ML070120196

Requests for Additional Information Regarding the Review of the License Renewal Application for James A. FitzPatrick Nuclear Power Plant

ML070120196
Person / Time
Site:	FitzPatrick
Issue date:	01/19/2007
From:	Le N NRC/NRR/ADRO/DLR/RLRB
To:	Peter Dietrich Entergy Nuclear Operations
Le, Ngoc, NRR/DLR/RLRB, 415-1458
References
TAC MD2666
Download: ML070120196 (9)

Text

Jan uary 19 , 20 07 M r. P eter T. Di etri ch

S i te V i ce P re si d e n tJa me s A. F i tz P a tr i ck N u cl e a r P o w e r P l a n tE n te rgy N u cl e a r Op e ra ti o n , In c.P.O. B ox 11 0Ly comi ng, NY 130 93-011 0

SUBJECT:

REQUEST S FOR ADDIT IO NAL INFO RM AT IO N REGARDING THE REVIEW OF THE LICENSE RENEW AL APPLICAT IO N FOR JAM ES A. FIT ZPAT RICK NU CL EA R POW ER P LA NT (TAC N O. M D2 666)By l etter date d J ul y 31 , 20 06, En tergy N ucl ear Operati ons , Inc., su bmi tted an app li cati on purs uan t to Titl e 1 0 C ode of Fe dera l Re gula tio ns (CF R) Pa rt 54 , to rene w the op erati ng l ic ens e for Ja me s A. F i tz P a tr i ck N u cl e a r P o w e r P l a n t for re v i e w b y t h e U.S. N u cl e a r R e gul a to ry Co mmissi on (NR C). The NR C staff i s re v ie w in g the in f ormati on con tai ned i n th e l ic ens e rene w al appli cat ion and has identif ied, in the enclosur e, an are a w here additional inf orm ation is n e e d e d t o c o mp l e te t h e r e v i e w. Ba sed on di scu ssi ons w ith M r. R ic k Pl ass e o f y our staff , a mutual ly agree abl e d ate f or y our res ponse is w ithin 30 day s f rom the date of this letter. If y ou have any q uest ions reg arding this le tter o r i f ci rcumsta nce s re sul t i n y our nee d to rev is e th e re spo nse da te, p le ase co ntac t me at 3 0 1-4 1 5-1 4 5 8 o r v i a e-ma i l a t nbl@nrc.gov.Sin ce r ely,/RA/N. B. (Tommy) Le, Se ni or P roject M ana gerLi cen se Re new al B ranc h BDi v is io n o f Li cen se Re new alOf f ic e o f N ucl ear Re acto r R egul ati on Do cket No. 50-333 E n cl o su re: As state d c c w/e n c l: S e e n e x t p a ge Jan uary 19 , 20 07 M r. P eter T. Di etri ch Si te V ic e P resi den t James A. Fi tz Pa tric k Nuc le ar P ow er P la nt En tergy N ucl ear Operati on, Inc.P.O. B ox 11 0 Ly comi ng, NY 130 93-0 110

SUBJECT:

REQUEST S FOR ADDIT IO NAL INFO RM AT IO N REGARDING THE REVIEW OF THE LICENSE RENEW AL APPLICAT IO N FOR JAM ES A. FIT ZPAT RICK NU CL EA R POW ER P LA NT (TAC N O. M D2 666)By l etter date d J ul y 31 , 20 06, En tergy N ucl ear Operati ons , Inc., su bmi tted an app li cati on purs uan t to Titl e 1 0 C ode of Fe dera l Re gula tio ns (CF R) Pa rt 54 , to rene w the op erati ng l ic ens e for Ja me s A. F i tz P a tr i ck N u cl e a r P o w e r P l a n t for re v i e w b y t h e U.S. N u cl e a r R e gul a to ry Co mmissi on (NR C). The NR C staff i s re v ie w in g the in f ormati on con tai ned i n th e l ic ens e rene w al appli cat ion and has identif ied, in the enclosur e, an are a w here additional inf orm ation is n e e d e d t o c o mp l e te t h e r e v i e w. Ba sed on di scu ssi ons w ith M r. R ic k Pl ass e o f y our staff , a mutual ly agree abl e d ate f or y our res ponse is w ithin 30 day s f rom the date of this letter. If y ou have any q uest ions reg arding this le tter o r i f ci rcumsta nce s re sul t i n y our nee d to rev is e th e re spo nse da te, p le ase co ntac t me at 3 0 1-4 1 5-1 4 5 8 o r v i a e-ma i l a t nbl@nrc.gov.Sin ce r ely,/RA/N. B. (Tommy) Le, Se ni or P roject M ana gerLi cen se Re new al B ranc h BDi v is io n o f Li cen se Re new alOf f ic e o f N ucl ear Re acto r R egul ati on Do cket No. 50-333 E n cl o su re: As state d c c w/e n c l: S e e n e x t p a ge D I S TR I B U TI ON: S e e n e x t p a ge AD AM S Acc ess io n N o: M L07 012 019 6 OFFIC E LA:DL R PM:RL RB:DL R BC:RL RB:DL R NA M E SF igue roa NB Le SH off man f or RA ul uckDA TE 01/1 8/07 01/1 8/07 01/1 9/07OF FICI AL RECORD COPY Lette r to Pe ter D ie tric h, from N B Le, date d J anu ary 19 , 20 07

SUBJECT:

REQUEST S FOR ADDIT IO NAL INFO RM AT IO N REGARDING THE REVIEW OF THE LICENSE RENEW AL APPLICAT IO N FOR JAM ES A. FIT ZPAT RICK NU CL EA R POW ER P LA NT (TAC N O. M D2 666)DIST RIBUT IO N: HA RD COPY: D L R R/F E-MA IL: JFair RW ei sman AM urph y RPett is GGa l l e tt i D S h u m GBagchi SS mith (srs 3)S D u ra i sw a my YL (Renee)

Li RidsNrr Dlr R i d sN rr D l rR l ra R i d sN rr D l rR l rb RidsNrr De Ri dsN rrDci R i d sN rr D e E e mb Ri dsN rrDe Ee eb Rid sN r r De Eq va Ri dsN rrDss R i d sN rr D n rl Ri dsOgcM ai lC ente r Ri dsN rrAd es D L R S t a ff------------------____

___GHu neg s, SRI EC obe y RL aufer J B o s ka ENCLOSURE R E QU E S T F OR A D D ITIO N A L I N F OR M A TION J A M E S A. F I TZ P A TR I C K N U C L E A R P OW E R P L A N T LICENSE RENEW AL APPLICAT IO N (LRA)S E C TION S 2.3.3.2 , 2.3.3.9 , 2.3.3.1 0 , 2.3.3.1 1 , 2.3.4 S e ct i o n 2.3.3.2 S e rv i ce W a te r RA I 2.3.3.2-1 Li cen se Re new al dra w in g LRA-FM-46A , at lo cati ons B 6, B 7, a nd B8 , sh ow s four i sol ati on v al v es f or th e d rai n l in es and four i sol ati on v al v es on serv ic e w ater (SW) su ppl y l in es to th e el ectri cal ba y co ol in g uni ts. The L i ce n se R e n e w a l (L R) bou nda ry for ea ch sec tio n o f pi pi ng end s a t the Qu a l i ty A ss u ra n ce I (QA-I) bou nda ry i ncl udi ng the red uce r, ho w ev er, th e i sol ati on v al v es (is ol ati on v al v e a t ea ch sup pl y l in e a nd is ol ati on at e ach dra in l in e) u pstre am o f the redu cer and pi pi ng be tw een the red uce r an d i sol ati on v al v es la bel ed as S E IS M IC I are not sho w n a s w ith in the sc ope for LR. P le ase pro v id e a ddi tio nal i nformatio n o n w hy the se pi pi ng a n d i so l a ti o n v a l v e s a re n o t w i th i n t h e s co p e for L R a n d ju st i fy t h e b o u n d a ry l o ca ti o n s w i th re sp e ct t o t h e a p p l i ca b l e r e qui re me n ts o f Ti tl e 1 0 C o d e o f Fe d e ra l R e gul a ti o n s (C F R) P a rt 5 4.4 (a).RA I 2.3.3.2-2 License Renewal drawing LRA-F M-20B, at location E5, shows SW piping 22"-

W S-151-57 as in sco pe f or l ic ens e re new al. The l in e i s c onti nue d o n d raw in g LRA-FM-46A , at lo cati on B5. The con tin uati on on LR A-F M-46A do es not in di cate the pi pi ng i s i n s cop e n or d oes i t i ncl ude a li cen se rene w al bo und ary. The l in e i s c onti nue d o n a thi rd d raw in g, LRA-FM-36A , w hi ch w as not prov id ed by the ap pl ic ant. P le ase pro v id e a ddi tio nal i nformatio n o n w hy thi s s ecti on of pi pi ng i s n ot w ith in the sc ope of LR an d ju sti f y the bo und ary l oca tio ns w ith res pec t to the a p p l i ca b l e r e qui re me n ts o f 10 C F R P a rt 5 4.4 (a).R A I 2.3.3.2-3 Li cen se Re new al dra w in g LRA-FM-46A , at lo cati on C4 , sh ow s S W pi pi ng 8" W CS-151-114 cont inued f rom drawi ng LRA-FM-15A, location C1. Valv e ESW-23 and piping upstr eam is l a b e l e d QA-I. N e i th e r o f th e c o n ti n u a ti o n d ra w i n gs (L R A-F M-1 5 A a n d L R A-F M-3 6 A) w e re sub mitted as pa rt of the Li cen se Re new al A ppl ic ati on. P le ase pro v id e a ddi tio nal i nformatio n a s to w hy thi s s ecti on of QA-1 p ip in g f rom v al v e E SW-23 and up strea m i s n ot w ith in the sc ope of L R a n d j u s t i fy t h e b o u n d a r y l o c a t i o n s w i t h r e s p e c t t o t h e a p p l i c a b l e r e q u i r e m e n t s o f 1 0 C F R P a rt 5 4.4 (a). Se cti on 2.3.3.9 Fue l Po ol C ool in g and C le anu p RA I 2.3.3.9-1 Li cen se Re new al dra w in g LRA-FM-19A , at lo cati ons F 3 a nd F4, sho w s l in es W 19-1 51-1 A, 1B and 17 from skimmer su rge tan ks TK-8A and TK-8B to surge ta nk drai n v al v e V GW-15A as no t w i th i n t h e s co p e o f l i ce n se r e n e w a l. Th e p i p i n g a n d c o mp o n e n ts u p st re a m o f V GW-1 5 A a re la bel ed SE ISM IC I. P le ase pro v id e a ddi tio nal i nformatio n o n w hy the se sec tio ns of pi pe and co mp o n e n ts a re n o t w i th i n t h e s co p e for L R a n d ju st i fy t h e b o u n d a ry l o ca ti o n s w i th r e sp e ct t o th e a p p l i ca b l e r e qui re me n ts o f 10 C F R P a rt 5 4.4 (a).S e ct i o n 2.3.3.1 0 S e rv i ce , In st ru me n t, a n d B re a th i n g A i r R A I 2.3.3.1 0-1 Li cen se Re new al D raw in g LRA-FM-29A-0, a t l oca tio n G7 , sh ow s th at th e i n-sc ope ni trogen sup pl y for rea ctor coo la nt p ress ure bou nda ry ai r op erate d v al v es (AOV) 02A OV-17 an d 02AO V-18 does not extend to the actuat or but term inates at the downstr eam side of solenoid ope rati ng v al v es (SOV) SOV-1 7 a nd SOV-1 8, re spe cti v el y. P le ase pro v id e a ddi tio nal in f ormati on cl ari f y in g w hy the i n s cop e b oun dari es f or th e n itro gen su ppl y l in es to 0 2A OV-17 a n d 0 2 A OV-1 8 d o n o t e x te n d t o t h e a ct u a to r a n d ju st i fy t h e b o u n d a ry l o ca ti o n s w i th r e sp e ct t o th e a p p l i ca b l e r e qui re me n ts o f 10 C F R P a rt 5 4.4 (a). S e c t i o n 2.3.3.1 1 R e a c t o r B u i l d i n g C l o s e d L o o p C o o l i n g Wa t e r (R B C L C W)R A I 2.3.3.1 1-1 L i ce n se R e n e w a l d ra w i n g L R A-F M-1 5-B , a t l o ca ti o n s C 4 , C 7 , F 4 , a n d F 7 , sh o w s fou r RBCLCW con tai nmen t i sol ati on v al v es on sup pl y l in es to th e d ry w el l. The LR bo und ary for ea ch sec tio n o f pi p i n g e n d s a t th e A OV , h o w e v e r, p i p i n g a n d c o mp o n e n ts u p st re a m o f th e b o u n d a ry a re la bel ed SE ISM IC I. P le ase pro v id e a ddi tio nal i nformatio n o n w hy the se cti ons of pi pe and co mp o n e n ts l i st e d b e l o w a re n o t w i th i n t h e s co p e for L R a n d ju st i fy t h e b o u n d a ry l o ca ti o n s w i th re sp e ct t o t h e a p p l i ca b l e r e qui re me n ts o f 10 C F R P a rt 5 4.4 (a):*

LR drawi ng LRA-FM-15-B, locat ion C4, upstr eam of AOV 130B thr oug h v alv e 23B.*

LR drawi ng LRA-FM-15-B, locat ion C7, upstr eam of AOV 130A thr oug h v alv e 23A.*

LR drawi ng LRA-FM-15-B, locat ion F4, upst ream of AOV 132A thr oug h v alv e 20A.*

LR drawi ng LRA-FM-15-B, locat ion F7, upst ream of AOV 132B thr oug h v alv e 20B.Se cti on 2.3.4.1 C ond ens ate R A I 2.3.4.1-1 Tw o c ond ens ate stora ge tan ks prov id e th e p referred s ourc e o f w ater to h igh-p ress ure coo la nt i n je c t i o n (H P C I) a n d r e a c t o r c o r e i s o l a t i o n c o o l i n g (R C IC) d u ri n g p o st u l a te d s ma l l p i p e b re a ks. E a ch t a n k mu st c o n ta i n a r e se rv e s to ra ge ca p a ci ty o f 10 0 ,0 0 0 ga l l o n s a n d h a v e t h e c a p a b i l i ty of bei ng i sol ated from serv in g othe r sy stems. The tanks a re d esi gned to p rov id e th e re quire d f lo w ev en if the ab ov e grou nd porti ons of the tan ks are des troy ed by torn ado or earth quake. L R d ra w i n g L R A-F M-3 3-D i n d i ca te s th e L R b o u n d a ry for s y st e m p i p i n g o th e r th a n H P C I a n d R C IC is the no z z le pe netra tio n a t the sto rage ta nks, cre ati ng the po ssi bi li ty of a non-is ol abl e l eak from the tank. P le ase pro v id e a ddi tio nal i nformatio n o n w hy the foll ow in g secti ons of pi pe and co mp o n e n ts a re n o t w i th i n t h e s co p e for L R a n d ju st i fy t h e b o u n d a ry l o ca ti o n s w i th r e sp e ct t o th e a p p l i ca b l e r e qui re me n ts o f 10 C F R P a rt 5 4.4 (a):*

LR drawi ng LRA-FM-33-D, location G 7, piping f rom N-2 to and including v alv e 37A.*

LR drawi ng LRA-FM-33-D, location G 7, piping f rom N-3 to and including v alv e 38A.*

LR dr awin g LRA-FM-33-D, loc at ion G 6, pip ing f r om N-11 to and inc lud ing valve W T R-117 A.*

LR dr awin g LRA-FM-33-D, loc at ion G 6, pip ing f r om N-7 t o an d in cl ud ing valve FPC-724 A.*

LR dr awin g LRA-FM-33-D, loc at ion G 6, pip ing f r om N-9 t o an d in cl ud ing valve CSP-01A.*

LR dr awin g LRA-FM-33-D, loc at ion G 6, pip ing f r om N-8 t o an d in cl ud ing valve CRD-01A.*

LR dr awin g LRA-FM-33-D, loc at ion G 6, pip ing f r om C-3 t o an d in cl ud ing valve CRD-02A.*

LR drawi ng LRA-FM-33-D, location H6, piping f rom N-5 to and including v alv e 100A.*

LR drawi ng LRA-FM-33-D, location H6, piping f rom N-10 to and including v alv e 01A.*

LR drawi ng LRA-FM-33-D, location H6, piping f rom C-2 to and including v alv e 101A.*

LR drawi ng LRA-FM-33-D, location G 3, piping f rom N-2 to and including v alv e 37B.*

LR drawi ng LRA-FM-33-D, location G 3, piping f rom N-3 to and including v alv e 38B.*

LR dr awin g LRA-FM-33-D, loc at ion G 4, pip ing f r om N-11 to and inc lud ing valve W T R-117 B.*

LR dr awin g LRA-FM-33-D, loc at ion G 4, pip ing f r om N-7 t o an d in cl ud ing valve FPC-724 B.*

LR dra w in g LRA-FM-33-D , l oca tio n G4 , pi pi ng f rom N-9 to an d i ncl udi ng v al v e CSP-01B.*

LR dr awin g LRA-FM-33-D, loc at ion G 4, pip ing f r om N-8 t o an d in cl ud ing valve CRD-01B.*

LR dra w in g LRA-FM-33-D , l oca tio n G4 , pi pi ng f rom C-3 to an d i ncl udi ng v al v e C RD-02.*

LR drawi ng LRA-FM-33-D, location H4, piping f rom N-5 to and including v alv e 100B.*

LR drawi ng LRA-FM-33-D, location H4, piping f rom N-10 to and including v alv e 01B.*

LR drawi ng LRA-FM-33-D, location H4, piping f rom C-2 to and including v alv e 101B. R A I 2.3.4.1-2 Tw o c ond ens ate stora ge tan ks prov id e th e p referred s ourc e o f w ater to H PC I an d R CIC du rin g pos tul ated smal l pi pe brea ks. The tanks a re d esi gned to p rov id e th e re quire d flo w ev en if the abo v e grou nd porti ons of the tan ks are des troy ed by torn ado or earth quake. L R draw in g LRA-FM-25-A indicat es the LR boundar ies on the cros stie line f or th e two tank s are th e nozz le pen etrati ons at the stora ge tan ks, crea tin g the pos si bi li ty of a non-is ol abl e l eak from the tanks.P l e a se p ro v i d e a d d i ti o n a l i n form a ti o n o n w h y t h e fol l o w i n g s e ct i o n s o f pi p e a n d c o mp o n e n ts a re not wi thin the scope f or LR and jus tif y the boun dary locations w ith res pect to the applicable re qui re me n ts o f 10 C F R P a rt 5 4.4 (a):*

LR dr awin g LRA-FM-25-A, loc at ion H5, pip ing f r om N-1 on CST A to and inc lud ing valve 02A*

LR dr awin g LRA-FM-25-A, loc at ion H5, pip ing f r om N-1 on CST B to and inc lud ing valve 02B Fi tz Pa tric k Nuc le ar P ow er P la nt cc: M r. Gary J. Tay lo r Ch ie f E x ecu tiv e Off ic er En tergy Ope rati ons , Inc.134 0 E che lo n P arkw ay Jac kson, M S 39 213 M r. Jo hn T. Herro n Sr. VP an d C hi ef Operati ng Of f ic er En tergy N ucl ear Operati ons , Inc.440 H ami lto n A v enu e W hi te P la in s, N Y 10 601 M r. P eter T. Di etri ch Si te V ic e P resi den t En tergy N ucl ear Operati ons , Inc.James A. Fi tz Pa tric k Nuc le ar P ow er P la nt P.O. B ox 11 0 Ly comi ng, NY 130 93 M r. K ev in J. M ul li gan Genera l M ana ger, Pl ant Operati ons En tergy N ucl ear Operati ons , Inc.James A. Fi tz Pa tric k Nuc le ar P ow er P la nt P.O. B ox 11 0 Ly comi ng, NY 130 93 M r. Osca r Li mpi as Vi ce Pre si den t E ngin eeri ng En tergy N ucl ear Operati ons , Inc.440 H ami lto n A v enu e W hi te P la in s, N Y 10 601 M r. C h ri st o p h e r S ch w a rz V i ce P re si d e n t, Op e ra ti o n s S u p p o rt En tergy N ucl ear Operati ons , Inc.440 H ami lto n A v enu e W hi te P la in s, N Y 10 601 M r. Jo hn F. M cCa nn Di recto r, Li cen si ng En tergy N ucl ear Operati ons , Inc.440 H ami lto n A v enu e W hi te P la in s, N Y 10 601 Re si den t Ins pec tor's Of f ic e James A. Fi tz Pa tric k Nuc le ar P ow er P la nt U. S. Nu cl ear Re gula tory C ommis si on P.O. B ox 13 6 Ly comi ng, NY 130 93 M s. C harl ene D. Fa is on M a n a ge r , L i c e n s i n g En tergy N ucl ear Operati ons , Inc.440 H ami lto n A v enu e W hi te P la in s, N Y 10 601 M r. M i ch a e l J. C o l o mb Di recto r of Ov ersi ght En tergy N ucl ear Operati ons , Inc.440 H ami lto n A v enu e W hi te P la in s, N Y 10 601 M r. D av id W al la ce Di recto r, N ucl ear Sa f ety A ssu ranc e En tergy N ucl ear Operati ons , Inc.James A. Fi tz Pa tric k Nuc le ar P ow er P la nt P.O. B ox 11 0 Ly comi ng, NY 130 93 M r. Jame s Costed io M ana ger, Re gula tory C ompl ia nce En tergy N ucl ear Operati ons , Inc.James A. Fi tz Pa tric k Nuc le ar P ow er P la nt P.O. B ox 11 0 Ly comi ng, NY 130 93 Ass is tant Genera l Co uns el En tergy N ucl ear Operati ons , Inc.440 H ami lto n A v enu e W hi te P la in s, N Y 10 601 M r. C h a rl e s D o n a l d so n , E squ i re Ass is tant Attorn ey Gen eral Ne w Y ork De partmen t of La w 120 B road w ay Ne w Y ork, NY 102 71 Fi tz Pa tric k Nuc le ar P ow er P la nt cc: Re gion al A dmi ni strato r, R egio n I U.S. N ucl ear Re gula tory C ommis si on 475 A ll end al e R oad Ki ng of Prus si a, P A 19 406M r. S tev en Ly man Os w e go C o u n ty A d mi n i st ra to r 46 Ea st B rid ge Stre et Osw ego, N Y 13 126 M r. P eter R. Smi th, P resi den t Ne w Y ork Sta te E nergy , R ese arch , a n d D e v e l o p me n t A u th o ri ty 17 Columbia Circle Al ban y , N Y 12 203-639 9 M r. P aul E ddy Ne w Y ork Sta te D ept. of Pub li c S erv ic e 3 Em pir e St at e Pl aza Al ban y , N Y 12 223-135 0 Su perv is or Tow n o f S cri ba Ro ute 8, B ox 38 2 Osw ego, N Y 13 126 M r. Ja mes H. S ni ez ek BW R SR C Co nsu lta nt 54 86 Nit hs da le Dr ive Sa li sbu ry , M D 21 801-249 0 M r. M ic hae l D. Ly ster BW R SR C Co nsu lta nt 593 1 B arcl ay La ne Na pl es, FL 34 110-730 6 M r. Garrett D. Ed w ards 814 W av erl y R oad Ke nne tt S quare, PA 193 48 M r. R ic k Pl ass e Pro ject M ana ger, Li cen se Re new al En tergy N ucl ear Operati ons , Inc.James A. Fi tz Pa tric k Nuc le ar P ow er P la nt P.O. B ox 11 0 Ly comi ng, NY 130 93 M r. Ja mes R oss N u cl e a r E n e rgy I n st i tu te 177 6 I Stree t, N W , S ui te 4 00 W ash in gton, D C 20 006-370 8