Latest revision as of 05:19, 31 October 2019

Text

INT-007 Revised Oct 26, 2015 Case Exhibit List
	ML15299A109
Person / Time
Site:	Turkey Point
Issue date:	10/26/2015
From:	; Citizens Allied for Safe Energy (CASE)
To:	; Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
	SECY RAS
References
	RAS 28433, ASLBP 15-935-02-LA-BD01, 50-250-LA, 50-251-LA
	Download: ML15299A109 (12)
	v • d • e

INT-007 Submitted October 9, 2015 (Revised October 26, 2015)

In the Matter of Florida Power & Light Company (License Amendments for Turkey Point Nuclear Generating Units 3 and 4)

Docket Nos. 50-250-LA and 50-251-LA ASLBP No. 15-935-02-LA-BD01 2016 Evidentiary Hearing Citizens Allied for Safe Energy, Inc. Hearing Exhibits CASE WITNESS/LOCATION DESCRIPTION EXHIBIT No.

INT-001 BACKGROUND INFORMATION THE SCIENCE OF THE TURKEY POINT WETLANDS (revised October 26, 2015) (SPECIFIC DOCUMENTS LISTED AT INT-041 TO INT-054 INT-002 DERM STAFF - PENDING Units 3 & 4 Uprate Implementation Water Quality SUBPOENA Impacts DERM (SPECIFIC SLIDES LISTED AT INT-055 TO INT-075)

INT- 003 DERM STAFF - PENDING CCS Maximum Quarterly Salinity, September 1973 CORRECTED SUBPOENA to June 2015 DERM 1

CASE WITNESS/LOCATION DESCRIPTION EXHIBIT No.

INT-004 DERM STAFF - PENDING FDEP AO Turkey Point Dec 23, 2014 ML15035A227 SUBPOENA INT-005 DERM STAFF - PENDING DERM FPL NOTICE OF VIOLATION TP CCS SUBPOENA INT-006 DERM STAFF - PENDING DERM FPL SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT TP CCS SUBPOENA INT-007 CASE CASE Hearing Schedule INT-008 ADAMS MEMORANDUM AND ORDER Granting CASEs Petition to Intervene) March 23, 2014 ML15082A197 INT-009 ADAMS 2014 EA - TURKEY POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING UNIT NOS. 3 AND 4- ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT AND FINDING OF NO SIGNIFICANT IMPACT RELATED ATO THE ULTIMATE HEAT SINK TEMPERATURE LIMIT (TAC NOS. MF4392 AND MF4393) July 28, 2014 ML14209A031 INT-010 ADAMS INITIAL SCHEDULING ORDER May 8, 2014 ML15128A369 INT-011 ADAMS CASE Notice Of Supplemental Disclosures September 25, 2014. ML15268A358 2

INT-012 Full copy EMAILS TO CASE FROM Dr. Christopher Kelble, NOAA, August 18, 2015 INT-013 Full copy An Attack from Below: Water, Water, Everywhere:

Sea Level Rise in Miami INT-014 ADAMS LETTER JULY 10, 2014 FPL TO NRC LAR REVISE UHS ML14196A006 INT-015 ADAMS 2012 EA -TP 3 & 4 EA AND FONSI RELATED TO PROPOSED EXTENDED POWER UPRATE (TAC NOS. ME4907 AND ME4908) ME12074A248 INT-016 Full Letter, CASE Initial LETTER FEBRUARY 1, 2010 - DERM TO FDEP Statement, at 28-30 (FPL) Application to Renew Turkey Point Industrial Wastewater INT-017 ADAMS FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY DOCKET NO. 50-251 FACILITY OPERATING LICENSE License No. DPR-41 April; 10. 1973 ML013400438 INT-018 Quote, CASE Initial DERM INTERNAL COMMUNICATION Statement, at 37 Burzycki, Gwen to Guerra, Cynthia August 29, 2014 RE: FPL Cooling Canals INT-019 Quote, CASE Initial DERM INTERNAL COMMUNICATION Statement, at 38 Alvear, Elsa to Various, August 22, 2014

Subject:

Cormorant colony closest to FPL cooling canals undergoing severe decline 3

INT-020 Quote, CASE Initial DERM INTERNAL COMMUNICATION Statement, at 38 to 40 Otero, Luis to Various, May 14, 2014

Subject:

Uprate monitoring issues INT-021 Quote, CASE Initial DERM INTERNAL COMMUNICATION Statement, at 41 Otero, Luis to Various April 09, 2014

Subject:

CCS surface water TKN INT-022 Quote, CASE Initial DERM INTERNAL COMMUNICATION Statement, at 41 Grossenbacher, Craig to Pitts, Patrick April 14, 2015

Subject:

FW:

FPL Annual Crocodile Report INT-023 Quote, CASE Initial DERM COMMUNICATION Otero, Luis To: 'Shaw, Statement, at 42 Jonathan (SFWMD) June 11, 2015

Subject:

RE: Turkey Point Units 3&4 Uprate Addendum -

Tritium INT-024 Quote, CASE Initial DERM COMMUNICATION November 26, 2014 Statement, at 42,43 From Lee N. Hefty, Director, DERM To: Phil Coram, FDEP INT-025 Quote, CASE Initial EMAIL, July 16, 2015 Dr. Frank Mazzotti, Statement, at 47 Ecologist, to Mr. John Wrublik, FWS INT-026 Quote, CASE Initial Ecology and Conservation of the American Statement, at 47 Crocodile (Crocodylus acutus) in Florida., 2006, Dr.

Frank Mazzotti and Dr. Michael S Cherkiss 4

INT-O27 Quote, CASE Initial EMAIL March 1, 2015 Mr. Michael Pearce, Senior Statement, at 47,48 Director at FPL wrote to Mr. Steve Scroggs, FPLs senior director for project development INT-028 Quote, CASE Initial (TP 6 & 7) DEIS Comment Submittal from Miami-Statement, at 48 to 50 Dade County. May 22, 2015 ML15146A118 ADAMS Document INT-029 CASE Initial Statement, at 56 LETTER AUGUST 27, 2014 FPL TO SFWMD REQUEST FOR EMERGENCY AUTHORIZATION OF TEMPORARY WATER WITHDRAWAL FROM L-31E CANAL INT-030 CASE Initial Statement, at 56 MINUTES SFWMD GOVERNING BOARD MEETING to 58 SEPTEMBER 11, 2014 INT-031 CASE Initial Statement, at 56 The National Environmental Policy Act of 1969, as to 58, amended, Purpose, Sec. 2 [42 USC § 4321],

abridged.

INT-032 CASE Initial Statement, Calvert Cliffs' Coordinated Committee v. Atomic at 60,61 Energy Commission, 449 F.2d 1109 (D.C. Cir. 1971), cert. denied, 404 U.S. 942 (1972)

INT-033 CASE Initial Statement, at 63 LETTER JULY 25, 2014 NRC STAFF TO USFWF ADAMS REQUESTING CONSULTATION ON UHS TEMPERATURE INCREASE ML14206A800.

5

INT-034 CASE Initial Statement, at Reinitiation of Section 7 Consultation for Turkey 63,64 Point LAR to Increase Ultimate Heat Sink ADAMS Temperature Limit. Date Released: Monday, July 28, 2014 ML14206A808 INT-035 CASE Initial Statement, at 66 JULY 17, 2014 Turkey Point Units 3 and 4 ADAMS Docket Nos. 50-250 and 50-251 Renewed Facility Operating License Nos. DPR-31 and DPR-41

Subject:

License Amendment Request No. 231, Application to Revise Ultimate Heat Sink Temperature Limit - Request for Emergency Approval ML14202A392 INT-036 CASE Initial Statement, at EMAIL OCTOBER 25, 2015 FROM Nuclear 67,68 Engineer Arnie Gunderson to CASE RE: GRID RELIABILITY INT-037 CASE Initial Statement, EMAILS SEPTEMBER 1, 2015 between CASE and at 68,69 Mr. Tim Hoeg, NRC Senior Resident Inspector at Turkey Point regarding source of power when TP 3

& 4 were off line for uprate.

INT-038 CASE Initial Statement, AT Citizens Allied for Safe Energy, Inc. Petition to 72,73 Intervene and Request for a Hearing ADAMS October 14, 2014 ML14290A510 6

INT-039 CASE Initial Statement, Environmental Review Guidance for Licensing at 75/76 Actions Associated with NMSS Programs Division ADAMS of Waste Management Office of Nuclear Material Safety and Safeguards ML032450279 INT-040 CASE Initial Statement, at A. Hanley v. Kleindienst, 471 F.2d 823 (2d Cir.

80,81 1972), cert. denied, 412 U.S. 908 (1973)

INT-041 IN INT-001, at 1-7 WHAT IS SALTWATER INTRUSION? Saltwater Intrusion of Coastal Aquifers in the U.S. James Spatafo INT-042 IN INT-001, at 7 SFWMD FINAL ORDER WITHDRAWALS FROM L-31E CANAL AUGUST 14, 2015 INT-043 IN INT-001, at 7 Tara Dolan Study: A Case Study of Turkey Point Nuclear Generating Station: Perception and Power in Environmental Assessment June 18, 2012 INT-044 IN INT-001, at 8 2010 USGS Borehole geophysical logging for the Florida Power & Light Turkey Point Plant groundwater, surface water, and ecological monitoring plan INT-045 IN INT-001, at 9 TO 16 Origins and Delineation of Saltwater Intrusion in the Biscayne Aquifer and Changes in the Distributionof Saltwater in Miami-Dade County, Florida 7

INT-046 IN INT-001, at 17 McNeill, Donald F., 2000. A Review of Upward Migration of Effluent Related to Subsurface Injection at Miami-Dade Water and Sewer South District Plant INT-047 IN INT-001, at 17 (LINK) GROUND WATER ATLAS of the UNITED STATES Alabama, Florida, Georgia, South Carolina HA 730-G INT-048 IN INT-001, at 18 - 21 Biological Assessment on the American Crocodile (Crocodylus acutus) Turkey Point Nuclear Generating Unit Nos. 3 and 4 Proposed License Amendment to Increase the Ultimate Heat Sink INT-049 IN INT-001, at 21 Sources of Saltwater in the Biscayne Aquifer INT-050 IN INT-001, at 21, 22 Turkey Point Unit 1 Eco System BY RUSS FINLEY INT-051 IN INT-001, at 22 The National Park Service website: Biscayne Bay description INT-052 IN INT-001, at 23 to 25 Knowledge of Groundwater Responses A Critical Factor in Saving Florida's Threatened and Endangered Species Part I: Marine Ecological Disturbances Sydney T. Bacchus iNT-053 iN INT-001, at 26 Movement of water into and out of the CCS 8

iINT-054 N INT-001, at 26 How salinity descends from unprotected canals into the aquifer INT-055 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 Approximate Uprate Periods Nitrogen TKN Increase Uprate Implementation in CCS Surface Water Water Quality Impacts SLIDE 2 INT-055 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 Nitrogen TKN Increase in CCS Surface Water Uprate Implementation (graph)

Water Quality Impacts SLIDE 3 INT-056 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 Nitrogen Increase Likely linked to Apparent Algal Uprate Implementation Bloom in CCS - See next 3 slides showing Water Quality Impacts progressive deterioration of water clarity in the SLIDE 4 CCS INT-057 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 March 31, 2010 Google Earth View Uprate Implementation (of CCS)

Water Quality Impacts SLIDE 5 INT-058 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 March 6, 2013 Google Earth View Uprate Implementation (of CCS)

Water Quality Impacts SLIDE 6 9

INT-059 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 January 18, 2014 Google Earth View Uprate Implementation (of CCS)

Water Quality Impacts SLIDE 7 INT-060 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 Contours Based On Deep Well Tritium Results Uprate Implementation From the June 2011 Quarterly Sampling Water Quality Impacts (plumes from CCS)

SLIDE 8 INT-061 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 CCS Plume Expands to NE as Evidenced by Uprate Implementation Increasing Tritium Concentrations at TPGW-10 Water Quality Impacts (graph)

SLIDE 9 INT-062 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 Contours Based On Deep Well Tritium Results Uprate Implementation From the March 2013 Quarterly Sampling Water Quality Impacts (plumes from CCS)

SLIDE 10 INT-063 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 Salinity of CCS Surface Water Increasing Post Uprate Implementation Uprate as Evidenced by Increasing Specific Water Quality Impacts Conductance SLIDE 11 August 25, 2010 to March 31, 2014 (graph)

INT-064 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 Specific Conductance for CCS Surface Water Uprate Implementation Station TPSWCCS-1B Showing Increasing Trend Water Quality Impacts in Salinity SLIDE 12 August 25, 2010 to June 4, 2014 (graph) 10

INT-065 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 Salinity for CCS Surface Water Station Uprate Implementation TPSWCCS-1B Showing Increasing Trend Water Quality Impacts August 25, 2010 to June 4, 2014 (graph)

SLIDE 13 INT-066 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 Compilation of Available CCS Surface Water Uprate Implementation Salinity Trend Water Quality Impacts August 1973 to September 2014 (graph)

SLIDE 14 INT-067 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 Most Recent Available CCS Surface Water Salinity Uprate Implementation Trend Water Quality Impacts March, 2009 to August, 2014 (graph)

SLIDE 15 INT-068 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 Turkey Point G-III Boundary (Aerial View)

Uprate Implementation From FDEP November 16, 2009

SUBJECT:

FPL Water Quality Impacts Turkey Point NPDES Permit Renewal (FL0001562)

SLIDE 16 Exhibit 2 - ML102740614 INT-069 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 TPGW-1 & TPGW-L3 Approximate Location (aerial Uprate Implementation view, monitoring wells)

Water Quality Impacts SLIDE 17 INT-070 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 Monitoring Wells Outside G-III Boundary with Uprate Implementation Chloride Concentrations Above Seawater (graph)

Water Quality Impacts SLIDE 18 11

INT-071 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 Chloride Concentrations Attributable to CCS Uprate Implementation Contribution (graph)

Water Quality Impacts SLIDE 19 INT-072 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 CCS Surface Water Temperature Profiles August Uprate Implementation 27, 2010 to June 3, 2014 (graph)

Water Quality Impacts SLIDE 20 INT-073 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 Apparent Higher Than Expected CCS Surface Uprate Implementation Water Temperatures Post Uprate Water Quality Impacts August 27, 2010 to June 3, 2014 (graph)

SLIDE 21 INT-074 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 Pre and Post Uprate Temperature Profile for Uprate Implementation TPSWCCS-1B August 27, 2010 to June 2014 Water Quality Impacts (graph)

SLIDE 22 INT-075 INT-002, DERM Units 3 & 4 Model Lands Dry Season Water Level Profiles Uprate Implementation October 1 to May 15 for Years 2008 to 2013 Water Quality Impacts (graph)

SLIDE 23 12