ML20236S565

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Forwards Response to NRC 980526 RAI Re GL 96-06, Assurance of Equipment Operability & Containment Integrity During Design-Basis Accident
ML20236S565
Person / Time
Site: Calvert Cliffs  Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 07/20/1998
From: Cruse C
BALTIMORE GAS & ELECTRIC CO.
To:
NRC OFFICE OF INFORMATION RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (IRM)
References
GL-96-06, GL-96-6, TAC-M96792, TAC-M96793, NUDOCS 9807270035
Download: ML20236S565 (25)


Text

{{#Wiki_filter:. \ CH ARLES II. CRUSE Baltimore Gas and Electric Cornpany Vice President Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant Nuclear Energy 1650 Calvert Cliffs Parkway Lusby. Maryland 20657 l 410 495-4455 July 20,1998 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington,DC 20555 ATTENTION: Document Control Desk

SUBJECT:

Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant Unit Nos.1 & 2; Docket Nos. !0-317 & 50-318 Request for Additional Information, Response to Generic Letter 96-06 LIAC Nos. M96792 and M96793)

REFERENCES:

(a) Letter from Mr. C. H. Cruse (BGE) to NRC Document Desk, dated January 28, 1997, 120-Day Response to Generic Letter 96-06,

                                            " Assurance of Equ!pment Operability and Containment Integrity During Design-Basis Accijent Conditions" (b)      Letter from Mr. C. H. Cruse (BGE) to NRC Document Desk, dated I

May2,1997, Fevision to Commitments in 120-Day Response to Generic Letter 96-06, " Assurance of Equipment Operability and l Containment In<egrity During Design-Basis Accident Conditions" (c) Letter from Mr. A. W. Dromerick (NRC) to Mr. C. H. Cruse (BGE), dated May 20, 1998, Request for Additional Information Regarding j rfg Response to Guidance [sicJ Letter (GL) 96-06 for the Calvert Clifts! fd / Nuclear Power Plant, Unit Nos. I and 2 (TAC Nos. M96792 and M96793) References (a) and (b) provided Baltir.1 ore Gas and Electric Company's response to Generic Letter 96-06. Reference (c) requested adtlitional information. Baltimore Gas and Electric Company's response is contained in Attachment (1).

                  .dhUa1 i

9807270035 980720 PDR ADOCK 05000317-P PDR

                      - Document Control Desk July 20,1998 Page 2 Should you have questions regarding this matter, we will be pleased to discuss them with you.

Very truly yours, I 1 Ms ~z & CHC/EMT/ dim

Attachment:

Response to Request for Additional Information; 120-Day Response to Generic

                                                    ; Letter 96-06, " Assurance of Equipment Operability and Containment integrity During Design-Basis Accident Conditions" -

cc: R. S. Fleishman, Esquire H. J. Miller, NRC J. E. Silberg, Esquire Resident inspector,NRC S. S. Bajwa, NRC R. I. McLean, DNR

                                       . A. W. Dromerick, NRC                               J. H. Walter, PSC

.t l

ATTACHMENT (1) RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL P;/0! NATION; 120-DAY RESPONSE TO GENERIC LETTER 96-06, " ASSURANCE OF EQUIPMENT OPERABILITY AND CONTAINMENT INTEGRITY DURING DESIGN-BASIS ACCIDENT CONDITIONS - I I l Baltimore Gas and Electric Company Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant July 20,1998

  ,,                                                 ATTACHMENT (1)

RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION; 120-DAY RESPONSE TO GENERIC LETTER 96-06, " ASSURANCE OF EQUIPMENT OPERABILITY AND CONTAINMENT INTEGRITY DURING DESIGN-BASIS ACCIDENT CONDITIONS" In its submittals Baltimore Gas and Electric Company (BGE) indicated that a total ofsix pipe segments in each unit were susceptible to thermally-inducedpressuri:ation. The licensee indicated that operating instructions would be changed to include draining of three of the pipe segments prior to plant operations. For two ofthe pipe segments, BGE also indicated that no overpressurization would occur due to existing installed insulation. The NRC staffrequests that BGEprovide thefollowing information: Ouestion No.1: Provide the applicable design criteria for the piping and the valves; include the required load combinations. BGE Response: As stated in our initial response to Generic Letter 96-06, each unit at Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant has six lines that were found to be susceptible to overpressurization. Three of these lines are now drained prior to returr.ing the unit to operation following outages. Two of these lines were found to meet design limits due to the presence ofinsulation that limits the peak transient temperature. One line has been insulated in a manner similar to the previous two in order to limit the peak transient temperature such that design basis limits are met. ene tion Line Description Disposition Plant Service Water 37 Operating Procedure OI-23D has been revised to require draining Refueling Pool Recycle inlet 59 Operating Procedure OI 24H has been revised to requlre draining Refueling Pool Outlet to Fuel Pool 61 Operating Procedure OI-23H has been revised to Cooling Pipe require draining Containment Plant Heating Outlet 62 Line is insulated to limit peak transient temperature. Containment Plant Heating inlet 64 Line is insulated to limit peak transient temperature. Reactor Coolant Pump (RCP) Seal IC Line has been Insulated to limit peak transient Controlled Bleed Off temperature. The applicable design loading conditions and limits are provided in Updated Final Safety Analysis Report Chapter SA, Table SA-6. I 1 I l l 1

r a  ?.

 "..                                                 ATTACHMENT (1)

RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION; 120-DAY RESPONSE TO GENERIC LETTER 96-06, " ASSURANCE OF EQUIPMENT OPERABILITY AND CONTAINMENT INTEGRITY DURING DESIGN-BASIS ACCIDENT CONDITIONS" For the postulated event, Calvert Cliffs Level 3 loading conditions, Normal Operation + Pipe Rupture (Loss-of-Coolant Accident) + Safe Shutdown Earthquake, would apply. Primary membrane stress: P, & St Bending: n P1 ' P, s 4 St Cos x s2 Sg Note that for the bending limit, Pa is only M/Z and P. is intended to be PD/4t. St = Sy + 1/3 (S - Sy) The materials of the lines affected by this event are as follows: Line Description All wable Elastic Size and Material Stress (ksi) Containment Plant Heating Outlet 3" sch 40 A106 Gr B 40.9 Containment Plant Heating Inlet 3" sch 40 A106 Gr B 40.9 RCP Seal Controlled Bleed Off 3/4" sch 30 A376 TP316 40.1 Ouestion No. 2: Provide a drawing ofthe piping run between the isolation valves. Include the lengths and thicknesses of the insulation. BGE Response: The enclosed drawings are applicable to the affected lines as described below. Only the annotated sections are susceptible to overpressurization. These drawings provide requested details associated with piping lengths. Additionally, the thickness ofinsulation is listed in the table below. Unit 1 Unit 2 Line Description Insulation Thickness , Figure No. Figure No. Containment Plant Heating Outlet 1" A B Containment Plant Heating Inlet 1" A B RCP Seal Controlled Bleed Off 2" C-1 C-2 , Question No. 3: Provide the maximum calculated temperature and pressure for the pipe run. Describe in detail, the l method to calculate these pressure and temperature values. 1his should include a discussion of the heat transfer model used in the analyses and the basisfor the heat transfer coefficients used in the analyses. 2 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ - - - - - _ _ _ _ _J

   ,,                                                                                                       ATTACHMENT (1)

RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION; 120-DAY RESPONSE TO GENERIC LETTER 96-06, " ASSURANCE OF EQUIPMENT OPERABILITY AND CONTAINMENT INTEGRITY DURING DESIGN-BASIS ACCIDENT CONDITIONS" BGE Response: Finite element models representing the various piping configurations were constructed using code ANSYS 5.2. The pipe / water models were loaded with a surface convection and bulk temperature to simulate a Loss-of Coolant Accident event. The bulk containment temperature as a function of time is obtained from the Updated Final Safety Analysis Report. The outside convective coefficient is a function of temperature, obtained from an existing containment air / steam heat transfer model previously derived from the containment analysis. The enclosed Figures D and E show the containment temperature and the convective coefficient as a function of time. The thermal conductivity of the water in each model was conservatively increased by a factor of 10 to account for mixing and additional heat flow due to convection. A thermal transient analysis was then performed that resulted in a water temperature distribution across the pipe section as a function of time. The temperatures at the pipe center and the pipe inner diameter are plotted versus time in the enclosed Figures F, G, H, and 1. Under the final design configurations (i.e., post-insulation modification), the peak temperatures and pressures are as follows: Elastic Results: Line Description Maximum Temperature Maximum Pressure Containment Plant Heating Outlet 147 F 3000 psi Containment Plant Heating inlet 147 F 3000 psi J RCP Seal Controlled Bleed Off 165*F 5410 psi Ouestion No. 4: Baltimore Gas and Electric Company also indicatelfor one segment, either a relief device would be installed or insulation would be added to the piping section exposed to loss-of-coolant accident temperature. Please clarify the specific method chosen to prevent overpressurization. IfBGE is adding insulation, please provide the same information as for the two piping segments discussed in Question No.1.

                                                     .BGE Response:

The RCP seal controlled bleed-off line was insulated to limit the peak transient temperature. No relief device was installed. The response to Question No.1 includes the relevant information for this line. l 3 L________________ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ - - - -

i 1 ENCLOSURE (A) TO ATTACHMENT (1)

                                                                                                     ]

DRAWINGS AND FIGURES ) l Baltimore Gas and Electric Company Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant July 20,1998

       , _ _ , _ , 7__,       .__7__,_     _ _ , - . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ , , , _ . ,.,,-._..____.-__,__-.m,,._ , , . _ , __ ,_-._,,_.,___,_7-.____      _ - _ _ - - - , - , _ _ , _ _ _ - y- ,   - _ , _ _ . , . ,

4 4 4 o 8$ O

                        .--t'                                                                                                                                                                                                      ee l'

I

                                                                                                                                               \ .
   . f, i
   ' .I-
                                       - 1u
                                         - i i '                                               - - i -                                       .                                           .                ... ... . . _. _.__

~ .-

      ~

I w (113 (1) 3'

               \ &p                                                                                      8 Y                                                                                  #,gD s

g y 4 :g, e ofs 'h $*' o , f0 i h '8 i r 5 ' 0 e .' n

                                                                   *,s
                                                               **.d 9.'l81
                                                                                   =%

C * ' * *"# *' 5"4 s yt l 1005,96 ,0$5,9 6 Y 1e* ,o5 ,5 88 k y ','86

                                                                                                     *5 ' god P's6
                                                                                                                       ,s ssedu[n 4                                                                   s                             g h

i' < me.o . ouw mat-e/) MDURE P1 AT-Lh TK; E 7018

                                                                                        ^                            _

60 O SgA E-7052 Pa no. PW HT 9 ICT 100% at use us NO ugg ICODE 31,7 CLASS T F I LE LOC._ _ _ _ _ _ - - - - - N011CE USERS EIST REFER TO THE DCN CATALOGS OR THE C0ruTER12E0 DCN INDEX FOR APPLICABLE DCH'S , W **%e

NOTES: YAL VE MARN NO. 238-2 1.1-MOV-6579 FUNCTIONS AS A MANUALLY VE NANN NO. /-NO V -8./ 7f OPERATED VALVE (REF. FEC 88-0070-05).

2. PIPE CUT 8, CAP WUST BE MAOEMl HB57 CTMT. PENETRATION PIPING.

7 - w ) l v M.f I II (1-1/2-1-HB57-10012] \ f af Y R CONT *D ON /26/5A=0027 8 31.7 PIPING CODE-CLASS II

                                        - 9J //so /-//2-/3/
                                                /./Os No. #5/01                                                                 BECHTEL Q.C. LEVEL "B"
                                      #                                                                                         BECHTEL 6750-M-254                           -

V EF

           @    g                              J8SOJ'NBB/I*

HB-29 CALVERT CLIFFS UNIT NO.1 y HB-57 i secc. cHANor dPERTURE 7 CARD

           "             -[ f.-{l 1/2-1-NB57-1001-1)

PENE. NO. BE Also Available on Aperture Card

                     -  #,  ,                                                                                                      REFERENCE DRAWINGS:

f;k3$. ~ 60516 (M-406) (9" DWG NO. THIS DRA SCANNE 1-112-1, REF. 8 DATED 08/24/93, BGE F.P. DOC NO.12614A-0001.

                                                                                                                 =

DESCRIPTION DWN 05CN DE tR APPROVED jgg h UILT DCN A-0001-0002SH00016 of.s4 '5'""----- PLANT HEATING 12614A-0001-0002SH0002J e cim to.____ HOT WATER 93-029-005-00 ----- SYSTEM NO.112 aEct. E o ._ _ _ i e c Ea. _ _ -

                                                                                    "'"'"----                             BALTIMORE CAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY NUaEAR ENGl9d'[R!NG DEPARTbCNT C    CP        TION        WT
                                                                                                                                                             '        s 3
                                                                                                                       - c.               e,,,.                         <-
                                                                                                                                .                              i.iu i nArE _ _ _ _ _ _ _
                                                                                                                        '""ghi .ocu @                 12614A-0001     9 hevea '2"5""aululu!!!!i!!!!!!!N!!!!i!!!nunnia?!!!!!?ntnt1                                                           MU$$LunYl.d
                                                                                                                           %7Z700380                                       -

er (1) 3" VALVE MARK NO 2-MOV-6579 (d 3" VALVE MARK NO 238-2 l j PENETRATION CAP (N-8509 PO130-N721) 2 -112 HB 57- 2001-CONT D ON ISO 2-(JOB h ns e F .W -

                                                                                                                                                                                   'x "g
                                                                                                               <s} x(

[ l

                                                                                                                               /
                                                                                                                                    "'~             \

F

   ~

3 98-37-2001 4 PENE.NO.62

                                                                 \                                                 -6" e.

(Fg E W - f'i.O MCT WS

                                                                                                                                                ,, , d ' ,   F ACE
                                                                                                                                  - NOTE: FOR WELD NOS AT PENE: SEE DWG.                                         I C-240 SH 2 REV.1F                                      pet i

(61740 SH0002) 4 I ,# gh t h gb l 4 y.as.37-2002

                                                                                                                                             '4 "5"                                                                             l  '

t N T W ALL TO INStDE F ACE OF CONT Aigu v ( ( 2 - 11 s ( N-8509-PO130-N721) PENETRATION CAP 1 i l 3 1 4 I 5 IJ 1 1 2 7 u _- __ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ __ _ _

A I 1 I 23 (DOC,13615A 0034) -

510) b WT* 72-2-H B

p 2-112-1-HB57-2001-2) l, ' I

                                                                                                                                 ^PERTURE                              j CARD Also Available on Aperture Card                    c
              > in  ,+
                .,a  O 4                                                                                   THE HB57 ON THIS DRAWINC HAS RECEIVED THE ASME 4                                                                                                           "NA" CODE $T AMP

,NO.64 OO m , uSAS B31.7 PIPING CODE- CLASS 5 BECHTEL 0.C. LEVEL *B* 4 4

                                        +        f gg.238-2                                               BECHTEL 6750-M 254
                                  -+      + /                                                             CALVERT CLIFFS UNIT No. 2 CONT'D ON

'~ \ =*"~ EL.25' 0" iso

                                                                     ' 2-123615A 0033)                    REFERENCE DRAWINGS F .W-  X      f          f                       g 8510;                            u-476 (60-516' 7.

h ,

                                                        , , gg.,

D

        ~

M 71 SH2 (60-254E SH2) ONT N ENT gg.29 WALL HB-57 gg 7t3,

  • t. 2 wov-6579 FUNCTIONS AS A MANUALLY -

2 , P- *{* 6EEC. CHN4GE OPERATED VALVE. (REF. FEC 88-0070-5).

~.,*'                                                                                                             2. ALL PIPE AND Fif TINCS PER 92-767
          *S                                                                                                          (M-600) CLASS HB.

3 I,+ [

  • _ .i THIS DRAWING WAS SCANNED FROW W.W.KELLOCC CO.

DR AWING NUMBER 2-112-1. REV. 3F. DATED 02/09/73. BG6E CO F.P. DOC. No.13614 A-0001. E ritt toc. NOTICE >HB5720024) USERS W51 IEFER TO THE OCN CAIROCS OR TIE Coiru1ER12ED 000 lle[I ICR APPLita8LE DCNS

                                                                                                                                                                   ~

arv ; ocs aw.niesim oim jam oc ' se appaovte

                                                                                                                         .           rw[             h
                                           *h [gagT?dNdtM M"I.

[ s.oo, 3 [ acr

                                                                                                        = =o - - -

am .... PLANT EATING HOT WATER o,,,,,,,..., SYSTEN NO. 112 i.c . .

                                                                                                        " ' " * - - - -        8"ITd'.5d.EjEj,TR,1C, COMPANY       f c^smFwJ,,m ,2                 r" 3 m....... m.
  • o.
                                                                                                                                   ,      ,p,,,,,,,,,,

me......... ma y,,j- 136MA-0001 5 6 l 7 l {u.se""'"hnWyur,ihlinnulfit3lfMidff!E51 10 <; ;, % =;';; N 0 Y-M -

d t

         %[ %                                          . ..
                                                    ..{.],

f%s 0%

  -                                   '                                         9
                                                                       '1 '

I$'p,b* 0 .g p , 'i l  % ,9

                                                ,-[f g

h

                                                                                    .                                                                                                                                         g A
   ~

es 'ooe '. l p $,;$ ' .

                                                                                           .,e                          '

o

                                                                                         -                                      ,c, s

a( ..

                                                                                                                                         ,.                                                                                           r W

9 < g'.

                                                                                                                                                                                                       ...,,,,             y e c

PERTURE CARD  ; 3g j c-

                                                                                                                                                                        '  L} ;/g Also Apen. AvaHable on                                                   s5         , e ,.                  ., '
     )

Card s / 'e. ,.4 ,,

                                                                                                                               '                                8
                                   *                                                                                                        -{

g

                                                   ,                                                        g n

sz. y { ss

                                          "),              s tz-                                        b y                                             e'0:5
                                                                                                                                    ,,,,,...i                 l *' "" '

i,,,,,,..---'"*' ys' s ' -

                                                                                                                                     "   g.;2:1&%                                             ,.,,.

1'*, .. em.g%

                                                                                                                                                                                                     *iciii               ~ t'" .*g, es                                                         -

g%i.cn i mit'*'

                                                                                                                                     =;;,U.gma'*
                                                                                                                                       ,g;g                           ;o,,-o                  ,,,,, ,,,, inn siwc DETAtt 1                                                                          nes
  • a' i  : - ~ '
                                                                                                                                                                      ,,,,,,co,n a cata
                                                                                                                                     'jg,",,*,'"'*gt 31tL W #"

E tilitu 4

                                                                                                                                     ,                                                         '        \                         *

\ l- - w~ 2  ; 1 \

  • g s )

1 _m- - - " ' ' _ _ .

ac.ao. en. CISEco me. m eau y A 376 314 3 i It' VPIPE 50s.005. Sets. 55 ' 3 P0- V PIPE 50s.405. SILS. 55 a 376 lie 4 20' V PIPE 500.005. SILS. 55 a 376 316 l 5 6' fcPIPE 508.005. 5ES. $$ a 376 3t6 A .' 6 l' # PIPE 50s.805. 545, 55 a 376 316 1 56 6' fe* *lPE 504.005. Sati. 55 a 376 31 6  ! a 376 316 l to t' fe*PLM $04.305. SaLS 55 ' tI l' fs* PIPE 500.005. 5ES. 55 A 376 316 A 376 316 I 12 l' fe* PIPE 506.005. 545. 55. f.o.E. A 376 316 l 55 l' VPIPE 50s.305 2 5E5. 55 y 50 i- V P m SCw.e0s. $ES. 55 a 376 m _1 A 376 316 l fe* PIPE 508.005. SIL 5. 55.1.0.E.

          *s
  • 17 i V TEE 3000' 5W. 55 A 182 IM l
               %. '                                                                                    re
  • FEE 3000s Sg, $$ a.182 rM l
                    .                                                                       18 s                                                                                                                                f3H               l 19    i     V CPLt. 30008. 5W. 55                    A 182 s                                                                                                                       a 182 fM                I 20    1     V CPLt. 3000 s. SW. 55 a 182                   I 21        A* cap. 3000s IPT. 55                            r316 I,f                                                                                49
                                                                                            .s t'

i E* PIPE 50s.805. $sts. 55 n CPtt. 3000'. $W a 376 316 a.ist rM 8l! 44 1*I M*lE0. tilWill 55. 3000 L8 a 182 FM 45 1 t t

  • cap $C'EtEO. 55. 3000 LB. A 182 Flid ,'8 42 8 1* EIM VRWE.1996. $w 41 I t
  • ELW valve.1880. 5W ,l 40 1  %'5feal0M1 TEE. 5W. 55. 3000 Lt. a ts2 IM 39 l' 1* PIPE 504.005. 5EamE55. 55 A 376 314 f g r37 3 3g i .pi,E 504.005. 5EaEE55. 55 a 376 31 6 0 3 f

1* VPW scu.005. StaEE55. 55 a-376 su  ! CO [.N,$ 31 54 t- VPIPE 50s.e05. 5EasLE55, 55 a 376 lu j 5

     .*g
  • 47 1 fe' CPL t. . 3000 8 . 55. 55 a.102 F 3ti .

35 I f.* CPL t. 3000'. 5W. 55 a ter FM

 **'5 ,4Pg
  • 34 20' fe* PIPE 504.005. SIL5. 55 a 376 F3H  !'

I V ELL. 90* 3000s , gu g.182 IM j 33 T g 32 2' fe* PIPE 504.005. 5sti. 55 a 376 316 C. 31 i fe*C981AOL VRVE W. t-Cv-505 j 53 i fe*CatE vatt, emite. CL.ll , 52 1 fe* GATE valut. Etto. CL.it 51 i fe*GafE vaLWE. Infl0. CL.ll f' h 45

  • fe
  • ELL. 90*. 3000' 5W. 55 a It2 Flel j 9 A 376 316 46 l' VPIPE 504.00 SES. 55 25 t -re *CLOK vaLWE. metcen. CL.li j 24 i fe
  • CLOK VALVE. *1130. CL.ll .
      '                                                                                            t    f
  • CAP. 3000' . IPT. 55 a 182 FM j I

l NOTES: l FIELD TO CHECK ALL DlWENSIONS 1. gll

2. DELETED
3. DELETED j
4. WARK E ACH ERECTABLE SPOOL WITH SKETCH AND '

SPOOL DASH NO., LNE CL ASS. SYSTEW. UNIT 8. NO. WITH A NON-CHLORIDE BL ACK PAINT. I

5. O ocNOTc5 SPOOL oASs NuWeER. I
6. ALL PIPlNG PER ANSIB31.7 CLASS I 9
7. h DENOTES WELD NUMBER 8 BEND NO. f
8. TOT AL FOOTACE OF PIPNG 88' OF %" 5.S. I
9. OPERATING CON D.1 SEE SPEC. 6750-W 601 .

DE$lGN RATING J L ATEST REVISK)N g

10. 2" OF FIBERGL ASS INSUL AllON WITH S.S.JACKETNG IS ADDED ON %" CC-12-1009 FROW CONTAINMENT [].

PEN.1C TO 1CV-506 PER ESP ES199700215 REV.O. . C-I ,, I D r au) .'% ..

 "10"                           C 2. 5 kar M                                                                                     ~

THIS ORAwhG WAS REDRAWN FROM A BCE DwG.FSK-W-0825 g REV.9. DATED 05/08/74. . sue e.is anscasmes a.m asm a se menows

                                                                                                                                                                    ==%

m CC 12 e 4 g=l,=;;=;g' gg' ** col. f - - - pc. ..i ...... REACTOR COOLANT PUW S i

                                                                                                " ' " - - ~                   CONTROLLED BLEED-OFF l                                                                                                                                                                          I
                                                                                                          =---              TO VOLUNE CONTROL TANK i.u......                                           ,_                    i e..se.....               SatilaallRE GAS asID ELECTRIC COWAM mam easiassaim essenem F-  ;

a ...... Cgvg1 g{5, gN_l,1 i fDb ..

                                                                                                - ..-. .              .~. ,               .,,,,

Oatt . - - . . . . Y F FSk-W-0825 10 I lams '"*"$EWMINWGTMW":WlGTkDM*Ill 10 t'u ne f* ,;

                 $         l                              l                                                                                                .

ctQ 0797/YY>r -o:2,

1 a e 2 f C+3 i

y-~ l l

N,N t. av q~ - p.

                                                                      . :ff+fm. /e.9 Q. 3%e i
                                                                           .+             .

n . 4 t

                                  -                  rm            ',p >y
                                                                   ,                                          ry, l
                                     ,                #eg-                 .
                                                                                               'k 4

ph 9 .-.

                                                                                                                            % QI ,,, .. . %
                                                                                        /             '.~                            af s(~
                                                          - .., g,Y_-

g

                                                                                                                                            'N I                         .

f ,, (. _a

                                                ~

h

                                              ~                    ~
                                                                                               !                                   #%+

octut.1 ' octat 2 ot,,t.j l i i i l

  • 5 i i i: l s I I

~~

                  !                  I                   I                  y                  i y                                                       T si , .         . .                 ._     y
                                                                                                                          ..                                . . ' ' " -=='.__..-i                                                           .-                       -.

Mel

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             '8II~~
                                                                                                                          ^T"it.              '964. kiisk, ta M                  " 386 He 16     s [WEd. F. 3MP'. u i H                                              '
                                                                                                                                             'ICtsiieIts il alEh4                           18     t E*lidi.70IE. latl. SS                      Y 4       h4 ashe                            # e eisi~d.seCimf75                                 am      66           4, FeCursui~ ins. u                                                                                                                               0 4
                                                                                                                                              ' plat.~ ku. esc taf il QJ 'I's                         6'i' E s sti Ma ta' Int 5 0                         if f ts4 Y"YEWE.'Mn seCtml. u                                   CSUn's                          nEl')MINN GE71sti. 9                              ilff he
                                                                                                                          -F9r'E9i4~iiirtsCtar. ss                               altrbe                          m T1                       insA~ c. f               e-ear   rue            !'
                                                                                                                          -r ,.vrCww.was                                         . in      su                    er7ai.' ~ ~ ' '. mes a a                            riirne M9itCWieCTm .u                                a 3m      vi                    se"~                                  35            s-isFpq                !

ef'~ ' klJ'@TE 55 a lif~hj~ '

                                                                                                                          ~
                                                                                                                              'fT PI8Cld ie5Ilm' . 55                            alfbi am Pt' T't                  'd.II7td'ai.~ilkfl1 l                           a-lif'hi                        is     e li
                                                                                                                          ~57~ ~3p            'piM, Ma.se[titl. u                a.14      pi                    ti "I'.' W'PtM. Ms.eE.1R$. $5i(Es.~eBI1m[ll         alfh6                  j Cpi                                     . hu_seTjasi,,3v ss X       ln]E%Cws isFM'                       t. u                                      si                                                  a ser.Je_.             .

a_  :

                                                                                                                          ,,f,d.,     S $_Il(k8.]ea]bE 16                        a    86   04                    e        iV Ig,3,Jlp83 et                           6 JM, ,,Pt             g a 3M pij
  • N 10 Ofl.%.M.E85L.%la 3 gl -

_4 '81.L.M8._0E1 Mit._%I D.4 _1, hua.M istb_H *:: 't..M V_.OV!M..Va.uhinia uit M

                                                                                                                          %"                   '(hW, SsW".10. %$                 6 tot 'IM                       19,L
  • Gall _t4 ( enG1 R.H ,

V9 a est a se e* as

  • a w3see8. m. ss vi. ene. a H g9
                                                                                                                                                    -~~re                        e-ear 4                         im T            ms_ t.inerlei                       a talDe
         #                                    #e ,                                                                        -'fC                                  ev               6- 9       '>                   183  N          Ptf t. Ms.cul.1stl.15               a34     114 g
                                     '*                                                                                   -        ~

a 02 er ;. i hfur . Isma .

                                        .**                                                                               T;                    rgm,             .ei, 4        ,                   u,gg-;picy...escia,s                iseg, ,g gg_,,,,,agi_i                 ,

T Mit ei a set si is;j.**my sa m en. a;sssJe

                           'o.

n . m es a-ist m ser Pom. un.en, ut am De "if ms. at a-ist m em essi. we om, mas se am ne V CK mi.y. nen'. 'ee i ist~ rm not Fut. sens wris ein 9 .

e. ~
                                            'et                                                                              W 'i T9s C une si                 r                 eWim                            ni          r. nt.                w. ss             a#i.i T-"TT,.irTa st 'siin. a.n in          m                        .H             4#k d                                          #

as sau ens. saa H3  ; *nt. w. EsseClu. El a esT'ih

                                                                                  #'.4                                     X[ ~caden1qic,.ries                         a.it                                      n                     'sCw urn.o s t il,r' f < p ',

i a m um es stC ls e- m pe nl .n'sait east, one, a H

                                                                                                                           ~T 4
                                                                                                                                    ~
                                                                                                                                                 #18t. km ee. stl. 5%            a710he                                                                                                   (
        )         k'p                                                                                                         as             n m iserrei                         Derim to       64 TPM. Ma es. till $1                    am         P4
                                                                                                                           ii'MG *a:Eneien. R.H nl                  ha emet. site. R,ld C                                                                                                                           lo if PIMI Wit IE. M s.W                          5 IIIIll
  • VT'UFnICTfli.05' us, u a14 re _

ge m. mr , n. n aIw nu 8g6 am re 0 Y' '1ENW. n DBM's

  1. li i 15 m. ser . m, n 4 d .6*8./" 'T!" 'FifC'RilW'h n am si'
                    #' ."'di ,,                                                                                                                 ;aiillism{te                     aWr ni s .d'                       ' hs# ,9 KF                    em. suse. was u                am n T         1 if esc Mn 80.' ga C $$                    315 pl
                                                  . .O.
  • lf ' isC'ini~ ee7 a sie og $
                                                                                                                                                'mc- . .taTT yo yT                                                   sm         -

og i g rupt, um us uts. u azu ne

                                                                                                                            '~ii       i     E' tit. gr. uw=.18. H                a RN      Ut TT F.'teLC1 der w                                     On        r ue "If' ' Tit'7IICMi se, uts. u                          rm        ne
                                                                                                                            ' irTY.'71stis It~. uf. n                             am m
                                                                                                                            "" lit %'W.w TC n                                     Derrm
                                        ,,.                                                                                                                                                 'm "Y TT,'tanese*~ ePT                                   d 'idF
                                                                                            -e               se u
                                                                      *e                                                                                                                                          t rno to c.<ca at ceassana                                              (

e,* 3 LME GENDS #4(at PG55SLE

3. DSn.asetLE IBAPweteOle Wat vtl SEfout attimeG A Ct i S. O or'ao'<S saaet oa .es. ora -

6 4LL PAPIssG Ptil ase51 GH.? CLs51 ll 7 Q DiedOTES stLO samett 6 ette) te0 O TOT 4L F001 AGE Or piPeeG 25%'Or 9la* $ 1

            .s m,w; m=-
5) O C t f Wit 'W"
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       ,. _p A." CC,I                               _

Pt h

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    .. _04s C081       .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 -r; G'

x i s PERTURE -

 .;                                                                                                                                                                             CARD N        ,
t.
  • Also Avnilable on

% Aperture Card i

                                                                                                                                                                                                               "14 "                                                                    7 i
                                 .... i ..                        r               ..       - . .
                                                                                                    ,, g .,                                                                                     ,y, gango geasgarenarwo
                                                                                                                                                                                                ,v.es                                          enm. ag pe
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 . g ,, .o,t,we.e.csomecci             .                    ,

ia g g gp # = -* a'--~= * "" * * """'"

                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ...m.__                                                    j
                             .= == ea
                             ===         m                           ..Y nr e.# re er                                                of d'",di7.*""-                      P    -     -    -

p <, . . . CC If RE AC1DR COOL ANT Pute.

                             "*                                   **              *'                                                                                                                                                             CONTROLLLO BL(ED-OFF                       :
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     "*a==

J. in. . u.. o ' .". 'e"n e u suis

                             -e.-                                 . . .                                                                                                                                              . . . , _                                                              ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     .. .                        .        <.a.  . un ,c c..res,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     .s.se an.epie es e s                 J, opetitt Enestaa baia 4         -

w _mwn a + n r,.. >

                               .m_. .
                              ....e...

_ r_ ,,, r ....e. ,ba r

                               .                    i .,           .          i
          .                               ,                                         e                           ,

I is I n i..... +,,,mmw=:t=u o u .: i l

                                                                                                                                           - -                              -_-                       n a - -                                                         n
 . ** m N

NOTES

l. FIELD 10 CHECK ALL D1WENSIONS
2. USE BE CS WHERE PD$51BLE
3. Cl5sANTLE Ol8PHRAGW YALVf! 9EFD*E t!LDING
4. WARE E ACH EREC148LE SPOOL tlTH SKETCH AND
                                                                                                                                                                                               $P00L D ASH NG. , L4hE CLAS$. SYSTEM. UNIT &
40. plTH & NON CHLDRIDE OWK PAINT WARKER 3 ,

I ,l II

5. ] DENDTE$ SPCCL DASH NUNDER 4 SEND NO.

E (NUCLE.AR) E ALL FiPthG PEP AN51 B34.7 CLA$s I h DIN 01ES aELD NutIBER

6. OFCR COND.- SEE LAYE5;;T REV
                                                                                                                                                                      ,g                                             SDtCC GTSO tA-%g
                                                                                                                                                                      ,2 9 . Q . C. LEV F,.L' S' E

4D ALT. MAT (,1 tw o H f_

                                                                                                                                                                                !           11. VALVE GL A$4D S C.AL t.CAK-OFV CC4JN'S.

rI ro poiuv oovna wAno cr Hout2cuTALLy.

                                                                                                                                                                                        ~.

12 2'Wf/6fA6u'A$$ Nit;4'AWMn'4MS$.ARCKf//ht5 /3 ADDfD gg

                                                                                                                                                                                        % OY${f*tt*fs*ft%9AlvsftDW4/NMfNTM)V/CfD
                                                                                                                                                                                           . xv.wker2YsN9wasmkro -

f.,

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     /
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       /

V # I C 5 q. .

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     .r.

j! Aktc-st foc9 C IEi. 3 6 3" m 4s ,.

  • 3 --

3 . I @ h . ~ h*6f.;810.L i

                                                                                                                                                                      .F. g                                                                    j.        l E nc:26.70s                   e=

l

                                                                                                                                                                      ;;l g                      EW4 DML T                             -                .                .

m gy'hc a cesa, r :,=<k9 0,

                                                                                                                                                                       .g ,

e,.sep a ,,.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   =       .

3; * - /R pg . s lh  !"" '.mE-30) ## E? *~ %* , M I C. _

                                                                                                                                                   ," ll                  ,',
                                                                                                                                                                                    ,                  *:J7/ 4R.as _M w ev @ ac               -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     $ECTi<

coot $11 cu.c _IC_' , a g CODE R t &_1) I

                                                                                                                                                                            .I.

b? 4 9 W Su e60 EML 5 P'Ps SC- A% SK i w c p64 g;* eo " 5 W. A-er 96 F s 15* w sc . so s w t s. m >E s .5, s.sst w a.eBL F 94r. 1 4 h *E L.t. 90* 6cco 4 K. w . 8 A -3 ? & 3 84-e t'  % ' =#c ee 160 5 wL S. **e PE s s. pcesa otv, O ESC RIP TION MEaf eso. astus suo emoEis BILL OF MATERIAL ( I 1 l l w% u

                                                                                                                                                                                                    . ,,,,,,a g vg      U.      *'l      -

ON THIS DRAWING HAS

                                     /                                                                                                                                         PECEivCD THF, ASWE
                                                                                                                                                                               -hA- CCDE STNJP.

i bpf .

                                                                                                     *2           00NI"0" fVWNE"$l8'                                                                             e
                                                 %                     , / 

co "fe'ta f f l

                                 ..~

c # 5t* y/0 . s 3 3' e I i*ENET. LD PE N ET. t c. Zl'57'N  %"CC 1-2009 VCPLGi FCE - . 2*5W-4158

                                                                                                                                       .fgJmk O'        ..              . . _

Y

                                                        . /s                                                                       PENET. IB                                          PE N E.T. t A 1*HC-3f, loo 3                                     1V4*CC 8 200 D: #*

N R SLEEVE _gge.reow D-D G*t1D No.EZLE PENETRATION 4 NQ i A,iB,1C (10 CCMRJTER INF CRMATW TYDE 11 C EL.37' O' 293 *-57' une >Je rooter s. o. r:Il i o A*g. s, y s wec s2.zan e.c ' 2.m Y r, - .M.

                                            '                  - /                                       ,e ~ ~ ,o~

u m o , ,,r. n . t m .. ,v. y g- , - ---w . . c%--n i ...- 3 : ., .

                                                                                                                                                                  ~            " ""
                                                                       . V..                                           42'          PERTURE
  • W+,f y

J CARD s es &. ?f" (

                                                                                                                                                                ~
                  <2'                                                                                                          Also Available or 1                          ,
                                                                                                                  '+-            Aperture CW'    7    %
                                                                                                                                                                              \y y'                         "5" fer. F w.MP-925 uurt) Crur ) &,                                                                                         7                                  ,

nmmmmaman~xmmswm - - -_ sis.nt UP NO. 2-4 i Cost CooE: m o.cocio.now . IMOULATION CLAas: un .ca TH8CK: 3 %wigigygr/'p"""=<, y - - - gh , mo .ocsouma r-ef a ,,,.,,,,,A_,, le =) -~ ~ - = . - -o _ rae moo 4=r.4fV aw e ririno o.oa se. s 7 e an. . ,s ucy. c/ *

w. cr BECHTEL CORP

__- mo coax SAITRERSONES, M ARYLARI , - une. Ame noo:Er ?/4 unst wo.: 2 d .too.s cTmr CALVERT CLIFFS Ulili 1 & 2 _._ stes en Avnoo: r a'# ' - um.varraf,'ove ywa c[xaAvtanamata Tvet' s c i sm ic BALTIMORE GAS & ELECTRIC CO. ' - scemnos: owo.noa sucnicenoiwaniwo ousensur max.cenen: 550 M' 'T *1 # QUALITY CONTftOL DATA N NN C C - 17_ (NuctcAe) REACTOR Coot.Am- Pumps To Vot.ume. - ' rire utAt e.on.: . .r'{ 5dZ 8e44 SF Mart, . CONTRot TAh entinosucAtwas.:

                                                                                                                         .. .                                                                    .,          f v u ver w arnosa                                                                                         '
                                                                                              .. x -            -
                                                                                                                   +

qu ac.sysu m woa. g 5 g,, .- ,,e. .ve . . . .<

                                                                              .7.                             ..v.q                  6750: ISKfMP-3'080 e ,,

w ;m Mca c.x u RBOLT70035

  • 4 N
                     =

NOTES

1. FIELD TO CHECK ALL OlNENSIONS N
2. USE BENDS WHERE POS$lBLE l
d. MARK E ACH ERECT &BLE SPOOL stTH SKETCH AND SP90L DASH NO. , LINE CLASS, STSTEN, UNIT 8 NO. WITH A NON CHLORIDE Bl_Act PAINT N AME R
                                  =

m . . - . . .= . . - _ _ _ _ _ h 6 ALL PIPihG PER ANSI 831 'l CLASS T1 *

                       ~                                                                                        '
7. h DENOTES WELO NUNSER '2 *.

8 TOT AL FOOTAGE OF PIPING 68' ?.N [ 60//6 * [. hf+

                                                                                                                //              .-
                                                                                                                   -#                    e 9 owl em seg suc thwaiarzv                                             ,             ,N. .
                                                                                                    '                                     ~
10. C C LEVEL 't ~s
                                                                                                                                            ^'

li. ALT MAT't, cc.r2 nong

                                                                                                              \~              ,f

[p D' ~

                                                                                                                     ..                                 N#
                                                                                                                                                            - c it.SEVERAL Or THE SPAN LENGTHS BETWEEN SUPPORTS i                                                                 ,

5 ON THS DRAWING WERC FOUND TO EXCEED THE l ORIChAL DESIGN CRITERIA IN WO-30 OR M 18.  ; THEY WERE REVIEWED AND FOUND TO BE ,% ACCEPTABLE UNDER ESP Est99601371-000 REV.O.

                                 .      (REF.lSSUE REPORT IRO 028 989).

A_ -- il CouMit /N/d4/4ft:At 'Q" Lwl ME /& 5/4 l  % 'Ct./2 2Co 9 6/' 4/ l 0 2 l ble' 6:% VLa t oss Ito M b 1 i f l 2,'. ,' i- H 1 i i hb^ ll'Th*.JCo*l60',$L$,~it$l A l h.-  % Slb Z.L - .I'. s 1 . .h E ..t _. -

                                                                                                         ~ ~ ~                     ~'                ~

TV alaa .GArc VALVE Mt 7Mi' 2 '1 ht4 . cowr ect vev etcv-505) te u.a- er I to M .s i N4'. c.to in 20 f e 1 4 4 46 s bl A . CPW 6000s. ~r'- A t B2 L bs 6 f7 f i ' i 16 l t I 49 f f , < l' t N4* - TE6 bovo b*. t I3 9 4 e 6 4 4 i _ I c= lSO 2' M 4 - S CM. 160 $HLS. PIFE A 'ilb Sob - to s' - 9 p' - l \ b l' 7 t' 6 IS' 5 20' 4 (2' 5 IV Rg o o e r 9 o 49 t Tb4" CPLCa f cod" .ssu A =lL 2. % pc som ory.l D E s c R e P T I o es setAt esciAsian eso. estosistsisaussiusi BILL OF MATERIAL ( ,# - l

                                                                                                                                                              ,            m.,i j, l
                                                                                                                                                              ;"1"LTC 0e.a)l$

g

                                                                                                                                                              '?W EloE STAMP.,             ,j e a.i/' c aa rf (5~%v.-M P" ? c'.c ., o I,                        #                  '            
              ?

ys f [\

                                                           $         23                                                          ce"#

4d e.

                               '\
                                                                                                                                                \

) . g

       \e ob h' 2\ 4      3 r                    U.          -

1 [ Ic# M s.  : I 4c[ x . 2' " ^2 ,

t. .,_ _ .

APERTURE  ;

       ' @@. . ,                                                       !%s ,                                                                               CARD                   j                    -
       ,-                 p                                                                                                                                                       1
                                                                               \

5 W \ AISO Availab!o on

                                                                                                          '%c, s N -sopb qs
                                                                                                                                               /
        ' '0:,.               %.                    \i                         (                S q
                                                                                                                                        ~

g, .._ _- K,, - 6 g - y;

                                                                                'N
  • y -

ll 6 y% ('mM96slR. em / C# *,

  • 12 "

ur no. 2/41 cost coot: moutAnow ctass: - ( rnen: - ,mm ,

                                                  ~

12 34 u nsen6orari poo _ _ _ p(p nuo.c ocian neownts nennence hi nty can etscairtsoN om otou ot an arrnovto DmoPnOCEDune.h *h P&tD.NO.(CM - 4 61 (f.2 *J 3 0lj i uttp4meP.h. G., o.acomn= noo: us pyma poo.: se-338 nev. ri-- o. BECHTEL CORP  :

c. Anc noo:JR-st(p omT m : 2 2,

BAITIEt$80RS, M ARTLARB i  ; u noo: stoc.: Aux. ur ,'Np

6g CALVERT CLIFFS HIT 1 & 2 * ,

a ourm' BALTIMORE GAS & ELECTRIC CO.

  .1.fr. af ove n.dx..vca
   . WTER:                        INTEn PUnGE:      DwC.feO;           SEISMIC                                                 ELECTRIC (NOINEERINO Of P AR1 MINT                   ,

OUALITY CONTROL DATA CC- 12 (NI) CLEAR cm) _ ,.:t nur nos.: (NUCLEAR) REACIOR C06'LANT PUMPS CCtARC11ED mosmar .: ses alto or MATERIAL RifFD .0FF 'TO VOLUME..CO.NTR0t' TAN. K;. _ . . . _ _ _ . . - . . _ . . . . y,

                                                                                                                                                                            -'yy" afEV,.] h
                                                                                            ", p                  -; g         p .*
 . sv8 Tend 800;       , , , , , , ,         .       ,,,,.           .            .

k- DEDS. f80. ' 3'g

  '"*".:$fk ,                            "

Y5I! frI ... A67ANSK-MP .3023 . izj

                                                                                                              %)72 OES-Oi                                                                      -

Figure D Containment Temperature vs. time 70 - - - - -

                                                                                                                                                                                       ,300 t

60 - - ~ - - " ctmt temp. g}50-- l t ;. '

                                                                                                 ,. 1 4
                                                                                                                  '\

i { ctmt pressure

                                                                                                                                                                                      .-250w{

g '...j- i c '. e j

                                                                                                                             ',_ _ _ ,)
                                                                                                                                              -{.

sump temp. y

                                                                                                                                                                                      --200 j (40 --                                                            fi i                                           ,                  N.          .
                                                                                                                                                                                             - 8. '

Q 8 30 -- A+/ /

                                                                                       ,--           r; i

A - - -

                                                                                                                                                     - 4
                                                                                                                                                                   'h- !%:
                                                                                                                                                                     ']

6 5

                                                                                                                                                                                       --150 9 j                 -

20 -- i. E  : T r- ~ -- i  ; x I

i ,  : .

10- A1ll H M +1H]

. . NHil-++%R! . M ::b+HH! . ; . :. ::I . . .:::. 100 1 E-02 1 E-01 1E+00 1 E+01 1E+02 1E+03 1E+04 1E+05 1E+06 l i

Time (Seconds) ~ l Pmase64.1 psia at 177 sec.; Tmax=288'F at 71.5 sec.; Spray /CAC delay times = 70.9135.9 sec.; 2nd Spray off at 4.75 psig during post-RAS l i i-L__.________

h, 1 . . a Figure E Convective Heat Transfer Coefficient 2 ho (BTU /hr-ft -F) 500 400 300-200- ~ 100 - 0 100 150 200 250 300 CONTAINMENT AIR TEMP (F)

s Figure F Penetrations 62 and 64 without Insulatjon 1 *

                                                                                                                  "ANSYS 5.2 JAN 6 199 17:06:44 POST 26 zV   =1 DIST=.75 Xr   =.5
                                 , 307                                     .

Yr =.5 2r =.5 z-ourrER PrPE ED 960 { w 240 TEMI TEMP , j Z 226 I h1 F-g 200 j LJ  ! F-

                            <C     isv                                                                                        i 3                                                                                                 j I

167 PZPE CNTR 146 i 127

                                   '00 l            l          l 0       l       200   l      400  l          l 1

l l 600 800 1000 100 300 500 700 900 TIME (sec) 3" 3CH. 40 PIPE

s

                                                     .    .                      Figure G Penetrations 62 and 64 with 1" insulatiog 1

ANSYS 5.2 JhN 6 1997 17:10:32 POST 26 EV =1 DIST=.75 30 , xr =.5 Yr =.5 zr =.s 260 Z-BUrFER 260 m b v 247

c. -

E-- 220' W W g 200 W I-  ! i

                                       <C      187 3                                                                                                                                                                           i 167 Prrs zo/ core                                                       I 147
  • TEMP i '

TEMP I 120 ' 100

                                                             )         g            g               g                                                                          j(s10          32)

O 800 1600 2400 3200 4000 400 1200 2000 2800 3600 TIME. ( s e c ). l 3" CCH. 40 PIPE w/ 1" rIBERGIASS INSUL. I l

1 l

                                                  .     .                                                                          )

I Figure H Penetration IC without insulation i 1 - 5.2 l ANSYS JAN ( 1997 17:13:30 1 CST 26 f ZV =1 DIST=.75 30g Xr =.5

                                         +                                                                          Yr  =.5 PIPE rr)                                                    zr  =.5 z-eurren 266 m

LL v 240' CL 1 PD'E CUTR ' N Tene

  • 227 W TEMP F-g 200 W

W

                    <                      180" 3

167 14t! 120

                                                 }
                                           '               1 .

l l l i i i 4 0 200 400 l 600 300 3000 I 800 300 500 700 900 TIME -( s e e ) i l 3/4" SCH. 80 PIPE ! I

                                                                                                                                   ,1 l

l l

e

  .g.

Figure I

Penetration IC with 2" of Insulatida, 180 160 140- -

120 0. h 100-0: 0 80 - R

                           <                         60 40 20 0

0.0E+00 5.0E+04 1,0E+05 1.5E+05 2.0E+05 2.5E+05 3.0E+05 3.5E+05 4.0E+05 TIME (sec) lt l' e}}