNP-2 AND SOIL J
Ratio of m Differential Measured Settlement - Inches 1 to Allowable Date of Nearest Heasured Allowable Percent
, Penetration Installation Benchmark to Date2 Pipe Anchor Pipe Anchor U 8 in. No. 1 November 1977- 1 0.13 0.73 1.03 13 ' 18 7' 10 in. No. 2 December 1977 1 0.11 1.22 0.96 9 11 18 in. No. 3 April 1978 1 . 0.12 1.26 0.72 10 17 18 in. No. 4 March 1978 1 0.16 1.26 0.72 13 22 6 in. No. 8 November 1977 1 0.13 1.22 0.75 11 17 10 in. No. 10 January 1978 2 0.18 1.22 0.96 15 19 4
18 in. No. 11 March 1978 2 0.20 1.26 0.72 16 28 9 20 in. No. 12 January 1978 2 0.18 1.13 0.56 16 32 7 18 in. No. 13 April 1978 2 0.20 1.26 0.75- 16 28
)' 14 in. No. 24 November 1977 2 0.18 1.15 1.06 16 17 10 in. No. 41 February 1977 2 0.10 1.28 0.88 8 11
. 16 in: No. 42 March 1978 2 0.20 1.06 0.73 19 27
[. I .. 14 in. No. 134 March 1978 1 0.16 1.15 1.13 14 14
.f 20 in. No. 161 January 1978 1 0.12 1.13 0.71 11 17 g.
P w
i T
i IReported to the nearest 0.01 inch.
2As cf July 1985.
I r
ia
( .- - _ . -- _- . . - _ - --
.......,__.__.c.........___,,,_.. _,,,,,,,,_,m. ,
. .~...M TABLE 4
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS , !
{
DIESEL GENERATOR BUILDING AND. SOIL i E .
- Ratio of Differential Measured '
Settlement - Inches 2 to Allowable Date of Nearest Measured Allowable Percent Penetration Installation Benchmark to Date2 Pipe Anchor Pipe Anchor gr it, 6 in. January 1978 17 0.20 0.57 0.57 35 35
- 10 in. December 1971 17 0.493 0.92 ----
53 --
8 I,
\3 9
h e
r T
1 Reported to the nearest 0.01 inch.
3 2As of July 1985.
8 Earliest reading on Benchmark 17 is December 1972.
9?
?!
h P
1
E E
TABLE 5
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS f MAIN STACK AND SOIL E
Differential Ratio of Settlement - Inchesi Measured E' Penetration Measured Allowable to Allowable Installation Benchmark to Date2 in Pipe Percent 18 in. June 1974 23 0.04 0.45 '9 12 in. May 1974 23 0 04 0.45 9 20 in. June 1974 22 0.01 0.46 2
, 6 in. May 1974 22 0.01 0.46 2 E
F E
P.
at t
b P.
b 2 Reported *.o the nearest 0.01 inch.
2As of July 1985.
l
-- . . - . - .-- _ ~ ..---
F -
-i ; m j- .
F
~
-TABLE 6
- SUMARY OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS f INTAKE STRUCTURE AND SOIL E
Ratio of Differential f Date of Settlement - Inches 1 Measurtd to Allowable Nearest Measured Allowable 3 Percent Penetration Installation Benchmark to Date Pipe Support Pipe Support rt . 30 in. January 1978 25 0.23 1.38 0.66 17 35 er El. 97.28 ft.
,., 12 in. July 1974 25 0.23 0.99 1.19 23 19
- r. 18 in.
(Unit 2) February 1978 25 0.23 2.78 2.03 8 11
! 30 in. January 1978 25 0.23 1.38 0.66 17 35
{ El. 91.75 ft.
, , , (Unit 1) r 30 in. January 1978 . 25 0.23 1.38 0.66 17 35 El. 91.75 ft.
(Unit 2)
I 18 in. February 1978 27 0.11 2.47 1.27 4 9
- s. (Unit 1) r~'. 6 in. April 1976 26 0.02 1.50 0.94 1- 2 s .'
f' .
'h e
a l L l 1
y 2 Reported to the nearest 0.01 inch.
2 {
Measured differential settlements are estimates only, since complete records '
do not exist prior to July 1978. Measured settlements are as of July 1985.
8A11owable settlement is based on both pipe stress and support loads.
l l
E E
TABLE 7 j.
SUP#tARY OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS i REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND RADWASTE BUILDING HNP-2 Ratio of Differential Measured
.:F -
Date of Nearest Settlement - Inches 1 to Allowable Measured Allowable Percent Penetration Installation Benchmark to Date2 Pipe Anchor Pipe Anchor 1 in. No. 51 October 1977 2 and 5 0.12 1.54 --
8 --
, 6 in. No. 51 October 1977 2 and 5 0.12 1.14 --
11 --
1.5 in. No. 102 November 1977 2 and 5 0.11 1.07 --
10 --
8 in. No. 153 February 1977 4 and 5 0.06 1.48 0.88 4 7 E
fl. i y
?
L:
R b
b 2 Reported to the nearest 0.01 inch.
2As of July 1985.
s
TABLE 8
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS
{ REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND CONTROL BUILDING
[" Ratio or r.
Differential Measured Settlement - Inches 1 to Allowable Date of Nearest Measured Allowable Percent Penetration Installation Benchmark to Date2 Pipe Anchor Pipe Anchor rr L, 24 in. No. 59 May 1978 3 and 10 0.17 26.03 13.23 '. 1 r- 3 in. No. 60 January 1978 3 and 10 0.26 1.48 0.62 18 42 b-18 in. No. 61 August 1977 3 and 1.0 0.27 9.55 1.86 3 15 7
24 in. No. 61 September 1976 3 and 10 0.19 12.14 5.06 2 4 3
4 in. No. 68 January 1978 3 and 10 0.26 1.84 0.85 14 31 w
s.
4 in. No. 69 January 1978 3 and 10 0.26 1.99 0.78 l'3 33
?'
3 "1
n f'
r-M b
1 T
i 1 Reported to the nearest 0.01 inch.
l 2As of July 1985.
P a
et k
F F
TABLE 9
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS
. ; REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND TURBINE BUILDING HNP-2 E
m Ratio of Differential Measured
- Settlement - Inches 1 to Allowable Date of Nearest Measured Allowable Percent Penetration Installation Benchmark to Date2 Pipe Anchor Pipe Anchor
.- 10 in. No. 43 May 1978 4 and 13 0.09 2.12 1.68 4 5 m 4 in. No. 44 January 1978 4 and 13 0.07 1.30 --
5 --
3 in. No. 57 Novecer 1977 4 and 13 0.09 4.17 --
2 --
18 in. No. 57 July 1977 4 and 13 0.06 9.55 1.59 1 4 24 in. No. 57 September 1976 4 and 13 0.18 25.13 10.59 1 2 (E1. 154.46) 24 in. No. 57 September 1976 4 and 13 0.18 22.54 9.05 1 2 (El. 154.55)
L 8 in. No. 84 February 1977 4 and 13 0.08 1.13 1.01 7 8 f 10 in. No. 90 January 1978 4 and 13 0.07 2.51 1.f7 3 4 I 3 in. No. 92 December 1977 4 and 13 0.05 1.78 1.55 3 3 b
- s
- y. ,
(U
?. -
t
!=
[
i 1
I .
A 1 Reported to the nearest 0.01 inch.
2As of July 1985.
IN
~~ ~ ~ ~ ^ ~ ~ ~
( .
r TABLE 10 SU MARY OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS
- REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND REACTOR BUILDING HNP-1 I
Ratio of Differential Measured
- Settlement - Inches 2 to Allowable Date of Nearest Measured Allowable Percent Penetration Installation Benchmark to Dates Pipe Anchor Pipe Anchor
, 8 in. No. 183 January 1978 1 and 29 0.07 0.99 0.53 7 13 8 in. No. 184' December 1977 1 and 29 0.08 3.58 2.30 2 4 f.
[
[-
6 I.:
1 7
5 -
7 b
P S
?
6 3 Reported to the riearest 0.01 inch.
2As of July 1985.
f
. . . . . . ... . . . . - . . - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - -
F E
e- i
- t. .
1.
l m-m .
ib 7
FIGURES e
i
'l l
I.,
PT i..
rs.
?
). .
1
?
i f
4 0
4 l
l 1
I
y- -
l l
1 _ LEGEND N l h BENCHMARM - F-
~ PENETRATION (Unit 2 only)
- : g M
i g28 q g2 6T NE - I SE Q 50 10p FT NE 1
-- S 6 32 3 REACTOR "1 REACTOR
- 2 Scale
~
(hNE RADWASTE "2 RADWASTE1 # 2 3 S NW SW _
, , , . (h NW, 37 @9 NE SE 10 1 1
NE i SC SE TUR8INE
- l CONTROL TUftBINE *2 39 h NW Sk NW 2 # sW 3,
l 1 ,i 1
NOTE: Location of benchmarks and penetrations are for reference only. For exact locations and l, i
, details reference Plant Hatch Procedure E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT HNP-2-3425. .
BECHTEL i i
JOB 6511 POWER BLOCK BENCHMARK '
AND PENETRATION LOCATIONS FIGURE 1
m fu , ~- --v < s .
< vy -r
~y WN -W M-p- p ~
4N NE SE NI- S U - -
W
\ >> / =@ : , rei",'
0FFGAS (MAIN) STACK INTAME STRUCTURE LEGEND-
'rn NEM /
r E*
M /SE BENCNMARK a .
PENETRATION O SO 100 FT E M m Scale 19 20 fK NW'/ L)SW
' l DIESEL GENERATOR BUILDING l NOTE: Location cf benchmarks and penetrations are 1 for reference only. For exact locations and E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT !
BECHTEL details reference Plant Hatch Procedure !
HNP-2-3475. BENCHMARK AND PENETRATION JOB 6511 i LOCATIONS FOR OFFGAS STACK, INTAKE STRUCTURE AND DIESEL GENERATOR BUILDING FIGURE 2
c- y v -
--- m - m ----
M f' E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR 1.00 R EACTO R BUILDING U NIT 1 BENCHMARKS PLANT- SETTLEMENT 0.00 - O c'
d
~ 1.00 g 4 '
2 N
o
-2*00 9111Eh Q;;'iA. wo^
^ * - ^ - 0 - A ' '
AZ % Oa 56 50 5 * '
> v g o- .~x W >1$o >O >
0 '
M ' [I3 D3 a 3 '3 o o o 3
- - W ++U + F+ u+ e + 53+
s
+ & + .e3+
-3.00 1
-4.00 . . - . .
'69 '70 '71 '72 '73 '74 '75 '76 *77 '78 '79 '80'81 '82 '83 '84 '85'86'87 o SW TIM E-YEARS
+ SE
- o. NE a NW l
E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT BECHTEL j NOTE: Approximate time of structure completion i in May 1976. 8 REACTOR BUILDING UNIT 1 m 65U
{
BENCIMARK SETTLEENT FIGURE 3
[i
.r1
-, c gyT a o . ,
7 y 7 %, wm,,-- m---p; w- ,5-- --- ,y g - g- - g- q E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT- S ETTLEMENT R EACTO R BUILDING UNIT 2 BENCHMARKS 1.00 0.00 =
0
-1.00 --
g s
y -2.00 4 aQhh % e hb ol g',+
3 J 3 o13 9
-3.00 t
l
-4.00 --- --
'G9'70'71 '72 '73 '74 '75 '76 '77 '78 '79 '80 '81 '82 '83 '84 '85 '86 '87 TI M E-YEAR S a SW + SE o NE a NW E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT BECHTEL ,
NOTE: Approximate time of structure completion i I" Y
- m 65H REACTOR BUILDING UNIT 2 ..
BENCHMARK SETTLEENT FIGURE 4 f
\) S R UW 6 :D PTS 7 H m , ,
E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT- SETTLEMENT 1.00 RADWASTE BUILDINO U N IT 1 BENCHMARKS' O.OO -
l 0 - 1.0 0 -
T 2
W -2.00 9
-3.00 l
l
- 4. O O . . . _ . . _ . .
3
'69 '70 '71 '72 '73 '74 '75 '76 '7*/ '78 '79 '80 '81 '82 '83 '84 '85 '86 '87 I TI M E-YEARS o SW + SE o NE a NW E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT BECHTEL NOTE: Approximate time of structure completion not known. "
RADWASTE BUILDING UNIT 1 g BENCIMARK SETTLEENT lI f
-FIGURE 5
m O JJ 6 '3 LCY V ' 'Y V' ] $ 8 M M M M M, . .
] '
E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT- SETTLEMENT
- 1. 0 0 RADWASTE BUILDING UNIT 2 BENCHMARKS 0.00 n %m DG **
g"' D-gd $a ,
a 3 o >* 4 a 6*
e *
~ 1.0 0 l
. ,i 2
y -2.00 ,
2 i
?
-3.00 k
-4.00 ._ .
'69 '70 '71 '72 '73 '74 '75 '76 '77 '78 '79 '80'81 '82 '83 '84 '85 '86 '87 TI M E-YEARS !
E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT BECHTEL NOTE: Approximate time of structure completion in October 1975.
RADWASTE BUILDING UNIT 2 BENCIMARK SETTLEENT FIGURE 6 l
,, j @
7 . .. m . .a : :". - i rr q *- -* - ^; f= a
,] ' ,q ,q 7 ] ,
E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT- SETTLEMENT TURBINE BUILDINO U NIT 1 BENCHMARKS 1.00 0.00 ':
- M o
- " S '6 4 6 .A .6 s a sA M - 1.00 NteM ' *lmidd*++ e- + + "+ i .,. s+
'X P+ C+ .
I
, I-y -2.00 i o
- s .
I
)
-3.00 !
i i
-4.00 f
'69 '70 '71 '72 '73 '74 '75 '76 '77 '78 '79 '80 '81 '82 '83 '84 '85 '86 '87 il TI M E-YEARS !I o SW + SE o NE a NW !
E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT BECHTEL NOTE: Approximate time of structure completion in January 1975. JOB 6511 :
8 TURBINE BUILDING UNIT 1 BENCHMARK SETTLEENT i FIGURE 7 ,
.e 3- v7 cr 3 .~
o.y p .y o. 4 e. 9 g r m , , , , _q .y y q ,
E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR P LANT- S ETTLEM.e1N T 1.00 TURBINE BUILDING UNIT 2 BENCHMARKS 0.00 " -- ""'"
- N >
'MQ MD(" >" '
!G
-1.00 T
2 y -2.00
!il
-3.00
-4.00 . . - . .
~
'69 '70 '71 '72 '73 '74 '75 '76 '77 '78 '79 '80 '81 '82 '83 '84 '85 '86 '87 TI M E-YEAR S o SW + SE NE NW o a E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT BECHTEL f
NOTE: Approximate time of structure completion in May 1976. JOB 6511 TURBINE BUILDING UNIT 2 !
BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 8
, , . . - 1 , , -
.- r- -
1 : 4 -
- .t : q . i ;. , .
i ; ,
- E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT- S ETTLEMriNT 1.00 CONTROL BUILDINO BENCHMARKS i
O.00 i: *
! d i I _1,00 % b. afM @ _1M io i A 3a ia ia ia 4 a i "5MN $ ~+++
j8 3a
++ *+
58i$8i$8:$8l$8
+ s+ ,+
i g -2.00 -
o . !
2
-3.00 i
i
- 4. O O . . . .
k
'69 '70 '71 '72 '73 '74 '75 '76 '77 '78 '79 '80 '81 '82 '83 '84 '85 '86 '87 !
TI M E-YEARS !
[t NOTE: Approximate time of structure completion E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT BECHTEL [
i in January 1975.
JOB 6511 [
CONTROL BUILDING !
BENCHNARK SETTLEENT FIGURE 9 j-e
3 .. m y n-r g . = , ,m . ,. g .v 3.g 2j f .,y
, 3 p
, .q E. I. HATCH NU CLE AR PLANT-SETTLEMENT DIESEL GEN ERATOR BUILDING BENCHMARKS 1 00 0.00 ~-
I doo 1 Q & a "
S- 5
I 4 a s "A -'i l
'"g3 ig 4 8 '
"O 'OO g r .l El eg 10 x 0 y _ >_._.
- o 2.. __ _.
g - 1.00 y e o o ?
l T I E
2 l'
f y -2.00 ;
o .
l t
I
-3.00 l
l' I
I
-4.00 - -
l
'69 '70 *71 '72 '73 '74 '75 '76 '77 '78 '79 '80 '81 '82 '83 '84 '85 '86 '87 i
TI M E-YEARS i a SW + SE o NE a NW I I
I E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT BECHTEL e NOTE: Approximate time of structure completion f in January 1975. JOB 6511 ;,
DIESEL GENERATOR BUILDING :
BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT :
FIGURE 10
0 -v v v tr - ] v e';~+ +
,3 ; *y gg q)) .
.ca v N v7 1 3 .] ' ] [
E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT- SETTLEME T 4.00
^
0.00 =
t N
-1.00 T
- I n"'E@ @@ ge,a$ 3@
h 3E
+
- y -2.00 ,
E !.
I
-3.00 i i
I
.. I I
-4.00 . . _ . . . . _ . .
I
'69 '70 '71 '72 '73 '74 '75 '76 '77 '78 '79 '80 '81 '82 '83 '8 4 '85 '8 6 *B7
, TI M E-YEA RS o SW + SE o. NE a NW E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT BECHTEL NOTE: Approximate time of structure completion j in October 1974. JOB 6511 INTAKE STRUCTURE !'
I BENCIMARK SETTLEENT l FIGURE 11 l
t r ~ ,c m r v ~ > v u s> i < .r - 3, , y - - -
4 ; -
,.3 p , _. 3 .
4 y 3 E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT- S ETTLEMENT OFFOAS STACK BENCHMARKS 1.00 0.00 2 Y [ @i3 @9 0 is D 3 ijit '
pS e
b s
~ 1.00 1
2 y -2.00 o
2
-3.00 i l
1
-4.00 I
'69'70'71 '72 '73 '74 '75 '76 '77 '78 '79 '80 '81 '82 '83 '84 '85 '86 '87 TI M E-YEARS c3 S + W o NE E. I. HATCH NOCLEAR PLANT BECHTEL !
NOTE: Approximate time of structure completion !
in October 1974. JOB 6511 l OFFGAS (MAIN) STACK ,
BENCHMARK SETTLEMENT i i
FIGURE 12
, . . . . . . . . _ . _ . . __ _ . - ' - ._ ---- ~
- 1 . - 2 o^ I :E! I,E O G w
48 *** E, en . 4K W c g
!! - k!!
. 4
!! '!!g =!$
55! $5!
a n-k C 4 A 4 i i i t t m I I I I I I I I
/[l! rb.A I! k 1
- 1: e 9
$45 / . .
/fj g ; !
- gumnunrmm e l5i,-- g7 6 , y .m a
g m
- . , s' 1s \ <
s.c W et %
<= z w
," I. gl -
i S- __r
. I gsm
, g w
L.
c / /r u : : x .#n a 2 m
h ,,
y i i g e
l li sn (
l' i l
% '\ l
- <:H II', .l I D,. ;
y= p]q'pq yJ o ~
[ L
], e' ) 2
~ }
/ e c_ _ _ . _ . " ~
/
.. 2 .p!fA-alc){
n /9E!Ik!9!
1 .
m , ~ .. -
m.wr,Ns4 3' hi 41{. Tl;. s I l 1
.x ._ . _ _ _ __. 4 7 D ! ! li I- ,
~%x , pe,(=L y j ; g, , . I I r
N%g- > r i !,n i L
- 4 '
- = =; n
, ~~ m t:.. e<
_nh ~
r . -s ; __J is c i a N 'N 1 iE i -- s er y: ID
- i
- - 1, 3
I w f
,d R. _@_ada nz'r E :' 1"1 --'11 1 i 1 isi s) ["
Y \
r-
- n. g 1 .
r s'
APPENDIX A T
n TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION 3l4.7.8 SETTLEMENT OF CLASS 1 STRUCTURES
'b
'e e
4 4
L e
b D
h P
W D
k P
E d
n.
-g -
i e
L.
m 6 i TT -
l 3
P i.
av THERE ARE NO NOTES FOR APPENDIX A 3
i 7
s 7
4 l'
h a
D D
9
+
.. ..-...._ ._..- ..._ _ .. . ~ _ _ _ _ _ .- -
PLANT SYSTEMS 3/4.7.8 SEITLEMENT OF CLASS 1 STRUCTURES .
. l LIMITING CONDITION FOR OPERATION
- 3.7.8 The total settlement of each Class I structure or the differential settlement between or across Class I structures shall not exceed the y allowable values of Table 3.7.8-1.
s APPLICABILITY: All CONDITIONS.
ACTION:
- a. With either the total settlement of any structure or the dif-
, ferential settlement of any structures exceeding 75% of the allowable settlement value, conduct an engineering review of field conditions and evaluate the consequences of additional settlement. Submit a special report to the Commission pur-suant to Specification 6.9.2 within 60 days, containing the.
results of the investigation, the evaluation of existing and possible continued settlement and the remedial action to be taken, if any, including the date of the next survey.
- b. With the total settlement of any structure or the differenti.a1 9
settlement of any structures exceeding the, allowable settlement value of Table 3.7.8-1, be in at least HOT SHUTDOWN within 12 hours1.388889e-4 days <br />0.00333 hours <br />1.984127e-5 weeks <br />4.566e-6 months <br /> and in COLD SHUTDOWN within the next 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br />.
l SURVEILLANCE REQUIREMEsTS 1
4.7.8 The total settlement of each Class I structure'or the dif-ferential settlement'between Class I structures listed in Table 3.7.8-1
, shall be determined to the nearest 0.01 foot by measurement and calcula-tion:
- a. At least once per 31 days;
)
. 1. During the first 6 months of unit operation,
- 2. Until observed settlement has stabilized,* and
- 3. Whenever previously stabilized
- settlement exceeds O.10 inch since the previous reading.
- b. At least once per 6 months.
- s0.10 inch from previous reading.
HATCH - UNIT 2 3/4 7-31
J_ 3 *a m, m q ~
r r
) 1 . ) 4 g a g-' ; -s ;
TABLE 3.7.8-1 g ALLOWABLE TOTAL SETTLEMENT OR DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENT FOR CLASS 1 STRUCTURES
-4 m
Z Allowable Allowable Total e
Differential ~
Settlement settlement E Structure fInchest fInchest Reactor Building 1s.5
- 90 Control Building 2.5
- Diesel Cenerator Building 2.5
- Main Stack 2.5 * ,
intake Structure 2.5
- s
?
M l-m -
l e
i I
1 I
I i
i.
i' il i
t
- io be established and reported to the Commission by November 1, 1978. ;
. . e.- - em .e a .*aa+. . w e m e . w .. .. %=%,a.-.- '
m m.m.d - w. m .e - w a .
F 3- .
}. e k l
.... 4 es Oh APPENDIX B "Y'
i.
SETTLEMENT DATA e
REACTOR BUILDING. UNITS 1 AND 2 e*
'I e4 9
9 e
e F
- i.
I r
lf8 l
l il
- e. e -
4 ...:m ,~.._. w .. u . m . ....._ .. _.. _ m ; _ . ... .. .
j ADDITIONAL COMMENTS TO APPENDICES B THROUGH F J AS A RESULT OF NRC QUESTIONS
[ .
APPENDIX B
- 1. Item #6 of Section B: Northwest should be northeast.
- 2. Add the following to Section C:
(2) o Original elevations of ben,chmarks is based on settlement i
given on Figure 2A-16A, Sheet 2, Amendment 35, 7/77.
(3) o Asettlementmarker(benchmark)changewasmadefor the northwest marker in October 1977. It was assumed, that no movement of the marker occurred since the previous reading. An adjustment was made to the ref-erence elevation to account for the previous movement.
APPENDIX F i
i 1. Add the following to Section C:
(5) o Based on correspondence, it was concluded that the ref-erence elevations for each benchmark was changed in January 1975.
i
~
. 1 4
l i
1 ,
i j
_ . . . . . m..._..._.m..__..._.. _ _ . - . . . . . . . j
~
- l
- i. APPENDIX B SETTLEMENT DATA
- REACTOR BUILDING UNITS 1 AND 2 NOTES A. GENERAL
- 1. All reference elevations and survey readings are in feet.
y
- 2. All delta (movement) values are in inches.
- . 3. For the delta values, + indicates heave and - indicates settle-
~
ment.
99
- 4. For each structure, settlement markers and settlement benchmarks are used interchangably.~They are not to be confused with the N
reference benchmarks used for elevation control, shown on Figure 13.~~
L r- B. REACTOR BUILDING UNIT 1
- 1. Assumed a "zero" date for the beginning of settlement monitoring r in March 1969.
1 2. Settlement values for the southwest marker, between December 1969 and July 1970, were estimated from Figure 2A-16, sheet 1 of the r". Unit 2 FSAR, Amendment 35, issued in July 1977. No settlement J,* data for the remaining markers were available in this time frame.
.' 3. The settlement values in 1974, for all four markers were estimated from the same figure as in item 2 above.
- 4. The January 1975 reading for the northwest marker was changed from 0.079 feet to 0.179 feet.
- 5. A settlement marker (benchmark) change was made for the northwest marker in November 1977. It was assumed that no movement of the
'. marker occurred between November 1977 and the previous reading, a' July 1977. An adjustment was then made to the reference elevation i to account for the previous movement.
IT Li 6. New settlement markers (ber..hmarks) were established in January
! 1980forthesouthwest,southeastandnorth(6tmarkers. The y reference elevations were adjusted to account for the previous ,
movement.
(
l &#N
- f. .
1 T :
A s
. . . . . . . . -.... .. .. - _.. . .. ~ ._ ._ . .. _ .. .
N 4
- 7. The January 1981 reading for the southwest marker (benchmark) wis taken on the "old' marker. The reference elevation was c langed to account for this. Subsequent readings use the marker
.,,, established in January 1980.
C. REACTOR BUILDING UNIT 2
- 1. Assumed a "zero" date for the beginning of settlement monitoring in July 1972. This is based on notes appearing on Figure 2A-16, j sheet 1, of the Unit 2 FSAR, Amendment 35, issued in July 1977..
)
- 2. A settlement marker (benchmark) change was made for the southeast marker in April 1978. It was assumed that no movement of the marker occurred between April 1978 and the previous reading,
., February 1978. An adjustment was then made to the reference ele-vation to account for the previous movement.
- 3. New settlement markers (benchmarks) were established in January 1980 for the southwest and northeast markers. The reference elevations were adjusted to account for the previous movement.
e
'.e 4
6
,\
f 7
k 2
?
4
p " <:
pq . g -~ ~g ., a v 8 ; *
]'
e-y **3- -7 i y ; q r j { 'g
, 77,] .
g ,]
E. I. MTCE WCLC1 PLauf-MTMKai
- m. =.===.==========.-==..u=.o====.m-==============.=u====.mm.===-=.m..
I I SEACTOR LAlli 2 i KKTIR W!I 2 8 REKTOR Uuti 2 1 _8LKitt MIT_2 8 KarigRB I REKim Wil i I KKits eli i i KKTOR geli I I 8 C3 I SIRTEST MP*Et i SNTIEAST RAALES I IWITEASI RAMER I usainum miner I SOUINuEb; emRER I SOUTEASI paluCER I MATKASI Me&B B MRileESI MIEEE I g g 8. I===ml======1.======mm==.=In===.m.m====l.=u=====.---l.=====..=====l=.m=======8 I Mifu IREFEKEE SuBET SELIA IAEFEKKE SimWT KLTA laEFEKuCE SubvEV KLis terFEKuCE SuHEf MLTA IMFEREKE SMET KLTA IKTEKuCE SWRET Klie laEFEKuCE SURYET IELTA IREfEEEE 5@ WET KLl4 I I I ELET. REAtlas LUCES I ELIV. BEteluE tuCNE5 I ELEV. KatinE luce 5 I ELEf. KAlluE tuCHES I ELET. KA8 tug luCNES I ELEv. KattuE tuCNE51 ELET. KA0!al LUCES 8 ELEv. Mattei LUCES I Im =l-- =====Imm========.8====..=mm====I.======..-==ml==========1=====.====m.1 1 *69 I I I I I I I I i 8 JasteAAT I I I I I I I I I I FEteuaAf 8 I I I I I I I I I MACd i I I I I II I I I i' 8 m!L I I I I I I I I I 8 Mt i I i I I I I I I I JuE I I i 1 8 I I I l 8 JULY I I I B l 8 I I I '
I MEET I 8 I I I I I I I l CPTEMEll ! I I I i 8 I l -
I KlosER I i 1 I I I I I I I I NSWERGER I I I I I I I 4 l I KCEstER I I I I I S.021 -0.252 I I I I ;
I *18 I I I I I I I I I &
I Jauutif I I I I I 0.H5 -0.54 I I I I $
I FEleonet 8 I i I 4 0.H5 -0.54 I I I i [
t MACN 8 I I I l 8.854 -8.640 1 I I I '
I Art!L I I I I I 0.057 -0.604 I I I I l 3 nat i I I I I 5.86 -5.72 I I I i ?
I JuE I I I I I 0.873 -0.876 4 8 l 1 !
8 JULT I I I I l 8.076 -0.912 I l I I t
i Mdf i 1 I I I I
- I I I I CPTERKil i I I I 0.017 -0.924 1 0.002 -0.904 I 8.002 -0.904 1 0.079 -0.940 i f 3 KioKE I I I I I 8.e57 -I.H41 0.057 -l.H4 8 0.057 -1.H41 0.087 -1.H4 8 I a0vEneEE I I I I I 0.H4 -1.120 I O.H3 -1.116 8 0.H2 -1.lH I O.096 -l.152 i ,
I KCEstER 8 8 8 8 8 0.091 -l.100 8 8.0# -l.800 8 5.108 -l.296 1 8.lH -1.240 I I I '78 8 I i l I I I I I g i JanunRT I l I l l 8.H9 -1.III I 5.091 -l.100 1 0.11 -l.32 1 0.800 -l.2% i
- l 8 TEBRUARY I 1 I I I I I I I e I nAACu i i i 1 1 0.lH -l.240 l 8.lH -l.240 8 0.183 -1.2M 1 0.195 -1.26 I '
I I 0.IO6 -1.2121 0.100 -1.296 8 8.306 -1.272 1 0.186 -1.272 I I APtIL 8 I Mi i 8
I 8
I I I 8.117 -1.444 5 S.Ilt -l.4201 \ 0.121 -1.452 1 0.I86 -1.392 8 t i
1 JUE I I I _. I I I I I I I I JULY I I I I l 3.121 -1.452 1 0.132 -l.504 1 8.126 -1.512 l 8.189 -l.420 8 i I AUGUST I 1 I I I 0.123 -1.476 I I.134 -1.600 1 0.133 -l.596 8 8.125 -1.58 i
! CPIERKal i I i 1 0.132 -1.584 1 0.143 -l.116 i B.145 -1.74 I I.lu -l.632 I l.
I KIDER I I I I i I i l i t, 8 NOVEnKS I I i l . I 8.lu -l.632 8 0.143 -1.716 8 8.147 -l.764 1 0.842 -l.794 8 I:
I CEtneEn i I '72 I I
I I
I I
I I
I S.145 -1.74 8 I
E.853 -I.8M i I
3.152 -1.024 1 I
0.149 -l.708 I I
l'!
I JanuAaf I I I I I 0.14 -l.7528 0.15& -1.872 I I.1M -l.072 8 0.853 -l.036 1 1 1 FEMuA911 I I 4 3 8.847 -1.764 I O.156 -l.972 8 0.168 1.932 8 8.157 -l.004 8 I nata l 8 I I I 5.15 -1.8 I I.I50 -1.896 8 8.159 -l.90s 8 0.1M -l.872 I b' I AFRIL I I I I I 0.858 -l.096 3 S.lu -1.992 I O.lu -l.9921 5.162 -l.944 8 ['
I Mf I I I I I 0.154 -1.948 I I.165 -1.90 8 8.150 -1.896 8 0.155 -1.86 8 I I I I.157 -l.908 8 0.17 -2.84 I O.162 -l.944 8 0.156 -l.012 8
{
JusE i I .
I JULT I II II Bl 8I B.164 -1.9681 0.176 -2.ll21 0.164 -l.tet t 0.158 -l.096 1 !
I AUGUST I I I I I I l' 8 I !
l SEIIEnMal 8 I I i 1 8 l .I i FEE l .
C i e fP e^ ~, ' ~ * ) "~j j
~
g ,, 4 i
- 1 ~ " ; ~~ y L
,, ,4 ~ 1 4 i *
- ] ~~ ~]
E. I. MICN NKLIM PLMT-UTILEZNI m == .m== - m.m. mmumm m==.m========= . .. .m . . .. um . .... ..
8 I KETOS Wii 2 4 SEEin Lati 2 I KAC100 Hu!I 2 l KETOS Buli 2 l SEETM WII I 8 KE100 Wii l i KKitt Wii i I SEETIS Wil l I I C3 8 50miNWSi nMkE0 i Sluitut s MES I n00TEASi hMtEl 1 000iHutSi nMLES I SP5 mEST M Mit i SOUTE ASI MMES t 800 FEAST MMES l N0011alEST IA0kt0 t t & ! *=**== 1 ==*==**===l*=====**==*===*****l==============l*=**=====**=====l*============l============l=======**=***=*l 8 3 015 IEFE0EKI SuBVET BELf4 IKFE8EaE SWWT KLie IEFEKEE SuBVEV KLIA !KFE8EEE SWWEi 8% l0EFEKKE SutvEt SElle IKFE8EEE SWEV KLIA IKFE0ENCE SevET BELin ISEfEMEE SWWEt KLIA I 8 I ELEV. SEA 8156 IECES I ELit. KAttuS IENES 8 ELiv. SEAtluG luS t ELEV. fGesuS l a sl ELEv. KatlE luS I ELiv. KAtlE tuS I ELEV. KAOIE lutWS 8 ELEV. IEntlE IMS 8 l.---- mun m t ====mmun.mm la.um.m======. l=======.n==== Imm======mm i m==.am===mm im===ua-nuuum s I KT80E0 t i I I I 0.165 -1.90 1 0.102 -2.lH t 0.165 -1.90 1 0.162 -l.144 I I N0utnIES I I ,1 I I I I I t I IECin0E0 t i I I I I I t i I *73 I I I I I ! I I"F I I Jaun018 I t i 1 0.171 -2.052 8 0.104 -2.200 1 0.172 -2.064 3 0.1H -2.064 t i Fittuet t ! I I I 0.171 -2.052 1 0.104 -2.200 1 0.878 -2.052 1 0.872 -2.064 I I nAER I I I I t 0.173 -2.076 1 0.107 -2.244 I 0.171 -2.052 1 0.172 -2.064 I I APSit ! I I I I 8.176 -2.182 1 0.lM -2.2601 0.173 -2.076 1 0.172 -2.064 8 i Mt i I I I I 0.176 -2.812 I I.let -2.2601 0.172 -2.064 1 0.172 -2.h4 4 4 8 JuE I I I I I 0.877 -2.824 1 0.809 -2.260 1 0.172 -2.h41 0.172 -2.064 8 8 <RT I I I I I 0.lH -2,1241 0.lM -2.2601 0.172 -2.064 8 0.172 -2.064 1 !
I AtSuSi t ! I I I S.IH -2.124 I I.lM -2.2601 8.lu -2.h4 8 0.172 -2.064 8 $
I SEPTEnK01 I I t I 0.177 -2.824 8 0.109 -2.260 1 0.872 -2.h41 0.172 -2.h4 I i 8 KT00E01 I I I I S.lU -2.824 5 0.lM -2.2601 0.172 -2.064 4 0.872 -2.064 8 y iIONEnKS I I I I 8 8 I t t i EttnIES I I I I I I I i 8 I *74 8 8 1 1 I I I i l t Juut0T 8 8 I t I i 8 I I h I FEMuut i I I I I S.lH -2.124 I 8.l94 -2.320 1 0.l78 -2.052 8 0.17 -2.M I .
I M0Cu 8 8 I I I 0.101 -2.172 1 0.194 -2.320 1 0.178 -2.052 1 0.171 -1.052 I [
l APSit i I I I 8 I t i I t
! MV I l i I I I I I I I
-2.H I
- I Juut i I I I $ 0.170 -2.136 I I.194 -2.320 1 0.172 -2.064 1 0.17 I I I I 0.170 -2.136 1 0.194 -2.320 8 0.172 -2.h41 0.17 -2.04 8 I Jutt 1 0.170 -2.136 8 0.194 -2.320 1 0.172 -2.064 8 O.l7 -2.H I l t AusuSI I I $ 8 1 ,
8 SEPIEMESI l I I I 0.170 -2.136 I I.194 -2.320 1 0.172 -2.064 8 0.17 -2.H I e i K100E01 I I $ 1 8 1 4 5 j t etnSt0 t t t i I 0.170 -2.136 1 0.194 -2.320 1 0.178 -2.052 8 0.171 -2.052 1 ;
I IECEnIES t I I I I I.205 -2.46 1 0.210 -2.616 1 0.193 -2.316 1 0.19 -2.20 1 ,
I '75 t i i I I I I I i {
l Jaunt i I I I I 0.205 -2.46 1 0.222 -2.664 1 0.804 -2.200 8 0.179 -2.140 t j i FEponf I l i I I S.2 -2.43 0.217 -2.604 1 0.108 -2.172 8 0.175 -2.81 t MICN I 130.002 129.M2 -1.32 I 129.923 121.024 -l.100 t 829.938 129.039 -1.184 I I I.2 -2.48 0.22 -2.64 1 0.19 -2.20 1 0.10 -2.86 I l I APRIL i 130.002 121.091 -1.321129.923 121.025 -l.tf6 8129.938 129.04 -1.M2 8129.973 129.076 -l.1641 0.205 -2.46 1 0.22 -2.64 8 0.109 -2.268 1 0.101 -2.872 I I MV I 130.002 129.093 -l.300 t 129.123 129.023 -l.2 8 129.131 121.04 -l.M2 1 129.173 129.003 -l.00 8 0.208 -2.412 8 0.210 -2.616 8 0.105 -2.22 8 0.870 -2.l36 8 1 JuE I 130.002 129.094 -l.296 1 129.923 129.024 -l.III I 129.938 121.042 -l.0601129.173 129.002 -1.M2 8 0.2 -2.48 0.210 -2.616 1 0.105 -2.22 1 0.tn -2.8241
! Jutf I 130.002 121.096 -3.272 8 129.923 129.024 -l.100 1 129.931 121.030 -l.116 1 121.973 129.070 -l.14 1 0.199 -2.300 1 0.217 -2.6H I 0.185 -2.22 1 0.179 -2.140 1 0.190 -2.376 1 0.210 -2.616 I I.105 -2,22 1 0.101 -2.172 1 8 AusuSI 8138.002 129.Mt -l.3321129.923 129.022 -l.212 8129.931 121.048 -l.00 t 129.973 129.002 -l.M21 1 EEPIEnIESI 130.002 121.094 -l.296 1 129.923 129.023 -l.2 8 129.938 121.H -l.092 8 I??.ffl 129.001 -l.lH I 0.817 -2.364 1 0.217 -2.604 1 0.106 -2.232 8 0.10 -2.l6 I I KT00E0 t 130.002 121.094 -I.296 1 129.923 129.023 -l.2 I 129.931 129.04 -1.092 1 121.173 529.008 -1.104 1 0.197 -2.364 1 0.287 -2.604 1 0.106 -2.232 8 0.10 -2.16 8 [
t alvEnIES I 130.002 121.076 -1.582 8121.123 129.0M -l.360 I 129.934 121.026 -1.26 8 129.973 121.066 -l.204 I 0.190 -2.376 1 0.210 -2.616 1 0.106 -2.232 8 8.30 -2.16 I (:
8 GtLnES I 130.002 121.065 -1.644 1 129.923 121.0 -1.476 1 129.931 129.017 -l.360 1 121.973 129.054 -l.420 1 0.810 -2.376 1 0.210 -2.616 1 0.106 -2.232 8 0.181 -2.172 I i I '75 I I I I I I I I I I I Januut i 130.002 121.h3 -1.uS 8129.123 129.790 -1.5 t 129.938 129.017 -3.3601 129.tn 129.053 -1.44 1 0.t90 -2.376 8 0.210 -2.616 8 0.106 -2.232 1 1.102 -2.104 8 ;
I FE6 aunty 3130.002 129.059 -1.716 8129.923 129.nl -1.5 1 129.931 129.016 -I.30 t 129.973 129.053 -I.44 3 0.203 -2.436 1 0.210 -2.616 8 0.807 -2.244 3 0.101 -2.172 I '
-1.30 I 129.173 121.054 -1.420 I I.204 -2.440 8 0.210 -2.616 8 0.106 -2.232 1 0.102 -2.104 I i i SEC:s i 130.002 121.06 -1.704 3 121.923 129.797 -l.512 8 129.138 121.016
! APitt ! 130.002 129.064 -1.6561129.923 121.0H -l.420 t 129.131 129.014 -l.404 3 129.973 121.049 -l.400 1 0.202 -2.424 1 0.221 -2.652 1 0. t06 -2.232 I I t i Et i 130.002 129.064 -1.456 8 121.923 129.004 -1.420 1 129.931 129.014 -l.404 8 $29.973 129.049 -l.4001 0.202 -2.424 1 0.228 -2.652 I 0.106 -2.232 1 0.101 -2.172 1 !.
I Juw I i30.002 In.h3 -i.uS 1 nt.923 In.nt -i.5 8 129.93: ut.012 -1.420 tin.tn In.044 -I.540 i 0.202 -2.424 3 0.20 -2.6161 0.th -2.n2 1 0.iO2 -2.iH I Fi.GE 2
. . . .....-.m.__........_ _ _ . . _ _ . . _ . . .
~
,______s_e_____=_____m_______________________g_______________
- n.-u - n ~ =, m g s, y =, =
a I.
- _=:wM:v,az - - -
v
~ ~
v v~v v v v v -
?
_ : : ~
a
.* : s _ , ,_ w -, a s_ =_ e_ = q g. g :- g a
- g a-g - g
,. ,i _s g g a z,. : -
8 -- -
_m m_
\5m _ m_
m
_ m_
m m_ m s
.w_.E i=E!w_si ,' E. I. E. E. E. B. B. E. E. E.
g ge,
,g ,
a m
_ a_ a_ a
_ a_ a
_ a_ _a a_ ,
._______________________________________________________ i
!;_=!5j!Et i= MS 4 S- M 4 E 4 E I E 4
_jv? ? -
? ? ? ~ ~
v ~
f vy
- = : *
~ ~ -
n ~ - - - '
,s s - S i. . u !. - s_ n, c. =. ~. z. e
~. a. E. c. e.
- as- _-_: ,=5- . - -
- 4. - m
_ m_ m
_ a_ m
_ m_ a_ m sw, U u 8*RE.w_si . E. E. E. E.
a E. E. E. E. E. E.
sees a_ m a_ m m m_
,___.._______________________________=___________________
, ,, , m_ _ _ m_ _
v : :.-:M, ~n 3 sa g = = s, ,s s g a
- s a. a- a- a- a. ,
v
. :_=:w_g~~ ~ - ~ ~
? ~
? ~
= a = = *
- is_ , w:=n
_:~
~ s , ~
E. E.
=
g E. , ~
n ,
o ass:
, _w , , w --
8 m_ m
_ =_ m m_ _m m m
m is*R:w_e: :g ,
a
.. m.
s.
=.
s.
=.
s.
s.
- ,e,
,.g .
m_
m
_ a_
x_ n a
m
_ m_ a_ m_
a ~, m e *
- 2 i: . =5 is
- 8 8 ~ m a, a, R. S. 5 n , , f. -
~ ~
v ~ ~ ~ ~
v ~ ~ v y
_=:wMi-
~ o = n a = g n
.s_::_w!g~- 8 m =,
g - - 8 m ~
n n s. , n g
- s .: wa
,". 8. -
m a a e .- _ m_ _a _ m_ m_ a_ e_ _
sw_:
', V sug:U.:
a :w=:
- s m
g .
n g .
g s
n g .
s n g-m e :, :=e; m a =_ = m a a_ a_ m_ n_ -
, ,__...._s._________________________________________________ ,
=
i~=Eg!ifff!==iE55 K 5E595359E 59 55K505554 6 3 3 -
s a _: :
f <.- -
?ff7f.ffff w f? fifffff'? f f f
= rs_i -
wi=g: g = . n------
= m a n = s. s. y a ,n g s y = =,s. y s , s. g g m_ _mm_ m m _m m m m_ 5_ g .m_ m
- g, 8, m_ m_. -m_ m 2
,_s w : wy.--- _
m_ a_ _ m m_ m_ m m_5- __ __ _ _
s*E g i 2
=
- ==a .n.n. . n n, a. n..= n - a. n. n. a. , n .n n
n
! l, ,e
,eg., nm_ a.m_ e_ m
_ a_ m_ _m_ ___ m m_ m a na_ n_m_ __m _a a_ m m___m_ m mm- _ a_
a
_ m_
y ___..___________________________________________________
J l !Ej!@Ei 4 434344434 7 ; vvr r vi v 44 4E344E444 vvvvv; y
% E v
4 v
.c, l.=~s =g i :wlvvr _- .
- m. E. E.m. m -. E.
g _ ! : ._s.
g ~s. E. m E. c. . c._a._ M . E. ~m. m_ e.
. ~ E. ~
- m. n. .e.. E. . E.. E. . ~g ~.
1, ,w s s, ,
_ w m___ e n m _m_ m_
__ __ m - m m_ m m z__ m a_ m_ _m_ __ _m m_ m m a_ _m m m
.*E:n .w e lg . .v--
8
- e. c. =. =. c. c. e. n. c. e. s.o. c. : : : c. c. e. s. . ;-
.... . e. .
ge
,, ,. m _m_ _ e m_ m_ a_ _m_ ____m_ m_ m m m m m_m _ a_ m _m m_ __m_
_ m m m_ m_ m m_ a_
~= w_
!.-I::-
- O v;-
2 3a 3 v
s994 s 3 ] [..*2 H. g..g vt vvvvv; vr 2.2 9 "v*s22n2232 991979 v v v v v v v. y, v 9
2 v
7 v
9 8
. E_II-*!
swa : , E. E. E. E.
H.E.E.E.E."_E.E.E. E. E. E. .E. E.8 E. E.E.E. . n8 E. E.
o ,, = m_ m_ m_ m _ m m_ _m m_m
_ m_
_ _ m_ m m_ m_mem_x_ m_ m m m_ _ m _
_ n_
w-s ug,ag a gay a --- nuy-a yyyy_ y -au 1__ samass __ _ _ _ s__, s_ a_ _, _ _ _
o l l,, _ 5g i_ n_ i_ n_ i_n_n __ i n_i_n _ n_ n_ n __ n __ s s s_s_s_s_s_s_s_ s_ a_ m_
4 a4ca, san ~m,,--- a n 8 - -
2 I . g 8 3. =2 .5
~~: 5_lvir 2
v
-a%~-4asse Ma v vvr vt-am a m vt 2 -
vvvvvvvr ;
t n 8
y i
y = ~. -
8E..._.
m .-*, 8- a 8 s ~. Ma. z. =. s. n I. _.z..z s_ I. ~z. M a. s. s. s. a. a. a. E.
_- we n_m_m_.. B.
sg - m_ a_ _
m m_ _m_ m_ gm_ m_ m_ a_.
m_ a_ n_ n_ m_ e_
_ m_ m_ mm m_ _
m
_ h.
-~ ~~ ~
g ;y3:wdl:ss$ $ assa
(~~~~~s~s~s~a as (~s~s~a~s($$~s 5 % s-e g m_a_m_ a_ a__ m __ m_ m m m_ __ __ m_
_ m a um m a_ _ __n_ _ a a_ m ma_ a_ n a_ m_
c __y.._ y
= _.. __ _
y__ _ _
s.,
e E, u-- -s _g... --
y... --
W ,g e
- 5 g~lgMWW=. _ ,ga - ] g _, gW. .g_M_W e. saga g ] _=gE eN W e. g.g , ,g ,= g g _g e_ e EW s3W a. g E ,
___________________=__~_=_________=_________=g___-__=_
a w e w m e w
?. . .. . - . . . . . . . - . . . . _.. _ . . ~ . . _.. . a...._..-
r 1
s y a 2 a F 5==: 3 3 g_ gm_5-f ; ~ - -
I_i_.iw-ug
,s y g*: m.
. . E.
m_
s.
a a.
m_
s.
m E.
m.
a 5
E.
m.
,.I j
.W ,
,. E. E. E. I. E. E. E.
- E!.w@ ge
,n i
a.
a a a a_ m_
8 l_-ig_-l i.g!
~ m
~
E.
~
~
~
3 v ~
3 -
V :=
a ~,_.l
- . s. E. a. E. a. a.
r.- _s w .: _m .a. a m
m
_ _m W_: : -
y *E8E: w _e l
- E. E. E. E. E. E.
,: T,e ________ m. .
m.
m m
m m
y
- .-: a g 3 g g n m
_es=g: :=_ m
~
v
~ ~
v
. v a-E_I! : 88 ,I E.
m E. E. E. E. E.
m E.
m a
w,s_,: m, - m_ _a m_ m_ _ _
851.w=i 5 3
- 5 2 3 5
- I. . : :
5g=g ,
m m m m m a
_ m_
-*: - ,e ~
3 n m
a- E.
$- e WM8 v v ~
v r*
s
,E EI!*-*!
s a 3,s: . .
E g
9 m
2 g
E g
9 a
E g
" _yI W- .
. Y w 5 : E ,. : 3 3 3 3 3 3 I i. ,_ _.
. 5 ., m_ .m. m_ m_ a_ m
- e. *
- p 3.
. y: __
i" '!
v 3
4
- g C 9
g 2 L
- g. . . .
- = l =z.: I. =
r ,
E I H!-1l 9 2 9 f E f' E l 5
kr . a:
8]!5El w_ 8 51 n E s s s n
s a.
mis,3" 8 g, e
_d E
i a_
E i_
E a_
i_
n.
n l __ _ ___
8.=*[ s: 2 g g. g -
6 -
n ;
g -l,GMj r v y v v
' := -
- !,.: 9 is a. a. E. a. E. a.
se:
- _,:W W_
= m_ m_ ._ m_ m
_ a_ n c
85iw_e E. E.
m E. E.
m E. E. E.
- 35e[ a_
__a____________________________________________________
m.
. a_ m_ m_
=!
g! 9 7
5 E 3 5 9 7
R i f i f i b .. e.
En:-u g 3 3
- 8 . E. E. E. !!.
m_ a = a_ m. a m 3
- ,ag _ _ . _
_asl
- R
=i e
a a
a a
a a a
o ,5 a n n l~ g a_
n.
n_
n_
is"i 5 a 5
~
~
m - E. i!. E.
-=lG_g, y v v v v v v 3
i_I'-!,,: E.
m E.
m E.
a E.
m a
9 n E.
_s - m _
m.
s wI isR E, . 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 I e5 m m a
a a a m
_.g__ . _
_=_ _ _ . _ ;. _ .. . . .. . .
~~
. g...
s.E d-ga]g~~!_...ENWs 5d-gga]gjE...= _E E Wggga s=.o d - ] g~=~j EEW=81 E . . . - - ga sENWs wa =*Ee. m e m*Iem e m gIz. e 3 a d ggg=gE3 e a m s l___, _ ____
m
I I I___is.g.
e E 2 - =
Ig! :f I -
8 s- 3 :,
1.. wigg-w f
g g
f-E.
g T
E.
g 8
I.
- s :.
- =5=:
.==
i w-:
85: a: 4 4 4 :3 5 M5 I lE gL .
5 5 5 iisi
- - =
34 i
!sfin' 4 5 E i
- - ~ d- i !-
-: ~ . ::
li'lgwa I - -
-nlin a E 4 i i:si s
n n' M 8
- ~~:
is5:8*R*!,n
- w - - - -
l :5 5:
'UjIi n =. I f. V !. !__Eni. w E. E. E.
seein a m m : =g_:::
w :.,. _
.s... _ ____ _ _ ___ __ __ _
. sun 5 5 3 8
59 . .
i
=g::v v E i_*8 w_ ~ ~
I E. '
- e:
i.
s_ _wl:
- : :.c:
_in , , E. I == :
8:n m. m n : =w-a
- s, w -
B Eg u,ew , j a. . 3. .
5' 3 s.
5 i.s.!:!.
IEmi
.w l_ edl5M _ _ _ __ E ____ ________ . __ : i!
.s 9
e-s n l
- 5 ::
=~ ::
I _=-g! aI~
-3
_w.gc v v 3
v g s s, , :.e:
8 a m_ m m_ n.
i..
- s .:
5T d
lsy:U-w-
4 4 4 M
.m 1555
- RlEs tm m m n i
=u :
a e lg d: -
, :am:
y
_________________________I :. : a Ig M E
1_____,,
8 s 55 mf a,8 e. ______E f f a
f
=
If i i 1 1-sl!E s E s i i-
- 5 :
i
- s u
- n n n i g==:
E a- _ v . 5w8 l n. l :
g a n : g -:
8 img3w-:9.!.n 8g= -
a m
- _a=
=g.:
_ .!. E =. .:=. =. n. __ ..____ _ __ __ ___ _ l :
5 i a g g g :=vs. =::
-l.-
-gje g_,7 7 v
v l
- k,t 8 wsn g g a i != 5 5- wgi- g :.e:
5 ss 3,5m m- m -
- w-:
gw;I .- -
l 8
ID E. E. E. : i_ l_ I' i.
- i i.:- w e i n. a n : := a _. :.:
_. De:. : m.. _ . ._ __ _ __ _ _ _ _ __ -g E
la a =, e : :: :
a- , :- :
- =le.-gIr w_I m
r v - l
- :=
lgI: ung 3 3 =
g 5 Ias gin.m is
- 5g.
e m
a n
a a
i
- m=
- = =. :=
i Bs
-a g g g g ::==5 a :=
- t. g I. g.. _ _ =as:
5 .=gly
=_
g v
3 v
8 I
l is
=v i
l~ w
- =
8
.-s 8 ,- w_ 3 a 3 : =_=.
5 - .
s :y aw .. .. ...
gw J
gE g w 5 IIOd>]>"g Es5ga g %) m g.m gga ague.jladagg>"gg-))e.]jldmjg> , ga g_n-]e--i ,
i-
- _=___ _ _
________=..__ w w s_. w wns 1
E 1
I 1
e me ee = ...+e*.2.am ab.se e W e'eP hWm m.aee mie-h ho m.m eem..ar-- - - * - = * *** 'A * * -
aus l
gye e
e o
e W
'6e P
APPENDIX C SETTLEMENT DATA RADWASTE BUILDING. UNITS 1 AND 2 O
s~
'S eo W
e M
ee*
h R i w .
ao Emus 9'
I e
)
I
__.._..s.,_.._,....__.___ - -.
APPENDIX C
- g SETTLEMENT DATA RADWASTE BUILDING UNITS 1 AND 2 NOTES 2.
A. GENERAL y, 1. All reference elevations and survey readings are in feet.
+ 2. All delta (movement) values are in inches.
- 3. For the delta values, + indicates heave and - indicates settle-
., ment.
.. 4. For each structure, settlement narkers and settlement benchmarks are used interchangably. They are not to be confus-d with the a
reference benchmarks used for elevation control, shown on Figure 13.
n B. RADWASTE BUILDING UNIT 1
- 1. Assumed a "zero" date for the beginning of settlement monitoring in January 1972. This is based on Figure 2A-16, sheet 2, of the Unit 2 FSAR, Amendment 35, issued in July 1977.
- r
_ 2. New settlement markers (benchmarks) were established in July 1978 for each marker. The reference elevations were adjusted to account for the previous movement.
~
C. RADWASTE BUILDING UNIT 2
_. 1. Assumed a "zero" date for the beginning of settlement monitoring '
in October 1975. This is based on Figure 2A-16A, sheet 5, of the
> Unit 2 FSAR, Amendment 35, issued in July 1977.
- 2. 'All survey readings from October 1975 to March 1977 were estimated from figure referenced in item 1 above.
- l 1
l 1
?
c F 1 b
c d
. y T y y y D' ' , ' p q q 7 .g g j , g> q q ,
,- v E.1. uma uuttiae Plast-8ETILEEu!
= = = = . = = = = . - = = = = = .============ . - - --..-=.=======.u===================
I I gatueSit MIL 8!E Wii 2 8 000sAEXE Ou!LSIuS unli 2 i Satualit Mittles uuti 2 i M0mastE OultlluG WII 2 i Sagua6TE WilllE m!! ! I MeuaETE tulL0 tee WII I I gatua5tf Bu!L8!E Wii 8 I hemastE Inittles mII i t I Wat i 50mitaEST neatII I Sturggg maanta I uteTWall naas10 t ut0Tuuf 51 neatit i SeuimSI RAAkit i 50gTEa51 ustkit I ue014a61 RAAE0 8
- N00inutST mattit I g g !=. == 8 -
g =
=l.-===.-====l.=.-======.==t-=====.=8== -=====l=====-- t 8 IANTE IERHE $504f OELie IMFEBEEE SIAnf IElit IKROEIEE SIMET SELI4 ISEFEMuG SuSWI KLIA BEFE8EuCE SuSET SELTA IMMENCE SuMET SELTA ISEFE8EEE StuMET KLIA ISEFEREE! St0(f Elle I l 8 ELEf. KalluE IKES I ELiv. OEaglE LUCES 8 ELEV. SE40 lug I M SI fliv. KatleG I M SI ELiv. KatlE IMS I Elit. Katsus lus I ELEV. IEatius IIDES l ELit. OEaglE IMS 1 1 I .I ==========8-===== .=I.====== ==ta.=====.a====.8===========l== ======8 8 ~72 8 8 .I I I I I I I 8 Janung? I $
I I I I II II II ep 88 g i Klauett i I I I 1 I I I -
I RAACu I 8 8 I I I I I I e I aPOIL 8 I I I I l 8 I i '
I mr I I I I I I I I I I JuuE I I I I & 1 I I I ',
8 JuLT I I I I I I l 8 l 1 1 MEl l l I I I I I i I (
l CPIEn0ESI I I I I I I I I 3 i K!00E0 I I I I I I I I I I i ISWENGES I I I l 8 8 8 8 1 j l CCEn0E0 8 I I I I I I l 4 8, 8 *I3 8 8 I I I 8 8 8 I I Jaguaat 8 p 8 I i 1 0.030 -4.456 1 0.030 -0.42 1 0.027 -4.324 1 0.030 -8.4 % 8 8 I TEMuatt i I I I I 0.H -0.40 1 0.036 -0.432 I S.027 -0.324 1 0.839 -0.460 I t naacu I I I I I 0 M3 -0.5361 0.M -4.40 8 8.03 4.M I 0.030 -0.4 2 I t
[
I artit 8 l l I I 8.M3 -0.5861 0.M -0.40 8 0.03 4 .36 1 0.038 -0.4 % i i .a. i i i i 1 0.M3 -0.m i 8.M -. 40 i 0.n -0.M i 8.0. -. 4s i
{,
8 JuE I I I I I 8.H7 -0.564 8 . 0.H3 -0.516 I I 0 H2 -0.504 I
- I Jutt i I il 1 1 0.M7 4.24 I S.M3 -0.516 I I 0.M2 -0.504 i f I auSust i I I I I 0.053 -0.636 I 0.058 -0.612 8 0.035 -0.42 8 0.M5 -0.54 I l Critn0Ett t l lr 8 8 0.055 -0.M i 8.052 4 .624 1 0.037 4 .444 3
- 8.M5 -0.54 i i K10KI I I I I I 0.057 -0.604 1 0.058 -0.612 I 8.430 -0.4 2 I S.M4 4.5M l '
8 InvEnKB i i I I i 8 I I l I I Cum a l 8 8 I I I I I I I I ~74 8 8 8 I I I I I I l 8 Januser I i I i I 0.m7 -0.604 5 0.05: -0.682 1 0.8m -4.a61 0.045 .54 8 I Tithua011 I I I l 0.055 4.M I S.M7 -0.564 8 8.034 -0.400 1 0.M3 4.516 8 I naatu ! I I I I 0.055 -0.M i 8.05 -0.6 I 0.037 -0.444 8 0.0 % 4 .552 8 f 8 aptil i I i I i i i I 8 I
{ l MT I
- I I I I I I I I i 8 JuE 4 I I I I 0.25 -0.M i 8.053 -0.6M I S.M3 -0.5161 0.M1 -0.500 8 I JULT I I I I I 0.050 -0.696 8 0.053 -0.6M i 0.H2 4.504 I 0.040 -0.576 I I AUGUSI I I l' I I 0.06 -0.72 8 0.053 -0.6M I 0.HI -0.4921 0.05 -S.68 t I CPIEnttil i I I
- 8 I l 4 I I i
I K10E0 8 8 8 8 I 0.067 -4.004 8 0.063 -0.756 1 0.053 -0.636 1 0.051 -0.612 1 l s0wn0E0 I I I I I 0.062 -4.744 5 0.062 -4.744 1 0.053 -0.636 I 0.05 -0.6 I I CCin0E0 t I l I I 0.061 -4.732 8 0.061 -0.732 1 0.052 -0.624 1 0.Mt 4.5001 8 '75 8 8 8 8 I I I I I
, t 44mit**v I I I I I 0.054 -0.640 8 0.054 -0.640 8 0.H4 -0.520 8 8.M3 4.586 I [
t FEteuatt i I I I I 0.054 -0.640 1 0.054 -0.640 1 0.M4 -0.5201 8.M2 -0.5041 l t nanCu I : 1 I I 0.05 -e.6 8 0.05 -0.63 0.H -0.40 8 0.04 -0.40 I [
t art!L I I I l ! 8.050 -0.696 5 0.059 -0.700 8 0.M7 -0.564 I 0.M7 4.24 3 ;
l 8 MV i I l 8 1 0.036 -0.432 1 0.033 -0.196 1 0.029 -0.340 1 0.026 -0.312 I [
l 1 JulE I I I I l 0.M2 -0.5M I 0.030 -0.4M i 8.012 -4.304 1 0.031 -0.372 1 - i 8 Jutt ! 8 l 8 8 0.H7 -0.504 3 0.04 -0.40 8 0.034 -G.400 8 0.032 -0.304 1 ,
PAGE I
E.i. .rc.uKt, w M a uMM 5-I SeemSTE IstL8!uE mit 2 8 teenSTE BCLilas m!! 2 i BatmsfE au!Ll!E im!! 2 8 hesA5fE fUttalus mII 2 I seem5it Bu!Ll!E WII I I tathASTE Br!Ll!E mli I I BA8m5ft Suittis WII I I HAnsit ButtBlut sti 18 8 UEat i SmileEST NAAtf8 8 90gTKaSi SAf4E8 I BIIfKa$i RARKf8 8 NORTME11 RAALES I SauTNIEli nAAti8 I SOUTMAST nai4Et 1 ESIIKaEl RAABE8 8 NORittEli RAAKIS I I i I .
- ._ . _ ._i. _. _i ._ _ _ i _ _ ._ .
iI MuTu :KFE8EEE SURET Klie :KTEKKE $WWET KLIA INFEKKE SuhET BELTA lKFEKKE $3 WET KLf4 ISEFEaEKE SuhET KLia KFEKKE EUMET KLIA IKTEKIEE SevET BELIA IKTERENE SWHEt DElla t i I ELET. BEastus ful!-_ELif. Ka6IE IMSI ELiv. BEuleS IKK5 t ELEt. K681uS IMS I ELIV. KAtluG IKIES I ELit. IEasluG IM5 I ILET. Katie IKIES I ELEV. KMIES luS 8
- _.._l_...._.,. l ._ _ . .. t iaii i .i i i 8.H5 4 54 i ..Hi 4mi ...a 0.4u i ..no -0.4. i I UttaIEli i l I i 0.H9 -0.580 I O.042 -0.504 8 8.837 4.444 I"F8.835 -0.42 8 i K100ER 8132.309 832.309 8 8 132.24 !!2.24 8 8132.2u 132.2u 9 8 132.268 132.268 8I t i I I I nevEnsts I !!2.3M 132.385 -0.840 8 132.24 132.24 8 8132.2u 132.2u 8 8 132.268 132.265 -0.8 % 8 i t i I I BENNIES I 132.3M !!2.308 -0.012 8 132.24 132.24 8 I 132.2u 132.265 -8.8121132.268 132.24 -0.824 8 8.H5 4 .54 i S.042 -0.504 8 8.8 % 4 .432 I I.033 -0.396 I i *h 8 I I I I I I i 1 1 JamAM i 132.3M 132.309 8I 132.24 !!2.239 -4.012 8132.2M 132.264 4 824 8 132.268 132.264 4 048 I I.946 -0.552 8 8.HI 4492 5 0.037 -0.444 I
- 8.634 -0.400 1 I TEteutef 8 II2.3M !!2.385 -0.040 I 832.24 !!2.24 8 8 IE2d 132.268 -0.06 8 132.268 !!2.262 -8.072 3 8.84 -0.552 1 0.H4 -0.4921 0.037 -8.444 4 8.833 -0.396 t ,
I antal I l 832.24 132.230 48241 !!2.2u 132.252 -0.168 I 132.268 132.254 -0.560 I S.tu 4.552 8 8.H -0.48 8 4.837 4 .444 1 0.034 -0.400 t I aPS!L i 132.3M 132.296 -0.1% i 132.24 132.234 -0.0i2 8132.2u !!2.251 -4.18 8 132.268 132.252 -0.192 I O.045 4 .54 8 8.HI -8.492 l 0.037 -4.444 1 0.834 -0.480 1 +
8 att i 132.3M 132.297 -8.144 1 132.24 132.233 -4.004 8132.2u 132.258 -0.10 8 !!2.268 !!2.252 -0.192 1 0.H5 -0.54 8 8.042 -0.504 I S.818 -4.4 % 1 0.835 -0.42 1 !
I Just i 132.309 832.297 4 144 I 132.24 132.227 -8.12 I 132.2u 132.25 -4.192 I 132.268 132.241 -8.228 1 8.H9 -8.500 8 0.945 -0.54 8 0.04 4481 0.838 -0.4 2 I j I JULT L l!2.3M 132.295 -8.168 8 8 I I 5.051 -0.612 8 8.H7 -0.%4 8 0.037 -8.444 8 8.04 4 48 I t I august I I !!2.24 132.237 -4.8% 1132.24 1E257 -8.100 I I 0.839 -4.468 I 9.848 -8.492 1 0.03 -0.34 1 0.828 -0.336 I t i SEPitneE8: 132.309 132.304 -8.06 8 132.24 1224 0 8132.2u IE2% -0.12 8 132.268 132.26 -0.096 I I I I I I I c70sta I 132.3e9 132.386 -4.su 8 8 I I a.e42 -4.5e4 8.e44 -0.52s I e.s34 -0.4e8 : e.838 -e.3721 !
I blMneES I I i 1 1 I I I I I CttaeER I !!2.309 132.384 -8 86 8 132.24 IE24 !
I I 132.24 IE25 412 I 132.268 132.259 4.les 1 0.HI -0.492 8 0.0 4 -8.552 I I.835 -0.42 8 8.029 -0.348 J t '77 8 I I I I I I I l 3 I Janua#7 8132.3M 832.299 -0.12 8 132.24 132.238 4024 8132.2u 132.251 -8.18 I !!2.248 IE252 4192 I I I I
- I l 1 FEtsuatt I 132.389 132.295 -8.168 i !!2.24 132.236 -0.04$ 8 !!2.2u 832.24 *-8.241132.268 132.247 -O.252 I l I I I l 8 mand 8132.3M 132.298 -8.216 8 132.24 132.236 -0.840 1 132.2 4 132.244 -0.264 1 132.268 132.243 -4.31 I I I I -
8 APSIL 4 832.3M 132.289 4.24 5 132.24 IE235 -0.06 8132.2u 132.243 -8.276 8132.268 132.242 -8.312 8187.917 107.875 -4.584 8107.964 107.918 -0.5521 187.963 107.929 -0.408 8187.967 107.9M 4340 I l 8 saf I !!2.3M 132.385 -0.HS I 132.24 132.235 -0.86 I 132.2 2 132.2 4 -8.24 8 132.268 132.243 -4.38 8 I I I e-I JuuE I 132.389 132.384 -0.06 1 132.24 132.232 4.094 8 832.2u 132.243 -0.2M 3132.263 132.143 4.3 I 8 JULT t I!2.3M 132.384 -0.86 8 132.24 132.238 -0.l00 t IE2u 132.24 4 24 8 132.268 132.246 4 .264 8 187.917 107.872 I I I 1 l' I AUGUST I 132.3M 432.385 4HG I 132.24 132.2% -0.848 I 132.2d 132.242 -8.290 I 132.268 132.244 4 .288 8
-8.54 8 107.964 187.915 4 .500 I 107.963 187.927 4 432 8 187.967 107.935 4 .304 8 i
},
8 i I l I CP7EnK81 132.389 132.384 -0.86 8 132.24 132.232 -8.896 8132.2M 132.242 -0.200 t 132.268 132.245 -0.276 8 I I I I i I KYOK8 8132.389 132.3 -8.190 t 132.24 132.23 -0.12 8132.2u 132.2M -0.36 8 132.268 132.24 -0.336 1 107.987 107.87 -8.M4 8187.964 107.916 -0.576 8 107.963 107.927 -0.432 1 187.967 107.934 4 .396 8 8 EMEneEB I 832.389 132.3 -4.100 8 132.24 132.232 -0.096 i IE24 132.237 -8.348 1 132.268 132.238 -8.36 I I I I I ,
a CCIRK8 8132.309 132.3 -0.100 I 132.24 132.23 4.12 8 832.2u 132.22 -0.h I !!2.264 132.236 -8.384 i I t 8 I l.
I 70 t i I -
1 I I I I I e
! Januaaf 1132.;tt 132.388 -0.04 !!2.24 132.23 -4.12 I 132.2 2 !!2.235 - 4.372 1 132.268 132.237 -0.372 I I flaaust I I!2.3M 132.'I -3.185 6' 132.24 132.23 -0.12 1 132.2 4 832.235 -0.372 1 132.268 !!2.234 4 .36 8 I
I I I I j; I I I ll I naeul ! 132.3M 132.3 -0.100 1 !!2.24 132.23 -0.12 8132.2M 132.233 -0.396 I 132.268 132.237 -0.372 I I i 1 1 I I art!L 8 132.389 832.307 -8.324 8 132.24 12235 -0.86 8132.2u 132.243 -0.276 I 132.268 832.244 -0.218 I 187.917 107.874 4 .!!6 1 107.964 107.916 4 .576 1 107.963 107.929 4 408 8 107.967 187.938 -0.348 1 [
t att i 132.389 432.383 -0.872 I 132.24 132.233 4.884 8132.2u 132.243 -0.276 I 132.268 132.247 -0.276 I i I i i 6 Jute I 132.389 132 112 g.gu 8 IE24 132.22 -8.048 8132.2u 132.245 -0.2521132.268 132.249 -0.220 I I i i 1 I JLtt i 132.3M 132.304 -0.06 8 132.24 132.238 -8.8001 132.2u 83'.243 -0.2M I !!2.268 132.243 -8.3 1 107.982 187.801 -8.432 8 807.964 187.926 -0.4 % i 107.963 187.932 .l.372 1 187.967 107.944 -0.276 I {
I AUEU57 8 432.389 132.299 -0.12 1 132.24 132.232 -8.096 I 132.2M 132.239 -0.324 I 132.264 132.24 -0.3 % 1 8 I I I I CPTEa0ERI 132.3M 132.3H 4861 132.24 132.235 -0.86 8 IE2n 132.242 -0.298 8132.268 132.2 4 -8.264 I I i I i I KTOKR I 832.389 132.299 -0.12 8 132.24 132.234 -0.072 1 132.2 2 132.238 -8.3M i 132.268 832.242 -4.312 1 132.318 132.278 -0.48 8 132.389 132.267 -0.544 I 132.339 132.204 -9.42 1 132.31 132.254 -3.312 I f
t 8 NovEnsEt I 132.389 132.387 -0.824 8 132.24 132.238 -0.824 IE2a 132.24 -0.24 8 132.268 132.249 -0.228 I I I I I
- I CCIneEt I 132.389 IE383 -0.472 I IE24 132.233 -O.0441132.2d 132.242 -8.200 1 132.268 132.2 4 -0.264 I I I I i !
I '79 I I I I I ! I I I 2 I Janusar i 132.309 132.298 4 252 I 132.24 132.2 3 -0.144 I 132.2 2 132.224 -0.584 I 132.268 132.227 -8.497 8 132.318 832.28 -0.C6 t 132.389 432.268 -0.492 1 832.319 132.207 -8.384 8 132.31 132.206 -8.298 1 8 FEmmWf I I I I I I t ! I l PAGE 2
.- a g g a a g n
=
s-
=g m.
n
?
f ~
v f f e 4
!! 88 E E E E E E E av t=1
== d d
,. am - - d_ d_ d_ d_ n_
l ix a
- i
- Is 9 9 9 9 9 i
j .E E , a d a -
a a a
_.a.
N ... _ J _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ____ _ _ __ _ _
.- 3 x 5
- E R 3 5- E![g f Y Y Y Y Y Y {
n! wg _.! =
9 I -
~
9 a = l d
- ig Am E E E E 4
- d-g .
. w _e a. a. a. a. a. a. a.
lE_.s._____
-as g , a_ a a_ a_ a
_ a_ a_
P -
i 3 g n -
l
=
a=I 1.=gl
- _ E ?
4 4
n Y
f 3
?
3
?
81 w n ~
g e , E. s g _w : g ~
E. 9 ~ ~
a,--
m a.
. a_ a
_ d.
a a
a
- *5' we
- m 3 ,g E.
g _.. a E.
a E.
a .
E.
a E.
a_
E.
a_
E.
a_
=
8
.-l E. 5 3 a e 3
, E.
s- s3_l -
e v 4 - -
e s *! -u]
S-'g g 9 9 E. E.
9
=
~
A
~
ag.e w a- a_ a
_ a_ a_ d a
.. Y *~ I I . 2 2 2 2 i
- InwE, :, =, ,I d
n a_
n a_
n 2
n a
2 n'
a 2
n a_ _ a_
]
~ *
=
s-
!."3
=w gi
,A s 3
=
y 2
y 2
w-g !
? f e ?
i o
a s
. . g- E.
a E. E. E. E. . E. 9
~
a g-ly ,l=
- - a_ a_ a_ a, =
a .,
1l,I w5 wl em s 2
- _.,.,.l.________._._______._._._.._._
a_
2 a_
2 n
2 a
2
=
2 a
2 a
i'
- ~ f.=8 = g a
"' = a a Es!E!! Y Y f Y Y 7
- r. Eli s'
- g
- g g g -
n iwg:l!
a .
a
. 9
, a.
. _ d.
. a.
. a_
1 w ,s 3 3 s 3 s lE:9.
~ ~
- =2 a n a
_ d_ d
_ a
- s. ~s-
= :=_g e
e -
= a a 9 : f. - --
ass.m v - - - - d -
Ell _wg m
~ e n
a n
s =_I E8, w A A
- A.
E.
A
~
A 9
A 9
A_
- R 5 =. =. =. =. =. =. =.
t 1 .s. .Es_.
a a a_ a_ a a_
~
w __I_ __
_ _ _____-_a ______ __ __ ___
= l,-8 a g g e a s s -
Mligl i_w
= n e
e a a n- n a n n 3-s_:lg.,i a a d a B =
1
- p is89 e E E E E E g l,El
,= ,
d
_ d_ d
_ d_ d E
n_
_g _ _
gg2 _yEWWs
- - _y5 5. _yE,n uI g _ - f f a gg:, g s. g
.., g gy-Eg
, w : E =gsm ,gg-Enggg=-51s. _
g g a g ,;; =g
_ _ .i. .l.a _ w =
w*sem -
=._ . __ m
. m ,
=
.-l = a ~
= =g 3, f a. a. 4- ,
a- s _ . v v t 11 s e = g g a g Ea 8E3 au 2 5 d d d d my - - - -
a a
~5 EIg a a a E l
,: _ _ .. g ;
- =sl 3i a_ a d
a_ a d 8 . A_ . _ _ a., =. R a. 3 a.
E 8E :_I_j i E !! s8 .
f a g .
f
=
~
f g .
f a
~
f m
~
as _
8 a a a_
a, w - a_ a_ a_ _
g . . . .
E ne a. a. a. a. a. a.
g 15
_ y g e ,-
a_ a_
a_ a_
a_
a_
a 3 5 g a 5
= i.g m .
,m
.s=I=w_ e f , - f i a 2 2 I_._I i, '** a.
a n.
a
=.
i
-s r ,e =g -
n.
- a_ a_ a_
E :
a _ l 9, g! ,
5: E E E d
E d
E d
E d
l: _ .,. ,.. l=e: _ .3.
d d
l- e g 3 a 3 e E l=*s,i.g! [E_l n
t t
=
s-
?
l l
a g g m
w !=1l_sl g ~ ~
- yl U. gI
'a_t a Ea% :
s H ==
le,e, m -
m n
a a_
e n
a n
e a
a_
e n
a_
m n
a_
a_
=
n_ .
i
g '
8
= m a a E
5 I.
]s l~--1..3_1 I=s= w
= a-
? .*
4 -
v s-
?
2 a
!si:
l.=_-:
sy,
l
m5 :i n.
a_
=
~
a_
a d_
a.
a_
a.
a_
=
n a_
...U.l s s, s~ s~ s l
g:w -
8-
, 3 n a a a_ a_ a_ a_
_ _ .i. .a. 3 .. ________ _ __ _ _ _____ __ ___ _ ___ _ _ _
E =
,"s=ig."g3 8 3,
j 3
f
=.
7 s
2 a-s_i s O E n- d n
=
ing sa 1-1 iugi, 3=: e a a a_
a a
, ,. E :
s
=
s
=
a s
=
s
=
s
- aE:u 1 a =. I *:
I :ce: ,,
- 'a t
'a_t a
"_ 'a t
a
'_t a_
E :~ : .-
- =
samgsg:g :- _.
a 4
g n
a
=
a s
't III I wi a a E a a n l E InglIi!
=U.:
e
=
d d e E e
=
5 . =. =. =. =. .
a 1:: gg Eag - a_ a_ a_ a_ a_
I E le
~ ' _j -
=
g a, g =
g .
gag l,=,g i
i IIII*-!!
- =a am:g s
E
=
a 5
4
=
. a E
=
5 d_
E d
=
a a
I .m y 5 .
85Hsw.e:
- s
_II 8 E. E. E. E. E. E.
g 3-d- a a_ a_ a_ a_ a_
[
,g l..__=_____=_____=_.._
a 51
=
y--- -
1 =
s5
= : W W:]gg,g ,, g;_l 5
- gne- 5 W:]3 5,3 3;ly--
mi=t ,
r, g E
- w. e n- g g g,,g
= ,,g;_j :;; 5 w5e.5 2 1G=,3 san 3.1e. -=__= .
_.=._____ __ =_
_ _=_ _
E
r 1
, s. . :
a I, iv
!!'s!
mm -I1 I=, i:5!
r my -
I- sf
.j ls L
" El .
ll_.1mls'.._3 8,
___ !3"i la '
a- g I tv
!I e
ag r-n. 1 sL
==
m , am- qga5 e- e El ,
I :lsi i
5".as!
- Jani g_--
7+
- -_g!j--------
i=n :is :
1,.
ge l!II-ni jai,jgs 8 d a
i ig=,, si g.,
,. == gin. mm s:_sug p
8g ,II" : jIn3 -
_ __ i $__,
i :E E
-IIjEs-
!s!"li
-in ! i+ g en. -vi i 1 s:
a
==-g a gge:
+-
V
- g!am I l i
g lIsiv lme - :lmi . !
.. : __.s.i._al ,I_I=! -
- E t-8 ve int!sl"8 lm i
..I I,
iv i.e5 s
.r.
a ,,eg .
1
- i 3_.
ai! Igg
i i is -i P- w a g .: l I g
- g : :
)
I:!aEg1, i :- l s-3=s:
H.
4
. i, 2
,-, sa i
- n-I s+ s L.
5 LII!s!!
- i.j-n 3 s,- s! ,
ay l*eg!gwl gg ;
f a ll.:! l !E ir
- E-El:
I I
E-l!
2 3.
- y :7--------l ;- g sv -
i.,v-is!,,
6 isga3-n: -
I 1 E
- t. eglaIl a,,I l s!
= = gt .
% , I ggas I -
N wE l _..MEE8I I .: : :- :E{:
53 5
-: .: l 5 21 .
- :2 : 3 0E .
8E I-lW! s
! =f j g!
5 le!! !
l -
- :n-!
sa=yj.IEmg g gg g l
"I:s u. "
lE-I
- I :i i
M_ 53=.:5 l___=3 ________
. l .IN-liita
=
__3_ _lm r g Iis -
m
F F
1 F -
F, dPPENDIXD no SETTLEMENT DATA TURBINE BUILDING UNITS 1 AND 2 b.
l I_
b g:
s I
s 7-
.?
?
5.
R e
F F
. APPENDIX D
\- SETTLEMENT DATA
( TURBINE BUILDING UNITS 1 AND 2 -
m NOTES a.
m A. GENERAL
- 1. All reference elevations and survey readings are in feet.
le 2. All delta (movement) values are in inches.
- 3. For the delta values, + indicates heave and - indicates settle-
., ment.
~
- 4. For each structure, settlement markers and settlement benchmarks are used interchangably. They are not to be confused with the reference benchmarks used for elevation control, shown on Figure 13.
P B. TURBINE BUILDING UNIT 1
- 1. Assumed a "zero" date for the beginning of settlement monitoring in January 1972.
- 2. The reported survey reading for the southeast marker in' July 1978 6 was 111.926 feet. Based on previous and subsequent readings this was assumed to be incorrect. Changed survey reading to 111.826
,, feet.
3.
New settlement markers (benchmarks) were established in July 1978 for the northwest, northeast and southeast markers. The reference 2- elevations were adjusted to account for the previous movement.
- 4. A new settlement marker (benchmark) was established in June 1979 for the southwest marker. However, no readings have been taken due to high radiation.
C. TURBINE BUILDING UPIT 2
- 1. New settlement markers (benchmarks) were established in May 1977 for each marker. It was assumed that no movement of the markers occurred between May 1977 and the previous reading, April 1977.
An adjustment was then made to the reference elevation to account for the previous movement.
1
f
- 2. / new settlement marker (benchmark) was established in June 1977 F- for the northeast marker. It was assumed that no movement of
~ pe marker took place between June 1977 and the previous reading, my 1977. An adjustment was then made to the reference elevation '
to account for the previous movement.
- 3. The northeast marker (benchmark) was destroyed in March 1978. A new marker was established in April 1978. It was assumed that no lF
- movement occurred between April 1978 and the previous reading, February 1978. An adjustment was then made to the reference ele-m vation to account for the previous movement.
,, 4. No survey readings have been taken on the northwest marker (bench-mark) since January 1979 due to high radiation.
w.
6
- 6.
PF m.
b.
b
.i -
p.
s N'
?
i Y
is et i.A
- T 6
2 T
a Y
a
F ___--_--------_-___-_-------_---_-__--_------__------
!.- - s ssessgg3.9=
I=ss:s_g: i
- s99 . . ?:
v et ve?ve t E. E.aa tv 8 8 E. E.
r
~F !!I 3e=l.gsi
- ! I IIIIEZIEEE e asssssssse RESSEE es- se s aglIm; -
sw ggs g F : -E5 , M- _s .
-s E 1- ---______ s--__----____----__--__------_-----_
i e casse:
j=s gGj _j i- -
e .
9 9gegtemase
. T???
- - * ?p *: "" *" s * *: s
. T ???? ??'??*
i8
- .E8_a s-e
- 3 I -sa..aa
= c - - e. s. s- . s. =. asa.
me idga -3:
E m s esssssse s ss ss-X s:: v .: :
.:
- gswag 3
- seel s :
r'
- = :-
e ==sggam-
- = gs .ss.es ge:
~
assisl- e 99- . . *9 ?pt e-?-e- - e--
!!!!.w! 3 3 n 8 as-as is :
g,j, ,5; 1
33==-4.s-
--8 s .8 s ss.ss 8 Iw
- - ::qs :
R
- En
- m. .
- -__* 1_--____________--_--__----________---_--..---..--
l- :m.: .
a sa,EE.g~f.a .. ~,
wi . .s mz .
8E= i fffff??fff if +f in : :
7 :=glEM; - I II_z____333 za99
_.~ __
as 33
. u se== 3 .g s sesss- sse se es W :Eg: W:
E 8w-iw
- _g.s*wg.:!
3 U
- g see
. :W -
a :~
.. .: -:999,9 =se y.
a ass:zl:
- 8 :
- =_:: --???
a : : w: .
e
. g. =. =. q =.
33_: g s
ag-:
- 1: ,:: ======
swE:U s : ......
nama=a I:E !: ,EI1_--------_____ 555555 i_
1n ---____________----________-----
- := .x,~-,3 g.:g a: s===s.-
3
,. III si. ;
ggagag
- =-; ..a.a.
- . g ,s ,5: ,, ======
w i ,- ., .
8-E!
8E EEEEEE aaaaaa 7
!__:Esi 8
- d:
- =.
- N=:____---_______-----___--___________----__=====.=- .~.~ ~
s l- : w: az=s, sess-P 8vgl
- =
Emism ,i:
.~
=s.~.i ass
- aa=aaa s la=g;.g=:
, , sl == ===:
ingin=.:
g := ,9~, a. ~t a.9, 2 1 l__ag
.-ml g ======.
e l=~ !.=8 - as s,s, = =,
-s
.s=:
i gis l -
7 8891 : -8 s8 ggac==
l=
,g3: gi
..a---
==_
IE s i E55555 m
l]N!I lgEg aaaaaa 3 --___ ---_-_-_
g_______--___;_----------
y.. >>
_y... ~~
_-----_==--==_ =
~~
y
- w I s.-
- = . g ,ga g_g=- 5W W
m.gg
=
~
-ga ggmEWW=.glu,,
g-uw z 3 mI5a,g g =gEffcgE5,ggg
_g_y...3
'
agg ,, ;
, 1__---__3__=------_----_-___-----__-__=-_------_---------
m .
m
i: is !8~ E EIEEE~~I E 8 5 f jie:g!"!?7 4 fifff77f f 7 E
i E
f E
i E
f E
f I
f E
f f
- sIg! 8:! 5E
- s
~ _
a sis _a_s_EEE a_ 8 m E E 5 m E a '
1
- em.*s: s s sessssss s - = a a a = a n g
- sw-:g Y:.Rw-:
= = = -
= _
i f :I-5gEg;I .
s a- .
s.
s s_
4 a
4 a
4 4 a_ a_
4
=
g
=
g 1
i
- . _ _.z. _g _ _ _ a _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
_ _ = _ _ =_ _ _ =_ _ _ _ = _ _ =_ _ _ _= _ _ _ _ _ _
i
!=
- -ian me a sasaass:
m-mmm , m e a a a e
a n g s a
- g ~
8 g T*. gs=l=_g ?? wi ? ?????sy? *
? ? ? ? ?
. m
? ? ?
? ?
!*i!_wi.ce se: s*ss e
e .rsesss"
. e. .e .e r s. s. e e .e
.. s s . E a
s a
sa i a
B a
a m g
- mw., mi
= = = = = = -
iW~ig.
f.- ag E w=:: =
=
e
=
m
=
m n
m
=
n
=
=
!_ : =,= =,
=_
_ =_ =
=
x x
- - :.=:gg -
E g =* **m*s, = a s s e s a a 8 8 2 2
- = :=s-:=_g:vv D
s.. .
v ?????? v a- a -
E.
T v
,8 v
7 v
E.
v v
a-T
- 83 : .w:~E 3
. _.s : -
a s =. =.... c e r u. ~s s. s. .a .a .a a
=
a
. e. =
- ea g :g . sees s seeses s - = a a a a a a g
- w. = .= = = = = = = _ _n
- w-:E : . . . . . . - -
-5 s: s s : - -
!:!l:lEi 5 s s 5 s s E E
- asw:.,I ~
= .as~ .~~., a. : = = ,. m s . .
s
. g .
s s
~
=
E. ji=iEEjff f 44f++++f ? f f f f f f
!!I! w:e-
.... s.e emeeg-c. z, n n
- =_gwg:.s m - -
s s n, q g g .
.aNsaw ..
_. . =,
e -= =
=
=
!w :E 1 9 E M E I E I
e
- E-5lEe:
- - gg dj a
=
a
=
w
=
a
=
a
= ~
n :- r------------------------------------ -------------
g :=
~
is=:g_g: :- ???-:. s,. :: gs,: , ==s,an=
a= ~nm~n. esp :
m g g
~e =,~e s,s,a,a, ~s,sassss n
a ??s,4,- = , s, n~ 3
????-??? ? ????????? ? ?? ?? ?
s :
a :51::
- =_g = 2 .; w i = .= = = 2, E,a' 2, n a,g g
- s =
. g..=33 s
= : 3 ,s a3 ,s ,s ,= ,s ,e,,, s = s s, ===
e
=
33, g ig :,3 .= = = =,_=_ = = _= =_ _= = = _= =_ =
, _ __ = _ = =_ = = = = = = m_ m_
_ ______ _ m m_ m_
____ _ m m m m n e_ m_
!*gju.iercee =======e= e re====cem eccetere === c
.w=:----- ------m--
,: e,= = =__= =_ =__=_ = _ __=___ = _= = = _= = =
=
--m-mmm-m
=___=_=___ =_ m m_ m m m mmmmmmen me- m z_ _m __ m m m_ _ m__nm _ e_
_ m_m=
. :~ g . : ~ . t n a.
- - .s s a a
.. m a. s. ~ ~,.,s_ _u =
- ~~u....
==_ssssss. l.a .. ~.
as==s s.a ~a. = ~
ig.:g_5::sess?
- .g ; s. e. t s. ? ? v s. , s. e. s. a. s. s. s. s. e. s. e. s. e. s. s s. s. s e. s. s.
- s w g ws :: j- s
,_ n:d_ a_
- ~ ~ g _ . . g ~ .
s s .s s a .s s s. . a a ..-..*m...
sssem
=nn_EEEEEE em
_ ~~_-.
.: ==:=s .a= =
m.
ige,!
. =:=e_=d5_ _ _ e E d_ _e = E _d d
_ _ _= E_ ,n nnnni si_n n l*j,w.!
i gusgsssss la m
- g=:ggggg .....
gee ==_=== =_ _= = _= = _= _= = =
ggg . .8ggggg ....
g . .mm.mmmmm ss mm =====
mm-mm -mm mmm_ m__ _a m_ m e___= = =_
=== am
,, _ ___ _ _ __ =_ = __m_ m m m__ m_ m m_
_ __ m_
- ~ .
in==s-~- g===g==s~ -
- --- ---- --":"**:2" '5: :
i insa=g:-
- = :
,se
-- ??????
. - -- E. E.*- * * * ~ c ~
vetterve? ???- --
~ !wg;!w_SSBEE-
- z E .,,.~..~E n =~~mmeen
= E :8_c_cc-cc c ---
crec EEm.E DEE E igg
- w, l
. w' :i =____= = i _= =d=E=s==_d __ ___ _ _= =_ n E _n n n n n _n i_ ____
_ ____ _n n_ n i n E n i_ n_ n n _ _
1s5:g :
e:fe.Ec. c _,c r. ,E c. ,=- . .. . .. .
- c _ c esEEEEEEE s E c. E cs. s. E . sE. .
s E
- S ,g,5 = i s =_ s _i =_ _i s =_ _=
i___jl2 ___ _ _ _ _==_ =_ = _=n_in_ini_n_n_ nin_n_nnn__n _nnn_ n_
8~
- - I_.-im_a_s_s_s- w. as_ffa.
_ m..a..c..a.a ~. = a. a -ss - a. ~. =. _ .a. a. . s =Ia og. .wassess seses g ssssss.sss ess- s s sse g*l:wwi===sE j=_! i:E:: 5: ~2:55::~ *~:
.__:w 3._:-__a_.
- agnan====
= -aa___
8 8 E. S. E.
=
=_gg=== m . m m s-m g= 'a mmmmmmmm.
_ ..~_. = = = x x_ = = = e=. . = _
.. m .mm E.
- iw5!w*e!_____ :
- ed:=====. s. a. s. s.a.===== s. s. a. s.
- a. _5.5.5.5.5.5.5.5
- s. 5. 5. 5. 5. 5. 5. 5. 5 f. f. f. f.
i .7 j . = ==m===m= mmm m g ___i.s._:-_ :_ _ _ _
== ..
___=_______ - ._
mmmmmmmm _ __- _- ___- __ _- _ _
=. ..
= ._
- = s!ig=III2 d ~
.I I sgs~g1_g-II=. . ,~15E,e I I
=aw= In"#*gn~g=g=E,EIe.
s=~ =a = e.v"5jgy~=g==EIe.
l______g w=aIn ~e P:. _____________________=.._________________________= a sw -
m sw w*sm ~
I
r..
- :- !- ,s a -
- m E. E. -
E. -
I=s=!==!:=: -
? ? t ? ? ? ?
i
. !_I:-!!
- a- y :: m:
8
- s. E E
R R
H
,. E. E
- u_
sw- :
,-5:E 6.
- g gm -
s: - =.
a
- a. n. .
=.
a a.
=. n.
1 _. _,. ,=..3 ,, ,' _= _ _a _
a a
_ _m
_ w ___ __ _ ____ __ _ _ _ ___ __ -
Ff-
.a " M = *. *: 9 =
!= .- -
t t t
- s==.E_g; 4
t ? ? . t
. ? ?
- !!ks _ .j _ w g! .: 2 m a a ~
E 8 n -
t t
- 9 g
- sgs:
m 5 _m m_ m m_ -
!w,:q -: z ,, _
- E En*e,
. s a_ a a a a a
- _ :,=e,-
- _a a a
_- a a
_- a_- a_
- i- ! -! e = = g a a =
- = =$ : .:
- s"gW.: : --
,. T '
- 7 7 7 7
!.*-I:_w : = c c g = = =
- =_ rg: *.
m m
9 m
5
- 3,,s
, : 3 w ,: _ _ _
m.
_ _m e.
m
!Ei!E I_I :
4 9 m
R M m
9 a
4 a
4 i:_ zlE=si w z_
a_
a_
m
- _ : =
- ,a .:w-I,:
!!I!-sl F
d n
a sea:Es:
sagrams
.. ii8
!*~!U.i E
]n :!
g
- weg
- =e.
g _ _ _s __________________________________________________
w
- ~ : - g
- = s=:m_g:
- = : .
a n
- _,i:_w::
. a :=_ ,y, 8
8E*iai8 gw1 . :
- g
- E::n--:
E E =e : .i
__z w z ___ _..__ _ ___._ _ ___ _ _ _ ________
- _~ ::=ws .:
- , , _ ~ ~
' . . I s a =
,!E-!EM] f f f .
d d d d a
. .I s _g m
.w
.n.
- . 2.:_
- m g
- gs:3.. -
m: . - m_ m
_ a_ m m_
- w,
- g-E:ma!
8 l e-a a
=
. l
- _E :=e: .m. m m
_- m m 1
- :, , _ _- m_- n_- 4 g~
.=
s.- = = s = m =
- s=.:.s_g:
== .: -
s s -
~
a.
n 1
i
- wj:-,l s - , _ - .
am_ s
- g_ : s. a. , ,
.. g =. e. =. ,
- g - = m_ m m-j
,a g s,g u ,,g
- _ _m _m _ ,
!*g.:Ww!
gg eg a. a. a. a. a. a. a. 1 g g m m m_ m m_ n J
. _ m_
g_~__j.g
._________________________________________________ J g= .- -i a g a e = 3 m
- n-
.w E!:: .
9
- - d 1
I
!*I ge_j_w = c = -
= = n
. .wgl n- m 9 9 m n -
3 sg-:3*: W: -
m m
m a m m m
,,R8E e 8 I.
"_- :,=e:
g sum:, ,
m E.
m_
I.
a E.
m.
I.
m I.
m_
E.
m
_____y_. _____y__ _ __
y___ _.;
.m -- --
s- : -m ggg _ =E sm. ,= g E E g=.g: .. WEc
- h ==E3m =5E = g g ; h
- = 5 :
l_____:_EgI,g].gEffsjt.m=gsm w W W a g g=:m w n ,] m E ,,
.=,=al
=
=
m g
E _ __ ___ ____ ___ ___._____ _ _ ___ _ __ ____ __ _
- " 8
I. 3
". =
- - s . E. a. . T E jI$
_s= z : ? ? ? ?
.=_I _!: 3 3 3 g "m "a
- a- - : wa:s ,. a n ,., _ _
l*g:~ 8 W l5' , a- e n a E g E8 w
- je, r,!:
e n
m a n
a n
a
=
n a
n m
- =-
8 s a 3 a g :
a-is=l.-l n -
a-I a .
jusj_w-*i
- g_-g8 :
=
?
=
? ?
n
?
n
=
- a.
- I = _s .- *! m g,g wy m_ _ m_ m_ n_ _=
5 8EE:9.l ig : w-
=
_a
=
a
=
a
=
a
=
a
=
a
! .. _ _y ,e E ,______________
3 g- 1.- a = = n, a, e E is=:w_g:
.= := :
s,fa a- -
T v v v
g_ :w m e n = = c
.=_ =_5: - - - m m -
igsig.: : .m. m a_ a_ m. m E
, y -
isg!U,j = = q q q q
!s : E_ m a_ a_ a_ a_ a_
- _ __I_== w
- _ : :_.2 .: . _ __ ___.__ ____ _ ___ __ __ _.. _ __ __ _
E :
8_:*I ::
4 -:
= j!NI w! ---
.=_:$3:
- w*
._u.
a say: a w s.
I 4
- U . ::
3 e
.ig-5:w=:
- === -
- :=
8s-g G
- ~ :--!
- =
in s=:=g:
s.-
- =_:8 g
=. ==;*!!
8 4
=:s$1iwy:5=g
- a i
w
- af:I:
is E =e: :
- _ z:a ...:z 8 :.
ji=l2ws gMi
~
=
e d
=
d
~
=
d
~
=
d
=
d j=!Ij;rwj g c, e
, ,= - e e
c, 8 . _
3,3w ,. 3,!
jw~;ge j m_
m e
a_
e
=_
.=,G.
- _ :=E,
- = :
=.
m
=.
m
=. =. =. =.
,, _ _ m.
. m_ m_ m_
S
,_ .._y - _ _ _________ _ ________ __ ____ _ _
~ e a n s~ a =
- . =s := = : w _ :s.=g: ~
~
e n-1,i:
- _ : w : = -
m = -
- =
- =_:ws: n E m - - -
- g u, ,a g g ,i m_ m m m
m m
sw- : . . . . .
- aR
.g g~_e: :_ - e. e. e. e. 5 e.
- , ; m a_ a_ e_ n_ e_
E l.=_.
~
- i.g:! _ .:. =n E .
- 3
= = a
=
.~ .~ .n ls=.==_. .
j!$! w! = = = = a n E .=_;wg-
- g 33,!.
, y, m
m m_
m_ 5 m_
m_
.,_._ s
- sg_ g ::w w :. :3 .
y .
a n E. E.
8 m
- _ :-e; a m m E g :--
e_
.i. g ______________.g.._
s
_w-- .
m_ _
m m_
w B ::55=#1 E g =g :_1wwg_=
s ,n- - s j Ea .= g g ;;_g= - ss g. = 3=W ls- : mE = - 5 s 35 = g g =gE:
4 lxs H In.ga,gg
~ *=Es sm =g,= as 3 a t ,t 3. .3=m
~
- ___ : __~.=_.__ .=._ =___. _~.= =._
E ._ ___ . _ .
F j.-_ _ _: _ *_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ :, ..,
. :3 :
- = - :
sa-!=!::I :
f :El _w:
- c:
- ==
!Is!{II .
=ay: m -
E ,:E g-E F sw- I : - -
- E
- -- 5 :*e.:: E : s
- 5==
.=*:: -
- aE:
- _az*.a_
- 8
- E.sgI::
3- 22 2
=r :
- n
,s 2
- E jg E:
- e : s: : =m-:
sm8:
- W:
m: :
- :g
- M :
. g E:W=.::w : : :I
- :=:a _. :
- T
- _ .:.:we :m s
- - !.": : 22 :
- =
- a5:3Ol: s_:
j 27 :
- ,I::
- _ w : : -
~ :gs: g:
- s_:
a w: *:
3 5..g:
- s c .:
sw-ag e a
=5
=
- -R:Ee::
- E
=
==~:
_z**z________:
Sa5:
a
,g=w:
.- : :s
- 2
- : 8 .-s = ** W - =
- : 2.g:
n :m -: :
r' e' swIn:]-g 8838 88 say: w:
8
- 8.::
=
- : :ge: :
6 9 :Wg_::
y g iw U==. :: =_g,=
a i- isdi
- - r -- r - - - - - - - - :
i EE"i a
- ~ : := = g
== :: : :- = .
- s s.=!:: : : :? :
s u
-c,s:s
_Ia: w: : :
- =_- g: : :..: .
2 : =ca:
. :a g I g: g ,:: :- :z-:
- : a sw5.I
. I : ! =e : =
- l. == =
Eg::
- _ _2*_2________:
s
_a_:=
-: .: : z. :
s, : s : :- =
- 8 su
- 3I ::
g et :
- =
- s : :
se- :Es- :E s: : ==== .
sm8:E:3m:
- W E8I :
n 3 3
=
- g =.:=
I 8888 8
8 25':
- 88 7
i, _ _ .!. .
s *. _! _ _ _ _ _ _ _ !,
. i_3=i
- _5:
=~ : =g
?" := s.g=8 :
a5: :=_1 W : : T 6 jug!
.a : -E 3
3.ae
- g E s : :===:
5.Ru: s l =g :
- ,g U
lu . :: -
23-:
- _E:
- l_~g_II___
s E! ____ l 5_325
,~ ,
8= :.-8 :- =~ :
la 8 3_,5.W!! I:.w8
- g?
- ==
==
,E:!)I! g
- 8 say. m: ! E,,g: E ri 8w-! -
- E==
==8: -
,. l-5:I:Ee!
- E -
e: .
3
- ss:
8__8M_l________.g -
s."
w i :Ig-GE...
NER=
m i
_ _3 _gm e g I m - l:
e # ,
F .
T
- x
-i. *
' APPENDIX E Y
6 SETTLEENT DATA
-r*
b*
CONTROL BUILDING AND DIES,EL GENERATOR BUILDING P
- i. ,
'I. +
F 'i e'
r-
.4 .
i >
Fs
?.g.
a '
b f,
h I
w '
j -
i h
e ri m
'I y .
u 0
9,
~
. _ _ _ _ _ - ___....~
F Y APPENDIX E l SETTLEMENT DATA e CONTROL BUILDING AND DIESEL GENERATOR BUILDING
,,, NOTES f
e A. GENERAL
- 1. All reference elevations and survey readings are in feet.
. 2. All delta (movement) values are in inches.
- 3. For the delta values, + indicates heave and - indicates settle-ment. ,
- 4. For each structure, settlement markers and settlement benchmarks y are used ir.terchangably. They are not to be confused with the reference benchmarks used for elevation control, shown on Figure 7, 13.
B. CONTROL BUILDING F
k 1. Assumed a "zero" date for the beginning of settlement monitoring in January 1972. -
~
- 2. The settlement values for all four markers (benchmarks) in 1974 A were estimated from Figure 2A-16A, sheet 1, of the Unit 2 FSAR, Amendment 35, issued in July 1977.
- 3. New settlement markers (benchmarks) were established in July 1978 for each marker. The reference elevations were adjusted to account p for the previous movement.
)
, C. DIESEL GENERATOR BUILDING
. 1. Assumed a "zero" date for the southeast and southwest markers (benchmarks) for the beginning of settlement monitoring in a December 1972. This is based on Figure 2A-16A, sheet 3, of the Unit 2 FSAR, Amendment 35, issued in July 1977. No "zero" dates could be established for the northwest ar ' northeast markers.
- 2. The settlement values in 1974 for all four markers (benchmarks) 6 were estimated from the above referenced figure in item 1.
7..
F F
- 3. 'Wew settlement markers (benchmarks) were established for each f narker in October 1977. It was assumed that no movement occurred between the October 1977 reading and the previous reading, July 1977. An adjustment was then made to the reference elevation to account for the previous movement.
C
'[,
e 1
p ..
+
I i .
2
F
- .g:
8 = 88 8=
1 a= := =w _ :
m 5. e : 5. N. N. H.
Y t tvetta et sex N. 3s E.
t E.
?
y ? 3 ****"N.*
e- -s s .t 4 t t-si:.w- : g zz-~ - ~
i s:
838 " 8 iswyg: w:
- 3
.s.M.M.E.E.E.E.8E.
..... E.
. .M .
s . s e s .. .E. s 1 re 1 gw_li e!, > .
- g i s i ]: E ! . I-
- __zN_a_:_____________________________________________
88 8.-i u .
- . s . m t tv-a ~gng2-cmags re a =
!s != -
m .s ? --
=
m g s ===ge5.:- s
, !. g !. w _g : i t vtette t t - . y may????
tv
!! i-E s !eEEEEEE8EEE sessss ssa 4 E E E E EE8BEEE m sw s81 *s :
sw!;Rm:
- e s s s 44 esse u :I.U.a
- w
- = le=: w m:
.. .s.w__._ _____ _____ __ __ . _____________
18 i.-i - a s e ,m~~~~ = = =
~
- = - e e s = ,= a. ,e e- n , , ens,ss =====a5
, ggsgMg: ? ?vettette ? ? ? ? ? ?- t isli_w! = = = = =- n======
,,, :a_:
y w!ygg:
, ,y ggg=.=.=.=.=.=.=
.- s .- .- . .- s . .
ss--
!W Ig!wi8
- = :e :
7, : _ .:. s m i j! !.-j -
szeg~egns ea = =~ = s a
.= ;=g s- ?????ys ? s- n n s =,sa==g
?ysen??- .s L. -
- g =i w .. :!
? ? ? -
us
- s_g w!
E f. i.8'
- 2 5 m 5 : " E
- k 83:8::"
_5 e
- =ww I :g w: .
3.
-: ......-. . a .- -
. s . ss ....-
C.. : D wI:we.l
- n
- =_
, : m_ __!_:= _______________________________________________
_ e: -
.= -
e~ asy
- g = = y.
a- agsgge:
. g :
num:=_g: : : -4g==g g -
w : etty. .s T ?e
- s .
e t
?
. e.e..--
n T ette
- Di.l.wi .
+,
- r g a
- ~
8
- s_:
- WW :
. m: -
3.m.=s=s==
.e ,s a~ ,
a g ,
8~8 E, ,s,....
o :-- I e:
- 355::Es::
2 ,. :
3- _.3.- W _z: ___ .
- im : s. 5 ., ., I s- .., ,. = . E E .
- E E ,...,-, .:::..=.
!g-lE_g: 8 ! ffffffffff f f f f f f??ffff e- is3: _,:: - -
- s 33
- Iz...~...--
an====ss a a a a I = ,. ,.= .== _ .
ngs:Rw: : sesss sses e s e e e e- ssse 4~ : E:
- 8 5: ,W ,.,::
3
- =2:
- w :
n.-i ____ __ _______ ______ __ ____ _____ __ _ _ __
smessa m
- v e r: = .g
- w.:
- E. E. , ~ **~* --
n~r~,22 t-et?? e r ; ; :: Tr;r ,
lg*gil *l I
333335 sssses 5 s s E E i E HE2EEEE )
>- :Wws.gg:
g .
s s s ss sess ,
355f Eel i
__lEeel:
l l
- w*lg_I l~.-8 8 emez zzzema
??s-
=
a- g. s= gs,sggg= . s...-
8 v??? ??? ? ? r -
rr rrr; u ie zl,.s8 : I I.I.a-:e 2 ~2
- s -: -l -
...s s--- .- .- E. E. E. E~5s . .a I. I. I.
P
, 8WW8 *:__
- 5B ,U =.:y :
i.
l,__ :Ed : =_i_ __ _ _, . _
_ a _ _ __
y... .. .. -.
= _=yEffe gg,gI4]w=_Eff=]s I wsI z_~=.l..E832l -
,- m _~.___
w gIe-E wn-3 =gg4 w ~ - s3=y E de f c ll 3,3 3. !
w gem ~ is.-
, l___ __ . _ __ .
e u nw ~
=__ _ __ _ _ =__
b b
uc u uw m~ 7-. rq mggwqq3 E. I. Ilettu NUCLE 3 Pt a=1 $E!!LEggi
. _ . _ _ . = _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ . . . _ . . . _ . _ _ . . _ . . . _ . _ _ _ . _ . _ . _ _ _ . _ . . _ _ _ . _ _ . . _ _ . . . . _ .
I taultet tultlluG . _ . _ . _ . _ _ .
1 1 C8siteL WilliuG I COutROL NILituE I CONTROL BUILBluG I E3 i SeuinutSt RAAKER I i I I!ESEL Ett4 TOR WillfuGI SIESEL EEB6TM IUILllust IIESEL KEMis Iu!Latet etESEL EEulMISE IulLDial Seufuf ASI RAMit NERINEA57 NAnkEt i ustDNEST RAALES $ $sC1 Nut 3I MAREER I SeuTEAST NAALEA I . l._._._.l_.._...._...l.._...._._.__.l..____..._..l..___..__...l.__._..__...l__.__._...._i__...._.__,
8 unfufAST AAAKEB l. IB6isuEST NAAK!R I I
I sma IEFEREnEE nJavET MLM IEEHMitE5unEt NLia IEFEKaEE 5uavEt KLia IMFinEstE stavEt KLIA IKFEKEE SuhEt MLIA IAEFEREKE SuMEt KLIA BREFEREEE lutvET KLTA 10EFE I ELEv. Katie IEES I ELEf. IF46ta6 IEut$ 1 ELEV. MAstus IEE5 I Elit. REA6!E tutut5 8 ILEV. IEastuG IEIES I ELiv. MMluG IERES I ELET. KA0!E luoEl I ELEY. SEuls LUCES 8 -
il=*======
AuGull 8 = ======= l a===
0.000 -l.02 1 == =" 5.099a = =-3.100 l a== 8 = =*a= === =* = 8 = ===a a * === =a l _a==a a a == = == = l == = == _= = = =l a == == === == =l===*===== a = l 0.879 -0.940 I I.873 -0.04 8 8.8 % -0.432 1 0.633 -0.396 8 8.850 -0.696 8 ,8.M1 -0.4921 1 SEPTENGERI 5.094 -1.120 I S.lu -l.2721 0.886 -!.0I2 1 5.001 -0.972 3 I Kf00E4 I I l t 8.834 -0.408 8 0.835 -0.42 8 5.058 -0.696 f*F B.M -0.48 I I l 1 I I t i utvENIts i i 1 1 I l t MCISER I 8.009 -1.068 8 8.090 -l.14 8 8 I I [
0.004 -I.800 8 8.072 -0.864 1 0.037 -0.444 I I.034 -0.400 8 i '76 I I 0.056 -0.672 8 0.04 -0.40 1 I I I I l I Jesumf I S.809 -1.060 1 0.1 -1.21 l i 0.079 -0.940 1 0.073 -8.94 1 0.039 -0.468 8 0.83 -0.36 8 8.055 -0.M i I FEIAuntf I 0.007 -1.M4 8 8.841 -0.492 I 0.096 -l.152 1 0.076 -0.912 1 8.07 -0.M 1 0.M -E.48 8 0.83 -8.M i l RAACu I s.887 -1.M4 I S.955 -S.M l S.M2 -0.5M i I.097 -I.1641 5.075 -0.9 I 5.071 -0.052 1 8.039 -0.468 1 0.03 -S.36 1 i APf8L I 8.006 -1.032 1 0.095 -l.14 8 8.04 -0.9121 0.054 -0.He 1 0.048 -0.492 1 i' 0.072 -0.064 1 0.833 -8.396 8 0.03 -0.36 1 0.055 -0.M i 8.04 -0.552 3 I Ref I 8.006 -1.012 3 0.096 -l.152 I S.04 -0.9121 0.072 -0.064 5 0.037 4 .444 i s.026 -0.312 8 0.855 -0.u I 8.448 -4,5M i !
I Jute 8.te7 -1.M4 8 8.101 -1.212 1 0.0e1 -0.972 8 8.874 -0.000 I g.817 -0.444 i s.028 -0.336 8 8.053 -0.636 I I.047 -S.24 i $
8 Jutt I a.000 -1.056 I I.102 -1.224 I 8.004 -1.000 1 0.075 -0.91 0.038 -0.4 % 1 l Ausust 1 0.028 -0.336 8 0.055 -0.M i 8.048 -0.5 4 I 0.009 -I.064 5 0.106 -1.272 I I.084 -l.sel i B.871 -8.3521 0.030 4 .456 I I.028 -0.336 1 0. 855 -S.M i 8.844 -0.528 i
(
! CPite4Ett i I I I s
3.039 -t.468 8 0.038 -0.4 % i O.855 -0.M i 8.02 -0.24 8 l KlosEt I s.809 -I 864 i S.lM -l.2401 8.es2 -0.9841 5.072 -0.864 I 8.e42 -0.5041 0.835 -0.42 8 - 0.054 4.He 8 0.023 -0.2 4 I
(
i nevEWS I I I I I g I I I I i cctmEn 1 0.091 -1.092 I s.106 -1.2n I s.004 -I. Set 1 0.e74 -s.ese 8 i
0.M2 -e.504I s.eu -0.4321 0.e51 -e. net I s.sn -e.a4 I i *n i I I I I I I I i
1 JAsumf f I I ;
I I I I l i FEIAuAff 1 I i i g I I i
- I 1 nAACs !
1 I i I l 8 I I l l I l
e I APelt I 112.011 111.928 8 mf f -l.Be i III.944 111.036 -1.296 I lit.tH lit.Ge -l.800 3112.083 111.938 -0.0H I 130.059 130.521 -0.4% 3129.978 IN.933 -0.4% i 129.958 129.M8 4.721 130.u3 138.440 -0.88 i L I I I I I I I I 6 I JuuE I I l I l l I I Juti 8 112.0!! 111.92 -1.M21 111.944 111.834 -1.32 I 111.164 111.001 -0.196 1 112.883 111.932 4 .852 1 130.859 138.823 -0.4 % i 129.971 129.933 -e.456 8129.958 129.091 I i .
1 Muf t -8.72 8 130. 4 3 138.448 -0.18 8 1 I I I I I I I I I sEPiE nel i i 1 8 f I " I l ,/. " l I
I f) 10BER I 112.811 111.919 -1.184 I 188.944 111.034 -l.12 I Ill.964 III.80 -1.III i 112.803 lit.932 -0.852 I 13I.364# _31.326 1 -0.4 2 1 13I.678y 131.
H -0.456 8138.tM III.tNr a" -0.72 8131.057 331.M2 -0.18 8 .
I movEneEA I I i 1 I I I I I I Kttua l I I I I I I I I ;g i I I I I I I I I g
I -
1 JmuMf I 182.011 113.119 -1.lM i ll1.944 til.033 -1.3321 111.964 111.00 fl.088 8112.003 111.938 -0.064 8131.3H 131.320 -0.432 8 831.678 138.H1 4.444 8 838.tM 131.924 -8.70 1 131.057 131.M2 8.10 1 I FEIRUMf 8 I I I I I I I I
I WW I I I I I I I I I l' s apt!L 8 112.011 lit.fil -1.1161 111.144 Ill.026 -1.416 I 111.914 til.Se3 -0.972 I 112.003 111.935 -0.016 8 838.M4 131.316 -0.541 131.P8 131.625 -0.6341 138.999 131.914 -8.9 1 131.057 131.gM 4.336 I I pf I i I I 1 i l i I I JUNE I I I I i 131.364 131.316 -0.5M i 131.678 131.627 -0.6121131.199 131.926 -0.756 1 133.057 138.827 -0.36 1 -
8 JULT I 112.011 111.917 -1.120 I 183.944 118.838 -1.3 % i lil.tH 111.80 -1.080 I 112.003 138.932 4 .052 I 8 Mut i I I l l !:l '
1 1 I I I I I I 3 5 ,E.El i i i i i i f-i i i. .
I c:100Ea i 138.332 138.034 -1.!M 1130.096 IN.903 -l.3% i 138.MI 138.003 -1.056 8 130.116 130.045 -0.852 8 131. 3 4 131.324 -0.48 8 131.670 131.638 -0.48 8131.909 131.921 -0.886 8131.057 !!!.035 -0.N41 !'
8 NovEn0E41 I i 1 3 8 8 8 I k~
l sEttneEn i I I I I I i 7, I I l I !
I i i i i i i I Juutaf 813e.132 13s.s35 -1.164113s.096 129.905 -I.332 313e.MI 130.005 -1.e32113s.Il6 13a.e44 -e.s64 8131.u4 131.322 -e.5M l 131.670 131.6% -e.5841 131.999 138.915 -0.e001 135.057 131.e35 -e.44 F I I FEBRUMV I I I I I I I I I g!
l 8. .
PAGF 2 '
N " "
M C M ] M ,M M E. I. MTCH uuCLEO PLAu?-CTTLEEut m . u==..u m.u==== .m..
-..=.=u.u====.m= =====.u= ==.u=i=mn..nonu= mom . .. . u .m ..un .mu.u... .uuuumn.mu n..
I 1 CWitel 8u1t512 l CM128L SultlluG 1 Cou1ROL SultituG I Couttat IUILIINE i YEAR ! SOUINuESI MRRER I SOUTEASI RAtttR i NORIEASI MARK [t i NORIHutSI MRlER I IIESEL GEERAlm SultlluGI SIESEL EEhEkt.T88 Be!LituSI SIESEL GENERA!5 8UILlluGI $!ESEL GEuf14f8R SUILllu I SoulHufSI futrER I l nu.u.....m SOUTEASI MGLER I u0RIEA51 MRt[A l, uBRimIST MRKtt n I .lman.m. mu.un..l u =m...====u-l==u= i I NENTH -u====.nlumnumuumumul.m.m mu==muulumnumnum..===1 . .... u ... I I 18EFEKEE SURVEf KLTA IEFEREEE SWVET KLit I?tFEKEE SURVEf KLie IMFERENCE SURVET KLTA IKFEKEE SuRVEV KLTA lKFEREEE SURVET KLI im I-ELEV.
m KAtluGn.m !MSl.u==u.u=====m!a==
I ELEV. KASING IMS 1 ========u ELEY. KMinG IEES I ELEV. REAlluG IEES I ELEV. KA81ui IMS I ELEV. RIAlluG im5 l ELEV. KA81uE LUCES l ELEV.
l =u.u==.m 1 NRCN I I nam m g uoum.mmuu.a.u lm um.uuummmu l =======u====l ====.= m===m 1 I I I I i I Will 8 I 1' I l i I I I I CV 1 1 I I I INF l I I I I I JUE I 138.132 138.836 -1.152 8138.M6 129.971 I JULT I I -1.5 3 138.891 830.882 -1.868 8 138.116 138.845 -0.852 8 131.364 131.313 -3.612 8 131.678 131.624 -0.648 8 131.981 131.184 -1.82 1 138.857 131.817 -8.48 I I I l i 1 I MMI I I I I I I 1 1 l CPIEnKil I I I i I I l l i
! 8Cf00ER ! I I I I I I I i 8 1 i NOVEneER 1 1 1 1 8 l l i 1 8 KCIPKR I I I I i 1 I I 'C3 1 1 8
I 1 I l t I i 1 1 JanuART I 138.132 130.034 I FEBRUAAV I I -1.1761 138.M6 I 129.974 -l.4641I 138.898 138.802I -1.h8 l 138.116 138.842 -I.888 I 13. 364 131.328 -8.4321 131.478 131.648 -0.444 81 I I l 8 MRC: l l l t i 8
i FRIL 8 1 l I i I I I I I I I I I MY l I I i l 1 i i !
I JUE i l i I I i l I I I JULT I 130.132 138.83 -1.224 1 130.896 129.981 -1.38 8 138.891 138.885 -l.032 8 138.116 138.I37 -8.948 I 138.364 131.315 -8.588 8 131.678 131.623 8 AUGUST I I I -0.66 8 131.189 131.913 -8.912 1 138.857 131.429 -0.336 8 l l t i I I SEPIEMBERI I I I I I I I
'l DCTOKA 8
- I I 8 8 I I l l 1 NOVEAKA l l l 4 l 8 I I I I I I KCEnKR I I I
I I i i 1 1 t
'81 1 I I I I I I I I II IEtRut.a; JAmuARV I i 134.832 138.834 I -l.176 8 138.896 l 129.178 1.416l 8 138.891 830.088 -0.196 1 138.186 138.847 -0.028 8 131.364 131.331 -8.396 8 138.678 131.444 -8.4 i I I I I I haRCH I I I I I I I I I I . #EIL I I I I I I 8 Mf 8 I I I l 1 1 i i l l i I JUE i l I I l 8 I I i 8 JULV I I I I l I I l i i I -
1 AUGUST I 138.332 138.034 -1.176 8 138.896 129.18 -1.392 8 138.891 138.883 -1.8 % ! 138.116 138.842 -0.888 8 131 344 131.381 -0.54 1 131.678 131.628 -8.6 8 131.189 138.983 -0.982 1 131.857 131.83 -8.324 8 I SEPIEMbERS I I I !
I i 1 l l l OCTOBER I l' I l i I I I
)
i NOVERKt i I I I 1 i I I i 1 !
I MCI'IBER I 1 8 I I I I I I I '82 8 1 I I
- I I f l January l 138.l32 138.83 -1.224 1 138.896 129.911 -1.5 3 134.891 138.881 I I I j
-1.02 8 138.886 138.842 -0.888 8 131.364 131.329 -0.42 8 138.678 131.64 -0.456 I 138.921 131.119 -8.84 1 135.057 131.837 0.24 i j I FEttuART I I I I I I l l '
I MACH I I I I I I I 1
I WRIL I I I l I I I I I My i I I 1 I I I I I I I I I Juht i I I ! I l l I l l JULV ! 138.132 138.832 -1.2 8 138.016 129.978 -1.416 1 138.891 138.881 -l.80 1 130.116 134.881 -8.1 ! 131.364 131.316 -0.576 l 138.678 131.623 -8.66 8 131.989 131.985 -1.888 8 131.857 131.826 -0.372 1 1 Aususi I i ',
i i l I l i 8 SEFitnKRI I i ,
I I i l i I KIOKa l I
! l I I I I I I I
- FAGE 3
" l it __________________________________________________
f 2
- 5 m a is*___1.g
- = s- n E. -
4 E
g i=_5 ? ? ?
- s=g s,
,; ~
a a
u a
.R a
a a
I a
=
a gwy; m, = = = = = =
5 - _ _
- gE:q _
! , : s a a a sa a
_ :_ .: a a a a a
- s __;g ;
- .. _ _ _ _ = _ _ _ _ _ = _ _ _ _- _ _ = _ _ _ _ _ _ = _ _ _ _ _ = _ _ _ _ _ = _ _ _ _ _ _ _
a
.t _.
.e a. a a a
1 8
i 55"!E-!
Y f f f Y f i_sl!.,w! -.
s n
a a
=
a a a a )
=
isw-s a = = a s :i = = = = = I 5 imE:!e:!
igEj i .s =El E
d E
i_
E d_
E d_
E d_
E d_
- __..___=_______________________________________________
- = :=g:
!.=i : =, 2 : =
n
=
E , ,
m igenz_: ? ? ? ? ? ?
- s :_w: : a, sa = g =
ag_:w a
=
a
=
a m
- gw:3,g: w 3
a a 5
i gR:g m
a s:
- _w s 2
a a
=
a
=
a
=
a
=
a na g _ _ .5. g _ : - _ _ = _ _ _ _ _ _ = _ _ _ _ _ _ __ = _ _ _ _ _ _ = _ _ _ _ _ = _ _ _ _ _ _ = _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
- M !.gi
- 5 _:
- s := :
i g g g z ,_ g 9
?
R.
s 5
?
2,
?
9
?
m n
? l
- 33: _ : v
~ . - . -
g = a n. a a n
!!5!$-.i Ei d d E d d 5 EE-
- 8
- me:U.::
- W sum
- = ,=e:
s:
9 3 3
=
9 a
9 9
e a_ =_ a_ =_
g 5
a numsw_: := .g:: e 9
?
a
?
e
?
e 9
?
3
?
=
9
?
I 5 :: :
~
I id _w: = = =
= 3 K
" l 5A ta_:rg: 9 9 9 9
- R R
_ R R R R
. ::WW:: : - - - - - -
. :gf:g.ws:.
- ,o a .
=.
=.
=.
=.
=.
=.
1 g idd: R R R
_ R_ R_ R_ _ _
E g s
Egg $$j
- 2W: $
i i
~
s i
~
s i
~
s i
=
i i
=g:g_::
g=:= 3 w: s
- _ = E 8 g s
- *:5W: E =
- w. .
ag
- ::q n o f . w _e :n .
a.
- s. s._
- s. s._ =._
- =di R_ R_ R_ R R R_
j-__: .=i _______________________________________
a = = s = s _________
! ::w===_g: :=
- A- n
- 9 *
- y v v v
=l:_w:
!a : : = = = = = =
n 5 sa_
- w rg:
- Ww : * ::
155:_s:--:g :
m m
n g
n m
g m
m g .... s. s. s. s. s. s.
g jddj R_ R_ R_ R R
_ R_
E g___,,___j,___~_____________R
- 3.- ? -
~
~
r
=
~
2
~
- w==Gg_j .
r v v v
- s je .i 2! = 3 2 8
M M
( .a_: 5; -
R R
.- R R
- g-: y: w.: - _ R_ _ _ R_
- --:q a-:
a_
~
a_
- n ~
R.:m . -=. . =. _
. =.
- :gg= 5 :: R R R R R 5 :
II
~~
E I. 3 s
""""":--"""""""""E"----""""""_"E""""""""""""G'*""""""""
s.=5 :" _wa==
MWfs a =s
R_ _
s
" S g =. a ==,g es==m sHm.
w 2555 ~~
s
- e ism
- wn- 333m8,4 =u ws- a m m ,3 zgEe a sz a s a= = m :
2 w 3- 23.
m g ,s a . 3,3 "= a g
- _____:___~_=____________~=___________~=___________~_=_ __
i 1
y- p y G. y r l 't V' v F 'W W- -
( g % M ,
y E. l. t"TCn WELED PLMi-Mi1Cul I
...m====-=.-==.=.===.=====..mu===..==...==..==mm..=.m..m I CRTRAL WIL815 i C8uTML SUIL9fE I talaK NiillisG Cm! POL N!LllE 1 I SIESEL Knigt MillIE! SIESEL KEMist WILilE: BIEEL KEMTM tulL9tEt SIEWL E:1MIM Wit 9lEl l C~1 1 $8ulmEST Mettl I $001EA51 MAKER 1 WRTNEAST RAAtti ! N0tiHutSI MaEEt i SWTMEST MAtit i 505161 MKER I meRT M I Maata I, natinuEst MAKER 8 8 & ! ==. m. == 3.==. === .=m.s .=== ==.m == 3 =.=.. .=. === m : = .= ==...=mm == g n ==...m== =.= m u l a.m u......= m.a gue .== == =.= . I I MuiN IKTEKEt SURVEY KLIA IKFEgEEE SURET KLIA lAEFEKEE SutVEV KLIA lKFEKEE SURWEt Klin IKTIKEt SURvit KLIA !KTEKE! Suntf Klie IKFIKEE SUREf MLI4 INTEAEEE smeEt Klia 3 i
I I .(LIV.
= = REA41E
. IMS I tELiv.
.m KAtlE tutNES I ELEV. REA61NG IdCNES I (LEV. KAllE LUCES I EttV. KA81E LEES I ELif. REA6155 IEES I ELIV. EMIE IMS 1 ELEv. eletaG lat t i JUNE I m.m.m um t .==.
mmm = t .=....===.= == m 3 . ==..=== .=.= l =====. m.= ==us : .==.m == == = == : .-= ....m = = m g I I I I I I I I I JULT I I 'l 3 I I I MMi t I 8
- 7 7-1 1 I I I I l l SEPTENBERI I I l
I I I I l I KiBGER I I I l
I I I I I I I I WWEntER I I i ! l I I L i IECIPIER I ! I i l I 1 i l 1 si 8 I a i ! i i sm os . I
.m . mm .==.= === ==== === me n-m= = =..m.====== =.. ..m..m.= = === = = ===== == =mn. ..m . = = m l .=.m.-========.
essassess e s s e s s e ess ee e eeeee eeeess es s e s ses s e ssee e eee ee eee ses s e ss eess e s s a s s e s se n e s se ssesses s e s s esse s s es ses s e sse s s e Mllnun Klla . -1.2401I INMitM e 15 JANUARY,1905 KLTA . -1.5121I 15 JAu0447,1994 MilM KLI4 . -I.116 i MIINUN Klia . -l.032 I MIIM Klia . -0.612 I Ml!NUE Klia . -0.696 i MIINUR KLI4 . -l.832 i MilAUN KtfA . -0.412 e JULY,1985 315 KitBER,1973 135 Juuf 1979 1 IN AUGUSi I 15 JULV,1993 e s s e n en su o us e e s s senunenn us u n un e uennu s en su o u s pe n n enn uu ss e s s e s s es c u en n uun e e n n u us e s,s e n nu s e neu e s up u eI ne IE SEPTERIES,1973 e
- u. 1904 s e uun en n us e o u s ensuena eue nnuousunn e s unnu nunen b
4 e.
i I
I; i
l f
f AGE 5
.T--~i_._...-..
E t
[
{ A
'PPENDIX F e
de SETTLEMENT DATA v
u- -
INTAKESTRUCTUREANDO7 GAS (MAIN) STACK l
L.
M
- 7. *
[.
C
?
s P
t s
5
f E
APPENDIX F SETTLEMENT DATA f INTAKE STRUCTURE AND OFFGAS (MAIN) STACK -
{ NOTES
~
A. GENERAL
- 1. All reference elevations and survey readings are in feet.
- 2. All delta (movement) values are in inches.
fo 3. For the delta values, + indicates heave and - indicates settle-
[. ment.
- 4. For each structure, settlement markers and settlement benchmarks
(,a are used interchangably. They are not to be confused with the reference 13.
benchmarks used for elevation control, shown on Figure I: B. INTAKE STRUCTURE
( 1.
Assumed a "zero" date for the beginning of settlement monitoring in July 1972.
f' 2. No survey readings are available between July 1972 and July 1978.
L. GPC correspondence indicates that the structure settled about 0.1 foot.
fl '
- 3. New settlement markers (benchmarks) were established in July 1978, for each marker. The reference elevations were adjusted to account
,r for the estimated previous movement of 0.1 foot.
u C. OFFGAS(MAIN) STACK 1.
Assumed a "zero" date for the beginning of settlement monitoring in September 1971.
T,
- 2. Between September 1971 and April 1972 more than one survey reading L was taken in certain months. The reported reading here is an average of those readings for a particular month.
P
- 3. New settlement markers (benchmarks) were established in January 1973 for each marker. It was assumed that no movement occurred between January 1973 and the previous reading, July 1972. The f
a refere.nce elevations were adjusted to account for the previous movement.
m
!!j 1
~
1 e i
F E
f' ,
- 4. Jil settlement values in 1974 for each marker were estimated from Figure 2A-16A, sheet 4, of the Unit 2 FSAR, Amendment 35, issued in July 1977. :
- 5. It was assumed that the February, March and April 1975 survey Ti. readings for the south marker (benchmark) were reported incor-
- rectly. The readings were changed from 119.891, 119.890 and 119.891 feet to 119.981, 119.980 and 119.981 feet.
- 6. Anewsettlementmarker(benchmark)wasestablishedforthesouth marker in May 1975. It was assumed that no movement occurred f; between the May 1979 and the previous reading, April 1975. The reference elevation was adjusted to account for the previous movement.
- 7. It was assumed that the January 1976 survey reading for the south marker (benchmark) was reported incorrectly. The reading was changed from 119.997 feet to 119.979 feet.
C
- b. 8. New settlement markers (benchmarks) were established for each marker in January 1980. The reference elevations were adjusted i
to account for previous movement.
7 E'
C
- h.
'W L
T a ,
U a . .
l 2
flI I b
i I
o .
E
- :=_g:
- :s :
- . :.w:
- : 3:
- : m:..
s a
8g :
. ! i mi j .- -
is .. _. w==> _ _. y _
r 5.-l -ngs- s--==u_
! :- e aa~ ~ ,g- ac .:o ,.:uag,
~ u .e: .=: e ni ~
. To. -
- Gm.E_g: :
- ??? ??jjf
? ?????????? ? ? ? ?
.s
=. 9. ,. 5 3 f. 5. 5. ~. :_ u__n._~_. . . . .
- . , s. ., ,. g g a. g a. ,n a. =. a. =.
a_ s_ _ s_ _s a_ s_ a _s a
- 3,3: w; 3 , _ _
_a_mmmmm_mm i**ig.i :::: z --
> a : == --.: g =:
.---- =: =. =: gg888g8g-8 8
- , :, ,= e : . ..
- -____;._________________________________==.=__==_
= s _a n _s _a _s a s s. _a
_ _ __. _===== .
-sez e gggs s sa f,:.. : :
m:=m ::.E:: -s ...: . - g =- --s=
.- . =-- -:se .4 a =. =- -- =
i ??- ????? ? ??vettett-
? ? ? ?
- Gl::_v:
- =us=
,,-- s,a s,s a,
=
, unn=e===ce = = = =
s _, g s , s z ,::ES: suas_ _s__a_ s _s a a_
- n---- a-n_-
_m _ _m _m _m _m _ _ n
}
smI:g : ~g~~
.i :
.w en -
~~~~~.
~
E. ...
g...g g E. a. . E. g. .E.. g
,: = .3 .:
a s a_ s.
_____ _ _ __ ___ _= .=.==_=== .===___
5 a u_ s_ s. a_s_
_7 ,_ ;,. y ___ _
- :.g: g z4 I. E.E.8,8: 5 4
- 3 M:8- - - - - --
5 8,5 E. ~ 2E
-- -- s . ~2 5 E 5 5 5 5
.E ?? ?-??? ? ????-??s.?
sg==
? ? ? ?
m m :-
!- ~
==g =- ggggg ~
- n==u====n = = = =
y .3_Eg_w!
- .. 8 w
s_ 8 :. 5 s __a _s_ s a_
a g-- - - - -
m m z_ z 5 _m_ __ m_mm
@ !*Eg., i i ==== ===== =
maammmmmma
- ~,.
a : ==: ~~~~, ~~~~~
e n
- __._________.._____._.__n,.
- ,ee:
, ; ens __
a m_ m a_ n n_ a m g
l : :- : m a
U
- I=n=E_5::
EgE: -W:
__: I :
-*2
. : g 'N : * ::
_V :
gmE:5e:
. 3 d:
- __aM a:_ _
32 :
!E"!Eg!
._E. .
i ; jga:-Ej -
- sm-iME:
8 En:
- EN::Q asI:==:.:
=
P : : :: d :
)
- .w. :
S : -
- g==:=_:
3.g"::
P :
r
- wis:=w:: -
y ::=_ . I:
- g'" _mW ::: E: s:
w m ImS:
- 4 I :E -
s ::
s :__aM_a:_______________________________________________
!=
i E_I !
J 3
inli in
!a=igs- wi
.Eg.mWI w
i- I l E 5:::w"Ew: . :
g .I _a .w. _ :
__ _ =_ -- __ _
__y____ _ ___ g a w I sa, e
~
- _g Ejg5l=_IIIR 3
~*
g a ,g g* _--- - gjEggy'"=g,m:.
gI t_IE2 I
.. _w Es I - I ..
a gwa- g= su2 3 3 3. . g y
, , a a a
_g__ e mz - _ .=._ __ a*Ee.
__ __.=.
x
.. __ m
_ _~=.__
4 h*-
.. - . .+ ~ . _ .
i
- ;: w= :.g :
!*Mi
- z:
i: .
- U.n
- sg,mel:: -
F. g i
l
- - * (
- __M__,_____________________________________________*-
u e e 1
w .! 2. H a. a* ca~~~ *3ea ~ ~
FJ, . sgW: - -
4 d. T d. T d. d. 4. p u. d. e
~
4 M M e -n E ~e ~.n 3 n n 2
~
~
3 e
~
e
~
g
- Get g _g
- d. d. d. d. d. d.
- d. d. d. d. y 4 d. I
- E
- M :: E _E ,~z 8 - sf~~a r ~
33_1: : 5' s
- R w ::.
e d es=:E esse
=====ss
ffr.~__f3 e ========
essesses ezz eE = E e
~
=
a 5
s
~
s
~
s
[
...a
= =
I " I 5. 5 !.
j j$ej E. E. E. E. E. E. E. E. E. E. E. E. E. E. E. E. E. E.
22222222 2 2 E. E. E. E. E. E.
g g"m, _2_2_2_ ___2 _2 2 2 2 _2 2_
2
_ _2 2
' + 3 !.*!
R 32342
____._.._.._.._.______._____ . _ _ ___ __ 2
- * : 5 ::- $ .g.: ?
-Q 4 d~nn,4222 ~~~ g 3, ,D.g~~ ~3 3 2,2 %. g g 2 2 2 2 F = '
?*??????? ?.
. . n n - -
- g3!.B: : ???????? ? ? ? ? ? ?
_a 2 s20: 33% :
l 3 :
g ,g" ,gW a g m
- IWg: ""t e s *. *. *. *. ). *: * *;**ss C C CS *
,j s= **:= _E 2 R2:320 . . .
S 2
2
- _2 _2 2 _2 _E
_ _t _2 _5 _%2 _2 = _E = _9_t*: S _t _t. _E. _t _
s EEEEEEEEE im=
. eessesees E EEEEEEEE e es.:seses EE e e E e
e E E
- _ :g _g _ === =
_=_==.__=_==.__= === = s e i
_== .=. _= .=.
!."! 3 3 252222CMR
.=.___=_ .=. .=.
', g C g3335352 3 i
l -
- j~$):: 9
? ?
7 747dddp77
?*?* ??
y .7~~7~7~ 3~
7 ,2 2 d
g 3 7
_: b ???????? ? ? ? '
?. ?
u : E=! ~8 -eR -R z-r e *=====
[- W~ : s= =?=s_=?t_m::ic =e *.*. *.....
- *= *= *=* .c*.c l
w % *. *; * * *
m
=
= 1* 3_E.
- m . ; iw: g - "_e__=.=. =
_ _= _e c _e _= ___ _=_ = = e e 3
e R
=
e.
~
ti g,$,9g
- a -
_ _ _ =_
A 5
,._,"s : .
s s. f f ~z z~ ~ ~zzz e sczzzzze z
. -~ ~
e z
~
c l -
sesessses 4 sesssges s e s e =
n
. . 8:
- W __=_= ==
_=_= === = === = s 4 i
g _y .
_ __=_= __==. __= .=._ __.=.__.=. .=. __=_ -
g :. : .
g 3.Egi i
c : _- ~
s . :
U
- _g=gi*lI lI_-: ! -
p~ d gI
- g!.g E:i
, :=E e:
t s : :E. m E :.
- 3 i:__iw_5_______________________________________________
- = . :
!N*!G~g:i
- gE:g=g.:
IE-: Wal D [g!!awg -
- _ ~- g .: W. E .:g f?. g :=d e
g
- .w..a.
A s .
j,gw.= '
i ag
- m_gi
.s 5
!_! WI: *~
l=5 =!gi:
1
.~
inw *.i:
.I -5:
t a 3,
. N.. _* :. _ _
I ma __ _ __ __
I __
i.
T
- E.:gIl :S
- ~n
- M
- 8 ::
. gE=::13:
.WI!mW:
7 5-
- g g.w=:
ru 9.: :
- seen
- W
- h g ~~ ~~ ~:~E ~~ ~~~
y"I. . -. ~.~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ E ~ ~ -- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~~ ~E ~~ ~ ~~
- w g . .e . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 3 .~..~. ~ ~ ~_ ~
l E.5 .W *
- 8 EC 3 .Ww" I z .rww *s dg - .
"faz.
'o I w I :gg-
. a I .d=g. g it y c o ==~MS Eg .g _ =-
3 *= *=~ ~ 2 's15d- **
3 s _l ._
RW W. U w _=
m- M Ur*n M za
__'= _ _ _3.8r=-ia35EI.._s.g"M
~ .
E* ':
- U " w* E e- a
'2 '.
d _
__ .'._ __ __SX e - ,r...
n ! '
4 y i ,
E. I. CCN sutLCl Plast-5EllLEEuf m==.m. . . . . = = = = . . . . . . . . = = . . = = . = . . . = = = = .
I l Isikt $1aK1M i laint situtint I lufME Sigutim I leimE SiputtuRE I KFEAS STEE I 0FFEAS STEE I 0FFSAS STER I I VEAR I SaufuESI NAAER I saufEA61 NAtaER ntTNEASI NAAttt I I
l g I.m=== m=.= . m..
1 WetWESI RAAKER 1 SOUTH RARKtt i NItfEASI RAMER I KEI MAKER l- I
- l. =1-
===.=l=========.1=.=======1====m=====-l========mm=I==========.-1 II RIstW IKTEKKE SWWEf SElle IKFE8EEE MNET KLIA 10EFEREKE SuMET KLIA 18EFEREKE $5HET KLin ItEFEKKE suMET DELIA IKFERENCE SuRWEV KLIA !KT 1 mm I.m===.
'"*, KAssas IKES I ELET. l..
RE*Ma
== =.
lutaE5 i ELEv. Kaelus intE5 I ELEV. REMIM INCE5 i ELEV. REelm IMS I ELEv. REatlE IMS I ELEV. REMIS IMS I ELEV. Keld lutNES I
==.I l ... .. .= .l-...==.== . l. .mm I WG l i ===m l ======.m mm t. .m====.=m l I I I I I l aptit I l I l i i I mt I I 1119.47 !!t.973 -0.1401119.992 119.97 -0.264 1 IN.01 119.981 -0.340T ' T I I i i i I I i JuE I I I I l l I i i i MT I Ill.17 Ill.07 -1.2 I 111.195 Ill.095 -1.2 IM.5M IM.439 -l.2 1 309.642 109.542 i
-l.2 I lit.907 119.977 -4.82 1 119.992 119.976 4 .192 1 IM.08 119.906 -0.200 l I I ANEUST I til.17 111.060 -1.224 I 118.195 111.097 -l.176 I IM.5M IM.434 -1.26 I IM.H2 IM.530 -1.240 8 I I I I I E*PitnHal 118.17 111.072 -l.176 I 181.195 Ill.M4 -l.212 I IM.539 IM.439 -I.21109.642 iM.542 -l.2 I I l I KiseEt i 188.17 Ill.074 -1.852 I 818.195 til.M5 -I.21 IM.5M IM.434 l i I aletta i i -l.26 i AM.H2 IM.545 -1.IH I 119.907 819.976 -0.132 I lit.M2 819.976 -0.192 I IN.fi 111.907 -G.276 8 l l i I I I 1
1 1 CCENER I III.17 111.073 -1.1641111.195 til.093 -l.224 I IM.539 IM.44 -1.100 l IM.H2 IM.5M -l.2401 1 I I i '79 I I I I 8 L l i i I I JAsuAtt i Ill.17 til.07 -I.2 I Ill.195 Ill.M -l.26 I IM.539 I FEleuAff 8 1
'M.83 -I.3001109.H2 IM.5M -1.236 I Itt.907 119.97 -0.204 I 119.992 119.973 -0.2201 IN.08 119.901 4 .340 l l 1 8 1 I MO I I 1 1 I I l i I I I I APtil i I I I I I I I I MV I I I I I l l I I I I I I Jut i Ill.17 111.072 -l.176 I 111.195 til.M4 -l.3321 IM.5M IM.431 -1.296 I IM.642 IM.534 -l.296 8 8 I I I I JULT I I i ,
1 1 I I I I I MMI I I I I I I CritneERI I I l I I I I I I KIOGER I 8 . I I l I I I I l l l I I N000ER 1 I i 1 I KCinus 1 8 l 1 1 1 1 1 I I I I I '03 8 I I I I l
. 1 I JanuntY i I I til.17 111.063 -l.204 I I11.115 Ill.M5 8 FEleuAlf l I -1.32 I IM 539 IM.428 -1.3321 It" e42 IM.53 -l.344 I 119.907 119.977 4.12 I lit.M2 lit.973 -0.2201 820.01 119.986 -e.280 I i 1 l l l 8 8 I I RAntu 8 I I I I I l l 8
- 1. APRIL 8 I I I I I mi I I l I I i I .I I I i I JuE I I i l 8 8 1 l L l l I JULT I Ill.17 Ill.067 -I.236 I 111.195 111.00 -I.M i IM.539 IM.435 -l.2401 IM.H2 IM.5M -1.240113.061 120.0M -0.144 l 120.0M 120.M4 4.2H I 120.004 120.06 -0.205 I I AuEusi ! I I i I I I 8 8 I KPitnMal i I I I
.I ,
I L l I
- I KIDIER I I I I i 1 1 I I I N090ER I i 8 i l I i 1
- 1 I GCEn0ER I I I I I I l I l I l i
'Il I I I I I I I I' I JesuAav i 118.17 111.073 -l.164 1 111.195 111.005 -1.32 I IM.5M IM.435 -1.240 I IM.H2 IM.54 1.224 i L l I I t' I FEIAUAAV I I I I I i i I I l RAACM l l I mit i I I
I I l I L l I f.
I I I I I I l ut l l 1 I I I I il I I f 1 JuuE I i 1 I l i I Mt i I
. 8 l
- I I I I I I I I AuGUSI I til.17 111.062 -1.296 8111.195 til.070 -1.4M i IM.539 109.439 -1.21109.642 IM.542 -l.2 8 820.061 120.046 -0.10 I IN.tu 120.M3 -0.2761 1 l I SEPIEnIEtt i I I I l.
I K10ER I I I I I 'I $ 1' I I I I I I
PAN 3 :
?
I
f e, 7 ,, tm m c '.rm m C n " 1 n9 -1 , m, 9 J
- f. I. tTN tM ,tAMauEM
_ _..m_ _. _.
I tuTHE510EIME I
_ . . ........_.m ..._._._....
1 IETMt STAKTURE I laIME SteutiME I la w U m oi i ............_m__.................__.
I CM i $$UTNESI neMES I IguTEASI takit i NORIWASI AAABER SFiles 51ALk . WFGA5 Stats 1 GH645 SIER I I I g I ..mm. 8 uORINNESI Rukla ! $0b7N RAAttt I i MsTR l u.am.au.mu mm. lu==.m m. .m1 ..
.=== =. i n == = =..mu 8 useINE AEl namit utSI MAKit t. t i = g .======. ..= l == ==.======= l-===.- =
I ml ,
1.=u n====m 8KFEREKt SUBYEY KLie IAEFEKKF Sisivtf MLIA IEftKuCE Suavtf KLtA SEFEREEE SMVEV NL16 IEftMU suM I ELIV. EEA0!st IKES I ELiv. KAtluG
======g .m .mou lutes m.=I l ELEV.
--===REAtlNE IEE5 l.mm. t ELEV.
mm===1.nuKAlle IEME5 8 noulu-.--u=====.I Elft. Mattut IEE31 Ettv. EMIE In0E5 8 (Liv. KMlut IKIES1 ELEv i IsvENIES I I ..
,I I I I
.=1 -- g 8 NCEnBER 1 8 *02 I 1
I I I I I I
1 gg :
i I I t
l I I I I Jesunet I 111.17 Ill.057 -I.3561111.195 Ill.073 -1.464 I IM.5:9 IM.434 -1.26 8109.H2 109.537 I I Filmonov I I l l.26 I IN.06l IN.H -0.252 I IM.066 120.036 -0.36 8 l I Mn 1
- i I I l I I I t I I I i I Art!L I I I I I I I 1 Mr i I I I I
- I I I l I JuE 8 I I I I t i I I I I I I JET I 118.17 111.059 -l.332 I 111.195 111.075 I I 1 MMi l I -1.44t I IM.539 IM.437 -1.224 i 8 IM.H2 IM.539 -l.236 I IN.061 120.M7 -0.1601 IN.066 IN.043 4.276 I I l I StPIEnstal I I I I l i I I l I KTOMA 8 I I I I l 1 I I 1 utvEn0ER I I 1 I I I 1 l l 1 McEn0E01 I t I l l I '03 I i 1 1 I t 8 I I I
! I I 1 Januatf I 111.17 111.053 -1.404 I ill.t*5 Ill.07 I i 1 I FilethWV I I -l.5 II IM.539 IM.420 -1.332 i I IM.H2 IM.531 -1.3321120.068 120.M3 -0.216 8120.064 820.039 -0.324 I I I I natta i I i 1 t 1 I 1 I 4 i APRIL I I I I I I l I Mr i I I I I i 1
- I I I I Juut I I 1 I I I I I I I I I l I JULT I Ill.17 til.06 -l.32 8 111.195 111.07 I 1 MMi t i -1.5I 4 IM.539 IM.433 -1.272 8 IM.H2 IM.535 -I.294 I 13.06l IN.H4 -0.2b4 i IN.066 120.Mi -0.3 I 120.004 120.052 -0.304 1 I E7 Tin 0Ett l i I , t 8 l I I I 1
i E80KR I I I 1 1 1 I l I nevEMBEA I I I I I t 1 8 I l I MEMEt t i I 1 1 1 I I I l l I
- 04 8 8 I I l 8 8 I I I II FEMuAtt JAmuARf I 111.17 111.053I -1.4M i 111.195 Ill.060 -I.524 I IM.539 IM.427 -1.344 8 IM.H2 IM.53 -1.344 I I I i I I I I I I I Wu l I 1 i i i 8 8 I i i APtIL 1 I I I I I I t i 1 MV I I I I I I I l I l I JuE 8 I I 8 8 I I I I I 3 JAV I i I l i 8
l l l 1
Il SEritnK04 AuGusi i Ill.17 til.061 -1.300 I 111.195 til.076 -1.4201 IM.539 IM.435 -1.2401 IM.H2 109.537 -l.26 I I I i I I I t i I i KTOKa l I t 1
i I I I (
i NevEp0ER 8 I I 1 i I 1 I I I Ctinett I I I I I I I I I I I '05 I 8 I l I I I I t I JANuAtf I 8 I I I I FE0puAtf I 118.17 l11.056 I-1.3601 Ill.If5 118.071 t -1.400 I IM.539 I IM.438 -1.296 I IM.642 IM.534 -l.2961 120.061-0.3113.004 120.t'l -0.N41N.05II IN.066
-0.396 I IN.Mi I I WG I I I 1 i l i l i 1 I 8 I APalt i 8 I I I I I I I I MV i I I I I I I I t i i 1
- FAGE 4
l l m_
-1
_____ i: :.o I lei : :
g- : :
- = =
a : :
W_l Rw. : : :
w : : :
E : : =
we f.
l em. :
i__M. .
..: 3 = . = . =.
I W_ f !? E g- u g i: : _:
- . ====
I_ 3: m 8
..s__
Imu g.l:
w -
8 g-.5 :5 l 5En:
I, _ _em]E___E _, w ____________________g e 5-_i
- : 59 I=
In E. -
=v E. I gew_iI.g:
? l : =
E. l l. w i c- i E
- .E_i :
3 i :=.=
E -
I .EwlH, :wl:i
!E I*1:les: a. ==~=
. =a==
___IE_a_E____________________i j.g8 8 a l:?a.= =i I g-
!sw_8 ? :
- 3 E 15$!-j! I I l i
5 *. E i isai 52 y-
!!=i mj E
=5;gei .w :
- een aw : m a.
i:
- 5. a :=. . ,5 :
=g.:
=
- - rn.- r---------------------: :- :
5s s lgestg:
till wia
_: 9v
=
i i
- n ==
=r i ni Im=!w 8 s ! :n-:
5 -
- a. :s g y_ ;. R w ; -
- 3589 g- :gg.: E. - -
g
=
_
ge:
- 55,=:
_ _ _I n_ _ _! ___________________
_ _a : _.==a_:
- 5 I !-
ige l:g_lg! r- 8 i
=
- _yl
- i.wu.
s g
g
. :- ::._ g:=
3 8
- g .:
E i w
i.g,-l 8 8
l
- Ig=:
i lin_gg n w-ag : q e 'l .. : :
- ___og : -
= =_ ~ :!,a m i.
9 __7_____________________!
- == =
- 1.g: -
m
- :n :
=r ig2:g_I i
I y i :
- s:
=
1.gl wg- w a g
=.e:
R :- wa i.g,1 =
l
==.:
=w a:
gmig e
ads,e i
e_
- 53:
- a ==~:
__l-ga .i._=__ _ =am:
=_ :
I :
55 i l=f-i _f 8
if i E it5!!lN 89 13 : E83
- - 3 a
=.
l:
i=m =
.=
si .
lM! sawn : 8 l .
335::-3 S l I
==~:
g =as=
E __is__
n au 3
w 1 X :.] _*_! gee-
= i - u a al a s s. = 1 s ] H . . l a. i.
m ~ - Eem 38
____I_ _______I E
1
. . 5 i.
ENCLOSURE 2 9
._.. ~ ; *. .
- . 4 i .& ,
'.. y .t.,
-l- . ' a :. 0.;
.l
. ht "
u,. .
Jyt 2 91986
> Mr. P. R. Bemis '
M Georgia Power Company -
333 Piedmont Avenue
- 14th Floor. Nuclear Operations Atlanta, Georgia 30308 f
f E. I. Hatch Nuclear Plant Units 1 & 2 Bechtel Job'6511 - 034 - R66720 REA RESPONSE LETTER Request for Engineering Assistance REA - HT- 66720. EVALUATION OF BUILDING i
SETTLEMENT DATA File: A29.3/A35.1/0110/A57.75 B-GP-14504 l
Dear Mr. Bemis:
In response to your request in the subject REA, we have completed our review and evaluation of the January, 1986 settlement data. Enclosed (see attachment A) are Tables 1 through 10 and Figures 3 through 12 of the " Report on Settlement l of Major Plant Structures "(Ref.B-GP-14384 dated June 16,1986) which have been
[ updated to reflect changes resulting from the January 1986 data.
In summary, all structures reviewed are performing as they have in the past. No total settlements have reached'the preaicted values, and all differential settlements are less than their corresponding allowable. However, we should point out that, six markers (all four in the Diesel Generator Building and the Northeast Marker in each Reactor Building) recorded movements exceeding 0.10 i inches from the previous survey of J;ly 1985. While the Individual marker in the case of the Reactor Building excreded the 0.10 inch criterion, the average settlement for the structure did not exceed the Technical Specification re-survey requirement. Consequently, a re-survey of the Reactor Building markers was not required (viz, by interpretation of Technical Specification Section 4.7.8). The markers for the Diesel Generator Building, however, were re-surveyed to confirm the validity of the data.
Finally, the January 1986 settlement data shows no notable departure from the historical settlement information available, and serves to re-affirm the conclusions and reco.unendations in the referenced report.
Also enclosed (see attachment B) are corrections to Tables 1, 3, and 4 (previously issued based on the July 1985 data) of the referenced report.
Please note that these tables have been superseded by the updated tables contained in Attachment A and are included for information only. Please update your copy of the referenced report accordingly, i
__........._.___..._.._..m_t.,__w,_. _;._.. .
lJ'Ji. E E 1986 2 B-GP-1450' Mr.P.R.Bem{s r
i .
With regard to your request to develop personal computer software to compute building differential settlement, the work is well underway and is forecast to be complete in early August.
If you have any question on require additional information concerning the matter, please do not hesitate to contact us.
Very truly yours, Driginal signed by E JUL 2 9 1986 Gaffo.urA. A.csIKosi Project Engineer GAK:CLW:SJ0:blf Enclosures Attachment A (20 sheets)
Attachment B ( 3 Sheets) cc: Southern Company Services, Inc. bec: J. Lydard, w/1 W. F. Garner, w/l K. khianey,t;/1 W. L. Orr, w/l C. L. Weaver, w/1 Georgia Power Company (Atl) A. Sanver, w/1
- v. R. Jordan, w/1 M. Lewis, w/1 L. T. Gucwa, w/l R. S. Nadolski, w/1 Disk CIVIL 8 M. J. Blackwood, w/1 R. D. Baker, w/l Georgia Power Company (HNP)
H. C. Nix, Jr., w/l S. Tipps, w/o I
l 9e
4 . .
-ATTACHMENT A TO B-GP-14504 f
(20 SHEETS)
I Y
l l
l f
)
l l
i L
L l
f 1
i l
r Se
l TABLE 1 PREDICTED AND MEASURED TOTAL SETTLEMENTS l
I.
1
[ RATIO OF MEASURED .
SETTLEMENT-INCHES 2 TO PREDICTED-%
MEASURED .
STRUCTURE PREDICTED MAXIMUM TO DATEz MAXIMUM TO DATE8 I l
Reactor Building Unit 1 3.1 2.8 2.7 90 87 Reactor Building Unit 2 4.5 2.0 1.3 44 40 Turbine Building Unit 1 1.5 1.2 1.1 80 73 Turbine Building Unit 2 2.0 0.3 ---
15 --
j Radwaste Building Unit 1 1. 5 0.8 0.7 53 47 l Radwaste Building Unit 2 3.5 0.5 0.1 14 3 Control Building 2. 0 1.5 1.5 75 75 Diesel Generator Building 2.0 1. 0 . D. 8 50 40 Offgas (Main) Stack 2.0 0.4 0. 4 20 20
, Intake Structure 2.0 1.54 1.54 70 75 i
l l 1 l
[ l l
i 3 Settlements are reported to the nearest 0.1 inch.
2*anuari1986 reading.
8A11 measurements are currently indicating heave.
4 Measured settlements are estimates only, since complete records do not exist prior to July 1978.
,, y _.
- . TABLE 2
SUMMARY
OF DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS ACROSS STRUCTURES
..l. .
I '
t DIFFERENTIAL RATIO OF BETWEEN SETTLEMENT MEASURED REFERENCE DIRECTION BENCHMARK INCHES 2 _ TO ALLOWABLE STRUCTURE DATE OF TILT NUM8ERS1 ALLOWABLE MEASURED 3 PERCENT Reactor 5-76 N-S 1 and 2 0.40 0.05 13 Building N-S 3 and 4 0.41 0.06 15 Unit No. 2 E-W 1 and 3 1.67 0.18 11 i E-W 2 and 4 1.61 0.07 4 Radwaste 10-75 N-S 5 and 6 1.85 0.37 20 Building N-S 7 and 8 1.92 0.31 16 Unit No. 2 E-W 5 and 7 1.58 0.02 1 E-W 6 and 8 0. 96 0. 04 4 Control 1-75 N-S 9 and 10 1.00 0.16 16 Building N-S 11 and 12 0. 95 0. 24 25 E-W 9 and 11 3.01 0.24 8 E-W 10 and 12 3.46 0.16 5 Turbine 5-76 N-S 13 and 14 2.59 0. 23 9 Building N-S 154 and 16 2.46 0. 30 12 Unit No. 2 E-W 13 and 154 2.96 0. 18 6 E-W 14 and.16 3.37 0. 11 3 Diesel 1-75 N-S 17 and 18 5.09 0.14 3 Generator N-S 19 and 20 4.73 0. 24 5 Building E-W 17 and 19 2.47 0. 43 17 E-W 18 and 20 2.47 0. 05 2 Offgas 10-74 N-S 21 and 22 0.44 0.14 32 (Main) E-W 21 and 23 0.55 0.08 15 Stack E-W 22 and 23 0.50 0.06 12 Intake 10-745 N-S 24 and 25 2.50 0.20 0 Structure N-S 26 and 27 2.50 0.07 3 E-W 24 and 26 0.65 0.01 2 E-W 25 and 27 1.25 0.12 10 2 Refer to Figure 1 for benchmark. identification.
2 Reported to the nearest 0.01 inch.
3As of January 1986.
4No current survey data are available for benchmark 15; used last available data, January 1979.
sActual benchmarks used were established in July 1978.
l l
i
. TABLE 3
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS
. j- REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND SOIL Ratio of Differential . Measured i Settlement - Inches 2 to Allowable Date of Nearest Measured Allowable Percent Penetration Installation Benchmark to Date2 Pipe Anchor Pipe Anchor 8 in. No. 1 November 1977 1 0.01 0.73 1.03 1 1 10 in. No. 2 December 1977 1 0.01- 1.22 0.96 1 1 18 in. No. 3 April 1978 1 0.0 1.26 0.72 0 0 18 in. No. 4 March 1978 1 -
0.04 1.26 0.72 3 6 6 in. No. 8 November 1977 1 0.01 1.22 0.75 1 1 10 in. No. 10 January 1978 2 0.11 1.22 0.96 9 11 18 in. No. 11 March 1978 2 0.13 1.26 0.72 10 18 20 in. No. 12 January 1978 2 0.11 1.13 0.56 10 20 18 in. No. 13 April 1978 2 0.13 1.26 0.72 , 10 18 14 in. No. 24 November 1977 2 0.11 1.15 1.06 10 10 10 in. No. 41 February 1977 - 2 0.02 1.28 0.88 2 2 16 in. No. 42 March 1978 2 0.13 1.06 0.73 12 18
, 14 in. No. 134 March 1978 1 0.04 1.15' 1.13 3 4 20 in. No. 161 January 1978 1 0.0 1.13 0.71 0 0 I
~
I 3 Reported to the nearest 0.01 inch. l 2As of January 1986. i
TABLE 4
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS j, DIESEL GENERATOR BUILDING AND SOIL Ratio of Differential - Measured Settlement - Inches 2 to Allowable Date of Nearest Measured Allowable Percent Panetration Installation Benchmark to Date2 Pipe Anchor Pipe Anchor 6 in. January 1978 17 0.02 0.57 0.57 4 4 10 in. December 1971 17 0.353 0.92 ----
38 --
d b
4 s
3 Reported to the nearest 0.01 inch.
. 2As of January 1986.~
sEarliest reading on Benchmark 17 is December 1972.
em -
TABLE 5
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS j, MAIN STACK AND SOIL i :
~
Differential Ratio of Settlement - Inches1 - Neasured Measured Allowable to Allowable Penetration Installation Benchmark to Date2 in Pipe Percent 18 in. June 1974 23 0.10 0.45 22 12 in. May 1974 23 0.10 0.45 22 20 in. June 1974 22 0.04 0.46 9 6 in. May 1974 22 ,
0.04 0.46 9 t
l i
1 2 Reported to the nearest 0.01 inch. I 2As of January 1986. '
l
\
mr --,m_--
TABLE 6
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION OIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS g, INTAKE STRUCTURE AND SOIL f -
Ratio of Differential -
Measured Settlement - Inches 1 to Allowable Date of Nearest Measured Allowable 3 Percent Penetration Installation Benchmark to Date2 Pipe Support Pipe Support 30 in. January 1978 25 0.29 1.38 0.66 21 44 El. 97.28 ft
. 12 in. July 1974 25 0.29 0.99 1.19 29 24 18 in. '
(Unit 2) February 1978 25 O.29 2.78 2.03 10 14 30 in. January 1978 25 0.29 1.38 0.66 21 44 El. 91.75 ft.
(Unit 1) 30 in. January 1978 25 0.29 1.38 0.66 21 44 El. 91.75 ft.
(Unit 2) 18 in. February 1978 27 0.17 2.47 1.27. 7 13 (Unit 1) 6 in. April 1976 26 0.10 1.50 0.94 7 11 i
2Reportedtokhenearest0.01 inch.
2 Measured differential settlements are estimates only, since complete records do not exist prior to July 1978. Measured settlements are as of January 1986.
8 Allowable settlement is based on both pipe stress and support loads.
l l
l TABLE 7 l
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS i qEACTORBUILDINGHNP-2ANDRADWASTEBUILDINGHNP-2 l .
Ratio of Differential - Measured Settlement - Inchest to Allowable Date of Nearest Measured Allowable Percent Penetration Installation Benchmark to Daten Pipe Anchor Pipe Anchor ,
1 in. No. 51 October 1977 2 and 5 0.16 1.54 --
10 --
6 in. No. 51 October 1977 2 and 5 0.16 1.14 --
14 --
1.5 in. No. 102 November 1977 2 and 5 0.14 1.07 --
13 8 in. No. 153 February 1977 4 and 5 ' O.12 1.48 0.88 8 14 s
2 Reported to the nea' rest 0.01 inch.
2As of January 1986.
TABLE 8
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS
{ REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND CONTROL BUILDING l .
Ratio of Differential - Measured Settlement - Inches 2 to Allowable Date of Nearest Measured Allowable Percent Penetration Installation Benchmark to Date2 Pipe Anchor Pipe Anchor 24 in. No.,59 May 1978 3 and 10 0.14 26.03 13.23 1 1 3 in. No. 60 January 1978 3 and 10 0.23 1.48 0.62 16 37 18 in. No. 61 August 1977 3 and 10 0.24 9.55 1.86 3 13 24 in. No. 61 September 1976 3 and 10' O.17 12.14 5.06 1 3 4 in. No. 68 January 1978 3 and 10 0.23 1.84 0.85 13 27 4 in. No. 69 January 1978 3 and 10 0.23 1.99 0.78 12 29 4
1 r
l 2 Reported to the nea' rest 0.01 inch.
2As of January 1986.
TABLE 9
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS fEACTORBUILDINGHNP-2ANDTURBINEBUILDINGHNP-2 l -
Ratio of Differential -
Measured Settlement - Inches 2 to Allowable Date of Nearest Measured Allowable Percent P::netration Installation Benchmark to Oate2 Pipe Anchor Pipe Anchor 10 in. No. 43 May 1978 4 and 13 0.01 2.12 1.68 1 1 4 in. No. 44 January 1978 4 and 13 0.01 1.30 -- 1 --
3 in. No. 57 November 1977 4 and 13 0.01 4.I7 '
1 --
18 in. No. 57 July 1977 4 and 13 ' O.14 9.55 1.59 1 9 24 in. No. 57 September 1976 4 and 13 0.26 25.13 10.59 1 2 (El. 154.46) 24 in. No. 57 September 1976 4 and 13 0.26 22.54 9.05 ,1 3 (El. 154.55) 8 in. No. 84 February 1977 4 and 13 0.17 1.13 1.01 15 17
~
10 in. No. 90 January 1978 4 and 13 0.01 2.51 1.77. I 1 3 in. No. 92 December 1977 4 and 13 0.04 1.78 1.55 2 3 I
l l
1.
1 2 Reported to the nearest 0.01 inch.
2 As of January 1986.
l w
TABLE 10
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS lREACTORBUILDINGHNP-2ANDREACTORBUILDINGHNP-1 Ratio of ,
Differential -
Measured i Settlement - Inches 1 to Allowable Date of Nearest Measured Allowable Percent Penetration Installation Benchmark to Date2 Pipe Anchor Pipe Anchor 8 in. No. 183 January 1978 1 and 29 0.11 0.99 0.53 11 21 8 in. No. 184 December 1977 1 and 29 0.12 3.58 2.30 3 5 I ".
1 Reported to the nearest 0.01 inch.
2As of January 1986.
. 1
1 1
E. I. HATCH NU CLE AR PLANT s' R EACTO R BUILDING U N IT 1 BENCHMARKS i
1.00 me, e
0.00 C Cl 0
6 -1.00; T > __ .
s 2
w o
-200 v+ % --ym. a - _4_ o#SO
^
e.o ,8 sa se
- ^
- O 0
s A
a a
e ,
g 3
2 ophig@t l00 13 a ,
3 0 13 +13 i3 o la
- - ,,- % ++U , + +.+ y + +- p
+ e- + + . + .
-3.00 l
1
-4.00 - - - - -----
'69 '70'71 '72 '71*74 '75 '76 '77 '78 '79 '80 '81 '82 '83 '84 '85 '86 '87
! TI M E-Y E AR S c SW + SE o NE A NW l
l '
! E. I. MATCH NUCLEAR PLANT BECHTEL 1
i NOTE: Approximate time of structure completion i in May 1976. m 65H REACTOR SUILDING UNIT 1 l BENCWARK SETTLEE NT FIGURE 3 i
j -
1 l - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
4 L H
. E 5 E T 6 R H U C G 7 K m I F
_ 8 6 -
8 T
N 2 5 A T 8 L
P TT IN NE R UM N 4 A E GL NT E
A S 8
' W L
C U
Ii DE LK 3 N N H
LS I
UK PRA 8
' T C
A BR RM A
M a H OH T
H 2 CK RC 8 I
AE EB R
ANE 1 E
EB '
8 E
L2 SN R
CT 0A I ,
8 E UNU Yo 9 E-NGN 7 M
I I
D T 8
HL I 7 E
S- n o
CUG 7 i
t e
T R 7
+
l p
m AOT 6 o
c HCA 7 e r
u E .,' t
.R ;
5 W c u
S I 7 r
' t s
. f 4 o o E 7
' e m
i t
3 .
7 e6 t7 a9
= m1 2 i xy 7 oa
- rM p
- 0 0 d 0 0 0 0 Ai pn 0 0 O.
0 0 1 O 1 2 3 4 :
E
- - - - 1 0
N 3
8 c ~ a
u
(
E. I. HATCH N U CLE AR PLANT-SETTLEMENT RADWASTE BUILDING U N IT 1 BENCHMARKS - - -
1.00 _ _ _
0.00 :=
h i p 9 3 1
9 9 g
-1.00 I
W b
2 y - 2.00 9 .
-3.00
-4.00
'69 *70 '71 '72 *73 '74 '75'76'77 '78 '79 '80 '81 '82 '83'84 '85 '86 '87 TI M E- Y E ARS c2 SW + SE o NE a NW E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT KCHTEL NOTE: Approximate time of structure completion JOB 6511 not known. RADWASTE BUILDING UNIT 1 BENCHMARK SETTLEE NT FIGURE 5
E. I. HATCH NU CLE AR P LA NT- S ETTLE M ENT
- RADWASTE BUILDING U N IT 2 BENCHMARKS 1.00 w-y
-, e ,m $ GI & 9 aE @O
~
g" g4 ge ,
a 3 o 4 0 4 a 4* b 1
L.s c -1.00 T
2 y -2.00 9
-3.00
-4.00
'69 '70 *71 '72 '73 *74 '75'76'77 '78 '79 '80 '81 '82 '83 '84 '85'86 '87 TI M E-Y E ARS o SW + SE o NE a NW E. I. HATCH MUCLEAR PLANT BECHTEL NOTE: Approximate time of structure completion JOB 6511 in October 1975. RADWASTE BUILDING UNIT 2 KKMARK SETTLEENT FIGURE 6
L 1 7 E 1 T 5 E _
H 6 R C U B G T .
E O J
I F _
N m, 7
. 8 _
. E .
-F ,6 M A ,
8 T
N A
1 E SC 5 8
L P
TT IN N
L 6 +
R A
UE E T 1; 4 8
E L
C GL NT IT T e +
3 U
W ES -F 8
' N H
C T
UK Bt u SKR A
-7 2
A H EM NI I C A 8
. BN M O + A 1 RE UB THC b "
1 8
E
. T NNE O +
-i 0 AB 8
' E L1 +
+
- 9 SN R
7 PT I E +
+
' A E
N o P 8 Yo 7
RU CW'A 7
E AGN '# 7 M I
n I '
T EDL ^ 6 E i o
LIU ^
MI 7
S t l
e CB M 5 p
m o
7 + c UEN '
e r
4 NBR I
7 u t
c _
u U 3 r _
t HT 7 S
W f
s _
C = 2 7
o e .
T '
o m5 i7 t9 A
1 1
7 e -
t y H 0 ar ma i u 7
- xn _
. oa rJ I ^
9 p 6 pn
- Ai 0 0 0 0 0 0 :
E0 0 0 0 2
0 3
0 4
E T
O 1 0 1 N
M NI 2yo I l : 1, j, , ,, i. 1i 11):iI L
~
E. I. HATCH N U CLE AR P LANT- S ETTLEMENT
- TURBINE BUILDING U NIT 2 BENCHMARKS 1.00 mm IB B l
m'g a: n e,I Pe15 s i
0,00 ~MS. n= wd e 3
,A ~
~
,o 1 , ,o ,
P fh &M{"
l I
! E)
-1.00
~
1 2
y -2.00 i o 2
l
-3.00 i
i j
-4.00
)
'69 '70 '71 '72'73'74 '75'76'77 '78'79'80'81 '82 *B 3 '8 4 '85 '86 '87 TI M E-Y EA RS NW C3 SW + SE o NE a I -
i E. I.1;ATCH NUCLEAR PLANT BECHTEL 1
! NOTE: Approximate time of structure completion JOB 6511
! in May 1976. TUR8INE BUILDING UNIT 2 i
BEKMARK SETTLEENT I FIGURE 8 I
i i
l
,, : li L 1 9 E 1
- T 5 E H 6 R C U E B G T ~~
B O J
I F
N 7 8
. E '
6 4 $ ,
M A 8+
8 T
l l
E 1 $ , 5 A L
P T
N L 8 l
0 8+ -
R A
GE I
I IE T 1 s , -4 8 E.
l DL LT T 0 8+
3 C
U N
IT UE BS E 1 $ e l 8
W N
H C
S s p 8+
2 T
A H TM N
8 OC K - ' . Cl l R 6 8+ - a I E B
TAM }5&
- 1 B
E NH A;+
1 3 , 0 ACN 8
' E LEB O 8 ,
N $" 9 SN R
P M 6 f ++
- 7
- ' A E ~
G dt "+ 8 7
Yo RND -
7 I '
M E A 7 M AIL l
'e 7 I T n EUB M*q 6 E i o
LL .
e 7 S t e
COR c L
g '
5 l
p m
o UTN _
z 7
+ c
- 4 e h, r NOC ~ _ '
7 t u
c u
% 3 r H I 7'
w S
t s
C : 2 7
f o
T .
o e
m5 i7 A
- 1 t9 7
- e 1
H 0 t y ar ma 7 iu
' xn oa I 9 rJ P p
- 6 pn
' Ai 0 0 0 0 0 E0 0 -
0 2
0 3
0 4
E T
1 O ' O
- N m g1bL2yo2 J.
0 L 1 E
T E H R C U T E B
G I
F N. . .
7 s -
E 1
e sa >
M s
- T G a9 _ N N E 2" , s a
A L
I DT LN L P ae -
R UE I
4 T 3s i s
A E
L BE RT L
T S a9 a W C
U N
F is '
s
- N H C
R EK NR S *, *9 .
2 T
A EA GMH d 3a > H
- CHi .s LC i
^9 o _
A . EN I SE EB TN i
ss >
i
, s
- E
. I D
NEB aa
^9o
- .o A s
- E LGN s n, am
> 9 SN R 7
PDL I
aa
- i
_ - A E
I J. a#T'o sY 7
o RB t
^ mo m
eoo
^ E
^ 7 M AR i 7 I A. -
T EOT s E n
o LAR i
v S t
e CEN h< 5 l
p m
UEG $% 7-
+ o c
gM 4 e r
NLE i 7
- t u
c S 3 u
! r II E 4 7 W t s
S D
C 2 7
f o
T -
1 o
i e
m A 7 t
e H 0 t
a m
7 i I
e o" x
r
, s p
p
. A 0 o 0 o o 0 E0 c.
o 0,
1 o.
2 c.
a 0
4 E
T O
_ - - - N lIWr E w51yos I:!:ll _1 I. !l, , ' ' !i; ;ii l'l!' .
i ! i !!,
--- ~- - ' - - - - - ~
}
E. I. H ATCI-I NU CLE AR P LANT- S ETTLEMENT INTA K E STRUCTURE BENOHMARKS _
O.00 1
i d
I * '
_1.00 l w E h13hih+igh13 8
> V 5
2 y -2.00 .
o
-3.00 i
- 4.O O . - - . - -
- 69*70'71 '72 '73 '74 '75 '76 '77 '70'79'80'81 '82 '83'84 '85 '86 '87 TI M E-Y EARS
! E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PUWT BECHTEL NOTE: Approximate time of structure completion in October 1974. gg JOB 6511 3, g BENCMARK SETTLEENT FIGURE 11 0 9
E. I. HATCH N U C LE AR PLANT- S ETTLE M ENT OFFOAS STACK SENCHMARKS 1.00 v=-
^
l i qw.gp%W fiS BfR3 58 9';9'? 'd 58 i
!c y - 1.00
! T t-6 m
, ig - 2.c o -
o 2
i
- -a.co l
- 4. O o es2 h3 .h4 '85 *b6 'b7
'69 '7o '71 '72 '73 *7'4 '75 '76 '77 '78 '79 '80,*s1 TIME-YEARS c S + W 9 NE E. I. HATCH NUCLEAR PLANT KCHTEL NOTE: Approximate time of structure completion in October 1974. 65H OFTGAS (MRIN) STACK K EHMARK SETTLEMENT FIGURE 12 .
4
O k e ATTACHMENT B TO B-GP-14504
( 3 SHEETS) e e@
TABLE 1 0
PREDICTED AND MEASURED TOTAL SETTLEMENTS t
j -
RATIO OF MEASURED i
) SETTLEMENT-INCHES 1 TO PREDICTED-% :
MEASURED STRUCTURE PREDICTED MAXIMUM TO F MAXIMUM TO DATE2 Reactor Building Unit 1 3.1 2.8 2.6 90 84 R; actor Building Unit 2 4. 5 2.0 1.7 44 38 Turbine Building Unit 1 1.5 1.2 1.2 80 80 Turbine Building Unit 2 2.0 0.3 ---
15 --
l Radwaste Building Unit 1 1.5 0. 8 0.6 53 40 Radwaste Building Unit 2 Control Building 3.5 2.0 0.5 $ 0.1 14 5
,1. 5 1.5 75 75 Diesel Generator Building 2.0 1.0 1.0 50 50 Offgas (Main) Stack 2.0 0.4 0.3 20 15 Intake Structure 2. 0 1.44 1.5 Q
- 70 r31 16 l
l l
l I
l 2 Settlements are reported to the, nearest 0.1 inch.
2 July 1985 reading. -
8A11 measurements are currently indicating heave.
4 Measured settlements are estimates only, since complete records do not oxist prior to July 1978.
n-
n- .
~
> TABLE 3
SUMMARY
0F PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS e: REACTOR BUILDING HNP-2 AND SOIL l
Ratio of Differential Peasured Settlement - Inchess to' Allowable Date of Nearest Measured Allowable Percent Penetration Installation Benchmark to Dates Pipe Anchor Pipe Anchor 8 in. No. 1 November 1977 1 0.13 0.73 1.03 [O 10 in. No. 2 December 1977 1 0.11 1.22 0.96 9 11 18 in. No. 3 April 1978 1 0.12 1.26 0.72 10 17 18 in. No. 4 March 1978 1 -
0.16 1.26 0.72 13 22 6 in. No. 8 November 1977 1 0.13 1.22 0.75 11 17 10 in. No. 10 January 1978 2 0.18 1.22 0.96 15 19 18 in. No. 11 March 1978 2 0.20 1.26 0.72 16 28 20 in. No. 12 January 1978 2 0.18 1.13 0.56 16 32 18 in. No. 13 April 1978 2 0.20 1.26 0.72 ,
16 28 14 in. No. 24 November 1977 2 0.18 1.15 1.06 16 17 10 in. No. 41 February 1977 2 0.10 1.28 0.88 8 11 IG in. No. 42 March 1978 2 0.20 1.06 0.73 19 27 14 in. No. 134 March 1978 1 0.16 1.15i 1.13 14 14 20 in. No. 161 January 1978 ,1 0.12 1.13 0.71 11 17 3 Reported to the nearest 0.01 inch.
2As of July 1985.
l l
l
(- -
TABLE 4
SUMMARY
OF PENETRATION DIFFERENTIAL SETTLEMENTS DIESEL GENERATOR BUILDING AND SOIL l- .
l :
Ratio of Differential Measured Settlement - Inches 2 to Allowable Date of Nearest Measured Allowable Percent Penetration Installation Benchmark to Dates Pipe Anchor Pipa Anchor 6 in. January 1978 17 0.20 0.57 0.57 35 35 10 in. December 1971 17 c.% 3 0.92 ----
[ -- '
F A
3 Reported to the nearest 0.01 inch.
2As of July 1985.
8 Earliest reading on' Benchmark 17 is December 1972.
N.
- g".---_,
- ENCLOSURE 3 ATTENDANCE LIST h~ OCTOBER 21, 1986 MEETING WITH GPC TO DISCUSS <
s :
HATCH 2 BUILDING SETTLEMENT DATA ,
NAME ORGANIZATION G. Rivenbark '
NRC/NRR C. P.. Tan. NRC/NRR J. Heidt GPC 1
M. Lewis Bechtel 'l C. Weaver Bechtel i
l i
i I
i i
l