ML12326B000

Donald C, Cook, Units 1 and 2 - Enclosure 4 (Cont.) to AEP-NRC-2012-101, Response to Second-Round RAI Item 54.b, and Submittal of Revised Tables Re the Application for Amendment to Transition to National Fire Protection Association Standard

ML12326B000
Person / Time
Site:	Cook
Issue date:	11/09/2012
From:	Indiana Michigan Power Co
To:	Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
AEP-NRC-2012-101, TAC ME6629, TAC ME6630
Download: ML12326B000 (76)

Text

Indiana Michican PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Affachrnent AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.5.11 [Water SupplyYard Main MaintenanceIssues]Means shall be provided to isolateportions of the yard fire main loopfor maintenance or repair withoutsimultaneously shutting off thesupply to both fixed fire suppressionsystems and fire hose stationsprovided for manual backup.Sprinkler systems and manual hosestation standpipes shall beconnected to the plant fireprotection water main so that asingle active failure or a crack to thewater supply piping to thesesystems can be isolated so as notto impair both the primary andbackup fire suppression systems." Compiles" C~omplies with use ofEEEEse Complies withclarificationComplies:Isolating valves with postindicators or curb boxes areinstalled in the fire protectionheader so that the entire loop isnot disabled shouldmaintenance be required on asmall section.Complies with use of EEEEs:Approved valves are notprovided at the main riser tobranches of hose outlets or ateach riser controing more thantwo hose stations. Isolationvalves are not provided for theTurbine Building hose systemsrisers and supplies. A review ofthe system design in *CNPNFPA Code Deviations andJustifications" verified thatadequate isolation valves areprovided for a majority of thehose risers without adverselyimpacting the operation ofsprinklers protecting safetyrelated equipmentUFSAR, Section 9.8.1, "WaterDistribution", Item b)CNP "NFPA Code Deviations andJustifications', Rev. 20120-164-007, "NFPA Code DeviationEvaluation D.C. Cook Units 1 and 2".Rev. 1FPPM, Rev. 11, Table 5.1, SectionE.3.(a).Flow Diagram 12-5152 seriesRFC-12-3003Sectionalizing valves have notbeen provided for isolating hosestation risers from the fire mainloop contained within theTurbine and Screen HouseBuildings. The areas affectedinclude Fire Zones 80, 84, and142. Justifications for thesedeviations are found inseiyMlaA 1.tRevision I PaGetVWi I"7Revision IPage A-71 Indiana Michigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transtion Repott -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference DocumentCalculation No. 0120-164-007,"NFPA Code DeviationEvaluation D.C. Cook Units 1and 2".Complies with clarification:A single pipe break can causeloss of primary (sprinkler) andsecondary (hose station)suppression in Fire Zones 28,30, and 32. However, a yardhydrant and/or a more remotehose station can be used toplace a hose stream in service.A single pipe break can causeloss of primary (manual charcoalfilter deluge system) andsecondary (hose station)suppression in Fire Zones 49and 50 at elevation 633'.However, a sectionalizing valvein the 6" auxilary buildingheader allows FHC 64 atelevation 633' to be available forbackup.A single pipe break can causeloss of sprinkler protection aswell as loss of one or more ofthe hose stations in Fire Zones79, 80, 84, 85, 90, 91, and 97.However, one or more of theremaining hose stations in eachzone will remain in servicedespite the worst case pipebreak.CNP_TWAC_v',1 .Oh13WM 2 TMM.ni ý Offib Volen 12U0Revision 1PapeA-72 Indiana Michidan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Attachment AAtdtanachnt A Powtr CNP anF 805 Elmntst ReFPo 8 aten AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-I -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.5.12 [Water SupplyCompatible ThreadConnections]Threads compatible with those used .Compliesby local fire departments shal beprovided on all hydrants, hosecouplings, and standpipe risers.Exception: Fire departments shallbe permitted to be provided withadapters that allow interconnectionbetween plant equipment and thefire department equipment ifadequate training and proceduresare provided.Threads which are compatiblewith those used by local firedepartments are provided on allhydrants, hose couplings andstandpipe risers.TRP-2070-TAP-400-FPP, "Fire Drts,Rev. 1. Section 3.3.2.c.CNP Fire Pro-Plans, Volumes I, II,and III, Revisions 9, 7, and 12respectivelyCWnP MDC_%1.1.GbTOMOM~~~~~ m@"A=CtM"I1*W2Revsin Pae -7Revision 1PageA-73 Indiana Michigan Po"rCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Affachment AAdanchment Power Cor anF D 05 Trmntso ReFor 8 apten AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-I -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.5.13 [Water SupplyHeader Options]Headers fed from each end shall be 9 Compliespermitted inside buildings to supplyboth sprinkler and standpipe -Complies by previoussystems, provided steel pipng and NRC approvalfitings meeft the requirements ofANSI B31.1, Code for PowerPiping, are used for the headers (upto and including the first valve)supplying the sprinkler systemswhere such headers ae part of theseismicanly analyzed hosestandpipe system. Where provided,such headers shall be consideredan extension of the yard mainsystem. Each sprinkler andstandpipe system shall be equippedwith an outside screw and yoke(OS&Y) gate valve or otherapproved shutoff valve.Complies:Turbine and Auxiliary Buildingheaders are double-end fed.Thes headers are fed fromboth ends and piping is CNPtype A-31 or S-31. A-31 andS-31 piping is ASME SA-106Grade B seamless carbon steelor ASME SA-1 34 welded plate.Each system is equipped with ashutoff valve.Complies by previous NRCapproval:The hose stations and12-5152 System DrawingsES-PIPE-I OO0-QCS, "Pipe MaterialSpedficationw, Rev. 3UFSAR, Section 9.8.1, "WaterDistribution', Item d)I&M response to Appendix A toBranch Technical Position APCSB9.5-1 for Units No. 1 and 2, itemE.3.(d)NRC Safety Evaluation supportingAmendment Nos. 31 and 12 tostandpipes provided for CNP are License No. DPR-58 and DPR-74,in accordance with the pages 6-7requirements of BTP 9.5-1,Appendix A for plants which RFCs 12-2229, 12-2621, 12-2740,received a construction permit 12-2983before July 1, 1976. SectionE.3.(d) of Appendix A to BranchTechnical Position APCSB 9.5-1on interior manual hose stationsdoes not contain anyrequirements for hose stationoperabirity in the event of anSSE.By the response to Appendix Ato Branch Technical PositionAPCSB 9.5-1 for Units No. 1and 2, dated January 31, 1977,item E.3.(d) I&M stated:"All hose standpipes at CookPlant are spaced at approximateCejV..vt1.1.Gi03012 Tnwwbn D~n~ AP at Yua 1.2hRevision IPage A-74 Indiana Michten PowerCNP NFPA 805 Tirensihon Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-I -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference Document75 foot intervals in the turbine,office, and auxliary buildings.Each hose station is providedwith a 1- 1/2-inch water spraynozzle, a minimum of 75 feet of1-1/2-inch hose, a 1-1/2-inchangle hose valve, a spannerwrench, a backup 2-1/2-inchangle hose valve, 2-1/2 to 1-1/2-inch reducer and a 1-1/2-inchhose cap.We are proposing to installadditional hose station capabilityat access areas to the controlroom cable spreading room, theauxiliary cable vault, theswitchgear room cable vault,and the containment penetrationcable tunnels.'The NRC Safety Evaluation,dated July 31, 1979 states:7The standpipe system provideswater to hose stations at variouslocations throughout the facility.The licensees have committedto install additional hose stationsand, where necessary,standpipes to satisfy theguidelines of Appendix A to BTP9.5-1. We have reviewed theproposed additions and findthem acceptable.We have reviewed the designcrfteria and the basis for theReiTnACVP.g IA7W0MTrMfMn DMWaW AM OSO VWWMla I."MRevision IPage A-75 Indiana Michican PowerCNP NFPA 805 Tran&Won Report -Attachment AInin ihiaa Poa NfFA85TastinRot-AtcmnAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference Documentwater fire protection system. Incertain areas we have requiredaddta proction systems tobe instaMled. We find Utht thewater fi protection system, asmodfiedmeets te giensof Appendix A to BranchTechnical Position APCSB 9. 5-1and applicable National FireProtection Associationstandards and is, Uherfore,acceptable."The additional protectionsystems have been installed perthe RFCs. The hose station andstandpipe configuration, asapproved by the SE Report, isstill used at CNP. There havebeen no plant modifications orother changes that wouldinvalidate the basis for approval.This feature remainsunchanged.3.5.14 [Water Supply All fire protection water supply and

• N/A N/A -Section Heading, see N/AControl Valve fire suppression system control compliance bases below forSupervision] valves shall be under a periodic compliance statements forinspection program and shafl be specific subsections.supervised by one of the followingmethods.1Mn1W 2 T"Wlfa A0h CM& VOM 10Revision I Page A-76 Indiana Michican PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.5.14 (Water SupplyControl ValveSupervision] (a)Electrical supervision with audibleand visual signals in the maincontrol room or other suitableconstantly attended location.0CompliesPer the Annunciator PlantProcedures, valve positions areinspected on a monthly basis.These procedures also confirmthat valves are properlysupervised during inspection.1-OHP-4024-101, *Annunciator #101Response: Plant Fre System', Rev.191-OHP-4024-102, "Annunciator #102Response: Miscellaneous Areas FireSystem", Rev. 122-OHP-4024-201, "Annunciator #201Response: Plant Fire System", Rev.212-OHP-4024-202, "Annunciator #202Response: Miscellaneous Areas FireSystem', Rev. 133.5.14 [Water SupplyControl ValveSupervision] (b)3.5.14 (Water SupplyControl ValveSupervision] (c)Locking valves in their normalposition. Keys shall be madeavailable only to authorizedpersonnel.Sealing valves in their normalpositions. This option shall beutilized only where valves arelocated within fenced areas orunder the direct control of theowner/operator." N/AoN/AN/A -The requirements of NFPA N/A805, Section 3.5.14 are met bythe option discussed in Section3.5.14(a).N/A -The requirements of NFPA N/A805, Section 3.5.14 are met bythe option discussed in Section3.5.14(a).aeT7VC.,1AlbMaM 2 Tu.llo OMMM 11ob%*W 0IRevision I Page A-77Revision 1Page A-77 Indiana Michican PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Affachrnent AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference DocumentFPPM, Rev. 11, Table 5.1, Section3.5.15 [Water SupplyHydrant CodeRequirements]Hydrants shall be installed

• Complies withapproximately every 250 ft (76 m) clarificationapart on the yard main system. Ahose house equipped with hose andcombination nozzle and otherau=xiary equipment specified inNFPA 24, "Standard for theInstallation of Private Fire ServiceMains and Their Appurtenances,"shall be provided at Intervals of notmore than 1000 ft (305 m) ong theyard main system.Exception: Mobile means ofproWding hose and associatedequipment, such as hose carts ortrucks, shall be permitted in lieu ofhose houses. Where provided, suchmobile equipment shall beequialent to the equipmentsupplied by three hose houses.Fire hydrants have beenprovided at the recommended250-foot approximate spacingconnected to the yard loopheader with two exceptions.Hydrants I and 14 are located350' apart in straight linedistance and 422' apart in actualtravel distance. Hydrants 4 and7 are located 320' apart insright line distance and 406'apart in actual travel distance.This configuration is consideredadequate given the strength ofthe water supply and theavailability of sufficient hosefrom the hose houses in theyard.Hose house between hydrants 2and 7 are located more than1000 ft apart along the yardmain system. However, a firetruck containing equipmentequivalent to at least two hosehouses is provided for the firebrigade's use.Procedure 2270-066-003specifies the hose houseinventory and confirms that allitems required by NFPA24-1984 are contained within.Procedure 12-FPP-2270-066-005 specifiesthat the fire truck contains theFPPM, Rev. 11, Table 5.1, SectionE.2.(g)Plant Drawing 12-5260-44, Rev. 44Plant Procedure 12-FPP-2270-066-O03, "MonthlyInventory of Fire Hydrant Cabinets-,Rev. 2, Attachment 1Plant Procedure 12-FPP-2270-066-005, "Fire TruckInventory and Operability Test", Rev.2, Attachment 1NFPA 24-1984, Standard for theInstallation of Private Fire ServiceMains and Their AppurtenancesO-TWC.Y1.1.ftTamX.wAwwcAwmVwts 1- -.20tbIRevsio I ageA-7Revision 1Page A-78 Indiana Michican PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Documentequipment equivalent to threehose houses.3.5.16 [Water SupplyDedicated Umits]The fire protection water supplysystem shall be dedicated for fireprotection use only.Exception No. 1: Fire protectionwater supply systems shal bepermifted to be used to providebackup to nuclear safety systems,provided the fire protection watersupply systems ere designed andmaintained to deliver the combinedfire and nuclear safety flowdemands for the duration specby the applicable analysis.Exception No. 2: Fire protectionwater storage can be provided byplant systems serving otherfuntcions provided the storage hasa dedicated capacity capable ofproviding the maximum fireprotection demand for the specifiedduration as determined in thissection.Standpipe and Hose Stations.* Submit for NRCApprovalPer OP-1 2-5152 series flowdiagrams and Section 4.1.2 ofthe FPPM, the fire protectionwater supply system is normallydedicated for fire protection useonly. Periodically, the fire watersupply system is used for non-fire related purposes, and inthese cases, the fire protectionwater supply system is designedand maintained to deliver thecombined fire and non-fire flowdemands. Justification isdocumented in EngineeringEquivalency Evaluation 11.61,and in accordance withI0CFR50.48(c)(2Xvfi) isprovided in Attachment L of theTransition Report.FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 4.1.2OP-12-5152 series Flow DiagramsEngineerng Equivalency Evaluation11.61, -Use of Fire Water forOtherThan Fire-Related Purposes', Rev. 03.6 Standpipe and HoseStations* N/AN/A -Section Heading, see sub- N/Asections for any specificcompliance statementsl bwm'at~z OinUWMing_7D1Z 121Revisio IMMDeto Plagem A-7Revision IPage A.79 Indiana Michican PowerCNP NFPA 805 TransNion Rewd -Affachtnent AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.6.1 [Standpipe andHose Station CodeRequirements]For all power block buildings, ClassIII standpipe and hose systemsshall be installed in accordance withNFPA 14, "Standard for theInstallation of Standpipe, PrivateHydrant, and Hose Systems."e Compiles with use ofEEEEsN Complies by previousNRC approvalComplies with use of EEEEs:Manual hose stations arelocated thQouht the plant andare designed for either NFPA 14Class II or Class Ill service. Thehose stations are capable ofdirecting an effective stream toany safety-related area of theplant. The standpipe and hosesystems comply with NFPA 14,1971, 1978, and 1986 Editions,as evaluated in the CNP NFPA14 Code ComplianceEvaluations.Complies by previous NRCapproval:Hose stations designed forClass II service are not in directcompliance with this section.However, the standpipe systemwas previously found to beacceptable by the NRC.By the response to Appendix Ato Branch Technical PositionAPCSB 9.5-1 for Units No. 1and 2, dated January 31, 1977,item E.3.(d) I&M stated:"All hose standpipes at CookPlant are spaced at approximate75 foot intervals in the turbine,office, and auxiiay buildings.Each hose station is providedwith a 1-1/2-inch water spraynozzle, a minimum of 75 feet ofUFSAR, Section 9.8.1, "WaterDistribution', Item f)0120-164-003, "NFPA 14 -CodeCompliance Verification ChecklistD.C. Cook Units I and 2", Rev. 1, AllSections09-0120-0123, "NFPA CodeCompliance Evaluation Donald C.Cook Nuclear Plant", Rev. 009-0120-0381, "Extended NFPACode Compliance Evaluation for theDonald C. Cook Nuclear Plant", Rev.10120-108-005, "NFPA 14 -CodeCompliance Verification ChecklistD.C. Cook Units 1 and 2", Rev. 0, AllSections0120-164-007, "NFPA CodeEvaluation Deviation Evaluation D.C.Cook Units 1 and 2", Rev. ICNP "NFPA Code Deviations andJustifications', Rev. 2I&M response to Appendix A toBranch Technical Position APCSB9.5-1 for Units No. 1 and 2, 1/31/77,item E.3.(d)NRC Safety Evaluation supportingAmendment Nos. 31 and 12 toLicense No. DPR-58 and DPR-74,aejTW., 1*fuRevision I Page A-80Revision IPage A-80 Indiana Michidan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference Document1-1/2-inch hose, a 1-1/2-inch 7/31/79, pages 6-7angle hose valve, a spannerwrench, a backup 2-1/2-inch RFCs 12-2229, 12-2621, 12-2740,angle hose valve, 2-112 to 1-112- 12-2983inch reducer and a 1-1/2-inchhose cap.We are proposing to installadditional hose station capabilityat access areas to the controlroom cable spreading room, theauxiliary cable vault, theswitchgear room cable vault,and the containment penetrationcable tunnels.*The NRC Safety Evaluation,dated July 31, 1979 states:7Te standpipe system provideswater to hose stations at variouslocations throughout the facility.The licensees have committedto install additional hose stationsand, where necessary,standpipes to satisfy theguidelines of Appendix A to BTP9.5-1. We have reviewed theproposed additions and findthem acceptable.We have reviewed the designcriteria and the basis for thewater fire protection system. Incertain areas we have requiredadditional protection systems tobe installed. We find that thewater fire protecton system, asTCWMm ea1.. tReIsion IMNDN Page A-81 t.Revision 1Page A-81 Indiana Michigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Documentmodified, meets the guidelinesof Appendix A to BranchTechnical Position APCSB 9. 5-1and applicable National FireProtection Associationstandards and is, therefore,acceptable."The additional protectionsystems have been installed perthe RFCs. The hose station andstandpipe configuration, asapproved by the SE Report, isstill used at CNP. There havebeen no plant nodifications orother changes that wouldinvalidate the basis for approval.This feature remainsunchanged.3.6.2 [Standpipe and A capability shall be provided to

• Complies with use of Hydraulic calculations have CNP 'NFPA Code Deviations andHose Station Capability ensure an adequate water flow rate EEEEs been performed to provide Justificationso, Rev. 2Limitations] and nozzle pressure for all hose verification of the ability of thestations. This capability includes the existing standpipe system to Calculation No. MD-12-FIRE-008-S,provision of hose station pressure deliver adequate flow for all Rev. 0reducers where necessary for the hose stations to supply water forsafety of plant Industrial fire brigade fighting fires in accordance withmembers and off-site fire the guidance of NFPA 14.department personnel.la'otJM2 TOWmiftn A e COdO V N t.bIRevision 1 Page A-82 Indiana Michigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Attachment AAtaachiant Power CoP and 805 Trmntso RePr 8 ataer AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-I -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.6.3 [Standpipe andHose Station NozzleRestrictions]The proper type of hose nozzle to 9 Compiles withbe supplied to each power block clarificationarea shall be based on the area firehazards. The usual combination

• Complies withspray/strait stream nozzle shall Required Actionnot be used in areas where thestraight stream can causeunacceptable damage or present anelectrical hazard to fire-fightingpersonnel. Usted eletically safefixed fog nozzles shall be providedat locations where high-voltageshock hazards exist. All hosenozzles shall have shutoff capabilityand be able to control water flowfrom full open to full dosed.Complies with Clarification:The appropriate type of hosenozzle Is provided to eachpower block area. All hosenozzles have shutoff capabilityand are able to control waterflow from full open to full dosed.CNP complies with NFPA 14with exception to size, locationand spacing, including hoselength, of selected hose stationsas documented in CNP report"NFPA Code Deviations andJustifications," Revision 2.12-FPP-4030-066-023, "Test andInspection of the Plant Fire HoseStandpipe Stations", Rev. 4, AllSections"Donald C. Cook Nuclear Plant NFPACode Deviations and Justifications",Rev. 2, Section NFPA 14 (Pages 41thru 51 )FPERAI7Complies with RequiredAction:Fire Pre-Plans will be revisedand subsequent training will beupdated to re-enforce use ofelectrically safe fixed fognozzles in high voltage settingsand use of straight streamnozzles for hydrogen fires. Referto Implementation Item S-3.10.CW-MTC_'V1.1 .b1WTmSIeT um Pin CA b 0fmt 1.2.0Revision 1PageA-83 Indiana Michigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transitlon Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.6.4 [Standpipe andHose StationEarthquake Provisions]Provisions shafl be made to supply -Complies by previouswater at least to standpipes and NRC approvalhose stations for manual firesuppression in all areas containingsystems and components neededto perform the nuclear safetyfunctions in the event of a SSE.By the response to Appendix Ato Branch Technical PositionAPCSB 9.5-1 for Units No. 1and 2, dated January 31, 1977,item E.3.(d) I&M stated:"All hose standpipes at CookPlant are spaced at approximate75 foot intervals in the turbine,office, and auxiary buildings.Each hose satn is pwith a 1-1/2-Inch water spraynozzle, a minimum of 75 feet of1-1/2-inch hose, a 1-112-inchangle hose valve, a spannerwrench, a backup 2-1/2-inchangle hose valve, 2-1/2 to 1-1/2-inch reducer and a 1-1/2-inchhose cap.We are proposing to installadditional hose station capabilityat access areas to the controlroom cable spreading room, theauxiary cable vault, theswitchgear room cable vault,and the containment penetrationcable tunnels. "The NRC Safety Evaluation,dated July 31, 1979 states:"The standpipe system provideswater to hose stations at variouslocations throughout the facility.The licensees have committedto install additional hose stationsand, where necessary,I&M response to Appendix A toBranch Technical Position APCSB9.5-1 for Units No. 1 and 2, 1/31/77,item E.3.(d)NRC Safety Evaluation supportingAmendment Nos. 31 and 12 toUcens No. DPR-58 and DPR-74,7/31/79, pages 6-7RFCs 12-2229, 12-2621, 12-2740,12-2983OWjTWCL.vt tbT,W~AVsM .. Owý"Mý 12*mI.1U2Revision I Page A-84Revision IPage A-84 Indiana Michiden PbvverCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Attachment AniaaMclian Poe N!FA85TastinRiot-AtcmnAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference Documentstandpipes to satisf theguidelines of Appendix A to BTP9.5-1. We have reviewed theproposed additions and findthem acceptable.We have reviewed the designcriteria and the basis for thewater fire protection system. Incertain areas we have requiredadditional protection systems tobe We find that thewater fi protection system, asmodified, meets the gukinesof Appendix A to BranchTechnical Position APCSB 9.5-1and applicable National FireProtection Associationstandards and is, therefore,acceptable."The additional hose stationcapability has been installed perthe RFCs. The hose station andstandpipe configuration, asapproved by the SE Report, isstill used at CNP. There havebeen no plant modifications orother changes that wouldinvalidate the basis for approval.This feature remainsunchanged.l Tmmuwm Deasmaw D Oe~~Ua 1ete .1Revision I Page A-85Revision IPage A-85 Indiana Michidan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transftn ReDort -Affachment AAtta Michment A -NEI 0FP0 805 rn1 -n od tlti -A hm A'Attachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference Document3.6.5 [Standpipe and Where the seismic required hose *N/A Hose stations are not cross- OP-12-5152 Series Flow DiagramsHose Station Seismic stations are cross-connected to connected to non-fire protectionConnection Umitations] essential seismic non-fire protection water supply systems. FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 4.12.water supply systems, the fire flowshall not degrade the essentialwater system requirement.3.7 Fire Extinguishers Where provided, fire extinguishers

• Compiles with Complies with clarification: FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 14.1of the appropriate number, size, clarification I&M has committed CNP toand type shall be provided in comply with NFPA 10, 1984 09-0120-0123, 'NFPA Codeaccordance with NFPA 10,

• Compiles with use of edition, for portable fire Compliance Evaluation Donald C.'Standard for Portable Fire EEEEs extinguishers. Fire extinguishers Cook Nuclear Plant', Rev. 0,Extinguishers." Extinguishers shall are not provided inside 5/16/1988be permitted to be positioned containment due to radiologicaloutside of fire areas due to reasons, however, water mist 0120-108-001, "NFPA 10 Coderadiological conditions. fire extinguishers have been Compliance Verification Checklist',made available outside of Rev. 0, 5/15/1988containment for use insidecontainment 09-0120-0381, 'Extended NFPACode Compliance Evaluation for theComplies with use of EEEEs: Donald C. Cook Nuclear Planto, Rev.The fire extinguishers comply 1, 1/14/1991with the requirements of NFPA10, 1984 Edition, as evaluated in 0120-164-001, 'NFPA 10 CodeCNP NFPA 10 Code Compliance Verification Checklist,Compliance Evaluations. Rev. 1, 1/14/1991'Donald C. Cook Nuclear Plant NFPACode Deviations and Justifications',Rev. 2, 4/12/06UFSAR, Section 9.8.1, 'Inside PlantPortable Equipment', Items b) and c)lrJWXU12 Tama" Daum"* 1.2c IRevision I Page A-86 Indiana Michidan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Repod -Affachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference Document3.8 Fire Alarm and Fire Alarm and Detection Systems.

• N/A NIA -Section Heading, see sub- N/ADetection systems sections for any specificcompliance statements.TMftn AMMin.Osis~un 12.0~m2Revision I Page A-87Revision IPage A-87 Indiana Michigan PoiwerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Affachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.8.1 Fire AlarmAlarm initiating devices shall be

• Complies with use ofinstalled in accordance with NFPA EEEEs72, "National Fire Alarm Codex."Alarm annunciation shall allow theproprietary alarm system to transmitfire-related alarms, supervisorysignals, and trouble signals to thecontrol room or other constantlyattended location from whichrequired notifications and responsecan be initiated. Personnelassigned to the proprietary alarmstation shall be permitted to haveother duties. The following fire-related signals shall be transmitted:Per the FPPM, I&M has FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 14.1committed CNP to comply withNFPA 72D and NFPA 72E for UFSAR, Rev. 20, "Fire Protectionthe installation of fire alarm System", Section 9.8.1,initiating devices. CNP complies "Miscellaneous Protective Features",with NFPA 72 as evaluated in Item gthe CNP NFPA 72D and NFPA72E Code Compliance CNP "NFPA Code Deviations andEvaluations. Refer to I&M Justifications", Rev. 2"NFPA Deviations andRecommendations" for NFPA Engineering Equivalency Evaluation72D-1967 and NFPA 72E-1974 11.41, "Raised Floors in Controldeviations and justifications. Rooms", Rev. 0Per the UFSAR, "Fire protectionfunctions are displayed on acomprehensive annunciatorpanel in the control rooms toalert the operator in case of fire,primary fire pump operation, orfire system malfunction.Pressure gauges on the panelalso tell the operator thepressure conditions in the fireprotection water pipingheaders.*09-0120-0123, -NFPA CodeCompliance Evaluation Donald C.Cook Nuclear Plant", Rev. 0,5/16/19880120-164-005, "NFPA 72D CodeCompliance Verification Checklist",Rev. 0, 5/16/880120-164-006, "NFPA 72E CodeCompliance Verification Checklist",Rev. 0, 5/16/8809-0120-0381, "Extended NFPACode Compliance Evaluation for theDonald C. Cook Nuclear Plant", Rev.1, 1/14/19910120-164-005, "NFPA 72D CodeCompliance Verification Checklist -Extended*, Rev. 0, 12/14/900120-164-006, "NFPA 72E CodeTinTWC- TlsfU.ft1w-IReisonI ag A8RevisionIPage A-88 Indiana Michican PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition ReDort -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference DocumentCompliance Verificationa Checklist -Extended", Rev. 0, 12114190.3.8.1 Fire Alarm (1)Actuation of any fire detectiondevice0 CompilesAutomatic detection actuation FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 4.1.1signals are transmitted to thecontrol room. Per the FPPM, 1-OHP-4024-101, "Annunciator #101automatic fire alarm systems are Response: Plant Fire Systemn, Rev.actuated by detectors that sense 19fire conditions. Fire alarmdetection devices generally 1-OHP-4024-102, "Annunciator #102transmit signals to the local fire Response: Miscellaneous Areas Firealarm panels and then to the System-, Rev. 12control room annunciators, or,they transmit signals directly to 2-OHP-4024-201, "Annunciator #201the control room annunciators. Resoonse: Plant Fire System". Rev.All CNP fire detection systemalarms sound and are visuallydisplayed on the emergency firepanel in the respective controlroom.212-OHP-4024-202, "Annunciator #202Response: Miscellaneous Areas FireSystem", Rev. 13aejMC_.1.i 1I~~12Rev7Aio I Pae -8Revision IPaeA-89 Indiana Michican PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transftn Repod -Affachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.8.1 Fire Alarm (2)Actuation of any fixed firesuppression system0 compiesThe fire suppression systemalarm signaling capabilities thatmay be used involve automaticsprinkler waterflow, C02 systemmonitoring and Halon systemmonitoring. These systemsalarm in the control room uponactuation per the FPPM.All CNP water-using systems;sprinkles, deluge, andstandpipes, are instrumented toprovide flow indication and toprovide audible and visualannunciation in the respectivecontrol rooms.FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 4.1.1UFSAR, Rev. 20, "Fi ProtectionSystem-, Section 9.8.1.1-OHP-4024-101, "Annunciator #101Response: Plant Fire System", Rev.191-OHP-4024-102, "Annunciator #102Response: Miscellaneous Areas FireSystem-, Rev. 122-OHP-4024-201, "Annunciator #201Response: Plant Fire System", Rev.212-OHP-4024-202, "Annunciator #202Response: Miscellaneous Areas FireSystem", Rev. 13OujTMC.".1 bRevision I Page A-90Revision 1PageA-90 Indiana Michigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Ttansition Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.8.1 Fire Alarm (3)Actuation of any manual fire alarm 9 CompliesstationAutomatic fire alarm systemsare actuated through manualpull stations. The systems alarmin the control room uponactuation.FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 4.1.1UFSAR, Rev. 20, Fire ProtectionSystem-, Section 9.8.1.1-OHP-4024-101, '3Annunciator #101Response: Plant Fire Systemn, Rev.191-OHP-4024-1 02. '"nuncator #102Response: Miscellaneous Areas FireSystem-, Rev. 122-OHP-4024-201, 'Annunciator #201Response: Plant Fire Systen*, Rev.212-OHP-4024-202, "Annunciator #202Response: Miscellaneous Areas FireSystem-, Rev. 131WMM12 TMMMVO~w"A bCftV W1I"Revision IPage A-91 Indiana Mkhigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.8.1 Fire Alarm (4)Starting of any fire pump, CompliesPer the FPPM, the firesuppression system alarmsignaling capabilities include firepump monitoring. The signalsare monitored in the controlroom.Per the UFSAR, fire protectionfunctions are displayed on acomprehensive annunciatorpanel In the control rooms toalert the operator in case of fire,primary fire pump operation orfire system malfunction.FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 4.1.1UFSAR, Rev. 20, "Fire ProtectionSystem-, Section 9.8.1.1 -OHP-4024-1 01, "Annunciator #101Response: Plant Fire System", Rev.191 -OHP-4024-102, "Annunciator #102Response: MiscellaneDUs Areas FireSystem", Rev. 122-OHP-4024-201, "Annunciator #201Response: Plant Fire System", Rev.212-OHP-4024-202, "Annunciator #202Response: Miscellaneous Areas FireSystem-, Rev. 13T3WD12 Ts Rm VWaiTML 1.1.0Revsio I PlhM@OWa=Wgetf A-9Revision IPage A-92 Indiana Michigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.8.1 Fire Alarm (5)Actuation of any fire protectionsupervisory device* Complies Complies:The fire suppression system" Compiles by previous alarm signaling capabilitiesNRC approval include supervisory alarms.Complies by previous NRCapproval:Per letter by I&M to NRC datedDecember 2, 1991:"There actually are more thantwo circuits that are notelectronically supervised. Theseinclude some water flow,sprinkler alarms, fire detection,and suppressionactuatkn/nitiating systems thatare not electronically supervisedin accordance with NFPA 72D.Justifications for each areoutlined in Attachment 3 to thisletter."The NRC Safety Evaluationdated 1/24/95, Section 3.0states:"Based on the regular testing toconfirm operability, the dalymonitoring of the alarm panels,the fact the circuits have notexperienced integrity problems,and the circuits only providesecondary annunciation of iocalfire alarms in the control room,the staff finds these additionalunsupervised circuitsacceptable. "FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 4.1.11-OHP-4024-101, "Annunciator #101Response: Plant Fire System', Rev.191-OHP-4024-102, "Annunciator #102Response: Miscellaneous Areas FireSystem", Rev. 122-OHP-4024-201, "Annunciator #201Response: Plant Fire System", Rev.212-OHP-4024-202, "Annunciator #202Response: Miscellaneous Areas FireSystem", Rev. 13NRC Safety Evaluation, *Donald C.Cook Nuclear Plant, Unit Nos. 1 and2 -NFPA Code Review and RelatedAppendix R SER Clarifications (TACNos. M82265 AND M82266)',1/24/95, Section 3.0Letter from I&M (Fitzpatrick) to theNRC (Murley), "NFPA Code Reviewand Related Appendix R SERClarifications" dated 12/2/91, Body ofletter and Attachment 3Cp-TVACY1.1. tlTO2MW T O UNO Am b (1VO 1.0Revision 1Page A-93 Indiana Michigan Pot"rCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Affachinent AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference DocumentThe unsupervised circuits, asapproved by the SE Report, arestill used at CNP. There havebeen no plant modifications orother changes that wouldinvalidate the basis for approval.This approved justification forthe unsupervised crcuitsremains unchanged.3.8.1 Fire Alarm (6)Indication of alarm system trouble

• CompliesconditionThe emergency fire panelprovides annunciation in theassociated control room in theevent of a trouble signal.1-OHP-4024-101, "Annunciator #101Response: Plant Fire System', Rev.191-OHP-4024-102, "Annunciator #102Response: Miscellaneous Areas FireSystem", Rev. 122-OHP-4024-201, "Annunciator #201Response: Plant Fire System*, Rev.212-OHP-4024-202, "Anmnxnior #202Response: isceflaneous Areas FireSystem-, Rev. 13aej1WCi .1.AM3U12 TfWWA DSUSUUASýC~iS V"WS I"2Revision IPage A-94 Indiana Mkhigan Pb"rCNP NFPA 805 Transibon Report -Altschrnar# AAtanchment Power PoP anF 805 Trmntsi RePo 8 Caten AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-I -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.8.1.1 [Fire AlarmCommunicationsRequirements]Means shall be provided to allow aperson observing a fire at anylocation in the plant to quickly andreliably communicate to the controlroom or other suitable constantlyattended location.e CompliesPer Plant Procedure PMP-2270-FRP-001, personnel observing afire or explosion at any locationin the plant are able tocommunicate quickly with thecontrol room by telephone, PAsystem, or radio.PMP-2270-FRP-001, *Fire ResponsePlan, Rev. 11, Section 3.1.1.bUFSAR, "Plant Communications",Rev. 20.1, Section 7.7.5,Per the UFSAR, "The plant isprovided with a telephonesystem, independent of thepublic address system. Thereceivers are located in theoffices, control rooms and mostof the paging stationsthroughout the plant."3.8.1.2 [Fire Alarm Means shall be provided to

• N/A N/A -Section Heading, see sub- N/APrompt Notification promptly notify the fowing of any sections for any specificLimits] fire emergency in such a way as to compliance statements.allow them to determine anappropriate course of action:RiTio ; C_VagA.-5Revision I Page A-95 Indiana Michigan PovverCNP NFPA 805 TransWon Report -Affachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.8.1.2 [Fire AlarmPrompt NotificationUrnits] (1)General site population in alloccupied areasC CompilesPer the FPPM, "Plant wide firesirens can be activated by thecontrol room after a firecondition Is confirmed."Per the UFSAR, "The plant firehorn alarm system, consisting ofmotor-operated horns, isprovided throughout the plant toalert personnel of a fire. Thesehorns are distinctly different insound from the evacuation sirensystem."FPPM, Rev. 11, Table 5.1, SectionE.1.(b)UFSAR, Rev. 20, "Fire ProtectionSystem-, "Miscellaneous ProtectiveFeatures", Section 9.8.1, Item f3.8.1.2 [Fire AlarmPrompt NotificationLimits] (2)Members of the industrial fire

• Compliesbrigade and other groupssupporting fire emergency responsePer Plant Procedure PMP-2270-FRP-001, the fire brigade isimmediately notified during a fireor other emergency. Firebrigade notification of a fire isprovided by a siteannouncement over the PlantPublic Address System andthrough personal electronicpagers.PMP-2270-FRP-001, "Fire ResponsePlan", Rev. 11, Section 3.4 andSection 3.7.1UFSAR, Rev. 20, "Fire ProtectionSystem", *Miscellaneous ProtectiveFeatures", Section 9.8.1, Item fPer the UFSAR, *Manualoperation of the plant-widesystem is done fronm the controlrooms by the plant operators tosignal the plant fire brigade oncea fire has been verified."Oj-T~kQyl.1lbReisonI ag A9Revision IPage A-96 Indiana Michican Po*vrCNP NFPA 805 Transftbn Report -Affachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.8.1.2 [Fire AlarmPrompt NotificationLImIts] (3)Off-site fire emergency response

• Compliesagencies. Two Independent meansshall be available (e.g., telephoneand radio) for notfication of offsiteemergency services.Per PMP-2270-FRP-001, whenrequested, the securtydepartment will contact theBerrien County Dispatch Centerby caNing the offsite emergencynumber, 911.PMP-2270-FRP-001, *Fire ResponsePlan", Rev. 11, Section 3.2 andSection 3.7.1CNP Fire Pre-Plans, Volume Ill, Rev.12, Section 3Per the Fire Pre-Plans, VolumeIll, Radio communications shallbe established betweenBridgman and Lake TownshipFire Departments and the CNIPFire Brigade Leader immediatelyupon manning fire stations.Portable radios equipped withCNP Fire Brigade frequencieshave been provided to the LakeTownship and Bridgman FireDepartments. The CNP FireBrigade has access to an 800MHz radio to allow forcommunications with BerrnenCounty Emergency ResponseAgencies.HM12 TMUIN, OWMV AvMo 00f VOWN 1.2.0Revision 1Page A-97 Indiana Michigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Trvn&Won Repod -Affachmw# AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.8.2 DetectionIf automatic fredetection is Comples with use ofrequired to meet the performance or EEEEsdeterministic requirements ofChapter 4, then these devices shallbe installed in accordance withNFPA 72, 'National Fire AlarmCode,* and its applicableappendixes.Automatic fire detection systemscredited to meet therequirements of NFPA 805Chapter 4 are identified in theindividual Fire Safety AnalysisReports.Per the FPPM, I&M hascommitted CNP to comply withNFPA 72D and NFPA 72E forthe installation of fire alarminitiating devices. CNP compileswith NFPA 72 as evaluated inthe CNP NFPA 72D and NFPA72E Code ComplianceEvaluations. Refer to I&M"NFPA Deviaftis andRecommendations' for NFPA72D-1967 and NFPA 72E-1974devations and Justifications.CNP Fire Safety Analysis ReportsFPPM, Rev. 11, Section 14.1CNP NFPA Code Deviations andJustifications, Rev. 209-0120-0123, 'NFPA CodeCompliance Evaluation Donald C.Cook Nuclear Plant', Rev. 00120-164-005, 'NFPA 72D CodeCompliance Verification Checdist',Rev. 00120-164-006, "NFPA 72E CodeCompliance Verification Checklist',Rev. 009-0120-0381, 'Extended NFPACode Compliance Evaluation for theDonald C. Cook Nuclear Plant', Rev.10120-164-005, "NFPA 72D CodeCompliance Verification Cheddist -Extended', Rev. 00120-164-006, "NFPA 72E CodeCompliance Verification Checklist -Extended", Rev. 0103W12 TrmiWmN OMMM Arm Cub Vanim 1.2ARevision IPageA-98 Indiana Michican PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference Document3.9 Automatic and Automatic and Manual Water-

• N/A N/A -Section Heading, see sub- N/AManual Water-Based Based Fire Suppression Systems. sections for any specificFire Suppression compliance statements.Systems3.9.1 [Fire Suppression If an automatic or manual water- a N/A WA -Section Heading, see N/ASystem Code based fire suppression system is compliance bases below forRequirements] required to meet the perfonrance or compliance statements fordeterministic requirements of specific subsections.Chapter 4, then the system shall beinstalled in accordance with theappropriate NFPA standardsincluding the following:IWA12 T b12ARevision IPage A-99 Indiana Michigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transftn Report -Affachnient AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.9.1 [Fire SuppressionSystem CodeRequirements] (1)(1) NFPA 13, -Standard for theInstallatio of Sprinkler Systems'* Complies with use ofEEEEsSuppression systems credited to CNP Fire Safety Analysis Reportsmeet the requirements of NFPA805 Chapter 4 are Identified in FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 14.1the individual Fire SafetyAnalysis Reports. 09-0120-0381, -Extended NFPAThe sprinkler systems complywith the requirements of NFPA13, 1971 and 1983 editions, asevalated in the CNP NFPA 13Code Compliance Evaluations.Code Compliance Evaluation for theDonald C. Cook Nuclear Plant', Rev.109-0120-0123, 'NFPA CodeCompliance Evaluation Donald C.Cook Nuclear Plant', Rev. 00120-108-004, 'NFPA 13 -CodeCompliance Verification ChecklistD.C. Cook Units I & 2". Rev. 00120-164-002, "NFPA 13 -CodeCompliance Verifiation ChecklistD.C. Cook Units I & 2", Rev. 10120-164-007, "NFPA CodeEvaluation Deviation Evaluation D.C.Cook Units I and 2", Rev. 1CNP 'NFPA Code Deviations andJustifications', Rev. 2Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.41, "Unit I Fire Zone 53 (AA46)and Unit 2 Fire Zone 54 (AA47)Boundary Evaluation', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation12.20, *Unit I Turbine Oil Tank RoomFire Zone 95 (AA2Ar, Rev. 0Ta"mRIftom At~ft ft ,k cat WW.,I"Revison 7PageA-1aRevision IPage A.-100 Indiana Whim PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transfflon Report -Affachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference DocumentEngineering Equivalency Evaluation12.22, *Units 1 & 2 Auxiliary BuildingNorth and South Elevations 609' FireZones 44N (AA36) and 443 (AA42)Analysis of Sprinkler System-, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency EvaluationN, 'Partial Detection and SuppressionSystems for Fire Zone 26 (AA30),Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation0, "Partial Detection and SuppressionSystems for Fire Zone 11 (AA10)',Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency EvaluationP, "Partial Detection and Suppressionfor Fire Zone 23 (AA29)0, Rev. 0C ij a11,1000=2 TruWM ODGnuMM AP Cade Vais 1.22Revision IPage A-101 Indiana Michidan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Tmnsftn Report -Affachtnent AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.9.1 (Fire SuppressionSystem CodeRequirements] (2)(2) NFPA 15, "Standard for WaterSpray Fixed Systems for FireProte1ctio"* Complies with use ofEEEEsSuppression systems credited to CNP Fire Safety Analysis Reportsmeet the requirements of NFPA805 Chapter 4 are identified in FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 14.1the individual Fire SafetyAnalysis Reports. 09-0120-0381, "Extended NFPACNP complies with NFPA 15,1973 edition, as evaluated in theCNP NFPA 15 CodeCompliance Evaluations.Code Compliance Evaluation for theDonald C. Cook Nuclear Plant", Rev.109-0120-0123, "NFPA CodeCompliance Evaluation Donald C.Cook Nuclear Plant", Rev. 00120-108-1375, "NFPA 15 -CodeCompliance Verification ChecklistD.C. Cook Units I & 2", Rev. 00120-164-004, "NFPA 15 -CodeCompliance Verification ChecklistD.C. Cook Units I & 2", Rev. 10120-164-007, "NFPA CodeEvaluation Deviation Evaluation D.C.Cook Units I and 2", Rev. 1CNP "NFPA Code Deviations andJustificaions", Rev. 2Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.41, "Unit 1 Fire Zone 53 (AA46)and Unit 2 Fire Zone 54 (AA47)Boundary Evaluation', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation12.20, "Unit I Turbine Oil Tank RoomFire Zone 95 (AA2A)r, Rev. 0CNWTTIM C_VD,1+/-.0VVr302M Aýmm 60 % m al " ii URevison IPageA-1IRevision 1Page A- 102 Indiana Michican PowerCNP NFPA 805 Trensftn Rooort -Affwhment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference DocumentEngineering Equivalency Evalution12.22, *Units I & 2 Auximlary BuildingNorth and South Elevations 609' FireZones 44N (AA36) and 44S (AA42)Analysis of Sprinkler System', Rev. 03.9.1 Fire Suppression (3) NFPA 750, 'Standard on Water e N/A Water mist systems are not Fire Hazards Analysis, Rev. 14System Code Mist Fire Protection Systems' installed at Cook Nuclear PlantRequirements] (3)3.9.1 [Fire Suppression (4) NFPA 16, "Standard for the 9 N/A Foam-water and foam-water Fire Hazards Analysis, Rev. 14System Code Installation of Foam-Water Sprinkler spray systems are not installedRequirements] (4) and Foam-Water Spray Systems" at Cook Nuclear Plant.Revsio2 TIWOOM DOWmwdA ft VPag A103Revision 1 Page A-103 Indiana Michigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.9.2 [Fire SuppressionSystem Flow Alarm]Each system shall be equipped with .Compilesa water flow alarm.SCompies with use ofEEEEsCompiles:Fire protection functions aredisplayed on a comprehensiveannunciator panel in the controlrooms to alert the operator incase of fire, primary fire pumpoperatio, sprinkler waterflowsupervisory alarms, or firesystem malfunction. Pressuregauges on the panel also tell theoperator the pressure conditionsin the fire protection water pipingheaders.Compiles with use of EEEEs:Refer to CNP "NFPA CodeDeviations and Justifications" forNFPA 72D-1967 and NFPA14-1971 for justifications todeviations related to thisrequirement.FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 4.1.1UFSAR, Section 9.8.1,"Misellaneous Protective Features",Item g)1-OHP-4024-101, "Annunciator #101Response: Plant Fire Systemo, Rev.192-OHP-4024-201, "Annunciator #201Response: Plant Fire System", Rev.21CNP "NFPA Code Deviations andJustifications", Rev. 2IW30WJ12 TNFMWM WIwe c Ammio Coft VAn 12JRevision IPage A.104 Indiana Mkhidan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Affachnwnt AAta.chment 8 -AEm AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-I -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.9.3 [Fire Suppressionsystem Alarm Locations]All alarms from fire suppressionsystems shall annunciate In thecontrol room or other suitableconstantly attended location.* Complies with use ofEEEEsCompiles:Fire protection functions aredisplayed on a comprehensiveannunciator panel in the controlrooms to alert the operator incase of fire, primary fire pumpoperation, sprinkler waterfiowsupervisory alarms, or firesystem malfunction. Pressuregauges on the panel also tell theoperator the pressure conodionsin the fire protection water pipingheaders.UFSAR, Section 9.8.1,iscellaneous Protective Features",Item g)FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 4.1.11-OHP-4024-101, "Annunciator #101Response: Plant Fire System", Rev.191-OHP-4024-102, "Annunciator #102Response: Miscellaneous Areas FireSystem", Rev. 12Complies with use of EEEEs: 2-OHP-4024-201, "Annunciator #201Refer to CNP "NFPA Code Response: Plant Fire System", Rev.Deviations and Justifications" for 21NFPA 72D-1967 and NFPA14-1971 for justifications to 2-OHP-4024-202, "Annunciator #202deviations related to this Response: Miscellaneous Areas Firerequirement System", Rev. 13CNP "NFPA Code Deviations andJustifications", Rev. 23.9.4 (Fire Suppression Diesel-driven fire pumps shall be

• Complies The fire pump house structure is UFSAR, Section 9.8.1, "Fire PumpSystem Diesel Pump protected by automatic sprinklers, protected by a dry pilot preaction House Structure"Sprinkler Protection] sprinkler system. Sprinklers areprovided in each primary firepump room.CNP _MAt~l.MlMM2 Tmin~ Do, AM= Ca su VWmkm 1"Revision I Page A-105 Indiana Michigan PbwerCNP NFPA 805 Tranetion Report -AffachineW AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.9.5 [Fire SuppressionSystem Shutoff Controls]Each system shall be equipped with 9 Compliesan OS&Y gate valve or otherapproved shutoff valve. 0 Complies with use ofEEEEsComplies:All sprinkler systems areequipped with isolation valves.Complies with use of EEEEs:valves are Installed insome portion of the fireprotection system. These valveshave been evaluated to meetthe intent of the NFPArequirements by EngineeringEquivalency Evaluation 12.26.Flow Diagrams 5152 SeriesUFSAR, Section 9.8.1, "WaterDistribution", Item d)Engineering Equivalency Evaluation12.24, "NFPA 24 -Listed ValveDeviation 12-ZMO-400 & 401", Rev. 03.9.6 [Fire SuppressionSystem ValveSupervision]All valves controlling water-basedfire suppression systems requiredto meet the performance ordeterministic requirements ofChapter 4 shall be supervised asdescribed in 3.5.14.e Compes withdlariftcationValves are supervised asrequired. Valve positions areinspected on a monthly basis.Plant Procedure 12-PPP-4030-066-01 1, "Fire ProtectionValve Lineup Verification", Rev. 3,Section 1.41-OHP-4024-101, "Annundator #101Response: Plant Fire System", Rev.191 -OHP-4024-102, "Annunciator #102Response: Miscellaneous Areas FireSystem", Rev. 122-OHP-4024-201, "Annunciator #201Response: Plant Fire Systm , Rev.212-OHP-4024-202, "Annuncator #202Response: Miscellaneous Areas FireSystem-, Rev. 13CNP_1MC-"l.1Ib1W/3B/M2 OD ulVmlw t2A.JRevision IPage A.106 Indiana Michigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference Document3.10 Gaseous Fire Gaseous Fire Suppression

• N/A N/A -Section Heading, see sub- N/ASuppression Systems Systems. sections for any specificcompliance statements.3.10.1 [GaseousSuppression SystemCode Requirements]If an automatic total flooding andlocal application gaseous firesuppression system Is required tomeet the performance ordeterministic requirements ofChapter 4, then the system shall bedesigned and installed inaccordance with the followingapplicable NFPA codes:C CompliesGaseous fire suppressionsystems credited to meet therequirements of NFPA 805Chapter 4 are identified in theindividual Fire Safety AnalysisReports. These systems aredesigned and installed inaccordance with the applicableNFPA codes, as reviewed in thesub-sections of this element.CNP Fire Safety Analysis Reports'rfWWftDOMA AM af Wo1*I1wa2Revision I Page A-107Revision IPage A-107 Indiana Michigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 TranwYlon Repod -Affachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.10.1 [GaseousSuppression SystemCode Requirements] (1)NFPA 12, "Standard on CarbonDioxide Exngjusing Systems"* Complies with use ofEEEEsC02 extinguishin systemscredited to meet therequirements of NFPA 805Chapter 4 comply with NFPA12-1968, as evaluated in CNPNFPA Code ComplianceEvaluations, and EngierngEquivalency Evaluations.FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 14.109-0120-0123, "NFPA CodeCompliance Evaluation Donald C.Cook Nuclear Plant, Rev. 00120-108-002, "NFPA 12 CodeCompliance Verilication ChcIdist,Rev. 0"Donald C. Cook Nuclear Plant NFPACode Deviations and Jusifkcations",Rev. 2Engineeing Equivalency Evaluation12.19, "C02 Fire SuppressionSystems in Fire Zones ContainingConcentrations of C~able insulation(Fire Areas AA7, AA8, AAM, AA10,AA29, AA30, AA31, AA37, AA38,AA39, AA40 AA41, AA43, AA44,AA45, AA48, AA49, AA50, AA51,AA52 and AA53)', Rev. 0Eng ng Equivalency Evaluation1221, "Analysis of Fire Zones 13, 21,57, 58, and 59 Lack of C02Suppression System Calculations',Rev. 0CW-WAC"-._1. JIW3WUI Tw~f 0812AýCO W .Revision 1Page A-108 Indiana Michigan PowerCIVP MFPA &75 Tmnsffion Repod -AffachnxW AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.10.1 [GaseousSuppression SystemCode Requirements] (2)NFPA 12A, 'Standard on Halon1301 Fire Exnguishing Systems"* Compis with use ofExisting EnieringEquivalency Evaluations(EEEEs)Halon 1301 Fre ExtinguishingSystems credited to meet therequirements of NFPA 805Chapter 4 comply with NFPA12A-1977, as evaluated in CNPNFPA Code ComplianceEvaluations EngineenEquivalency Evaluations.Fire Protection Program Manual(FPPM), Rev. 11, 92/2009, Section14.109-0120-0123, "NFPA CodeCompliance Evaluation Donald C.Cook Nuclear Plent, Rev. 0,5/16/19880120-108-003,*NFPA 12A CodeCompliance Verfcation Checklist',Rev. 0, 5/14/1988*Donald C. Cook Nuclear Plant NFPACode Deviations and Justificaons',Rev. 2, 4/12106Engineering Equivalency Evaluation12.23, -Analysis of Fire Zones 57 and58 Lack of Halon SuppressionSystem Calculations', Rev. 03.10.1 [Gaseous NFPA 2001, *Standard on Clean N/A There are no dean agent fire N/ASuppression System Agent Fire Extnusn Systems" exingulsln systems requiredCode Requirements] (3) to meet the performance ordeterministic requirements ofChapter 4.1t3'w312 TMM DAMyM A 1 VOlW tURevision 1 Page A-109 Indiana Michigan PowCNP NFPA 805 Transition R@W -Aftdvnent AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.10.2 [GaseousSuppression SystemAlarm Location]Operation of gaseous firesupprssion system shallannunciate and alarm in the controlroom or other constantly attendedlocation identified.0 ComleOperation of all gaseous irm UFSAR, Section 9.8.1,suppressi systems annwuncite '-iscellaneous Protection Features!,and alarm in the control room. Rem g)SD-12-COAUX-100, 'SystemDescription for Low Pressure CarbonDioxide Fire Fighting System" Rev 1,Section 6.1 and 6.2SD-12-HALON-100, -SystemDescription Fire Protection -HalonSystems-, Rev. 0, 7/15/19961-OHP-4024-101, Anwnumdator #101Response: Plant Fire System", Rev.191-OHP-4024-102, -Annunciator #102Response: Miscellaneous Areas FireSystem', Rev. 122-OHP-4024-201, 'Annunciator #201Response: Plant Fire System', Rev.212-OHP-4024-202, 'Annuncitor #202Response: Mscelaneous Areas FireSystem', Rev. 13Oj-TDA.-. '1.6bTmrIt~n n A 06mft~w 12*tW 2maRevision I Page A-hORevision IRage A-1 10 Indiana Michigan PowerCIVP NFPA 805 Transftn Romd -Aftedunent AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.10.3 [GaseousSuppression SystemVentilation Limiinsý]Ventilation system design shall take .Complies withinto account prevention from over- clarication-asrzto during agentinjectim, adequate slng toprevent loss of agent, andconfinement of radioactivecontaminants.Per Section E.5.(d) of FPPMDesign Basis Table 5.1, theCardox (Cheme-tron) designcalculations and pre-op testshave confirmed that offsettingrequirements to preent over-pressurtzation ae satisfied.Per Section 9.8.1 of the UFSAR,Many of the plant ventilatingfans are arranged so that theymay be shutdown on actuationof an automatic fire system toprevent spread of fire or smokeor, In the case of C02 or Hat-protected areas, to retain anextinguishing concentration ofte fire fghting agent"FPPM, Rev. 11, Section Table 5.1,Section E.S.(d)Fire Hazards Analysis, Rev. 14,Section 3.4.3 and 3.4.4UFSAR, Section 9.8.1,Mlsceflaneous Protective Features-,item d)FL-15771, Cardox DesignCalculations "Low Pressure CarbonDioxide Flow CalculationsSD-12-HALON-100, -SystemDescription Fire Protection -HalonSystems', Rev. 0, 715/1996Fire areas and fire zones thatare protected by C02 systemshave boundary penetrations(i.e., dampers, seismic gaps andopenings around cables,conduits and pipes) sealed toensure retention of the C02concentations. In some fireareas, however, dampers havenot been provided for duct workthat communicates directly withthe plant exterior or that passthrough ote areas within ratedconstruction boundaries to theplant exterior. For the C02systems in these fir areas,connaton tests have beenMe at demonsrate thatuI&WA TMOOMM ADU CMf VMW t1.2Revision 1P6ge A-111 Indiana Michigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 TranaWn Report -Aftechnwit AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Documentthe required concentration levelscan be maintained withoutdampers. The affected firezones In which this situationexists are 40A, 40B, 42A, 45,46A, 47A and 478.3.10.4 [Gaseous In any area required to be protected ,N/A Not Applicable. CNP does not NoneSuppression System by both primary and backup have any areas required to beSingle Failure Umits] gaseous fire suppression systems, protected by both primary anda single active faiure or a crack in backup gaseous fireany pipe in the fire suppression suppression systems.system shall not impair both theprimary and backup firesuppression capability.3.10.5 [Gaseous Provisions for locally disarming .Compiles Plant documents ensure that FPPM, Rev. 11Suppression System automatic gaseous suppression disarming automatic gaseousDisaring Controls] systems shall be secured and under systems is secured and under SD-12-COAUX-100, "Systemstrict administrative control. strict administrative control. Description for Low Pressure CarbonDioxide Fire Fighting System* Rev 1,Section 9.2SD-12-HALON-100, "Fire Protection -Hal-m Systems", Rev. 0, 7/15/19963.10.6 [Gaseous Total flooding carbon dioxide Complies with The normally occupied areas of FPPM, Rev. 11, Table 5.1, SectionSuppression System systems shall not be used In darification the plant are considered to be EF3.(d)C02 Limitations] normally occupied areas. the general floor areas of theauxiliary and turbine buildings, UFSAR, Section 9.8.1, "Low-Prssureas well as the control rooms. Carbon Dioxide System"Total flooding C02 systems arenot used in these areas. Fire Hazards Analysis, Rev. 14,Section 3.4.3-MUMo2 T Pagef A.112Revision I Page A-1 12 Indiana Midhican PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Aftachrwnt AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference Document3.10.7 [Gaseous Automatic total flooding carbon Comples A discharge delay time with Fire Hazards Anlys, Rev. 14,Suppression system dioxide systems shall be equipped audible alarm is incorporated Section 3.4.3 and Section 4.1.7.C02 Warnings] with an audible pre-discharge alarm into each automatic systemand discharge delay sufficient to design to allow personnel fime SD-12-COAUX-100, *Systempermit egress of personnel. The to leave the area. C02 systems Description for Low Pressure Carboncarbon dioxide system shall be are provided with an odorzer. Dioxide Fire Fighting System", Rev 1,provided with an odorizer. Section 4.13, 4.17 and 6.23.10.8 [Gaseous Positive mechanical mean shall be

• opiles 002 systems can be isolated by SD-12-COAUX-100, "SystemSuppression System provided to lock out total flooding five different methods. These Description for Low Pressure CarbonC02 Required carbon dioxide systems during work are: Dioxide Fire Fighting System", Rev 1,Disarming] in the protected space. Section 9*Individual hazard "DetectionIsolating Key-Lock Switches.* Grouped hazard "MainDetection Isolating Key-LockSwitches (Master IsolationSwitches).e Automatic Isolation (ControlRoom Cable Vault only)." Header Shutoff Valves." Tank Shutoff Valves.When entering a C02 protectedarea, to assure safety, one ofthe above methods must beemployed to Isolate and blockan operation of the C02 system.The method selected isdependent on the length of timethe work In the area is expectedto take and the nature of thework.IRevion2 Tm1, PaMgoed A-m1 13Revision 1 Page ,A-113 Indiana Michigan PbwerCNP NFPA 805 Transffiw Report -Attadwwnt AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference Document3.10.9 [Gaseous The possibllty of secondary thermal .Complies M&M performed a study that took FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 12.1 item (3)Suppression System shock (cooling) damage shad be into account damage to safety-Cooling Considerations] considered during the design of any related electrical equpmn due Technical Evaluation 12.1. -Fregaseous fire Suppression system, to thermal shock caused by Suppression Effects Stud, Rev. 0but particularly with carbon dioxide. gaseous Suppression systemactuations."3.10.10 [Gaseous Particular attention shall be given to a Compies Corrosive characteristics of SD-12-HALON-100, Tire Protection -Suppression System corrosive characteristics of agent agent decomposition products Halon Systems", Rev. 0, Section 1Decomposition Issues] decomposition products on safety has been considered.systems.3.11 Passive fire This section shall be used to e N/A N/A -General Statement; No N/AProtection Features determine the design and Technical Requirements.installation requirements for passiveprotection features. Passive fireprotection features include wall,ceiling, and floor assemblies, firedoors, fire dampers, and throughfire barrier penetration seals.Passive fire protection features alsoinclude electrical raceway firebarrier systems (ERFBS) that areprovided to protect cables andelectrical components andequipment from the effects of fire.RUei2 ft== 1I Page O.1I.Revision I Pag A-1 14 Indiana Michigan Pb"rCNP NFPA 805 TranwIton Report -Attachinent AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.11.1 BuildingSeparationEach major building within thepower block shall be separatedfrom the others by barners having adesignated fire resistance rating of3 hours or by open space of at least50 ft (15.2 m) or space tha meetsthe requirements of NFPA 80A,*Recommended Practice forProtection of Buildings from ExteriorFire Exposures.-Exception.: Were a performance-based anasis determines theadequacy of building separation,the requirements of 3.11.1 shall notapply.* Complies with use ofEEEEsCompiles:The Auxilary Building,Containment Buildings, ServiceBuikling, and Turbine Buildingare separated from otherbuildings by 3-hour barriers orby greater than 50ft of openspace.The Auxilary Building isadjacent to the ContainmentBuildings and Turbine Building.The Auxiliary Building isseparated from the ContainmentBuildings and Turbine Buildingby a reinforced concrete wallwith a 3 hour3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br /> rated design.Openings are rated or havebee evaluated as equivalent oradequate for the hazard.The Containment Buildings areadjacent to the AuxiliaryBuilding. The ContainmentBuildings are separated from theAuxiliary Building by a reinforcedconcrete wall with a 3 hour3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br /> rateddesign. Openings are rated ordiscussed with individual FireSafety Analyses Reports.The Service Bulding is adjacentto the Turbine Building. TheService Building is separatedfrom the Turbine Building by areinforced concrete wall with a 3hour rated design. Openings areFPPM, Rev. 11, Table 5.1, Section D,*General Guidelines for PlantProtectionsCNP Fire Safety Analyses Reports,Rev. 0Fire Hazards Analysis, Rev. 14Enginmerng Equivalency Evaluation9.39, Fire Zone 70 (AA57A) to FireZone 129 (AA2A) BoundaryEvaluation", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.46, "Seismic Gaps Between theContainment and Auxiliary BuildingsBoundary Evaluation (Fire AreasAA2A, AA2B, AA3, AA7, AAS, AA9,AA10, A1 1, AA27, AA29, AA3M,A31, AA34, AA35, AA37 andm/38), Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.54, *Unit1 Main Control RoomCable Vault Penetration Seal W51 11Fire Zone 57 and 91 (Fire AreasAA50 ard AA2A), Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.65, *Fire Door Closure Evaluation(Fire Areas AM2, AA7, AM, AA14,AA15, AA23, AA24, AM30, AA31,AA34, AA.35, AA36/42, A37, AA38,AA39, AA41, AfJA3, AA44, AA45,AA48, and AA.53), Rev. 0100J012 TuMio Wu Aýicef dWMW 1t0Revision IPagp A-1 15 Indiana Adichidan PowerCIVP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Affachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference Documentrated or discussed withindividual Fire Safety AnalysesReports.The Turbine Building is adjacentto the Auxiliary Building and theService Building. The TurbineBuilding is separated from theAuxiliary Building and ServiceBuilding by a reinforcedconcrete wall with a 3 hour3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br /> rateddesign. Openings are rated ordiscussed with individual FireSafety Analyses Reports.Complies with use of EEEEs:A seismic gap exists around theContainment Buildings thatprovides an opening ofapproximately 6 in. between theContainment Buildings and thewalls, ceilings and floors of thestructures irmmedately adjacentto containment his openinghas been determined adequateby an engineering evaluation.CNP currently utilizes theexception to Section 3.11.1,which is endorsed.CMTOOCjt..via 12Revision I Page A-i 16Revision 1Pagp A-1 16 Indiana Michican PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transthon Report -AttsMnw# AAtanchment Power Por and 805 Trantst ReFor 8 aptet AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference DocumentCNP Fire Safety Analysis Reports,3.11.2 Fire BarriersFire barriers required by Chapter 4shall Include a specific fire-resistance rating. Fire barriers shallbe designed and installed to mestthe specific fire resistance ratingusing assemblies qualified by firetests. The qualification fire testsshall be In accordance with NFPA251, "Standard Methods of Tests ofFire Endurance of BuildinConstruction and Materials," orASTM E 119, "Standard TestMethods for Fire Tests of BuildingConstruction and Materials."a Complies with use ofEEEEsComp"les:Fire barriers required by Chapter4 are Identified in the individualFire Safety Analysis Reports. Aspec" f fire-resistance rating forall fire barriers is incudedAll wals, floors, and ceilingsseparating fire areas are eitherreinforced concrete constructionwhich exceed a 3 hour3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br /> firerating, or are of concrete blockconstruction with a 3 hour3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br /> fireresistance rating or have beenevaluated as equivalent oradequate for the hazard. Thedesign and installation of firebarriers meets the requirementsof ASTM E 119. Al openings forcable, pipe, and ductwork inwails, floor, and ceilingsseparating fire areas have beensealed with foamed in placesilicone which was tested for upto five hours fire exposure In anASTM E 119 wall fire test. Cabletray openings have been sealedand verified by ASTM E 119tests.cN, Fire ,Safety Analysi Reports,Rev. 0Fire Hazards Analysis, Rev. 1412-FPP-4030-066-5, Inspection ofFire Rated Assemblies0, Rev. 0FPPM, Rev. 11, Table 5.1, Section D,"General Guidelines for PlantProtection"Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.7, "Fire Zone 5 (AA5/6) to Unit 1Fire Zones 62A, 62B and 62C (AA54)and Unit 2 Fire Zones 63A, 63B and63C (AAS) Removable Block Walls-,Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.9, "Turbine, Awdlrhyy andContainment Buildings BoundaryEvaluation", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.11, "Storage of Fammable Gasesin Fire Areas AA2A. AA2B, ,A andA340, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency EvaluationComplies with use of EEEEs: 11.12, "Stairwells and ElevatorEach barrier which contained a Construction Boundary Evaluationsfeature with an unrated (Fire Areas AA1, AA2A, AA2B, AA3,component was analyzed with AA56, AA36 and AA4L2, Rev. 0respect to its fire suppressionand detection systems, proximity Engineering Equivalency Evaluationto safeshutdown equipmentr 11.18, "Radwaste Areas in Fire Zones?jW3W32 TwP_--ft". 1Revision IP"geA.117 Indiana Whiden PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Altadvnent AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Documentand the Impact that the unratedportion of the fire barrer oLdhave on safe-shutdowncapability. These barriers whichcontained unrated componentshave been evaluated asequivalent or adequate for thehazard.3, 31 and 32 (AA3) BoundaryEvaluation', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.36, 'Unt I and 2 Hot ShiownPanel Enclosure: Unit 1 Fire Zone144 (M.MO) and Unit Fire Zone 145(AA5) r, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.38, "Fire Protection Pump House(Fire Area YD)', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.39, 'Fireprooing for the WestMotor Driven Auxiliary FeedwaterPump Endosures Fire Zones 17A(AA16), 17B (AA17), 80 (AA2A) and84 (m2Br, Rev. 0Engineeing Equivalency Evaluation11.41, Unt I Fire Zone 53 (AA46)and Unit 2 Fire Zone 54 (AA47)Boundary Evaluation', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.44, 'Expansion of Fire Zone 33and 146 and Unrated Fire Doors (361and 362) Fire Zoes 32, 33 and 34(Fire Areas AA3, AA34 and AA35r,Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.51, 'Screenhouse, and WaterIntake System Boundary EvaluationFire Zone 142 (AA2A) to Fire Zone143 (YD)', Rev. 0Tmols" wemu DOfthm, 1.2A12Revision I Page A-118Revision IPage A-1 18 Indiana Mkhiden PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transibon Repad -Machment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference DocumentEngineering Equivalency Evaluation11.66,'-Yard (YD) toFire Zone 19(AA24) Boundary Evaluation-, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation12.11, 'Structura Steel Evaluations InFire Areas MA2A. AA2B, MA3, AA34,AA35, AA56 and AA58, Rev. 0Engineerng Equivalency Evaluation12.16, 'Radiant Heat Shiels for FireArea AA58', Rev. 0OW-WjLV1 bNW30M 2 Trin.m.mawmMeO 'gI 'is.Cg uitO1Revision I Page A-119Revision IPage A-1 19 Indiana Michigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Ttansffion Report -Attachnwj AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.11.3 Fre BarrierPenetrationsPenetrations in fire barriers shall be

• Compliesproided with listed fire-rated doorassemblies or Hated rated fire

• Comples with use ofdampers having a fire resistance EEEEsrating consistent with thedesignated fire resistance ratng ofthe barrier as determined by theperformance requirementsestablished by Chapter 4. (See3.11.3.4 for penetration seals forthrough penetration fire stops.)Exception: Where fire areaboundaries are not wall-to-wall,floor-o-celng boundaries with allpenetrations sealed to the fire ratingrequired of the boundaries, aperibmiance-based amnysis shallbe requitred to assss the adequacyof fire barrier brmng the f&reboundary to determie If the barrerwil withstand the fire effects of thehazards in the area. Openings infire barriers shall be penrmed to beprotected by other means asacceptable to the AHJ.Compiles:In general, fire-rated doorassemblies or listed rated firedampers having the fireresistance rating consistent withthe fire resistance rating of thefire barrier are provided. Fire-rated assemblies which Includefire-rated doors and firedampers required by Chapter 4ae outlined in the CNPindividual Fire Safety AnalysesReports.Comples with use of EEEEs:Where fire-rated doorassemblies or listed rated firedampers ae not provkied withthe fire resistance ratingconsistent with the fireresistance rating of the firebarrier (e.g. hatches, watercurtains, manways, etc.), theassemblies have beenevaluated to be equivalent oradequate for the hazard.CNP Fire Safety Aalyses Reports,Rev. 0Basis d=ocuentation for EngineeringEquivalency Evaluations is lited In3.11.3(1) through 3.11.3(3)cWe-7W4c%4.t 1TWO"* si 1.11Mcot ai"ImuRevision I Page A-I 20Reisibn 1Page A-120 Indiana Michigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 TransWon Repod -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.11.3 [NFPA 80 -FireDoor and WindowRequIrements] (1)Passive fire protection devices such

• Complies withas doors and dampers shall clarfcaonconform with the folwn NFPAstandards, as applicable:

• Coajles byrevious(1) NFPA 80, Standard for FireDoors and Fire Windows'NRC approva* Complies with use ofEEEEsComplies with clarification:All doors are UL Class A (3hour) fire rating or a UL Class B(1-1/2 hour) rating to becommensurate with the severityof the hazard as determined bythe performance requirementsestablished by Chapter 4 ofNFPA 805. Per the FPPM, I&Mhas committed CNP to complywith NFPA 80. Modifications torated fire doors are made inaccordance with NFPA 80 inorder to ensure that the fireprotection features of the doorare not degraded.Fire rated doors that aredesigned to be left in the openposition, if desired, are providedwith self-closing hardwarewhich, when activated byexposure to the heat of a fire,allows the door to close.Complies by previous NRCapproval:During the review forcompliance with Appendix A toBTP 9.5-1, the NRC identifiedconcerns relating to theInstallation placement and ratingof fire doors at CNP. I&Mcommitted to upgrading affectedfire doors and per the NRCSafety Evaluation, dated July31, 1979, which states:FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 14.42NRC Safety Evaluation supportingAmendment NoL 31 and 12k,License No. DPR-58 and DPR-74,7/31/79, page 13, Other temRelating to the Station Fire ProtectionProgram, Item BI&M Letter -Request for Approval andExemptions", dated March 31, 1983,Section 7.2.6NRC Safety Evaluation "Donald C.Cook Nuclear Power Plant, Unit Nos.1 and 2 Fire Protection -Request forExemption from Requirements ofAppendix R to 10 CFR 50, SectionIII.G and III.0', 12/23/83, page 5,Section 4.0, ConclusionEngineering Equivalency Evaluation9.5, 'Fire Zones 70 (AA57A) and 73(AA57B) Hatch Evaluations', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.13, "Fire Zone 53 (AA46) and FireZone 57 (AA50) Hatch Evaluation',Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.14, "Fire Zone 43 (AA36) and FireZone 56 (AA48) Hatch Evaluation',Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.15, -Fire Zone 40B (AA398) andW30M2 Tn"W AI Ceft VOOM I."Revision 1PaeA-121 Indiana Michican PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transftn Report -Affadment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference DocumentFire Zone 55 (MA48) Hatch"fe conclude that Fere doors and Evaluation", Rev. 0dampers are provided orcomitted where necessary inaccordance with Me provisionsof Appendix A to BranchTechnical Posfitn APCSB 9.5-1and are, therefore, acceptable."These cnofmmiets to remedyany deficiencies listed in theaforementioned SafetyEvaluation Report have beenfulflled per the FPPM, whichstates:'he noted deficines werecorrected or appropriatejustifcations have beenprepared."The fire doors wheredeficiencies were corrected orJustifications prepared, asapproved by the SE Report, arestill used at CNP. There havebeen no plant modifications orother changes that wouldinvalidate the basis for approval.The corrected doors remainunchanged. The Justification forthe any deficiencies remainsvalid and unchanged.Complies with use of EEEEs:Where any unrated doors arelocated in fire area boundaries,an evaluation has beenEngineering Equivalency Evaluation9.16, "Fire Zone 41 (AA40) and FireZone 55 (AA48) Hatch Evaluation',Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.17, "Fire Zone 54 (AA47) and FireZone 58 (AA51) Hatch Evaluation",Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency EvauatIon9.18, "Fire Zone 52 (AA3) and FireZone 59 (AA52) Hatch Evaluation-,Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.19, "ire Zone 45 (AA43) and FireZone 60 (AA52) Hatch Evaluation-,Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluatio9.21, "Fire Zone 110 (AA2A) and FireZone 43 (AA36) Door Evaluation-,Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluaton922, "Fire Zone 111 (AA2B) and FireZone 44S (AA42) Door Evaluation",Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.23, "Fire Zone 116 (AA9) BoundaryEvaluation', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency EvaluationCaw_1Damv .0iTu,,ll DSSUz 1'W2Revision I Page A-122Revision IP"V A- 122 Indiana MichAwn PowerCNP NFPA M Tramftn Report -Attacturmont AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference Documentperformed to determine the 9.24, "Fire Zone 117 (AA29)doors are equivalent or Boundary Evaluation", Rev. 0adequate for the hazard.Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.25, "Essential Service Water PumpHouse Hatch and Fire DamperEvaluation (Fire Areas AA2A, AA32ad AAn33r, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.31, "Fire Zones 62A, 62B and 62C(AA54) Boundary Evaluation", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.32, "Fire Zones 63A, 63B and 63C(AA56) Boundary Evaluations", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.37, "Fire Zones 5 (AA5/6) and 32(MA3) Boundary Evaluations", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.39, "Fire Zone 70 (AA57A) to FireZone 129 (AM2A) BoundaryEvaluation', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.1, "Auxiliary Building El. 587 toSpent Fuel Heat Exchanger Pit PumpRoom Hatch Boundary EvaluationFire Zone 5 (A5/6) mad Fire Zone 36(AA3) Hatch Evaluation', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.9, "Turbine, Auxiliary andContainment Buildings BoundaryEvaluation", Rev. 011&A2 TMl IMM6MMAOul VfM 1."Revision 1Page A-123 Indiana Michiban PowerCNP NFPA 805 Trans#= Report -Alfachnient AInin lhanPwrCN FA85Tasto Rrjot-AtcmnAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference DocumentEngineering Equivalency Evaluation11.15, 'Swltchgear RoomConstction Bounday RoomEvaluation Unit I Fire Zones 14, 40A,408,41 and 42A (AA13, A-39A,AA39B, AA40 and AA41) & Unit 2 FireZones 20, 45, 46A, 47A and 478(AA25, AA43, AA44, AA45A andAA45B)", Rev. 0Engnering Equivalency Evaluation11.37, *Fire Zones 52 and Fire Zone44N Hatch Evaluation', Rev. 0Engieerng Equivalency Evaluation11.39, 'Fireproofing For The WestMotor Driven Auxilary FeedwaterPump Enclosures Fire Zones 17A(AA16), 176 (AA17), 80 (AA2A), And84 (mA2B)', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.44, -Expansion of Fire Zone 33and 146 and Unrated Fire Doors (361and 362) Fire Zones 32, 33, and 34(mre Areas M3, A34 and AA3)',Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.56, 'Turbine Building Main SteamAccess Way Fire Zones 110 to 114,Fire Zones 111 to 115, Fire Zones112 to 2N, Fire Zones 113 to 2S (FireAreas AA2A, AA2B, AA2C), Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.65, 'Fire Door Closure Evaluation(Fire Areas AA2, AA7, AA8, AA14,112 TMM 0lfrM I"Revision IPage A-124 Indiana Michigan PbvwrCNP NFPA 805 Transition Repolt -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-I -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference DocumentAA15, AA23, AA24, AA30, AA31,AA34, AA35, AA36/42, W37, AA38,AA39, AA41, AA43, AA44, AA45,AA48, and AA53r, Rev. 0@e~wx_"vi lbTIO pft ewblow"" I lii tRevIsion 1 Page A-125Revision IPage A-125 Indiana Michigan POverCMP NFPA W5 Transftn Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.11.3 [NFPA 90A -FreDamper Requirements](2)Passive fire protection devices such

• Compliesas doors and dampers shallconform with the following NFPA .Complin by previousstandards, as applicable: NRC approval(2) NFPA 90A. Standard for the .C;omnift with use ofInstallation of Air-Conditioning and EEEEsVentilating Systems"Compiles:All ventilation dampers carry ULClass A (3 hour3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br />) fire rating or aUL Class B (1-1/2 hour) rating tobe commensurate with theseverity of the hazard asdetermined by the performancereqtudiemet established byChapter 4 of NFPA 805. Per theM&M has committed CNPto comply with NFPA 90A.Modifications to rated firedampers ae made inaccordance with NFPA 90A inorder to ensure that the fireproteton features of thedamper are not degraded.Compiles by previous NRCapproval:Technical specification-relatedfre dampers and HVAC systemdesi have been reviewed bythe NRC for damper placementand ratings. These dampershave also been reviewed by I&Mfor rating and installation.Per letter from I&M to the NRCdated June 15, 1984:"In the area of HVAC ductworkwe have recently discoveredthat technical exemptons arerequired for 17 ducts whichpenetraM fire barrle. Theseareas ae 4pfied by lowFPPM, Rev. 11, Section 14.4.3I&M Letter 0692R "Request forAdditional Technical Exemptions toCertain Fire Dampers and SelsmicGaps", 6/15/84I&M Letter 0692U "Appendix RTechnical Exemption for SeismicGaps and HVAC Duct Penetrations-,8/13/84NRC Safety Evaluation of FireProtection Requests, 8/27/85, Section3.4Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.1, "Fire Zone 43 (AA36) and 91(AA2A) Duct Evaluation"Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.Z "Fire Zone 54 (AA47) and FireZone 73 (AA578) Duct Evaluation"Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.3, "CCW Pump Air Supply DuctEvaluation: Fire Zone "AS (AA42)"Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.4, "Auxiliary Building Vertical AirShafts Evaluation: Fire Zones 12(Wl 1) and 22 (AA27)"Enineering Equivalency Evaluation9.7, "Fire Zone 13 (AA12) and FireZone 14 (AA13) Boundary Evalustion"aejTW-.1.i iTWOuOef"MO0af~vo I"i1wJ7IV2Revision I Page A-126Revision IPageA-126 Indiana Michigan PlowerCNP NFPA 805 Tmn&ftn Report -AffaichmeW AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Documentcombustible lodng, and ductoudet being located in an areasufficienl removed fromequipment irVortant to the safeshutdown of the facility. Soundengineering can beused to justify our request fortechnical exemption of therequirements for fire dampers.'Per letter from I&M to the NRCdated August 13, 1984:"The evaluation concludes that,because of a low combustibleloading of less than 15 minutesin all applcable fire areas/zones,the location of safe shutdowncomponents/circuits and thedetection and suppressionsystems available in the subjectfire ares/zones, adequateprotectio from duct related firedamage is and safeshutdown capabit is ensured.As discussed with your staff, theevaluation includes fiveadditional ventilaton ductpenetrations without firedampers, that also requiretechnical exemptions. Theseduct penetrations listed belowwere not identified in the June15, 1984 letter."The NRC Safety Evaluation,dated August 27, 1985 states:Engeeing Equivalency Evaluation9.8, *Fue Zone 20 (AA25) and FireZone 21 (AA26) Boundary Evaluation"Engineering Equivalncy Evaluation9.33, "Fire Zone SA (AAS/6) to 1386(AAI) Boundary Evaluations"Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.34, "Fire Zone 36 (AA3) to FireZone 5 (AASl6) Boundary Evaluation"Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.35, "ire Zone 108 (AA2A) to FireZone 33A (AA34) BoundaryEvaluation"Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.36, Tire Zone 109 (AA2B) to 34A(AA35) Boundary Evaluation"Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.37, "Fire Zones 5 (AA5/6) and 32(AA3) Boundary Evaluations"Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.38, "Fire Zone 69 (AA3) to FireZones 108 (AA2A) and 109 (AA2B)Boundary Evaluations"Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.40, "Fire Zone 7 (AA7) to Fire Zone61 (AA5/6) Boundary Elevation"Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.41, "Fire Zone 37 (AA36) and51 (AA3) HVAC Duct Penetrations"1Ab1OFWM2 TWOMM DiMMnM Aý flb* VaImM I"Revision IPage A.12 7 Indiana Michican, PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transftion Report -Affwhment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document"Based on our evaluation, wethat we havereasonable assurance that the22 Auxiliary Buidingundampered ventilation ductpenetrations wiN not affect safe-shutdown in the event of a fire inFire Area A, B, C, D or E. Thelack of fire dampers In these 22ventiation duct penetrations is,therefore, an acceptabledeviation from the guidefines ofSection D.L.() of Appendix A toBTP APCSB 9.5-1.The 22 undampered ventilationduct penetrations, as approvedby the SE Report, still exist atCNP. There have been no plantmodifications or other changesthat wod invalidate the basisfor approval. The Justilication forthe ventilation ducts remainsvalid and unchanged.Complies with use of EEEEs:Engineering equivalencyevaluations have beenperfored for any unrateddampers located in fire areaboundaries. These engineeringequivalency evaluationsdetermined the dampers areequivalent or adequate for thehazard.Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.14, -Cable Spreading RoomConstruction Boundary Evaluation(Fire Areas AA3,AA7, AAS, AA9,AAIO, AA29, AA30, AA31, AA34,AA35, AA36, AA37, AA38, AA42,ma48, AA50, AA5w and AA52Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.15, "Sw-tchgear RoomConstruction Boundary RoomEvaluation Unit 1 Fire Zones 14, 40A,40B, 41 and 42A (AA13, AA39A,AA39B, AA40 and AA41) & Unit 2 FrweZones 20, 45, 46A, 47A and 47B(AA25, AA43, AA44, AA45A andAA45B)Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.16, tLube Oil Storage Rooms FireZones 83 and 95 (AA2A), and 88 and100 (AA2B) Boundary EvaJationEngineering Equivalency Evaluation11.45, Building HVAC DuctPenetrations Boundary EvaluationFire Areas AA1, AA3, AA516, AA36and AA42"Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.56, "Turbine Building Main SteamAccess Way Fire Zones 110 to 114,Fire Zones 111 to 115, Fire Zones112 to 2N, Fire Zones 113 to 2S (FireAreas A2A, AA2B, AA2C)"Engineering Equivalency Evaluation12.13, *Fire Damper Closure RevieWS _ _".12Twat ONVAN" AOI 086m V" 1J.U12WfI12RevIsion 1 Page A-128Revision IPage A.128 Indiana Michiden PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transftn Report -Affadwm# AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.11.3 [NFPA 101 -Uf.Safety CodeRequirements] (3)Passive fire protection devices such

• Complies withas doors and dampers shall clarificationconform with the followin NFPAstandards, as applicable:(3) NFPA 101, -Lfe Safety Code"CNP cOm with carificationwith regards to NFPA 101, 2000Edition. NFPA 101 companis achieved through NFPA 80and NFPA 90kA NFPA 101,2000 Edition, Secton82-3.21 (a) with regards to ratedfire door assemblies refers toNFPA 80. NFPA 101, 2000Edition, Section 9.2.1 withregards to rated fire dampersrefers to NFPA 90A. Table B-i,Section 3.11.3(1) and 3.11.3(2)discuss ompliance of NFPA 80and NFPA 90A.FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 7.0 andSections 14.4.2 and 14.4.3@jTW*4_1.1.btTMMOOWM Oat" t"Revision I Page A-129Revision IPage, A.129 Indiana Michlban PowerCNP NFPA 805 Tmnsftn Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.11.4 ThroughPenetration Fire StopsThrough penetration fire stops forpenetrations such as pipes,conduits, bus ducts, cables, wires,pneumatic tubes and ducts, andsimilar building service equipmentthat pass through fire barriers shalbe protected as follows.* Complies* Complies by previousNRC approval* Complies with use ofEEEEsComplies:CNP specification ES-FIRE-0601-QCF details therequirements for the installationand maintenance of fire ratedseals and fire stops at CNP. Thescope of this specification is forpenetration seals that areinstalled or are being installed atCNP that will function to preventthe spread of fire.Additionally, per specificationES-FIRE-0601-QCF, CNPallows the use of additional teststandards ASTM E-814, MEEB634 and NFPA 251 fordevelopment of standard firetest, and qualification of firerated penetration seals.Complies by previous NRCapproval:By the response to Appendix Ato Branch Technical PositionAPCSB 9.5-1, dated January 31,Plant Specification ES-FIRE-0601-QCF, "Fire Rated Seals", Rev. 3I&M response to Appendix A toBranch Technical Posito APCSB9.5-1 for Units No. 1 and 2,1/31/77,Section D.1.0)NRC Safety Evaluation dated 7/31/79,Pg. 13, "Other Items Relating to theStation Fire Protection Program",SectionAEngneing Equivaency Evaluation9.35, "Fire Zone 108 (AA2A) to FireZone 33A (AA34) BoundaryEvaluation-, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.36, -Fire Zone 109 (AA2B) to 34A(AA35) Boundary Evaluation', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.37, "Fire Zones 5 (AA516) and 32(AA3) Boundary EvaIluations", Rev. 01977, item D.1.0) I&M stated: Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.2, "Fire Zone 7 (AA7) to Fire Zone"all openings for cable, pipe, and 38 (AA37) Boundary Evaluation",ductwork in these walls, floors, Rev. 0and ceilings have been sealedwith foamed in place silicone Engineerng Equivalency Evaluationwhich was tested in march 1975 11.3, "Fire Zone 27 (AA31) to Firefor up to five hours fire exposure Zone 39 (A38)", Rev. 0in an ASTM E 119 wall fire test."Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.4, "Unit I Auxilary BuildingThe NRC Safety Evaluation,OP3TMC_4 *IMbTIWAIn DM.WOMinOCsp ft1WU2Revision I Page A-130Revision IPage A-130 Indiana Michican PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Repod -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Documentdated July 31, 1979 states:"The test report shows that thepenetration seal passed a 3-hour E-1 19 type fire exposuretest. However, the test includedonly the Unit 2 penetrationdesign. The licensees haveprovided a comparison betweenUnit I and Unit 2 penetrationseal designs to justify that theUnit 2 design is the "worst case"for fire testing. We agree withthis evaluation and concludethat the Unit 2 seal tests areacceptable for the Unit I seals.We conclude that thepenetration fire stops which arein place provide sufficientprotection from the unboundedspread of fire along electricalcables. We base this conclusionon our knowledge of ASTME- 119 fire tests including thosecited by the licensees whichsubstantiate the fire resistiveability of penetration fire stopsconstructed with silicone foam."The foamed in place siliconedesign, as approved by the SEReport is still in use at CNP.There have been no plantmodifications or other changesthat would invafldate the basisfor approval. The foamed inplace silicone design and theJustification of the worst caseElevation 620 ft.-6 In. to AuxiliaryCable Vault Fire Zone 44n to FireZone 56", Rev. 0Engineefn Equivalency Evaluation11.5, "Unit 1 EPS/4 KVSwitchgearComplex Ventilation Shaft BoundaryEvaluation (Fire Areas 'A39A,AA39B, AA40, AA4i md AA48)w,Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.6, "Fire Zones 45 (AA43), 46Athrough 46D (AA44), 47A (AA45A),47B (AA45B) to Fire Zone 60 (AA52)Shaft Boundary Evaluation', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.7, "Fire Zone 5 (AA5/6) to Unit IFire Zones 62A, 62B and 62C (AA54)and Unit2 Fire Zones 63A, 63B and63C (AA5) Removable Block Wals",Rev. 0Engineering EquWvalency Evaluation11.15, -Swltchgear RoomConstruction Boundary RoomEvaluation Unit I Fire Zones 14, 40A,40B, 41 and 42A (AA13, AA39A,AA39B, MA40 and AA41) & Unit 2 FireZones 20, 45, 46A, 47A and 47B(AA25, AA43, AMA44, AA45A andAA45B)", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.16, "Lube Oil Storage Rooms FireZones 83 and 95 (AA2A), and 88 and100 (AA2B) Boundary Evaluation",oe_TW_...Yl bTMOMinuAgiNMVWWAMI.R1+/-1m~2Revision I Page A-131Revision IPage A-131 Indiana Michican PowerCNP NFPA 805 TransOm RepW -Altachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Documentconfiguration has not changed. Rev. 0Complies with use of EEEEs:Where through penetration firestops are not protected inaccordance with Section 3.11.4,these assemblies have beenevaluated to be equivalent oradequate for the hazard.Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.17, 'Diesel Generator Fuel oi DayTank Rooms Fire Zones 15 (AA14),16 (AA15), 18 (AA23) and 19 (AA24)Boundary Evaluationw, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.20, 'Narrow Space Openingsbetween Items and theBarrier or Between Penetrating ItemsBoundary Evaluation", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.24, "Fire Retention Capability ofNonconfrming Fire Seals in FireZones having a Low Fire Severt,Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.26, 'Fire Retention Capability of aHELB 3 Pressure Boundary Seal (FireAreas AA19, AA20, AA21 andAA22)', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.27, 'Generic Fire Seal Design 1',Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.28, 'Generic Fire Seal Design 2(Fire Areas AA7, AA, AA40,AA43, AA45A, AA45B, AA48 andAA52), Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.29, 'Generic Fire Seal Design 3 inoWlMC-v. 1.MTIUsM 9OWOA N& WMIM I3."1W 201Revision I Page A-732Revision IPage A-132 Indiana Michigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference DocumentFire Areas AA2A, AA2B, and AA15",Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.30, "Generic Fire Seal Design 4(A2)r, Rev. oEngineering Equivalency Evaluation11.31, "Generic Fire Seal Design 5(Fire Areas AA31 and AM38)", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.32, "Generic Fire Seal Design 6(AA2)', Rev. 0Engineerng Equivalency Evaluation11.33, "Generic Fire Seal Design 7(Fire Areas AA7 and AA37)", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.34, "Generic Fire Seal Design 8",Rev. 0Engieenng Equivalency Evakluion11.35, "Generic Fire Seal Design 9",Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.47, "Fire Zones 44N (AA36), 44S(AA42) and 52 (AA3) PenetrationSeals", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.48, "Fre Zones 15(AA14), 16(AAMS) 18 (AA23) and 19 (AA24)Penetration Seals", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency EvaluationC _'tC_,,.v1 bWWizA2 as & m Van"* 1+/-2Revision I Page A-133Revision IPope .A-133 Indiana Mkhican PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transffion Rewd -Affachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference Document11.49, -Acceptablity of Valve 2-FP-392-2-11 RCP Fire SuppressionPriming Water Check Valve (FireArea AA58), Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.50, Embedded Condult Fire WrapProtection (Fire Areas AA14 andAA24)-, Rev. 0En rng Equivalency Evaluation11.51, Screenhouse and WaterIntake System Boundary EvaluationFire Zone 142 (AM2A) to Fire Zone143 (YD)-, Rev. 0Ergi ng Equilency Evaluation11.54, *Unit I Main Control RoomCable Vault Penetration Sel W51 11Fire Zone 57 and 91 (Fire AreasAA50 and AA2Ar, Rev. 0Engineerin Equivalency Evaluation11.56, *Turbine Building Main SteamAccess Way Fire Zones 110 to 114,Fire Zones 111 to 115, Fire Zones112 to 2N, Fire Zones 113 to 2S (FireAreas A2A. M2B, M2cr, Rev. 0IWNtT .1MRevision Am Pagt e" "13Revision IPap A-134 Indiana Whiban PowerCNP NFPA 805 TransMon Report -Aftchnmot AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.11.4 [Annular SpaceRequirements] (a)The annular space between thepenetrating item and the throughopening In the fire barrier shal befilled with a qualified fire-resistivepenetration seal assembly capableof maintaining the fire resistance ofthe fire barrier. The assembly shallbe qualified by tests In accordancewith a fire test protocol acceptableto the AHJ or be protected by alisted fire-rated device for thespecified fire-resistive period." Complies" Complies by previousNRC approval* Complies with use ofEEEEsComplies:CNP specification ES-F[RE-0601-QCF detals therequirements for the instalationand maintenance of fire ratedseats and fire stops at CNP. Thescope of this specification is forpenetration seals that areInstalled or will be installed atCNP that will function to preventthe spread of fire. Per Othspecification, the contractorinstalling the fire seals mustfumish documentation that theconfigurations have passedASTM E-119 fire and hosestream tests that have beenperformed and documented byan Independent laboratory.Per the FPPM, penetration sealsare required to be fire tested todemonstrate ty meet therequired fire rating of the barrier.Seals at CNP are tested Inaccordance with ASTM E-1 19requirements.Additionally, per specificationES-FIRE-0601-QCF, thestandards which can be used fordevelopment of standard firetest and qualification of fire ratedpenetration seals are ASTME-814, MEEB 634 and NFPA251.Rev. 11, Section 12.2.2 andTable 5.1, Section D, GeneaGuidelines for Plant Protection"Plant Specification ES-FIRE-0601-QCF, "Fire Rated Seals, Rev. 3,9/17.2010, Secton I.2 Section 142.and Attachment 1, Typical DetailsI&M Donald C. Cook Nuclear Plant"Response to Appendix A to BranchTechnical Position APCSB 9.5-1 forUnits No. I and 2", 1/31/77, SectionD.1.0)NRC Safety Evaluation Report dated7/31/79, Pg. 13, "Other Items Relatingto the Station Fire ProtectionProgram", Section A.Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.35, "Fire Zone 108 (AA2A) to FireZone 33A (AA34) BoundaryEvaluation", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.36, "Fire Zone 109 (AA2B) to 34A(AA35) Boundary Evaluation", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation9.37, "Fire Zones 5 (AAM/6) and 32(AA3) Boundary Evaluations", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.2, "Fire Zone 7 (AA7) to Fire Zone38 (AA37) Boundary Evaluation",Rev. 0CW7M 01+/-Revision I Page A-135Revision IPage A-135 Indiana Michiden PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Affachn7ent AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference DocumentComplies by previous NRCapproval:By the response to Appendix Ato Branch Technical PositionAPCSB 9.5-1, dated January 31,1977, item D.1.(j) I&M stated:"al openings for cable, pipe, andductwork in these walls, floors,and ceilings have been sealedwith foamed in place sionewhich was tested in march 1975for ip to five hours fire exposurein an ASTM E 119 wall fire test."The NRC Safety Evaluation,dated July 31, 1979 states:"The test report shows that thepenetration seal passed a 3-hour E- 119 type fire exposuretest However, the test includedonly the Unit 2 penetrationdesign. The licensees haveprvlod a companho betweenUnit I and Unit 2 penetrationseal designs to ju.ti., ta theUnit 2 design is the mWorst cose"for fire testing. We agree withthis evaluation and concldethat the Unit 2 seal tests areacceptable for the Unit I seals.We conclude that thepenetration fire stops which arein ploa provde sumcientprotection from the unboundedspread of fire along elecrcalcables. We base this conclusionEngineering Equivalency Evaluation11.3, "Fire Zone 27 (AA31) to FireZone 39 (AA38)", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.4, 0"Unt 1 Auxiliary BuildingElevation 620 ft-6 in. to AuxiiaryCable Vault Fire Zone 44n to FireZone 56", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.5, "Unit I EPS/4 KV SwitchgearComplex Ventilation Shaft BoundaryEvaluation (Fire Areas AA39A,AA39B, AA40, AA41 and AA48)",Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.6, "Fire Zones 45 (AA43), 46Athrough 46D (AA44), 47A (AA45A),478 (AA45B) to Fire Zone 60 (AA52)Shaft Boundary Evaluation', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.7, "Fire Zone 5 (AAM6) to Unit 1Fire Zones 62A. 62B and 62C (AA54)and Unit 2 Fire Zones 63A, 63B and63C (AA5) Removable Block Wais",Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.15, -Switchgear RoomConstruction Boundary RoomEvaluation Unit I Fire Zones 14, 40A,40B, 41 and 42A (AA13, AA39A,AM39B, AM40 and AA41) & Unit 2 FireZones 20, 45, 46A, 47A and 47BaejTWC_1 aV1U12Revision I Page A-136Revision 1Page A-136 Indiana Michican PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Documenton our knowledge of ASTME-119 fire tests incin thosecited by the licensees whichsubstantiate the fire restivmability of penetration fire stopsconsfucted wth sificone foam.The foamed in place siliconedesign, as approved by the SEReport, is still in use at CNP.There have been no plantmodificaticns or other changesthat would invalidate the basisfor approval. The foamed inpilce silicone design and thejustification of the worst caseconfiguration has not changed.Compiles with use of EEEEs:Engineering equivalencyevaluations have beenperformed for any penetrationsthat do not provide a fireresistance rating at least equalto that of the fire area barrlerItself. These engineeringequivalency evaluationsdetermined the penetrations areequivalent or adequate for thehazard.(AAM25, AA43, AA44, AA45A andAA45B)s, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.16, Lube Oil Storage Rooms FireZones 83 and 95 (AA2A), and 88 and100 (AA2B) Boundary Evaluation',Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.17, Diesel Generator Fuel oil DayTank Rooms Fire Zones 15 (AA14),16 (AAMS), 18 (AA23) and 19 (AA24)Boundary Evaluation", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalncy Evaluation1120, -Narrow Space Openingsbetween Penetrating Items and theBarrler or Between Penetrating ItemsBoundary Evaluationa, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.24, "Fire Retention Capability ofNonconforning Fire Seals in FireZones having a Low Fire Severity',Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation1126, "Fire Retention Capability of aHELB 3 Pressure Boundary Seal (FireAreas AA19, AA20, AA21 andAA22)', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.27, "Generic Fire Seal Design 1",Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation1Nr3612 TM DInMUM A OMM VOWNi "Revision I Page A-137Revtion IPage A-137 Indiana Michican PoverCNP NFPA 805 Transitfon Report -Affachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference Document11.28, -Generic Fire Seal Design 2(Fire Areas AA7, AA8, AA39A, M40,M43, A45A, M45B, M4 andMA52)r, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.29, "Generic Fire Seal Design 3 inFire Areas AA2A, AA2B, and AA15",Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.30, *Generic Fire Seal Design 4(AA2)', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.31, -Generc Fire Seal Design 5(Fire Areas M31 and 38)r, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.32, uGeneric Fire Seal Design 6(AA2)-, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluatio11.33, -Generic Fire Seal Design 7(Fire Areas AA7 and AA37), Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.34, -Generic Fire Seal Design 8-,Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.35, Generic Fire Seal Design 9-,Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.47, -Fire Zones 44N (AA36), 44S(AA42) and 52 (AA3) PenetaionSealso, Rev. 0CIW_T7W_V 1.11403M 2 TfiM" M A0 0r Vuli 1.21Revison IPageA-1IRevision IPage A-138 Indiana Michican PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transftn Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference DocumentEngineering Equivalency Evaluation11.48, "Fire Zones 15 (AA14), 16(AA15) 18 (AA23) and 19 (AA24)Penetration Seals", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.49, "Acceptablity of Valve 2-FP-392-2-11 RCP Fire SuppressionPriming Water Check Valve (FireArea AA58), Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.50, "Embedded Conduit Fire WrapProtection (Fire Areas AA14 andAA24)r, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.51, "Screenhouse and WaterIntake System Boundary EvaluatonFire Zone 142 (AA2A) to Fire Zone143 (D)", Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.54, "Unit I Main Control RoomCable Vault Penetration Seal W51 11Fire Zone 57 and 91 (Fire AreasAA50 and AA2A), Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.56, "Turbine Building Main SteamAccess Way Fire Zones 110 to 114,Fire Zones 111 to 115, Fire Zones112 to 2N, Fire Zones 113 to 2S (FireAreas AA2A, AA2B, AA2C), Rev. 0e --Mc vlt.1*Revsons 1Page A-139 Indiana Michigan PowerCIVP NFPA 805 Tmnsthon Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.11.4 [Conduit InternalFire Seals] (b)Conduits shall be provided with aninternal fire seal that has anequivalent f rating tothat of the fire barrier thoughopening fire stop and sh" bepermitted to be Installed on eitherside of the barrier in a location thatis as close to the barier aspossible..Complies" Complies by previousNRC approval* Complies with use ofEEEEsComplies:CNP specification ES-FIRE-0601-QCF details therequirements for the installationand rnaintenance of fire ratedsafs and fire stops at CNP.Complies by previous NRCapproval:By I&M submittal, dated October20, 1988, Pg. 2 stated:FPPM, Rev. 11, Section 12.2.4 andTable 5.1, Section D, "GeneralGuidelines for Plant Protecton"Plant Specification ES-FIRE-0601-QCF, "Fire Rated Seals", Rev. 3,9/17.2010, Section 7.8, 8.4.4 andAttachment 1, Typical Details.I&M Letter "Status of Internal ConduitFire Seal Program and NRCInspection Report 85013, Item 2.R"Exception: Openig inside conduit4 in. (10.2 cm) or less in diametershall be sealed at the fire barrierwith a fire-rated internal seal unlessthe conduit extends greater than 5 ft(1.5 m) on each side of the firebarrier. In this case the conduitopnn shall be prov withnoncombustible material to preventthe passage of smoke and hotgases. The fl/ depth of the materialpacked to a depth of 2 in. (5.1cm)shall constitute an acceptablesmoke and hot gas seal In thisapplcadon."In consonance with ourpolicy Dated 10/20/88, Pg. 2to maintain a safe as possiblep/ant, we plan to seal conduits NRC Safety Evaluation Report datedthat meet the following critera: 4126M90, evaluation of I&M response1) An open-ended conduit is one to Unresolved Issue related to post-in which the contained cables fire safe shutdown methodology, Pg.exit the conduit into a non- 10, Section 2.18.2enclosed air space and do notdirectly enter into a metal Engineering Equivalency Evaluationenlosure such as a junction box 9.35, "Fire Zone 108 (AA2A) to Freor other sirnilr noncombustible Zone 33A (AA34) Boundarycosure. Evaluation", Rev. 02) Whan both ends of a doubleopen-ended conduit terminate at Engineering Equivalency Evaluationthe wail, it wh be treated as a 9.36, "Fire Zone 109 (AA2B) to 34Aslev and sealed. (AA35) Boundary Evaluation", Rev. 03) For double open-endedconduits maller than 2 inches in Engineering Equivalency Evaluationdlameter. 9.37, "Fire Zones 5 (AA5/6) and 32a. W?,en both ends of the (AA3) Boundary Evaluations", Rev. 0conduit terminate less than onefoot from the berie, at least one Engineering Equivalency Evaluationend will be sealed. 11.2, "Fire Zone 7 (AA7) to Fire Zoneb. When only one end of the 38 (AA37) Boundary Evaluation",conduit terminates less than one Rev. 0foot from the bamer, only thatOWTWCy"1.b1V12Revision I Page A-140Revision IPage A-140 Indiana MichAwn PowerAndianachmeant A wer -E0 TCNP NFPA 805 TransEm on Report -Attachap ent AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-I -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Documentend of the condut wi be sealed.4) For doubl openended Engineering Equivalency Evaluationconduft 2lnchesIn d*taeer 11.3, Fre Zone 27 (AA31) to Firea. VWmn both erds of fte Zone 39 (AA38r, Rev. 0conduit terminate less Umn 3feet fmrm the banter, at least one Engineering Equivalency Evaluationend will be sealed. 11.4, 'Unit I Auxiliary Buildingb. Mwn only one end of th Elevation 620 ft.-6 in. to Auxliaryconduit terminates less than 3 Cable Vault Fire Zone 44n to Firefeet from the bafrler, only that Zone 56-, Rev. 0end of te conduit wi be sealed.5) Double opnanded conduits Engineering Equivalency Evaluationgreater han 2 inches in 11.5, -Unit I EPS/4 KV diameter be sealed on at Complex Ventilation Shaft Boundaryleast one end." Evaluation (Fire Areas AA39A.The NRC Safety Evaluation,dated April 26, 1990 states:'/ntema/ condLut seats areprovided as delineated in a letterto the staff dated October 20,1988. The intemal seal programis consistent with the guidanceprovided in AppendIx A to 8TPAPCSB 9.5-1 and is, therefore,acceptable.'AA39B, AA40, AA41 and AA48),Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.6, 'Fire Zones 45 (AA43), 46Athrough 46D (AA44), 47A (AA45A),47B (AA458) to Fire Zone 60 (AA52)Shaft Boundary Evaluation', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.7, "Fire Zone 5 (AA16) to Unit 1Fire Zones 62A, 628 and 62C (AA54)and Unit 2 Fire Zones 63A 638 andThe Internal conduit sealing 63C (AA5) Removable Block Wails',criteria, as approved by the SE Rev. 0Report is still in use at CNP.There have been no plant Engineering Equivalency Evaluationmodifications or other changes 11.15, "Switchgear Roomthat would invalidate the basis Construction Boundary Roomfor approval. The critert for Evaluation Unit I Fire Zones 14, 40Ainternally sealing conduit has not 408, 41 and 42A (AAI 3, MA39A,changed. A39B, A40 and AM41) & Unit 2 FireZones 20, 45, 46A, 47A and 47BaWMWi ,*f'1900 TM"WDM~ft*VsaisWWA I"2Revision1IPage A-141 Indiana Michigan PovverCNP NFPA 805 Tran0lon Report -Affachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference DocumentComplies with use of EEEEs:Engineering equivalencyevaluations have beenperformed for any penetrationsthat do not provide a fireresistance ratng at st equalto that of the fire area barrieritself. These engineeringequivalency evaluationsdetermined the penetrations areequivalent or adequate for thehazard.(AA25, AA43, M44, AA45A andAA45B)', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evalution11.16, 'Lube Oil Storage Rooms FireZones 83 and 95 (AA2A), and 88 and100 (AA2B) Boundary Evaluation',Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.17, "Diesel Generator Fuel oil DayTank Rooms Fire Zones 15 (AA14),16 (AA15), 18 (AA23) and 19 (AA24)Boundary Evaluationo, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.20, 'Narrow Space Openingsbetween Penetrating Items and theBarrier or Between Penetrating ItemsBoundary Evaluation', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.24, 'Fire Retention Capability ofNonconforming Fire Seals In FireZones having a Low Fire Severity",Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation1126, 'Fire Retention Capability of aHELB 3 Pressure Boundary Seal (FireAreas AA19, AA20, AA21 andAA22)', Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.27, 'Generic Fire Seal Design 1',Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency EvaluationCIM_I"C_VI.IMJTMEMM 88WMVAm= 090 VO¶ I"b1-IRevision I Page A-142Revsion IPage A-142 Indiana Michigan PbwerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Affachnwnt AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference Document11.28, "Generic Fire Seal Design 2(Fire Areas AA7, AAS, AA39A, AA40,AA43, AA45A, AA45, AA48 andAA52)-, Rev. 0Engineerng Equivalency Evaluation11.29, "Generic Fire Seal Design 3 inFire Areas AA2A, AA2B, and AA15",Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.30, "Generic Fire Seal Design 4(AA2)-, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.31, "Generic Fire Seal Design 5(Fire Areas AA31 and AA38r, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.32, "Generic Fire Seal Design 6(AA2)., Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.33, "Generic Fire Seal Design 7(Fire Areas AA7 and AA37), Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.34, "Generic Fire Seal Design 8",Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.35, "Generic Fire Seal Design 9",Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.47, "Fire Zones 44N (AA36), 44S(AA42) and 52 (AA3) PenetrationSeals", Rev. 0C1a._. M'C_"u .1.2*Tomelft DOAM Aý 01t Vamim t"2,Revision I Page A-143Revision 1Page A-143 Indiana Michiban Po*vrMP NFPA 805 Tmnsftn RepW -Altachment AInin Mola Poe NfFA85Tasto eot-AtcmnAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-I -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 Element NFPA 805 Requirement Compliance Statement Compliance Basis Reference DocumentEginewering Equivalency Evaluation11.48, -Fire Zones 15 (AA14), 16(AA15) 18 (AA23) and 19 (AA24)Penetration Seals*, Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.49, -Acceptability of Valve 2-FP-392-2-11 RCP Fre SupessionPfming Water Check Valve (FireArea A58), Rev. 0Engineering Equivalency Evaluaion11.50, "Embedded Conduit Fire WrapProtection (Fire Areas AA14 andAA24)", Rev. 0Engineeing Equivalency Evaluation11.51, Screenhouse and WaterIntake System Boundary EvaluationFire Zone 142 (AA2A) to Fire Zone143 (YD)", Rev. 0Engineern Equivalency Evaluation11.54, -Unft 1 Main Contrl RoomCable Vault Penetration Seal W51 11Fire Zone 57 and 91 (Fire AreasAA50 and AA2A), Rev. 0Engineering EquMicy Evaluation11.56, -Turbine Building Main SteamAccess Way Fire Zones 110 to 114,Fire Zones 111 to 115, Fire Zones112 to 2N, Fire Zones 113 to 2S (FireAreas 2A, AAM2, AM2C), Rev. 0a, iP vt..MMm=" T1MMi mmm.0AýsCrnb t-- I.0Revison IPageA-1IRevision IPage A.144 Indiana Michigan PowerCNP NFPA 805 TranOon Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-1 -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Document3.11.5 ElectricalRaceway Fire BarrierSystems (ERFBS)ERFBS required by Chapter 4 shall

• Comp. ebe capable of resisft the fireeffects of the hazards in the area. e Complies with use ofERFBS shall be tested in EEEEsaccordance with and shall meet theacceptance criteria of NRC GenericLetter 86-10, Suppleent 1, "FireEndurance Test AcceptanCriteria for Fire Barrier SystemsUsed to Separate Safe ShutdownTrains Within the Same Fire Area."The ERFBS needs to adequatelyaddress th design requirementsand limitations of supports andintervening items and their impacton the fire barrier system rating.The fire barrier system's ability tomaintain the required nuclear safetycircuits free of fire damage for aspecific thermal exposure, barrierdesign, raceway size and type,cable size, fill, and type shall bedemonstrated.Complies:ERFBS that are credited to meetthe requirements of NFPA 805Chapter 4 are dentified In theindividul Fire Safety AnalysisReports. ERFBS are Installed tomeet th requirements of GL86-10, Suppleent 1.Complies with use of EEEE:Engineering EquivalencyEvaluation 11.57 evaluatesunprotected supports asadequate for the hazard.CNP Fire Safety Analysis Reports12-FPP-4030-066-016, -Inspection ofThewrmoag, Darmatt and Mecatieswrapped enclosures', Rev. 2.FPPM, Rev. 11, Table 5.1, Section8.2 and Table 8-1.Engineering Equivalency Evaluation11.57, "Fire-Wrapped Cable Traysand Conduit Evaluations (Fire AreasAA14, AA24, AA32, AA39A, AA45A,m2A and m2B), Rev. 0Exception N 1: MWn thetemperatures fins the fire barriersystem exceed the maximumtemperature allowed by theacceptance crteria of GeneneLetter 86-10, 'Fir EnduranceAcceptance Test Criterie for FireBarrier Systems Used to SeparateRedundant Safe Shutdown TrainingWithin the Same Fire Area,'Supplement 1, hunctionality of thecable at these elevatedtemperatures shall bedemonstrated. QualificationCNP_--MuC_1.1.1b10MW12 TMinIM IGAOMiVAMM CVA I"Revision IPage A-1415 Indiana Whidan PowerCNP NFPA 805 Transition Report -Attachment AAttachment A -NEI 04-02 Table B-I -Transition of Fundamental Fire Protection Program and Design Elements (NFPA 805 Chapter 3)NFPA 805 ElementNFPA 805 RequirementCompliance Statement Compliance BasisReference Documentdemonstration of these cables shaflbe peribmied in accordance withthe electrical testin requirementsof Generic Letter 86-10,Supplement 1, Attachment 1,"Attachment Methods forDemonstrating Functioafly ofCables Pr'otected by Raceway FireBarrier Systems During and AfterFi7re Endurance Test Exposure.IException No.2: ERFBS systemsemployed prior to the Issuance ofGenric Lefe 86-10, Su~pplment1, are acceptable proviing that thesystem successfuly met the limitinend point temperature requirementsas specified by the AHJ at the timeof acceptance.TWMpv

• lU-I,RevIsion 1 Page A-146Revision IPage A.146