ML19325F094
| ML19325F094 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 11/01/1989 |
| From: | Grimsley D NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM) |
| To: | Kuperman A NUCLEAR CONTROL INSTITUTE |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19325C113 | List:
|
| References | |
| FOIA-88-451 ACRS-GENERAL, NUDOCS 8911140085 | |
| Download: ML19325F094 (8) | |
Text
e a
J """ "^" ~ M ~ "ATORY ea***aemannes
,,nc pom Raoueet muse' Rim FOdA 451 L
-jV m oe.m im
!] -l j
RESPONSE TO FREEDO O
A m at I lea'iw W
i i
J INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST
.e i
c:ee /
NOV i 19e9 e
l Decem evem M E'afassas ew a
Raouter:R Alan J. Kuperman PART 1.- AGENCY RECORDS RELEASED OR NOT LOCATED (See chec&ed bomeel No egency records subsect to the requer %ve been located.
No addetsonef agency records evbgect to the request have been located, Requested records are ovellable through ers9ther pubhc destnbution pec;;.em. See Comments Section.
Agency records subtect to the request that are identifed on Appendiales) are already eventable for pubhc enspection and copying m the X
NRC rubhc oocument Room 2 t,o t Si,eet. N W., W,shm, ton. oC 2ossS Agency records subject to the request that are contifed o. AppendimiesL B*
e bemg made available for public inspection and copymg M the K NRC Pubhc I?ncument Room. 2t2o c Street. N.W., Ween yrm, DC. In e folder under tNs FOIA wmber nd requester name.
The ionproprietary version of the proposal (s) that you agreeo to ac6ept 6n a teiophone cor.orsat on with a member of my staff is now bero made evadaL4 for pubhc inspection and copying et the NRC PutAc Docurrient Room 212o L Street N.W.. WasNngton, DC m a folder undes tres FOIA number and requester name.
Agency eMords subsect to the request itset are identifed or Appendimiesi may be inspected eno copied et the NRC Local Pubhc Document P om identifed in the Comments Secten.
Enclosed to enformepon on how you may oh(sitt access to and the charges for cupymg records placed in tre NRC PutAc Document Room. 212o L Streu. N W.,
weeNnoton, DC.
Aosney records subsect to the requttt are enclosed.
- Documents B/1 through B/16 are enclosed.
y Recorde s.sbgoct to the requer' have been referred to another Federal eger*ytes) for review aid dwact response to you.
~
X Yau *i ** bi"*d by 'h* NRC for fe.s i ishng 174.16 In view of NhC's response to tNs request, no further acten is bemg taken on appealletter dated No.
PART 11. A-INFORMATION WITHHELD FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE Cortem infoemation 6n the requested records is bemg withheH from pubhc disclosure pursuant to the esempteons described en and for the reasons s.Jied in Part e, et ctione 8. C. and D. t.V released portions of the documents for wNch oniy part of the record is oeing withheld are being made available for public mspection and X
copvng a ihe NRC ru%c oocument Room. 212o L Street. N w.. wasNngton. oC. e foider under ih FoiA numter and r.2oesier nome COMMfNTS j
i I
"Y 8911140085 891101 FOIA PDR PDR KUPERr1 A89-451 4
o
.}
b TURE. OtRCC kl. e alV I N OF TR EDOM OF INFORMATION AND PUBLICATIONS SERVICES Y
1% Y
~
t t
ene casone aa4, %. n..
,J
e MEEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT RESPONSE roiA NuMeERist FOIA 451 OAT,N0Y11 togs
~
PART 3.8-APPLlCABLE EXSRFfl0NS C
Recorde subject to the teouset that are described on the enclosed hr,andixleel are t4ing withheld in their entirety or in part under the Esemptions and 'or the feseone est forth below pursuant to 6 U.S.C. 662ib) and 10 CFR 9.17tel c4 NRC Regulations,.
N 1i The wahheld information to property cieneified pursuent to taenut6ve Order (EXEMPTION tl i
l L
- 3. The wfthhold informeten v.mes solely to the intemel portonnel rules and procedures of NRC (EXEMPTION 2)
L
- 3. The withheid information is specifically enempted from public disclosure by statute mdcated. IEXEMPTION 3)
Sections 141 146 of the Atomic Energy Act which prohibits the dasClosure af RestnCted Date of Formerty Restected Data I42 U S C. 216121661.
Secten 147 of the Atomic Energy Act whch prohibits the disclosure of Unclassifed Safeguards intnematen 142 U.S C. 2167).
- 4. The withheld mformaten es a trade secret or commercial or financial mformation that im bent, withheld for the reasontsi indicated. (EXEMPTION di The enformation 6s considered to be confidential busmess (propnetary) information.
The inforrestion e considered to be pros.netary information pursuant to 10 CFR 2,790idH1).
The mforenetion was submrtted and reemvea in confidence p arsuani to 10 CFR 2 790tdl(2).
E. The witnheid mformaten consets of mteragency or miraegency records that are ret evadate through discovery during htigaten (EXEMPTION 61. Applicable Pnvlege:
Dehborative Process: Disdosure of predecisional mformation wo sid tend to mhibit the open and frank enchange of adcas essential to the dehberative proce Where records are withheld m their entwety, the facts a ; hisatrcebly mteriwmed with the predecisional mformation. ft.ars also are nn reasonably segregeble tectuel portens tocause the release of the f acts would permit an mdueet mau.ry mto the predecisional process of the agency.
Attomey work peuduct privilege 4 Documents prepared by an attorney er contemplation of htigaten i Attorney-chent envilege. IConfidentiel communicatens between an attorney and his her chent I
- 6. The withheid informaten e esempted from public disclosure because its disclosure would result m a clearty unwarranted invasion of personal privacy. (EXEMPTION 6)
.+
- 7. The withheld inforr.etion consists of records tranpiled fix law enftreement purposes and is bemg withheld for the reason (s) mdicated. (EXEMPTION 7)
Disclosure could reasonably be espected to interfere with an ei..orcement proceedeg because it could reveal the scope. direction, and focus of en.
forcement of forts. and thus could possibly allow them to take acten to shield potential wrongdomg or a violation of NRC requnernents f rom mvestigators.
EXEMPTION '/ (All Disciosure would constitute en unwarranted invasen of personal pnvecy (EXEMPTION 7tCil The mtormaten cor9 sts c.f names of individuals and other mformation the distlos we of which could reasonably be ennected to reveel adentities of confidentes sources IExtMPTION 71010 i
OTHE.R 4
PART N. C-DENYlN. ^8FICIALS.
Pursuant to 10 CFR 9 26fb) andic 9 26 ici of the U S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission regulations. it has been determmed that the mformation withheld is enempt from productica or disclosure, and twt its producten or disclosure as contrary to the pubhc mterest. The persons responsibl.) for it e demal are those offcials identifed below as den eg officels and the Diretor. Division of Freedom of information and Pubhcations Servces. Office of Administration and Resources Management for a.sy v
sen.ais that may be appealed to the Eauutive Directoe for Operatens (E005 DENYING OFFICIAL TITLEtOFFICE RECORDS DENIED APPELLATE OFFICIAL E METARY EDO Thomas E. Murley Director. NRR Anoendh C Y
PART H. D-APPEAI. RIGHTS The danica by each denying official 6dentrfed m Part II.C may be appealed to the Appelnate 0;?cialident.fied m that se<* an. Any such appeal must be in wretmg and must be made withm 30 days of receipt hf thse response. Appeels must be addressed es oppropriate to the Esecu4ve Director tor Operations or to the Secretary of the Commesson.
U.S; Nucleet Regulatory Comm6ssion. Wes moton, DC 20666, and should clearty etsie on the envelope and in the letter that it is en " Appeut from en initial FOtA Dec6een."
s iIIC PC Aed 404 (Port n!
U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION FOIA RESPONSE CONTINUATION nvi
i n'
i e
Re: F01A-88-451
)
APPENDIX A l
DOCUMENTS ALREADY AVAILABLE IN THE PDR P
- 1.
12/6/83 5ECY-83-500 - Ciarification of General Physical Protection Requirement. Accession No. 8312140585 e
2, 4/20/84 SECY-83-500A - Clarification of General Physical Protection Requirement. Accession No. 8405180013 3.
5/2/84 Inspection and Enforcement Manual Temporary Instruction 2545/1. Accession No. 8412260211 4.
8/20/84 Memo from D. Eisenhut to R. Burnett, subject: Analysts of Non-Power Reactor Sabotage. Accession No. 8403310410
_ 3 s
t b
9 D
0
~.
. ~, -
---n..
~
L i
o Re:
)
APPENDIX B DOCUMENTS BEING PLKlTD IN THE PDR to W. Dircks, subject: 290th ACRS Meeting t
Memo from R. Fraley(4 pages) 1.
7/2/84 Follow-up Items.
2.
7/6/84 DOE Source Selection Justification.
(1 page) 3.
7/16/84 Note from R. Burnett to W. Brown, re:
Proposed Statement of Work.
(7 pages)
Analysis of Memo from R. Burnett to D. Eitenhut,) subject:
4.
7/31/84 Nonpower Reactor Sabotage.
(2 pages 5.
8/21/84 Hemo frcm W. Brown to R. Eurnett, subject: Statement of Work for Consequences of Sabotage at Nonpower Reactors.
(1 page) 6.
G/22/84 Note from "BB" to W. Brown.
(1 page) [The attachment to this document is identified on Appendix A, document 4.]
1 7.
8/27/84 Memo from R. Burnett to R. Brown, subject:
Statement of Work for Consequences of Sabotage at Nonpower Reactors.
(9 pages) l-L 8.
8/30/84 Memo from R. Burnett to R. Brown, subject:
Statement of ork l
for Consequences of Sabotage at Nonpower Reactors.
(1 page) 9.
8/30/84 Memo f rom R. Brady to R. Burnett, subject: Security / Classification Requirements for FIN A7153 (Los Alamos National Laboratory).
(5pages)
- 10. 9/4/84 Memo for R. Brown to R< Burnett, subject: Consequences of Sabotage at Nonpower Reactors, FIN A7153.
(1 page) 4 l
- 11. 9/6/84 Letter from R. Brown to R. Romatowski, re: NRC Form 173, Standard for DOE Wovk.
(11 pages)
- 12. 9/21/84 Memo from R. Burnett to J. Davis.
(3 pages) 13, 9/26/84 Telecomunication Message from L. Garvey to D. Carlson.
(3 pages)
- 14. 10/1/84 Project and Budget Proposal for NRC Work.
(14 pages) 15.
10/1/84
?roject and Budget Proposal for NRC Work.
(16 pages)
- 16. 10/1/84 Draft Project and Budget Proposal for NRC Work.
(17 pages) j 17.
10/9/84 Letter from A. Jennings to D. Carlson, subject:
t.onsequences 3
of Sabotage of Nonpower Reactors.
(17 pages)
i l
t Re:
F0!A-83-451 APPENDIX B DOCUMENTS BETNE'WRTD IN THE PDR l
(continued) l t
18.
10/17/84 Letter from D. Carlson to T. Bott, enciosing copy of
" Declaration of Dr. James C. Warf."
(11 pages) 19, 10/29/84 Letter from A. Jennings to D. Carlson, subject: Consequences of Sabotage of Nonpower Reactors.
(15 pages) 20.
11/8/84 Note from D. Carlson, attaching LANL's revised proposal.
(15 pages) 21.
11/14/84 Letter from T.F. Bott to D.M. Carlson, enclosing work plan for Task 1.
(7 pages) 22.
11/15/84 Letter from T.F. Bott to D.P. Carlson, subject:
Nonpower Reactor Sabotage Study Status Report for October 1984.
l (2pages) 23.
12/14/84 Letter from T.F. Botts to D.M. Carlson, subject:
Nonpower Reactor Sabot 6ge Study Status Report for November 1984.
i (2pages) 24.
12/27/84 Letter from D. Carlson to L. Sullivan.
(1 page) 25.
1/14/85 Letter from T.F. Bott to D.M. Carlson, subject: Nonpower l
Reactor Sabotage Study Status Report for Decemb2r 1984.
l (2 pages) 26.
1/15/85 Memo from R. Burnett to R. Brown, subject:
Evaluation of Proposal from Los Alamos National Laboratory.
(1 page)
'27.
1/23/85 Letter from T.F. Bott to D.M. Carlson, responding to 12/27/84 Itr.
(1page) l 28, 2/13/85 Letter from T.F. Bott to D.M. Carlson, subject: Nonpower Reactor Sabotage Study Status Report for January 1985.
l (2 pages) 29.
2/22/85 Memo from James Partlow to various addresses, subject:
Revision of IE MC 2545 and the Applicable Inspection Procedures.
(35pages)
- 30. 3/25/85 Letter from W.D. Zerwekh to D. Carlson, subject:
Nonpower Reactor Sabotage Study Status Repot t for February 1985.
(2 pages) l 31.
5/15/85-subject: Quality Memo from R. Erickson to various addresses,(4 pages)
Assurance Procedures for Contracted Work.
e
Re: F0!A-88-451 L
APPENDIX B DOCUMENTS BUIE 7CXtTD IN THE PDR (Continued)
- 33. 6/21/85 Letter from W.D. Zerwekh to D.M. Carlson, subject: Nonpower Reactor Sabotage Study Status Report for May 1988.
(2 pages) 34.
7/3/85 Note from.' ion Carlson to " Lewis" enclosing signed NRC Form 173.
(10 pages) 35.
7/25/85 Letter from R. Brady to R. Sabre.
(1 page) l
- 36. 8/1/85 Letter from Zerwekh'to D.M. Carlson, subject: Nonpower Reactor
^
Sebotage Study Status Report from June 1985.
(2 pages)
- 37. 8/23/85. Letter from W.D. Zerwekh to D.M. Carlson, subject: Nonpower Reactor Study Status Report for July 1985.
(2 pages) subject: Nonpower Letter from h.D. Zerwekh to D.M. Carlson, August 1985.
(2 pages)
'38.
9/16/85 Reactor Sabotage Stuay Status Report for 39.
9/27/85 Letter from A. Jer.nings to T. Sweitzer, subject: Consequences of Sabotage of Nonpower Reactors.
(9pages) 40.
10/11/85 Letter from D. Carlson to W.D. Zerwekh.
(1page) 41.
10/22/85 Letter from W.D. Zerwekh to D.H. Carlson, subject: Nonpower Reactor Sabotage Stuay Status Report for September 1985.
(2 pages) 42.
11/14/85 Memo from G. McCorkle to R. Brown, subject:- Change of Project Manager.
(1page) 43, 11/15/85 Menn from R. Brunett to R. Brown, subject: Evaluation of Proposal from Los Alamos National Laboratory.
(9pages) i 44, 11/21/85 Letter from R.S. Brown to R. Romatowski regarding NRC Form 173.
(2 pages) 45.
11/21/85 Letter from W.D. Zerwekh to T. Sweitzer, subject: Nonpower Reactor Sabotage Study Stetus Report for October 1985.
(2 pages) 46.
1/29/86 Letter from R. Brown to R. Romatowski.
(1 page) 47.
3/18/86 Letter f t om W.D. Zorwekh to C. Wither, subject: Nonpower Rea.ctor Sabotage Study Status Report for February 1986.
- 48. 5/21/86 Letter from C. Wither and D. Carlson to J. Hyder.
(1 page)
l
?-
o i
l Re:
F0!A-88-451 APPENDIX B DOCUMENTS BITERTAITD IN THE PDR (Continued)
- 49. Undated Viewgraphs.
(5 pages)
)
- 50. Undated Statement of Work - Consequences of Sabotage at Nonpower Peactors.
(7 pages)
- 51. Undated Project Descriptive Suninary.
(2 pages)
I
- [
\\
L f
+
j, l
1' l'
i P
\\
,,.,, - ~
,,,~ -,, - -,., - - -
Ret F0!A-88-451 APPENDIX C RECORDS B,ETETITHRELD IN PART 1.
4/16/85 Letter from W.D. Zerwekh to D.M. Carlson, subject: Nonpower 1
Reactor Sabotage Study Status Report for March 1985.
(2 pages)
Portions withheld pursuant to Exemption 1.
2.
8/9/85 Note from Carlson' to various addressees, (1 page), released, 6ttaching letter from W.D. Zerwekh to D.M. Carlson, subject:
Assumptions Used in the Nonpower Reactor Sabotage Study (9 pages). Portions withheld pursuant to Exemption 1.
3.
9/30/85 Note from D. Carlson to various addresses, (1 page), released, i
attaching letter from W.D. Zerwekh to D.M. Carlson, subject:
l Assumptions Used in the Nonpower Reactor Sabotage Study.
(8 pages) Portions withheld pursuant to Exemption 1.
4.
1/15/87 Nonpower Reactor Sabotage Study.
(131 pages) Portions withheld pursuant to Exemption 1.
e l
!~
1 L
k II////
8'&O l
g,4 e,g.
% 4*
mee emumios ys g#r////, +
m n n ae v a.,,
>>p l.0 5 En I!M yElL2g u
L" Eala l I.25 1.4 1.6 p
4 150mm 4
6" th>,f,,,% I;[ks e
- -. Mi_ _
4*&(#
8,
(([
s[
IMAGE EVALUATION 4
k//77;%*gkgy, ;>s,gg,@y TEST TARGET (MT-3) 4
+
l.0 Em M ylf] U1 l-l EI l!IM e,
_m
=
I 1.25 1.4 1.6 l
4 150mm 4-6"
[%
/;;bp
->,4y g,,,i/,
////
5,
,4,y
////
' ^ '
4+
i 49&
l Ah 4)%'?
M
///// p (g y IMAGE EVALUATION TEST TARGET (MT@
ppp
+
l.0
'MM y[jE4 l-l E m Me l
m
'I.25 1.4 I.6 4
150mm -
4 6"
l
- *4,zz, go' 4N
- 4y_y,7,//;
<> a%///
++4 tv o
y l
1t
[
%n.
}
l
.+d[Ak>#
///p
/ g b g, #,
IMAGE EVALUATION k//71 gM TEST TARGET (MT-3)
,4 4
!xxk x
I.0 lf 2 EL4 E 9 R?4
!!2 BL2g 1.I m
I48=
1.25 1.4 1.6 4
150mm 4
6" d*
- z;<h
'4 s,gy p%
////
seg+;
e77777 t
v
. cw
4, l
DT+9)f</
(([,
b gg+;,
, IMAGE EVALUATION 4
..,-.,<r-l.0
'd M W yl jim 1 E m llE j
sl l=
pe j
l.25 1.4 1.6 i
4 150mm
?
l 4
6" kc%
f;;b/4
'/
r,,gs,y,,,,,,,.
4
%s t
g J
A
.