ML19225C702
| ML19225C702 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Davis Besse  |
| Issue date: | 06/29/1979 |
| From: | Harold Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Roe L TOLEDO EDISON CO. |
| References | |
| TAC-11649, NUDOCS 7908020339 | |
| Download: ML19225C702 (3) | |
Text
~w
~
DISTRIBUTION:
.,.'s Docket File J
e q rm s rms M
- s ORB #4 Rdg
/ "
. c '.
1 r.:ca :u ro:,7.w - two.'J
_L PDR
?
n m... o. c. s ".s A$
f,
^
NRR Rdg I
i s.
o m
- c..
VStello DEisenhut C-de..:o. 50-3.:5 BGrimes WGamill TJCarter WRussell Mr Le all E. h e 0 ELD "ica ?c.:s Ic':nt, f acili ties I&E (3)
' - 31,
.at RReid ici
'o.ai:;n C;
'ny GVissing n /Ina RIngram
.,)
':u s :n
/cnue Gray File
- a. v.~ 2 JRBuchanan m
,.].%, C.:o iu s
N-TERA ACRS (16) p,'. c. g,,,
This levar is to express cur concern over _he ir.ilcre of Tolcdo Tdicen
' ny (:ECO) to bring to the attention of tha IRC Staif r.:ccers evaluating Ceh2 Cc ' :y's cr glic.ica li th the Cc:aission's ccafir mi.o.y ceder of I'ay 16, IN?, '
a ala Ccc c. :.'cc (~0) !79-CG2 a t C tvis-3 sse 1.
'l2 hova several
- 1. a s, n o t in c'.h
- 1.w, rel: Ling to TECO canr.gc:acat's aucreness of this it, cn J.he caasaa fcc "c.ilure to discuss this event in cc: vaicaticas
' i th tha..iC S taf f dact anting the actions taken in raspaase to the ay 16 Ceder.
'y ?
.c.r N ccil 27,1T/9, YECO cen.titted, coag oiN r.h ~ cs, to "
- e
- o i '.
all a,..s of [tha < miliacy 6 _J nt :r] sy3 ;::a to fur. hec.. L..de nuats for ac:ded ralicbility cad pecfor.'coce."
The cca :i', :at as ce ceniiimd and rcquired by parcgraph IV(1)(a) of the Cco.aission's *ay 15, Ocdar.
Ca..y 21,19/9 t, oruc';1e Occurccace 79-CS2, icyo!-
.g ice vr W n'.ili'ry fc ' :,..:c (?.2 'l} suc tico pressure swi tches and ou t-o f-talecc.aca vi o uo s 2 tpa i n i.s, cccucced.
This was reparted to JRC's Ragico III, Of fica of Inspactica cad Enforce: ant by letter (LER 79-052) of June 15, 1979.
- Despite, Ec'. r/er, nuoaccus meetings and exchanges of correspcndence between TEC0 i
!C c; e:. r.g t';c cel i abili ty of tha AF'.-! sys tcm, the event ::as not s.
.. :n o f t 'e
' bcrs of toa Sta f f's Eulic'.;as :nd Ccors
,0
.)
2 :
T.
,. o:.
1.. i a.; c
- 1fac.cc uith.30 :'ay 16, Cr Ier.
To U.a c:-trary, L. ce (TECO) to R. Reid (:RC) identi icd
' :r ci.* j 23,1979 fcc:
Ly 1 1
, aly s.irce LER's since Jac.uary 1973 involving the AF'.I systcn; no r:cetica
' 3s cada of the :'ay 21, 1979 cvent.
'_ ;; cs. D. . ass, G. :'ne tis, and R. Cr.pra o f E.E visi tc J h/is-30ssc I C5:ilcciv cnd t 1,
. ;- d
- .h L "ce, T. i'ucc:y (The Statien Smar;;F_.. ant) c'.d ctF2r TECO 1979.
The subject of A?! LERs as on the in. ? ting
,.:csc nel cn June 8,
<.janda and the SRC Staff v.as again infcrred that thare had baan only 3 LER's s i x e # re I ry 19 73.
Again, no mntion was od.2 of the by 21 event.
3 I O W ' O Q~: %v c
f' ll
)SCk 4
(
e
~
L 2,
1
,g n' s
% "3 <, h,, n hnnE!.:n 9080F0 3 3 a
a
<d a
u 7
455 005
W "A-
- r. l.o..all E. 100.
antaining the evaluation of TEC0's ccmplicnce A Staff $1faty Evaluation (
- i th L:;a Ct :iss f oa's l'ay i; ccdar t::s finalizcd en Jt'na 27 ar.d,crovided to 7:4 cn cat r ta.
On page 6 of that SE ue discuss "Lhe 3 Tailuces of AFW a ats fcc.1 J:.nuacy 1973 to r'aie" cf h i ch i.s :'ad ':nc'iledge.
sjst 1 c:
.. _.n l. '1u2:
n,:ad w,yl c. a r '...a ci :.a SE 4 ill ta rcquircd in
'.,. o i I. ' ', ; - J i?.
In c 'iLi:, to m a 1:
!t
,n:31 : cal ntion ir:.1 iM._. :d a rt,1y
- 1. a the ccri:s ci i > C.- h e, '.o
.ill ce,uica Inst:ces
~-
t
.o
. c. :,i :.
nj i;. n o :rs c='cecrioJ iti.0's
- 11ci.u ':d : 1.cciccs zith f r.j fi:C0 r :na j _. _ n t c id 7.C :':c u t.s. : n ci a l l y i: : a fe Jo.
'.].'.
i - :c t 3.
- i.i b as
_11 s ? L; ;g t t N1y 3 o
l.
.c
.a ti :2 a f i.'ia J iy 23 s-
- .d occacced sinca Jcc.varj 1073, :as i:c. ' a :.:ce c i 7,0 7 0 n U !
If If the no t, e:gl ai n '.hy not, and '.Oc n '. cs ha r ide c'taca of i t.
- s.:r is yes, e:: plain :hy the event cas not discussed in the :*ay 23
' y 23 lettcc lat::e
.ilca e ; plain ':hy TECO did rot rup?l~:cnt tha
<o ':cass t'.'. '.y E l " c at o c ca i s e tha..a.ce r i n the i ' :. :as d i _ cu s a i _ ',s
. i L3. :C ca. cc r. f r.g.4'.1 ral f a: i l i ty.
2.
E glaia.hy Oc :'cy 21 cvent tas cot 'crot.;ht up at the J:ue 3, 1979 dis.uis.:as M:
n i iC. nd.TECO perscanal en AF'.' LE3s.
"e h va caen
..li ci. :d c. a c a c i..a a le u. : n i c.g....;a g._ ca. i c a.,;.a c: n.
c,, a,c,
c
': c.
- 1. e o ? i 0 7 9 C 'i ?.
Is ihr, c c.
<?
li he
.y.'
y,
.3 cc is es, e, lain th.' it.C0,alic).' a t c.
l..
_ s >i.
.r.
..g rot _ntially unsafa con <!itions to 03-1 cad fEC0 - ~.ca-at.
- Also, s
discuss v'.o ' ithin TEC0 r.'anagcmant tras infor '.cd of.:0 79-C32 nd tden cnd hce: were they so infor.~cd.
Sinceraly, W
/
/'
Q.
b.*
,k
/
s,.
e
.i V
,,1 r O l d d.
u, ?_ ' n, L i f _ <. s a f'
..' h Oi,ilCe Cs 6.JCICac haaCCOP
.egulation p
y t>i ' I ' )
..u.
gyH
. 1 i..~
{ {;
q
/! "r
- m J
1.')
7 1 /*
~J Ni()
~
l i
l l
Toledo Edison Company I
cc:
Mr. Donald H. Hauser, Esq.
The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company P. O. Box 5000 Cleveland, Ohio 44101 l
Gerald Charnoff, Esq.
Shaw, Pittman, Potts and Trowbridge 1800 M Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C.
20035 Leslie Henry, Esq.
Fuller, Seney, Henry and Hcdge 300 "3dison Avenue Toledo, Ohio 43604 Mr. Robert B. Borsum Babcock & Wilcox Nuclear Power Generation Division Suite 420, 7735 Old Georgetown Road Bethesda, Maryland 20014 Ida Rupp Public Library 310 Madison Street Port Clinton, Ohio 43452 A t.-
4J) rLjn/-
v 7-