ML20091E335
ML20091E335 | |
Person / Time | |
---|---|
Site: | Davis Besse ![]() |
Issue date: | 11/12/1991 |
From: | CENTERIOR ENERGY |
To: | |
Shared Package | |
ML20091E333 | List: |
References | |
NUDOCS 9111190250 | |
Download: ML20091E335 (22) | |
Text
Enclosure 1 COLR Page 1 of 22 Revision 0 TOLEDO EDISON COMPANY DAVIS-BESSE UiGT 1 CYCLE 8 CORE OPERATING LIMITS REPORT r
LIST OF EFFECTIVE PAGES-Page C-1 through C-22 Rev. O C-1 9111190250 911112 FDR ADOCK 05000346 P PLR
. .- ~ . . .- -- - - . . ~ - . - - . . - _ . -
COLR Page 2.of 22- '
Revision 0-Technical Specification /COLR Cross-Reference-technical Specification COLR Figure / Table 3.1.3.6 Figure la Regulating Group Position ,
Limits, O to 200 110 EFPD,_Four RC Pumps 3.1. 3. 6 - Figure Ib Regulating Group Position Limits, 200 110 to 400-110 EFPD, Four RC Pumps 3.1.3.6 Figure Ic Regulating Group Position Limits, after 400 110 EPPD,'Four RC Pumps 3.1.3.6 Figure 2a Regulating Group Position.
Limits, O to 200 110 EFPD, Three RC Pumps 3.1.3.6- Figure 2b Regulating Group Position Limits, 200 i10 to 400 110 EPPD, Three RC Pumps 3.1.3.6 Figure 2c Regulating Group Position Limits, after 400 210-EFPD, Three RC Pumps 3.1.3.7 Figure 3 Control Rod Core Locations. ,
and Group Assignments 3.1.3.9 Figure 4a APSR Positions Limits, O to 400 110 EFPD, Four RC Pumps
-3.1.3.9 Figure 4b APSR Positions Limits, After 400 110 EFPD, Three or Four-RC Pumps, APSRs Vithdrawn 3.1.3.9 Figure 4c APSR Positions Limits, O to 400 110 EFPD, Three RC Pumps C-2
COLR Page 3 of 22 Revision 0 3.2.1 Figure Sa AXIAL POVER IMBALANCE Limits, O to 200 110 EFPD, Four RC Pumps 3.2.1 Figure 5b AXIAL POVER IMBALANCE Limits, 200 110 to 400 10 "%'D, Four RC Pumpt, 3.2.1 Figure Sc AXIAL POVER IMBALANCE Limits, after 400 110 EFPD, Four RC Pumps 3.2.1 Figure 6a AXIAL POVER IMBALANCE Limits, O to 200 i10 EFPD, Three RC Pumps 3.2.1 Figure 6b AXIAL POVER IMBALANCE Limits, 200 110 to 400
$10 EFPD, Three BC Pumps 3.2.1 Figure 6c AXIAL POVER IMBALANCE Limits, after 400 110 EFPD, Three RC Pumps 3.2.4 Table 1 QUADRANT POVER TILT Limits 3.1.1.3c Table 2 Negative Moderator Temperature Coefficient Limit i
e C-3
COLR Page 4 of 22 Revision 0-TOLEDO EDISON DAVIS-BESSE UNIT 1 CYCLE 8 CORE OPERATING LIttITS REPORT 1.0 Core Operating Limits This CORE OPERATING LIMITS REPORT for DB-1 Cycle 8 has been prepared in accordance with the requirements of Technical Specific; tion 6.9.1.7. The core operating limits have been developed using the methodology provided in the references.
The following cycle-specific core operating limits are included in this report:
- 1) Regulating rod insertion limits
- 2) Rod program group positions
- 3) Axial power shaping rod insertion limits
- 4) AXIAL POVER IMBALANCE operating limita and
- 5) QUADRANT POVER TILT limits
- 6) Negative Moderator Temperature Coefficient limit 2.0 References 1). B&V Fuel Company Topical Report BAV-10122A Rev. 1, " Normal l
Operating Controls", May 1984
- 2) B&V Fuel Company, Topical Report BAV-10116A, " Assembly Calculations and Fitted Nuclear Data", May 1977
- 3) B&V Fuel Company, Topical Report BAV-10117P-A, " Babcock & Vilcox Version of PDQ User's Manual", January 1977
- 4) B&V Puel Company, Topical Report BAV-10118A, " Core Calculational Techniques and Procedures", December 1979.
- 5) B&V Fuel Company, Topical Report BAV-10124A, " FLAME 3 - A Three-Dimensional Nodal Code for Calculating Core Reactivity and Pover Distributions", August 1976 t
I C-4 i
COLR Page.5 of122 Revision 0
- 6) B&V Fuel Company,-Topical Report BAV-10125A, " Verification of the Three-Dimensional-FLAME Code", August 1976
- 7) B&V Fuel Company, Topical Report-BAV-10152A, "N00DLE'- A-Multi-Dimensional Two-Group Reactor Simulator", June 1985
- 8) B&V Fuel Company, Topical Report BAV-10119 P-A, "Pover Peaking Nuclear Reliability Factors", February 1979
- 9) Log Number 3139, dated January 11, 1990 (T. V. Vanbach (NRC) to D. C. Shelton (TE)). (NRC SER for Rod Program)
- 10) Log Number 3441, dated April 10, 1991 (J. R. Hall, Sr. (NRC) to D. C. Shelton (TE)). (NRC's SER for Negative Moderator Temperature Coefficient Limit)
- 11) Log Number 3609, dated October 29, 1991, (J. B. Ilopkins (NRC) to D. C. Shelton (TE)). (NRC's SER for change to Technical Specification 5.3.1) 4 T
A d
I' e
3 1
p C-5
COLR Page 5 of 22 Revision 0
- 6) B&V Fuel Company, Topical Report BAV-10125A, " Verification of the Three-Dimensional FLAME Code", August 1976
- 7) B&V Fuel Company, Topical Report BAV-10152A, " NOODLE - A Multi-Dimensional Two-Group Reactor Simulator", June 1985 8). B&V Fuel Company, Topical Report BAV-10119 P-A, "Pover Peaking Nuclear Reliability Factors", February 1979
- 9) Log Number 3139, dated January 11, 1990 (T. V. Vambach (NRC) to D. C. Shelton (TE)). (NRC SER for Rod Program)
- 10) Log Number 3441, dated April 10, 1991 (J. R. Hall, Sr. (NRC) to D. C. Shelton (TE)). (NRC's SER for Negative Moderator Temperature Coefficient Limit)
- 11) Log Number 3609, dated October 29, 1991, (J. B. Hopkins (NRC) to D. C. Shelton (TE)). (NRC's SER for change to Technical Specification 5.3.1)
C-5
COLR Page 6 of 22 Revision 0 Figure la Regulating Group Position Limits, O to 200110 EFPD, Four RC Pumps --
Davis-Besse 1, Cycle 8 This Figure is referred to by Technical Specification 1.3.6 (200,102) (277,102) (300,102)
^
?
POWER LEVEL 100 -
CUT 0FF=100%-
(266,92)
SHUTOOWN 80 -
N t (250,80)
E OPERATION RESTRICTED h
30.60) >(250,60) 60 -
UNACCEPTABLE 4- OPERATION-S e
a i 40- -
ACCEPTABLE u
OPERATION
[u
-$ (98,28.5) h20 -
E
't i i i t I i 1 0' t i I t 0 100 200 300 Rod Index (% Withdrawn)
GR 5 8 I 1 0 75 100
' I I I GR 6 8 O 25 75 100 i 1 GR 7 i 0 25 100 -
Note it A Rod Group overlap of 25+5% between sequential withdrawn groups 5 and 6, and 6 and 7 shall Se maintained.
C-6 I 1
COLP, Page-7'of 22 Revision 0 Figure Ib Regulating Group Positico Limits, 200110 to 400 10 EFPD, Four RC Pumps --
Davis-Besse 1. Cycle 8 This Figure is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.3.6 (279,102) (300,102)
^
100 POWER LEVEL 0 CUT 0FF=100%
SHUTOOWN UNACCEPTABLE MARGIN p 80 OPERATION LIMIT (250,80)
W 2
N
$ 60 - (218,60) [250,60)
?
o T 40 -
/
$ ACCEPTABLE y 0PERATION P (178,28.5) b x
2 20 -
(0.3)'
0 I I i I ' s e i i f I i
'O 100 200 300 Rod Index (3 Withdrawn)
GR 5 . I I i 0 75 100 GR 6 i f i 1 0 25 75 100 -
l GR 7 a i 1 1
0 25 100 i
Note 1: A Rod Group overlap of 2515% between sequential withdrawn groups 5 ;
and 6, and 6 and 7 shall be maintained. .!
l l
1 C-7
CCLR Page 8 of 22 '
Revision 0 Figure 1c Regulating Group Position Limits, After 400110 EFPD, Four RC Pumps --
Davis-Besse 1, Cycle 8 This Figure is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.3,6 (273,102) (300,102)
^
100' POWER-LEVEL CUT 0FF=100%
" GN (250,80) 80 -
0 ER m LIMIT
?
_ $ 60 (218,60) ,(250,60) o OPERATION y RESTRICTE0 m
E 40 -
E ACCEPTABLE
] OPERATION
$- M78,28.5) m 20 ~
(0,3) 0 ' ' ' I I 8 I I I ' I I C 100 200 300 Rod index (% Withdrawn)
GR 5 ' t I O 75 100 GR 6 i I i 1 0 25 75 100 GR 7 8 8 8 0 25 100 Note 1: A Rod Group overlap of 25 35% between sequential withdrawn groups 5 and 6, and 6 and 7 shall be maintained.
C-8
COLR-Page 9 of 22 .,
Revision 0 J
- Figure 2a Regulating Group Position Limits, O to 200110 EFPD. Three RC Pumps --
Davis-Besse 1, Cycle 8 This Figure-is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.3.6 i
100 -
UNACCEPTABLE 4
, OPERATION h 80 -- (200,77) (277,77) -(300,77)
SHUTDOWN !
g MARGIN (266,69) g LIMIT
.=
.[y 60 -
4 (250,60)-
4
& OPERATION w RfSTRICTED (130,45.5) >(250,45)-
h 40 -
D S.
u-o 20 - (98,21.9) ACCEPTABLE OPERATION (0,2.8) 0' ' ' ' I 8 I ' l ' ' ' ' ,
o 0 100 200 300 Rod-Index (% Witharawn)
GR 5 8 I I 0- 75 100 GR 6 ' I I I O 25 75 100 GR 7 e i J 0 25 100 l Note 1: A Rod Group overlap of 25+5% between sequential withdrawn groups 5 and-6, and 6 and 7 shall Se maintained.
C-9 r- 4 ,(---+---ni- w- m ,- -w y 3--~q -
,y
- yw- -
COLR Page 10 of 22 Revision 0 Figure 2b Begulating Group Position Limits, 200110 to 400 10 EPPD, Three RC Pumps --
Davis-Besse 1, Cycic 8 This Figure is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.3.6 100 -
E go _ (279,77) (300,77)
W -
?
UNACCEPTABLE SHUTDOWN w OPERATION MARGIN P 60 -
LIMIT (250,60)
S
- 2 a:
% (218,45.5) r(250,45) 0 PERATION b RESTRICTED S
b x
2 20 - (178,21.9)
ACCEPTABLE OPERATION (0,2.8) 0 i I i l I I I I I I I I O 100 200 300 Rod Index (% Withdrawn)
GR 5 I I i 0 75 100 GR 6 I I I l 0 25 75 100 GR 7 I I J 0 25 ' 'JO Note 1: A Rod Group overlap of 25 15% between sequential withdrawn groups 5 and 6, and 6 and 7 shall be maintained.
C-10
COLR Page 11-of 2.2 Revision 0 Figure:2c Regulating Group. Position Limits, . ,
After 400+10 EFPD, Three RC Pumps -- t Davis-Besse 1 Cycle 8 f i
This-Figure is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.3.6 100 -
r UNACCEPTABLE OPERATION S 80- - (273,77) _(300,77)
Rc.-
a b
E. -
SHUTDOWN (250,60)
]y60 MARGIN LIMIT n
E ..
(218,45.5) ,(250,45)
I 40 -
0 Y*'
-OPERATION RESTRICTED 5
k (178,21.9) 20' -
-ACCEPTABLE OPERATION (0
.3 2.8)'
0 i e 1 i t i I I i I i 'l 0 100 . - 200 300-Rod Index (% Withdrawn)
GR-5 I I i 0 751 100 GR 6 I i i 1 0 25 75 100 GR 7 l- t 1 0 25 100 s.
Note 1: A Rod Grcup overlap of 25+5% between sequential withdrawn groups 5 and 6, and 6 and 7 shall be maintained.
C-11
! C01.R Page 12 of 22 Revision 0 Figure 3 Control Rod Core Locations and Group Assignments --
Davis-Besse 1, Cycle 8 l
j This Figure is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.3.7 X
.:', N l
A B 4 6 4 C 2 5 5 2I D 7 8 7 8 7 E 2 5 5l 2 F 4 8 6 3 1 6 8 4 l
G S 1 1 5 H W- 6 7 3 4 l3l 7 6
-Y K 5, 1 1l l 5 L 4l 8 6l 3 l6 8 4 ft ,
l2 5 l 5 2 N l l 7 8 7 l8 7 0 l l 2 <
5 5l 2 P l l l 4 6 l4 a I i l i i l I
Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 X Group Number Group flo. of Rods, Function 1 4 Safety 2 8 Safety 3 4 Safety 4 9 Safety 5 12 Control 6 8 Control 7 8 Control 8 8 APSRs Total 61 C-12
COLR Page 13 of 22 Revision 0 Figure 4a APSR Positions Limits.
O to 400 110 EFPD, Four RC Pumps --
Davis-Besse 1, Cycle 8 This Figure is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.3.9 l RESTRICTED REGION 100 T- (0,102) (100,102) '
80 -
E W
F2 4
EE 60 -
$! PERMISSIBLE a OPERATING REGION d
5 o 40 -
T b
S b
g 20 -
c.
l 0 i i i i i i e i e i l
0 10 20 30 40 50 60- 70 80 90 100 l APSR Position (% Withdrawn)
I l
C-13 h.
COLR Page 14 of 22 Revision 0 Figure 4b APSR Positions Limits, After 400110 EFPD, Three or Four RC Pumps, APSRs Vithdrawn -- Davis-Besse 1, cycle 8 This Figure is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.3.9 100 S 80 -
E c.
a f
5 60 -
APSR INSERTION NOT ALLOWED
- IN THIS TIME INTERVAL 8
E cr D 40 -
li b
a.
! 20 -
E e
0 ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' '
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 APSR Position (% Withdrawn)
C-14 j
C0' R l'an c 15 of 22 Revision 0 rigure 4e APSR Positions Limits.
0 to 400 310 1:rPD. Three RC rumps --
Davis-Besse 1. Cycle il This Figute is referted to by Technical Specifica', ton 3.1.3.9 100 -
80 - RESTRICTED REGION s' (0.77; (100,77) 2 a
E
$ 60 -
3 S
E cr t
" PERMISSIBLE 40 -
5 OPERATING REGION d
E E
a a -
20 0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 APSR Position (% Withdrawn) l C-15 t
COLR i l' age 16 of 22 Revision 0 rigure Sa AXI AL POVER IMPALA!JCE Limits, O to 200 t 10 ErPD, four RC Pumps --
Davis-Desse 1. Cycle 8 This rigat e in t elet ied to by Technical Specification 3.2.1 J
- 110
(-18,102) - --
'. (14,102)
~
~100
(-20.92) -- 90 (I '92
(-30,80): -
- 80 ,(18,80)
RESTRICTED - RESTRICTED REGION cz
-- 70 REGION Ys if
(-30,60) o a 60 a i (18,60) h PERMISSIBLE* W - - 50 OPERATING REGION S g .-- 40 t
30
{--
t'
$. -- 20 t_
k g- 10 i i i i i '
i e i i i
-50 30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 AXIAL POWER IMBALANCE (%)
I l
C-16 s
-- N
- C0tJ(
Page 17 of 22 Revision 0 rigurc $b AXIAL POVER IMilALANCE Limits, '
200110 to 400 10 EFPD, Pour RC Pumps -- !
Davis-llesse 1. Cycle 8 i
i This figure is referred to by Technical Specification 3.2.1 i
.g 110 ,
(-20,102) , , ;;(14,102)
- WO
(-20,92) > i iib'92)
. - 90 f
(-30,80)t - - 80 i >(18,80) x T
RESTRICTED 6 RESTRICTED REGION ]- - 70 REGION i
(-30.60) t o (18,60)
> PERMISSIBLEW--
60 .
OPERATING e :
REGION w
. 50 i 4.-
- j. 40 e
e
- g. 30 L- 4
{-- 20 n.
- - 10 t
i i l l I i i i i !
-50 -40 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20- 30 40 50 AXi AL POWER IMBALANCE (%)
C-17
~. . . - . . - . . . . - , _ _ , , . . , . . _ _ , _ . - _ - _ - . - ~ _ _ . . _ . _ - _ _ . . . _ , . - - . - _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - - _ - _ -, a
- - - - - . _ ~ - . _ - . . . . - . - . . - _ - -
COLR Page 18 of 22 Itevision 0 Figurc Sc AX1AL POVER IHBALANCE Limits, At ter 400 110 EPPD, four itC Pumps --
Davis-Besse 1, Cycle 8 This figure is teferred to by Technical Specification i 3.2.1 L
. 110 I
(-23.102) - (20,102)
- 100
(-30,92) 1 o(20,92)
- - 90
(-30,80) 6 - - 80 O(20,80)
RESTRICTED PERMISSIBLE $ - RESTRICTED REGION OPERATING g- 70 REGION REGION
(-30.60) O 3- - 60 O(20,60)
W g- - 50 e
a:
g- - 40 T
8- - 30 b
b g- - 20 8
n.
10 1 1 1 I t f l I i
-50 -40 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 AXIAL POWER IMBALANCE (%)
~
{ j
COLR Page 19 of 22 Revision 0 Figure 6a AXIAL POWER IMBALANCE Limits. l 0 to 200110 EFPD, Three RC Pumps --
Davis-Besse 1. Cycle 8 i
This Figure is referred to by Technia.tl Specification 3.2.1
-- 110
- 100
- - - 90
(- 13. i.,77) - -
80 ,(10.5,77) v
(-15,69) , E- -
70 t (11.2,69) a.
(-22.5,60)i a- -
60 < p(13.5,60)
RESTRICTED l RESTRICTED REGION W-
,- - 50 REGION
(-22.5,45)q i 8 o(13.5,45) g- - 40 t
y- - 30 t'
_$? $- - 20 ad
-se i
E o. a n. - - 10 t*
I i l i l I i i i 1
-50 -40 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 AX1AL POWER IMBALANCE (%)
C-19 U
_ . _ . _ _ . . __ .. _ _ ..__._.--.._. _ . _ _ _ =--_ _ _ _- -- _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ .
t COLR l Page 20 of 22 Revision 0 Figure 6b AXIAL POVER IH13ALANCE Limits, l 200110 to 400t10 EFPD, Three RC Pumps -- i Davis-Besse 1. Cycle 8 ;
i i
This Figure is referred j to by Technical Specification 3.2.1 ,
t 1
i I
- 110
- 100 .i
-- 90
-- 80
(-15,77):: ;, (10.5,77) ;
0
(-15,69) >
4 ,(11.2,69) 2
}
(-22.5,60)<
f- - 60 i i(13.5,60) -
RESTRICTED RESTRICTED .
REGION --
50 REGION
(-22.5,45) < > if a >(13.5,45) a W- - 40 g 2
o-- 30 sex g- - 20
$42 6
~5S u
!ga y- - 10 e
t i i i i i ! I i J
-50 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 AXIAL POWER IMBALANCE (%)
C-20
COLR Page 21 of ?2 l Revision 0 t P1gute 6c AXIAL POVF.R lt! BALANCE Limits, After 400110 EFPD, Thtee RC Pumps -- -
Davis-llesse 1, Cycle fl This figure is referred I to by Technical Specification 3.2.1 '
- 110
- .100
- - 90
(-17.2,77) _ . . 80 (15,77) 5
(-22.5,69)< - - 70 g(15.69)
(-22.5,60) h o (15,60) 4> g- - 60 RESTRICTED a RESTRICTED REGION E REGION
- 50 >
(-22.5.45)o
- 0(15,45) [
8- - 40 E
u E- 30 w Y dE 8 GCE ID-20
$5G S kWW a to g- - 10 ,
c.
t l l 1 l t I i f i 1
-50 -40 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 l AXIAL POWER IMBALANCE (%)
l:
1-
! c-21 I. .- .- --- -.
b
COLR ;
Page 22 of 22 i Revision 0
, Tabic 1 OVADRANT POVER TILT Limits i
. This Table is referred to by Technical Specification , 3.2.4 t
Steady. state Steady-state Limit for Lim 3t for '
Quadrant Power Tilt Thermal Thermal Transient Maximum as measured by: -Pover f 60% Power > 60% Limit Limit symmetrical incore 6.83 4.11 10.03 20.0 detector system-Pwer Range channels 4.05 1.96 6.96 20.0 Minimum incore detector 2.80* 1.90* 4.40* 20.0*
system
- Assumes detector strings with >60% depletion are excludeu from the minismin
'incore system configuration.
Table 2 Negative Moderator Terrperature Coefficient Limit This Table is referred to by Technical Specification 3.1.1.3c Negative Moderator Temperature coefficient Limit -3.73 x 10" 6k/k/*F (at- PATED THERMAL POWER)
-C-22