ML20093N857
Text
) ( 0_ _
p %ug gw UNITED STATES O.
+
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
//A I
WASMNGTON,D C.20555 M
J lFwr CCT28 nez ano bckebNos i S0-329/330
/9 MEMORANDUM FOR: Elinor G. Adensam, Chief Licensing Branch #4, DL h
James P. Knight, Assistant Director THRU:
v
\\
for Components & Structures Engineering DE FROM:
s Franz P. Schauer, Chief Structural Engineering Branch, DE
SUBJECT:
MIDLAND ASLB HEARINGS.- STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING INPUT -
JUDGE PARBOUR'S CONCERNS Plant Name: Midland Plant Unit 1 and 2 Licensing Stage: OL Responsible Branch: LB #4, D. Hood and R. Hernan, LPM Requested Completion Date: October 28, 1982 Status: Complete In response to the verbal request of M. Wilcove of OELD, we have reviewed the transcript provided by OELD and have determined that the SEB area of concern
. identified by Judge Harbour applies only to consideration of structure-to-structure interaction.
The r: cent SSER No. 2 of October,1982, addresses Judge Harbour's concern for the postulated structure-to-structure interaction between the Turbine Building and the Control Tower and Electrical Penetration Wings of the Auxiliary Building and, also, between the Service Water Pump Structure and the Circulating Water Intake Structure. Section 3.7.2.4 (Structural-to-Structure Interaction) of SSER No. 2 discusses the potential for interaction between these buildings ard provides information on clearance provided between these respective buildings for critical dynamic conditions. The analysis of actual and required clearance values as discussed in this section indicate that there is no contact between these Gtructures, even considering Icading conditions that include the Safe Shutdown Earthquake (SSE).
/ W
'a
. Schauer, Chief Structural Engineering Branch Division of Engineering
'cc: See next page
Contact:
hok8hopge284071s F. Rinaldi, SEB, RICEB4-96 PDR X24921
W5sf2W'.M.M$i!FLgJ5?QW~~T %. 3.:. ;
IM D V4k)D TSTAMDIM7 G
l...
.#. -.a.a 7,,,g em l y,.-
..... s. r- -.
- m,.y p 1..
ce n.
. -~2.cp, y,
- c4 e
. e.,
c1 a}
c..
n.. -
..u n
Q
- 2.,.,7.r.m.. f. ; :,.
,,. 3, ' p. $..
aT,
gg -,4 h,
NI,.? a. 1 j h.f a
g
.+
- j f
'l 4
[.. <.
s 9 h'
... :. R k g h a,,.
t.d.,e A,,._
- a.,,.
... J.
s I-r o
R-t3 4.< J e. s T.
1 p.
@Js*3,:
j Tg O.
P.~ @- 3.
,. S cg
'w
,. g,;,s..,:
.c j M
w.
.. o. m.
gas.+
r-^
- .
- ;, n.,g. : n. :. :., m
.s.. sa v;y.
3
.- g. :w.
- g
.y 7.... ~..c.=
,.s n a x.. ~ :
- .y., y
.g 8
_r,
.. s fE Mu..
~
.2 gj[!y[....;y*]o.
f.Q.f.l]
- f.Q y
hY. l{ G,.' _{f.,
.. w.a
.;g i i
~.w.
.. <p,.
u-
.w........~.,....
s4
......v.
- .~..a.-g.
,. n.
w, st
.v
.u..
- n a.4 ~a'u
- .g..., e.r.~ 4 8 c. #b.MIr
.w n,.
c.
lbg.,,:
,.+
,. mW q M.W ;y;.
<c
- mM J
y.
$., ~ 5,' gi Q 4 s g. N g
. c.
- . 3-
~.
- 4..
p-m
[w.w'
&W. M MQ,N j'"
Ip I Ylvk. %&
E h-b
..:..W.$k:c;4.n yi
..2 7 :. Q.:.c. R... m.n.j p. % p
[p;s,.
X.., L.Q
}.l Q,' e
.. ;.Q $h a.
m y
~
O li
..+
.. *,. - w:?.ng, t
.s 4
a.t a o.
. c.
2 e
v.
g Q *
- '. l., ;
..g llg.
., f*...y.Li}_ _ ~2
+
p%
rs w-m m -
q =}i.of 6
- y..,.:a%n w
, CD.$y'l.i.?Fgisktq!K%q
,=
rf g;ggg gg p&g
,,, W=,p <.f,.
.g pg 25 k.
n *.,u' y.....,+t,:4.c.
e a
u....
r v
e
...u,.
e.
.c m s.
, ~..,.
J': o m.
- a si t
4
.& e e, ~.,,,. r,,.
. r -
.- a 1
a &..
~
- s
.,. " - sp.4 E
..h
' k yt" ay #ft,f gl
^
t-
- "g u
.s 2 ?'
i 4 k l
n A
y M}s h
6 1 A'e. w b'Q"* <;. iy av g
rm' '.
a
'g
.C
.2
?
4
.a e 9.
. ig7 5! )
< ' w.'I a
r.',*.n 3. :,M i.
,.4
.,C.,,, 3 -
u
.~;y J *. g 2:
Q4 $
,a,,,e.
..A.
n...
< s.
a t.
a.
6
.. s.e. a r
")-
.ht.,;*- (~ 3 '.,g $.A
,,,g..
.< c,,,
y
't-Q; g.- aq
_ Sp pky g-er f.,W,2.m(i.;%a l[..,o l s.
~
~
f.;.u c1.)
6 a ?[ g. E,,
4 r
o
.g j w,.-( -
+,g.'5 l
2 :%,
? y .r.s.
g
=
2 t.
.s a J u
E. g.s.e.,2 El
..J.ir *,. 4..t..t#. u -q.gh.J ws
+
pr-a39 r
Ji fig' >a b
b 2 xE:y-
[-
4 i i
.n
! g..
.,a 1.4;*
.y m
.t g %.fr.. _., 7. y.W <
i 33 ?@=J
. :n.
c
..t e-7-4 z
...aik z
=L u,..
.y.
2
.3...
,,a
~
c
.~9
. 4.
1
. g et-J p
- g. ;, -
3 9
-t 3
3 g
c
[A
^
4 i
se i
5 8. E } ll.]s Q,, 5f. ".; d... d' ~~;: '1 j
- T 4
s3
~2 l
$j} 2 5.
.a,e e.
h$ v
! -4 1 E
i n
Li !!! r ji '.rj
~ ~
.d g
,.u..u, se f
Ss M ! I I k eI p
,,, e I
t s
'4
..I
+,
s_: w L.t t
J-re y
n\\s\\s2
^
- h.:414 Suk+: in&J. be h -h%wkn 4 c
pchnent ssee* 2 Schons. To hSpnwd 14
..[
n 6,882. sesson on Mb.
6eehc.bnscal En3meen$ echon oM bduai S
L
~.
1 lu=se.t. ee.swrea Isoci%
t 25.4.4.2 2.s.4.g.).3.s.4.s.2 N6 %d
?
Sechns 2
besd Genendee b'hy y.2-4Q 3 2.s.4.5.4,2.s.4.s.5, 23.4.5.6,2.s4.6.3 ad 2.s.4-8.
4 t
\\
f s
.I
=V
- e p
[!
l l
k 1,
f l
lj.
i
! I*
P
}
. l 7 -.,..
1 1
- . t,
'~
- >. *.a. s.
_ _ _..... _.,_ e
_.a._....
j ~-
g4
.I Edoms 8A.
ugg g
,i d.to,e.
,..-s i
b n s % b % r 4.4 4
am %ypope ww **?
unc $4 :
s Gnbbn
% Be nd ard hhmS
. rewumm ssa.*z
~
- 4. A i)
%ho 2s.4.4.2,n8
% s. Nae h y6,e d.Kane>
h a s kM e <es M 1-a -.
m 9< m%k,ko, J.do<mipMtc.4st$m%)
essio w
4,h.2 ssez *2.
~
%3.Ned h egk,s L J.Kam,
pon 2.s.4.4.2 96.d,tkn.6)w.,,4 9.z-ssh2-n ba b a b d. % s j
4pd b tesA 4.%k i
s Q.as % & % %
366,J% se A
( % % M %.A 4.4.$)
ssta
- 2. '
%.u A bAok Atk -
J.h L
j Subns 2.s.4.1.dt-oq is d44 w,S grA W
ts.A.2($z-i0 '25.4.ssand sb9A4.,1 pybs
$240
.) %,. w h n \\ a u g A 1
any&on \\e.o k s u b s s d m 64
% sbc.Lo emiAns obs L. lease casa.s (Ed.hst orwa.is'st S4.ssQ
-,wa m ~ ~dn "% g *"w* a a s sa.s"5 M C 4""_. o@e u
@tP._%_$9d4P __fabi 3
~-
=%.-..a.
%._.1.,,,,_*
--l i
c.
l Eric,\\g 244 u\\ e k2 J.k'qne 5
cf. ~.
f Dhmsm. ConhnSoc. Mo.d. '(Corif.)
%s<e. Sh4 %We is %a weed feep u c. 5 Onkdmm on be % nd ora) bhm -
_rewewer l
4A.5) sseg M
.f Seder 1.5.AA.i(h.2-3d M. Sed kehasnSd-d.kowe.
ceip fm3 hky N k
kbr bme dwmded b proOm.
w& pgn,eh
(, M c. 4 M. h s s i o 6 )
s 1
i.
d..b,,
~
Ser.bn 9 '5.6.6 k.2-so)
@A. dB1 SEssied J.4,e and 1.S.b.t hj.2_g o9.
\\ssot om 6mc owhyg b sjdgyed h R.Gonales
,4C.agrq/* NNM *W Wa%.2$.E*^% %'*
)
ssa 2
9es.be. u a l
. MdM4 neulkc6 %..Jb O Dig F.Nkn d
i mk a
?A mm u.-, ara W
seb =pk y a -., - x.i,.. g n w nd b a ~ r @y 9
v
.hentdse f
6% wbp ed hs t
ReS c m E mi. b o d.14 a u k
o e.M%som e
3 e sM mdW Ashp(Mmd En weQff
.br os pm respnse-o Lc. b. An abcked i
3
~
.. ~a... :. :
-_....-_.___.a
1
]
y Ed.R 5a4 i
i-
!3 ii e.::
'l s hane L
-. ~
'f b m)(d br)enCC No-COnh-mms <-
tsu mes &
= s5
% s w der
_o a r ecat ww.e.,,
- sum, t
Ca, ni.m O.[
F4 d
p e
i l
\\4.b.2.)
combbapar,nEr,J.
kad<sspaa 13
%%k i
+oc a. 4, m m - o b,n a<mlabeann3 h e ho O sa m b pj hkN.lS'67.St& Sten abkeO j
W en Conhn b s i.
SSER El
'es.h is a W J.be Sdon2.S.4.d.'2.(g.2-%)
ha adda.u disc.ussiom ad Sdon 2,5.4A.3(f 2-34) o} h s b rev, e,
3 con.pnemk 4mrden, l
B and o ye reasorn li e sb@ psibn en b
40
.l
'2.b SSEE * '2
- d. h I' L
suf,on 2.s.4.5.5 $.2 423 %,matWgl l;
hrbskhoivimurartie
-3 d4 njutht.kon is %T I
L.
q yrohkernh b shelureswkJ,N.
~
%uea k d.
(.nov.is %s de &sio,,)
i z se 1
a
4 ws m hrieeew air-m
>a-b.
44 '
- )
Ewel k u\\ s e 2
,?
O.h <a
! w.....
Offth n R, i
COY 1
- NRC Sk
_ oAwlion
- @,ikkMe o<hnimVdk_T
'i C
miewe3 I
b.-
Set F. bib k ? Chn k M 4 Wl h ion) F. b tdi P.then 6
).
S4r 6hnb %.24 4 hs61) conbb S.2 AsWi 9.
ssea% %L 2s.4.4.<z brmAc.ond.cos S
I.
y 3
%ad WW
.i adbeuedorJ3
(_bc.w'st Sesri,d 3
,I I
3
' l
'4 4
f
$4 e
~
l4 l
I t,i
\\
.}
9-
-.:.yc.;. : --.... _.~..-... -.-
7
_