IR 05000440/1979008
| ML19256F218 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Perry  |
| Issue date: | 11/05/1979 |
| From: | Norelius C, Phillip G, Williams C NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19256F217 | List: |
| References | |
| 50-440-79-08, 50-440-79-8, 50-441-79-08, 50-441-79-8, NUDOCS 7912180234 | |
| Download: ML19256F218 (23) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:' . . U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
OFFICE F INSPECTION AND ENFORCEMENT
REGION III
i f Seport No.
50-440/79-08; 50-441/79-08
i Rocket No.
50-440; 50-441 License No. CPPR-148; CPPR-149 , Licensee: Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company Post Office Box 5000 Cleveland, OH Facility Name: Perry Nuclear Power Plant, Units 1 and 2 Dates of Investigation: September 25 - 26, 1979 Investigation At: Perry, Ohio , . ? / f/ f Investigator:- . A.
hillip e - l5 A N LL l n u lg lq q Reviewed by: C. E. Morelius, Assistant to th Director W, ~ J2y p.
. Cordell Williams, Reactor Construction and Engineering Support Projects Section No. 2 Investigation Summary: Investigation on September 25 - 26, 1979 (Report No. 50-440/79-08 and 50-441/79-08).
Areas Investigated: An anonymous individual alleged two techinicians employed by U.S. Testing Company at the Perry site had performed work for which they were not qualified. The investigation of this allegation consisted of a review of pertinent procedures and records and interviews of personnel and involved eight investigation hours by one investigator.
Results: The allegation was not substantiated and no items of noncom-pliance were identified.
!1i .i
i i 1608 212 79121802 34
. REASON FOR INVESTIGATION . An unsigned letter dated June 23, 1979 was received by Region III al-legingthattechniciansemployedbyU.S.TestingCompanyattheferry Nuclear Power Plant site performed tests before documentation r(flected gthey were trained and qualified to perform them.
-I } t SUMMARY OF FACTS An anonymous letter dated June 23, 1979 was received by Region III al-leging U.S. Testing Company personnel at the Perry site were performing tests before documentation reflected they were qualified to perform them.
Copies of several U.S. Testing Company records relating to two specific individuals were enclosed with the letter.
The investigation determined that one individual was employed for a few days. During this time he performed a test in the field under the sur-veillance of the laboratory supervisor and was fired for inadequate perfo rmance.
The file of the second individual will show he was a qualified Level 2 Inspector at the time he performed tests corresponding to the copies of records furnished by the alleger.
Based upon an examination of these two specific examples, the allegation was not substantiated.
An overall evaluation of the training and qual-ification program of U.S. Testing was not undertaken during this in-vestigation.
No items of noncompliance were identified.
.l I i i
? o . 1608 213 ~
'. DETAILS 1.
Persons Contacted E Cleveland Electric Illuminating j i i W. Kacer, CQS General Supervising Engineer Gilbert Associates Inc.
R. L. Vondrasek, CQS Quality Engineering Supervisor J. J. Connelly, CQS Lead Civil Quality Engineer Kaiser Electric Inc.
M. Kritzer, QA Engineer, Civil U.S. Testing Company A. C. Von Nyvenheim, Site Supervisor P. Wang, Assistant Lab Supervisor 2.
Introduction By letter dated June 23, 1979 an anonymous individual provided copies of records relating to the qualifications of two technicians employed by the U.S. Testing Company (UST) at the Perry Nuclear Power Plant (PNPP) as well as records of tests on which their names appeared. These records were supplied to demonstrate that the in-dividuals performed functions before they were qualified for them.
Copies of qualification records and test documents supplied by the anonymous alleger relating to individual A are attached to this report as Exhibit A.
Copies of similar documents supplied by the alleger relating to Individual B are attached as Exhibit B.
This investigation was limited to an examination of the qualifica-tions and work of those two individuals.
3.
Qualifications and Work Performed By Individual A The UST Lab Supervisor advised that Individual A had previously been employed by UST at the Midland site. After an extended leave of absence he was re-hired by UST for work at PNPP. After Individual A had undergone a few days of orientation and appeared to understand his job, the Lab Supervisor prepared a Proficiency Evaluation Record dated April 9, 1979.
Individual A then worked with other inspectors l performing a few tests. The inspectors who worked with Individual A Y informed the Lab Supervisor that they were of the opinion that - { Individual A did not know how to perform the work. The Lab; Supervisor i-said he assigned Individual A to perform a test in the field and then observed his actions from a distance. On the basis ofihis observations, the Lab Supervisor concluded that Individual b's performance was unsatisfactory and fired him.
1608 214-3- >
The Lab Supervisor stated he subsequently learned that Individual A had suffered a nervous breakdown following his employment at Midland.
He said he had concluded that Individual A's inability to perform as an inspector at PNPP after having performed the same work at Midland was due to his illness.
3 t It was noted that UST files contained a Documentation of Qpalifications - I certifying Individual A as a Level IB inspector which was dated t April 12, 1979. A copy of this record was obtained and is attached to this report as Exhibit C.
The Lab Supervisor had no explanation as to why this document was dated after Individual A had performed some inspection work on April 9 and 11, 1979 and his performance was found to be unsatis-factory. The Lab Supervisor however, pointed out that Individual A had only worked two or three days with other inspectors before he was terminated on April 13, 1979.
4.
Qualifications of Work Performed By Individual B UST files regarding Individual B contained records showing he was certified as a Level I inspector on August 29, 1977 and as a Level II on April 24, 1978. The Level II Documentation of Qualifications was updated on November 13, 1978 and again on March 26, 1979.
Copies of these documents were obtained and are attached to this report as Exhibit D.
It was noted that the earlier Level II Documentation of Qualification records, those dated April 24, 1978 and November 13, 1978 had not been among the materials supplied by the anonymous alleger. These Documentations of Qualification predate the January,1979 test records on which Individual B's name appears as a Level II inspector.
It was noted however, that none of Individual B's Documentations of Qualification indicate he was certified for test ASTM C-127-68 or C-127-73.
On the January, 1979 record for these tests (Exhibit B, page 4) which was supplied by the alleger Individual B'r; nam appears in the " checked by" blank. The Lab Supervisor stated that.he test was performed, as indicated on the test record, by a qualified Level II inspector and that Individual B had merely checked the mathematical calculations of the data entered on the record. He stated that an individual performing this function need not be qualified to perform the test.
It was ascertained that Individual B is no longer employed by UST having terminated his employment on or about May 25, 1979.
1.
Close-Out Discussion I i ( On September 26, 1979 the investigation findings were discussed with the following site personnel: R. L. Vondrasek, J. J. Connelly, and M. Kritzer.
It was indicated that although some discrepancies were noted in the records relating to Individual A, his employmeIlt at the-4-1608 215
~ site was brief and there was not sufficient basis for a finding of noncompliance.
It was further indicated that although some ad-ditional records and related procedures had been reviewed, the in-vestigation had been limited to a review of the qualificati,ons and work performed by two former UST employees only.
{ t
?: Attachment: Exhibits A 'F t through D
5 s Y- ! I
. - 1608 216-3-
w ar . i 'g PROFICIE.NCY EVALUATION RECORD Name (Individual A) (Last) (Fi rst) gin 1-ai k k eo o D'3'I(A) .j-ou
Evaluated For Level - IB care 4-9-79 '.ocatic e. PNPP ' Inscection and' Test. Activity Civil Soils and Concrete Tests Aab And Field JC Ph. cadure or Test 5tandard - Applicable Job Specifications, QCP's and Instructions t CHECX POINTS RESULT 5* - Oral intarview Prac: ,I.
Work Activities / Tasks S i Z.
Inspection / Test Critaria S ~ S l S 3.
Ac:aptance Standards S l S
Recording of Inspection /Tes: Results S S 5.
Nonconformances S S 5.
Designateo Types of Ins'pections
7.
Tecnnician Responsibilities
, S b . A5ME Ceces', AS.TM 3 tis, etc., Recuirements as Acolicarie ~ S 3.
S l S E
- .
Use anc Calibra ti:n Control o .n.spect on, -- . " Examinaticn anc Testing Etui: ment S S ' ~,. .; Evaluation Of Insrection Test Results NA l NA
- .
Proficiency in Supervision of L:wer Lavei Personnel '2.
EreDaration of Insoection anc Test ., _ MA NA_ i Procacures ! NA I
- 2.
Ur.cers:anoing Of COnstructicn Cuality NA. ~ ;ntrol Fr: gram Requi. e:r.ents . NA NA, 'd.
!acacility fer Reviewing anc Acoroving $ Ins ec: on, E.xamination ana Testing er:cacures . nA nt
- 5.
. Cacao.111:y for Evaluating -he Aceouacy of Activities to Ac:: molt sn 'ne :nssection, - E.ta=ina: en and Tes: Objec: ves NA NA ".se "S" jfor Sa:isfac::ry, '"J" 'or 'Jnsati sfac::ry, 'NA" #:r !o:
- heck 05ints Aco!'can: e,-cr -acn '.avel :
Acciica:1e.
- ? _ ave i. t i aru.h .avei... ; nru.... 1 : o: ona,., :. ave s ?...;: . c.'tru :.- ... .. .,. .x.. = . . EE?d.%RKS -; o WW Y @ sm l -
II nature f _ L _ . E '.a ve l en .t 2 1 er - - - - I* i".nial Recar-.fication i Sicnattre 1Ana 717 - '~~' _ _ I-Ca t2 ' .
- t - - _.. t - . Exhibit d _._. . , .. _., g, m,.-- r. %, -, __.-, - Page 1 gr.o .. , u.-m - v..------- - _ - - - - .. -...
., .............. . CLIENT - C.E.1.
" . O' exoa r: J08-PNPP UNITS 1 & 2 - N'W ' P.O. #-1092
- port ~10: __
Re .'
? '2io Cr$5S SOIL: . Date ,,,_/) - 4, - i,.,, ,
,
- .
_ 5511s!,7,n=pec or: Anca:c e/ni ' _ - (Individua1 A) '. 'D25t N y , - o.
Oqf6 /[Cf $
, t -
- 1.oca tion n $0.310
'
- .
_ . _ '_ E 9M _ - _ Q yk &u. . . _ __ _ y Offset JV ] tem __ _ y _ ' i ift. of Apraratus & Sand, Ib
- Elevation fio
_
3 'Jbtal Sand.4Yt. of Apparatus T. Unused Sand, lb _ jS. n _ in hole, Core & Plato Ib. (1)-(2
_j oo D2nsity of Calibrated Sa.-d pcf (Form 10-8A) ) ^
J 2.S*) ~ Volu e of hole, c=ne,& plate, cu. ft.
89.2 2 6 Volune of core & plate cu. ft.
(3);(4) - 7 volute of hola, cu. ft.
(Form 10-8A) . syo 9 (5)-(G) . o 9,.y 0992 et Density 5.>2tc=inaticn . ifet Wt. of mt:1 t, centa'3cr, Ib {
. ) 10 9 Tare Nt..of car.tcircr, lb Ti"9G~ - ~ lbt 1.'t. of !* t' r, lb (C)-(9) ^ ~~ ' a
l , (, y- -l . Wet 6:nsity r, oil, pcf (10);(7) ., (, ,7.2 q l - J T*i.o !bisture Ibtermi:ution . I
13 Dry h't. of soil & centainer, pstbt Ut, of coil a contaimr, ~ 14 Ut. of water ,yoe ~ Contaimr p, ~ps (12)-(13) ~jg7,f ~ ---
16 Dry 1Yt. of soil (13)-(15)
t .
, 3oy p
tbisture contant, t ((14);(lG))x100 .
p-jj,7 . ., t Ecrccnt Cc.,= action y, g g g '8 Dry D:nsi,y per ([11) + ( (17)+100)-)l00 9 Proctor'fuxim_m.
'O Optir:u.1 : bis ture,uansity pcf - Ig,g c/ ~ ~
' ~ 1 Perccnt Ccrinction ((1B);(19))x100 , , g' - i y . Ibrnished by ? M - - - . s
-
- f I i ,f .
. , I . - go$@ _ , - - , ' g - 3 r.nmen t No. 8
_ _ 1 10-8 ' d i l
- (
l ]
1 @ 8 218 , _ _ .. Exhibit A Page 2 nf A
' s-outNT - C.E.1, Asnt D1556-64 O 23 ~" JOB-PNPP UNITS 1 & 2 . p P.O. #-1092 NQ't 3".
' Cr$5S SorL: ~ - A oate /'df. 79 - - sEns Insb:or:
- . AREA:p %/ u ;2 ' g f Kn n-",o..,, n 'mst No - pvhi ' I , \\
- (.ocation N gnp7 k
S z,gexaty: - %,oW E pg_k __ .- , - Item v Of(set L \\ - T~tJt. of Agoratus & Sand ~ ' ' - , 2.Wt, of Apparatus & Unused S Elevation( go7j -- '
-
, Ib Udtal Sand in hole, Corc & Pl and, Ib A f, pp \\ \\
5 voltr:e of hole, cene & platD:nsity of Calibrated Sa- _p,@S ,6 \\ . Volune of cerc & p . orm10-8A) jg,gy _ g 4 g g ( 7 voltnc of hola, cu. late o, cu. ft.
_ (3) ~ (Form 10-8A)(4) ,, /gr.g ~ cu. ft.
ft. (5)-(G)
t et Density 02 terr:inaticn ~ i . 8 ifct Wt. of. Ibt'l L contaff - pT'-~
Tare Mt..of contain2r, Ib er, lb . ,
_ tht 1.t. of I:at'l', lb (0)-(9) , g.] - l1 Wet 6:nsity soil, p:f (10) (7)
- j Tl g
. l ~ - l g,92 t lbisturo Cetoreti:ntion ., (, - - tyd, g, t 3 Dry Wt. of soil & centairc2 tbt ut, of coil ~G ccTen - " . l i , gas Ut. of water r, gas gggg3
- contairer gn, g:s (12)-(13)
y epi E ~ ( lbisture Content, i, Dry Wt. of soil (13)-(15) ( .
. - ,j ((14) (16))x100 ,, y s g ,gg9
p , Percent Cc.,: action q -- - Dry Densit:y per y 7.
t j j hector Maxi:r.:n :.((nsity p::(f )+100)-)100 11) + (
g] optir: urn reisture, t u ' pyy \\ ^ ( ?crcent Cc.goction ((lB)
g . t l
- (19))x100
- Ashed by _. $ j .
g , fa)w . 4i ~ ( )z-i l'. g$b ' L
-
~ r i Int No. 8 . ' 8' \\ Q}9 1 Y l , - _ - _ . m ~,.,,,,,, u I _ . w n _r,a >--. --u t.
'
-, .. -... ... .... -..... - . Project: $h ph* ' 5s_1s,2.. Report No: i.ab. No: Op3/,FR . . srH Test:
71 Tag No.: ;79 // /(c.)
Class Soil': "A" FILL ~
003t500: /V/IM [O & 9 7' Mr IO 2 6 /- I Test Descripticxt: GRADATTON As 't38/ , Date Tested: Elevation: 693 Offset: P" _ r Washid Gradation Dry or t!ashedeGradation Pcs(s2 . l Act. Cu:n. ! Cur.. t ~ Act!. Cum.
Cum t i f Reta:r.cd Nt.iRet.
P.ctained Pas sinc Socc.
i Wt. Ret.
-
. . .. ..
s.. . . ' t sc , B/4
100 . . \\& C / ^9 0 /00 \\ _ _ . - i !_14" i 1.. ._ l'
j OC 85-100 - i O WO /00 ' I . t ' ' i n - -- yff l &l . o fe-e o too i - - 60-100 l F.0 4 93-I@ q v,9 l i - , i , t ' is , " I '@ /et,7 33.est
j i i . .i
i 1:16 - k28) 275'1 5/.34
\\ j i l i ~ I ' on _ Iws j @ 4-09..;2-73. m
, i - - j tsb } . . t '
- . 6 id 5fa,6 9 7. y'/ _T ! ' l l Gb 557.O c1f, 92 /. / l
- -5
,. r idSh4 al*Cr C35h - SICYC SI 2C bh. O. . ' a I Total
_ _.
__ . _ _ Rerv4f A3 * Technidiarl* (Individual A) _ 9T~$ ~WTW - neview.a sy: +M ~ - a m y=~= n3.2 rom 10-2 v ,t ta' e v - - - - - 1608 220 _
.-.- onnunesvna . -- suu-PNPP UNITS lf.2.. . I'4 port No: STH Test: ~N3b 1 _ l.ab. No; ' '
__ gpyjp g _ Tag No.:_ 21/O./(c.)
Test Descriptico: C1,us Soil: "A" FIu, camATTon _ .Date Tested: _ lo:stion:_ Ih// e+<-,.u. 54/70 hof Washed Gradatio,n _ Elevation: _ 6 P7 Offset: P" B:
9 yio Dry or Washedpradation Act. Ctn.
' Cum. t
'
Nt.! Ret.
P.etained i Passinc , Socc.
, .[Wt. Ret Act. Cta.
L Ctr.. * < '
,
L 6" t Reta:ned.
Pcssint ' n . , . i i - I - q ' - 3a ' , - l - - d t
o l 100 j o /o o i I .14"
E > t
_ L 1" , I.
a L
h ' -
o a /00 85-100 i ) t ' i i - 1/2" h l
i ] t -_ , i h ~ l i i ' '1 , t I o
/00 ~ ip 47.s g II u.. t 7, , 9/ ij 60-100 ( . { .. !S i f , _ h t I l 30,'Z. / ?!
SY _ i .I , i 35 06 16l ] \\ ' [ _ hp-92.0 5;2p l _ l - I , i +'e d-N l _
L
s _ L U jsas _ , , 4/2, 9 ~':.1 7 j lb~h5 a r . , . .
. _ _0 ,r j < - - . n . l p l
' {i , - 53d,Y h 9 7,.fS' t/ t d 2.
~Il $ -di- )f
b SS~C. Y N ? 7.3 2 l D. 7 $
- ~5
{ L I G
i ch4 af:cr e.sh - Sieve siac 5 6 0,2 j - - 3.- c , -
t_ - Total emirb il - i I n i r - __ [ Technician (Individual A) > d ReVicW.d by:[" h[' _ ATTACl:?1ENTNb.2 Form 10-2 f8Pbd c
Project: $o
- '
rp t; Irs _15, k: ort A : 1.ab. No-
- MJN
. .
- '
~ Class Soil: "A" FILL (. ASTH Test: 3 71 Tag No.: aqop ec Test Description: anAnAtron Lo:stion: Sp// F t m n, ca oo Ds 99W Dat Tested: <//v/79 Elevation: aW Offset: /.2 ' Dry of Washai Gradation Dry or WashesGradation
-Act. Ctra.
Cum. % % . l Act. Cum.{ Cur.. t
' .' WtjRc't.
P.ctained Pas sinc Socc.
t t.
Ret.
Retnined P:ssi: . 't. . -
6 I ~ ' ' ' - e
3st a - l 100 h
0 /00 l - ) . _14" l . 1" , I - 85-100 3/4" O
/00 - l 1/2
. . i ( l.3 h sc o . . 60-100 l @ 4o. V 7.25
i ! !?, l / d 9. / 2 &. 4,4 7/ l ' i
rM '
1 - 2 S9. & t/&. 72
. i e r 3r) l l ! 297,/ 7 /. 4/ 7 Af f 16-45 l 155 . . . . - e ' S 53 9 16 99
l ! O 5 49.1 27o /,3 l l
-5 , i.
feish4 af:cr ensh - Sieve size j , ~ , y i Total g rS-4 li l E* 4 'A' "D ~ ~ Technician: (Individual A) f L '
' ' " " " Reviewed by:luhbs 16I)8 222 ATuomar d 2 rcra m-2 vgudicJ s
w DOCUMENT OF (ANSI N4 5-3,6)OUALIFICATION ~ This is to , certify that has been and is qualified services in the following to perf orm inspectio (Individual B) ,_ areas: - ASTM Test Numbers: testing n and 0-31-69, C-33-71a, 0- ) c-136-71, c-138-73, c39-72, G-LO-73, 0-117-6 i i ?: C-566-67 c-702-75143-71 D-75-71,D-1556-64, D-2049-49 D His capa.
0-62-68,,c'-29-48, c,-617-73,D 1 -
, bility in these areas i - 557-70, D-2034 , -2216-71, , Basis for Certificati s Level IIc on: Formal Education . ._.innlied Science. Construction TechnolS.U.N.Y. a r: Associates Degree in ' Related Training __priental to th Graduated June 1975 _ ogy.
ANSI NIA.2 5. ANSI N45,2 6 e requirements of Appendix B t o 10CFR50, , testing and inspection of construction material, A L102, HL-105, UST-Audit-1 United States Testing Quality . rocedures of , UST-CA-1, UST-W1, SQC 151 Contro Related Experience, fi/10/78 t rough s: ., FL-101QCF-14, HIr-101, hns been trained to rerform tho tresent-United States . . e Co., Inc. - He . e additional duties of a Level II These inclu.ie the ability t . > Tn addition, he bm been extensiv l_ o.sunervise.. and evaluate Technician.
gdibration for all iobsite t e y trained to cerform the cerfomed by others.
he has demonstrated his ability testing eculpment.
entire ranne of Subsecuent to this traini f calibration program for the t manage, without direct sur o ng,
esting lab.
~ ervision, the Power Plant (UST) He has perfom d 8/22[77toL/10/78-Per 7echnician in _a satisfactory mane the duties of a Level I N e ry Nuclear uclear Testing and documentat{on of the afo These duties include the p f r.
% rementioned ASTM tests.
omance t er Ffebbf He has been thorough 15
gM , ' De///j$,, Ms ay: ' signated ' United States TestiRepr.dsentative ' ,,
W . ng Co.
}
. i Exhibit B . Page 1 of 4
p. s i - g - _ y I DOCUMEj t. T OUALIFICATION (ANSI N45-2. 6) ~ This is to certify that services in the following areahas been and is _ nnatvidual B) erform inspection and testi_ng s:- } . .
l ~.
- .
His canability in these areas is I,evel 1. asis for Certification _ IIC -: Relat*od Experience. trained end also . htinn_and docum.c_ntation. observed in the nerfom . rnee nr the applicable jobsite specific tiIn addition, he has been fe _ zed with a on.
6/77 to 8/77: Soils Investigation, Inc. - Duties i Worked at Ernpi_re - all phases of construction, concrete plncluded testing and in
acement and backfill.
Jerfonned routine in-omcess test _.- He has s on fresh concrete operations, and soils backfin. H batch vlant _ _ Level IIC for the dates of 3/19/79 thru the prese ha __ a b _ e Concrete Co-ortlinator.
ent.
His duties vill _ - _ - _ - _ _ , . - - _ ~
_ ' i - $ , i_ __
. J . - Date:- l608 224 ,
_ By: _ Designated Representativ ~ United States Testing Co e . ' 2 l' & $ ~.sb S L NfD:* ll Page 2 o."
Exhibit B ' M'k;; 2 ='-
UNITED STATES TESTING CO , Pine Aggrega te sieve Anayisis nep ANY, INC, Perry fluclear Power Pla ZG0I # 'O ; . ort - & ~ g' Units 1 and 2 Date sonpled:j' @&;/qw h h f J.k C C'lC nt 8088)les.
b ~.\\bt$ F-soinpled Dy: [/' ab No.
_
i _ - - Date - SIEVE ANAL YSIS ASTH-C136t-\\i' ')9 SAMPLE IDENTITY - SAND-71*
F64 bat'54e/4 SIEVE SIZE ACCUHULATED.
WE,1GHT, GHS.
PERCENT . . _ 3/8" RETAltlED PERCElli , O _.
No. 4 P_A SS IftG - O S'PECS.
~ O [00 _ Ho.'8 O 100 /.[ /8-8
Ho.16.__ ,
- $
No.30 - 102 7 O. [7 95-100 - /85 - . 39'f.k . /613 80-1M 8&6d Of'. O' . _f_f_ 11o.50 so-8s . [@8, O '$6 Of . __fgS__ No.100 ' 2_S-60 ' __[[_, PAN fN 3f ]_0- 30 . $3d. Y
. 'A4 2-10 Ac F.H.
?< $0 m .
.. , Ma ter.ai Finer than !{o 2.3-3.1 200 Sieve ASTM-C117-69 . ORIGINAL DRY WEIGHT- . ' DRY WEIGHT AFTER WASHI!1G [3[,[ - [3 d, S , - , .$ LOSS
. [. 3 fEST PERFORMID BY PERCEllT LOSS !b I0 .AB CHIEF REVIEW ~~
- '
UALITY C0!! TROL REVIEW RESUL TS CitECKED BY ' ' A 0 5,* eve ' -
d"* d " . thnd fe ansake,i - yg ggg.. ' n-10, 6Peb 76
- ~^~
, - -, - - . = _. _.., -... _.... - - - Exhibi,t 3 __ -- . n
W5' ' . CLIENT - C.E.I.
. . J0ll-PNPP UNITS 1 & 2 ..' P.O. #-1092 - . MONTHLY TEST RESULTS OF' CONCRETE FINE & COARSE AGG.
I
. .FOR: 7* I 1.
PROJECT'. PNPP - TEST ASTM C-128-68 & C-127-73 - , DATE SAMPLED: /- d - 29 DATE TESTED: /- - /9 - ~ #8 bADDu?~ D= th+Gb - G C . Q h gri< Fine AgU. ASTM C-128-68 Pa l - x 100 ! SAMPLE NO.
s-1 ks-2 s-3 A[g.
A. PYC + H 0 633.[o 653.8 653.6 - B. PYC+H,0 + Sample k b 2. 2.
9 b2.9 N 6 2.. [ C. Ut. of SSD Sample. Foo. O S00.0 500.0 ' " D. SP.G (SSD) .'2. 612.
_~2.. b 21 . 2. 6 ( 8 .~2..b2.
_.
' E. Ut. of oven dry sanoln 49 h,3 M9 7, l $Q 6.@ _ F. % Absorntion O. b 'l.
O. NO O.61 0. 6 . I - COARSE AGG ASTM C-127-73 A h-B-D=A-C < x 100 SIZE c \\" Poa Gravel l' 3/4" Limestone _ Sanple Nt:tber 1 " Limestor.e P-1 P-2 P-3 'C-1 C-2 C-3 L-1 L-2 !L-3 A.
SSD Wt. in Air SYO'7 SW1 35'7/ / , B.
Wt. in Water /A / ElV/ 217Y 22bb N/4) c.
we. Oven Dry / 3383 3VV8 35yf ' D.
t Absorption j O.7 / G70 07/ ! ' E.
Avg. Absdrption
O.7 X XX F.
SP.G.
(SSD) ,
2.69I .2.d78 G.
Avg. SP. G ..3 b78
.2.68 Acceptance criteria for S.G. for F.A s Acceptance criteria for S.G. for C.A: min. (Acceptance criteria: min. lFor F. A :me t 'e s ted byPrA fif Leve12C. Checked byJIndIB) I no _ For C. A :ce t__ ' M Level _
- I.
'.7G E er S d R.I'J.JK,u w., ...I. '.1.' e 4.... . -......
, Exhibit B - w.
_ .._.r JJ:. Es. f.5D+T.'N.N"' 4 ~7 8 m . ._, - ... _...... - . ._...--=.m.. - -
+ UNITED STATES TESTING COMPANY, INC.
, DOCUMENT OF OUALIFICATION (ANSI N4 5-2. 6) ~ . This is t'o certify that _ (I"diVid"81 *) .. has been and is qualified to per i -- services. in -the following areas s form s.nspection 4@ testing ~
-
x.
- - - ' s His canability in these areas is Level . IB Basis for Certification: _ Formal Education . esy4, TMhnninev at T.ansinc c . Related Training - unity collere Michiga,n Department of State Highways at transportationEn in concrete and soils technology.
Self instruction . Related Experience _ r._e_9otn _ 1-7 4-70 TL et Testing. Pan,< maeleer pnw.r ulant.
Five years with Michiran Dent. of ' State Hichways _ _ (cor: rete, soils, and lab work).
and Transportation Also Employal by U.S. Testin), at the _ Midland Michigan Project.
Oriented to Apperriix B to 10CFR50, ANSI N45 2 5 an _ NLS.2.6 and United States Testine, Quality Control Procedures . _ , OCP-1 thn2 _ QCP 14, AL-101, HL-102, HL-105, UST audit 1, USTCA-1 - FL-101.
, UST-M 1, sac 15.1 and - _ - - . - - -_ e - - E $ g ? v - ~ _
- 'c: 'l 2 /19 A gf R.7f 1608 227
. By: " J-h nc h a u ,/- ,. d & ltu t ~z f t.;. T,2 %.a s'-6.i Designated Rep'res6ntat$ve - . United seates resti=; ca.
- - - WW Wzs/7 9 5Yh' ?,
( " 'Tgg' I i . - , I~ b- ---
-............ ; , . DOCUMENT OF OUALIFICATION
i (ANSI N45-2. 6) ' .fb7) . ,.. e, ... - - . - -... This is to certify that n., m. 4,,,,, o has been and is qualified to pertor:n inspection and testing services..in the fellowing areas-
AS'q{ Test Ihu::bers: 0-31-69, C-33-71a, C-39-72, C-40-73 C-117-69, C-125-68, ~C-136-71, C-138-73, C-143-71, C-172-71, C-183-73, C-192-69, i i C-231-72T, C-566-67, C-702-75, D-75-71, D-1556-64, D-2049-69, D-2216-71, D-42-73 . His caeability in these areas is Level I ~ Basis for Certification: . - For:nal Education c: U.4 J. at Osnton.New Yo W.
a=socintee U mn-= = % Applied Science, Construction Technology.
Relate?. Training Oriented to the recuirements of Accendix B to 10 CFR 50, ANSI 115.2 5. ANSI IL5.2.6, ANSI ?E5.2.16. ed the Standard Procedures of test- ,ima,_ani jnspectim.of constructien materials for power generation projects: United States Testing Quality Control Procedures GCP-1 through QCP-14, HIr-101, HL-102, HL-105, UST-Audit-1, UST-CA-1, UST-TQ-1, SQO 15.1, FL-101.
Related Deperience: to cresent-United States Testine. Perry Nuclear power Plant He has performed the duties of a Level Ienuclear testing technician in a satisfactory canner. These duties include the performance and docunentation - of the aforementioned AS'IM tests. He has been thoroughly trained and also ob-served in the oerfo =ence of testinc and documentcticn.
In addition. he has been familiarized trith the applicable jobsite specifications.
- 6/77 to 8/77: Worked at Empire Soils Investigation, Inc. - Duties included testing and inspection of all phases of construction, concrete placement and back 111
He has performed routine in process tests on fresh concrete, batch Plant operations, and soils backfill.
. . . Date: 8 o7 f-77 RECEIVED By: M cn 4v SEP I UII Des:.gnatec Represe' nta t.: ve - jp g United States Tasting C Q 8 220 .sjv 7 PNPP.-SOlDC Page1o? ' r7
- s . _ DOCUMENT OF QUALIFICATION (ANSI N45-2. 6) This is to certify that _ has been and is qualified to per (Individual B) services in the following areas: form inspection anq testing ASDf Test Numbers: 0-31-69, 0-33-71a, 0-39-72, 0-40-73, 0-117-6
t'- 136-71,-0-138-73; c=12i3:71, 0-172-71 0-125-68, , {t 0-231-72T, 0-566-67, 0-702-75, D-75-71, D-1556-64, D-20 , 0-18 " 17: G7, , D-2216-71, ".',2 73 D -Ao 3 y( 'f).- 6 8, C.)J - 6 0, C-f,/7-7) , D- / 597-7of His cacability in these areas is Level II Basis for Certification: Formal Education Applied Science, Construction Technology.S.U.N.Y. at Canton, New York: . Associates Degree in Related Training _ Graduated June,1975.
Oriented to the recuirements of Appendir B to 10 CFR 50 N YS.2.b _ ANSI 245.2.5, ANSI C;.2 5, AmI E5.2.16, and the Stananni Proced , ing and 'inspectioxibi' ca" *~m+46" ~+a'4a1= fn* mua* canam+ 4 6n m n iecta - _184 + a c+,t a.
Te=+4na on=14tv Coritrol Prceadures DCP-1 thro uch OCP-14, W 101, W102. W10% USB-Audit-1, Usp-CA-1, UST 'IQ-1 , SOC 15.1, FL-101.
4/10/78 . Related Exoerience : to present - thited States Testing Co., Inc. - He has been trained to perfom the additional duties of a Ievel II Technici an.
These include the ability to supervise end evaluate the work perfomed by oth ers.
In addition, he has been extensively trained to perfom the entire range of calibration for all jobsite testing equipment.
Subsequent to thia
training, he has demonstrated his ability to mnnge, without direct supervision, the calibration pr _ ogram for the testing lab.
8/22/77 to 4/10/78 - Peuy thelear Power Plant (UST) He fomed the duties of a Ievel I nuclear testing technician in a satisfactory mannar{ These duties include the perfomance ard doc ___ . umentation of the afore-mentinh ASTM tests. He has been thorou6hly trained and also obser'ved in the Date:__ Y df ~ ~/k . . _ By: /I s% ' _ } y g/ g Des 1gnatec Representat1ve ~ <- United States Testing Co.
1608 229 . - Exhibit D Page 2 of 7
g . g" tu dlAltb 1 t b il N L.s L.,U M Q Y lW L.e.
's ,. , a < , ' Sheet 2 ' DOCUMENT OF OUALIFICATION (ANSI N45-2,6) This is to certify that _ (Individual B) has been and is qualified to perform inspection and xesting _ _ _... se.pt, ices. in..the following areas - j
? . His capability in these areas is Level II Basis for Certification: . Formal Education - Related Training Related Experience verfomance of testing and documentation.
In addition, he has been fa:nmnvized with the applicable jobsite specification.
6/77to8/77: Worked at Dspire Soils Investigation, Inc. - Duties included testing and inspection of all phases of construction, concrete placement and back fill.
He has perfonned routine in process tests on fresh concrete, batch plant operations, and soils backfill.
.
5 h ! x
T 1608 230 Date: By: Designatec Representative United States Testing Co.
Exhibit D , Page 3 of 7
UNirED STATES TESTING COMPANY, INC.
DOCUMENT OF OUALIFICATION . - (ANSI N45-2. 6) This is to certify that
(Individual B) services in the following areas:has-been and is quaII'fied to perfor
ASTk Test Enbers: 0-31-69, 0-33-71a, 0-39-72, 0-40-73, 0-117-69, 0-125-48, 0-136-71, 0-138-73, 0-143-71, 0.-172-71, 0-183-73, 0-231-72T, 0-566-67, 0-702-75 D-75-71, D-1556-64, D-2049-69, D-2216-71, 0-42-68, 0-29-48, 0-617-73, D-1557-70, D-m34 His cacability in these areas is Level II Basis for Certification: . . Formal Education _ S.U.N.T. at Canton, New York $ Associates Degree in Applied Science, Cbnstruction Technology.
Graduated June, 1975.
Related Training Oriented to the requirements of Append 42 B to 10CFR50, ANSI 145.2 5, ANSI N45.2.6, ANSI 145.2.16, and the Standard Procedures of testing.andsinspection-of construction material = for power generation proj United States Testing Qun14ty Control Procedures QCP-1 through QCF14 . HL-101, HL-102, HL-105, us-Audit-1, UST-CA-1, UST-IQ-1, SQc 15.1, FL-101.
Related Ecperience: 4/10/78 to present-TMted States Testing Co., Inc.- He has been trained to nerform 'the additional. duties of a Ievel II Tec . These include the abil4ty to supervise and evaluate the work performed by othe . . In addition, he has been extensively trained to perform the entire range of calibration ^for all jobsite testing equipnent.
Subsequent to this training, he has demonstrated liis ability to manage, without direct supervision, the en14hration program for the testing lab.
8/22/77 to 4/10/78 - Pe w Nuclear Power kant (UST) He has performed the duties of a Invel I Nucle
Techhialan in a satisfactory manner.
These duties include the performance and documentation of the aforementioned ASTM tests.
He has been thoroughly Date: // /P </ ~ By: / // [ 1608 231 'g, utT* #/z1ha' / ' s Designated Representac2ve g, gg United States Testing Co. ' - . Exhibit D Page 4 of 7 . -
( UNITED STATES TESTING COMPANY, INC.
- Sheet 2 DOCUMENT OF QUALIFICATION (ANSI N45-2. 6) Thh.s is to certify that (Individu 1 B) }
h&s-been and-is qualified to perform inspection and mesting sesvices in the following areas: t His canability in these areas is I,evel TT . Basis for Certification: . Formal Education Related Training _ trained and also observed in the cerforsnea of testing and documentation.
In addition, he has been familiarized with the apolicable.lobsite'erecification.
6/77 to 8/77: Worked at Envire Soils Investigation, Inc. - Duties included testing nnd inspection of all phases of construction, concrete placement and backfill-He has perfor=ed routine in-process tests on fresh concrete, batch plant operations, and soils backfill- , . c.
. .. '
> i + i
- , '608 232 ' Date: // J f By:
/ e s Designated Repregentative United States Testing Co.
Exhibit D Page 5 of 7
, - --.... - v.-w....v v v....,- .. u m.
. DOCUMENT OF OUALIFICATION
(ANSI N45-2.6) . This is to certify that _(Individual B) has been and is qualified to per seryices in the following areas: form inspection and te ting ASTM Test Numbers: s
' C-136-71, 0-138-73, 0-143-71, 0-172-71C-31-
. _ -. --. S . - , C-42-68, 0-29-68, c.-617-73, D-1557-70, D , 0-183-73, C-231-72T His capability in these areas is Level IIC Basis for Certification: _ Formal Education _ S.U.N.Y. at Canton, New York: . Associates Degree in _an H M 9eience. Constnietion Technology.
Graduated June 1975.
Related Training _ Oriental to the reouirements of Appendix B t _ o lOCFR50.
ANSI NL5.2.5. ANSI NL5.2.6. ANSI Nh5.2.16. and the St andani Procedures of _ testine and inspection _of construction materials for power ge United States Testing Quality Control Procedures QCP 1 thr _ _ L102, blOS, UST-Audit-1, UST-CA-1, UST-TQ-1, SQC 15.1, FL-101o
- Related Evperience . L/10/?a_tn preent-United States Testing Co.. Inc. - He . hem been trphed to perfom the additional duties } of a Level II Technician.
_ These include the nbiH tv to supervise and evaluate the work perf . In addition. he has been extensively trained to perf y others.
_ om the entire rance of f calibration for all Mobsite testinc eculement.
Subsecuent to this training,
he has demonstrated his abilit3.yo manane, without dire t c supervision, the _ calibration pronram for the testing lab.
8'/22/77 to h/10/78 - Pen,y thiclear __ Power Plant (UST) He has nerfomed the duties of a L
Technicipn in a satisfactory maner.
evel I Nuclear Testing These duties include the perfomance _ _ and docu.
tation of the aforementioned ASTM tests.
He has been the ly Date: 7J24 / 4 g,, }gg By: / fy; A i Designated Repr4Sentative ~ . , United States Testing Co.
m Exhibit D ' Page 6 of 7 .
g _....uv. u v... v vv....... .... ~. .
. DOCUMENT OF (ANSI N45-2.6)OUALIFICATION,
This is to segvices.in. the.followinhas been and is qualif (Individual B) certify that _ _ _ _. . e to per r.
g ar."as: form inspection _
l and tiesting .q . _ _ _ _. .
- .
__ % His cacability in these Basis for Certificati areas is Level on: IIC Relat'ed Experience. trained testins; and documentatiand also observed in the perf . on.
onnance of the applicable jobsite In addition, he has been f - . specification.
amiliarized with Soils Investigation, Inc 6/77 to 8/77: ,,,, all phases of construction. - Duties included testing and iWorke nspection of . perfomed routine in-process t, concrete placement and bac He has . operations, and soils backfill ests on fresh concrete, bat h . c plant Level IId for the dates He has satisfactorly perf . be Concrete Co-onlinatorof 3/19[79 thru the present ormed as a His duties . . will . .. 1; L
'
- By: 1608 234 United States TestinDesignated Re ative g Co.
Exhibit D ,,. - }}