ML19337B440

Viewgraphs of, Structural Modeling Refinement & Development of Improved Analytical Procedures.

ML19337B440
Person / Time
Site:	Columbia
Issue date:	09/18/1980
From:	BURNS & ROE CO.
To:
Shared Package
ML19337B432	List: ML19337B433 ML19337B435 ML19337B436 ML19337B439 ML19337B440
References
NUDOCS 8010020411
Download: ML19337B440 (33)

Text

. - _ . - .

O .

STRUCTURAL MODELING REFINEME'lT M

DEVELOPMENT OF IMPROVED ANALYTICAL CROCEDURES (0BJECTIVE #2) l l

THIS DOCUMENT CONTAINS POOR QUAllTY PAGES l

8010020f//e4

o .

I BURP:S NJU HOL. INC. .

. .. . .cn . o. . .. 9 e

, w 0.t:n .. . . 0a n" . . - Uc+ t;n -. . P*ne Na .--

c , .....; N o . . _. _ Ca.c. No. f.r. e t co ni . o n '. . t-By . _ ,_ f.neth eff ADW'Ovec Title - - '

[ ^

i l l

1

/ .

o

/ .

\

p I

l [I I J

vn c

XiTdm ,* !.r fH ~XIS) y.

~ ~~-

k*eXfM \

Ll.V ._

i

r. >

/

/

. .~, .

- I i

1 w

• tg .. . . . ... - - _ t . .._.. ... .

~

1 v.

/

V -

e -- - .

do% ~72,.5,

. . d. .

. / / *WW. W_%V - /.6

_ __/ / ,)c.- (+)

' / .

7 i , . ,-

.as i' , / <

< .- i -

/ / /

,  % b Ol(,=Ol$

Wf$LI (&

l SG7 ;"H/C doA-D.$

1 Y ,

l l 1 l

l s

BUltNS AND itOt., INC.

ree nuwen s CH<

• O * *= > " 's * *

v. o * .. . ._ . D 4 t- . . . _ . _ . . Pci.6 f +<>

. Pa<:e No.

,be.e.v.td f=3 _ _ . .. C44C. No

-s ._ . Sheet Qnt. on Sne.:t _

13 . . . . .. CJ'fC E Cd A potCved T in _ .

8

.l l }

S '

g __ .

! f

.\

gi a .

j , . .

-. . . . . . / ,.- , / *

/ _, /,

... . . g

/ /,JJ llW, ,

i

, /  %,, /

./

-- ~

/ .. / / '

s

-- // - \

/ ! /

o Q . / (',/ / s

% f / / #

fn /// /\

-. /, / . . . . -

'"" N  :

/ _i vr i e\^

\

-- - CA - - - --

i LA

, 2 gWe>.24 5 gs,4 , --- - --

j/ . ; .,

.i ,.

- j%7;tepg, ,m

.l4l/

i 7 s

..- V /l.ll

_ / / /

6,.4 ,~n,%)._1*~r? - -

T,f,/~ A W/ "

s .

.....N Bwlomc AL=fcc 70 Hya m y.umic !cibo.S Y

e .

k

STRUCTURAL MODELING/ ANALYTICAL PROCEDURES

SUMMARY

AXISYMEETRIC WATER-STRUCTURE-SOIL COUPLED SYSTEM ASSUMED.

o REASONABLE ASSUMPTION SINCE MAJOR STRUCTURAL COMPONENTS ARE AXISYMMETRIC, ARBITRARY (NON-AXISYMMETRIC) LOADING HANDLED THROUGH DECOMPOSITION TO FOURIER HARMONICS.

FINITE ELEMENT METHOD OF ANALYSIS USED. FINITE ELEMENTS UTILIZED:

- AXI-SYMMETRIC SHELL ELEMENTS AXI-SYMMETRIC SOLID ELEMENTS THREE-DIMENSIONAL FLUID ELEMENTS SOLUTION OBTAINED IN FREQUENCY DOMAIN o MORE EFFICIENT / ECONOMICAL FOR THIS TYPE OF PROBLEM. l l

A MODIFIED VERSION OF ASHD-2 COMPUTER CODE WAS USED. i l

LINEAR PROPERTIES ASSUMED FOR ALL THREE SYSTEM COMP 0ENTS: j WATER (INCOMPRESSIBLE, INVISCID), STRUCTURE AND S0ll.

o ASSUMPTION VALIDATED BY CAORSO/TOKAI-2 TEST RESULTS.

STRUCTURAL DAMPING CONSIDERED HYSTERETIC.

o ADVANTAGEOUS FOR USE IN SYSTEMS WITH DIFFERENT ELEMENT DAMPING VALUES; FREQUENCY INDEPENDENT.

REFINED MODELING OF STRUCTURAL COMPONENTS CONSTITUTING THE SUPPRESSION CHAMBER NtiiED BOUNDARY WAS IMPLEMENTED USING SOLID FINITE ELEMENTS.

IMPROVED ANALYTICAL PROCEDURES ADEQUATE FOR SUCH APPLICATIONS WERE DEVELOPED.

RESULTS OBTAINED WERE DIFFERENT FROM THOSE OBTAINED  ;

ANALYZING THE ORIGINAL MODEL.

RESULTS OBTAINED COMPARE ADEQUATELY WITH MEASURED BUILDING RESPONSES AT CA0RSO.

1 i

)

i l

i

l

. I I

i f

38 1I0 i

1 3

b \

O g o e--e 71 4 a144.23

- %l O-m .

)

0 g

<>-D I4 0 3) 7 a 87.29

- % 24 i l

C 3 1

2 58.25, .

c 3 W3 o 0  :)

Es 12.1' -

. O e o 6 6 3 e o.o' 1 3

i ,.

I i I

,i 41.3 3'_

g -

c GA.9 -.

WASEDIGTCW N POEX SUFFLY ST3 TEM CACRSr RI.AC"'OR 3C!*3::TG ' "*

m P n w 30. 2 CONVIN!!CNAL MCOE* 57

? : ?!G' .

i i

l

• i I

N i \'

. .

1 i ,, 7 a 134.29 .- . ,

t i mg, l 1

~

e  ;

.i l.

Z . 87. 21. ' . -,

w 3 sa.n: .

\!bb l

I 7 = 2 2. 2 ' - -

l

.f .i .l.i .l .

e .t .i.l .i .l .I T.

• 6 o ,

rrt _

1 0.o. ,_

y Ns ;.

vx_ 1

, ,.I N

f. # (

_. ._-._.._I

.ATT.' .

43

. .! - 08 9 i

li d 1 N N NCPWEllSUFFLT N CACRSC REACOR 3C;;;;;G U"-

m 7%w n 2 .v3RCVIO .v.CCEL 7,1

3 -

i h LEGEND Wf CONVENTIONAL MODEL

'p d .8

-- IMPROVED MODEL .

?l -

9 e "Q @ .E 1:-

(D

% .l i

1 z :o i O m ,

d8 9 '

i,  ;-

ye y . . .

l

$$ IU

u i 20 6 g.) g'! 3

g

, Q o .g- A x o i i 4 i /  ;

N:.i

,-!j J .., i u{ js /

1 s  ;

o s / x .

I -

l

!

.s :

! i f p /

?O lp a ss o \hg\,\ s -

l

/

j 9 ,d. ,l ' '

1 v

~/e ._ - \/

' %. oo 2'o. oo u'o. oo s'o. on n'o. oo n'20. oo ihn.on FREQUENCY (112 )

ioo.on iso.ooj

-s 3 ,

• ;

u, b

l

WNP-2 REACTOR BUILDING RESPONSE TO SRV DISCHARGE LOADS 1

l

MATHEFATICAL MODEL 1

l l

l l

l l

\

l

i l

l 4

SRV DISCHARGE EVENTS / LOAD CASES

o SINGLE VALVE DISCHARGE CASE (INNER AND OUTER) 1 o TWO VALVES DISCHARGE CASE i

o ADS VALVES DISCHARGE CASE i o ALL VALVES DISCHARGE CASE AXISYMMETRIC LOADING CONDITION NEARLY SYMMETRIC LOADING CONDITION I

a i

CALCULATED RESPONSES (ALL RESPONSES SHOWN CORRESPOND TO A FAXIMUM PRESSURE AMPLITUDE OF +1. pst. TO OBTAIN REAL/ DESIGN LEVEL i'

RESPONSES MULTIPLY RESULTS SHOWN BY +11.20.) i

.

l l

l l

l l

I

i l

l C

C e

e . _

m e

O e

_= -

C C

_ =a C

i C c

.c I N e

c.x  ;

_e u '

cz  ;

t.:J l 1

a '

o l i e ua .

!' _c t.:_

l k '

e i C a

a _c i n, =

1 i, l e

e s

- - _ c' b -

t c r C

_ c C

ch a cc 'a os 't

_0I= (3) cc t N G I).88313336 ca 'a on 'o cd NN NC N N N 'IZ2TICE RIS?cNsz A; RP'I SU??CRT w n. EAR P1n:n 30. 2 C 'IE'v'IS .W? 3.3a

e C

e

= . _

C

=

e

=.'

C C

. =

.~_

l i

C I o

=

• l c 1

.a-N

=  !

e C >- .

cu

==

ta

=

a Ct c .L.:

. c:::

_a'O u.

e l C i

. l r=C.

-)

Ii e C

_e F

N

.- r t

~

e C

cs E cc c c h 'a ca 't ca t cs 'o cc c

.Gi* (3) NGil.S'313006 d

NN NO ?WE3L SWFLI M '7ERTICAL RISPCNSI A; apy 3(;ppeg; N m inc.m so. 2 ' ALL VALVES - SF? 3,35

e C

O e . -

O C

.. e

.= ..

C C

i

~

O C

i

.C-N_

e C >-

.C u

=z w

a a

Ow

.z.

.cO u C

C 1

_C 2

,9 h

I C 1 C 9

.f _C

~

_u c

c .__

_c - e C

cc .p

'CC ' E cs a oc'a os 't oc 't as <c

.0 t = (3) N 0 I _10'd :.,l e' J -u N N N SY3 TEM HCR *0N*A, ars;cnSZ AT R?V SU??CR*' **

M P E"ECT 30. 2 S*NGI.Z 7A!,'/Z ( m;Z3) _ *m- ~- S.4a

C C

~ .

. e a . _

C C

e 1

1 I

e  !

c 1

• 1 e 1

.~-

1 C

o C

= _C N

e C >-

_c u

=z u:

2 O

e ta c

.e:

.eo u_

l e

C

_e-e C

_=

j N L

A Y

~ o C

-02,sI cc 't cs 'c ch 'c

, 03 'a cz 'o oc '0

,u

. .G t = (D) N r. i- w _:

1 WN NC PmER sayLT sTs:sn sca;;;g;A;,, 3337C382 C E?V SU??CR"^

M P E*ECT 100. 2 SIMOIE 7)L VI '(!!CIR[ - $?? g , ,g 3

e C

, e

= . _

o C

O

_=- .

=

a .

C e

Q e

_e-N_

e C

.h

_a u

=z i w 2

o CW o.c::

_e u.

e e

O C

I .

_e

'A 4

e Q

_e N

I o

w r e e u C

C co s cc s cc h cc 'c co a oc 't cc 'c" c.Ci* (D) N G I J. S 'd 3 1 3 3 3 6 WASLW PUBLIC PCarn SUFFI.T STrmt ECR!::0NTE RES?CNsz A; R2V SC??CRT '

M PET E 2 S OC2 VMVI (CCTIR) .9? 3.4c

e C

, o

= . _

e C

e

~~~_~ .

C O

O

_m -

C O

• C

.c-a

=

C o >..

_c u

=z e

o a

ou o .z

_c u_

e i e I C i .

_=-

c i e o

!i _ e' N

~

e ch a cc a os ': ca 's ca 's ch 'c cc 'c z GI= (3) NG ilS'd373J J S dASEDIGTCiG PCELZ PCWER SUFFL7 ST3 tdt #

3CR*3CNTAI RESPCNSI AT 2?V SU??CRT

• K".2AR P E T NO. 2 SUiGLE VAI7Z (CC"IR) - SF? 9,4(

em n c

-- o O

o - -

C o

o

r C

C C

.N

=

0 o

.c~'

N

~

/

C

.c CJ

• Z t.:J C

C CL:

' = 1.:

c

- J o

- n

/ [ c

.c .-

~ c

" C

} r f ,,. C N

F_ _

C N O CC'S CC '3 CC'h CG E CC 3 CC i CC ' b*

eOP (3) NGM.SM37333S N N N SWFLT SYSTEM VIRT!CAI RISPONSI 0F CON;A;;;33;;; CGCRE m P n zc; E 2 SEILI A; DIApg3Acx 7.,ceg ,

A!.J VAI7IS- yyp 9.5a

e Q

O l C l e

C C

I C

• C e

.n_.

C C

C

.c-N_

=

C o >.

.c u

=z w

a o

ew c

.e

.em u O

C

% %N \ .c 8

U f -$

EF __

T o D ca at c ct c ac c sc 'c nc 'c ac'c ccM (J) NCI188313JJ8 I

1 N PcnI.:C Pownt suryLT sty:zu UN

'lIRT CAL RESPCNSE OF CONTAINMI.7 Ex=mut PnECT E 2 83 A 5~,*IAl*IIS - SFPAT O!APHRAGM ." 0CR . .

s.:b t

l

C Q

e e

C O

Q

=.- .

> a C

e

_n C

C e

.o N_

O o >-

_e u

=z tu o

A-o o tu ll o: .a

_e u_

m 1

1 O

[C C

_o ww e

- C

_e N

a O

cc o sz c cz o sc o cc c" st o at c (3) NO I16'd373JJ6 -

l wasarscTeu PcaL:c Pcessa suyFT.I SY3 TEM HCRI:0:CA;. RESPCNSI CF CO!CA TMI:t "

i m pign;zc? 30. 2 SEEII A " OI APHRAG.V. F

= _:rc:.'I n:.n e er._-..,, _'2C. .FR3 s.sa

1

• a

- e

.__ - . _ . . . _ .__..________-_ o e

e C

C O

_=

e

. o C

_n C

C -

e

_c N

=

c

_c u

=z e

( 2

- o ow c . c:

_e t

// -

1. g

_=c.

e C

rN l

[ i- f- [_~~~-_ l 8

si 'a cc Y cz 'o ac c hz'c zI o ha c CD) NGIISM373336 WED8CCit PCEL*C PCOMDL SCFFLI Sm HCRI*CNTE JJ.SPCNSE CF CC.'C.LM

• 6 Phw n 2 SEZI.L AT DIAp3pAcx 7.CCR 9.5b S3GI.I 'IAl*/r ret - p s _ e- a

e c

-. . . . . _ _ s . #~ . e

. \

c ,

i

== . .

1 e 1 C

= \

O 1

_7  !

1 1

=  !

o .

I o I

. .N l C

C o l ra N j _

ft a s

c >- .

.c U m--

u

! O o

Et:

~. %

t

_ c t.

' \. o o

- - /- _e .-

' w

> c o

- _ - _c

.N h xN_

e I

Q h3 "O CC C 3i'C 3;'C. . . - - 0,0_# c hC 'c CC ' b" (3) N g t .,. e .;: t o .s .; my wAsaneCTCN PUBI.:::: POWER SUFFI.T STSTEN V-20!CA . RESPCNSI CF C0!CA!:U.Z:C MM

• x":. tut PEM 30. 2 SHI!.I I:I TE3 ::Rrc.1 ' 3*h AI.* VALVTS -F.??

o .

- - - - - - -. - .--.. ........-__..s=

e e

e c

e e

e -

e=- ..

e e

e

_m-.

e e

o

.e N

e p e >-

.o a

=z tu a

C

, eu o:

l .e s .ca u- ,

f e

e

- _e~

g

- o e

- ~ r. .

.e N

i  %%

e Q ~4e l fiz s'o ca a g;.c g;.g 'c-'

noc oc c-(3) NOIJ.tiy31333h WM PCECC PONDt scyg,y g ,7g,--. A,. .USPCNSI CF Ca'i"'An:~vn;.- CM N PE'Ec?no.2 SHII.* Of NI gyp ~. . 3.'/b A_,.~ IA*.'/Ts - gy7

p. Q e .

e e

I C

I C e

_=

a .

e

• , o i .

e

, _u O

O e

l a N

. l I.

! o >-

I l _o u

==

w m

i.

a c u:

.4 .c:

_ce u.

i

/ /

O I C

_e

- =

- - ~

~~ - -

1 O C

F F F [ --

__ ~ -

e C

EI'c ci c ac c sc 'c sc 'c ac 'c cc @.

(3) NOI168313338 wAscoc?38 FUsL:c Ponta scryLY STsTzu HCRI:CNTA;., .US?CNSI CF CO2i"'A2 0c:;; FIM

'80 CLEAR PET 150, 2 33 4 */A*273ORr4E!L S.[iG".,IN (CCr. a) wF?

3 33

I i

, 4

( . ,

i 1

1

~ .. . _ . - .

o s

., a .

i o

o l

o C

o

_w- .

1 l

c Q

c

.N O

C c

c

~

m N

i o l * >-

J _Of) i *2 E W

'r ~3

,h C 1 m CW j .%

, _c L:

r o r

o C

"E Ff."F

~

o O

ANN _e N

"{mn0!$a3,3?ll* ac 'o x4 M M N SD FLT STsTsu HCRjjC!,Cn RIsyc333 cy g;3u,,, r,, ngig

- ,m w. m. 2 3-- v :'ar car--- '

SING:.2 vn ,g (eg7y,q) , yp g,gh

9

+

4 8 m OS DISCUSSION OF RESULTS l l 1

1

l l D* lD lD 030lh )

m o M o M J)U . InL= l

...a :7;+ \

.~,1 - f .,-

v .y.' . - 2 . . ; ,: . J '; .%;.L :,HX. 4' ;t,5,~G

L

. - c.'h;.Qn o ..J ':

h.

W+W 5

2;&q rN&m 'Wi3av:r: .; 4 .i- in- ! g.:1M ,:..:t ^ G:.n

.  ;

.s I

} ' :: . _-+.' ~ . ~ ';;b.ll :3. [ y ag?y,R;.f;y:p:c.*i}

p.> .

Q-1gQWOW:QE Q.. W j.: 1.sM*2:9 -,';e;Cs. lpyV;p

" ' R $ M M .- F M** % Y f 3$.'d:7lJk. .

. b bk

.t.L.50 # 6 W D! Q .. ..>..n.,

,,~. im[j y.'# [s.$f.// 4 ?c'N

. a , e~e.n:a. . .y: , ..a.:. ,

.s

.,e.c.

,- m. s..,...s.v. ,. ,~y .sn.

y,,.c ..s m

,w.. o. w . n.~n s

g.y.-5.> p 4z.a M.nerv~ .v..#w.-2 a.-

oDm . Q ;. x..!.,6 4 " Of?p w$ w A .e@- -

,,,G.-@~ g.J'3p

.., n,. . *w, FJ $ h.iM Q'5

. M. ,;.S '.E-; s..c g.,e , ,w .w;-m,

..:.s. o .m..

3.. ..o. . . . . .

- u c 4 .. ,

~c .,.. ., x .

1-> e .,

o, .% 6 +. r. s n::\,.. n .u:. % s. ;.%. . - A ';h.l.

" .Q.%. .-pp,tn,hf .)? jhd&. Mlly$ - a k Q[:h

~ %.,n.'l~@'ES.;iz, * .AGT9;.'Q.Wlh.

~ *"* "G."

~.e-[

e . . n.gra v.r _. . ; .e. .-

. : t w .g m . s ;- n~; . p . ,s

.s

. y. . . -.n - 9 - -p.. .>v.:Mw .-0'm .

a,1 w .j.. , .a. .<,., .

.- ~, .,.,,

..  %. a. .

.s. . 1 WiW.P.1,.6 . 4., W.5t%. eQ. . / c-a W - . .:" g/d,M. g... R.9

'fC 3.,,s s ae

• s. .

• ? *y ' i,,. y4

..

• m - . u =.

-- ~.. . ., t' - .

., .$4 44.0,4%%

• ^

. . h ' ,.. 'l$ , 3.nWr. J.s~ ' h ::.l..*.. ~

~,V ' .4 Y . M y. M &f t ?.W

- Y'Nr5 *[R'.k-i$"'hIIh..pi' r M .

r eni },'. '"i [( j'#fhj{$[,f'dj l Y ;fh* sf'Y- "',"

.,;,c y . D ..~ '.." %

. -f ll

.s <

-w) m --

2.-.g * ~ "#l ", ' . %* @.I; 7 * .q., .N p A- 'y -

. op

.' l' It y c.

- [gDJ)'[ . . s . 'W; l.r k- < J,[.d; m . -

-G.E')i? ,

nngar. ' . $ <)Ll$.W}.$.l 'm-C I

._ N . @ I* N:/ W -

Y T-T'*-V**

k ;$*/.

[$?!%}

mema

[

r w , e}r' v !. ~ ~

,,{

• MM I . ,,

1. iNEN?$ '~M

.; 4 f% .

.a i,, hI5!!NdM,$Y ,

.M; .1.<.n".:.h- .?. pg- ? J.W* p ta' '. .f.

^ ^

.n . _,. .9,

., ,>f)r; ;..y w% we f w-q,.,y.

u

.o . -

. ~.. , v ,,e q.-: .-n .w

...'g.

.~ L -1

-* ryd' n ;. a e e>-

m.,nas.-rd M c.ts.4 .d .,.

• N -w .

St. .

.y .f5 4 O

'- Q' '$a' %..V . 1

. Q $,m M., . I)l

%,7.y'< g . v

8... m. -:, s.t::

ar .q' w.

.. ~ ps. .m. .

u g;t ue of . usp .

-. : .w, ew. ,5.

7 ~.6a%.a.M,%..j G C

-c.:c,r:q VM

%w y FwC7=

,u w $ m i rit u e ,:. 9

n. . .co== M ~, .

4. ; .Wq R y* o -Qp.W

,.:. wm..-. y$;M M 'g

-4.  ??x;w r, .W p.. - - ~ ~ .~  ! x.

== ==%:@..

um ..n.

t

.< - a

% . ~ ~ p,#u4;.p%J.&.r;cc-h, _w.!C

. .e c: .

, -m E*j t'm. ,yW:Q DeADMAGE;On. ! d w it S*. .. % . ' h -

_' .} DMCE ' I [Q' )fg f [*#3UPPORT M I ,

c .fr -

p,,.c . .4 cou=. ; ew

. f.;. x.

j .; p;, *.?... g M  :. ym.- M ...f.r *f4 v +.:,..,

,_ -v-g .p:.y,

+

e -t v .__,c (/c w

. ~ .w. . w u

, m,?.o . .:.m;- .

W w 3.1; ,A, ._-e.; .-Eniv8M39 simm edif4MerwrisvesF .

Mark 11 Pressure Suppression Containment ZONEI ZONE 11 Z O N E lil WASHINGTON PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM FIGURE ZONES OF STRUCTURAL RESPONSE NUCLEAR PROJECT NO. 2 8.9

M REFERENCE 8.5

, , , - . - REFERENCE 8.6 1.o I I i  ! i

__ LJ i '

• i i .

6

..r  ! '_ _

SUGGESTED LIMIT F0lt -

MACHINE FOU:3DATICNS 'IF -~I I ' t  !

' l f

/ /

,4. . _.

( lI  : e I /

~ II / I AVERAGE LIMIT o.1 'Nl / ID' -v/

w:fI Z i

s OF HUMAN i TOLERANCE

- k. L i }- i i ,

i I

, ./. . i i,,.f i s 6 ii i i i 6 6 .-n i ,

i<ii-  :', i i/t i:i l

\' I lll MI l lllI

\ ^

ll l /l N BEGIN TO BE '

/

/

kjg;g i I

UNPLEASANT I ! !III l

. . o.o1 ~-

, e .Y.r, .

4 , . . . . . . . <, ..

g 6 6 *6 i.i 6

' ' BEGIN TO

- 6 i i i. /4 i' PERCEIVE

g. I !IlI / t  !  : .Iti w-l l' i / i

~

ji l/

w g y '

6 \ /

O. col \s# -

e t i'. t . . . ,..

.i i . . .

I  ! I I e ,fl

]

i 1 ll 1 I i Ill l l

ll ll llt lD l /DUNOR. MVM* %2W 1

~Ts* s i-o.00o1 / h .; N b 5 5

. I s lo so 100 35g,(ce)

FREQUENCY OF V!BRATION, e.p .

WASHINCTCN PUBLIC PCWER SUPPLY SYSTEM VEMION TOLEPANCE ODSERVATIONS NUCLEAR PROJECT NO. O g , c)tCfLP MYA*

i _

N REFERENCE 3.5

,,--- REFERENCE 8.6 l

1.0

< i , , . .

1

' I

• t ,, i  ! . l

. I [ , i:

i

,{ g i e

~~bIl

- - ~ ~

SUGGESTED L!fitT FOR , h-

- ~ ~ ' '

MACH!!iE FCU;1DAT10fiS. -

I l i I ' l l .-

l \/i /

e

- 1

, , /.-7 .

f I f AVERAGE LIMIT I CF HUMA'4 l 0.1 [lN -f IT I l l I TCLERAfiCE I p __v. -

-w. ,t. ,  ;

. i # , t . + ie i A 6 . t i i e I e X iI

. i/I 6 ? , ,

i i/I i i 11 N1 i i6 i l M t I iiit

, 'h ^

lI [ / l Y BEG!?1 TO 3E - '

j  ;- .

UNPLEASAt47

/ , l l I lll

- 0.01 6

. r

/

1. 2 _ i r-4 i + , i ., , ,x .

t g 6 6 - 6 i i i

/ 't SEGIfl TO '

p 1ei *I i/' '

'PERCE!YE i g ii il / l l i i +isi "I '

w. lll -

ll / l l!i ll s

x l/ I I N /

d O.001

\

\s

[ '

i ,,e: 4  ! e i, i.,

, .. . . i .. .

t il .

I t iI .I6I i ti a /T I I i i til l ,Hi / '\ l i Il:  !; *

• A " ^' "

u  !/ / M l !8_

j. Ui s t.

0.0001 I 1 5 10 50 100 A 7.3 E CGE)

FREQUE! ICY OF VIBRATIOrte eps-WASIIINGTCN PUBLIC PCWER SUPPLY SYSM FIm VIDRATION TOLEMNCE CDSERVATICNS NUCII.AR PRCJECT NO. vs. cAcRGo CATA

.

. l N' REFERE!CE 3.5 l

, , - - REFERENCE 8.6 1.0 , , .. , . ..,i I

QLi i ' '

' ii'I

! ' ..'.t i

' }_ { _ _ . }

' - ~~ - - - -

SUGGESTED LIMIT FOR MACH!tl5 FCU;1DATICris I '

'. .h 1.1 . . . . .

1 I Ii ,

' l l l l! f l 1 g/ /

/

/ l

,d.

l1I Ii /

i / /

AVERAGE LIMIT 4.1  ! 4i

/ OF HUMAtt j i i TOLEP.ArlCE

- af '. .M lk, }ii ,

/ ,

• t *s i /

$ A l 4 l i i l 8,d I &

.! i< i ii i s i i,ri iin N1 1 1i;sti 1<l I i i t il

\ N lll ll / ' I Y BEGIN TO BE ~

/ ,l >

UNPLEASAt4T

/ g/l f l I I!li I

. . 0.01

/

/?-T \

f g

i __ .

i + +ie

.. i i i

_e i .

I 6 i

/ \ I g i ii.I i/i e'3EGIN PERCEIVE TO '

g i II il / l i : ! . tie "i l i l' i / I !Ii l k -- '

l . / l w g l / I

a. /

0.001 \s#

. il... t . , , , ..

i . . . 4 . . . i.,

n , , , , ,,,

. et , i,-} l ] lI l l l l i l l1. Rerjat. AMC.CteC';te ' A /LA Av A3

                                       ,/         \/                             jv                                     5                             pf
           .          0.0001                                                                                                I     s y g g,g}

l 5 10 50 100 j FREQUENCY OF VIBRATION, q,. WASitINCTCN PUSLIC PCWER SUPPLY SYSTEM FIan 11I",, RATION TOLED,%NCE OBSERVATIONS NUCI. EAR P E'EC'T NC. 2 4 , @ gCo Wk

o N REFERENCC 8.5

                                      ,,--- REFERENCE 8.6 I

1.0

                                                                              ;                               ,          1                           ;

i i_a, , . .

                                                      .I            !                                   '

1

• J i

                                                                 ._l_ d                                 I
                                                                                                                                       ~~7~

SUGGESTED LIMIT FOR - #' - T

                                                                                               'I       I MACHINE FOU 4DATIONS 11I        I               '   l                            _/

I l \, ' [

                                                                                                    -.. I- /

j i . f i 8 i y l AVERAGE LIMIT l OF HUMAN O.1 l lN .f lT v I  : TOLERAt1CE p_i, , a_. , .. i.. ; ; ,; .. , i e A 6 i e i i e ip.l l

                                              .        I/ 1 e ?            !'                    !      t j' t i i !!                                                            j N1               L i!Il                         X1 ! I t il!                                                                     ,
                                                ,     h

• l!ll / [j l 1 BEGIN TO 3E -

                                            /
                                              /

ll j

                                                                                 ,         I     l UNPLEASANT l i ll!I l
                         ."      0.01
                              .                        i f

4.,.-T.- -

                                                                                                                                                                                 ;

ii>t - f  ! ..

                                                                               '                                                                                               ;

5 -

                                                                                                'T BEGIN TO p                                       i 'i         *1
                                                                                           !/.          .' PERCEIVE i

1 g l l ii i / 1 l i e i. I "i u,. If l / I I!!  ! s . l/ I I l w g / 1 5 N / - 0.001 \ t i ., te i .i . i ii

                                    -                                    i    ,            4            .         ,      ,

i ii! t i iii 1 i A I i'.ll l l' ll, rg / lMNEMO# "" l A{l% IA / V Ql l id'

• ei M-t-

                                                <[

l O.0001 >

                                                                                                                                                       .2202                     '

1 5 10 50 100 AI3E h 6) FREQUENCY OF VIBRATION, eps. WASHINCTCN PUDLIC PCWER SUPPLY SYSM I* VICRATION TOLERANCE OBSERVATIONS NUCII.AR PR^4 CT NO. 2 g, p 4 l

9 ,, ,

     /

CONCLUSIONS-AN IMPROVED SRV DISCHARGE LOAD DEFINITION WAS DEVELOPED USING CAORSO IN-PLANT SRV TEST RESULTS. THIS DEFINITION (AS WELL AS CAORSO DATA) IS CONFIRMED BY TOKAI-2 IN-PLANT SRV TESTS. STRUCTURAL MODELING AND ANALYTICAL PROCEDURES ADEQUATE FOR CALCULATING RESPONSES OF A MARK II CONTAINMENT STRUCTURE SUBJECTED TO SRV DISCHARGE LOADS HAVE BEEN DEVELOPED. WHEN THE IMPROVED LOAD IS APPLIED TO THE CA0RSO CONTAINMENT THE CALCULATED RESPONSES ARE COMPARABLE TO TEST RESULTS. WHEN THE IMPROVED LOAD IS APPLIED TO WNP-2 ITS STEEL CONTAINMENT PREDICTED RESPONSE IS COMPARABLE TO TOKAI-2 STEEL CONTAINMENT MEASURED RESPONSE. FINITE RESPONSES TO SRV DISCHARGE LOADS WERE RECORDED (AND ARE PREDICTED) IN THE WETWELL AREk ATTENUATED RESPONSES IN THE DRYWELL AREA AND NEGLIGIBLE RESPONSES OUTSIDE THE PRIMARY CONTAINMENT. I}}