ML100910303
| ML100910303 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Fermi  |
| Issue date: | 03/17/2009 |
| From: | Moore C NRC/RGN-III/DRS/OLB |
| To: | Detroit Edison |
| References | |
| Download: ML100910303 (77) | |
Text
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: Fermi 2 Scenario No. 1 Op-Test No: 2009-1 Examiners: C. Moore Operators:
D. Reeser C. Phillips Initial Conditions: IC-99, MOC, 89% Rx. Power Turnover: _ The plant is currently operating at 89% power at MOC following a power reduction for replacement of the #3 LPSV Unitized Actuator. B CRD Pump is out of service for pump rebuild.
Expected return to service is 4 days. Center SAC is NON-PREFERRED USE due to oil leaks on the Compressor. Plans for the shift are to shift GSW pumps to run #6 GSW and shutdown #2 GSW to repair leaks on the discharge strainer. Also the shift is to raise power with flow to 95% and hold to validate Power vs Steam Flow per GOP 22.000.03.
NOTE: The crews Pre-job Briefing for the reactor power increase is to be conducted prior to entering the simulator. (Suggested time 30 minutes prior to beginning the scenario.)
Event Malf. No. Event Event No. Type* Description 1 N/A N(BOP) BOP Transfers GSW Pumps per 23.131 section 4.3. Run #6 N(SRO) GSW and shutdown #2 GSW 2 N/A R(ATC) ATC Raises Recirculation Flow to raise Power to 95% per R(SRO) 22.000.03 C32MF0027 I(ATC) A FW Flow Instrument Failure. ATC shifts to Single 3
Element I(SRO) 4 D11MF0021 N/A A Fuel Pool Radiation Monitor Upscale - SRO enters TS LCO 3.3.6.2 5 T41MF0002 C(BOP) D1 CCHVAC Return Fan Trip - AOP 20.413.01 entered -
C(SRO) SRO enters TS LCO 3.7.3, 3.7.4 - BOP starts D2 CCHVAC P50MF0014 C(BOP) West Station Air Compressor unloads. East Compressor 6
trips on Auto Start. AOP 20.129.01 entered. BOP manually P50MF0017 C(SRO) starts Center Station Air Compressor.
B31MF0066 M(ALL) Small recirculation loop leak in Drywell. ATC places Mode 7
switch in SHUTDOWN due to rising Drywell Pressure. EOP 29.100.01 Sheet 1 and 2 entered 8 C11MF0001 M(ALL) Failure to Scram (ATWS). Rods Stuck and RPS Total Scram Failure. EOP 29.100.01 Sheet 1A entered. BOP inhibits C71MF0006 ADS (CT). ATC performs FSQ 1 thru 8. SRO directs 29.ESP11.
C41MF0003 C(ATC) SRO directs SLC injection. ATC Injects SLC. First Pump 9
C41MF0004 C(SRO) started immediately trips. Second pump started runs. (CT)
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor Appendix D, 38 of 39
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: Fermi 2 Scenario No. 1 Op-Test No: 2009-1 Examiners: C. Moore Operators:
D. Reeser C. Phillips Initial Conditions: IC-99, MOC, 89% Rx. Power NOTE: Continued from page 1 Event Malf. No. Event Event No. Type* Description EOPRF0011 ALL SRO directs 29.ESP.03. ATC manually inserts Control Rods 10 thru per 29.ESP.03(CT) SRO directs 29.ESP.10. ATC resets EOPRF0014 ARI to perform scram-reset-scram per 29.ESP.03. All rods insert when ARI is re-initiated multiple times (twice).
EOPRF0007 ALL SRO directs Terminate and Prevent. BOP performs 11 Terminate and Prevent for Level to lower RPV level <114 EOPRF0010 inches. Maintain RPV level 50 to 100 inches (CT).
12 E51MF0002 C(BOP) RCIC isolates on high exhaust diaphragm pressure. BOP utilizes alternate systems to maintain level.
C(SRO) 13 EABQFU_T C(BOP) BOP initiates Torus Cooling/Torus Sprays. BOP initiates R1CC Drywell Sprays. (CT) E1150-F028A fails during Torus C(SRO)
Cooling Lineup BOP utilizes Division 2 for Containment Cooling
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor Appendix D, 38 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: N/A Page 1 of 20 Event
Description:
_Overview_
Initial Conditions:
The plant is currently operating at 89% power at MOC following a power reduction for replacement of the #3 LPSV Unitized Actuator. B CRD Pump is out of service for pump rebuild. Expected return to service is 4 days. Center SAC is NON-PREFFERED USE due to oil leaks on the compressor. Plans for the shift are to shift GSW pumps to run #6 GSW and shutdown #2 GSW to repair leaks on the discharge strainer. Also the shift is to raise power with flow to 95% and hold to validate power vs steam flow per GOP 22.000.03. Raise power to 92%, then raise at 3% per hour to 95%.
The objectives of this scenario are to:
- 1. Recognize, respond to, and take the required actions for an instrument / equipment failures requiring the use of operator and Tech Spec actions.
- 2. Direct and supervise the Shift team during Normal, Abnormal, and Emergency operations.
- 3. Recognize and respond to A Feedwater Flow Instrument Failure
- 4. Recognize and respond A Fuel Pool Radiation Monitor Failure Upscale
- 5. Recognize and respond to Division 1 CCHVAC Return Fan Trip - AOP 20.413.01
- 6. Recognize and respond to Loss of Station Air - 20.129.01
- 7. Recognize and respond to High Drywell Pressure
- 9. Execute steps of PC Control - 29.100.01 Sheet 2
- 10. Recognize and respond to trip of an SLC Pump
- 11. Manually insert Control Rods per 29.ESP.03
- 12. Recognize and respond to Isolation of RCIC
- 13. Execute steps of Primary Containment Control EOP
- 14. Initiate Torus Cooling, Torus Spray and Drywell Spray using the RHR System
- 15. Recognize and respond to failure of E1150F028A Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 The crew will be required to respond to the following order of events:
- 1. Transfer GSW Pumps
- 2. Raise Recirculation Flow to raise Power to 95%
- 3. A FW Flow Instrument Failure
- 4. A Fuel Pool Radiation Monitor Upscale (TS LCO 3.3.6.2)
- 5. D1 CCHVAC Return Fan Trip (TS LCO 3.7.3, 3.7.4)
- 6. Loss of Station Air Compressors
- 7. Small Recirculation Loop leak in Drywell.
- 8. Failure to Scram (ATWS). Rods Stuck and RPS Total Scram Failure.
- 9. SLC Pump Trip
- 10. RCIC isolates on start at L2
- 11. Crew manually inserts Control Rods
- 12. Failure of E1150F028A
- 13. Crew initiates Torus Cooling/Torus Sprays/Drywell Sprays Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 1 Page 3 of 20 Event
Description:
_Transfer GSW Pumps per 23.131___
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior 0 min SRO
- Acknowledges GSW Pump shift complete BOP
- BOP conducts short Brief on shift of GSW Pumps
ROLE PLAY: Chemistry confirms NPDE requirements will NOT be exceeded.
- BOP contacts Outside Rounds to walkdown and verify #6 GSW Pump ready for start ROLE PLAY: After about 2 min., Outside Rounds reports #6 GSW Pump Ready for Start
- BOP directs Outside Rounds to place Strainer Controller for #6 GSW Pump in CONTINUOUS ROLE PLAY: After about 1 min, Outside Rounds reports #6 GSW Pump Strainer Controller is in CONTINUOUS o BOP makes HI-COM announcement for GSW Pump start
- Crew Update Starting #6GSW Pump, Stopping #2 GSW Pump
- BOP Starts #6 GSW Pump by placing CMC Switch in RUN.
ROLE PLAY: After about 1 min., Outside Rounds reports good start on #6 GSW Pump
- BOP Stops #2 GSW Pump by placing CMC Switch in OFF-RESET o BOP verifies correct system pressure response to pump shift
- BOP directs Outside Rounds to place #6 GSW Pump Strainer Controller in INTERMITTENT ROLE PLAY: After about 1 min., Outside Rounds reports #6 GSW Strainer Controller in INTERMTTENT Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 1 Page 4 of 20 Event
Description:
_Transfer GSW Pumps per 23.131___
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior BOP
- BOP directs Outside Rounds to place #2 GSW Pump Strainer Controller in OFF ROLE PLAY: After about 1 min., Outside Rounds reports #2 GSW Pump Strainer Controller in OFF
- BOP reports pump shift completed Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 2 Page 5 of 20 Event
Description:
_Raise Recirculation Flow to raise Power to 95% per 22.000.03__
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+10 min SRO
- Conducts brief for raising power to 95%
- Directs BOP to monitor and maintain Condensate Filter Demineralizer Flows >2000 GPM
- Directs ATC to maintain Turbine Flow Limiter 5% > Reactor Power.
- Directs ATC to maintain Turbine Speed Load Demand 100 MWe greater than actual.
- Directs ATC to commence raising power with recirculation flow.
o Hi-Com announcement raising reactor power to 95%.
- Crew Update, Raising reactor power with Recirc flow.
- Raises reactor power per SOP 23.138.01, Reactor Recirc System, Section 6.1, by adjusting North and South RR MG Set speeds using B31-R621A and B, N and S RR MG Set Speed Controllers. Speed will be incrementally increased on N and S RR Pumps to achieve about 95% Power o ATC will direct RB Rounds to monitor and maintain RR MG Set Lube Oil Temperatures 110 to 130 degrees F ROLE PLAY: RB Rounds responds to monitor and maintain RR MG Set Lube OIL temperatures110 to 130 degrees F
- Maintains Turbine Flow Limiter 5% > Reactor Power.
- Maintains Turbine Speed Load Demand 100 MWe greater than actual.
- BOP directs Turbine Building Rounds monitor and maintain Condensate Filter Demineralizer Flows >2000 GPM ROLE PLAY: Turbine Building Rounds responds to monitor and maintain Condensate Filter Demineralizer Flows >2000 GPM Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 3 Page 6 of 20 Event
Description:
_A FW Flow Instrument Failure Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+30 min MALFUNCTION - C32MF0027 - A Feed Flow Transmitter Failure SRO
- Acknowledges Alarm 3D164
- Direct shift to Single Element
- Conducts Brief
- Acknowledges DCS in Single Element
- Announces 3D164
- Identifies A Feedwater Flow reading low at 0
- Identifies DCS has shifted to Forced Single Element
- Reviews 3D164 ARPs
- Recommends shifting to Single Element
- Shifts to Single Element
- Reports DCS in Single Element Control o May Note IPCS Heat Balance Affected by Instrument Failure Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 4 Page 7 of 20 Event
Description:
_A Fuel Pool Radiation Monitor Upscale Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
+40 min MALFUNCTION - D11MF0021 - A Fuel Pool Radiation Monitor Failure SRO
- Acknowledges Alarms identified by ATC
- Enters Tech Specs
- LCO 3.3.6.2 (24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br />)
- LCO 3.3.7.1 (Tracking)
- Conducts Brief ATC
- Announces alarms 3D31, 3D35
- Dispatches operator to investigate failure of Fuel Pool Radiation Monitor in the Relay Room ROLE PLAY: Investigate failure of Fuel Pool Radiation Monitor in the Relay Room ROLE PLAY: Reports A Fuel Pool Radiation Monitor reading upscale, all others reading normal BOP
- Checks indication of Fuel Pool Radiation Monitor recorder on back panel
- Reports A Fuel Pool Radiation Monitor reading upscale, all others reading normal Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 5 Page 8 of 20 Event
Description:
_D1 CCHVAC Return Fan Trip Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+40 min MALFUNCTION - T41MF0002 - D1 CCHVAC Return Fan Trip SRO
- Acknowledges Alarm
- Acknowledges Division 1 Return Fan Trip
- Enters AOP 20.413.01
- Conducts AOP Brief
- Directs BOP to start Division 2 CCHVAC
- Enters Tech Specs
- LCO 3.7.3 (7 Days)
- LCO 3.7.4 (30 Days)
- Acknowledges Division 2 CCHVAC BOP
- Announces Motor Tripped Alarm 8D72
- Identifies Division 1 CCHVAC Return Fan Trip
- Dispatches RB Rounds Operator to investigate Trip of Div 1 CCHVAC Return Fan ROLE PLAY: Reactor Building Rounds replies; Investigate trip of Division 1 CCHVAC Return Fan
- Dispatches Operator to check Division 1 CCHVAC Return Fan breaker for cause of trip ROLE PLAY: Investigate Division 1 CCHVAC Return Fan Breaker at 72C-2A-1B
- Informs RB Rounds Starting Division 2 CCHVAC
- Crew Update: Starting Division 2 CCHVAC
- Starts Division 2 CCHVAC using AOP 20.413.01
- Reports Division 2 CCHVAC is running ROLE PLAY: After about 3 min., Reactor Building Rounds reports no obvious cause for trip at D1 CCHVAC Return Fan ROLE PLAY: After about 5 min., Operator reports no obvious cause for trip at 72C-2A-1B Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 6 Page 9 of 20 Event
Description:
West Station Air Compressor Loading Failure, East Station Air Compressor Trip Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+50 min MALFUNCTION - P50MF0014 - West Station Air Compressor Loader Failure MALFUNCTION - P50MF0017 - East Station Air Compressor Trip SRO
- Acknowledges Alarm 7D72
- Acknowledges loading failure report on West Station Air Compressor from BOP
- Acknowledges East Station Air Compressor Trip report from BOP
- Enter AOP 20.129.01 Loss of Station and Control Air
- Conducts AOP Brief
- Directs BOP to start Center Station Air Compressor
- Announces Alarm 7D72
- Reports West Station Air Compressor running unloaded
- Reports trip of East Station Air Compressor
- Directs Turbine Building Rounds to investigate unloader failure on West Station Air Compressor ROLE PLAY: Investigate loading failure on West Station Air Compressor.
- Directs Radwaste Operator to investigate breaker following trip of East Station Air Compressor ROLE PLAY: Investigate trip of East Station Air Compressor. at breaker 72N-4D
- Informs Rounds operator Center Station Air Compressor being started.
- Crew Update: Starting Center Station Air Compressor
- Starts Center Station Air Compressor as directed.
- Reports Station Air Pressure rising Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 6 Page 10 of 20 Event
Description:
West Station Air Compressor Loading Failure, East Station Air Compressor Trip Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
- Completes additional subsequent actions as directed ROLE PLAY: After about 3 min., Turbine Building Rounds reports unknown cause for loading failure on West Station Air Compressor ROLE PLAY: After about 5 min., Radwaste Operator reports Ground Fault, 64 device indicated on 72N-4D breaker.
Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 7 Page 11 of 20 Event
Description:
_High Drywell Pressure Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+60 min MALFUNCTION - B31MF0066 - A Recirc Loop Leak SRO
- Requests Scram Reports o May direct Mode Switch to SHUTDOWN on rising High Drywell Pressure
- Crew Update: Entering EOPs on Failure to Scram and High Drywell Pressure
- Announces Reactor Scram Signal on High Drywell Pressure
- Places Mode Switch in SHUTDOWN
- Identifies/Announces Failure to Scram Condition
- Depresses Manual Scram Pushbuttons
- Provides Scram Report when requested Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 8 Page 12 of 20 Event
Description:
_ATWS (Rods Stuck) /RPS Failure Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+61 min MALFUNCTION - C11MF0001 - ATWS - Rods Stuck MALFUNCTION - C71MF0005 - Total Scram Failure SRO
- Transitions to EOP 29.100.01 Sheet 1A
- Directs ATC to perform FSQ 1 thru 8
- Directs BOP to confirm isolations and actuations for level as they occur
- Directs BOP to maintain pressure 900 to 1050 psig. May expand lower end of band due to leak in drywell.
- SRO acknowledges FSQ-1 thru 8 complete
- ATC performs FSQ 1 thru 8 (Hard Card)
- 1. Confirm Mode Switch in SHUTDOWN
- 2. Confirm RR Flow Runback to Minimum (Hard Card)
- Place or verify A & B Flow Limiter 2/3 Defeat Switch to DEFEAT
- Adjust Setpoint of B31-R621A(B) N(S) RRMG Set Speed Controllers to 30%
- 3. Shutdown RR Pumps
- 4. Confirm ARI - verifies auto initiation or performs manual initiation
- ATC reports FSQ-1 thru 8 is Complete and Reactor Power is %
Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 8 Page 13 of 20 Event
Description:
_ATWS (Rods Stuck) /RPS Failure Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior BOP
- BOP verifies isolations and actuations for level as they occur (Hard Card)
- BOP defeats Drywell Pneumatic Isolation with Keylock Switches on H11 P808 and P817
- BOP reports Drywell Pneumatics bypass and restored and 29.ESP.11 ordered ROLE PLAY: About 10 min after request, install defeats for 29.ESP.11 and report to Control Room that 29.ESP.11 is complete Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 9 Page 14 of 20 Event
Description:
__First SLC Pump started trips/Second Pump starts Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+64 min MALFUNCTION - C41MF0003 - Trip SLC Pump A OR MALFUNCTION - C41MF0004 - Trip SLC Pump B SRO
- Directs SLC Started
- Starts SLC Pump and identifies Pump Trip
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 10 Page 15 of 20 Event
Description:
__Manual Insertion of Control Rods/Scram-Reset-Scram per 29.ESP.03 Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+65 min SRO
- Directs ATC to insert Control Rods using 29.ESP.03
- Contact Tagging Center(Operator outside CR) and directs performance of 29.ESP.10 ROLE PLAY: Tagging Center acknowledges perform 29.ESP.10 ROLE PLAY: About 10 min after request, trigger ESP10 Defeats and report to Control Room that 29.ESP.10 is complete
- Using 29.ESP.03, utilizes one or more of the following to attempt to insert Control Rods:
Raise CRD Hydraulic D/P (section 2.0)
Manual Control Rod Insertion (section 3.0)
Scram-Reset-Scram (section 4.0)
- Attempts to drift rods using section 2.0 Place CRD Flow Controller in MANUAL Starts 2nd CRD Pump Open Flow Control Valve using CRD Flow controller Open C1152-F003 to maximize cooling water flow
- Manually inserts Control Rods (CRITICAL TASK) #
Place CRD Flow Controller in MANUAL Starts 2nd CRD Pump Adjust Flow Controller and C1152-F003 to maintain sufficient D/P for rod motion Place the RWM in Bypass Close C11-F034 if needed to maintain drive D/P
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 10 Page 16 of 20 Event
Description:
__Manual Insertion of Control Rods/Scram-Reset-Scram per 29.ESP.03 Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior ATC Insert the Cram Array Insert rods in checkerboard pattern spiraling out from center. Continue inserting remaining rods spiraling out from center
- Scram Reset and Scram Reinitiation Verify 8 Blue Scram lights are on May re-open C1100-F034 to re-charge accumulators After 29.ESP.10 is complete, reset ARI Verify SDV vent and drain valves are open Allow the SDV to drain (3D94 Clear)
Initiate a manual scram by performing one or both of the following:
Depress four manual scram pushbuttons Arm and depress ARI pushbuttons If Rods move inward, repeat
- Crew Update: All rods in
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 11 Page 17 of 20 Event
Description:
__Terminate and Prevent/Maintain RPV Water Level Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+66 min SRO
- SRO determines that Terminate and Prevent is required. Crew Update We have met the conditions to Terminate and Prevent for Level
- Directs BOP to Terminate and Prevent all injection into the RPV with the exception of Boron, CRD and RCIC
- BOP Acknowledges order to Terminate and Prevent
Maintain level 50 to 100 inches on Wide Range
- BOP performs Terminate and Prevent (Hard Card)
- 1. CS Division 1 Pumps to OFF
- 2. RHR Division 1 Pumps to OFF
- 3. SBFW Pumps to OFF
- 4. CS Division 2 Pumps to OFF
- 5. RHR Division 2 Pumps to OFF
- 7. Crew Update: Lowering RPV Level
- 8. If RFP Running, Lower Speed on both RFP in Manual to close FW Check Valves.
- 9. When RPV Level is less than 114 inches, commence feeding with available sources. (CRITICAL TASK)
- After rods are all in, restores and maintains RPV level 173 to 214 inches using available systems.
Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 12 Page 18 of 20 Event
Description:
___ RCIC isolates on start at L2.
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior MALFUNCTION - E51MF0002 - RCIC Isolation
+68 min SRO
- Identifies RCIC has isolated
- Utilizes SBFW or Feedwater to Maintain RPV Level 50 to 100 inches o May direct investigation by Rounds Operator for cause of RCIC isolation at Testability Cabinets Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 13 Page 19 of 20 Event
Description:
__ Crew initiates Torus Cooling/Torus Sprays/Drywell Sprays Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior MULFUNCTION - EABQFU_TR1CC - E11-F28A Failure Malfunction EABQFU_TR1CC- E11-F028A was not run during this scenario. It was removed during validation because it was not needed and did not add value to the scenario. It was not removed/deleted from this scenario guide by mistake.
70 min SRO
- Acknowledges report on E1150F028A
- Directs BOP to prepare to Spray Drywell
- Directs ATC to shutdown all Drywell Cooling Fans
- Verifies DWSIL Curve (on IPCS)
- Directs BOP to Spray Drywell
- Directs Torus and Drywell Spray override to BOP BOP
- Place Division 1 RHR in Torus Cooling/Torus Spray Lineup (Hard Card
- BOP reports failure of E1150F028A o BOP may direct operator to check breaker at MCC position for E11-F028A (72B-3A-2A)
ROLE PLAY: Investigate failure of E1100-F028A at MCC 72A-3A-2A ROLE PLAY: After about 5 min, reports visual inspection shows no apparent cause for valve failure at MCC 72A-3A-2A
- BOP reports ready to spray Drywell
- BOP sprays Drywell (Hard Card) (CRITICAL TASK)
- BOP monitors Torus/Drywell Pressure
- BOP acknowledges Torus and Drywell Spray Override Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 o BOP stops Torus Sprays if required.
o BOP stops Drywell Sprays if required.
Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 1 Event No.: 13 Page 20 of 20 Event
Description:
__ Crew initiates Torus Cooling/Torus Sprays/Drywell Sprays Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior ATC
- ATC stops all Drywell Cooling Fans
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: Fermi 2 Scenario No. 2 Op-Test No: 2009-1 Examiners: C. Moore Operators:
D. Reeser C. Phillips Initial Conditions: IC-20, MOC, 100% Rx. Power Turnover: _ The plant is currently operating at 100% Power at MOC. The # 6 GSW Pump is out of service for motor replacement. Expected return to service is 4 days. Plans for the shift are to shift MTLO Pumps to South Pump running and North Pump in automatic NOTE: The crews Pre-job Briefing for the reactor power decrease is to be conducted prior to entering the simulator. (Suggested time 30 minutes prior to beginning the scenario.)
Event Malf. No. Event Event No. Type* Description 1 NA N(BOP) BOP Shifts MTLO Pumps per 23.114.01 sect 11.0 N(SRO) 2 C97MF1087 NA Seismic Event. at 0.02g H and V. AOP 20.000.01 entry 3 C11MF0075 C(ATC) CR 06-31 Drifts out of Core. SRO enters AOP 20.106.07.
C(SRO) Control Rod fully inserted and disarmed. SRO enters TS LCO 3.1.3.
4 P43MF0025 C(BOP) Trip of N TBCCW Pump. AOP 20.128.01 entered. BOP C(SRO) start standby pump.
5 C51MF0002 I(ATC) APRM 2 Downscale. ATC bypasses APRM 2. SRO enters I(SRO) TS LCO 3.3.1.1 Tracking LCO 6 BB01B3103 C(ATC) B1 RR Oil Pump Failure. B RRMG Trip. AOP 20.138.01 C001C_MT C(SRO) entry. Loss of HD. BOP evaluates for potential Loss of FSEIZUR Feedwater Heating per AOP 20.107.02.
7 NA R(ATC) ATC Inserts Cram Array <65% power. SRO enters TS LCO R(SRO) 3.4.1 8 C97MF1087 NA Aftershock - Seismic Event. at 0.04g H and V. AOP 20.000.01 entered
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor Appendix D, 38 of 39
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: Fermi 2 Scenario No. 2 Op-Test No: 2009-1 Examiners: C. Moore Operators:
D. Reeser C. Phillips Initial Conditions: __________________________________.
NOTE: Continued from page 1 Event Malf. No. Event Event No. Type* Description 9 B31MF0064 ALL B RR Pump Lower Seal Failure, followed by B RR Pump Upper Seal Failure. Crew identifies slowly rising Drywell B31MF0065 Pressure.
B31MF0066 10 NA M(ALL) ATC places Mode Switch in SHUTDOWN due to rising Drywell Pressure. SRO enters EOP 29.100.01 Sheet 1 and 2.
BOP maintains RPV level and pressure. ATC starts Torus Cooling/Torus Spray. ATC starts Drywell Spray. (CT) 11 B21MF0060 C(BOP) All RPV Level Instrumentation Fails. Crew identifies Loss C(SRO) of RPV level indication. SRO enters 29.100.01 Sheet 3.
B21MF0059 BOP depressurizes RPV and Crew floods RPV to the Main B21MF0073 Steam Lines. (CT)
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor Appendix D, 38 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 2 Event No.: NA Page 1 of 16 Event
Description:
_Overview_
Initial Conditions:
The plant is currently operating at 100% Power at EOC. The # 6 GSW Pump is out of service for motor replacement. Expected return to service is 4 days. Plans for the shift are to shift MTLO Pumps to South Pump running and North Pump in automatic.
The objectives of this scenario are to:
- 1. Recognize, respond to, and take the required actions for an instrument / equipment failures requiring the use of operator and Tech Spec actions.
- 2. Direct and supervise the Shift team during Normal, Abnormal, and Emergency operations.
- 3. Recognize and respond to Seismic Events
- 4. Recognize and respond to Control Rod Drift out of the Core
- 5. Recognize and respond to TBCCW Pump Trip
- 6. Recognize and respond to APRM Downscale
- 7. Recognize and respond to Reactor Recirculation Pump Trip
- 9. Execute steps of EOP 29.100.01, Primary Containment Control Sheet 2
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 The crew will be required to respond to the following order of events:
- 1. Shift MTLO Pumps per SOP 23.114
- 2. Seismic Event
- 3. CR 06-31 Drifts out of the Core (TS LCO 3.1.3)
- 4. Trip of N TBCCW Pump
- 5. APRM 2 Downscale (TS LCO 3.3.1.1)
- 6. B RRMG Set Trip (TS LCO 3.4.1)
- 7. Seismic Event
- 8. RR Pump Seal Failures
- 9. Leak in Drywell
- 10. Loss of all RPV Level Instrumentation Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 2 Event No.: 1 Page 3 of 16 Event
Description:
__ Shift MTLO Pumps per 23.114.01, Section 11.0__
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior 0 min SRO
- Directs BOP to Shift MTLO Pumps per 23.114
- Acknowledge pump shift complete BOP
- Conducts short brief on MTLO Pump Shift per 23.114, section 11.0
- Contacts Turbine Building Rounds that MTLO Pumps will be shifted. Requests check that South MTLO ready for start.
ROLE PLAY: Turbine Building Rounds reports South MTLO Pump ready for start.
o High-Com announcement: Starting South MTLO Pump, shutting down North MTLO Pump.
- Crew Update: Starting S MTLO Pump
- Starts South MTLO Pump ROLE PLAY: Turbine Building Rounds reports good start on South MTLO Pump
- Contacts Turbine Building to check local pump discharge pressure at 60-70 psig ROLE PLAY: Turbine Building rounds report local oil pressure at 65 psig
- Place North MTLO Pump switch in OFF-RESET
- Place North MTLO Pump switch in AUTO
- BOP reports pump shift complete Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 2 Event No.: 2 Page 4 of 16 Event
Description:
_ Seismic Event. at 0.02g H and V.
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+30 min MALFUNCTION - C97MF1087 - 6D69 - Seismic Event/Trouble SRO
- Acknowledges Seismic Event/Trouble alarm
- Acknowledges Power, Pressure and level are stable
- Enters AOP 20.000.01, Earthquake
- SRO acknowledges seismic information
- Conducts AOP Brief
- SRO directs ATC/BOP to monitor parameters
- Monitors plant conditions and announces Power, Pressure and Level are normal
- Monitors parameters as directed BOP
- Announces 6D69 Seismic Event/Trouble Alarm
- Reviews ARP 6D69
- Directs Operator to investigate Seismic event using SOP 23.612 in Relay Room ROLE PLAY: Investigate Seismic Event in Relay Room using SOP 23.612.
ROLE PLAY: After about 2 min, Operator reports seismic information: Event light is ON, ERROR light is OFF, printout shows 0.02g horizontal and 0.02g vertical.
- Monitors parameters as directed
- BOP directs Reactor Building Rounds to reset CCHVAC Purge Compressors ROLE PLAY: Reactor Building Rounds acknowledges reset CCHVAC purge Compressors
Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 2 Event No.: 2 Page 5 of 16 Event
Description:
_ Seismic Event. at 0.02g H and V.
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior ROLE PLAY: Outside Rounds acknowledges starting all MDCT Fans
Reports good start on all fans Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 2 Event No.: 3 Page 6 of 16 Event
Description:
___ CR 06-31 Drifts into Core _
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+31 min MALFUNCTION - C11MF0075 - CR 06-31 Continuous Withdrawal ( 1 min delay) Delete C11MF0075 to allow CR to settle to 00 SRO
- Acknowledges Rod Drift Alarm
- Acknowledges CR 06-31 Drifting out of the core
- Enters AOP 20.106.07, Rod Drift
- Conducts AOP Brief
- Directs ATC to fully insert CR 06-31
- Directs ATC to hydraulically disarm CR 06-31
- Enters Tech Spec 3.1.3 (Condition C - insert - 3 hours3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br />; disarm -
4 hours4.62963e-5 days <br />0.00111 hours <br />6.613757e-6 weeks <br />1.522e-6 months <br />)
- Acknowledges CR 06-31 is hydraulically isolated
- Announces Rod Drift Alarm
- Identifies CR 06-31 drifting out the core
- Drives CR 06-31 fully in using Emergency - IN
- Reports CR 06-31 fully inserted
- Dispatches RB Rounds to HCU 06-31 ROLE PLAY: Go to HCU 06-31 and standby to hydraulically disarm CR 06-31 ROLE PLAY: RB Rounds: Standing by at HCU 06-31
- ATC directs RB Rounds to close C11-F103 at HCU 06-31 ROLE PLAY: Close C11-F103 at HCU 06-31 ROLE PLAY: C11-F103 at HCU 06-31 is closed
- ATC directs RB Rounds to close C11-F105 at HCU 06-31 ROLE PLAY: Close C11-F105 at HCU 06-31 ROLE PLAY: C11-F105 at HCU 06-31 is closed
- Reports to CRS that CR 06-31 is hydraulically isolated Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 2 Event No.: 4 Page 7 of 16 Event
Description:
__ Trip of N TBCCW Pump. _
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+40 min MALFUNCTION - P43MF0025 - North TBCCW Pump Trip SRO
- Acknowledges Trip of North TBCCW Pump
- Enters AOP 20.128.01, Loss of TBCCW
- Conducts AOP Brief
- Directs BOP to Start South TBCCW Pump
- Announces Trip of North TBCCW Pump
- Dispatches TB Rounds Operator to investigate trip of North TBCCW Pump at pump ROLE PLAY: Investigate Trip of North TBCCW Pump
- Informs TB Rounds Operator that South TBCCW Pump will be started ROLE PLAY: Starting South TBCCW Pump
- Starts South TBCCW Pump ROLE PLAY: After about 1 min, TB Rounds reports Good Start on South TBCCW Pump
- Dispatches Operator to investigate breaker for tripped North TBCCW Pump at 72M-2D ROLE PLAY: Investigate trip of North TBCCW Pump at 72M-2D ROLE PLAY: After about 3 min, TB Rounds reports No apparent cause for North TBCCW Pump trip at the pump
- BOP reports South TBCCW Pump running ROLE PLAY: After about 5 min, Operator reports no apparent cause for trip at 72M-2D Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 2 Event No.: 5 Page 8 of 16 Event
Description:
__ APRM 2 Downscale Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+50 min MALFUNCTION - C51MF0002 - APRM 2 Failure SRO
- Acknowledges Alarm 3D98, 3D113
- Enters Tech Spec
- LCO 3.3.1.1 (Tracking LCO)
- LCO 3.3.2.1 (Tracking LCO)
- Conducts Brief ATC
- Announces Alarm 3D98, 3D113
- Identifies Failure of APRM 2 Downscale
- Reviews ARPs
- Identifies applicable TS to SRO
- Dispatches Operator to Relay Room to investigate failure of APRM 2 ROLE PLAY: Investigate failure of APRM 2
- Bypasses APRM 2 per SOP ROLE PLAY: After about 3 min, report from Relay Room, no apparent cause for failure at APRM 2, APRM 2 reading downscale.
All other APRMs reading normal Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 2 Event No.: 6 Page 9 of 16 Event
Description:
___ B1 RR Oil Pump Failure. B RRMG Trip.
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+60 min MALFUNCTION - BB01B3103C001C_MTFSEIZUR - B1 RR Oil Pump Failure SRO
- Acknowledges Trip of B Recirc Pump o Acknowledges B1 RRMG Oil pump trip
- Enters AOP 20.138.01, Crew Update Entering AOP for Recirc Pump Trip o May make Hi-Com announcement for RR Pump Trip
- Directs BOP to validate Feedwater Temperature drop with guidance from AOP 20.107.02, Loss of Feedwater Heating
- Acknowledges Feedwater Temperature change is satisfactory.
o Contact Chemistry and Radiation Protection for power change
- Acknowledges Power > 67.2%
o May Contacts WWM for assistance and follow-up ATC
- Announces Trip of B Recirc Pump
- Evaluates Alarms 3D132, 3D136, and 3D155 o Reports B1 RRMG Oil Pump trip o Reports High RPV Water Level Alarm, RPV level recovering o Directs Reactor Building Rounds to investigate trip of B1 RR Oil Pump ROLE PLAY: Investigate trip of B1 RRMG Oil Pump o Directs operator to investigate Breaker for B1 RRMG Oil Pump at 72E-5D ROLE PLAY: Investigate trip of B1 RRMG Oil Pump at 72E-5D
- Verifies A RRMG set speed is < 75%
- Verifies power < 67.2%
- Reports Power > 67.2%
Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 2 Event No.: 6 Page 10 of 16 Event
Description:
___ B1 RR Oil Pump Failure. B RRMG Trip.
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior ATC
- Verifies 3D129 and places 2/3 Limiter Defeat Switch in DEFEAT
- Closes B3105-F031B
- Reopens B3105-F031B (may be delayed by Cram Array)
- Reports actions complete with exception of lowering power with Cram Array o May monitor LPRMS for instability ROLE PLAY: After about 3 min, report no indications at pump for cause of trip ROLE PLAY: After about 5 min, report no apparent cause for trip at breaker 72E-5D BOP
- Announces Loss of Heater Drains
- Validates Feedwater Temperature drop with guidance from AOP 20.107.02, Loss of Feedwater Heating is consistent with power change
- Reports Feedwater temperature change is consistent with power change Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 2 Event No.: 7 Page 11 of 16 Event
Description:
___ Insert Cram Array <67.2% power Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+65 min SRO
- Directs ATC to insert Cram Array (red cram rods) to <67.2%
- Inserts Cram Array (red cram Rods)
- Reports Cram Array (red cram rods) inserted o If power still greater than 67.2%, may request to insert another group of rods o Inserts another Cram Array group o Reports 3rd rod group inserted, power < 67.2%
Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 2 Event No.: 8 Page 12 of 16 Event
Description:
___ Aftershock - Seismic Event. at 0.04g H and V. _
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+75 min MALFUNCTION - C97MF1087 - 6D69 - Seismic Event/Trouble SRO
- Acknowledges Seismic Event/Trouble alarm
- Acknowledges Power, Pressure and level are stable
- SRO acknowledges seismic information
- Monitors plant conditions and announces Power, Pressure and Level are normal
- Monitors parameters as directed BOP
- Announces 6D69 Seismic Event/Trouble Alarm
- Reviews ARP 6D69
- Directs Operator to investigate Seismic event using SOP 23.612 in Relay Room ROLE PLAY: Investigate Seismic Event in Relay Room using SOP 23.612.
ROLE PLAY: After about 2 min, Operator reports seismic information: Event light is ON, ERROR light is OFF, printout shows 0.04g horizontal and 0.04g vertical.
- Monitors parameters as directed Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 2 Event No.: 9 Page 13 of 16 Event
Description:
___ B RR Pump Seal Failures. Rising Drywell Pressure.
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+80 min MALFUNCTION - B31MF0064 - B RR Pump Outer Seal Failure MALFUNCTION - B31MF0065 - B RR Pump Inner Seal Failure MALFUNCTION - B31MF0066 - A Recirc Loop Leak SRO
- Acknowledges rising Drywell pressure ATC
- Announces Alarm 3D147
- Reports rising pressure on inner seal on RR Pump B
- Reviews ARP
- Announces Alarm 3D145
- Reports lowering pressure on both RR Pump B seals o May attempt B RR Pump isolation per SOP 23.138.01 BOP
- Announces rising Drywell pressure, Crew Update rising Drywell pressure Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 2 Event No.: 10 Page 14 of 16 Event
Description:
_Mode Switch to SHUTDOWN - Rising drywell pressure _
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+85 min SRO
- Directs ATC to place Mode Switch to SHUTDOWN
- Requests Scram Reports
- Crew Update, Entering EOPs on High Drywell Pressure and Level 3
- Directs BOP to Verify Isolations/Actuations for Level as they occur (Hard Card)
- Directs BOP to maintain RPV pressure 900 to 1050 pounds o May lower pressure band due to leak in Drywell
- Crew Update, Entering EOPs on High Drywell Temperature
- Directs ATC to Verify initiation of EECW, isolation of EECW to the drywell, and to restore cooling to CRD.
- Directs ATC to place Division 1 RHR in Torus Cooling and Torus Spray Mode o May direct ATC to close E1150F010
- Verifies within DWSIL (IPCS)
- Directs ATC to shutdown all Drywell Cooling Fans
- Directs ATC to prepare to spray the Drywell
- Directs ATC to spray the Drywell
- Directs Torus and Drywell Pressure Override to ATC (0 psig)
- Places Reactor Mode Switch in SHUTDOWN
- Provides Scram Report
- Verifies initiation of EECW
- Verifies isolation of EECW to the drywell Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 2 Event No.: 10 Page 15 of 16 Event
Description:
_Mode Switch to SHUTDOWN - Rising drywell pressure _
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior ATC
- Restores Cooling to CRD Pumps
- Shutdown Drywell Cooling Fans
- Place Division 1 RHR in Torus Cooling and Torus Spray Mode (Hard Card)
- Starts Division 1 RHRSW (Hard Card) o May close E1150-F010
- Performs lineup to spray the Drywell
- Sprays the drywell when directed by SRO (CRITICAL TASK)
- Stops Torus or Drywell Sprays if override conditions met (0 psig)
- Provides Scram Report
- Restores and maintains RPV water level 173 to 214 inches with available systems
- Verifies isolation and actuations for level as they occur
- Maintains RPV pressure as directed
- Reports when out of Pressure Band Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 2 Event No.: 11 Page 16 of 16 Event
Description:
___ RPV Level Instrumentation Fails. RPV Flooding Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+90 min Malfunction - B21MF0060 - Division 1 Reference Leg Failure (12A)
Malfunction - B21MF0059 - Division 2 Reference Leg Failure (12B)
Malfunction - B21MF0073 - Floodup Level Transmitter Failure SRO
- Acknowledges Loss of all RPV level Indication
- Crew Update: We have met the conditions for RPV Flooding
- Transitions to EOP 29.100.01 Sheet 3
- Directs ATC to bypass and restore Drywell Pneumatics
- Directs BOP to Close MSIVs, Main Steam Drains, RCIC Steam Supply and HPCI Steam Supply Valves
- Directs BOP to Flood the RPV to Main Steam Lines
- Identifies/Verifies Loss of all RPV level Indication
- Bypasses isolation signals with Keylock Switches and opens Drywell Pneumatics Valves if closed BOP
- Identifies/Verifies Loss of all RPV level Indication
- BOP closes MSIVs, Main Steam Drains, RCIC Steam Supply and HPCI Steam Supply Valves
- BOP floods RPV to the Main Steam Lines with available systems as directed by the SRO (CRITICAL TASK)
- BOP directs operator to monitor SRV tailpipe temperatures ROLE PLAY: Monitor SRV Tailpipe Temperatures in the Relay Room ROLE PLAY: After flooding conditions are established, report SRV tailpipe temperatures for the open SRV(s) are 265 degrees and lowering slowly.
Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: Fermi 2 Scenario No. 3 Op-Test No: 2009-1 Examiners: C. Moore Operators:
D. Reeser C. Phillips Initial Conditions: IC-20, MOL, 100% Rx. Power Turnover: _ The plant is currently operating at 100% Power at MOC. South Main Turbine Lube Oil Pump is out of service for motor replacement. Expected return to service is 3 days. Plans for the shift are to shift TBCCW Pumps to South and Center TBCCW running and North TBCCW shutdown. Severe Thunderstorms are forecast throughout the day. Monroe County is under a Severe Thunderstorm Warning until 6PM today.
NOTE: The crews Pre-job Briefing for the reactor power decrease is to be conducted prior to entering the simulator. (Suggested time 30 minutes prior to beginning the scenario.)
Event Malf. No. Event Event No. Type* Description 1 NA N(BOP) BOP Shifts TBCCW Pumps per 23.128 sect 6.0. South and N(SRO) Center Pumps running.
2 D11MF0015 ALL B MSL Radiation Monitor Fails Downscale. SRO enters TS LCOs 3.3.1.1 and 3.3.6.1 P41MF0006 C(BOP) Trip of #2 GSW Pump. AOP 20.131.01 entered. BOP starts 3
a standby pump C(SRO) 4 N21MF0029 C(BOP) Trip of North RFP. RR Runback. Loss of HD. AOP C(SRO) 20.107.01 entered. BOP Injects into RPV with SBFW at 1200 gpm.
NA R(ATC) ATC Inserts Cram Array to <65% Power. BOP shutdown 5
SBFW pumps.
R(SRO) 6 B21MF0023 ALL SRV A spuriously opens. AOP 20.000.25 entered. Fuses for SRV A pulled. SRV closes. SRO enters TS LCO 3.4.3, 3.6.1.6 7 C11MF0004 C(ATC) A CRD FCV fails closed. AOP 20.106.03 entered. ATC C(SRO) shifts to B FCV.
8 B21MF0102 M(ALL) Spurious MSIV Closure. Reactor Scram. EOP entry -
29.100.1 Sheet 1. Loss of HFPs. G SRV sticks partially B21MF0023 open. BOP/ATC restore and maintain RPV level.
NACDN22M 801ATVSP 9 E41MF0005 ALL HPCI isolates upon receipt of start signal at L2. BOP uses alternate injection systems. SBFW F001 fails to fully open.
N21MF0031
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor Appendix D, 38 of 39
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: Fermi 2 Scenario No. 3 Op-Test No: 2009-1 Examiners: C. Moore Operators:
D. Reeser C. Phillips Initial Conditions: IC-20, MOL, 100% Rx. Power NOTE: Continued from page 1 Event Malf. No. Event Event No. Type* Description 10 E51MF0013 C(BOP) RCIC Trip following injection. BOP uses alternate injection C(SRO) systems (CRD, SLC) 11 NA ALL RPV level continues to lower. BOP reports unable to maintain level above TAF. BOP inhibits ADS. (CT)
B21MF0030 M(ALL) EOP entry to 29.100.01 Sheet 3. At TAF, SRO directs ED.
12 BOP attempts to opens 5 ADS SRVs. (CT). H SRV fails C(BOP) to open. BOP opens another SRV.
C(SRO) 13 NA ALL BOP/ATC restores and maintains 173-214 inches with Low Pressure Systems (CT)
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor Appendix D, 38 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 3 Event No.: NA Page 1 of 17 Event
Description:
_Overview_
Initial Conditions:
The plant is currently operating at 100% Power at MOC. South Main Turbine Lube Oil Pump is out of service for motor replacement. Expected return to service is 3 days. Plans for the shift are to shift TBCCW Pumps to South and Center TBCCW running and North TBCCW shutdown. Severe Thunderstorms are forecast throughout the day. Monroe County is under a Severe Thunderstorm Warning until 6PM today.
The objectives of this scenario are to:
- 1. Recognize, respond to, and take the required actions for an instrument / equipment failures requiring the use of operator and Tech Spec actions.
- 2. Direct and supervise the Shift team during Normal, Abnormal, and Emergency operations.
- 3. Recognize and respond to Main Steam Line Radiation Monitor
- 4. Recognize and respond to GSW Pump Trip
- 5. Recognize and respond to Reactor Feedwater Pump Trip
- 6. Recognize and respond to multiple SRV Failures
- 10. Recognize and respond to Loss of Feedwater
- 12. Execute Steps of Emergency Depressurization EOP 29.100.01 Sheet 3 Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 The crew will be required to respond to the following order of events:
- 1. Shift TBCCW pumps per 23.128
- 2. B MSL Radiation Monitor Fails Downscale Failure (TS LCO 3.3.1.1 and 3.3.6.1)
- 3. Trip of #2 GSW Pump
- 8. Loss of Feedwater System
- 10. Emergency Depressurization Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 3 Event No.: 1 Page 3 of 17 Event
Description:
___ Shift TBCCW Pumps per 23.128 sect 6.0__
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior 0 min SRO
- Directs BOP to shift TBCCW Pumps per 23.128
- Acknowledges Pump Shift Complete BOP
- Conducts short brief on shift of TBCCW Pumps
- Contacts Turbine Building Rounds to prepare for shift of TBCCW Pumps ROLE PLAY: Turbine Building Rounds reports South TBCCW Pump ready for start
- Acknowledges South TBCCW Pump ready for start o Makes Plant Announcement for Pump shift
- Contacts Turbine Building Rounds to inform of imminent start of S TBCCW Pump ROLE PLAY: Turbine Building Rounds acknowledges start of South TBCCW Pump
- Starts South TBCCW Pumps and stops North TBCCW Pump
- Monitors pressures, D/P Control Valve response and temperature to verify correct response.
ROLE PLAY: Turbine Building Rounds reports Good Start on South TBCCW Pump
- Acknowledges Turbine Building Rounds on satisfactory start on NSouth TBCCW Pump
- Informs SRO TBCCW Pump shift is complete Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 3 Event No.: 2 Page 4 of 17 Event
Description:
___ B MSL Radiation Monitor Fails Downscale _
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+10 min MALFUNCTION - D11MF0015 - B MSL Radiation Monitor Fails Downscale SRO
- Acknowledges Alarm 3D84
- Conducts Brief
- Enters Tech Spec
- LCO 3.3.6.1 (12 Hours)
- LCO 3.3.1.1 (12 Hours) o May Contact WWM for assistance and follow-up ATC
- Announces Alarm 3D84
- Dispatches Operator to Check MSL Radiation Monitors in Relay Room ROLE PLAY: Investigate MSL Radiation Monitors in the Relay Room.
ROLE PLAY: Operator reports No apparent cause for B MSL Radiation Monitor failure. MSL B radiation Monitor reading downscale. All other monitors reading normal.
- Checks MSL Radiation Monitor Recorder Indications on back on H11-P601
- Reports MSL Radiation Monitor B reading downscale.
Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 3 Event No.: 3 Page 5 of 17 Event
Description:
___ Trip of #2 GSW Pump. _
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+20 min MALFUNCTION - P41MF0006 - Trip of #2 GSW Pump SRO
- Acknowledges report of #2 GSW Pump Trip
- Crew Update Entering AOP for Loss of GSW
- Enters AOP 20.131.01, Loss of GSW
- Conducts AOP Brief
- Directs BOP to start available GSW Pump
- Acknowledges indicated cause of pump trip o May request follow-up by Tagging Center/WWM BOP
- Announces Motor Tripped Alarm 7D72
- Announces Trip of #2 GSW Pump
- Directs Outside Rounds to investigate trip of #2 GSW Pump at pump and breaker ROLE PLAY: Outside Rounds Operator acknowledges investigate Trip of Number 2 GSW Pump
- Starts available GSW Pump o Makes plant announcement for start of GSW Pump
- Contacts Outside Rounds Operator to inform that GSW Pump has been started.
- Monitors GSW pressure to ensure correct system response to pump start ROLE PLAY: Outside Rounds reports, Good start on Number ?
GSW Pump
- Acknowledges good start on GSW start
- Checks indicated GSW intake level indication ROLE PLAY: Outside Rounds reports, 64 Device tripped on Number 2 GSW Pump Breaker
- Reports indicated cause of #2 GSW Pump trip to SRO Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 3 Event No.: 4 Page 6 of 17 Event
Description:
___ Trip of North RFP. RR Runback _
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+30 min MALFUNCTION - N21MF0029 - Trip of North RFP SRO o Crew Update: Trip of North RFP
- Conducts AOP Brief
- Directs BOP to start SBFW and inject at 1200 GPM
- Acknowledges SBFW injecting at 1200 GPM
- Monitors Power, Pressure and Level
- Announces RPV level is recovering BOP o Crew Update: Trip of North RFP o May direct operator to investigate potential cause of North RFP trip
- Starts SBFW using Hard Card Start West and East Aux Oil Pumps Start West and East Standby Feedwater Pumps Verify N2103-F001, SBFW Disch. Valve automatically opens Throttle open N2103-F002, SBFW Flow Control Valve until desired flow is achieved
- Reports SBFW injecting at 1200 GPM
- Reviews ARPs for applicable alarms
- Shuts down SBFW as directed using Hard Card Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 3 Event No.: 5 Page 7 of 17 Event
Description:
___ Insert Cram Array to <65% Power ___
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+ 35 min SRO
- Directs ATC to insert Cram Array
- Inserts Cram Array (red cram Rods)
- Reports Cram Array (red cram rods) inserted
- Reports power still >65%
- Insert another Cram Array group
- Reports 3rd rod group inserted Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 3 Event No.: 6 Page 8 of 17 Event
Description:
___ SRV A spuriously opens. __
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+45 min MALFUNCTION - B21MF0023 - SRV A Failure SRO
- Acknowledges Alarm and open SRV
- Conducts AOP Brief
- SRO acknowledges SRV indications o Directs BOP to Start RHR in Torus Cooling o May inform Crew of impending Plant Shutdown per AOP
- Enters Tech Spec
- LCO 3.4.3 (Tracking LCO)
- LCO 3.6.1.6 (14 days)
- Announces 1D61, SRV Open Alarm
- Identifies Open SRV
- Attempts to Open and attempts to close SRV A
- Reports SRV will not close
- Requests Tagging Center send Operator to Relay Room to pull fuses for SRV per Enclosure A in AOP 20.000.25 ROLE PLAY: Send Operator to Relay Room to pull fuse for SRV A per Enclosure A in AOP ROLE PLAY: After about 3 min, call CR on phone and report standing by to pull fuses for SRV A
- Crew Update Pulling fuses on SRV A
- Directs operator to pull fuses on SRV A
- Reports indication lost on SRV A after fuses are pulled ROLE PLAY: After about 3 min, contact CR on phone and report fuses pulled on SRV A Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 3 Event No.: 6 Page 9 of 17 Event
Description:
___ SRV A spuriously opens. __
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior o May direct operator to monitor SRV A tailpipe temperature in Relay Room o Start RHR in Torus Cooling per SOP 23.205 ATC
- Reports Steam Flow - Feed Flow mismatch returned to original value o May report MW returned to original value Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 3 Event No.: 7 Page 10 of 17 Event
Description:
__ CRD A Flow Control Valve Fails Closed Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+55 min MALFUNCTION - C11MF004 - A CRD Flow Control Valve Failure SRO
- Acknowledges Alarm
- Conducts AOP Brief
- Announces Alarm 3D13
- Dispatches operator to investigate failure of A FCV ROLE PLAY: Investigate failure of A FCV ROLE PLAY: After about 2 min, report no apparent cause for A FCV failure
- Directs operator to check CRDM temperatures in Relay Room ROLE PLAY: - Check CRDM temperatures in the Relay Room
- Directs operator to place C11-K009A flow controller in MANUAL ROLE PLAY: Place C11-K009A in MANUAL ROLE PLAY: C11-K009A is in MANUAL
- Directs operator to rotate Valve Control Knob for failed FCV until valve indicates closed ROLE PLAY: Rotate Valve Control Knob for failed FCV until valve indicates closed Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 3 Event No.: 7 Page 11 of 17 Event
Description:
__ CRD A Flow Control Valve Fails Closed Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior ATC ROLE PLAY: A FCV indicates closed
- Directs operator to verify standby FCV in Manual and output set to minimum ROLE PLAY: Verify standby FCV in Manual and output set to minimum ROLE PLAY: Standby FCV is in Manual and output is set to minimum
- Directs Operator to open C1100-F046B and F047B ROLE PLAY: Open C1100-F46B and F047B ROLE PLAY: C1100-F046B and F047B are open
- Set C11K612 to MANUAL and set to minimum
- Directs operator to place C11-K009B in AUTOMATIC ROLE PLAY: Place C11-K009B in Automatic ROLE PLAY: C11-K009B is in AUTOMATIC
- Directs operator to close C1100-F046A and F047A ROLE PLAY: Close C1100-F046A and F047A ROLE PLAY: C1100-F046A and F047A are closed
- Increase flow with CRD flow Controller to 63 GPM and place controller in AUTO
- Monitors plant during Flow Control Valve shift Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 3 Event No.: 8 Page 12 of 17 Event
Description:
___ Spurious MSIV Closure. Reactor Scram _
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+65 min MALFUNCTION - B21MF0009 - 00012 - Inboard MSIV Closures MALFUNCTION - NACDN22M801ATVSP - Condenser Pumps Trip MALFUNCTION - B21MF0029 - SRV G Failure SRO
- Directs crew to prepare Scram reports
- Completes Scram Reports
- Enters EOP 29.100.01 Sheet 1
- Directs BOP verify isolations and actuations for level as they occur
- Announces Reactor Scram
- Places Mode Switch in SHUTDOWN
- Gives Scram Report
- Gives Scram Report
- Verifies isolations and actuations for level as they occur
- Monitors and maintains RPV pressure 900 to 1050 psig using Low
-Low Set
- Attempts to maintain RPV Level 173 to 214 inches o May identify G SRV open Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 3 Event No.: 9 Page 13 of 17 Event
Description:
HPCI isolates on start signal at L2. SBFW N2103F001 fails to fully open.
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+70 min MALFUNCTION - E41MF0005 - Spurious HPCI Isolation MALFUNCTION - N21MF0031 - SBFW N2103F001 Failure SRO
- Acknowledges HPCI Isolation/unavailable
- Acknowledge SBFW N2103-F001 not full open BOP
- Identifies HPCI isolation
- Use other systems for RPV Injection
- Reports cannot restore and maintain 173 to 214 inches
- Attempts to maintain RPV level 0 to 214 inches o May direct Rounds Operator to investigate cause of HPCI isolation o May attempt to start tripped Condenser Pumps
- Identifies SBFW F001 valve not full open and providing limited flow
- Directs operator to investigate N2103-F001 Valve on SBFW ROLE PLAY: Investigate failure of SBFW N2103-F001 ROLE PLAY: After about 3 minutes, report N2103-F001 partially open
- Directs Operator to manually open N2103-F001 ROLE PLAY: Manually open N2103-F001 ROLE PLAY: After about 5 min, report handwheel on N2103-F001 will not turn, need help from Maintenance Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 3 Event No.: 10 Page 14 of 17 Event
Description:
_ RCIC Turbine Trip._
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+75 min MALFUNCTION - E51MF0013 - RCIC Turbine Trip SRO
- Acknowledges RCIC Trip
- Acknowledges SLC Pump started
- Reports RCIC has tripped
- Directs operator to investigate RCIC for cause of Trip ROLE PLAY: Investigate RCIC for cause of trip ROLE PLAY: After about 5 minutes, report no apparent cause for trip of RCIC ATC
- Start SLC A or B Pump
- Reports SLC Pump started
- Reports 2nd CRD Pump started Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 3 Event No.: 11 Page 15 of 17 Event
Description:
_RPV level continues to lower. Inhibit ADS_
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior SRO
- Acknowledges cannot maintain level above TAF
- Conducts brief for Emergency Depressurization BOP
- Reports cannot maintain level above TAF
- Reports level at Level 1, and auto start of RHR and Core Spray Pumps.
Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 3 Event No.: 12 Page 16 of 17 Event
Description:
_Emergency Depressurization__
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior MALFUNCTION - B21MF0030 - H SRV Failure SRO
- Transitions to EOP 29.100.01 Sheet 3
- Directs ATC to restore Drywell Pneumatics
- Monitors RPV Level
- Reports RPV Level at Top of Active Fuel
- Opens additional SRV(CRITICAL TASK)
- After 461#, Reactor Low Pressure Alarm, reports Low pressure systems aligning for injection ATC
- Monitors RPV level
- Restores Drywell Pneumatics Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 3 Event No.: 13 Page 17 of 17 Event
Description:
_Restore and Maintain RPV Level 173 to 214 inches__
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior SRO
- Directs BOP/ATC to restore and maintain RPV level 173 to 214 inches
- Directs BOP to coordinate level restoration
- Acknowledges Level in Band
- Directs ATC to close E1150-F010 valve
- Acknowledges maintain RPV level 173 to 214 inches
- Reports RPV injection from Core Spray and RHR pumps
- Directs ATC to shutdown pumps as needed
- Directs ATC to throttle flow as needed
- Shuts down pumps as needed
- Throttles flow as needed
- Shuts down Pumps as directed
- Throttles flow as directed.
- Closes E1150-F010 Valve
- Starts Division 1 RHR in Torus Cooling/Torus Spray Mode Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: Fermi 2 Scenario No. 4 Op-Test No: 2009-1 Examiners: C. Moore Operators:
D. Reeser C. Phillips Initial Conditions: IC-20, MOC, 100% Rx. Power Turnover: _ The plant is currently operating at 100% Power at MOC. The Center Heater Drain Pump is out of service for pump rebuild. Expected return to service is 5 days. Plans for the shift are to shutdown Division 1 RHRSW Pumps following Biocide Injection. Grid load is very high due to abnormally high outside air temperatures. SOC has requested plant maintain maximum generation.
NOTE: The crews Pre-job Briefing is to be conducted prior to entering the simulator. (Suggested time 30 minutes prior to beginning the scenario.)
Event Malf. No. Event Event No. Type* Description 1 NA N(BOP) BOP shuts down Division 1 RHRSW following Biocide N(SRO) Injection per 23.208 2 P42MF0005 C(BOP) Trip of Center RBCCW Pump. AOP 20.127.01. BOP starts C(SRO) standby Pumps and restores D1/D2 EECW to standby 3 C51MF0003 I(ATC) APRM 3 Upscale to 120%. ATC Bypasses APRM 3. TS I(SRO) LCO 3.3.1.1 Tracking LCO 4 NC04LS_L ALL Problem with 6S FW Heater level transmitter causes High XPN436BZ Level signal resulting in Extraction Steam Valve closure.
SOUT MCC position trips when attempt made to re-open valve.
N30RF0030 NA R(ATC) Loss of FW Heating due to 6S Heater problem. AOP 5
20.107.02 entry. Power increase from FW temperature R(SRO) decrease. SRO directs power reduction. Rod insertion or flow decrease to lower power by ATC 6 C11MF1116 C(ATC) Shaft Shear on A CRD Pump. AOP 20.106.01 entry. ATC C(SRO) starts B CRD Pump E41MF0010 I(BOP) Spurious start on HPCI. BOP shuts down HPCI. SRO enters 7
TS LCO 3.5.1. BOP Verifies RCIC Operable.
I(SRO)
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor Appendix D, 38 of 39
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: Fermi 2 Scenario No. 4 Op-Test No: 2009-1 Examiners: C. Moore Operators:
D. Reeser C. Phillips Initial Conditions: IC-20, MOC, 100% Rx. Power NOTE: Continued from page 1 Event Malf. No. Event Event No. Type* Description 8 E41MF0007 C(BOP) Steam leak on HPCI. SRO enters EOP 29.100.01 Sheet 5 HPCI fails to isolate, E41F002 Fuse Blows and E41F600 E4AHCLOS C(SRO) fails to operate. Rounds replaces fuse in E41F002 after ED ETVSP and valve closes isolating leak.
E4AQFU_T R1CC 9 NA M(ALL) SRO directs Manual Scram before MSO in HPCI Room ATC places Mode Switch in Shutdown. (CT) SRO enters EOP 29.100.01 Sheet 1. BOP/ATC restores and maintains RPV level 173 to 214 inches.
TA20TEN42 M(ALL) Rising temperature in SE Core Spray Pump Room exceeds 10 5ZSOUT MSO requiring ED. SRO enters EOP 29.100.01 Sheet 3 and directs ED (CT). BOP opens 5 ADS SRVs. BOP/ATC TA20TEN20 maintain RPV level. All room temps trend down.
6ZSOUT
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor Appendix D, 38 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 4 Event No.: NA Page 1 of 15 Event
Description:
_Overview_
Initial Conditions:
The plant is currently operating at 100% Power at MOC. The Center Heater Drain Pump is out of service for pump rebuild. Expected return to service is 5 days. Plans for the shift are to shutdown Division 1 RHRSW Pumps following Biocide Injection. Grid load is very high due to abnormally high outside air temperatures.
The objectives of this scenario are to:
- 1. Recognize, respond to, and take the required actions for an instrument / equipment failures requiring the use of operator and Tech Spec actions.
- 2. Direct and supervise the Shift team during Normal, Abnormal, and Emergency operations.
- 3. Recognize and Respond to RBCCW Pump Trip
- 4. Recognize and Respond to APRM Failure
- 5. Recognize and Respond to CRD Pump Failure
- 6. Recognize and respond to Spurious Start of HPCI
- 7. Recognize and respond to Steam Leak in Reactor Building
- 8. Execute steps of Secondary Containment Control EOP 29.100.01 Sheet 5
- 10. Execute steps of Emergency Depressurization EOP 29.100.01 Sheet 3 The crew will be required to respond to the following order of events:
- 1. Shutdown Division 1 RHRSW Pumps
- 2. Trip of Center RBCCW Pump
- 3. APRM 3 Failure to 120% (TS LCO 3.3.1.1)
- 4. 6S Feedwater Heater Level Transmitter Failure
- 5. Loss of Feedwater Heating
- 6. CRD Pump Failure
- 8. Unisolable Steam Leak in Reactor Building
- 10. Emergency Depressurization for 2 temperatures > MSO Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 4 Event No.: 1 Page 2 of 15 Event
Description:
__ Shutdown D1 RHRSW Pumps __
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior 0 min SRO
- Acknowledges pump shutdown complete BOP
- Conducts short brief for RHRSW Pump shutdown per 23.208 section 8.1
- Informs Reactor Building Rounds that Division 1 RHRSW are being shutdown ROLE PLAY: Shutting Down Division 1 RHRSW Pumps
- Directs Reactor Building Rounds to stop Division1 RHRSW Radiation Monitor Sample Pump ROLE PLAY: Stop Division 1 RHRSW Radiation Monitor Sample Pump ROLE PLAY: After about 1 min, report Division 1 RHRSW Radiation Monitor Sample Pump is shutdown.
- Crew Update:, Shutting down Division 1 RHRSW Pumps
- Depress CLOSE Pushbutton on E1150-F068A
- When flow indicates approximately 5500 GPM:
o Shutdown RHRSW Pump A o Shutdown RHRSW Pump C
- Verify E1150-F068A fully closes
- Reports Division 1 RHRSW Pumps shutdown.
Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 4 Event No.: 2 Page 3 of 15 Event
Description:
___ Trip of Center RBCCW Pump. _
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+10 min MALFUNCTION - P42MF0005 - Trip of Center RBCCW Pump SRO
- Acknowledges trip of Center RBCCW Pump
- Conducts AOP Brief
- Directs BOP to perform Attachment 1 of 20.127.01
- Directs BOP to place EECW/EESW in standby
- Acknowledges overload condition at 72F-2D
- Reports trip of Center RBCCW Pump
- Verifies Division 1 and 2 EECW Auto starts
- Dispatch Operator to check Center RBCCW Pump for cause of trip.
ROLE PLAY: Check Center RBCCW Pump for cause of pump trip.
- Dispatch Operator to check breaker for Center RBCCW Pump at 72F - 2D ROLE PLAY: Check Center RBCCW Pump Breaker at 72F-2D for cause of pump trip.
ROLE PLAY: Starting South RBCCW Pump
- Starts South RBCCW Pump ROLE PLAY: RB Rounds reports, Good Start on South RBCCW Pump ROLE PLAY: After about 5 min, Operator reports, No apparent cause for trip at Center RBCCW Pump ROLE PLAY: After about 5 min, Operator reports, At 72F-2D, Center RBCCW Pump, have an overload flag showing on breaker.
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 4 Event No.: 2 Page 4 of 15 Event
Description:
___ Trip of Center RBCCW Pump. _
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior BOP
- Performs Attachment 1 of 20.127.01(Verifies Valve Lineup)
- Depress RESET Pushbutton
- Open P44-F604 (CRD Supply)
- Places Div 1 EECW/EESW in standby per SOP 23.127
- Depress RESET pushbutton for Div 1 EECW
- Verify white EMERGENCY MODE light goes OFF
- Close P4400-F602A, Div 1 EECW Makeup Tnk Iso Vlv.
- Open P4400-F603A, Div 1 EECW Supply Iso Vlv.
- Open P4400-F601A, Div 1 EECW Return Iso Vlv.
- Stop P4400-C001A, Div 1 EECW Pump and place in AUTO
- Place P44-K800A, Div 1 EECW Hx Temp Ctrlr, in MANUAL.
- Adjust P44-K800A, Div 1 EECW Hx Temp Ctrlr, until flow is less than or equal to 50% on P45-R803A, Div 1 EESW Flow Ind.
- Place P4500-C002A, Div 1 EESW Pump, in OFF/RESET.
- Place P44-K800A, Div 1 EECW Hx Temp Ctrlr, in AUTO.
- Place P4500-C002A, Div 1 EESW Pump, CMC Switch in AUTO.
- Open P4400-F613, Div 1 EECW To Batt Rms A/C Iso
- Open P4400-F614, Div 1 EECW To Penet Clrs Iso
- Locally reset T4100-B033 Battery Rooms AC Unit Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 4 Event No.: 2 Page 5 of 15 Event
Description:
___ Trip of Center RBCCW Pump. _
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior BOP
- Places Div 2 EECW/EESW in standby per SOP 23.127
- Depress Isolation Valves RESET pushbutton for Div 2 EECW.
- Verify white EMERGENCY MODE light goes OFF.
- Close P4400-F602B, Div 2 EECW Makeup Tnk Iso Vlv.
- Open P4400-F603B, Div 2 EECW Supply Iso Vlv.
- Open P4400-F601B, Div 2 EECW Return Iso Vlv.
- Stop P4400-C001B, Div 2 EECW Pump.
- Place P4400-C001B, Div 2 EECW Pump, CMC Switch in AUTO.
- Place P44-K800B, Div 2 EECW Hx Temp Ctrlr, in MANUAL.
- Adjust P44-K800B, Div 2 EECW Hx Temp Ctrlr, until flow is less than or equal to 50% on P45-R803B, Div 2 EESW Flow Ind.
- Place P4500-C002B, Div 2 EESW Pump, in OFF/RESET.
- Place P44-K800B, Div 2 EECW Hx Temp Ctrlr, in AUTO.
- Place P4500-C002B, Div 2 EESW Pump, CMC Switch in AUTO.
- Informs SRO that EECW/EESW back in Standby Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 4 Event No.: 3 Page 6 of 15 Event
Description:
__ APRM 3 Upscale to 120%. _
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+25 min MALFUNCTION - C51MF0003 - APRM 3 Failure SRO o May acknowledge Alarms 3D97, 3D101, 3D102, 3D113
- Acknowledges APRM failure
- Enters Tech Spec LCO 3.3.1.1 (Tracking LCO)
- Reports APRM 3 Failure
- Directs Operator to Relay Room to check APRM 3 ROLE PLAY: Investigate failure of APRM 3 in the Relay Room
- Reviews applicable ARPs
- Bypass APRM 3 ROLE PLAY: After about 3 min, (by telephone) report no apparent cause for APRM 3 failure Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 4 Event No.: 4 Page 7 of 15 Event
Description:
___6S Feedwater Heater Level Transmitter Failure _
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+30 min MALFUNCTION - NC04LS_LXPN436BZSOUT - 6S FW Heater Level Transmitter MALFUNCTION - N30RF0030 - N3016F614 Breaker Trip SRO
- Acknowledge 6S Heater High level Alarm
- Acknowledge Lowering Feedwater Temperature o Acknowledge Heater 6S Emergency Drain open
- Acknowledge rising reactor power BOP
- Announce 6S Heater High Level Alarm
- Report Extraction Steam Valve to 6S Heater closing o Report Heater 6S Emergency Drain Valve open
- Report rising reactor power Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 4 Event No.: 5 Page 8 of 15 Event
Description:
__Loss of Feedwater Heating _
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+40 min SRO
- Conducts AOP brief
- Directs ATC to reduce power by performing Subsequent Action A1 of 20.107.02
- Reports power at about 103%
- Lowers power by lowering Core Flow on both RRMG sets
- Lowers power by insert Cram Array rods
- Validates Feedwater Temperature reduction per subsequent Action A2 of 20.107.02 (Enclosure A)
- Reports Feedwater Temperature is in acceptable range Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 4 Event No.: 6 Page 9 of 15 Event
Description:
__Shaft Shear on A CRD Pump__
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+50 min MALFUNCTION - C11MF1117 - Shaft Shear on B CRD Pump SRO
- Acknowledges Alarm 3D5
- Acknowledges problem with A CRD Pump
- Conducts AOP Brief
- Directs ATC to perform Subsequent Action A of 20.106.01
- Acknowledges Alarm 3D13
- Acknowledge B CRD Pump running
- Announces Alarm 3D5
- Identifies problem with A CRD Pump
- Dispatches Reactor Building Rounds Operator to check A CRD Pump.
ROLE PLAY: Investigate A CRD Pump and verify B CRD Pump ready for start
- Places CRD Flow Controller in MANUAL and closes Flow Control valve
- Close Pressure Control Valve C1152-F003
- Announces Alarm 3D13
- Dispatches operator to check temperature on CRD mechanisms in Relay Room.
ROLE PLAY: Check CRDM Temperatures in Relay Room.
Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 4 Event No.: 6 Page 10 of 15 Event
Description:
__Shaft Shear on B CRD Pump__
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior ATC ROLE PLAY: After about 3 min, Operator reports B CRD Pump ready for start. Reports motor running on A CRD Pump, but pump not rotating.
- Provide reports from field to SRO
- Starts B CRD Pump
- Adjusts CRD flow and pressure as required and places CRD Flow Controller in AUTO ROLE PLAY: After about 1 min, report good start on B CRD Pump
- Report B CRD Pump running
- Shuts down A CRD Pump ROLE PLAY: After about 5 min and after B CRD Pump start, report (by telephone),1 CRDM Alarmed, 34-31. Highest temperature was 260 F and now lowering. Acknowledging alarm to clear CR annunciator.
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 4 Event No.: 7 Page 11 of 15 Event
Description:
__Spurious Start of High Pressure Coolant Injection System__
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+60 min MALFUNCTION - E41MF0010 - Spurious Start on HPCI SRO
- Acknowledge Alarm 2D28
- Acknowledge HPCI start
- Acknowledges invalid start signal on HPCI
- Acknowledges HPCI is shutdown o Conducts Brief
- Announces Alarm 2D28
- Announces HPCI is initiating
- Shuts down HPCI using Hard Card
- Reports HPCI is shutdown
- Verifies RCIC is operable using SOP 23.206 o May direct operator to Testability Cabinets to investigate for any initiation signals ATC
- Monitors Reactor Power
- Monitors RPV Level Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 4 Event No.: 8 Page 12 of 15 Event
Description:
__Steam Leak on HPCI - Sec Cont EOP Entry__
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+65 min MALFUNCTION - E41MF0010 - HPCI Steam Leak SRO
- Acknowledges Alarm 3D34, 1D66, 16D27
- Enters EOP 29.100.01 Sheet 5, Crew Update, entering EOP on Secondary Containment temperature
- Announces Alarm 3D34 BOP
- Announces Alarm 1D66
- Announces Fire Alarm 16D27 - Zone 4
- Reports automatic isolation of HPCI has failed after 2D49 and 2D53
- Attempts to isolates HPCI by closing E4150-F002 and/or E4150-F600
- Reports E4150-F600 failed to operate
- Reports E4150-F002 MCC position tripped
- Directs Operator to check MCC position for E4150-F002 at 72C-3A-4A ROLE PLAY: Check MCC for E4150-F002 at 72C-3A-4A ( continued to next event)
Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 4 Event No.: 9 Page 13 of 15 Event
Description:
__Manual Scram - RPV Control EOP Entry Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+70 Min SRO
- Conducts EOP Brief
- Request Scram Reports
- Directs BOP to verify isolations and actuations for level as they occur
- Places Mode Switch in SHUTDOWN before MSO (CRITICAL TASK)
- Provides Scram Report
- Provides Scram Report
- Verifies isolations and actuations for level as they occur
- Restores and maintains RPV level 173 to 214 inches with available systems
- Maintain RPV pressure 900 to 1050 psig with Bypass Valves ROLE PLAY: After about 5 min, report no indications of problem at 72C-3A-4A after visual inspection. Request permission to open door and check fuses.
- Directs operator to open door on MCC ands check fuses at 72C-3A-4A ROLE PLAY: Open door and check fuses at 72C-3A-4A Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 4 Event No.: 10 Page 14 of 15 Event
Description:
__Second Temp > MSO - Emergency Depressurization Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior
+75 min MALFUNCTION - TA20TEN206ZSOUT - CS Pump Room Temperature SRO
- Announces rising temperatures in Southeast Core Spray Pump Room
- Conducts Emergency Depressurization Brief
- Enters 29.100.01 Sheet 3
- Directs BOP to Prevent injection from pumps not required for ACC o May anticipate ED and direct BOP to fully open Turbine Bypass Valves
- Directs ATC to restore Drywell pneumatics
- Identifies in IPCS that room temperatures are lowering
- Crew Update: Room temperatures in Reactor Building are lowering ATC
- Restores Drywell Pneumatics
- Assist with RPV level control
- Start Division 1 RHR in Torus Cooling (HARD CARD)
Appendix D, Page 39 of 39
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 2009-1 Scenario No.: 4 Event No.: 10 Page 15 of 15 Event
Description:
__Second Temp > MSO - Emergency Depressurization Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior BOP
- Shuts down all RHR and CS pumps o Fully open Turbine Bypass Valves (Anticipate ED)
- Maintains RPV level 173 to 214 inches with FW and/or SBFW ROLE PLAY: After ED in progress, report that fuses at 72C-3A-4A were blown, new fuses have been obtained and installed, ready to close breaker for E4150-F002
- Directs operator to re-energize E4150-F002 ROLE PLAY: Operator reports breaker closed for E4150-F002
- Identifies E4150-F002 energized and closing
- Reports to SRO that E4150-F002 closed Appendix D, Page 39 of 39