ML20127J731
| ML20127J731 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Big Rock Point File:Consumers Energy icon.png |
| Issue date: | 11/03/1987 |
| From: | Hayes B NRC OFFICE OF THE INSPECTOR GENERAL (OIG) |
| To: | Zech NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20127J714 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-92-252 NUDOCS 9301250242 | |
| Download: ML20127J731 (15) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:._. - ,. .,
~'*
'l uni 1 L D ST A T ES I
[') - 1 NUCL E AR REGULATORY COMMISSION
'? - ~! i WA$mNGTON D C 70555 ' w' w. . . ::
1, i November 3,1987 MEl'ORANDUP FOR:, i rr.an 7pch j
'-}p9 < e -!
FROM: f4I. n Hafes, Directo j L l 1 Office of Investigati 'ns
- 1 l
SUBJECT:
MOTIFICATION OF OPENINC OF 01 IfiVESi!GATION l l 1 The Cournssion has directed that you be informed whenever the Office of l Investigations .(01) opans a new investigation. The attached documents briefly j l set forth infornation responsive to this requireront. If you desire r. ore 1 1 detail on any 01 investig3 tion, please let ne know. Attachments; i
- 1. Investigation Status Record
- 2. Reavest for In',estigation j
(3-87-020) 1 cc w/ Attach Comissioner Roberts Comissioner Bernthal Comnissioner Carr Connissioner Rogers
;/. atello, EDO S. Chilk, SECY S. Connelly, DIA W. Parler, OGC E. Pawlik, 01:PIII A. Davis, RA:RIII 4
9301250242 921013 PDR FOIA TUTAK92-252 PDR
.glh .
fi'(([-00& v
%M/ w sqy
N. 0 IOAM 3D U.S NUCLE AR REGULATORY Ccwvvo% INVESTIGATION STATUS RECORD mst aoc nous Tr. ve, wt w w c.e. w 4 c %.,i.m..i,s. w w.wr..i.. w.c. ,ei..n. ,r e.. nto u ,u,oav,,a o - m. r o. ,- ..m i ..w. e. % cs.,,- , n. c.u. smo 8 , n. o .r. .e i% c. va. .w - - me, io s.w, ., ,.. cm e w..an. Cast Nuv88 8 CAftGOR. Of f 6CE Y Jt 0 - Cet mAtihc at Act on I 6%Dmou At tect %$6( c 3-87-0?O _
*Ml,'"cC'," _
w warra>Ats w OI: Rill v ,%EhDOA A OTHER A55dG%to TO Sus;tCT RC' Paul BIG ROCK POINT - VALVE TAMPERING 51 ATUS ISwh a.re, and pmeo a bm' dowrvton) _ 10/28/87 - On 07/29/87, the RIII Administrator requested that 01: Rill investigate an alleged valve tampering event at the Consumers Power Company's Big Rock Point Nuclear Plant. Because the FBI was also evaluating whether to investigate this matter, the Request for Investigation was held in abeyance by 01 until
;he FBI reached a decision. The FBI has notified NMSS that they will not Nrsue inis matter . Accordingly,: this matter is being opened for investigation by OI:RIII. If the individual is identified who allegedly tampered with the valve,_hn/she wquid hava violated Section ?36 of the Atomic Eneroy_ Act, c
g. e
.--.~-w.---.~.. -,--n.. , , . . . . . _ , _ .
___ ,, m. M
= 4.n.._ - - - - , . , _ . - . _.m. ._ ,,,,_.__o_ . , _ __ _, _,,. , __ ~--. ~ ~ . - ~
e m hm -+h.yub.w.
g$b(f,$5khhb$ klhbFY (/IDEf R 2.790(a)) - ALLECER IDENTIFICATION SHEET A'!S NO. RIII-87-A-0042 [Co Fu r 1S +-)
)fEP7 r col 2(g;s &c ,. (kgcog FACILITY: Big Rock Point ALLEGER: !
i i':~=,,. tv: :::..n u m f~~ ggen "'
,g% .hh An a
~, // m
/.~! i*-
,e f.i -
h
, fY Sy,x .' Sw 6vmAw, fy2sd A"r ,
/
Acra ide_& /couud' >na >i-ap -
<b Adsh/ b //u. sA'9& pd yXi,wem/ wAa Odaup st .
2.).7 km vf J //ar / $< 44.f fri ytv,8 # /44<bd uwme,/' apapjfjnd ne '%J twks%an 6/M 4y<fiv A/.49)&'"- a>.2 ecy wya i L.,w n y y.<w n e n w - v j., wu jwud Smm%e teDZ' np. age AualAt. 7h .4anu Ajr r'ou . H,,,np/ma an.sd V a. &,n 4 ~4 inc s x .M wp y /as & &.d4 5 a ] k n .,! v u d ,4 ,< k p h j x y .
.s.] an u; :A a sywv.x > k n . w? wm aava;un,,,a ,fsd<.k lry f- & gwu us/& M s>uj'rtranfi, -Ja. cW/ t y nn4 pH s ;<b o hw.,%..
,Da,rd.y4p+e,6pe6<LuAyna<-4kpin-e n< ~ e? ~ x~-
e& knh.w9 n un~ a n m-.a
-A aned .lkGk St<wd.wnh-r cyQL cf s&w up sx p ,
amga.a .<ytemugamen h em,p.u. u,_ w
>L d' sy e J.f Ann Ed s>y Amwkge off,- 19 w ~. g )
p e +[hehyaj){ftM' t . phd7 s'j?M nE4<4y /V-Yon.7k
- it swwi< . nn a ,se,u h k ya. 7s. un. & gcia 'A uo m m:.kp.ui d.t%m(k;" 7M y . m M A- m p t 6 ,,, n N 2
l1 k . Q.flMh 7Ia &tAaut+" gr/ u w & r/ ll% 42 4 t g d nw-,eAw buy tefup.a ' t t'so A
//m 9 reg n y#& H A &n,my ,pw<ss'-
sim'nElkdT&f Au e ! 9 icxemsme m mes
~/" " tar *+ J M " in Ermdance wdh the freedom of information N O Ol 3 3 % " ') *
.) 21 [gkzf/1_6,56 n n-us _ pg . ,
i Q Y $ 3,uQ>&.uax.Lku ,,depy..sm.s'mypj<a-r'
&j !? ,6wj j% dAnst 6M:N .Ma,lau/w d' M n.
fktIZp4os' R4ej /.wM Mnk'.Zif M !"W}dQ & pm s.uy, , .be 19. nmin7.Aa%ny - A fe 7.qu ""# N iA's /wjf Idadpukkp r own brL
&,s4ec.' -frv >"?
bRsp.ste a 6 & u k.p w ia n i fy2']tsunu.h<Aruw, n&~+~ na - o ' 1 fyb ta oc . 6, 7, 8, ?). /knb N' dif t' met
. n voso :
- s,,
(sv Amsys?7y Amwg . 7M dMa is wm no n ma ./ bag &,v/Qs ' ^ rut tmd>ds),wA%/ 4 en % f lu ny. A,.u;,c , j a'g/Nv&cenei ., u h:C- ($le (<mjlu h e n 7, , ; e ai e,aNl.h 4 .sw 2p) f:
'j$ ,mh) y4r e l c% t/t(in Du~< auf) piko< pL <tpir, wa ysna cua 9 w/d ia,. k a asuia rat.e <w n,J
,thDJ ds/ 5 << V' /a ;4 du'd!y'y L fu h f y d u s
-% in u~ u.w w s. Jsvar,oasiy 3ca .f. p
fe l'or An 8 hj'y mp- (M 80 9 ? ) 14Ay zh y'te 9ay of tubar Asi%' Rggg xy,1on. p/ 4s& lus, cwit iyk &n Aid 7:3- S km- . k
/c sdjnwp.af
.dy'W bik} g/ h. twhj -
7 ns$$$Qt v64'tufmr14Wlh2 h la.ridaduJ &n.6 fit >n # & , s pory4 .s,.+ s U.uq e+ sp-L4 / con,BsR.wk' 4 fo .9H,d,<diy corrut a n no4hp Xu. tistz Aqejw no / f (basi,sse/mpf &~ dzw wnw <uu4 sJ At 94n/ wxo clou A Lag 4,o-1 A ad. 5 &
"" ^4 a 9
J d3
+
9 i d O Jk /uutt; y, rihv mr,f ,o,seuzc t $ ,e r
& /A'O V Nw f e ha',est AC 4917 ore bstf( ;
py).mwfr
.f4rs( -
k Cdco n A 4br/ .tysetsn f , J Y r-z , /A x E l 6 b.. evrje.
-k&) 2 9 9;n~
f !Y f( !. @ fd;f//ghl d ?' $ U!(' ,, nit d (-s f) h' L/ sr 2 0 A c u r:e d s e sn rv +iSD a'< /a/ ndsf' e pcvs /uaian . 74 ech /is'imw.6. 26.4 az .ptw i A<us:,u- Akh J-ypsa;Gow Squrves T[m h h f? h ut N j % c /t fr (Ad/ b
*^
W di.v. a w m % . s A & ,n , > n o s 2< n f ' s i? c A w ] M e s;/ p - lv,in_ l'eLnk<Qs.:cwl4d1 /taunpamq. b. . phy sau-4/p< tu aayw L n, p+J Au un Lan wsteda w ~fany iouag.- _. _ 0
! (jdfyff' d 1
- l I
l
( :.:1 dV.fg!stivij' '.' . .hh2sct.eiMg
; !)l,
}'TJ M
Z{$ Wi{AfmQi3h3 .
.i,
- g "r .
V. -
,- m i.
ek5h t .-
,i v.
f*j.-s$
. - l l
.. % ;;, 4 .
G"'
~~
fM ; s' ,{ * '. Y '; [: ,/ ' A q ff ( if N e ji s 4 eg 3
.._ m je;<ai h D,' s @
f d pa 2) .5%, .I ,, 3N ?*
- d
,t l' 5 , ,
l i,. dA b si E' .d, h. . 3., i ;- Lyn j gl n: f ri~
'I ij Tj! ;I 2 k. l /I,. l
;r e qf
. g[ki $1 .:a p@q;j;ts t ;
to we
~t~ ;: bg v.e* .
1 ; 'i " T 1p@84 ir s q c. y - .
-. -,6-i
;j ; i n %g j iRQs . - <f:{;u I I Illi$);plbN{ l b
\
N' (
i i
- e. a ,
,(N g .
1 11^, gic .. ! t
., i ,,
; c.xg. ,. .-
. ,, t
\
f . ' ' ., { 1.O %. i f *V a $j ,, < L[.
^4 b 4': ' .1' .
we n , ,
. f.M ' )j.
1
' .\ .r e W '
NtWi"Re. l
',N .e p ,
>1- ;
l
$ go y g. $, b d . .& ,
l hc v, , , ; 4c m j.g Q
! ,, { QRje l
u q..4
.,-s
. w r 3
, a.y g
=
4 , . l g/h'* ;j
. I ' i I l
'g 0
- e 30 ,- ., ;;, '
[ } 55 . ' ' .i
%awa' L.e.
1 - a:. Y ;
. . N.
; , q.h; '3pp s h Q . ilV g /'y
- i
~
g h
,,. 3 j . g.* . -g'# .
ft, y .
- f. j ' '9,<
y 3)
. g. 3 , Au -
,_ N .
') d,g' g4i, g' j
~
.q f ' 'ld. , h~'
w <: l
~,
l 4? T - l
I 3.
..! ) ,. /_ d -:/ . '. ' . ".._%,' s. w . _. , . 6_ .
__ls. v___.,.
'se t :r.k 4hny $y e { & - - --
.n.n.,v t 4 ..-ci
- g.
\ W~> _h_ _ '$$ ' .,
I "'._,,'."m"_.',c.u*'.*. . . ' V YO Y0 a- -- - -
- s. .
'NO 4 _W ** Y' S S- Y Y Yf __ !,
't L -
a i-. s so,m,w M- c., .-
$_ . 4,. J -d- J.' _4 r. A} w -
6 . m/w l&, lie : I. _L. t_, 2,._ 7 taux_.p_& *6o ( g [-Alia_tfi. __, . @ 09 M- f-[]
*'r o7 ~~~~~~)'
* ( / h b 8{--' ' ~~~~~ ~'tif+1. .
- ~-'n.. c.mg i.o,j{y ,0 ,e o s o,. ,u y pcy,c,.;
_og] v,lg Gi ci ;o (.ie
] ,, y t ..
,,.a io i n -%i gy ,
r i.e s
- n. 2: .%. 1e n . _o g 3 ic,o
, ,zu _ _._;. L_ rn .. .aij f1G Y ,~. b. ... i .. ?. .
gg s.
,,e s .i. ec . . . c a.
*)..hn.2Npl'ofe.'a. ngyi, C y c,' u, l veno *sentan O . , % . ,
g r *_v l ' <i ;r .
;M' . ., .h un. e a..e { 'n iNe or<>,,,...,
v o&'.t e oca .*i2Ne g gp
, , c n , . . .. . ! . .. h o
_ . . . A .. - v a s t %.a o v e: N No
- . ~ m o.. -
n. k Lj 3dI
- aost t v ot sc a.*1 os y, 4o hp /.4 e .e . Ay e ./An B. L.so1 E R _.Q.E E.
)-
yi 7 -
.1 -__._m_.~... , ___q 3 4
! c . . e.
%,%.. ,_ l .
*
- y.,.i....,s_.sil ..n.,..
S _ b__ _ . .,9_,
.; , P,
;; ig .; . .
- r . c - c esw o _ _ _ _ _ . . _ - .
I _ _. 9 g ___ .. MM 2 . .j M
- h_. /
_ j ^ G.. . . p -a _ _ _ _ _ 4 _ _ _m__ . i . .; . t i
.j.} . . .'
- - _ . . _ . _ _ _ _ . _ . . . . ~ _ _ . _.
- f. _ _. _
I i i
.... t ,. . ;
- . . - - _ - l .
! l !l { i 1
., 4 .; _ , __ . } ,
i l I L .. . . .m _LL.l._J_.m._n ,__ - Iq agi rl
$4VVAD* QT gg C 8' a PtMtCpM(C ,
in o se i . c .a. .-o i .y o 1.y _ y su As& Ar A_o .._ Wd l . Q : I$ % k c.d w%yLw&udd &Lc.&.rw Q. a _,
^
a 3 krY.-b,*&. L. Q C.X
.stELL m( h. ma .mp<s e o.ulch_ .a_ m _ _
.r'M .6, pi . . ._.. _ _ . m. _
. s i <' .c :
i m_ 9 7m _-ups _oco_. _ , _ m._. _. .. . _ . . _ . . . _ _ .
- - ~
- h. . . . . i ... . . . . _.
*.-45.<"
- m. .,
( ? ./ ' QY (_ . . . . _ . . ...-. - ...-
. um
~A- hh L.........,._..~__......... . ._ _ ____ ___.g t3tu,.g , . .p. ,.
& - H< 2. n _,,,
__. . .. _ _ ____ d k . . _ c , g g , ,--- . u ,fi?c as arrao.e , , A re a
- o 'o H + i -
* .3.;..._,, j eg H f' in i. e C v e_,_,,
im-c c r,,,j[,,.e4 - Oc
, ___ v . . i ; _ C,la
- # w.
.en. _
}ms.ai cai t
_ p.s v. _ww; .
. . . . _. . . .,.~$
- a e;.
n . 4. ce _J . , ___a,i m . h sa+ C W r ty D asian g v . n. gal.__
. . . . , Cis og 0wt v3m . .. .. . , c i...
l yL
%, c ,,u e v. cri A_ o . .a_ q ,. .
._q
.._._f e .! ', ' ) .
. . [ ...-
. . _ _~ ~ _. .
. _ , - _ ~ . _ _ , _
M3d
- I T '/M,f[Q__ _j' _
L j g["{Q'y _k,La0 f A,4 it Jt"q A .A// k/Mp. Ahi$d' 5 $ l+1 k%'s f msj-lkki fdgh (-{ . _
+U %pa
= ic kb y w .-
. , . .u !'M tyc. ; c .
v.;s. w
. p-g . 4 p,37
.., --- ,r.. .. iin
..-.- P e.om ..y n-m er . m D.
r i ..., 73 Ju 1 p i ,' u( n.
..g::3g. ,j i;- u%
*t i.s*.g&g ,'p,,a mq st a BDJ (d. Q '2]Q _.A. 1K1\bb KJ M L.
p 1 l CN .-AQ bD . . .. b b ...., es., a pE.v.,.. I ...
~, w....n m D .. nJo.
ves.oe' aw.,-ec 'dC 'u o w... v ., ..
. . =; e Ii m
~e v . s,...i a n C 1 a n e a.. .... . C,..'%. us.Y s a.w 0. S.. ........ - .., ~,
I eg' D ME ' O J .e ... .. . ,., O.,Z~, oc..e..~ S B. (. ', is i n . .. .n egoso v ot sce..etio~
.. . .)-
j- j a, ao b t.k.C,{,. D W _ \.
$ C ,0.h.i A . h .A . k } f & s Y LLC .L Na se s v .L$ 1. Df as . .
! cre e.... ,1 h.., ., a ; <. r,,
'~'-
. .r E'-%, -P1 ,.I"'".** . 1 f; Q e
cw .. r o.. . . c .c . .. .. l_]_II
.] h j ./. A ] O5
~~{ / 'o : m T h ur# i! _ f E " * $ .s / - n u ! .
f._f&._._r . 3]h. , _4_ e_.f. . .f&_ _ _ E _?. D_l_Q) l0.2 ,__. < ,s 5 '
,/ N__ t:C<!./_a g .Y ._. A- p e' n0 % n3 ? V*
5 {_ f u NJ $ / YW $< Qub %ts $4b 930t 2 M 919 1
;9M.Y.0.Vl/ l { : ,_ .c 5
;. . ew .-;c i n,cwj- .__ --.
- i i pq q . .
' -_ -- . . _ . -. LJ 2_ , . I i i ) _.._..4 . s, .
svv v ,. . c woa,etaroauto - v + . ,, p i a c a. r. c . . .. ~ i c i ... t .. . - ___ _. 33 u 1 C 2,.a a di -- . 4 b .A* k ..
. , \ .8E Ok. _
- _
- AcAxx's.ssu L
' .a l..
. i 4 A % \L . n .. d h.u' 3
4 w k A A sc A s
.w @ Q A . 3 / s 9 % .\ el f AM.s.
!1hl.S.p_g._.9 h k~ce_to pTao.s , .;f. h
.6,Q g,b .._t,_k R CL dDM a e & . ._
.(1 g 9 _.$i"~ k G h 1meca_in . 4 b A .
K.r...n.a.c.a a v e 1.0 M s
.u :e Aad t ,
. _c>y> n%.
hwe r', w _1% C CL- .hC W . 9 _. . .
,. 01S M d .. $ b k -
!t h L,EtO.YAS- k'k.? ~~ WY? O_N,
'i - . - - -
, - - - n .
-m., - . __ ( , _.
-h ~; _ -
-1 ,. . .
....~.., .,
.it e te-- $ .es ,% ou
* . b.' , .) -,e.
3. p.. -tu 1 e t -
~' ~ ~* e ..;- . _. _ -
^***'
.I y Ws '
(.Uv.'
- g. r ,,;,;; ... ,.
e....... m oc a ,...., 21.. . 3 g ,, y ,. ....- 5.
*a*e
'* C ' ' ""'8' l_ _.D * "
"'*"
- 09Ca'om l _: C + '*
- gu' ,.,/ f' ;S . , _ 4 F -
.,2
# 1.1.G._ P7._ ._ -.1t__ y-
.y/.w_ %, ..s , ~ . . . . . _. . . . .
n ,. .; ,
~ . - . < . . , _
n.,c.u.m. .
-4 ' ' " * ' .L V oy.u.,,,,g **** .Us** ,,
' * . e tc .~ r ' .
' ] 3 4 ^ *.L*t '* *' Lt P'S
. ... 1 . ?: L.* *
* ~ 4. p # - d
(. Cf
'L f g . .
--y., ,i, , .- .---ry 9
l 1 616, 547: 4086 06509G1 e ,, u . m 1.o s m ..o -o . l .. 7 wm M.AtNTEN ANCE ORDER u,i -mw i
'~ f' ' % %~~^^%K F u.C. M.utta. , s
~ -
n u u ( * * ..w c . . :.7
,, ,,,......sre...- - .,
9 2' 2 .
,o, u,. .,
d M- n ..r../ f.ud 5-~ " OO
....s.
I o .8 4 _ f l L $ .$ . .. . . _ _
.~ ; pit r ,
1__.usm-O rm.. t c y ,, g g-
.... n.u o a o . w . . . ., :
. 11.uw.xam -
l in' .s'rsy e
.._kedo 7 AteA A401wn &n r 4 /u- e.
M .gs 7w J_ 8_Z LM -C997 fo.e. s?or .
.Q . I l
? y.o....- #1p. _
r *s.o s.,..,.h_.y< / _. o... . j . ..
,e; , Aggg,;,;,,
satn,.va[2., ,] g., j n, , . p1,.3 y,. l ,,... i ,A l n , ~.
,_~a _.c . ai.
E. J m.. .. , o . <
._ n n- p .a u .a2 .n . _
ec u:"
. . l . .$Il0S$ $ iQd.l I.0.T ' J d202 I .
N< 1. O s'. 0 G . 5.On a.-
'.- l
.s,...... .. . - ... .: . .,g . ; m. .. m .. g ... g ..< l .
... .,, ,.,.. ,.e<,
e..
- t. g ... Wy ~ . % c % .. s t. . e g,,,..............-
D, .. A v o r. .. .c- LJ..Ms. !,-QA 2 g'..
't. 2, ..
....... ,,O, E ., cd s, .o .. :e i d v ,. i % - .. oc am..., .X s. ; %
,. ; r .. . .
., .n. .._.-
3, c. eaneu. v ossco . -. ..
- t. .' 13 Al.0[ . 2*td.< . . . _ . . . . . . . . _ .
b <.k/$< y (QB. .a fuss C C'c & {'.u g- I e o.. . c. gi , ) 3, . , , ._ t . - , . p.v . , ~ . . . n,1- * .d. t. .... . t '1 ; ., .. , L ,.J u ..o.- n.se o w -t. .j..; - - - - i rI '-
\/ \&oZ& /, / - e .I ; ~;
tm JDY 2,, $ (m
- .4cf - _ _o n - . /.-.
\ .
. i A . .,
g t .e i-
-. e
~
i i _1 , p q ;- . ,
~
9
- ..Ig.,_
1 j __
! ! l
> . -.i . _ -
5.svu A Av of WO A s: Pi n e c,a vi c 1cie Q
,-........c.-.........,.... _ _. ,_
% _ b . A. 6 1 A h e, et .e . .L_. .c .5_'t c 2 l k C. M A U. c, T' u .i ws t ...Sha a:aese u cermt.sy m ar_.._m...-.
l < ~ . , . . . . . _ . .
!. @ f #._ R E. .L.P S R Cl 2.i.__. m . . _ _ .
. .-- ~ . .
. s. !
._....___.m. . --. -. _ m. . . - . .
i a - A a.
- d. . . . .. .-. .A__ -
. - _s . . . . . . - , .
_sy,9 ;
,2 L._ .
--..a_--.-: .-
{*g , j e q q ,' ,
* = , .g. ,,; . _ .
g., 1
- : *'s t e n M a *. e - - J. . . . .
uo .1 - * ^" 'ilz* i , _ , _ _ _ 61 \-t,
. 4; . . - . -
r*3 C L' 'd . 1%*,r - . PM
.t:.I (CU;4i gg j gi Lh ATv- Qy~ W.O_l_ (
,,..,..,.3...,,.. . . . - . . . . . . . _ _ _ . . . - .
.- ..e I,_ e .. . .: _ ._.
- - - g,,,,,,,,
I . - - .
.f
(_ I. 4~*
, .- _ ,- .,.,n.
l,
.....4........ .......... _._.., . _ _ . _ ._ .
J io .s ) j ,- i . 87J O.OO 7_ : r t.4 riU u~
, ,,,,, J q&f,aa,{,5.*yir>J',
.. a
./ .*. ".4 t 6 3mg L%r g
~ " ~ ~ '
. '~~TJJb u l l fy 405d 1
- ..,......,.......e ,, i __
i
.. ~ %rmu ;
AAw A w k.A r-wro l tin st c' h [w PAID in t.eto. _Of .-. .. . . D eTe d a /8' f[ 3 ~
-- ~~ ~
~'~) po.h Comt)' "t od O..I kel i l ' ~~' '
f NP4b rs 'Lise j f g y ,4j
~ ' '*
- a.in sy~ j s . . . . - .,,, . i n iv .m i , . .a . ...
- o. . ,,, voat ni s..ee.
_.11 ?L U 2L _ IL., 31 . 3 ._ 4L 41 43 a q ., _, j t W,*2 1 . , j
,n . .. - L ..
m..
.m-;
4 a m , + . .s... . #a., , -w L
.g] T t t Ng A ,, ,
4..e., . MO W on $heg t A rt Of *O f_ .,a,y t le n ,P
*,t'. o Matene' 8 owett Y et . _lNo ,
w.' s... ..co
*. o M &ff flen. red res No Vort.f nato
- v e. e No gg t i . t, * , . ..i v es 8 y e. a.. -
. .. , , . . . . . , .a e . ,b , m.......
79 ) l ' P A 0 8- t~-E M .u t.S C n s # t ios . . . . . . . . _ . , 1 *, ac -.
.u .4._.. .. 2. . . . I I _I_ . {. ./ 4 C. . . . . . k / . ! /[ f. . _ . a _. _.u_. . .. . . . .. . .. 4 . , .
Q f, m_e_rLA'. _ _. ;.___
$i 1, _ .318 j;
Ose et ca .t,. ,t s t "*. s t e * . , l { I . 4e e N. - - - . , a ,a vv l v m *ao.. g ,q q ( j ' ' ,.,...,.,..t~mo . iu~ O j., o.,, ,. ., s, .,, l
.feP x c )! t/p he . A%. .bru e he . _ - . . . 4 9 2 /,o 1 / l . a.3_ _O . ,
p . di[u c s Y X.f_l'_Z_h.,n. " 7s' b_aAw._ .._I G W ~. b. _ I
- _4 a._ _ g
' a . 4 . l f I
,h....t . ...
- g. . . . . . . , , .
. e . . .
l % .4 2, .
- . _ _ _..I .
I J' \ l T ot.l j 'I V s uvu a p v OF vv0 A K, P( R F C A M( O n ,
, ~ .... C. . ~ , . .., ....
x .. Y h v J.m .G. h.rdALs F w/ Z~~o n,e.d.
~
A.6 o sit . 4. /. /.. % _. . .! J.Ljj .sh1
\
3 . P. C . 0,r' l.f ~ , R LAl.jL saLL# tl._ ./.A L ,K. i s .A .h E M4..-lJ - AL a. . l
.,LXfl u t hs.2 7 -
is .
.. g .* _.2.. u. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
- _ ~ . I 5 't k _ 4 5 ~ LL{Lyl C h s v_.1 g.). .
w . . ... . . . . . l
)n.].[...A..L,..K/k.g .
. . _ . .i
'.r. s w . - ... .
t -
. i l
i l l ' ..
](Ug t [' d.2 . D. M \,'/ t
'4 : ,i * -
~
'[/_
. ~ . .
-l#/8 l
23 wr-Jl , - s
- 4 - ,
l
- , ; ,; .7, ... .-rnm..
n .c .,,, o . m g< s 10 198]. _ _ _ . . l l i ._ DU M RT (0 m 01 G M u
!- i ElG..ROCX FGE co-, ei. n , u .i . - '
- l l g J g 4
S a e ed.t.e.g # wu* o.as pe* eased .o. ,ft g.a o.o
..n
^ C n e . ec e.
l
, ( ... .. . . e . . e A v e.c . .. .
,L o.. cu .non. ca n*
c c. s y_,' ',*_,, g_. ,,. L.,L.,_] .+ u .a. . i .- . ,.j. < '
~~~~~'"~~~ f(
- f. .jOf
/j'.. _CW fg em. o; $'~~}
_ cm...,e c . c se
. . . 4. ..n....
- r~ - l,__t':mch21L _ ' ^ "'" ' " w * ~__ _. .
""'.7p . 1 l * * ". ,
- * *J a* "'l krv =..c. ~
'YS4N bN % *d$$ &i$24 5 AMM g I
O /- xJYpVoWcf V r m - tk.' Vf
.a f-C-
,,a -
33-3r ks 3 g(4j= /Y -18 yo sss pq R y 7* N R.-n - F
= 4)
.g. -
g d**e / w,
+b,l y / ,&
e - 43 e<e r sr
\ -
31 ~ O floci f ang h dy 8941 ' d4 g_ ~
,/4 / '
(Serica 1 enly) I
^'
15 - =21 Fig.1 - Perts C: *:n; P ART 1 Llif . L #
- 4. G.si. R:as 21. 0,& P43 l
t Ic Heu ca-* N. 34.'re @ sFeth w '-
- 11. His %'s *35. $st 9e<Ung '
12, H,W De.e Ptets *)f, B edy Cet'..t . 2 bg'd, ., I s. t dotsawiPh(3
- u. Y 1, . $:..
16.S'd*
- 29. Rett Pi4 17.H : Nats - *40. Cuids BvtMen (1) ,
j 18, Tip Closvr e
- J ) . Velv e le si }
l 11. B Wp '42 law Yeles . !- 14 Bes* Cloter* 14. P! set Ring ($eeles I acly) 7-7 (. ,
; ' - - ~ - . - - - - _ - - , _ , _ _ _ . , . ____
i e:, . . -- -.
, , , . . , , , , .I .$ .%
g [ '
.1
^ ^^^
"~
.l
-+
=
{
,,3-x~. _-~.
} .
MKMEZ-EfA4UR--M hkr.A 4'..BWw.ro. MY WW *^ E h'M - -- f; _ . . A 'd, K 2 % .. ' AN#/M'NM'AMR m inww k .Te t e . we .f_ q.n
.rm2.mcmmw 2= n g m w- .
m% 2 / _ zw e,
-h-4.& m e m ~< .we
~ o. ru a ._ m' y bys y fpy] /py _ _.)--
6
,,fd *V 7Qjc_.
i , e 3S.$s */ V*i ;
,i t -
-- 4
) f,r...a , ,s. 6,., ,.,
$f- . _.
_ _ __b^ m'90
.] (. h --. - _ . ]}Q_-f_()h--b-**~' - .f _h_h' f "_ _ . f_)
el$$.t to: t> w . ha A S . ..
.-/0
%x -'
+
N ///t'_.n_t,y).v?y' .
/ [f. -. . /_ $ -. .f I l )
s.e0(15. 6 7, NN t /r a n . _1. -. . _ _ _ _ ] - _ _.
.6 *
.e.e 4 e.m +. .,ye .%maygiy
,.m.mhe es.. _-
jjj)
,.,m., ,
5^^'~~
*~~~**Q f, _ [$ jJ
- t. s * , 0 i M l,
- i /N 'l 1_
r 4 s( em ,w r . - p U..r f s,/ f f r C,y.[f.,f -QV .p// $A'. (//* w a,--. s .
- - _y, . --
.q- <,,,4 --
4 . ' -; s .- _ _ - . ....__ . g = naaf v.- y
,q,(, 3,,( { 4. 4
-- .g , - g - - i ,
/ __ u_ ._ 3 s:n e...' __.
;: ._ g,,; J : s. .. . f.__..,-
n a s 4 s s ', s ts* C . u ' \_ . ^*F.s_/./.
,) . _ _( -Q. .'_ .f. y s '_ _ .
,._- __. / J.W- . __._//V__'_/t)^ ** [. _f. . -
""( E - * . * . . . .p //' [/,D.'.,
u, egg g i , y/a._/'i . V .
.//s ' - - - - * " . _ . - . - .. .
. e_ --c..,.
et e,: .- i s , dei er i , 4.e, ef.7 __
.. ._ m _; _ _ _ _ . . . .
- - * ' " ~ * - -~F*-
pg g gg __
*
- g*
a2 3, e e d
+ = ~ * * * * *
. .._.-{.'_..,..g"=.-****
..-t .
h - k- . . ~ - - - - . . - - - - - C 0 I ' ' ' L i I "'
- _
. ___ _ - . . _ .. . L A.d M _ . _.
1 ~ , _ . -
.. .. . . . - - ~.+ ~-.-- * . - -
i
\ ,g, p- J7- <pff'.jif, f,f _
q wa m .t .vn_ g;S y ' j/( //
.a.
w,c,... _ - , , , . , .-
/g n [ ,--t
._.4
<a.,-
. . _ , _ , ,__._4__.
1
--ar-4, ,
q . , r. i6 , I ,~ r g _7 -4 ..---.-_-+,-.. - g-__ ---- ._. _ . _ - . _ _... ..4 A* s- --~ 9 -~ ~-
,- _ n- =
- m,, n ~ \ n ; s g
.}/y f - - - ..f . l .
_- -~~ -~~~- M ~. -. . .- , - , _ _ ..k_ - _ __ _ , . - _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ .
,. o m , ,n > Jn> ,. n, a xt.%,*. / v W / f i . d'[wD *' / h " ! N ^i
/ [ ) 3.._4 "_
".?,y([ ,i/ft1
^
i m.. ,t}(/ , S3 / a 4i r c e m m 's < e _ 9 /)<-4) j% / /NL ] y l Il fd}' 'M/.
- , i t - 9 7 i MM,2 n.# _ . / 8'W _fcg;f D Ci'l [ ff}Wlf R VA'.# 3pgf_ __
/f Efl'U.*f ._,
_ agg L o ns s , u n . a __ fg:r/ g c/rf
- ..-.~
~
- - ~
.q. v c. x v u- fi rr _ __._..- . . . . - _ . - . _ . - _- --- ._ -
g wat vt pct'1 IPla Tt'l A'[ _ f/j J (/ , __ , , _ , _ n ,.sg c ets_____ _ .._._-_____4 ____.._.__a_.____~ . . _ __. . _ _-__ -
- + -
we '
- - $ - ~ ~ ~ - - ~ ~ ~ ~ --s - - - -
{}lRA $(4I.Af5s e10 b( T / , # *) - i - ~.
. g._~f. .._fVo . . .,_.@] ,g. _. .
m a t i. t. tietate it a ..W. _ _-4 _l . h__ _.---,3.__ M_ ' _-3.-__- _ . _ _ _,.
,es.tt w ars : m.sVff.__.f. y._ . _ __ ___.__.
_-_T. kf,jm0}(aiCA/ ISO, 4 A V( ! A 4
&l/,%* Y 5 ' ". e .__ $N!:SW^ W.l0ISU8. &b/'(Uk,f --_ . ,,'![A(~
. g_n/ dl0 ggna ,. yh<l.&..
RIk!'(f45 a 17
, ,s wa < v rn .s.ys.* /.~h viv / w -- -
x u g, .I* - - ~ = - - - - ~ + + - - a., a gj 6 a ', Tg, b [ A [g* 7D &3 C1.' L72 /fi t'E fp .ghet M4_.przp_ nwyngr_ m t . .. . _ - -. s t e _ _ __ . . _ ._
-.... . . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ O
'N M
*N U
- N . . . -
a
._.._~.'_'*-6i. _ _~~+h_ . _ _ . , . . _ . . _ _ . .. . _ .
. y n'/.. S,$
f C ki tC% r*16* % ..flf /*_ 1 /. _ . . _ -. A.!(/ * [,U_ . . -. . -- . . _
~~**"'
^ * ~ " " * ' * '
J"Q -[/
*~'~"-~^~~*~N
' ' " * " ' ' ' . ' ' * * ' " * * .",*__' ~. ~ ' -,y.
' ~~' . ' " -
' '**"'~
t to $ l Gi . $I y, I(I[Et%^k .
.h * -' ~_-
d (.. / < Q -. _ _ _../ n///f__ r s e t s a ;
- su stt. _. .._ [ .Q f/ . e*q's , .C . , . .-- _
+
- _ .__+ -~ y .._ - ~~--*~
yc*s', s ? e *, s! t 2..4* /a.nA. _f.,s. (( '~ [_ fQgfi /* } y _ --- - . _ _ . . - - ~_L. E, . *&aS *e d */"2 1 f.' -. . . -
/: .s..-. . - -
- r. . e. s 's a ' J ,. l [l 1
- d!. { ac .j l/ glf' /~'f/
. .h h. i'] O fZf*/. . - [$. sOf - ,
-- - - _ - - - - - - - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___ - - _ ---------_m___ _ _ _ _ , , _ _ _ , _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
, GLi
- y M-l7 W
V f 5 o .s L. ._T D5 cc c. T ioO d%. (V-uCOO MO LENAGE:._ bW, j, P Ac. AiMG o . K' La Axa.cf= F L cc>c eb cycoD Z. % C e< f DE F'c> L> n coE z 04 . MOT C O C s< E D 3.y\/dLV'E. M ov uT
- LE 3E 4.KETS O < .
v Of -
' . Ait trVE / F T r iu c5 C<, TiGMT - MC LF.
CCT E C A LL CLakd w LS O tJ . Co. t 'EcLT5 E'tc.Lv=. / 1iCM,
~. - r -f i
. > L7 6 O< _ {gy> p
/(, i /, ' ., ._
C6 et 900,0 , 3 2 n , c .- 7 c: c c ou - cycO . 7, y'L L 's ! c-
'o e Vn w - c ni % Lco w ;>
Ac % s no e easgeo L E AW L. C 'T - RooE LrTE O h , , b 'O NA,c2 Lc ax Ac;c - Jeca bxeo Sc
?! .
2 e w ..:.c L . dene.ecT6-Ry D.VEUq BLP Cy-ucro 3 0spectrD E nc, LR15 - 0< <cr do Suet -Of 3 D EP: pdh ide o no IRS PE
' ,t ik. - . - , - ,.-
y-- -- .- o a 7
,; V " - -; ,
~'
k W G . ,--
- U flI D. $ 41( % -
} NUCL E AH -RE CUL A10RY: rOWissiON
- f. HEClON !O 3[. '; i Lf I
~ E.. " a.'e i E 169 54 00St VI. L T 830AD :
f+ # h J : C.L E N ( L L Y N. IL L INO f 5_- H 13 7 - s u.^': ...t yet, _ ; 5 . ;; 7 MiPORANDUM.FOR: Charles E. Norelius, . Director, Division of RadiatiorySafety :l and Safeguards' 1 FROM: John A. Grobe , Di rec tor, Enforcerrent and-- Ir ves t igatier= Coordination Staff ;
SUBJECT:
ALLEGER'S COMPLAINT RE: BIG FOCK POINT VALVE TAMPERING . INCIDENT (50-155) (AMS NO. Rill-87-A-0042) On March 21, 1988, the alleger in the Big Rock Point valve tampering incident /alleg6 tion (ANS fo. Rlll-87-A-0042) telephoned Region III Security Inspector Gary L. _Pirtle to. complain that Region III _ had not. Informed him of? the NRC's resolution of his concerns. Pirtle's memorandum, Jacumenting the-March 21, 1988 infor mation', is enclosed.
- l. The Region III investigation and Compliance Specialist wrote.to the-alleger _on. -
November 23, 1907,Jan_d informed-him of the resolution of his other-concerns. In that letter, he was also informed the valve tampering- issue was still under l review by the Nuclear Regulatory Commi5siori. At that time'the matter had been
- referred to the Office of-Investigations; however,-01
- RII_l--has subsequently.
l returned the matter to Region III. The issue is .still under review by_ l Region Ill. l- ! The. Enforcement and Investigation Coordination Staff in conjunction with the- - L Safeguards and Security Section reviewed 'he i1spection report: pertaining -to; the _ valve tampering incident / allegation and determined that a: portion of the report can be'sent to the general,public. However,_ another section of that-report remains exer"pt from disclosure sincel that section _ contains Safeguards Information. By-separate correspondence the Enforcement and Investigation Coordir.ation 5taf f has mailed _ the- publicly available portion of tht report to
'the alleger.
This inforn:ation is forwarded for your information.
- f ,^ ! .'
4 C. k h l- . hn.A. Grobe
. Director', En forcement anc
; Investigation Coordination Staff i>
Enclosures:
- 1. Memo dtd 3/22/88; l= --Pirtle to Weil-
- 2. Memo dtdl3/23/88, Pirtle to Pill files cc w/ enclosures: ,,
rscn p
. - n.
.w ? -
~- . . _, _ _ _
u_.,
# '- -~~"
Jun 01 - 1998 - FEMORANDUM FOR:- Chorles E.- livrelius, Director Division of Radiation Safety and Safeguards Region 111 FR0y: Pritr. L. Grimes, Acting Director Division of Reactor liispection and Sofeguaros, h 4 SULJECT: FESPONSE TO EVALUATION HENOP.AfCUM . FGTEhTIAL REGtJLATORY CEFICIENCY PERTAINING TO VITAL EN'ITPEi!T TAMPERING 1his is in response to your r.ercrandutr of April 1,1988, in which Acb raised concerra obcut enforcement potential for a recer.t tampering incident. We agree With your essessrtri Of the incident and the actiUHS ybb took. Accorcian; to your remorandum the FBI- declined to investigate the potential criminal offense iad r AF Act Section 236b. We assure, therefore, that the fects did not warrant further investigation for criminal presecution purposes. We bevc tcer informed that the developr.er.t of a rule is underway that wculd Frevice i, busis for citing incividuals for violations of regulations or license conditions and imposing individual civil penalties for future incidents of sicilar nature. This ef fort is jr. iire with your suggestion. Security plans implementing 10 CFR 73.55 generally provide the necessary mechanisms to remove an individur.I's site occess authorizations. With the strengthening of accest acthur uation programs thot should be retlized soon, future perpetretors, of simiier acts ::hculd be prevented from cairirt access to 6ny other site, proviced that licensees are willino to document all. matters surrcur.cir 9 a termination or resignation and to share thet ir.fctnation. We cu. gpreciate your frustration with er issue such as this, but we believe ycur otiice rai,d5ed this incident properly t rc 6pplied exactly the correctin dCtj0n that has dppr0pricte,
, bXN Prian K. Grimes, Acting Directcr
., Division of Reactor Inspection cr.d Sefecuards, NRR l C0hikCT: Robert Skelton
; h-(301) 492-3208 f) g\ - f,
(& 7 Distribution N L RSGB rf h5keitcn DRSI rf Tht% % N p RErickson LBush p BKGrirces f@a .O
*See Previous Cercurra.ce
. WL , n / V1 n/ g.
efC 'T6CB*
- (JLApR5GB*K :RSGB* :AD 5 :0GC :
. . . . :R$keltob:tn
. . : .. . . . . . Q .' Q. . : . . . . .IEI. . . . . .. : . . . . . . . . . .. .g. 4.:.............
- NAME :LLbush :FAErickson : 1o 6 ner :
p ...._:........ p ....:_.. .........:..............:..............:...............:............. ' DATE :05/03/88
- 05/05/PC :05/23/88 :05/1;l/88- :05/#4/88 :
%r , eq q5 twt by}}