ML20127J710
| ML20127J710 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Palisades, Big Rock Point File:Consumers Energy icon.png |
| Issue date: | 10/13/1992 |
| From: | Grimsley D NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM) |
| To: | Tutak R AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20127J714 | List:
|
| References | |
| FOIA-92-252 NUDOCS 9301250235 | |
| Download: ML20127J710 (6) | |
Text
-
y comw.sioN u s.r4 un Recut -
,,, t,.,,
m-t nn
..,j RESPONS - TO FREEDOM OF x lwt l l e^atiAt j
INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST wu
!s%.....
OCT 131992
' nom f wva m w e,;
j I
ftE QUE S1 L R Mr. Ryan Tutak PART 4.-AGENCY RECORDS RELE ASE D OR NOT LOCA1ED ISce crecw boes!
No agency rnorm tubset to the request have been located.
No additionat apncy records subsect to the request ha.e twen locaed i
s o. yam See Commants sect on.
Requested records ce avnoable throut another putAc datobut.cn r
C Agency records sabject to the request that are ider tihed m Appesia.ies) are airest y,ivadable for pubhc inweet or' a'id copyq et the X
NRC Pub 6c Docuw.t Room. 2120 L St ect. N W, NsNngton. DC.
b Arncy rMoms sub ect to the rn9est that are idenObed in Appem14aled are Deing made avadable for pubhc irntMt on and copying 3
he N9C Pubbe Document Room. 2120 L Street, N W,, %shmgton, DC, in a folder under this FOt A number.
X at t The nono oriet.sry version of the ra oposaHs) that you agreed to accept in a telephone conersation with a member of my staf f es now lang made a.ifatde for pubhc Tpection and tap ring at the NRC Pubbc Docurnent Room. 2120 L Street. N W, Nshmg'on, DC, m a folder under ihn FOI A nut,br Agency records subject to the request that are identihed in A
'e n (t"0 may be inspnted and u3pm1 at the NRC Local Pubhc Document Room idotified in the Comments section.
E ncNd 4 era-tmaMn on troa you may obte <ceu to and " e charrs 'or cepymg records lowed at the M1C E.tsic Document noem,2120 L S,et,
'1
(
N W._ Nihoc'cn. DC.
y Av ncy reco es subst va the req mt 44 encos-Records u.b ect to tne request haa been referred to anot%r F edw 4 roc ys.m tar rewee ond d. rect env>m ir vnu i
x 1%
34.80 (less 100 pgs. O no charge) e You un be bmed by tN NHC ior h es tota'.ns X.
You wih rMer.c a refu d from the NHC m the amount of $
n In wew of NRC's respome to (Ns rensest, no f urther act>on a be na taken on actu@ tetter d awd _..._
..__.No PA_RT 11. 4 -dNFORYATtON Wt THHE LO F ROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE Certain Information in the reavested recoMs is t>eing withheld from put>he disclosu e purs" ant to the e 4empt+om descriherf in anti for the reasons stawi r
in Part ti. E C, ed O Any rdeased parbor's of the documerus ic Ach omy ran o' tnp record a berg a a hheld art berg myiv a.a. tat # for pubM insoction.4 n ev q in tN N AC P bhc Docum-;nt Po m,2120 L Suret,7 W, hh.nron DC m a fWer under th s FOi A numoer.
y o
COMW N TS
- Copies of the records identifled on enclosed Appendices C and D and the releasabic portions of the records identified on
(.cic3ed Appendix E are enclosed, The fee for the processing of your FOIA request is noted below:
$34.80 Duplication - 174 pgs. @ $0.20 per pg.
=
This completes NRC's action on your request.
0 0N untiomtcret oms /O > t u tOOM OF MONMAHON ANO PUBUCAflON$ 5LfiVICtS
}'
lt d !-
h
& 64
/
~
9'301250235 921013 PDR FOIA TUTAK92-252 PDR mc enw w wm o unn
~~'
~
f Os A s,Unre t %
DATE RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF ~
- INFORMAY10N ACT (FOI A) REQUEST FOIA 252 OCT 1' 3 k' j'!
(CONTINUATiOM
~
PAR 1 !! 8-- APPUCABLE EXEMPTIONS i
b, are be ng withhe!d en th6r entwety or in pct under the Hecords wtject to the request that are described in the enclosed Appendimies).
EtGmption No.N and for it-e reasonW given be'ow pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 552(b) and 10 CF R 9.17(a) of NRC regulations.
j
~
j
- 1. The mthheld mtormaten is property classif.d pu<susnt to Esecutwo Order. (Emempt on U
]
--.~._._ _ _
- 2. The withheid in*ormat.on ee!ates so ely to the niemal pewonnel rules and procedures of NRC (Exempt on 2) n l
- 3. The withhew informabon is speruficaay enempied hcm puche d scko_ vee by statute ind,cated. (E nempt,on M
[;
Sections 141-1d5 of the Atomic Energy Act. *Nch prohib ts the dMkuute of Restricted Date ce Foernerty Rest #ctet Data i42 U.S C. 2161216M.
..Q Section 10 of the Atom.c Energy Act. *Nch p chib:ts the dricmsure of UnclassAed 54'eguards informat:en (42 U S C. 2161L
@i>
4
-. The mtteeld mformat.ori ** a trade secret o* comme < cia! or fmem ial ete mat.on that is t emg otht eid toa the 'easoNs> indicated. K aernpt:on 4) 4
...e The mformation is conMeved to be cc.af, dent.af busmess trop <+14evi efo< mat.on a
].g, The it'tormation is cor.s.dert d to be p oprieta v informar on N<suarit to 10 Cf R 2190af 6 t s k$.M, n
[
The whrmaton was sam ttut amt ret e.ved its w bn <se po<swa..t to M Cf H 2 NO.m D
,.t.9 or. _ _ _IEnemot on St Apphcabw Pn. der.... _..
r
/%%v
!S The whe4t mformat e cms %ts et +ma yem m e mem eew,4 t% ** e n y a* r
/
OW.eretn.e Process D sclosure of predecisionsi mtnemat.on wuvid wt to e* tat the we and tear 4 e. haege et mens eswe:e.ai to t w rscweran,e pmm To e a =,o are no renot aMy 54 yegable ' actual Whe*e <6 Corda Jfe Withbe'd e ?hed *f brely the f 3 cts are rYatotat% niertemed et$ ifm preJeDoora] mf er c,%c e
portions becsuse t*e reicase of tae tam novid ceem>t e md.m.i noe, vio the c.<em wn._c t m m O % arm y 4
Atte'inev woch pocuet puege 10ccumems pecca ed tw an niterv m. mnwnw or ri ow w i Attomey-cLent pnvi ege. (ConfMeat ai communicatum betwee e xmmey ed ms her chertl 6. The etWo min < mat e n esemoted %m putbc Niosee recaee % d ecue am vut m a ocey eaa"r ted m eu ' 9 pe' swr p>.ac v (E xemp5on 6)
-X-
___.,,._..___.~._.~_.-m 7 The w4thheld information censets of,e:c,d> cc<wed fo< ia* en'ceccment purrotes and is be +9 w ahhmi+ %< t*.e reawn si moeated (E semption 7) 1 Disclosure could reasonabf y be ewected to mie'fer* mth an m'ortvment procMnq because t covid reveal the sure d, rect.on and fxus ut
- entonemem efforts. ed thus cwd poss.biy anow reop.enri 2 a tm vtion to shei potem 4: m cWe o* a v tre of NRC req, rements from mvemgrors. (E rempt on 7 ( An U.sdo$ure would constitute an unwananted.<w asen of wwaf pmacy. M mempt.on NCH l5 m-4
- ><"-i oe;"
- nra n <f
) - T he m'amt.e asats c+ names +t u 4.n e" I contama sources. (Enempt on 7 (DU
_.1, OTHLH-
. _. ~.. - _.. _. _. -
_m.
PART_I_L_C...DENYIN.G OFFICIALS
- ~. _ _
' Pursuant to 10 CF R 9 254t3 ed or 9 25tc) oftne U S Nacsva Reg #awy Comm w rm x os t M t m ries.w rc m c me 3,e>.m -se m t t,om p.g o
duct.on or d&lowe. and that its product on of d sc'ove,s contra *y to the pubbc irue est Tne persons respom ble tv ine dene a.e thnse of f c+s dent f:ed beftw as dem.ng otheiats and the D rector, Desert of Freedom of Informat.on and P# cat.ons Sewes 04(e of Adm sutrat:on rP am dee a4 that may be arpeated to the Euecutwe Diretor for Ocemons (E uot
. -, - -.OF HCI A L APPE L L A T E mit omcE RECORDS din!ED f
~
oENmc ornctAt _ _
__e_._._.
-.._. N.
N -
O A..B_e r t Davis Rexigrwudmininuttor m b N_ E_ _
_ X4_.__
REG Ill l
I 4
.. + -
f i
p
_.e-__.~_
____4+g.--+
l PART li. D-APPEAL RIGHTS The denial by eash denymg ott.<iai,denbf;ed in Pvt ILC may be appMed to the Appenate Of f.cd identd ed tMrs. Any such appeal must be mete in wotmg ethm 30 dan of rece r of thk)FespOf188, AppeallimJit be addreped as appropfiate, to the E accutae Dgectof for Oce<ations, to the Secretary of the Comm.suon, o< eo the inspector Genera; O s. NacNar
. Rejpelatory Commission, Washington. DC 20555, and should clearly stare on the envefoce acd in the lettue that it is an Appeaf from en imtiaf FOfA Decision."
U.S. NUCLEAR HEGULATORY COMMISSION NRC FOftM 464 (Part 2) (1-91)
Re:
FOIA-92-252 APPENDIX C DOCUMENTS MAINTAINED AT Tile PDR HUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION 1.
4/14/87 Note for Partlow, Grimes, Erickson, and Bush from McPeck, subject:
"Information Assessment Team Hotification/ Big Rock Point 1, " (2 pgs.),
acc. No. 8804130141.
__.m_____
Re:
FOIA-92-252 APPENDIX D RECORDS MALHTAINED IN THE PDR UNDER THE ABOVE REQUEST NUMBER HUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION 1.
11/3/87 Memo for Chairman Zech from Ben B.
Hayes, subject:
" Notification of Opening of OI Investigation,' (2 pgs.).
2.
4/15/88 Memo for Norelius from Grobe, subject:
" Alleger's Complaint Re; Big Rock Point Valve Tampering Incident (30-155) (AMS No. RIII-87-A-0042),
(1 pg. ).
3.
6/1/88 Memo for Norelius from Grimes, subject:
" Response to Evaluation Memorandum -
Potential Regulatory Deficiency Pertaining to Vital Equipment Tampering," (1 pg.).
He:
FOIA-92-252 APPENDIX E DOCUMENTS DEING REl. EASED IN PART HUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION 1.
Undated Alleger Identification Sheet, (1 pg.) -
EXEMPTIONS 6 & 7C.
2.
4/10/87 Handwritten Summary Notes, (12 pga.) -
EXEMPTIONS 6 & 7C.
3.
4/15/87 Letter to Individual from NRC, (1 pg.) -
EXEMPTIONS 6 & 7C.
4.
4/16/87 Memo, subject:
" Allegation at Big Rock Point (Valve Tampering) Docket No. 50-155), Allegation No. RIII-87-A-0042, (5 pgs.) - EXEMPTIONS 6 & 7C.
b.
4/27/8'/
Memo, subject:
" Allegation at Big Rock
.olot (Valve Tampering) Docket No. 50-155, Allegation No. RIII-87-A-0042, (3 pgs.) - EXEMPTIONS 6 & 7C.
6.
Undated Questions for Interview with Individual, (3 p g s:. ) - EXEMPTIONS 6 & 7C.
m 7.
6/4/67 Memo, subject:
- Review of Transcript for 5/4/87 Interview with Ind:vidual,"
(109 pgs.) - EXEMPTIONS 6 & 7C.
8.
4/14/87 Handwritten notes with attachments, f49 pga.) - EXEMPTIONS 6 & 7C.
9.
6/6/87 Letter to Individual, (1 pg.) -
EXEMPTIONS 6 & 7C.
10.
6/1C/87 Letter to Individual, (1 pg.) -
EXEMPTIONS 6 & 7C.
11.
6/26/87 Memo, subject:
" Contact with FB7 in Reference to Valve Tampering Event at Big Rock Point Allegation RIII-A 042,"
(2 pga.) - EXEMPTIONS 6 & 7C.
12, 7/30/87 Letter to Individual, (1 pg.) -
EXEMPTIONS 6 & 7C.
-l Re:
FOI A 252 APPENDIX E (cont'd)
DOCUMENTS DEINO RELEASED IN PART NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION 13.
7/30/87 Memo, subject:
- Discrepancies Noted in Information Provided to the_NRC.by Point,* (2 pga.) - EXEMPTIONS 6 L 7C.
14.
10/23/87 Memo, subject:
" Alleged Valve Tampering at Big Rock Point (50-155) '(AMS No.
R11I-87-A-0042), (1 pg.) - EXEMPTIONS 6~
L 7C.
15.
11/23/87 Letter to Individual, (1 pg.) -
EXEMPTIONS 6 & 7C.-
16.
1/20/88 Memo, subject:
" Followup on Investigation Priorities," (1 pg.) --
"Outside Scope
- of Request.
I.
17 J/22/88 Memo, subject:
"A11eger's' Complaints in Reference-to Big Rock _ Point Allegation Pertaining to Valve _ Tampering Incident *
(3 pgs.) - EKErPTIONS 6
&/C.-
18.
3/23/88 Memo, subject:
" Telephone Contact ~ with-1 Individual Pertaining to Big Rock Point-Allegation,* (1 pg.) - EXEMPTIONS 6 1L 7C.
19.
3/29/88 Letter:to Individual, (1Epg.) -
EXEMPTIONS 6 & 7C.
20.
6/28/88 Letter to--Individual. ( 1 pg. ')-
+
EXEMPTIONS 6 & 7C.
i
kiay 28,19G2 FREE 00M 0F INFORMM10N
.Mr. Donnie Grimsley ACI REQUESI Director of Freedom of Information and Publications Services
_j~
United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission
/ g p* gg Washington, D.C. -20555 Y &l-Y ?
v
Dear Mr. Grimsley:
This is a non-commercial request under the Freedom of Information and Privacy acts.
As stated in section (4) (A) of the Freedom of Information Act,5 U.S.C. 522, as amended -
in 1974 by public law 93-52, the information requested by Grand Rapids Magazine is
'primarily benefiting the general public," so i request a waiver of any '
- I request a complete and thorough search of all filing systems and locations for all records maintained by your agency pertaining to the enclosed docum'ent, which is an intern <! hand-written N.R.C. letter (ACN# 8804130141) that has bee 1 previously releasea under a FOIA request (as is indicated at the bottom left-hand corner of the front page).
This is a request for all records 1 hat are related to all matters discussed in the letter, including, but not limited to: the conclusions of the investigation; any penalties or discipline against employees of Big Rock Point nuclear plant or Consumers Power
. consequent of the investigation or of the events which prompteo the investigation; transcriptions of mterviews of people (NRC staff, Co<sumers Power employees or I
contract employees) for the NRC investigation.
This request specifically includes, but is not limited to, numbered and lettered subfiles, memos, investigation reports, licensee event reports, copies of photographs, search slips, abstracts, tapes or handwritten typed logs, transcriptions of telephone-conversations and any other kinds of documents.
I wish ta make_ tt clear that ! want all records in your_ office.* identifiable.with" this request even though reports on titose records or copies of the records remain in another -
office, such as Region !!! in Chicago.- I do not want ' interim
- documents only. I want all-documents as they. appear in all files, in all forms in all units of your agency.
Il documents are denied in part, please sp?cify the exemptions claimed for each page or.
passage. For documents withheld in their entirety, please state, in addition; the date_of and the number of pages in each document. If any records responsive to this request are -
stamped or in any way identified as classified (or as ' safeguards information"),please treat this as a request that such records be declascified.
l-I request that excised material be " blacked out' rather than ' whited out" or ' cut outand -
that the remaining non-exempt portions of documents be releastd as provided for under the Freedom of information Act.
Please advise 6f any destruction of records and include the date of and authonty for such l-destruction.
Please call rather than write if you have any questions concerning this request, i
f
. / st \\ t'D P e J
/.
L
- -~._.,.,_.:--
-. -... ~ -
..= -
~
! expect a response to this request within ten (10) workin0 days,'as provided for in the Freedom of Information Act.-
Sincerety..
~ if {};Q. lLt.,$t
/
/
/ -
Ryan Tutak/ Reporter Grand Rapids Magazine i:
549 Ottawa Avenue, N.W.
Grand Rapids, Michigan 49503-1444 (616) 459 4545 4
S 4
1 a
9 2
y e-t
-c--
e w
w y
e w-u a-