ML20034H176
| ML20034H176 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Millstone, Browns Ferry, Byron, Turkey Point, River Bend, Vermont Yankee, Vogtle, Big Rock Point, Zion, Marble Hill, Crane File:Consumers Energy icon.png |
| Issue date: | 12/07/1992 |
| From: | Grimsley D NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM) |
| To: | Gilinsky V AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED |
| Shared Package | |
| ML18058B973 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-92-436 NUDOCS 9303160132 | |
| Download: ML20034H176 (4) | |
Text
%
- u-FORA 436
~ ~~.j RE SPONSE 1YPE h -[ '
O RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF l m^t IXlr^"2^t L
1 k INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST dan
[f -.fg DE.C - 71992 DOCK E t NUMi$E hiS6191appkr.etisel RE QUESTE R Mr. Victor Gilinsky PART t.-AGENCY RECORDS RELEASED OR NOT LOCATED fSee chece edbones/
i
{-
No agency records subject to the request have been located.
[I No additional agency records subject to the requut have beer, located.
I j.-
Requested records are avaliable through another pubhc distrsbution program. See Comments section.
1-l Agency records subject to the request that are identifWd in Appendentes) are a' ready available for pubhc inspection and coppng at the k-N RC Pubhc Document Room. 2120 L Street, N W., Weshington. DC.
l.
Agency records subject to the request that are identifsed in Appendentesl are being made ava?sble for public mspection and copying et the NRC Public Document Room 2120 L Street, N.W.. Washington, DC, in a ioider under this FOl A number.
The nonproprietary version of the proposalls) that you agreed to accept in a telephone conversati >n w:th a member of my staff is now being made available for pubhc inspectron and copying at the N RC Pubhc Document Roorn. 2120 L $+reet, N.W., Washington, DC. in a folder under this FOI A number.
Agency records sub}ect to the request that are identified in Appendixtes) may be sspected and copied at the N RC Local Pubhc Document Room idntified in the Comments section.
Enclosed is information on how you may obtam access to and the charges 6r copvmg records located at the NRC Public Document Room,2120 L Street, N.W., Washinoton DC.
Agency records subject to the request are enclosed.
l Records subject to the request heve been referred to ar other Federal agencybest for review and direct response to you.
b Faes You will be billed by the ARC for fees totahng 5 Yoa will receive a refund f rDm the N RC in the amount of 5 In view of N RC's response to this request, no further action is being taken on ap;wai letter dated
. No.
PART II. A-INFORMATION WITHHEt f.) F ROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE Certain information in the requested records is being withheld from public dmlau e pursuant to the ememptions described in and ior the reas ins stated r
in Part 31, D. C, and D. Any released portions of the documents for which only part of 'the record is beir63 nithheld are being made available for public y
inspection and copying in the NRC Pubisc Docurrent Room,2120 L Street, N W., Washington, DC in a folder under this FOtA number.
COMMENTS I
RECTOp. IVISIOh F F RE EDOV DF INFORMATION AND PUBLICATIONS $ERVICt'5 sich uRE. D l
lhut !
f w.#
s.
930316'3132 921207
~)
- PDR FSIA GILINSd92-436 PDR-
~ i:rc rnNa ent iPAr il N m' '
n
=.
f Qld asuMBEQ45P DAtt 4
RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST FOIA - 92436 DEC - 71932 tCONTINUATION)
PART it.B-APPLICABLE EXEMPTIONS C
flecords subject to the request that are described in the enclosed Appendixles) are being withheld in their entirety or in prt under the Ecemption No.M and for the reasonM given below pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 552M and 10 CF R 9.17(a) of N RC regulations.
- 1. The withtetd mformatron is properly ctesstfed pursuant to Emecutive Order. (Ememption 1)
- 3. The withheld otormation relates sosely to the mternal personnel tu es and procedsres of NRC (E merr.pten 2) n
- 3. The withbeid mformation en specehcotty enemptea from pubbr drstiosu e by s atste irubce*ed (Exempbon 3)
Sections 141145 ofthe Atomic Energy Act. wh,cb prch+.is the d4ciove of Rentacted Data or Formerly Restricted Data (42 U.$ C. 21612165L Section 147 of the Atomic Energy Act.mNch prohtits the d4ctosure of Unclass:fied Safeguards infor'nalaan (42 U.S C. 2167).
- 4. The wrthheid information es a trade secret or commercial on 'mants en?cmetron that es berng a nbheid 90' the reator.M mdicated fE nmptior. 4)
The mformaton a consicered to t,e conhoential teess ap'npoetnws m'rmeovn The mforrnanon a contacered to be reprw!ary enformet.on pursuant to 10 CF R 2 790idiit)
. -. _ _ ~.-.
The anformat.on was udrmttec and rec eivec m conhornu pursuant to 10 CF R 2 790 92-
)( 35 The w+thhod mformate consists cd imegents o> ent agenc e ru n as itc se net.. a * "o t y* am ; e, ce g be9 st.on II semption bl Appi.catne Pr deDe:
I Dehbceative Process Distiosure ci p.coecis,or ai Mormate awm ter o to m%a the open and "r
- c acriege of.oess essent.at to twe neobevative prot er s
+4e f acts a'e ent n'e t sah,,r.f r*1ers :re 1 artt. !be gierden's.c o.at it i<rempon There a+p a e ric se upr,gth styggatsit. f e;tuat f
M4ere recd 90s are evettAed vr. thes erwpet, e
r i portrons tecause the reit.ase of the f acts w ount* pc rmit an amtnct rnoun ir,io the reo c.s..mai er es of tte aperg,
.4 si e i. mv.*
u u %..i Attorney woa pencet pve,p D meme m pee r ed O.
p.~.'
-. j )(
Attorney-chent prWege. (Confoentia! commumcations between an attorney end h s'her throt)_ _ _ _. - - _ _ _
l6 The wtehead enfr.rmation s e mer,pted ' rom p bi c o,5cesse te avse 4 o v %s* oom 'esst m e N. i.weted mase M pe'sceral Pwan (E mempnon 6)
}
_g
~ _.
- 7. The wnhhead enformation cons sts of recores comoded io' 9* cr'on emer't NFese* a'id 4 !*'49 *1'^ eld 'O' the reasemst 'ndic ated ;E remption 7)
Disttosure co4d reasonac!y be espected to mie fere a rth an eMe went Mees o ms t.ecauw it coatti revea' tte scepe, th ect.on, and focus of
'I enforcement efforts, a ad thus could poss#v ahow recip>ents to take acteon to shie:d patent al *rorwto ag or a totapon of NRC reauirements i
ff Dm myestet;3 tors llaempiton 7 (All Osclosure would const<tute an unmananted enm awn e' pe'sona: posacy. ((semphan 7(CH The er.'ormanor, conwsts v rames c4 revoes% are ot%e' e e-" the m iwm Mawh re " " ev e os t+ e-m occ ied to se ve-a: ior" st a s 0+
conhoenns > aes. (E memption ? IDD OT Hti s<
PART il C-DENYING OFilCIALS Pu%ent to 10 CF R 925:b) ano or 9 2Dri of the v 5 Nsc-en-F egv:sf ow Comwsw rep % tern. et has been newmened that the infrrnmon remod is esempt from eu dutbor' or d<sclowe and 1 hat as p'oduct.oe o* d sc:oss*e s co' Tre y tr., the putut irwest The tersens resp %tre for tar aeroat ye those of 6c es der *tf.ed beton as tieny,ng toe a y den.d:s tha1 roay t,e sptwaied to,t.e E necupve D rec or off,c.a3 end tne Dnector, D..+on of Freedom of I-tomat un and PubLcr ans Sm<es 0" te o Admm.s r
n at. "
n for Ope etom (EDOL l
A5 Pf LLATE Of fiCIAL DENVfNG OFFICIAL TIT!.E Of nCE I
RE CORDS DINit D
_r.._..'q.--..-
l L__{DO.. yECAE TA8:V G
John Hoyle Assistant Secretary of the l tcQenh r I
b.y Commission I
9
~
t 1,
- - - - - - - +
e 4
PART lt D-APPEAL RIGHTS Th2 demal by each denymp oftcra' ident:fied in F' art ALC may be appealed to the Apoetate Ofbr:at ident.f.ed the<e. Any such appesi mus be mace m writing *rtNn 3D days of receipt 0 this response. Appea's must t e addressed. as appropnate, to the L ucudve Director for Opervieans to the Secreta y of the Commission, or to the inspector General. U.S. Nuclear e
8 Reputatory Comm. mon, Washmoton, DC 2DLLS, and shoalet dearly siete ori tne envelose and m the letter that <t is en " Appeal f*om an initiat FOt A Decision."
i U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISS!ON NRC FORM 464 (Part 2) (191) b
Y
~(
's Re:
POIA-92-436 APPENDIX C RECORDS PARTIALLY WITHHELD FUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION 1.
5/2/80 SECY-A-80-65, Director's Decisior Under 10 CFR.2.206 (Metropolitan Edison Company) (DD-80-16) (34 pages) EX. 5 2.
1/2/81 SECY-81-1, Di actor's Denial of 2.206 Petition (In the Matter of Consumers Power Company of Michigan) (11 pages)
EX. 5 3.
1/22/81 SECY-81-54, Director's Denial of 2.206 Relief (In the Matter of Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corp.) (41 pages) EX. 5 4.
2/3/81 SECY-81-86, Review of Director's Denial of 2.206 Petition (In the Matter of Consumers Power Company of Michigan) (39 pages) EX. 5 5.
3/4/81 SECY-81-136, Director's Decision Under 10 CFR 2.206 (In the Matter of Commonwealth Edison Company) (16 pages).
EX. 5 6.
5/1/81 SECY-81-279, Petition to Review Resumption of Construction at Marble Hill (30 pages) EX. 5 7.
6/10/81 SECY-81-367, Director's Denial of 2.206 Relief (In the-Matter of Gulf States Utilities) (45 pages) EX. 5 8.
6/17/81 SECY-81-379, Review of Director's Denial of 2.206 Petitior. (22 pages) EX. 5 9.
7/17/81 SECY-81-424, Review of Director's Denial (Ir. the Matter of Commonwealth Edison Company) (37 pages) EX. 5 j
10, 7/24/81 SECY-81-445, Review of Director's Denial I
of 2.206 Petition (36 pages) EX. 5 11.
7/28/81 SECY-81-453, Director's Denial of 2.206 J
Relief (In the Matter of Tennessee Valley Authority) (57 pages) EX. 5
i g.
Re:
FOIA-92-436 i
APPENDIX C (continued) f RECORDS PARTIALLY WITHHELD l
NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTIOE
-6 12.
8/12/81 SECY-81-482, Director's Denial of 2.206 Relief (Florida Power and. Light Co.,
Antitrust) (11 pages) EX. 5 13.
8/13/81 SECY-81-484, Review of Director's Denial of 2.206 Petition (DD-81-12) (54 pages)
EX. 5 i
14.
10/23/81 SECY-81-610, Issuance of Notice of l
Hearing in Civil Penalty Action (5
)
pages) EX. 5 I
15.
10/29/81 SECY-81-619, Request for a Hearing on Big Rock Point (5 pages) EX. 5 16.
10/29/81 SECY-81-620, Request for a Hearing on Turkey Point (6 pages) EX. 5 17.
11/3/81 SECY-81-627, Issuance of Notice of
' Hearing in Civil Penalty Action'(5 l
pages) EX. 5
)
i 18.
11/6/81 SECV-81-638, Review of Director's Decision on 2.206 Petition'(Commonwealth Edison Cor.pany) (11 pages) EX. 5 19.
11/6/81 SECY-81-639, Review of Director's Decision on 2.206 Petition (Northeast j
Nuclear Energy Company) (10 pages) EX. 5
?
20.
11/18/81 SECY-81-658, Review of Director's Decision on 2.206 Petition (Florida j
Power and Light company) (20 pages)
EX. 5 21.
12/1/81 SECY-81-673, Issuance of Notice of r
Hearing in Civil Penalty Action (5
[
pages) EX. 5 j
22.
12/11/81 SECY-61-690, Northern California Power Agency's Petition for Antitrust' Enforcement Action (2.206) Against Pacific Gas & Electric Co. and i
Modification of License Conditions (3 f
pages) EX. 5 l
l l
VICTOR GILINSKY t
August 25, 1992 FREEDOM OF INFORMATION Samuel Chilk ACT REQUEST Secretary Nuclear Regulatory Commission Od
-k2 - [.8 [o -
Sc(s'/-27-SPz Washington, DC 20555
Dear Sam:
I am writing to follow up, af ter long delay, on our discussions over my collection of NRC papers at the Hoover Library.
As you know the papers have been opened to the I.
public with the exception of a set of about 700 or so whose public release gave concern to the General Counsel.
l It seems to me that the best way to resolve the question of public availability of these remaining pacers, and to e
do it in an amicable and f air manner, is for the General Counsel to formally apply to them the strict standards of the Freedom of Information Act.
The papers are a well-defined category and there l
should be no problem in identifying them.
No doubt the General Counsel has a list.
I expect the papers are all neatly stacked in a corner somewhere.
In order to I
trigger the formal review, I therefore request the papers in question be released under the Freedom of Information Act.
Sincercly, j
f l
Y
/mi
/
i l
i tx.L1,n!:g Lcf g=
%n Y g p, gr 3
7 u
.g
-q 'Yyh
'Ye M
b,34e q
N k
,, g g l
t..k.
e