ML17059B664: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Created page by program invented by StriderTol
Created page by program invented by StriderTol
Line 17: Line 17:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:WestinghouseSavannahRiverCompanyATTACHMENTIA@AmtCALONOREVISIONPAGENOP.O.Ai.28802RTR-2661August15,1989TO:S.D.CurryFROM:E.L.Bryant,$WLEADEXPANIANRLADIT~INREATBILDINGATTHEVANNHVERIINTRDTlNWalkdownstodeterminetheseismicadequacyofselectedsafetysystemshavebeenperformedforLandKreactorsutilizingtheUnresolvedSafetyIssue(USI)A-46methodologysponsoredbytheSeismicQualificationUtilityGroup(SQUG).Actualexperiencedatafromearthquakes,testdatacompiledbytheElectricPowerResearchInstitute(EPRI),andotherdataforcertainclassesofnuclearplantequipmentmakeuptheSQUGdatabase.AnchorageisalsoaddressedintheUSIA-46methodology.However,leadexpansionanchorsarenotincluded.SomesafetyrelatedequipmentintheSavannahRiverSite(SRS)reactorbuildingsissupportedbyleadexpansionanchors.DesignloadcapacitywasbasedontheallowableloadslistedinSRSStandardB8Mwhichwasintendedtoprovidedafactorofsafetyof4.However,walkdownshaverevealedthatsomeleadanchorsarenotinstalledperB8M,andthereforetheactualloadcapacityoftheseanchorsmaybelessthanindicatedintheB8M.Atestingprogram(SP-2449)wasdevelopedand107abandonedanchorsinK,L,PandRreactorbuildingsweretestedtodetermineshearandtensionloadcapacities.ThisRTRdocumentstheresultsofthistestingprogramandprovidesamethodforconfirmingadequacyoftheleadshelltypeanchor.Testresultsshowthatthetensionloadcapacityoflead"9708070i3597073iPDRADOCK05000220PPDROSR2582'Wta89>~~qoh')  
{{#Wiki_filter:Westinghouse SavannahRiverCompanyATTACHMENT IA@AmtCALONOREVISIONPAGENOP.O.Ai.28802RTR-2661August15,1989TO:S.D.CurryFROM:E.L.Bryant,$WLEADEXPANIANRLADIT~INREATBILDINGATTHEVANNHVERIINTRDTlNWalkdowns todetermine theseismicadequacyofselectedsafetysystemshavebeenperformed forLandKreactorsutilizing theUnresolved SafetyIssue(USI)A-46methodology sponsored bytheSeismicQualification UtilityGroup(SQUG).Actualexperience datafromearthquakes, testdatacompiledbytheElectricPowerResearchInstitute (EPRI),andotherdataforcertainclassesofnuclearplantequipment makeuptheSQUGdatabase.Anchorage isalsoaddressed intheUSIA-46methodology.
~a RTR-2661Page2August15,1989lTTACHMENTCCALCNOoREVISION~<IiFNOtypeanchorsatfailureisbelowthedesignfailureloads(i.e.,fourtimestheB8M).Therefore,thenewlowerallowableloadslistedinTable1shouldbeusedforleadshelltypeanchors.IfthecalculatedloadontheanchorisgreaterthantheTable1load,theanchorstillmaybeadequateprovidingitisloadtestedtoprovethatit.iscapableofcarryingtheseismicdemandload.AregressionanalysiscorrelationbetweentorqueandloadhasbeendevelopedbySRLbasedontestmeasurementsandcanbeusedforproofloadtestingthoseleadtypeshellexpansionanchorsthatexceedsthenewlowerallowable(AppendixA).TheanchorboltshouldbetorquedtoinduceatensionloadontheanchorwhichconfirmsitscapacitytocarryitscalculatedseismicdemandloadortheBSMdesignallowableload.Thisapproachmayresultinalowerfactorofsafety.Thefactorofsafetyof4wasintendedtoprovideahighlevelofconfidencethattheanchorwillsupportthedesignload.Becausetheanchorswillbeloadtestedtotheseismicdemandordesignallowableload,alowerfactorofsafetyisconsideredacceptable.TestsalsoshowthattheBSMvaluesforshearloadsareacceptable.Table1AnchorSize,inches'urrentTensionAllowableLoad(BSM)7001200200030005500NewRecommendedAllowable.LoadBasedOnTests60087097012803160ProofTorqueForBSMDesignAllowable,ft-Ib24503769*ApplicableonlyforanchorsthathavepassedthetightnesstorqueperRTR-2582  
However,leadexpansion anchorsarenotincluded.
Somesafetyrelatedequipment intheSavannahRiverSite(SRS)reactorbuildings issupported byleadexpansion anchors.Designloadcapacitywasbasedontheallowable loadslistedinSRSStandardB8Mwhichwasintendedtoprovidedafactorofsafetyof4.However,walkdowns haverevealedthatsomeleadanchorsarenotinstalled perB8M,andtherefore theactualloadcapacityoftheseanchorsmaybelessthanindicated intheB8M.Atestingprogram(SP-2449) wasdeveloped and107abandoned anchorsinK,L,PandRreactorbuildings weretestedtodetermine shearandtensionloadcapacities.
ThisRTRdocuments theresultsofthistestingprogramandprovidesamethodforconfirming adequacyoftheleadshelltypeanchor.Testresultsshowthatthetensionloadcapacityoflead"9708070i35 97073iPDRADOCK05000220PPDROSR2582'Wta89>~~qoh')  
~a RTR-2661Page2August15,1989lTTACHMENT CCALCNOoREVISION~<IiFNOtypeanchorsatfailureisbelowthedesignfailureloads(i.e.,fourtimestheB8M).Therefore, thenewlowerallowable loadslistedinTable1shouldbeusedforleadshelltypeanchors.Ifthecalculated loadontheanchorisgreaterthantheTable1load,theanchorstillmaybeadequateproviding itisloadtestedtoprovethatit.iscapableofcarryingtheseismicdemandload.Aregression analysiscorrelation betweentorqueandloadhasbeendeveloped bySRLbasedontestmeasurements andcanbeusedforproofloadtestingthoseleadtypeshellexpansion anchorsthatexceedsthenewlowerallowable (Appendix A).Theanchorboltshouldbetorquedtoinduceatensionloadontheanchorwhichconfirmsitscapacitytocarryitscalculated seismicdemandloadortheBSMdesignallowable load.Thisapproachmayresultinalowerfactorofsafety.Thefactorofsafetyof4wasintendedtoprovideahighlevelofconfidence thattheanchorwillsupportthedesignload.Becausetheanchorswillbeloadtestedtotheseismicdemandordesignallowable load,alowerfactorofsafetyisconsidered acceptable.
TestsalsoshowthattheBSMvaluesforshearloadsareacceptable
.Table1AnchorSize,inches'urrentTensionAllowable Load(BSM)7001200200030005500NewRecommended Allowable
.LoadBasedOnTests60087097012803160ProofTorqueForBSMDesignAllowable, ft-Ib24503769*Applicable onlyforanchorsthathavepassedthetightness torqueperRTR-2582  


RTR-2661Page3August15,1989IgfEFtiF<REWSipgPA()ENOANCEo~1.Themeanmeasuredtensionfailureloadofleadtypeexpansionanchorsislessthan4timesBSM.2.ThenewlowertensionloadcapacitiesofleadtypeexpansionanchorsthatarelistedinTable1shouldbeusedforwalkdowns.3.ThetensionloadonanchorstobeseismicallyqualifiedshouldbecalculatedandshowntobebelowtheTable1values.4.AllleadtypeanchorsshouldbeproofloadedifthecalculatedseismicdemandloadexceedstheloadcapacityistedinTable1orifB8Mallowablesareassumed.5.ThetorquenecessarytoinduceatensionloadoninstalledanchorsshouldbedeterminedfromthecorrelationgiveninFigures8-11atthe95%confidencelevel.6.BSMshearloadcapacitiesareadequate.7.FurtheruseofleadtypeexpansionanchorsatSRSshouldbediscontinued.Leadtypeshellexpansionanchorshavebeenusedinthereactorbuildingstosupportsomesafety-relatedequipment.Aspartoftheseismicupgradework,theadequacyoftheseanchorswasevaluatedusingtheUSIA-46methodology.Thismethodologyisbasedonapplicationofactualearthquakeexperiencedata,testdatacompiledbyEPRI,andotherdataandisusedtoevaluatetheseismicadequacyofcertainclassesofnuclearplantequipment.AnchorageisaddressedbySQVGbutspecificdataonleadtypeexpansionanchorageisnotavailable.AllowableloadsspecifiedinBSMwereoriginallyusedduringthewalkdownsforthepurposeofanchorageevaluation.ThewalkdownsrevealedthatmanyoftheleadanchorswerenotinstalledperBSMandtheactualloadcapacityofleadtypeexpansionanchorswasquestionable.  
RTR-2661Page3August15,1989IgfEFtiF<
REWSipgPA()ENOANCEo~1.Themeanmeasuredtensionfailureloadofleadtypeexpansion anchorsislessthan4timesBSM.2.Thenewlowertensionloadcapacities ofleadtypeexpansion anchorsthatarelistedinTable1shouldbeusedforwalkdowns.
3.Thetensionloadonanchorstobeseismically qualified shouldbecalculated andshowntobebelowtheTable1values.4.Allleadtypeanchorsshouldbeproofloadedifthecalculated seismicdemandloadexceedstheloadcapacityistedinTable1orifB8Mallowables areassumed.5.Thetorquenecessary toinduceatensionloadoninstalled anchorsshouldbedetermined fromthecorrelation giveninFigures8-11atthe95%confidence level.6.BSMshearloadcapacities areadequate.
7.Furtheruseofleadtypeexpansion anchorsatSRSshouldbediscontinued.
Leadtypeshellexpansion anchorshavebeenusedinthereactorbuildings tosupportsomesafety-related equipment.
Aspartoftheseismicupgradework,theadequacyoftheseanchorswasevaluated usingtheUSIA-46methodology.
Thismethodology isbasedonapplication ofactualearthquake experience data,testdatacompiledbyEPRI,andotherdataandisusedtoevaluatetheseismicadequacyofcertainclassesofnuclearplantequipment.
Anchorage isaddressed bySQVGbutspecificdataonleadtypeexpansion anchorage isnotavailable.
Allowable loadsspecified inBSMwereoriginally usedduringthewalkdowns forthepurposeofanchorage evaluation.
Thewalkdowns revealedthatmanyoftheleadanchorswerenotinstalled perBSMandtheactualloadcapacityofleadtypeexpansion anchorswasquestionable.  


RTR-2661Page4August15,1989CALCNOREVISIONPARENOAdcHoRAtotalof107Jeadtypeanchorscovering5anchorsizeswereloadtestedtofailureintensionand36anchors,3sizes,weretestedtofailureinshearperSP2449.Basedonthetestresults,newlowerallowableloadsfortensionweredeterminedand-arelistedinTable2.TheshearfailureloadsexceededthosepredictedbyB8Mandtherefore,theB8Mvalueswereretained.Theleadtypeexpansionanchorsexhibitedpoorloadperformanceintensionasevidencedbyawidevariationinfailureloads.Becauseofthispoortensionperformance,itisconcludedthatfurtheruseofleadtypeexpansionanchorsshouldbediscontinuedatSRS.TestswereperformedunderSpecialProcedure2449onabandonedleadtypeexpansionanchorsinSRSReactorAreas.Thefollowingconditionswereprerequisitestotesting:-Anchordidnotpulloutorbecomeloosewhensubjectedtoatightnesstorqueofapproximately20%oftheinstallationtorque.-Perpendicularityoftheanchorwiththewallwaslessthan5degreesoffset.-Anchorlocationwasgreaterthan10diametersfromthenextloadedanchororaconcreteedge.Becauseofthelimitednumberofavailableanchors,someanchorscloserthan10diameterstothenextabandonedanchorwereused,Thetestwasconsideredacceptableifconcretespallingdidnotprotrudeintotheareaoftheadjacentanchor.Also,someexpansionanchorsweretestedifpartofthethreadedshellwasabovetheconcretesurfacebutalloftheleadringthatsecurestheanchortotheconcretewasbelowthefaceoftheconcrete.Inthiscase,ametalspacerwasusedtoprovideagapbetweenthebaseplateandanchorduringthetightnesstorque.TETPThetestsetupisshowninFigure1.Ahydraulicramwasusedtoapplyaloadtotheanchorfortensiontests.Astudrodwitha  
RTR-2661Page4August15,1989CALCNOREVISIONPARENOAdcHoRAtotalof107Jeadtypeanchorscovering5anchorsizeswereloadtestedtofailureintensionand36anchors,3sizes,weretestedtofailureinshearperSP2449.Basedonthetestresults,newlowerallowable loadsfortensionweredetermined and-arelistedinTable2.Theshearfailureloadsexceededthosepredicted byB8Mandtherefore, theB8Mvalueswereretained.
Theleadtypeexpansion anchorsexhibited poorloadperformance intensionasevidenced byawidevariation infailureloads.Becauseofthispoortensionperformance, itisconcluded thatfurtheruseofleadtypeexpansion anchorsshouldbediscontinued atSRS.Testswereperformed underSpecialProcedure 2449onabandoned leadtypeexpansion anchorsinSRSReactorAreas.Thefollowing conditions wereprerequisites totesting:-Anchordidnotpulloutorbecomeloosewhensubjected toatightness torqueofapproximately 20%oftheinstallation torque.-Perpendicularity oftheanchorwiththewallwaslessthan5degreesoffset.-Anchorlocationwasgreaterthan10diameters fromthenextloadedanchororaconcreteedge.Becauseofthelimitednumberofavailable anchors,someanchorscloserthan10diameters tothenextabandoned anchorwereused,Thetestwasconsidered acceptable ifconcretespallingdidnotprotrudeintotheareaoftheadjacentanchor.Also,someexpansion anchorsweretestedifpartofthethreadedshellwasabovetheconcretesurfacebutalloftheleadringthatsecurestheanchortotheconcretewasbelowthefaceoftheconcrete.
Inthiscase,ametalspacerwasusedtoprovideagapbetweenthebaseplateandanchorduringthetightness torque.TETPThetestsetupisshowninFigure1.Ahydraulic ramwasusedtoapplyaloadtotheanchorfortensiontests.Astudrodwitha  


RTR-2661.Page5August15,1989NCHosdoublenutononeendwasinsertedthroughtheboreoftheramandscrewedintotAeanchoraboutonediameter.Thentheramwasusedtoapplyaloadapproximately325lbstotheanchor.Allsubsequentloadswereappliedtotheanchorbytorquingtheautandmeasuringtheresistingloadonthehydraulicramthatistransmitted.totheanchor.Boththetorqueandtheloadwererecordedinstepincrementsuntilfailure.Forsheartests,aspecialshearplateassemblywasmade(Figure1).Aboltwasinsertedthroughtheshearplateassemblyintotheanchor.Thehydraulicramwasthenplacedundertheshearplateassemblytopushtheshearplateupward.Theresistingpressureatfailurewasrecorded.Bothtensionandshearloadcapacities(Table2)forleadtypeexpansionanchorsweredetermined.Themeanmeasuredtensionloadsatfailurewereallbelowtheexpectedfailureloads(i.e.,B8Mx4).Therefore,newlowerdesignallowableloadsarerecommendedwhichincludesafactorofsafetyof4.Atightnesstorquewasappliedtoscreenoutpoorlyinstalledanchorsduringwalkdownsandwasalsoappliedduringthesetests.Anchorsthatfailedthetightnesstorquewerenotloadtested.Thus,thenewlowerrecommendedvaluesareapplicabletoanchorsthathavebeenscreened(i.e.,passedthetightnesstorque).Additionally,aspartofthewalkdowneffort,calculationsshouldbeperformedforallleadshelltypeanchorstoshowthattheseismicdemandloadisequalorbelowthenewlowerrecommendedloads.Iftheseismicdemandloadexceedsthenewrecommendedvalue,theanchormaystillbeadequateprovidingtheanchorboltistorquedtoaproofload.Theinducedproofloadwillconfirmwhethertheanchorcancarryitscalculatedseismicdemandload.MostpipesatSRSwasdesignedtoANSIStandardB31.1usingB8Manchorageallowables.PipesdesigntoANSIB31.1hasproventobeseismicallyruggedbasedonearthquakeexperiencedata.Therefore,ifseismicqualificationofSRSpipingisaccomplishedbyevaluating'heas-builtconditionagainstANSIB31.1(i.e.,noloadcalculations),thenB8Mallowablesmustbeassumed,andtheanchorboltsmustbe  
RTR-2661.Page5August15,1989NCHosdoublenutononeendwasinsertedthroughtheboreoftheramandscrewedintotAeanchoraboutonediameter.
Thentheramwasusedtoapplyaloadapproximately 325lbstotheanchor.Allsubsequent loadswereappliedtotheanchorbytorquingtheautandmeasuring theresisting loadonthehydraulic ramthatistransmitted.to theanchor.Boththetorqueandtheloadwererecordedinstepincrements untilfailure.Forsheartests,aspecialshearplateassemblywasmade(Figure1).Aboltwasinsertedthroughtheshearplateassemblyintotheanchor.Thehydraulic ramwasthenplacedundertheshearplateassemblytopushtheshearplateupward.Theresisting pressureatfailurewasrecorded.
Bothtensionandshearloadcapacities (Table2)forleadtypeexpansion anchorsweredetermined.
Themeanmeasuredtensionloadsatfailurewereallbelowtheexpectedfailureloads(i.e.,B8Mx4).Therefore, newlowerdesignallowable loadsarerecommended whichincludesafactorofsafetyof4.Atightness torquewasappliedtoscreenoutpoorlyinstalled anchorsduringwalkdowns andwasalsoappliedduringthesetests.Anchorsthatfailedthetightness torquewerenotloadtested.Thus,thenewlowerrecommended valuesareapplicable toanchorsthathavebeenscreened(i.e.,passedthetightness torque).Additionally, aspartofthewalkdowneffort,calculations shouldbeperformed forallleadshelltypeanchorstoshowthattheseismicdemandloadisequalorbelowthenewlowerrecommended loads.Iftheseismicdemandloadexceedsthenewrecommended value,theanchormaystillbeadequateproviding theanchorboltistorquedtoaproofload.Theinducedproofloadwillconfirmwhethertheanchorcancarryitscalculated seismicdemandload.MostpipesatSRSwasdesignedtoANSIStandardB31.1usingB8Manchorage allowables.
PipesdesigntoANSIB31.1hasproventobeseismically ruggedbasedonearthquake experience data.Therefore, ifseismicqualification ofSRSpipingisaccomplished byevaluating
'heas-builtcondition againstANSIB31.1(i.e.,noloadcalculations),
thenB8Mallowables mustbeassumed,andtheanchorboltsmustbe  


RTR-2661.Page6August15,1989ATTACHMENTCALCNOprooftorquedtoinducedtheBSMdesignallowableload.lnthiscase,onlyonetorquetest(notightnesstorque)wouldberequiredandcalculationoftheanchorloadwouldnotbenecessary.SQUGmethodology.permitsafactorofsafetyof2fornon-shelltypeanchorsbutrequiresafactorofsafetyof4fortheshelltypeanchor.However,thisproposedprogramrequires100/overification.ofstrengthofthoseleadshelltypeanchorsthatexceedthenewlowerrecommendedloadsorifB8Mallowablesareassumedbyperformingatorquetest.Thetorquetobeappliedshouldbeselectedbasedonthelowerbound95%confidencecurve(Figures8-11)andwillinduceanequivalentmeanloadontheanchorofapproximately1.5timestheseismicdemandload.Thus,theSQUGrequirementofachievinga95%confidencelevelthattherearenomorethan5%nonconforminganchorsismet.TheBSMshearloadallowableswillberdtainedbecausethemeasuredshearloadcapacities(Table2)exceededtheB8Mfailurevalues.Sheartestsofthe3/4"and1"anchorswasnotperformedbecauseno.suitableanchorscouldbefound.Table2LeadShellExpansionAnchorsAnchorSize,inchesTensionTestsNumberofTestsB8MDesignAllowabeLoadFailureLoadPerB8M'eanMeasuredFailureLoadNewRecommendedAllowableLoadTorqueBasedOnB8MDesignAllowableLoad,ft-IbShearTestsNumberofTestsB8MAllowableFailureLoadPerB8MMeanMeasuredFailureLoad35341710970012002000300055002800480080001200022000262337464456587014058600880970128031602437506916128400800140020003500160032005600800014000279657367934
RTR-2661.Page6August15,1989ATTACHMENT CALCNOprooftorquedtoinducedtheBSMdesignallowable load.lnthiscase,onlyonetorquetest(notightness torque)wouldberequiredandcalculation oftheanchorloadwouldnotbenecessary.
SQUGmethodology.
permitsafactorofsafetyof2fornon-shell typeanchorsbutrequiresafactorofsafetyof4fortheshelltypeanchor.However,thisproposedprogramrequires100/overification.
ofstrengthofthoseleadshelltypeanchorsthatexceedthenewlowerrecommended loadsorifB8Mallowables areassumedbyperforming atorquetest.Thetorquetobeappliedshouldbeselectedbasedonthelowerbound95%confidence curve(Figures8-11)andwillinduceanequivalent meanloadontheanchorofapproximately1.5 timestheseismicdemandload.Thus,theSQUGrequirement ofachieving a95%confidence levelthattherearenomorethan5%nonconforming anchorsismet.TheBSMshearloadallowables willberdtainedbecausethemeasuredshearloadcapacities (Table2)exceededtheB8Mfailurevalues.Sheartestsofthe3/4"and1"anchorswasnotperformed becauseno.suitable anchorscouldbefound.Table2LeadShellExpansion AnchorsAnchorSize,inchesTensionTestsNumberofTestsB8MDesignAllowabeLoadFailureLoadPerB8M'eanMeasuredFailureLoadNewRecommended Allowable LoadTorqueBasedOnB8MDesignAllowable Load,ft-IbShearTestsNumberofTestsB8MAllowable FailureLoadPerB8MMeanMeasuredFailureLoad35341710970012002000300055002800480080001200022000262337464456587014058600880970128031602437506916128400800140020003500160032005600800014000279657367934


RTR-2661Page7August15,1989ATTACHMENTCALCNO.OPAGENODANLThenewlowerrecommendedallowableloadsarebasedonthemeanloadmeasuredatfailureforthesamplepopulationtested.Themean(i.e.,samplemean)wasthenstatisticallyadjustedtoobtainatruemeanloadatthe95%confidenceinterval.ThefailureloaddistributionwasassumedtobeGaussian.TheallowableloadslistedinTable2providesforafactorofsafetyof4.Forloadsexceedingthenewlowerrecommendedloads,torquetestsmaybeperformedtodetermineanchoradequacy.Aleast-squaresregressionanalysiscorrelationsbetweentorqueandloadatthe95%confidencelevelweretabulatedbySRL(AppendixA)andhavebeenplottedonFigures8-11.Thetorquetobeappliedshouldbeselectedbasedonthelower95%confidenceboundcurveandwillinduceanequivalentmeantoadontheanchorofapproximately1.5timestheseismicdemandortheB8Mload.Also,thetorquetobe'appliedshouldnotbeextrapolatedbeyondtherangeofthe95%confidencelines.TENINTETensiontestswereperformedinP,L,KandRreactorbuildingsforfivedifferentsizesofleadshellexpansionanchors.Thesetestswereperformedinmanydifferentlocationsofthereactorbuilding:0level,-20and-40cleanareasandradiationzones.Atotalof107tensiontestswereperformed(AppendixB).Fewertestswereperformedforthe5/8,3/4and1inchanchorsbecauseofthelowavailabilityofanchors.Someanchorswereloadtestedwithouttorquingbecausetheanchorswerecrossthreaded.All1-inchanchorswerefoundatthefloorlevelandcontainedexcessiveamountsofrust,thereforethetorquetoloadrelationshipwasnotdeveloped.Testsshowedawidevariationintensionloadcapacities(Figures2-7)foreachanchorsize,reactorarea,andmodeoffailure.Thiswidevariationmaybeexpectedbecausetheholdingcapacityoftheanchorislargelydeterminedbythecorrectholesizeandcompactingoftheleadringbetweentheconcreteandthethreadedshell.Theamount  
RTR-2661Page7August15,1989ATTACHMENT CALCNO.OPAGENODANLThenewlowerrecommended allowable loadsarebasedonthemeanloadmeasuredatfailureforthesamplepopulation tested.Themean(i.e.,samplemean)wasthenstatistically adjustedtoobtainatruemeanloadatthe95%confidence interval.
Thefailureloaddistribution wasassumedtobeGaussian.
Theallowable loadslistedinTable2providesforafactorofsafetyof4.Forloadsexceeding thenewlowerrecommended loads,torquetestsmaybeperformed todetermine anchoradequacy.
Aleast-squares regression analysiscorrelations betweentorqueandloadatthe95%confidence levelweretabulated bySRL(Appendix A)andhavebeenplottedonFigures8-11.Thetorquetobeappliedshouldbeselectedbasedonthelower95%confidence boundcurveandwillinduceanequivalent meantoadontheanchorofapproximately 1.5timestheseismicdemandortheB8Mload.Also,thetorquetobe'applied shouldnotbeextrapolated beyondtherangeofthe95%confidence lines.TENINTETensiontestswereperformed inP,L,KandRreactorbuildings forfivedifferent sizesofleadshellexpansion anchors.Thesetestswereperformed inmanydifferent locations ofthereactorbuilding:
0level,-20and-40cleanareasandradiation zones.Atotalof107tensiontestswereperformed (Appendix B).Fewertestswereperformed forthe5/8,3/4and1inchanchorsbecauseofthelowavailability ofanchors.Someanchorswereloadtestedwithouttorquingbecausetheanchorswerecrossthreaded.
All1-inchanchorswerefoundatthefloorlevelandcontained excessive amountsofrust,therefore thetorquetoloadrelationship wasnotdeveloped.
Testsshowedawidevariation intensionloadcapacities (Figures2-7)foreachanchorsize,reactorarea,andmodeoffailure.Thiswidevariation maybeexpectedbecausetheholdingcapacityoftheanchorislargelydetermined bythecorrectholesizeandcompacting oftheleadringbetweentheconcreteandthethreadedshell.Theamount  


RTR-2661Page8August15,1989ATTACHMENTPAGENOC.5offorcefore~uringadequatecompactingoftheleadwasprobablynotspecifiedduringtheoriginalinstallation.Approximately7%oftheanchorsfailedduetoconefailureaftheconcrete.Someofthefailures(22%)wereduetoacombinationofaconcretefailure(i.e.,concreteconedidnotpenetratetobottomofanchor)andslippageoftheanchoroutofthehole.Another22%'oftheanchorsfailedbecausethenon-leadportionoftheanchorbroke.Thelargestportion(47%)oftheanchorsfailedbecauseofslippage(i.e.,theanchorwaspulledoutofitsholewithoutspalling).About40%oftheslipfailureswereduetopoorinstallation(i.e.,noconcretespallingorsignificantgallingoftheleadsleevewasapparentindicatinganoversizedholeorinsufficientpackingoftheleadsleeve).Nearlyallofthe3/4inchanchorswerenotinstalledperB8M.Inspectionoftheanchorsafterpulloutshowedthatinmostcasesonlyoneofthemultiplestackedunitsprovidedsupport.Alistoftheanchorsthatfailedthetightnesstests(allturnedinholeexcept1anchorwhichwastorquedagainstbaseplate)ortheperpendicularityrequirementswasnotkeptbutitisestimatedthatabout10'-15%oftheanchorstestedwererejectedbasedonthoserequirements.ETEDatawasalsocollectedtodeterminethecorrelationbetweentorqueandloadforthe3/8,1/2,5/8,andthe3/4inchanchors.Regressionanalysiscurvefits(Figures8-12)weremadeforeachsizeanchorandshowagoodcorrelationbetweenmeantorqueandload.Also,agoodlinearcorrelationbetweenthemeanfailureloadandboltdiameterwasdetermined.Thelowerbound95%confidencelines.for-torqueandloadarealsopottedonFigures8-11basedonSRLanalysis.TorquetestsshouldbeusedtodemonstrateanchorinstallationadequacyfortheB8Mdesignallowablesoriftheseismicdemandloadiscalculatedandexceedsthenewlowerallowables(applicabletoKandLareasonly).ThetorquesselectedfromtheFiguresforloadtestingtheanchorshouldbebasedonthe95%confidencelinesandwillmettheSQUGrequirementthattherearenomorethan5%nonconforminganchors.Widevariationintorqueatanyspecificloadwasalsoexperienced.Torquevalues..differbecauseofperpendicularityoftheanchorwiththewall.Thistypeofinstallationwouldcausetheramtopullthe
RTR-2661Page8August15,1989ATTACHMENT PAGENOC.5offorcefore~uringadequatecompacting oftheleadwasprobablynotspecified duringtheoriginalinstallation.
Approximately 7%oftheanchorsfailedduetoconefailureaftheconcrete.
Someofthefailures(22%)wereduetoacombination ofaconcretefailure(i.e.,concreteconedidnotpenetrate tobottomofanchor)andslippageoftheanchoroutofthehole.Another22%'oftheanchorsfailedbecausethenon-leadportionoftheanchorbroke.Thelargestportion(47%)oftheanchorsfailedbecauseofslippage(i.e.,theanchorwaspulledoutofitsholewithoutspalling).
About40%oftheslipfailureswereduetopoorinstallation (i.e.,noconcretespallingorsignificant gallingoftheleadsleevewasapparentindicating anoversized holeorinsufficient packingoftheleadsleeve).Nearlyallofthe3/4inchanchorswerenotinstalled perB8M.Inspection oftheanchorsafterpulloutshowedthatinmostcasesonlyoneofthemultiplestackedunitsprovidedsupport.Alistoftheanchorsthatfailedthetightness tests(allturnedinholeexcept1anchorwhichwastorquedagainstbaseplate)ortheperpendicularity requirements wasnotkeptbutitisestimated thatabout10'-15%oftheanchorstestedwererejectedbasedonthoserequirements.
ETEDatawasalsocollected todetermine thecorrelation betweentorqueandloadforthe3/8,1/2,5/8,andthe3/4inchanchors.Regression analysiscurvefits(Figures8-12)weremadeforeachsizeanchorandshowagoodcorrelation betweenmeantorqueandload.Also,agoodlinearcorrelation betweenthemeanfailureloadandboltdiameterwasdetermined.
Thelowerbound95%confidence lines.for-torqueandloadarealsopottedonFigures8-11basedonSRLanalysis.
Torquetestsshouldbeusedtodemonstrate anchorinstallation adequacyfortheB8Mdesignallowables oriftheseismicdemandloadiscalculated andexceedsthenewlowerallowables (applicable toKandLareasonly).ThetorquesselectedfromtheFiguresforloadtestingtheanchorshouldbebasedonthe95%confidence linesandwillmettheSQUGrequirement thattherearenomorethan5%nonconforming anchors.Widevariation intorqueatanyspecificloadwasalsoexperienced.
Torquevalues..differ becauseofperpendicularity oftheanchorwiththewall.Thistypeofinstallation wouldcausetheramtopullthe


RTR-2661'age9August15,1989cl3KC9..~eHoRanchoroutatynangleandwouldyieldanincreasedtorquevalue.Also,someboltsdonotfittightintheanchoruntiltorquedagainstthebaseplate(i.e.,threadcontactbetweenboltandanchorisnottight).Insomecasesthiscouldallowtheramto-bemountedwithsomeoffsetfromperpendicularity.Additionally,theconcretewallwasvisiblynotflatinsomelocationswhichwouldallowtheramtopullthe.anchoratanangleyieldinghighertorques.Allofthesevariablescouldresultindifferenttorquevaluesforthesameload.SheartestingwasperformedonlyinRReactorArea.However,tensiontestsshowednosignificantvariationinfailureloadcapacitiesasafunctionofreactorarea(Figure12).Thusthesheartestsareexpectedtoberepresentativeofallreactorareas.Themeanmeasuredshearloadwasdeterminedforthreedifferentsizeanchors(Figure13,14)basedontheresultsof36differenttests.Testswerenotperformedonthe3/4and1inchanchorsbecausenonecouldbefound.Themeanmeasuredshearloadsat'ailurewere50to74%greaterthanfailureloadsindicatedinBSM.Onlyoneofthe32anchorstestedfailedataloadslightlylessthantheBSMvaluetimes4(Figure14).  
RTR-2661'age9August15,1989cl3KC9..~eHoRanchoroutatynangleandwouldyieldanincreased torquevalue.Also,someboltsdonotfittightintheanchoruntiltorquedagainstthebaseplate(i.e.,threadcontactbetweenboltandanchorisnottight).Insomecasesthiscouldallowtheramto-bemountedwithsomeoffsetfromperpendicularity.
Additionally, theconcretewallwasvisiblynotflatinsomelocations whichwouldallowtheramtopullthe.anchoratanangleyieldinghighertorques.Allofthesevariables couldresultindifferent torquevaluesforthesameload.Sheartestingwasperformed onlyinRReactorArea.However,tensiontestsshowednosignificant variation infailureloadcapacities asafunctionofreactorarea(Figure12).Thusthesheartestsareexpectedtoberepresentative ofallreactorareas.Themeanmeasuredshearloadwasdetermined forthreedifferent sizeanchors(Figure13,14)basedontheresultsof36different tests.Testswerenotperformed onthe3/4and1inchanchorsbecausenonecouldbefound.Themeanmeasuredshearloadsat'ailurewere50to74%greaterthanfailureloadsindicated inBSM.Onlyoneofthe32anchorstestedfailedataloadslightlylessthantheBSMvaluetimes4(Figure14).  


FIGUREIATTACHMQfCALCNOREVISIONPAGENOT0GUURESSUREGAUGEANCHORTORQUENUTIIIIIIHYDRAULICRANANCHORHEARASSENBLYPRESSUREGUAGEHYDRAULICRAN
FIGUREIATTACHMQf CALCNOREVISIONPAGENOT0GUURESSUREGAUGEANCHORTORQUENUTIIIIIIHYDRAULIC RANANCHORHEARASSENBLYPRESSUREGUAGEHYDRAULIC RAN


ATTACHMENT."""~NO.CJ1FAILURELOADScMODETENSIONTEST3/8"ANCHOR60005000A-ANCHORFAILUREC-COteaETEVAILURES-SUPFAILUREB-S8CFAIURE4000ClC03000MEANw2623AASSSSSSSSSACBSSSSSACSSAASBBSSASAASFA1LUREMODEF1QURE2
ATTACHMENT
."""~NO.CJ1FAILURELOADScMODETENSIONTEST3/8"ANCHOR60005000A-ANCHORFAILUREC-COteaETE VAILURES-SUPFAILUREB-S8CFAIURE4000ClC03000MEANw2623AASSSSSSSSSACBSSSSSACSSAASBBSSASAAS FA1LUREMODEF1QURE2


FAtLURELOAD8cMODETENSlONTESTS0/2"ANCHORCAI.CNOCJZ80006000A-ANCHORFAILUREC-CONCRETEFAILURES-SLIPFAILURE8-S8CFAILURE4000MEAN~37462000ASSSASSSSSSSSSSSASBBBASBBCSCCAAAASFAILUREMOOEFIGURE3
FAtLURELOAD8cMODETENSlONTESTS0/2"ANCHORCAI.CNOCJZ80006000A-ANCHORFAILUREC-CONCRETEFAILURES-SLIPFAILURE8-S8CFAILURE4000MEAN~3746 2000ASSSASSSSSSSSSSSASBBBASBBCSCCAAAAS FAILUREMOOEFIGURE3


CAl.CNOFAlLURELOAD5,MODETENStONTEST6/8"ANCHOR12000100008000A-ANCHORFA1LUREC-CONCRETEFAlLURES-SLlPFA1LURECS-S8CFAlLURE4000MEANa4456CSSASCSCSCSSSASCSCSCSAFAILUREQQM~ROURE4  
CAl.CNOFAlLURELOAD5,MODETENStONTEST6/8"ANCHOR12000100008000A-ANCHORFA1LUREC-CONCRETEFAlLURES-SLlPFA1LURECS-S8CFAlLURE4000MEANa4456 CSSASCSCSCSSSASCSCSCSAFAILUREQQM~ROURE4  


ATTACHMENTCALGNDllDriSiONOFAILURELOAD5MODETENSIONTEST3/4"ANCHORA-ANCHORFAlLURES-SLlPFAlLUREC-CONCRETEFAlLUREMEANa5870SCSSSAASSAFAILUREMODEFlOUAEI  
ATTACHMENT CALGNDllDriSiON OFAILURELOAD5MODETENSIONTEST3/4"ANCHORA-ANCHORFAlLURES-SLlPFAlLUREC-CONCRETEFAlLUREMEANa5870SCSSSAASSAFAILUREMODEFlOUAEI  


ATTACHMENTCALCNOO~REVISIONnouZMeHoP-MEANFAILURELOADTENSIONTEST3/8,1/2,6/8,&3/4ANCHORS70006000CltCOItl4000O3000.0.3750.'50.6250.75ANCKOROIAMETER(IN.)FIGURE6  
ATTACHMENT CALCNOO~REVISIONnouZMeHoP-MEANFAILURELOADTENSIONTEST3/8,1/2,6/8,&3/4ANCHORS70006000CltCOItl4000O3000.0.3750.'50.6250.75ANCKOROIAMETER(IN.)FIGURE6  


CALCNO>AGFNOMEANFAILURELOADVS.ANCHORSIZETENSIONTESTy~-529.20+8360.8xR"2~0.985Ol4000NCI03000z20000.0000.$250.2500.3750.5000.6250.750ANCHORSEEFtQURE7  
CALCNO>AGFNOMEANFAILURELOADVS.ANCHORSIZETENSIONTESTy~-529.20+8360.8xR"2~0.985Ol4000NCI03000z20000.0000.$250.2500.3750.5000.6250.750ANCHORSEEFtQURE7  
Line 50: Line 91:
TORQUEVSLOADTENSIONTEST3/8"ANCHORcPAGENO6000500040003000Q020001000SPYeLOWERCONFSENBOuWO)ya-798+64.86x020406080TORQUE(FT-LB)FIGURE8  
TORQUEVSLOADTENSIONTEST3/8"ANCHORcPAGENO6000500040003000Q020001000SPYeLOWERCONFSENBOuWO)ya-798+64.86x020406080TORQUE(FT-LB)FIGURE8  


ATTACHMENTCAI.CNOREVISIONPAGENOC.l-HopTORQUEVSLOADTENSIONTESTS1/2"ANCHOR700060005000400088~8830002000mmaBmGQ1000y~-1002+60.31x0020406080100TOROUF.(FT-l.B)FlGURE9  
ATTACHMENT CAI.CNOREVISIONPAGENOC.l-HopTORQUEVSLOADTENSIONTESTS1/2"ANCHOR700060005000400088~8830002000mmaBmGQ1000y~-1002+60.31x0020406080100TOROUF.(FT-l.B)FlGURE9  


TORQUEVSLOADTENSlONTEST5/8"ANCHORATTACHMENTCAI.CNOo.REVISIONdPAGENO1000080006000400020009P/eLOWERCONFIDBOUNDIy~-1602+73.08x20406080100120140TORQUE(FT-LB)FIGURE10  
TORQUEVSLOADTENSlONTEST5/8"ANCHORATTACHMENT CAI.CNOo.REVISIONdPAGENO1000080006000400020009P/eLOWERCONFIDBOUNDIy~-1602+73.08x20406080100120140TORQUE(FT-LB)FIGURE10  


TORQUEVSLOADTENSIONTESTSia-ANCHORATTACHMENTveHo&REVISIONOOopticpet2d1000080004000200095YeLOWERCONFIDENCEBOUNDY~-2147+?5.2XTHISCORRELATIONEXCEEDSTHE95'loLEYELBY10FT-LBTOPERMITLOADTESTTO-1.5x20406080,100120140TORQUEFT-LBFIGURE11  
TORQUEVSLOADTENSIONTESTSia-ANCHORATTACHMENT veHo&REVISIONOOopticpet2d1000080004000200095YeLOWERCONFIDENCE BOUNDY~-2147+?5.2XTHISCORRELATION EXCEEDSTHE95'loLEYELBY10FT-LBTOPERMITLOADTESTTO-1.5x20406080,100120140TORQUEFT-LBFIGURE11  


CGDZDEATTACHMENICCALCNOREVISIONPAGENOMEANFAILURELOADTENSIONTESTANCHORSIZE&REACTORAREA3/4-K58715/8-ALL44565/8.R47045/8'1001/2-ALL1/2-FIxILINCOlLO1/2-P1/2-L1/2-K3722323726233/S-R23213/S-L3108284201000200030004000500060007000MEANFAILURELOAO(LB)FIGURE12  
CGDZDEATTACHMENI CCALCNOREVISIONPAGENOMEANFAILURELOADTENSIONTESTANCHORSIZE&REACTORAREA3/4-K58715/8-ALL44565/8.R47045/8'1001/2-ALL1/2-FIxILINCOlLO1/2-P1/2-L1/2-K3722323726233/S-R23213/S-L3108284201000200030004000500060007000MEANFAILURELOAO(LB)FIGURE12  


REVISIONPAOFNOC~MEANFAILURELOADSHEARTEST3/8,0/2,&5/8ANCHORS100008000OilhIACJIA40002000'00.3750.50.625ANCHORDIAM.(IN.)FIGURE13  
REVISIONPAOFNOC~MEANFAILURELOADSHEARTEST3/8,0/2,&5/8ANCHORS100008000OilhIACJIA40002000'00.3750.50.625ANCHORDIAM.(IN.)FIGURE13  


ATTACHMENTCALCNOREVISIONooPAGENQSHEARFAILURELOAD12000MEANMEASUREDMEANPERBSMs/s1/2'NCHORSIZE(INCH)FIGURE14.3/8'  
ATTACHMENT CALCNOREVISIONooPAGENQSHEARFAILURELOAD12000MEANMEASUREDMEANPERBSMs/s1/2'NCHOR SIZE(INCH)FIGURE14.3/8'  


NiagaraMohawkPowerCorporationNineMilePointNuciearStation,UnitNo.1In-StructureResponseSpectraExcitationSSE(NUREG/CR-0098,PGAof0.13G)BUILDING:ReactorELEVATION:259'OW/COL:LA8DAMPING:5%MODELNODE:582.01.56C01.0II+IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIee/IJgeIIII~II~/IerII~/I.,j/jltlIIIII~l'll'ell'el'llIel"4I,feIIIIIIILIIII~IrIIIIIIIIIIIt'IIIIIrrIIIIII~ee~I//ILIIII1IIIIIII'IIIIII~~---e.~t-I~III~IeIII~IIIIIIII'tI1.5xBoundingSpectrum------North/South---East/WestIIIIIIIt---vIILIIIIr--"~ILJIIIIII---rILIIII.II-r-ILII1IIIILLIIIIILIIIII,IIIIiIIIII~I~III'IIIIIIIIIIIIIrIIIIII4IIIIIIIIIIIIII--.D(RECT(ON"IIIIIIIIIIII0.5I~/----r'-Ie/Ie/e/I'.IIrIIIIIItIIIJILIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJIIIIIIIIILLIIIILIIIIIII.IIII'III~eII'IIIItIIIII'tJ'tIJII'lIIIIIIIIIILI""r"--~lae--IILIIIII-t---r---II001020Frequency(Hz)30aW40m~I-eZom  
NiagaraMohawkPowerCorporation NineMilePointNuciearStation,UnitNo.1In-Structure ResponseSpectraExcitation SSE(NUREG/CR-0098, PGAof0.13G)BUILDING:
ReactorELEVATION:
259'OW/COL:
LA8DAMPING:5%MODELNODE:582.01.56C01.0II+IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIee/IJgeIIII~II~/IerII~/I.,j/jltlIIIII~l'll'ell'el'llIel"4I,feIIIIIIILIIII~IrIIIIIIIIIIIt'IIIIIrrIIIIII~ee~I//ILIIII1IIIIIII'IIIIII~~---e.~t-I~III~IeIII~IIIIIIII'tI1.5xBoundingSpectrum------North/South
---East/West IIIIIIIt---vIILIIIIr--"~ILJIIIIII---rILIIII.II-r-ILII1IIIILLIIIIILIIIII,IIIIiIIIII~I~III'IIIIIIIIIIIIIrIIIIII4IIIIIIIIIIIIII--.D(RECT(ON" IIIIIIIIIIII0.5I~/----r'-Ie/Ie/e/I'.IIrIIIIIItIIIJILIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJIIIIIIIIILLIIIILIIIIIII.IIII'III~eII'IIIItIIIII'tJ'tIJII'lIIIIIIIIIILI""r"--~lae--IILIIIII-t---r---II001020Frequency(Hz) 30aW40m~I-eZom  


NineMilePointUnit1AQ6BoundingSpectrumVs.SSEPlot0)C00.1QtDO0.01IIIIIJTTIIII+IItTIIIIIIIIIIIIIJIIIIIIIIIIII-rarI4I--LJIIII8IIIIIIIIIIL4IIIIIIII-4IIIIIIIIIILJ-I-IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJIIIIIIIIIIILJLIiC'IiIItIIILJLIIIIIIr1iIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIrorTIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIQIi'I1ITTIIIIgiIIIIIIIIIIIITI1IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII+9IHIIIIIIIrarIIIIIIIIIII4IIIIIII4IIIIIIIIL4I-IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIILJIIIIIIIIIIIIIILJIIIIIIIIIIIJ.IIIIIIT1IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIITIIIIIIIIIIIIIIILJIIIIII-r-i--IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIrIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII44I4IIII1II'IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIL.IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII1IIIILI4IIIIIaIII4IIIIIIIIIIIIIL2I--JIIIIIIIIM~IIIsrIIIIIIIIIII.IIIIIIIIIiIIIIIIP1SSEi"JLJJLI-LIIIIIIIIIIIIIII--w-a-tw-rIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJLJJLILIIIIIIIIIIIII11TiIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII---a---i--1-1-r-i-rIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII/IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIBhund@~Spectrum""0.1Frequency(Hz)10100UWTtlWcOril}}
NineMilePointUnit1AQ6BoundingSpectrumVs.SSEPlot0)C00.1QtDO0.01IIIIIJTTIIII+IItTIIIIIIIIIIIIIJIIIIIIIIIIII-rarI4I--LJIIII8IIIIIIIIIIL4IIIIIIII-4IIIIIIIIIILJ-I-IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJIIIIIIIIIIILJLIiC'IiIItIIILJLIIIIIIr1iIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIrorTIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIQIi'I1ITTIIIIgiIIIIIIIIIIIITI1IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII+9IHIIIIIIIrarIIIIIIIIIII4IIIIIII4IIIIIIIIL4I-IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIILJIIIIIIIIIIIIIILJIIIIIIIIIIIJ.IIIIIIT1IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIITIIIIIIIIIIIIIIILJIIIIII-r-i--IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIrIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII44I4IIII1II'IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIL.IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII1IIIILI4IIIIIaIII4IIIIIIIIIIIIIL2I--JIIIIIIIIM~IIIsrIIIIIIIIIII.IIIIIIIIIiIIIIIIP1SSEi"JLJJLI-LIIIIIIIIIIIIIII--w-a-tw-rIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJLJJLILIIIIIIIIIIIII11TiIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII---a---i--1-1
-r-i-rIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII/IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIBhund@~Spectrum" "0.1Frequency (Hz)10100UWTtlWcOril}}

Revision as of 21:53, 29 June 2018

Lead Expansion Anchor Load Capacity in Reactor Buildings at Savannah River Site, Rev 0
ML17059B664
Person / Time
Site: Nine Mile Point 
Issue date: 08/15/1989
From: BRYANT E L
WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC COMPANY, DIV OF CBS CORP.
To:
Shared Package
ML17059B657 List:
References
C.0SQUGANCHOR-R, C0.0SQUGANCHOR-R00, CO.0SQUGANCHOR, CO.SQUGANCHOR, RTR-2661, NUDOCS 9708070135
Download: ML17059B664 (50)


Text

Westinghouse SavannahRiverCompanyATTACHMENT IA@AmtCALONOREVISIONPAGENOP.O.Ai.28802RTR-2661August15,1989TO:S.D.CurryFROM:E.L.Bryant,$WLEADEXPANIANRLADIT~INREATBILDINGATTHEVANNHVERIINTRDTlNWalkdowns todetermine theseismicadequacyofselectedsafetysystemshavebeenperformed forLandKreactorsutilizing theUnresolved SafetyIssue(USI)A-46methodology sponsored bytheSeismicQualification UtilityGroup(SQUG).Actualexperience datafromearthquakes, testdatacompiledbytheElectricPowerResearchInstitute (EPRI),andotherdataforcertainclassesofnuclearplantequipment makeuptheSQUGdatabase.Anchorage isalsoaddressed intheUSIA-46methodology.

However,leadexpansion anchorsarenotincluded.

Somesafetyrelatedequipment intheSavannahRiverSite(SRS)reactorbuildings issupported byleadexpansion anchors.Designloadcapacitywasbasedontheallowable loadslistedinSRSStandardB8Mwhichwasintendedtoprovidedafactorofsafetyof4.However,walkdowns haverevealedthatsomeleadanchorsarenotinstalled perB8M,andtherefore theactualloadcapacityoftheseanchorsmaybelessthanindicated intheB8M.Atestingprogram(SP-2449) wasdeveloped and107abandoned anchorsinK,L,PandRreactorbuildings weretestedtodetermine shearandtensionloadcapacities.

ThisRTRdocuments theresultsofthistestingprogramandprovidesamethodforconfirming adequacyoftheleadshelltypeanchor.Testresultsshowthatthetensionloadcapacityoflead"9708070i35 97073iPDRADOCK05000220PPDROSR2582'Wta89>~~qoh')

~a RTR-2661Page2August15,1989lTTACHMENT CCALCNOoREVISION~<IiFNOtypeanchorsatfailureisbelowthedesignfailureloads(i.e.,fourtimestheB8M).Therefore, thenewlowerallowable loadslistedinTable1shouldbeusedforleadshelltypeanchors.Ifthecalculated loadontheanchorisgreaterthantheTable1load,theanchorstillmaybeadequateproviding itisloadtestedtoprovethatit.iscapableofcarryingtheseismicdemandload.Aregression analysiscorrelation betweentorqueandloadhasbeendeveloped bySRLbasedontestmeasurements andcanbeusedforproofloadtestingthoseleadtypeshellexpansion anchorsthatexceedsthenewlowerallowable (Appendix A).Theanchorboltshouldbetorquedtoinduceatensionloadontheanchorwhichconfirmsitscapacitytocarryitscalculated seismicdemandloadortheBSMdesignallowable load.Thisapproachmayresultinalowerfactorofsafety.Thefactorofsafetyof4wasintendedtoprovideahighlevelofconfidence thattheanchorwillsupportthedesignload.Becausetheanchorswillbeloadtestedtotheseismicdemandordesignallowable load,alowerfactorofsafetyisconsidered acceptable.

TestsalsoshowthattheBSMvaluesforshearloadsareacceptable

.Table1AnchorSize,inches'urrentTensionAllowable Load(BSM)7001200200030005500NewRecommended Allowable

.LoadBasedOnTests60087097012803160ProofTorqueForBSMDesignAllowable, ft-Ib24503769*Applicable onlyforanchorsthathavepassedthetightness torqueperRTR-2582

RTR-2661Page3August15,1989IgfEFtiF<

REWSipgPA()ENOANCEo~1.Themeanmeasuredtensionfailureloadofleadtypeexpansion anchorsislessthan4timesBSM.2.Thenewlowertensionloadcapacities ofleadtypeexpansion anchorsthatarelistedinTable1shouldbeusedforwalkdowns.

3.Thetensionloadonanchorstobeseismically qualified shouldbecalculated andshowntobebelowtheTable1values.4.Allleadtypeanchorsshouldbeproofloadedifthecalculated seismicdemandloadexceedstheloadcapacityistedinTable1orifB8Mallowables areassumed.5.Thetorquenecessary toinduceatensionloadoninstalled anchorsshouldbedetermined fromthecorrelation giveninFigures8-11atthe95%confidence level.6.BSMshearloadcapacities areadequate.

7.Furtheruseofleadtypeexpansion anchorsatSRSshouldbediscontinued.

Leadtypeshellexpansion anchorshavebeenusedinthereactorbuildings tosupportsomesafety-related equipment.

Aspartoftheseismicupgradework,theadequacyoftheseanchorswasevaluated usingtheUSIA-46methodology.

Thismethodology isbasedonapplication ofactualearthquake experience data,testdatacompiledbyEPRI,andotherdataandisusedtoevaluatetheseismicadequacyofcertainclassesofnuclearplantequipment.

Anchorage isaddressed bySQVGbutspecificdataonleadtypeexpansion anchorage isnotavailable.

Allowable loadsspecified inBSMwereoriginally usedduringthewalkdowns forthepurposeofanchorage evaluation.

Thewalkdowns revealedthatmanyoftheleadanchorswerenotinstalled perBSMandtheactualloadcapacityofleadtypeexpansion anchorswasquestionable.

RTR-2661Page4August15,1989CALCNOREVISIONPARENOAdcHoRAtotalof107Jeadtypeanchorscovering5anchorsizeswereloadtestedtofailureintensionand36anchors,3sizes,weretestedtofailureinshearperSP2449.Basedonthetestresults,newlowerallowable loadsfortensionweredetermined and-arelistedinTable2.Theshearfailureloadsexceededthosepredicted byB8Mandtherefore, theB8Mvalueswereretained.

Theleadtypeexpansion anchorsexhibited poorloadperformance intensionasevidenced byawidevariation infailureloads.Becauseofthispoortensionperformance, itisconcluded thatfurtheruseofleadtypeexpansion anchorsshouldbediscontinued atSRS.Testswereperformed underSpecialProcedure 2449onabandoned leadtypeexpansion anchorsinSRSReactorAreas.Thefollowing conditions wereprerequisites totesting:-Anchordidnotpulloutorbecomeloosewhensubjected toatightness torqueofapproximately 20%oftheinstallation torque.-Perpendicularity oftheanchorwiththewallwaslessthan5degreesoffset.-Anchorlocationwasgreaterthan10diameters fromthenextloadedanchororaconcreteedge.Becauseofthelimitednumberofavailable anchors,someanchorscloserthan10diameters tothenextabandoned anchorwereused,Thetestwasconsidered acceptable ifconcretespallingdidnotprotrudeintotheareaoftheadjacentanchor.Also,someexpansion anchorsweretestedifpartofthethreadedshellwasabovetheconcretesurfacebutalloftheleadringthatsecurestheanchortotheconcretewasbelowthefaceoftheconcrete.

Inthiscase,ametalspacerwasusedtoprovideagapbetweenthebaseplateandanchorduringthetightness torque.TETPThetestsetupisshowninFigure1.Ahydraulic ramwasusedtoapplyaloadtotheanchorfortensiontests.Astudrodwitha

RTR-2661.Page5August15,1989NCHosdoublenutononeendwasinsertedthroughtheboreoftheramandscrewedintotAeanchoraboutonediameter.

Thentheramwasusedtoapplyaloadapproximately 325lbstotheanchor.Allsubsequent loadswereappliedtotheanchorbytorquingtheautandmeasuring theresisting loadonthehydraulic ramthatistransmitted.to theanchor.Boththetorqueandtheloadwererecordedinstepincrements untilfailure.Forsheartests,aspecialshearplateassemblywasmade(Figure1).Aboltwasinsertedthroughtheshearplateassemblyintotheanchor.Thehydraulic ramwasthenplacedundertheshearplateassemblytopushtheshearplateupward.Theresisting pressureatfailurewasrecorded.

Bothtensionandshearloadcapacities (Table2)forleadtypeexpansion anchorsweredetermined.

Themeanmeasuredtensionloadsatfailurewereallbelowtheexpectedfailureloads(i.e.,B8Mx4).Therefore, newlowerdesignallowable loadsarerecommended whichincludesafactorofsafetyof4.Atightness torquewasappliedtoscreenoutpoorlyinstalled anchorsduringwalkdowns andwasalsoappliedduringthesetests.Anchorsthatfailedthetightness torquewerenotloadtested.Thus,thenewlowerrecommended valuesareapplicable toanchorsthathavebeenscreened(i.e.,passedthetightness torque).Additionally, aspartofthewalkdowneffort,calculations shouldbeperformed forallleadshelltypeanchorstoshowthattheseismicdemandloadisequalorbelowthenewlowerrecommended loads.Iftheseismicdemandloadexceedsthenewrecommended value,theanchormaystillbeadequateproviding theanchorboltistorquedtoaproofload.Theinducedproofloadwillconfirmwhethertheanchorcancarryitscalculated seismicdemandload.MostpipesatSRSwasdesignedtoANSIStandardB31.1usingB8Manchorage allowables.

PipesdesigntoANSIB31.1hasproventobeseismically ruggedbasedonearthquake experience data.Therefore, ifseismicqualification ofSRSpipingisaccomplished byevaluating

'heas-builtcondition againstANSIB31.1(i.e.,noloadcalculations),

thenB8Mallowables mustbeassumed,andtheanchorboltsmustbe

RTR-2661.Page6August15,1989ATTACHMENT CALCNOprooftorquedtoinducedtheBSMdesignallowable load.lnthiscase,onlyonetorquetest(notightness torque)wouldberequiredandcalculation oftheanchorloadwouldnotbenecessary.

SQUGmethodology.

permitsafactorofsafetyof2fornon-shell typeanchorsbutrequiresafactorofsafetyof4fortheshelltypeanchor.However,thisproposedprogramrequires100/overification.

ofstrengthofthoseleadshelltypeanchorsthatexceedthenewlowerrecommended loadsorifB8Mallowables areassumedbyperforming atorquetest.Thetorquetobeappliedshouldbeselectedbasedonthelowerbound95%confidence curve(Figures8-11)andwillinduceanequivalent meanloadontheanchorofapproximately1.5 timestheseismicdemandload.Thus,theSQUGrequirement ofachieving a95%confidence levelthattherearenomorethan5%nonconforming anchorsismet.TheBSMshearloadallowables willberdtainedbecausethemeasuredshearloadcapacities (Table2)exceededtheB8Mfailurevalues.Sheartestsofthe3/4"and1"anchorswasnotperformed becauseno.suitable anchorscouldbefound.Table2LeadShellExpansion AnchorsAnchorSize,inchesTensionTestsNumberofTestsB8MDesignAllowabeLoadFailureLoadPerB8M'eanMeasuredFailureLoadNewRecommended Allowable LoadTorqueBasedOnB8MDesignAllowable Load,ft-IbShearTestsNumberofTestsB8MAllowable FailureLoadPerB8MMeanMeasuredFailureLoad35341710970012002000300055002800480080001200022000262337464456587014058600880970128031602437506916128400800140020003500160032005600800014000279657367934

RTR-2661Page7August15,1989ATTACHMENT CALCNO.OPAGENODANLThenewlowerrecommended allowable loadsarebasedonthemeanloadmeasuredatfailureforthesamplepopulation tested.Themean(i.e.,samplemean)wasthenstatistically adjustedtoobtainatruemeanloadatthe95%confidence interval.

Thefailureloaddistribution wasassumedtobeGaussian.

Theallowable loadslistedinTable2providesforafactorofsafetyof4.Forloadsexceeding thenewlowerrecommended loads,torquetestsmaybeperformed todetermine anchoradequacy.

Aleast-squares regression analysiscorrelations betweentorqueandloadatthe95%confidence levelweretabulated bySRL(Appendix A)andhavebeenplottedonFigures8-11.Thetorquetobeappliedshouldbeselectedbasedonthelower95%confidence boundcurveandwillinduceanequivalent meantoadontheanchorofapproximately 1.5timestheseismicdemandortheB8Mload.Also,thetorquetobe'applied shouldnotbeextrapolated beyondtherangeofthe95%confidence lines.TENINTETensiontestswereperformed inP,L,KandRreactorbuildings forfivedifferent sizesofleadshellexpansion anchors.Thesetestswereperformed inmanydifferent locations ofthereactorbuilding:

0level,-20and-40cleanareasandradiation zones.Atotalof107tensiontestswereperformed (Appendix B).Fewertestswereperformed forthe5/8,3/4and1inchanchorsbecauseofthelowavailability ofanchors.Someanchorswereloadtestedwithouttorquingbecausetheanchorswerecrossthreaded.

All1-inchanchorswerefoundatthefloorlevelandcontained excessive amountsofrust,therefore thetorquetoloadrelationship wasnotdeveloped.

Testsshowedawidevariation intensionloadcapacities (Figures2-7)foreachanchorsize,reactorarea,andmodeoffailure.Thiswidevariation maybeexpectedbecausetheholdingcapacityoftheanchorislargelydetermined bythecorrectholesizeandcompacting oftheleadringbetweentheconcreteandthethreadedshell.Theamount

RTR-2661Page8August15,1989ATTACHMENT PAGENOC.5offorcefore~uringadequatecompacting oftheleadwasprobablynotspecified duringtheoriginalinstallation.

Approximately 7%oftheanchorsfailedduetoconefailureaftheconcrete.

Someofthefailures(22%)wereduetoacombination ofaconcretefailure(i.e.,concreteconedidnotpenetrate tobottomofanchor)andslippageoftheanchoroutofthehole.Another22%'oftheanchorsfailedbecausethenon-leadportionoftheanchorbroke.Thelargestportion(47%)oftheanchorsfailedbecauseofslippage(i.e.,theanchorwaspulledoutofitsholewithoutspalling).

About40%oftheslipfailureswereduetopoorinstallation (i.e.,noconcretespallingorsignificant gallingoftheleadsleevewasapparentindicating anoversized holeorinsufficient packingoftheleadsleeve).Nearlyallofthe3/4inchanchorswerenotinstalled perB8M.Inspection oftheanchorsafterpulloutshowedthatinmostcasesonlyoneofthemultiplestackedunitsprovidedsupport.Alistoftheanchorsthatfailedthetightness tests(allturnedinholeexcept1anchorwhichwastorquedagainstbaseplate)ortheperpendicularity requirements wasnotkeptbutitisestimated thatabout10'-15%oftheanchorstestedwererejectedbasedonthoserequirements.

ETEDatawasalsocollected todetermine thecorrelation betweentorqueandloadforthe3/8,1/2,5/8,andthe3/4inchanchors.Regression analysiscurvefits(Figures8-12)weremadeforeachsizeanchorandshowagoodcorrelation betweenmeantorqueandload.Also,agoodlinearcorrelation betweenthemeanfailureloadandboltdiameterwasdetermined.

Thelowerbound95%confidence lines.for-torqueandloadarealsopottedonFigures8-11basedonSRLanalysis.

Torquetestsshouldbeusedtodemonstrate anchorinstallation adequacyfortheB8Mdesignallowables oriftheseismicdemandloadiscalculated andexceedsthenewlowerallowables (applicable toKandLareasonly).ThetorquesselectedfromtheFiguresforloadtestingtheanchorshouldbebasedonthe95%confidence linesandwillmettheSQUGrequirement thattherearenomorethan5%nonconforming anchors.Widevariation intorqueatanyspecificloadwasalsoexperienced.

Torquevalues..differ becauseofperpendicularity oftheanchorwiththewall.Thistypeofinstallation wouldcausetheramtopullthe

RTR-2661'age9August15,1989cl3KC9..~eHoRanchoroutatynangleandwouldyieldanincreased torquevalue.Also,someboltsdonotfittightintheanchoruntiltorquedagainstthebaseplate(i.e.,threadcontactbetweenboltandanchorisnottight).Insomecasesthiscouldallowtheramto-bemountedwithsomeoffsetfromperpendicularity.

Additionally, theconcretewallwasvisiblynotflatinsomelocations whichwouldallowtheramtopullthe.anchoratanangleyieldinghighertorques.Allofthesevariables couldresultindifferent torquevaluesforthesameload.Sheartestingwasperformed onlyinRReactorArea.However,tensiontestsshowednosignificant variation infailureloadcapacities asafunctionofreactorarea(Figure12).Thusthesheartestsareexpectedtoberepresentative ofallreactorareas.Themeanmeasuredshearloadwasdetermined forthreedifferent sizeanchors(Figure13,14)basedontheresultsof36different tests.Testswerenotperformed onthe3/4and1inchanchorsbecausenonecouldbefound.Themeanmeasuredshearloadsat'ailurewere50to74%greaterthanfailureloadsindicated inBSM.Onlyoneofthe32anchorstestedfailedataloadslightlylessthantheBSMvaluetimes4(Figure14).

FIGUREIATTACHMQf CALCNOREVISIONPAGENOT0GUURESSUREGAUGEANCHORTORQUENUTIIIIIIHYDRAULIC RANANCHORHEARASSENBLYPRESSUREGUAGEHYDRAULIC RAN

ATTACHMENT

."""~NO.CJ1FAILURELOADScMODETENSIONTEST3/8"ANCHOR60005000A-ANCHORFAILUREC-COteaETE VAILURES-SUPFAILUREB-S8CFAIURE4000ClC03000MEANw2623AASSSSSSSSSACBSSSSSACSSAASBBSSASAAS FA1LUREMODEF1QURE2

FAtLURELOAD8cMODETENSlONTESTS0/2"ANCHORCAI.CNOCJZ80006000A-ANCHORFAILUREC-CONCRETEFAILURES-SLIPFAILURE8-S8CFAILURE4000MEAN~3746 2000ASSSASSSSSSSSSSSASBBBASBBCSCCAAAAS FAILUREMOOEFIGURE3

CAl.CNOFAlLURELOAD5,MODETENStONTEST6/8"ANCHOR12000100008000A-ANCHORFA1LUREC-CONCRETEFAlLURES-SLlPFA1LURECS-S8CFAlLURE4000MEANa4456 CSSASCSCSCSSSASCSCSCSAFAILUREQQM~ROURE4

ATTACHMENT CALGNDllDriSiON OFAILURELOAD5MODETENSIONTEST3/4"ANCHORA-ANCHORFAlLURES-SLlPFAlLUREC-CONCRETEFAlLUREMEANa5870SCSSSAASSAFAILUREMODEFlOUAEI

ATTACHMENT CALCNOO~REVISIONnouZMeHoP-MEANFAILURELOADTENSIONTEST3/8,1/2,6/8,&3/4ANCHORS70006000CltCOItl4000O3000.0.3750.'50.6250.75ANCKOROIAMETER(IN.)FIGURE6

CALCNO>AGFNOMEANFAILURELOADVS.ANCHORSIZETENSIONTESTy~-529.20+8360.8xR"2~0.985Ol4000NCI03000z20000.0000.$250.2500.3750.5000.6250.750ANCHORSEEFtQURE7

TORQUEVSLOADTENSIONTEST3/8"ANCHORcPAGENO6000500040003000Q020001000SPYeLOWERCONFSENBOuWO)ya-798+64.86x020406080TORQUE(FT-LB)FIGURE8

ATTACHMENT CAI.CNOREVISIONPAGENOC.l-HopTORQUEVSLOADTENSIONTESTS1/2"ANCHOR700060005000400088~8830002000mmaBmGQ1000y~-1002+60.31x0020406080100TOROUF.(FT-l.B)FlGURE9

TORQUEVSLOADTENSlONTEST5/8"ANCHORATTACHMENT CAI.CNOo.REVISIONdPAGENO1000080006000400020009P/eLOWERCONFIDBOUNDIy~-1602+73.08x20406080100120140TORQUE(FT-LB)FIGURE10

TORQUEVSLOADTENSIONTESTSia-ANCHORATTACHMENT veHo&REVISIONOOopticpet2d1000080004000200095YeLOWERCONFIDENCE BOUNDY~-2147+?5.2XTHISCORRELATION EXCEEDSTHE95'loLEYELBY10FT-LBTOPERMITLOADTESTTO-1.5x20406080,100120140TORQUEFT-LBFIGURE11

CGDZDEATTACHMENI CCALCNOREVISIONPAGENOMEANFAILURELOADTENSIONTESTANCHORSIZE&REACTORAREA3/4-K58715/8-ALL44565/8.R47045/8'1001/2-ALL1/2-FIxILINCOlLO1/2-P1/2-L1/2-K3722323726233/S-R23213/S-L3108284201000200030004000500060007000MEANFAILURELOAO(LB)FIGURE12

REVISIONPAOFNOC~MEANFAILURELOADSHEARTEST3/8,0/2,&5/8ANCHORS100008000OilhIACJIA40002000'00.3750.50.625ANCHORDIAM.(IN.)FIGURE13

ATTACHMENT CALCNOREVISIONooPAGENQSHEARFAILURELOAD12000MEANMEASUREDMEANPERBSMs/s1/2'NCHOR SIZE(INCH)FIGURE14.3/8'

NiagaraMohawkPowerCorporation NineMilePointNuciearStation,UnitNo.1In-Structure ResponseSpectraExcitation SSE(NUREG/CR-0098, PGAof0.13G)BUILDING:

ReactorELEVATION:

259'OW/COL:

LA8DAMPING:5%MODELNODE:582.01.56C01.0II+IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIee/IJgeIIII~II~/IerII~/I.,j/jltlIIIII~l'll'ell'el'llIel"4I,feIIIIIIILIIII~IrIIIIIIIIIIIt'IIIIIrrIIIIII~ee~I//ILIIII1IIIIIII'IIIIII~~---e.~t-I~III~IeIII~IIIIIIII'tI1.5xBoundingSpectrum------North/South

---East/West IIIIIIIt---vIILIIIIr--"~ILJIIIIII---rILIIII.II-r-ILII1IIIILLIIIIILIIIII,IIIIiIIIII~I~III'IIIIIIIIIIIIIrIIIIII4IIIIIIIIIIIIII--.D(RECT(ON" IIIIIIIIIIII0.5I~/----r'-Ie/Ie/e/I'.IIrIIIIIItIIIJILIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJIIIIIIIIILLIIIILIIIIIII.IIII'III~eII'IIIItIIIII'tJ'tIJII'lIIIIIIIIIILI""r"--~lae--IILIIIII-t---r---II001020Frequency(Hz) 30aW40m~I-eZom

NineMilePointUnit1AQ6BoundingSpectrumVs.SSEPlot0)C00.1QtDO0.01IIIIIJTTIIII+IItTIIIIIIIIIIIIIJIIIIIIIIIIII-rarI4I--LJIIII8IIIIIIIIIIL4IIIIIIII-4IIIIIIIIIILJ-I-IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJIIIIIIIIIIILJLIiC'IiIItIIILJLIIIIIIr1iIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIrorTIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIQIi'I1ITTIIIIgiIIIIIIIIIIIITI1IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII+9IHIIIIIIIrarIIIIIIIIIII4IIIIIII4IIIIIIIIL4I-IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIILJIIIIIIIIIIIIIILJIIIIIIIIIIIJ.IIIIIIT1IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIITIIIIIIIIIIIIIIILJIIIIII-r-i--IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIrIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII44I4IIII1II'IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIL.IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII1IIIILI4IIIIIaIII4IIIIIIIIIIIIIL2I--JIIIIIIIIM~IIIsrIIIIIIIIIII.IIIIIIIIIiIIIIIIP1SSEi"JLJJLI-LIIIIIIIIIIIIIII--w-a-tw-rIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJLJJLILIIIIIIIIIIIII11TiIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII---a---i--1-1

-r-i-rIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII/IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIBhund@~Spectrum" "0.1Frequency (Hz)10100UWTtlWcOril