ML18040B298: Difference between revisions
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol) |
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol) |
||
| (One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
| issue date = 08/15/2018 | | issue date = 08/15/2018 | ||
| title = Resolution of Comments on Draft Safety Evaluation for Topical Report BAW-10247P-A, Supplement 2P, Revision 0, Realistic Thermal-Mechanical Fuel Rod Methodology for Boiling Water Reactors, Supplement 2: Mechanical Methods. | | title = Resolution of Comments on Draft Safety Evaluation for Topical Report BAW-10247P-A, Supplement 2P, Revision 0, Realistic Thermal-Mechanical Fuel Rod Methodology for Boiling Water Reactors, Supplement 2: Mechanical Methods. | ||
| author name = Morey D | | author name = Morey D | ||
| author affiliation = NRC/NRR/DLP/PLPB | | author affiliation = NRC/NRR/DLP/PLPB | ||
| addressee name = Peters G | | addressee name = Peters G | ||
| Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
| docket = 99902041 | | docket = 99902041 | ||
| license number = | | license number = | ||
| contact person = Rowley J | | contact person = Rowley J | ||
| package number = ML18040B294 | | package number = ML18040B294 | ||
| document type = Safety Evaluation | | document type = Safety Evaluation | ||
| Line 16: | Line 16: | ||
=Text= | =Text= | ||
{{#Wiki_filter:}} | {{#Wiki_filter:RESOLUTION OF COMMENTS BY THE OFFICE OF NUCLEAR REACTOR REGULATION ON DRAFT SAFETY EVALUATION FOR TOPICAL REPORT BAW-10247P-A, SUPPLEMENT 2P, REVISION 0, REALISTIC THERMAL-MECHANICAL FUEL ROD METHODOLOGY FOR BOILING WATER REACTORS SUPPLEMENT 2: | ||
MECHANICAL METHODS FRAMATOME, INC. | |||
PROJECT NO. 728/DOCKET NO. 99902041 This attachment provides the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staffs review and disposition of the comments made by Framatome Inc. (formerly AREVA Inc.) on the draft safety evaluation for Topical Report BAW-10247P-A, Supplement 2P, Revision 0, Realistic Thermal-mechanical Fuel Rod Methodology for Boiling Water Reactors Supplement 2: | |||
Mechanical Methods. | |||
Page Line Proposed Change/Comment NRC Response Please revise the draft safety evaluation to reflect approval of the use of Zry-2 recrystallized material for cladding and Z4BTM material for water channels. | |||
Please revise the burnup limitation for fuel assembly growth to be consistent with the additional information to be provided as discussed in the letter accompanying this summary table. | |||
1 24 Delete highlighted proprietary Brackets used to show inserted material, brackets, information is not not proprietary information. Brackets not proprietary deleted as suggested in final SE. | |||
2 22 Delete highlighted proprietary Brackets used to show inserted material, brackets, information is not not proprietary information. Brackets not proprietary deleted as suggested in final SE. | |||
3 5 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
3 26 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
3 29 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
3 34 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
Attachment | |||
Page Line Proposed Change/Comment NRC Response 3 35 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
3 39 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
4 1 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
4 30 Delete highlighted proprietary NRC staff agrees with suggested brackets, information is not editorial changes. Final SE modified proprietary accordingly. | |||
4 38 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
4 41 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
5 31 to Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested 34 proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
5 36 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
5 39 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
6 15 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
6 39 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
6 42 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
6 43 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
7 1 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
7 8 to Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested 11 proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
7 37- Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested 38 proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
Page Line Proposed Change/Comment NRC Response 8 17- Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested 18 proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
8 20- Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested 21 proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
8 29 Suggest replacing non-ATRIUM NRC staff agrees with suggested with tie rod editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
8 42 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
9 1 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
9 7 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
9 12 Suggest deleting ATRIUM type NRC staff agrees with suggested editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
9 16 Suggest deleting ATRIUM type NRC staff agrees with suggested editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
9 17- Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested 18 proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
9 18- Suggest deleting ATRIUM type NRC staff agrees with suggested 19 editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
9 20- Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested 21 proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
10 1-2 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
10 5 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
10 7 Suggest deleting ATRIUM type NRC staff agrees with suggested editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
10 8-9 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
A1 5-6 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
Page Line Proposed Change/Comment NRC Response A1 20 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
A3 14- Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested 15 proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
A7 24 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
A9 18 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
A9 25 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
A10 1 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
A10 16 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
A10 24 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly. | |||
A10 26 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.}} | |||
Latest revision as of 22:41, 21 October 2019
| ML18040B298 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | 99902041 |
| Issue date: | 08/15/2018 |
| From: | Dennis Morey NRC/NRR/DLP/PLPB |
| To: | Peters G Framatome |
| Rowley J | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML18040B294 | List: |
| References | |
| Download: ML18040B298 (4) | |
Text
RESOLUTION OF COMMENTS BY THE OFFICE OF NUCLEAR REACTOR REGULATION ON DRAFT SAFETY EVALUATION FOR TOPICAL REPORT BAW-10247P-A, SUPPLEMENT 2P, REVISION 0, REALISTIC THERMAL-MECHANICAL FUEL ROD METHODOLOGY FOR BOILING WATER REACTORS SUPPLEMENT 2:
MECHANICAL METHODS FRAMATOME, INC.
PROJECT NO. 728/DOCKET NO. 99902041 This attachment provides the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staffs review and disposition of the comments made by Framatome Inc. (formerly AREVA Inc.) on the draft safety evaluation for Topical Report BAW-10247P-A, Supplement 2P, Revision 0, Realistic Thermal-mechanical Fuel Rod Methodology for Boiling Water Reactors Supplement 2:
Mechanical Methods.
Page Line Proposed Change/Comment NRC Response Please revise the draft safety evaluation to reflect approval of the use of Zry-2 recrystallized material for cladding and Z4BTM material for water channels.
Please revise the burnup limitation for fuel assembly growth to be consistent with the additional information to be provided as discussed in the letter accompanying this summary table.
1 24 Delete highlighted proprietary Brackets used to show inserted material, brackets, information is not not proprietary information. Brackets not proprietary deleted as suggested in final SE.
2 22 Delete highlighted proprietary Brackets used to show inserted material, brackets, information is not not proprietary information. Brackets not proprietary deleted as suggested in final SE.
3 5 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
3 26 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
3 29 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
3 34 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
Attachment
Page Line Proposed Change/Comment NRC Response 3 35 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
3 39 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
4 1 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
4 30 Delete highlighted proprietary NRC staff agrees with suggested brackets, information is not editorial changes. Final SE modified proprietary accordingly.
4 38 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
4 41 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
5 31 to Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested 34 proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
5 36 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
5 39 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
6 15 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
6 39 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
6 42 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
6 43 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
7 1 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
7 8 to Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested 11 proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
7 37- Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested 38 proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
Page Line Proposed Change/Comment NRC Response 8 17- Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested 18 proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
8 20- Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested 21 proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
8 29 Suggest replacing non-ATRIUM NRC staff agrees with suggested with tie rod editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
8 42 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
9 1 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
9 7 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
9 12 Suggest deleting ATRIUM type NRC staff agrees with suggested editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
9 16 Suggest deleting ATRIUM type NRC staff agrees with suggested editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
9 17- Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested 18 proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
9 18- Suggest deleting ATRIUM type NRC staff agrees with suggested 19 editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
9 20- Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested 21 proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
10 1-2 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
10 5 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
10 7 Suggest deleting ATRIUM type NRC staff agrees with suggested editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
10 8-9 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
A1 5-6 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
Page Line Proposed Change/Comment NRC Response A1 20 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
A3 14- Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested 15 proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
A7 24 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
A9 18 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
A9 25 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
A10 1 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
A10 16 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
A10 24 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.
A10 26 Highlighted information is NRC staff agrees with suggested proprietary, add proprietary brackets editorial changes. Final SE modified accordingly.