ML18018A898

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Requesting Withholding Pursuant to 2.790 Consisting of Mark II Containment Program LTR Rept, Lead Plant Containment Response to Improved Chugging Lead Definition June 1978
ML18018A898
Person / Time
Site: Nine Mile Point Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 07/07/1978
From: Sobon L
General Electric Co
To: Stolz J
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NFN-280-78
Download: ML18018A898 (6)


Text

g gy/lagEGULATORY INFORMATION DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM (RIDS)

DISTRIBUTION FOR INCOMING MATERIAL TOPREP REC: STQLZ J F ORG: SOBON L J DOCDATE: 07/07/78 NRC GEN ELEC DATE RCVD: 07/ii/73

'OCTYPE: LETTER NOTARIZED: NO COPIES RECEIVED

SUBJECT:

LTR 1 ENCL 20 REQUESTING WITHHOLDING PURSUANT TO 2. 790 INFO... FORWARDING P NFO CONSISTING OF MARK II CONTAINMENT PROGRAM LTR REPT>> "LEAD PLANT CONTAINMEhlT RESPONSE TQ IMPROVED CHUGGING LOAD DEFINITION>> " JUNE 1978.

REVIEWER INITIAL: X JM DISTRIBUTOR INITIAL: g DISTRIBUTION OF THIS MATERIAL IS AS FOLLOWS PROPRIETARY TOPICAL RPTS RE MARK II CONTAINMENT

<DISTRIBUTION CODE PT02)

INTERNAL: BEG F I LE~+W/0 ENCL 50-322 FILE++LTR ONLY CENTRAL FILE<<<<4I/2 ENCL 50-352 FILE++LTR ONLY 4 /~+

50-353 FILE4+LTR ONLY 50-358 FILE++LTR ONLY 50-373 FILE++LTR ONLY ~FI.L&m JULY 50-397 FILE++LTR ONLY 50-410 FIL NRC PDR++LTR ONLY ROCTUR ENG BR++ /2 ENCL Vlf'~M/ I7 CONTAINMENT SYSTEMS4+W/7 ENCL C ANDERSQN4+W/ENCL AD- FOR ENGR~I)/2 ENCL I PELTIER+4W/ENCL ~g ~5yt M D LYNCH++W/ENCL J SNELL~~W/ENCL ~'F

~~g A BOURNIA++W/ENCL W KANE44W/ENCL M Zl S MINER~~W/ENCL D TIBBETTS~+W/ENCL+ /0 DEPUTY DIR DPM++LTR ONLY D VASSALLQ++LTR ONLY LWR02 CHIEF4+LTR ONLY LWR03 CHIEF++LTR OhlLY LWROi CHIEF+~LTR ONLY AD FOR PLANT SYSTEMS++LTR ONLY M RUSHBROQK+<LTR ONLY W PIKE+4LTR ONLY LWR04 CHIEF++LTR ONLY EXTERNAL: LPDR S PORT JEFFERSON-PDR4+LTR ONLY POTTSTQWN I PA-PDR>+LTR ONLY BATAVIA>>OH-PDR+4LTR ONLY CHESTERTON>> IN-PDR++LTR ONLY QGLESBY>> IL-PDR++LTR ONLY RICHLANDiWA-PDR++LTR ONLY OSWEGO>> NY-PDR4+LTR ONLY TERA++LTR ONLY NSIC++LTR ONLY L DREHER W/AFF++LTR ONLY ACRS CAT ~~W/16 EllCL ~'EZ +A~ ~7 DISTRIBUTION: LTR 65 ENCL 37 CONTROL NBR: 781920041 SIZE <P+44P END

NUCLEAR ENERGY P R 0J E CTS 0 I VI S I 0 N GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY, 175 CURTNER AVE., SAN JOSE, CALIFORNIA 95125 MFN-280-78 MC 681, (408) 925-3495 July 7, 1978 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Division of Project Management Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Mashington, D. C. 20555 Attention: Mr. John F. Stolz, Chief Light Mater Reactor Branch No. 1 Gentlemen:

SUBJECT:

MARK II CONTAINMENT PROGRAM LETTER REPORT, "LEAD PLANT CONTAINMENT RESPONSE TO IMPROVED CHUGGING LOAD DEFINITION,"

JUNE 1978 Twenty (20) copies of the subject letter report are being provided by General Electric Company on behalf of the Mark II Owners Group for information as part of the Mark II Containment Supporting Program, Task A. 1S. This letter report provides the results of a comparison of the Mark II containment response to the lead plant 4T Bounding Loads Report chugging load specification with that for an improved load specification based on an impulse chug source at the vent. This com-parison was done for a pre-stress concrete, reinforced concrete, and steel containment to show that the 4T bounding load specification is conservative and suitable for lead plant application. In addition, this study introduces aspects of improvement in this load definition for consideration in subsequent plant evaluations.

The enclosed report contains information which the General Electric Company customarily maintains in confidence and withholds from public disclosure. The information has been handled and classified proprietary by General Electric as indicated in the affidavit submitted with report QW

~~ ~)MQ(341

~

0 Psl

GENERAL '; ELECTRIC J. F. Stol z Page 2 July 7, 1978 NEDE-23617-P by my letter to 0. D. Parr dated August 11, 1977. The request is hereby made that letter report "Lead Plant Containment Response to Improved Chugging Load Definition" be withheld from public disclosure in accordance with 10CFR2.790.

Since this letter report has not been assigned an alpha-numerical identifi-cation and is being provided for your information, we do not intend to submit a non"proprietary version.

Very truly urs, L. J. Sobon, Manager BWR Containment Licensing LJS:sj/251-252 Enclosures cc: C. J. Anderson (NRC)

I. A. Peltier (NRC)

R. L. Tedesco (NRC)

H. Chau (Mk II Owners Group)

H. C. Brinkman (Mark II Owners Group)

L. S. Gifford (GE, Bethesda)

Fi 1 e: 3. 2. 7

0'