ML20197J033

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Partially Deleted e-mail Informing of Scheduled Internal Meeting on 980605 Re Old Issue That Need Resolution Maint Rule Compliance at Browns Ferry,Unit 1
ML20197J033
Person / Time
Site: Browns Ferry Tennessee Valley Authority icon.png
Issue date: 06/02/1998
From: De Agazio A
NRC
To: Black S, Hebdon F, David Nelson
NRC
Shared Package
ML20197H447 List:
References
FOIA-98-330 NUDOCS 9812140241
Download: ML20197J033 (3)
v • d • e


Text

- _ . - m -__._ _ _ . _ . . _ . _ _ _ __

g/ ff ,p 3(

9 h . l.H f From: Albert De Agaz j [ /

WNP5.S ; FJH, WNP6.DJN, WNP6. MAS, WNP5.RLS, JAZ #

To:

I l

Dates- 6/2/98 10:27am subject: Browns Ferry, Unit 1 maintenance 2ssue fg Good Morning, i I have scheduled an internal meeting on an old issue that needs resolution l l s maintenance rule compliance at Browns Ferry, Unit 1 (BFN1). The meeting will {

be held in Room O-16 B6 from 0930 to 1100, June 5, 1998. j

,The following chronology should help refresh your memories and/or prepare you  !

for the. meeting. ,

l The NRC conducted an inspection of the implementation of 10 CFR 50.65 at l s CFN1 (April 4 through 18, 1997). The results are documented in Inspection Report 50-259/97-04 (May 21, 1997).

The inspection team found that TVA had scoped SSCs for Unit i under the rule considering plant status (i.e., shutdown and defueled). Unit i systems supporting Unit 2 or Unit 3, common systems, and systems needed to maintain safe shutdown of Unit 1 were properly scoped. h other systems usually in the scope for an operating plant were not included in the scope, and performance monitoring, data collection, and trending were not being performed because the systems were not in use or were

( in layup.

1 The inspection team concluded that TVA's actions to implement the rule at Unit 1 are technically adequate, however, the inspectors raised the question as to whether the approach taken is legal under the maintenance rule (URI 50-290/97-04-01).

Region II issued TIA 97-015 (June 4, 1997) requesting assistance ... to develop a list of actions necessary for TVA to comply legally with the Rule on  !

Unit 1. Region requested the list of actions be provided directly to TVA.

I NRR letterd o TVA July 30, 1997, states 'that the paragraph (a) (1) l limitation for plants that are permanently shutdown does not apply to BFN1. l Thus, full compliance is required. The letter indicated that three options l

l are available:

l Revise the scope of the monitoring program for Unit 1 {

l Submit certification of permanent shutdown per 50.82 (a) (1) l Submit a request for an exemption.

i-j The letter requested that TVA indicate which action it believes is j l

applicable, or discuss how another proposed option is consistent with the

, regulations.

  • TVA responded by letter (September 29, 1997) stating its contention that .

the Unit 1 program is in compliance.with the rule and presented its reasons ]

for this belief. /

9812140241 981202  : . - + N " e C1- 3 l PDR FOIA *1 4

"...,-s e . $' u . 4 j LOCHBAU98-330 PDR FO: A. h"#"D""

, p -

1 n

,_ . . . . - - _ - _ . _ . . . ~ - . _ . - . -- - . . . . _ . . - . _ - _ - - . . . ...-_-_ _. -__ _

o 5 -

TVA and NRC staff met in Rockville on January 26, 1998, and a Meeting Summary sas issued (February 6, 1998). The last paragraph of the Meeting Summary describes TVA's proposed resolution.

TVA submitted its proposed program to resolve the issue (letter dated k 1

April 3, 1998). It i 1998, Meeting Summary.

imilar to the program outlined in the January 26, h//

V, ,

l -

l i I will provide each of you copies of the documentation discussed above if

requested.

a

}

i i

4 ty.H j

i

]

j siJ ----

The purpose of the June 5 meeting is for the staff to review and discuss the NRC position prior to the appeal meeting, and to inform Division management of l the issue.

I j The following, or alternates if necessary, are requested to attend the June 5 meeting:

S. Black F. Hebdon

]

D. Nelson or M. Satorius R. Spessard J. Zwolinski If you believe others from your staff need to attend, please feel free to j bring them along.

4 i Al De Agazio 415-1443 l

l

CC
WNP4.BAB2, WNP4.BWS I

j .e i

i I

i

. _ = . . . -

~ -

l a

.' i 8- l i

l Mail Envelope Infos (35740BBA.2B0 : 8 : 11019)

]

Subject:

Browns Ferry, Unit 1 maintenance issue Creation Dates 6/2/QB 10:27am From: Albert De Agazio Created By: WND2.WNP3:ADA Recipients Action Date & Time Post Office WND2.WNP3 Delivered 06/02/98 10:27am FJH (Frederick Hebdon) Opened 06/02/98 10:35am Deleted 06/03/98 06:57am JAZ (John Zwolinski) Opened 06/02/98 12:33pm Deleted 06/02/98 12:34pm Post Office WND2.WNP4 Delivered 06/02/98 10:27am BAB2 CC (Bruce Boger) Opened 06/02/98 12:35pm BWS CC (Brian Sheron) Opened 06/02/98 02:33pm Deleted 06/02/98 02:34pm Post Office WND2.WNP5 Delivered 06/02/98 10:27am RLS (R. Lee Spessard) Opened 06/02/98 10:44am Deleted 06/02/98 04:34pm SCB (Suzanne Black) Opened 06/02/98 11:29am

( Post Office WND2.WNP6 Delivered 06/02/98 10:27am DJN (David Nelson) Opened 06/02/98 11:30am MAS (Mark Satorius) Opened 06/02/98 04:53pm 1 l

Domain. Post Office Delivered Route WND2.WNP3 06/02/98 10:27am WND2.WNP3 WND2.WNP4 06/02/98 10:27am WND2.WNP4 WND2.WNPS 06/02/98 10:27r WND2.WNPS WND2.WNP6 06/02/98 10:27am WND2.WNP6 i Files Size Date & Time i MESSAGE 4206 06/02/98 10:27am l

View 4109 06/02/98 06
27am Options Auto Delete: No l Rxpiration Dates None Notify Recipients: Yes l Priority: Normal
Reply Requested
No I

Return Notification:

Send Notification when Opened Concealed subject: No Security: Normal To Be Delivered: Immediate Status Tracking: All Information l

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20197J033&oldid=3341240"