ML022660500

Summary of Meeting with NEI Regarding ESP Issues

ML022660500
Person / Time
Site:	Nuclear Energy Institute
Issue date:	10/07/2002
From:	Ronaldo Jenkins NRC/NRR/NRLPO
To:	Nuclear Energy Institute
Jenkins R, NRR/NRLPO 415-2985
Shared Package
ML022590031	List: ML022590339 ML022660500
References
Download: ML022660500 (9)

Text

October 7, 2002 ORGANIZATION: Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI)

SUMMARY

OF MEETING WITH THE NUCLEAR ENERGY INSTITUTE (NEI)

REGARDING EARLY SITE PERMIT (ESP) ISSUES On August 22, 2002, representatives from the Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI) met with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staff. The meeting was requested by NEI in order to discuss issues related to ESP applications and reviews. Representatives from Dominion Generation (Dominion), Exelon Generating Company (Exelon) and Entergy Operations, Inc.

(Entergy) were in attendance. is a list of the meeting attendees. NEI provided handouts (Enclosure 2) during the meeting which can be accessed through the Agencywide Documents Access and Management System (ADAMS). This system provides text and image files of NRCs public documents. The handouts mentioned above may be accessed through the ADAMS system under Accession No. ML022590339. If you do not have access to ADAMS or if there are problems in accessing the handouts located in ADAMS, contact the NRC Public Document Room (PDR) reference staff at 1-800-397-4209, 301-415-4737 or by e-mail to pdr@nrc.gov.

Follow-up Items from the July 16th Meeting The NEI Early Site Permit Task Force (ESPTF) committed to submit a detailed schedule of activities of the Seismic Demonstration Project prior to the next meeting and invited the staff to participate in future developmental tasks.

Topics for Next Meeting The NEI ESPTF proposed the following topics to be discussed at the September 25, 2002, meeting:

 ESP-8: Use of a bounding approach for providing fuel cycle and transportation information required by the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA)

(Table S-3 and S-4).

 ESP-10: Use for ESP of relevant findings from 10 CFR 51, Subpart B, Appendix A (License Renewal Generic Environmental Impact Statement (GEIS)).

 ESP-20: Use of existing site/facility information. The staff informed NEI that discussion of Petition for Rulemaking (PRM)-52-1 and associated matters would be prohibited until the completion of the petition process. NEI responded that matters outside of PRM-52-1 would be the subject of the discussion.

ESP-1 (ESP Application Template)

The staff provided a response to NEI via e-mail on August 19, 2002 (See Enclosure 2), to the NEI ESPTF draft document entitled Standard Table of Contents for Early Site Permit Applications which was distributed during the July 16, 2002, meeting. After describing the format of the Common Table of Contents (See Enclosure 2), the NEI ESPTF took an action item to develop any further questions for staff consideration for the next meeting which they will transmit 2 weeks prior to the meeting date.

ESP-12 (Severe Accident Mitigation Alternatives [SAMA])

The staff provided a response to NEI via e-mail on August 19, 2002 (See Enclosure 2), to the NEI ESPTF draft document ESP-12 which was distributed during the July 16, 2002, meeting.

After some discussion, it was agreed that the staff would seek to perform SAMA analyses depending on the detail of the information available in the ESP application. Therefore, further discussion on this topic will be deferred until the resolution of the plant parameter envelope (PPE) issues by the staff and the NEI ESPTF.

ESP- 6 (Use of a Bounding Plant Parameter Approach) and ESP-7 (Guidance For Satisfying 52.17(a)(1) Requirement for Description and Safety Assessment of the Facility)

The staff provided a response to the NEI ESPTF draft documents ESP-6 and ESP-7. The NEI ESPTF provided a follow-up presentation on the subject issues (See Enclosure 2).

The staff presentation emphasized the following concerns with the use of the PPE approach in ESP applications: (1) Information provided to-date is conceptual and abstract in nature.

Specific application or case studies are needed in order to test the bounds of the required staff review effort; (2) For the staffs environmental review the surrogate facility information needs to result in a realistic and realizable construction for staff evaluation; and (3) ESP-6 and ESP-7 proposes to defer disposition of ESP review items until the Combined License (COL) stage.

Any future COL action items dilute the value of the ESP.

The ESPTF presentation conveyed the following new points regarding the subject approach:

(1) Revised August 21, 2002, Form and Content of an ESP to be granted by the Commission will not specify type of reactor; (2) Applicants will not specify the type of plant (e.g.,

Pressurized-Water Reactor (PWR), Gas-Cooled Reactor); however, the technical basis used to develop the PPE would be fully disclosed to the staff; (3) The COL action to build one out of three facilities approved by the ESP under the PPE framework for a given site would not reopen the alternative sites issue if previously closed out in the ESP; (4) ESPTF would accept the business risk associated with the fact that staff approval of the PPE parameters would not imply future approval of those parameters for any design; and (5) ESP terminology and working definitions for Title 10 of the Code of Federal Regulations (10 CFR) Part 52 were introduced for future meetings. NEI took an action item to e-mail to the New Reactor Licensing Project Office (NRLPO) ESP Project Manager the revised Form and Contents of an ESP.

The staff and NEI ESPTF agreed that technical examples would be essential for the staff to make a determination on whether the bounding PPE approach could satisfy the staff review requirements associated with 10 CFR Part 50 and 10 CFR Part 100. This topic will continue to be on the agenda of future meetings until a resolution is achieved.

The staff encouraged the ESPTF to make a presentation of their PPE approach to the Advisory Committee for Reactor Safeguards (ACRS). The staff plans to meet with the ACRS in November on the development of an ESP review standard.

Public Comments A representative from Greenpeace requested staff feedback on the case law which requires that the staff perform a SAMA analysis during the ESP review. The staff took an action item to respond to the questions on this matter at the next meeting. The Greenpeace representative was asked to e-mail the subject questions to the NRLPO ESP Project Manager.

/RA/

Ronaldo V. Jenkins, Senior Project Manager New Reactor Licensing Project Office Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Project No. 689

Enclosures:

As stated cc w/encls: See next page

ML022590031-Pkg.

OFFICE PM:NRLPO DD:NRLPO NAME RJenkins MGamberoni DATE 9/26/02 10/3/02 Document Name: C:\ORPCheckout\FileNET\ML022660500.wpd Distribution for Meeting Summary Dated October 7, 2002 Hard Copy NRLPO Rdg.

RJenkins MGamberoni (original)

E-mail PUBLIC RidsNrrOD (SCollins/JJohnson)

RidsNrrAdip (WBorchardt)

NRLPO Group FEltawila TBergman JTappert BZalcman TKenyon JWilson AKugler KManoly TFoley TCerne JBlake RGardner CPaulk CMunson GBagchi EFox CHinson SKlementowicz EThrom RMcIntyre SAli JMitchell DTerao RPalla CBray AFernandez JMoore JLee MKotzalas (NRR Communication Coord)

MEL-Zeftawy CAbbott SWeerakkody KGibson EImbro DThatcher

Meeting With the Nuclear Energy Institute August 22, 2002 Attendance List NRC Nuclear Energy Institute Jim Lyons, NRR Russell Bell Ronaldo Jenkins, NRR Ron Simard Joe Williams, NRR Robert Bishop Kaz Campe, NRR Jerry Wilson, NRR Other Attendees Nanette Gilles, NRR Joe Sebrosky, NRR Thomas P. Mundy, Exelon Nuclear Thomas Kenyon, NRR Eddie Grant, Exelon Gene Imbro, NRR George Zinke, Entergy Goutam Bagchi, NRR Mike Bourgeois, Entergy Robert Palla, NRR Joe Hegner, Dominion David Terao, NRR Steve Routh, Bechtel Barry Zalcman, NRR Bob Evans, Enercon Services Stephen Koenick, NRR Guy Cesare, Enercon Services Jay Lee, NRR George Beck, Parsons E & C Tom Foley, NRR Mike Cambia, Parsons E & C Jocelyn Mitchell, RES Glenn R. George, PA Consulting Ron Gardner, RIII Roger Huston, Licensing Support Services Antone Cerne, RI Ellen Anderson, Licensing Support Services Jerome Blake, RII Patricia Campbell, Winston & Strawn Chuck Paulk, RIV Lane Hay, SERCH Bechtel Janice Moore, OGC Jim Riccio, Greenpeace Cassie Bray, OGC B. P. Singh, Department of Energy Jenny Weil, McGraw Hill David Ritter, Public Citizen-Critical Mass Joseph Malherek, Public Citizen-Critical Mass Enclosure 1

cc: Mr. Ralph Beedle Ms. Wenonah Hauter Senior Vice President Public Citizen and Chief Nuclear Officer Critical Mass Energy Project Suite 400 215 Pennsylvania Avenue, SE 1776 I Street, NW Washington, DC 20003 Washington, DC 20006-3708 Mr. George Alan Zinke Mr. Charles Brinkman Project Manager Westinghouse Electric Co. Nuclear Business Development Washington Operations Entergy Nuclear 12300 Twinbrook Pkwy., Suite 330 M-ECH-683 Rockville, MD 20852 1340 Echelon Parkway Jackson, MS 39213 Mr. David Lochbaum, Nuclear Safety Engineer Union of Concerned Scientists Mr. Thomas P. Miller 1707 H Street, NW, Suite 600 U.S. Department of Energy Washington, DC 20006-3919 NE-20, Rm. A286 Headquarters-Germantown Dr. Gail Marcus 19901 Germantown Road U.S. Department of Energy Germantown, MD 20874-1290 Office of Nuclear Energy, Science

& Technology Mr. Steve Degerdon NE-1, Room 5A-143 Fagan Engineers 1000 Independence Avenue, SW 113 East Chemung Place Washington, DC 20585 Elmira, NY 14904 Mr. William D. Magwood, IV Ms. Marilyn Kray U.S. Department of Energy Vice President, Special Projects Office of Nuclear Energy, Science Exelon Generation

& Technology 200 Exelon Way, KSA3-E Director of the Watchdog Project Kennett Square, PA 19348 NE-1, Room 5A-143 1000 Independence Avenue, SW Mr. Edward F. Sproat, III Washington, DC 20585 Vice President-Intl Projects Exelon Generation Mr. Paul Gunter 200 Exelon Way Nuclear Information & Resource Service Kennett Square, PA 19348 1424 16th Street, NW, Suite 404 Washington, DC 20036 Mr. Laurence Parme General Atomics Mr. James Riccio 2237 Trinity Drive Greenpeace Los Alamos, NM 87544 702 H Street, NW, Suite 300 Washington, DC 20001 Mr. Joseph D. Hegner Lead Engineer - Licensing Mr. Ron Simard Dominion Generation Nuclear Energy Institute Early Site Permitting Project Suite 400 5000 Dominion Boulevard 1776 I Street, NW Glen Allen, VA 23060 Washington, DC 20006-3708

Mr. Edward L. Quinn David A. Repka, Esq.

MDM Services Corporations Winston & Strawn Utility Operations Division 1400 L St., NW 28202 Cabot Road, Suite 205 Washington, DC 20005 Laguna Nigual, CA 92677 Mr. W. Edward Cummins Mr. Michael Corletti Advanced Plant Safety & Licensing Advanced Plant Safety & Licensing Westinghouse Electric Company Westinghouse Electric Company P.O. Box 355 P.O. Box 355 Pittsburgh, PA 15230-0355 Pittsburgh, PA 15230-0355 Mr. Steven A. Hucik, General Manager Mr. H. A. Sepp Nuclear Plant Projects Westinghouse Electric Company GE Nuclear Energy P.O. Box 355 175 Curtner Avenue, M/C 780 Pittsburgh, PA 15230 San Jose, CA 95125-1088 Lynn Connor Dr. Regis A. Matzie Doc-Search Associates Senior Vice President of Nuclear 2211 sw 1ST Ave - #1502 Systems Portland, OR 97201 Westinghouse Electric Company P.O. Box 500 Barton Z. Cowan, Esq. 2000 Day Hill Road Eckert Seamans Cherin & Mellott, LLC Windsor, CT 06095-0500 600 Grant Street 44th Floor Pittsburgh, PA 15219 Mr. Jack W. Roe SCIENTECH, INC.

Mr. Ed Rodwell, Manager 910 Clopper Road PWR Design Certification Gaithersburg, MD 20878 Electric Power Research Institute 3412 Hillview Avenue Mr. Russell Bell Palo Alto, CA 94304-1395 Nuclear Energy Institute Suite 400 Mr. Edwin Lyman 1776 I Street, NW Nuclear Control Institute Washington, DC 20006-3708 1000 Connecticut Avenue, NW Suite 410 Mr. John Schlecht Washington, DC 20036 Institute of Iron Working Industry Suite 400 Mr. James F. Mallay, Director 1750 New York Avenue, NW Regulatory Affairs Washington, DC 20006 FRAMATOME, ANP 3315 Old Forest Road Rod M. Krich, Vice President Lynchburg, VA 24501 Licensing Projects Exelon Nuclear 4300 Winifield Road, 2nd Floor Warrenville, IL 60555 Mr. Stephen P. Frantz Morgan, Lewis, & Bockius, LLP 1111 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20004

Mr. David Ritter Mr. Ernie H. Kennedy Research Associate on Nuclear Energy Vice President New Plants Public Citizens Critical Mass Energy Nuclear Plant Projects and Environmental Program Westinghouse Electric Company 215 Pennsylvania Avenue, SE 2000 Day Hill Road Washington, DC 20003 Windsor, CT 06095-0500 Mr. Tom Clements Mr. James Blyth 6703 Gude Avenue Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission Takoma Park, MD 20912 280 Slater Street, Station B P.O. Box 1046 Mr. Horace R. Hall, Commercial Manager Ottawa, Ontario Nuclear Business Team K1P 5S9 UCAR Carbon Company, Inc.

P.O. Box 2170 Mr. Thomas W. Ortciger, Director Clarksburg, West Virginia 26302-2170 Illinois Department of Nuclear Safety 1035 Outer Park Drive Hugh Jackson, Policy Analyst Springfield, IL 62704 Public Citizens Critical Mass Energy and Environment Program 1724 Duarte Drive Henderson, NV 89014 Patricia Campbell Winston & Strawn 1400 L Street, NW Washington, DC 20005 Mr. Vince Langman Licensing Manager Atomic Energy of Canada Limited 2251 Speakman Drive Mississauga, Ontario Canada L5K 1B2 Mr. Victor G. Snell Director of Safety and Licensing Atomic Energy of Canada Limited 2251 Speakman Drive Mississauga, Ontario Canada L5K 1B2 Mr. Glenn R. George PA Consulting Group 130 Potter Street Haddonfield, NJ 08033