ML20084C182

Responds to NRC Re Release of Two Remaining Stub Tubes for Repair.Insufficient Technical Justification Exists to Phase Out Tube Sample Surveillance Program.Stub Tube Repair Operation Proceeding W/O Sample Surveillance Program

ML20084C182
Person / Time
Site:	Oyster Creek, 05000000
Issue date:	06/25/1968
From:	Ritter G JERSEY CENTRAL POWER & LIGHT CO.
To:	Morris P US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
Shared Package
ML19289B326	List: ML20084C182 ML20084C331 ML20084C502 ML20084C552 ML20084C740 ML20084C761
References
NUDOCS 8304070562
Download: ML20084C182 (1)

Text

^"

.p. ~ , . . _ . _ _ _ .

.tr %r90M,n.xr:n-n 3

t - NNNN//RD/- X c .

• Ti% 553 (, (,

,,99 v , ,

^

USAEC IQS GTUN

&bVE& bd$ 50-1/Q* '

UU USH TLXA135 TLX222 (51)PD00P D Bf Comnfiams P MPA254 PD NORRIETOWN NJER 3 515P EDT DOC PETFR A HOFFIS DIRECT 00, DIVISICU OF REACT 0E LICENSING ' '

L'NITED 7TSTES ATOMIC E ERGY COMISSION k' ASHDC CUBJECT: OYETEP C9EER REACTOR VESSEL REPAIR M' T HIS IS IU PFF'3ONSE TO YOUR LETTER OF JUNE 25, 1968'To MR JOHN E LOGAN VICEPPFSIDENT JEEEEY CENTRAL POWER AND LIGHT CONCERNINC RELEASE OF THE TUO DE: AININ' STUP TUPEP FOR REPAIF. THESE STU'3 TUBFC ARF DESIGNATED S3 AND T4 IN AIMEUDMENT NUNB::.R 35. UE ARE ?FCCEEDING TO ISPLEMENT THE ACTIONS OUTLINED ON PAGE OSE OF YOUR LFTT!m AF YCU DM RE'IUEFTED. C ITH REC ARD TO PAGF T'.'O i: HICH ':CULO IlVCLVi *XPOEur: D i- CLAD AND UNCLAD SAM LF" GF ETUT TUFr FATETIol Tn T E '- PrACTOR OCLANT WE ARE UNAULr. TO DETEFMINE E0'. A:'.Y c:E A '. J i JL I.\FO.NATICN COULO 2F CFTAINED FRO? EUCH A JJFVEIL.W' 5 01h U , . TEL U^.ECNS F0E THIS AT& AS FOLLC;.": CNE-F A Bi' ULT CF THE STUE TUZF REPAIF ONLY CLAD STUE TU?E "ATREI;L lILL rF _ > P0 c; TO TF 9EACTOR COOLANT.

THE CLAJDIE3 .iTFrIAL I' T EL 20~- ST AINLZRS STEEL UHICH L.' AS DISCUESED IN A.V.F::D c 1 'T N J ~FU 37 I' SOFF PEEIETAST TO INTEGRANULAR C 0i^ P ^ I C S T H W T P:' A U FT:.i. I T I C rT'INLERr cTFEL IN COMMCN USE

< IN i.4CTOP ?LAUTE. Ti'0--IT IS NCT / W 1tLE TO Ele:ULATE IN CLA" OE UFCL AD S EPL S THE ^CTUA .

I' 0FF TTI:3 CONDITIONS TO WHICH THE STUI TurEF ILL r E YXEl D ( J . :. . , T HE T HERM AL GR ADIENT S , .

PFr.FcUPE Am' PE~IFU AL "TF"rF TD t!HICH THE 09E TU3ES ARE SUEJECTED.)

IT IS TEEEFF0m 00'4 C')IlICN T HAT T HERT Ic INSUFFICIENT TECHNICAL JUFTIFICATION FO' c a r " Y I .i OUT T u r T'K c AX?L' EURVELIANCE PF00FE. 'i CCCEDIN GL Y LT U PRU 'TLY OF CCELDIT TO CCNFLETE I THr cTur TUF RrPTIU C?NATIOP I:.CLUDI!M CLADDING OF THE i;EMilSILU

T '..' O FTUn-TUoFS 0

THE rSSI^ TP4T 1 STU TUEE MATEPIAL 9AMPLF

. GURVELIFNCE Fr C 9 A: ' JILL NOT PE V JIRED. FOR YOUP INFORMATION AT PFF9 TNT THF" ;PF TUO RE MINI' 3 SAMPLES OF UNCLAD STunTUEE XD 1/2" EY 1/2" SURFACE AREA) 1 i

NATEPIAL (APPFOX 1/2" 0Y l INCF AND TUP AMPLEE OF CLAD ST'JR TUF: AATEFIAL (APPROX 90 DEGREE

.L SFCNENTF CF TH" T'..'O HING SAMPLES i:EMOVED FROF CLAD ETUB TUEES) .

4 FINAL DICPOSITIO" 0F THEN SAMPLEE HAE NOT YET PEEN DETERMINED 0 H RITTER JERSEY CFNTRAL POWEP AND LIGHT CO PO BCX 55 MORRISTCUN i

NJEh -

0 i 25 1965 E3 T4 35 30EL 37 1/2" 1 1/2" 1/2" S0.

/20.n h hT/df

.. OR.7/g/gl , s=

u,. vs

,/

Q f I

' ' M@ye

. znr F f d'f g 3 %'s .

$m; n

c_.

m

. m m -- m O, USAEC HQ3 GTUN Sr9 m 93 .~-

W- E m

s VU WSH o >-un  :;E 719P EDT \ [

ca n D

00 G 2 4 () 3 b* ' , B304070562 690106 . 3. o PDR ADOCK 05000219 g@ ~.

- wi QIf &,5*

g k :p..n.p,,..g% w . - y.

p;p g 9.. e.mg.yQT.TW( ex .e w.yJ7'K*f97*.fQiW w gygg p%s.?;,3% W$;g m +

m @,: m . m m . n w c. w. a . w .

.lf.;<q. ;gs@Q;W.W.fCOP ,,.. e..c.

w vg gp W. Q@s m 7.pqJph dt yr?!n ikg/i.h..

h.,..(6JKMRE9)k. r;.,s.

1;M,  :  ;

.f n.y %<.o  %. , . %.m:.m.

Ky ;'\ . . . >

.., .,.,u.~nn.4,

_ sco y,a n ...

4 y ;s, ;. Q, y, n.4 p ,.. w... M>~.

1. .,p;.,o p .w

.z , ,, 4, +p,{ -. p. :

y e.s:Luw,,p

&,y& p

. . . a.i ;9 _ s..g f; w. . y p , w f . !. ',u, N;a:

e :, ,3.q,%j.;'yaf :p%

p.,,. . .e s ;;[p.7 ;o_7;yA M7,.M vN q.4lad(

g.r Q

• p S, ?,sN . s , yy.':y .n . . .~

. . .,eu;#:

i i

l 4

I 3R" ] W lg Q g g ggg:>g i g g*;:ppp.q;gg;gg g p , a. ., y m y ...g., m , y e G J

a. , _, o MEMO ROUTE SUP"' Sa '"' "o": ta's- For concurrence. For action.

g Fbrm arc-93 Gev. May14. 1947) Note and return. For sicnature, f or In'er rition. l l To man:. .no unm nmAu aturaxs {

t 1

P. A. Morris OYSTER CREEK UNIT NO. 1

[

a THRU: R. S. B.vd [^rE Compliance informed us that evidence of intergranular_ f s 1 attack on the exterior surfaces of the safe ends i i I k attached to isolation condenser otitlet ston linos j To ma e .u aniti  % As P(2P,5 core spray lines (2), and control rod drive I cc: F. Schroeder _ hydraulic return line_(lL_.has_bcen. observed. Por _

$ S. Levine Amendment 40, Jersey Central reported that inter-J. O'Reilly A- - ' , , , _ granular attack Was_founion_one (l lof the_safc_nnda_

V. Stello of the isolation condenser steam line. No formal rospon90 frem Jernev Centrn1 to dneo on rho TO (Marne an ' uni') 6Niil4LS darks

- . EE'iscrepancy.

$- L 4 _. ._ __

I ATE

..ed L

F liO fA t'.ame ar d t.m!) FEMARAS R. Tedesco O

/,b N t

t__

b[

PHehE M. OAiL

7e 9/23/68 -

_ ,,o n, . u . s. . m. .,m. , <. e m .m . . . _ . . . . . , ,._..._,n.,,,_.

6 f

1

. _ - . , . . . ~ . - _ - . . . . . .