ML20094M332
Text
- #7
~
=e
^~
/
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION o
~U I
REGION 111 k
8 790 ROOSEVELT ROAD GLEN ELLYN, ILLINOIS 80137 eeee.
August 6, 1982 MEMORANDUM FOR:
R. L. Spessard, Director, Division of Project and Resident Programs RMO THRU:
R. F. Warnick, Acting Director, Office of Special Cases THRU:
W. D. Shafer, Chief, 1
~ Projects Section FROM:
R. J. Cook, Senior Resident Inspector, Midland Site
SUBJECT:
SALP III EVALUATION PERIOD Refs T. N. Tambling memo dated July 12, 1982 During our discussiens with you and Mr. D. C. Boyd on July 19-20, 1982, it was my understanding that you were in favor of extending the SALP III evalua-tion period for the Midland Site from June 30, 1982 to December 31, 1982 for the following reasons:
- 1) The SALP.II report was given to the licensee on April 26, 1982 and some of the issues are still being resolved between the licensee and the NRC.
The last meeting conducted,on these issues was on August 5, 1982.
- 2) With the late issuance of the Cycle II SALP report and some of the more controversial aspects of the SALP report being discussed at the present, the NPC could come under criticism for not allowing enough time for the effects of the SALP II comments to be implemented into the licensee's performance. A cursory review of the inspection and enforcement records for the period July 1,1982 through June 30, 1982, indicates that in some of those areas identified as Category 3 during SALP II would remain Category 3 during SALP III.
- 3) Lengthening the SALP III evaluation period to December 31,1982 can be used as a perfozmance motivator in the following form: If the licensee is informed that he now has an additional six months to show improve-ment - the licensee may take atcivantage of the time and SALP III could reflect that there were difficulties in t he first portion, but as a result of the findings for SALP II, the licensee was responsive. Should the record show that there is no or little improvement even after the results of SALP II, then this is an indicator without much doubt as to the steps the NRC needs to take in dealing with this utility.
8408150622 840718 PDR FOIA RICE 84-96 PDR
.-.y 1
R. L.' Spessard 2
August 6, 1982 The above concepts were discussed with Mr. T. N. Tambling on July 19 or 20,1982 and he (Mr. Tambling) appeared to be receptive to these ideas and to extending the SALP III period to December 31, 1982.
Sincerely, d'C j
R. J. Cook Senior Resident Inspector Midland Site Resident Office cc:
D. C. Boyd T. N. Tambling e
w
-,7 a, --..
my, - -,
.n-4 a-g n,-,,..,,,.,
p-,c y, -,,,,,,, -w-..,y,y e---
-e, y
y yy-w
,---r-
N&
Age;p, f
f-fL.
Yl's tldes 1'L,;}. (D RJ iu6 - 7><iw9 &L
/
2imn
$M swY J
WJJX DD./
.&%L,.J. O isa 9 t SA l'-
,7':a Md C.4 swn /w.u.2' mA L -~..
i'/ uvap~%~
!J
.9%m J
^
~
y
~
J/.
f
.r hih, /L $ mb % /fa
- t-
'i
^ = ^ ^ -".
J-
/
6Aw s
')
/
w,w 6~ w'i,
/)
23 JJ & (544P)DY(Aq-)
/r pn~
M tu s
.E;i aL a um%
an 7j)
,k W Ne
.e.$$lY' '-
.:)
D. J (t? D J....
was
'/y +
LL., L.D. - ds>>a
.g 2 /.J. ~ &.... -
ty a
f 7
[
WAl J bu A11J
,/ - A n @
L
/s p :
g -
- Q1 z a a a -e a
' ( -
.sLJ4 m m
,d ~
-00)
.!' ~
t> J L
- X' a
L__lo'A f YY d~x<, LJ- (6 Q-& ff
< A
& %v.d4 A ~ ~ ~ w a,yJ.
..~a...
k....
e o -
e 9 9
.e o
^'b"-
/N -
Q. F 5/-o y m..'..,
8. 3/ 3 n
pin. 2 na
[zijs - &$ &_ m gA.
W 0" O I~ d f& - ^L M&
y M.
y?
2 4)9' U w out' J-yL.
/A 5%J di- -. '.
5;~u uuj -
\\ J y t.L 4 i uuc y
a-Myo-<~J-
/.$ L *?
/). ~
ys -
c0
. W 5/ %
& a w / x.9L 9 7 J
--ex i g
u,s 1:!xlRC kyJ - Q xe ~ & f i OKe 5ll w 3
/~.
q cric.
Ask p i c.h.,LJ u" J h.-
Q yA- -
&p nxs t-s-
a w.a4 gxs j.. :.
J m
.s e..
J iud 6 On -
- lal J / L '-
l,'
i
h 4P @MF W b 4 wh h%b--
_mw....
,,,,,,,,,g,,,,
,g e'
e 9
.O e
1 MA E 9 (if 4
.L L C& G
<fC) 3
- Ae e L 4 A57mp-k A g(q /- sl~dL~
~ /M.
qs s,p e.
X~ -
a n s ~ J a n -> ssrm pn.a u d i
& ;s'&-
0-O f
I u
- ara 4-gm wA "c^!L J A 4 t w yy4-Mg T -
A @Q3f7j [~h7 " -
h uwu a z=3 U W w a},.
6 sasf qAu n-ad 'O &'
M
-. J L m m qq ~ g.
AA WW n
e.
e
. 9 O
e O
k'aL-
"fn cdJ ZLL, p k.,._ n l a J J
- asrw w - w ay 3
Jq -
%g.p A n.d~1J m J x % u ~
> a wm m p m
Wk w1I
.~.t A' :--
~
a G J y p h J y y-x.sa m
7 dM 6._ 4 __
m Ll L- @i sk.A l~p m
~
py q..
fg s n >r y - L (/~,f)
Ifw--
m y7 J y a g g A
.... -.. y&L up
. 7?id C g.
.a.
.,,ms
..==e-c.
- e e-o e
- * *'^
..gLJ..,
A C-ALL n J
_.. _..._..4 JC..
- a g
- Osrr-ci
/%
>M M
$Q Mc$
A ~ C_
. w s t _. a u s n, r g L4 w n a,_
ELL M -
h
.e.
=
m -=
x.-
.e w,
y
-,e me p.
w whp
--h-gs -e
&W.we 6
6my-eN 4 N
e 9
6+=84mer*
6 4mm. Nae e
.N'#.
- MMN"--
..-----..n..
. - -. ~. -..
.L tw.A E.S (d.yd AL &~9 4 ~..cp 1 ~ -zr 8.c-M u/
L,.....
~.
JU.e mO 6
,4 f A J 3
i7) - w K)L.a n.Ja, A D d,
5 ~.~a l.
k l.1 i
1 W, D W s
- n. J W A~ h W-w~.&
b~,LJ r wlJJ ~ &J n-fd
- W m T lw-S.~~.c.L E~yc
~~
Wz
'y.
g;tL n Q Q h&A J~
vgc. Am &... -.
s w.
i J
~
d
., f.
g.,
s
/
W
=====~
sl~. &.,m
,~ J a a y. d L._...=.
J JLJ.
+wq W.Jh -
Y 6
a m.d q.
%.a W -
p.4 6W&W*
m es e
e..
p e
- ....*..e*==e.
me--
c--,
--7..,--.,.c-----,
.-w
,y, y--p
-,s.ygg.
+,-.y
,,e,-
y -
'M U*O%..*
~
^66
,g 4
0 O
e 9-ee e
/
J J
W
- -.-..A J f & JL..
.. n,
!!JJ.
L km
-. 6i}. %.
54-/.L.
[
X$< al, f&,
ny..
(1.,d. -
w am n.s9ne w F a-s
-~
N ujLM
- k. J ~.
.... _... _ C a 2 AA, gn w.ac.- M & J to,
~
A3.
~
2.
~
M=,u E&.LL.
..f m
W
~~
J
.N6M..M p yA 4.
y.
~
- 5..
&'^~
~
=
. - : -. 4g-
- g.; =--....-
-.-...*., =
6.....,.
t e.ee e
--.--,.-.--.-.----.=**.=~,.,-..--.n.-
- * + * * * * *
- - = = = * * *. * * = = -
ao mm e..
~gu..
- =.
='e.
-.--,,.,---,,,,....-,-.-.,.,.-n
7 j
l 5M L/' y - m x 34p ?
fa -
LO fp D
~ ~
/
~
h)& - M. MM
~
M f
A
~
p-w Q)Q
~~
sG k Q J L Strl-v" y d. g-P/-i, 714 g [f M.
WJ
- G4 NK ? -
.. ". '. ~.
,.e...-...
,c.'
^ *
(y A 2-e ~,'- @ g g d ~.% -
WJ - WM 4 c
go a w Hydc 4-e.
e a-
-e a-4.
m-e-
. =
.e Sh.ege g
n sac.. ecs.c& rj ou A x n.
a.co. KSce)._
- -........L _.
e c.
M
=.
e-ep.
.ei
,m.
,,4m e,
..a
.6+
e.
M=**
.**N
- ==-.
~.
SHARON WARREN STATEMENT GIVEN AT THE CLOSE OF THE SALP MEETING WITH THE LICENSEE ON AUGUST -4, -1982 AT THE MIDLAND HOLIDAY INN, MIDLAND, MI.
. We recognize that although this is a public meeting, it is primarily a meeting between the regulator (NRC) and the licensee. I appreciate the opportunity to attend and make a brief statement.
As everyone is aware, the Lone Tree Council and the Government Accountability Project has been monitoring the Midland situation for the last four months and the NRC SALP ratings reflect our findings with the exception of the Category I 4
rating for HVAC. We are glad the licensee managed to obtain the Category I rating in one other area - Fire Safety.
Furthermore, we are aware that NRC will not change these SALP ratings. However, if any changes are made, it should only be in HVAC because of all the problems that exist in that area.
I am confident that RIII's next SALP report will reflect the HVAC problems.
I wish to reiterate that the HVAC problems of the ZACK Co. are as serious at Midland as they are at LaSalle.
The licensee is aware that the 10 CFR 21 report, released yesterday and prepared by the licensee, represented a review of 951 safety-related - I repeat safety-related travelers. Of those reviewed, there were problems with 270 of them. In the study of the licensee's fine of $38,000 only two years ago by the NRC, I find it incredible that the.same procedures have been followed by ZACK and the licensee as the ones which precipitated that fine.
A more comprehensivo statement is being delivered to Mr. Keppler today in Washington' by the Government Accountability Project.
Thank You
--m g-s-s
- + - -.
a------p--a m
%p mw-- *,-g---
-.,rt+
e u.--
- m.=
-p---
-1 W-y
,,j, O
bde Sa>
- g yeo SDrte E l
\\ s fi VP,y,ds ro u.,ar
\\,a n ';;ka p.+ -
\\ g.,) y.
p' u.J s
\\
3pttng f. A 1
\\gcraprank
\\
\\
\\
\\
{
l
- m. -
v't
.~
u l
l t
-,._.. _ _. _ _ -.. _ _. _ _ - - _ _.. _ - _. - _ _ _ _ _. _ _. _ - _ - _ - - _ _ _ _ _ ~ _ _
_,,.s._
0 5
O e
E B
f O
.A 1
6
~
w d'
&nJ
's I
s r~-
b'&
,;p &,y.a
-: r, a
i J
I
]
\\'
i B
B L
4 P
g.,m m
-==--.--.w
.~....4..-..
e f
i 0n & Qll a g6-(
J
\\ o 2 2 8r Y-OkW -
1
.p
_- f f------_--
w 4e.
- w. me.w em e
u.m ai am mi we eme gmuuse eee agemus.,m-4ein-.
mma e u.eee-e.6
-e-
.==..
mee.-ei-==
=mm.o enes.
e.--
-eemini en
, -+
me.w..-~.mmi..,-
.see e-4
.- - - = - --+-
ee..
-we*
-.gn=-ee--mee-ep.mu--.
.-.-ee.
,-m-4
.w_..,
~,
,e..
e.
~... _-.. _ _
e.
.==- -- --
e
.m.
..e.
O e--,.-,-o
.. -..e.
.m_.em-
. ~. -
e.
e.
W&eem-mmee
.-eamse um e w.sm.
g.
e.
ces.
e.
-e-.
.oh e
,, sum e
.e
- emmen 5e e
w.
ese m.
um a ww o
O
= =, - -e.-
-eae em e.-e e.mmm e.-
=am--.
...~
.a
.- - -e-.-
- + = - * --- -
-~&
e.-em+-
- me e
-em-
- we eem og vammm.=4-we.egemesse-e 4
+-*
- 6-96 W
N6 6
6=6w 6es
- N6 e NaDw
.e-e-g>
h eme + eme =
.-mNe.eme m e w
a e-
-eamp..
r e ai m.-emeeme.e ee
--mme mum-
- e==
m.*
- Eli e
p= w ewe.es g
eswee.ew e,mps.--
we, in = N m
-esia.4m-
.e-n eeg6-e hawg-eme--emi-en-m -
e-w,+eeeumsgy.e,--
+w m
.-,4-
+
e-e.
-w meem em.-
e-e-o e
h e-m -s
-ee e
e---
e D
-im e emum-- ++=,... -. - - +
.e--
..m.
-e-
=== -.
..=w-
-= + -
..a St
- er==
msmemumm mm---
4-gm-ge ewem-.
e.
-. -. ---.*emo egimm-w.
-==
-'eim
-6m ee
-' game.-
m
,muum.m.
-.we
+,m.m.
>= ewow e es.apm e - e e m.-m-*emum-
-e"N am e
e mm-
-.e--
e e,
---emee
'-ines e.
O a.
=
.--*----mm,me.
.n
.-e
..-=.
EM*O
+e e a.4.
eo se*-e
-*h*4'EP4*
- -*'"'N
- ""d**
'88P**e emom e
e emb en
- emN N
,e-Nesm.
.-- we u.-
w
,.M=mur ee-em-N
- 8
- M="89*
%="*; N.
9 ge amme't p
t s epup-ee ge sammee>*== ww.+ -ew < =.ar en ra-9 + e *
.e-w*
= 9 e
g.---,
.w ar-,,
---,,.---, -,%e-
-_-, - - -. - - - - - -,,.,, -,. -me,
.3.. 3...:...
<.......~.a2.-~......u....;'a..
.. ~..
.:...a.. s :
n Ac Or1 1
YM a4,
~
s.
,.&- e haiE. 'Il
!90'.'!0i James W Cook dl o.m.
..g N
VJa& Giij Vice President - Projec:s, Engineering j
and Construction oeneret Offices: 1945 West Parnell Road. Jackson. MI 49201 * (5171 788 0453 August 2, 1982 Fl'. !;. : U /J. 5.. t.:
u J,
,,33
}
-.H.4 i
l
? -
yt
_t.'
...c-i
,i v
Mr Harold R Denton, Director YI'~7
- TM Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
~3; ;
Att: Division of Licensing 9
l' i '
i US Nuclear Regulatory Commission 9.
["~~~h g,
/j Washington, DC 20555 MIDLAND PROJECT MIDLAND DOCKET NO 50-329, 50-330 MIDLAND CONCRETE WALL CRACK REPAIR PROGRAM FILE: 0485.16 SERIAL: 18371 A meeting was held on June 25, 1982 between Consumers Power Company and the-NRC to resolve outstandir.g technical issues regarding the soils remedial actions. During the meeting, Consumers Power Company committed to repair concrete cracks in the category I safety grade buildings affected by the soil fill. The purpose of this letter is to formally document our commitments.
The crack repair pregram Consume Power C upany has committed to perform is based on the recommendations o our consultants and the concerns expressed by the NRC Staff.
It applies to he Diesel Generator Building, Sgrvice Water
. Pump _ Structure, Control Tower and Electric /l Penetrations Areas of the luxiliary Building and Feedw4ter Isolatioq/ P.it_s.
The Program, which will be completed prior to the firstIrefueling of/the plant, consists of the following g'
g gg - g% SWE Ch three points:
gn a
- 1) Repair by epoxy inje tion any acks in the structures which are below the permanent ground - ter ta e and which exhibit weeping characteristic. This rep will be performed from the inside of the structures.
- 2) Coat the splash zone of the exterior surface of the south wall of the Service Water Pump Structure which is in contact with cooling pond water with waterproofing compounds. The waterproofing compound will be one of the three compounds recommenddby consultants in their report
" Effects of Cracks on Serviceability of Structures in the Plant" submitted to the Staff as an enclosure to letter from J W Coo ( *o H R Denton, Serial 16884, Dated April 23,1982 _or equivalent.
$OOI AUG 161982 oc0782-0193a100 y3=rs20802 PDR ADOCK 05000329 A
,PDR
~
e e-y
., :.l__...._ m.
i-
-.m.
j, I
2
'3) Repair-by epoxy injection existing cracks which are 20 mils and larger Land apply a sealant to the surfaces of the concrete walls in the following accessible areas (i.e. areas where removal of soil or installed equipment or installed components is not necessary to perform the repair). The extent (length) of the crack that will be
. injected with epoxy will be limited to crack widths of 10 mils or larger.
Diesel Generator Building (a) All accessible interior reinforced concrete walls.
(b) All accessible exterior concrete walls.
Control Tower & Electrical Penetration Areas (a) All accessible exterior concrete walls.
SWPS (a) All accessible exterior concrete walls.
Prior to the initiation of repair.s...all cracks.20 mils and largit_and. weeping cracks _in_the_ applicable areas will be identified. A verification of this identification to a tolerance of +5 mils will be performed. This verification and subsequent repair will be in accordance with the quality program. The material for structural epoxy adhesive will be "Concresive-1380" manufactured
' by Adhesive Engineering Company, or equivalent.
d JWC/WJC/mkh J
f oc0782-0193a100
w-
,----r
n..,
2.e.....,.....
a..
I er '.
7 3
?
2 CC Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board, w/o CBechhoefer,~ASLB, w/o MMCherry, Esq, w/o FPCowan,-ASLB, w/o RJCook, Midland Resident Inspector, w/o RSDecker, ASLB, w/o q
SGadler, w/o JHarbour, ASLB, w/o GHarstead, Harstead Engineering, w/o DSHood, NRC, w/o (2)
DFJudd, B&W, w/o i
- JDKane, NRC, w/o FJKelley, Esq,' w/o RBlandsman, NRC Region III, w/o WHMarshall, w/o JPMatra, Naval Surface Weapons Center, w/o W0tto, Army Corps of Engineers, w/o
. WDPaton, Esq, w/o SJPoulos, Geotechnical Engineers, w/o FRinaldi, NRC, w/o HSingh, Army Corps of Engineers, w/o/
BStamiris, w/o oc0782-0193a100
'O.e e
.m.
4
e....-
.~...,
c..,.....
o
[
4 BCC RCBauman, p-14-312B, w/o AJBoos, Bechtel, w/o JEBrunner, M-1079, w/o WJCloutier, P-24-611, w/o BDhar, Bechtel, w/o EMHughes, Bechtel, w/o RWHuston, Washington, w/o JKMeisenheimer, P-14-100, w/o JAMooney, P-14-115A, w/o DBMiller, Midland, w/o MIMiller, IL&B, w/o KBRazdan, P-14-419, w/o JARutgers, Bechtel, w/o/
JRSchaub, P-14-305, w/o PSteptoe, IL&B, w/o TJSullivan/DMBudzik, P-24-624A, w/o RLTeuteberg, P-24-505, w/o TRThiruvengadam, P-14-400, w/o DJVandeWalle, P-24-414, w/o FCWilliams, IL&B, w/o NRC Correspondence File DBMiller, Midland, Bechtel Bldg JAMooney, P-14-115A GBSlade, Midland DLSovers, P-13-407 DMTurnbull, Midland RAWells, P-14-113A oc0782-0193a100 m
ens e
awe
-me emme o ee m==e
=
,..,.. c u.,... ~..: :... _ ~ _.
..u.....
.a.
e
.s s
i CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY Midland Units 1 and 2 Docket No 50-329, 50-330 Letter Serial 18371 Dated August 2, 1982 At the request of the Commission and pursuant to the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, and the Energy Reorganization Act of 1974, as amended and the Commission's Rules and Regulations thereunder, Consumers Power Company submits additional information on Midland Concrete Wall Crack Repair Program.
CONSUMERS P0b R COMPANY By J
Cook, Vice President Projec, Engineering and Construction Sworn and subscribed before me this M day of August 1982 0.mL $ km gf Notary Piglic ceveny A. AV2rf Jackson County, Michigan My Cormission Expires @_./4 /f 8 f/
mi0782-0193b100
=...
.