ML060950351
| ML060950351 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Vermont Yankee File:NorthStar Vermont Yankee icon.png |
| Issue date: | 02/28/1998 |
| From: | Morgan M NRC/NRR/ADRO/DLR/RLRC |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| morgan M NRR/NRC/DLR/RLRC, 415-2232 | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML060950189 | List:
|
| References | |
| TAC MC9668 | |
| Download: ML060950351 (6) | |
Text
XI.M12 Thermal Aging Embrittlement of Cast Austenitic Stainless Steel (CASS) 1 AUDIT WORKSHEET GALL REPORT AMP PLANT: ______________________________
LRA AMP: __________________________
REVIEWER: ______________________
GALL AMP: XI.M12, Thermal Aging Embrittlement of Cast Austenitic Stainless Steel (CASS)_
DATE: __________________________
Program Element Auditable GALL Criteria Documentation of Audit Finding Program Description A. The reactor coolant system components are inspected in accordance with the American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code,Section XI. This inspection is augmented to detect the effects of loss of fracture toughness due to thermal aging embrittlement of cast austenitic stainless steel (CASS) components. This aging management program (AMP) includes (a) determination of the susceptibility of CASS components to thermal aging embrittlement based on casting method, molybdenum content, and percent ferrite, and Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
Comment:
B. (b) for potentially susceptible components, as defined below, aging management is accomplished through either enhanced volumetric examination or plant-or component-specific flaw tolerance evaluation. Additional inspection or evaluations to demonstrate that the material has adequate fracture toughness are not required for components that are not susceptible to thermal aging embrittlement.
Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
Comment:
C. For pump casings and valve bodies, based on the assessment documented in the letter dated May 19, 2000, from Christopher Grimes, Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), to Douglas Walters, Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI), screening for susceptibility to thermal aging is not required. The existing ASME Section XI inspection requirements, including the alternative requirements of ASME Code Case N-481 for pump casings, are adequate for all pump casings and valve bodies.
Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
Comment:
XI.M12 Thermal Aging Embrittlement of Cast Austenitic Stainless Steel (CASS) 2 Program Element Auditable GALL Criteria Documentation of Audit Finding
- 1. Scope of Program A. The program includes screening criteria to determine which CASS components are potentially susceptible to thermal aging embrittlement and require augmented inspection. The screening criteria are applicable to all primary pressure boundary and reactor vessel internal components constructed from SA-351 Grades CF3, CF3A, CF8, CF8A, CF3M, CF3MA, CF8M, with service conditions above 250°C (482°F). The screening criteria for susceptibility to thermal aging embrittlement are not applicable to niobium-containing steels; such steels require evaluation on a case-by-case basis. For potentially susceptible components, aging management is accomplished either through volumetric examination or plant-or component-specific flaw tolerance evaluation.
Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
Comment B Based on the criteria set forth in the May 19, 2000 NRC letter, the susceptibility to thermal aging embrittlement of CASS components is determined in terms of casting method, molybdenum content, and ferrite content. For low-molybdenum content (0.5 wt.% max.) steels, only static-cast steels with >20%
ferrite are potentially susceptible to thermal embrittlement.
Static-cast low-molybdenum steels with 20% ferrite and all centrifugal-cast low-molybdenum steels are not susceptible. For high-molybdenum content (2.0 to 3.0 wt.%) steels, static-cast steels with >14% ferrite and centrifugal-cast steels with >20%
ferrite are potentially susceptible to thermal embrittlement.
Static-cast high-molybdenum steels with 14% ferrite and centrifugal-cast high-molybdenum steels with 20% ferrite are not susceptible. In the susceptibility screening method, ferrite content is calculated by using the Hulls equivalent factors (described in NUREG/CR-4513, Rev. 1) or a method producing an equivalent level of accuracy (+/-6% deviation between measured and calculated values). A fracture toughness value of 255 kJ/m2 (1,450 in.-lb/in.2) at a crack depth of 2.5 mm (0.1 in.)
is used to differentiate between CASS materials that are nonsusceptible and those that are potentially susceptible to Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
Comment:
XI.M12 Thermal Aging Embrittlement of Cast Austenitic Stainless Steel (CASS) 3 Program Element Auditable GALL Criteria Documentation of Audit Finding thermal aging embrittlement. Extensive research data indicate that for nonsusceptible CASS materials, the saturated lower-bound fracture toughness is greater than 255 kJ/m2 (NUREG/CR-4513, Rev. 1).
C For pump casings and valve bodies, screening for susceptibility to thermal aging embrittlement is not required. The staffs conservative bounding integrity analysis shows that thermally aged CASS valve bodies and pump casings are resistant to failure. For all pump casings and valve bodies greater than nominal pipe size (NPS) 4 in., the existing ASME Section XI inspection requirements, including the alternative requirements of ASME Code Case N-481 for pump casings, are adequate. ASME Section XI, Subsection IWB, requires only surface examination of valve bodies less than NPS 4 in. For valve bodies less than NPS 4 in., the adequacy of inservice inspection (ISI) according to ASME Section XI has been demonstrated by an NRC-performed bounding integrity analysis (Reference letter from Christopher Grimes dated May 19, 2000).
Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
Comment:
- 2. Preventive Actions A. The program consists of evaluation and inspection and provides no guidance on methods to mitigate thermal aging embrittlement.
Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
Comment:
- 3. Parameters Monitored/
Inspected A. The AMP monitors the effects of loss of fracture toughness on the intended function of the component by identifying the CASS materials that are susceptible to thermal aging embrittlement. For potentially susceptible materials, the program consists of either enhanced volumetric examination to detect and size cracks or plant-or component-specific flaw tolerance evaluation (loss of fracture toughness is of consequence only if cracks exist).
Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
Comment:
XI.M12 Thermal Aging Embrittlement of Cast Austenitic Stainless Steel (CASS) 4 Program Element Auditable GALL Criteria Documentation of Audit Finding
- 4. Detection of Aging Effects A. For pump casings and valve bodies and not susceptible piping, no additional inspection or evaluations are required to demonstrate that the material has adequate fracture toughness.
For potentially susceptible piping, because the base metal does not receive periodic inspection per ASME Section XI, the CASS AMP provides for volumetric examination of the base metal, with the scope of the inspection covering the portions determined to be limiting from the standpoint of applied stress, operating time, and environmental considerations. Examination methods that meet the criteria of the ASME Section XI, Appendix VIII, are acceptable.
Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
Comment:
B Alternatively, a plant-or component-specific flaw tolerance evaluation, using specific geometry and stress information, can be used to demonstrate that the thermally-embrittled material has adequate toughness.
Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
Comment:
- 5. Monitoring and Trending A. Inspection schedules in accordance with IWB-2400 or IWC-2400 and reliable examination methods provide timely detection of cracks.
Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
Comment:
- 6. Acceptance Criteria A. Flaws detected in CASS components are evaluated in accordance with the applicable procedures of IWB-3500 or IWC-3500.
Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
Comment:
B Flaw tolerance evaluation for components with ferrite content up to 25% is performed according to the principles associated with IWB-3640 procedures for submerged arc welds (SAW),
disregarding the Code restriction of 20% ferrite in IWB-Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
XI.M12 Thermal Aging Embrittlement of Cast Austenitic Stainless Steel (CASS) 5 Program Element Auditable GALL Criteria Documentation of Audit Finding 3641(b)(1). Extensive research data indicate that the lower-bound fracture toughness of thermally aged CASS materials with up to 25% ferrite is similar to that for submerged arc welds (SAWs) with up to 20% ferrite (Lee et al., 1997). Flaw evaluation for piping with >25% ferrite is performed on a case-by-case basis by using fracture toughness data provided by the applicant.
Comment:
- 7. Corrective Actions A. Repair is performed in conformance with IWA-4000 and IWB-4000 or IWC-4000, and replacement in accordance with IWA-7000 and IWB-7000 or IWC-7000. As discussed in the appendix to this report, the staff finds the requirements of 10 CFR Part 50, Appendix B, acceptable to address the corrective actions.
Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
Comment:
- 8.
Confirmation Process A. Site quality assurance (QA) procedures, review and approval processes, and administrative controls are implemented in accordance with the requirements of 10 CFR Part 50, Appendix B. As discussed in the appendix to this report, the staff finds the requirements of 10 CFR Part 50, Appendix B, acceptable to address the confirmation process and administrative controls.
Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
Comment:
- 9.
Administrative Controls A. See Item 8, above.
Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
Comment:
- 10. Operating Experience A. The AMP was developed by using research data obtained on both laboratory-aged and service-aged materials. Based on this information, the effects of thermal aging embrittlement on the intended function of CASS components are effectively managed.
Consistent with GALL AMP:
Yes No Document(s) used to confirm Criteria:
Comment:
XI.M12 Thermal Aging Embrittlement of Cast Austenitic Stainless Steel (CASS) 6 EXCEPTIONS Item Number Program Elements LRA Exception Description Basis for Accepting Exception Documents Reviewed (Identifier, Para.# and/or Page #)
- 1.
- 2.
ENHANCEMENTS Item Number Program Elements LRA Enhancement Description Basis for Accepting Enhancement Documents Reviewed (Identifier, Para.# and/or Page #)
- 1.
- 2.
DOCUMENT REVIEWED DURING AUDIT Document Number Identifier (number)
Title Revision and/or Date
- 1.
- 2.
- 3.
- 4.
.