ML20147G278

Final Response to FOIA Request for All Documents Re NRC Investigation of Wg Dick Allegations About S&W & Lilco. Forwards App a & B Documents.Documents Available in Pdr.App C Documents Partially Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 6)

ML20147G278
Person / Time
Site:	Nine Mile Point, 05000000, Shoreham
Issue date:	03/03/1988
From:	Grimsley D NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM)
To:	Palast G UNION ASSOCIATES
Shared Package
ML20147G281	List: ML20147G278 ML20147G573 ML20147G623 ML20147G697 ML20147G730 ML20147G749 ML20147G909 ML20147G936 ML20147G962
References
FOIA-88-56 NUDOCS 8803080175
Download: ML20147G278 (5)

Text

..

U . NUCLEA3 RE!ULATORY C"MMISSION  %-c Fosa s tover v,vetusi H /

F01A-88-56

/ pag.g ( _ aseosSt nPt I # RESPONSE O EDO X'"l"*

\,.seeh) INFORMATION ACT (FO!A) REQUEST MARI 3I "%8 1

e DOCittf Nvedet A S t# appareaei fiEQUESTER Mr. Gregory Palast PART 4.-RECORDS Rett ASED OR NOT LOCATID l$ae checked ocaest 40 69ency records owb,ect to the roovest have been located.

No addetonal agency recorde sube to the roovest have been located Agency records m brect to the request that are coetded m Append;a A e,e si,ead, e,suse fo, poic meet n and c eg in the NRC Puu.c Docoment R .

X iri7 H street. N.w., wah.gton. DC.

A ney records sub,.ci to me r w.si eat are e.nteed . Append,, B are e.e.eg made e,a48ue fe pww.c ,nspect.on and copy g . t~ NaC Pww.c Docw-X Room,1717 H Street. N W. Washegton. DC. e a foeder under the FOIA number and reawester name.

The nonpropretary ve son of the propos.sisia that you agfood to accept e a tesophone conversation veth a member of my sta'f a now being made avalatdo for pubhc mspectea and coving at the NRC Pubhc Occument Room.1717 H Street N W.. Washegton, DC. m a fonder wrder the FOIA number and roovester name.

Enclosed is informatoi on how youmay obts.6 access to and the charges for copyng records placed n tN NRC Pwehe Document Room.1717 H Street. N W.. Washegton. DC.

Agency records ht> poet to the request are eettosed. Any apphcable charge for Copes of the records provded and Oeyfrent procedw<es are reted in the comments secton.

Records subsect to the request have been re'e< red to another Federed agencytes) for re,ew and detect response to you in vow of NRC's response to the roovest no funhet action a being taken on appeal iener dated PART ti. A-INFORMATION WITHHELD FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE Certae eformaton in the roovested records e being wrthheid from owb6.c desclosu r e pursuant to the FOIA enemptons described e anc for the reasons stated m Pa't it. sec.

y tons 8. C. and D. Any re'essed sortens of the documents for which only part of the record e teing wrthheid a's being made avadet=e for pubt.c especten and copyng e ce NRC Pou.c cwwen.ni Room. i7i7 H Stro.t. N w , wasn.gion. DC. a fo.de, unde, the Foix numbo, and wester nam..

Comrrenta A previous FOIA request submitted by Mr. Dick may be of interest to you. Copies of the

• equest NRC's response and the released documents are maintained in the NRC Public Document Room located at 1717 H. Street, NW, Washington, DC 20555, in file F01A-86-685 under the name Dick.

A 1

& s DetCton Div5CN $ ANO $

e 8803080175 880303 PDR FOIA PALAST88-56 PDR NRC FORM eM trart p et a6i

FREEDOM OF l~ FOT.M ATION ACT RESPONSE FOu NUMatas' FOIA-88-56 Dai E - MAR 3 1988 4 A..T 115- APPLICA8LE FOli EXEMPTIONS Record

• subsect to the request that are desenbod in the enclosed Append ces C

. are teng wrthhe4d in their entirety or in part under FOI A Esemptons end for the reasons set forth telow pursuant to 5 U S.C M2(b) and 10 CFR 9 ' Jai of NRC Regulations.

1. The wthheld informaton e progerh ciaeeded purswant to Enocut%e Order 12356 IEXEMPTION 1)

2. The wthhed informainn reistes solen to the iMemel personnel rules and procedu es r of NRC, IEXEMPTION 2) 3 The wthhew eformation e specifcaay esempted from pubhc deciosse by statute inecates (ExtMPTiON 3)

Secten 141 145 of the Atomic Energy Act wNch prohib.ts the d scloswre of Restncted Oata or Formody Restncted Data 142 U S C. 216121666.

Secton 147 of the Atoresc Energy Act *Nch proheets the disclowre of Unclassded Sa regwards informaton (42 U.S.C. 2167L

4. The wthhed informaton e a trade secret or corvercial or feancel eformaton that a boeg wthheid for the reasorWel mecated (EXEMPTION 4)

The informaton a cons 4erW to be confidental bus. ness (prooretaryl anformaton.

The informaton e cons 4ered to te propretary informaton pmant to 10 CFR 2 790id41).

The informaton nas svtattes and reconed in conf 4ence from a fore 9n source pursuant to 10 CFR 2 790tdn2L r

5. The wthhou informaton corests o eteragency or etrangene, reco-ds that are not awadebee thrcogh decovery dunne htgaton Oscloswee of predece.onal eformaton would tend to chbt the open and frank enchange cf does essente' to the del.beratrve process Whwe records are wth>e+d in thee entrety, the facts are inestratatdy intertened eth the credecrnosal rdonneton. There a6so are no reasonatdy negregab6e factual port one becavse the release of the facts would permd en moweet equery eto the prooocoonal process of the egency. IEXEMPTION 51 X 6 The wthheid eformetron e enervted from pwbhc dado wre tocawse ets doctosure wouks reswrt e a clea% unmarra,ted evas.on of reasonal oressey (EXEMPTION 61

7. The ethheid informaton coments of evestgatory records comosed for law enforcement purposes and s teng ety.o6d for the ressorust ed<ated (EXEMPTION 71 Doctossre would etw4ere avth an en%rcement proceeeng tocawse a could revesi the scoce erecten, end focus of enforcerrent e* orts. and thws covid poss@v anow them to taae acton to shou potentel

• tor 9soeg of a votaten of NRC reowrements from evestgators. (EV(MPTION 7tAH Doctosure wovid constavte a9 wr**erroatM invason of personal prmacy (EXEMPTION 7tCH The informaton corensts of names of roweals and other eformaton the d4clowre of *NN wovu reveal contrtes of cor44ent.ei soveces. tExEMPTION 7tDI)

PART 11 C-DENYING OFFICIALS Purswant to 10 CFR 9 9 and 'or 915 of the U $ Nwcieer ReguWtory Ccreasson regulatore a has been determeed that the o ' formaton wthhe6d o esempt fecrn proActon or encicwe.

and that ns p,oducson o, decicus e contmo ih. puu.c ete,.st The p.rseas ,esconse4. for in. dens are ihoser o eceis e.nwed te o. es d.nye, o*,c.s and the c,eeso,.

Orreon of Rules and Reco'ds. OfSce cd Aomenstraten, for any denets that may be oppealed to the Esecutrve Director for Operations <tooi DENYING OFFICIAL TITL E < OF F iC E RECOROS r'YED APPELLATE OFFictAL William T. Russell Regional Administrator, " " " * "o bginn i Ann. C y l

l l

I l

PART ll D- APPE.AL RIGHTS The oenial by each denying otfoal ident4 fed in Part li.C may be appealed to the Aprecate Offcal identrfed in trxst sect on. Any such appeal must be in wntrig and must be made withan 3) dan of receipt of this response. Appeats must be address 3d as appropnate to the Esecutrve Oirector for Operatons or to the Secretary of the Comminaon, U.S. Nuclear Rqutatory Commessaon, Wash.ngton, DC 20555, and should clearty state on the envelope and in the letter that ft es an "Appeal from en inst.al FOLA Decision.

anac eom end iPen a

• • • U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISS!ON FOlA RESPONSE CONTINUATION ,

l

REF: F0!A-88-56 APPENDIX A DOCUMENTS AVAllABLE IN THE POR/LPOR i

4 DATE ORIGINATOR RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION

1. 5/23/83 R. Starostecki M.S. Pollock, Long Inspection No.

NRC, Region I Island Lighting 50-322/83-13 Company (AccessionNo.

8306060210)

)

i ,

t i

.! j l

i 7

i

]

l l

l

T i

1 APPENDIX 8 i

DOCUMENTS BEING PLACED IN THE PDR  !

FOIA REQUEST NUMBER 88-56 i

DATE ORIQINATOR RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION  !

l 6/5/85 Allegation Panel Decisions with Allegation Description attached. I (2 pages) l

2. 4/2/86 J. Strosnider, A. Shropshire, Memo

Subject:

HRC, Region I NRC, Region I Closure of i 1

Allegations at l Shoreham t (2 pages) 1 I

n I 1

i 1

1 1

i i

)

1 1

d

REF: FOIA-88-56 I

APPENDIX C '

) DOCUMENTS BEiNG WITHHELD IN PART PURSUANT TO EXEMPTION 6 j OATE ORIGINATOR RECIPIENT DESCR1' 'j

! 1. 3/1/85 R. Starostecki, W.G. Ofck Lett. response NRC, Region I to letters dated 1/26/85 and 2/14/85 (2 pages)

2. 3/5/85 Investigative Interview (Closed Meeting) - W.G. Dick and W.J. Lazarus (145 pages) .

3. 4/10/85 R. Starostecki, W.G. Dick Letter referring to NRC, Region I March 3, 1985 inter-view with Mr. Lazarus (1 page) 4 7/9/85 R. Starostecki, W.G. Dick Follow-up to 4/10/85 i NRC, Region I letter without

] enclosure (3 pages) 5, 10/8/86 Allegation Receipt Form

6. 10/22/86 W.F. Kane W.G. Dick Letter

Subject:

NRC, Region I Allegations against e Shoreham and Nine Mile Point Unit 2 (1 page)

I i,

i l

l

, _ . _ . - . . . . - - , ,