ML19337B433
| ML19337B433 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Columbia |
| Issue date: | 09/18/1980 |
| From: | BURNS & ROE CO. |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19337B432 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8010020400 | |
| Download: ML19337B433 (14) | |
Text
.
9 SRV DISCHARGE LOADS I:!PRC'/EJ DE?I?lITI001 AilD APPLICATIO ! ".ETHODCLOGY TO l! ARK II C0flTA!liliEllTS PRE?AREJ 3Y BUR?!S AliD RCE, I?!C.
FOR APPLICATICtl TO WASHINGT0il PUELIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM WilP-2 THis DOCUMEilT CONTAINS POOR QUAllTY PAGES i
8 010 0 2 0V00'
SRV DISCHA.?CE C'/ '!T DESCRI3ED IN OFFR - RE/. 3 IN sui 2ARY, AFTER SRV ACTUATION THE FCLLOWI?iG E/E?lTS TAXE PLACE SEGUEilTIALLY.
SR'/ OPE.'lS; STEA.'1 FR0ii ?!AIN STEAfi L!.'IES FL0t.is INTO Af!D PRESSURIZES THE SRV DISCHARGE LINE (SRVDL);
lIATER INITIALLY Ill SRVDL IS DISCHARGED I'1TO SUFFRESSI0il FOOL;
- AIR INITIALLY Ill SRVDL IS DISCHARGED INTO SUFFRESSION FOOL; ST A!1 FLOWS THROUGH QUENCHER HOLES AND CONDENSES I'l THE SUFFRESSION FOOL.
P9ESE'!T 59V Discu;;gE Lean gE:!;t!Tig.il i
THE LOAD IS DE?It!ED AS SR'l " AIR EU33LE'.' LOAD AllD IS SPECIFIED AS A " RIGID 'dALL" PRESSURE LOAD ACTINC.2.': THF.
SUPPRESSI0ti PCOL WETTED PERIMETER.
THE LOAD SPECIFICATION IS DESCRI3ED IN DFFR-REV. 3 AflD COISISTS OF THE FOLL0t!ING ELEMENTS:
I.
PEAK (POSITIVE AtlD !iECATIVE) PRESSURE i
AEPLITUDES; II.
AN IDEALIZED PRESSURE TIME HISTORY (FREQUENCY CONTENT);
III.
SPATIAL DISTRIBUTION FOR PRESSURE, AND A METHOD FOR C0fiBI.'ll.'!G MULTI?LE SRV DISCHARGE EFFECTS.
l
RES?ONSES OF WNP-2 CONTAI.'E.'lT STRUCTURE CALCULATED USIlG PRESENT/DFFR-REY. 3 LOAD DEFI.'lITI0fl ARE UNREALISTICALLY LARGE.
l SRV SINGLE ' <- /E - SUBSECUENT i
SSE 4
i RPV SUPPORT I
I i
10.3 I
j L
b HORIZCNTAL L
i L
L t
i l
i 4.)
=
m j
3.0b r- - s l
i E
I i
O l
5 i
\\
i i
e- - -
=
l I
I l
i w
i i
i 1
I D
l
\\
N
\\
y 1.3 g
j
'i L
t I
i'
~
l
'l
~
F s
/
\\f 7
y 1
i l
~
i I
.4 -
I
,I
\\<
1 x
3*
r-.,
\\
I i
I
.2 1
.- - i j
i I
4
.3 1.0 1.2 1.62.02.4 3.2 4.0 6.J 3.3 10. 12 15 ;0 24 32 40 FRECUENCY (Hz)
WPPSS - NUCLEAR PROJECT 22 Surns and Roe, fnc.
11/7/79 I
f
=.. -
._.._ =
i 1
- ed J
SRV $1NCLE VALVE - SUBSECUENT SSE RPV SUPPORT io i
[
VERTICAL
~
i l
i l
l t
4L f
3-l i
m i;
2-I I,
i-3 i
e-p I
\\
l I
I s
=
1 l
.F l
a t.o L-'
y u
U
\\
f 3 I I
1 l
i i
o o
i F.1
.4
(.
i
.3 -
f
't I
.2 f
~
t
(
J i
r I
.4
.s
.s i
1.2 1.s 2 2.4 3.2 4
s a to 12 is zo :4 22 ao FREQUENCY (H2)
I A
WPPSS - NUCLEAR PROJECT =2 Burns and Roe, Inc.
11/7/79 6
t L
l SRV SINGLE VALVE - SUBSECUENT SSE s
STABILIZER TRUSS 10.0 i
HORIZONTAL I
L 4.0 -
y
__q L
I t
3.3
,I i
p I
I I
k i
i 2.3 f
t---
a s
i----
=
2
/
l i
i e
i
/
f i ;
o 1.3.
s l
t I I
w j
u l
i, U
i i
W
\\
l s.
~
r y
l A,
.50
.40 l..
1, x
.30
/.
?
1.
/
.20
/
/
(.
/
/
1
/
!s
.4
.6
.3 1.0 1.2 1.6 2.0 2.4 3.2 4.0 5.0 3.310.012.015 J 20 24 32 40 FRECUENCY (H:*)
WPPSS - NUCLEAR PROJECT x2 r
t Burns and Rce, Inc.
11/7e79 I
i
\\
4 1
I J
l i,
SRV SINGLE VALVE - SUBSECUENT
]
l SSE I
1
~
i STABILIZER TRUSS f
10 g
g i i i
F i
t g
VERTICAL i
}
e,TO PEAK 1
VALUEi 3
CF g
22.5 i i a
.g
?
D 4
r.
64
-l g.
It -
i 3-i 4
I ll s
l J
1 g
2 l
Il 8
I g
5 s
i' i
=
i 2
f, O
f i
4 1.3 -
L g.
.. _4..
i
=
l.
I a
t
(
./,*!
a 1
i m
l 0
/
N I
,b f.
I<
e I
t 3. _.
I l
.4
.3
(
i i <
l i
pJ l
~
i.
N
/
i 4
l l
l m..
4
.5 3
t' i.6 2 2.4 3.2 4 6
3 10 12 15 20 24 32 40 FRECUENCY (HZ)
WPPSS - NUCLEAR PROJECT =2 Burns and Ace. Inc.
11/7/7'3
CA0RSO IN-PLANT (FULL SCALD SRV DISCHARGE TESTS BECAME AVAILABLE At!D CONFI?f-iED EXPECTED C0flSERVATISi1 IN LOAD DEFINITION AND PREDICTED STRUCTUPAL RESPONSES.
i i
CONCLUSIONS I.
PRESENT/DFFR SRV DISCHARGE LOAD DEFINITION IS l
CONSERVATIVE.
i II.
STRUCTURAL MODELING TECHNIQUES AND ANALYTICAL i
PROCEDURES PRESENTLY USED TO CALCULATE STRUCTURAL l
RESPONSE TO SRV DISCHARGE LOADS NEED IMPROVEME.'lT.
I i
l i
t 4
1
. ~
- e OBJECT!'/ES OF T'r!IS STUDY I.
TO DEVELOP AN IMPROVED (.".0RE REALISTIC) SR'l DISCHARGE LOAD DEFINITION FROM AVAILABLE CA0RSO IN-PLANT SRV TEST RESULTS.
II.
TO DEVELOP STRUCTURAL F0DELING TECHNIQUES AND ANALYTICAL PROCEDURES ADEQUATE FOR CALCULATING STRUCTURAL RESPONSES TO SRV DISCHARGE LOADS IN BWR - MARK II GEOMETRY.
i TEST DATA USED IN THIS STUDY IN-PLANT (FULL SCALE) SRV ACTUATION TESTS IMPLEMENTED IN TWO FOREIGN BWR - MARK II PLANTS:
CA0RSO/ ITALY AND TOKAI-2/ JAPAN (SIMILAR TO WNP-2) o THESE PLANTS HAVE SRVDL's EQUIPPED WITH CROSS-QUENCHERS (SIMILAR TO THOSE USED IN WNP-2),
o TESTS INCLUDED SINGLE AND MULTIPLE SRV DISCHARGES, AT INITIAL AND SUBSEQUENT ACTUATION,
e SRV TESTS IN CAORSO PLANT (CONCRETE CONTAINMENT)
TWO SETS OF MEASUREMENTS OBTAINED INDEPENDENTLY BY:
o GE, UNDER "REVAL0TE" PROGRAN, MOSTLY INSIDE PRIllARY CONTAINF.ENT; PRESSURE Af1D ACCELERATION MEASUREMEiTS USED IN THIS STUDY.
o AfiN, UNDER "STRET" PROGRAM, NOSTLY OUTSIDE PRI!1ARY CONTAINNENT; ACCELERATION MEASURE?!ENTS USED IN THIS STUDY.
NOTE:
DIGITIZED DATA AVAILABLE ON MAGNETIC TAPES AND USED IN THIS STUDY TO ACHIEVE THE TWO V.IN OBJECTIVES.
l l
l
1 1
SRV TESTS IN TOKAI-2 PLOT (STEEL CONTAINMENT) i TO DATE, 0.'lLY SuffARY OF 70KAI 2 TEST.1ESULTS AVAILABLE i
AND USED Ifl THIS STUDY AS CONFIR"ATORY DATA (PRESSURES AND ACCELERATIONS).
1 i
I 4
1
-., _ _ -.