ML20011E449

Comments on Plant Draft SALP Rept.Author Believes That SALP Rept Accurately Describes Performance of Plant Staff & Conclusions of NRC Insp Staff as Documented in SALP Input. Plant Should Be SALP 1 in Security

ML20011E449
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	10/25/1989
From:	Everett R NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION IV)
To:	Crutchfield D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Shared Package
ML20011D121	List: ML20011D120 ML20011D122 ML20011E336 ML20011E429 ML20011E435 ML20011E437 ML20011E438 ML20011E439 ML20011E440 ML20011E441 ML20011E442 ML20011E444 ML20011E445 ML20011E446 ML20011E447 ML20011E448 ML20011E449 ML20011E450 ML20011E451 ML20011E452 ML20011E454 ML20011E455 ML20011E456 ML20011E457 ML20011E458 ML20011E459 ML20011E460 ML20011E461 ML20011E462 ML20011E463 ML20011E468 ML20011E469 ML20011E470 ML20011F392 ML20011F393 ML20011F394 ML20011F395 ML20011F400 ML20011F401 ML20011F404
References
NUDOCS 9002140063
Download: ML20011E449 (1)

Text

1. ***%,%

' UllTED STATES NUCLEAR [EGULATORY COMMISSION

$y f

f RE010N IV 5

811 %Y4 4 PLAZA DRIVE. SulTE Itub

, e'

1. A NOTON.TEXAB 70011

'A t 5 m MEMORANDUM FOR:

Dennis M. Crutchfield, Associate Director For Special Projects Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation FROM:

R. J. Everett, Chief Nuclear Material Licensing Section Division of Radiation Safety and Safeguards

SUBJECT:

' COMMENTS ON COMANCHE PEAK DRAFT SALP REPORT I was responsible for the NRC's inspection programs in Security and Emergency Preparedness during most of the subject SALP period.

With regard to emergency planning, I believe that the SALP report accurately describes the performance of the Comanche Peak staff and conclusions of the NRC inspection staff as documented in their SALP input. With regard to Security, some changes could be made to more accurately describe thr. conclusions of the inspection staff.

The-applicant's audit program consisted of an audit group within the Security group.

The report probably gives toe applicant too much credit in this regard.

On the other hand, we knock them fer ' heir lack of readiness for final phase lock down. Many of the problems arter:ieted with this lack of readiness were beyond the control of the security praur, i.e.. c0nstruction activity and large numbers of personnel onsite.

The exten;ier, of the SALP period allowed more of the readiness issue to come out.

Based upon the experiences of the Security staff in performing preoperational inspections at other plants, Comanche Peak should be a SALP 1 in Security.

R. J

, Chief Nuclear Material Licensing Section 4

QyQkI