ML17324B219

From kanterella
Revision as of 09:33, 29 June 2018 by StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Review of App R Procedures for Post-Fire Remote Emergency Shutdown Outside Control Room,Dc Cook Nuclear Plant Units 1 & 2, Technical Evaluation Rept
ML17324B219
Person / Time
Site: Cook  American Electric Power icon.png
Issue date: 11/06/1986
From: FRESCO A
BROOKHAVEN NATIONAL LABORATORY
To:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Shared Package
ML17324B217 List:
References
NUDOCS 8702030539
Download: ML17324B219 (15)


Text

BROOKHAVEN NATIONALLABORATORY TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORTFORUSNUCLEARREGULATORY COMMISSION OFFICEOFNUCLEARREACTORREGULATION

'PWRDIVISIONOFLICENSING

-GROUPAPLANTSYSTEMSBRANCHREVIEWOFAPPENDIXRPROCEDURES FORPOST-PIRE REMOTEEMERGENCY SHUTDOWNOUTSIDETHECONTROLROOMLICENSEE:

Indiana&MichiganElectricCompanyFACILITY:

D.C.CookNuclearPlant,Units1&2REVELCONDUCTED:

October27-29'986NRCREVIEWERS:

A.Singh,NRRD.Wigginton, NRRBNLTECHNICAL SPECIALIST:

AnthyFresco(MechacalSystems)/I0ateBROOKHAVEN NATIONALIABORATOR" lpgQIASSOCIATED UNIVERSITIES, INC.CILII8702030539 870128PDRADOCK05000315FPDR

~~-ii-CONTENTSSectionPage1GENERALSUMMARY~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~2~PERSONSCONTACTED

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ee23~DOCUMENTS REVIEWEDe

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~3.13~23.3NRCCorrcapondence.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~LicenseeDocuments.

~~.~~~~~~..~~.~~~~~~~~~~..~~~.~.Procedures.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.~~~~~~~.~~..~~~...~~~~~~~~~~~~~e~~~~~~~3334~POSTFIRESAFESHUTDOWNe~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~'~~~~4.1SystemsRequiredforSafeShutdown.

~~~~~~~~.~~~~~~~4.2AreasRequiring Alternative Shutdown.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~46~PRCDURFS~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~e~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~5.1Procedure forUnit1RemoteEmergency Shutdown.

~~~~5.2RepairProcedures RequiredtoAchieveColdShutdown~~~~~~~~~~~~~~710ee 1~GENERALSUMMARYDuringthetimeperiodofOctober27-29,1986,ateamofNRCpersonnel fromtheOfficeofNuclearReactorRegulation, PlantSystemsBranchandtheDivisionofLicensing personnel andA.FrescoofBNLconducted aspecialreviewandwalk-downoftheemergency remoteshutdownandassociated repairprocedures asre-quiredbytheNovember22,1983SafetyEvaluation ReportfortheAlternate Shut-downCapability attheD.C.CookNuclearPowerPlant,Units162.TheteammemberswereassistedinthewalkdownbytheSeniorResidentInspector.

Theresultsofthisreviewwillbetransmitted toRegionIIIHeadquarters.

ThereviewwasnotintendedtoaddressotherAppendixRissues,suchasseparation ofcomponents requiredforsafeshutdown, associated

circuits, orfireprotection features.

Ingeneral,thelicensee's procedures werefoundtobeworkablebutcertainstepsrequirereorganization,

revision, oramplification toprovideadditional guidancetotheoperators.

Apotentially seriousproblemwasidentified tothelicenseeinapost-review conference callonNovember5,1986concerning Attach-mentNos.3and7whichrelatetolocalmanualde-energization ofbreakersintheSwitchGearRoomstopreventspuriousoperation ofpumpsandvalves.IfafireoccurredintheSwitchGearRoom,thealternative localoperations werenot'escribed intheprocedure, andupondiscussion withthelicensee, appearedtoinvolvepneumatic orelectrical jumpering duringHotStandbyorHotShutdownconditions.

SeeSection5.1.1(d)forfurtherdiscussion.

Possibleproblemswerealsoidentified withemergency lighting.

Thearrangement andusageof.thecross-ties'nd oppositeunitequipment toachievesafeshutdownintheaffecteduni(requiredclarification andanoverallanalysistojustifytheactions'aken in'"theprocedures toachievetheperfor-mancegoalsofAppendixR,e.g.,isolation ofletdownflow,usagerequirements forpressurizer PORVsandheaters,etc.wasnotavailable duringthereview.Itwasalsorecommended thatthelicenseeprovideachartindicating theassignment ofthepersonnel requiredtoimplement theprocedure.

Thelicenseewasadvisedthatifanylocaloperatoractionsarerequiredtobeperformed intheyardarea,e.g.,verification thattheflowpathisavailable andthereisasufficient highpressurenitrogensupplyforsteamgenerator power-operated reliefvalveoperation, that8-hourbatterypoweredemergency lightingisrequiredfortheaccesspathorelseanexemption requestshouldbefiled.Finally,theteamprovidedguidancetothelicenseeontheconductofafullscopeAppendixRaudit.

2.PERSONSCONTACTED NAMEW.G.Smith,Jr.J.E.Rutkowski PEJacquesK.R.BakerM.OnkenR.Heathcote W.NelsonD.RumpfH.RumserG.TollasJ.St.AmandJ.ConradJ.Stubblefield C.MilesJ.Feinstein A.AuvilR.L.ShobergW.G.SotosE.BrownG.WeberB.Jorgensen TITLEPlantManagerAss'tPlantMgr.QualityControl/FireProtection Coord.Operations Operations Operations Operations Operations Operations Operations Operations Operations TrainingI&CPlanningMgr.-NuclearSafetyLicensing NS&L...Asst.SectionMgr.-I&CI&CElectrical EngineerSectionManagerSeniorResidentInspect.COMPANYIndiana&MichiganElectricCo.I&MI&MI&MI&MI&MI&MI&MI&MI&MI&MI&MI&MI&MAmericanElectricPowerServiceCorp.AEPSCAEPSCAEPSCAEPSCImpellCorp.USNRC 3~DOClJMENTS REVIEWED3.1NRCCorresondence1.LettertoJ.E.Dolan,IndianaandMichiganElectricCompany(1&M)fromMr.C.E.Norelius, NRCRegionIII,datedSeptember 22,1982transmit-tingtheresultsofAppendixRauditconducted April12-16,May14,June10,1982atD.C.Cook.2.LettertoMr.J.E.Dolan,I&M,fromMr.S.A.Varga,Operating ReactorsBranchNo.1,DivisionofLicensing, datedNovember22,1983transmit-tingtheSafetyEvaluation ReportonAlternative ShutdownCapability atD.C.Cook.3.2LicenseeDocuments 1.Indiana&MichiganElectricCompany,"NuclearRegulatory Commission-AppendixRAudit-October27,1986-Alternate ShutdownCapability-DonaldC.CookNuclearPlant-Bridgman, Michigan."

3.3Procedures ZDNo.TitleRev.Effective Datel.**12WHP4023.100.001

=Unit1'Emergency RemoteShutdown02.**1MHP2140.082.001 Maintenance Procedure for-1Repowering an"kHRPump6/10/8610/23/863.**1MHP2140

~082.003Maintenance Procedure forRepowering Pressurizer BackupHeaters10/23/864~**1MHP2140.

082.005Maintenance Procedure forRepowering Containment Valves10/23/866.**1THP6030IMP.305AppendixRPost-Fire Repowering 1ofIn-Containment Valves5.**1THP6030IMP.304Pressurizer PORVCableRepair18/14/8610/23/86 4.POSTFIRESAFESHUTDOWN4.1SstemsRuiredforSafeShutdownThelicenseeprovidedabriefpresentation ofthesystemsrequiredforsafeshutdown.

Theteamreviewedthiswithinthetimeavailable asbackground infor-mation5ustifying theactionstobetakenintheprocedures.

4.1.1Reactivity ControlInitialreactivity controlisprovidedbytrippingthereactorcontrolrodsusingthescramswitchesinthemaincontrolroom.Thereactorcanalsobescrammedbytrippingtheturbin'eatthefrontstandardandalsoatotherunspecified locations'dditional negativereactivity toachievetherequiredborationmarginis'rovided bytheboratedwaterintheRefueling WaterStorageTankutilizing theoppositeunit'schargingpumpsdischarging intothereactorcoolantpumpsealinfection lines.Thelicenseewasadvisedtohaveavailable, forthefullscopeAppendixRaudit,ananalysisshowingthattheRWSTalonedoesprovidesufficient negativereactivity capability toachieveandmaintaincoldshutdown.

4.1.2ReactorCoolantMakeup(Inventory andPressureControl)Inventory controlofthereactorcoolantsystemisprovidedbythereactorcoolantpumpsealinfection pines.andchargingsystem.Foralternative shutdownoutsideoftheaffectedurii't.'.s controlroom,sealinfection isprovidedbytheoppositeunit'scharging'pump'viaadischarge headerunitcrosstietoRCPseals.Chargingthroughthenormalcharginglinecanbeprovidedbytheoppo-siteunit'sBoronInfection flowpath.Thesystemalignments aresummarized inthelicensee's introductory presentation onalternate shutdowncapability (Ref.3.2-1)asfollows:BoratedCoolingWaterSource:OppositeUnit'sRWSTorAffectedUnit'sRWST(viaunitcrosstie)

OppositeUnit'sCVCSAuxiliary Systems:OppositeUnit'sEmergency PowerSystemOppositeUnit'sHVACOppositeUnit'sCCWControl:NormalvalveandpumpcontrolonoppositeunitLocalmanualcontrolofvalvesonaffectedunitInstrumentation:

LocalshutdownpanelpoweredfromoppositeunitOtherlocalself-powered indict6rs Pressurizer leveliscontrolled bysupplying sufficient volumeflowtosupporta25'F/hour cooldownrate.Thelicensee's positiononpressurizer pressureanduseofthepressurizer PORVsduringhotstandbyandhotshutdownisthattheheatlossesfromthepressurizer aresuchthatpressurewillberehucedwithina72hourperiodtoallowuseoftheresidualheatremoval(RHR)systemwithoutuseofthepressurizer PORVsandthatthePORVsarenotrequiredtomaintainhotshutdown.

Thelicenseedidnotprovidetheanalysisto)ustifythisbutwasadvisedthattheanalysisshouldbeavailable forthefullscopeAppendixRaudit.ThecablestothePORVscanberepairedtoallowpressurecontrolduringthetransition tocoldshutdown.

4.1.3DecayHeatRemovalForlossofoffsitepowerconditions, naturalcirculation isestablished bydumpingsteamfrom'atleasttwoofthefoursteamgenerators viatheatmospheric steamgenerator PORVswithmakeuptothesteamgenerators providedbytheAuxil-iaryFeedwater SystemfromtheCondensate StorageTanktosupporta25'F/hour cooldownrate.Ref.3.2-1describes thesystemalignments asfollows:Auxiliary Feedwater isprovidedbyeithertheaffectedUnit'sturbine-driven pumpviathenormalflowpathoreitheroftheoppositeUnit'smotor-driven pumpsviaadischarge headerunitcrosstietothenormalflowpath.CoolingWaterSource:Auxiliary Systems:OppositeUnit'sCST.Affected Unit'sCSTLakeMichiganviaoppositeUnit'sessential service,waterOppositeUnit'sEmergency PowerSystem(MDAFPuse)OppositeUnit'sHVAC(appliesonlytooneoftheoppositeUnit'sMDAFP)Control:LocalcontrolpanelforTDAFPNormalvalveandpumpcontrolforoppositeUnit'sMDAFPsLocalmanualcontrolofvalvesonaffectedunitInstrumentation:

LocalTDAFPPanel(TurbineSpeed)Thesteamgenerator PORVsarepoweredfromthealternate sourcewhichisthebackupnitrogensupplylocatedintheyardarea.Controlisateitherlocalcontrolpanelsorasabackupbylocalmanualoperation ofthevalves'andwheels.

Instrumentation isatalocalshutdownpanelpoweredfromtheoppositeunitandatotherlocalselfpoweredindicators fortheN2supply.4.1.4SupportSystemsandProcessMonitoring Instrumentation Thefront-line systemsaresupported bythesystemsdescribed in4.1.1to4.1.3whileprocessmonitoring isprovidedatlocalcontrolpanelswithintheplant.Neitheroftheseaspectswerereviewedinanydetailduetotimecon-straints.

4.1.5ColdShutdownTheRHRsystemisusedtoachieveandmaintaincoldshutdown.

RHRispro-videdbyeithertrainofnormalRHRpoweredfromtheoppositeuniE.Ref.3.2-1describes thesystem"alignments asfollows:Auxiliary Systems:OppositeUnit'sEmergency PowerSystemOppositeUnit'sESW(viaunitcrosstie)

OppositeUnit'sCCW(viaunitcrosstie)

Control:Temporary RHRpumpcontrolfromoppositeunit,NormalESWandCCWpumpandvalvecontrolfromop-positeunitLocalmanualcontrolofRHR,ESW,andCCWvalvesonaffectedunitInstrumentation.

RHRpumploadfromtemporary RHRpumpcontrolstationinoppositeUnit'scontrolroom(Valveoperation coordinated withindications providedatlocalshut-downpanelatanotherlocation)

Thelicenseehasdeveloped repairprocedures forrepowering anRHRpump,pres-surizerbackupheaters,pressurizer PORVcables,andin-containment valves'nly repairoftheRHRpumpsandpressurizer heaterswasdiscussed intheSafetyEvaluation Report(Ref.3'1-.2)~NomentionismadeintheSERconcerning theuseofthepressurizer PORVs.;ICwassuggested tothelicenseethattheirusebe..clarified forthefull-scope'.audit asmentioned in4.1.2above.I4.2AreasRuiriAlternative ShutdownTherearefourareasineachunitwhichrequireimplementation oftheremoteshutdownprocedure intheeventofafire:~ControlRoomCableVaultAuxiliary CableVault~SwitchGearRoom~ControlRoomSincethereisa3-hourratedfirebarrierbetweeneachunit'scontrolroomandthereissignificant crosstiecapability betweensystemsrequiredforsafeshutdown, theShiftSupervisor directsoperations fromtheoppositeunit'scon-trolroom.Thehotshutdownpanelslocatedwithineachcontrolroomwerenotdesignedtomeetthedemandsofafireaspostulated byAppendixR.

5~PROCEDURES Theprocedure reviewedindetailandwalkedthoughduringthisplantvisitwas:**12-OHP4023100001,"Unit1Emergency RemoteShutdown,"

Rev0,6/10/86Thisprocedure isstructured withamainbodyandeightattachments'ttachment No.1relatestotheestablishment ofthechargingheadercrosstiefromtheop-positeunitwhileNo.2providesfortheinitiation ofAuxiliary Feedwater flow.ttachment No.3concernsisolation oftheReactorCoolantSstemandthenerators gorsandNo.4pertainstocontrolofthesteamgenerator PORVs~Attach-mentNos~5&6describethestepstoprovideRHRcoolingusingUnit2Essential ServiceWaterandComponent CoolingWaterPumper'ttachment No.7instructs thee-energization of'quipment fromtheswitchgearroomstopreventspuriousactuations andNo.8providesfortherestoration ofoffsitepower.Therepairprocedures werealsoreviewedbutinlessdetail.5.1Procedure forUnit1RemoteEmerencShutdownThelicenseepersonnel explained, bymeansofahand-drawn chart,thereas-signmentofthenormalplantoperating stafftoformthefirebrigadeandtoimplement theprocedure.

Theresultswasthatfouroperations personnel arerequiredtoimplement theprocedure, threefromtheaffectedunitandonefromteunaffected unit.Thelicenseewasadvisedtoprovideasimplified staffingassignment chart'for thefull;+cope AppendixRaudit.Commentsgenerated duringthereviewandwalkthrough willbeprovidedseparatelybelow:5.1.1Reviewa)'ainPortionStep4.2.2-Itwasrecommended thatthisstep,whichdirectstheoperatortolocallytripthereactor,includethelocations ofotherftriioermeansorppngthereactoroutsidethecontrolroom.Theseotherloca-tionsshouldbereviewedtodetermine theirsuitability undertheconditions ofafirerequiring controlroomevacuation.

Itwasalsorecommended thatthestepincludeastatement instructing theoperatortoverifythecontrolrodpositions, ifatallpossible, beforeevacuating thecontrolroom.Step4.2-3-Thisstepdirectsthepersonnel torapidlyaccomplish certainoftheattachments withprioritybeinggiventoAttachment Nos.1andine2.SinceAttachment No.1concernsestablishment fRCP1RCSn)ectionflowtocoolthesealsandalsotoprovidemakeutththetimeavailable toperformtheseactionsistypically atmaeupoeleastonehourunlessapressurizerPORVhasspuribusly opened.Therearetypically only30minutesavailable toprovideAFWflowtothesteamgenerators beforeboildrysothatperformance ofAttachment No.2isusuallymoretimelimited.Itwasrecommended thatthisbeindicated intheprocedure.

NotepriortoStep5.3.5Thisnotestatesthatpressurizer PORVuseislimitedbytheairbottle(N2)backupcapability andthatthePressurizer ReliefTank(PRT)hasnoquenchordraincapability andhasbeen'receiving RCPsealleakoff.Further,ittellstheoperatorto"Planitcare-fully."Upondiscussion withlicenseepersonnel, itwasstatedthatthereisadequateN2supplytoprovideover70operations ofthePORVsandthatrupture.ofthePRTrupturedisksisnotofcon-cernexceptthatextensive cleanupofthecontainment wouldberequired.

Again,itwasrecommended tothelicenseethatananaly-sis5ustifying theN2supply,thenumberofPORVoperations requir-edtodepressurize, theassumptions regarding therupturedisk,andtheoverallusageofthePORVsbeavailable forthefullscopeAppendixRaudit.ThelicenseewasalsoadvisedthatiflocaloperatoractionsarerequiredintheyardareatoassureadequateN2supplytothePORVsthat8-houremergency lightsbeprovidedfortheaccesspathoranexemption requestshouldbefiled.Thelicenseeagreedwiththeteam'sconcernovertheuseoftheterm"Planitcarefully",

andindicated thattheprocedure wouldbere-visedaccordingly toprovideclearerinstructions totheoperator.

b)Attachment No.1Therewerenosignificant commentsduringthereviewprocess'~c)Attachment No.2\Caution-Thecautionstates"Sincecorecoolingmodeisnaturalcircula-tion,donotoverfeedoroversteam."Theteamexpressedtheconcernthatthisappearstoprovidearigidmindsettotheoperators thattheprocedure isonlyapplicable forlossofuff-sitepower.Thereisaseparateprocedure forremoteshutdownintheeventofafirewithoffsitepoweravailable.

However,thereisnodirectprovision fortheoperatortoreturntothatprocedure intheeventthatoffsitepowerisrestoredwithoutonsiteoperatoractions~Thelicenseeagreedtorevisethepro-ceduretoaddressthisconcern.Steps2.6,3-6&4'-Thesestepsinstructtheoperators tomanuallyoperatethehandwheels ontheAFWpumpdischarge linestoestablish andmaintainlevelinthesteamgenerators withoutindicating aminimumrecommended level.Theteamrecommended thatthelicenseerevisetheprocedure torecommend maintaining levelatapointproviding sufficient con-tingency.

d)Attachment Nos.3and7Therewerenosignificant commentsontheseattachments duringthereviewbuttheywerethesubjectofaconference callbetweenthereviewteamandthelicenseeonNovember5,1986.Specifically, No.3concernselectrical isolation oftheReactorCoolantSystemandtheSteamGenerators topreventspurious Oeoperation andNo.7electrical isolation ofpumpsandvalvesfromtheSwitchGearRooms.BNLexpressed theconcernthattheactionsdescribed intheSwitchGearRooms,suchasmanuallytrippingthebreakers, couldnotbgperformed ifthepostulated fireoccurredintheSwitchGearRooms~Thelicensee's responsewasthatthesituation ofafireintheSwitchGearRoomiscoveredbyanotherprocedure forremoteemergency shutdownwhenoffsitepowerisavailable.

Thisalternate procedure wasnotcrossreferenced norwasitreviewedbytheteam.Uponfurtherdiscussion,'t appearedthatitcallsfor3umpering ofvalvesand/orbreakersduringthehotstandbyorhotshutdownconditions topreventspuriousoperations.

Thelicenseewasstronglyadvisedthatanyjumpering isconsidered arepairandassuchisnotallowedduringhotstandbyorhotshut-downconditions

~Also,itcannotbestatedthatthetwoprocedures areinpar-allelsincetheprocedure underreview,i.e.,forthecaseoflossofoffsitepower,doesnotcoverafireintheSwitchGearRooms,whichrequiresevacuation oftheaffectedu'nitscontrolroom.Adequateandpropercrossreferencing, whichtheteamfeltisessential, didnotexistinthereviewedprocedure.

Thelicenseeagreedtoreviewtheprocedural responseandmethodology accordingly inpreparation forafullscopeAppendixRaudit.e)Attachment Nos~4,5,6,and8Therewerenosignificant commentsduringthereviewphaseexceptforanyactionstobetakenintheyardareatoassureN2supplyandtheprovision ofemergency

lighting, aspreviously notedin(a)above(pertaining toAttachment No.4)~5.1~2Walkdowna)MainPortionSomeoftheteammembersfoundthequalityoftheoperators communicatioris skillstobepoorattimes.Itshouldalsobenotedthathand-held radiosaretheonlycommunications meansavailable underlossofoffsitepower.Inaddi-tion,thereareonlytwochannelsavailable, F-1andF-2,andonlyoneofthosechannels, F-l,isbackedupbyarepeaterstation.TherepeaterstationislocatedintheUnit2Switchgear RoomsothatintheeventofafireinthatSwitchGearRoom,onlytheF-2channelisavailable, whichthelicenseeconcededhassomedifficult areasbetweenwhichthecommunication ispoorornon-.existent.

Therewerenoothersignificant commentsnotedduringthewalkdown.

b)Attachment No.1Step1.1-'hereappearedtobeinadequate emergency lightingfortheoperatortocheckclosedvalves1-CS-536and1-CS-534.

Step2.1-Thesequenceofactionstode-energize thebreakersagMCC1-AZV-Aand1-AM-Dappearedtobereversed.

Thatis,itwasmoretimeeffi-cientfortheoperatortoperformtheactionsrequiredatMCC1-AM-DbeforeMCC1-AZV-Aparticularly sincetheyar'eatdifferent eleva-tions~ Step2.2-AsimilarproblemsexistsinStep2.2inthatitiseasiertoisolatecontrolairto1-RV-251, 1-RV-252, and1-RV-255neartheBatchTankbeforeenteringtheBoronInjection Tank(BIT)Roomtoverify1-IMO-255 and1-IMO-256 closedsothatitappearstheorderofthestepsshouldbereversed.

Emergency lightingattheBatchTank"areawasnotavailable toperformtherequiredfunctions whiletheemergency lightingintheBITRoomwasinadequate beingononlyonesideoftheBIT,whichisaverylargeandtalltank,whileactionsarerequiredonbothsidesofthetank.Step2.3-Sinceentry'intotheBITRoom,asrequiredbyStep2',andintotheBITOutletValveRoom,asrequiredbyStep2.3,necessitates theuseofanti-contamination

clothing, itismuchlesstimeconsuming iftheprocedure includedanotedirecting theoperatortogatheranextrasetofanti-C'swhenperforming Step2.2inpreparation forStep2.3.Insummary,allowingfortheinherentdifficulties ofperforming thisattachment withaninspector taggingalong,itappearsthattheimplementation isexces-sivelylongandcanbe'streamlined.

c)Attachment No.2Thisattachment, whichprovidesforinitiation ofAuxiliary Feedwater flow,waswalkedthroughbytheSeniorResidentInspector whosecommentsfollow:pGeneralComments~~'$1.Thelicenseeshouldwalkthrougheachpersonon.eachintendedfunction.

2.Thelicenseeshouldassureindependence ofactivities byvariousagents,i.e.,whichstepsrequirepriorcommunication andauthoriza-tion.Step2.0-Intheeventthattheaffectedunitsturbine-driven AFWpump,(TDAFP)shouldfailtostartorfailtorunafterstarting, itrequiredap-proximately 10minutestosimulatetheinitiation ofAFMflowusingtheoppositeunit'smotor-driven AFVpumps.Thelicenseeshoulddetermine ifthistimeintervalcanbereduced.Steps2.6,3.6,and4.5-Theprocedure shouldspecifyaquantitative throttlepositionfortheoperatortolocallymanuallyoperatethehandwheels oftheAFWpumpdischarge controlvalvestomaintainsteamgenerator levels.(Thiscommentissimilartothecommentbytheteamonthisstepnotedduringthereviewprocess.)

5.2ReairProcedures ReuiredtoAchieveColdShutdownTheprocedures listedinSection3.3,Nos.2through6werebrieflyreview-edandappearedtobesubstantially detailedtofacilitate implementation.

No walkthrough wasconducted butacheckwasmadeofwhetherthetoolsandequip-mentrequiredtoimplement theprocedures wereavailable onsite.Thisequipment wasfoundtobeinseparately storedandlabeledcontainers inareasreadilyaccessible toplantmaintenance personnel.

January2798.'i.DOCKETNO(S).~0->>5and~0->>6Hr.JohnDolan,Vicepresident IndianaandMichiganElectricCompanyc/ooAmericanAElectric PowerServiceCorporation 1Riverside PlazaColumbus, Ohio43216

SUBJECT:

D.C.CookNuclearPlant,UnitsIand2DISTRIBDIION:

DocketPileLocelPDRNRCPDRPWRf34ReadingBJYoungblood:

ReadingMDuncanDWigginton ACRS(10)NThompson EJordanJPartlowBGrimesNoticeofReceiptofApplication, datedDraft/Final Environmental Statement, datedNoticeofAvailability ofDraft/Final Environmental Statement, datedSafetyEvaluation Report,orSupplement No.datedEnvironmental Assessment andFindingofNoSignificant Impact,datedNoticeofConsideration ofIssuanceofFacilityOperating LicenseorAmendment toFaci1ityOperating License,datedQBi-Weekly Notice;Applications andAmendments toOperating LicensesInvolving Nocededd*ddddd.dd~del3Exemption, datedConstruction PermitNo.CPPR-,Amendment No.datedFacilityOperating LicenseNo.,Amendment No.OrderExtending Construction Completion Date,datedMonthlyOperating Reportfortransmitted byletterdatedAnnual/Semi-Annual Report-datedtransmitted byletterdatedThefollowing documents concerning ourreviewofthesubjectfacilityaretransmitted foryourinformation.

Enclosures:

AsstatedOfficeofNuclearReactorRegulation CC:SeenextpageOFFICE/SURNAME)DATEI3PWR$/4/PWR-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~noan/.ra01////87~~~~/(Pe~~~~~~~~~-A.DVa.gga.ntan....

01/Q7/87~~~eÃe>(e~~~~~~~~~PWRIIO~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~e~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~NRCFORM3181101801 NRCM0240OFFICIALRECORDCOPY

"~I'Clf'II1\'1-l,yI4h~W~81'l~~'b~%'C'