ML20209B717
| ML20209B717 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 10/05/1982 |
| From: | Kerrigan J Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Cooper W TELEDYNE ENGINEERING SERVICES |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20209B723 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-86-151 NUDOCS 8210200098 | |
| Download: ML20209B717 (2) | |
Text
. , . . : . . e.. - ..:- - -
- . . x - . -
- .. . c.w " --
- 1.uwwu L:L%& sin V , .
DISTRIEbi10N Central Files 007 5 PRC SYSTEM 1982 LBf3 Reading ,
JKerrigan 08tT11erling JLee OELD OI&E Dr. W. Cooper Teledyne Engineering Services ACRS(16)
JKnight 130 Second Avenue Walthma, Massachusetts 02254 PKuo LChandler
Dear Dr. Cooper:
This letter responds to your request of August 3,1982, for specific infomation items regarding the Brookhaven Report. The information (hard copy) had been provided to you by advance mail.
Attached is a letter, dated September 10,1982, from Brookhaven which explains the infonnation we sent to you.
Sincerely. .
gigin Sisnad B73 Janis D. Kerrigan, Acting Gief -
Licensing Branch f3 Division of Licensing
Enclosure:
As stated cc: See next page I
21s.2 f$ M5N1 77-G I
o,,,ea ...:. L.BD.... .. ..AMn.... .. .1. .s.
l m,.mo ....h.i.eCU.n 9.:lb.....J.KMdSAn.....---
l
.!.09../.
am y .0. 9./...i..c ../. 8..2...... a - .s ./.82.....
sac ronu sis oc.ac> nacu :24 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY __ . , _ csm e-n>=
..u ....:.............:.=L- 'w. ? sw.uwn., . . . :. m?wc-2 <- xw ny. _
cc: Mr. Richard Hubbard MHB Technical Associates -
Suite K 1723 Hamilton Avenue San Jose, California 95125 Joel Reynolds Esq.
Center for Law in the Public Interest 10951 West Pico Boulevard Third Floor Los Angeles, California 90064 Herbert H. Brown, Esq.
Hill, Christopher & Phillips, P.C.
1900 M Street, N. W.
Washington, DC 20036 Bruce Norton, Esq.
Suite 202 3216 North 3rd Street Phoenix, Arizona 85012 David F. Fleischaker, Esq.
P. O. Box 1178 Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73101 -
Mr. George A. Maneatis Pacific Gas & Electric Compan7 P. O. Box 7442 San Francisco, California 94120 Dr. Jose Roesset 3506 DuVal Road Austin, Texas 78751 s
9 0
0 I
l
{
- 7. . ,
7 ,x, . .
. , . + : L.a uk :- w. 4 Ah - =- =~k ' :" ~' ~ '
@n"2 ' d' " "'"A" -
-,,.. . .s v .
w' ._* . .
~
'BROOKHAVEN IMllONAL LABORAlORY ASSOCIATED UNIVERSillES. INC.
' Department of Nuclear Energy Upton. Lc g lMond. NC:w York 11973 Building 129 -
(51 0 282- 2448 FTS6W ..
September 10, 1982 Dr. P.T. Kuo Structural Engineering Branch Rom No. 550 Phillips Bldg.
7920 Norfolk Avenue US Nuclear Regulatory Cmmission Bethesda, MD 20014 ,
Dear Dr. Kuo:
Th'is is to confinn that we have complied with your request to supply-additio'nal information pertaining to Model B.
Given below is a li,st of items which I:have delivered to your office on September 8,1982:
1 - Comouter pri'ntout (File DCMDD1). This printout contains a listing of the input deck used by.
BNL for Model B. It includes the geometry of the finite element model, boundary conditions, a defini-tion for both the steel and concrete portions of the structure, and the mass distributions.
9 2 - Comouter printout (Tape ND6488). This printout is a digitized listing of the mocal shapes (i.e.,142) and frequencies for Model B.
3 - Computer orintout (Fil e 'DCM0012). This printout is a listing of the floor response spectra generated for Model B corresponding to three equipment damping values (i.e., 2,3, and 4 percent).
4 - Set of geometry plots ( 3 sheets), set of modal shape plots (10 sheets), list indicating the floor number, fan cooler number and the corresponding node used for the floor spectra shown on pages 56-75 of the BNL report.
r p -n ,f Jd 1 YWc - if
, q e 9 m a ' y W 77~ ?'
I
. . . . _ _ _ -. ._.m.. __ _
, , s. . . .. . .. ... u .. u.; -- - = J .%:" * *i-@ "' ' A '* = " " # **#""~?
, , - 2 . w. ..
Dr. P'.T. Kuo '
Septenber 10, 1982 Referring to items 1-5 of the TES request (see attached sheets) the above given data answers all q,uestions pertaining to items 1, 3 and 4. TES item 2 refers to a user's manual which is available 'in the public domain. I am .
neverthless, sending you a copy for transmittal to TES. Finally, with respect to TES item 5, although some hand calculations were made during the various stages of the work, all of our solutions were generated by computer and are thus in your posse ~ssion.
' a- :1-24 .2.
Regarding the requested TES item 6-8, relating to the piping analysis, I have sent out to you today (9/10/82) by express rail the following: -
(a) - Diablo Canyon Piping Problem 6-11, Model B, enve'loce:
Tnis printout includes the input carc images of tne computer deck, the nodal and element output data, and the analysis results (i.e., nodal displacanents, element '
' forces and moments) for deadweight and thermal analyses, the modal solutions (i.e., model shapes and frequencies) and the response spectrum solutions corresponding to the
, Model B spectra using the x,y and z component combinations with modal ~ clustering effects. It also included the ASiE Class 2 evaluations for .this problem.
(b') - Diablo Canyon Piping Problem 4A-26 model B, envelooe:
Identical 'information as tnat of item (a) above,' for problem 4A-26. <
(c) - Copy of PSAFE2 Manual, -This is a ' draft manual for the BNL piping analysis code. (This document is in the process of being modified).
. ~
Items a, b and c represent the current practice used for piping system analysis and as such it answers all items requested by TES. Multiple response analysis was carried out for study purposes only, since this is not presently an acceptable methodology for licensing requirenents. In view of this, the results of this study are not included in our transmittals.
l l -5%#
Si ncerel,Iy yo'urs, '
!II -),'. / -
ll s.
l'Th Morr.is Ieich, Head D.(/ N Str,uctur'al Analysi s Division im -
Attachment '
cc: R. Bosnak /
M. Hartzman /
J. Knight l
L
^ - _ ____
y... u ._ . . .. . .-; C __ g.::f la a,,.c -
n d.. - .
. .. ,. g , s, ,
]t j Jran;mittal - Picosc Sign and Return Acknowledgement gggg ggg 3-~ Rcquest for Information (RF1)
When Requested Assign Control Number Page.l of 2 0 Receipt (TES use oniy) Controi No. < W /-OoB/ -
DYWu NU$ir\EiiV V
Originator W. E. Cooper /S. L. Chin Transmit To: Mr. H. E. Schierlino Projtet No. 5511 Office of Nuclear Reactor Reculation AU. S. Nuclear Reculatory Comission' '
Orte 8/3/82 ~
7920 Norf'olk Ave.
Cliznt PO - 5-2-82 N/A Bethesda, MD 20114 Trrnsmitted Under Separate Cover To:
NOTE: Furnish complete identification for items transmitted (below). _
O i
M. U LJ i
IQTY TYPE ITEM IDENT NO. REV DESCRIPTION - Titla and Number of Sheets / Paces :r
- l. l 4 1 each Please provide the following documents: (FOR BROOXHAVEN WORK)
(1). Copy of Input and Output listings for Model B-Containment Annulus Structure Analysis.
(2). Copy of Program Manual used for Containment Annulus
, Structure Analysis. -
(3). Copy of list of nodes of worst. spectra (Model B) used in fioures on o' aces 56 to 75.
(4). Copies of all plots and digitized format for Model 8, inclusive of mode shapes, geometry plots, spectra, i
l participation factors, and mass contributions.
i (5). Copy of any hand calculations associated with Containment .
Annulus Str;d tura Analysis. 1 g PA - - % i, n -
I ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF RECEIPT BY[ M TITLE 466Jd{d_ DATE A I ~A d V ' V DISPOSITION FOR PREVIOUS REVISIONS' OReturn to TES O uark void ODestrov uncontrailee NOTE TO ADDRESSEE: Unless stated otherwise the listed items are furnished to you as Controlled '
Documents. Please sign and return the number 2 copy to:
TELEDYNE ENGINEERING SERVICES 130 Second Avenue Waltham, Massachusetts 02254 Attention: Document Control. Project _f#N DISTRIBUTION: 1 and 2-Addressee 3-Document Contro! 4-Originator / Project Manager 4/81
.... ;_ m . :.; . .. .l U - M*h '#/n ' ' ' "
I- d N ^h E I [ h CONTINUATION SHEET -
g g yG M $
d fiequest. '
O Receipt (TES Use Only)
Transmitta! Pdge 1 of 2-
- Q RFI .
Originator- W. E. Cocoer/S.L . Chin on tro! No. f~f// - CO R/ Date Auoust 3.1982 A
9 o
w 2TY TYPE ITEM IOENT NO. REV DESCRIPTION - Title and Number of Sheets /Paoes Y
, .J L 1 each Please provide the' following documents:
(For Brookhaven work)
, (6). 'Copyd. Inout and Outout listinos fn- ninf ~ ,,-41.-
r.
6-11 and 4A-26 associated with the Model B analvsis. '
(7). Copy of Program Manual used for oipiria analysis.
(8). Copy of all output on page 132 of Brookhaven Recort items b) thru g) associated with Model 8 analysis.
l N .
OTE: Please Sign Receipt and Return to TES. See Page 1
- STRIBUTION: 1 and 2. Addressee 3-Document Control 4-Originator / Project Manager U! .