ML20133C812
| ML20133C812 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 05/01/1984 |
| From: | Spessard R NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
| To: | James Keppler NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20132B617 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-85-236 NUDOCS 8507220001 | |
| Download: ML20133C812 (3) | |
Text
-.
e i
(
- o
\\.
MAY 1 1984 MEMORANDUM FOR:
James G. Keppler, Regional Administrator FROM:
R. L. Spessard, Director, Division of Engineering
SUBJECT:
QUARTERLY REPORT OF OPERATOR LICENSING ACTIVITIES SECOND QUARTER FY 84 This is the report of the Operator Licensing Section activities for the Second Quarter of FY 84.
Attached are the following two sections which comprise this report:
Section A - FY 84 Budget Estimates vs. Examinations Administered to Date Section B - Results of Examinations by Facility - 2nd Quarter FY 84 In addition to the budgeted activities reflected in Section A, resources were expended in answering requests from applicants for regrading of examinations.
- iLInc.] t Isn
- ,d iy i;.L. 4c::crd" t
R. L. Spessard, Director Division of Engineering
Attachment:
As stated cc w/ attach:
D. H. Beckham, NRR E. Greenman, RI A. Gibson, RI]
W. Seidle, RIV J. Lineman, RV i
d 8507220001 850528 hTHA
-236 PDR C ID
(
Section A FY 84 Budget Estimates vs. Examinations Administered No. Examinations No. Examinations Type of Examination Budgeted for FY Administered FY to Date Initial 200 115 Replacement 130 135 Requalification 75 18 Instructor Certifications 60 24 Non Power 32 13 e
e
2 :.ee
].-
(
C Section B Results of Examinations By Facility - 2nd Quarter FY 84 Type of No.
No.
Facility Examination Examined Passed Passed Callaway SR0 18 17 94%
Davis Besse SRO 1
1 100%
RO 6
5 83%
Dresden SR0 3
2 66%
R0 1
1 100%
Duane Arnold SR0 a
3 100%
RO 4
3 75%
Monticello SRO 7
7 100%
R0 1
1 100%
Prairie Island SRO 7
5 71%
Quad Cities SRO 6
5 83%
Zion SRO 4
4 100%
Westinghouse Instructor Training Center Certifications 1,1 9
81%
GE Training Instructor Center Certifications 7
6 86%
0 0
R0 1
1 100%
Univ. of Illinois R0 1
1 100%
w
Q INFORMATION REPORT Mav 23,1984 SECY-84-81 A For:
The Commissioners From:
William J. Dircks Executive Director for Operations
Subject:
RESULTS OF OPERATOR LICENSING EXAMINATIONS AND REQUALIFICATION EXAMINATIONS FOR SECOND QUARTER FY 1984
Purpose:
To inform the Commissioners of examination and licensing activities for Reactor Operators and Senior Reactor Operators, including requalification examination results.
Discussion: The enclosed tables report licensing action results, including issuances, denials or withdrawals and pass / fail rate for each NRC licensing examination component.
The results are presented as a combined total and broken down by region.
We have also included a graph summarizing the examination results by region for this quarter.
It shows the percentage pass rate by license and exam type and the total number of exams given broken down by region. We continue to see variations in the percentages in the individual categories of the Regions; however, these variations reflect the impact on small sample sizes when one test administration results in a large failure rate.
We are continuing to track trends in examination results by region and have not identified statistically significant trends that are not explained.
Also included are tables showing the results of the requalification examinations given for the second quarter FY 1984. All completed requalification examinations were evaluated as satisfactory with the exception of Ginna (RI) and Trojan (RV).
Regions I and V are completing follow-up audits and actions prior to final program evaluations. As noted
Contact:
Don H. Beckham, NRR X24868
_ OC /M/ ) h W/n UJVJV" m
h
A The Commissioners in the last quarterly report, Region III continues to evaluate the Prairie Island requalification program. When the final audit reports are completed, they will be summarized in a future quarterly report.
e William J. Dircks Executive Director for Operations
Enclosures:
1.
Operator Licensing Tracking System Quarterly Status Report (Examination Results and Licensing Actions) - Total (All Regions) for Second Quarter FY 1984.
2.
Operator Licensing Tracking System Quarterly Status Report (Examination Results and Licensing Actions) for Regions I through V for Second Quarter FY 1984. '
3.
Graph of Exam Results - Percentage Pass vs.
Exam Type - Second Quarter FY 1984.
4.
Requalification Examination Results for Regions I through Region V for Second Quarter FY 1984.
o e aer ae e.
9.h e 4
a g
e O
e e
0 ENCIDSURE 1 O
e S
e e
-- =.
c..u. u,u. s.
1 MAL R-1236315 OPERAltR LICEMSIN3 TRACKING SYSIEn (ALL REGIONS) l CAIEt 85/02/84 ACTIVITY STATES REPO2T 2nd Qtr IT 84 -
i 91/08/84 THROUGH 03/31/84 i'
f r EXAMINATION RESULTS I
i WRIliEN ORAL SIMULATOR 10TAL OFA55 9 FAIL 9FA55 BFAIL OPA55 erAIL 1AKE3 i
IMITIAL - RO 77 /
95 79 /
IS 23 /
I 13 j
83.7% / 16.3%
88.8% / 11.2%
95.8% /
4.2%
SRO 65 /
8 67 /
7 23 /
4 76 3
89.9% / 11.0%
99.5% / 9.5%
85.2% / 14.8%
/
2 9 /
/
3 23 8,17
,...X
/
..1
- 1....I REAFFLICATIONS - RO
.5%,. 5%
X
%/
...X SRO 14 /
9 10 /
2 2 /
8 21 I
100,9% / 9.9%
83.3% / 16.7%
100.8% / e.8%
{,
UPGRADE - SRO 25 /
11 28 /
3 5 /
8 36 69.4% / 39.6%
10.3% /
9.7%
100.0% /
8.0%
4 !
1 TOTAL - RO 94 /
17 8%,/
11 24 /
I 116 I.'
89.7% / 15.3%
84 9% / 11.1%
96.9% /
4.0%
I SRO let /
19 105 /
12 38 /
4 833 i,
84.6% / 15.4%
89.7% / 10.3%
88.2% / II.8%
I 3
e I
}'
i 1
l I
i i,
{
e i '
TUTAL (ALL REGIONS) 9-1236315 OPERATER LICENSING TRACK!MG SYSTEM DATE8 95/02/84 ACitVITY STATUS REPORT 2nd Qtr FY 84 01/01/89 THROUGH 93/31/84 LICENSING ACTIONS
~
DISSUED SDEMIED SWITHDRAWN
- * ' ~
INITIAL -
RO -
122 92 14 SRO -
199 17 11 INST CERI -
39 12 6
LTD SRO -
0 8
8 REAPPLICATIONS -
RO -
15 7
1 SRO -
26 2
2 INST CERT -
3 2
9 LTD SRO -
0 0
9 UPGRADE -
SRO -
32 8
3 TOTAL -
RO -
137 g.
49 IS i
SRO -
167 27 16 INST CERI -
92 14 6
LTD SRO -
0 0
0 REMENAL -
RO -
134 1
0 SRO -
286 0
1 IMST CERT -
9 9
9 LTD SRO -
0 0
0 e
i t
l i
4=N 0
e e
e S
4 O
ENCIDSURE 2 e
S e
D
r-T
.N
. 9-
-3 n
'A C a
- o O Cr
.J E
- u
==s.
4 IAJ an N e
e N
=
K M N
>= W M ".
aJ glg $
04
> = > =
=,4 M M M M M
M M e e. *= c.
e s. s e.
m e.
e e.
- e
==
o g4 O u.
e a e e e
e en N
== e e
4
=J N%%% %%%% %% NNNN 3
E M M M M M
M M
== en esem mome me eeMe e
e o
e e
e e
ensn 4
e e e e e
e M L
e Pm
==
e Ew
>=
en>en e 80 O h= %
=J M M M M M
M M EM*
m eenNN Oeme
- N f*MN MOM 4
e e
e e
gL%
g b
N.
E0 e e e
N
.e UwM
.=
=
e
..=
due ed K
4
%%%% %%%N \\% %%%%
>= en E 30 E
C e= 3 O
M M M M M
,et M
e m en M E40 en e0 an e e.
== e. *= e.an M.
m== g en N
N es-e 4
N==
S e
M 9=
m en en E g
b W W e e W
W W E >=
==
e-m w >=
U m= 9 M M a0 E
.J > %
w e=
W a= e 90%
>= 4==
4 e K
W bO M M M M M
M M an P= N P=
esse MM an m en W e
e e
e e
e e
e e e e M
e M
==
m
== N EW
>=
%%%% %%%% \\% %%%%
>=
me M M M M M
M M g
eMem weem eh O Pe e N 3
N e== e e
e o
M e s=
e en M e e e
en e W W e
e W
W e.
O O O O O
O O N E E E E
N u
' en en en en i
f i
1
- i J
en IM
=J f
4 E
Q 4
e6 M
O 4
>=
>=
M N
O N
w
>=
0
>=
e E
4 b
en %
M U
D
- = en
==
Me
=d e.
L M*
b NW 4
e
- * > =
W 0N M
MU 3-
R-1236315 OPERATOR LICENSING IRACKING SYSTEM RegiCn I UATE: 05/02/84 ACTIVITY STAlt5 REPORT 2sd W 1-YH 01/01/84 IHROUGH 03/31/84 4
1,ICINSING ACTIONS 4
SISSUED IDEMIED
!WITHDRAWtt
~ * ' '
l INITIAL -
RO -
51 11 6
SRO -
21 4
1 i
INST CERT -
4 2
0 i
LTD SRO -
0 0
0 l
REAPPLICATIONS -
RO -
G 1
0 SRO -
1 0
0 INST CERT -
0 0
0 4
LTD SRO -
0 0
0 UPGRADE -
SRO -
9 S
9 i
I TOTAL -
RO -
51 12 6
SRO -
38 9
f g.
1 INST CERT -
4, 2
0 LTD SRO -
0 0
0
)
REMEWAL -
RO -
35 1
e i'
SRO -
69 O
I r;
INST CERI -
0 0
0 LTD SRO -
0 0
0 4
j 1
4 9
4 4
j.
v QC
- =
- 6
=
1.
C w C CY
~
as h ~5 M
4W t'J P
G e
e N M mg N
- N N g
04 M M M M M
M M 4
- m. N o.
e m. m e. a o.
e m N o.
g4 O en.
80 e
e o e
80 e
s= e g
e 4
.J
\\\\\\\\ \\\\%\\ \\\\ \\\\\\N M
M M
. M.. M.
M M m.
e,
-~-.
en en
4
= e e e e
a e
L e e e e e
C W
p=
en
>en ee Ch%
EW*
M M M M M
M M
=4M p
e e. N = e m. m e.
s e.
t e. N m.
WL\\
p UWe 3
m==
e e e
- P
- = *=
4Ee E
ad 8" an E 4
\\\\\\\\ \\\\\\\\ \\\\ \\\\\\\\
>4 0 m
=
M s-O O
M M M M M"
M M 4
- E en N e. d. e.
m e.s e.
M e.
N a.=m en.
E.e s C g
en
- =
e
=
e g
4
== e e e e ~~ e en en z m
E s=
b e e e
W
- W >=
m u e= e ^
M== ep
.a > %
a.e =
w es e OUN a-4==
4 e W
LO M M M M M
M M W N. ** e.
m e. s e.
N e.
W N. M e.
e en e
S.
O e M e=
m em se g
W W
\\\\\\\\ \\\\\\\\ \\\\ \\\\\\\\
s=
ens M M M M M
M M g
s e. h e.
e m. m e. N e.
G a m e.
a=
e=
e=
ee 3
- e e e e
- e e F e
e e e
O O O O O
O O E E
.M E
E E E en en en en 8
I I
I e
a an W
-f a
- C K
O 4
N Pe O
4 e=
M N
O e
ens 0
s=
en %
E 4
b
"" en see t9 3
Me e
e a
M **
4 NW
- = a=
mE 44 iM NC E
"'m-vvw~ww,.
v,-,,------
OPERATOR LICENSING 1 RACKING SYSTEn Region II R-1236315 DATE: 05/02/a4 ACTIVITY STATUS REP 00f 2 xl Qtr IT 84 et/es/a4 THR0usu es/st/a4 LICENSING /CrIONS.
1 1
DISSUED ODEMIED OWLIllDRAWN INIIIAL -
RO -
27 2
2 i
SRO -
29 3
1 INST CERT -
12 9
I LTD SRO -
O O
O REAPPLICATIONS -
RO -
3 0
0 SRO -
0 0
0 INST CERT -
0 0
9 LTD SRO -
O 9
9
],
UPGRADE -
SRO -
9 1
I i
10TAL -
RO -
30 2
2 j
SRO -
30 4
2 INST CFRT -
12 0
1 LTD SRO -
0 0
0 g.
.I i
1 REMEWAL RO -
32 0
e SRO -
let t
9 INST CERT -
0 9
0 4
i LTD SRO -
0 0
8 i
i 1
J l
t I '
6 i
Il i.
e 1
T 00 e
a
=.e b
C e.#
C Cf h
N e N 4 e e
m e
- =
M N f gg; N O
o=
s 4
e
=.J H H H H H
M M e m *= e m o.
- eo e m m e.
m e.
ee e
e e
o at at Ok e t O
e e
e t en es 4
ma M M M
M
- e. M.. M
.M N
- eNe NS ee.
mm oN e e
e e
eN.
4 e en e e e
e e 9
e e
e.
m.
e 9 e.
e
==
a e=
==
EW e-I?>>
an #
E0 O m= %
M M M M M
M M E ag e o.e O so N an== =e m e== M.
e m.
N m N an.
e ggs g
e M e e e
W f UWM
- =
4 as e
=J t2
- = en E 4
30 at O s= 3 O
M M M M am M M
- = M N an m an a e esem sh e.
E4O
== es9 e o
e N og e mise-E W
en e ** *= In en en =
W W e e e
P E >=
- =
- =
W >=
U >= e s=* ** e8 e a > %.
e.e e at e= e OU%
a= 4==
4 e at W
bO 4
M M M M M
M M sw
- so m e emme N eo m agin a og e
e e
e e
e 6
m &
S e
M 99 *=
Em M
- =
W a=
e=
M M M M M M
M M at esmee meme em an N IS P
== eN e o
e e
N *ea 3
f e e e e
e W e e e
e et a-
==
e O O O O O
O O as at at at E
at at en en 40,,
GA r
B 1
l 1
W e
4 E
O 4
W e=e O
4 a=
m M
N O
N eo t-O a=
e E
4 L
an N M
U 3.
- en M
Me J
e
. =b M ao b
NW 4
- = =
W 14 M
. -. -K.b1.
~
u
+-
v, s
g On lll OPERAIOR LICEH51N3 1 RACKING SYS1[M
,R-1236315 AC11VITY STATES REPORI 2nd Qtr FY 81
.CAIE 85/02/84 01/01/84 IHROUGH 93/31/84 LIGNSING ALTIONS i
9155UED SDEMIED SWITHDR AWM INITIAL -
RO -
27 18 1
~ ~ ' '
SRO -
44 10 2
INST CERI -
14 5
4 LTD SRO -
9 9
9 REAPPLICATIDMS -
RO -
10 5
1 SRO -
20 2
2 IM5T CERT -
3 2
9 LTD SRO -
O 9
8 UPGRADE -
SRO -
12 l
2 TOTAL -
RO -
37 23 2
SRO -
76 13 6
INST CERT -
17 7
4 L18 SRO -
0, 9
0 n'
a REMEWAL -
RO -
41 0
0 SRO -
53 0
e IMST CERI -
9 9
9 LTD SRO -
0 O
9
~
e i
Region IV R'-1236315 OPERA 10R LICEISING TRACKIH3 SYSIEn ACTIVITY SIAICS REPORT M @r IT 84
.CATE8 45/02/84 8t/0t/84 THROUGH 03/3t/84 EXAMINATION RESULTS WRITTEN ORAL SIMULATOR 10TAL 9PA55 8 FAIL IPA 55 OFAIL OPA55 erAIL TAKEM IMITIAL - RO 31 /
4 14 /
1 0 /
e IS 73.3% / 26.7%
93.3% / 6.7%
0.0% /
e.s*
SRO 5 /
3 7 /
3 9 /
e 18 62.5% / 37.5%
78.9% / 30.04 0.8% /
8.8%
REAPPLICATIONS - RO 9 /
I 4 /
t e /
3 13 10.0% / 10.9%
89.9% / 20.9%
0.0% /
9.8%
SRO 2 /
8 3 /
O 9 /
3 5
100.0% /
9.9%
100.9% /
0.0%
0.0% /
9.9%
UPGRADE - SRO 13 /
7 17 /
3 9 /
9 20 65.9% / 35.9%
85.0)./ 15.04 8.8% / e.8%
TOTAL - RO 29 /
5
'ts' /
2 0 /
8 28
~
80.0% / 20.0%
98.9% / 18.9%
8.0%./
8.8%
SRO 29 /
IS 27 /
4 8 /
8 35 66.7% / 33.3%
88.8% / 18.2%
0.9% /
O.8%
Region IV OPERATOR LICENSING TRACKING SYSTEM R-1236315 ACIIVliY STATES REPORT M @r IT 84 CATER 85/92/84 e1/es/84 THROUGH 93/31/84 LICf36ING MTIONS SISSUED SDEMIED OWITHDRAWM IMITIAL -
RD -
5 0
5 SRO -
7 9
3 INST CERI -
2 1
9 LTD SRO -
0 0
8 REAPPLICATIONS -
RO -
2 1
9 SRO -
4 8
8 INST CERT -
8 9
9 LTD SRO -
0 0
8 UPGRADE -
SRO -
0 1
0 TOTAL -
RO -
7 1
5 SRO -
Il 1
3 INST CERT -
2 1
0 LTD 5RO -
0 0
0 y.
REMEWAL -
RO -
7 8
9 SRO -
29 9
0 INST CERI -
9 0
0 LTD SRO -
0 0
0
~.
I 4
e
t-v 00
>=
L.
C s,e O Cf
.,a 2 p1 7 4W e e
- art e
In >
w 0
- = W E N S4
> >=
4 M M M M M
M M e m m e.
m e. m e. m e.
s e. e m.
ad u4 OW e e e e e
.e m
em 4
=d
%%%% %%%% %% \\\\\\\\
DE N M M M M
M M em art e e. s e.
e m. m e. e s.
c o. e s.
art art 4
e e e e e
e e b
.o
.e e
=
C w
e=
en>
en e*
g f% o %
Z ef =
M M M M M
M M s e. e s.
S e. ** e.
m e.
s e.
- e.
- e 3 M rn gg%
p uwe a
e e o e o
e e 4ge e
N AC d
=
>= en E 4
30 er O p= D O
M M M M
- f" ~ M M e s. t e.
e m. m e. m e..e m. e e.
.E.C. O g
w g
en arl Z e e e e o
e e w
e so
.m
.o E
e=
=
=
=
w>
u e.= 9 e
so
.J > %
em.=
ate = e t9u %
o= 4 **
4 e
at w
t=
U M M M M se M M M e. e m.
w e. e m. e m. e s. s e e
an e e e e
e e E
N e
a W
=
- =
e-
- s M M M M M
M M et
- e. c e.
e s. eh e.
m e.
- = e. m e.
3 en o e e e
e o N e e
N e os e=
em O O O O O
O O aC at at et aC et E en art Erl ert i
1 1
I e
.e 09 W
.,e a
4 E
Q 4
a=e O
4 8=
N a=
RC O
e
- =e
>=
0
>=
th %
E 4
L
== art me U
D s9 e we me ne.
W'l
- b NW L
= =
4 44 W
Of in E
1
OPERA 11R LICENSING 1 RACKING SYSTEM Regicn V t,
t-1236315 ACTIVITY STAIUS REPORT 1A1Es 95/02/84 e1/8t/84 THROUGil 83/31/84 2 xl Qtr IY 84 LICFRSING ACTIONS a
9155'f ED ODEMIED OWITHDRAWM
~ " ' '
INITIAL -
RO' -
12 11 8
SRO -
16 8
4 INST CERT -
3 9
I LTD SRO -
O 8
9 REAPPLICATIDMS -
RO -
t 9
0 SRO.-
t 9
9 INST CERT -
8 0
0 LTD SRG -
8 8
9 UPGRADE -
SRO -
1 0
0 TOTAL -
RO -
12 11 0
SRO -
18 9
4 INST CERT -
3 0
1
)
LTD SRO -
0 0
0 s.
.s REMEWAL -
RO -
19 s
O SRO -
44 9
8 INST CERT -
O O
9 LTD SRO -
0 0
0 j
4 b
I
~l e
( - -. - -
.. - ~.. -
e 4
4 ENCIOSURE 3 O
9 l
4 l
w.e I
h5 i,
sEssmEnEEEEEu? g _
111111111111111111111111111111lIl' 5
jj j$
~
i a
em s
ammEEmmEussas s
a
.2 ev m
111111111111111111111111111111111111%
j g.g jj
=
m
=~
8 8
S S
2 Me g
15E555555555E 5 3555555555E 3_ 8 m
g 11111111111111111lll111111111111111 5*_
iiiiiiiiii;igigiggiiiiiggi;;;;;;igi;igii g gj s
3-g j]
EmuummusuulEIusi E.
g E
a
-o
- ni lassEumEEmRI E" IEEEEEEEEEEEmul E
,528 lilllllliE,
lOgg 11111111111111111111111111111111 5
se j,,
g 8
3 3
2 E
S 8
2 5g 15E5555555E1]g 55555555555 111111111111111111111111 5a l111111111111111111111111111 5"E 5
g*!
E h
E IEEEEEEmmEEE g8 EEEEEmuumEEEi l
11111111111111111111111111111111115 11111111111111111111111111 9
-s
.a, c.
. - ~
... ~.
Ym O
&y e
O 4
D e
ENCIDSURE 4 0
s S
0 L
ENCLOSURE 4 REQUALIFICATION EXAMINATIONS Second Quarter FY 1984 Region I Facility Results Ginna Unsatisfactory. Utility has implemented a program to upgrade their requalification program.
Region I is following this closely and will report the results when the requalification program is completed.
TMI-1 Satisfactory. This was an operational readiness avaluation conducted by Region I.
f I
t 6
REQUALIFICATION EXAMINATIONS
. l Second Quarter FY 1984 Region II Facility Resul ts Browns Ferry Satisfactory. Gave total of fifteen R0 and SRO NRC written examinations.
Eleven passed. Also gave in-plant oral exams to six additional people. All six passed.
Summer Satisfactory. Substituted two categories on written exam for seventeen SR0's and five R0's. All but three SR0s passed. Gave oral exams to nine of those people and all passed.
The three NRC failures were also identified as failures by facility grading.
Turkey Point Satisfactory. This was an audit of utility grading.
9 2
REQUALIFICATION EXAMINATIONS Second Quarter FY 1984 Region III Facility Results Big Rock Still in progress. Results will be reported next quarter.
Dresden Still in progress. Results will be reported next quarter.
Kewaunee Satisfactory. Completed audit of utility graded exam. Region III will participate in requalification written exam in May. These results will be reported next quarter.
Prairie Island Still in progress. Due to the marginal results of the requalification programs last quarter, Region III will participate in next requalification examination.
G
t REQUALIFICATION EXAMINATIONS Second Quarter FY 1984 Region IV Facility Results No exams given.
O e
W
- ~
t-REQUALIFICATION EXAMINATIONS Second Quarter FY 1984 Region V Facility Results Trojan.
Marginal. Utility is submitting corrective action program to Region V for their review. Results of this review will be reported next quarter.
O e
.,m..
I
,a me e m
+
e e
a p
DO NOT REMOVE THIS PAGE!!!!!
DW/RESULTS OF EXAMS /0L's o
O N e+
..;