ML20044C304
Text
+
s
,,s*
[pm af cqS o
UNITED STATES
., g
.,,j 1, i f'I NUCLEAR REGULATGiiY COMMISSION Y
' t OFFICE OF INVESTIGATIONS FIELD OFFICE. REGION I ' g Gj /./- @ g ?]
475 ALLENDALE ROAD
'g '
,e KING OF PRUS$1A. PENNSYLVANIA 19406 April 22,1991 MEMORANDUM FOR: Charles W. Hehl, Director 4'
Division of Peactor Proje ts, ion I FROM:
Chester W. White, Director
)
Office of Investigations Fie'id'0ffice, Region I l
SUBJECT:
ALLEGATION RECEIPT REPORT RE: ALLEGED SUBSTANDARD CONNECTORS.
l MILLSTONE UNITS 1, 2, AND 3 Attached for your action is an Allegation Receipt Report of a concern raised hy (
on Friday, April 19, 1991, 1
l
Attachment:
As stated l
l l
l l
l 9
"..*~.*'r;*,
-l h. 3 Ci '. fi,'J i.;, 4.
$CI. (K2i.Q;. PS _..
7'
^
C
~~
Toi A _f2./. /.s:- --
~-
~
lf
/
l 9303220120 921217 HUBBARD92-162 PDR
a
/
ALLEGATICN RECEIPT REPORT Cate/ Time A7M bCO 29 Receivec:
April 19, 1991 1:00 o.m.
Allegation No.
(leave clank)
Adcress:
l l-i Name:
City / State / Zip:
Phone:
Confidentiality:
Was it recuested?
Yes No X Was it initially grantec?
Yes No X was it finally grantec by the allegation panel Yes No X
- oes a conficentiality agreement neec to be sent Yes No X to alleger?
"as a conficentiality agreement teen signec?
Yes No x emo cocumenting *ny it was grantea is attacnec?
Yes No X v
Aliecer's Ercioyer:
l'illstone Unit 2 Position /
Title:
liC Technician Facility:
Doctet No.:
advised the
( Allegation Summary (brief cescription of concern (s):
f oll owina:
Accroximatelv 10 months ago,
{
[uastrovidedacracke,dCAnutbyaMillstoneworker.
[iI["""
went to the warehouse where the nut had been stored and found Mr.
Numcer of Concerns:
Employee Receiving Allegation:
C. W. White (first two initials ano last name)
Type of Regulatea Activity (a) X Reactor (d) _ !afeguaras (b) _ Vencer (e) _ Other:
(c) _ Materials (Specify)
Materials license No. (if applicable):
Functional Area (s): _ (a) Ocerations (e) Emergency Preparedness
_ (b) Construction (f) Onsite Health ano safety
_ (c) Safeguards
_ (g) Offsite Health anc Safety
_ (d) Transportation
_ (h) Other:
(NRC Region I Form 207 Reviseo 10/89)
d-e
~
i Page l of 2
Cetailed Cescription cf Allegation: 160 cracked nuts (approximately 1/2 of f
the total).
then went to John Coleman) and
' to get rid of the reported the matter.
Coleman allecedly told.
1 cracted nuts and put the good ones back.
tnen raised, with Coleman, the issue of the problem of possible cracked nuts already installed at the plant.
Allegedly, nothing was done.
stated that i s reluctant to report the matter to the NRC.
this incident took place approximately 13 months ago, an[
took his l
4 concern to the Nuclear Concerns Program who have not dispositioned it satisfactorily for stated that he was notifying the NRC at this time because he had talkedtd two days ago and th= issue was still unresolved.
B eamm ale % E Faul_i Coleman's supervisor is Cuncan McCory.
l i
i i
I i
NRC Region I Form 207 I
(Revisec 10/89)
?
s T'
7 r
--- -im
h, APR 611 '91 17:02 HRC MILLSTONE'0FFICE P02 f
)
ALLEGATION RECEIPI REPORT DateMirre j Received: b pri
(,197f It'.304.M.
All'egation No.
El-9/ '4-OoG3 (leave blank)
P r ty St t Confidentiality:
Vas it requested?
'Yes No' /
Vas it initially granted?
Yes No Vas it finally granted by the. allegation panel Yes No
~
Oces a confidentiality agreement need to be sent to alleger?
Yes No Has a confidentiality agreement been signed?
Yes No ~
Memo cocumentir.g why it was granted is attached?
Yes No _
6A5Nltft4/bhSO PositienAitle:
e Facility: Mt o/16 2.
Docket No.:
80 ~334 (Allegation Sum.ary (brief description of concern (s): h. b A k/V (6 f
concerned about operatwn of & local secunh ala;m for.
f agess mfo He auntlou >h. 5). A awe,oa as to O fidY0 r orm(ftOri ClFff Ad - d lo6td-( Afd
/14 bt b4f64 -
~
4 N *i N e ber of Concerns:
1onfzg.1 F.6Ndb lort '
'l Eeployee Receiving Allegation:
(first two ihitials and last name) l Type of Regulated Activity (b _ Vendor (e) _ Safeguards (d) a Reactor Other:
(
(c [ Materials (Specify) l l
Materials License No. (if applicable): _
FunctionalAres(s):
5'Ta) Operations
~
~(b) Construction f Onsite Health and Safety (c) Safeguards g Offsite Health and Safety.
- (d) Transportation
[h Other:-
(NRC Region 1 Fors 207,,sa.e.
1 Revised 10/89).
ja g,g c.rasO:1 Act, cnmp!.ca -.N M -
l
..,,.. m. 4 A01h o3,h/6 W.
~
h
-l m
APR 01 '91 17:02 NRC MILLSTONE OFFICE P03 k.
b 4
p" ** f41 =4 pw.., r,1 k *1.1.Nr*: { r-f,...1 r
r* -- e
- i w w c b, 1 r-. i.
s.
b n b e f* 1 1 k h E' 61 1 fr*h t" ~ E I. d O C C pJ C.d
- h ; U P Wr3 r @ 5 3 f ) Qn t** d f
e e
t t"C.!b l E E 5 CL t ; f. p,
.:::; c; 1 r E i Or ihp b.: t E t ;... h e n * ; p., ; c n rgen; t g, i RM--b l 2 ).
T, Fi : C -..T r f G r was A C C;t.. ;ctOr t. 5. p r g,.,; w g } y w- ; g g ;t M*II5tene U :
! t e r' Tne alleger c-d m s cc u,ri er e r. t.w c ri a m.. ;he e _.. l. a r y t o.1 :. r..g
.: t31 ar r-s e t o a r. v rs t. ; M. c
..p i conc.itics and t sgg 2 r.g f or t.h e cc+*r:. t; p
'a p i n t c r,a r,; t.c r ; c r.
r "' - i l ! _,
- 76. e.
g 4 1 ;g., c.-
t yg.-; 3 3
.; -. r. e au 2.;er> L L '.1 1 v,,, CL t.s& Qucir t 1 y i O! g r.e : Ly i h g.
t ;n t-J.;.,r I a., i n ;,;, i.
bstr i T. C 2 3 _. n 1. C '.t F C C
.hE
.f'6' f.* 3 6." J ~. 4 "" Of ( f. Q (C..
- l } r ' y U g '. 1 ;i i g t CG E t h Gt' IBe ; O C ; \\ 4 6. J j *i; t' L* 'I E 1.. F
- ^ !h6 4fEJ 4 CF" Y..' f F 2; 1. a t.-11,'
6.
")
.u O..,..
-L +.
...,.,s..
..., c. 3. k.
c....,.
s s.w.cz.
...... '\\ r _
..u.
... c-s..t.
..s1 y
t t.
a:,
,... r r e..
y..tr...m.c e.
e
~.,,:
L..,t,...,....e h g ii. un...t. W :. s.
r 4.
.C 3
tu.
c.
4".1 F c:.".."
5-11 oc wfE hcl S L:
- h t.P ; I DO ?Cr * ! ". O iT E r..
hr
- u ;' E Y. '3
..C.
~
'". 1 ~. :. B L-Bf2 *'* :5 *. 3 L.' i.
- % C " + i L 1:
t *1 i l; 12 E *. : ' n d lrI 1 B.. ' * ). I <*E y' i s.1 1.0. ~y that w:2 st;j
- r. e r.;
p t f t.1 ::. ; r.t c the trEd.
7 h r-2 I ; s.;c r wa i.
c..#..:
S.....
U.
t...
. C- )
. l. c,_ Lt G e... ;.,. C f A
...i..'...'s. e.
~
. c. c m. % :_.... g. <
v
, ci a
_-i t-_
w L... v = ::.
- 4, I n 4 4 4 E.3L.
6 i
r.,..
..ps ei.
- g. 4 ~. t.. t,
,.m,.,, c..
i t
E J L E L.*
ts i u, r u t t. C r. Z ::C 0 ;
- C E n t e De i"9 CCC*."GitGF.
I ~. c E d t. Li r i t.
7 J ' * . t:
- C.C h :.i M.
E 1 F t 6:.C r Flp Q *. O E L
~J i.
t*e J. - tC.
Ihe 2.1 1 t.* C?
C' d
~*E r.
... 4.re..-c
,W Gq.t c_.L......
g5 gs e......
i
...,i..._.4.
.g.
,.. e-
.4..y.
.c
-s 7
O.w, 1 L....
+
.e
,.,w L...L
..9
. _....,. F...s W ;.. h
,w, p...
.,.q4 9J+
a4:
e.
.,J w..... a
.2.
s c:..
g.* s.
pn s
.JDi-...
- 4. s..,.
a
..=.
t;
- a....
v., u. r: c r
,ic_
~
.1 6 p: s t.-
g..:,......
J...
. gbr tC -1 y FE,1C t.
i..s c a
...=-p,.,
t
.. 7,_. c....r
.r
. w
,v
. p, g
. =
...)et g.
,.c.
.6.
u_ s a m.
.e i
..L
...y.
,. s v..,...c.
s.. e,, m.
.. 3
- 4
.. o... _. r
_.v C r.
m.
1:. -..
... t..
..s
.w
,r.
1 e.-
un.
.'. gc: a v,
+7
- 6. a.,..
..r.E L.
m. : u. c 4..
r.
v
+.1 v.
c. E e.
t, 1.. ' ** ~~
- r. t'
- ,.. ~ ' ' ' ' ' '
'. " =-.., _ c.' c '..
- o* i..*'. : C. *.*. ~~ -I.
..'t.-
w._
e, u s11 eger ' E rel;4<e2 E p t!em *;t5 t.*. :.- a u : ; t. ' O al er m E..i s.t c.sr m
.t u
- c. c _ r......
v...-. s r. m e..s e...
c..m.. h.
x_ _v- =.
.., i. L...
,.a3 n d,.... n +-.*-
.e.#
-.m a n d s. ; c ;.'61.s !!wt t....aut r.r : : Ed eccess na.s c;.0 /rt.d.
1 1
~;.
T h r. c l i s 4. :a r hs L e : t ?.e a w e cv :Pe meet: g tetasia IN: t G C, 9 :.
N or t h c i. s.t. Ut. 2 t : es r c.re s en t & t s v -s; 6 f t E-r t *. o Si'd P c.v.2.tg e E r.-
e : t.,,
o n M e.r t t.
~ ' ~. 1971.
T h e A l l e:g e r b r i i e '. e s, th6 E 2 nc e br. I t. psrt d tin-
'problet hb C N. : h6 cc sc;&ss t o tM 2recretional c., ch ang e It 2.t o curre.: natnir t h. s me e t i n ;;.
The I m p e c t u-tc1d the alleger u w3.e.
d riot ;; 4.r t u t.'. c me t : r: g, enc a s dsrected tc put :n tra :nspLcticn report a cunre y tf the tep:ct ditcussed at this rieet2ng.
The alls p berl i eves th1. : h3c m et1Dn#1 e:: Change 15 vary I mp O** t ant tc ha n-end c t h c.'
nhistleblowers.
The alleger a s 4.nv e ci the FDIA a p pt c a c. h. nowever he would mornietE I
if ho could ecQu2 r e the a nf ormst;en.
The :ntoector told the alleqer ' E-would Oct b a c i: t o h a r.
ct r.: s c;u e s t i o n.
T Hi". IN WECTOR DI'iC0 3EE THF,. APDVE TWC 13EUES WITH THE DRP SEC.T ION CH3 EF ON AFRIL 1.
?
?,,,.
I t
f i
t
%*,. r.~.'. 2 1
' t. '. 'r-
~..' '. : g*. r.. + + '.
?
- 6... ri :. -
' L rs.
4.
t.'
c* '-
<-i.".'+..*.~~'.
CO.-
G'ns to t."; r r G-is 2 C' c r. T tf.%:Ct;.
' t. 7 c e t w r. :.
- c. r r.
J 2 E t ct C: trri <.
t.
- -. e-t. t
- h. e
> ~ '
-~'.r.
, c' - G L u"Y.
.. 2 '. c...' 1 a- '. i.. "
M-
~ C W. w-':
f.' Oh C C F. I 5 Cl E,. f, - Or 4 ' ** f E. 0 ~ d *. 2 ~ "
F-. : " -
% F - f 1..' /
'..l". '. 2 S.t M L s
t*Odia;2on r:c -
- t, i
(* 1.a r :.'. h.*.- F ;-; ;#: -
- '. c
- t
- .' J r' : F 4.*.'
t Vf i.,.:!.
+
p.3 e.
,4
- h.. r.,,
...e.g 4
,,1.,,.c.
J.,.,.
. c...e(
Os.-.
5
,u f
.r.
~, o i - (.*. 4 g r+ *.- c a.
- A...- -
+ p..,.
6
- k.g
,i.6.e.**-...*..e.
f s
a.
=I e'
c'. J C.. r
,.1f..'*. *.: C.*,-- z?
w w
- s
- i t:" t:.
.'I
- s *
's*' - - - ~
". 5 ".
- '4
- t. b.
t*,,.
s..~-
t - +6
. i,*.r 4-
. r J, 4,. 4.J.
. :. * * ~ '
. i t a
T-<
,r.rp+.1
- p. :.-
t -.1 a..
g s.
n.
- .e,.va4 L.,s.. >
+..t.
. s, s,,.,. c
+
... s.
L. e
.r i
t.
.- a a:. f.7
.(i....s...
'+:
.i.1 g,....
.-5..
k e
- r ye i*. '..,-
A :, g..,
.1,. t
.?,..:. -+
<. t ;- :
..s.-..v.
.r t ?,. r,, *..-'; -i*-
e-i w
.g..i..,
. ;,,, 6...=.-..,,. - r.
- 4. p 7...
-.a m.
,s
. 6 e.
+.
4
=.i.-
3 e,. +..m.
3...,.
1 s
-...s 4
,-.g+..
e-,, p -.
-1
- e..v
..-.4.
4 2
4%....
'iL t
t w.
=*
-..t b -*
r" ~
4 4P
+.y....
- f-1.':
r.'
J ed....
e*
s.
.(
s.
a
.s.
..
- f
.p
--...,t,e
.i
.. s 4..,1 g
-. ~.
6
-4
~*na.. -.
-g L.
4.
4 9' 41 L.
.,re.,..=+
4..
s
?."
.--s
,3
(-
y.* 4 -
..L.
..,c,.,....*.. s. e
~
.t
.s
- t. r....*.-..s>
..J..
i 1
a i
k 6
6 I
e i
h e
i s
t
}
?
- k.
}
f
.I