ML20054A865
| ML20054A865 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 06/10/1981 |
| From: | NRC - SYSTEMATIC ASSESSMENT OF LICENSEE PERFORMANCE REVIEW |
| To: | NRC - SYSTEMATIC ASSESSMENT OF LICENSEE PERFORMANCE REVIEW |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19310G156 | List:
|
| References | |
| FOIA-81-392 810609, NUDOCS 8204160216 | |
| Download: ML20054A865 (6) | |
Text
._.
?.
MINUTES - SALP MEETING 81-08 June 9, 1981 4
The SALP Review Group convened at 9:30 a.m. on June 9,1981 for meeting 81-08 in the Air Rights Building Room 5233.
Attendees were:
N. C. Moseley, IE R. A. Purple, NRR C. Michelson, AEOD J. H. Sniezek, IE R. H. Wessman, IE 1.
R. H. Wessman briefed the SALP Review Group on facility reviews.
Conclusions reached are as follows:
a.
Shoreham.
Regional actions approved.
All Review Group members concurred that this facility was tentatively considered to be " average."
b.
Millstone 3.
Regional actions approved.
All Review Group members. concurred that this facility was tentatively considered to be " average."
c.
Beaver Valley 2.
Regional actions approved.
Moseley, Purple and Michelson concurred that this facility was tentatively considered to-be " average."
Sniezek considers this facility to tentatively be " average-candidate for.
good."
d.
TMI-1.
Regional actions approved.
All Review Group members concurred that this facility was tentatively considered to be " average."
2.
The Review Group re-examin2d those facilities previously considered as
" average-candidate for poor." Those facilities were rated as follows:
Below Average Average 4
Calvert Cliffs Indian Point 2 Rancho Seco Hatch Crystal River 3 Catawba Lacrosse Browns Ferry Watts Bar.
l DC Cook Davis-Besse Zimmer-t San Onofre 1 Arkansas' WNP-1/4 Summer The Review Group plans to re-examine all facilities considered as "below average" at the June 16 meeting.
An updated " score sheet" is attached.
Dk4[hf216 8j j103 UDELLsI'392 PDR b
'e.
. 3.
NRC Manual Chapter 0516 was discussed.
The Review Group considered the concept of one report containing facility overall perfornance evaluations in lieu of separate SALP Board reports and the SALP Review Group report issued several months later.
The SALP staff will research this concept with ELD.
On June 9,1981, subsequent to the Review Group meeting, ELD advised the staff that thywould not recommend withholding results of SALP Board evaluations from the PDR until the time when the Review Group report is issued.
A timely public release of NRC findings discussed with licensee management is suggested.
Consequently, the staff plans to leave Draft Manual Chapter 0516 unchanged.
The Manual Chapter will continue to require the issue of SALP Board findings as part of the report documenting the NRC meeting with licensee management.
4.
Draft 2 of the final report was discussed.
Extensive comments were made and will be incorporated in Draft 3.
This will be discussed at the next meeting.
5.
The next meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, June 16, 1981 at 9:30 a.m. in the Air Rights Conference Room (5033).
The agenda will be:
(a)
Facility reviews for last five facilities.
(b)
Re-examine facilities tentatively considered as "below average."
(The attached " score sheet" lists these facilities).
(c)
Review Draft 3 of the final report.
l 1
I i
Operating Reactors Above Average Average Below Average Region I Yankee Rowe Ginna Peach Bottom Vermont Yankee Maine Yankee Salem Millstone 1, 2 Haddam Neck Beaver Valley 1 Indian Point 3 Oyster Creek Calvert Cliffs Pilgrim
- TMI-l FitzPatrick Indian Point 2 Region II Oconee North Anna Surry Farley
- McGuire 1 Brunswick Robinson Crystal River 3 Sequoyah 1 Browns Ferry Turkey Point St. Lucie 1 Hatch 1
1 Region III Prairie Island Zion Palisades Point Beach Quad Cities Davis-Besse l
Dresden Monticello Big Rock Point Kewaunee Duane Arnold La Crosse DC Cook
- Evaluated with operating reactors
Operating Reactors (Continued)
Above Average Averace Below Averaae l
Region IV Cooper Ft. St. Vrain Arkansas Fort Calhoun Region V Trojan Rancho Seco San Onofre 1 Totals:
9 25 15
Construction Reactors Above Average Average Below Average Reyson I Hope Creek Seabrook Limerick Shoreham Millstone 3 Beaver Valley 2 Region II Summer Catawba Shearon Harris Watts Bar McGuire 2 Grand Gulf Che rokee Sequoyah 2 Yellow Creek Phipps Bend Hartsville Bellefonte Vogtle Region III Perry Midland Fermi Marble Hill LaSalle Zimmer Braidwood Byron Callaway Clinton
e Construction Reactors (Continued)
Above Average Average Below Average Region IV Wol f Creek River Bend Commanche Peak Waterford 3 Region V WNP-3/5 WNP-2 San Onofre 2,3 WNP-1/4 Palo Verde Totals:
0 31 7