ML20127C625
| ML20127C625 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Waterford  |
| Issue date: | 07/02/1984 |
| From: | Harold Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Fincher M AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20127B509 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-85-123 NUDOCS 8504050296 | |
| Download: ML20127C625 (2) | |
Text
b,..
NK y SR
.b..
[
DISTRIBUTION:
w/o enc 1 July 2, 1984 TOSB R/F HDenton/ECase JFunches GEdison PFine Mr. Murray C, Fincher 721 Bocage Lane Handeville, Louisiana 70448 m
Dear Mr. Fincher:
This is in reply to your letter to me on June 9,1984, concerning the licensing of the Waterford Unit 3 nuclear power plant.
I appreciate your
~ interest in'this matter.
There are a number of complex safety issues with regard to Waterford. The staff of the Nuclear Regulatory Comission (NRC) has implemented a special team approach to the safety review and inspection to assure that the issues are resolved on a schedule to satisfy the needs of the hearing process and the licensing decision. A senior NRC manager has been dedicated to this te'am Effort to assist in the overall management of the activities involved. -
~
Almost 60 people, including NRC staff from Headquarters and from various Regional Offices and consultants, spent about six weeks at the Waterford site, completing their field work on May 25, 1984.
Among the issues involved are the adequacy of the following: the coanon foundation basemat of the reactor building, which has undergone cracking; fire protection; technical specifications; the emergency feedwater system;
~
..and construction practices.
Initial findings iridicate that some of the allegations of improper practices during construction may have merit, and the NRC staff is assessing their safety significance.
On June 13, 1984, the Director of the NRC Division of Licensing wrote to the President of the Louisiana Power and Light Co. about a number of prob-lems having potential safety implications and requested him to propose a program plan and implementation schedule to address these problems and to propose actions to assure that such problems will be precluded from occurring in the future.
All of the actions by the NRC are for the purpose of assuring the protection of the public health and safety. Consistent with this purpose, every effort is being made by the NRC to resolve the remaining problem areas as soon as possible.
@ /8 -$$ - 2
-l
. 'en#4%#z% xA s[7
~
~
T.T...............
"""i >
om>
- u.s. ceo so.3-4o morsmacesotocueno OFFICIAL RECORD COPY m
l s 9 E
With regard to your request for a document on what happned at Three Mile Island, enclosed is the " Report of the President's Comission on the Accident at Three Mile Island" issued on October 30, 1979.
Sincerely.
Onsensisyfed bl OS.WA d 1
l Harold R. Denton, Director Offic.e of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Enclosure:
As stated J
s
~'
-~* See Previous Concurrence
..D....
.'t. QR.......
.....D..I..R..R......
ornec k..T..O..S.B...:.P.P..A..S.*...
...T. O S..B..:.P..P A.S.*...
...D.I R.P.P.A..S.*.....
u ac*a-c>. P.F..i. n..e..:.n..o......
...G..E.d..i..s.o..n........
....J. F.u..n.c..h..e.s......
...E.G..C.
a h..e..........
.....H. R.....o..n.....
i.
.... /........../. 847 M
.. 7/........ 84 onc>
6../.2. 9../.8. 4...
.... 6../. 29../.84....... 6../.29./. 84
=c row ais no, emacu ono OFFICIAL RECORD COPY
- us. co un-4oo.
........-.........._..._...m,..,.a.,._,..___.._,_
2131.il"SiM3230 r& 5 ' 6
- v 5'"2 2 "2a' 5
trg 21.0 7.18. IP 00000256 WORDS - FILE INPUT e DC 04. FC 00, EC 00-21.0 7.18.5 X M04, P!, T17 21.0 7. 21. 4 C C 0 0N T, * -- *, * ------- *. T M 5
.SX1 e
21.07.23. SYSTEM-S ECOND COST F AC TOR = 5.0310 21.07.23.
g 21.0 7.2 3. JOB FXFCUTFD O S/N 201 21.0 7. 23. A T T ACH e Q 40C, ID.N I*A SXM.
21.0 7. 2 3. PF N IS 21.07.23.040C
%)@
21.07.24.AT CYe 032 $N.P 21.0 7. 2 4. F T N 5, t = 0 4 0C. L O. F S E TMta/RFS.
I SUI 1
5 O 18 CP SECONDS COMP L ATt01 TIME.
21.0 7. 25.L I B R AR Ye INL 5LIS.
21.0 7. 7 5. LG O.
21.07.28.
STOP 21.07.28.
113400 MAXIMUM FXECUTTON Ft.
21.07.28 0.417 CP SECONDS EXECUTTON TIMF.
21.07.20.0P 00007552 WORDS - FILE OUTPUT. nc 40. FC 00 EC 00' 21.07.29.MS 10752 WORDS (
34304 MAX USFO) 21 0 7. 28.C P 4 813 SFC.
.All 40J.
21.07.28.10 1.845 SEC.
1.R45 ADJ.
21.07.28.CM 71.589 KWS.
4.369 40J.
21.07.28.55 7.029 21.07.28.
COST OF SS = 5
.217 21.07.29.PP 5.610 SEC.
DATE 09/26/84 21.07.28.EJ END OF JOBe **
ese********
XMOA00 //f/ FND OF LTST #f//
$0048888888 XMQAQO //// END OF L IST 11/f O
d 4
i l
e O
W
i N1SCO 29 QC 23
.01006
.01093 2
8 04+
6 00262
.00546 6
N00TER (NDEI 7
QC 4
.00175
.00000 04+
3
.00131
.00000 SLINE 61 OC 57
.02492
.02732 10 18 28 32 36 04+
4
.00175
.03000 TOMPKINS-8FCKWITH 280 OC 141
.06165
.06011 7
11 39 45 54 58 e3 72 76 99 103 04+
139
.06078
.06011 10 30 33 43 46 58 71 102 113 116 133 WALDINGER 40 QC 32
.01399
.01639 3
12 15 04+
8
.00350
.00546 1
E B ASC O 780 QC 293
.12812
.12568 1
26 44 61 88 98 114 117 133 150 154 165 167 199 202 221 234 251 260 266 ?f8 271 275 04+
487
.21294
.21311 8
21 30 40 49 50 e4 90 103 126 129 136 144 145 146 171 177 191 216 21 7 240 252 253 255 256 287 242 295 297 114 327 365 373 388 192 414 459 463 466 EBASCO INDF) 21 QC 21
.00918
.01093 3
12 04+
0
.00000
.00000 LPEL 99 OC 0
.00000
.00000 04+
99
.04329
.04372 21 31 52 58 60 61 63 66 SN1 INFL N05/9E 1 4 L604 V.
S /N 201 07/13 / 84 21.07.18.SxMQa00 FROM 21.0 7.18. I P 00000756 WORDS - FILE IN#t SC 04, FC 00, E C 00 21.0 7.18.S X MQ 4, P 2, T17 21.0 7. 2 3. 4 C C q uM T. * -- *, * ------- *. T M 5
.SX1 21.07.23. SYSTEM-SECOND COST F ACTOR = S.0310 21.07.23.
21.0 7. 2 3. J OB FXFCUTFD O S/N 201 21.0 7. 2 3. 4 T T ACH,0 4 0C, [D. NSXM, 21.0 7. 2 3. PF N IS 21.07.23.040C 21:RT:32:e!~E!;.R'RS"A!!S'!,,s.
I
, g os[2c-CONTRACTOR TOTAL TYPE NUMRER PP PS SAMPLE ITEMS AMERICAN BRIDGE 14 QC 9
.00394
.00546 2
04+
5
.00219
.00000 RC8 INSULATION 38 QC 37
.01618
.01639 13 16 22 04+
1
.00044
.00000
~
C8CI (NDE) 33 OC 26
.01137
.01093 4
19 04+
7
.00306
.00546 3
COM90STION ENGINEER 48 OC 39
.01705
.01639 32 37 38 04*
9
.00394
.00546 3
FEGLES 18 QC 17
.00743
.00546 14 04+
1
.00044
.00000 FISCHBACHEMOORE 155 CC 113
.04941
.04918 14 21 27 60 79 96 99 l
112 113 04*
42
.01836
.01619 6
18 38 GEO (CMT) 146 0C 146
.06384
.06557 4
23 28 45 68 80 95 104 109 110 119 138 04+,
0
.00000
.00000 GEO (NDEI 120 QC 120
.05247
.05464 6
9 33 46 53 75 97 100 103 109 i
04+
0
.00000
.00000 GULF ENGINEERING 34 QC 25
.01093
.01093 12 17 04+
9
.00394
.00546 6
.02930
.02732 5
31 37 40 57 04+
5
.00219
.08220
.08197 7
20 38 39 80 99 00 107 110 120 123 144 147 101 75 04+
104
.04547
.04372 25 30 37 43 73 80 P4 98 NISCO 29 QC 23
.01006
.01093 2
8 04+
6 00262
.00546 6
NGOTER (NDE )
7 QC 4
.00175 00000 04+
3
.00131 00000 L.
GC 138 ESASCO 04+
253 s
GEG (NDE I OC 46 SLINE OC 32 l
l I
h I
l 1
i i
i l
f f
5 J
ss1Lt.
j CONTR ACTOR TOTAL TYPE NUMBER PP PS SAMPLE ITFMS i
i AMFRICAN BRIDGE 14 QC 9
.00394
.00546 2
04+
5 00219
.00000
---... -.... r v n.,
1R oc 37
.01619
.01639 11 16 22
~
i
neareva s
-u see WALDINGER OC 12 l
gen (CMTl OC 138 l
ERASCO-GA+
253 i
GEO INDE I OC
.46 i
SLINE OC 32 b
i j
a i
1 1
a i
i l
I i
1 1
i i
l 1
i 1
i i
l i
tir3 sM seu.
j CONTEACTOR TOTAL TYPE NUMRER PP PS SAMPLE ITEMS i
AMERICAN SRIDGE 14 QC 9
.00394
.00546 2
l GA+
5
.00219
.00000
TOM PKI N S-8 EC KWI TH OC 45 gfG J.A. JONES OC 31 EBASCO QA+
287 TOMPKINS-BECKWITH OA+.
46 BEB INSULATION QC 16 E8ASCO QC 167 GE0a(NDEI OC 6
ERASCO GA+
40 ESASCO (NDEI QC 12 ME R C UR Y QC 123 GED (CMT)
OC 95 ERASCO OA+
297 MERCURY 04+
98 ERASCO QC 266 TOMPKINS-BECKWITH OC 103 FIS CHB AC H& MOOR E QC 99 ERASCO CA+ '
191 TOM PKI NS-B EC KWITH QA+
30 LPEL GA+
58 NISCO
~
QA+
6 ESASCO
'0 C 98 EMASCO GA+
145 ME9CURY QC 107 WALDINGER QC 12 GEO (CMil GC 138 ERASCO 0A+
253 GEO INDEI QC 46 SLINE OC 32
GEO ICMT)
CC 23 F9ASCO QA+
388 FISCHBACHEM30RE QA+
18 E8ASCO QC 199 TOM PKI NS-8 EC KWI TH OC 39 SL INE QC 10 ERASCO 0A+
292 MERCURY QC 39 TOM PR I NS-8 EC K W I T H QA+
113 i
MERCURY QA+
37 GEO INDEI OC 9
FRASCO QA+
30 EBASCO QC 61 COMSUSTION ENGINEERING OC 32 NISCO QC 8
E8ASCO QA+
126 GEO (C NTI QC 8
I LPEL QA+
63 CBE! (NDEl 0&+
3 FISCH8 ACHE 300RE OC 79 E8ASCO QA+
255 ERASCO OC 268 MERCURY QC 147 g g g~
TOM PKI NS-B EC KWI TH QC 45 g fC.
J.A. JANES QC 31 E8ASCO QA+
287 TOMPKINS-8ECKWITH QA+
46 BE8 INSULATION QC 16 of 1A7
e t z t.n s r4.H e. ria nw t ut et FRASCO 04+
120 COMBUSTION ENGINEERING 04+
3 ERASCO QC 1
VALDINGER OA+
1 i
EBASCO GA+
256 ME R C,UR Y OC 101 GEO (CMil GC 110 J.A. JONES OC 5
ME R C UR Y QA+
43 E8ASCO GA+
216 1
EBASCO QC 234 TOMPKINS-BECKWITH QC 58 TOMPKTNS-8ECKWITH QA+
58 GEO (NDE I OC 53 EBASCO QA+
59 i
LPEL QA+
61 CBCI (NDEI QC 19 MERCURY OC 38 E8ASCO OC 275 EBASCO QA+
171 FISCH8ACHEMJORE QC 113 GULF E NGINEERING QC 12 GEO (CMil GC 23 E9ASCO QA+
388 FISCHBACHEM00RE QA+
18 EBASCO QC 199 TQM PKI NS-B EC K WI TH OC 39 SLINE' QC 10
3E8 IN SUL A TION OC 13 F94SCO G40 144 TOM PK I N S-B EC K WI TH QC 7
TOM PKI N S-8 EC K WI TH Q&+
10 E945CO QC 26 FISCH8 ACHEMOORE QC 60 E84 $CD 04+
240 ME R CUR Y QC
_20 AMFRICAN BRIDGE QC 2
GULF E NGINEE RING 04+
6 ESASCO QA+
466 ERASCO QC 154 NFRCURY QA+
25 SLINE OC 36 WALDINGER QC 15 E84SCO 04+
327 GED ICMil GC 28 ME R CUR Y QC 99 LPEL Q4+
60 GE O INDE)
QC 33 i
E84SCO 04+
414 F94SCO QC 44 TOMPKINS-SECKWITH OC 72 TOM PKI N S-B EC K WI TH QA+
43 FISCH84 CHEM 00RE OC 21 FRASCO 0A+
129 COMBUSTION ENGINEERING 04+
3 ERASCO QC 1
..eenvuera ne.
s
et 14 F9ASCO 044 21 GE O (MDE)
QC 103 ESASCO QC 202 ME R CUR Y QC 95 E9ASCO Q1*
146 FISCH8ACHEM00RE QC 14 a
GEO (CMil GC 119 TOM PK I NS-B EC K WI TH QC 76 TOMPKINS-BECKWITH OA+
102 ERASCO 0A+
314 ESASCO QC 260 ME R C UR Y 04+
80 FI SCHR AC HE M30R E 04+
6 EBASCO 046 373 MERCURY OC 144 LPCL QA+
52 COMBUSTION ENGINEERING QC 38 EnASCO QC 221 ESA SCO 0A+
392 J.A. JONES OC -
57 GED INDEI QC 97 GED (CMT)
QC 80 8E8 IMSULAft04 OC 13 ESASCO 04+
144 TOM PK T N S-B EC K WI TH QC 7
TOMPKINS-8ECKWITH QA+
10 ERASCO QC 26 FISCHBACHEM30RE QC 60
E4ASCO 0A+
8 TOMPKINS-BECKWITH QC 11 TQMPKINS-BECKWITH 04+
133 MERCURY OC 80 t
E84SCO OC 114 ESASCO 04+
295 NIsch OC 2
GEO (NDEI OC 109
~
ESASCO (NDE)
OC 3
J.4. JONES QC 40 F84SCO 04+
136 ESASCO QC 133 i
FISCHR ACHEM00RE OC 27 ME R CUR Y OA+
84 E8ASCO GA+
252 4
ME R CUR Y QC 120 GEO (CMT)
GC 109 TO M PKI N S-B EC K W I TH GC 99 TOMPK I NS-8 EC K WI TH OA+
71 ESASCO 04+
365 EBASCO QC 165 LPCL 04+
31 I
SLINE QC 28 i
FFGLES QC 14 E84SCO 04+
21 GEO INDEI QC 103 E84SCO OC 202 ME P C UR Y QC 95
COMBUSTION EEGINEF3T C OC st ESASCO GA+
103 GE D (CMT)
OC 68 TOMPKINS-BECKWITH QC 63 TOM PKI NS-8 EC KWI TH GA+
33 BES INSULATION OC 22 QA+
217 F8AS{0 E8ASCO QC 271 GEO (NDEI OC 100 FISCH8ACHEM00RE QC 96 ME R C UR Y OC 175 ESASCO GA+
177
,1 ME R CUR Y OA+
30 WALDINGER OC 3
LPEL QA+
66 l
EBASCO QC 150 l
FBASCO 0A+
90 CBE! (NDEI QC 4
GEO (C MT)
OC 1 04 GutF ENGINEERING -
OC 17 E8ASCO OA+
8 TOMPKINS-BECKWITH OC 11 TOM PKI NS-B E C K WI TH OA+
133 ME R C UR Y QC 80 ESASCO QC 114 EBASCO GA+
295 MISCO OC 2
~
GF0 (NDEI QC 109 FRASCO ('40 E l QC 3
l lf3 Supe's i m =**f'f ' "
4 s y At e p E9ASCO QA+
463 h h /M pd Y O dttewed E9ASCO QC 88 ME R CUR Y QC 2
P e oe r't, we 7be 9[N 08" 9%!
- i T8" *I GEO (C Mil QC 45 A
of O A f o c p ere o - e /.
a TO M PK I NS-S EC K W IT H QC 54 TOM PKI NS-S EC K W I TH QA+
116 ERASCO QA+
49 GEO INDEI QC 75 FISCHB ACHEM10RF QC 112 MERCURY QA+
73 LPEL QA+
21 ESASCO QA+
64 FBASCO QC 253 J. A. JONES QC 37 SL I NE QC 18 ESASCO QA+
,A+
38 Q
FISCH8 ACHEM00RE ERASCO QC 117 COMBUSTION ENGINEERING QC 37 ESASCO QA+
103 GEO (CMT)
QC 68 TOMPKINS-BECKWITH QC 63 TOM PKI NS-B EC 4W I TH QA+
33 RC8 INSULATION QC 22 F9ASCO QA+
217
,