ML18117A371

4 to Updated Final Safety Analysis Report, Chapter 5, Appendix 5A, Figures

ML18117A371
Person / Time
Site:	Crane
Issue date:	04/06/2018
From:	Exelon Generation Co
To:	Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Shared Package
ML18117A343	List: ML18117A350 ML18117A352 ML18117A353 ML18117A355 ML18117A359 ML18117A360 ML18117A361 ML18117A362 ML18117A363 ML18117A364 ML18117A366 ML18117A367 ML18117A369 ML18117A370 ML18117A371 ML18117A372 ML18117A374 ML18117A375 ML18117A376 ML18117A377 ML18117A379 ML18117A382 ML18117A383 ML18117A384 ML18117A386 ML18117A387 ML18117A388 ML18117A389 ML18117A390 ML18117A391 ML18117A392 ML18117A393 ML18117A394 ML18117A395 ML18117A396 ML18117A397 ML18117A399 ML18117A400 ML18117A401 ML18117A403 ML18117A404 ML18117A406 ML18117A407 ML18117A408 ML18117A409 ML18117A410 ML18117A411 ML18117A413 ML18117A414 ML18117A415 ... further results
References
TMI-18-047
Download: ML18117A371 (41)

Text

_r"4

_t"t

---

~ -----+-_..

~~--_--~----------+--t"t

---

......;~----.....~

~o REACT ION P(t}

lai!J Nuclear 1MI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82 p.5A.FIG-l Total Reaction vs Time Curve Fig.5A-l

1

~

_WINGS & ENGINES J

\\-

ATTACHED h \\

~J

\\

V

~WINGS & ENGINES

,JI""

DETACHED j

\\

I

\\ \\

V

~

JV

~~ ~

11 16 1.

1 12

)(.

=

10

~

1&1 U

I¥ 2

I t-U C

A.

6 2

o o

.01

.12

.21

.2.

.21

.32

.36

...0 TIME -

SlCONDS B:imNuclea, 1MI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82 p.5A.FIG-2 Load Time Curve for 720 Aircraft at 200 Knots Fig.5A-2

~~ :']

~

J II

~

T

'I

~

Ir 1

1\\

11 IIWM++

~

I

l I

11 l

n

~

~

~

100 1.6 1.2

• o

~

~

1.0 aco

~

u

~z

~ 0.1 a

)(c2 0.6 o.~

so

~o 30 20 FREQUENCY (CP$)

10 5

3 2

0.2 0.01 0.02 0.03 O.~

0.05 0.1 PERIOD (SECONDS) 0.2 0.3 O.~

0.5 1.0 ra:im Nuclear 1MI Unit-'

Update -,

7/82 p.5A.FIG-3 Maximum Dynamic Load Factor vs Period or Frequency of a One-Degree-Freedom System under the Impact of Boeing 720 Fig.5A-3

cr Z

al~ j

,II a::

C II

'it

[a:iEl Nuclear TMI Unit-1 Spherical Cap under a Ring Load u-c "0

0

=~Q

~

II II II a::

Update -1 7/82 p.5A.FIG-4 Fig.5A-4

I I

I

~ I u.

~

DC U

DC

~

Z w

Q C)

DC

~

)

-I CDex DC c

0 Q.

u.

c V) 5 Q.

U W

~

DC A.

)

~w u..

DC 0

Q.

~

-I w

~

GIl:

2

~

DC 0

Z

~

0 ta::il!I Nuclear TMI Unit-l Update -1 7/82 p.5A.FIG-5 Spacial and Time Distribution of Load on Shell Fig.5A-5

N N

~Nucl..r 1MI Unit-l 1ft*

62 o

Update -1 7/82 p.5A.FIG-6 Grid for Dynamic Finite Element Analysis of Aircraft Impingement on Dome Fig. SA-&

)

0.1 SECONDS 0.2 0.3 I

II NOTE: eKSI CORRESPONf)5 TO A LO D OF 5800 KIPS

(~ 20 )(

E.1611T Of TII£ AIR-VERTICAL D'SPL~CEMENT OFT"EIAPEX (BASED O~ ~=.lKS')

I~

0.16 SEC' CASE @ TIt.1E Of LOAD APPLICATI$N 0.4 TIME AFTE~*BE INNIN6 OF IMP.

I

t.

• 0

@)~I tJ. : 0.16 SEC 0.2

• 0.16 SEC 0.8 I

1.0 I

\\!V-4

t. =0 z

I ta.

II ~

C'" 0 I

t.

• 00

~

.6 TIC SOLUTION

~

---

~-- 1--,'---

C "C

Q.

~

C'D CO I

N U1

J>

I......

Vl>

~a I-J

""C:)

~; -1m

a m

!,~

3:

ao

=;: c

a::;':::1 Z

.... n en"

... C

.... m I

1:....... n n

.... :1 I:-a

~ci' II om

a :I en m

.... :::a m....

~o c:::a mC n

0

!!.:I=m m

0 0'

a cP'

~.

I/)£FL.C _..

()

~

<:)

SIRE S5 - P~I

(-)

CO/rl'~ESSIO" I2iE Nuclear TMI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82 p.5A.FIG-8 Deflections and Stresses for Aircraft Impingement for Time = 0.16 Seconds"Constant Deceleration Fig.5A-8

350.....----......----.....----.....----....

0.4 0.3

\\

0.2 TIME-SECONDS 0.1 C-JJ9C o~----.......----......---------........

o 250.....-----4------+--~~--+------I 50~----_+_----+_+_----_+_-~~-~

\\

\\

100 ~----+-----4~_+_------+-_+----4I 300 ~-----+-----~r__-----+-----~

a a

~ 200.....------+---;.---+----""'--+------1 V) to-w W

LL.

I to-g 150 ~-----+---........--+-----......-----I

~

\\

\\

Iai!J Nuclear 1MI Unit-l Update -1 7/82 p.5A.FIG-9 Velocity Diagram for 720 Aircraft at 200 Knots Impact Speed with Wings and Engfnes Detached Fig. 5A-9

350....---~-----....---..........---.....

300 I------~----~~---_+_----_I 0.4 G.!

0.2 TIME-SECONDS 0.1 0.....----....----......----.....---........

o 250 C-1l9C a

z0u 200 w

\\

~

~w W

&L I

\\

~

U 150 0

-oJ

\\

w>

\\

\\

100

\\

\\

\\

50

((il!] Nuclear TMI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82

p. 5A.FIG-IO Velocity Diagram for 720 Aircraft at 200 Knots Impact Speed with Wings and Engines Attached Fig. 5A-l 0

IfJO 110 10 60 AIRCRAFT WEIGHT BREAKDOWN FUSELAGE 51,000 La EMPENNAGE 5,680 NOSE GEAR 700 MAIN GEAR 5,380 INB. ENG.

10,800 OUTB. ENG.

10,300 WING STR.

29,700 S

113,560 LB 0

PASS. & BAGS 13,000 8

CARGO 10,000 FUEL 63,440

~

G. W**

200,000 LB

~

4 w

c:L.

~ASS DI5l

£ 70 co

-J LOSS f OU R POll. ION I

OFW 1J(j z

0

~

i=

coa:...

U) is...

2 isw

~

I DISTANCE - FEET o

200 4{)()

60D 800 F.5.

IfJOO IZOI

'"10 B:iEl Nuclea, TMI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82

p. 5A.FIG-I1 720 Aircraft Mass 0istribution Fig.5A-11

7

/

/

V

~

7

,~

---~~

~

~

I I

I I ~

Pa,..." CRUSHING LOAD IN POUNDS

)( 10'

[aj[I Nuclear TMI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82

p. 5A.FIG-12 Boeing 720 Fuselage Buckling (Crushing) Load Fig.5A-12

r =0.0" MAXIMUM DISPLACEMENT OCCURS AT CENTER OF DOME AT TIME t =.2 SEC.

41)wJ:

U!

I to-Z W

~

W U

~-'

Q.

~

Q

~

U to-Ol:

W>

-2.0 --

r..-

...L.

---J o

0.1 0.2 TIME - SECONDS 0.3 o.~

lm1!I Nuclear 1MI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82 p.5A.FIG-13 Time Variation of Shell Vertical Displacements with Wings and Engines Detached Fig.5A-13

.O~,...-----------------------------.

MAXIMUM DISPLACEMENT OCCURS AT CENTER OF DOME AT TIME t =.2 SEC.

,=0.0"

-1.2 0t.~:::__-------------------..,-~--~

....-4

-1.6 I/)w

];:

U Z

-O.~

I...zw

~wu

-0.8

~

-oJ a..

I/)

Q

-oJ

~

U...

al:

W>

-2.0 o

0.1 0.2 TIME - SECONDS 0.3 O.~

((iI!] Nuclear TMI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82 Time Variation of Shell Vertical 0isplacements with Wings and Engines Attached

p. 5A.FIG-14 Fig.5A-14

MAXIMUM AND MINIMUM WINGS & ENGINES ASSUMED PRINCIPAL STRESSES TO BE DETACHED FROM AT THE TOP AND BOTTOM FUSELAGE SURFACES OF THE DOME 2

W I

0 W

I¥...

W I¥ A.

i

-2

~...

U

~

A.

~

-~

CJ...

w

~

-6 w

W I¥...

Q

-I wz CD MAXIMUM COMPRESSIVE STRESS 20 IS 9372 PSt u

-10 0

0.1 0.2 0.3 O.~

TIME - SECONDS

~Nuclear 1MI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82 p.5A.FIG-I5 Time Variation of Shell Surface Stresses Aircraft with Wings and Engines Detached Fig. 5A-15

2 0."

0.3 BOTTOM SURFACE MAXIMUM COMPRESSIVE STRESS IS 9352 PSI

,=o*

0.2 TIM! - SECONDS 0.1 MAXIMUM AND MINIMUM PRINCIPAL STRESSES AT THE TOP AND BOTTOM SURFACES OF THE DOME

-10.....------..&.-------.....------.....--------'

o v;

~

I O.....-------------.'---;.--~-~P"""'""---------__I V)

V) wa:

~

V)w

~

-2

~

U

~

Q.

o

~

w

)o

~

-6 wa:

~

V) ow

~

-8 co 2o U

OBi!) Nuclea, TMI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82

p. 5A.FIG-16 Time Variation of Shells Surface Stresses Aircraft with Wings and Engines Attached Fig. 5A-l &

FOURlEi SERIES =.Q7955*,1575 COS, +.1558 COS 2'*.1"6 COS 3' + *\\33 COS'"

• . 1208 COS 58 + ~ 1058 COS 6' *.08CU COS 71 +.0722 COS 8'

• .0551 COS 98

&o*

~Nucl..r 1MI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82

p. 5A.FIG-I7 Pressure Distribution for Aircraft Impact Fig. 5A-17

020"1r Update -1 7/82 lail!J Nuclea, TMI Unit-1

.75" 1129 FT*K/FT

~

.\\1'

+

150 -

~

<<9 140 -

~

0.-A 130 -

~

120 -

<0

~

~

110 -

100 -

t-W 90-wu.

80

~

to-70

~>

W

.-oJ 60 w

SO -

40 30 20 10 0

MERIDIONAL MOMENTS

.SHEARS DEFLECTIONS Aircraft Impact at Girder to Dome Transition

p. SA.FIG-IS Fig. 5A-18

Update -1 7/82

~Nuclear TMI Unit-1

.....-1.04" 326 K/FT 150 _

--+-.............-..~

998 FT-K/FT 17.5 x 106 LB (TOTAL LOAD) 140 -

so -

130 -

30-40 -

10 -

20 -

100 -

110 -

120 -

1616 FT-K/FT

...w 90-wu.

• 80-zo I ~>

~ 60-LIJ 0-MERIDIONAL MOMENTS SHEARS DEFLECTIONS Aircraft Impact at Spring Line p.5A.FIG-19 Fig.5A-19

Update -1 7/82 1.14 "

p. 5A.FIG-20

\\

\\

\\,,

I

/

/

/

,/

ELEV.149'-1"

~Nuclear TMI Unit-1 Radial Deflection Impact at Spring Line Fig.5A-20

.127"l r I

t Update -1 7/82

[ffi[1 Nuclear TMI Unit-1

......- 1.00"

- 177 K/FT 184 K/FT

~ -226 K/FT 14-- 1297 FT-K/FT 1658 FT-K/FT 150 -

140 -

130 -

120 -

110 -

100 -

t ww u.

80 -

z0 t-70 -

<>w 60 -

...J W

50 -

40 -

17.5 x 106 LB 30 -

(TOTAL LOAD) 20 -

10 -

0-MERIDIONAL MOMENTS SHEARS DEFLECTIONS Aircraft Impact at Grade

p. 5A.FIG-21 Fig. 5A-21

z y

/

~~_a__

(a) GEOMETRY (b) 51 X FORCE COMPON ENTS AT NODAL POINT tai!I Nuclear 1MI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82

p. 5A.FIG-22 Rectangular Finite Element Fig.5A-22

Update -1 7/82 Heat Exchanger Vault Moment Diagram For the Roof Slab

[ffil!l Nuclear 1MI Unit-1 thickness:

6-:'0 N--

MOMENT ENVELOPE impact positio/IS p

n along secflon A-A F,,' V'~

cr,.';/co /

.IP>>pa.c~

Q. 5 oircrorf

'2"*..

.....-.--- 60'* 6..---~----

6O~6 -"--....-t

b. 5 momenTS Secn'tn?

AA d~

fo

• o..,

~

HOn?I?,.,f 2,800 2,'00 2,40D 2.,200 2,000

/,800

'S

"'ao

/'400

.~

""~

/,].00

~

~

- /,roo

\\J

.~

800

~

~

"00

.\\':::"

400

~

t::

200

~

~

~/

200

.~

400 i)

~

ftJoo ctJ 800 1,000 1,200

/,'100

/'fDOO

/,800 2,000

p. 5A.FIG-23 Fig.5A-23

TMI UFSAR Figures 5A-24 through 5A-25 Deleted

v

p. 5A.FIG-26 BimNuclear TMI Unit-1 Critical Aircraft Impact-Direction 1 Update -1 7/82 Fig.5A-26

IMPACT DIRECTION <D c==::C>

r -----A --.............._

SEE TEXT PG. SA-18

-,f I-

• I I

' *.~:

~... '.

la:im Nuclear TMI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82

p. 5A.FIG-27 Concrete Cover to Protect Against Aircraft Impact Fig.5A-27

~

t'o...

t-l

--~

~.--..

~

.---- _.-~... ---

I I

f I

I I

I I

I I

II I

I I

I If I TYR I

I 15P~'N6'1 I

I I

I I

I I

I I

II 8iI!l Nuclear 1MI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82

-p. 5A.FIG-28 Detail of Anchor Block Fig.5A-28

IMPACT OlQECTION A

A (a.)

lb)

I

~-- ASSUMEC N. A..

0]!]Nuclear TMI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82

p. 5A.FIG-29 Prestress Stresses after Nine Tendons Fail Fig.5A-29

8 zo..-

uuJ ex 6

t-u<

Q.

~

~~

t'{)

ta:im Nuclear 1MI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82

p. 5A.FIG-30 Critical Aircraft Impact - Directions 2 and 3 Fig.5A-30

p. 5A.FIG-31 ta:iZ!l Nuclear TMI Unit-1 Equal Spacing of Roof Tendons Update -1 7/82 Fig. 5A-31

UPdate - J 7/82 Do,.,. rendons

BUTTRESS ir IMPACT

~

DIRECTION 0

~..... - - -

~Nucl..r TMI Unit-'

Update -,

7/82 Minimum Spacing of Hoop Tendons

p. 5A.FIG-33 Fig.5A-33

ELEVATION DUE TO A.IRCRAF"T)

IMPACT DU& TO L.OSS OF HOOP PRESTRESS DuE To VEsctlCAl PfiEST2ESS DUE TO HOOP PRESTRESS DUE TO VEJCT'C~

PRESTRESS E:LEVATION DUE TO HOOP PRe:5aT~e:~S

\\DUE. TO ArRCRAFT IMP~T TO A.L.

PRESTRE~S LOS~ OF' H P

F>QE&TRESS Iai!l Nuclear 1MI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82 Comparison of Prestress Loading

p. 5A.FIG-34 Fig.5A-34

I I

I I

I 1

~I ir, I

~I I

~I Ie!'

~I

~

I~

~I I~

~!

w

!~

w

~r J'~

I~

01

~I Ii

~..

1<1(

10 w

/

I~

~

~I 10

~I 10 I~

51 I~

I~

UI V Ie Ij

~I 1&1) 10 C)

I~

~I

!~

-.~

{

Ie!' 'f I~

)""

IS I~

V t

~

t

'"~\\

0.4 0.3 0.2 TIME* SECONDS 0.1 cs/r r

,'\\

S' (j

-, I r; f-I

. I

~

I 1\\

./

U

' :/

0.

u,

! \\

L"'

~ "

4, I

\\

J I

\\-

I /

I

\\

I,

\\

I

,~-

\\

f\\, /

I

~

-~

~

~J oo CALCULATED REMOTE "G" LEVEL 90 80 70 C)

~ 60

..J w

Uw 0

w 50 C)

<I(

...J W

&I) 40

>u.

w

~

0

~

30 w

~

20 10 0.4 0.3 0.2 TIME* SECONDS 0.1 RIGID STRUCTURE R{~

o o 20 15

'0 2

)(

co

.J e!'

0 10

~

0

..J Z2

~

U

~

W 01:

5 SEE TABLE 5A-6, REACTION LOAD CALCULATIONS WITH WINGS & ENGINES DETACHED la:im Nuclea, TMI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82 Reaction Load and Fuselage Decel. (Calculated for 720)

p. 5A.FIG-35 Fig.5A-35

f~

/ \\

I

\\

\\

~

~

\\

~V'"

V 1\\

0.-

0.3 0.2 TIME. SECONDS 0.1

.......~

I V l\\

/

I 1/

I C.119C (TEST)! I I

r I,,

j I,

./\\

~

I I**

l

~

I

~

I

~

,~

I*

1;('

I l'.1

\\

,I

/

\\

\\.

~. f I

A20 (IALCULjTED)

~

I~

~

I'"

o o

80 90 CALCULATED REMOTE "G" LEVEL 70 d

I 60

.Jwuw Q

SO w

C)

~

.J W.,...0

J

&L Wt-O 30

~

W 0:

20 10 0."

0.3 0.2 TIME. SECONDS 0.1 RIGID STRUCTURE

~

R

---+

~

o o

20

-0 15 0-

)(

a>>

.J g

Q

~

10 0

.J Z

0 t=u

~

W 0:

5 SEE TABLE SA.7, REACTION LOAD CALCULATIONS WITH WINGS AND ENGINES ATTACHED

~Nucl..r TMI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82 Reaction Load and Fuselage Decel. (Calculated for 720)

Fig.5A-36

p. 5A.FIG-36

2

--- TOP SURFACE STRESS

---

BOTTOM SURFACE STRESS MAXIMUM COMPRESSIVE STRESS:; 5268 PSI r

HOOP STRESS

/",,---,_

}I (BOTTOM)

/'

---

~

.......~

MERIDIONAL STRESS

.....~-----

TOP BOTTOM

~L

-8

-2

-6 a

UJz en

~ou In Q..

I 0

~w a::...

In Wa::

Q....,

...u

~

Q..

~

o...

w

~a In In Wa::...

In

-10 o

0.1 0.2 TIME -

SECONDS 0.3 0.4 ra:imN~I..r 1MI Unit-l Update -1 7/82

p. 5A.FIG-37 Hoop and Meridional Stresses at 36 Inches from the Edge of the Load Area Fig.5A-37

r = 115.2"

~I\\ 1\\

tL

'\\

~

\\

~

\\

\\

1

~I MAXIMUM AVERAGE SHEAR STRESS ACROSS SECTION = 482 PSI SHEAR AT r = 145.2-= 354 PSI UL T1MATE SHEAR STRESS FROM CHAPTER 26 OF ACI 318 = \\I = 3.5~ +0.3 fpc v=3.5x 10.1 +0.3. 1600=128 PSI) 354 PSI OK la]!] Nuclear TMI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82

p. 5A.FIG-38 Average Shear Stress in the Dome at the Time t=0.20 Seconds, Wing and Engines Remain Atuched to FUHIaga Fig.5A-38

r =115.2"

~I' I'"

t:;L

'\\

~

\\

a::

\\

\\

/

II MAXIMUM AVERAGE SHEAR STRESS ACROSS Sf CTION =4&2 P~'

SHEAR AT, = U5.2"=354 PSI ULTIMATE SHEAR STRESS FROM CHAPTER 26 OF ACI 31S=v=3.5K +0.3 fpc v=3.5

• 70.7 +0.3. 1600=728 PSI) 354 PSI OK 0i!jNuclear TMI Unit-l Update -1 7/82

p. 5A.FIG-39 Average Shear Stress in the Dome at the Time t=0.20 Seconds, Wing and Engines Detached from Fuselage Fig.5A-39

.J uI Qo L

Iai!J Nuclear TMI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82

p. 5A.FIG-40 FEM Model-Radial Stresses Due to Prestress and Aircraft Fig.5A-40

/','"l

~

'V 0

\\)

Ci 0

o Update -1 7/82 rai!l Nuclear 1MI Unit-l o

Q o

0

~

0 I

0'0

()

,0 0

L

=r

--~==================================================================================~o~=-====-_.-

-_..---.--rta

~!*

~I r---------------------

~'

DOME SECT'ON

p. 5A.FIG-41 Radial Stresses Due to Prestress and Aircraft Impact Fig.5A-41

RADIAL TENSION ZONES HOOP AND MERIDIONAL COMPRESSION ZONE

- -~

_ ~ _~TENDON

- - ~--_.~

-& TENDON

~---7--------

G.. TEN DON ci<

~

'0-'

~-

lmmNuclear 1MI Unit-1 Update -1 7/82

p. 5A.FIG-42 Zones in Compression or Tension Due to Prestress of Aircraft Impact Fig.5A-42