ML13177A285
ML13177A285 | |
Person / Time | |
---|---|
Site: | Wolf Creek |
Issue date: | 06/30/2013 |
From: | Westinghouse |
To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
References | |
WCAP-17678-NP, Supp 1, Rev 1 | |
Download: ML13177A285 (99) | |
Text
A-141 Status: M N U Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: NK054 Equipment Class: (14) Distribution Panels Equipment
Description:
DIST 125 VDC Project: WCNOC SWEL Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): CTRL, 2016.00 ft, 3404 Manufacturer/Model:
Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Seismic Walkdown of an item of equipment on the SWEL. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of judgments and findings. Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
Anchorage
- 1. Is anchorage configuration verification required (i.e., is the item one of the 50% Yes of SWEL items requiring such verification)?
- 2. Is the anchorage free of bent, broken, missing or loose hardware? Yes
- 3. Is the anchorage free of corrosion that is more than mild surface oxidation? Yes
- 4. Is the anchorage free of visible cracks in the concrete near the anchors? Yes
- 5. Is the anchorage configuration consistent with plant documentation? (Note: Yes This question only applies if the item is one of the 50% for which an anchorage configuration verification is required.)
Verified per E-020-00009
- 6. Based on the above anchorage evaluations, is the anchorage free of Yes potentially adverse seismic conditions?
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
A-142 Status: M N U Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: NK054 Equipment Class: (14) Distribution Panels Equipment
Description:
DIST 125 VDC Interaction Effects
- 7. Are soft targets free from impact by nearby equipment or structures? Yes
- 8. Are overhead equipment, distribution systems, ceiling tiles and lighting, and Yes masonry block walls not likely to collapse onto the equipment?
- 9. Do attached lines have adequate flexibility to avoid damage? Yes 0
- 10. Based on the above seismic interaction evaluations, is equipment free of Yes potentially adverse seismic interaction effects?
Other Adverse Conditions
- 11. Have you looked for and found no adverse seismic conditions that could Yes adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment?
Comments Evaluated by: Hunter Young Date: 5/1/2013 Is-.-,*' : Tim Nealon 5/1/2013 0
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
A-143 Status: Y N U Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: NK054 Equipment Class: (14) Distribution Panels Equipment
Description:
DIST 125 VDC Photos NK054 0969 NKSNR (nq7N NKUb4 UV I1 NKUb4 U912 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement I June 2013 Revision 1
A-144 Status: NU@
Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: NK054 Equipment Class: (14) Distribution Panels Eniuinment Descnntinn: DIST 129 VDC NK054 0973 NK054 0974 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
A-145 Status: Y N U Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: NNO14 Equipment Class: (16) Inverters Equipment
Description:
7.5 KVA Project: WCNOC SWEL Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): CTRL, 2016.00 ft, 3404 Manufacturer/Model:
Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Seismic Walkdown of an item of equipment on the SWEL. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of judgments and findings. Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
Anchorage
- 1. Is anchorage configuration verification required (i.e., is the item one of the 50% Yes of SWEL items requiring such verification)?
- 2. Is the anchorage free of bent, broken, missing or loose hardware? Yes
- 3. Is the anchorage free of corrosion that is more than mild surface oxidation? Yes
- 4. Is the anchorage free of visible cracks in the concrete near the anchors? Yes
- 5. Is the anchorage configuration consistent with plant documentation? (Note: Yes This question only applies if the item is one of the 50% for which an anchorage configuration verification is required.)
Verified per M-766-01076
- 6. Based on the above anchorage evaluations, is the anchorage free of Yes potentially adverse seismic conditions?
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
A-146 Status: M N U Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: NNO14 Equipment Class: (16) Inverters Equipment
Description:
7.5 KVA Interaction Effects
- 7. Are soft targets free from impact by nearby equipment or structures? Yes
- 8. Are overhead equipment, distribution systems, ceiling tiles and lighting, and Yes masonry block walls not likely to collapse onto the equipment?
- 9. Do attached lines have adequate flexibility to avoid damage? Yes
- 10. Based on the above seismic interaction evaluations, is equipment free of Yes potentially adverse seismic interaction effects?
Other Adverse Conditions
- 11. Have you looked for and found no adverse seismic conditions that could Yes adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment?
Comments Evaluated by: Hunter Young Date: 5/1/2013 Tim Nealon 5/1/2013 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
A-147 Status: [ N U Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: NNO14 Equipment Class: (16) Inverters Equipment
Description:
7.5 KVA Photos NNU14 U1915 NNU14 UVh I NNO14 0978 NNO14 0979 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision I
A-148 Status: I-f N U 1 Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: NNO14 Equipment Class: (16) Inverters iment DescriDtion: 7.5 KVA NNO14 0981 NNU14 U932 NNO14 0983 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
A-149 Status: M N U V Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: NNO14 Equipment Class: (16) Inverters Fnii inmnant rf*laQrintinn- 7 r kVA NNU14 U954 NNO14 0985 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision I
A-150 Status: M N U Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: SE054B Equipment Class: (20) Instrumentation and Control Panels and Cabinets Equipment
Description:
W NUC INSTM NIS 2 Project: WCNOC SWEL Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): CTRL, 2047.50 ft, 3605 Manufacturer/Model:
Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Seismic Walkdown of an item of equipment on the SWEL. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of judgments and findings. Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
Anchorage
- 1. Is anchorage configuration verification required (i.e., is the item one of the 50% Yes of SWEL items requiring such verification)?
- 2. Is the anchorage free of bent, broken, missing or loose hardware? Yes
- 3. Is the anchorage free of corrosion that is more than mild surface oxidation? Yes
- 4. Is the anchorage free of visible cracks in the concrete near the anchors? Yes
- 5. Is the anchorage configuration consistent with plant documentation? (Note: Yes This question only applies if the item is one of the 50% for which an anchorage configuration verification is required.)
Anchorage documentationbrought in field did not reflect as-installed configuration. Verify whether as-installedconfiguration which was as-built in field meets CLB anchorage configuration documentation.
Licensing Basis Evaluation:As-installed configuration verified per NCR ISN21407EW againstDwg C-0008 (Ref. 22).
- 6. Based on the above anchorage evaluations, is the anchorage free of Yes WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement. 1 June 2013 Revision 1
A-151 Status: [ N U Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: SE054B Equipment Class: (20) Instrumentation and Control Panels and Cabinets Equipment
Description:
W NUC INSTM NIS 2 potentially adverse seismic conditions?
Interaction Effects
- 7. Are soft targets free from impact by nearby equipment or structures? Yes
- 8. Are overhead equipment, distribution systems, ceiling tiles and lighting, and Yes masonry block walls not likely to collapse onto the equipment?
- 9. Do attached lines have adequate flexibility to avoid damage? Yes
- 10. Based on the above seismic interaction evaluations, is equipment free of Yes potentially adverse seismic interaction effects?
Other Adverse Conditions
- 11. Have you looked for and found no adverse seismic conditions that could Yes adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment?
Cabinet internals could not be accessed during at-power walkdowns.
Internalswill be inspected during next bus outage.
Top of panel is bolted to adjacentpanel SDO55A. Verify whether bolting modification reconciled individualequipment qualification.
Licensing Basis Evaluation: Condition is analyzed per WCNOC Ca/c XX-FH-009-002. No adverse seismic concern.
Cabinet opened on 2/24/13: No adverse seismic conditions.
. Comments WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
A-152 Status: MN U Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: SE054B Equipment Class: (20) Instrumentation and Control Panels and Cabinets Equipment
Description:
W NUC INSTM NIS 2 Initial Issue, 11/15/12. Evaluators: H. Young & T. Nealon 5/1/13 issue updates Question 11.
Evaluated by: Hunter Young Date: 5/1/2013 Tim Nealon 5/1/2013 Photos SE054B 9-18 151 SE054B 9-18 152 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
A-153 Status: M N U Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: SE054B Equipment Class: (20) Instrumentation and Control Panels and Cabinets FnhiinmnPnt "P..qrintinn" W NI I IN5RTM NIR 9 SE054B 9-18 153 SE054B 9-18 154 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
A-154 Status: Y N U Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: SEO54B Equipment Class: (20) Instrumentation and Control Panels and Cabinets Fnliinm*nt frs__trintinn- W NI IC IK.NTA III 9 SE054B 9-18 157 SE054B 9-18 155 SE054B 9-18 158 SE054B 9-18 159 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
A-155 Status: M N U V Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: SE054B Equipment Class: (20) Instrumentation and Control Panels and Cabinets FI=ninmnnt 1"A-_rintinn- W NI IC. IIrlTMNl5q9 SE054B 9-18 160 SE054B 9-18 161 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision I I
A-156 Status: F N U Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: SENY061A Equipment Class: (20) Instrumentation and Control Panels and Cabinets Equipment
Description:
EXCORE NEUTRON DETECTOR AMPLIFIER Project: WCNOC SWEL Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): AUX, 2047.50 ft, UNK Manufacturer/Model:
Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Seismic Walkdown of an item of equipment on the SWEL. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of judgments and findings. Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
Anchorage
- 1. Is anchorage configuration verification required (i.e., is the item one of the 50% No of SWEL items requiring such verification)?
- 2. Is the anchorage free of bent, broken, missing or loose hardware? Yes
- 3. Is the anchorage free of corrosion that is more than mild surface oxidation? Yes
- 4. Is the anchorage free of visible cracks in the concrete near the anchors? Yes
- 5. Is the anchorage configuration consistent with plant documentation? (Note: Not Applicable This question only applies if the item is one of the 50% for which an anchorage configuration verification is required.)
- 6. Based on the above anchorage evaluations, is the anchorage free of Yes potentially adverse seismic conditions?
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
A-157 Status: [ N U O Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: SENY061A Equipment Class: (20) Instrumentation and Control Panels and Cabinets Equipment
Description:
EXCORE NEUTRON DETECTOR AMPLIFIER Interaction Effects
- 7. Are soft targets free from impact by nearby equipment or structures? Yes
- 8. Are overhead equipment, distribution systems, ceiling tiles and lighting, and Yes masonry block walls not likely to collapse onto the equipment?
- 9. Do attached lines have adequate flexibility to avoid damage? Yes
- 10. Based on the above seismic interaction evaluations, is equipment free of Yes potentially adverse seismic interaction effects?
Other Adverse Conditions
- 11. Have you looked for and found no adverse seismic conditions that could Yes adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment?
Cabinet internalscould not be accessed during at-power walkdowns.
Internals will be inspected during next bus outage.
Cabinet opened on 2/24/13. No hazards.
Comments Initial Issue, 11/15/12. Evaluators: H. Young & T. Nealon 5/1/13 issue updates Question 11.
Evaluated by: Hunter Young Date: 5/1/2013 Tim Nealon 5/1/2013 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
A-1 58 Status: [l] N Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: SENY061A Equipment Class: (20) Instrumentation and Control Panels and Cabinets Equipment
Description:
EXCORE NEUTRON DETECTOR AMPLIFIER Photos SENY061A 1036 SENY061A 1037 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision I
A-159 Status: Y N U Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: SENY061A Equipment Class: (20) Instrumentation and Control Panels and Cabinets Fni linmAnt Ipqrrintinn" EXCORE NEUTRON DETECTOR AMPLIFIER SENY061A 1039 SENY061A 9-19 408 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement I June 2013 Revision 1
A-160 S Ei Status: M N U Seismic Walkdown Checklist (SWC)
Equipment ID No.: SENY061A Equipment Class: (20) Instrumentation and Control Panels and Cabinets Equipment
Description:
EXCORE NEUTRON DETECTOR AMPLIFIER
'jt"NYUtf1A V-1U 411 SNYUb1A U-19 412 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision I
B-1 APPENDIX B AREA WALK-BY CHECKLISTS (AWCS)
This appendix shows only the AWCs from the at-power seismic walkdowns performed the week of September 17, 2012 that were revised plus the AWCs resulting from the refueling outage seismic walkdowns performed on February 24, 2013. The AWCs from the at-power seismic walkdowns that are not shown herein can be found in Appendix B of Reference 34.
B-2 Status: F N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area : AUX, 2047.5,1507 Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of judgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially Yes adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant Yes degraded conditions?
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and Yes HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g.,
condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial Yes interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
SGSO2B is flush with pyrocrete covering column to the East. Verification required to determine if essential vibration-sensitiveequipment is located within.
Licensing Basis Evaluation:
SGSO2B could not readily be determined to be without potentially adverse spatial interactionhazard. CR 66243 was generated by WCNOC to reconcile condition. Per CR #66243, a review of the panel determinedthat although the panel does contain relays that could potentially be vibration sensitive, the relays would only be requiredto function during post-accident sampling.
Momentary relay chatterduring a seismic event would not impact the ability of the analyzer to perform its design function or impactplant operation. The relays would not be permanently affected and work following the seismic event. No further action is required.
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-3
. Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area : AUX, 2047.5, 1507 Status: M N U
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes that could cause a fire in the area?
Noted flammable tanks West of GSPIOOOIB. Well-secured. No hazard.
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
Various temporary equipment due to outage. Scaffold is anchored, well-braced, and secured.
Noted un-chocked chemisty gas sampler. No credible interactionhazard,but corrected by Operationsimmediately.
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Yes adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
Comments Evaluated by: Hunter Young Date: 05-01-13
"*4K Timothy Nealon 05-01-13 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1 I
B-4 Status: [Y N U0 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area : AUX, 2047.5, 1507 Area # AUX, 2047 Area # AUX, 2047 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement I June 2013 Revision I
B-5 Status: MI N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area : AUX, 2047.5, 1507 Area # AUX, 2047 Area # AUX. 2047 Area # AUX, 2047 Area # AUX, 2047 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-6 Status: [ N Ui Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area : AUX, 2047.5, 1507 Area # AUX, 2047 Area # AUX, 2047 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-7 Status: M N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area : AUX, 2047.5, 1507 WK '"we Area # AUX, 2047 Area # AUX, 2047 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-8 Status: Y] N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area : AUX, 2047.5, 1507 Area # AUX, 2047 Area # AUX, 2047 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement I June 2013 Revision 1
B-9 Status: M N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area : AUX, 2047.5, 1507 Area # AUX, 2047 Area # AUX, 2047 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-I0 Status: M N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area: CTRL, 2016, 3404 Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of judgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially Yes adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant Yes degraded conditions?
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and Yes HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g.,
condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial Yes interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
Between NK04 & NK74, rigidconduit couplerbridges equipment gap.
Couplermounts to flexible panels and poses no seismic hazard.
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes that could cause a fire in the area?
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes a associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and w
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-11 Status: MI N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area : CTRL, 2016, 3404 temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Yes adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
Comments Evaluated by:
, 1;
ýýAC-- ý"_ýýI Hunter Young Date: 05-01-13
/"'K -,Timothy Nealon 05-01-13 Area # CTRL, 2016, 3404 1017 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-12 Status: YN U 0 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area : CTRL, 2016, 3404 CTRL,3404 1018 Area #2016, Area # CTRL, 2016, 3404 1018 Area ;F L; i KL, ZIUIb, i4U4 IUmI9 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement I June 2013 Revision 1
B-1 3 Status: M N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area: RX, 2000, 2301B Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of judgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially Yes adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant Yes degraded conditions?
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and Yes HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g.,
condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial Yes interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes that could cause a fire in the area?
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-14 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Status: yI] NUO Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area: RX, 2000, 23011B temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
Scaffold & temporary items within zone of influence due to outage. Items will be removed prior to startup. No hazard.
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Yes adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
Comments Evaluated by: Hunter Young Date: 05-01-13 Timothy Nealon 05-01-13 Area # RX, 2000, 2301B 1086 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-15 Status: EYI N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area: RX, 2000, 2301B Area # RX, 2000, 2301B 1085 Area # KX, ZUUU, l3U18 1UST Area # RX, 2000, 2301B 1088 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-16 Status: M N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area: RX, 2000, 2301B Area & RX. 2000_ 201R InRQ Area # RX, 2000, 2301B 1090 Area # RX, 2000, 2301B 1091 Area # RX, 2000, 2301B 1092 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-17 Status: M N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area: RX, 2000, 2301 B Area # RX, 2000, 2301B 1093 Area # RX, 2000, 2301B 1094 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-1 8 Status: M N U' Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area: RX, 2000, HBHV7176 Proximity Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of judgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially Yes adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant Yes degraded conditions?
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and Yes HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g.,
condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial Yes interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes that could cause a fire in the area?
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Y associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-19 Status: M N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area : RX, 2000, HBHV7176 Proximity temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
Scaffold & temporary items within zone of influence due to outage. Items will be removed priorto startup.No hazard.
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Yes adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
Comments Evaluated by: Hunter Young Date: 05-01-13
"/t*.. TimothyNealon 05-01-13 Area # RX, 2000, HBHV7176 Proximity 1099 Area # RX, 2000, HBHV7176 Proximity 1102 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-20 Status: Y N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area : RX, 2000, HBHV7176 Proximity Area # RX. 2000. HBHV7176 Prximitv 1103 Arma A RX 9000 HRHV717A Prnximitv 1104d Area # RX, 2000, HBHV7176 Proximity 1105 Area ;F iv, zuuu, mtsmv1t~
i trroximiTy 11 ut WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision I
B-21 Status: M N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area: RX, 2026, 2403 Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of judgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially Yes adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant Yes degraded conditions?
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and Yes HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g.,
condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
Floor-to-ceilingcable tray HSS supports with socket at top allowing vertical movementt. No hazard.
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial Yes interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes that could cause a fire in the area?
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes V
associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-22 Status: E- NU@
Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area : RX, 2026, 2403 temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
Temp items and scaffolding due to outage. Will be removed prior to startup.
No Hazard
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Yes adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
Comments Evaluated by: Hunter Young Date: 05-01-13 Timothy Nealon 05-01-13 Area # RX, 2026, 2403 1125 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-23
. Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area: RX, 2026, 2403 Status: [Y] N U Area # RX, 2026, 2403 1126 Area # RX, 2026, 2403 1127 Area # RX, 2026, 2403 1128 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-24 Status:
S
- N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area: RX, 2026, 2403 Area # RX, 2021, 24U3 1129 Area *h x, 2U~b, 2U*4UI3 113(2 Area # RX, 2026, 2403 1131 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement I June 2013 Revision 1
B-25 Status: M N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area: RX, 2026, 2404 Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of judgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially Yes adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant Yes degraded conditions?
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and Yes HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g.,
condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
Floor-to-ceiling cable tray HSS supports with sockett at top to allow verticals movement. No hazard.
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial Yes interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes that could cause a fire in the area?
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-26 Status: Ei N@e Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area : RX, 2026, 2404 temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Yes adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
Comments Evaluated by: Hunter Young Date: 05-01-13
- -.-. Timothy Nealon 05-01-13 Area # RX, 2026, 2404 1113 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-27 Status: M N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area: RX, 2026, 2404 Area # RX, 2026, 2404 1114 Area ;F KA, ZU:b, Z4U4 1115 Area # RX, 2026, 2404 1116 Area # RX, 2026, 2404 1117 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-28 Status: E-] N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area: RX, 2047, 2502 Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of judgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially Yes adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant Yes degraded conditions?
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and Yes HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g.,
condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)? 0
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial Yes interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes that could cause a fire in the area?
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions Yes associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-29 Status: M N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area : RX, 2047, 2502 temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
Temporary items and scaffolding due to outage. Will be removed priorto startup. No hazard.
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Yes adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
Comments Evaluated by: Hunter Young Date: 05-01-13
- '*' **- Timothy Nealon 05-01-13
- s7n Area # RX, 2047, 2502 1136 Area # RX, 2047, 2502 1138 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
B-30 Status: M N Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
U.
- RX, 2047, 2502 Area # *X,2047, 2502 1142 Area # RX, 2047, 2502 1141 0
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement I June 2013 Revision 1
B-31 Status: M N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location (Bldg, Elev, Room/Area): Area : RX, 2047, 2502 Area # RX 2047 27;l2 1141 Area # RX, 2047, 2502 1144 Area # RX, 2047, 2502 1145 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
C-1 APPENDIX C LICENSING BASIS EVALUATIONS
SUMMARY
This appendix shows a complete updated summary of the Licensing Basis Evaluations for the at-power seismic walkdowns performed the week of September 17, 2012 and the refueling outage seismic walkdowns performed on February 24, 2013.
0 WCAP- 17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
0 -2 Item Item Tag/ID Component
- or Room No. Description Issue Description Status Resolution 1 EGLT0002 CCW SURGE TK B SWT observed scaffolding in zone of influence Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
of level transmitter with no bracing or wall SWT received WCNOC Scaffolding anchorage at top bay (3 bays total). Members Evaluation (Scaffold Request # 12-SO189, appear suitable to withstand moment so as to Work Order # 11-345393 (Reference 24))
preclude collapse, but verification is required that validates scaffold installation in from scaffolding documentation on site. accordance with procedure. SWT concludes from engineering judgment that scaffolding is acceptable given member capacity in bending and light loading due to single bay at the top. No adverse seismic concern.
2 EKJ03B INTERCOOLER SWT could not verify 1-1/4" anchor bolts in Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
HEAT EXCHANGER field. Verify from CLB documentation. AB-83 bolts verified as 1-1/4" per C-IC51 11 (Reference 25).
3 FKJ02C KKJO1B AIR SWT could not verify 3/4" double-nutted Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
INTAKE FILTER anchor bolts in field. Verify from CLB AB-69 anchor bolt verified as 3/4" and documentation. double nutted per C-0033 (Reference 26).
4 GNPT0934 CONTAINMENT Anchorage documentation brought in field was Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
ATMOSPHERE not sufficient to verify anchorage. Verify SWT received M-771-00048-W04 whether as-installed configuration which was (Reference 27), which calls out 4 no. 3/8" as-built in field consisting of 4 no. 3/8" bolts bolts for mounting. Anchorage configuration meets CLB anchorage configuration is verified.
documentation.
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
C-3 Item Item Tag/ID Component
- or Room No. Description Issue Description Status Resolution 5 KKJO1B STANDBY DIESEL SWT observed an anchor bolt with 10" Y Licensing Basis Evaluation: Operability (GENERATOR) projection whereas 8" required per CLB Evaluation KJ-12-015 (Reference 28) via CR documentation. Verification was required to #57391 determined that the as-installed determine whether condition was previously condition is not in violation of the seismic analyzed or condition is acceptable as- licensing basis given that all bolts undergo installed. zero net uplift under all design load combinations. CR #57391 is tracking this observation.
Update Submittal Report CR Status Update:
Per WCNOC, CR #57391 generated WO 12-357965 to perform maintenance during the B EDG TSEO.
6 NE002 STANDBY #2 Component is on the common skid with Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
KKJO1B (rule of the box) and therefore has the See resolution for KKJO1B above.
same anchorage concerns. (see Issue CR #57391 is tracking this observation.
Description for KKJO IB.)
Update Submittal Report CR Status Update:
Per WCNOC, CR #57391 generated WO 12-357965 to perform maintenance during the B EDG TSEO.
7 NF039B CONT SHED/SEQ Adjacent cabinets are flush. Concern regarding Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
CH 4 LOGIC potential sensitive equipment changing state SWT review of WCNOC Calculation due to chatter. Check that cabinets are XX-FH-009 (Reference 23) confirms that attached. cabinet NF039B and adjacent cabinets NF039A and NF039C have been analyzed for proximity concerns with adjacent cabinets and are therefore acceptable.
V .7678-NP, Supplement 1 Ju Re
0 4 Item Item Tag/ID Component
- or Room No. Description Issue Description Status Resolution 8 NGO04C 480 VAC Observed 1-7/8" clearance from back of MCC Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
(drip shield) to concrete wall. There is concern Using a conservative lower bound frequency that the MCC could close the gap in SSE event estimate of 5 Hz, a modal shape factor (SF) and cause equipment to malfunction, of 1.6 for cantilever action, and taking the Verification needed to ensure gap is sufficient peak spectral acceleration of approx. Ig at given MCC flexibility (gap oriented in weak the 2047.5 ft elevation for 3% damping direction) and high elevation of the Aux (conservative), the upper-bound Building (2047.5'). displacement is 6.3 in (= 1.6*386.4 in/s 2
- Ig
/ (2*pi*5 Hz) 2). Therefore, a 1-7/8" gap is acceptable. This conclusion is based on the use of the component displacement equation described on pg 5-1 and obtained from Reference 22.
9 RP081A/B SUBCOOLING SWT noted same top support bolting Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
MONITORING modification as for SB041. Verify whether Condition is analyzed per WCNOC CABINET modification documents the qualification Calculation XX-FH-009 (Reference 23). No reconciliation of individual equipment. adverse seismic concern.
10 SA036E ESFAS CH4 LOGIC Adjacent cabinets are 1/16" apart. Check that Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
CABINET cabinets are bolted together so as to preclude SWT review of WCNOC Calculation chatter. XX-FH-009 (Reference 23) confirms that cabinet SA036E has been analyzed for proximity concerns with adjacent cabinets and is therefore acceptable.
11 SB032C W SS PROT SYS SWT noted a modification to add top support Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
OUT 1 TRN to fasten SBD32D to SBD33A. Verify whether Condition is analyzed per WCNOC modification documents the qualification Calculation XX-FH-009 (Reference 23). No reconciliation of individual equipment. adverse seismic concern.
12 SB032D W SS PROT SYS SWT noted a modification to add top support Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
OUT 2 TRN to fasten SBD32D to SBD33A. Verify whether Condition is analyzed per WCNOC modification documents the qualification Calculation XX-FH-009 (Reference 23). No reconciliation of individual equipment. adverse seismic concern.
WCAP- 17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
C-5 Item Item Tag/ID Component
- or Room No. Description Issue Description Status Resolution 13 SB041 W PROCESS 1.) SWT noted cable tray with 1/4" vertical Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
ANALOG clearance to top of cabinet support 1.) Inspection of vertical response spectra at PROTECTION SET modification. Concern is that differential this level confirms that 1/4" is more than CAB-04 movement between the floors can cause adequate separation for vertically rigid equipment to spatially interact and cause components. No adverse seismic concern.
change of state in SB041. Both pieces can be 2.) Condition is analyzed per WCNOC Calc taken as rigid in the vertical direction. Verify XX-FH-009 (Reference 23). No adverse from In-Structure Response Spectra whether seismic concern.
clearance is acceptable.
2.) Cabinets RPO 18, SB041, and SB042 are bolted at their tops. This appears to be a modification not included in original equipment qualifications. Verify whether modification documents the qualification reconciliation of individual equipment.
14 SB079 RPV LEVEL INSTR Anchorage documentation brought in field did Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
SYS PROC PROT not reflect as-installed configuration. Verify Detail 5 on WCNOC Dwg C-0008 SYS whether as-installed configuration which was (Reference 29) indicates an acceptable as-built in field meets CLB anchorage anchorage weld pattern of 3/16" fillet welds, configuration documentation. 2" long at 8" o.c. The as-installed configuration recorded in the field meets this requirement; therefore, there is no adverse seismic condition.
15 SE054B W NUC INSTM NIS 1.) Anchorage documentation brought in field Y 1.) Licensing Basis Evaluation: As-installed 2 did not reflect as-installed configuration. configuration could be verified per NCR Verify whether as-installed configuration ISN21407EW against Dwg C-0008 (Ref.
which was as-built in field meets CLB 22). 2.) Licensing Basis Evaluation:
anchorage configuration documentation. Condition is analyzed per WCNOC Calc 2.) Top of panel is bolted to adjacent panel XX-FH-009 (Reference 23). No adverse SDO55A. Verify whether bolting modification seismic concern.
reconciled individual equipment qualification.
.7678-NP, Supplement 1 Ju Re
0-6 Item Item Tag/ID Component
- or Room No. Description Issue Description Status Resolution 16 SGK04B CONTROL ROOM Cannot visually identify 2 interior anchor bolts Y Licensing Basis Evaluation: Follow-up A/C UNITS on N side of AlHU. Bolts may be covered in walkdown performed by WCNOC revealed concrete. Action required to verify whether the the interior anchor bolts installed in bolts are present. accordance with configuration documentation. Photographs (located in SWC) were reviewed by the SWT and confirmed to be acceptable. No issue.
17 SGK05B CLASS 1E ELEC SWT noted tubing/piping support mounted off Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
EQUIP A/C/ UNIT of AHU that does not appear to be included in SWT inspected WCNOC DCP #09879 original equipment qualification (possibly from (Reference 30), which states that the later modification). Verify whether connecting equipment between the more modification is documented and AHU recently installed condenser and the AHU equipment qualification reconciliation was does not invalidate the individual equipment addressed. seismic qualifications and that the qualification of the AHU remains valid.
Therefore, no adverse seismic concern.
18 TEGO0B CCW SURGE SWT observed scaffolding in zone of influence Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
TANK B of the tank soft targets (site glass) with no SWT received WCNOC Scaffolding bracing or wall anchorage at top bay (3 bays Evaluation (Scaffold Request # 12-SO 189, total). Members appear suitable to withstand Work Order # 11-345393 (Reference 24))
moment so as to preclude collapse, but that validates scaffold installation in verification is required from scaffolding accordance, with procedure. SWT concludes documentation on site. Also, scaffolding is from engineering judgment that scaffolding braced to tank legs. While the tank legs and is acceptable given negligible additional anchorage appear adequate to withstand loading due to SSE on rugged tank legs.
relatively light added scaffold lateral load, verification is required to confirm equipment qualification for tank was reconciled.
19 XNG02 CLASS 1E LOAD SWT observed bolting from XNG02 to Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
CENTER adjacent and flush cabinet NG002. While it The SWT concluded that the presence of TRANSFORMER was confirmed that adequate bolting was bolting is not required to preclude seismic provided to preclude chatter, one bolt hole was chatter; therefore no adverse seismic noted to be empty without a bolt. Verify condition.
whether bolt is required from configuration documentation.
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement I June 2013 Revision 1
C-7 Item Item Tag/ID Component
- or Room No. Description Issue Description Status Resolution 20 DGB Rm Area Walk-By 1.) SWT noted fire piping is flexibly supported Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
5201 (rod-hung) with Victaulic couplings. Verify 1.) Per WCNOC Specification M-650 whether 2:1 adequacy from qualification (Reference 3 1), fire piping in diesel documents. 2.) Noted lighting supported by its generator building is designed for Seismic own conduit spanning horizontally. Concern is Category 2:1 qualifications; therefore no that flexibly support light could overstress adverse seismic condition.
conduit and fall. Verify whether lighting 2.) Re-inspection of photos shows conduit is support is adequate. galvanized rigid conduit, which has significant bending capacity to resist vertical loading of light. No adverse seismic concern.
21 AUX Rm Area Walk-By SWT observed scaffolding in zone of influence Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
1502 of safety-related equipment with no bracing or SWT received WCNOC Scaffolding wall anchorage at top bay (3 bays total). Evaluation (Scaffold Request # 12-SO 189, Members appear suitable to withstand Work Order # 11-345393 (Reference 24))
movement so as to preclude collapse, but that validates scaffold installation in verification is required from scaffolding accordance with procedure. No adverse documentation on site. seismic concern.
.7678-NP, Supplement 1 Ju Re
S 0-8 Item Item Tag/ID Component
- or Room No. Description Issue Description Status Resolution 22 CTRL Rm Area Walk-By Observed portable table approx. 3/4" from N Licensing Basis Evaluation:
3601 control panel. Table could rock and impact the No qualification document was identified to panel. Shift manager indicdted that justify presence of table in proximity to Engineering qualified the table for SSE. Verify safety-related control panel equipment.
whether the table has seismic calculation CR #57419 was issued by WCNOC to justifying placement where it was located or determine if the table has been seismically remove to a safe location. evaluated for this location as well as documenting removal of table to a safe location.
Update Submittal Report CR Status Update:
CR #57419 determined the metal table to be an Unstable Non-Plant item, and the equipment was removed until it could be proved acceptable. CR #68288 was generated by WCNOC on 4/25/13 and re-assessed the table to conclude that the item was incorrectly classified and is a Stable Non-Plant item.
23 CTRL Rm Area Walk-By General note for equipment w/ modified top Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
3605 fasteners added to rigidly connect tops of Bolted connections of cabinets in the control cabinets. Verify whether modifications room area is analyzed per WCNOC reconciled individual equipment qualifications. Calculation XX-FH-009 (Reference 23). No adverse seismic concern.
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
C-9 Item Item Tag/ID Component
- or Room No. Description Issue Description Status Resolution 24 AUX Rm Area Walk-By Observed vertical HSS cable tray supports Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
1409 welded to the floor and connected to the ceiling HSS section verified to only react lateral above. Connection at ceiling appears to be a load at its top connection per Detail 3 on C-jacket connection that only transfers lateral 1408 (Reference 32). Therefore, there is no load. If the ceiling connection transfers vertical adverse seismic condition.
load, there is a concern the support's connections will fail in an SSE event due to differential floor displacement. Verification is required to determine whether either the ceiling connection transfers vertical load or if the support and its connections are designed for the vertical load transfer due to SSE.
25 NK024 125 VDC NO 4 E-051-00059 (Reference 33) specifies 6 no. 6" N Licensing Basis Evaluation:
long fillet welds whereas 6 no. 2" long fillet No CLB documentation could readily welds provided in field. Verify whether as- validate the as-installed configuration. CR installed configuration meets CLB anchorage #65012 generated by WCNOC to reconcile configuration documentation, configuration. Per CR #65012, the field configuration was confirmed by WCNOC to be in conformance with seismic qualification report E-051-00052. The CR also states that the drawing was revised to add note stating that the floor mount welds are in accordance with seismic qualification test report E-051-00052 as well as changing the 6" callout to 2" callout.
V i17678-NP, Supplement I JU Revs
0 Item Item Tag/ID Component
- or Room No. Description Issue Description Status Resolution 26 AUX Rm Area Walk-By Cabinet SGS02B is flush with fireproofing Y Licensing Basis Evaluation:
1507 covering column to the East. Verification SGS02B could not readily be determined to required to determine if essential vibration- be without potentially adverse spatial sensitive equipment is located within, interaction hazard. CR #66243 generated by WCNOC to reconcile condition. Per CR
- 66243, a review of the panel determined that although the panel does contain relays that could potentially be vibration sensitive, the relays would only be required to function during post-accident sampling. Momentary relay chatter during a seismic event would not impact the ability of the analyzer to perform its design function or impact plant operation. The relays would not be permanently affected and work following the seismic event. No further action is required.
KEY:
Y - The Seismic Licensing Basis is satisfied and no adverse seismic condition exists.
N - As a result of the walkdown inspection, a corrective action was required.
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
D-1 APPENDIX D PEER REVIEW CHECKLISTS There was no change to this appendix. The SWEL Peer Review Checklist can be found in Appendix D of Reference 34.
June2013 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement I June 2013 Revision I
E-I APPENDIX E BASE LIST 1 The Base List 1 components for the refueling outage seismic walkdowns performed on February 24, 2013 are the same as those for the at-power seismic walkdowns performed the week of September 17, 2012, except that components belonging to system type PN (Instrument AC Power) were removed since system type PN was identified as non safety-related. This appendix shows the single page of the Base List I table presented in Appendix E of Reference 34 requiring a revision. Please refer to Appendix E of Reference 34 for the Base List 1 components not identified herein.
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
E-2 Wolf Creek Base List 1 (cont.)
Base List 1 Screen No. 1 Screen No. 3 Item Walkdown (SC - I Licensing Screen No. 2 (Safety Function Number Equipment Description Buildingt 2
- Basis?) (Screens In?) Support(")
601 TKJ02C START AIR TANK D/G DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC DHR CF 602 TKJ02D START AIR TANK D/G DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC DHR CF 603 TKJ04A D/G A AUX LUBE OIL TANK DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC DHR CF 604 TKJ04B D/G B AUX LUBE OIL TANK DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC DHR CF 605 XNGO1 CLASS lE LOAD CENTER TRANSFORMER CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC DHR CF 606 XNG02 CLASS 1E LOAD CENTER TRANSFORMER CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC DHR CF 607 XNG03 CLASS IE LOAD CENTER TRANSFORMER CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC DHR CF 608 XNG04 CLASS I E LOAD CENTER TRANSFORMER CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC DHR CF 609 XNG05 FEED MCC NG05E ESW Yes Yes IC DHR 610 XNG06 FEEDS MCC NG06E ESW Yes Yes IC DHR Notes:
I RC= Reactivity Control, PC= Reactor Coolant Pressure Control, IC = Reactor Coolant Inventory Control, DHR = Decay Heat Removal (including Ultimate Heat Sink),
and CF = Containment Function 2 AUX= Auxiliary Building, CB= Control Building, CC=Communication Corridor, DGB= Diesel Generator Building, ESW= Essential Service Water Building, RB=
Reactor Building, YARD= Yard Ju V 17678-NP, Supplement 1 Re
F-I APPENDIX F SWEL 1 The SWEL 1 components for the refueling outage seismic walkdowns performed on February 24, 2013 are the same as those for the at-power seismic walkdowns performed the week of September 17, 2012, except that component XPN08B (120 V Instrument AC Transformer; SWEL Item 112) was removed. XPN08B was removed because it belongs to system type PN (Instrument AC Power),
which was identified as non safety-related. This appendix shows the complete SWEL 1 list for the refueling outage seismic walkdowns. The SWEL 1 components for the at-power seismic walkdowns are summarized in Appendix F of Reference 34.
WCAP- 17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
F-2 SWEL 1 Screen #4 Sample Considerations Screen #1 Screen #3 SWEL (SC - I Screen #2 (Safety Major new or IPEEE Walkdown Item Walkdown Licensing (Screens Function Equipment System replacement Environment vulnerability Deferred to Number Equipment Description Building Basis?) In?) Support) Class Type equipment? (Temp, 'F) enhancement? Outage?
I ABHV0014 LOOP-I MAIN AUX Yes Yes PC DHR POV (7) AB X hot/dry STEAM ISOLATION VALVE 2 ABPT0002 STM GEN B AUX Yes Yes PC DHR Inst. Racks (18) AB mild/dry STEAMLINE PRESSURE 3 ABPV0002 SG B ATMOSPHERIC AUX Yes Yes PC DHR POV (7) AB hot/dry RELIEF VLV 4 AEFV0039 EBBOIA AUX Yes Yes PC DHR POV (7) AE X hot/dry FEEDWATER ISOLATION VALVE 5 AELT0502 STM GEN B WIDE RB Yes Yes PC DHR Inst. Racks (18) AE hot/humid Yes RANGE 6 AELT0519 STM GEN LEVEL A RB Yes Yes PC DHR Inst. Racks (18) AE hot/humid Yes NARROW RANGE 7 ALHV0030 ESW TO MDAFW AUX Yes Yes PC DHR VALVE (8) AL PUMP B 6" BTFL VLV W/LIMITQ 8 BBLISI321 RV SUBCOOLING AUX Yes Yes RC Inst. Racks (18) BB mild/dry MONITOR TRN B 9 BBPT0456 PRESSURIZER RB Yes Yes PC Inst. Racks(18) BB Yes PRESSURE 10 BGFCV0121 CENTRIFUGAL CHG AUX Yes Yes RC PC IC POV (7) BG hot/dry PMP FLOW CONTROL II BGHV8105 CHARGING PUMPS AUX Yes Yes PC IC CF MOV (8) BG mild/dry TO REGEN HX/CTMT ISO 12 BGHV8152 LETDOWN SYSTEM AUX Yes Yes IC CF POV (7) BG mild/dry CONTAINMENT ISO VLV 13 BLHV8047 REACTOR M/U AUX Yes Yes IC CF POV (7) BL mild/dry WATER CONTAINMENT ISO VM17678-NP, Supplement I JU Re
a .3 SWEL 1 (cont.)
Screen #4 Sample Considerations Screen #1 Screen #3 SWEL (SC - I Screen #2 (Safely Major new or IPEEE Walkdown Item Walkdown Licensing (Screens Function Equipment System replacement Environment vulnerability Deferred to Number Equipment Description Building Basis?) In?) Support) Class Type equipment? (Temp. IF) enhancement? Outage?
14 BMHV0002 SG B BLOWDOWN AUX Yes Yes PC IC CF POV (7) BM hot/dry AFAS ISO 15 BNHV0003 RWST SUPPLY TO AUX Yes Yes CF MOV (8) BN hot/dry CTMT SPRAY PUMP B1 16 BNLT0931 RWST LEVEL YRD Yes Yes RC IC Inst. Racks (18) BN hot/humid TRANSMITTER (2) DHR 17 BNVOOI I RWST OUTLET ISO AUX Yes Yes RC IC (8) BN VALVE DHR 18 CGMOIB DIESEL GENERATOR DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC Fans (9) GM hot/humid BLDG SUPPLY FAN DHR 19 EEGOI B COMPONENT COOL AUX Yes Yes RC PC IC Heat EG mild/dry WATER HEAT DHR Exchangers (21)
EXCHANGER 20 EF156 ESW CONTROL ESW Yes Yes RC PC IC Control Panel EF hot/dry PANEL DHR CF (20) 21 EFHV0024 ESW B/SERVICE CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC MOV (8) EF X mild/dry WATER CROSS DHR CF CONNECT VALVE 22 EFHVO040 ESW TRAIN B TO SW CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC MOV (8) EF X mild/dry CROSS CONNECT DHR CF VALVE 23 EFHVO052 ESW B TO CCW HX B AUX Yes Yes RC PC IC MOV (8) EF DHR CF 24 EFHVO098 ESW PUMP B ESW Yes Yes RC PC IC MOV (8) EF hot/humid DISCHARGE AIR DHR CF RELEASE VALVE 25 EFTE0062 ESW B TEMPT TO CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC Temp. Sensor EF mild/dry POWER BLOCK DHRCF (t19) 26 EGHVO016 CCW TRAIN B AUX Yes Yes DHR MOV (8) EG X mild/dry RETURN ISO VALVE 27 EGHV0102 CCW TO RHR HX B AUX Yes Yes DHR MOV (8) EG mild/dry ISO 28 EGLT0002 CCW SURGE TK B AUX Yes Yes DHR Inst. Racks (18) EG mild/dry WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
F-4 SWEL 1 (cont.)
Screen #4 Sample Considerations Screen #1 Screen #3 SWEL (SC - I Screen #2 (Safety Major new or IPEEE Walkdown Item Walkdown Licensing (Screens Function Equipment System replacement Environment vulnerability Deferred to Number Equipment Description Building Basis?) In?) Support) Class Type equipment? (Temp, °F) enhancement? Outage?
29 EGTE0032 CCW HX B OUTLET AUX Yes Yes RC DHR Temp. Sensor EG mild/dry TEMP (19) 30 EGTV0030 CCW HX B TEMP CV AUX Yes Yes RC DHR POV (7) EG mild/dry WAFER BTTFLY VLV 31 EJFCV061I RHR PUMP B AUX Yes Yes DHR MOV (8) EJ hot/dry MINIFLOW VALVE 32 EJFIS0611 RHR PMP PEJOIB AUX Yes Yes DHR Inst. Racks (18) EJ mild/dry MINIFLOW CONTROL DISCHARGE 33 EJHV8809B RHR TO ACCUM INJ AUX Yes Yes DHR MOV (8) EJ mild/dry LOOPS 3 & 4 ISO VLV 34 EKJ03B INTERCOOLER DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC Heat KJ X hot/humid HEAT EXCHANGER DHR CF Exchangers (21) 35 EKJO4B LUBE OIL COOLER DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC Heat KJ X hot/humid DHR CF Exchangers (21) 36 EKJ06B DIESEL JACKET DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC Heat KJ X hot/humid WATER HEAT DHRCF Exchangers (21)
EXCHANGER 37 EMFT0917B CCP B TO BIT FLOW AUX Yes Yes RC IC Inst. Racks (18) EM mild/chemical TRANSMITTER DHR 38 EMHV8814B SI PUMP B RETURN AUX Yes Yes RCIC MOV (8) EM hot/dry TO RWST ISO DHR VALVE 39 EMHV8923B SAFETY INJECTION AUX Yes Yes IC DHR MOV (8) EM hot/dry PUMP B SUCT ISO VLV 40 EPHV8808B ACCUMULATOR RB Yes Yes DHR MOV (8) EP hot/humid Yes TANK B OUTLET ISO VALVE 41 FC0219 LOCAL CONTROL AUX Yes Yes PC DHR Control Panel FC X hot/dry PANEL FOR TD AFW (20)
PUMP 7678-NP, Supplement I Ju Re
a 0-5 SWEL 1 (Cont.)
Screen #4 Sample Considerations Screen #1 Screen #3 SWEL (SC - I Screen #2 (Safety Major new or IPEEE Walkdown Item Walkdown Licensing (Screens Function Equipment System replacement Environment vulnerability Deferred to Number Equipment Description Building Basis?) In?) Support) Class Type equipment? (Temp. *F) enhancement? Outage?
42 FCHV0312 AUX FW PUMP AUX Yes Yes PC DHR MOV (8) FC hot/dry TURBINE MECH TRIP/THROT VLV 43 FEF02B ESW SELF-CLEAN ESW Yes Yes RC PC IC Other (0) EF X hot/dry STRAIN. (MTR OP.-IN DHR CF MOV PROG.W 44 FKJ02C KKJOIB AIR INTAKE DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC Other (0) KJ hot/humid FILTER DHR CF 45 GKV0766 SGK04B WATER CB Yes Yes RC PC IC MOV (8) GK mild/dry REGULATING DHR CF VALVE 46 GKV0768 SGKO5B WATER CB Yes Yes RC PC IC MOV (8) GK cool/dry Yes REGULATING DHR CF VALVE 47 GMHZO019 DSL GEN RM EXH DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC Other (0) GM hot/humid DMPR B, GMDOOIO DHR CF 48 GMTE001 I DIESEL GEN VENT DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC Temp. Sensor GM hot/humid SUPPLY FAN I B DHR CF (19) 49 GMTZOO I lB ACT FOR DG VENT DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC Other (0) GM hot/humid SUPPLY FAN DHR CF DAMPER GMD0007 50 GNPT0934 CONTAINMENT RB Yes Yes CF Inst. Racks (18) GN mild/dry Yes ATMOSPHERE 51 GNV0002 CTMT COOLER B RB Yes Yes CF POV (7) GN X hot/humid Yes ESW OUTLET FLOW CONTROL VLV 52 GSHV0021 H2 PURGE OUTER AUX Yes Yes CF MOV (8) GS mild/dry CTMT ISO BUTT VLV 53 GTRE031 CTMT ATMOSHERE AUX Yes Yes CF Inst. Racks (18) GT mild/dry RADIATION MONITOR 54 HBHV7176 RCDT PUMPS DISCH RB Yes Yes CF POV (7) HB Yes HDR INSIDE CTMT ISO 55 JELT0021 EMER FUEL OIL DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC Inst. Racks (18) JE hot/humid DAY TK B LEV DHR CF WCAP- 17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
F-6 SWEL I (cont.)
Screen #4 Sample Considerations Screen #1 Screen #3 SWEL (SC - I Screen #2 (Safety Major new or IPEEE Walkdown Item Walkdown Licensing (Screens Function Equipment System replacement Environment vulnerability Deferred to Number Equipment Description Building Basis?) In?) Support) Class Type equipment? (Temp, 'F) enhancement? Outage?
56 KAPCV0103 TKA05 OUTLET AUX Yes Yes DHR POV (7) KA mild/dry PRESSURE CONTROL VALVE 57 KJ0122 GAUGE PANEL DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC Control Panel KJ hot/humid DHRCF (20) 58 KKJ0IB STANDBY DIESEL DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC Eng. Gen. (17) KJ hot/humid (GENERATOR) DHR CF 59 LFFV0096 CTMT NOR SUMPS AUX Yes Yes CF POV (7) LF mild/dry TO FLR DRN TK OUTSIDE CTMT ISO 60 NB002 4.16 KV BUS # CB Yes Yes RC PC IC Med. Volt NB cool/dry Yes DHR CF Swgr. (3) 61 NB00213 CTRL BLDG LC NG02 CB Yes Yes RC PC IC Med. Volt NB Yes SWGR BRKR DHR CF Swgr. (3) 62 NE002 STANDBY #2 DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC Eng. Gen. (17) NE hot/humid DHR CF 63 NF039B CONT SHED/SEQ CH CB Yes Yes RC PC IC Control Panel NF cool/dry 4 LOGIC DHR CF (20) 64 NG002 480 VAC CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC Low Volt Swgr. NG cool/dry X Yes DHRCF (2) 65 NG00201 MAIN BREAKER CB Yes Yes RC PC IC Low Volt Swgr. NG cool/dry Yes DHRCF (2) 66 NG00206 NG02A FDR BRKR CB Yes Yes RC PC IC Low Volt Swgr. NG cool/dry Yes DHRCF (2) 67 NG002B 480 VAC MOTOR AUX Yes Yes RC PC IC MCC (I) NG mild/dry Yes CONTROL CENTER DHR CF 68 NG004C 480 VAC AUX Yes Yes RC PC IC MCC (I) NG mild/dry Yes DHR CF 69 NG006E 480 VAC ESW Yes Yes RC PC IC MCC (I) NG hot/dry Yes DHR CF 70 NK004 125 VDC BUS CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC Dist. Panel (14) NK cool/dry Yes SWITCHBOARD DHR CF 71 NK012 125-VDC NO.2 60- CBtCC Yes Yes RC PC IC Battery Rack NK cool/dry CELL BATTERY DHRCF (15)
. 17678-NP, Supplement I S Ju Re
S 07 SWEL I (cont.)
Screen #4 Sample Considerations Screen #1 Screen #3 SWEL (SC - I Screen #2 (Safety Major new or IPEEE Walkdown Item Walkdown Licensing (Screens Function Equipment System replacement Environment vulnerability Deferred to Number Equipment Description Building Basis?) In?) Support) Class Type equipment? (Temp, *F) enhancement? Outage?
72 NK014 125-VDC NO.4 60- CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC Battery Rack NK cool/dry CELL BATTERY DHR CF (15) 73 NK024 125 VDC NO 4 CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC Battery Chg NK cool/dry Yes DHR CF (16) 74 NK044 DIST 125 VDC CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC Dist. Panel (14) NK cool/dry Yes DHR CF 75 NK054 DIST 125 VDC CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC Dist. Panel (14) NK cool/dry Yes DHR CF 76 NNO14 7.5 KVA CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC Battery Chg NN cool/dry Yes DHR CF (16) 77 PALO I B AUX FEEDWATER AUX Yes Yes PC DHR Horz. Pumps AL hot/dry PUMP (5) 78 PAL02 AFW PUMP-- AUX Yes Yes PC DHR Horz. Pumps AL hot/dry TURBINE DRIVEN (5) 79 PBGO2B BORIC ACID AUX Yes Yes RC Horz. Pumps BG X hot/dry TRANSFER PUMP (5)
MOTOR 80 PBG04 NORMAL AUX Yes Yes RC IC Horz. Pumps BG hot/dry CHARGING PUMP (5) 81 PBGO5B CENTRIFUGAL AUX Yes Yes RC PC IC Horz. Pumps BG hot/dry CHARGING PUMP DHR (5) 82 PEGOI B COMPONENT COOL. AUX Yes Yes RC PC IC Horz. Pumps EG mild/dry WATER PUMP DHR CF (5) 83 PEJOIB RESIDUAL HEAT AUX Yes Yes IC DHR Vert. Pump (6) EJ X hot/dry REMOVAL PUMP 84 PENO IB Containment Spray AUX Yes Yes CF Vert. Pump (6) EN hot/dry Pump B 85 PKJ03B AUXILIARY LUBE- DG Yes Yes RC PC IC Horz. Pumps KJ X hot/humid OIL (KEEP-WARM) DHR CF (5)
PUMP FOR KKJOIB 86 RLO17 ESF MCB CB Yes Yes RC PC IC Control Panel RL cool/dry DHR CF (20) 87 RL020 ESF MCB CB Yes Yes RC PC IC Control Panel RL cool/dry IIDHR CF (20) 1 WCAP- 17678-NP, Supplement I June 2013 Revision 1
F-8 SWEL I (cont.)
Screen #4 Sample Considerations Screen #1 Screen #3 SWEL (SC - I Screen #2 (Safety Major new or IPEEE Walkdown Item Walkdown Licensing (Screens Function Equipment System replacement Environment vulnerability Deferred to Number Equipment Description Building Basis?) In?) Support) Class Type equipment? (Temp, IF) enhancement? Outage?
88 RL021 REACTOR CB Yes Yes RC PC IC Control Panel RL cool/dry AUXILIARIES PANEL DHR CF (20) 89 RP08 IA/B SUBCOOLING CB Yes Yes DHR Control Panel RP cool/dry MONITORING (20)
CABINET 90 RP290 DC DISTRIBUTION AUX Yes Yes RC PC IC Control Panel RP mild/dry DHR CF (20) 91 SA036E ESFAS CH4 LOGIC CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC Control Panel SA cool/dry CABINET DHR CF (20) 92 SB032C W SS PROT SYS OUT CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC Control Panel SB cool/dry I TRN DHR CF (20) 93 SB032D W SS PROT SYS OUT CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC Control Panel SB cool/dry 2 TRN DHR CF (20) 94 SB041 W PROCESS CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC Control Panel SB cool/dry ANALOG DHRCF (20)
PROTECTION SET CAB-04 95 SB079 RPV LEVEL INSTR CO Yes Yes IC Control Panel SO cool/dry SYS PROC PROT SYS (20) 96 SE032 SOURCE RANGE AUX Yes Yes RC Control Panel SE mild/dry Yes CHANNEL 2 PREAMP (20) 97 SE054B W NUC INSTM NIS 2 CB/CC Yes Yes RC Control Panel SE cool/dry Yes (20) 98 SENY061A EXCORE NEUTRON AUX Yes Yes RC Control Panel SE mild/dry Yes DETECTOR (20)
AMPLIFIER 99 SGKO4B CONTROL ROOM AUX Yes Yes RC PC IC AHU (I0) GK X mild/dry X A/C UNITS DHR CF 100 SGK05B CLASS IE ELEC. CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC AHU (10) GK X cool/dry X Yes EQUIP. A/C UNIT DHR CF 101 SGL09B ROOM COOLER FOR AUX Yes Yes RC IC AHU (10) GL hot/dry PEMOIB DHR 102 SGLIOB RHR PUMP ROOM AUX Yes Yes IC DHR AHU (10) GL hot/dry COOLER 7678-NP, Supplement 1 U~
a .9 SWEL 1 (cont.)
Screen # Screen #3 Screen #4 Sample Considerations SWEL (SC- I Screen #2 (Safety Major new or IPEEE Walkdown Item Walkdown Licensing (Screens Function Equipment System replacement Environment vulnerability Deferred to Number Equipment Description Building Basis?) In?) Support) Class Type equipment? (Temp, 'F) enhancement? Outage?
103 SGLI5B PENETRATION AUX Yes Yes CF AHU (10) GL mild/dry ROOM COOLER 104 TEGOIB CCW SURGE TANK B AUX Yes Yes RC PC IC Tank (21) EG mild/dry DHR CF 105 TJE02B EMERGENCY FUEL DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC Tank (21) JE hot/humid OIL DAY TANK DHR CF 106 TKA04 AFW CTRL/MAIN AUX Yes Yes PC DHR Tank (21) KA mild/dry STEAM ARV ACCUM 107 TKJOIB DIG B JACKET DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC Tank (21) KJ hot/humid WATER EXPANSION DHR CF TANK (08 TKJ02C START AIR TANK DGB Yes Yes RC PC iC Tank (21) KJ hot/humid D/G DHR CF 109 TKJ04B D/G B AUX LUBE DG1 Yes Yes RC PC IC Tank (2l1) KJ hot/humid OIL TANK DHR CF 110 XNG02 CLASS IE LOAD CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC Transformer (4) NG cool/dry Yes CENTER DHR CF TRANSFORMER III XNG06 FEEDS MCC NG06E ESW Yes Yes IC DHR Transformer (4) NG hot/dry Yes I
Note:
The Walkdown Deferred to Outage column was populated at the time of the SWEL development site visit on August 27-28, 2012, and was later modified depending on component accessibility during the at-power walkdowns in September, 2012.
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
G-1 APPENDIX G WOLF CREEK COMPOSITE SWEL TRANSMITTAL This appendix shows only the SWEL transmittal for the refueling outage seismic walkdowns performed on February 24, 2013. The SWEL transmittal for the at-power seismic walkdowns performed the week of September 17, 2012 can be found in Appendix G of Reference 34.
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision I
G-2
- Westinghouse Seismic Walkdown Equipment List, Revision 1 I In Response to NTTF Recommendation 2.3: Seismic Wolf Creek Generating Station ROLANDO PEREZ Equipment Selection Pe a 4~r-n Lead A-eA 3/ A47c'1.
Idate I
DEREK SEAMAN 3A/G 20/3 Equipment Selection Personnel date E-RIC-CARL-SGN N.,
k 312541,3 Station Operations date I
Wolf Creek Seismic Walkdown Equipment List March 6, 2013 Page I I WCAP- 17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
G-3 Seismic Walkdown Equipment List, Rev. 1 Attachment to LTR-RAM-lI-12-083, Rev. 1 NTTF Recommendation 2.3: Seismic Walkdown Wolf Creek Generating Station Revision History Revision 0 of this document provides the Seismic Walkdown Equipment List (SWEL) developed prior to the Wolf Creek Generating Station (WCGS) At-Power Seismic Walkdowns, performed during the week of September 17, 2012. The SWEL contained a total of 117 components (112 in SWEL 1 and 5 in SWEL 2).
Revision 1 of this document revised the SWEL 1 table provided in Attachment 1 of this document to remove a component (XPN08B) associated with system type PN (Instrument AC Power). This component was removed because it was identified as being non safety related. The removal of XPN08B reduced the number of SWEL items from 117 to 116. It was not deemed necessary to replace XPN08B with a component of a similar class of equipment since the remaining equipment list still satisfied the Reference 1 guidance. XPN08B is a transformer and this component type, along with other attributes, remains adequately represented on the SWEL.
Seismic Walkdown Equipment List (SWEL)
A listing of structures, systems, and components (SSCs) that will be viewed during the walkdown, the SWEL, has been prepared in advance of the walkdown effort.
The selection of SSCs process described in EPRI Technical Report 1025286, Seismic Walkdown Guidance for Resolution of Fukushima Near-Term Task Force Recommendation 2.3: Seismic, dated June 2012 {Reference 1), was utilized to develop the SWEL for Wolf Creek.
The SWEL is comprised of two groups of items:
4- SWEL 1 (Attachment 1) is a sample of items to safely shut down the reactor and maintain containment integrity.
- o. SWEL 2 (Attachment 2) is a list of spent fuel pool related items. Note that no rapid drain down items have been identified for Wolf Creek Generating Station, however, it is recommended that an area walk-by of the spent fuel building instrument air be conducted to ensure gate seal integrity.
Wolf Creek Operations and Engineering Staff Members participated in the selection of SSCs compiling the SWEL and provided direct input to the Equipment Selection Personnel during the SWEL development process. This input included:
- Confirmation of the equipment information retrieved from the Wolf Creek Seismic Category I documentation.
Wolf Creek Seismic Walkdown Equipment List March 6, 2013 Page 21 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
G-4 Seismic Walkdown Equipment List, Rev. 1 Attachment to LTR-RAM-II-12-083, Rev. 1 NTTF Recommendation 2.3: Seismic Walkdown Wolf Creek Generating Station
" Discussions with the Equipment Selection Personnel to identify upgrades, modifications, and replacements of equipment which might be pertinent to the selection of the SWEL.
" Input into the selection of the SWEL using operational experience relevant to equipment classifications, safety function support, and environmental considerations.
- Approval of the components selected for the SWEL.
The process detailed in Reference 1 for the Selection of SSCs to produce the SWEL was discussed with the Wolf Creek Operations and Engineering Staff Members during the site visit August 2 7th through 2 8 nd, 2012. The details describing the process for Selection of SSCs to produce the SWEL will be provided in the "Selection of SSCs" section of the Submittal Report.
References
- 1) EPRI Technical Report 1025286, Seismic Walkdown Guidance for Resolution of Fukushima Near-Term Task Force Recommendation 2.3: Seismic, dated June 2012.
Affachments
- 1) Seismic Walkdown Equipment List 1
- 2) Seismic Walkdown Equipment List 2 I II Wolf Creek Seismic Walkdown Equipment List March 6, 2013 Page 3 I WCAP- 17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
G-5 Seismic Walkdown Equipment Ust, Rev. 1 Attachment to LTR-RAM-Il-12-083, Rev. 1 NTTF Recommendation 2.3: Seismic Walkdown Attachment I - SWEL 1 Wolf Creek Generating Station Screen Screen Screen lt Sample Considerations SWLScreen Walkdown Walkdown " #2 Major new Deferred Item Equipment Description Building (SC- I (Screens (Safety Equipment System or Environment to Comments Number Ucensing In?) Function Class Type replacement (Temp, *F) vulnerability Outage?
Basis?) Support) equipment? enhancement?
I ABHV0014 LOOP-1 MAIN STEAM ISOLATION VALVE AUX Yes Yes PC DHR POV (7) AB x hot/dry ABPT0002 STM GEN B STEAMUNE PRESSURE
Racks AE hot/humid Yes Inst. Racks 6 AELT0519 STM GEN LEVELA NARROW RANGE RB Yes Yes PC DHR AE hot/humid Yes (18)
ESW TO M DAF EPUMP B 6" BTFLVLV 7 ALHVG030 W/TO W/UMITQ AUX Yes Yes PC DHR VALVE(8) AL Inst. Racks 8 BBLIS1321 RVSUBCOOUNG MONITORTRN B AUX Yes Yes RC BB mild/dry (18)
Inst. Racks 9 BBPT0456 PRESSURIZER PRESSURE RB Yes Yes PC BB Yes (181 CENTRIFUGAL CHG PMP FLOWCONTROL 10 BGFCVG121 <CAT 2 AOV PROGRAM VALVE> cTIME AUX Yes Yes RC PC IC POV (7) BG hot/dry CRITICALACTION EQUIPMENT-11 BGHV8105 CHARGINGPUMPS TO REGEN HX/CTMT AUX Yes Yes PC IC CF MOV (8) BG mild/dry ISO LETDOWN SYSTEM CONTAINMENT ISO 12 BGHV8152 AUX Yes Yes ICCF POV (7) BG mild/dry VLV REACTOR M/U WATER CONTAINMENT 13 BLHVR047 AUX Yes Yes ICCF POV (7) BL mild/dry ISO I
Wolf Creek Seismic Walkdown Equipment Ust March 6,2013 Page 4 I Ju V 7678-NP, Supplement 1 Rew,
Seismic Waikdown Equipment Ust, Rev. 1 Attachment to LTR-RAM.I-12-083, Rev. 1 NTTF Recommendation 2.3: Seismic Walkdown Attachment 1 - SWEL I Wolf Creek Generating Station item Walkdown SWLScreen Screen Screen
_____Walkdown Screen 44 Sample Considerations
" 2 93 Major new Numb Equipment IPEEE Deferred Comments Di(Screens Equipment System or Environment to UcnsngIn?)
Ncensing Function Class Type replacement (Temp, F) vulnerability 1 Outage?
Basis?) Support) equipment? enhancement?
14 BMHV0002 SG B BLOWDOWN AFAS ISO AUX Yes Yes PC ICCF POV (7) BM hot/dry 15 BNHV0003 RWST SUPPLY TO CTMT SPRAY PUMP B AUX Yes Yes CF MOV (8) BN hot/dry RC IC Inst. Racks 16 BNLT0931 RWST LEVELTRANSMITrER (2) YRD Yes Yes I n 8) SR BN hot/humid DHR (1B)ho/ui 17 BNV0011 RWST OUTLET ISO VALVE AUX Yes Yes RC Ic (8) BN DHR RC PC IC B COGM01B DIESELGENERATOR BLDGSUPPLY FAN DGB Yes Yes Fans (9) GM hot/humid DHR COMPONENT COOL WATER HEAT SCPC IC Heat 19 EEG01B AUX Yes Yes Exchangers EG mild/dry EXCHANGER DHR E (21) n Gl RC PC IC Control 20 EF156 ESW CONTROL PANEL ESW Yes Yes EF hot/dry DHRCF Panel (20)
ESW B/SERVICE WATER CROSS CONNECT sRC PC IC 024CS/CCVALVE Yes Yes MDV (5) EPF mild/dry VALVE OHR CF 22 EFHVOO40 ESW AV TRAIN B TO SW CROSS CONNECT CS/CC Yes Yes sRC PC IC MOV (8( EF X miuld/dry VALVE DHR CF SCPC IC 23 EFHV0052 ESW 8 TO CCW HX 8 AUX Yes Yes MOV (8) EF DHRCF ESW PUMP B DISCHARGEAIR RELEASE SC PC tC 24 EFHV0098 ESW Yes Yes MOV (8) EF hot/humid VALVE DHR CF SCPC IC Temp.
25 EFTE002 ESW BTEMPT TO POWER BLOCK CS/CC Yes Yes EF mild/dry DHRCF Sensor (19) 26 EGHVO016 CCW TRAIN B RETURN ISO VALVE AUX Yes Yes DHR MOV (8) EG X mild/dry I
Wolf Creek Seismic Walkdown Equipment Ust March 6, 2013 Page 5 1 WCAP- 17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
G-7 Seismic Walkdown Equipment List, Rev. 1 Attachment to LTR.RAM-l-12-083, Rev. 1 NTTF Recommendation 2.3: SeismdcWalkdown Attachment 1 - SWEL I Wolf Creek Generating Station Screen Screen Screen Screen B4 Sample Considerations SWEL #1 Walkdowr
- 3 MjrnwDfre Walkdown #2- Major new Item Equipment Description Bulding (S - I (Screens ESafety Equipment System or Environment IPEEE to Comment Number Licensing in?) Function C'.ss TZ replacement (Temp, *F) vulnerability Basis?) Support) equipment? nhancement?
27 EGHV0102 CCW TO RHR HX B ISO AUX Yes Yes DHR MOV (8) EG mild/dry 28 EGLT0002 CCW SURGE TK B AUX Yes Yes DHR Inst. Racks EG mild/dry (18) 29 EGTE0032 CCW HX B OUTLET TEMP AUX Yes Yes RC DHR Temp. EG mild/dry Sensor (19) 30 EGTVOO30 CCW HX B TEMP CV WAFER BT'FLY VLV AUX Yes Yes RC DHR POV (7) EG mild/dry 31 EJFCV0611 RHR PUMP B MINIFLOW VALVE AUX Yes Yes DHR MOV (8) EJ hot/dry RHR PMP PEJOIB MINIFLOW CONTROL Inst. Racks 32 EJFIS0611 DISCHARGE<TIME CRITICALACTION AUX Yes Yes DHR El mild/dry EQUIPMENT, 33 EIHVBS09B RHRTO ACCUM INJ LOOPS 3 & 4 I50 VLV AUX Yes Yes DHR MOV (B) El mild/dry RC PC IC Heat 34 EK.O3B INTERCOOLERHEAT EXCHANGER DGB Yes Yes Exchangers KJ I hot/humid DHRCF (21)
RC PC IC Heat 35 EKJO4B LUBEOILCOOLER 0GB Yes Yes Exchangers IO hot/humid OHRCF c(21) eh u Heat RC PC IC 16 EIC06B DIESELJACKET WATER HEATEXCHANGER 0GB Yes Yes ExcRhanger t hothumid DHR CF (21)
RC IC Inst. Backs 37 EMFTg917B CP B TO BITFLOW TRANSMITTER AUX Yes Yes EM mild/chemical DHR (19)
RC IC 38 EMHV8814B Si PUMP B RETURN TO RWST ISO VALVE AUX Yes Yes MOV (8) EM hot/dry DHR 39 EMHV8923B SAFETYINJECTION PUMP B SUCT ISO VLV AUX Yes Yes ICDHR MOV (8) EM hot/dry Wolf Creek Seismic Walkdown Equipment Ust March 6,2013 Page 61 7678-NP, Supplement 1 Ju Re
0 0-8 Seismic Waikdown Equipment List, Rev. I Attachment to LTR.RAM-ii-12-083, Rev. 1I NTTF Recommendation 2.3: Seismic Walkdown Attachment 1 -SWEL1 Wolf Creek Generating Station SWEL Screen Screen Screen #14Sample Considerations Waldown Item Walkdown Description Building (SC -I 111 2 (Safetyr
- 3 ewPETE Major new Deferred Commentd Num Equipment (Screens (Safety Equipment System or Environment to Comments Number Ucensing I Function Class Type replacement (Temp, vulnerability Basis?) Support) equipment? enhancement?
ACCUMULATOR TANK BOUTLET ISO 40 EPHV8808B VALVE
41 FCO219 LOCALCONTROL PANEL FOR TD AFW AUX Yes yes PC DHR Control PC X hot/dry PUMP Panel (20)
AUX FW PUMPTURBINE MECH 42 FCHV0312 AUXpFHROT VLV AUX Yes Yes PC DHR MOV (8) FC hot/dry High attention level item TRIP/TM ROTVLV 43 FEFO2B ESW SELF-CLEANSTRAIN. (MTR OP.-IN ESW Yes Yes RC PC IC Other (0) EE hot/drV MOV PROG.) OHR CF 44 FKJO2C KKJO1BAIR INTAKEFILTER DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC Other (0) KJ hot/humid DHRCF BC PC IC 45 GKV0766 SGKO4B WATER REGULATINGVALVE CB Yes Yes MOV (8) GK mild/dry DHRCF BC PC C 46 GKV0768 SGKOSB WATER REGULATING VALVE CB Yes Yes MOV (B) GK cool/dry Yes DHR CF RC PC IC 47 GMHZ0019 DSLGEN RM EXH DMPR B, GMDOOIO 0GB Yes Yes Other (0) GM hot/humid BC PC iC Temp.
48 GMTEOO1 DIESELGEN VENT SUPPLY FAN 1B DGB Yes Yes RC Semp. GM hot/humid OMBCF Sensor(11()
49 GMTZ0011B ACT FOR DG VENT SUPPLY FAN DAMPER Yes Yes BGB RC PC IC Other(0) GM hot/humid GMD0007 DHRCF Inst. Backs So GNPT0934 CONTAINMENT ATMOSPHERE RB Yes Yes CF GN mild/dry Yes (1B)
CTiVYTCOOLER B ESW OUTLET FLOW 51 GNVOOO2 RB Yes Yes CF POV (7) GN S hot/humid Yes CONTROL VLV 52 GSHV0021 H2 PURGE OUTER CTMT ISO BUTTVLV AUX Yes Yes CF MOV (8) GS mild/dry Wolf Creek Seismic Walkdown Equipment Ust March 6, 2013 Page 7 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision I
G-9 Seismic Walkdown Equipment Ust, Rev. 1 Attachment to LTR-RAM-1l-12-083, Rev. 1I NTTF Recommenidation 2.3: Seismic Waikdown Attachment 1 - SWEL 1 Wolf Creek Generating Station Screen Screen Screen #4 Sample Considerations SWL Wldw 1 Screen #3Walkdowni Walkdown -2 Major new Deferred Equipment sScreens ty Equipment System or Environment to Number Lcensing In?) Function Class Type replacement (Temp, F) vulnerability Outage?
Basis?) Support) equipment?
CTMT ATMOSNERE RADIATtON Inst. Racks 53 GTRE031 MONITOR MONITOR AUX Yes Yes CF R (18) GT mild/dry RCDT PUMPS OISCH HDR INSIDECTMT 54 HBHV7176 ISO RB Yes Yes CF POV (7) HB Yes 55 IELTOO21 EMER FUELOIL DAY TK B LEV
CTMT NOR SUMPS TO FLR DRN TK 59 LFFVOO96 AUX Yes Yes CF POV (7) LF mild/dry OUTSIDE CTMT ISO 60 N8002 4.16 KVBUS N2 <TIME CRITICALACTION CB Yes Yes RC PC IC Med. Volt NB cool/dry Yes EQUIPMENT, DHRCF Swgr. (3)
RC PC IC Med. Volt 61 NOD0213 CtRL BLDG LC NG02 SWGR BRKR CB Yes Yes NB Yes DHRCF Swir. (3)
62 NE002 STANDBY #2 DGB Yes Yes NE hot/humid DHRCF (17)
RC PC IC Control 63 NF039B CONT SHED/SEQ CH 4 LOGIC CB Yes Yes NF cool/dry DHR CF Panel (20)
BCPC IC Low Volt 64 NGO02 480 VAC CB/CC Yes Yes R C Sw V2l NG cool/dry x Yes DHRCF Swgr.(2)
RC PCIC Low Volt 65 NG00201 MAIN BREAKER CB Yes Yes NG cool/dry Yes DHR CF Swgr. (2)
I Wolf Creek Seismic Walkdown Equipment Ust March 6, 2013 Page B8 JU le 7678-NP, Supplement 1 Re
0 .0-Seismic Walkdown Equipment Ust, Rev. I Attachment to LTR-RAM-lI.12-083, Rev. 1I NTtF Recommendation 2.3: Seismic Walkdown Attachment 1 -SWEL I Wolf Creek Generating Station Screen Screen Screen #4 Sample Considerations SE akonII Screen #3Walk~down SWEWalkdown #1 2 (aeyIEEComments ten Dsio#3 - Major new PEEE Deferred Equipment (SC- 1 Screens Equipment System Or Environment to Licensing in?) uncton Class Type replacement (Temp, vulnerability"Fg Basis?) Support) equipment? enhancement?
66 NG00206 NG02A FOR BRKR
BCPC IC 67 NG002B 480 VAC MOTOR CONTROL CENTER AUX Yes Yes MCC(1) NG mild/drV Yes DHRCF BCPC IC 68 NGOO4C 480 VAC AUX Yes Yes MCC(1) NG mld/dr Yes DHRCF RC PC IC 69 NG006E 480 VAC ESW Yes Yes MCC(1) NG hot/dry Yes DHR CPF RC PC IC Dist. Panel 70 NKO14 125 VDC BUS SWITCHBOARD CB/CC Yes Yes OHRCP (14) NK cool/dry Yes 71 NKO12 125-VDC NO.2 60-CELL BATTERY CB/CC Yes Yes PC IC Battery NC NK cool/dry DHR CF Rack (15)
BCPC IC Battery 72 NK014 125-VDC NO.4 60-CELL BATTERY CB/CC Yes Yes NK cool/dry DHR CF Rack (15) 73 NK024 125 VDC NO 4 CR/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC Battery Chg NK cool/dry Yes DHR CF (16)
BCPC IC Dist. Panel 74 NK044 DIST125 VOC CB/CC Yes Yes NK cool/dr Yes DHRCF (14)
BC PC IC 0ist. Panel 75 NKO54 DIS' 12.5 VDC CB/CC Yes Yes NK cool/dry Yes ODHRCF (14) 76 NNO14 7.5 KVA CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC Battery Chg NN cool/dry Yes DHRCF (16)
Hort.
77 PALOIB AUX FEEDWATER PUMP AUX Yes Yes PC DHR AL hot/dry Pumps (5)
Hort.
78 PAL02 AFW PUMP-TURBINE DRIVEN AUX Yes Yes PC DHR AL hot/dry Pumps (5)
I Wolf Creek Seismic Waikdown Equipment List March 6, 2013 Page I WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision I
G-11 Seismic Walkdown Equipment List, Rev. I Attachment to LTR-RAM-l1-12-083, Rev. 1 NTTF Recommendation 2.3: Seismic Walkdown Attachmentl -SWEI 1 Wolf Creek Generating Station SScreen Screen Screen 14 Sample Considerations SWL Wldw 1 Screen f3Walkdown Walkdown 11 2 R - Major new Dfre Item Description Building (SC.-S 0 (Safetyjrne PE Deterred Comments N er Equipment D pBd si- (screens ty Equipment System or Environment to N In?) Function Class Type replacement (Temp, *F) vulnerabilt Outage?
Basis?) LSupport)*equipment? enhancement?
79 PBG02B BORICACID TRANSFER PUMP MOTOR AUX Yes Yes RC 11BG X hot/dry Pumps (5)
Hort.
80 PBO04 NORMALCHARGING PUMP AUX Yes Yes RCIC I r BG hot/dry Pumps (5)
RC PCIC Hort.
81 PIGOSB CENTRIFUGALCHARGING PUMP AUX Yes Yes IBG hot/dry DHR Pumps (5)
ECPC IC Moro.
82 PEGOtB COMPONENT COOL WATER PUMP AUX Yes Yes CEG mild/dry DHRCF Pumps (5)
Vert. Pump 83 PEJO1B RESIDUALHEAT REMOVAL PUMP AUX Yes Yes IC DHR EJ hot/dry (6)
Vert. Pump 84 PENO1B Containment Spray Pump B AUX Yes Yes CF EN hot/dry (6) 115 PKI03B AUXILIARY LUBE-OIL(KEEP-WARM) 06 Yes Yes RC PC IC Horz. J 1 hot/humid PUMP FOR KKJO1B DHRCF Pumps (S)
RC PC IC Control 86 RL017 ESFMCB CR Yes Yes RL cool/dry DHR CF Panel (20)
BCPC IC Control 87 RL.20 ESFMCB CB Yes Yes RL cool/dry DHR CF Panel (20)
BC PC IC Control 88 RL021 REACTORAUXILIARIESPANEL CB Yes Yes RL cool/dry DHRCF Panel (20)
Control 89 RPO1SA/B SIECOOUNG MONITORING CABINET CB Yes Yes DHR C RP cool/dry Panel (20)
RC PC IC Control 90 RP290 DC DISTRIBUTION AUX Yes Yes RP mild/dry DHR CF Panel (20)
RC PC iC Control 91 SA036E ESFASCH4 LOGIC CABINET CB/CC Yes Yes SA cool/dry DHRCF Panel (20)
Wolf Creek Seismic Walkdown Equipment List March 6, 2013 Page 10 I 7678-NP, Supplement I S Ju Re
S .
Seismic Walkdown Equipment Ust, Rev. 1 Attachment to LTR-RAM.II.12-083, Rev. 1I NTTF Recommendation 2.3: Seismic Walkdown Attachment 1 - SWEL 1 Wolf Creek Generating Station Screen Screen Screen B4 Sample Considerations E umWalkdown SWLScreen e1i#2 u3
-Walkdown Item EupetDescription !Building (SC - 1 (Sres (Safety Eupet ysm Major ornew nvomnt IPEEE Deferred toComments Number Eup nt(Screens Equipment System or Environment Comet Ncensing in?) Function Class Type replacement (Temp, F ) vunerabiity utage?
Basis?) Support) equipment? enhancement?
RC PC IC Controi 92 5B032C W SS PROT SYSOUT 1 TRN CB/CC Yes Yes SB cool/dry DHR CF Panel (20)
RC PCIC Control 93 SB0320 W SS PROT SYSOUT 2 TRN CB/CC Yes Yes SB cool/dry DHR CF Panel (20)
Rd 5B041 W PROCESS ANALOG PROTECTION SET CB/CC Yes Yes RC PC IC Control SB cool/dry CAB-04 OHR CF Panel (20)
Control 95 SBO79 RPV LEVELINSTRSYS PROC PROT SYS CB Yes Yes IC SB cool/dry Panel (20)
Control 96 SE032 SOURCE RANGECHANNEL 2 PREAMP AUX Yes Yes RC SE mild/dry Yes Panel (20)
Control 97 SEO54B W NUC INSTM NIS 2 CB/CC Yes Yes RC SE cool/dry Yes Panel (20)
Control 98 SENY061A EXCORENEUTRON DETECTOR AMPLIFIER AUX Yes Yes RC SE mild/dry Yes Panel (20)
RCPCIC ddr 99 SGKO4B CONTROL ROOM A/C UNITS AUX Yes Yes RC CF DHR AHU (10) GK X mild/dry x BCPC IC 10D SGKO5B CLASS IEELEC.EQUIP. A/C UNIT CB/CC Yes Yes AHU (10) GK X cool/dry S Yes DHRCF BC IC 101 SGLD9B ROOM COOLER FOR PEMO1B AUX Yes Yes AHU (10) GL hot/dry OHR 102 SGLIOB RHR PUMP ROOM COOLER AUX Yes Yes IC DHR AHU (10) GL hot/dry 103 SGL1SB PENETRATION ROOM COOLER AUX Yes Yes CF AHU (10) GL mild/dry BCPCIC 104 TEGOB CCW SURGE TANKB AUX Yes Yes Tank (21) EG mild/dry DHRCF I
Wolf Creek Seismic Walkdown Equipment Ust March 6, 2013 Page 11 1 WCAP- 17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
G- 13 Seismic Walkdown Equipment List, Rev. 1 Attachment to LTR.RAM.l-12-083, Rev. 1 NTTF Recommendation 2.3: Seismic Walkdown Attachment 1 - SWEL 1 Wolf Creek Generating Station Screen Screen Screen H4 Sample Considerations ScEL Screen Walkdown Walkdown f#2 Major Item Equipment Description IBu~ding (SC - I Screens Safety Equipment System or new Environment IPEEE Deferred Comments Number Nube EupetLicensing Uenin Basis?) In?) Fucin Function Support)
Class CuF Type replacement equipment?
(Temp, F) enhanceeranlty? t nenhancemet?Outage RC PC IC 105 TJEO2B EMERGENCYFUEL OIL DAY TANK DGB Yes Yes T (2)
DHRCF Tn J Jh o/ui u 106 TKA04 AFW CTR/MAIN STEAM ARV ACCUM AUX Yes Yes PC OHR Tank (21) KA mild/dry RC PC IC 107 TKJO1B D/G B JACKETWATER EXPANSION TANK DGB Yes Yes Tank (21) KJ hot/humid DHRCF 108 TKJ02C START AIR TANK D/G DGB Yes Yes RC PC IC Tank (21) KJ hot/humid DHRCF 109 TKJO4B D/G BAUX LUBEOIL TANK 0GB Yes Yes RC PC IC Tank (21) KJ hot/humid DHRCF PC PC IC Transformer 110 XNG02 CLASS 1E LOADCENTER TRANSFORMER CB/CC Yes Yes NG cool/dry Yes DHRRCF (4)
Transformer 111 XNG06 FEEDSMCC NGO6E ESW Yes Yes IC OHR NG hot/dry Yes (4)
R.m CodnPressurCe d r(RCPC)
R=som Cuodr m.ar-CmnV
. (RCIC)
DecsyuHt Rrwm I(DHR)
CmtWimnmtFuncbm (CFI Wolf Creek Seismic Walkdown Equipment Ust March 6, 2013 Page 12:
V Jul, 7678-NP, Supplement 1 1w Rev
0 Seismic Walkdown Equipment List, Rev. I Attachment to LTR.RAM-11-12-083, Rev. I NTTF Recommendation 2.3: Seismic Walkdown Attachment 2 - SWEL 2 Wolf Creek generating Station SWEL Screen Associated Item Item Walkdown Eqimn ecpinBuilding Equipment System (Seismic Screen N2 wiapid with Rapid Comment Number Equipment Class Type Licensing (Screens In?) Draindown?
Basis?)
Heat 1 EECOO1B FUEL POOL COOUNG HEAT EXCHANGER EC EB Yes Yes No Exchangers 2 SGGO4B SFP PUMP ROOM COOLER B AHU GG GG Yes Yes No 3 PECOIB FUEL POOL COOUNG PUMP PUMP EC FB Yes Yes No 4 ECHV012 FUEL POOL HEAT EXCHANGER SHELLSIDE OUTLET ISO MOV EC FB Yes Yes No FUEL POOLCOOUNG PUMP DISCHARGE FLOW 5 ECFTTO AS TRANSMfilER Inst. Racks EC FB Yes Yes No I
Wolf Creek Seismic Walkdown Equipment Ust March 6,2013 Page 13 I WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
H-1 APPENDIX H QUALIFICATIONS This appendix shows only the qualifications of new personnel involved with the refueling outage seismic walkdowns performed on February 24, 2013. The qualifications of personnel involved with the at-power seismic walkdowns performed the week of September 17, 2012 can be found in Appendix H of Reference 34.
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
H-2 Seismic Walkdown and SWEL Development Resumes Lawrence J. Comfort, P.E.
WORK HISTORY 2009-present Civil Engineer,Wolf Creek Nuclear Operating Corp, Design Engineering Section.
1997- 2009 Civil Engineer,Shafer, Kline and Warren, Iola, Kansas.
1990-1997 Civil Engineer, Omaha District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Geotechnical Branch.
1987-1990 CivilEngineer,Kansas City District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Geotechnical Branch.
EXPERIENCE Engineering, Design, and Construction Nuclear power plant design engineering: Developed change packages and evaluations; Participated in calculations, commercial grade dedications, safety classification analysis, USAR changes, and inspections; provided engineering support for refuel and forced outages.
Geotechnical design: Excavation and backfill for nuclear safety related structures, layout and repair of flood control levees, channels and dams, including slope stability and seepage studies; layout of coal mine reclamation projects; lagoon design.
Hydrology and hydraulics: Sediment evaluations for ultimate heat sinks, site flooding studies, design of storm water systems, and flood control structures; raw water sourcing, yields, and intakes.
Dam safety inspection: analysis, repairs and instrumentation; dam breach inundation studies.
Design of municipal water distribution systems and wastewater collection and treatment systems.
Basic site design, land survey and topographic mapping.
Specification writing, cost estimation, and contract administration for construction projects.
Environmental permitting: NPDES (construction storm water) and Corps of Engineers 404 wetland.
Logistics Develop task, scope and budgets for engineering design projects.
Participate in the management of an engineering office, including personnel, budgeting, and planning.
Write specifications for purchase orders.
Emergency Operations and Recovery Emergency operations and post flood recovery: Cities of Garnett and Iola, Kansas, Southeast Kansas floods, 2007; US Army Corps of Engineers, Midwest floods, 1993, Black Hills Floods, 1995, James River North and South Dakota Floods, 1997.
Emergency security construction survey and design, Dept, of Defense, Operation Desert Storm, 1991.
Damage inspector - Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), Loma Prieta Earthquake, California, 1989.
EDUCATION 2009 - Present: Continuing Engineering Support Training - Wolf Creek Nuclear Operating Corp.
2008 American Council of Engineering Companies - Kansas, Emerging Leaders Program.
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
H-3 1988 - 2009 Short courses: Engineering management, Hydraulics, Hydrology, Wastewater, Railway systems, geotechnical engineering, Hazardous waste site operations and safety, Dam safety, maintenance and design, Environmental law, 0
1987 Kansas State University, Manhattan, Kansas. Bachelor of Science in Civil Engineering.
CERTIFICATIONS Professional Engineering License (Civil) State of Nebraska, 1993 Professional Engineering License (Civil) State of Kansas, 1995 WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision I
0~~
Certificate of Completion Lawrence Comfort Training on Near Term Task Force Recommendation 2.3
- Plant Seismic Walkdowns July 11. 2012 Date ROW K aaaWWS Ep MWAV.
Sftucbgj RSabfty Asnmegdm, MD J~.
H-5 ROLANDO PEREZ Principal Engineer, Risk Applications and Methods II Westinghouse Nuclear Services Division Education:
B.S. Chemical Engineering University of Puerto Rico, 1973 M.S. Nuclear Engineering University of Puerto Rico, 1975 Summary:
Rolando Perez is a Principal Engineer in the Risk Applications and Methods II Group of Westinghouse's Nuclear Services Division. Rolando has over 15 years of experience in Westinghouse and over 35 years of experience in the nuclear safety area.
From 1976 to 1977 Rolando worked for Westinghouse as a Training Engineer. Rolando supported the development of training programs for engineers and non-technical personnel of nuclear power plants.
Rolando conducted lectures on reactor core physics, health physics, fluid systems, protection systems, and plant operational concepts. Rolando was also involved in preparing and grading written examinations for Reactor Operator candidates.
From 1977 to 1979 Rolando worked for Westinghouse as a Transient Analyst. Rolando was responsible for performing the non-LOCA transient analyses for the nuclear plants designed by Westinghouse.
From 1979 to 1990 Rolando worked for Combustion Engineering (CE) as a Setpoint Analyst. Rolando was responsible for performing setpoint related calculations for the nuclear power plants designed by CE that employ analog-based reactor trip and monitoring systems (typically called the "CE analog plants").
Rolando was also involved in performing analyses associated with the setpoint process in the following areas: Core Physics and Thermal Hydraulics, Non-LOCA Transient Analysis, and Statistical Combination of Uncertainties.
In 1990 Combustion Engineering was acquired by Asea Brown Boveri (ABB). Rolando continued his role as a Setpoint Analysis under ABB until the year 1999.
In 1999 Westinghouse acquired ABB's nuclear division. Rolando continued his role as a Setpoint Analyst under Westinghouse. In the year 2009 Rolando expanded his expertise to include the CE-designed plants that employ digital-based reactor trip and monitoring systems (i.e., the plants that use the Core Protection Calculator System, CPCS, and the Core Operating Limits Supervisory System, COLSS; typically called the "CE digital plants").
WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision 1
H-6 Peer Review Team Rksumes Walter Djordjevic EDUCATION:
B.S. - Civil Engineering, University of Wisconsin at Madison, 1974 M.S. - Structural Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1976 PROFESSIONAL REGISTRATION:
State of California, State of Wisconsin, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, State of Michigan, State of Arizona, State of Missouri PROFESSIONAL HISTORY:
Stevenson & Associates, Inc., President 1996 - present; Vice President and General Manager of the Boston area office, 1983 - 1995 URS/John A. Blume & Associates, Engineers, Boston, Massachusetts, General Manager, 1980 - 1983; San Francisco, California, Supervisory Engineer, 1979 - 1980 Impell Corporation, San Francisco, California, Senior Engineer, 1976 - 1979 Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, Boston, Massachusetts, Engineer, 1974 - 1976 PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE:
" Structural Engineering
- Structural Dynamics
- Seismic Engineering
- Construction
" Vibration Engineering
- Expert Witness
- Committee Chairman Mr. Djordjevic founded the Stevenson & Associates Boston area office in 1983 and serves as President and General Manager. Mr. Djordjevic is expert in the field of structural engineering - more specifically, in the areas of structural vulnerabilities to the effects of seismic and other extreme loading phenomena.
As a structural dynamicist, Mr. Djordjevic also heads the Vibration Engineering Consultants corporate subsidiary of Stevenson & Associates for which he has overseen numerous designs of vibration sensitive microelectronics facilities for such clients as IBM, Intel, Motorola and Toshiba. He has personally been involved in such projects as resolving vibration problems due to construction activities for the Central Artery Project (Big Dig) in Boston for which he was retained by Massport. Finally, Mr. Djordjevic has been personally retained as an Expert Witness a number of times relating to cases involving construction, structural and mechanical issues.
He has performed over a thousand hours of onsite seismic and other natural phenomena (including tornados, hurricanes, fire, and flooding) inspection walkdowns to assess structural soundness and WCAP-17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision I
H-7 vulnerabilities. He has inspected microelectronics fabrication facilities, power facilities, and hazardous material government and military reservations. He is one of the most experienced seismic walkdown inspection screening and verification engineers having personally participated in seismic walkdowns at over 50 U.S. nuclear units.
In recent years, he has concentrated on screening inspection walkdowns and assessments for resolution of the USI A-46 and seismic IPEEE issues, on numerous facilities. The following provides a partial list of recent projects:
American Electric Power - D.C. Cook Station Boston Edison Co. - Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station (SPRA)
Commonwealth Edison Company- Braidwood StationPM, Byron Stationpm, Dresden Stationpm, Quad Cities StationPm Consumers Power Co. - Palisades Nuclear StationPM Entergy - Arkansas Nuclear One Florida Power & Light - Turkey Point Station New York Power Authority - James A. Fitzpatrick Nuclear Power Plant Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation - Nine Mile Point Station Pm Northern States Power Co. - Monticello Nuclear Generating Plant Northern States Power Co. - Prairie Island Nuclear Generating Plant Omaha Public Power District - Fort Calhoun Station (SPRA)
Public Service Electric & Gas - Salem Nuclear Station Rochester Gas & Electric - R.E. Ginna Station Wisconsin Electric - Point Beach Nuclear StationPM (SPRA)
Wisconsin Public Service - Kewaunee Nuclear Power PlantpM (SPRA)
PM Indicates projects where Mr. Djordjevic served as Project Manager Hanford Reservation Savannah River Plant Reservation Rocky Flats Reservation Tooele U.S. Army Depot Anniston U.S. Army Reservation Umatilla U.S. Army Reservation Newport U.S. Army Reservation Aberdeen U.S. Army Reservation He is a member of the IEEE 344 Standards Committee, Chairman of the ASCE Working Group for Seismic Evaluation of Electrical Raceways, and Chairman of the IES Committee for Microelectronics Cleanroom Vibrations Representative projects include overseeing the SEP shake-table testing of electrical raceways, in-situ testing of control panels and instrumentation racks at various nuclear facilities, equipment anchorage walkdowns and evaluations at various nuclear facilities. He is the principal author of the CERTIVALVE software package to evaluate nuclear service valves, and contributing author in the development of the ANCHOR and EDASP software packages commercially distributed by S&A.
Mr. Djordjevic is expert in the area of seismic fragility analysis and dynamic qualification of electrical and mechanical equipment. He has participated in and managed over twenty major projects involving the evaluation and qualification of vibration sensitive equipment and seismic hardening of equipment. As demonstrated by his committee work and publications, Mr. Djordjevic has participated in and contributed steadily to the development of equipment qualification and vibration hardening methodology.
WCAP- 17678-NP, Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision I
H-8 PROFESSIONAL GROUPS Member, Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Nuclear Power Engineering Committee Working Group SC 2.5 (IEEE-344)
Chairman, Institute of Environmental Sciences, Working Group for Standardization of Reporting and Measuring Cleanroom Vibrations PARTIAL LIST OF PUBLICATIONS 1979 ASME PVP Conference, San Francisco, California, "Multi-Degree-of-Freedom Analysis of Power Actuated Valves", Paper No. 79-PVP-106.
1983 ASME PVP Conference, Portland, Oregon, "A Computer Code for Seismic Qualification of Nuclear Service Valves", Paper No. 83-PVP-8 1.
1983 ASME PVP Conference, Portland, Oregon, "Qualification of Electrical and Mechanical Equipment at Rocky Flats Reservation Using Prototype Analysis".
1984 ANS Conference, "Qualification of Class 1E Devices Using In-Situ Testing and Analysis."
1986 Testing of Lithography Components for Vibration Sensitivity, Microelectronics, Cahners Publishing 1990 Nuclear Power Plant Piping and Equipment Conference, "Development of Generic Amplification Factors for Benchboard and Relay Cabinet Assemblies", Paper No. 106, Structures and Components Symposium, held by North Carolina State University 1991 Electric Power Research Institute, "Development of In-Cabinet Response Spectra for Benchboards and Vertical Panels," EPRI Report NP-7146 WCAP-17678-NP., Supplement 1 June 2013 Revision I
CD
-o CD CD ta
V V -
~i)
- ~ ~..wmnnst rnnnnnnrn~~.wn~ ~
i~i C q 6~EPR! p 4
'0 C
Electric ResearchPower Institute W~cr~fictcorf Adjic c curt 0
CC 4 fl1is is to (grrtifij t1~at 4
C Walter :431,0r-b I*ruir 4 4as Tompletirb I
C C
§N*Sir ui 3 KE Tolursr C
1+31 1992~
C C
'A LiDavid A. Freed, MPR Associates SQUG Training Coordinator
,, T Robert P. Kassawara. EPRI SQUG Program Manager
==*
=ipmh*Nt=*
gg J 0N WN NUNN TO"INWESIV =*
,0
C-)
C (b
4~:1~.
T11x I I1T1111 T1,1111rIIyIIII IT TI IIT TII IrTI rlX IIIIIIIVx 'l IIIIX IIT I I X141 111T-IAI I rII4 C4 05 EU, C4 Certificate of Completion 1ý1- E kwA4 Walter Djordjevic Success~lul Completed Training on Near Term Task Force Recommendation 2.3 - Plant Seismic Walkdowns Date: 06/26/12 Bruce M. Lor(- Instructor Ilk&
NTTF 2.3 Seismic Walkdown Course
)
- ~- ~- -