ML20105C666

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Ack Receipt of Comments to Shoreham Commission Rept. Emergency Planning Proposal Being Considered by NRC Does Not Propose to Reduce 10-mile Emergency Planning Zone But Adds Prompt Evacuation within 2 Miles from Reactor
ML20105C666
Person / Time
Site: Shoreham File:Long Island Lighting Company icon.png
Issue date: 12/12/1983
From: Dircks W
NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO)
To: Kouts H
BROOKHAVEN NATIONAL LABORATORY
Shared Package
ML20105B503 List:
References
FOIA-84-250 NUDOCS 8401170536
Download: ML20105C666 (2)
v • d • e


Text

_

JW

. kg.

h, o

UNITED STATES g

,8 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION o

r,E wasHWGTON, D. C. 20888

.....f

}

December 12, 1983 Dr; Herb Kouts, Chairman Department of Nuclear Energy Brookhaven National Laboratory Building 197 Upton, NY 11773

Dear Dr,

, y.eutf:

Thank you for providing me with a copy of the comments to the Shoreham Comis-sion report which you, Bill Ronan and Fred Kahn prepared.

In that the NRC has concluded that it would be inappropriate for it to vote or otherwise adopt the-Comission's final report, we will not be taking an official position with regard to your comments.

However, I did want yon to know that I felt that the views expressed by each of you were very helpful in providing a better under-standing of the issues addressed by the Comission and that they contributed

'substantially to a more balanced presentation of the facts.

Two observations may, however, be of assistance.

In reviewing the document attached to your comments entitled "Shoreham Comission", I did observe one statement on page 9 which you may wish to modify somewhat for accuracy. On that page you state that " studies currently being conducted by the NRC are studying the future contraction of the emergency planning zone from the current-ten-mile requirement to two miles".

In fact, the emergency planning proposal now being considered by the-NRC Staff does not propose to reduce the present ten-mile' emergency planning zone, but rather, adds a requirement for prompt evacuation within the first two miles of the reactor. The Staff's proposal does provide, however, that while evacuation beyond the two-mile zone is unlikely, it cannot be entirely ruled out for ususual accident sequences or particularly adverse meteorology.

The second point which you may wish to consider is Fred Kahn's statement on-page two of his " Conclusions" to the effect that it is a " ridiculous process L

by which opponents to the location at Shoreham were told that the siting decision was not the proper forum for weighing their objections, but that instead they would properly be considered after the plant had been constructed".

While I understand the point Fred is addressing, in fact, the question of D

location was considered at the construction permit hearings in 1970. The issue i

that was delayed for final consideration at the operating license stage was-emergency planning. Your comments addressing the necessity for this delay (paragraph 5, page 4) do, I believe, clarify this concern.

T@fjgof p &;

p "

2 /

m 6 90 i

M9 g,

-g 7

e

'w yy e

yrWg-Nw'yt

n.

~

2

-2_

If I'can be of any'further assistance to you on these points please do not hesitate to contact me.

Sincerely, 474 Wdjias!.Dircre William J. Dircks Executive Director for Operations cc: John H. Marburger Alfred E. Kahn William J. Ronan i

DISTRIBUTION:

E.Christenbury (Chron)

G.Cunningham 4.Dircks ELD FF (2) (50-322)

NRC Central File B.Bordenick E.Reis EDO rf

(

t i

r.

cA

.:______g __ 4:_____________::____________::__________

EDO g 4

____:____________M__'_ _ _ _ _ : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _f_ 4 $

OELD 0FC :

OELD NAME : E.Christenbury/amb : G.Cunningham : W.Dircky,7

_____:________________.__:..____________: ___________:_____________:____________:---_________~

DATE :

12/1^183 12/ N83 :

12//.7/83 :

T Ub bl((bMi

[e~ -

(

o w

rt AS Aooness mEPuts TO Tws NORMAN F.* LENT W ASHINGTON. E.C. OFFICE

" J UNLESS CTMERW15E INDICATED

/

222. man $a"E' N E $$ue C0""" 0" '"'"GY

=, = ~

Congress of tit Buitet $tates

^ ~ * ' " " ' " "

' - - = ' ' " ' "

. = = =

=

c 17 M-.T.EE O.N.~O

,__,ew Yoe,,, m.,$. 0 COvuiT N

O N,

f O Maats osa Paas y a Hau Tw"yg""b MAssartoua Paa( hrw Yeaa 11?.2 g

September 1, 1983 co

.uo.

Mr. Caulton Kammerer

Director, Office of Congressional Affairs Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555

Dear Mr. Kammerer:

On March 24, 1983, I wrote to you concerning three letters I had received from constituents.

I asked you to reply to thes2 letters and forward-y.our response to me.

As of this date, I have yet to hear-from you or your office.

I am very concerned about this ~ unnecessary -delay and expect a prompt reply to this letter.

~ Enclosed please find a copy of my orij;inal letter to you and copies of the letter from-my constituents.

Kindly reply to their concerns. and forward the response to me.

Tnank you for your cooperation in this matter and I expect to hear from you in the very near future.

iberely p

w NO 1 F. LENT M ber of Congress NFL/laf

- Enc..

e 9/) N.

h

~

n

$u V

~

C}

V e

e v

m--

- M

p. e.,.am e.

- * * = =.

.,a '..'9. i.s. g..en.fmurn,.,ae 1

-.j j:g,,.4

. ae r.

.. r

  • W..l 4

....c., *:

1.

.p.. r. i s

.T.:=w

- w,N,. g ge r

..,.. V:.e

..at t.

e

e..

4 grei g,,,,'t.'

- g P. ; %..

    • h Wr s.;..t.i.. ' .-

T 8,

+

t-

..al

-c.-,-

. v. ;.

-w

.3

..,.m.

March 24, 1983 U #'NYu.h

- OsrM%-c.- v..

.J..

~..

r,m.. 1 ;.yxr.st'. 's

~~ M ""~'**. W W

. t!:m.s::.1:.

.a a.

..e.

3

.Mr...Ca

' ton Fammerer-

- {.E, < O..'.O<,,.

c.

'j,

'l Dire.,ctor-OErice of Congressional Affairs 3

United States-Nuclear. Regulatory Conuniss6on Wa=M agton, D.C. 20555 ATTN ' Steve Kent

': ": ; L '+* %...,:

...p

.Deat &, _s.

1; M'Y.i -

~~

dM.Y by 'I-am anclosing these three letters from consEituen$s ~.

t;

,cf5mine who are from Levittown, New York.

All thre'Tlattersb:.*.O M' '

e de. lyith the Shoreham 'niselear power plant.

I would appre-

' M E:.:

a 4'

ciate;1f'you' could' answer theri concerns and th'enTt6l'relaiy? '

'Q*

tha('information back to me.

Thank yyu for your. cooperation.'

~

....;..?.....>.

  1. ^

. ~.-

With best' wishes:I remain,'

~r.

..:. :4.....

. Sincerelf,' 'f9"f'"Mk"h*ENM,..w

-....::.;m.,.::....

r.h. o.8[U6....:.-d v1.-

+

yw v4,y.::;.:...4.;. e.....:.

~.. u- -

. %e.v.:: -

. u ".., :

. -ym.wss.c.,t

~ '

NORMAN F. LBMt

-- i' NE Member of Congress

. Ec.

4

~

,. 5

.4,,9 t,*

=.

  • . * %! a*g '*$.'

.e... cc m :

..1.

w M.1.

. m..':.yy%. >; -

s'

~

~:

..rd Q f C-

~

w :u..~.

-4

.!:s....

~..e..

(

=

l NFL/rg

-Q.r;., j

-.

  • m e,:
  • -'*%.D

., '., :h,

. '*- b M..

,,:. t... D'* H~

..P'.-I, hh h:...

~

fh.. -* '.

". '.'N..: * :., g

  • b '

~ ~.

....;. v..: m..p.

W

-I e

v e.

. ~.

j

- e,,-. E-

- ~. - - -

  • l 1

,.---.-.,..----.,,..~.-n--..--.--

- ~ ~ - ~ - - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - - - - ~ - ~ ~ - ~ ~ ^ ~ ~ ~ ~ ' ~

~ ' ' " '

.m lfM

'ty!![ $!ii?5 g'(,., if.3 b

h

. t p.-

S C6/

b.

/

hm;d/D,1983

' ~

f g604.L -

'G l*

s_

v jilid f/

o0.

00l0

.)

J eL9/24% bd,'

, mmu

.. y

~

  • S!

g w & u fl L ' y u

Cc/b f&

la, Y Q-

~64 G 2

Mt & A

[,C

'k

_f f

cYYMb b.-f.-

Y bl M My fcul f f./

k.._-..

3 Y

' Y./d G Ylcbr/d b w %

9 u.e6 /& wad / yn ce/d j.a.4 gf _.

.4'cp8 i;cin 2:

/l'

'?-C $

i r; ny' ccN c

M

) tis, '

,- ["_.. %hfi!! j$$ij;Nis".M$iin j*'.5[.*hir! mi. h.! ' y- # ' h "' [;; [ W if$.* Y $.' M h. M fh 5 s

T i

.._.. -..... =..

v.

a-

- ~

, :.?.._.

"3..,, >

.w.n=w c.

c., ~

y u

. ui, 1

', ;.Y

  • GT m

e s

  • o;..
p. - #.

r l"

. MAR 2419g3 Q

.N...

j i

?

4

,i p

/

V

' M_,y ee

.......u... '

O

- =,....

]%vM,Ri'Y.

~

M' y

$ hA

&a

_ m ; gym ~

z) ::

~inc ge!

m..e jl

~

  • ~' % K

~

- Et.

s

. - -....., ~.

p

-_g +

.~

.h. ~ 1 AA E u u P d s i;f '*

L v..

.w.

)

0

  1. /

M/ 2

..caau aw oha e__..._.a it E

~'

id4L 3a&%m Aha,ma

~ llpa:l#dco k owi u sa m A. b r..> '....u s ca p L ua Qt g_g 3: -

l'., l"s F"-:. Y Q,,

1._E.;

[

.P

.,'.1 n::.:g 4m

..y.

/gf ~' ~

~.

-Sii m.mg

.e.

i de

.g 5e

..:. a

~

~

F-W.Ei?.

Q.{, {=?

LYbh

'K "s., D 1

f.f., 2:::

,,,1;.[

.ifit*

pa:r.s.,E.

-p.h..h Kf

%.~..Yqr$'m 7.%-: :p, :.J:;

.: ;;g *i'F%

... - 6 hr

~

Sy.

L m?M, e - "/

'.te

u r,..

L5 m'

t G 1l' y QQ' [

p) 1 C-G 'M de.ve %n,0%' lsn) Ii'75co 7TLcw A 7, A33

.b.' 'QL CL > l C R-Veccaa ko. vac n ccmn.v.c.0 h)

,. D. c.

9 0 5 t 5 7,e

~

f. _W g

,Ceoi,

~

j e.

s own,,.n e.- > u J) kid.Uh a.Xuce Ac w, 194a.->J ii.cu.Ld.Ot

. bLs&d iRc+ye.

i as & am. emu.a.cp.ov= y ^- uw a,p.R n cm

=

ih

/<c.

cue a.R

)eq@ koyt cgf llc 'q c'cy, s,Jv; nw.7

, ~..

..!.k c,t c c v te iLec u t t.ft ec.c n > vck.bn.,2.come om w,

M.d' cc n.d Ll. 'J'.

2

'ex2.- /Le

~

m cw w y' c a c < Md Q f,

u-c. ccAl Ownb f - Q Les cf v a.u. i W + Le.

~

C /dicen 2

ch.f.d. Lesca ch 0

awar.

cJ2 k,% cLo e-f cLwecpo

'x s ch.. H.ac.Ao.J.tA.una.1.1.c pec & y

.Acaid hta CAeaed

/

d s;ili SR5 (_/d44

'i e d,. h g Coro 1 LaRosa N

W ht::

c1

~ " *' Iip.!.l s " Y dit!5! Q.i!HIi@!!i!!!!q

.irMi%,:e{*'.i; :. ' F ig...., :

7..

.............

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20105C666&oldid=4302285"