|
---|
Category:CONTRACTED REPORT - RTA
MONTHYEARML20148D6041997-03-31031 March 1997 Confirmatory Survey for Fsv Nuclear Station,Psc, Platteville,Co,Final Rept ML20148D5861997-03-26026 March 1997 Confirmatory Survey Plan for Group E Effluent Discharge Pathway Areas at Fsv Nuclear Station ML20134C8721997-01-29029 January 1997 Draft Confirmatory Survey for Fsv Nuclear Station Public Svc Co of Co,Platteville,Co ML20092G3681995-06-19019 June 1995 Confirmatory Survey for Repower Area Fsv Platteville,Co, Final Rept ML20084F3931995-05-16016 May 1995 Draft Rept, Confirmatory Survey for Repower Area Fsv Platteville,Co ML20245E6601989-01-0606 January 1989 Independent Review of Fire Protection Program Plan,Public Svc Co of Co,Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20245D1951988-10-31031 October 1988 Integrated Technical Evaluation Rept for Review of Fort St Vrain Tech Spec Upgrade Program ML20151B0031988-03-31031 March 1988 Technical Evaluation Rept for Plant Protective Sys Trip Setpoints for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20151S6061988-02-29029 February 1988 Rev 1 to Technical Evaluation Rept for Conformance to NRR Generic Ltrs 83-36 & 83-37 by Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20195G9611987-12-14014 December 1987 Technical Evaluation of Proposed Redundancy Requirements for Helium Circulation Tech Specs to Accommodate Rapid Depressurization Accident, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20234D6291987-12-14014 December 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St.Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Oct 1987 ML20236V3191987-10-31031 October 1987 Draft Plant Protective Sys Trip Setpoints for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20235R4161987-10-31031 October 1987 Draft Eg&G Technical Evaluation Rept for Plant Protective Sys Trip Setpoints for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20235V8871987-10-31031 October 1987 Draft Plant Protective Sys Trip Setpoints for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20236C2611987-09-28028 September 1987 Fort St Vrain Safe Shutdown Using Condensate Sys ML20236U7221987-08-0606 August 1987 Addendum to Review of Proposed Tech Spec Change:Core Inlet Valves/Min Helium Flow & Max Core Region Temp Rise, Limiting Conditon for Operation 4.1.9, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20246J3191987-07-31031 July 1987 Evaluation of Operator Roles in Mitigating High Energy Line Break at Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20235R6121987-07-0101 July 1987 Investigating Causes & Consequences of Cracked Graphite Fuel Elements ML20235M8321987-06-30030 June 1987 Conformance to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 2.2.1 - Equipment Classification for All Other Safety-Related Components:Fort St Vrain, Final Informal Rept ML20215A9031987-06-0505 June 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Apr 1987 ML20235G1141987-06-0404 June 1987 Draft Fort St Vrain Safe Shutdown from 82% Power, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20234C6091987-06-0404 June 1987 Fort St Vrain Safe Shutdown from 82% Power, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20215L9331987-05-31031 May 1987 Evaluation of Integrated Sys Study of CRD Mechanism Rod Position Indication Instrumentation for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Technical Evaluation Rept ML20214H2061987-05-15015 May 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Mar 1987 ML20215M3901987-04-30030 April 1987 Final Conformance to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 2.2.2 - Vendor Interface Programs for All Other Safety-Related Components: Fort St Vrain, Informal Rept ML20210A3851987-04-13013 April 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Progress Rept for Feb 1987 ML20214R8711987-03-31031 March 1987 Technical Evaluation Rept Evaluation of Bldg 10 Electrical Mods Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20214Q5411987-03-31031 March 1987 Evaluation of Confinement Environ Temp Following High Energy Line Breaks Proposed for Fort St Vrain Environ Qualification Program, Informal Technical Evaluation Rept ML20207T3721987-03-10010 March 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Jan 1987 ML20207R9471987-03-0606 March 1987 Rev 1 to Review of Fort St Vrain Onsite AC `Standby' Power Sys Re Compliance to Single Failure Criterion & Ser ML20212F6771987-02-13013 February 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Progress Rept for Dec 1986 ML20216J1991987-02-0404 February 1987 Evaluation of Long-Term Effects of Moisture Ingress in Fort St Vrain Nuclear Reactor ML20210P6451987-01-31031 January 1987 Draft Evaluation of Confinement Environ Temps Following High Energy Line Breaks Proposed for Fort St Vrain Environ Qualification Program, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20245B3401986-12-31031 December 1986 Technical Assistance for Fort St Vrain Task Ii:Pcrv & Pcrv Tendon Evaluation, Final Technical Evaluation Rept ML20207K4701986-12-31031 December 1986 Final Review of Convection Heat Transfer Coefficients Utilized in Fort St Vrain Main Steam Line Break Analysis, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20212B7321986-11-30030 November 1986 Evaluation of Proposed CRD & Orifice Assembly 300 F Temp Limits,Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20197C5981986-10-31031 October 1986 Review of Convection Heat Transfer Coefficients Utilized in Fort St Vrain Main Steam Line Break Analyses, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20213D8251986-10-31031 October 1986 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Progress Rept for Sept 1986 ML20214W4521986-10-16016 October 1986 Review of Proposed Tech Spec Change:Core Inlet Orifice Valves/Min Helium Flow & Max Core Region Temp Rise, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20214P4681986-09-30030 September 1986 Conformance to NRR Generic Ltrs 83-36 & 83-37 by Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20211A6091986-09-26026 September 1986 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Aug 1986 ML20236D3811986-09-24024 September 1986 Technical Evaluation of Dcrdr Info Supplementing Summary Rept for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20209F1021986-09-0505 September 1986 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr for Jul 1986 ML20212Q1011986-08-31031 August 1986 Conformance to Reg Guide 1.97,Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20213G5811986-08-0707 August 1986 Draft Review of Fort St Vrain Onsite AC 'Standby' Power Sys W/Regards to Compliance to Single Failure Criterion & Ser ML20205E3711986-07-31031 July 1986 Conformance to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 2.1 (Part 1), Equipment Classification (Reactor Trip Sys Components) Fort Calhoun,Millstone Unit 2,Nine Mile Point 2 & Fort St Vrain, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20244E1901986-07-31031 July 1986 Conformance to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 2.1 (Part 1) Equipment Classification (Reactor Trip Sys Components), Fort Calhoun,Millstone Unit 2,Nine Mile Point Unit 2 & Fort St Vrain ML20204E6811986-07-24024 July 1986 Technical Assistance to Region IV - Fort St Vrain, Monthly Business Ltr Repts for May & June 1986 ML20207J7931986-07-0909 July 1986 Fort St Vrain Fuel Element Dynamic Response ML20236D3741986-06-20020 June 1986 Technical Evaluation of Dcrdr Info Supplementing Summary Rept for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station 1997-03-31
[Table view] Category:QUICK LOOK
MONTHYEARML20148D6041997-03-31031 March 1997 Confirmatory Survey for Fsv Nuclear Station,Psc, Platteville,Co,Final Rept ML20148D5861997-03-26026 March 1997 Confirmatory Survey Plan for Group E Effluent Discharge Pathway Areas at Fsv Nuclear Station ML20134C8721997-01-29029 January 1997 Draft Confirmatory Survey for Fsv Nuclear Station Public Svc Co of Co,Platteville,Co ML20092G3681995-06-19019 June 1995 Confirmatory Survey for Repower Area Fsv Platteville,Co, Final Rept ML20084F3931995-05-16016 May 1995 Draft Rept, Confirmatory Survey for Repower Area Fsv Platteville,Co ML20245E6601989-01-0606 January 1989 Independent Review of Fire Protection Program Plan,Public Svc Co of Co,Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20245D1951988-10-31031 October 1988 Integrated Technical Evaluation Rept for Review of Fort St Vrain Tech Spec Upgrade Program ML20151B0031988-03-31031 March 1988 Technical Evaluation Rept for Plant Protective Sys Trip Setpoints for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20151S6061988-02-29029 February 1988 Rev 1 to Technical Evaluation Rept for Conformance to NRR Generic Ltrs 83-36 & 83-37 by Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20195G9611987-12-14014 December 1987 Technical Evaluation of Proposed Redundancy Requirements for Helium Circulation Tech Specs to Accommodate Rapid Depressurization Accident, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20234D6291987-12-14014 December 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St.Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Oct 1987 ML20236V3191987-10-31031 October 1987 Draft Plant Protective Sys Trip Setpoints for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20235R4161987-10-31031 October 1987 Draft Eg&G Technical Evaluation Rept for Plant Protective Sys Trip Setpoints for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20235V8871987-10-31031 October 1987 Draft Plant Protective Sys Trip Setpoints for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20236C2611987-09-28028 September 1987 Fort St Vrain Safe Shutdown Using Condensate Sys ML20236U7221987-08-0606 August 1987 Addendum to Review of Proposed Tech Spec Change:Core Inlet Valves/Min Helium Flow & Max Core Region Temp Rise, Limiting Conditon for Operation 4.1.9, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20246J3191987-07-31031 July 1987 Evaluation of Operator Roles in Mitigating High Energy Line Break at Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20235R6121987-07-0101 July 1987 Investigating Causes & Consequences of Cracked Graphite Fuel Elements ML20235M8321987-06-30030 June 1987 Conformance to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 2.2.1 - Equipment Classification for All Other Safety-Related Components:Fort St Vrain, Final Informal Rept ML20215A9031987-06-0505 June 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Apr 1987 ML20235G1141987-06-0404 June 1987 Draft Fort St Vrain Safe Shutdown from 82% Power, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20234C6091987-06-0404 June 1987 Fort St Vrain Safe Shutdown from 82% Power, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20215L9331987-05-31031 May 1987 Evaluation of Integrated Sys Study of CRD Mechanism Rod Position Indication Instrumentation for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Technical Evaluation Rept ML20214H2061987-05-15015 May 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Mar 1987 ML20215M3901987-04-30030 April 1987 Final Conformance to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 2.2.2 - Vendor Interface Programs for All Other Safety-Related Components: Fort St Vrain, Informal Rept ML20210A3851987-04-13013 April 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Progress Rept for Feb 1987 ML20214R8711987-03-31031 March 1987 Technical Evaluation Rept Evaluation of Bldg 10 Electrical Mods Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20214Q5411987-03-31031 March 1987 Evaluation of Confinement Environ Temp Following High Energy Line Breaks Proposed for Fort St Vrain Environ Qualification Program, Informal Technical Evaluation Rept ML20207T3721987-03-10010 March 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Jan 1987 ML20207R9471987-03-0606 March 1987 Rev 1 to Review of Fort St Vrain Onsite AC `Standby' Power Sys Re Compliance to Single Failure Criterion & Ser ML20212F6771987-02-13013 February 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Progress Rept for Dec 1986 ML20216J1991987-02-0404 February 1987 Evaluation of Long-Term Effects of Moisture Ingress in Fort St Vrain Nuclear Reactor ML20210P6451987-01-31031 January 1987 Draft Evaluation of Confinement Environ Temps Following High Energy Line Breaks Proposed for Fort St Vrain Environ Qualification Program, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20245B3401986-12-31031 December 1986 Technical Assistance for Fort St Vrain Task Ii:Pcrv & Pcrv Tendon Evaluation, Final Technical Evaluation Rept ML20207K4701986-12-31031 December 1986 Final Review of Convection Heat Transfer Coefficients Utilized in Fort St Vrain Main Steam Line Break Analysis, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20212B7321986-11-30030 November 1986 Evaluation of Proposed CRD & Orifice Assembly 300 F Temp Limits,Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20197C5981986-10-31031 October 1986 Review of Convection Heat Transfer Coefficients Utilized in Fort St Vrain Main Steam Line Break Analyses, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20213D8251986-10-31031 October 1986 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Progress Rept for Sept 1986 ML20214W4521986-10-16016 October 1986 Review of Proposed Tech Spec Change:Core Inlet Orifice Valves/Min Helium Flow & Max Core Region Temp Rise, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20214P4681986-09-30030 September 1986 Conformance to NRR Generic Ltrs 83-36 & 83-37 by Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20211A6091986-09-26026 September 1986 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Aug 1986 ML20236D3811986-09-24024 September 1986 Technical Evaluation of Dcrdr Info Supplementing Summary Rept for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20209F1021986-09-0505 September 1986 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr for Jul 1986 ML20212Q1011986-08-31031 August 1986 Conformance to Reg Guide 1.97,Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20213G5811986-08-0707 August 1986 Draft Review of Fort St Vrain Onsite AC 'Standby' Power Sys W/Regards to Compliance to Single Failure Criterion & Ser ML20205E3711986-07-31031 July 1986 Conformance to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 2.1 (Part 1), Equipment Classification (Reactor Trip Sys Components) Fort Calhoun,Millstone Unit 2,Nine Mile Point 2 & Fort St Vrain, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20244E1901986-07-31031 July 1986 Conformance to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 2.1 (Part 1) Equipment Classification (Reactor Trip Sys Components), Fort Calhoun,Millstone Unit 2,Nine Mile Point Unit 2 & Fort St Vrain ML20204E6811986-07-24024 July 1986 Technical Assistance to Region IV - Fort St Vrain, Monthly Business Ltr Repts for May & June 1986 ML20207J7931986-07-0909 July 1986 Fort St Vrain Fuel Element Dynamic Response ML20236D3741986-06-20020 June 1986 Technical Evaluation of Dcrdr Info Supplementing Summary Rept for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station 1997-03-31
[Table view] Category:ETC. (PERIODIC
MONTHYEARML20148D6041997-03-31031 March 1997 Confirmatory Survey for Fsv Nuclear Station,Psc, Platteville,Co,Final Rept ML20148D5861997-03-26026 March 1997 Confirmatory Survey Plan for Group E Effluent Discharge Pathway Areas at Fsv Nuclear Station ML20134C8721997-01-29029 January 1997 Draft Confirmatory Survey for Fsv Nuclear Station Public Svc Co of Co,Platteville,Co ML20092G3681995-06-19019 June 1995 Confirmatory Survey for Repower Area Fsv Platteville,Co, Final Rept ML20084F3931995-05-16016 May 1995 Draft Rept, Confirmatory Survey for Repower Area Fsv Platteville,Co ML20245E6601989-01-0606 January 1989 Independent Review of Fire Protection Program Plan,Public Svc Co of Co,Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20245D1951988-10-31031 October 1988 Integrated Technical Evaluation Rept for Review of Fort St Vrain Tech Spec Upgrade Program ML20151B0031988-03-31031 March 1988 Technical Evaluation Rept for Plant Protective Sys Trip Setpoints for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20151S6061988-02-29029 February 1988 Rev 1 to Technical Evaluation Rept for Conformance to NRR Generic Ltrs 83-36 & 83-37 by Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20195G9611987-12-14014 December 1987 Technical Evaluation of Proposed Redundancy Requirements for Helium Circulation Tech Specs to Accommodate Rapid Depressurization Accident, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20234D6291987-12-14014 December 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St.Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Oct 1987 ML20236V3191987-10-31031 October 1987 Draft Plant Protective Sys Trip Setpoints for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20235R4161987-10-31031 October 1987 Draft Eg&G Technical Evaluation Rept for Plant Protective Sys Trip Setpoints for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20235V8871987-10-31031 October 1987 Draft Plant Protective Sys Trip Setpoints for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20236C2611987-09-28028 September 1987 Fort St Vrain Safe Shutdown Using Condensate Sys ML20236U7221987-08-0606 August 1987 Addendum to Review of Proposed Tech Spec Change:Core Inlet Valves/Min Helium Flow & Max Core Region Temp Rise, Limiting Conditon for Operation 4.1.9, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20246J3191987-07-31031 July 1987 Evaluation of Operator Roles in Mitigating High Energy Line Break at Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20235R6121987-07-0101 July 1987 Investigating Causes & Consequences of Cracked Graphite Fuel Elements ML20235M8321987-06-30030 June 1987 Conformance to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 2.2.1 - Equipment Classification for All Other Safety-Related Components:Fort St Vrain, Final Informal Rept ML20215A9031987-06-0505 June 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Apr 1987 ML20235G1141987-06-0404 June 1987 Draft Fort St Vrain Safe Shutdown from 82% Power, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20234C6091987-06-0404 June 1987 Fort St Vrain Safe Shutdown from 82% Power, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20215L9331987-05-31031 May 1987 Evaluation of Integrated Sys Study of CRD Mechanism Rod Position Indication Instrumentation for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Technical Evaluation Rept ML20214H2061987-05-15015 May 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Mar 1987 ML20215M3901987-04-30030 April 1987 Final Conformance to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 2.2.2 - Vendor Interface Programs for All Other Safety-Related Components: Fort St Vrain, Informal Rept ML20210A3851987-04-13013 April 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Progress Rept for Feb 1987 ML20214R8711987-03-31031 March 1987 Technical Evaluation Rept Evaluation of Bldg 10 Electrical Mods Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20214Q5411987-03-31031 March 1987 Evaluation of Confinement Environ Temp Following High Energy Line Breaks Proposed for Fort St Vrain Environ Qualification Program, Informal Technical Evaluation Rept ML20207T3721987-03-10010 March 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Jan 1987 ML20207R9471987-03-0606 March 1987 Rev 1 to Review of Fort St Vrain Onsite AC `Standby' Power Sys Re Compliance to Single Failure Criterion & Ser ML20212F6771987-02-13013 February 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Progress Rept for Dec 1986 ML20216J1991987-02-0404 February 1987 Evaluation of Long-Term Effects of Moisture Ingress in Fort St Vrain Nuclear Reactor ML20210P6451987-01-31031 January 1987 Draft Evaluation of Confinement Environ Temps Following High Energy Line Breaks Proposed for Fort St Vrain Environ Qualification Program, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20245B3401986-12-31031 December 1986 Technical Assistance for Fort St Vrain Task Ii:Pcrv & Pcrv Tendon Evaluation, Final Technical Evaluation Rept ML20207K4701986-12-31031 December 1986 Final Review of Convection Heat Transfer Coefficients Utilized in Fort St Vrain Main Steam Line Break Analysis, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20212B7321986-11-30030 November 1986 Evaluation of Proposed CRD & Orifice Assembly 300 F Temp Limits,Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20197C5981986-10-31031 October 1986 Review of Convection Heat Transfer Coefficients Utilized in Fort St Vrain Main Steam Line Break Analyses, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20213D8251986-10-31031 October 1986 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Progress Rept for Sept 1986 ML20214W4521986-10-16016 October 1986 Review of Proposed Tech Spec Change:Core Inlet Orifice Valves/Min Helium Flow & Max Core Region Temp Rise, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20214P4681986-09-30030 September 1986 Conformance to NRR Generic Ltrs 83-36 & 83-37 by Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20211A6091986-09-26026 September 1986 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Aug 1986 ML20236D3811986-09-24024 September 1986 Technical Evaluation of Dcrdr Info Supplementing Summary Rept for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20209F1021986-09-0505 September 1986 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr for Jul 1986 ML20212Q1011986-08-31031 August 1986 Conformance to Reg Guide 1.97,Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20213G5811986-08-0707 August 1986 Draft Review of Fort St Vrain Onsite AC 'Standby' Power Sys W/Regards to Compliance to Single Failure Criterion & Ser ML20205E3711986-07-31031 July 1986 Conformance to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 2.1 (Part 1), Equipment Classification (Reactor Trip Sys Components) Fort Calhoun,Millstone Unit 2,Nine Mile Point 2 & Fort St Vrain, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20244E1901986-07-31031 July 1986 Conformance to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 2.1 (Part 1) Equipment Classification (Reactor Trip Sys Components), Fort Calhoun,Millstone Unit 2,Nine Mile Point Unit 2 & Fort St Vrain ML20204E6811986-07-24024 July 1986 Technical Assistance to Region IV - Fort St Vrain, Monthly Business Ltr Repts for May & June 1986 ML20207J7931986-07-0909 July 1986 Fort St Vrain Fuel Element Dynamic Response ML20236D3741986-06-20020 June 1986 Technical Evaluation of Dcrdr Info Supplementing Summary Rept for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station 1997-03-31
[Table view] Category:TEXT-PROCUREMENT & CONTRACTS
MONTHYEARML20148D6041997-03-31031 March 1997 Confirmatory Survey for Fsv Nuclear Station,Psc, Platteville,Co,Final Rept ML20148D5861997-03-26026 March 1997 Confirmatory Survey Plan for Group E Effluent Discharge Pathway Areas at Fsv Nuclear Station ML20134C8721997-01-29029 January 1997 Draft Confirmatory Survey for Fsv Nuclear Station Public Svc Co of Co,Platteville,Co ML20092G3681995-06-19019 June 1995 Confirmatory Survey for Repower Area Fsv Platteville,Co, Final Rept ML20084F3931995-05-16016 May 1995 Draft Rept, Confirmatory Survey for Repower Area Fsv Platteville,Co ML20245E6601989-01-0606 January 1989 Independent Review of Fire Protection Program Plan,Public Svc Co of Co,Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20245D1951988-10-31031 October 1988 Integrated Technical Evaluation Rept for Review of Fort St Vrain Tech Spec Upgrade Program ML20154S3461988-08-31031 August 1988 Notification of Contract Execution,Mod 3,to HTGR (Fort St Vrain) Training Course. Contractor:Ga Co ML20154S3511988-08-31031 August 1988 Mod 3,incorporating Change of Name Agreement from Ga Technologies to General Atomics,To HTGR (Fort St Vrain) Training Course ML20151B0031988-03-31031 March 1988 Technical Evaluation Rept for Plant Protective Sys Trip Setpoints for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20151S6061988-02-29029 February 1988 Rev 1 to Technical Evaluation Rept for Conformance to NRR Generic Ltrs 83-36 & 83-37 by Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20195G9611987-12-14014 December 1987 Technical Evaluation of Proposed Redundancy Requirements for Helium Circulation Tech Specs to Accommodate Rapid Depressurization Accident, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20234D6291987-12-14014 December 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St.Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Oct 1987 ML20235R4161987-10-31031 October 1987 Draft Eg&G Technical Evaluation Rept for Plant Protective Sys Trip Setpoints for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20235V8871987-10-31031 October 1987 Draft Plant Protective Sys Trip Setpoints for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20236V3191987-10-31031 October 1987 Draft Plant Protective Sys Trip Setpoints for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20236C2611987-09-28028 September 1987 Fort St Vrain Safe Shutdown Using Condensate Sys ML20236U7221987-08-0606 August 1987 Addendum to Review of Proposed Tech Spec Change:Core Inlet Valves/Min Helium Flow & Max Core Region Temp Rise, Limiting Conditon for Operation 4.1.9, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20246J3191987-07-31031 July 1987 Evaluation of Operator Roles in Mitigating High Energy Line Break at Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20235R6121987-07-0101 July 1987 Investigating Causes & Consequences of Cracked Graphite Fuel Elements ML20235M8321987-06-30030 June 1987 Conformance to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 2.2.1 - Equipment Classification for All Other Safety-Related Components:Fort St Vrain, Final Informal Rept ML20215A9031987-06-0505 June 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Apr 1987 ML20235G1141987-06-0404 June 1987 Draft Fort St Vrain Safe Shutdown from 82% Power, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20234C6091987-06-0404 June 1987 Fort St Vrain Safe Shutdown from 82% Power, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20215L9331987-05-31031 May 1987 Evaluation of Integrated Sys Study of CRD Mechanism Rod Position Indication Instrumentation for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Technical Evaluation Rept ML20214H2061987-05-15015 May 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Mar 1987 ML20215M3901987-04-30030 April 1987 Final Conformance to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 2.2.2 - Vendor Interface Programs for All Other Safety-Related Components: Fort St Vrain, Informal Rept ML20210A3851987-04-13013 April 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Progress Rept for Feb 1987 ML20206H7461987-04-0808 April 1987 Notification of Contract Execution,Mod 1,to HTGR (Fort St Vrain) Training Course. Contractor:Ga Technologies ML20206H7621987-04-0808 April 1987 Mod 1,reflecting Administrative Changes Due to NRC Reorganization,To HTGR (Fort St Vrain) Training Course ML20214R8711987-03-31031 March 1987 Technical Evaluation Rept Evaluation of Bldg 10 Electrical Mods Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20214Q5411987-03-31031 March 1987 Evaluation of Confinement Environ Temp Following High Energy Line Breaks Proposed for Fort St Vrain Environ Qualification Program, Informal Technical Evaluation Rept ML20207T3721987-03-10010 March 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Jan 1987 ML20207R9471987-03-0606 March 1987 Rev 1 to Review of Fort St Vrain Onsite AC `Standby' Power Sys Re Compliance to Single Failure Criterion & Ser ML20212F6771987-02-13013 February 1987 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Progress Rept for Dec 1986 ML20216J1991987-02-0404 February 1987 Evaluation of Long-Term Effects of Moisture Ingress in Fort St Vrain Nuclear Reactor ML20210P6451987-01-31031 January 1987 Draft Evaluation of Confinement Environ Temps Following High Energy Line Breaks Proposed for Fort St Vrain Environ Qualification Program, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20245B3401986-12-31031 December 1986 Technical Assistance for Fort St Vrain Task Ii:Pcrv & Pcrv Tendon Evaluation, Final Technical Evaluation Rept ML20207K4701986-12-31031 December 1986 Final Review of Convection Heat Transfer Coefficients Utilized in Fort St Vrain Main Steam Line Break Analysis, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20212B7321986-11-30030 November 1986 Evaluation of Proposed CRD & Orifice Assembly 300 F Temp Limits,Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20197C5981986-10-31031 October 1986 Review of Convection Heat Transfer Coefficients Utilized in Fort St Vrain Main Steam Line Break Analyses, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20213D8251986-10-31031 October 1986 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Progress Rept for Sept 1986 ML20214W4521986-10-16016 October 1986 Review of Proposed Tech Spec Change:Core Inlet Orifice Valves/Min Helium Flow & Max Core Region Temp Rise, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20214P4681986-09-30030 September 1986 Conformance to NRR Generic Ltrs 83-36 & 83-37 by Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20211A6091986-09-26026 September 1986 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr Rept for Aug 1986 ML20236D3811986-09-24024 September 1986 Technical Evaluation of Dcrdr Info Supplementing Summary Rept for Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station ML20209F1021986-09-0505 September 1986 Technical Assistance to Region IV (Fort St Vrain), Monthly Business Ltr for Jul 1986 ML20212Q1011986-08-31031 August 1986 Conformance to Reg Guide 1.97,Fort St Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Informal Rept ML20213G5811986-08-0707 August 1986 Draft Review of Fort St Vrain Onsite AC 'Standby' Power Sys W/Regards to Compliance to Single Failure Criterion & Ser ML20205E3711986-07-31031 July 1986 Conformance to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 2.1 (Part 1), Equipment Classification (Reactor Trip Sys Components) Fort Calhoun,Millstone Unit 2,Nine Mile Point 2 & Fort St Vrain, Technical Evaluation Rept 1997-03-31
[Table view] |
Text
_. . - - _ _ _ . - - _ _ _ . - - - , _ _ _ . . - _ - - - - . _ _ - - - _ _ . _ _ - - _
l UCID 20038 !
f I
l 8 l.
4
. TECilNICAL EVALUATION REPORT ON Tl!E NEUTRON DETECTOR DECALIllRATION AT Tl!E FORT ST. VRAIN NUCLEAR CENERATING STATION {
(Docket No. 50-267)
James C. Selan
!! arch 21, ,1984 0
7 Y
l Ihis la en info mal tepost latended relmasdy fue laternal ne lim 6ted esternal datethuskin, g,,
lhe opinkine and tuntludans seeted see ihnee of the authos and may of may emt be those l g oftheIatmeatney.
1his wosh wse suppoeted by the United hesten Nucleas llegulatney Comm6 eken un.in a Memosendum of Underatending 36th the United States llerestment of I nessy.
I N
[\
gqvst(00
l ABSTRACT This report documents the technical evaluation on the decalibration of the neutron detectors at the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating St ation. The evaluation is to determine that thn added circuitry for generating a floating trip setpoint as a function of indicated power meets NRC design criteria and has no adverse ef fects on the plant protection system.
The evaluation finds that the floating trip setpoint circuitry meets the design criteria specified in the plant's FSAR and will produce a reactor trip (as a function of indicated power) before the true power limit value in the Technical Specifications is exceeded.
FOREWORD This report is supplied as part of the Selected Operating Reactor Issues Program 11 being conducted for the U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Office of Nucicar Reactor Regulation, Division of Licensing, by Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory.
l The U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission funded the work under the authorization entitled " Selected Operating Reactor Issues Program II,"
B&R 20 19 10 11 1, FIN No. A-0250.
h j
TABLE OF CONTENTS P,,,a gg, 8
INTRODUCTION . 1
- 1. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
a 2
- 2. DESIGN REVIEW CRITERIA . . . . . . . . . . . .
DESIGN DESCRIPTION 3
- 3. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
4 EVALUATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 4.1 Circuitry Design Changes . . . . . . . . . . 9 4.2 Calibration Requirements . . . . . . . . . . 11 4.3 Technical Specifications and Test Provisions . . . . . 12
- 5. CONCLUSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 REFERENCES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 TABLE OF ILLUSTRATIONS Figure 1. PPS floating trip circuit . . . . . . . . . . 4 Figure 2. Heat balance calibration . . . . . . . . . . 5 Figure 3. PPS floating trip point circuitry for Fort St. Vrain Unit 1 . 6 Figure 4 Nuclear channel test setup, bloc't diagram . . . . . . 7 Figure 5. PPS channel configuration . . . . . . . . . . 8 Figure 6. Dual Linear Channel Drawer. . . . . . . . . . 10
-111-t
I e;
- I TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT ON THE NEUTRON DETECTOR DECALIBRATION AT THE FORT ST. VRAIN NUCLEAR CENERATING STATION (Docket No. 50-267) l James C. Selan
- Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Nevada 0
- 1. INTRODUCTION The excore neutron detectors at the Fort St. Vrain (FSV) Nuclear Generating Station are located in the prestressed concrete reactor vessel adjacent to the core. The instrumentation inputs from these neutron flux detectors are used in reactor' control and the plant's protection system (PPS).
The excore neutron detectors,12 in number, are located in 6 wells
- at 60' intervals around the core cavity. The function of these twelve detectors (power range)'are as follows:
(1) .Six detectors are used in the PPS. The signals from these six are combined into three channels by two 180' opposing detectors.
The range.of these detectors is from 1.5% to 150%.of full power.
These three channels provide a trip signal in a 2 of-3 channel logic at J40% of full power.
(2) Six detectors are used in reactor control. They also have a range f rom 1.5% to 150% of full power. The signals from these detectors (flux controller) are used to regulate the position of the control rod pair and runback rods to control the power level in the core. The flux recorder, flux integrator (megawatt-hour meter), and power / flow module also receive input from the flux controller.
i The netitron flux level as measured by the power range detectors is
, ef fected by the motion of the control rods. This motion can alter the radial core power distribution so that the flux levels measured are not directly proportional to the 'true core thermal power level thus indicating "decalibration" )
. . , of the detectors.
Analyses have shown that motion of the rod banks near the center of the core causes the detectors to underpredict true power changes while rod banks near the outside cause overprediction of true power changes [Refs. I and 2].
The effects of this decalibration and resulting over/under predictions of true power could cause spurious trip signals or cause design limits to be exceeded before a protective trip occurs.
The rod withdrawal prohibits (RWPs) are also af fected by detector decalibration. These RWPs are activated at 120% reactor power and at a power level that is not within the range as permitted by one of the three positions of the interlock sequence switch (ISS).
The ef fects of rod motion on decalibration of the detectors was analyzed by General Atomic Company (GAC). CAC recommended a circuit design change be implemented to provide for a " floating trip setpoint" to l eliminate the decalibration problems due to rod motion. By letters dated January 11,1979 [Ref.1], November 29, 1979 [Ref. 2], May 16, 1983 [Ref. 3],
and November 30,1983 [Ref. 4], Public Service Company of Colorado, the licensee, submitted General Atomic Company's analysis and design reports and plant technical information on the proposed design change for a floating trip ;
setpoint circuit at the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Cenerating Station. !
t The purpose of this report is to evaluate the design modification of a floating trip setpoint circuit to determine that it meets NRC design criteria and will not adversely af fect the operation of the PPS. The eval-uation only included the instrumentation and control modification and did not cover reactor physics or core performance. !
- 2. DESICN REVIEW CRITERIA The review criteria that were applied in determining the accept-ability of the floating trip setpoint circuitry in the PPS are listed below.
The existing reactor trip system design is based on this criteria.
(1) "AEC Ceneral Design Criteria for Nuclear Power Plant Construc- I tion Permits," 1967 edition [Ref. 5].
Criterion 7: Suppression of Power Oscillations Criterion 12: Instrumentation and Control Systems
. Criterion 15: Engineered Safety Features Protection Systems :
Criterion 19: Protection Systems Reliability '
Criterion 20: Protection Systems Redundancy and Independence Criterion 21: Single Failure Definition Criterion 22: Separation of Protection and Control Instrumen-tation Systems criterion 23: Protection Against Multiple Disability for Protection Systems Criterion 24: Emergency Power for Protection Systems Criterion 25: Demonstration of Functional Operability of Protection System Criterion 26: Protection Systems Fail-Safe Design Criterion 39: Emergency Power for Engineered Safety Features (2) IEEE Standard: " Criteria for Protection Systens for Nuclear Power Cenerating Stations," IEEE 279-1968 [Ref. 6].
_____________-_____m. _ _ _ - _ _
. l
- 3. DESIGN DESCRIPTION The floating trip setpoint circuit (FTSC) design is shown in Figures 1 through 5 These figures are taken f rom the General Atomic Company Report
[Ref. 1].
~
The basic function of the FTSC is to produce a floating trip setpoint that will vary at a constant offset above indicated power which will always produce a trip signal before the reactor reaches the 140% true power value specified in the Technical Specifications. Figure 1 shows the basic electronic components which make up the floating trip setpoint circuitry (indicated by the dashed lines). The theory of operation can best be described using Figure 3.
An indicated power signal derived f rom the power range detectors (0-150%) is fed to a dif ferentiator, sample and hold (S/II) circuit, and to the two bistable trips (reactor and rod withdrawal prohibit).
The dif ferentiator outputs a signal (volta) which is proportional to the rate of change of the indicated power. This output is fed to a bistable trip where it is compared to a pre selected rate of power change. If the com-parator goes low, the S/ll circuit will continue to sample the indicated power i input. Should the comparator go high, the S/II will hold its last input signal before the S/l! goes high and feeds this value to e summer. At the summer, the input value from the S/II is added to the pre-selected trip of fset value. If the sum exceeds an adjustable high setpoint (100-140%), the output holds at the high limit. If the sum is less than the adjustable low setpoint (60-140%)
than the output holds at the lower limit. The output value then goes to the reactor trip histable and to the RWP summer. At the reactor trip bistable (programnsbic) if the indicated reactor power is greater than the trip setpoint ,
(f rom the summer), a reactor trip signal is produced. l l
At the RWP summer, the high or low setpoint output is added with the pre selected RWP offset setpoint. The output is then f ed to the RWP l programmable histable. If the comparator goes high, an RWP trip is produced. ;
1 In addition to the FTSC, a circuit is added for heat balance cor-rection as shown in Figure 2. The irdicated true power as calculated f rom the heat balance equations in the data logger will be indicated on an added me te r. The circuit will correct for non-PPS readouts, megawatt-hour meter, power and flow mnasurements, and the flux-recorder. It should be noted that this circuit receiven an input f rom the data logger and is not connected with o the FTSC nor part of the PPS. This circuit was not reviewed since it is inde-pendent of the change for the floating trip setpoint circuit used in the PPS.
e Figure 4 shows the test actup to calibrate cach nuclear channel.
A nuclear channel consists of a detector and one half of a dual linear drawer as shown in Figure 5. Figure 5 shows one channel of the three PPS channols where a coincident logic of two out-of-three is required to produce a trip.
3 e
e p .__
lc:s l
E 5 E E I!!
I as,(
- s. BE g lasd l 6 e
EEM E g
l l $ 5 luse EEE ci I
= 5 hk 7 l
E 8 Ia *a E 3
E 3
I l
as 8
d l d a a E l 1 7 s =
l E, a 8 1 O
- i. 7, g W I -
Ie (*@
W O I *WE2 E W ; 4 "J };
I l
x2 E d. s !N l l l 5@.1 u e
l S. l a l,}
I $3
-- ge ! W =
~
l m3" 5 + " - g- m 3
I E5 0 NE $"
l s de s =5 5 E E ", 3 l . a = =E 4 l
gm ,
I a$ 3 00 !
IE l S! E e : -o : p e l !! .
i l
ai t-l
,L "
_J s=f, ..
aEd W
l l
l l
- u. - - . - - .
t i
E -!
ya gE
. hh"! a yEx o'32 l
EEE a F- 1
~
E E E E a =8c 2 R ;9 a
l
,=g3 85 8 $",E W""
- w N : :: ( ,
$kk b l 5 g 1 i o w" n g .
i EElH5 ,
___ _ .. _. I l gal 55 g ]
3 nleft t .
Ek t 5W j
. a g gl
~
e d
i s e ena ase ong q
$.E d8s
$b MQ=O "
gj !
f *O b
i::
i' t a Be
, Ukb<5 bk l g %r,n ;
sseu '
L_ _ _ _ _
l 5
I e e t
\O dh ~8 '
" Y
. lbl w :.: ft
\&
y 3
p '
{mr Vi vs 4.i.-
I _ .
s .h
~ .
H M g it M
+g t s "se.hst J~ ';,
q s il E
=
g s' t-n 1,4 a}i s r
Ti r
g
\o,\,. t.
e E h
g a g }* d1*gfa, t< -
Ns -
2 ik g c
,\
gv - 11 L
\
\
dh
.e \
8 9
) ,
d r__$_______________q l 1
- l l j h -
i Il l., l,
,1 i h , , i -
l t
l i
i:
i -
I I I l
i 'f.
I = I 4 I, .
i
- R. ,I <
a 1
l NI I h.
- I B i .
- p '
Iidd j B l .,
""" c B I l &
N C I l I
I i L.__ __ ,.___________ a o _
g n
2d l
l
r - --- T - - 7 l1 lI I
l 1f s l __t_
[f- i l
l{TH*l,h~m r p- I e!!
ia n_- I an u l F r tj w ni
, t
,jg
' : I
".i rf f Io o I o o l i
u f l I
1 n L _. _ _ n ._ _.._i _' "_" W R.
4i i
- 1
[f
- h. A
. _ ~1 f 3 h -
I
) $ $
n : ;
R n
- : n I I qh 4 au
'o I~ QI} IN ,fik}
l l
r o o r- 5 g ;
l
~~) '
- "I l l aY l .
83 f"33' l E N l'"
W 8
I 94 hil n l 1 [._ "l h I cle ela ll k*
o*****
I Ll X ..) LXJ 2.l l l B g Bu<hw I ,_ _
gl l [ ( l
, x v i L. _. ._, ._ . ._. _. J v v v
.n.
r
- a:: = '
- 4. EVALUATION This section presents an evaluation on various aspects of the pro-posed neutron detector decalibration.
La 4.1 Circuitry Design Changes The Fort St. Vrain plant protective system design is based on the
'3
-1967 edition of the NRC General Design Criteria [Ref. 5) and IEEE 279-1968
[Ref. 6] as stated in the plant's Final Safety Analysis Report.
-The addition of the FTSC to the PPS involves replacing the entire dual linear power range channel drawer and modules with the drawer shown in Figure 6. All the required modules (not shown) for the FTSC are located within the drawer. There are no external modifications to the drawer / modules required.-
A review of. drawings, schematics, and drawer specifications sub-mitted- (e.g. dual linear power channel schematic and assembly, floating trip
- setpoint schematic, bistable trip circuits, period rate circuits, linear
. amplifier schematic,- and operation manual) [Ref. 3] finds that the FTSC does not alter any of the original system design criteria. This includes the criteria of redundancy, overall logic, failure modes, field wiring, arrange-ment, independence, testability, reliability, or physical separation of the reactor trip circuits [Ref. 4].
. A failure modes and effects analysis (FMEA) was performed by General Atomic Company [Ref.1]. The FMBA analyzed each component of' the FTSC with res pe ct to the " Failure Mode," " Channel Ef fect," and " System Effects." The results of their analysis -demonstrated that no single f ailure of any portion of the FTSC will prevent the PPS from initiating or completing a reactor trip or rod withdrawal prohibit. The addition of the FTSC does not change the failure modes of the original system.' The change does add one additional failure mode. This is the f ailu're of a channel to detect a high rate of flux increase. This failure mode will not prevent PPS action since the original system was not rate dependent and the upper trip. limit (existing system) is still active to activate a, trip.
A review of,the FMEA f[nds that most of the component f ailures n .(e.g. - shorts, opens, or' high output) either causes no detection of high flux rates or cadses the trip point not to. float (may.either go high, low, or zero) at the channel level. These failure modes at the system level
- result either in a spurious 1 channel--RWP and- trip or in loss of channel RWP detection with a trip still detectable with the remaining 2 PPS channels.
Therefore, component failures within'the FTSC will neither prohibit nor adversely affect the PPS from initiating [its protective function since the trip limits of the original system _are still effective. ,
4 . ~* g 9 4 0 ~
y
.. e r .%
?
i r
f
' '~ f ^ g *"y W-' O o** ' m.ngr y % Mw
-- -~
,,jy W. . .
g ;.2 ..
~.agg % ;
,s . . cg- -
.- - + +
~
- . a -.-.- - . - . - ;
= m . --
g 50 me . 50 foo , -
, g -
_ _ - ~ __ _
. = s, 2 i ,.
' el- J'
^
~
mest no / -
ed a mcod Isa !
1 rown - powen
- * * . _ . - , - . ,_ a a tl ,
I L t .- :
i
.'l.
ggv ya ~'
. .L + nauma gm _] ~W
- 3. '
) T7 - , c. -2 2 '~
l^ ' *
, ',w'- ". . , 'y .
3,. e _.M Q._ ( n .. _
m i;
s,}. - ;
9I
%".-". Fase use : *=s e L mer :sse au-i == w I, !
p =ma. -
La. a s ==:ase 40 a. c r-* e- gy* o ?: ; j
- r --
_ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _m m . ,,.a ,- m , gm. 38 , , .-c ] }
4J,*1,4, :'j-@.. %+o%M%9;m-new. .W
- ~r.,, ,.,:. .d. ,;-r,,_3;...
- w. w:.,_.: .a;.:c;C-9fr,W +
aww s, -pe. Q.L .
l i
FRONT VIEW .,
t t
grsea..ese; .ee-a .* -=- g l- '
my _
7.-
. ., >a?;&gy,.y.,ey
- .y ,+;_
w.
l
-' 2 , . M. --
,y ,
t
- .. ~. - . .. ~c:mnane.m > .- . . -
- p . ~..ne
- 7 n =.
-..-..u.-nu l
t 1 f, _M
~ O= ' $+. [..b.,.~?, --k ce .
$ .$ $-gy.. $J gs %,@.
- m?$ W+
k g :.~s
! M T N kN -)
b .
Nh '
-- ..=. .d~ G?s,x&fi.WGFtM::&,=
% .pw .y-:. : icy M idi n Nj * , '+;, - ".6&
!<3D - ~~
ja. ,e - (.u., .a . n r. ....a w .sw = . . .. .
~:,..: m . .1 .w +
[,W c'Q Q.S ' y " W A; -~ xQ %f$hR'hlp,.
g.i'F g 1.
. .;- . ..yk.'ghh x..::y,f5h,,~ l r .e 44 rp:-wa.y< peg g g,i q .%, g' --py. qq 4.h
- g
.rq4 y .K& . - -- - -- -
- c-- - a -
- ~.[,-kh[~-)E{EM M bye [dh~.c-~.:h$NWM[h,.- 8
-7gle*; . ~ T.j
_. l
~-
i 1 .c n . & ,. v.t--_-- --
i I
i
!- REAR VIEW r
i Figure 6. Dual Linear Channel Drawer l i
... .-.__-.o_.. _ _ . - - e
A review of the dual linear drawer schematic finds that the circuit boards and switches are interlocked to provide automatic channel tripping if their performing function is prohibited. The interlock path is accomplished by the +15 Vdc supply where interruption causes the bistable trips and trip relays to de energize to their tripped condition. For loss of bus voltage or sensor, channel trip is also automatically initiated.
>O 4.2 Calibration Requirements General Atomic Company recommends the following calibration require-ments [Refs. I and 2]: ..
(1) At least one calibration is required during every 24-hr period when operating in low power or power modes.
(2) To prevent or clear RWPs which occur due to inaccurate detector readings, a calibration should be done whenever any channel approaches or reaches an RWP setpoint.
(3) To ensure that the interlock sequence switch (ISS) is switched at the proper power level, the following requirements are made:
- a. With the ISS in the startup mode, a calibration is required when heat-balance power is between 2% and 4% of rated power.
The methods to determine heat-balance power level are given in Technical Specification Surveillance Procedure 5.4.1.1.4 c-D.
- b. When increasing power'with the ISS in the low power mode, a calibration is required when heat-balance power is between about 24% and about 28% of rated power.
- c. When decreasing power with the ISS in the low power mode, a calibration is required when heat-balance power drops below about 35% of rated power.
(4) Whenever the operator has reason to believe that one or more detectors are giving anomalous readings, a calibration should be performed.
(5) Whenever individual detectors differ by more than 10%, the proper
- functioning should be verified.
(6) Add the following items to the existing FSV calibration procedure, 3 S.R.5.4.1.1.4c-D:
Control rod bank partially inserted Position (inches withdrawn)
Regular rod position (inches withdrawn)
(7) Calibrate detectors prior to the withdrawal of rod group 3C (for cycle 2).
F The uncertainties analysis used to establish the above calibration requirements considered instrunentation uncertainties, calorimetric uncertainties (heat balance equations), and conservative uncertainties in the analysis used to establish the required trip setpoints. Taking these uncertainties into account, a margin of safety (% of rated power) larger than the total uncertainties (%) was established to ensure that a trip occurs below the Technical Specification values.
margin = (required trip setpoint) - (programmed trip setpoint)
This margin was conservatively fixed at 7% to 28% of rated power.
A review of the above General Atomic Company calibration requirements finds that they will add assurance that the FTSC will adjust the PPS trip set-points as a function of indicated power within a margin of safety to ensure the TS limits are not exceeded.
4.3 Technical Specifications and Test Provisions The limiting conditions for operation (LCOs) are in Table 4.4-1 and Table 4.4-3 and the surveillance requirements are shown in Table 5.4-1 and Table 5.4-3 of the FSV Technical Specifications. The required trip set-points, minimal number of operable channels, minimum degree of redundancy, and permissible bypass conditions are listed. A change is required in the test provisions to include the manufacturer's detailed test procedures for the new circuitry.
- 5. CONCLUSIONS Based on the information submitted by the Public Service Company of Colorado, on the neutron detector decalibration, at the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, it- is concluded that:
(1) The proposed circuitry changes for adjusting the PPS trip set-points (reactor and RWP) as a function of indicated power, meets the NRC design requirements as given in Section 2 above and as stated in the plant's Final Safety Analysis Report.
(2) The licensee make necessary changes in operating procedures to follow General Atomic Company's recommendations on the cali-bration requirements for the proposed circuitry changes.
(3) The test provisions in the plant precedures be changed to accomodate- the manufacturer's detailed test procedures for the added circuitry.
Accordingly, I recommend that the NRC staff accept the neutron detec-tor decalibration circuitry change to adjust the PPS trip setpoints as a function of indicated power.
L
REFERENCES
~(1) Public Service Company of Colorado (J. K. Fuller) to the NRC (W. P. Gammill),
dated January 11, 1979.
- (2) Public Service Company of Colorado (J. K. Fuller) to the NRC (S. A. Varga),
g- dated November 29, 1979.
(3) Public Service Company of Colorado (H. L. Brey) to the NRC (J. T. Collins),
dated May. 16, 1983.
(4) ' Public Service Company of Colorado (H. L. Brey) to the NRC (E. H. Johnson),
' dated November 30, 1983.
(5) General Design Criterion 7, 12, 15, 19-26, and 39, "AEC General Design Criteria for Nuclear Pever Plant Construction Permits," 1967 edition.
(6) IEEE Standard: " Criteria for Protection Systems for Nuclear Power Gene-rating Stations," IEEE 279-1968.
J,*
O
^
b
,3.-
DISCLAIMER This document was prepared as an account of work' sponsored by an agency of the United States Go,ernment.
- Neither the United States Government nor the University of California nor any of their employees, makes any warranty, empress or implied, os assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, com-pleteness, or usefulness of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed, or represents that its ow would not infringe privately owned rights. Reference herein to any specific commercial products, proccu, or seriice by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise, does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recomumendation, or favoring by the United States Government or the University of California.
The views and opinions of authors expremed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the United States Government thereof, and shall not be used for advertising or product endorsement purposes.
Aml Printed in the United States of Amenca Available from National Technical information Service U.S. Department of Commerce 5285 Port Royal Road
$pnngfield, VA 22MI Price: Printed Copy $ ; Microfiche $4.50 Domestic Domestic Page Range Price Page Range Price 001-025 $ 7.00 326-350 $ 26.50 026-050 8.50 351-375 28.00 051-075 10.00 376-400 29.50 076-100 11.50 401-426 31.00 101 125 13.00 427-450 32.50 126 150 - 14.50 451-475 - 34.00 151-175 16.00 476-500 35.50 176-200 17.50 501-525 37.00 201-225 19.00 .526-550 38.50 226-250 20.50 551-575 40.00 251-275 22.00 576-600 41.50 276-300 23.50 601-up' 301-325 25.00
' Add 1.50 for each additional 25 page increment, or portion thereof from 601 pages up.
se
. - - . . .. . . - . - . . . - . .. .. , , - . . . . - . _ ..._, - ___ __ _ _ _ _ _ . - ..- +--=*- -,,._4.-s.,m.6eu.4_
s ' ,',
s < .
hj l TechnicalInfortnation Departnrent
- Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory :^ ,
University of California . Livermore, California 94550 -
t j<> ' l s
O Y,
. i., ~
r .
v.; 5,i I
' ;< ,^ $.4 :
M s j v*
. A .4
- < M {v
.A Vi sgs: . r
. (j;f$bII. ,
I a
- .'i., x:. !
- .^3x;9
. y :.:.
~
fx (.. :^ '.i
/ MM J
FM 2 : ;
-' 1 l
< d.i:!: k r i ,
i O , -
r~,;y' l'f ,
.gr p sgy 4%/
1 I T s /# '
- ^ . .
c' < '.
f<:* '_
h 7 '-
>> y i
s y .
< s
- 3 '
-4 1
~
s ,, k<
9> 43l a- -~.% u.,
.0 O' 's A ',<
--r,- - -- - ~ - -. __m.c < , , -%a --, 4