Letter Sequence Other |
|---|
|
Results
Other: 05000366/LER-1984-001, :on 840203,personnel Detected Fracture in 66- Inch Vent Header in Bay 5.Caused by Brittle Facture of Vent Header Matl.Vent Header Will Be Repaired & Addl Changes or Sys Mod Will Be Made to Improve Sys, BECO-84-150, Responds to IE Bulletin 84-01, Cracks in BWR Mark I Containment Vent Headers. Util Endorses GE Svc Info Ltr 402 Recommendations.Equipment Damage Has Not Occurred & Inerting Sys Operation Suitable, FVY-84-110, Forwards Response to NRC Request Re Actions Taken in Response to GE Significant Info Ltr 420 Concerning Hatch-2 Vent Header Crack, GO2-84-512, Discuss GE Recommendations Re Hatch Unit 2 Event Concerning Large Crack in Torus Vent Header Due to Brittle Fracture,Per GE 840214 Info Ltr 402.Only Recommendations 1 & 2 Apply,As Sys Not Yet Used to Inert Containment, ML18029A151, ML20080R767, ML20083L655, ML20083R739, ML20084L425, ML20084L444, ML20084R170, ML20091B787, ML20097E003, ML20097H269, ML20098A026, ML20098F071, ML20098F159, ML20098G674, ML20098G682, ML20198P818, NLS8400242, Submits List of Actions Taken on Recommendations from GE 840214 Svc Info Ltr 402, Wetwell/Drywell Inerting. Evaluation of Inerting Sys Design Determined That Failure of Cold Temp Shutdown Switch Cause of Problem, SNRC-1082, Submits Status of Evaluation Re IE Info Notice 84-17, Problems W/Liquid Nitrogen Cooling Components Below Nil Ductility Temp & GE Svc Info Ltr SIL-402, Wetwell/Drywell Inerting
|
MONTHYEARML20080R7671984-02-10010 February 1984 Responds to IE Bulletin 84-01 Re Insp for Cracks in Mark I Containment Torus Vent Header.No Apparent Cracking or Relevant Indications Found on Unit 1.No Addl Cracking Found Beyond Original Cracking on Unit 2 Project stage: Other ML20080N5661984-02-10010 February 1984 Forwards Drywell Coating Evaluation, Technical Data Rept, Per SEP Topic VI-1, Organic Matls & Post-Accident Chemistry Project stage: Request ML20198P8181984-02-14014 February 1984 Svc Instruction Ltr 402, Wetwell/Drywell Inerting. Related Info Encl Project stage: Other 05000366/LER-1984-001, :on 840203,personnel Detected Fracture in 66- Inch Vent Header in Bay 5.Caused by Brittle Facture of Vent Header Matl.Vent Header Will Be Repaired & Addl Changes or Sys Mod Will Be Made to Improve Sys1984-03-0404 March 1984
- on 840203,personnel Detected Fracture in 66- Inch Vent Header in Bay 5.Caused by Brittle Facture of Vent Header Matl.Vent Header Will Be Repaired & Addl Changes or Sys Mod Will Be Made to Improve Sys
Project stage: Other ML20087H1481984-03-13013 March 1984 Forwards GE Repts on Metallographic Exam of Metal Samples Taken from Cracked Vent Header,Per NRC 840206 Meeting W/ Util,Bwr Regulatory Response Group & Ge.Vent Header Cracking Brittle Fracture Caused by Injection of Cold Nitrogen Project stage: Meeting ML20083L6551984-03-30030 March 1984 Submits Info on IE Bulletin 84-01, Entitled Cracks in BWR Mark I Containment Vent Headers. Primary Containment Drywell to Torus Bypass Tests Performed.Status of GE SIL 402 Recommended Actions Listed Project stage: Other ML20084L4441984-03-31031 March 1984 Analysis of Vent Header Cracking at Hatch 2 Project stage: Other ML20084R1701984-04-0505 April 1984 Comments on Status of Recommendations of GE Svc Info Ltr 402 Re Wetwell/Drywell Inerting.Evaluation of Nitrogen Inerting Sys Design Performed & Redundant Low Temp Shutoff Valve Added Project stage: Other ML20083R7391984-04-18018 April 1984 Forwards Response to GE SIL 402 Generated Due to Large Crack in Torus Vent Header at Another Operating Plant Attributed to Brittle Fracture Identified During Insp of Cold Nitrogen Into Torus During Inerting Project stage: Other ML20084L4251984-05-0707 May 1984 Forwards Analysis of Vent Header Cracking at Hatch 2. Analysis Shows That Observed Cracking Can Be Explained by Injection of Cold Nitrogen Into Containment & Any Cracking Expected to Be through-wall,detectable by Visual Insp Project stage: Other ML20091B7871984-05-23023 May 1984 Provides Status of GE Svc Info Ltr 402 Re Vent Header Cracking Incident.Recommended Ultrasonic Testing Not Planned Due to Lack of Baseline Test Data.Cracking from Injection of Cold Nitrogen Detectable by Surface Exam Project stage: Other NLS8400242, Submits List of Actions Taken on Recommendations from GE 840214 Svc Info Ltr 402, Wetwell/Drywell Inerting. Evaluation of Inerting Sys Design Determined That Failure of Cold Temp Shutdown Switch Cause of Problem1984-09-12012 September 1984 Submits List of Actions Taken on Recommendations from GE 840214 Svc Info Ltr 402, Wetwell/Drywell Inerting. Evaluation of Inerting Sys Design Determined That Failure of Cold Temp Shutdown Switch Cause of Problem Project stage: Other FVY-84-110, Forwards Response to NRC Request Re Actions Taken in Response to GE Significant Info Ltr 420 Concerning Hatch-2 Vent Header Crack1984-09-14014 September 1984 Forwards Response to NRC Request Re Actions Taken in Response to GE Significant Info Ltr 420 Concerning Hatch-2 Vent Header Crack Project stage: Other ML20097E0031984-09-14014 September 1984 Forwards Response to IE Bulletin 84-01 Re Potential for Cracking in BWR Vent Headers Using Nitrogen Inerting Sys. Nitrogen Inerting Sys Not Used at Facility.Recommendations Identified in GE Svc Info Ltr 402 Addressed Project stage: Other GO2-84-512, Discuss GE Recommendations Re Hatch Unit 2 Event Concerning Large Crack in Torus Vent Header Due to Brittle Fracture,Per GE 840214 Info Ltr 402.Only Recommendations 1 & 2 Apply,As Sys Not Yet Used to Inert Containment1984-09-14014 September 1984 Discuss GE Recommendations Re Hatch Unit 2 Event Concerning Large Crack in Torus Vent Header Due to Brittle Fracture,Per GE 840214 Info Ltr 402.Only Recommendations 1 & 2 Apply,As Sys Not Yet Used to Inert Containment Project stage: Other BECO-84-150, Responds to IE Bulletin 84-01, Cracks in BWR Mark I Containment Vent Headers. Util Endorses GE Svc Info Ltr 402 Recommendations.Equipment Damage Has Not Occurred & Inerting Sys Operation Suitable1984-09-14014 September 1984 Responds to IE Bulletin 84-01, Cracks in BWR Mark I Containment Vent Headers. Util Endorses GE Svc Info Ltr 402 Recommendations.Equipment Damage Has Not Occurred & Inerting Sys Operation Suitable Project stage: Other ML20098G5571984-09-14014 September 1984 Submits Supplemental Info in Response to IE Bulletin 84-01, Cracks in BWR Mark I Containment Vent Headers. Program Initiated to Address Concerns of GE SIL 402 & Implementation Schedule Project stage: Supplement ML20098A0261984-09-17017 September 1984 Forwards Responses to Recommendations Contained in IE Bulletin 84-01, Cracks in BWR Mark I Containment Vent Headers & GE Svc Info Ltr 402, Wetwell/Drywell Inerting. No Anomalies Indicated in Drywell/Wetwell Pressures Project stage: Other ML20097H2691984-09-17017 September 1984 Forwards Response to GE Significant Info Ltr 402 & IE Info Notice 84-17 Re Nitrogen Inerting Sys Project stage: Other SNRC-1082, Submits Status of Evaluation Re IE Info Notice 84-17, Problems W/Liquid Nitrogen Cooling Components Below Nil Ductility Temp & GE Svc Info Ltr SIL-402, Wetwell/Drywell Inerting1984-09-18018 September 1984 Submits Status of Evaluation Re IE Info Notice 84-17, Problems W/Liquid Nitrogen Cooling Components Below Nil Ductility Temp & GE Svc Info Ltr SIL-402, Wetwell/Drywell Inerting Project stage: Other ML20098F1591984-09-26026 September 1984 Submits Mods Identified for Completion Prior to Liquid Nitrogen Inerting of Containment.Low Temp Switch Will Be Replaced & Relocated to Improve Response Time & Eliminate Adverse Impact of Cold Outdoor Ambient Temps Project stage: Other ML20098F0711984-09-27027 September 1984 Responds to GE Svc Info Ltr 402 Re Wetwell/Drywell Temp. Design & Operation of Nitrogen Sys Provides Adequate Assurance That Impingement of Liquid or Extremely Cold Nitrogen Against Vital Plant Components Will Not Occur Project stage: Other ML20098G6821984-10-0101 October 1984 Responds to Verbal Questions Concerning Recommendations of GE Svc Info Ltr 402 Re IE Bulletin 84-01, Cracks in BWR Mark I Containment Vent Headers. Steps Taken to Evaluate & Implement Containment Inerting Recommendations Project stage: Other ML20098G6741984-10-0101 October 1984 Responds to IE Bulletin 84-01, Cracks in BWR Mark I Containment Vent Headers. No Evidence of Outside or Inside Vent Header & Nitrogen Penetration Cracking Found.Addl Insps & Evaluations Will Be Performed Project stage: Other ML18029A1511984-10-0505 October 1984 Forwards Responses to GE Svc Info Ltr 402 Re Wetwell/Drywell Inerting.Operating Instructions for Containment Inerting Sys & Primary Containment Sys Revised Project stage: Other ML20138A2251985-11-29029 November 1985 Summarizes 851108 Mgt Meeting at Region II Ofc Re Util Response to Recommendations of Svc Info Ltr 402 in Handling Unit 1 Nitrogen Inerting & Purge Line Crack Discovered on 841215.Summary of Topics & List of Attendees Encl Project stage: Meeting 1984-04-05
[Table View] |
Text
_
,D' s
PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC COMPANY 2301 M ARKET STREET P.O. BOX 8699 PHILADELPHIA, PA.19101 JOHN S. KEMPER V IC E-PR ESID E NT susengsmeno aura mass ARCH Mr. A. Schwencer, Chief Docket Nos.: 50-352 Licensing Branch No. 2 50-353 Division of Licensing U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Cm mission Washington, DC 20555
Subject:
Limerick Generating Station, Units 1 & 2 Liquid Nitrogen Inerting Syst m
References:
- 1) I.E. Bulletin No. 84-01, dated 2/3/84
- 2) GE Service Mformation Intter No. 402, dated 2/14/84
- 3) I.E. Information Notice No. 84-17, dated 3/5/84
-File:'
GOVT 1-1 (NRC)
Dear Mr. Schwencer:
The reference docunents discuss concerns over the use of liquid nitrogen type inerting systems at BWR plants with Mark I and II containment - designs.
'Ihese concerns were generated by events at Georgia Power Cmpany's Hatch Unit 2, when very cold nitrogen (either liquid or gaseous) was injected into the torus air space. The
' injection stream inpinged directly upon the torus vent header, initiating brittle failure of the steel used in the header.
The portions of the reference documents that are applicable to Limerick recmmend evaluation of the liquid nitrogen vaporization systm design and operation.
The Limerick design specifically included consideration of the potential hazards of handling liquid nitrogen as discussed in FSAR Section 9.4.5.1.
The liquid nitrogen vaporization and containment inerting systems at Limerick are essentially identical to those in use at Feach Bottm Atmic Power Station.
A detailed review of the Limerick design and relevant Peach Bottom operating experience has been empleted. As a result of this review, the following modifications have been identified for cmpletion prior to the inerting of the Limerick containment (6 months after initial criticality per Technical Specification 3.10.5):
replace and relocate the existing low tenperature switch to inprove response time and eliminate the adverse impact of cold outdoor ambient taperatures
\\
remove existing manual bypass around law tmperature shutoff valves 8410020402 840926 1 0 PDR ADOCK 05000352 A
pon
gc o
- provide an automatic low tenperature isolation signal to the inerting line contairment isolation valves provide an ambient vaporizer and a topping heater to eliminate deperxlence on auxiliary steam for low flow operation provide control rom indication of the tenperature of the nitrogen gas being supplied to the containment.
The cmpletion of these modifications will provide added assurance that liquid nitrogen related failures will not occur at Limerick.
Sincerely, OCNf JIIA/cmr/09248405 cc: See Attached Service List
./
cc: Judge Lawrence Brenner
'dudge Peter A. Morris-
- Judge Richard F. Cole Judge Christine N. Kohl Judge Gary J. Edles Judge Reginald L. Gotchy Troy B. Conner, Jr.,. Esq.
Ann P. Hodgdon,'Esq.
Mr. Frank R. Romano Mr. Robert L. Anthony Ms. Maureen Mulligan' Charles'W. Elliot, Esc Zori G. Ferkin, Esq.
Mr. Thomas Gerusky Director, Penna. Emergency Management Agency Angus R. Love, Esq.
- David _Wersan, Esq.
-~ Robert J._Sugarman, Esq.
Martha W. Bush, Esq.
-Spence'W. Perry, Esq.
Jay M.-Gutterrez, Esq.
Atomic Safety & Licensing Appeal Board Atomic Safety & Licensing Board Panel.
Docket & Service Section Mr. James Wiggins-Mr. Tinothy R. S. Campbell
- - -