ML20095A045
| ML20095A045 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 05/02/1978 |
| From: | NRC |
| To: | NRC |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19258A087 | List:
|
| References | |
| CON-BX18-001, CON-BX18-1, FOIA-84-96 NUDOCS 8408210367 | |
| Download: ML20095A045 (6) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:-..--..-. _, _ _ _ w __m.. ~ _ _. _. _ _ o- .w ,:..,.0- ./:q;Q'.-; ~ n z... NRC SITE VISIT May 2, 1978 'g,sJ,d@6 - r I. Agenda . 4 j-Status of Construction (Orientation Room) % M 8:30 - 9:30 9:30 - 11:00, Group Tours Lunch 12:30 - 3:30 Specific Group Discussions (Conference Rooms). j 3:30-- 4:30 Wrap-up/ Exit Meeting (Conference Rooms) II. Tour Groups Hy'drology-RAD Geotechnical Water Use Assessment Engineering Plant Effluent Accident (Exclusion Proj ect (Foundation) Chemical Analysis Areas) Management Beskid. Johnson Farrell Hinson . Hood Gillen Beskid Campe ?Prasad(B) Echols 'Afifi(B) Romano Patel(B) ?Krause(B) Derickson LeFevre(B) Vaslo Prasad(B) W.Strod1(C) m JzZabritski(C) ~
- B. Wheeler (C)
Anderson (B)* Lodwick(B) T.Sullivan(C) R.Bauman(C) D. Anderson (C) Papadakas(B) T.Sullivan(C) Clements(C) R. Green (C). Wheeler (B) Schmidt (NUS) *D.Vokal(C) J.Hurley(B) A.Zeitoun(C)
- E. Evans (C)
- B. Peck (C)
JoWildern(C) Kowalchuk(C)
- D.Sibbald(C)
Vehicle: Vehicle: Operations Construction Blazer Blazer Abbreviations: (B) - Bechtel (C) - Consumers Power Company = (NUS) - N.U.S. Corporation BHPeck/pp 5-1-18 8408210367 840718 PDR FOIA RICE 84-96 PDR w-- MM MM MMMMMmMM
E m.- 4 ...'.h { *' lm;h ; iT Y
- . [
>
- Y ' $. * ' ',
,$ Y e ....e : a vn 7 mg'g' gi,ef.s@; g ' Q *@... { W ew$.i[ny', .._,; g y(6f.rI'gw%' Q(Mw? rr ;Ms,'-;v[* r-g'h 3 -$?. -}e .a. ^3;;.t'%; 'm:~, rgh MQ
- 3..
qg t !*yJ K a.,.. Sh%.
- m.e^-
hh Y E? 'h ? bA . nR . n.. w + <, -. .,.w-e,. a%n4 4.. g - 1,:..n. 3,.^,ag..~"p.o_.=. g: m.Q : ;y.g4p~.y..u+ g%y. c y Q:,.,ca y y i, y, g. M -? p*;-v,L *..,..y '> [ s' ~*
- r,.;
? %.R ,1 .. v.- e ts+U 7 y ;_qv:
- m. 's 7
y_ Q.
- 7. ~, m s
. w r - - <, q:w,. ~. y. 2.J ' " * ^ ':-
- f} -
': s AV ~,%, ': %'*', - * ;).% QA
- v. a.w'g a
~ -sp !&j. Wf j..i c:~.~ M ,.'=*3- ~.s.. e/ [.,,[4 NZ ? ;&.' MyL.~- - :1 p' r" -u.J. '.%. . ~ M,? g-~. "is,:N#%.. ...s. tp . ~ ~ m. ~ QY . A ,+ + e b 'I~
- q p i e g, -
M. y. --[ -K 'M L m ~.; e; ,*...,u, w:2 ~ -/~ p ,A*"g . v')- '*8 , 2<- 3 y.s - -* - - ' ~- -~ [ [ [' .m.n.. a j p....*j
- 4 M'4%
w dy ", k abo..M . bt J n.a... ", -,.a_ _kh mm .., ;.r SO $5. (MC$ . C&W. M.
- ^g ^/ W #
+ ._..q.,.< ,.,i 41 w w,. , S. ;g,.1.q '; w.eh 8-c,, ;_ ,,g n. .. W L wc.. n s :W e, y *w. e :1
- 4 c
.M..,,. }WM ,c _ A s. J\\ r.h P
- ~yh, y -
v \\ <<.-~s>:h 4 'x .a-,-.,.,. Q \\* y '9' .5p -e. ..o 9 l.g * ~ .o a Q V g,y) ... _ -.- -. ;;.:f.. .. m; . ^ .,. as * ~~ ..-..n ,.. %e,, n s j,,, 9 >y * * ,,7 .,g_", 6 ..-*.e. ' A.. g m ..h.Me ps J, e d... ,*, f e.;- .. g.x .y. "4* y 9 p e g ,. v, "* : t, ,d
- ra
, 4 4. J - e. .r Y4 F =g-. e-N I ' - ;) . 2 .~. ~ j f,6 g s r f
- g..
~~ .E j- ,.i'.+.1 Ts ,.e
- g
,,,9m'.- 9 s 4 4 4 .,, 4 s
- ,L e
4 -'s
- ' %9
= < - ,,m_. ~ ' h- #*w .me M .l..,._,
- M sk g
+e+eoMm_
- N'#**
s %,4 .. e i 4 3 er. - .um.i m
- gH,5C Z 1T.W--, -. -.. -
a - ~ ~~ .c .g ; ,.Nbh.,
SUBJECT:
- .CPCo Midland Plant-Units.1 & 2 Diesel ~ Generator Building Meeting with NRC.at' Midland DATE:
December'4, 1978 'a =r e AGENDA 'i' j I. Introduction by CPCo II. History by Bechtel.(N.'Swanberg) a. Plant description b. Settlement monitoring program c. Brief history of site fill, placement d. Settlement of Category 1 structure Settlement of diesel generator building and pedestals e. .f., Review-settlement data and drawings (SK-C-620/623) g. . Consultants. s.-e-.,- ' L J ' "-- '4 III. Soil Exploration by Bechtel (S. Afifi) - a. Soil borings' - b. Dutch cone penetrations c. Laboratory tests d. Possible causes ~ IV. Consultant's Reco=endation by Dr. R.B. Peck and C.J. Dunnicliff ~ a. Preload ~ b. Instrumentation V. Status report by Bechtel (B.C. McConnell) a. Activities completed b. Activities in progress c. Activities planned for future 1) Corrective. action 2) FSAR conformance VI. Schedule by Bechtel (P. Martinez) a. Overall project b. Impact on project schedule c. Schedule for remedial measures s U - e.we .4 4._...,..
- .ewh 4*
~"** ^~~#"
u VII. Responses to open items in NRC Inspector's report dated 11/17/8 by Bechtel (B. Dhar)
- tyY l
a. Responses to Gallaghar's concerns: F.M 4 p%'r/g gM eV ' d/' l 1) Conflict between FSAR Table 2.5-14 and Table 2.5-10 regarding fill material -description [ 2) Conflict between FSAR Table 2.5-21 and, b,6 *,.. ' Specification C--210 regarding required number of passes for c.ompaction 4 - "., u t9,,,(' y 3) FSAR Section 3.8.5.5 - expected settlement -- " ~ *
- Md 4)
Conflict between FSAR Figure 2.5-47 and._,,,,, ,,,3 project drawing regarding foundation ,g h,,,,i. g3 u 4 f..a elevation %,o. 4 J.' o g a s sw q 5) Conflict in Specification C-210'regarding ' ' ' ~ " * " "
- compactive effort in test method 6)
Conflict between consultant's recommendation and Specification C-210 regariling lif t P., ".. thickness 7) + 2% tolerance in moisture content permitted .in Specification C-210 8) Cracks in the building structure b. FSAR Question 362.2 (Section 2.5.4.5.1), ' s,,,',',,e VIII. ' Closing Comments by CPCo c u P .--? -...... ~ - - -,. ______________________7____
Y ^-- = re* ' e' e ' ' ' ~' O' w.y.,a,.. v. A.m.m:.) m, a < ,e. m. A e -~A h W 5[A - Nt I .Wa w?.%Yh5 h.Y h :~3@k.y['I 1g m. wv ay g .L aM.,3e u,W k. y:.%.- e q0 * @.%. ~. m*$2?L.h.*hk-Mh "hd ksn"Mp$hM.g.y*@b[d..h.d7k.x$/.T widu.s c t'.W e; m
- h. aT
,,.Ik4'. k h k,R k. nl v. m;g.s;;s. n' %s g, %x ~. g' m &WJ3 5% 17..'q,-tyS 7)MQ* N.Y. m~M'&u.',t,*,.'h%. -.gG, ..g..~.5.;4,L -n
- h. : Q.; '.I.; y, f
.u. .q. , K. .. m.. 'Wh %"^ e g p.. m **T.M,- @bl*;fg. 4 _ h, p .. opp. ? .c m ,'hbTEWehN, $? T. mmh bN.I d,NMM [54$)7/.$ M N 7 5y%M W IG W:% &m w-}f+mMa..u% s[ wG. s} a. a. al w m w~ M b i W M
- n*~- ws &. ~Q.,Q., R!yW
..e S m ( QL .f n m,L '^W. n u. m pw.w% w.m+.4.m w +yC q m mu n c
- m. y3 yy. v..w.?-?,pW.m,m 4e e;> g. ~: ;y w
n m 5-kq-Ac.; c n. M o R x:g ty4p9 ' e -?. m. m e w m %., w m. . w;x Mti $. np-A5" 4 m. tr.Q.\\ ; b.-A x., SG LlQ,stM -g e W. c.ht 's - : s<> ' NMd$)gv~' YE*"W* %e&. w$' Fk' % .'Wp ...vA 4 M
- h. w..~F18DW f-
~ g- ~
- m'he% JNVdUW'.M; mb.b.% ^h"H_ MM., 2 T-
.% 4
- ?
- %WC$lk tom t
? ...a; p :: M _d % n. d % : %, G.M_~g%,, f...-,n..M,.& :wm. .. ma. .w f 3, gx^'7f&.1 },9]ryj;1:twQ; MM, Ap....., -. _. b..a 6 tf *:.;y;' _ p x.f R w w %,:_ %.. c, ( 4) @ %. 4 3.'.:s:: y.h %. 4,..r : > ',M Cc r % # ~ :*% f*2/.k s .:. a MJF d.C,* J$i S Ag.9 h- - i . u e M.- . u;. ' .y. 4,*n-w%, n ' :..m. c.t...u a n., . t.,p/.y f - f.s p. A, w.v A.; v - d.: - V...g WT, *Q,',e $@w),,.vf.'. R v M.Iy., N - 'y. k ,., :,. =. :, O - p 'F *., @' s >.? .4. wl - 1.- ,.3 .? r
- f.
.'.A. %,
- v.,o% y :a;,
- a q 3, p
.,u e* m,: ~c .. * ' L % v.".-Q* %=. * -1 e.... ~$. *. e.,t y &a, ..*:s Aba&os ~o s & f.s*M. 9 Co m w *m ::. r~ ?. - .., W -- 3:.T n.M !. s. > - Q ' }&'*~); w -. & %?Q 1.. -'
- E*'* r*S
- -ssm fKgMM Yh.g'pb.p.e4lJW... n.u'...;'.Qs%JQ.y.sQ
'.jc&.f.f7 rsx; 3 M M 3.? M N N.pn S,.,.s .%u. n.:w A,. y" W s "t-
- M R Q f y l*r -c*=
9i a, r w e** Y f.* fq,y;N y, Q-4 ev gum gm1 +V t 4 .x u -nn ri,q.suu. m.m .r eyg,;n J; ...p W g .a,. rf.v W.g.n w-e e h N
- S Mm%ywa%'Qwh Mw%r+gewwmww@w@www mmw Aen
%n m n$w>qe,(m{e:, W._ twanswwnw 6 -a. W w x w,c.n?.; s m,4.3.w t. nu p V.u;-sy. w.4',gg4 v.- y v 3 H.f. G:. te st
- ~
...,..., y..., g y, % pt. *>ee+%+ %k .Q5'2, ..Ja..a w g '~~ W q bc. A'*dt y % < n-l,'* Y,*I =~ N,. g w.., w s g $.4 c..#, .~ m . s '- ,*r... W, --S f - .A # 5 J../ % ai & g M. pm >a p 4 3 N y &&h*ty D N*W ? C,y*'* W O: R. ll.? R*? ?*& '- - ' A.Y. 4.$& h h (:S? l J 4 y. q ,e c 3 g -. ~ s MMy&yQ.Q p M ~t^??~'O.%,T t M 4 ,a
- ' =.iPW 'W; :by
- k7 Y& diy 4 Q
.m.a .,s %.+.~V *N - ~ %' u.~m a:4 y c., %em.....m.. (N.. m.,....
- c.." @ @ @ :i; n. - M ' L M -../w*A.r/-
a ~~. . s %,n. p.. ,. dg. 3,,. -n ..e.,%, +v - im.... y n #JM E ..,,tr u, }u G,.., D;,e . M m m.'.d M., 4'M ,r k,, ?Q:'M',r jk.%IRf&Q % *.t s'k i.[7*)4.Y'j ;, 'l *hl.h W,. 't, uk-w . a. %. 9 y -.- - ~ .~...,s....,.., <- 2 .y ~ S .e? "k ' ' 5 g..,g~ f:.5
- q.,e,5'$ Q 1**',D Q
~
- E,..!
a 0 & Vs. ?' i <h
- e ot r -
w.m.@, a.,@.w? t;%.,lk ~ ~ ? n. d.. .., ;. g., y. .,7.c0 - ' woo pa{ sk.4 gj - a 9qb ,;> y ' 4 c.e ,a .. n. $v 9y,+.g.a.m.z.p &s,.y &' y &w,:.:-ik W f S*&.S 3*.. P ~'m*-k'O Y k.y> W.: .c x. n.. p...m hgQ &u %< b a Q rh s-n sy-Y. z - s kk'$ 'm ,x ;;;;. pt:c. s-2.0 c. w.w wra M M.;-;ag^.ni.m -.. ;s... .;Ayn x. h.'2.m.. A r-M I.,$ #y &p;WF' .y i w %s.p.h.~-}m : e.
- , c_,r se.. v o...s,.s. f,.
- .e,,,.c,-:L.
~. .. N+AT- .a WC WfM'Y Wy' M.~.~;. w-J- -m't ,s. w
- m u..
7m,r; y ~ d- " : i 3.U' O f M '., ' W/5M% w. MWWtWsMWs MO, eM.,o..P. R&. - ',' - - -~ WF m-..pb., b-, a %.,.A@ny$We 0 M-O p.- V. * '? < A,.. m... WC#. _ 3. v, _ JhM,m. s % i w..w,..e&;^ r r My.s Qn:w%-
- 9. -......n
- ; t e..y.x
- 4..,
E-W 9. v. c . w% g;f*IK, 'UeJ to,1c: 'c.%*;;. : :y q' - ...v;. m n V%a .::.:::... W *c:.. - . a,.3..-s. y -y _. Nl}d;$ Y M %,~d.ruid h: n, M,s** ~' ' e ' E m ' ' 4*&%,Ql'* *. & *';W ',* . 'h . h. $; 2 y, ) f r. 4ce - m.t ca a i :..- _ a
- w. cw.%,.,.- ;,%so,. m,. rm m -.s.c.. e.
w x =.- , ~, - v L.f ty'M '.*,../ '.m pd. :..~ p .d J t w au ,,/ ;"y A 1 = a .. s '.. -.m.;9..%- .y. .r Y.,,,: - W %
- y' 1;.
a m,,..
- w.
e... p f - } d'j.MUdf W b ' Wi.,$. j(.e.RQ oM wtd _WL2 &,.9 L.L-L . t p L st4.m n b W,M; % 2
- . 1.0 ;
Q t %.c;+'d. % i ;L s..., ,.c.,c, .,, e .g s,_.. a. L... y I" h h D' a M ).{- i J. w. L[O t 8 *". I N um),..w.p*$hh a, 7. w a n. w, f. 3 n s.+ u ._~.v... ; %,. p.w,+... #. n9 X'Y A& HL. Y'iAL,. ~ 7-QQQ,! * * .-_n D J. h...;,,Q [,a L;z.;,' ; V - 1;,ic'i&f,l,;],Jm ' '..Ml,
- 3
m A 1 . w' h*.. Y^ e%M& E:?up".DJ.%&.t2j',c%n hiNCMj'k) & t e VvMMr d p M"'# **"'AT-M%.tW. ".:.% (*h /QpaA:htV#Re.Vf k f 0;c#.i l +d v, M,'? 4 I'Q7,W~^ , W %#4gYgW*j Ua W M ~ m m' %..,,, ~ ' y n.n?.m.Ws;_M-m.i a,. Kh wh.s &w M.. M. f c,:..>w->g;.w,,%w:p@,u.?m.m. c sw u e.m u.a.ep..t~ww, vgn.~3. .m--.- n x.n.g s, Aw .m 7inm n. s - e ~+ -r u
- w. e, y..r.w
~ - m ... :;. s f._, %.o. f's s._...J.9-ey;.f,,w,,3 .h:$f.
- D yI.
Q h h;hh h &.rff &$f f ? y.A~*: **:r:+ ~ J h ~ m. ..g.t-ca.y.',~i%. l.E f j :c~ ;.<.;,..., .. f. 4 W. a' :_.?.:# .w .x a m t. ~, %..%..ns.,ws. s.,. e. .w.< a .t s.e a. 3, i:$ 1 '/ f*.r,'g ; y g -4 Orv.N g sf.( y r ,4 u+,.i g g y pfr. g. r m,;.., i .,..,.g...- -...., r.
- s. : +
V. ,.. ~ ~ je.,cf:.:-f, _; W r...:. T . ddb bb 3 Mhh O~( dfm'*b'Md h M4
- ;*.. *: k...g: n. l%... & * %* >,W-.Q,n!D. m.R?.,.ll..,. s2.;.e.$ y. w ~.&:..v; &.,. if,
. e nhn.?b^.,**.e%f ' f*G!' &. *. zw~' g'.?.'*.~'s' y ^ Y .~ . s s: t A.m}3 'r 2: h,, .y:' 6.._;ty ,.fg..g esp .> v...s. .. j. y: .$'..ly 4.m. N '.,'. ' @.',* :.,",. J..4 W4 a *gt, '4. .,. r,* s p" m i o, m.,. ;;, s.. ; .;. - p. 5.. e q%.,.,.. g s.,,.-,%... , r ,n.. -..-m, .~, ps y D, - y. w.6. c, 4. s. 4 ;...,.. c,.. 3 g,., l1 .,s .p
- f. L,.
g g. ess C+y*.;;,,s.,, %., t9 m.T 4 .. 5. 3, ( , +.. ( e.. c r,...g, v< ; < n. > s. J.. 9 ..g.. u.. u. ;J.,, a,e s. m . a ..m. F 9 .,a.,. ,4. e ,, yj u .- 4 a..:
- .t.a,;24..; m
%v ye.v'; y '/./ ".r);'F?f* [,; %y--e..c.;..n,. op - ' ** - m. r.,..3n ~. . s... w 5:r+. n2 )...4- .~- P. .... -. n. '. m .o N % OW... x uN, MyT. 1 es... ~. 4n* .l< ' ;Q.. :l,4 r;, W. yf ; t,9 0 W.. y,, b .-. f y Q:,g'4k.%,, ~,, [. "..j./ ., ' } _ M.,.c W* :(f*I,y..'. 's,-. -2 f. kW} [. y. a - ..,4 y ",. p p.('yy ' 4 *y i.- ^ ey M. f .:r. tag.. &&.h. e,g ; P u o Wa,2:m.,,t,,H,,, go.. . V*.' %..h .*..L .g. ^ y . n.;.....p. 2.c,,.., . v w o. ,. ~.. w....., ..-n. s.'l*?'$f fj:f 2;A.j,h*'s~b&r; g it@rf f'.f'yf h )).f & ?ify $5'LYk1hff k )
- ,h. & ' &3, {~. &
.f,;d. ".X,:, ;t.,} Q @.R.i[.*&, r. f.,*f.'4' ',lu'.c,;h,q.' <p.q'_ a:-%,.t :[..)+ng,Q-Q. x, g?p& !.gg _5, ^.. J:[ %.~,.. y -t y. ,..~ ~.e ,( m ...r.- - a '";' R. s. j- ~ . ", ?.a.....,K*q g .N.Q.',s,,; y W,n ', n .wb ( _x s, %s b r..a^s,..os --wh.p4 .+ < <- v 1,- c 2* p i ~ 1 .s p . ~, aO .ff.C ~ q= ^ ' ' m;. g. s.~, yp,sg.'ch,;;r.".'.f,.] 3.,; my y.,,' 3,y y',~g.wu t*Q*QQ ;y_, - *.u i.,.. R Y' b M.- . ' W' 3 %.. W ' 2n Y-C o. ) ,. A.s: - ^ ff }. 'I., l' ,.,, en... N .s.6 rl. ~ _. b n ., i ". y, 7., m g. n ~..k... 4, t.-.g. g., j -g.A . p? n ,.mf.4 .,gvy'r[..+M*,3...uua,,....,l, % '.Lj 4. $p o f- .+. ,,,w m ,,, ;.g., c .. r, ., + a .s.
- ~
/ +. J.',c[.2,[j.}j, g.y} p ..9*^. ,.g. M - V:j tH, t -. W h4.~
- r..
.J ,~.~ W g4.
- /J c
} ',;,' 17 J.7 '~ p ~ f',, +; m.,y;qQQ' Y .s.a.w.~- G w.:,f.f & -f.. ...w % J,. W.s ..nw 'I, ..Y, U~ A-l*AbN (5k,AqlboA ..k *: bh.: . & W '.~" d l .4 c. .. oy,,e .c, g, x.... ~ .c v. -we s, , m,,.: .,., s.. .,a p m 7 p .p- .e, c. 4 .e he a ~ p. . y J e,.i m e x S
- .t;; @a g;.
g r..g &n,: (,, .9 v .i ,..m.:& y %;p;y: . q. /. 7.. : g.: - M :. y:,m, vw;,.,. .s.,.... y......n...g....., z.2
- , a
.. ~. ... -. -.: y,. 3 ~., d.k. _. =., >..... u, y m-t g...e-m:gg,&a; .m,.m. _.a. -. ; y. ,gg...,. u :.
- so.
m a ...v.a . s. .a. ..,....~; ,_ v_.g.. ..mc c. - s. ~~ ..~4. 2 .m . y},. ba p.:1 . 2.Lo ($ @ c.os bw. n -~t.m. A. 7 u 6 ~.2 4 ~ y/. r '-.D. W.ew._s. A..'.. a... r .;...,. N % w >M. m.... dC., ~ 'd 3._ t.1, e:S. m. .yya yf~. ,. ', pg. g,,fl.g.n.%. g ;gy c. g i, e 7..... 4. s. s .g =*.n, Ilp =. :- fy4:.y',i .s. p . n..,: y , -...x. _,..,. g >. g.... n, p, g. 6..w ..., v._ g _ _ m, e. _ ~., .l s y e.,
- y %,.
y, .t.
- ~,*.,
t.; g .-ep,t ..i .4 ..g.- .'} I). - f N [- f i- ..-,e. > =. - y g *.,.4[;g,2.r[.,g l( O e5, .,s.<,...y e ,,4 e 3, a...w..o.. y, ,. ~. ;,. - '.h
- p. 'oe k k 1
b r J, f .e, 4,. 3,. -,%., - m : m. w.'/*/J lh*e,
- g...., M.
59'. , t '. T' ~
- p,
.r i e ~5~ ,,e ..,. ~. ~. ?: - r w, ;,_Rs h.. W m e S.& ' = .,.~.1. e
- .. s w.'
,,a, s ,s r o. h(j i e .s 4 %,f, Hg A.M - 7 ll. - O..-. - w./. Q d. 2 , h,,.. ; t 6 w r #, /' ,a SD s g +- m ,,. ;y c t;n t ? h?k. . ~.>. m...',f'f.tN., o = } & ' &en. L, *..... '. ' _ )..Y, e,, :,... #. N ..., g_ ~ ,a l7 a ^ ;,r.,,.t..'s..: &.. ;*.,. 2 2,,2. M. p.c A.". 7 .( -. f
- c.... -
- u,
~ ;.. s. 4 'a.E.dsc h a[,el..s.M. e d s'. Lia.,'. d'h*t'h.N'h 'EI.51 g,. T d'.as P a' d ; ' ut.e4 a 6
u, w. , %.... y.' N [ $ N d i y $ $ D h!...h.) $. yi h.,. N ' D['.'"'( Mtddr$.6 I@%M'?. :;F. Af,? %,,a,t:.i.,s d._; %. i26,.:,[ d $ $tM I i .m M,h .1 e .w 74 i, ., +y'.N1 l
- '?l
$ 5 M,. c b UNITSO STATES .[ 5 . 4Q...T' 3-NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMM'SSION %.q o f.b. % afg j WASHINGTON. D. C. 20SSS dp%1 ' Y (' " '/- FEB 2 81979 i I f ~ ffq '/ !E .r s & ri .ts i.y'.v- '>J,p ' fig?;<2 - ' Docket Nos: 50-329 50-330 %.A:] , p.%m m: vgift d.T;"] >BORANDW FOR: Steven A. Varga, Otief,- Light Water Reactors 4W.M Branch No. 4, DPM mgpj@] Ap FRm: Darl Hood, Project Manager, Light Water Reactors ' &J4 Branch No. 4, DPM M.: - ,((
SUBJECT:
FOR'IH00 MING TRIP 'IO CBSERVE PRELOADING P90 GRAM FOR .bM! CONSOLIDATION OF BACKFILL BENE.GH DIESEL CENERATOR I fp BUILDING FOR MIDLAND PLAN'T UNITS 16 2 u.a p ::" - Date 6 Time: March'6, 1979 9:30 a.m. ?.C 3 .., t.'J j I4 cation: Midland Site ^ w ,73;
Purpose:
To observe preloading program, obtain results of measurements cr ,...U to date, and observe surveillance. J l'1 program for other structures en '... E'. -.. backfill.
- p. gs
.j
Participants:
NRC 0,, w@ t.ic D. Gillen D. Hood .c//f A. Hafi:: . R. Cook .@:y: .;~.. ,es;!M Censuners Pewer Conpany
- m
..f-c."... D. Miller -y. et a1
- i...e h
? 4',, g ' ).%:{6. m j ',ff)!'% MA // )' a- .V Darl Hecd, Project Manager ',' c ii Light Water Reactors Branch No. 4 4 '.,'f.,. ; Division of Project Management Y. cc: 3ee next page , 6.v 4 f' 1 Iy . ~ ;; .ya a,. s - -. W_ h { Q. _,.._ __... - I ..r ys e p.'.+.
c,..,. A J y.M.. 4 g.n.?n-S. Z.lC. S,_.iy:r.&;. ". .u.n-lu _Q.h;2...M ylwyQ:l.'t.T-5?&$llW&%%f%$]&_gt? k!;iy -. T ._g. m. s,. 36 f.! ~~ ,~ ..w il m% @, f3 UT ? Ea.a. r) L a s r. 4 .9 i k Consumers Power Company FEB 28 1979 p e'j$ f .d ces: >Tt Michael I. Miller, Esq. Mr. S. H. Howc11 @'h.igy Isham, Lincoln & Beale Vice President d. d Suite 4200 Contumers Power Company
- FWD One First National Plaza 212 West Michigan Menue g'j Chicago, Illinois 60670 Jackson, Michigan 49201
[N;$i Judd'L. Bacon Esq.. G/4ff' Consumers Power Company .1,N4 212 West Michigan ~ Avenue fp'" Jackson, Michigan 49201 {j.m..; t d g;ph Mr. Paul A. Perry
- w Secretary kW Consumers Power Company h- 'VW 212 W. Michigan Avenue r.d Jackson, Michigan 49201 Myron M. Cherry, Esq.
/G One IBM Plaza ?d; Chicago, Illinois 60611 d.dfj , 'jd4 Mary Sinclair 5711 Summerset Drive 0'3.'m
- * :.jl'j Midland, Michigan 48640
- y.,
- [j Frank J. Xelley, Esq.
[D d.6! Attorney General M.y State of Michigan Environmental . 47 '
- Protection Division f',g..
66 3 720 Law Building Lansing,.51chigan 48913 's Mr. Wendell Marshall Mc y;.1l Route 10
- h. '. / -
Midland, Michigan 48640 ' w, :1 .l 4,,51 .4 g ' 'c? -j Grant J. Merritt, Esq. 3.7 ' Thompson, Nielsen, XIaverkamp & James J 4444 105 Center + f.c 20 South Eighth Street ,c. Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402 s m:n. "o i 3 h _ h.
- .y
- s'
<p y ~ , i .- 4 .I,. c a
,y 414 g.. s,. ,. n ";,, .g...gqi a ~,~s ' ? n 4%Q-a'e.d; y%,._,. 3: Q.+. u ' c m., ? m22-w; gag;g s 43_. c. ..,,.... g,yg. xJ, A i.*.K 4 j 'j - -
- .w i
MEETING NOTICE FEB 2 81979 L-.N.1 .3.' .1 Docket File-J. Knight . "'il NRC PDR. S. Hanauer. ~ Local PDR R. Tedesco I ;.,c..,0!J TIC F. Schauer r S. Pawlicki . -;T LWR #4 File i NRR-Reading 'K. Kniel H. Denton T. Novak '7 '.4@j E. Case Z. Ros: toc:y ' YIi D. Crutchfield R. Bosnak ~D. Bunch R. Satterfield ? R. Boyd W. Betler l' 'R. Mattson ~ F. Rosa l RT DeYoung' V. Moore ? D. Muller. M. Ernst < D. Ross. R._Denise D. Vassallo R. Ballard D. Skovholt B. Youngblood W. Gammill W. Regan ~' F. Williacs G. Chipman 1 J. Stol:
- R. Houston
~ R. Baer J. Collins O. Parr' 'W. Kreger 'S. Vargs G. Lear. P. Collins M. Spangler T. Speis V. Benaraya W. Haass L. Hulman 0 C. Heltemes H. Ornstein ACRS (16) J. Ledoux, IE Particip [ ( D. Gil,len ) 7/4 r r .,...a.. Project Manager: D. Hood R. Cook _ g Attorney, ELD IE (3) SD (7) M. Service Receptionist L. Rubenstein L. Soffer l:i s } .g +. - - ?4 .4 w I -s t 4 l '.-9N*jv*"
- -w P
. **. e mppr
- e
..m, .g,, a a ~ g. 6
w v . a n 2.? .. x., WE$gg k;j ~I } %, ~ ~ ~ R. -il: i ~ .-Jcy .~~---a.- _g s. . '.' 3}, e 4 UNITED STATES j g , 'g y* ' t, NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMisslON WASHINGTON, D. C. 20686 ,, 9 3. g j e c'; c y MAR 2 81979 hd..
- . SS N. ?iU*
Docket Nos.: 50-329 he. 50-330 aAgj ~. *3 ;.y Steven A. Varga, Chief, Light. Water Reactors Branch No. 4 7M MEMORANDUM FOR: Division of Project Management 4 - "., 4, - 3 FROM: Darl S. Hood, Project Manager, Light Water Reactors i Branch No. 4, Division of Project Management ~
SUBJECT:
FORTHCOMING MEETING ON OPEN ITEMS FROM-STAFFS REVIEW PART I 0F MIDLAND PLANT,- UNITS 1 & 2 FSAR: '.'.) Date & Time: Tuesday, April 10,1979 - 8:30 a.m. Wednesday, April 11, 1979 - 8:30 a.m. r-Location: April 10 - Rm. 6110, Maryland National Bank Building, Bethesda, Md. y April 11 - Rm. P-500, Phillips Building, Bethesda, Md. ~
Purpose:
To discuss open items associated with the staff's FSAR review of Midland Plant, Units 1 & 2 a
Participants:
NRC D. Hood All FSAR Technical Reviewers Consumers Power Company R. Bowman, et.al. '0arl S d) ct Manager Light Water Reactors Branch No. 4 Division of Project Management
Enclosure:
Agenda cc: See next page ah Y u-gy ; _ ~ l
~ R. , e..j;g. _ gpys, - 4g..g-f:j,. p g.; y,,'. w? . ;1: - 1
- w -
-e p=. u, q_ o _ ^ --, .~ . n.;;- i., i 3,;w.j. ~ 'cyc hi$C;3 frQj Consumers Power Company-1,4' f c I(f2'ffa - - Michac1 1. Miller, l.sq. Mr. S. H. Howell CCs: 8,,pW ! sham, Lincoln & Beale Vice President 2 Suite 4200 Consumers Power Company %/3 One First National Plaza 212 West Michigan Avenue w@d Chicago, Illinois 60670 Jackson, Michigan 49201 k(.N]n d Judd L. Bacon, Esq. 2 ;,';. Consumers Power Company T ";- 212 West Michigan Avenue k;, / Jackson, Michigan 49201 ...:5 ist Mr. Paul A. Perry O. Secretary Je Consumers Power Company ~~4 7.S : 212 W. Michigan Avenue ..Q Jackson', Michigan.49201 p N,c Myron M. Cherry, Esq.
- M; One IBM Plaza
:H - 0 Chicago, Illinois 60611
- .)..y. *
.67E Mary Sinclair c.~< 5711 Summerset Drive Midland, Michigan 48640
- f Frank J. Kelley, Esq.
f Attorney General i ?- State of Michigan Environmental Protection Division 720 Law Building e Lansing, Mi'chigan 48913
- n Mr. Wendell Marshall Route 10 s
Midland, Michigan 48640 Grant J. Merritt, Esq. Thompsnn, Nielsen, Klaverkamp A James J 4444 IDS Center 80 South f.lght.h Street Minneapolis, Minnesota SM07 x g h e 4 8 ? ~* b
- I k
-~.-4
- s s,
- e * :;. - -,
-.--.-3--- -r
p. ;.. m -~. m. [' , ' fy1;'; _; L,-.y y f
- Rag; 23 3 m.
, v, .,:y,,,,,. .:3;ygggg a /.: ; a,;;ww ww. i-x a._.ca w y' p+, .c l- ~ .re.g., ,..C;?] .t~- itiM. f(3' n$@83 A.GERA it - The NRC staff is presently compiling a listing of those areas ?f,f of the FSAR for which review has not been concluded. Some d.:~JC of the items require information from the applicant. Other
- s Y;Ml! 3 items represent a disagreement in positions between the gfz ?q '
-applicant and the staff. a:_ - j:(( .j(.)y The listing of open items will serve as the meeting agenda. J The list' will be transmitted under separate cover letter about ".4.',;.' .g March 30,1979.
- ^,
NRC Staff Technical Re' viewers from each Branch will attend 7. "j,3 M - portions of the meeting during which their review areas are covered. The Licensing Project Manager will notify the ' ";V appropriate reviewers as each Branch's area is reached during the meeting. h J 4 4 4 e 9 I 6 ., + 4 a ~ ,f 4 g b b _ ge _"4
- ~
,y-.---. ..... ~.
_ _ = _ - _ _ - - - -. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 2 A y, y.. a L -... ~. ..._...~.....:_..,.... _, a _2 .m
- }.
~ bi,':-Ef .....,a' ! W.1 MAR 2 81979 is. MEETING NOTICE DISTRIBUTION 2..: o- ' 'T 'J Docket File J. Knight S. Hanauer !.Q j'. NRC POR Local PDR R. Tedesco r S. Pawlicki I?Md TIC lN'i,:0 Branch LWR #4 File F. Schauer K. Kniel PA S ' NRR Reading T. Novak 3;;3 H. Denton 'U...; E. Case Z. Rosztoczy 'l ~ ' D. Crutchfield R. Bosnak R. Satterfield ".i; D. Bunch W. Butler
- i. 3' '
R. Boyd F.' Rosa R. Mattson V. Moore ~4 - ; R. DeYoung D. Muller M. Ernst ~ R. Denise D. Ross D. Vassallo R. Ballard D. Skovholt B. Youngbl.ood W. Gammill W. Regan F. Williams G. Chipman J. Stolz R. Houston ~ R. Baer J. Collins
- 0. Parr W. Kreger
~ G. Lear S. Varga P. Collins M. Spangler T. Speis V. Benaroya L. Hulman W. Haass -~ C. Heltemes H. Ornstein ACRS (16) J. LeDoux, IE Principal Staff
Participants:
L. Crocker All FSAR Technical Reviewers H. Berkow Project Manager Attorney, ELD IE(3) SD (7) Licensing Assistant Receptionist L. Rubenstein L. Soffer
- % D S
eee.*
- 1 _1. _
_g' O.q.$,...'jjg.gr]{ ' < U jf ..i ( ((?'g't, f -' .,.x
- W..
.L cQ ~ Q c# UNITED STATES j
- 4.. _. ;
px 4 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION . I )d WASHINGTON, D. C. 20N j \\v/ , cd f MAR 2 01979 [.. ~ 00cket Nos: 50-329 50-330 p'. s* T. ;.. ll.l<* APPLICANT: Consumer Power Company ^- FACILITY: Midland Plant, Units 1 & 2
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF MARCH 6,1979 TRIP TO OBSERVE ~ STATUS OF S0IL PRELOAD PROGRAM On March 6,1979, members of the NRC visited the Midland site to observe the status of the preloading program being perfonned in order to conso-lidate 'the fill in the vicinity of and underneath the' diesel generator building. Participants and contacts are listed in Enclosure 1. The preload program consists of placing granular fill (sand) inside the diesel generator building and for some distance outside the building. The level of preload at this stage consisted of a 10-foot uniform height. Further preload operation is dependent upon the applicant's evaluation of the results of this stage. A proload height of 20 feet above final plant grade is the maximum expected. The preliminary data being obtained on the response to the 10-foot preload was reviewed. The data suggests that additional compaction is being achieved, particularly at the upper levels of the fill. As ~ 'm expected, a rapid rate of settlement was experienced initially in response to the preload, and the rate of settlement generally decreased thereafter. The preliminary data also suggests that the south-east corner of the diesel generator building is settling at a greater rate than the south-west corner. The applicant also noted that the concrete encasement for the condensate line located underneath the western half 2:. of the building is now believed to be in direct contact with the building foundation. This situation is being closely monitored and the validity of the measurements is being checked. The preliminary measurements of ground water behavior beneath the building in response to the preload showed local variations in level. This tends to further confirm that the fill material under the structure is variable. ' The applicant reported that instrumentation previously installed in the tank farm area was being relocated so as not to interfere with con-struction activities. 4 4th y J,~1 a A ~ M - - ~ ~ y y r yv <g 1 f 4
7.t hijg -gg'g. g y [ I7dhj@MQigygjjhjk}f};q<c: g _,.m_v _.%,...u --.___s .1. -e- - :,;3.p. .&j' W.;;; 3 b:.1 -
- , 3
- 3. ~ - 21 MAR 2 01979
,d.[yj Measurements of an underground service water pipe located between the , Ict;.;] diesel generator. building and turbine building indicate a substantial variation in elevation. The Bechtel representative stated that this
- variation is believed to be due to faulty initial installation, and
- eg;
- .S that the pipe would be replaced upon completion of the preload program.
].gQ A general tour of the site was made, including all seismic Category I ~ ' c';: structures founded upon. fill. The data reviewed during' th'e trip will be reported in Bechtel's interim [D,; '. f, report 5 to MCAR 24 and will be forwarded by the applicant to the NRC in April 1979. I d l Ans .L Darl Hood Light Water Reactor Branch No. 4 Division of Project Management
Enclosure:
As stated cc: See next page 9 %e a& a P I ,. Q 'f-l y.;-l, 7-] 't._. s i k A i 1 ,-. a -. -. ~.
c m. .,,._, m _. khE(i&lfk{kfiyhh,h{$f { ~ ' :9[.f5& &fhj".ffhn'll$hf?jkQ$ Q $ $l Q , d . l.{ ( =~ ~ yd3-l; .q . zy MAR 2 01979 a
- a..
Consumers Power. Company <A f -v l ::l g - ~ ' : :: ::y. CCs* Mr. S. H. Howell ,,g i Michael I. Miller, Esq. Vice President 3,'/j. Sl Isham, Lincoln & Beale Consumers Power Company g@. AQ One First National Plaza Jackson, Michigan 49201 Suite 4200' 212 West Michigan Avenue c R l-)
- S
- /t.f Chicago, Illinois 60670 s
+ Judd L. Bacon, Esq.
- '.i Consumers Power Company 212 West Michigan Avenue' Jackson, Michigan 49201 s
-r Mr.~ Paul A. Perry ' Secretary Ccnsumers Power Company 212 W. Michigan Avenue Jackson, Michigan 49201 Myron M. Cherry, Esq. One IBM Plaza Chicago, Illinois 60611 ~ Mary Sinclair 5711 Summerset Drive Midland, Michigan 48640 Frank J. Kelley, Esq. Attorney General ~ ' State of Michigan Environmental Protection Division 720 Law Building Lansing, Michigan 48913 Mr. Wendell Marshall , J, Route 10
- f. ; "..
Midland, Michigan 48640 '[. '
- Grant J. Merritt, Esq.
'd Thompson, Nielsen, Klaverkamp & James "4;' ' 4444 105 Center .T 80 South Eighth Street Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402
- t...y
.- e.
- h
? s d - e.e & - ... ~, ...,,. _ - - - ~ ._.~,...,.-,7 s -
pp p _r ,;,,, p __ ,.n??Yb;@l@@i.@ffGgyyl-llQ:sh,,f3.f+jifpgy.Qgjyfjgfggyp.grfeg:gy y y _ s4
- im j"
- [ R:
. :-, 7.l
- ...g I .S$
A, .. a. i y, NRC' PARTICIPANTS
- e.
.g..v.?-
- , x~
- .u..
~ N,.fli Darl -Hood - Division of Project Management, NRR "l@.i Dan Gillen-Geotechnical Engineering Branch, DSE/NRR 1 Abdel Hafiz Structua1' Engineering Branch, DSS /NRR .i 0 . Gene Gallagher I&E, Region III .$. a.. g ..i CONTACTS ..4 a g + ' Consumers Power' Company Thiru Thiruvengandam Charles Hunt Bob Wheeler s Bechtel Charles McConnel Austin Marshall F 9 S= Ai A J',, 4 v+ ^ g er i *I f e. g s' ~ i f g 8# @J
- s g o
e-9 ,_Y, 7*4 0 \\
- p.. ;.
, 4. -... -. E 4 9"' g O e E
- SmD
.+ .m ..._.7.... ,., ~
- "M i T,_
- ~. * ~
- ~
sewa,,pe, w
n ""s'[' 2 / I. Y g - se ^ *., 7 E
- 2. a l a :
_u. _s:,. s: .:,_-s u u nw_;.u M h z, m?... yv5
- p. c.
~ p'.) y, y!' .r.,g-h.,f /
- \\o,,
unireo staras yJ NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION n U35jt i ,1 'wAssinaron. o. c. 2 osse s m" :m %..... /a NOV 141978 s,.*p, v.:c;; ! V3-Docket Nos: 50-329 r.=._u 50-330 ~ Q.s. ~ ~.97; MEMORANDUM FOR: Steven A. Varga, Chief, Light Water , Reactors Branch No. 4, DPM b 'a FROM: Darl Hood, Project Manager, Light Water Reactors Branch No. 4, DPM
SUBJECT:
FORTHCOMING MEETING AND SITE VISIT ON' SETTLEMENT OF MIDLAND STRUCTURES [' Dato 6 Time: December 3, 1978 1:00 p.m. 9:00 a.m. December,4, 1978 ~ [ Location: Midland, Michigan Plant Site r
Purpose:
To discuss and observe settlement of the Diesel Generator Building and other structures.
Participants:
NRC E-' helle r D. Gillen D. Hood 'i3 R. Cook (Site) A. Hafiz Consumers Power Company j G. Keeley, et. al, 0 A nt. Darl Hood, Project Manager Light Water Reactors Branch No. 4 C 'g Division of Project Management ^;) P '.
Enclosure:
Agenda cc: See next page sy d 1 I A 6tAl"I"A-t v # W WT ' Y I
?:^i j.; % M l Y ?G2 9 3 5 % i) Q .. ;f. :% ::.. .:l...... ~ ', ;~. ~ ' _+ -~ g, - - --. m. -.~:.~.~. - ;:4m.., ..., no.. 3-Q,,.;,P{: 1.* ? $- ?:$ f.yf., fgj t.onsumers Power Company NOV 141978 ^. ?,v. yfp.. c s: -y CCs* l.1
- Yj3!
Michael I. Miller, Esq. . J, e.fjj 'Isham, Lincoln & Beale-py.L; . Suite 4200 WJg? One First National Plaza '#28 Chicago, Illinois 60670 WhG ij$} Judd L. Bacon, Esq. i. 1.-:e ; ~: Consumers Power Company 50;$.'". 212 West Michigan Avenue in.;, Jackson, M.ichi gan' 49201 7 p.t. f..f _... 4, Mr. Paul A. Perry ~ COJ:s . Secretary Consumers Power Company' ".~ N $ 212 W. Michigan Avenue c Jackson, Michigan 49201 .J ..<. y:. Myron M. Cherry, Esq. '. / One IBM Plaza 'O ' Chicago, Illinois 60611 ~- Mary Sinclair 5711 Summerset Drive s, Midland, Michigan 48640 Frank J. Kelley, Esq. Attorney General State of Michigan Environmental Protection Division
- s. >
720 Law Building Lansing, Michigan 48913
- 2. 2..y 24 ' s, Mr. Windell Marshall Route 10
'i's, Midland, Michigan 48640 s Mr. S. H. Howell Vice President
- .../
Consumers Power Company J. " : 212 West Michigan Avenue - e. ;.... Jackson, Michigan 49201 Jf e .yj. a e, I ~ l. = r + b n e } . w.... _. 7 i
+. n. x. i y, ~ <h..v p s. _ f. y gg. AgJ.7j,kgg[.yg,gsp43;g.2. c-9.ggw~ g na ~ --.~. u m - w. c - r.
- p.
Wtf
- &w, s'-
.i : m .@ f-3: R.1 p.t
- ENCLOSURE NOV 141978
- f g.
AGENDA ggg $sq. ~ hh9 Pursuant.to 10 CFR 5'0'.55(e), Consumers Power Company h.Mg '(CPCO) notified Region III of the>0ffice of Inspection 4GW and: Enforcement on September 7,1978 that settlement of the ~ M Mif - Midland Diesel Generator Building foundations and genera' tor pedestals'was' greater;than expected and that a soils-(L.//2,4f' ?._. boring program had been started to determine the cause and extent of the problem. An interim-status. report was i, igi 4 >.e::0 'provided to Region III by CPCO's attached letter of September 29, f, -i ( ?.- 1978. h[ N Region III conducted 1 inspections on this matter on October 24-27, ^
- my, '. > >
1978 (Inspection Report No.* 50-329/78-12; 50-330/78-12. %w:/ engineer has contracted Goldberg, Zoino,
- J The architect
- g +
Dunnicliff.6 Associates (Consultants in Geotechnical
- 9;'.-8
- j Engineering) to conduct laboratory tests on soil samples obtained during the soils boring program including
.,: N a series of soils. classification tests and determination ~ M'a of' engineering soils properties. Results were provided y' to CPC0 November 6, 1978. ~ Members of the NRC will observe' settlement of the foundation and structures on Sunday, December 3, 1978. s. The meeting on December 4, 1978 will discuss results 'M of the architect - engineers investigative soils test & C: program and those matters of the Region III inspection y,. is report.- q k i - 6 T b 5 g ,4 s t .G:, s 3.m W; I + t
- * ~
.4
- i.-
}, '.f y'{ .e f g "F 6 eme-& T , e 4'y,, f'- ss
c ['.jf$f:h ~j O E ,p h 'l 3 ~'. __:J=.ac.m. .2: - = 37
- u... _ w..;
-"Ei r w .,.}~. - + g. c. e e 9. :: ,ukj. NOV 141978 @"'w, M EETING NCTTICE DISTRIBUTION -.'M.R 9,:g..,, ; k-n Docket' File J. Knight $ y, ' NRC PDR D. Ross
- t..m Local PDR R. Tedesco dMiE[i
. TIC S. Pawlicki 4 LWR #4 File Chief, SEB
- ed'if' NPR Reading K. Kniel fG-H. Denton W. Haass
- 4 '.
E. Case T. Novak D. Crutchfield. Z. Rosztoczy D. Bunch R. Bosnak' '; ^: R. Boyd Chief, ICSB D. Vassallo W. Butler p A.: -' D. Skovholt F. Rosa e, " ' $3 ', ' W. Gamill V. Moore 1,f F. Williams R. Vollmer - A J. Stolz M. Ernst R. Baer R. Denise ' +
- t O. Parr R. Ballard S. Varga B. Youngblood
'Lu'~ R. Clark W. Regan 7' T. Spels G. Chipman P. Collins J. Collins C. Heltemes W. Kreger R. Houston G. Lear R. Mattsen M. Spangler R. DeYoung V. Benaroya D. Muller, J. Stepp ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ACRS (16) L. Hulman L. Crocker H. Ornstein 't : H. Berkow L. Dreher Project Manager: D. Hood B. Faulkenberry P Attorney, ELD
Participants:
L. W11er 7 Gi1 @ Reg. IE (3)
- vuok, III SD (7) n.
M. Service A. Hafiz Receptionist L. Rubenstein t 9 / 1 L 'g 9 .6ee & +..
.-- a
- r..
~ ..? ~ ' '.. ? :.
- a-3
~ ' ' = neo f , unllTED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION o. r,; a wasnessoTom, o.c. 2eems a / %,..... / r p JUN 211979 Docket Nos.: 50-329 and 50-330 APPLICANTi Consumer Power Company. FACILITY: Midland Plant, Units'1 and 2
SUBJECT:
SU MARY OF TRIP TO INSPECT TEST PITS The attached memorandum summarizes'the trip by NRC staff person'nel on June 7 1979 to observe test. pits in the plant area fill at the Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2 site. l -%. Ibo Darl S. Hood, roject Manager ~ Light Water Reactors Branch No. 4 Division of Project Management
Enclosure:
As stated cc: See next page i r l' l I 3 r0 -n a d i n as,r i t: " I ( f T L. ( y } { .y
= -- m - 1 g [ Consumers Power Company ~ 4 j 'cc: Mr. S. H. Howell Michael I. Miller, Esq. Isham, Lincoln & Beale Vice President Consumers Power Company j Suite 4200 212 West Michigan Avenue One First National Plaza Chicago,; Illinois 60670 , Jackson, Michigan 49201 Judd* L. Bacon, Esq. j. Consumers Power Company h; 212 West Michigan Avenue 'p/ Jackson, Michigan 49201 -i Mr. Paul A. Perry Secretary Consumers Power Company 212 W. Michigan' Avenue Jackson,' Michigan 49201 ~ Myron M. Cherry, Esq. One IBM Plaza y=== Chicago, Illinois 60611 t Mary Sinclair. 5711 Sunmerset Drive Midland, Michigan 48640 Frank J. Kelley, Esq. ~ Attorney General ~ State of Michigan Environmental m, Protection Division 720 Law Building Lansing, Michigan 48913 i Mr. Wendell Marshall h Route 10 f."." Midland, Michigan 48640 Grant J. Merritt, Esq. (- Thomoson, Nielsen, Klaverkamp & James 4444 105 Center 80 South Eighth Street Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402 a
- 9. 4
- Mr. Don van Farow, Chief
~ Division of Radiological Health Department of Public Health P. O. Box 33035 y Lansing, Michigan 48909 1
- .e. Y
? f L~, ,-4 .i
Qt ' ' ~~ ~r ,x n: -.2:. x. c.: .l' ]- g aae d [ o UNITED STATES ^ "g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION .g a WASHINGTON, D. C. 20666 t /- June 14, 1979 i f l- / { MEMORANDUM FOR: Darl Hood, LPM Light Water Reactors Branch No. 4,'DPM FROM: Daniel M. Gillen, Gedtechnical Engineer Geotechnical Engineering Section Geosciences Branch, DSS j j THRU: Lyman W.. Heller, Leader g/f p? ~ Geotechnical Engineering Section Geosciences Branch, DSS
SUBJECT:
MIDLAND SITE VISIT TO INSPECT TEST PIT PROGRAM On Thursday, June 7, ~ 1979, J. P. Knight, '. Heller, R. Lipinski, and L I visited the Midland 1 & 2 plant site for a general tour of the structures founded on the plant fill, and an inspection of the test pit program in progress. ~ 4 After a short introductory meeting we accompanied representatives of Bechtel and Consumers Power Company on a tour of the Category I structures to be effected by plant. fill remedial work. These included the diesel generator building, service water pumphouse, auxiliary building railroad bay, auxiliary building control room and electrical penetration areas, diesel generator fuel oil storage tanks, and barated water storage tanks. During the afternoon, while J. P. Knight 1d R. Lipinski were engaged in discussions with Bechtel and Censumera structural personnel, L. Heller i and I were conducted on an inspection of the test pits in the plant fill and other open excavated areas. Three test pits were observed in various stages of completion (TP #'s 2, 3 and 4). We observed Goldberg, Zoino and Dunnicliff personnel sampling and performing density tests in test pit #4 3 adjacent to the service water pumphouse. We also visited Goldberg, Zoino and Dunnicliff's on site soils testing facilities. A brief departure meeting was held for coments and questions that had arisen n p during the inspection tour. A list of applicant personnel contacted during d our tour is attached. g .1 h 13 14 a Daniel M. Gillen, Geotechnical Engineer Geosciences Branch, DSS i
Enclosure:
As stated cc: See next page &(fW YAnAOth/2~)= k I r~ l
a-. ?- .u :.: r z.:.:. . ;:..?
- 2 :..
= 4 Darl Hood 2- >.r ~ cc:.w/ enclosure-J. Knight R. Jackson L. Heller R. Lipinski D. Gillen i. s l 3 + .( r. h I ( 1 i e . - -. ~ k ,) P 1 1 s e 6 i e=0 ~ ~ ~ - - -
.;,~-- p g y...,+., ' 7. l a List of Contacts Bechtel: S. Afifi 0 P. A. Martinez A. Boos . P. E. Johnson B. Dhar ' C. Weidner Consumers Power Company: C. A. Hunt k. R. M. Wheeler T. C. Cooke m D. E. Horn D. Sibbald 1 P4 6 4 4 o b 4 0 64 n i' I t e ..a l _ _ ~.
k(.. ..., c...
- g
- g w
MEETING SUM 4ARY DISTRIBUTION c 1 'H. Denton JUN 211919 ' Docket File NRC PDR-Local PDR.
- t TIC NRR Reading Branch File 54 f
-E.. Case + D. Bunch ~ D.-Ross t-D. Vassallo W. Gammill J. Stolz R. Baer
- 0. Parr S. Varga C. Heltemes L. Cro_cker D. Crutchfield F. Williams R. Mattson R. DeYoung Project Manager D. Hood Attorney, ELD M. Service
!! (3) ACRS (16) R. Denise L. Rubenstein ~ ~ ~ NRC
Participants:
J. P. Knight L. Heller R. Lipinski ' O. ^tilen I .~ m g. =.e,.--,}}