ML20211E650
| ML20211E650 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 11/10/1983 |
| From: | Chopko M NRC OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL (OGC) |
| To: | Fisher G DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20209C072 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-86-151 NUDOCS 8702240372 | |
| Download: ML20211E650 (4) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:._ s._. e s .* . s '. .c WI.SHINCTON. D. C. 20555
- i. '- .' - / *.\./.. . . .'.. . ,E s.
e ! . &'J. .' ,.~
.- (s y .s e~~
v, -.
.*".4 Nover.ber 10, 1983 v; 3, .
!? .
[
~.
Mr. deorge A. Fisher, Clerk T s.t. U.S. Court of Appeals for the *
. District of Colu.bia Circui:
L'nited States Cccrthouse 3rd Street .and John Marshall Place, N.W. t. Washington, D.C. 20001 t-=s;
- e. - ay nus
. r_ _e 3 m.:.ev. .- e r. n p r n- r.- ,
. re.- ..u
- y. h 2. . ,
- - : .r O .e, NC. cl-20 "., r.Nn .c r.. .- 7~" _T e. o_= _T .c.w
. o n .v~ _ .=..= .=._
.' . ::.r.
-- , C: . : .
.~.u . \, . h..u, ',, _: . . nu., ..
o O . 6 0-10_i s
+
D. ._ c- ._ .u._ . e _4sh._._. i
- Enclosed c. lease find the cric.inal and three cce. ies cf ' t".a he C ,_ac._' _4c . 'c s.av, _e ~_ ' a_ .c. . _4 . . . ' . a_ c
._ c ...._# _c _e _d , . . '
. .e. . . .k.a_
referenced cases. __..-__e_..., . ( , . p
#,d
/- *f~ / 6 .
I s V . '/ . :.i,-4O
?,
Mark E. Chcpke
- Senior Attorney Office of the General Ccunsel a
i t
Enclosures:
As stated a j cc: Counsel of Record (w/ encl.) . I l l t f, l 8702240372 FOIA 870212 [ 1 PDR PDR (j ' HOLMES 86-151 f , -
\~. -
me a. .*& e w *m.md e [
%)'***. * .P;.; . , .7....g% @f
.,, we~.m-
*;a- ,1. pew,=* ;- r *a d'/'*
- x:rr~, 2 '* * ~ ' = n *-
~~~
. .g. . . . - -
._m.. .
. ._. Ce r. .. T.-. r i
.:. . r or g r ~.,y r C.;.
T
- h. e e%v
% c e.- .4 _'*- ..'.- o w.. ' 5.
. _4s .1 0 %..
c a;" c *. . Nove.m'o e r , 1983, copies of the foregoing "RIspoNDENT U.S. .
. . ~. .. .
N~JC7 71..:.
. .- " G U. 1.*. O..v. C O. W .. .c.c .v s .",'.C 0.0. C.c _' '."_0",
, "1 O .e..v.r n'u.r",m-v.
pn-..
- v e. s,r .s s. n
. . a h. .
i were served en counsel for all .cartie. s h.v placing a copy in the mail, . postpaic, to the following: l'.ichael J. Strurtwasser, Esq. John R.'Phillips, Esq. 35 S0 Wilshire 31vd. Joel R. Reyncids r I sc. . Los A.ngeles , CA 90010 Center for aw in the o O. 14 C . .. e .e.e .. Joseph 3. Knotts, Jr., Esq. Debevois & Libe man 10951 West Pico 31vd. Third Floor 1200 17 th Street, N.W..
.. . . Los Angeles, CA 90064 nasn*nc on, DC 200 a d - .
- 4. *2,.4.,.*..
s-*. q
.r 9 3 .J .q s b. . 3 . s
-=,.
*..*c.*..,
-..m~.3..
. . .. . .; .. .-: g. . . .
. O, .% .., .. **.7
. s
~3
.amw-..; .: s.w Q" C . 3- e n ee
...n.., .
wa m'.* -u es_,, ~y m .
. ..; s.<r. c..m. ...
1 L. . ,. f . . . . .. .~ .e m
. .g..
- g
- 3. 7 -.,. ... 3 . .,.. ,
.t.Q. 7 - v. " *r *3 .
sw. *
.e.
v c o w, s. .e :,. u" a, 9 .J. .
.Can T. '*wi sco, . cwe'. a3 4 ' ~' O r'. y y = .' ' 3 . =. .c =, . ' w .- .
*a. . c. A %.1 s
c. 3 .
**oem*
n .ww.w moS 9, _4 g . _.*S J nwm.. .
- a 4
- v.c. gg-. f.. n. .we4..
e .
- p. c. ..-.;
s ., . - - . . , s' C u".:,.~..^.,
/ I nn sp
-~
.- v < p- 2
.v. ..: .~~.. . r. w~?:~.wm
.....4.g,
..w :: ,
C . . ..; n c, e., :. %. o eg.
%.7.......
.. . U.,... .* a . .O.o.-..*..~.
; . w.; . . . . . .'.q..
%^
**W d s .%. ~:.y - ~..m. .. , . n.e C /. U .R, .R .,
. O
+ ._
. . s , y_ y ; ,,. . : ., ., -x,. . . . . ~
. .u . .
. ~ :;,
. . - - . e. .
. . . (, .
u_ _. . _ . _ .g,-
-...:.u.,.--,- . :..
. . :.u u v u :. . v: n:::
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
)
-e.n h, ..,U. . O .. c. .o. O :s,..:= n d = v,=.,
)
pr.nC7, r m. ew7 . , *
)
)
., Petitioners, ) - ' * ' -- .
)
- v. ).
Nos. 81-20'15 - 8.-10sa-
)
U.S. NUCLEAR REGUI.ATORY ) - COMMISSION, ET AL., )
)
Respondents. )
)
)
C :~. O.~ G:~. '. ~:.~ ~: ~:~_' . ' :'.a' n'.'4' , "t":.r w ,'u* n" 0:~ ) m.. q,.,,-- t r.:. .2n_. O: C T ma: """0 D. *.u'"n' , )
)
Petitioner, )
- v. ) No. 81-2034.
r
)
. . = . = . . = . .. ._ .. .. . . .
L* w* -.--..e,
.v y .- -. - - - s . -- .
--. -. , . , j t
2 .e 7 . . u . . s . )
)
)
o b-v
.n .r ..
- b. c nr0 4 e. rec.:..cw
...v . C.v =.~i- .v. , s p
.r .. . e . . .
- m. .
)
,3. g .. . g...-- .- --c...,.
- .:. 0 Y . . s u ".. + . ..O. . i . : . :". :.:. s.: w . a, 6m.".1 o.. -.
w S.g,s v '., -D- O ,. ..,Vms.,
. * -O n
,, c =. . . .. ~. ~
. . . . . =.s+:.:r~
._. . . u y -,.o-
. u
- .u..s . 7,- .s.*. = v,..,: .: . . . . = .:
Petitioners San Luis Obispo Mothers Fcr Peace, _e t g., have =cved this Court fer a stay of the November 2, 1983 order of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc=.ission ("Cc==issien" or "NRC") authoriring Pacific Gas and Electric L Cc==any ("PG&E" or "the licensee") to load fuel into the (
p- = ,::- - ud .' : . ;-
- v -sDOs: r.-- ::, . ..
125 UN:vE:5. v 4 ELE EE:<ELEv CA 947 : (415) 541-9296 LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL TO Teledyne Engineering Services DATE 10/25/83 130 Second Avenue SUBJECT Soils Waltham. MA 02254 ATTN Dr. W. E. Coooer (cover only) PROJECT IDVP PROJECT NUMBER P105-4 Transmitted herewith is/are the following: P105-4-449-128, 129, 130 Proposed references 36-38 for ITR 68 Rev. 1. These references were given to Dr. Costanti.no. l l l i l e cc: H. Schierling (cover only)"'
, \
Via: Hand Delivery Mail / h j
'/
i Federal Express XX l Robert ' . C l o ui_ Ass o'c i a t e s By
,# jog UNITED STATES g c NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
, g- M ; f gr
. ATOMIC SAFETY AND L! CENSING APPEAL PANEL O p eren-U$1 .
%, [ WASHINGTON, D.C. 20555 1D NOV 15 P1 :07 0FFICE November 14, 1983 C0CHE :
MEMORANDUM FOR: Docketing and Service Branch Office of the Secretary FROM: . Jean Shoemaker c ecretary to the Appeal Board
SUBJECT:
PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY (DIABLO CANYON NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNITS 1 AND 2) DOCKET NOS. 50-275 OL AND 50-323 OL Pursuant to the Commission's ex parte regulations (10 CFR Section 2. 780 (b) ) , the Chairman of the Diablo Canyon Appeal Board requests that the attached Novem-ber 2, 1983 letter from Ms. Gail C. Tedford, and November 5, 1983 letter from Mr. Bob Schumann, with attachments (two newspaper clippings), be placed in the Public Document Room and that copies of both letters be served on the parties to the proceeding. Attachments
, . , /
November 2,1983 Nuclear Regulatory Camission Members c/o San Luis Bay Inn Avila Beach Road Avila Beach, California 93424 Gentlemen: It is frustrating not to be able to leave my work at Cal Poly to make my presence felt at the hearings you are now conducting on Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant. 'Ihis issue is of uppermost importance in my life and relates airectly with my concern for a healthy future. I strongly oppose the plant's operation on these grounds:
- 1) there is no viable solution to waste disposal!;
- 2) Diablo Canyon is yesterday's mistake - a bad investment being forced on the inhabitants of our County; and, as local residents are acutely aware of,
- 3) the construction and repairs ara being " accomplished" under highly questionable circumstances involving individuals with limited responsibility to end results.
(This last point, by the way, is yacc disturbing to those of us who do not profit in any way (financially), but have daily contact with Diablo workers, many of whom have no " investment" in a future and, judging from the attitudes expressed, could'nt care less about outcomes, locally or nationally!) We love our home and community and will do whatever is necessary to protect our/its future! We are cognizant of the dynamics this situation presents to M&E; we are not ignorant of the management problem M&E and its stockholders are faced with. Many of us have even expressed a willingness to bridge the gap between m&E and those cpposing the operation of the plant. We, however, ng not willing to accept M&E's
" assurances" that the plant can, in fact, function safety and accurately; we gill not place cur faith behind empty, self-serving interests; we cannot ignore the fact that the site rests on the edge of an earthquake fault!
If we hope to unite our community around the plant's role as a safe, efficient producer of energy, something has to " budge". My hope is that you, both as individuals and as a federal body, can honorably use your innovative potentials to set a precedent by creating a truly responsive, responsible alternative to nuclen.r technology. 'Ihe opportunity is before you! (It has been suggested that many of the inhabitants of California may gladly contribute a portion of their resources to help offset M&E's blunder, in or6er to g themselves of a nuclear reactor "in their backyard. ") smm f
( 4 Please, gentlemen, let us not limit our thoughts about the issue and its pro-ductive resolution. 'Ihose of you with a voice in this re.atter have a crucial role in , the resolution and must look responsibly to the future. We who are limitedin our opportunity to facilitate a positive, productive outccme look to you and ask you. to be true to a larger, global consciousness.
'Ihank you for the opportunity to express my concerns and hopes. -
Sincerely,
~
[. tC L Gall . Tedford 967 W. Foothill Blvd. San Luis Obispo 93401 i t i I i f L i l i r l
+
4 11/5/83
Dear Your Honor,
Greetings!! First off let me welcome you to the beautiful central coast. A'nd I do hope you get a chance to visit some of the scenic and historical areas .of this county. The reason I am writing to you is to give you a view point about-Diablo Canyon from a local and concerned citizen. The following are some key issues / problems to which I see with the entire operation of the plant: Evacuation Plan: In such a case where the persons of the local area encompassing the plant will have to remove themselves to another " contamination-free" location. If this situation did arise there are many questions that need to be solved now, a) Sure it may work on paper, but in actual situation?? Case in point (news-paper article # 1) It's mid summer and it's late afternoon /early evening and residents of the central coast are on their way to a county fair (located in Paso Robles). The main link between San Luis Obispo and the' fair is Highway 101. North. This fare way crosses over Cuestra Ridge -a coastal range. , NOTE: Hichway 101 is basically the only way out of the central coast area. As noted in the article, there were 3 accidents on the " ridge" ahd you must admit the situation was not in a life or death type deal. People were just cruising to the fair, this would not be the case if there were some sort of accident at Diablo Canyon. For Your information: The distance from the " ridge" to Madonna Road is about 9 miles. b) One such practice evacua+ ion was done a few weeks ago in San Luis Obispo, it was deemed " excellent" by some federal advisor. But the facts are:
** only a few schools particapated in this " exercise", not the entire school system.
** Of the schools that did partake-a large number of the students were with-drawn from school prior to the practice. Frmr my information about a tth of the children were not at school. How can you get an actual picture or feeling if a portion of the students aren't there???
** To remove all the children from the schools and transport them to a safe site it will be theoretically impossible.. The number of transportain vehicles is not enough. The drivers would need to make THREE seperate trips. And this brings us back to point "A"-- accidents, trafiic jams, etc. . .
** Then what of the parents-- many o.f the parents will disreguard school orders and go to the schools to pick up their children. TOT AL K AOS!!
Would you allow your children to go to school here knowing of this evacuation plan ? ?
$' ~11Mg155 831114
_ -~ n u suvv.u a _H PDR e ((\
~
.-. -- - - - , .~ - .._ . - . - - - - . . _ . - . - -.
- w. a.
i * (2)
. Workers with Drugs & Alcohol So what's new with America's_ Society? Alcohol and drugs plague a problem to j every industry in the U.S'. A., but that doesn't make it right-does it??
Last week I witnessed a auto accident and I assisted in basic first aid to the driver of the auto causing the accident. As I was talking to the gentleman, he told me that he was a " welder-inspector" at Diablo Canyon. Then I asked him how this accident happened, he said, "I just fucked up". I could tell he had been drinking s bars in Avila Beach-- h,o I asked e said, "No-himI was if he drinking was drinking at any of the local at work". 7 , Alcohol isn't the only substanced used at Diablo-- Avila Beach is virtually the " Drug Users Playground". There is alot of drugs sold to the locals and Diablo workers. . What I'm concerned about is the quality of work that is done by the so called i Diablo worker who is " loaded" while welding or inspecting or even at the controls of the plant. There is no way you can stop the flow of drugs into the
- q. plant.
Past and present workers 't There are a lot people who have and are still working at the plant. Several of my friends fit into this group. Their jobs ranged from inspecting, blue print 7 draftsmen, and bio tech. And the story is the same from all of them--Diablo has alot of mistakes. The reason why some of my friends resigned is because
- . they felt Diablo is a mistake-- before they were all for it. Plus they don't want to be associated with it if there is an accident. They might of had a hand in killing innocent people.
l If I may suggest-- why not talk to some of the workers, past and present.
- 'They can tell you a true gut feeling about the plant. I also may add, do this i~ in private-- with out P.C. & E. , the Mother's or anyone else. Ask the workers j about constrution, inspection, drugs, etc. . . . all this confidential.
1 i A Long Wait ' I recommend that you read this article (#2). It ask a very good question in ! regards to PGCE and when will them tell us-anything! I I thank you for your time and I hope this helps out somehow. i in Peace, i Bob Schumann j Concerned Citi:en 1255 Orcutt Rd. B 42 I San Luis Obispo, CA 1 93401 i 805-544-2255
- :* w v .*.g ;s 'n e-,v:- . . z. s .. ;w r ,, e '
-:.i v - .. . . . - - - a
.i 5
Q* M: i.R...&.
- . .W
%.o,.1]=?*.'A :*2* . '.'*'I;.1W.%, n. s .4.Qs *2'*",.-$C.; a#, 'si' s,,.5.G.f v b'.r',:4*%c a .' ,#nC'- .y*,.f.,4
' - >"* O
- j. . m.r .
- 2.,x
*%g,,,
..Ap* s M. , h. R,s U.*.:.*~* . w .s ;.,.,.< . . a *:.~d.- .. ~ .s C:m .fgs,4'.%: n'\.j a - ...
s, * <,. . . s w r.PE.*. s.. y .? .p .s. . ..
. c * **. *.J~ n** ,v ,,3, ; , .e Z,3 o
. : **l v
*Q '," .r o -- .N 7
;;r ;:::&,.
.s'. J.' "E.., we
. a .. ., ,p 4 tn. y \.'.
. k f; '~;,'
e .... A' .p*:a
. ,. . .4 .*. . "e- *
-7.
.'.3 a:.s.'R
,.i...~; .:. ..t'. ,P . ;rf.s . h=:%, , un. ., ==.. M.s"1. g,,r,c.. . .
; -e 4 /. t 4
,,; . ,.-.g.; . v..
g - ..~,- a .. . . . . -
.. ;. .. J. . . . .s. a.i . ,J,.
._2._ g%. ,/s .
. p, . . . .m.. ..,N, .. , jc e.+ s . y,.'
.r -
.=*wj ,t . g ;.. .s... s . ' .,, -..
4 Ofa. == . JP . *
. . - .
- y ;? , . = ,. ' : g
.. i .
- w. l . . . . .
N C.4 ': . . .'. .?.h.Y.' Y .. . k,.y .- g 's?
?. =.*.E" : l,I.*?
- n: h. ..* :".&. . e . *N.Q:;.".' 5= e' & .\
- n. : . . . . .. ' . , m ;- w * =g ..g. y ;?"
2 . .
*.},
. -. g .
1.. 4.;,, . j- e;- . ,i * ... , . ,r... ...g $ .,,. .y.,....yp.a. . .. .! t ..c . . _.. r.; . . . b.g.....w- '.yJ. ,. . ,-'?.., . f 3, , . 7.,m- : .,g. .,s
. . . 4- ga&tw,r ,5,, .4
. . * .; . . .se
.h...,......., ...,.
., .. 3 .
...,. . *. 4..s-.....s....p . .
&,' %. i n.-. *
. e.*:..+..g
.~'.
, . '*l h,,*& ' . y. O
'd.,'
. , ,. >...,':tJ. g,,.~y..,
;.e, V ff4. . s So
.,.~s.,.."'$'E. *** W. . ?. . .. .2. G**'*3. s. 7. ,+ ?.'etQ*).',.%.'.
, !2:'j
,, 0,**.f& . [ .K. .
.,o e- a.-
t e ee .1 ..e i f :. - e- ..
- *e,.y .(s.1,y e<
..,.a.-.. y M2 :.'. d i.' .:+
.5 .,.. .. e m'_ .- ' , %...:, ..4..
gr -m.p
.a
..!::::. ~; p! ;m . ? .i:p: - r.c:S3 V u.a w req :n,q-R ..
&.:.~*y'.m, -- C.
v,vV=.n,a
".,...,.'.'.[..
1: % ',. . .
.- pvC R
- . :. :mr a .
M. . . -*p
. . y.m. &Q~....?.J,:.M.-l?r.i>;.i'.kN.,'.s .- p ., R'..4.; . s..; f,.u . ..; * =4 s. W ?s[f.:.
.y G. ... h l.:;.-l.l
,. %. ,'.ys[..,( Q g;
.- . c. : ./ v,. ,g..r. :. .:
, or... . ... a pw -7.,. ,c.
. ..i. . . . . . . .. .. .. . . -
. ~ .. . . ..
u.u.? -
,* v....
..~ '. &* h ., **
. g , . ., lli .~.T.~*:d..[,,'a. , . ., n< $,n \., l - , , . ; ,,'
, .; , { , ,- -,[,4..,",';...-f,
,n:e .:. ,..v- s 6, <: .y .sn.,; . .. . . . . .,,.e.
.j . J,.i*;
.f w
; z.. , , ~..*...
.4..
**- 4
,a s y.
n ,n,,c-: , .~ .. % .
;.p,. ,.,,, , .L.Wi%, c':;D$51%,
". ~ s... .
%m$$&W.
.u:
E
... . . .. . ., . :. w. . . ~,.. ..w..
2.&~l!.as..
.. n .. .,. . . , .. ..
.. . .i.)L4> c$.?.RR . . , k ~.s.. QNfl.., ~.i L
2::p. .
, e. . / :, ,;i.. ..:, rn. +e. + 3 . . - .. . -t . & .. ..- m. :.
- i
~.. K-t :=. *w . . . - ~. . :..:- '...:.
.:.. s. ~. . *;, <
y 2:r ,,
,e. .;
. .r
.A.
= = - -
~ , . ,3,
,. . , , ;}j
. .;~. -
. ?
. ~,.Q.n.z . . n,..,...
. ,. -w 1 .. ',3 5'y::' .: .i' W .u hO Qe.
. $n.-. . ..O.; . ' , . . rT.*:.Q. .* !.%. ,; 4 6::.h. .s W y . v. t,,N.j.N..i.h.P.%:.,5.. . . . .
v:.'
.-; u .?:,.~,J.Q
,.e n 3.?:w . Q % 6"te . 2:. .w; .. q.@.?..h. .e
.. 1
+..~;':T . ~.t'.- i iM
. . HL:: :i .:.b.v. .t
%:c-- .. a.-..c:p'v.:. m .: a; Ls.-
- . w.:-.:c:..Y, .:;y .
. .v v, ;T; .: . :. . +,. m;:s .~;-Q e,:y . m - n .:n s...y m :
- .c, . :? a- c, .. . .r:. . h . . . :d : .? l : '~';. M < .y - . . . .- .C.
;. n:
. .v .,... . ..
- =.m e.y; w,y
.>. . . ?;. . .. > . o . .; .- , . ., . ;.
;..,*,.m..s.*.. . n.3. i .2.x ,.. u e.. . e.e:. . . . = .
. . -.... n.
.*.4. . . .. . . .
. - --, ~
..w..
.- . c.. ..v: .n. .. . . ...- m n..
q.-. e.e .~ .g n.
.~. .
. s . ,. o. w..
. . c ..; . s .-
W :~,2.%, * .%. . ? .:f;:: m..M. .1,d.s.,
..;. s., m w. , .ac. .;.,.2.u. :
.w a, ,;...- ..~, %:,.*. r.;a .'.. ;.:. W6SWff%%,k
.W
_ :.e?G.p-*,1
,.......a..r . . -
- n. . .c . % ;e .. n - ,.,,, 's Y
.t _.s .a;.
;,:-*. * . .. . ys % . . . .y q .- ogsl
. Y :,,.,,rg;. -g t q . ..s s gyp2s. pm,.s. . :. Qan ,Q s_ ,a.,r,;
- b. .,. . vc n g <.' . s ,.. .,, . . . .. e g. . ,,a. ,
,.3..=.
e
;e . .S ; 3 g, g-.,u . e. 9 - %.n. . ; . ; ,.,, ee e
p- v,u;.r.
, s,. . b,, y-m; .q;.g:.-4 ...
,, , ,..r,
'~ 4
*
- s .97 :3' C ; ,2:i<i.
3" ,. 3 L... 0l.h.
;. - . . ~ . . - ,. . :. ::.s,.
/ *... *l,J. : ' ^p*a' .-M.:. .",, ~ mh '".,~^. h:w*;?
.' .. L.a ~... X .u'.i . 4 .G.&'ETsf;~.).c*.'.A.
- g. . -
. ... ..r. M.s, %. . . . ... .rm% s . *- . ..-.m.r.s
*--. g. , f*t , ;, ) ;q .* .' * . * , . ' * * ,. . . .*..
, ~ 7. ~~"a # . *
'.f
- e,
. J;..';.*
1 s. . .f.y=.9 . ...q,....,,,>s 9 . ,,v\.'. - . . ;w . ; .J +s
; .s ?
,e,3 - a s.; e. . ., .:.. . w=mm, a. u . . f . e . a.. -
a
.f.f' ,;..-g*; *a o . : . :".' 7.4 ,%.m'
- C,:.w.,
; a -;- . : .r - " ..; =t= =
= y
% 'W:s.M.. . %. . [:i . '.k. ,/., 7;.p%.g . ,,u ~g
. % ~
- wt'. i=: ,, C J ~;. ;:y., r.:.'+;,. . .;,rWrf ,
u,. a , ? .ef'4 - W., .'. .v? t,,,. ,;* ..iad,, ? . .. , .
.. 5 .
-q. <, %..;p *sr3.,.,s. .i' .-::%. g. :: ..,.. ... ' -. 3'
. , ~;.* -
-;m.
f:,. .t, -L'; q:) v ..':-. ~ :-{ g. . , x: w 4,* ' . ,Oo :.. ., y .= ,e.. .::Vw:. .v, f. ';. we
~...e
- .: ? =. ! .. w 4- z. n. .* * :.
l e.. h- ,y, %* N . ? ~..*t -ri f :'s<.,-yJ).. =~.'W 1 ' 'k t.=gHic
..x.~. yin.:}s,4,,hahbeg&D.T; ,m s
- H f *'I l- .-1 x'4 '.j M d ; Q
,'.'l'."*.'.*.'.4. -n .-/ 6-- I . #
di.d' ..M_. . .'Il..,.af.ter.n. o.c_h wn.en
. M.. ;/#r.u,. tin- 23.W.*:.
. . s
...ES ....:...
. . /,. . ..... ..g.: ., W. . _. a ,., ,.s .. ..._ :-.";' + p"f f . -
~- ~-.. i. ,;..Q. r:a:r.3. .~ @ .cl.e-.c,a.ught.,ITC=
IW9 CCTS h.re. tied..ke?p "?
. W 5,2. i.'~.i
.- 5.':
. '. rl.W. .'.u.! .
- 1. %..~ ' 0+ . q.r;- ~u .e> ... M. _ .:"c
. Grad"e south. as f
- *l'.... .: . f,% -
"' *~,%:'... r : c,W* x,:nM.~?w. r.~..:E!W : . in:inM>g.mY ~h. . :*.3g'" '@~f.'.-f.. . gegp_p. .=z M. .,: 6 .. . ,,.d.t
~;, .: ---y
. i 4.p :. 2 --r ;W . u. . . m w.,
. . e . - ! w e: .w. -s *
. 3efcre tra:.5c was ' m. . . e:
y, W r/.m,Cm.n.
. . 4 6ther iccidents,oce"rred 9..
l
.x,
- .3 .' .
. ; ,. ,. ;w...
%. :~ . :3.; M.
. . ~j.< .
g' y . J . . :$.., . .
, . . . .ex
.g y .,eg. , . .r.m . ene
,g m.,_.
f, yG. .w,..- mvolvm..g . . ..
. cars i.. ..,;.. .
. . m. . L. _. . . . .s.s,.s.g.,..,,.,,,.,..
.r ..e
(
.:.t: : . ,, .. .. , .. . ..
,; ,. , :. r ;.y 3y
. ., . a .
- 2. --
. ,- u .n , q . .. t.hem oo
. . and .six. . .
se :.m]c.em,1 s. u .pe.?.;,.e no,: tQ.. r,. < -
,,rn. p s.. ..n..u.4 .an ,.wr s.w. ,c, ~..i -v. m .z, ..w . ;y. . .m. t
- cusiy.t i
.. . ,, ~.
. . . . '. ,D; ..r.:t -7' t: . .. . .W : ~- : '~ y& ..- .s.-- . . Unusually bca, .trah iccacu s
.U's ,: <
' D~ E'Ef .$ f,n.:'- . ." sr. -p.
-,. C$b6.'$f'*//Y -%.7'yN;e hesS:g to- ,
wa,, pf4!gr. %
- hi=dreds of peep 7"N,. % ~h j r'J.J
' Robles f6r the -San :Luis 0h 1
m,
.t;
.<.y .w .fr,/P3
- . cia.,.cO,E;FZ<
. ;:s e .. ~;.-a.u--w n #! N.='h.d. e -
3.j;.f.gct-Q. ...- W, ..%'N m:(i C4:f.ty w y m.r.3.w.w.ur to congestfon.. said Higu.way,P _... . . . . . ;., a 4 . y g g '. . r - . TrafffE.; r backhd
*- was e l
accidents occurred.Nfsb.th to 'Ma'donn[ N.dd.#a'f g -
. The problem started at aboi:t tE th'r~ e ~e I one of the' accidents at';fght, Khn Pereiof Fr6sno holds n'. 'p.m. when the engine of a':
- . ._. ._.. . cold pack to h'er head. Thfle cc
- nfortindelbe Shahnan Pel boc'e' driven by Roy 5Windef,'.!
l l litier, -, 4, son .=i-Chris,i.r; .6, and* daughier , .;.-c J1H,i3/.".WI; up $ .. . b.;. Remet'ca # en fire, a Ca"'
'*s. ;*b c .c.'* , . ;;J. . = - ,a H!ghway Pat Cl spokeswoman J.- a -!
l .
.- .. "'Ne ,
^
..,._en.....-*-=-s-..
l b
..o
~
I
/r 1
.. e*===
og l l l
~. . . ., .
a discharge of radiation. Even in
' the drill which occurred on Oct.19, it took PG&E 19 minutes to declare an alert because of a leak in the reactor coolant system which, in the drill, led to a release of radiation
. some three hours later.
If we are ever going to be able to
. . * .. minute
, be safely counts Theevacuated, philosophyevery' of waiting A /0/7# 8 EYa/t
~ \. " until the last possible moment" is not one which is conducive to public To the editor: .
In Saturday's Telegram Tribune, confidence nor to our safety a PG&E spokesperson is reported to Sandy S. Carsel
- San Luis Obispo have stated that PG&E waited 30
- days to report the finding of a
- container of radioactive material stolen from the Diablo Canyon Nu-clear Power Plantlast May because NRC rules allowed them that amount of time.
No statement could better exem-plify the reason for the erosion of public confidence in the nuclear industry. Even when something
- ha pens which is favorable, the uti.ity waits until the last pssible moment to make it public. would it
..then inform the public of something negative in less than the marimum allowable time?
We in this county are dependent upon PG&E to inform us if.there is Il@ f bf l l O l l 1
w ', , f:s. Rcbin Goldner NOV 18153 ocx 387 Ukian, California 95482 Cear t's. Goldner: I an responding to your letter of September 19, 1983 to the Nuclear Regulatory Comnission in which you express certain concerns regarding the safe operation of the Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant. As you are aware, the Comission suspended on November 19, 1981 the authority to load fuel and conduct low power testing which is granted under the Diablo Canyon low power license. At the same time the Comnission and the NRC steff required of the licensee, Pacific Gas & Electric Comoany, that an independent design verification program be conducted. This effort has been underway for nearly two years and is now coming to completion. The staff issued a safety evaluation of the entire program on August 5,1983 and a .second evaluation on Octeter 14, 1983 relating specifically to those matters that must be resolved prior to the commencement of fuel load operations. Copies of both reports are enclosed for your information. The Commission had a meeting in Washington, D. C. on October 28, 1983 to hear from the staff of the nuclear Regulatory Commission and all parties to the Diablo Canyon proceeding. In parallel with these considerations regarding reinstatement of the suspended license, preparations have been under way for a hearing before the NRC Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board on matters of design quality assurance. The hearing was opened on October 31, 1983 in the San Luis Obispo area. As we have stated frequently, the authority to load fuel and conduct cold system testing would not be reinstated until such time that the Commissier is satisfied that those matters which gave rise to the suspension of that authority have been adequately resolved. On November 8, 1983 the Commission 1 ret and Fevino found that those natters had been resolved voted to issue it.emorandum and Order CLI 83-27, reinstating fuel load and precriticality testina Wode 6 and Mode 5) authorization. Low power testing authorization hus not been reinstated and thus will require future Commission considera .icn.
NOV 18 15El I trust that the above information is responsive to your concerns. Sincerely, Thomas M. Novak, Assistant Director for Licensing Division of Licensing 4
Enclosures:
- 1. NUREG-0675, Supplement 18
- 2. NUREG-0675, Supplement 19 Ja i
]xY ,s t r
1
)! ~l ~
c' ' if.af t l I 8
' ' ffnb f p-e h\ '
DL:LBe3 -
.D OELD _:
CL :L2=3 HSchierl 'ing'/ytJLee G'JfS ton LChan' der Tf'fNak 10/f /83 10/0/83 10 /83 10/ . '/83 1(/p/83
t ,. /m iox 35-Ukiah, Jalif. 95482 3ept. 19, 1983 Nuclear Regula: cry Gottission
'!ashington,
.- L.C.
Tc the Concission, I address this letter concerning the licensing of Diablo Canyon ::uclear Power Plant to the whole encaission, and especially :.r. 's Gilinsky, 3radford .and Ahearne who c urageously stood un to corporate and political pressure durin the licensing decision two years ago, and publicly-expressed thy?r dnubts as to the safety of.the. plant. As you well know, their doubts were proved right, when'a few days later, sericus structural errors we.'ce.in' fact. dis-ccvered in the censtruction of the ulant's coolin,g system. I applaud :/.r.'s Gilinsky, 3radford and Ahearne's awareness of their personal responsibility to thenp'ublic, to prevent unnecessEry deaths and disease, and follow thger consciences 'icpite the fear of "large financial loss... and the sever impact such an action would have on the whole nuclear industry." (quotation fro: a private meno by an ERC staff member, printed in the L.A. Times 6/29/77) In the past, such fear has also caused a member of your cc mission to try to persuade the US Geological. Survey to change'its scientifically founded safety standards in order te " prove" Diablo Canyon wns " safe" without further alterations. This fear n1so caused your cornis'sion to. grant PG&E per-mission to load fuel rods and begin low level te-ting at Diablo before adequate research and confir ation of that research occured almost exactly two years ago.
, For these,;aasons, I ar skeptical as to how sincere ycur confidence"chrt "iablo Canyon is cc=pletely safe
..;ains ca.ior er.rthcuakes. Do vou really know?? According J te willian Dirc%c, " hundreds of errors in inc design and construe:1cn of critical components" have been corrected.
Tt 4.s my ha)pif -kat aven ?200 million (unfortunestely stolen from the censumers withcut their ce nsent) can make thr.t diseased plant well. And even if it could (which we will
- not know until snother Three
- :ile Island fiasco occurs),
tha; about the unsolved problems of waste disnosal and storace, chemical durnins h.ich has already drastically damagec the surrcunding eco-systems, and evacuation policies and procedures for victims of a potential malfunction. Can we not learn. frc: cct unities across the nation, notably those surrcunding Rocky Flats ~ucleir clearens Ilant, where inciden:0 of cancer (including pencer in children) is 5-15M higher, as are other
.adiati6Elliseasesand abnorcali'les such as leukemia, birth
. defects and miscarrir es. l w &' !
- 1
_ $** f fj v / L. n )I] ) f.}} &- f 1/
~
".uclear
- Re. quin or; Cottission pace 2 ~
Indeed th licensing of any nuclear power plant raises a plethora of aarety iscues and ethical questions. Diablo Canycn, which cits on an active earthquake fault, has
- r. ore than its chare. I implore, each one of you to ask yourselves in all honesty to yourself, your ccuntry, or whhtever you censider sacred, can you really sanzion such a hazardous power plant? I a:r praying ycu cannot.
Thank you for hearing my ccncerns and taking the time to listen to ycur own inner voice. I would appreciate a perscnal response to the issues I have raised. Sincerely, W $0_ Robindoldner cc: .lillian Dircks, NRC Chief of Cperations Darrell Eisenhut, Nuclear Reacter Recul-ti*.:n Office 2cward Utility hate !iormalization (TUR:If Jeeple's Energency Abalone .2.lliance Center fer the Law .'.esponse Plan, Interest in the Public
- .endocino Con =entary O
o t
... ./ .
x y v-
;+-
- O. p . v . l
,c. . . . ,
.1 ; . .
.y
'...n
/ . .- -
/ R. Goldner '
- e. ,.
' ' ~
. Dox 387 f.*'deu...
- ::1 :sLYlAYS ]:J}y{
Ukiah, Ca. 95482 2 I,Elb
- - n so '/
- t. -
' 7lP CDD dbtxa i <dw 2
.__ m - ..
L983 ! USA 20c l d l Mr. illiam Dircks Chief _of Operations j Huclear Regulatory Commission j - Washington, D.C. j - . .
-. i 9
e e c . .
, .. e. ..
.- . , UNITED STATEf.
., [ I' .
~
N UC L E A R R EGU L ATOR,Y C O*.i.'.T :" *
. , ~ . . . .- c e.. swr.:.w..o c w 4 '?~ uk ..{ ,5
' s, J
=...=
./ - .{
5.- FROM: ROBIN GOLDNER ORIG.tO5Lih+'Epsto7[KS2 M E 9:%s4 % m t I N " ',' "q g 6 iC/3ili'3
~
DOC DATE: 09/19/83 TO: CONMISSION NRR RCVD DATE: 09/27/83
** YELLOW **
5" FOR SIGNATURE OF: APPROPRIATE DESC: CC:
~
th -eee W 'Tf1ABEB?CANYrW2 DENTON/ CASE FUNCHES
- 1. VOLLMER REFERRED TO: DL) DATE: 09/27/83 2. NATTSON CONTACTrwm2]TL 3. THOMPSON
- 4. SPEIS
- 5. ORACE h0%k - 6. SNYDER kc.% Q -
Lnc v h .(e t t.co.u ' M i
%p. % ., ,
5.7.- - n-2 Y FLEASE REVIEW THE DUE DATE IMMEDIATELY: IF THE DUE DATE DOES NOT ALLOW ADEQUATE REQUESTS FOR REVISION OF YELLOW TIME TO RESPOND TO THIS TICKET, YOU MAY TICKET DUE DATES MAY BE MADE, WITH REQUEST A REVISED DUE DATE. THE REQUEST JUSTIFICATION, THRU THE WEEKLY WITS MUST INCLUDE A VALID JUSTIFICATION AND UPDATE UP TO ONE WEEK AFTER ASSIGN-EE MADE THROUGH YOUR CORRESPONDENCE CO- MENT BY NRR MAIL ROOM. THE NEW DUE ORDINATOR TO THE NRR MAIL ROOM (MAREN DATE, IF APPROVED BY NRR MAILROOM, BOWMAN OR MELANIE GARVER). WILL BE USED TO TRACK DIVISION COR-RESPONDENCE COMPLETION SCHEDULES. PLEASE DO NOT HAND CARRY CONCURRENCE PACKAGES TO DIRECTORS OFFICE WITHOUT FIRST GOING THRU THE NRR MAIL ROOM.
~' '~ GW f y-H3 LEossred a ra m e te r, n c. s,,,e ,,u Consulting Engineers
- Mechanical Dealgn and Analysis 13300 WATERTOWN PLANK ROAD. ELM GROVE. WISCONSIN $3122 '414 766-7580 November 23, 1983 Mr. Dennis Kirsch, Section Chief Region V U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1450 Maria Lane, Saite 210 Walnut Crun , *alifornia 94596 Copy: W. Laudan, NRCz'IE HQ, w/oncl.
!<cforen:E: NHC Contract No. 05-62-249 PAR: NRC/IE-82/83 S;i pr:: Task Order No. 56 Technical Assistance i.m Support of
':DE Work at Diablo Canyon p=r Scope of Werk dated November 6, 1983
Dear Mr. Firsch:
Fcrwardc-d nerewitn is copy of Report No. PAR (DCNP)-NDE-2,
- ove.-ber li , 1983, prepared by Kenneth Ristau pursuant to inspection work at Diablo Canyon last week.
Also attached is a copy of the Project Quality Plan we pre-pared for this assignment. We routinely prepare these plans for NDE assignments for NRC in accordance with our contractual commitment. Due to the urgency of this task, the plan was. availa le only in draft form to Mr. Ristau and Mr. Hunt before the i ypection. Please let us know if there is anything else required. We look forward to working with you again. Very truly yours, PAR' "TER, Inc. Richard A. Lofy C
' k O.h~2%(yff VM President F A L :rc.a 4 c.
E n O '. C ! ') .' t .d [0,/
/ #'
7 xa m yf
4.*,.. n .
/ ardnaaler, ker c. Report No. PAR (DCNP)-NDE-2 c o w s u tti n o twoiwcens Page 1 of 3 eta o n o v e. . wi s c o n s in November 22, 1983 -
Subiect-
- 1. Independent delta-ferrite measurements on 25 selected
- . stainless steel welds-to verify compliance with Code and~ '
Regulatory Guide 1;31 requirements. t 2. Visual and liquid penetrant examination of field welds FW110-lll-ll2 in isometric package 2-14-31. t . , 3. Exemination of radiographs of 102 weld joints for compli-ance with cedt, verification of adequacy of reader sheets l and evaluation cf everall quality of radiographs. 1 tofetences 4 1. Gatline of nondestructive examination war to be performed , at Diable Csnyon, November 14-18, 1963-by :.1<C cont ract , pcracnnc1 (Exntoit 1). i 2. Contract No. NRC-05-82-249 l . Task Order No. 56 ! 3. PAR: NRCi IE-8 2 '8 3 , i- -Writer of Re_ cort Kenneth A. Ristau, PARAMETER, Inc., NDT Level III, MT, PT,
- RT and UT Contract Personnel Assigned Daniel J.' Hunt, Wisconsin Industrial Testing, Inc.,
j Level II, MT, PT, UT l Introduction ! The NRC outline of work (Exhibit 1) designates 3 welds to be i liquid penetrant tested and visually examined. ! The 25 stainless pipe welds to be tested for delta-ferrite ! measurements were designated by Mr. Dennis Kirsch, NRC Section Chief. For a list of the welds and results of the inspection, l sov WIT report !Evnibit 3). Also see WIT report for results ! ^* " 1." 5 1 e n d ;- trant inspection (Exhibit 4).
*:r . . .t e n .z: ;ndicated the 102 welds of which radiograpns wor.- :c Le v:ewad ' Exhibit 21.
s 4 L.
a ea m ala e, n c. Report No. PAR (DCNP)-NDE-2 consuoiwo twoiseens Page 2 et= o n o v e, wisc o w siw November 22, 1983 - Record of Activities November 15 and 16 inspections were made by Dan Hunt and films were viewed by Ken Ristau. . In a short meeting with Dennis Kirsch, day end November 16, the results of our findings were conveyed verbally, as follows:
- 1. The delta-ferrite measurements met the NRC requirements.
- 1. Tne LPT of all three welds were approved but FWill had cne LP indication running transverse to the weld in the casc material of the pipe. It was approximately 1/2" away f r::: the weld and about 1" long.
- a. The radiographs of the welds were viewed and approved as acecuately meeting Code. Comments were also made by the writer concerning film quality, detail of reater sheet documentation and the excellent condition of the radiographs, nearly 10 years after x-ray date.
Conclusions ,
- 1. Having reviewed the radiographs and reader sheets of all 102 selected piping welds identified in Exhibit 2, the writer found reader sheet documentation detailed and clear.
Radiographs were readily available, in good order and of very good quality. Radiographs are approved as me.eting the requirements of applicable Codes.
- 2. All 25 welds selected for delta-ferrite measurements met the requirements of Code and Regulatory Guide 1.31 (See Exhibit 3).
- 3. Visual and liquid penetrant examination of FW110 and 112 were acceptable. FWill weld was also acceptable but an. liquid penetrant indication was noted in the pipe base material (See WIT Penetrant Report, Exhibit 4).
-s
Exhibit 1 to Report No. PAR (DCNP)-NDE-2 November 8, 1983 OUTLINE OF NON-DESTRUCTIVE EXAMINATION WORK TO BE PERFORMED AT DIABLO CANYON, NOVEMBER 14-18, 1983, BY NRC CONTRACT PERSONNEL GENERAL INFORMATION: Location: Diablo Canyon Nuc' lear Plant, Unit Nos. I and 2 San Luis Obispo, California Licensee: Pacific Gas and Electric Company Docket No. 50-275 and 50-323
Purpose:
- 1. Pe rform independent delta-ferrite measurements on . bout 25 selected stainless steel welds to verify ecmpliance with code and hegulatory Guide 1.31 requirements.
- 2. Visually examine and perform liquid penetrant examtnation cf field welds FW-110, 111, 112 in isometric package 2-14-31.
- 3. Examine about 100 weld radiographs and vertfy reader sheet, radiograph and evaluation adequacy.
Site
Contact:
Mr. Marvin Mendonca, NRC Senior Resident Inspector 805-595-2353 RV
Contact:
Mr. Dennis Kirsch, NRC Section Chief, 415-943-3740 Work Hours: 0730-1630, November 14-18, 1983 REQUIREMENTS: To be furnished at the Diablo Canyon Site by the licensee: Hard hats and safety glasses Insulation removal ' Scaffolding erection Escorts to locate welds in the plant Assistance to assemble documentation (radiographs) Electrical po,wer and extension cords for portable test equipment Working space for one or two persons to examine radiography records Viewer to examine radiographs Use of lunchroom and sanitary facilities Use of Xerox machine as back-up Calibrated severn gauge To be furnished at the Diablo Canyon Site by the NRC: Assistance as required by the Senior Resident Inspector Telephones in the NRC trailer Xercx machine for copying
2 To be furnished by the contractor: Certified level 11 or III liquid penetrant and qualified radiograph 1uterpreter examiner to conduct visual and liquid penetrant examinations and an examination of about 100 radiographs for adequacy Two copies of certifications and qualifications'tf-art coqpeactor personnel, and documentation verifying certification and qualification of liquid penetrant cleaner, penetrant and developer used shall be given to the NRC contact upon arrival at the Diablo Canyon Site. Measurements performed shall be in accordance with the latest editions of the ASME code. Two copies of all data sheets will be furnished to the NHC contact at the conclusion of the work. A letter report-including a description of the work performed, the data obtained or exemined, and evaluation of the adequacy of 12censee's ducamentation shall be prepared and delivered to the NRC Region V office by November 25, 19hi. An exit meeting will be held with the NRC contact at the conclusion of the work to discuss the scope and 11ndings. e O
?
fa r a ns e le r, bn c. Exhibit 2 to Report No. PAR (DCNP)-NDE-2 C O N s U LTI N G ENGINIIRs
- etu G n o v e, wis c o n siw Field Welds Chosen for Radiograph and Reader Cheet Review ISO Field ISO Field ISO Field ISO Field Drawina Wcld Drawing Weld Drawing Weld Drawing Weld 1-7-21 100 1-7-6 31A 1-7-1 215 1-07-22 106 1-7-21 101 1-7-6 32 1-10-19 144 1-07-22 107 1-7-21 105 1-7-6 33 1-9-34 216 1-07-22 108 1-7-16 80 1-7-6 282 1-7-24 124 1-07-22 109 l-7-18 81 1-7-6 280 1-7-24 126 1-10-9 SS"I l-7-14 62 1-7-6 283 1-9-42 249 1-07-22 110 1-7-14 63 1-7-9 294 1-9-42 245 1-07-22 til 1-7-14 64 1-7-9 284 1-9-42 250 1-07-22. 112 1-7-10 46 1-7-9 182 1-7-8 242 1-07-22 113 1-7-2 7 1-7-9 43 1-7-8 40 1-09-9 75 1-7-5 22 1-7-9 42A 1-12-8 100 1-09-9 73 1-7-5 23 1-7-9 42 1-12-8 103 1-09-9 72 1-7-5 24 1-8-323 1084 1-12-8 99 1-09-9 74 1-7-5 25 1-7-1 1 1-12-8 104 1-09-9 71 1-7-5 26 1-7-1 2 1-7-23 117 1-09-9 77 1-7-5 27 1-7-1 3 1-09-41 242 -
1-09-9 78 1-7-5 295 1-7-1 4 1-09-41 243 1-07-17 76 501014 362 1-7-1 20-1 1-09-41 244 1-07-17 77 1-8-321 1069 1-7-1 203 1-09-17 130 1-07-17 78 1-7-28 186 1-7-1 204 1-09-17 131 1-07-17 79
- 1-7-28 187 1-7-1 206 1-09-17 132 1-07-16 72 1-4-153 1428 1-7-1 207 1-09-38 230 1-07-16 73 1-4-153 1060 1-7-1 209 1-09-28 231 1-07-16 74 500136 251 1-7-1 211 1-09-38 232 1-07-16 75 1-7-6 28 1-7-1 213 1-09-38 233 1-07-19 82 1-07-19 83 1-07-19 64
F74/4</ 3 t u Rop;rt Ns. PAR (DCNP)-NDE-2 /m7 Adm.swo 87 43Cws.t Anr /$9m.cstsw) //-4i- 23 .
/7/s/rf sco.e 9 roc "-2PY7 67.t. 4zris 3-9-83
/ro .</wer.e se.ceasse ssmre ss.co n c
/- 8 -22 2 /// 7 > 7 5 7a <' /0 78
/ 328 // 75 m x 5 "7o < /0 7
/-8-322 //2cf 7 7 5 To < / o */c
/-8-322 /t.72 7 7 5 7a < sc *fo
/ 2 *? 8 /// 9 7 7 57d < /0 Yo
/ 22E ///P 4 7 7 S Yo 4 / 0 "/o
/- 2 .32 8 ///2 7 7 5 "fo < #
./O Yo
/ 320 /0fO 7 7 S Yo < /0 %
/ S '? O / 0 .-7 9 7 7 5 "Yo 4 /0 %
/-8 .S.20 ,o g 7 7 757$< /c %
/-8 20 .292
- 75 lb < /0 %
/ 20 2 9 3.4 7 7 6 Pb ' /0 Pb /-8 .20 .793 8 s ?5% < /0 % /- P 20- /50 > ~ / 0 7o / / 5 Yo /- 2 .2 0 /VS? .7 /0 96 < /S?b / - 8 .20 /Y8 .? /0 70 4 / 5 Tc /-8.20 /V 7 .7 /0 .7c -<' /$Pb / no /YS > 7 s 7o < /c 7c /-2 20 /Yd::, > 7 s-70 4 /0 7c / - 8 .2 /f, ' 757o < /C % / 2 20 ' 7575 4 /0 %
s'- 2 .2 2/ > 75 Pi < / 0 Ya
/- 2 -Q' 2? ' ?* 5% < /d 7c
/ - 2 .:2' i .2u > ~~ 5 7c < /O %
/- f .2 /9 755 < /0 %
\>VsrsW,%%d 0 .// /cc 3J
Exhibit 4 to Rap 2rt No. bs. r.uE-2 WISCONSIN INDUSTRIAL TESTING, INC. REPORT OF me NONDESTRUCTlVE s.i,nin anie, s,,... . .,.... i.. wi S.acos
. . .n.wis sss
.1.u.ui me,os v.o.ui m.ans EXAMINATION raa a.o., sm.on cis as (UT, MT..PT. ET)
.ustom.. j Lucation 4 Contract No lDaie
.//'/.' ' ~
- Z > 4 & O ( W .?> c , e < W </" ! ! / Y-/ % - 7.3 o Ne pien.unwinnon IContros Appart Nv
' ji can os Di. swing No
_J~ :'c - As i /_rc 7-/M- 3/,I 4re a ; n..:.t . ; St.rrace Concit:on 5g.ien. = fi t e M//- hC, ///
//,.7 it ne e ' s.,'..a e f 47r ,g;'f$ gZ2/o ype ct Emmeninanon . E a.ivn.n..sion Gianc:ud j A :. i.pi..nce sianet:arit No t P e rei .ri s..r e ET o uT o mo PT a - ,m g g g g ypw work I ciat Li noin Ei:innn..is Lym g__g_ _3,]5qqc l M.ori...e i vp-hsness g ra:c..v.as 1.. nip r.t.o.n. tru,3 Nep3 Repair O Rs (,Q g & gg g i
;J ,4,4,, gyy 7,y):,. Qg,,.,.,
T Eauipment- Pione i*si in. a . .I.truisoi.e D. e..e : .. . a.s .iv i. cvei T Egaiement r i ans.juc e. Ie>i cios. i L e.n~;n. - Ora r +i .. ,n i pensa...i, tswa
.i i i Tcui.. ,Ciy C t i:enis: O AC O CC C
" '*' "..,4..
. .a .
hta r tam C Rectifiec ; Mc;s.1 C C _.il O
~
I f ub'l#"t nl i ge ,g,p,g, . y p,,,n,,,,,,,,g,,.,,,,,,,g,,
,,g (,9,ff f .' # ,,,,,,,,,,;,g,t, f,,**..'# f f.n'* A C;~/4'5//,. $/s),~/WN ' O' M'' -' W^ ' O I' A "W'** O
- Y'N **O"5 O CfQct C(,ane C Crap D Porcsilf LF Lack of Fusion Li Linent trian atu.n
. Siaa LA L arr.inatiOn
@ ART NO. !ACC. R EJ. DhIC REMARKS PART NO. ACC. REJ. D[hT REMARKS l
- 9. t./- no_ . .i l
. /. , /
a //
$$ =
.. . - . . . - . _. . , , . . . . . . J' . . . . .
h_ .l_. . f fj . .. I $ i
. _ _ _ _ , . . . . . . . . . . k ;. j. . _ . . . . . . . . . . .
h $ $ /fl [ A ,* .. e r.._j__ ___. ' l
. . . . , . . . . - _ . . _ . . /$.csnc:'so.r. '- ' rE' .r,/. rh.c ... . /t'd .. . . !
-. --.--.;-. J. . .. . .. A "tWho.' M' : ./k? .-C -
- i
- .. . _ . . . - . _ . , i . .I . . .l --
I i j i , i i
"n m te ll i Numcer ci ire es 'Nwmeer of elems
$'*/f//'.J' 7*A'7.v sZd':/*&*C di/f/ ///<2 l CC';'*C R *I';'*o
- -- c .t t ev ,
l case c usim .e. :cai,
. 0. 1 r:.k '2f < b.: r-/ _27 A-M .72 e :ec.. wp cm ., o.m . . . i = , m se .. .o .. .i
. "e. ,
'. & ,,8' $.0 *( '. g,,,
o .* ardineler, n c. PAR: PQP-124 C O N S U tfi N G (NG8NIER$ Page 1 of 9 st. G e o v e, wisc o w sia 11 Total Pages', with Attachment PARAMETER, Inc. 12ro iect Qualitv Plan (POP)
, for P ac ; 1. : . /=els nnre a-6 9ervices to Support NT<C. ' T E Region V Perscnnel in
_jor.dustruct ve Examinatiens and Review of Radiograohs at Diable Can'/cn Nuclear Power Plant , Units 1 & 2 San Luis Obisco, California t 5 3 1
,/
i , Prepared for: e Office of Inspection & Enforcement O.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Contract No. NRC-05-82-249 l l A Task Order No. 56 I i ! , PAR: NRC/IE- 8 2 /8 3
'. 11,22/83i
_;+..; l Issue f ,._
..L. CaIn n.
4 g
.g - ,
l J /* f' L
.- ~.. ,
a rdm elar, n c. PAR: PQP-124 C O N S U LTl N G ENGlN((R$ 9 f l an G R O V 2, W 15 C O N $ l N Record of Revisions Issued by/ Revision Date Descriotion Concurrence 0 11/22/83 Issued in response to NRC Task Order No. 56 /'k'bci C t ;! . 5 d ,,p ; -a-on Contract No. 05 Walter J. coley - 249 6 / h' /~. I) u. inchhrd A. Lcf( ~ 4a J 6 . Djstrilution of PAR: POP-124, Rev. O and Controlled Conv No.
- of PAR: O/A-1, Rev. 4 (creviousiv submitted)
!;EC/IE Headquarters, Wolfgang Laudan Copy No. 2 EIT, Rcbert Grether Copy No. 1
. 1 s : r .:... . .:. r .' ' A: - POP-i2 , Rev. 0
- , :< C is g . :.- ., .e.-._s .rsen
_ _ - - . , . _ . . , _ _ -m.. _ , , . . - . - . , ,,,n _rr %,-
-- y ,a,-
. .o a rd m ala r, n c. PAR: PQP-124 con $ULUNG E N GIN f f t $
Page 3 ftm G a o v t, we$ con $lN Table of Contents Page Description 1 Cover Sheet 2 Record of Revisions 2 Distribution 3 Table of Contents 4 Introduction 4 Client i Ae plicsble Quality Assurance Programs 5 PARAMETER, Inc. Reference 5 Project 5 Scope 6 Assignments-and Contacts 7 Organization Chart 8 General Procedures and Requirements Epecific Procedures and Requirements 9 9 Attachment Attachment 1 Task Order No. 56, 2 pages
a e a m ala e, n c. PAR: PQP-124 C o N S U LTI N o NClN(st$ PObe 4 sta o n ov a, wisc o N slN Introduction This Project Quality Plan supplements.the PARAMETER, Inc. basic Quslity Assurance Program for the specific task of providing assistance and services to support NRC Region V Office of Inspection and Enforcement personnel in nondes-tructive examinations and review of radiographs at Diablo Canycn Nuclear Power Plant, Units 1 and 2, San Luis Obispo, California. This FARAMETER, Inc. 'roject Quality Plan .pplios spccific-all to : HC Of fice of Inspection and Enf orce-ment (NRC/IE) Ta s k Order No . 56, which is included as Attachment 1. The P Ai;AMETER, Inc. basic Quality Assurance Program which applics to this task order is iduntified as PAR: Q/A-1, hevisic. - 4, 6 3/82. This ProJcc: Quality Plan is provided to meet the require- 1 ments of 10 CFR 50, Appendix B, Quality Assurance. It is reccgnized that P ARAMETER, Inc. (the Contractor) is required
- c perfcrm all work under Task Order No. 56 in accordance with PAR: FQP-124, Revision 0, and PAR: Q/A-1, Revision 4.
Furtner, it is recognized that Wisconsin Industrial Testing, Inc. (WIT, the Subcontractor) is required to performnall work unJar this task order in accordance with the maintained copy issued 6/15/82 of their Quality Assurance Manual No. 101. Client Office of Inspection and Enforcement (IE) U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC)
L ', e a eIm alar, n c. PAR: POP-124 CONSULUNG E N GlN(f t $ Page 5 l Its G e o v t, wl5 CON $lN .
>l . t*
Aoplicable Quality Assurance Programs
- 1. PAR: Q/A-1, Revision 4, 6/3/82
" Quality Assurance Program for Engineering Design, Analy_ sis.and Testing on ASME B & PV Code and Other QuKlitf-Doc:pmented Projects" This PARAMETER, Inc. basic program is supplemented by PAR: PQP-124 for the specific purpose of responding to NRC Task Order No. 56, which is included as Attachment 1 of this plan.
- 2. Manual No. 101 Maintaincd issue of 6/15/82 "Qualit, Assurance Manual" W:sconsin Industrial Testing, Inc. (WIT)
Brookfield, Wisconsin PARAMETER, Inc. Ref erence
~
PAR: NRC/IE-82/83 l ProiaCt l ! Drrviding Assistance and Services to Support NRC/IE Region V Personnel in Review of Radiographs and Nondestructive Examin-ations at Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, Units 1 and 2, San Luis Obispo, California. Scope l 1. Perform independent delta-ferrite measurements on about 25 selected stainless steel welds to verify compliance with Code and Regulatory Guide 1.31 requirements. 1
- 2. Visuall, examine and perform liquid penetrant examination cf field welds FW-110, 111, 112 in isometric package 2 ..
l
- . F.::ar.ine radiographs of acout 100 pipe welds, and verify
.nder sneet, radiograph and evaluataur adequacy.
l t
o e a e a in a / s r, n c. PAR: PQP-124 C C N $ U LTl N G fNGINfff$ f l as C a o v e, w l $ C C N $ 3 M - Assianments and Contacts NRC Authorized Project Officer: IE Headquarters c? 4 (301) 492-494 Wolfcane Laudan
=
IE Region V Of fice Contact, NRC foetion Chief: (415) 943-3723 Dennis Kirsch IE Regi er ' (Diable canyon) Contact, NRC Senior Resident Inspectoi505) 595-2353 Marvin Mendenca F Ai( A M E : ;.2 , Inc. Project Director ( 414 ) 756-7580 Richard A. Lc f '. O/A Engineer Walter J. Folev Level III Kenneth A. Ristau Wisconsir. Industrial Testing (WIT) Administrative Contact (414) 781-0105 Robert Grether Level III and O/A Al Dolcaard Inspection Personnel Assigned Daniel Hunt *
- Certifications of this inspector are on file in the offices of PARAMETER, Inc. He is certified currently for PT at (SNT-TC-1A) Level II.
~
i itichard A. l.o l y , Pres. ConsulM ng_l'ngineer_ . _ . _M. _ , _A. Kraus ..h i;lic Contiacts Officer _ _ . . . _ _ _ Project Dii cet or Admin./ Tech. Secretary, If ._P oject Officer Design Eva1uation/ Review Contract Acc'tg. Staff and Consultant Coor. Admin. Services . Quality Assurance Audit - n 2 0 4 i I 2% 053 o% -
. o , '" la1ter J. Foley E='
Mgr. of Engineering Robert S. Dean Kenneth A. Itistau ;[ Co-Project Director ----- Sr. Staff Engineer f.e ve l 111 oi z- 2
~U/h bocumentation Alt. Co-Project Dir. Consultant
~5dv. Eng. Analysis i"
~
Eng. Analysis Nondestructive .D Review Review Examination i Drafting Computer l Subcontract Services Services --------------- Firm Tech. i Services l Testing Labs _ _ . Technical- Staff Consultants Subcontract Consultants -Metallurgical l Clerical J.J.Maurin, Thermal Anal. i Metallurgy, Electrical, NDE, -Physical _ Services L.E.Vlies, Adv.Eng. Anal. l Civil / Structural, Chemical, _-NDE W.E.Littleton, Mech.Eng. I _ Construction, liydraulics,etc. Fire Consult., A.I,.Schaeffler, Met.Eng. i Others, as
, l required i i
. . e i Project I,laison i ___________________________,
A. llennick - Hef. Data and Subcontractor m. o> m _ Documentation j3
-m o
' m PARAMETER, Inc. Organization for NRC-IE Technical Assistance 4 to Contract No. 05-82-249 PAR: NRC-IE-82/83
+
q, a ea m als r, n c. PAR: PQP-124 cowsud No' ewonat ta s Page 8 ftM G R O V t', -W I $ C O N $ 1 H General Procedures and Recuirements
- 1. All technical and administrative communications from NRC to PARAMETER, Inc. are to be~ directed to Mr. Richard A.
Lofy, Project Director. When Mr. Lofy is out of the office, telephone calls are to be directed to Mr. Walter J. Foley, O/A Engineer.
- 2. All technical and administrative communications from PARAMETER, Inc. to NRC are to be directed to the Author-ited NRC/IE Project Officer, Mr. Wolfgang Laudan.
- 3. PARAMSTER, Inc. is to be responsible for reviewing, audit-ing, and maintaining copies of Wisconsin Industrial Testing,
- 1. . c . (WIT) Quality Assurance Manual No. 101, maintained issue of 6,15/ 8 2. Date of Last Audit, April 13, 196; by Fenr.oth A. Fistau.
- 4. PARAMETER, Inc. is to be responsible for reviewing and auditing the qualifications of the Level II inspector assigned to on-site nondestructive examinations, fer certifying that his qualifications are up-to-date, and maintaining records of this audit. .
- 5. PARAMETER, Inc. is to be responsible for reviewing and auditing the qualifications of its Level III NDE Consultant, for certifying that his qualifications are up-to-date, fer maintaining records of this audit and for providing NRC with a copy of his qualifications before commencing work.
- 6. In compliance with the intent of 10 CFR 50, Appendix B, activities affecting quality are to be controlled to~an l extent consistent with their importance to safety.
i
- 7. In compliance with 10 CFR 50, Appendix B, sufficient records are to be maintained to furnish evidence of activities affecting quality, and these records are to be identifiable and retrievable.
In particular, the Q/A Manual of the subcontractor is to be check- ! ed thoroughly for commitment to l acequacy of records. 1 i l l
. .g a rdm ale r, n c. PAR: PQP-124 c o N S U LTI N G E N GI N E t t $ Page 9 ELM GROVI, W15 CON $1N Specific Procedures and Requirements
- 1. Upon arrival at the .Diablo Canyon Site, the Level III Consultant provided directly by PARAMETER, Inc. is to give the NRC/IE contact two copies of his certification and qualification documents.
- 2. Upon arrival.atl.the Diablo Canyon Site, the WIT Repre-sentative'is.to'gi've the NRC/IE contact two copies of his certification and qualification documents, and cer-
- fication of- 11gulo penetrant cleaner, penetrant and deceloper. .
- 2. Tr.c WIT Represenhative is to check that certification cf '.:censee's Severn _ gauge calibration is current.
- 4. l
, examinations _ and_ reviews are to be perf ornied in ac.urdance with'the latest editions of the ASME Code.
- 5. "wo copies of all data sheets are to be f urnished to the NRC/IE Centact at t.pe conclusion of the work.
6 . ,A letter report including aLdescription of the work per-formed, the' data obtained or examined, and evaluat2vn of the a'dequacy of licensee's documentation is to.be deliver-ed to Dennis Kirsch (Region V office) and Wolfgang Laudan (NRC/IE Headquarters) by November 25, 1963.
- 7. An exit meeting is to_be held with.the NRC/IE cont'ct a to-discuss the scope and findings.
Attachment
- 1. NRC/IE Task Order No. 56
.s .
Attachment 1 to PAR: PQP-124 November 8, 1983 - OUTLINE OF NON-DESTRUCTIVE EXAMINATION WORK TO BE PERFORMED AT DIABLO CANYON, NOVEMBER 14-18, 1983, BY NRC CONTRACT PERSONNEL GENERAL INFORMATION:
. Location: Diablo Canyon Nuclear Plant, Unit Nos. I and 2 San Luis Obispo, California Licensee: Pacific Gas and Electric Company Docket No. 50-275 and 50-323
Purpose:
- 1. Perform independent delta-ferrite measurements on about 25 selected stainless steel welds to verify ccmpliance with code and Regulatory Guide 1.31 requirements.
- 2. Visually examine and perform liquid penetrant e amir.ation of field welds FW-110, 111, 112 in isometric package 2-14-31.
- 3. Examine about 100 weld radiographs and' verify reader sheet, radiograph and evaluation adequacy.
Site
Contact:
Mr. Marvin Mendonca, NRC Senior Resident Inspector 805-595-2353 RV
Contact:
Mr. Dennis Kirsch, NRC Section Chief, 415-943-3740 Work Hours: 0730-1630, November 14-18, 1983 REQUIREMENTS: To be furnished at the Diablo Canyon Site by the licensee: Hard hats and safety glasses Insulation removal Scaffolding erection Escorts to locate welds in the plant Assistance to assemble documentation (radiographs) Electrical power and extension cords for portable test equipment Working space for one or two persons to examine radiography records Viewer to examine radiographs Use of lunchroom and sanitary facilities Use of Xerox machine as back-up . C:lzbrated setern gauge . To be furnished at the Diablo Canyon Site by the NRC: Assistance as required by the Senior Resident Inspector Telephones in the NRC trailer Xer;x machine for copying
.: s To be furnished by the contractor:
Certified level II or III liquid penetrant and qualified radiograph interpreter examiner to conduct visual and liquid penetrant examinations and an examination of about 100 radiographs for adequacy Two copies of certifications and qualifications of all contractor personnel, and-documentation verifying certification and qualification of liquid penetrant cleaner, penetrant and developer used shall be given to the !?RC contact upon arrival at the Diablo Canyon Site. Measurements performed shall be in accordance with the latest editions of the ASMI code. Two copies of all data sheets will be. furnished to the NRC contact at the conclusion of the work. 3 A letter report including a description of the work performed, the data citained or examined, and evaluation of the adequacy of licensee *s Reumentation shall be prepared and delivered to the NRC Region V off:ce by November 25, 1983. An exit meeting will be held with the NRC tcntact at the conclusion of the work to discuss the scope and
- d:ags.
e
+
b 4
DOCKETED USNR: 9 Dacember 1083 (i . [ ' ~ 'gg,y7.[- ((23 83 UEC 15 P3:09
- a. .: 7 :
Mr. John B. Martin P:: n.:iidi , s - Regional Administrator M" United Stated Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Region V 1450 Maria Lane, Suite 210 Walnut Creek, CA 94596 SEP/ED DEC 1 :yi Daar Mr. Martin: My thanks for your thoughtful reply of December 2 (Attachment A) to the November 4 letter of the Concerned Cal Poly Faculty and Staff addressed to NRC Chairman Palladino regarding two specific reasons for the lack of public confidence in the Emergency Response Plan for the Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant. It is indeed heartening to receive such a personal and courteous letter; we are most appreciative. In your last paragraph you kindly wrote: " Pleas e feel free to contact us if you wish to provide further data reflecting on your concerns . . ." Without wishing to be a burden to your office, I'd like to update one of the concerns mentioned in our Novernber 4 letter and bring a new chapter of another, older concern to your attention. One of our concerns in our previous letter was with an often flooded area known as the " Twin Bridges" or " Twin Trestles". Money to replace the bridges was said to be unavailable for at least three years. According to the Telegram-Tribune story of November 15 (Attachment B), County officials apparently realize a problem exists on one of only two ways out of Los Osos / Baywood Park (the other route is a two lane road leading into the city of San Luis Obispo which is also subject to flooding) and they intend to rebuild the B ridges . . Unfortunately, the article states that the effort could begin at the earliest in fiscal 1085-86, many, many months after full-power operations at Diablo Canyon are scheduled to be gi n. The other concern we would like to bring to your attention is the continuing problem with sirens being used as the primary method of notifying the population within the Basic Emergency Planning Zane. Per the Tete 2 ram-Tribune article of March 8 (Attachment C), power is interrupted severale, -' times each winter and when electricity is los t, the sirens which "do w w pff f 1.regular
, power
,n lines", are los t. Whether the exclanations offe rra. bv
, r w npu s
2 y;"' .
.. ?.
I
'. T 4
9 December 1983 Mr. John B. Martin Page.Two by the PG & E spokeswoman in the article are adequate is something for the NRC, FEMA and the California State OES to decide. We certainly do not believe there is an adequate back-up system. We are barely into our winter season and as Attachments D, E and F make clear, power has thrice been disrupted in the area. Undoubtedly, there will be additional partial or complete losses of power in our area this winter and each time some or virtually all of the sirens will be out of c ommis sion. Such back-up systems as expecting everyone to have a battery powered radio at the ready or counting on police cars with sirens to pick up the stack are pale imitations of a fully operating siren system. Our thanks for your attention to the matters raised. We appreciate your understanding why our group has continuing grave doubts about the Emergency Response Plan and why public confidence in this Plan is so low. Sincerely, i d D:. Richard Kranzdorf, Spokesperson Concerned Cal Poly Faculty and Staff 160 Graves Avenue San Luis Obispo, CA 93401 , ! Enclos ure s
- c c
- United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Chairman and Commissioners l Congressman Leon Panetta Congressman William Thomas Congressman Edward Markey United States Federal Emergency M.snagement Agency 1
i
- s. .'
[ ",
, UNITED STATES !?.,l1 '
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION I I REGION V 3,
'g b..,! [e,[ ,
1450 MARIA LANE. SulTE 210 WALNUT CREEK. CALIFORNIA 94596 Deceder 2,1983
. -:A ATTACHMENT A Dr.- Richard Kranzdorf, Spokesperson Concerned Cal Poly Faculty and Staff 160 Graves Avenue San Luis Obispo, California 93401
Dear Dr. Kranzdorf:
This is to acknowledge receipt of your letter of Noveder 4,1983 to the Chairman of the U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission and attachments thereto, expressing concerns regarding a lack of public confidence in emergency planning for the Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant and irrpediments to evacuation of elements of the public in the event of a nuclear energency. Thank you for the reasoned and documented statement regarding your concerns. They will serve as a basis for inquiry, hopefully leading to a sound evaluation and resolution of these concerns. Please be advised that we have provided copies of your correspondence to the U. S. Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEl%), which has a specific assignment by Executive Order of the President to take the lead in offsite radiological emergency planning and response. We will work closely with FEIM, the State of California Office of Emergency Services, and cognizant local emergency services elements in evaluating and resolving your expressed Concerns. Please feel free to contact us if you wish to provide further data reflecting on your concerns or if we may answer any questions regarding our handling of the evaludtion of your concerns. Sincerely, pbQ John & artinlsA@
- o. M 0-Regional Administrator es I n n .A N /! ,n 0)AbbfWY }
y, ( ? .
h . l ATTACHMENT B Joint effort seen to repair Twin B
- s Morro N wi money with the county to rebuild the thatlea Los Osos.
Twm The B ~ es are within the city thnits of Morro Bay but 'odically flood, blocking one of two ways ' into las Osos. The Morro Bay City Council on Monday directed its staff to formal-ise an agreement with San Luis O County to share costs in the bri'oges on South Bay The joint effort. which could begin la Sacalyear 190HS, willcost about 8t mGBen. Morro Bay and the coun-
. ty wiB each pay 10 percent, about
$100,000, and Caltrans will pay -
about 80 percent, or about $800,000, most of that federal funds, said City Adminstrator PaulBaxter. The county has been notified that Caltrans doesn't expect to have ( money available for the repairs for at least three years. South Bay Boulevard is occasion-ally Gooded at the bridges when Chorro Creek is backed up by high tides and winter rains.
- The council also accepted a 550,-
000 payment from the Harbor Com-massion that will be put into the city's general fund. The harbor fund had unanticipated revenues and lower-than-expected expenditures I this year of about $100,000. The Harbor Fund still owes the city about $20,000. A part of the surplus will be used by the llarbor Department to pur-chase two portable radios for $$,000. The remnining surplus will be put in a special account for maintenance and improvement projects.
e i i SAN illt$ DIEPQ 171llNTY 8 CALIF.) TELEGRAM TRIBUNE, TUESDAY, MARCH 8,1983 A.3 o Diab o[ sirens if power outi 11 an emergency at the Diable t,ecause, though emergency broad- IElectric system erected to warn of M County Emergency Coordinator
- Cenyon nuclear power plant were cast station KVEC has an emergen- emergencies at Diablo Canyon do Unda West agreed that, "in any :
X' 1J accompanied by a power failure, cy power supply, plug in radios work off regular power lines, PG&E kind of emergency, people should' % most of San 1.uis Obispo County's wouldn't work, Kranzdorf said. representative Suzanne G. Brown have battery operated radios. It- *1 aarning sirens wouldn't work, a 11 these problems were accompan, conceded. could be totally unrelated to Diablo', o group of anti nuclear Cal Poly facul- led by the kind of fierce storms the She said only those in remote Canyon. ; ty members said today. county sullered this winter, KVEC areas such as See Canyon have "There's no way that the county
- Ilad Diablo Canyon been operat. could be knocked off the air, and Independent, solar power systems. can either provide those (radios) or -
ing tius winter and a general cuer- w nd and flood damage could block Brown saki, however, that people require that people have them, but : evacu ti n r utes. don't need to hear sirens for infor- it just makes good common sense." ; bi t it wou d have en mation in an emergency, such as a major disaster with considerable " Virtually every road mentioned Asked about storm <aused travel: loss of hie," Itichard Kranzdorf, a as a major artery (in the county's Prolonged blackout. problems, West said that if evacua-member of the Concerned Cal Poly emergency plan) has been clogged "In an emergency situation, peo- tion routes were impassable or if Faculty and Staff, said during a or blocked or out of commission at ple ter.d to be pretty level headed," there was too httle time to evacu-news conference st Mission Plaza. least once this winter " Kranzdorf lshe said. " People want to know, ate, county emergency officials it cou)d prove fruitless to turn on said, land if they want to know badly would ask people to remain Indoors . radius for emergency information l Most sirens in the Pacific Gas and /enou,gh,they'lllind a way." instead of evacuating. . t I
4 . I j ATTACHMENT D Damp yojidal weather; AIIskaEsitorm on tap The hhutory Alaskan storm that total to 3.34 inches. The normal brought chilly rains and 8 to 124oot rainfall for this thne of year is 1.64 mrf to the Central Coast this week- inches, he said. De total last year and will leave clear skies behind at this tkne was 3.37 inches. today, but residents should brace There were some is-Wences for a repeat performance for the from the storm. Thanksgt'ving weekend. \ Suzanne G. Brown of Pacific Gas Nat! anal Weather Service spe:ial- and Electric Co. said Templeton ist Mike cant hall in Santa Marta and north Maar adero lost electnci-predicted mostly fair skies today. ty off and on for an hour from 1:30 and Tasaday, with nightthne tem-. p.m. Saturday. It affected 4,000 , paratures to the upper 20e emmeninars, to add 40s. will be northwest A tree on a power !!ne knocked from 18 to 20 mph today. out power for 130 Camhna custom-Temneratures dipped to 29 de. , ers on Pine Knolls from 12:30 to i 63 grees and 2 in la pneendaco Santa Marganta. this mormng Brown f :15 p.m.were said there Sunday, short scat-
"It looks like the next storm will tered power failures elsewhere in the county due to blown fuses.
be h,,ere c ,,,= just in thne for r=1=4 i On the ocean today, winds will be M 1said. weekend storm dumped 41 northwest 15 to 5 knots, with seas 3 inches of rain, bringing the == =1 feet and northwest swells 8 to 12 Winter storm watches were in effect 64-6 the West today as snow continued to fall in Nevada, Utah. Anzona and Colorado. One to 2 feet of mow fell in the 1 ' Sierra Nevada and around Lake Tahoe, the Nathnal Weather Serv-Ice reported. i..
^
Sig s:orm
~
a Ls::ers. . acrossa SLO coun:y By Tom Fulks bours. Staff Writer V/g County sheriff's deputy Wilbur Mills said his department received High winds and heavy rains a few telephone calls Thursday
^ TTACHMINT I spawned in Alaska roared into the night, mostly about burglar alarms Central Coast on Thursday, causing that went off accidentally. ,
At Morro Bay ~ Harbor. 6- to 8 f'oot power failures in some areas and swells h. i tioats from getting neavy surf along the coast, Big surf is blamed for the aminng through the 600 foot entrance this of a sailboat off the Big Sur coast- morning, the Coast Guard reported. line Thursday afternoon. Its two The waves were running close passengers are still misang. (See together and.at least one fithmg separate story on Page A-2.) boat had to wait more than two wnue Thursday's downpour hours outside the entrance before it should dissipate by this evening, could enter safely, according to the another storm is expected to slam Coast Guard. into the area by enriy Saturday, Renovation work on the city's to Jeff Smith of the Na- oorth breakwater was halted again L. leather Service in Santa because of the high waves and poor tional t varia. weather eaeans. Thursday's stormis the tail end of The Atascadero' Police Depart-Typhoon Marge tnat originated in ment's communication center had. the Pacific aff Japan and moved off to resort to emergency power for the Pacific Northwest, Smith said. about an hour durmg the night after The storm dumped 2.66 inches of PG4E lines serymg it went dead'. rain on San Las O , A power pole caught fire east of the city's season to Paso Robles at about 8 p.m. Thurs-8.52 inchen, almost dochie for the day as electrical aaniamaa' shorted ' rest of the county, E-4 to the out. California Department of For-Weather Service. estry firefighters quickly had the j Santa Margarita collected 1.74 Bre under control and then .tood by taches of rain, while Arroyo Grande anta after midai ht as PG&E crews recorded .36, Morro Bay .44 and repaired damage. Rhmadan .51 inches. Jim Bower of Pacific Telephone The forecast caHs for partly clou- Co. said his company received dy skies wtm decreasing showers "about double" the normal amount today wie highs in the 60s and of service calls with scattered fail-winds variable at 20 mph, Snuth ures throughout the county, but were n se us repons of torm-related electric blackouts ge~ affected about 3,000 homes and busi-nesses in the North County and Cambria, s' aid Pacific Gas and v y ,J ,/ Electric Co. representative Suzanne I*I ue:Qeu_: v l G. Brown. The Telegram-Tribune is A &ninute power failure struck being delivered late today but a large part of San Luis Obispo at it is not your paper carrier's 1&O5 a.m. , today, forcing French fault. A Annute electrical and San Luis Obtspo General hospt- power failure in San Luis.0b. tals to book up emergency genera- ispo this morning delayed I* e power failures be 6 p.m. Thursday aspicked wmbanup at about , au and continued throughout the night, ' AT Brown said. Power was restored to most areas by 8 a.m. today, said AGRICUt.TURE.. . ..A4 CLASSIRED... . 9-7 Cambria, there were seat. .8-5 COMICS...... . tered but pretty thorough outages," COMMUNITY... . . . . A-6 she said. In Cambria and Atascadero, CROSSWCRD . .3-12 blackouts occurred when trees and EDITORIAL ........... ..A-10 branches fell on power lines, Brown ENTERTAINMENT. ..S.6 said. OBITUARIES.. ..A.9 Paso Robles Airport was without SPORTS .. ..S.1 power most of the night when the STCCKS.. ..A.% mam electne line servmg it went TV LCG A.0 down, said Brown, adding Pas NEATHER" "A 1 Robles radio station KPRL was { - - - - - - - _ _ _ _ _, _ __ _ , _ _ _
ATTACllMENT F y Storm l1 \ [^ dj trings i
'f rain, - - - a.eA. rM.,. . mp _d M ._g.
moming toppled about five trees la to start the motor, we swamped the w hs Osos, one tree la Cambria and boat (a small inflatable skiff)," said k ULia V #% & C *
% ljfOy one la the North County. Lucy Kelleway, vice principal at me I
U UI The students stranded.oa the school
- sandspit were from Orange Coun- "All but 38 of our students had
[ A weekend storm that struck The storm also forced Grover ty's Dana Hills High School Northern California with hurricane City, Morro Bay and Paso Robles to wetsults and many of them almply Morro Bay Harbor Patrolmen swam back across the harbor. We force winds brought only scattered postpone their Christmas parades Larry Linder and Dick Rodgers quickly warmed h rest with fresh cloudbursts to the Central Coast. and San Luis Obispo to delay its reported ferrying 35 of the 57 stu- clam chowder and hot chocolate Na serious damage was reported Chrishus in the Plaza. dents and two teachers back across made over our campfires." in San Luis Oblp County as a The Paso Robles and Grover Cup the harbor to near their Morro Bay De county's heavlest ralafall was result of Saturday a storm, though parades were regcheduled next Sat. State Park campalte la the evening. In Santa Margarita, where 1.33
.its einds were blamed fx electrical urday - the Paso Robles parade at "At least two of the kids were ao inches fell and San Luis Obispo, b!:ckouts affecting about one-Ililrd-il a.m. and the Grover City parade cold they couldn't hold onto any- which recorded f.22 inches.
of colirity residents. at lo a.m. thin and had trouble standing," j In Norbrn Galifornia, the storm "Thidorm s'tra'ie[135 n high school Christmas la the Plaza will also said. None' of the students overturned vehicles and planes, students from Southern California take place next weekend, said Saa ge utred hospital treatment, but shut down roadif and bridges, felled it I.uls Obispo Special Events Coordi. may sure made a beeline to their trees,' sank boots, mangfed homes on Brythe Morro liarbor Bay sands ied Patrolmen [ err. Morro the nator Joan Ponza. campfires. and
- cut powe P to an estimated tudents t fet "Everything's going to be exactly The students were stranded on the quarter-million people.
Most o e 3*wer failures oc- the same (as plarmed)," she said, spit after a day of clamdigging and "the entertainment and every. The storm was blamed for at least i as studying tidepool Hie. three deaths. P e ifn'"sh er thing." "The rope on our boat's onhard a st e In San LeaMiro, a 98-year-old ! cod sometimes shook the wires No information was available this starter broke when we prepared to woman was hurMd by the winds lato themselves so hard that they snorning on plans for rescheduling - i banged together, said Suzanne G. *
- wn of Iacific Gas and Electric E{U Eng
- k e C. h p,p,, said gusty winds on Saturday She said a single blackout in - See SR)RM, Page A 3
! northern Atascadero and southern i Templeton affected 3,000 customers
! for 1% hours while 3,580 homes and businesses la Arroyo Grande and a steel fence and killed. Near Wil. In the the Sierra Nevada, the Oceano were without power for loss, a mother and son were killed storm closed Interstate 88, the malu about an hour Saturday morning. when their car hit a flooded section transmountain freeway, with bils-and ran lato another car. zard snows and stranded many me-A series of failures hit San Luis
- Obispo's Foothill Boulevard area. The Weather Service reported torists. .
leaving 1,986 customers without wind gusts up to 80 mph on San National Weather Service fore- , power for 15 minutes, and 193 for an Francisco Bay, clocking peak gusts caster Bill Grebe blamed the nasty hour or more. Another 2,113 were of 92 mph on San Bruno Mountain a conditions on a front " anchored to effected by momentary outages. few miles south of San Francisco. an intense surface low in Northern
- Brown said. The Golden Gate Bridge was California."
i She said that 250.000 of PG&E's 3 closed because of the high winds The Weather Service said another million customers in Northern and and all ablpping in the Golden Gate storm may threaten rain on the Central California suffered power channel west of the bridge iras . Central Coast by Tuesday widle a losses during the storm and 8.000 - halted for a thne because of moun- ' tidrd storm is expected in Cahfornia Inostly on the San Francisco Penin- tainous waves. before the weekend. sula - were still without power this morning.
M Ef%{%i *
- Q TECHNICAL CONSUL TA Date G Br.denbaugh 1723 Hamilton Avenue-Suite K Richard B Hubbard San Jose. Cantornia 95125 Gregory C Minor March 4, 1986 Phone- (408) 266-2716 Mr. Donnie H. Grimsley, Director Division of Rules and Records g Office of Administration - _ , OM or w . ,m,. ,,n U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ACT REQUEST Washington, D.C. 20555 p p gf RE: FOIA REQUEST
Dear Mr. Grimsley:
Pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act, please make available at the Commission's Washington, D.C., Public Document categories: Room single copies of records in the following A. From the Chron Files of Mr. Hans Schierling from September 1, 1981, through December 31, 1983, all records concerning in any way the Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, Units 1 and/or 2. B. From the Reading Files of Mr. Hans Schierling from September 1, 1981, through December 31, 1983, all records concerning in any way the Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, Units 1 and/or 2. Please provide partial responses as batches of documents become available. If you have any questions concerning this request, please contact me at the telephone number given above. Your prompt attention to this request will be appreciated. Very Truly Yours, re o A. Holmes Associate Consultant
'f P sn [,
lo. I 1 _}}