L-2010-078, Attachment 9, St. Lucie License Amendment Request Extended Power Uprate, Core Operating Limits Report (COLR) Markups (for Information Only)

Attachment 9, St. Lucie License Amendment Request Extended Power Uprate, Core Operating Limits Report (COLR) Markups (for Information Only)

ML101160209
Person / Time
Site:	Saint Lucie
Issue date:	04/16/2010
From:	Florida Power & Light Co
To:	Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Shared Package
ML101160214	List: L-2010-078, ANP-2903(NP), Rev. 0, St. Lucie Nuclear Plant Unit 1 EPU Cycle Realistic Large Break LOCA Summary Report with Zr-4 Fuel Cladding. L-2010-078, Attachment 1, St. Lucie License Amendment Request Extended Power Uprate, Description and Technical Justifications for the Renewed Facility Operating License, Technical Specifications, and Licensing Basis Changes L-2010-078, Attachment 2, St. Lucie License Amendment Request Extended Power Uprate, Supplemental Environmental Report L-2010-078, Attachment 3, St. Lucie License Amendment Request Extended Power Uprate, Renewed Facility Operating License and Technical Specifications Markups and Clean Pages L-2010-078, Attachment 4, St. Lucie License Amendment Request Extended Power Uprate, Technical Specifications Bases Markups (for Information Only) L-2010-078, Attachment 5, St. Lucie Extended Power Uprate Licensing Report, Appendix D, List of Key Acronyms L-2010-078, Attachment 5, St. Lucie Unit 1 Extended Power Uprate Licensing Report, Appendix B, Additional Codes and Methods L-2010-078, Attachment 5, St. Lucie Unit 1 Extended Power Uprate Licensing Report, Appendix E, Supplement to Licensing Report Section 2.4.1, Reactor Protection, Engineered Safety Features Actuation, and Control Systems L-2010-078, Attachment 5, St. Lucie Unit 1 Extended Power Uprate Licensing Report, Appendix a, Safety Evaluation Report Compliance L-2010-078, Attachment 5, St. Lucie Unit 1, Extended Power Uprate Licensing Report, Appendix F, Caldon Ultrasonics Engineering Reports, No. 733, Rev 3, and No. 740, Rev 0 L-2010-078, Attachment 7, St. Lucie License Amendment Request Extended Power Uprate, Summary of Regulatory Commitments L-2010-078, Attachment 8, St. Lucie License Amendment Request Extended Power Uprate, Criticality Summary Report Spent Fuel Pool and New Fuel Vault L-2010-078, Attachment 9, St. Lucie License Amendment Request Extended Power Uprate, Core Operating Limits Report (COLR) Markups (for Information Only) L-2010-078, St. Lucie License Amendment Request Extended Power Uprate, Applications for Withholding Proprietary Information from Public Disclosure L-2010-078, St. Lucie Unit 1 License Amendment Request for Extended Power Uprate L-2010-078, WCAP-17197-NP, Rev. 0, St. Lucie Unit 1 RCS Pressure & Temperature Limits & Low-Temperature Overpressure Protection Report for 54 Effective Full Power Years. ML101160182 ML101160186 ML101160189 ML101160191 ML101160192 ML101160195 ML101160196 ML101160197 ML101160198 ML101160201 ML101160202 ML101160204 ML101160205 ML101160207 ML101160208
References
L-2010-078
Download: ML101160209 (12)

Text

St. Lucie Unit 1 L-2010-078 Docket No. 50-335 Attachment 9 ATTACHMENT 9 LICENSE AMENDMENT REQUEST EXTENDED POWER UPRATE CORE OPERATING LIMITS REPORT (COLR)

MARKUPS (For Information Only)

FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT ST. LUCIE NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 1 This coversheet plus 11 pages

___________________________________________________________________________________

St. Lucie Unit 1 EPU LAR Att. 9-1 Core Operating Limits Report (COLR) Markups

St.. Lucie Unit 1 L-2010-078 Docket No. 50-335 Attachment 9 LIST OF PAGES Core Operating Limits Report 5 of 13 Proposed COLR Table 3.2-1 (new page) 6 of 13 (replaced by Proposed COLR Figure 3.1.1a)

Proposed COLR Figure 3.1.1a 8 of 13 (replaced by Proposed COLR Figure 3.2.1)

Proposed COLR Figure 3.2.1 9 of 13 (replaced by Proposed COLR Figure 3.2.2)

Proposed COLR Figure 3.2.2 10 of 13 (replaced by Proposed COLR Figure 3.2.3)

Proposed COLR Figure 3.2.3 St. Lucie Unit 1 EPU LAR Att. 9-2 Core Operating Limits Report (COLR) Markups

PC/M 08032, Rev 0 Attachment 14, Page 5 of 13 1.65 2.5 Total Integrated Radial Peaking Factor - FrT (TS 3.2.3)

The calculated value of FrT at RATED THERMAL POWER shall be limited to  1.70 The power dependent FrT limits are shown on Figure 3.2-3.

2.6 DNB Parameters - AXIAL SHAPE INDEX (TS 3.2.5)

The AXIAL SHAPE INDEX shall be maintained within the limits specified in Figure 3.2-4.

New Text The following DNB-related parameters shall be maintained within the limits shown on Table 3.2-1:

a. Cold Leg Temperature

b. Pressurizer Pressure

c. Reactor Coolant System Flow rate

d. AXIAL SHAPE INDEX 2.7 Refueling Operations - Boron Concentration (TS 3.9.1)

With the reactor vessel head unbolted or removed, the boron concentration of all filled portions of the Reactor Coolant System and the refueling cavity shall be maintained uniform and sufficient to ensure that the more restrictive of the following reactivity conditions is met:

a. Either a Keff of 0.95 or less, which includes a 1000 pcm conservative allowance for uncertainties, or 1900

b. A boron concentration of  1720 ppm, which includes a 50 ppm conservative allowance for uncertainties.

2.8 SHUTDOWN MARGIN - Tavg Greater Than 200 0F (TS 3.1.1.1)

The SHUTDOWN MARGIN shall be greater than or equal to 3600 pcm.

2.9 SHUTDOWN MARGIN - Tavg Less Than or Equal To 200 0F (TS 3.1.1.2)

The SHUTDOWN MARGIN shall be greater than or equal to 2000 pcm.

St. Lucie Unit 1 Cycle 22 COLR Rev 0 Page 5 of 13







St. Lucie Unit 1 - Proposed COLR Table 3.2-1









Table 3.2-1 DNB MARGIN LIMITS PARAMETER FOUR REACTOR COOLANT PUMPS OPERATING Cold Leg Temperature d 5510F Pressurizer Pressure* t 2225 psia Reactor Coolant System Total Flow Rate tJSP

AXIAL SHAPE INDEX COLR Figure 3.2-4

• /LPLWQRWDSSOLFDEOHGXULQJHLWKHUD7+(50$/32:(5UDPSLQFUHDVHLQH[FHVVRI

 RI5$7('7+(50$/32:(5SHUPLQXWHRUD7+(50$/32:(5VWHSLQFUHDVHRI

 JUHDWHUWKDQRI5$7('7+(50$/32:(5



PC/M 08032, Rev 0 Attachment 14, Page 6 of 13

, , ,. " I ' ** I ' ,t I

• 1 , ** '" 1 'I" " , .

""r---' "rr .' . ' 'TTT-- 'TTTT-- 'Trrr' --rrr"r'j-'rrTT

, , I I " " " " . " .

, " ' " I , . " " " " , .

, " , "

• I I I I I " I ' l ' " , .

',', ',',',:,~: ", ' '," ',',-.~: i:' ','_',i: ,~*,',

._ ~ _ , -'r"i"'j'"

-, ".

+++-, "t"i"'j"'["'-"i"'j--'[-'-:'" "';-"[-":"-j"-I"'["':'--1-- ;..

,++++.

:: : : ! : : : ! : :!!

. _ +++.+" ,.++_+__1_J.. ..:__ ..+, ~,

(60, 1.70

~

:

1,70 ~-,*t~'-~1.-..~- : ~[- -~: ~J~: ~]-: ~1-: ~I-: ~:-: *[-:*l-: ~t-: ~f-: ~:-j~:~J~: ~J-: ~]-: ~:- : *r-: *[-~ [-: ~t-:~: -J~: ~]-: ~I-:~- : ~:-.:~]f: +I-: +I-: ~[~:-

........

IL ---:--"1""- '-r----: ":"rr- --rr-:--T' '-rrTr---"1""T"rr- -oro; r-r- "rrTT"'

"'01.68 ~

,

>

,

"

,

" I '

" "

" "

" "

, , ' ,

" "

,

I t '

j

,

t I

,

• I Q>

• , , * " t I " " " '" * , I

" , , * * , , . , . " " " " " " 1 I , I c:

.2">

co

.~

• 1.1***J:*:.:'**:l**f.:r****:I* I::I** '*

• J.:I**'** "*.:.r.I*:.!}: ***':.I.I:.I:.: ***::J::1::.I::.

~ i i : i : i !: i j ! i

<b1 .66 !: : I : : : : : : : :

i::!  :; i i :::: j j i i

,:: i  ::::  ::::

"- ..L.L .,L.LL.L-L.L -__ i..L.L~._ ,.-~-.LL..L .. _.LL..L..L.... L.~-.LL. _.L..L..LL,.

ILTH.:":r jI:r' I:'L:rr:.:L:j.IIL .itl:.

a..

"'0

~

J en m1.64 I

,

I

,

,

• t,

"

"

,t"

""

" "

1

,

,

,

,

,

..

I'

,t

. " ,

",'

""

~

,

• I , " " " , , , . " I ,

" I I ' " . " , ~ I I I " I 1

• 1.1.. ..[**::.'***1***[.r.:** I*** >*.I**;... .J**1*.I*.'*** j***:***[I** :**1]:.1**1** ***1.*1*.1.:.1**

1.62

. ,

, , , I

• t I ,

, * , I , , , ,

,

, , , 1

,

,

,

,

,,

,

f

" I . I . I ,. " 'I., "" "" I,.

~

_ _ _1 " .. __ * .. _ _ . . . ... _ _ ",, _ _ ** R ~ "' _ _ "' " . " _ _ "" A .. ~ _ ~ ~ _ , , _ ~ _ " ' .. r .. _ _ ~ I. _ _ "' . . . __ , .. ,,f _

., , . " , " " , , " ,~., l ' "

• t * ,

T:LT ::1+LIiII LH'III:H ::I:H:r:'H::I:

" , '" r " , ' , ' , ~ " , ' , , . . , t ,

" , ." , ' , ' , I ,~ f'" ,,'. ** I ,

" I " . " " , I * ~ ,1 " " , , " "

• I , * ~ j I . , ~. , I . . " I I

• I " ' . . ,

1.60 o o 20 30 40 50 60 70 Time at Full Power to Realign CEA, Minutes FIGURE 3.1-1a T

Allowable Time to Realign CEA vs. Initial Fr St. Lucie Unit 1 Cycle 22 COLR Rev 0 Page 6 of 13







St. Lucie Unit 1 - Proposed COLR Figure 3.1-1a



(60, 1.65)



7 0HDVXUHG3UH0LVDOLJQHG)U











       

7LPHDW)XOO3RZHUWR5HDOLJQ&($0LQXWHV







),*85(D

$OORZDEOH7LPHWR5HDOLJQ&($YV,QLWLDO)U7





PC/M 08032, Rev 0 Attachment 14, Page 8 of 13

~ UNACCEPTABLE OPERATIO

~ 16.0

+""

ro (J)

I m

I-15.0 ....---------l~----____I_~---------_4i>

c

i

s:.

ro (J)

Q..

(J)

.0 ro 14.0-3=

o

<<

13.0 -l-.-.- ~'----------~.__---------'

BOl Cycle Life EOl (Fuel + Clad + Moderator)

FIGURE 3.2-1 Allowable Peak Linear Heat Rate vs. Burnup St. Lucie Unit 1 Cycle 22 COLR Rev 0 Page 8 of 13



St. Lucie Unit 1 - Proposed COLR Figure 3.2-1

 



$OORZDEOH3HDN/LQHDU+HDW5DWHNZIW



81$&&(37$%/(23(5$7,21







$&&(37$%/(23(5$7,21



%2/ (2/

&\FOH/LIH



)XHO&ODG0RGHUDWRU 





),*85(

$OORZDEOH3HDN/LQHDU+HDW5DWHYV%XUQXS





PC/M 08032, Rev 0 Attachment 14, Page 9 of 13

<D

>

<D

.....J

"- 0.90

<D s:

0 Q..

Q)

.0 0.80 co s:

0

<<

E

J E

'xco

~

\f-0 0.60 c

0

u co

"-

LL 0.50 a.4 a ,--'--&-..........e--h----'--'----'----;.........-"---'--....:...-...:---'---'---'-----'r--'----------'---...;--J.--<!If--l-~

-0.6 -0.2 0.0 O. 0.4 0.6 Peripheral AXIAL SHAPE INO (Not Applicable Below 40% Power)

Note: AXIAL SHAPE INDEX limits for Linear Heat Rate when using Exeo Monitoring System)

FIGURE 3.2-2 AXIAL SHAPE INDEX VS. Maximum Allowable Power Level St. lucie Unit 1 Cycle 22 COlR Rev 0 Page 9 of 13



St. Lucie Unit 1 - Proposed COLR Figure 3.2-2







 5HJLRQRI

5HJLRQRI

8QDFFHSWDEOH 8QDFFHSWDEOH

)UDFWLRQRI0D[LPXP$OORZDEOH3RZHU/HYHO 2SHUDWLRQ 2SHUDWLRQ



 



   

 5HJLRQRI

$FFHSWDEOH

2SHUDWLRQ











      

3HULSKHUDO$;,$/6+$3(,1'(;

 

1RW$SSOLFDEOH%HORZ3RZHU 



1RWH  $;,$/6+$3(,1'(;OLPLWVIRU/LQHDU+HDW5DWHZKHQXVLQJ([FRUH'HWHFWRU

0RQLWRULQJ6\VWHP 



),*85(

$;,$/6+$3(,1'(;YV0D[LPXP$OORZDEOH3RZHU/HYHO





PC1M 08032 1 Rev 0 Attachment 14, Page 10 of 13 I  :

t::::::r:::::L::r:::: ::::::r-::t::::-T ----1---- --T--- -j---- r----r---- --r------T:::t:::

:  ; I:  : I  :

a::

w ......: I ~ _..-1 _ ~ Unacceptable Operation Reg on .) .

S 0

a.. -:::::::-:1:::::::::::::::1::::- ::::::::::[:::::::~ :::--'---T- +--- ---- --1----- --1----- +---- r:::l::::::::::::

-J

<<

~

-_

,

~ I ~

. __ 1..

j  :

• • • • • • f*******~*******~--*

~. ~ ~...

Fr  ::; 1.7 * [1 +0.47 x (1 - P)] ~----.--~

.~ ~

~

~

.

.

a:: ....) 1 ~ J.- i** -l-- ~ J--..-..;... I .. - i** -.. -.L-..)-.-.. -.L..-.-.~ ..---.L-- ~-.- .

w I

t- 0.9 ~~~~~~t~~~~~~L:~::~].~:.::.~~.::::: 1:::::::t:::::::t:: :~:~~t:~~::: i::::: ::1:::~:: :1::::::: l~~::: . l_._~~::~:::~:~:~:::::~ J""':~~".~.~.' 0.89)

I  : I  : I  : I  : I  : I I  : I  :

a i

0 w """:"""r  ; -"'-"':""" *r-****.;- -r.-.--.;. **---*r-*-*** 1"'" **r******r-** i--***-*i**-**--r***----:**----*

l- ******~*******r*****~* .. A e: table eratio~ Re io : *******[******"["******:*******r****-1-******

<<

0:::

\f-0 0.8 c:

0 13C\'S l0-U.

Q)

..0 0.7 C\'S 3:

T::: ::)1::::::: J::::::: r: :::::j:::::::[:::::::[::::::r:':::I:::::J::::::1:::::::r:::::::r:::::::t::::::r:::::r:::::I::::::

0  : I  : I  : I:  ; I  : I  : I  : I  :

<<

:!: I  : I  : I  : I  : I  : I  :

1.7 1.71 1.72 1.73 1.74 1.75 1.76 1.77 1.78 1.79 Measure FIGURE 3.2-T Allowable Combinations of THERM POWER and Fr

---

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

St. Lucie Unit 1 Cycle 22 COLR Rev 0 Page 10 of 13



St. Lucie Unit 1 - Proposed COLR Figure 3.2-3



 8QDFFHSWDEOH2SHUDWLRQ

$OORZDEOH)UDFWLRQRI5$7('7+(50$/32:(5 3



)U7  >[ +/-3 @



$FFHSWDEOH2SHUDWLRQ (1.79, 0.82)







       

0HDVXUHG)U7

),*85(

$OORZDEOH&RPELQDWLRQVRI7+(50$/32:(5DQG)U7