ML20150D157

Response of State of Ny to NRC Staff First Set of Interrogatories & Requests for Production of Documents Re Hosp Evcacuation Time Estimates.* Certificate of Svc Encl. Related Correspondence

ML20150D157
Person / Time
Site:	Shoreham File:Long Island Lighting Company icon.png
Issue date:	03/18/1988
From:	Zahnleuter R NEW YORK, STATE OF
To:	NRC OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL (OGC)
References
CON-#188-5905 OL-3, NUDOCS 8803230139
Download: ML20150D157 (12)

Text

o 6765

' EbMEMUlfUM 00CMETED USHRC

~-

DATE: March 18, 1988

'88 itg 21 pd fj UNITED STATES OF AMERICA --

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION crFME 00Ch[!,I h; N N- [-

o g ,;

Before the Atomic Safety and Licensina Board In the Matter of )

)

LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-322-OL-3

) (Emergency Planning)

(Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, )

)

Unit 1) )

i RESPONSE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK TO THE NRC STAFF'S FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION

.0F DOCUMENTS REGARDING HOSPITAL EVACUATION TIME ESTIMATES This is the State of New York's response to the NRC Staff's First Set of Interrogatories and Requests to Produce to Suffolk County, State of New York and Town of Southampton Concering Hospital Evacuation," dated February 29, 1988 ("NRC Staff's First Set of Interrogatories and Requests").1 To the extent that the NRC Staff's First Set of Interrogatories and Requests seeks information and documents of any sort that are not within the possession, custody or control of the State of New York, but, rather within the possession, custody or control of 1The Board's "Memorandum and Order (Ruling on LILCO's Motion for Summary Disposition of the Hospital Evacuation Issue),"

dated February 24, 1988 and received by the State of New York on March 1, 1988, established a discovery period commencing upon receipt of the Order. This response is being served within the time frames established in 10 CFR 2.740b, 2.710 and the Order.

M 8803230139 880318 PDR ADOCK 05000322 ()D-)

G PDR

L counties, towns or other local governments (including suffolk County the Town of Southampton), the State of New York objects.

Counties, towns or other local governments are autonomous from the State of New York and are not within the State of New York's control. Accordingly, the burden of obtaining such information is the same for the NRC Staff as it is for the State of New York.

To the extent that the NRC's First Set of Interrogatories and Requests seeks information and documents of any sort that are protected against disclosure, for example, by attorney work product doctrine, the State of New York objects.

NRC Staff Interrocatories Nos. 1-2

1. With regard to hospital evacuation time estimates, identify the person [s] whom Intervenors expect to call as a witness. For each witness:

a. State the substance of his or her testimony, including the facts and opinions to which the witness is expected to testify;

b. Provide the basis for each such opinion;

c. Identify and provide all documents, including upon which the witnesses intend to rely;

d. Identify all prior statements made by the witnesses in testimony or deposition, in this or other proceedings, which concern the subject matter of their testimony.

Response: In response to paragraphs 1(a) snd 1(b), on March 9, 1988, the State of New York identified David T. Hartgen, Ph.D.,

as an expert witness it expects to call to testify on hospital evacuation time estimates. Dr. Hartgen will likely offer ]

1 testimony concerning the bascs and accuracy of LILCO's hospital 2

l l

O evacuation time estimates. Although Dr. Hartgen's review of the calculations underlying the time estimates has not been completed yet, Dr. Hartgen's testimony will probably concern questionable methodological assumptions and procedures regarding travel speeds, reception hospital assignments and capacities, vehicle allocations, route designations and other assumptions and procedures. It is possible that further discovery, investigation and analysis could have an effect on the substance of Dr.

Hartgen's testimony.

In response to paragraph 1(c), at this time, the State of New York has identified several such documents, they are attached hereto. If any such documents are identified as a result of further discovery, investigation and analysis, they will be provided as appropriate.

In response ta paragraph 1(d), as the NRC Staff is aware, Dr.

Hartgen testified in the 1984 emergency planning hearings and 1987 reception center hearings concerning Shoreham evacuation time estimates. Dr. Hartgen's prefiled testimony was provided to the NRC Staff when it was filed in those proceedings. Other than that profiled testimony and Dr. Hartgen's February 1, 1988 affidavit submitted in this hospital evacuation cime estimate proceeding, the State of New York is not aware of any such statements.

2. For each witness identified in response to Interrogatory 1, provide a statement of the witness' educational and professional background, with specific reference to his or her qualifications to give the particular testimony.

l 3

-0 Respon_ae: The State of New York.provided the NRC Staff with a copy of Dr. Ha'rtgen's most current resume under cover of a letter dated March 9, 1988.

Obiections Stated by Counsel Counsel states all objections, assertions of privilege, and answers not requiring verification.

,',;/. & / ktb Q Fabian G.fy41dhfno Richard J. Zahnleuter Special Counsel to the Governor Attorneys fcr Mario M. Cuomo, Governor, and the State of New York 4

1 VERIFICATION STATE OF NEW YORE) SS:

COUNTY OF ALBANY )

David T. Hartgon, Ph.D., beint dul/ sworn, deposes and says:

that he has read the answers to Interrogatories Nos. 1-2 and that based upon such information of which he has personal knowledge and with which he has been provided, he is informed and believes the matters stated therein to be true to the best of his knowledge and belief, and on these grounds, alleges that the matters stated therein are true and therefore verifies the foregoing on behalf of the State of New York.

v.,w C ,s!, W David T. Hartgen,(Ph.D.

Sworn to before me this N' S day of March 1988

[ k b Notarf4ublic il h aw . Amuse -

t'etary P.stut bta'a o, :.n.. a-Qualifg d 'n A ., m r . ,. :i i d A(6..th fio. 4766943 Co e >ss*oon I rp.tes T .i .

DOCMETEt.

USNRC a

DATE: March 18, 1988 M MAR 21 P6 :04 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA f0C T ChkO[h' c

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BRANCH Before the Atomic Safety and Licensina Board In the Matter of )

. )

IONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-322-OL-3

) (Emergency Planning)

(Shoreham Nuclear Power Station )

s )

Unit 1) / )

i s \

t k' 4 c

'fiEElkICATE OF SEELCJ %

.\

, i'.

D hereby, certify that copies cf th') "Responrd of the State of New York to'the JRC Staf f's First '3et of Interr gatories and I'equ e s+1 for Production of Documents Regarding Hospital Eva'cuation Time Estimates" have been served on the following this luth day of March 1988 by U.S. Mail, first class, except ep noted by asterisks. , '

< )

? ,

Mr. Frederick J.TShou Spence W. Perry, Esq.' ,

s William R. Cumming, Esq.

4, Atomic Safety anrj Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Offide of General Courael,I)

( Washington, D.C. s20555 Federal Emergency Managenenlt Agenc 7

l 500 C ! t,rcety S .W. , Room M0' T s s

' Washington,' D.C. 20472,7 i Dr. Jerry R. Klin;k .Mr. James ?)'P,1eason, dhairman s 5tomic Ssfety and Licehing ~ Bohrd i At.omic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U . S'. Nuclear Regulatory' Commission s Washington, )>.C. 20555 ,

Washington, D.C. 205C25 i g ' 5 1 I

t) (

g I %., t ' (

\ \ '

4

'{ A  %

a g

T

) T T

s. ,

\

. ?,

i

's '

A l

l

, \

\

, y  !

' N

\, ss s i

\

q (

~

5

_ l

.,h ^

._L_ . - - ~-.  % t_

s Anthony F. Earley, Jr. , Esq. Joel Blau, Esq.

General Counsel Director, Utility Intervention Long Island Lighting Company N.Y. Consumer Protection Board 175 East Old Country Road Suite 1020 Hicksville, New York 11801 Albany, New York 12210 Ms. Elisabeth Taibbi Mr. Donald P. Irwin Clerk Hunton & Williams Suffolk County Legislature 707 East Main Street Suffolk County Legislature P.O. Box 1535 Office Building Richmond, Virginia 23212 Veterans Memorial Highway Hauppauge, New York 11788 Mr. L.F. Britt Stephen B. Latham, Esq.

Long Island Lighting company Twomey, Latham & Shea Shoreham Nuclear Power Station 33 West Second Street North Country Road Riverhead, New York 11901 Wading River, New York 11792 Ms. Nora Bredes Docketing and Service Section Executive Director Office of the Secretary Shoreham Opponents Coalition U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 195 East Main Street 1717 H Street, N.W.

Smithtown, New York 11787 Washington, D.C. 20555 Adrian Johnson, Esq. Hon. Patrick G. Halpin New York State Department of Law Suffolk County Executive 120 Broadway, 3rd Floor H. Lee Dennison Building Room 3-16 Veterans Memorial Highway New York, New York 10271 Hauppauge, New York 11788 MHB Technical Associates Dr. Monroe Schneider l 1723 Hamilton Avenue North Shore Committee Suite K P.O. Box 231 San Jose, California 95125 Wading River, New York 11792 l

E. Thomas Boyle Lawrence Coe Lanpher, Esq.

Suffolk County Attorney Kirpatrick & Lockhart Building 158 North County Complex 1800 M Street, N.W.

Veterans Memorial Highway South Lobby - Ninth Floor l Hauppauge, New York 11788 Washington, D.C. 20036 Mr. Jay Dunkleburger George Johnson New York State Energy Office U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Agency Building #2 Washington, D. C. 20555 Empire State Plaza l Albany, New York 12223

! 1 s

e

1 s l I

l Mr. James P. Gleason Douglas J. Hynes Chairman Town Board of Oyster Bay Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Town Hall 513 Gilmoure Drive Oyster Bay, New York 11771 i Silver Spring, MD 20901 I i

l David A. Brownlee, Esq. Mr. Philip McIntrie Kirkpatrick & Lockhart FEMA 1500 Oliver Building 26 Federal Plaza Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15222 New York, New York 10278 Mr. Stuart Diamond Business / Financial NEW YORK TIMES 229 W. 43rd Street New York, New York 10036

/ i ,-2 /// f'

/ [ 0,/'l. , [ffbNS%

Ri6hard J. Zahrtfenter, Esq.

Deputy Special Counsel to the Governor Executive Chamber Capitol, Room 229 Albany, New York 12224 (518) 474-1273

• By Telecopier

• • By Federal Express

-= 1 g

)

4 5ICitIAN 50571TAL IVACUATICf F.ftt 19 MILI-RAI. ?!NI TII!CLt!

SctsAt10:LILC0 CUP Answer: Nat tise: 12.34 16.22 17.23

.""" IsraaP""'"""' ""5coser Afterse"' "' Winter Adverse" Notes Casulative Distrib Ites tength Scale Sist. Speed Tiet 5ss tiet Speed flee ses time fine sas itse C1 stance $ss time there 17.1 Amts1 arrive at treats. 2.50 2.50 2.52 2.56 2.66 2.66 Impet distrbatica 9.81 2.58 at 8 est.

17.2 trecessing at er 8.58 3.66 0.58 3.00 0.53 3.19 Processts; tiet 4.01 3.00 process 18.86 3.92 at 5.I.

17.3 Trnal to $sif. Infire. II.tl f.12 3.12 1.14 4.14 1.21 4.49 Actsals .503,1.121 18.06 4.25 lead pt .111 1.84 20.00 0.f t 16.09 0.12 8.12 19.89 4.56 at Bf! 8 dry -

lit 56 56 14.39 29.88 8.12 16.09 8.98 0.16 46.86 E.66 at tec 30 t ill/t1 Av. 3.50 9.59 1.83 20.t0 0.09 16.08 8.11 0.12 Cale dist 2.17 46.85 6.11 aslead it.30 1.61 at Brest. -

17.4 Losilag - 8.33 4.25 0.58 4.54 0.53 4.93 38.30 1.16 process .

Qsene at 5.1. (?) 8.17 4.81 0.18 5.11 Doess. saclear 18.36 8.48 at 5.1.

18.36 8.74 loed+e 17.5 frv te IF1 heandry 4.83 E.00 8.31 4.56 5.99 8.17 5.18 0.31 5.58 18.11 8.19 at 17! bdry 17.5 8 83r7 to tecpt sosy. 24.97 2.!! 6.68 2.64 7.81 2.88 1.30 T.A. Rosp. 107.16 9.70 at tec Bo LII 56-55 15.43 15.06 1.83 12.00 1.29 1.37 107.16 13.31 g + said III 5*-53 2.25 15.88 0.15 12.08 0.19 9.20 128.60 10.93 at Brest.

0.59 9.25 10.00 8.93 8.50 1.16 1.23 1.8.60 11.18 pr: cess Innket/ Pal /l&O/Ni 15.78 Ctter 137.45 11.94 at 5t Ch 137.45 12.31 g

• load 17.7 Nesitoring 6.66 7.11 1.30 posit. at 8.! 138.52 12.34 at IPL bd 17.1 Uniced 8.33 6.99 0.51 8.32 0.54 6.84 Act 31,.5, allt talance 17.11 frv to trentwood. 13.43 9.62 7.61 0.77 9.99 8.82 9.66 Other .

ht/f&Ch/Ful/Sanken 9.21 28.00 9.46 16.69 0.58 8.62 111 53-55 2.25 48.00 0.86 32.00 8.87 B.87 It.111 1.89 20.00 0.09 16.08 9.12 0.13 17.11 frocessing 8.25 7.86 8.25 9.34 0.27 9.92 23.3 frv to suff. Inf. 18.05 0.54 8.40 0.68 10.02 0.72 19.65 11.111 1.34 29.9) 0.t1 16.00 0.12 8.12 t!! 56-66 14.39 40.08 8.36 32.C0 0.45 0.48 tt 101/L!av 1.83 20.00 8.89 15.00 0.11 0.12 ,

Qvete at 5.t. 8.81 0.98 1.04 Docusentatics inclear.

• 23.4 Lending I.33 1.74 8.55 11.50 9.53 12.22 1.83 35.88 8.05 8.79 30.00 0.06 11.56 8.CE 12.25 23.5 frv to IPI bori 1.28 13.41 Actual .1 23.8 frv to perpt. aosp. 26.97 8.11 9.18 1.13 12.69 118 56-55 15.43 40.00 9.39 32.44 0.48 0.51 11t 55-53 2.25 40.00 0.tl 32.18 0.87 8.87 5:sken/ Pal /IECh/N1 15.71 f.59 9.29 29.88 0.46 16.09 0.58 0.62 Other ,

Csete at tecit. Rosp (?) 8.29 9.47 0.58 Docas. acclear 23.9 Unicastig 0.32 18.31 0.50 13.56 0.53 14.52 23.19 frv to trentwood 13.43 0.52 19.93 0.77 14.43 0.12 15.34 Speeds low, relative to reverse other Ni/86d/Ful/Santes 9.29 20.60 9.46 16.08 0.54 8.62 111 53-55 2.25 40.08 1.06 32.95 0.87 8.17 f t.111 1.31 20.00 0.89 16.98 8.12 0.13 23.11 Processing 8.25 11.18 9.25 14.61 8.27 15.69 St. Garles Isap. 3'rd Tave 5C.3 frv to St. Qarles 15.85 0.00 11.98 1.90 15.65 1.06 16.66 f t.111 4.80 28,88 9.28 15.00 9.25 9.27 It.147 18.10 21.98 4.55 16.00 0.60 9.72 It 25A/Nytt/IDEp 3,19 8.63 1.95 35.88 9.86 30.00 - 8.87 8.97 SC.4 Loahrt 8.33 12.31 4.50 15.15 9.53 17.11 SC.5 frv to IP1 ndry Bosp/Nytt/tt 251 1.70 8.63 1.87 35.80 S.83 12.34 30.80 8.04 16.22 0.04 17.23

e gyps.gmh+M49-h e. 5 y l9f68 9 '.

/ 3 5a g

• h Lgg -

1. 3 z _ . 2 .s L m n _ . 9 0 1 . h .._. _._.._.__..__.._ _ _.

.uv#C nF 'is m 'J Lal

... _ow9d4rA."it: P- it : 5i ) , _zz. _.m 3 . . _ _

<!T1l* lW\ C \i M' }[# \? .

f _.. - .

(vG .11vm sw ,

h.

(-

34 IG$~s a_

jm 10 - @ B it

\ _ _ S ,e 2

V4uf 't.

.\ 0. d it 1*-

M N.

%,A/ n, l

s,. > s g s ~_ ar y~, '

N 'u & _. ._ . _. / .

}

u p.,,e % c d. o ._ . S . H. - -

W \I \\dy uu.t.vnt e e.ce_ s.st ] 3, i I .

/

/

%\ 1.?6 95%

i . 8 LV . $;/1v d* b.h _ .h

• 3 . .

/- .

- /

l c Ny*b ~~

{

i \ e j f

\ 8* & .

i 7

\ %h., '

k

. tv (,. nsc

.\ \'.1 %

\W.6b

', _ y if,,,T- \\' i 9 M.66

...==.

1

, - .')g

',

• A f,y J /W/

7py ) i , 9; 4 ) (, . A ".

(\U ic] ( 16 13J '

, . u y.. < .

., skgA ,

. / ws hg .

-....g_.--_- + _

g) %@ C

. u,3(b { ' . - - - . '^~

....- ---- ~ 11 0 5 'p,h,C) $'

~RtX({A'$0 x 'e v -

.~

--m...&.:~.z' _ _ _

--- -. - .... - -- - ^ ' ~

.g ~---

_ -.. . - - -.- = ~ - __

"tL 4, S v_,

-~~- . ..

' ~ '~ @ . G

@1 # ru , _ _

3.n

%s._ ,9. ,.gs.s .-

y 3. gf w ~

' p 1.g .

.1 i

wa -

/

s

{ 's s

~

.. - ,l /

p

.~

.s, y._ . s, N s , .- /, y, f

l Y Y -W s.

N.

f I

i I

g  :.i.' . ,,. ,/

.l

_ ,/ -l 7' )

ns ...

• ~ ^^~ ' ^ * * ~

l I

% - I - '

.._ _ _ . ..._... . . _ ~--% -

,. l. ~

j n

p b $$

~

/

- , _ , j -

r i  !

J 1 /

(~~-  !

) i

\. '

f

- .~. \

\ '

i ,. \ \.

_N  !  ! \

I i

}

.. . . . _ . - f --

_ ' I_ . _

~ \

r

, f, l -

~

/ .-

! l

(

~ '

.s N

s j g 1

~ ~ - .

\ _

,, I

)

e