ML20091E335

Rev 0 to Davis-Besse Unit 1,Cycle 8 Core Operating Limits Rept

ML20091E335
Person / Time
Site:	Davis Besse
Issue date:	11/12/1991
From:	CENTERIOR ENERGY
To:
Shared Package
ML20091E333	List: ML20091E331 ML20091E335 ML20091E338
References
NUDOCS 9111190250
Download: ML20091E335 (22)

Text

Enclosure 1 COLR Page 1 of 22 Revision 0 TOLEDO EDISON COMPANY DAVIS-BESSE UiGT 1 CYCLE 8 CORE OPERATING LIMITS REPORT r

LIST OF EFFECTIVE PAGES-Page C-1 through C-22 Rev. O C-1 9111190250 911112 FDR ADOCK 05000346 P

PLR

=

~..

.- -- - -.. ~ -

COLR Page 2.of 22-Revision 0-Technical Specification /COLR Cross-Reference-technical Specification COLR Figure / Table 3.1.3.6 Figure la Regulating Group Position Limits, O to 200 110 EFPD,_Four RC Pumps 3.1. 3. 6 -

Figure Ib Regulating Group Position Limits, 200 110 to 400-110 EFPD, Four RC Pumps 3.1.3.6 Figure Ic Regulating Group Position Limits, after 400 110 EPPD,'Four RC Pumps 3.1.3.6 Figure 2a Regulating Group Position.

Limits, O to 200 110 EFPD, Three RC Pumps 3.1.3.6-Figure 2b Regulating Group Position Limits, 200 i10 to 400 110 EPPD, Three RC Pumps 3.1.3.6 Figure 2c Regulating Group Position Limits, after 400 210-EFPD, Three RC Pumps 3.1.3.7 Figure 3 Control Rod Core Locations.

and Group Assignments 3.1.3.9 Figure 4a APSR Positions Limits, O to 400 110 EFPD, Four RC Pumps

-3.1.3.9 Figure 4b APSR Positions Limits, After 400 110 EFPD, Three or Four-RC Pumps, APSRs Vithdrawn 3.1.3.9 Figure 4c APSR Positions Limits, O to 400 110 EFPD, Three RC Pumps C-2

COLR Page 3 of 22 Revision 0 3.2.1 Figure Sa AXIAL POVER IMBALANCE Limits, O to 200 110 EFPD, Four RC Pumps 3.2.1 Figure 5b AXIAL POVER IMBALANCE Limits, 200 110 to 400 10 "%'D, Four RC

Pumpt, 3.2.1 Figure Sc AXIAL POVER IMBALANCE Limits, after 400 110 EFPD, Four RC Pumps 3.2.1 Figure 6a AXIAL POVER IMBALANCE Limits, O to 200 i10 EFPD, Three RC Pumps 3.2.1 Figure 6b AXIAL POVER IMBALANCE Limits, 200 110 to 400 1

$ 0 EFPD, Three BC Pumps 3.2.1 Figure 6c AXIAL POVER IMBALANCE Limits, after 400 110 EFPD, Three RC Pumps 3.2.4 Table 1 QUADRANT POVER TILT Limits 3.1.1.3c Table 2 Negative Moderator Temperature Coefficient Limit i

e C-3

COLR Page 4 of 22 Revision 0-TOLEDO EDISON DAVIS-BESSE UNIT 1 CYCLE 8 CORE OPERATING LIttITS REPORT 1.0 Core Operating Limits This CORE OPERATING LIMITS REPORT for DB-1 Cycle 8 has been prepared in accordance with the requirements of Technical Specific; tion 6.9.1.7.

The core operating limits have been developed using the methodology provided in the references.

The following cycle-specific core operating limits are included in this report:

1) Regulating rod insertion limits

2) Rod program group positions

3) Axial power shaping rod insertion limits

4) AXIAL POVER IMBALANCE operating limita and

5) QUADRANT POVER TILT limits

6) Negative Moderator Temperature Coefficient limit 2.0 References 1). B&V Fuel Company Topical Report BAV-10122A Rev. 1, " Normal l

Operating Controls", May 1984

2) B&V Fuel Company, Topical Report BAV-10116A, " Assembly Calculations and Fitted Nuclear Data", May 1977

3) B&V Fuel Company, Topical Report BAV-10117P-A, " Babcock & Vilcox Version of PDQ User's Manual", January 1977

4) B&V Puel Company, Topical Report BAV-10118A, " Core Calculational Techniques and Procedures", December 1979.

5) B&V Fuel Company, Topical Report BAV-10124A, " FLAME 3 - A Three-Dimensional Nodal Code for Calculating Core Reactivity and Pover Distributions", August 1976 t

I C-4 i

COLR Page.5 of122 Revision 0

6) B&V Fuel Company,-Topical Report BAV-10125A, " Verification of the Three-Dimensional-FLAME Code", August 1976

7) B&V Fuel Company, Topical Report-BAV-10152A, "N00DLE'- A-Multi-Dimensional Two-Group Reactor Simulator", June 1985

8) B&V Fuel Company, Topical Report BAV-10119 P-A, "Pover Peaking Nuclear Reliability Factors", February 1979

9) Log Number 3139, dated January 11, 1990 (T. V. Vanbach (NRC) to D. C. Shelton (TE)).

(NRC SER for Rod Program)

10) Log Number 3441, dated April 10, 1991 (J. R. Hall, Sr. (NRC) to D. C. Shelton (TE)). (NRC's SER for Negative Moderator Temperature Coefficient Limit)

11) Log Number 3609, dated October 29, 1991, (J. B. Ilopkins (NRC) to D. C. Shelton (TE)).

(NRC's SER for change to Technical Specification 5.3.1) 4 T

A d

I' e

3 1

p C-5

COLR Page 5 of 22 Revision 0

6) B&V Fuel Company, Topical Report BAV-10125A, " Verification of the Three-Dimensional FLAME Code", August 1976

7) B&V Fuel Company, Topical Report BAV-10152A, " NOODLE - A Multi-Dimensional Two-Group Reactor Simulator", June 1985 8). B&V Fuel Company, Topical Report BAV-10119 P-A, "Pover Peaking Nuclear Reliability Factors", February 1979

9) Log Number 3139, dated January 11, 1990 (T. V. Vambach (NRC) to D. C. Shelton (TE)).

(NRC SER for Rod Program)

10) Log Number 3441, dated April 10, 1991 (J. R. Hall, Sr. (NRC) to D. C. Shelton (TE)). (NRC's SER for Negative Moderator Temperature Coefficient Limit)

11) Log Number 3609, dated October 29, 1991, (J. B. Hopkins (NRC) to D. C. Shelton (TE)).

(NRC's SER for change to Technical Specification 5.3.1)

C-5

COLR Page 6 of 22 Revision 0 Figure la Regulating Group Position Limits, O to 200110 EFPD, Four RC Pumps --

Davis-Besse 1, Cycle 8 This Figure is referred to by Technical Specification 1.3.6 (200,102)

(277,102)

(300,102)

?

^

POWER LEVEL 100 CUT 0FF=100%-

(266,92)

SHUTOOWN N

t (250,80) 80 E

OPERATION h

RESTRICTED 30.60)

>(250,60) 60 UNACCEPTABLE 4-OPERATION-Sea i 40-ACCEPTABLE u

OPERATION

[

u (98,28.5) h20 E

0'

't t

i i

I t

i i

t I

i 1

0 100 200 300 Rod Index (% Withdrawn)

GR 5 8 I

1 0

75 100 GR 6 8 I

I I

O 25 75 100 GR 7 i i

1 0

25 100 Note it A Rod Group overlap of 25+5% between sequential withdrawn groups 5 and 6, and 6 and 7 shall Se maintained.

I C-6 1

COLP, Page-7'of 22 Revision 0 Figure Ib Regulating Group Positico Limits, 200110 to 400 10 EFPD, Four RC Pumps --

Davis-Besse 1. Cycle 8 This Figure is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.3.6 (279,102)

(300,102) 100 POWER LEVEL

^

0 CUT 0FF=100%

SHUTOOWN UNACCEPTABLE MARGIN p

80 OPERATION LIMIT (250,80)

W2 N

60 (218,60)

[250,60)

?

/

o T

40 ACCEPTABLE y

0PERATION P

(178,28.5) bx2 20 (0.3)'

0 I

I i

I e

i i

f I

i s

'O 100 200 300 Rod Index (3 Withdrawn)

GR 5. I I

i 0

75 100 GR 6 i

f i

1 0

25 75 100 GR 7 a i

1 1

0 25 100 A Rod Group overlap of 25 5% between sequential withdrawn groups 5 Note 1:

1 and 6, and 6 and 7 shall be maintained.

1 C-7

CCLR Page 8 of 22 Revision 0 Figure 1c Regulating Group Position Limits, After 400110 EFPD, Four RC Pumps --

Davis-Besse 1, Cycle 8 This Figure is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.3,6 (273,102)

(300,102)

^

100' POWER-LEVEL CUT 0FF=100%

GN (250,80) 80 0 ER LIMIT m

?

_ $ 60 (218,60)

,(250,60) o OPERATION y

RESTRICTE0 m

E 40 E

ACCEPTABLE

]

OPERATION M78,28.5) m 20

~

(0,3) 0 I

I 8

I I

I I

I C

100 200 300 Rod index (% Withdrawn)

GR 5 '

t I

O 75 100 GR 6 i I

i 1

0 25 75 100 GR 7 8 8

8 0

25 100 Note 1:

A Rod Group overlap of 25 5% between sequential withdrawn groups 5 3

and 6, and 6 and 7 shall be maintained.

C-8

COLR-Page 9 of 22 Revision 0 J

- Figure 2a Regulating Group Position Limits, O to 200110 EFPD. Three RC Pumps --

Davis-Besse 1, Cycle 8 This Figure-is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.3.6 i

100 UNACCEPTABLE 4

OPERATION h

80 (200,77)

(277,77)

-(300,77)

SHUTDOWN g

MARGIN (266,69) g LIMIT

.=

.[

60 4

(250,60)-

y 4

OPERATION RfSTRICTED w

(130,45.5)

>(250,45)-

h 40 D

S.

u-

%o (98,21.9)

ACCEPTABLE 20 OPERATION (0,2.8) 0' I

8 I

l o

0 100 200 300 Rod-Index (% Witharawn)

GR 5 8

I I

0-75 100 GR 6 '

I I

I O

25 75 100 GR 7 e i

J 0

25 100 l

Note 1:

A Rod Group overlap of 25+5% between sequential withdrawn groups 5 and-6, and 6 and 7 shall Se maintained.

C-9 r-4

,(---+---ni-w-

m

-w y

3--~q

,y si yw-

COLR Page 10 of 22 Revision 0 Figure 2b Begulating Group Position Limits, 200110 to 400 10 EPPD, Three RC Pumps --

Davis-Besse 1, Cycic 8 This Figure is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.3.6 100 E go (279,77)

(300,77)

W

?

UNACCEPTABLE SHUTDOWN w

OPERATION MARGIN P 60 LIMIT (250,60)

S

2 a:

(218,45.5) r(250,45) 0 PERATION b

RESTRICTED S

bx 2 20 (178,21.9)

ACCEPTABLE OPERATION (0,2.8) 0 i

I i

l I

I I

I I

I I

I O

100 200 300 Rod Index (% Withdrawn)

GR 5 I

I i

0 75 100 GR 6 I

I I

l 0

25 75 100 GR 7 I

I J

0 25

' 'JO Note 1:

A Rod Group overlap of 25 5% between sequential withdrawn groups 5 1

and 6, and 6 and 7 shall be maintained.

C-10

COLR Page 11-of 2.2 Revision 0 Figure:2c Regulating Group. Position Limits, After 400+10 EFPD, Three RC Pumps --

t f

Davis-Besse 1 Cycle 8 i

This-Figure is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.3.6 100 r

UNACCEPTABLE OPERATION S 80-(273,77) _(300,77)

Rc.-

a bE.

SHUTDOWN

] 60 MARGIN (250,60) y LIMIT n

E..

(218,45.5)

,(250,45)

I 40 0

Y

-OPERATION RESTRICTED 5

k 20' (178,21.9)

-ACCEPTABLE OPERATION (0 2.8)'

.3 0

i e

1 i

t i

I I

i I

i

'l 0

100

- 200 300-Rod Index (% Withdrawn)

GR-5 I I

i 0

751 100 GR 6 I i

i 1

0 25 75 100 GR 7 l-t 1

0 25 100 s.

Note 1: A Rod Grcup overlap of 25+5% between sequential withdrawn groups 5 and 6, and 6 and 7 shall be maintained.

C-11

C01.R Page 12 of 22 Revision 0 Figure 3 Control Rod Core Locations and Group Assignments --

Davis-Besse 1, Cycle 8 l

j This Figure is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.3.7 X

N l

A B

4 6

4 C

2 5

5 2I D

7 8

7 8

7 E

2 5

5l 2

F 4

8 6

3 1 6 8

4 G

S 1

1 l

5 H

W-6 7

3 4

l3l 7

6

-Y K

5, 1

1l l

5 L

4 l 8

6l 3

l6 8

4 ft l2 5

l 5

2 N

l l

7 8

7 l8 7

l l

2 5

5l 2

0 P

l l

l 4

6 l4 I

i l

l a

i i

I Z

1 2

3 4

5 6

7 8

9 10 11 12 13 14 15 X

Group Number Group flo. of Rods, Function 1

4 Safety 2

8 Safety 3

4 Safety 4

9 Safety 5

12 Control 6

8 Control 7

8 Control 8

8 APSRs Total 61 C-12

COLR Page 13 of 22 Revision 0 Figure 4a APSR Positions Limits.

O to 400 10 EFPD, Four RC Pumps --

1 Davis-Besse 1, Cycle 8 This Figure is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.3.9 l

RESTRICTED REGION 100 T-(0,102)

(100,102) '

80 E

W F2 4

EE 60 PERMISSIBLE OPERATING REGION ad 5

%o 40 T

bS b

g 20 c.

0 i

i i

i i

i e

i e

i 0

10 20 30 40 50 60-70 80 90 100 APSR Position (% Withdrawn)

C-13 h.

COLR Page 14 of 22 Revision 0 Figure 4b APSR Positions Limits, After 400 10 EFPD, Three or Four RC Pumps, 1

APSRs Vithdrawn -- Davis-Besse 1, cycle 8 This Figure is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.3.9 100 S

80 E

c.

a f5 APSR INSERTION NOT ALLOWED 60 IN THIS TIME INTERVAL 8

E cr D

40 li b

a.

20 Ee 0

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 APSR Position (% Withdrawn)

C-14 j

C0' R l'an c 15 of 22 Revision 0 rigure 4e APSR Positions Limits.

0 to 400 10 1:rPD. Three RC rumps --

3 Davis-Besse 1. Cycle il This Figute is referted to by Technical Specifica', ton 3.1.3.9 100 80 RESTRICTED REGION s'

(0.77; (100,77) 2 a

E$3 60 S

E cr t

PERMISSIBLE 40 5

OPERATING REGION d

E E

a a

20 0

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 APSR Position (% Withdrawn) l C-15 t

COLR l' age 16 of 22 i

Revision 0 rigure Sa AXI AL POVER IMPALA!JCE Limits, O to 200 10 ErPD, four RC Pumps --

t Davis-Desse 1. Cycle 8 This rigat e in t elet ied to by Technical Specification 3.2.1 J

- 110

'. (14,102)

(-18,102) -

~ ~100

(-20.92)

(I '92 90

(-30,80):

- 80

,(18,80)

RESTRICTED RESTRICTED 70 REGION REGION cz Ysif 60 ai (18,60)

(-30,60) o a

h PERMISSIBLE W - - 50 OPERATING REGION S

g.-- 40 t

{--

30 t'

$. -- 20 t_

kg-10 i

i i

i i

i e

i i

i

-50 30

-20

-10 0

10 20 30 40 50 AXIAL POWER IMBALANCE (%)

I l

C-16 s

-- N

C0tJ(

Page 17 of 22 Revision 0 rigurc $b AXIAL POVER IMilALANCE Limits, 200110 to 400 10 EFPD, Pour RC Pumps --

Davis-llesse 1. Cycle 8 i

i This figure is referred to by Technical Specification 3.2.1 i

110

.g

(-20,102)

(14,102)

- WO

(-20,92) i iib'92) 90 f

(-30,80)t

- 80 i >(18,80) x T

RESTRICTED 6

RESTRICTED REGION

]- - 70 REGION i

(-30.60) t > PERMISSIBLEW--

60 o (18,60)

OPERATING e

REGION

$.. 50 i

w 4.-

j.

40 e

eg.

30 L-4

{-- 20 n.

10 t

i i

l l

I i

i i

i

-50

-40

-30

-20

-10 0

10 20-30 40 50 AXi AL POWER IMBALANCE (%)

C-17

_ - _ -, a

~.

. -.. -.... -, _ _,,..,.. _ _, _. - _ - _ -. - ~ _ _.. _. _ - _ _... _,. - -. - _ _. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - -

- - - - -. _ ~ -. _ -.... -. -.. -

COLR Page 18 of 22 Itevision 0 Figurc Sc AX1AL POVER IHBALANCE Limits, At ter 400 10 EPPD, four itC Pumps --

1 Davis-Besse 1, Cycle 8 This figure is teferred to by Technical Specification i

3.2.1 L

. 110

(-23.102) -

(20,102)

- 100

(-30,92) 1 o(20,92) 90

(-30,80) 6 80 O(20,80)

RESTRICTED PERMISSIBLE RESTRICTED REGION OPERATING g- - 70 REGION REGION 3- - 60 O(20,60)

(-30.60) O W

g- - 50 e

a:

g- - 40 T

8- - 30 bb g- - 20 8

n.

10 1

1 1

I t

f l

I i

-50

-40

-30

-20

-10 0

10 20 30 40 50 AXIAL POWER IMBALANCE (%)

{

~

j

COLR Page 19 of 22 Revision 0 Figure 6a AXIAL POWER IMBALANCE Limits.

0 to 200110 EFPD, Three RC Pumps --

Davis-Besse 1. Cycle 8 i

This Figure is referred to by Technia.tl Specification 3.2.1

-- 110 100

- - 90 80,(10.5,77)

(- 13. i.,77) v 70

(-15,69)

E-t (11.2,69) a.

(-22.5,60)i a-60

<p(13.5,60)

RESTRICTED l

RESTRICTED REGION W-REGION

- 50

(-22.5,45)q i 8

o(13.5,45)

-g- - 40 t

y- - 30 t'

_$?

$- - 20 ad

-se i

E o. a

n. -

10 t*

I i

l i

l I

i i

i 1

-50

-40

-30

-20

-10 0

10 20 30 40 50 AX1AL POWER IMBALANCE (%)

C-19 U

_ _ _ =--_ _ _ _- --

t COLR l

Page 20 of 22 Revision 0 Figure 6b AXIAL POVER IH13ALANCE Limits, l

i 200110 to 400t10 EFPD, Three RC Pumps --

Davis-Besse 1. Cycle 8 i

i This Figure is referred j

to by Technical Specification 3.2.1 t

1 i

110 I

- 100

.i 90 80

(-15,77)::

, (10.5,77) 0

(-15,69) 4,(11.2,69) 2

}

(-22.5,60)<

f-i(13.5,60)

- 60 i RESTRICTED RESTRICTED REGION 50 REGION if

(-22.5,45) < >

a>(13.5,45) aW- - 40 g

2 30 o--

sex g- - 20

$42 6

~5S

!ga y-u 10 e

t i

i i

i i

I i

J

-50 -30

-20

-10 0

10 20 30 40 50 AXIAL POWER IMBALANCE (%)

C-20

COLR Page 21 of ?2 l

Revision 0 t

P1gute 6c AXIAL POVF.R lt! BALANCE Limits, After 400110 EFPD, Thtee RC Pumps --

Davis-llesse 1, Cycle fl This figure is referred I

to by Technical Specification 3.2.1

- 110

.100 90 80 (15,77)

(-17.2,77) _

5

(-22.5,69)<

70 g(15.69) h

(-22.5,60) 4 >

g- - 60 o (15,60)

RESTRICTED RESTRICTED a

REGION E

REGION

$- - 50 0(15,45)

[

(-22.5.45)o 8- - 40 E

u E-30 Y

wdE 8

20 GCE ID-

$5G S

kWW a

- 10 to g-c.

t l

l 1

l t

I i

f i

1

-50

-40 -20

-10 0

10 20 30 40 50 l

AXIAL POWER IMBALANCE (%)

l:

1-c-21 I

b

COLR Page 22 of 22 i

Revision 0

, Tabic 1 OVADRANT POVER TILT Limits i

This Table is referred to by Technical Specification 3.2.4 t

Steady. state Steady-state Limit for Lim 3t for Quadrant Power Tilt Thermal Thermal Transient Maximum as measured by:

-Pover f 60%

Power > 60%

Limit Limit symmetrical incore 6.83 4.11 10.03 20.0 detector system-Pwer Range channels 4.05 1.96 6.96 20.0 Minimum incore detector 2.80*

1.90*

4.40*

20.0*

system

• Assumes detector strings with >60% depletion are excludeu from the minismin

'incore system configuration.

Table 2 Negative Moderator Terrperature Coefficient Limit This Table is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.1.3c Negative Moderator Temperature coefficient Limit

-3.73 x 10" 6k/k/*F (at-PATED THERMAL POWER)

-C-22