ML052060136: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
Line 15: Line 15:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:J. Caruso & G. Johnson 5/11 /05 LIMERICK & PEACH BOTTOM LSRO EXAM OPERATING EXAM COMMENTS Limerick JPMs 0 JPM2700- 1 )Confused by initiating cue. Wouldn't the applicant normally prepare this checklist himself? Shouldn't cue indicate - Review the FHDs Checklist provided as the on-coming FHD? 2) Is the intent to have the applicant complete pages 2 and 3 of the checklist?
{{#Wiki_filter:J. Caruso & G. Johnson 5/11/05 LIMERICK & PEACH BOTTOM LSRO EXAM OPERATING EXAM COMMENTS Limerick JPMs 0     JPM2700- 1)Confused by initiating cue. Wouldnt the applicant normally prepare this checklist himself? Shouldnt cue indicate - Review the FHDs Checklist provided as the on-coming FHD? 2) Is the intent to have the applicant complete pages 2 and 3 of the checklist? Dont understand task, please explain. 3) Typo step la. ....Rod Block ...4)
Don't understand task, please explain. 3) Typo step la. "....Rod Block ..." 4) Maybe we should provide page 1 without pages 2 and 3 (e.g. the note after step'#23 TS 3.9.2 provides one of the answers (at least one with audible alarm in the CR) this really doesn't test understanding - direct look-up).
Maybe we should provide page 1 without pages 2 and 3 (e.g. the note after step#23 TS 3.9.2 provides one of the answers (at least one with audible alarm in the CR) this really doesnt test understanding - direct look-up). 5) Licensee did not provide handouts for final JPM; also still typo in step l a Handouts received and validated with JPM. Typo fixed e     JPM 2701 Stay Time Calculation - This is a very simple math problem doesnt test understanding only ability to do simple calculation. Please attempt to enhance task this is really a GET level question/task not license level. Rich agreed.
: 5) Licensee did not provide handouts for final JPM; also still typo in step la Handouts received and validated with JPM. Typo fixed e JPM 2701 Stay Time Calculation - This is a very simple math problem doesn't test understanding only ability to do simple calculation. Please attempt to enhance task this is really a GET level question/task not license level. Rich agreed. JPM significantly improved with additional complexities that discriminate at LSRO level. 0 JPM 2014 CCTAS revision - 1) Please list applicable procedure steps in the standard so that JPM steps and procedure steps can be correlated.
JPM significantly improved with additional complexities that discriminate at LSRO level.
: 2) step 3.3.5 , writes the approving RE initials at the change ... How and when does he get the RE'S approval??
0     JPM 2014 CCTAS revision - 1) Please list applicable procedure steps in the standard so that JPM steps and procedure steps can be correlated. 2) step 3.3.5 , writes the approving RE initials at the change... How and when does he get the RESapproval??
Procedure steps added as appropriate. Additional cues added for RE input. 0 JPM 2063 Moving Dummy Fuel Bundle - 1) General Comment for all JPMs - Initiating cue should indicated that the applicant is assigned as the FHD or RPO. Are we going to have an RPO assigned to assist or does the examiner act as the FHD? Who will that person be?
Procedure steps added as appropriate. Additional cues added for RE input.
: 2) Please list applicable procedure steps in the standard so that JPM steps and procedure steps can be correlated.
0     JPM 2063 Moving Dummy Fuel Bundle - 1) General Comment for all JPMs - Initiating cue should indicated that the applicant is assigned as the FHD or RPO. Are we going to have an RPO assigned to assist or does the examiner act as the FHD? Who will that person be? 2) Please list applicable procedure steps in the standard so that JPM steps and procedure steps can be correlated. 3) Why arent steps 2, 3, and 4 critical? 4) Cue preceding JPM step #17 provide RE authorized change to the CCTAS for the exam to support cue.
: 3) Why aren't steps 2, 3, and 4 critical?
Initiating cues for position being tested added to all applicable JPMs. Cues added as necessary. Steps 2 , 3 and 4 are simply communications and not critical.
: 4) Cue preceding JPM step #17 provide RE authorized change to the CCTAS for the exam to support cue. Initiating cues for position being tested added to all applicable JPMs. Cues added as necessary.
0       JPM 2045 Moving Dummy Fuel Bundle from Fuel Pool to Prep Machine - 1) Initiating cue should indicated that the applicant is assigned as the FHD or RPO. 2) Cue- CCTAS not required - why? 3) Why are JPM steps 7, 8 and 13 marked N/A? 4) Please mark JPM step #17 with the applicable procedure step, 3.1 3.3.
Steps 2,3 and 4 are simply communications and not critical.
Initiating cues added. Discussed CCTAS requirements with licensee and agree not required for this move. JPM steps 7,8 and 13 done by FHD, not applicant (RPO).
0 JPM 2045 Moving Dummy Fuel Bundle from Fuel Pool to Prep Machine - 1) Initiating cue should indicated that the applicant is assigned as the FHD or RPO. 2)
 
Cue- CCTAS not required - why? 3) Why are JPM steps 7, 8 and 13 marked N/A? 4) Please mark JPM step #17 with the applicable procedure step, 3.1 3.3. Initiating cues added.
0       JPM 2029 Install Rod Pos. Test Box - 1) Is this a required task for LSROs - who normally performs this task? 2) Is this task really safety significant 3) What are we really testing with this task?
Discussed CCTAS requirements with licensee and agree not required for this move. JPM steps 7,8 and 13 done by FHD, not applicant (RPO).
Confirmed task is LSRO applicable. If task done incorrectly could result in Tech Spec violation.
0 JPM 2029 Install Rod Pos. Test Box - 1) Is this a required task for LSROs - who normally performs this task? 2) Is this task really safety significant
0     JPM 2060 Respond to Alarm           - no comments.
: 3) What are we really testing with this task? Confirmed task is LSRO applicable. If task done incorrectly could result in Tech Spec violation.
0     JPM 2053 Response in unexpected rise in SRM count rate, JPM steps f and g critical??
0 JPM 2060 Respond to Alarm - no comments.
0 JPM 2053 Response in unexpected rise in SRM count rate, JPM steps f and g critical??
After discussions determined steps f abd g not critical.
After discussions determined steps f abd g not critical.
0 JPM 2061 Transfer Spent Fuel in Pool, Response to Dropped Fuel
0     JPM 2061 Transfer Spent Fuel in Pool, Response to Dropped Fuel 1) Initiating cue add the word ....seven spent fuel bundles...2) Why are JPM steps 2-6 and 9-13 N/A? 3)
: 1) Initiating cue add the word "....seven spent fuel bundles ..." 2) Why are JPM steps 2-6 and 9-13 N/A? 3) Who is the spotter for this JPM? 4) How would he normally contact the SSV? Added "spent" to cues. Steps 9-73 not done by applicant. Spotter is a third person (not being examined) 0 JPM 2062 EAL Classification - very similar to the PB EAL call can one of these calls be modified?? Although the initiating event for each is a decreasing fuel pool level, it was determined this was acceptable since Limerick EAL is based on Rad Levels with a resulting ALERT and PB based on Fuel Pool Level with a resulting UE . Peach Bottom JPMs JPM NLSR03037 Semi-Automatic Fuel Transfer within Spent Fuel Pool 1) Step 9 will the dummy fuel actuate the hoist loaded light? 2) Didn't see the copy of the approved CCTAS for transfer.
Who is the spotter for this JPM? 4) How would he normally contact the SSV?
Added spent to cues. Steps 9-73 not done by applicant. Spotter is a third person (not being examined) 0       JPM 2062 EAL Classification - very similar to the PB EAL call can one of these calls be modified??
Although the initiating event for each is a decreasing fuel pool level, it was determined this was acceptable since Limerick EAL is based on Rad Levels with a resulting ALERT and PB based on Fuel Pool Level with a resulting UE           .
Peach Bottom JPMs JPM NLSR03037 Semi-Automatic Fuel Transfer within Spent Fuel Pool 1) Step 9 will the dummy fuel actuate the hoist loaded light? 2) Didnt see the copy of the approved CCTAS for transfer.
Determined hoist loaded light will light. Final CCTAS will be provided after RE on security agreement.
Determined hoist loaded light will light. Final CCTAS will be provided after RE on security agreement.
JPM 3019 Fuel Move within Spent Fuel Pool - Hoist Loaded light Extinguished
JPM 3019 Fuel Move within Spent Fuel Pool - Hoist Loaded light Extinguished 1) JPM Step 1 why are you starting in the right location instead of having applicant position the bridge?
: 1) JPM Step 1 why are you starting in the right location instead of having applicant position the bridge? Set up changed to have bridge moved away from final location JPM NLSR03048 Functional Test of Refuel Interlocks
Set up changed to have bridge moved away from final location JPM NLSR03048 Functional Test of Refuel Interlocks 1) Is this an LSRO JTA didnt see it on the list - is this really performed by LSROs or at an least RO task or do I&C do this (Rich said okay if RO task)? 2) I assume this is all simulation but the JPM says candidate lifts leads?? Ex. JPM step 2.
: 1) Is this an LSRO JTA didn't see it on the list - is this really performed by LSROs or at an least RO task or do I&C do this (Rich said okay if RO task)? 2) I assume this is all simulation but the JPM says candidate lifts leads?? Ex. JPM step 2. Determined this is an LSRO task. JPM changed to clearly indicate the lead lifting is simulated.
Determined this is an LSRO task. JPM changed to clearly indicate the lead lifting is simulated.
JPM 3049 This JPM is very simplistic and doesn't test LSRO understanding there is really only one critical step to turn the ARM off and check downscale and white light illuminated.
JPM 3049 This JPM is very simplistic and doesnt test LSRO understanding there is really only one critical step to turn the ARM off and check downscale and white light illuminated.
This JPM was replaced with one involving FHD turnover checklist. Replacement JPM is discriminatory at LSRO level. Verified against OP-PB-112-101-1011.
This JPM was replaced with one involving FHD turnover checklist. Replacement JPM is discriminatory at LSRO level. Verified against OP-PB-112-101-1011. Will
Will validate the morning of the exam before any applicants go up on bridge.}}
 
validate the morning of the exam before any applicants go up on bridge.}}

Latest revision as of 01:11, 24 November 2019

Draft - NRC Comments on Licensee Developed Material (Written & Operating Tests) (Folder 2)
ML052060136
Person / Time
Site: Peach Bottom, Limerick  Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 05/11/2005
From: Caruso J, Johnson G
Operations Branch I
To:
Conte R
References
Download: ML052060136 (3)
v • d • e


Text

J. Caruso & G. Johnson 5/11/05 LIMERICK & PEACH BOTTOM LSRO EXAM OPERATING EXAM COMMENTS Limerick JPMs 0 JPM2700- 1)Confused by initiating cue. Wouldnt the applicant normally prepare this checklist himself? Shouldnt cue indicate - Review the FHDs Checklist provided as the on-coming FHD? 2) Is the intent to have the applicant complete pages 2 and 3 of the checklist? Dont understand task, please explain. 3) Typo step la. ....Rod Block ...4)

Maybe we should provide page 1 without pages 2 and 3 (e.g. the note after step#23 TS 3.9.2 provides one of the answers (at least one with audible alarm in the CR) this really doesnt test understanding - direct look-up). 5) Licensee did not provide handouts for final JPM; also still typo in step l a Handouts received and validated with JPM. Typo fixed e JPM 2701 Stay Time Calculation - This is a very simple math problem doesnt test understanding only ability to do simple calculation. Please attempt to enhance task this is really a GET level question/task not license level. Rich agreed.

JPM significantly improved with additional complexities that discriminate at LSRO level.

0 JPM 2014 CCTAS revision - 1) Please list applicable procedure steps in the standard so that JPM steps and procedure steps can be correlated. 2) step 3.3.5 , writes the approving RE initials at the change... How and when does he get the RESapproval??

Procedure steps added as appropriate. Additional cues added for RE input.

0 JPM 2063 Moving Dummy Fuel Bundle - 1) General Comment for all JPMs - Initiating cue should indicated that the applicant is assigned as the FHD or RPO. Are we going to have an RPO assigned to assist or does the examiner act as the FHD? Who will that person be? 2) Please list applicable procedure steps in the standard so that JPM steps and procedure steps can be correlated. 3) Why arent steps 2, 3, and 4 critical? 4) Cue preceding JPM step #17 provide RE authorized change to the CCTAS for the exam to support cue.

Initiating cues for position being tested added to all applicable JPMs. Cues added as necessary. Steps 2 , 3 and 4 are simply communications and not critical.

0 JPM 2045 Moving Dummy Fuel Bundle from Fuel Pool to Prep Machine - 1) Initiating cue should indicated that the applicant is assigned as the FHD or RPO. 2) Cue- CCTAS not required - why? 3) Why are JPM steps 7, 8 and 13 marked N/A? 4) Please mark JPM step #17 with the applicable procedure step, 3.1 3.3.

Initiating cues added. Discussed CCTAS requirements with licensee and agree not required for this move. JPM steps 7,8 and 13 done by FHD, not applicant (RPO).

0 JPM 2029 Install Rod Pos. Test Box - 1) Is this a required task for LSROs - who normally performs this task? 2) Is this task really safety significant 3) What are we really testing with this task?

Confirmed task is LSRO applicable. If task done incorrectly could result in Tech Spec violation.

0 JPM 2060 Respond to Alarm - no comments.

0 JPM 2053 Response in unexpected rise in SRM count rate, JPM steps f and g critical??

After discussions determined steps f abd g not critical.

0 JPM 2061 Transfer Spent Fuel in Pool, Response to Dropped Fuel 1) Initiating cue add the word ....seven spent fuel bundles...2) Why are JPM steps 2-6 and 9-13 N/A? 3)

Who is the spotter for this JPM? 4) How would he normally contact the SSV?

Added spent to cues. Steps 9-73 not done by applicant. Spotter is a third person (not being examined) 0 JPM 2062 EAL Classification - very similar to the PB EAL call can one of these calls be modified??

Although the initiating event for each is a decreasing fuel pool level, it was determined this was acceptable since Limerick EAL is based on Rad Levels with a resulting ALERT and PB based on Fuel Pool Level with a resulting UE .

Peach Bottom JPMs JPM NLSR03037 Semi-Automatic Fuel Transfer within Spent Fuel Pool 1) Step 9 will the dummy fuel actuate the hoist loaded light? 2) Didnt see the copy of the approved CCTAS for transfer.

Determined hoist loaded light will light. Final CCTAS will be provided after RE on security agreement.

JPM 3019 Fuel Move within Spent Fuel Pool - Hoist Loaded light Extinguished 1) JPM Step 1 why are you starting in the right location instead of having applicant position the bridge?

Set up changed to have bridge moved away from final location JPM NLSR03048 Functional Test of Refuel Interlocks 1) Is this an LSRO JTA didnt see it on the list - is this really performed by LSROs or at an least RO task or do I&C do this (Rich said okay if RO task)? 2) I assume this is all simulation but the JPM says candidate lifts leads?? Ex. JPM step 2.

Determined this is an LSRO task. JPM changed to clearly indicate the lead lifting is simulated.

JPM 3049 This JPM is very simplistic and doesnt test LSRO understanding there is really only one critical step to turn the ARM off and check downscale and white light illuminated.

This JPM was replaced with one involving FHD turnover checklist. Replacement JPM is discriminatory at LSRO level. Verified against OP-PB-112-101-1011. Will

validate the morning of the exam before any applicants go up on bridge.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML052060136&oldid=2198290"