Text

Forwards Proposed Method of Resolution of Deficiencies Noted in Technical Evaluation Repts Re safety-related Electrical Equipment,In Response to 840424 Request
	ML18092A208
Person / Time
Site:	Salem
Issue date:	06/08/1984
From:	Liden E; Public Service Enterprise Group
To:	Varga S; Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
	NUDOCS 8406250196
	Download: ML18092A208 (36)
	v • d • e

,,----

Ps~G*

Public Service Electric and Gas Company P.O. Box 236 Hancocks Bridge, New Jersey 08038 Nuclear Department June 8, 1984 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Off ice of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Division of Licensing Washington, D. C.

20555 Attention:

Gentlemen:

Mr. Steven A. Varga, Chief Operating Reactors Branch, No.* 1 RESOLUTION OF TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORTS FOR ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION OF SAFETY-RELATED ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT SALEM GENERATING STATION UNITS NO. 1 AND 2 DOCKET NOS. 50-272 AND 50-311 In January, 1983, PSE&G received the Safety Evaluation Reports (SERs) regarding the Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment at Salem Generating Station, Units 1 and 2.

The SERs each contained a Technical Evaluation Report (TER), written by Franklin Research Center under contract to the NRC, which noted a number of environmental qualification deficiencies for safety-related electrical equipment at Salem Generating Station.

On April 24, 1984, a meeting was held with members of your staff to discuss PSE&G's proposed method of resolution for each of those deficiencies.

The proposed resolution, as discussed with your staff, for each of the environmental qualification deficiencies listed in the TERs, is summarized in Enclosure 1 to this letter.

Discussions also took place at the meeting regarding PSE&G's general methodology for compliance with 10 CFR 50.49, "Environmental Qualification of Electric Equipment Important to Safety for Nuclear Power Plants," which became effective February 22, 1983.

The purpose of this letter is to provide documentation of the discussions held at the April,

___ 1984 meeting. __ _

8406250196 840608 PDR ADOCK 05000272 P

PDR The Energy People 95-2168 (80M) 11-82

Mr. Steven 6/8/84 to this letter contains a master list of electrical equipment for environmental qualification within the scope of 10 CFR 50.49.

The master list contains a summary description of the method of environmental qualification for each equipment item as discussed with your staff at the April 24, 1984 meeting. also provides the resolution of the Franklin TER descrepancies.

The equipment list is identical to the list of equipment submitted in response to Paragraph (g) of 10 CFR 50.49 by our letter dated May 9, 1983, regarding "Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electric Equipment within the Scope of 10 CFR 50.49."

Pursuant to 10 CFR 50.49 (g), the environmental qualification of electrical equipment will be complete by the second refueling outage after March 1982 for both Unit 1 (current outage) and Unit 2 (outage scheduled for January 1985).

The justifications for continued operation (JCO's) previously submitted are still applicable for both units.

The two generic deficiencies listed in the SER and the attached TER for the Salem Generating Station were "submergence and chemical spray" (TER, Sections 4.3.4 and 4.3.5). provides our responses to these generic issues.

At the April 24, 1984 meeting, your staff also requested confirmation that all design-basis events which could result in a potentially harsh environment (including flooding outside containment) were addressed in identifying safety-related electrical equipment which was to be environmentally qualified.

The environmental effects resulting from all postulated design-basis accidents documented in Chapter 15 of the Salem Generating Station Updated Final Safety Analysis Report (UFSAR), including the Loss-of-Coolant Accident (LOCA) and the Steam-Line Break Accident (SLBA) inside containment, were considered in the identification of safety-related electrical equipment which was to be environmentally qualified.

The environmental effects resulting from High-Energy Line Breaks (HELBs) outside containment were also evaluated in the identification of this equipment.

Therefore, all design-basis events were considered in the identification of electrical equipment within the scope of Paragraph (b) (1) of 10 CFR 50.49 (i.e., "Safety-related electric equipment *** relied upon to remain functional during and following design basis events *** ").

Mr. Steven 6/8/84 The method of identification of electrical equipment within the scope of Paragraph (b) (2) of 10 CFR 50.49 (i.e.,

"Nonsafety-related electric equipment whose failure under postulated environmental conditions could prevent satisfactory accomplishment of safety functions.*. ") is described in to this letter.

No additional electrical equipment at Salem Generating Station was identified during this review, which had not been previously included in the master list.

The method used to identify electrical equipment within the scope of Paragraph (b) (3) of 10 CFR 50.49 (i.e.,

"Certain post-accident monitoring equipment") involved a variable-by-variable comparison of the specific requirements of Regulatory Guide 1.97, "Instrumentation.** to Assess Plant and Environs Conditions During and Following an Accident," to the design of Salem Generating Station.

An evaluation of this comparison was then conducted to determine which instrumenta-tion and sampling equipment at Salem Generating Station re-quired environmental qualification.

The results of this eval-uation are described in our September 28, 1983 letter on "Implementation of Regulatory Guide 1.97 for Emergency Response Capability."

The applicable Regulatory Guide 1.97 variables will be included as part of the master list after resolution and approval has been received from the NRC.

Additionally, the concerns identified in NRC IE Information Notices 81-29, 82-52, and 83-72 have been considered in our review.

In conclusion, we believe that the "Master List of Electrical Equipment for Environmental Qualification, Salem Generating Station, Units l and 2", complies with the requirements of paragraph (b) of 10 CFR 50.49.

The environmental qualification documentation maintained in the Salem Generating Station Equipment Qualification (EQ) file complies with the requirements of 10 CFR 50.49.

The Salem Generating Station EQ File is available for NRC audit at any time.

The file was verified in 1982, and we are currently reviewing the verification documentation to ensure its completeness.

We also believe that Salem Generating Station can continue to operate without undue risk to the public health and safety based on the completed equipment qualification supplemented by the JCOs previously submitted.

As we discussed at the April 24, 1984 meeting, it is requested that supplemental SERs be issued to indicate that PSE&G's Equipment Qualification Program, as described in this letter, meets the requirements of 10 CFR 50.49 and that the deficiencies noted in the SERs dated January, 1983 are considered resolved.

Mr. Steven 6/8/84 We would be pleased to answer any questions you may have regarding the enclosed information or our request for the supplemental SERs.

Attachments Sincerely, E. A. Liden Manager -

Nuclear Licensing and Regulation C

Mr. Donald C. Fischer Licensing Project Manager Mr. James Linville Senior Resident Inspector

ENCLOSURE 1 MASTER LIST OF ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT FOR ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION SALEM GENERATING STATION, UNITS 1 AND 2

FRC f!

2 I

f !

3 4

5 6

7 8

9 10 DESCRIPTION RC Hot/Cold Leg Narrow Range Temperature - Rosemount Model 176KF RTD RC Hot/Cold Leg Wide Range Temperature - Rosemount Model 176 KS RTD Pressure Transmitter, Reactor Coolant Syste* Pr;,:rnure Post Accident Monitoring - Barton Model 763 Prod Lot 2 Differental Pressure Transmitter Pressurizer Level - Barton Model 764 Pro Lot 2 P~essure Transmitter, Pressurizer Pressure Trip Input to Reactor Protection System, Rosemount Model 1153AGA Solenoid Valve, Air Supply Valve for Pressurizer PORV's -

ASCO M0'.'lel.82lJ02 Limit Switch, Position Indication for Valves -

NAMCO Model EA 180 Differential Pressure Transmitter, Accumulator Level Indication - Barton Model 384 Transducer, Control for Atmospheric Relief Valves MSlO's - Fisher Govenor Model 546 Pressure T;:-ansmit t-c:r, Steam pressure control for Atmospheric Relief Valves - Fischer and P-r*nr Mn~~l ~ORPI04l CATEGORY Ila Ila lb lb lb Illa Ia Ib Illa Illa Public Service Electric and Gas Salem Generating Station Unit 1 Franklin.Research Center TER Status QUAL IF ICAT ION DEFICIENCIES

a.

Qualification Documentation

b.

Aging

c.

Qualified Life

d.

T/P Exposure:

Profile

e.

Spray

f.

Testing

g.

Instrument Accuracy

a.

Qualification Documentation

b.

Aging

c.

Qualified Life

d.

T/P Exposure:

Profile

e.

Spray

f.

Tes ting

g.

Instrument Accuracy

a.

Aging

b.

Qualified Life

c.

T/P Expr*sure:

Profile

d.

Test Failures

a.

Aging

b.

Qualified Life

c.

T/P Exposure:

Profile

d.

Test Failures

a.

Similarity

b.

Aging

c.

Qualified Life None None

a.

Qualification Documentation None None RESOLUTION Will be replaced during present outage with a qualified RTD.

RDF Corp. 21204.

Will be replaced during present outage with qualified RTD Model Conax P/N7A76-10000-0l Replaced *with qualified Rosemount Model ll53D Pressure Transmitter.

Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model ll53D Pressure Transmitter.

Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model 1153D Pressure Transmitter.

None Required Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model 1153D Pressure Transmitter.

Exempt -

None Required Exempt - None Required

.J."1 \\!.

1'.I '

q L*' I ',.,.*

'I STATUS Qualified PSE&G EQ Report No. 45.

Westinghouse Report l<<:AP-8687, Sup. 2 -

EOSA Rev. 1, March, 1982 Qualified PSE&G EQ Report No. 40.

Conax Report IPS-875, Oct. 15, 1982.

Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lab Report 45592-3 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lab Report 45592-3 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lab Report 45592-3.

Not in the scope of lO SP CFR 50.49 Qualified Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49. Wyle Lab Report 45592-3 Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49

FRC IJ II 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 FRC 3/4 DESCR IPTlON Electric Motor, CoolinR to Rod Drive Mechanisms - Westinghouse Model FFC2F25F Limit Switch, Operator Indication & Valve Control Masoneilan Model 4962 Control Switch, Local Control of MSl67 Hydraulic Pump -

Micro Switch Model 910 Local Control of MSl67 Hydraulic Pump - Terminal Block, Electrical Connection - Cinch Jones Mode 1.

Differential Pressure Transmitter, Auxiliary Feedwater Flow - Fischer and Porter Model IOB2495 Differential Pressure Transmitter - Fisher & Porter Model 1082495.

FA1416, FAl4919, FA0432 - Monitors RHR Pump Discharge. FA-0218 Monitors Containment Spray FA31602-l,

~rt31652-l, FA31722-l, FA31762-l

= Flow Control for Service W:ter Valves.

Square Root Extractor, Auxiliary Feedwater Flow - Fischer &

Porter Model 50ES3212 Pump Motor, Drives Charging/Safety Injection Pump

- Westinghouse Model C:ATEGORY Illa lb lb lb lb lb lb Ila Public f.ervice IUectric and Gas i~al.er.i Genen1tinCJ fltril:i.on Unit l.

l;orpnk1 i.n Rc~*?arch ':unt'""'..-

'1'ER.

None Status QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Similarity

b.

Aging

c.

Qualified J,ife

d.

T/P Exi>osure:

Duration frofile

e.

Test Failures

f.

Instrument Accuracy

a.

Similarity

b.

Aging

c.

Qualified Life

d.

T/P Exposure:

Duration Profile

a.

Test Failures

f.

Instrument Accuracy*

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualifjcation Documentation

b.

Similarity RESOLUTION Exempt - None Required Replaced with qualified NAMCO Model EA-180 Limit Switch Removed from the Control Circuitry.

Removed from the Control Circuitry.

Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model 1153D Pressure Transmitter.

Replaced all except FA-0218 Containment Spray Addition Tank Header, with qualified Rosemount 1153D Pressure Transmitters; will replace FA-0218 during Present Outage with a qualified Rosemount 1153D Pressure Transmitter.

Will be relocated to a mild environment during present outage.

I,I I* :1

'I STATUS Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13. Wyle Lah. Report 17448-17 Dec.

2, 1980.

See discussion Item No.

36 Local feature for Main Steam Stop Valve for easy maintenance.

Removed from Control Circuitry Local feature for Main Steam Stop Valve for easy maintenance.

Removed from Control Circuitry Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lab. Report 45592-3 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No. 49. Wyle Lab Report 45592-3.

Originally Controller was located in Inboard/Outboard Penetration area.

Will be relocated to Electrical Penetration area (Benign).

FRC comments resolved and motors are qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No. 16.

See column on reso.lutions.

FRC if IB (Cont'd) 19 20 21 FRCl 5/6 DESCRIPTION Pump Motor, Drives RllR Pump Transducer, Control for Valves 1RH20, l lRlllB, 12RH1B -

Fisher Controls Model 546 Flow Transmitter, RllR Pump Recirc. Flow Control FA2569, FA24BI - Barton Model 2B9A CATEGORY Ila Illa Illa l'ubl ic Ser*vice El ec:tric ilncl Gils

~nlern Cenerntinn ~tntlon Unit l Franklin Research Center TER Status QUALIFICATION DEFICIENC IF.S Franklin Res~arch concerns:

a.

Lack of traceability of installed iootors to the reference test report.

b.

Lack of documented evidence for the qualification of the motor to lead splice

c.

The i.nsulat ion class was not stated.

d.

The installed grease (bearing) lubricant was not identified.

See Franklin Rese~rch concerns llB Nooe None*

RESOLUTION

a.

Our analysis of WCAP 8754 contained in PSE&G EQ-16 Report identified an anomaly concerning insulation thickness. Westinghouse answered our question via a letter dated March 24, 1981 con-tained in EQ-15 volume 2 Tab 1505.

Westinghouse has used only thermolastic epoxy insulation in their ouc lear motors.

b.

There are actually two splices per phase in the iootor.

One between the thermolastic epoxy and the internal cable and a second at the lead box.

The first splice was supplied with the motor from Westinghouse *. As stated on page 1-1 of WCAP8754, Environmental Qualification of Class IE Motors for Nuclear Out-of-Containment Use, "... all large AC motors manufactured by Westinghouse for nuclear service employ the same insulation system and types of bearings, a generic ~ualification of these iootors is possible." The splice material is actually qualified by WCAP 7829, Fad cooler Motor Unit test, under component testing for Scotch 70 splice tape summarized in Table 22 on page 46.

The second splice is made with Okonite splice kits.

As stated in 2A, only therioolastic epoxy insulation with thermal endurance as shown in Figure 4.1, page 4-2 of WCAP 8754 is used.

The curve is equal to or greater than the requirement of Class F insulation.

d.

PSE&G used Westinghouse approved Terresstic No.

46, manufactured by Humble Oil and Refining See Franklin Research concerns #18 Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Exempt from Qualification 1.I I

I

'I STATUS FRC comments resolved and motors are qua Li fied.

Exempt from Qualification Not in the scope of LO CFR 50.49

FRC #

22 23' 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 34 FRCl 7/8 DESCRIPTION Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valves for Main Steam Isolation Valves -

ASCO Model FT8321A2 Level Transmitter, Containment Spray Additive Tank Level Indication - Barton Model 332/352 Electrical Connector, Rod Position Indication Wire Connectors -

AMP Model 4806Rl47S 4800R147P Solenoid Valve, Control for Main Steam Isolation Valves -

ASCO Model FT8321A4 Limit Switch, Position Indication for Valves -

NAMCO Model D2400XST Limit Switch, Position Indicator for Valves - Masoneilan Model 4962.

Limit Switch, Position Indicator and Valve Control -

NAMCO Model D2400X Square Root Extracter, Flow Pressure Control.

Fischer &

Porter Model 50ES3212 Flow Controller Fischer & Porter Model 53EG3000 Transducer Flow/Pressure Control Fischer & Porter Model 53El3000 Pressure Transmitter Barton Model 332 351 Limit Switch, Position Indicator for valves.

NAMCO Model D2400X CATEGORY lb Illa Illa lb lb lb lb lb lb lb lb lb Public Service Electric and Gas Salem Generatinq Station Unit 1 Franklin Research Center TER Stet:. 11E:

QLJAL IF IC AT ION DEFICIENCIES

a.

Qualification Documentation None None

a.

Qualification Documentation

b.

Similarity

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation RESOLUTION Replaced with quali~ied ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valve.

Exempt - None Required Exempt - None Required Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valve.

Replaced with qualified NAMCO Model EA-180 Limit Switch.

Relocated to a mild environment, System redesigned; function is now performed by a mechanical device.

System redesigned; function is now performed by a mechanical device Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model 1153D Pressure Transmitter.

Replaced with qualified NAMCO Model EA-180 Limit Switch

.,1.*, 1!

I

'l. *',, '~ i *.. jl

'I STATUS Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44. ASCO Report No. AQR-67484 Rev.

o.

Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 QualLfied per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44. ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ No. 13.

See discussion for Item No. 36.

Wyle Lab Report 17448-17.

Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13.

See also discussion for Item No. 36.

Wyle Lab Report 17448-17.

Originally was located in Mechanical Penetration area.

Re-located in Switchgear room (Benign)

Modified from Electronic to Pneumatic Control Modified from E lee t ronic to Pneumatic Control Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle lab Report 45592-3.

Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13.

See discussion for Item No.

36. NAMCO Report QTR-105 - Rev. 3, Aug. 20, 1981).

FRC II 15 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 FRCI 9/10 DESCRIPTION Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Safety-Related Control Valves.

ASCO Model NP Series Limit Switch, Valve Position Indicator NAMCO Model EA-180 Instrumentation and Control Panel, Enclosure for Instrumentation -

PSE&G Model I, 2, 3, 4 Bay Motorized Valve Actuator, Motive Power for Valve Openings/

Closings Limitorque Model SMB, Class B Insul~tion Terminal Block, Connection Point within PSE&G Terminal Box/Panel Buchanan Model 2Bll2N Electrical Cable Splice, Termination/Junction of Electric Cables - Raychem Model WCSF N Electrical Penetration, Provide Electrical feeds thru Containment Boundary - Conax Model canister type LVP MVP Electrical Cable, American Insulated Wire CATEGORY Ila Ila Illb Ila la Ia Ia Ile Public f.er.vice F.lectr le aml <:as f.alero Gener;itlnq i>tnt.i.nn Unit 1 F'rankli.n 11esearcii Le111:er 'l'hH Status QUAJ.IF I CATION DEFICIF.NCIES

a.

Submergence Franklin Research concerns:

a.

'::h<: method used by Salem to seal the Limit Switches.

b, The concentration of chemical spray used in the test as compared to in the plant.

c.

The length of the qualified life of the Limit Switches.

None

a.

Qualification D0cumentation

b.

Aging None None None a.

Aging

b.. Qualified Life RESOLUTION PSF.&G has analyzed the potential loss of power (due to submergence) and this analysis has been reviewed and approved by the NRC (Reference in Salem FSAR response to Q*uestion 6.28)

a.

Conax Connectors are used to seal the Limit Switches from the environment.

b.

The test chemical spray was composed of boric acid, water sodium thiosulfate & sodium hydroxide at a ph between 10 & II with a coverage of.015 gallons/min./ft2.

The test was maintained for 4 days.

Plant condition cal led for a ph greater than 8.5 for 22.5 hours5.787037e-5 days 0.00139 hours 8.267196e-6 weeks 1.9025e-6 months .

c.

Qualified life of over 40 years. Maintenance requirements: NAMCO Controls, Maintenance Instructions. PSE&G Field Directives to Station None Required Will be qualified or replaced during present outage None Required None Required None Required PSE&G is reviewing the cable documentation with the intent of extending the life of the cable. Wyle Lab is in the process of testing the cable for extended Ii fe.

. J *,,1

'"' i* '~.~.

11 STATUS FRC question resolved.

Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No. 44.

ASCO Report AQR-67484 Rev.O NAMCO Model EA-180 Limit Switches are qualified by manufacturer.

Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13.

Wyle I.ab Report No. 17448-17 Outside the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Qualified Qualified Qualified c

e.

FRC ii 43 44 FRCl 11/12 DESCRIPTION Electrical Cable, Samuel Moore, EPR (EPDM) Insulation Electrical C2~"2, Boston Insulated Wire, Bostrad 7E Insulation.Bostrad 7 ESPE Jacket Boston Insulat~d Wire XLPE Coaxial Cable CATEGORY Ile Ii.a Public. Service Electric and Gas Salem Generating Station Unit 1 Franklin Research Center TER Status QUAL IF IC AT ION DEF IC IE NC IES

a.

Aging

b.

Qualified Life

a.

Qualific3tion Documentation

b.

Similarity

c.

T/P Exposure:

Profile Franklin Institute had several questions concerning the several types of cable:

a.

PS.E&G has not provided information either on the SCEW sheets or in analysis EQ-OS to establish that the installed cahle constructions are the same as those constructions which successfuliy passed a test which envelopes the required Salem Parameters.

b.

The report also refers to F-C38S9-l for test results.

Report F-C38S9 is a report

.of testing conducted on var

a.

ious BIW cable construction in accordance with IEEE 383-74.

The cables tested and the results of the test are reproduced on page Si.

The report indicates that some constructions successfully passed test while other cahle constructions did not.

Report B912 (170S) is a test summary which dis-cusses test results on Triaxial cable.

The Test profile does not envelope the Salem profile. The report also discusses test results on a coaxial cable.

The reported test duration exceeds the Salem accident duration but the reported peak temperature is 50° F below the peak temperature described by the Salem required profile.

RESOLUTION

a.

BIW has retested this product to expand and update their previous testing.

Analysis of that report is contained in EQ Report No. 34.

BIW letter dated May 24, 1982, indicates that all of the nuclear EPR insulation (Bostrad 7E) manufactured by BIW is of the same formulation.

This connection is established by the QAF2l forms attached to ail safety-reiate~ orders.

There-fore, the appropriate correlation has been established.

b.

The questionable cables reported on page Si:

are for multi-conductor flame retardant XLPE and single conductor #16EPR cable.

The BIW part number indicates that the cables were laboratory test samples (LSS number vs a part number).

The BIW report indicates, and verbal discussions with BIW have confirmed, that the compounds used in the questionable laboratory samples are not used in nuclear products.

a.

This is covered by EQ. Report No. 27.

That report covers three separate sets of testing.

The first two sets were at a maximum temperature of 300°F.

The third test was to the IEEE 323 LOCA profile which is to 340°F peak.

The last test shows that there is not a change in state of the insulation whic°h allows the use of the long term aging data in Figure 2.

That data indicates that our required 1 minute hold at 350° is equivalent to approximately a lS minutes hold at 300°F.

The test peak of 300'F was held for lS minutes in the first test and 240 minutes in the second test.

Therefore, the tests temperatures meet or exceed the Salem.requirements.

'I 1',i I jl

. *' I",.,,.,

'I STATUS Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

36 NTS Report SS8-1088, Oct. 9, 1981.

Qualified per PSE&G Report No. 34.

BIW Cable Co. Report B91S, Nov.,

1980 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

27.

BIW Cable Co. Report B912, Nov., 1980

FRC IF DESCRIPTION 44 Boston Insulated Wire BIWF (Cont'd)

Fluoropolymer 4S 45 47 48 49 so FRCl 13/14 Boston Insulated Wire All Electrical Cable, Triangle -

Model not stated Electrical Cable - Anaconda Wire and Cable, EPR Insulation Electrical Cable, Rockbestos Electrical Cable, Okonite -

Model not stated Motor Control Center, Power to Various Motor Operated Valves -

General Electric Model 7700 Motor located in Containment, Drives Fan Cooler Motor -

Westinghouse Spin No. PSE RCADCF CATEGORY Ia Ia Ila Ia IV

'na Public Service Electric and Gas Salem Generating Station Unit 1 Franklin Research Center TER Status QUALIF !CATION DEFICIENCIES

a.

Rel'!"rt B913 is a summary report of in format ion concerning Coaxial and Triaxial cable with BIWF Fluoropolymer insulation.

The document refers to tests report in F-C3859-l which are discussed on page Sh and Si.

a.

Descriptions of cable constructions contained in the referenced test reports do not correspond to

'.!escriptions provided by the licensee on the SCEW sheets o~ in Analysis EQ-05.

None None RESOLUTION

a.

The cables in question are not insulated with BIWF Fluoropolymer.

a.

IEEE 383 and IEEE 323 allow the use. of representative samples in performing specific testing.

The use of two conductor and seven conductor cab le is* considered representative of the cables at Salem according to IEEE 383.

None Required None Required STATUS Qualified Qualified

a.

Similarity

b.

Aging These cables are not used in safety-related circuits, Falls under Category Illa therefore exempt.

c.

Qualified Life

d.

Testing None Documentation not made available

a.

Qualification Documentation

b.

Similarity

c.

Qualified Life

d.

Aging Program

e.

Radiation Franklin Institute had 3 questions rega~ding the qualification of the motors:

None Required PSE&G considers this equipment to be qualified.

Documentation has been classified as proprietary but is available for examination at our office.

Qualified Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

14 FRC comments resolved and lll)tors.

qualified

FRC {)

50 (Cont'd) 51 52 53 54 55 56 rn,-.1 DESCRIPTION Hydrogen Recombiner, Limits Combustible Cas Build-up Inside Containment - Westinghouse Model Electric~l Connector, Connections of Electric~! Cables at Equipment Terminal Blocks -

Burnd y Model HY LUG Thermocouple, Containment Air Temperature (TA 4312 thru 432 l; TA 4348) - Tern Tex Model 304 250 TG 12, SA2 Ill CC TC J.evel Switch, Containment Sump Level -

GEMS Model LS 800 Thermocouple 1 Incore Temperature

- Westinehous" Spiu lfo. Rt:RIVI 583 FOl4 Humidity Detector, Measures

Humiclity in Containment Foxboro Model 2Fl IAG CATEGORY IV Ile Illa lb Illa I I Ia Public Service Electric and Gas Polem Generntinn Station Unit l Franklin Research Center TER status QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES

a.

Lack of traceabi li'ty of installed motor to the referenced test report.

b.

It was not stated whether the motor had an integral air-to-water heat exchanger.

c.

The motor insulation class and type were not stated.

Documentation not made available.

a.

Aging

b.

Qualified Life

c.

Aging Simulation None

a.

Qualification Documentation None None RESOLUTION

a.

Our Analysis of WCAP 8754 contained in PSE&G EQ-16 Report identified an anomaly concerning insulation thickness.

Westinghouse answered our question via a letter dated March 24, 1981 contained in EQ-15 volume 2 Tab. 15.05.

Westinghouse has used only thermo last ic epoxy insulation in their nuclear motors.

Therefore, these motors do have thermolastic epoxy stator insulation.

b.

The motors have integral air-to-water heat exchanger.

c.

Our analysis of WCAP 8754 contained in PSE&G EQ-16 Report identified an anomaly concerning insulation thickness.

Westinghouse answered our question via a letter; motors do have thermolastic epoxy stator insulation.

Exempt -

None Required Exempt -

None Required

,, J. '1 11

'I STATUS Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

50.

Westinghouse Reports WCAP-7820 Sup. 6, Oct., 1976 and WCAP-9347 July, 1978 Qualified 40 years per PSE&G Report EQ-19. Wyle Lab. Report 17448-1 Not in the scope of LO CFR 50.49 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

43.

Wyle Lab. Report 45700-l, Dec. 8, 1982.

Not in the scope of.10 CFR 50.49 Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49

FRC ti 57 58 59 60 61 62_

63 64 65 66 FRCL 17/18 DESCRIPTION Radiation Monitor, Containment Radiation Detector High Range -

Trapelo Model TA 63A Reed Switch, Rod Position Indication - Westinghouse Model KD 8805 12 Radiation Detector, Neutron Detection - Westinghouse Model SR WL23706 LR WL23707 PR WL23708 Electric Motor, Nozzle Support Cooling - Westinghouse Model TBFC Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Model NT 344A75 Hydrogen Analyzer, Combustible Gas Detector -

Bacharach Model ND Limit Switch, Valve Position Indication NAMCO Model EA-170 11302 Limit Switch, Position Indication for Valves -

NAMCO Model D2400X Pressure Transmitter, Boron Injection Tank, Safety Injection Pump Disch~~ge Pressure -

Fischer & Porter Model 50EPL04L AC Differential Pressure Transmitter, Auxi L i,ary Feedwater Flow -

Fis~her and Porter Model LOB2495 CATEGORY Ib Illa III a II Ia Ib Ib Ib Ib II a Ib Public Service Electric and Gas Salem Generatinq Station Unit 1 Franklin Research Center TER Status QUALIFICATION_

DEFICIENCIES

a.

Qualification Documentation None None None

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Similar~ty

b.

Aging

c.

Qualified Life

d.

T/P Exposure:

Pressure

e.

Test Failures

f.

Instrument Accuracy

a. *similarity

b.

Aging

c.

Qualified Life

d.

Test Failures e,

Instrument,Accuracy RESOLUTION Replaced with qualified Victoreen Model E~empt - None Required Exempt -

None Required Exempt - None Required Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series* Solenoid Valve Replaced with a qualified model Replaced with qualified NAMCO Model EA-180 Limit Switch.

Replaced with qualified NAMCO EA-180 Limit Switch Will replace PA-0227, PA-7461, and PT-0942 with a qualified Rosemount ll53D Pressure Transmitter*

.during present Unit L Refueling Outage Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model LL53D Pressure Transmitter

.. I". 1i

'1

,1

, I STATUS Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

41.

Victoreen Qualification Report 950.30 Not in the scope of LO CFR 50.49 Not in the scope of LO CFR 50.49 Not in the Scope of LO CFR 50.49 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

Asco Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

38.

ExoSensors Inc. Report EXO-QTR-101, Rev. 2, March, 1982 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13.

See also discussion for Item No. 36, Wyle Lab Report No.

17448-17, Dec. 2, 1980 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13. See also discussion for Item No. 36. Wyle Lab. Report No.

17448-17, Dec. 2, 1980 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lab. Repart 45592-3 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lab. Report 45592-3

FRC ff 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 FRCl 19/20 DESCRIPTION Square Root Extractor, Auxiliary Feedwater Flow - Fischer &

Porter Model 50E53212 Differential Pressure Transmitter, RHR Pump Discharge Flow - Fischer & Porter Model 1082496 Pressure Transmitter, Steam Pressure Trip Input for Reactor Protection System - Rosemount Model 1153 AGA Limit Switch, Position Indicator for Valves -

NAMCO Model D2400X2 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve ASCO Model LB831654 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve Control for Purge Air Inlet Outside Isolation -.ASCO Model HTX8344A75 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve Control for Pressure -

Vacuum Relief Damper -

ASCO Model HTX834475 Solenoid Valve,.Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve ASCO Model X8342B22 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve Control for Purge Air Inlet Outside Isolaton - ASCO Model HTX834477 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Model HTB34477 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Model HTB34475 CATEGORY lb Ib Ib lb Ib Ib Ib Ib Ib lb lb Public Service Electric and Gas Salem Generating Station Unit 1 Frankiin Mesearch Center TEK Status QUAL 11' ICATION DEFICIENCIES

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Similarity

b.

Aging

c.

Qualified Life

d.

Instrument Accuracy

a.

Similarity

b.

Aging

c.

Qualified Life

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation RESOLUTION Relocated to a mild environment during current Unit l Outage.

Originally was located in the Inboard/Outboard Penetration Area Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model ll53D Pressur~ Transmitter Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model ll53D Pressure Transmitter Replaced with qualified NAMCO EA-180 Limit Switch Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valve Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valve Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valve Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valve Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valve Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valve Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves

.*.1

', ;i I

' I ' ! ' ' ~,I,. jl STATUS Relocated to Electrical Penetration area (Benign)

Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49. Wyle Lah. Report 45592-3 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lah. Report 45592-3 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13.

See also discussion for Item No. 36. Wyle Lab Report No.

17448-17, Dec. 2, 1980 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.44. ASCO Report No. AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Report No. AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO OCest Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.. ASCO Test Report No. AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.*

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0

FRC it 7B 79 BO Bl B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 87 FRCl 21/22 DESCRIPTION Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Model LBXB3146 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Model FT8320Al01 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment Isola~ion Valve -

ASCO Model FTB321A2 Solenoid Valve; Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Model B31654 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Model XB342B22 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Model FTB31654 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Model FTB314B6 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve ASCO Model FT831654 Limit Switch, Position Indication - Micro Switch Model LSQ051 Limit Switch, Position Indication for Valves -

Masoneilan Model 496 2 CATEGORY lb lb lb Ib lb lb lb lb lb Ib Public Service Electric and Gas Salem Generating Station Unit 1 Franklin Research Center TER Status QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation RESOLUTION.

Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves

Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves, except SV-621, SV-624, SV-627 and SV-630 which were deleted from the system Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Valves Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves Replaced with qualified NAMCO Model EA-180 Limit Switch Replaced with qualified NAMCO Model EA-lBO Limit Switches, except VC5 and VC6 which used a qualified NAMCO EA-740 Limit Switch

, I STATUS Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Tes.t Re po rt No.

AQR~674B4, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-674B4, Rev. 0 Qu~lified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-674B4, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-674B4, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev.O Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No AQT-674B4, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13.

Wyle Lab Report No. 17448-17.

See also discussion for Item No.

36.

Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13 and No. 46. ~ee also discussion Item it36.

EA-740 Limit Switches are qualified by manufacturer (Report QRT-111, dated Oct. 2,

FRC f}

88 89 90 91 92 93 94 FRCl 23/24 DESCRIPTION Limit Switch, Position Indication - Micro Switch Model LSQ051 Pressure Transmitter, Accumulator Pressure - Fischer &

Porter Model 5 OEP1031BCXA NS Motorized Valve Actuator, Motive Power for Valve Opening/Closings Limitorque Model SMB, Class B Insulation Motorized Valve Actuator, Motive Power for Valve Openings/Closings -

Limitorque Model SMB, Class H Insulation, Reliance Motor Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment-Isolation Valve -

ASCO Model X8342822 Pressure Transmitter, Steam Flow Trip to Reactor Protection System - Rosemount Model -

l 153AHA Electrical Cable, Containment Rockbestos/Silicone CATEGORY Illa lb Ila Ila lb lb lb Public Service Electric and Gas Salem Generating Station Unit 1 Franklin Research Center TER Status QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES

a.

None

a.

Qualification Documentation

b.

Similarity

c.

Aging

d.

Qualified Life

e.

T/P Exposure:

Duration Profile

f.

Test Failure

g.

Instrument Accuracy

a.

Qualification Documentation

b.

Aging

c.

Spray

a.

Qualification Documentation

b.

Aging

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Similarity

b.

Aging

c.

Qualified Life

a.

Similarity FRC stated that PSE&G did not identify cable with respect to:

wire size, arrangement o~ con-ductors, fillers, binders, etc. & rated characteristics RESOLUTION Exempt -

None Required Replaced with qualif~ed Rosemount Model ll53D Transmitter Will be qualified or-replaced during present with a qualified Motorized Valve Actuator Will be qualified or replaced during present with a qualified Motorized Valve Actuator outage outage Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves, except SV-621, SV-624, SV-627 and SV-630 which were deleted from the system Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model 1153D Pressure Transmitter The cable in the plant is a single conductor No.

2 on the Pressurizer Heater.

It has a thicker Insulation than the test sample and the same insulation compound as stated in our Report EQ-07.

IEEE 383 implies that a cable with thicker insulation than the tested cable is also qualified STATUS Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lab. Report 45~92-3 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

51.

Limitorque Report B0003 Qualified ~r PSE&G EQ Report No.

51.

Lhnitorque Report iivC03 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lab. Report 45592-3.

FRC comments resolved and cables qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

07. Wyle Lab Report 17448-12 Nov. 12, 1980

\\

-***-*---*-*-~

FRC i~

l 2

3 4

5 6

7 8

9 10 DESCRIPTION RC Hot/Cold Leg Narrow Range Temperature - Rosemount Model l 76KF RTD RC Hot/Cold Leg Wide Range Temperature -

Rosemount Model.

176 KS RTD Solenoid Valve, Pilot for Con-tainment lsolation Valve (SV0505) - ASCO Model LB8314B6 Limit Switch, Containment Iso-

. lation Valve Position Indication Micro Switch Model LSQ051 Pressure Transmitter, Pressurizer Pressure Trip Input to Reactor Protection System, Rosemount Model ll53AGA Solenoid Vabe, Air Supply Valve for Pressurizer PORV's -

ASGO Model 821002 Limit Switch, Position Indication for Valves -

NAMCO Model EA-180 Differential Pressure Transmitter, Accumulator Level Indication - Barton Model 384 Transducer, Control for Atmospheric Relief Valves MSlO's

- Fisher Governor Model 546 Pressure Transmitter, Stearn Pressure Control, for Atmospheric Relief Valves - Fischer Porter Model 50EP1041 CATEGORY Ila Ila lb lb lb III a Ia lb Illa Illa Public Service Electric and Gas Salem Generating Station Unit 2 Franklin Research Center TER Status QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES

a.

Qualification Documentation

b.

Aging

c.

Qualified Life d

T/P Exposure:

Profile

e.

Spray

f.

Testing

g.

Instrument Accuracy a *. Qualification Documef!tation

b.

Aging

c.

Qualified Life d

T/P Exposure:

Profile

e.

Spray

f.

Testi.ng

g.

Inst-.*urnent Accuracy RESOLUTION Will be replaced during next outage with a qualified RTD. RDF Corp. Model 21204.

Replaced with a qualified Model Conax P/N7A76-10000-0l

a.

Qualification Documentation Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves.

a.

Qualification.Documentation

a.

Similarity

b.

Aging

c.

Quatified Life None None

a.

Qualification Documentation None None Replaced all with NAMCO Model EA-180 Switches Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model ll53D Pressure Transmitter Exempt -

None Required None Required Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model ll53D Pressure Transmitter Exempt - None Required Exempt - None Required I

I. * \\ 1 ' l.~, II

'I STATUS Qualified PSE&G EQ Report No. 45.

WCAP-8687 - Supp 2-ED5A, Rev. 1, March,.1982.

Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No. 40. Conax Report IPS-875, Oct.

15, 1982.

Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No. AQR-67484 Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13.

Wyle Lab Report 17448-17, Dec. 2, 1980. See discussion Item No. 36 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lab Report 45592-3.

Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Qualified Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lab Report 45592-3 Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49

FRC II 11 12 13 14 15

. 16 17 18 DESCRIPTION Electric Motor, Cooling to Rod Drive Mechanisms - Westinghouse Model 77C2 725 7 Limit Switch,.Operator Indication & Valve Control Masoneilan Model 4962 Control Switch, Local Con~rol of MS167 Hydraulic Pump - Micro Switch Model 910 PGD533 Terminal Block, Electrical Connection - Cinch Jones Model Differential Pressure Transmitter, Auxiliary Feedwater Flow - Fischer and Porter Model 10B2495 Differential Pressure Transmittec, Monitors RIL~ Pump Discharge - Fischer & Porter Model lOB2495 Flow Transmitter, Auxiliary Feedwater Flow - Fischer &

Porter Model 50ES3212 Pump Motor, Drives Charging/Safety Injection Pump

-Westinghouse Model CATEGORY Illa lb lb lb lb lb lb Ila

~uoLic ~ervLce ~Lect£Lc tlnu Gas Salem Generating Station Unit 2 Franklin Research Center TER Status None QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Similarity

b.

Aging

c.

Qualified Life d

T/P Exposure:

Dur at ion Profile

e.

Test Failures

f.

Instrument Accuracy

a.

b.

c.

d Similarity Aghg Qua~ified Life T/P Exposure:

Dur at ion Profile

e.

Test Failures

f.

Instrument Accuracy*

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

b.

Similarity*

Franklin Re~earch concerns:

a.

Lack of traceability of installed motors to the reference test report.

b.

Lack of documented evidence for thfi! qualification of r-hn* *mnr-nr tn 1Pnrl

~nl ;IP RESOLUTION Exempt -

None Required Replaced with qualified NAMCO Model EA-180 Limit Switches Removed from the Control Circuitry Removed.from the Control Circuitry Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model 1153D Pressure Transmitter.

Replaced all except FA-0218 Containment Spray Addition Tank Header, with qualified Rosemount ll53D Pressure Transmitters; will replace FA-0218 next outage with a qualified Rosemount ll53D Pressure Transmitter.

Relocated to a mild environment.

Originally Controller was located in Inboard/Outboard Penetration area.

a.

Our analysis of WCAP 8754 contained in PSE&G EQ-16 Report identified an anomaly concerning insulation thickness. Westinghouse answered our question via a letter dated March 24, 1981 con-tained in EQ-15 volume 2 Tab 1505.

Westinghouse has used only thermolastic epoxy insulation in their nuclear nntors.

b.

There are actually two splices per phase in the mo tor.

One be tween the the,r~o last ic epoxy and thP.

in~er.Y1al. cable ancl. a: Rekhnl!..lit the l~ijd box.

STATUS Not 'in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13. Wyle Lab. Report 17448-17. Dis-cussion Item No. 36 Local feature for Main Steam Stop Valve for easy maintenance.

Re-moved from Control Circuitry.

Local feature for Main Steam Stop Valve for easy maintenance.

Re-moved from Control Circuitry.

Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lab Report 45592-3 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49. Wyle Lab. Report 45592-3 Relocated to Electrical Penetration area (Benign)

FRC comments resolved and motors are qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No. 16

FRC fl 18 (Cont'd) 19 20 21 22 23 24 FRC2 5/6 DESCRIPTION Pump Motor, Post LOCA Decay Heat Removal - Westinghouse Model T-ransducer, Control for Valves lRH20, llRH18, l2RH18 - Fisher Controls Model 546 Flow Transmitter, RHR Pump Recir. - Barton Model 289A Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valves for Main Steam Isolation Valves -

ASCO Model iiT332lA2 Level Transmitter, Containment Spray Additive Tank Level Indication - Barton Model 332/352 Electrical Connector, Rod Position Indication Wire Connectors -

AMP Model 4806Rl47S, 4800Rl47P CATEGORY Ila Illa III a Ib Illa II Ia Public Service Electric and Gas Salem Generating Station Unit 2 Franklin Research Center TER Status QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES

c.

The insulation class was not stated.

d.

The installed grease (bearing) lubricant was not identified.

See Franklin Research concerns 1118 None None

a.

Qualification Documentation None None RESOLUTION The first splice was supplied with the motor from Westinghouse. As stated on page 1-1 of ~AP8754, Environmental Qualification of Class IE Motors for.Nuclear, Out-of-Containment Use, " *.. all large AC motors manufactured by Westinghouse for nuclear service employ the same insulation system and types of bearings, a generic qualification of these m:>tors is possible." The splice material is actually qualified by WCAP 7829, Fan Cooler Motor Unit test, under component testing for Scotch 70 splice tape summarized in Table 22 on page 46.

The second splice is made with Okonite splice kits.

c.

As stated in 2A, only thermolastic epoxy insulation with thermal endurance as shown in Figure 4.1, page 4-2 of WCAP 8754 is used.

The curve is equal to or greater than the requirement of Class F insulation.

d.

The appropriate lubricant is Westinghouse grease S#773A773G05 conforming to WCAP7498-L, Section

17.

See Franklin Research concerns #18 Exempt - None Required J

Exempt -

None Required Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valve Exempt - None Required Exempt - None Required STATUS FRC comments resolved and m:>tors are qualified.

See FRC #18 Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Report No. AQR-67484 Rev.

o.

Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49

FRC IF 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 DESCRIPTION Solenoid Valve, Control for Main Steam Isolation Valves -

ASCO Model FT8321A4 Limit Switch, Position Indication for Valves -

NAMCO Model D2400XST Limit Switch, Position Indicator for Valves - Masoneilan Model 4962 Limit Switch, Position Indicator and Valve Control -

NAMCO Model D2400x Square Ro~t F~tracter, Flow Pressure Control.

Fisci1er &

Porter Model 50ES3212 Flow rc~croller Fischer & Porter Model 53EG3000 Transducer, Flow/Pressure Control - Fischer & Porter Mode 1 53E 13000 Pressure Transmitter Barton Model 332 351 Pressure Bellows, Containment Pressure Trip function for Reactor Protection System -

Barton Model 351 Limit Switch, Position Indicator for valves -

NAMCO Model D2400X Solenoid Valve, Pilot Vaive for

, Safety-Related Control Valves.

ASCO Model NP Series Limit Switch, Valve Position Indicator NAMCO Model EA-180 CATEGORY lb lb Ib lb Ib lb lb Ib IIIb lb II a II a 1' UU.LH.: ::>eL v.lt.:e

.L:..Let.: LL.Lt.:

iill<.I ud8 Salem Generating Station Unit 2 Franklin Research Center TER Status QUAL IF lCATION DEFICIENCIES

a.

Qualification Documentation

b.

Similarity

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation None

a.

Qualification Do~umentation

a.

Submergence

a.

Aging

b.

Qual~fied Life

r.

8nr;iv RESOLUTION Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valve Replaced with qualified NAMCO Model EA-180 Limit Switches Replaced with qualified NAMCO Model EA-180 Limit Switches Replaced with qualified NAMCO Model EA-180 Limit Switches Relocated to*a mild environment.

Originally located in Mechanical Penetration area System redesigned; function is now performed by a mechanical device.

Relocated to a mild environment.

Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model 1153D Pressure Transmitter Replaced with qualified NAMCO Model EA-180 Limit Switch PSE&G has stated that the valves have not been proven protected by lE Breakers.

PSE&G has analyzed the potential loss of power (due to submergence) and this analysis has been reviewed and approved by the NRC (Reference in Salem FSAR response to Question 6.28)

STATUS Qualified p*er PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report 67484 Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13. Wy le Report l 744 8-1 7 Dec. 12, 1980.

See discussion Item 36 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13. Wyle Lab Report 17448-17 Dec.

2, 1980. See discussi6n Item No. 36 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13.

Wyle Lab Report No. 17448-17

Dec. 2, 1980. See discussion Item No. 36.

Relocated to Switchgear Room (Benig;,)

Modified from Electronic to Pneumatic Control Modified from Electronic to Pneumatic Control Transmitter qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No. 49.

Wyle Lab Report 45592-3 Not in Scope Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13.

Wyle Lab. Report No. 17448-17 Dec. 2, 1980. See Discussion Item No. 36.

FRC question resolved.

Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No. 44.

ASCO Report AQR-67484 Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13.

Wyle.,Lab Repor~ 17448-17, Dec; 2, 1980

\\._

FRC If 36 (Cont'd) 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 FRC2 9/10 DESCRIPTION Instrumentation and Control Panel, Enclosure for Instrumentation -

PSE&G Model l, 2, 3, 4, Bay, Vertical NEMA 12 Enclosures Motorized Valve Actuator, Motive Power for Valve Openings/

Closings Limitorque Model SMB, Class B Insulation.

Terminal Block, Connection Point within PSE&~ T_:minal Box/Panels

- Buchanan Model 2Bll2N Electrical Cable Splice, Termindcion/Junction of Electric Cable - Raychem Model WCSF N.

Electrical Penetration - Conax Model Canister Type LVP MVP Electrical Cable, American Insulated Wire Electrical Cable, Samuel Moore, EPR (E?DM) In;ulation CATEGORY Illb Ila Ia Ia Ia Ile Ile Public Service Electric and Gas Salem Generating Station Unit 2 Franklin Research Center TER Status QUALIF lCAT ION DEFICIENCIES FRC had three questions regarding the qualification of NAMCO EA-180 Limit Switch:

a.

The method used by Salem to seal the Limit Switches

b.

The concentration of chemical spray used in the test as compared to in the plant.

c.

The length of the qualified life of the Limit Switches.

None

a.

Qualification Documentation

b.

Aging None None None

a.

Aging

b.

Qualified Life

a.

Aging

b.

Qualified Life RESOLUTION

a.

Conax Connectors are used to seal the Limit Switches from the environment.

b.

The test chemical spray was composed of boric acid, water sodium thiosulfate & sodium hydroxide at a ph between 10 & 11 with a coverage of.01*5 gallons/min./ft2.

The test was maintained for 4 days.

Plant condition called for a ph greater than 8.5 for 22.5 hours5.787037e-5 days 0.00139 hours 8.267196e-6 weeks 1.9025e-6 months .

c.

Qualified life of over 40 years.

Maintenance requirements: NAMCO Controls, Maintenance Instructions, PSE&G Field Directives to Stations None Required Will be qualified or replaced during next outage None Required None Required None Required PSE&G is reviewing the cable documentation with the intent of extending the life of the cable.

Wyle Lab

-r'): :f?~:; of *-~~~~"g the cable for extended life

- - 1 *,.I

.., i, *

~ I, 11 STATUS Outside the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Qualified Qual i.f ied Qualified Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

36 NTS Report 558-1088, Oct. 9, 1981.

FRC IF 44 FRC2 ll/12 DESCRIPTION Electrical Cable, Boston Insulated Wire, Bostrad 7E Insulation Bostrad 7 ESPE Jacket Boston Insulated Wire XLPE Coaxial Cable CATEGORY Ila Public Service Electric and Gas Salem Generating Station Unit 2 Franklin *Research Center TER Status QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES

a.

Qualification Documentation

b.

Similarity

c.

T/P Exposure:

Profile Franklin Institute had several questions concerning the several types of cable:

a.

PSE&G has not provided information either on the SCEW sheets or in analysis EQ-05 to establish that the installed cable constructions are the same as those constructions which successf4lly passes a test which envelopes the required Salem Parameters.

b.

The report also refers to F-C3859-l for test results.

Report F-C3859-l is a re-port of testing conducted on various BIW cable con-structions in accordance with IEEE "383-74 and IEEE 323-74.

The cables tested and the results of the tests are reproduced on page 5 i.

The report indicates that some con-structions successfully passed test while other cable constructions did not.

a.

Report B912 (1705) is a test summary which discusses test results on Triaxial cable.

The test profile does not envelope the Salem profile. The report also discusses test results on a coaxial cable.

The reported test duration ex1 eeds the Salem accident du.ation but the reported peak temperature is 50° F below the peak temperature described by the Salem required profile.

RESOLUTION a.* BIW has retested this product to expand and update their previous testing.

Analysis of 'that report is contained in EQ Report No. 34.

BIW letter dated May 24, 1982, _indicates that all of the nuclear EPR insulation (Bostrad 7E) manufactured by BIW is of the same formulation.

This connection is established by the QAF21 forms attached to all safety related orders.

Therefore, the appropriate correlation has been established.

b.

The questionable cables reported on page 5i:

are for multi-conductor flame retardant XLPE and single conductor l'H6EPR cable.

The BIW part number indicates that the cables were laboratory test samples (LSS number vs a part number).

The BIW report indicates, and verbal discussions with BIW have confirmed, that the compounds used in the questionable laboratory sam-ples are not used in nuclear products.

a.

This is covered by EQ. Report No. 27.

That report covers three separate sets of testing.

The first two sets were at a maximum temperature of 300°F.

The third test was to the IEEE 323 LOCA profile which is to 340°F peak.

The last test shows that there is not a change in state of the insulation which allows the use of the long term aging data in Figure 2.

That data indicates that our required l minute hold at 350° is equivalent to approximately a 15 minutes hold at 300°F.

The test peak of 300°F was held for 15 minutes in the first test and 240 minutes in the second_ test.

Therefore, the tests temperatures meet or exceed the Salem requirements.

!*.J *,

~

'I STATUS Qualified per PSE&G Report No.

34.

BIW Cable Co. Report B915, Nov., 1980 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

27.

BIW Cable Co. Report B912, Nov., 1980.

FRC IF DESCRIPTION 44 Boston Insulated Wire BIWF (Cont'd)

Fluoropolymer 4S 46 4]

48 49 so FRC2 13/14 Boston Insulated Wire All Electrical Cable - Triangle, Model not stated Electrical Cable - Anaconda Wire & Cable, EPR Insulation Electrical Cable, Rockbestos Electrical Cable - Okonite, Model not stated Motor Control Center, Power to Various Motor Operated Valves -

General.Electric Model 7700 Motor located in Containment, Drives Fan Cooler Motor -

Westinghouse Spin No. PSE RCADCF C~'l:~GORY lb Ia Ila Ia IV Ila Public Service Electric and Gas Salem Generating Station Unit 2 Franklin Research Center TER Status QUALI:'I':!,~!0t~

Y:::."ICIENCIES

a.

Report B913 is a summary report of information concerning Coaxial and Triaxial cable with BIWF Fluoropolymer insulation.

The document refers to tests report in F-C38S9-l which are discussed on page Sh and Si.

b.

Descriptions of cable constructions contained in the referenced test reports do not correspond to descriptions provided by the licensee on the SCEW sheets or in ~nalysis EQ-OS.

None None RESOLUTICN

a.

The cables in question *are not insulated with*

BIWF Fluoropolymer.

a.

IEEE 383 and IEEE 323 allow the use of representative samples in performing specific testing.

The use of two conductor and seven conductor cable is considered representative of the cables at Salem according to IEEE 383.

None Requir.ed None Required STATUS Qualified Qualified

a.

Similarity

b.

Aging These cables are not used in safety-related circuits, Falls under Category Illa.

therefore exempt.

c.

Qualified Life

d.

Testing None Documentation not made available

a.

Qualification Documentation

b.

Similarity

c.

Qualified Life

d.

Aging Simulation

e.

Radiation Franklin Institute had 3 questions regarding the qualification of the. motors:

None Required PSE&G considers this equipment to be qualified.

Documentation has been classified as proprietary but is available for examination at our office.

'I Qualified Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

14.

FRC comments resolved and motors qualified

~

I

FRC it so (Cont'd)

S2 S3 S4 SS S6 FRC2 lS/16 DESCRIPTION Hydrogen Recombiner, Limit Combustible Gas Build-up Inside Containment - Westinghouse Model Electrical Connec*tor, Connections of Electrical Cables at Equipment Terminal Blocks -

Burndy Model HY LUG Thermocouple, Containment Air Temperature - Tern Tex Model 304 2SO TG

~2 SA2 lH CC TC Level Switch, Containment Sump Level -

GEMS Model LS 800 Thermocouple, Incore Temperature

- Westinghouse Spin No. RCRIUI S83 F014 Humidity Detector, Measures Humidity in Containment -

Foxboro Mode 1 2 71, !AG CATEGORY IV IIc III a lb IIIa Illa Public Service Electric and Gas Salem Generating Station Unit 2 Franklin Research Center TER Status QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES

a.

Lack of traceability of installed motor to the referenced test report.

b.

It was not stated whether the motor had an integral air-to-water heat exchanger.

c.

The iootor insulation class and type were not stated.

Documentation not made available

a.

Aging

b.

Qualified Life

c.

Aging Simulation None

a.

Qualification Documentation None None RESOLUTION

a.

Our Analysis of WCAP 87S4 contained in PSE&G EQ-16 Report identified an anomaly concerning insulation thickness.

Westinghouse answered our question via a letter dated March 24, 1981 contained in EQ-lS volume 2 Tab IS.OS.

Westinghouse has used only thermolastic epoxy insulation in their nuclear motors.

Therefore, these iootors do thermolastic epoxy stator i~r:~*1::1tic~.

b.

The iootors have integral air-to-water heat ex1=hanger.

c.

Our analysis of WCAP 87S4 contained in PSE&G EQ-16 Report identified an anomaly concerning insulation thickness.

Westinghouse answered our question via a letter motors do have thermolastic epoxy stator insulation.

Exempt - None Required Exempt - None Required Exempt -

None Required

.,,... 1

..., !, * ~ 11 11 STATUS Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

SO.

Westinghouse Reports WCAP 7820, Sup. 6, Oct., 1976, and WCAP

. 9347 July, 1978 Qualified per PSE&G Report EQ-19.

Wyle Lab. Report 17448-1

~ot in the scope of 10 CFR S0.49 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

43.

Wyle Lab. Report 4S700-l, Dec. 8, 1982.

Not in the scope of 10 CFR S0.49 Not in the scope of 10 CFR S0.49

\\

-I FRC it 57 58 59

<~!

60 I

. I 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 FRC2 DESCRIPTION Pressure Transmitter, Reactor Coolant System Pressure - Barton Model 763 Lot l Reed Switc!**, !:od Position Indication - Westinghouse Model KD 8805 12 Radiation Detector, Neutron Detection - Westinghouse Model SR WL23706 IR WL23707 PR WL23708 Electric Motor, Nozzle Support Cooling - Westinghouse Model TBFC Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Model NT 344A75 Hydrogen Analyzer, Combustible Gas Detector - Bacharach Model Limit Switch, Valve Position Indication NAMCO Model EA-170 11302 Limit Switch, Operator Indication and Valves Control NAMCO Model D2400X Pressure Transmitter, Boron Injection Tank, Safety Injection Pump Discharge Pressure Fischer

& Porter Model 5 OEP1041AC Differential Pressure Transmitter, Auxiliary Feedwater Flow - Fischer and Porter Model lOB2495 Square Root Ext~actor, #135G Auxiliary Feedwater Flow Fischer

& Porter Model 50E53212 CATEGORY Ib Illa Ula Illa Ib Ib Ib lb Ila Ib Ib Salem Generating Station Unit 2 Franklin Research Center TER Status

a.

Aging QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES

b.

Qualified Life c.

T /P Exposure Profile

d.

Instrument Accuracy None None None

a.

Q"alification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Similarity

b.

Aging

c.

Qualified Life

d.

T/P Exposure Duration

e.

Test Failures

f.

Instrument Accuracy

a.

Similarity

b.

Aging

c.

Qualified Life

d.

Test Failures

e.

Instrument Accuracy

a.

Qualification Documentation RESOLUTION Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model ll53D Pressure Transmitter Exempt - None Required Exempt - None Required Exempt - None Required Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid v0 1... _1P.<;.

Replaced with a _qualified Exo Sensor Model.

Replaced with qualified NAMCO Model EA-180 Limit Switches.

Replaced with qualified NAMCO EA-180 Limit Switches Will replace PA-0227, PA-7461, and PT-0942 with a qualified Rosemount 1153D Pressure Transmitter during next Unit #2 Refueling Outage Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model ll53D Pressure transmitters Originally located in the Inboard/Outboard Penetration area

. l *' i,. ~ 1, j-1 STATUS Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lab. Report 45592-3 Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No. AQR-6748, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

38.

Exo Sensors Inc. Report EXO-QTR-101, Rev. 2, March, 1982 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13.

Wyle Lab. Report 17448-17, Dec. 2, 1980. See disc~ssion Item No. 36 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13. Wyle Lab Report 17448-17, Dec.

2, 1980. See also discussion for Item No. 36 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.49. Wyle Lab. Report 45592-3 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No. 49.

Wyle Lab. Report 45592-3 Relocated to Electrical Penetration area (Benig~)

(

FRC ii 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 DESCRIPTION Limit Switch, Position Indication for Valves -

Masoneilan Model 496 2 Limit Switch, Position Indication - Micro Switch Model LSQ051 Pressure Transmitter, Accumul,..tol" Pressure - Fischer &

Porter Model 5 OEP1031BCXA NS Motorized Valve Actuator, Motive Power for Valve Opening/Closings

- Limitorque Model SMB, Class B Insulation, Reliance Motor Motorized Valve Actuator, Motive Power for Valve Openings/Closings - Limitorque

.Model SMB, Class H Insulation, Reliance Motor Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Model *x8342822 Pressure Transmitter, Steam Flow Trip Input to Reactor Protection System - Rosemount Model -

1153AHA Differential Pressure Transmitter, Steam Generator Narrow Range Water Level, Trip Input for Reactor Protection System - Barton Model 764 Lot l Radiation Monitor, Containment High Range Radiation Monitor

' - 1 077 CATEGORY lb Illa lb Ila Ila lb Ib lb lb Public Service Electric and Gas Salem Generating Station Unit 2 Franklin Research Center TER QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES

a.

Qual~fication Documentation None

a.

Qualification Documentation

b.

Similarity

c.

Aging

d.

Qualified Life

e.

T/P Exposure:

Duration Profile

f.

Test Failures

g.

Instrument Accuracy

a.

Qualification Documentation

b.

Aging

c.

Spray

a.

Qualification Documentation

b.

Aging

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Similarity

b.

Aging

c.

Qualified Life

a.

Aging

b.

Qualified Life

c.

T/P Exposure:

Profile

d.

Instrument Accuracy

a.

Qualification Documentation RESOLUTION Replaced with qualified NAMCO Model EA-180 Limit Switches, except VC5 and VC6 which used a qualified NAMCO EA-740 Limit Switch Exempt - None Required Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model 1153D Pressure Transmitter Will be qualified or replaced during next refueling outage with a qualified Motorized Valve Actuator Will be qualified or replaced during next. refueling outage with a qualified Motorized Valve Actuator Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves, except SV-621, SV-624, SV-627 and SV-630 which were deleted from the system Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model 1153D Pressure Transmitters Replaced with qualified Rosemount 153D Pressure Transmitters Replaced with Victoreen Model, which was qualified by manufa~ ~ll\\,r~r

, 1 *' i, '~ !1. JI

, 1 STATUS Qualified per PSE&G EQ Re.port No.

13.

See Discussion Item 1/36.

NAMCO Model EA-740 Limit Switches are qualified by manufacturer (Report QRT-111, dated Oct. 2, 1980)

Not in the scope of 10 CFR 50.49 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lab. Report 45592-3 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

-ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lab Report 45592-3 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lab Report 45592-3 Qualified per PS~&G Eq Report No.

H~ tli!!le L~b Report 45050-1, June

\\

(

._. ___ J

FRC 41 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 FRC2 DESCRIPTION Differential Pressure Transmitter, RHR Pump Discharge Flow (FA1422, FA1423) - Fischer

& Porter Model 1082496 AC Pressure Transmitter, Steam Pressure Trip Input for Reactor Protection System - Rosemount Model 1153 AGA Limit Switch, Position Indicator for Valves -

NAMCO Model D2400X2 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Model Lrlo31654 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve Control for Purge Air Inlet Outside Isolation - ASCO Model HTX8344A75 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve Control for Pressure -

Vacuum Relief Damper - ASCO Model HTX834475 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve ASCO ::.:idel X8342B22 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve Control for Purge Air Inlet Outside Isolaton -

ASCO Model HTX834477 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valv*f for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Mode 1 HTB34'4 77 Solenoid Valve, P'ilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Mo<le\\ HT834475 CATEGORY lb lb lb Ib lb lb lb lb lb lb

a.

. b.

c.

d.

a.

b.

c.

Public Service Electric and Gas Salem Generating Station Unit 2 Franklin Research Center TER Status QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES S iinilari ty Aging Qualified Life Instrument Accuracy Similarity Aging Qualified Life RESOLUTION Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model l 153D Pressure Transmitters Replaced with qualified Rosemount Model ll53D Pressure Transmitters

a.

Qualification Documentation Replaced with qualified NAMCO EA-180 Limit Switches Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

. a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualificativr& ~u(;.u.111..::n.t.ttl.ion

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves

.Keplaceu wi ti1 qual i::: ~c,;i &SC;:'\\ NP Series Solenoid Valves Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves

\\

Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves

' I ' i '* '. ~ ~... j 1 STATUS Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No. 49. Wyle Lab. Report 45592-3 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

49.

Wyle Lab. Report 45592-3 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13.

Wyle Lab Report 17448-17, Dec. 2, 1980.

See also discussion for I tern No. 36 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44. ASCO Report No. AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Report No. AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE~G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-*57484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44. ASCO Test Report No. AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Tes,t Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0

{.

FRC ff 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 FRC2 21/22 DESCRIPTION Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Model L3X83146 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Model FT8320Al01 Solenoid Valve, Pil 0ot Valve for Containment Isolation Valve -

ASCO Model FT8321A2 Solenoid Valve, Pilot Valve for Cont~;nment Isolation Va~"e ~*

ASCO Model 831654 Solenoid Valve, Valve Operation (SV1120 thru SV1124; SV1115 thru SV1119; SV-621, 0624, 0627, 0630, 0633) - ASCO Model X8342822 Solenoid Valve, Valve Operation (SV0688) - ASCO Model FT831654 Solenoid Valve, Valve Operation

( SV0400, SV0423). - ASCO Mode 1 FT8314B6 Solenoid Valve, Valve Operation (SV0117, 118, 119; SV164) - ASCO Model FT831654 Limit Switch, Position Indication - Micro Switch Model LSQ051 CATEGORY lb lb lb lb lb lb lb lb lb Salem Generating Station Unit 2 Franklin R~search Center TER Status QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES

a.

Qualification Documentation

. a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification 'Documentation

a.

Qualifi~ation Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualifi~ation Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Qualification Documentation RESOLUTION.

Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves Replaced with qualified Asco NP Series Solenoid Valves Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves, except SV-621, SV-624, SV-627 and SV-630 which were deleted from the. system Replaced with qualified ASCO *NP.Series Solenoid Valves.

Replaced..,i.th qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves Replaced with qualified ASCO NP Series Solenoid Valves Replaced with qualified NAMCO Model EA-180 Limit Switches

.. ! *,.1

' ~. '

STATUS Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified pe~ PS~&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

Asco Test Report No.

AQR-67484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

44.

ASCO Test Report No.

AQT-6 7484, Rev. 0 Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

13 Wyle Lab Report 17448-17, Dec. 2, 1980. See discuss ion for Item No. 36

96 97 FRC2 25 DESCRIPTION Radiation Monitor, Containment High Range Radiation Monitor Victoreen Models: M865T, M866I, M862S, FU, COM808B Electrical Cable - Rockbestos/

Silicone CATEGORY lb Ila Public Service Electric and Gas Salem Generating Station Unit 2 Franklin Research Center TER Status QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES

a.

Qualification Documentation

a.

Similarity FRC stated that PSE&G did not identify cable with respect to:

wire size, arrangement of con-ductors, fillers, binders, etc.

& rated characteristics RESOLUTION Replaced with Victoreen Model, which was qualified by manufacturer The cable in the plant is a single conductor No. 2 on the pressurizer heater.

It has a thicker insulation than the test sample and the same insulation compound as stated in our Report EQ-07.

IEEE 383 implies that a cable with th.icker insulation than the tested cable is also qualified

'I STATUS Qualified per PSE&G EQ Report No.

41.

Wyle Lab Report 45050-1, June 12, 1981 FRC comments resolved. Cables qualified per PSE&G EQ Repo~t No.

07.

Wyle Lab Report 17448-12.

Nov. 12, 19 80

T_.....

of,,

ENCLOSURE 2 RESOLUTION OF NRC IDENTIFIED GENERiC iSSUES

CONTAINMENT FLOOD EVALUATION METHODOLOGY

1.

In performing the Containment Flood Analysis the initial assumption was that water will short-circuit the wiring within an electrical component, causing the circuit's protective device to open and thereby render the component and all other components powered by the same circuit inoperative.

2.

The specific flood level at which a component was considered to become inoperable is specified as follows:

a.

Solenoid valves bottom of solenoid coil,

b.

Motor operated valves -

bottom of motor housing,

c.

Pneumatic operated bottom of stem mounted valves limit switch,

d.

Instruments bottom of their electrical enclosure e

Circuits in centerline of junction junction boxes box or any part thereof

3.

Based on the above specified inoperable levels, a drawing search was performed to determine all electrical components located below the postulated flood level.

Subsequently, a site survey was performed to verify the installed elevations of all electrical components located below the postulated flood level.

4.

A listing was developed by circuit number of all submerged electrical components in containment and associated electrical components powered by the same circuit but not submerged.

The safety functions of each component rendered inoperable by the postulated flood was then established.

5.

A Failure Mode and Effects Analysis was performed to determine if loss of power to a device would prevent it from performing its safety function.

As a result of the analysis, any component that was determined not to be able to perform its safety function was moved out of the influence of the postulated containment flood.

Chemical Spray The effects of caustic spray have been addressed in the equipment qualification program.

The UFSAR value for the chemical concentration of the containment spray system is 0.2 wt.% solution caustic and 1.2 wt. % boric acid, resulting in a pH greater than 8.5.

The environmental qualification J

' 'ti

J.

CONTAINMENT FLOOD EVALUATION METHOIX>LOGY (Continued) review of the acceptability of the chemical spray testing of equipment was based upon the use of boric acid and sodium hydroxide (or equivalent) in a solution creating a pH of greater than 8.5 for a duration longer than 22.5 hours5.787037e-5 days 0.00139 hours 8.267196e-6 weeks 1.9025e-6 months .

The concentration of caustics used for the equipment qualification testing is equivalent to or more severe than those used in the Salem plant containment spray system, thereby satisfying the requirement of NUREG 0588.

In all applicable equipment qualification reports, the combination of caustic and acidic solutions resulted in a pH of greater than the design value of 8.5 for Salem.

J

v.. *' '*J

..J ENCLOSURE 3 METHODOLOGY TO IDENTIFY NON SAFETY RELATED EQUIPMENT WITHIN THE SCOPE OF 10 CFR 50.49 (b) (2)

SALEM GENERATING STATION, UNITS 1 AND 2

.. :/ J-:_)

,W METHODOLOGY TO IDENTIFY NONSAFETY-RELATED EQUIPMENT WITHIN THE SCOPE OF 10 CFR 50.49 (b) (2)

SALEM GENERATING STATION, UNITS 1 AND 2 Paragraph (b) (2) of 10 CFR 50.49 requires that licensees identify "Nonsafety-related electric equipment whose failure under postulated environmental conditions could prevent satisfactory accomplishment of safety functions *** " The methodology that was used to identify such equipment is summarized below:

1.

A list was generated of safety-related electric equipment as defined in paragraph (b) (1) of 10 CFR 50.49 required to remain functional during or following design-basis Loss of Coolant Accident (LOCA) or High Energy Line Break (HELB) Accidents.

The LOCA/HELB accidents are the only design-basis accidents which result in significantly adverse environments to electrical equipment which is required for safe shutdown or accident mitigation.

The list was based on reviews of the Salem Generating Station Updated Final Safety Analysis Report (UFSAR), Technical Specifications, Emergency Operating Procedures, Piping and Instrumentation Diagrams (P&IDs), and electrical distribution diagrams;

2.

The elementary wiring diagrams of the safety-related electrical equipment identified in Step 1 were reviewed to identify any auxiliary devices electrically connected directly into the control or power circuitry of the safety-related equipment (e.g., automatic trips) whose failure due to postulated environmental conditions could prevent the required operation of the safety-related equipment; and

3.

The operation of the safety-related systems and equipment were reviewed to identify any directly mechanically connected auxiliary systems with electrical components which are necessary for the required operation of the safety-related equipment (e.g., cooling water or lubricating systems).

This involved the review of P&IDs, component technical manuals, and/or systems descriptions in the UFSAR.

4.

Nonsafety-related electrical circuits indirectly associated with the electrical equipment identified in Step 1 by common power supply or physical proximity were considered by a review of the original Salem Generating Station electrical design including the use of applicable industry standards and the use of properly coordinated protective relays, circuit breakers, and fuses for electrical circuit fault protection.

METHODOLOGY TQ IDENTIFY NONSAFETY-RELATED EQUIPMENT WITHIN THE SCOPE OF 10 CFR 50.49 (b) (2)

SALEM GENERATING STATION, UNITS 1 AND 2 (Continued)

The systems and equipment generated in Steps 2, 3 or 4 above were then compared to the "Master List of Electrical Equipment".

The results of the above review indicated that no additional electrical equipment was identified which was not previously included in the Master List.

Therefore, the list of electrical equipment provided in Enclosure 1 to this letter is judged to address all electrical equipment within the scope of paragraph (b) (2) of 10 CFR 50.49.

ML18092A208

Text

Navigation menu

Search