ML042740517
| ML042740517 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Salem |
| Issue date: | 02/05/2004 |
| From: | Gita Patel NUCORE |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| LR-N04-0413 S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950, Rev OIR1 | |
| Download: ML042740517 (45) | |
Text
NC.DE-AP.ZZ-0002(Q)
CALC NO.: S-C-ZMDC-1950 l
CALCULATION COVER SHEET Page 1 of 44 REVISION: 01R1l CALC. TITLE:
l EAB, LPZ, & CR Doses - Main Steam Line Break (MSLB) Accident - AST
- SHTS (CALC): l 44
- ATT / # SHTS: I I
- IDV/50.59 SHTS: l213
- TOTAL SHTS:
l.50 CHECK ONE:
El FINAL 0 INTERIM (Proposed Plant Change)
E FINAL (Future Confirmation Req'd)
El VOID SALEM OR HOPE CREEK:
El Q - LIST 0i IMPORTANT TO SAFETY El NON-SAFETY RELATED HOPE CREEK ONLY:
FIQ nQs ElQsh OIF OR a1 STATION PROCEDURES IMPACTED, IF SO CONTACT RELIABILITY ENGINEER El CDs INCORPORATED (IF ANY):
DESCRIPTION OF CALCULATION REVISION (IF APPLQ:
N/A PURPOSE:
The purpose of this calculation is to determine the Exclusion Area Boundary (EAB), Low Population Zone (LPZ), and Control Room (CR) doses due to a Main Steam Line Break (MSLB) accident using the Alternative Source Term (AST) methodology and total effective dose equivalent (TEDE) dose criteria. The dose consequences are representative of an accident occurring in either unit.
CONCLUSIONS:
The results of analysis, presented in Section 7, indicate that the EAB, LPZ, and CR doses due to a MSLB accident are within their allowable TEDE dose limits.
Printed Name / Signatupe
/D Date ORIGINATOR/COMPANY NAME:
Gopal J. Patel/NUCORE 02/05/04 REVIEWER/COMPANY NAME:
N/A N/A VERIFIER/COMPANY NAME:
Mark Drucker/NUCORE I02/05/04 PSEG SUPERVISOR APPROVAL Paul Lindsay/PSEG IL i
1Or7 Al I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 2 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWERIVERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 REVISION HISTORY Revision Revision Description OIRO Initial Issue.
OIR1 Design input validation comments incorporated.
I.
I Nuclear Common Revision 9 I Nu l a Co m nR v s o 9
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 3 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE IREV:
02/05/2004 0
l l
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 PAGE REVISION INDEX PAGE REV PAGE REV I
0 25 0
2 0
26 0
3 0
27 0
4 0
28 0
5 0
29 0
6 0
30 0
7 0
31 0
8 0
32 0
9 0
33 0
10 0
34 0
11 0
35 0
12 0
36 0
13 0
37 0
14 0
38 0
15 0
39 0
16 0
40 0
17 0
41 0
18 0
42 0
19 0
43 0
20 0
44 0
21 0
Attachment A 0
22 0
23 0
24 0
I Nuclear Common Revision 9 Nuclear Common Revision 9
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 4 of 44 CALC.NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWERIVERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 TABLE OF CONTENTS Section Sheet No.
Cover Sheet I
Revision History 2
Page Revision Index 3
Table of Contents 4
1.0 Purpose 5
2.0 Background
5 3.0 Analytical Approach 5
4.0 Assumptions 9
5.0 Design Inputs 17 6.0 Calculations 22 7.0 Results Summary 29 8.0 Conclusions 30 9.0 References 31 10.0 Tables 33 11.0 Figures 40 12.0 Affected Documents 44 13.0 Attachments 44 I Nuclear Common Revision 9 I Nuclear Common Revision 9 I
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 5 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004
1.0 PURPOSE
The purpose of this calculation is to determine the Exclusion Area Boundary (EAB), Low Population Zone (LPZ), and Control Room (CR) doses due to a Main Steam Line Break (MSLB) accident using the Alternative Source Term (AST) methodology and total effective dose equivalent (TEDE) dose criteria. The dose consequences are representative of an accident occurring in either unit.
2.0 BACKGROUND
The consequences of a MSLB accident were previously analyzed using the TID-14844 source term methodology to assess compliance with 10 CFR 50, Appendix A, General Design Criterion (GDC) 19 and 10 CFR 100 Section 100.11 dose criteria.
LCR S03-05 proposes to amend the SNGS Units 1 & 2 plant operating licenses to implement the full scope Alternative Source Term methodology in lieu of the TID-14844 source term methodology. The TEDE offsite dose acceptance criteria specified in Table 6 of Regulatory Guide 1.183 (Ref. 9.1) is implemented in lieu of the whole body and thyroid dose guidelines provided in 10 CFR 100.1 1. Also, the 5 rem TEDE control room dose acceptance criterion specified in 10 CFR 50.67 (Ref. 9.3) is implemented in lieu of the 5 rem whole body and equivalent organ dose guidelines provided in 10 CFR 50 Appendix A GDC 19.
The MSLB accident is analyzed using plant specific design and licensing bases inputs which are compatible to the TEDE dose criteria. The MSLB analysis is performed using the guidance in Regulatory Guide 1.183 and its Appendix E (Ref. 9.1).
3.0 ANALYTICAL APPROACH:
This analysis uses Version 3.02 of the RADTRAD computer code (Ref. 9.2) to calculate the potential radiological consequences of the MSLB accident. The RADTRAD code is documented in NUREG/CR-6604 (Ref. 9.2). The RADTRAD code is maintained as Software ID Number A-0-ZZ-MCS-0225 (Ref. 9.4).
The calculation assumes that the CR air intake monitors preferentially select the less contaminated air intake when only one CREACS train is available. There are two CREACS trains that each provide emergency filtration and air conditioning services to the combined CR for the SNGS Units 1 & 2 plants (Ref. 9.19). Each CREACS train is safety related and required to be operable by a Technical Specification (Refs. 9.6.14 and 9.6.15). Each CREACS train takes outside air supplied through two independent ducts equipped with safety related fans and radiation monitors (Ref. 9.19), which make the CREACS air supply system single failure proof.
The redundant air intake monitors preferentially select the less contaminated air intake during an accident condition when the radiation level at a normal intake exceeds the setpoint value (see Section 6.7 for CR outside air intake radiation monitor setpoint evaluation). Based on the SNGS Units 1 & 2 plant-specific CREACS design and performance, the post-accident CREACS response is credited in the analysis with the CR outside air intake radiation monitor's ability to preferentially select the less contaminated air intake.
Nu l a Co m nR v s o I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1
I l CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 6 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE IREV:
02/05/2004 0
l l
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 Per Section 4.0, this calculation addresses the reactor coolant activity concentrations corresponding to (1) a preaccident iodine spike and (2) a concurrent iodine spike. There is no potential fuel failure during this event (Ref. 9.17, page 4).
3.1 Preaccident Iodine Spike Release In the preaccident iodine spike release scenario, a reactor transient has occurred prior to the postulated MSLB accident and has raised the primary coolant (PC) iodine concentration to the maximum value permitted by technical specifications. The PC iodine concentration of 60 itCi/g Dose Equivalent (DE) of I-131 is obtained from Figure 3.4-1 of the technical specifications (Ref. 9.6.7). The plant-specific PC iodine concentration corresponding to 1% fuel defects is obtained from Reference 9.11 (Table 4), and listed in Table 2. The iodine dose conversion factors are developed in Table I using the information in Reference 9.7 and used in Table 2 to establish the iodine scaling factor based on the iodine concentration of 1.LCi/g DE I-13 1, which is used to convert the iodine concentration of 1% fuel defects to 1 gCi/g DE I-131 in Table 3. The total isotopic iodine activity in the RCS is conservatively calculated in Table 4 using the PC mass determined at "cooled" liquid conditions (Section 6.1). Since the SNGS Units 1 & 2 PC normal noble gas isotopic concentrations are not readily available, the 1 00/E-Bar noble gas concentrations are not calculated. The PC noble gas concentrations corresponding to 1% fuel defects are conservatively used in Table 5 to determine the total RCS noble gas activity. The total isotopic activities released to the RCS are calculated in Table 6, which are used to develop the RADTRAD Nuclide Inventory File (NIF) SMSLBPRE def.txt for the preaccident iodine spike case.
The post-MSLB preaccident iodine spike activity transport and CR response models are shown in Figures 1, 3
& 4, which are used to determine the post-MSLB radiological consequences using the SNGS Units 1 & 2 plant-specific as-built design inputs and assumptions listed in Sections 4 & 5. The CR response model utilizes the SNGS Units 1 & 2 CR air intake monitor to preferentially select the less contaminated air intake after 1 minute (Ref. 9.10). A delay time of 1 minute for the CR pressurization mode to be fully operational is conservatively assumed. The EAB, LPZ, and CR doses are summarized in Section 7.1 for the preaccident iodine spike case.
The following paragraphs describe the activity transport paths from the one faulted and three intact steam generators (SGs). These activity transport paths are applicable to both the preaccident and concurrent iodine spike cases.
Faulted SG Releases Following a MSLB the faulted SG is assumed to steam dry. PC is assumed to leak into the faulted SG at the technical specification maximum leak rate of 0.35 gpm through any one SG (Refs. 9.6.4 & 9.6.5) [0.35 gpm/day
= (500 gal/day) / (1440 min/day)]. To maximize the offsite doses it is assumed that offsite power is lost so that the main steam condensers are not available. PC noble gas activity entering the faulted SG via Primary-to-Secondary (P-T-S) leakage is assumed to be released directly to the environment for 0-32 hrs through the pressure sensitive penetration area pressure relief panels (PAPRPs) using the applicable X/Q values (Design Inputs 5.5.13 & 5.5.14) without reduction or mitigation. Since the faulted SG is assumed to be dried-out, the PC iodine activity entering the faulted SG via P-T-S leakage is also assumed to be released directly to the I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1 Nuclear Common Revision 9 I
I I
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET l SHEET 7 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWERIVERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 environment (Figure 1) for 0-32 hrs through the PAPRPs. P-T-S activity dilution in the faulted SG is not credited. The release from the main steam line break outside containment is postulated as a ground level release to the environment.
Intact SGs Releases To maximize the calculated doses it is assumed that offsite power is lost so that the main steam condensers are not available. Consequently, following the MSLB transient the plant must cool down by releasing secondary coolant via the intact SGs atmospheric relief valves. The steam release from the three intact SGs continues for 32 hours3.703704e-4 days <br />0.00889 hours <br />5.291005e-5 weeks <br />1.2176e-5 months <br /> until the Residual Heat Removal (RHR) system is aligned to dissipate heat (Ref. 9.18). During the 32 hours3.703704e-4 days <br />0.00889 hours <br />5.291005e-5 weeks <br />1.2176e-5 months <br /> before the RHR system is initialized, the PC is assumed to leak into the three intact SGs at 0.65 gpm (i.e., the maximum technical specification total leakrate (I gpm) minus the 0.35 gpm leakrate into the faulted SG) (Refs. 9.6.4 & 9.6.5). The PC noble gas activity entering the intact SGs via P-T-S leakage is assumed to be released directly to the environment without reduction or mitigation. The PC iodine activity entering the intact SGs via P-T-S leakage is assumed to be diluted within the smaller Unit 1 intact SGs liquid mass. An iodine partition coefficient of 1.0 (i.e., no P-T-S leakage iodine retention in the intact SGs) is conservatively assumed in lieu of the value of 100 recommended in Regulatory Guide 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Appendix E, Section 5.5.4) to maximize the resulting dose. The P-T-S leakage iodine activity is assumed to be released to the environment at the SG steaming rates. The MSSV Set 1 being closer to the CR air intake (Ref. 9.5, pages 53 through 60), the X/Q values corresponds to the MSSV Set 1 release are conservatively used for the intact SG releases.
3.2 Concurrent Iodine Spike:
In the concurrent iodine spike release scenario, the primary system transient associated with the MSLB causes an iodine spike in the primary system. The increase in primary coolant iodine concentration is estimated using a spiking model that assumes that the iodine release rate from the fuel rods to the primary coolant (expressed in curies per unit time) increases to a value 500 times greater than the release rate corresponding to the iodine concentration at the equilibrium value (typically 1.0 ViCi/gm DE I-13 1) specified in technical specifications (i.e., concurrent iodine spike case) (Ref. 9.1, Appendix E, Section 2.2). The isotopic iodine appearance rates are calculated in Section 6.2 and Table 7 using the specific activity production and removal rates based on the most conservative letdown system parameters. The total isotopic iodine activity is calculated in Table 8 using the spike duration of 8 hours9.259259e-5 days <br />0.00222 hours <br />1.322751e-5 weeks <br />3.044e-6 months <br />. The total isotopic iodine and noble gas activities are listed in Table 9 and used to develop the RADTRAD NIF SMSLBCON dTf2tx forjthe concurrent iodine spike case. The RADTRAD model postulates that the 99% of all fuel activity is released into the RCS within 8 hours9.259259e-5 days <br />0.00222 hours <br />1.322751e-5 weeks <br />3.044e-6 months <br /> at a calculated rate of 9.60 cfm (Section 6.4). The activity transport-from-the RCS to the environment and the CR outside air intake radiation monitor response are the same as described in Section 3.1 for the preaccident iodine spike case. The post-MSLB concurrent iodine spike activity transport and CR response models are shown in Figures 2, 3 & 4, which are used to determine the post-MSLB radiological consequences using the SNGS Units 1 & 2 plant-specific as-built design inputs and assumptions listed in Sections 4 & 5. The EAB, LPZ, and CR doses are summarized in Section 7.2 for the concurrent iodine case.
3.3 Initial Steam Generator Iodine Inventory Activity Release:
I Nuclear Common Revision 9 I I Nuclear Common Revision 9 I
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 8 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 The initial iodine activity in the SGs is calculated based on the maximum secondary side liquid activity concentration of 0.1 pCi/g DE I-13 1 as allowed by technical specification (Ref. 9.6.6). When evaluating secondary liquid iodine releases, the larger Unit 2 SG volume is used to maximize the total iodine activity in the secondary liquid, which in turn yields higher secondary liquid release dose consequences. The faulted and intact SGs volumes and liquid masses are calculated in Section 6. 1, and the corresponding secondary liquid iodine activities are calculated in Tables 10 & 11 for the intact and faulted SG, respectively.
Following a MSLB the faulted SG is assumed to steam dry in two hours. For the initial secondary liquid iodine inventory release from the faulted SG, an iodine partition coefficient of 1.0 (i.e., no secondary liquid iodine retention) is conservatively assumed in lieu of the value of 100 recommended in Regulatory Guide 1.183 (Ref.
9.1, Appendix E, Section 5.5.4). The faulted SG secondary liquid iodine activity is assumed to be released to the environment through the PAPRPs at the faulted SG steaming rate of 24.67 cfm (Section 6.3.1) for 0-2 hours.
The initial secondary liquid iodine activity release from the faulted is calculated in Table 11.
For the initial secondary liquid iodine inventory release from the three intact SGs, an iodine partition coefficient of 1.0 (i.e., no secondary liquid iodine retention) is conservatively assumed in lieu of the value of 100 recommended in Regulatory Guide 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Appendix E, Section 5.5.4). The intact SGs secondary liquid iodine activity is assumed to be released to the environment at the intact SGs steaming rates. The initial secondary liquid iodine activity release from the intact SGs is modeled using the MSSV X/Q values. The intact SGs liquid iodine activities are calculated in Table 10.
Nuclear Common Revision 9 I Nuclear Common Revision 9
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 9 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004
4.0 ASSUMPTIONS
Regulatory Guide 1.183 (Ref. 9.1) provides guidance on modeling assumptions that are acceptable to the NRC staff for the evaluation of the radiological consequences of a MSLB accident. The following sections address the applicability of these modeling assumptions to an SNGS Units I & 2 MSLB accident analysis. These assumptions are incorporated as design inputs in Sections 5.3 through 5.6.
The radioactivity material releases and radiation levels used in the control room dose analysis are determined using the same source term, transport, and release assumptions used for determining the exclusion area boundary (EAB) and the low population zone (LPZ) TEDE values (Ref 9.1, Section 4.2.2).
4.1 Source Terms Per Reference 9.17, page 4, no fuel damage is postulated for the MSLB accident. Per RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Appendix E, Section 2) since no or minimal fuel damage is postulated for the limiting event, the released activity is the maximum coolant activity allowed by the technical specifications. Two cases of iodine spiking, a preaccident case and a concurrent case, are assumed.
4.1.1 Preaccident Iodine Spike Source Term Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Appendix E, Section 2.1) the first iodine spiking case assumes that a reactor transient has occurred prior to the postulated MSLB and has raised the primary coolant iodine concentration to the maximum value permitted by the technical specifications.
Per Technical Specification (TS) LCO for Specific Activity (Refs. 9.6.1 & 9.6.2), the maximum primary coolant iodine concentration permitted by the technical specifications at full power is shown in TS Figure 3.4-1 (Ref. 9.6.7) to be 60 jtCi/gm Dose Equivalent (DE) I-131. Technical Specification Section 1.10 (Ref. 9.6.13) defines DE I-131 as that concentration of I-131 (in tCi/g) which alone would produce the same thyroid dose as the quantity and isotopic mixture of I-131, I-132, I-133, 1-134, and I-135 actually present using the thyroid dose conversion factors (DCFs) specified in Table III of TID-14844; the TS Section 1.10 definition of DE 1-131 will be revised to be based on the DCFs specified in Federal Guidance Report 12 (Ref. 9.8). Therefore, this analysis calculates DE-131 in terms of the thyroid dose conversion factors specified in FGR 12. The preaccident iodine spike isotopic iodine concentrations are calculated in Table 4.
4.1.2 Concurrent Iodine Spike Source Term Consistent with RG 1.1 83 (Ref. 9.1, Appendix E, Section 2.2) the second iodine spiking case assumes that the primary system transient associated with the MSLB causes an iodine spike in the primary system. The increase in primary coolant iodine concentration is estimated using a spiking model that assumes that the iodine release rate from the fuel rods to the primary coolant (expressed in curies per unit time) increases to a value 500 times greater than the release rate corresponding to the iodine concentration at the equilibrium value specified in technical specifications (i.e., concurrent iodine spike case). The assumed iodine spike duration is 8 hours9.259259e-5 days <br />0.00222 hours <br />1.322751e-5 weeks <br />3.044e-6 months <br />.
I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1 I Nuclear Common Revision 9 I
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 10 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWERNVERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 Per Technical Specification LCO for reactor coolant specific activity (Refs. 9.6.1 & 9.6.2), the equilibrium primary coolant iodine concentration permitted by the technical specifications is 1.0 pCi/gm DE 1-13 1. The concurrent iodine spike isotopic iodine activity release rates are calculated in Table 7.
4.1.3 Noble Gas Source Term In both preaccident and concurrent iodine spike cases the primary coolant noble gas (Xenon and Krypton) concentrations are assumed to correspond to the maximum coolant activity allowed by the technical specifications.
Per Technical Specification LCO Specific Activity (Ref. 9.6.1 & 9.6.2), the equilibrium primary coolant non-iodine concentration permitted by the technical specifications is 1 OO/E-BAR. The parameter E-BAR is defined as the average, weighted in proportion to the concentration of each radionuclide in the reactor coolant at the time of sampling, of the sum of the average beta and gamma energies per disintegration, in MeV, for isotopes, with half lives greater than 15 minutes, making up at least 95% of the total non-iodine activity in the coolant.
Table 2 calculates a 1 percent failed fuel primary coolant iodine concentration of 3.58 gCi/gm DE 1-13 1, which is conservatively greater than the TS limit of 1.0 pCi/gm DE I-131. Since 1 percent failed fuel introduces more iodine activity into the primary coolant than is allowed by the Tech Specs, it can be conservatively assumed that 1 percent failed fuel introduces more non-iodine activity into the RCS than is allowed by the Tech Spec limit of 1 00/E-bar. Therefore, the PC noble gas concentrations corresponding to 1% fuel defects are conservatively used in Table 5 to determine the total RCS noble gas activity modeled for both the preaccident and concurrent iodine spike cases as shown in Tables 6 and 9.
4.1.4 Activity Release from the Fuel into the Primary Coolant Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Appendix E, Section 3) the activity released from the fuel (for both the preaccident and concurrent iodine spike cases) is assumed to be released instantaneously and homogeneously through the primary coolant.
4.1.5 Iodine Chemical Form Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Appendix E, Section 4) the chemical form of iodine releases from the steam generators to the environment are assumed to be 97% elemental and 3% organic. These fractions apply to iodine released during normal operations, including iodine spiking.
4.2 Transport 4.2.1 Primary-to-Secondary Leak Rates Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Appendix E, Section 5.1) for facilities such as SNGS Units 1 & 2 that have traditional primary-to-secondary leak rate specifications (both per generator and total of all generators), the Nuclear Common Revision 9
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 11 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
l Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 l
leakage is apportioned between faulted and intact steam generators in such a manner that the calculated dose is maximized. Per Technical Specification LCO for RCS operational leakage (Refs. 9.6.4 & 9.6.5), the primary-to-secondary leak rate into the faulted steam generator (i.e., the generator supplying the ruptured main steam line) is 0.35 gpm [= (500 gal/day) / (1440 min/day)]. The total primary-to-secondary leak rate into the three intact steam generators is 0.65 gpm (corresponding to the maximum technical specification leak rate for all steam generators of 1 gpm per TS LCO [Ref. 9.6.4 & 9.6.5] minus the leak rate into the faulted steam generator of 0.35 gpm).
4.2.2 Primary-to-Secondary Leak Primary Coolant Density Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Appendix E, Section 5.2) the primary coolant density used in converting the volumetric primary-to-secondary leak rates (e.g., gpm) to mass leak rates (e.g., Ibm/hr) is assumed to be 1.0 gm/cc (62.4 Ibm/ft3). Conversely, the temperature dependent specific volumes are used for converting the mass flow rates into volumetric flow rates to maximize the releases and consequently the doses.
4.2.3 Primary-to-Secondary Leak Duration Per RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Appendix E, Section 5.3), the primary-to-secondary leakage should be assumed to continue until the primary system pressure is less than the secondary system pressure, or until the temperature of the leakage is less than 100IC (212'F). The release of radioactivity from unaffected (i.e., intact) steam generators should be assumed to continue until shutdown cooling is in operation and releases from the steam generators have been terminated. Per Reference 9.18, shutdown cooling will be placed into operation at 32 hours3.703704e-4 days <br />0.00889 hours <br />5.291005e-5 weeks <br />1.2176e-5 months <br />.
In this analysis primary coolant is assumed to leak into the faulted and intact steam generators and be available for release to the environment for 32 hours3.703704e-4 days <br />0.00889 hours <br />5.291005e-5 weeks <br />1.2176e-5 months <br /> after the initiation of the event, at which time shutdown cooling will be placed into operation.
4.2.4 Noble Gas Releases to the Environment Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Appendix E, Section 5.4) all noble gas radionuclides released from the primary system (via the primary-to-secondary leaks) are assumed to be released to the environment without reduction or mitigation.
I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1 I Nuclear Common Revision 9 I
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 12 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05t2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 4.2.5 Transport Model RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Appendix E, Section 5.5) presents the following generic steam generator transport model for use in evaluating an MSLB accident:
STEAM GENERATOR TRANSPORT MODEL
[
Steam Space R
Prdmary V
6fi-l vBulk Water l
Release via the Faulted Steam Generator:
Per RG 1.183 (Appendix E, Section 5.5.1) a portion of the primary-to-secondary leakage will flash to vapor, based on the thermodynamic conditions in the reactor and secondary coolant. During periods of steam generator dryout, all of the primary-to-secondary leakage is assumed to flash to vapor and be released to the environment without mitigation. Per RG 1.183 (Appendix E, Section 5.6) operating experience and analyses have shown that for some steam generator designs, tube uncovery may occur for a short period following any reactor trip. The potential impact of tube uncovery on the transport model parameters (e.g., flash fraction, scrubbing credit) needs to be considered.
In this analysis the faulted steam generator is assumed to steam dry. Consistent with RG 1.183 (Appendix E, Section 5.5.1), during the period of faulted steam generator dryout, all of the 0.35 gpm primary-to-secondary leakage into the faulted steam generator is assumed to flash to vapor and all of the iodine and noble gas activity P-T-S leakage into the faulted steam generator is assumed to be released directly to the environment with no credit taken for iodine partitioning or scrubbing in the faulted steam generator.
Release via the Intact Steam Generators:
Per RG 1.183 (Appendix E, Section 5.5.1) with regard to the unaffected (i.e., intact) steam generators used for plant cooldown, the 0.65 gpm primary-to-secondary leakage can be assumed to mix with the secondary water without flashing during periods of total tube submergence. All of the noble gas activity in the primary-to-secondary leakage into the three intact steam generators is assumed to be released directly to the environment with no credit taken for iodine partitioning or scrubbing in the faulted generator. All of the iodine activity in the P-T-S leakage into the three intact steam generators is assumed to mix with the secondary water without flashing during this period of total tube submergence. Consistent with RG 1.183 (Appendix E, Section 5.5.4),
the radioactivity in the bulk water of the three intact steam generators (consisting of the initial secondary side I Nuclear Common Revision 9
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 13 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE IREV:
02/05/2004 0
l l
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 water iodine activity and the iodine activity introduced via primary-to-secondary leakage) is assumed to become vapor at a rate that is a function of the steaming rate and an assumed iodine partition coefficient of 1 to maximize the resulting dose.
4.3 Offsite Dose Consequences Regulatory Guide 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Section 4.1) provides guidance to be used in determining the total effective dose equivalent (TEDE) for persons located at the exclusion area boundary (EAB) and at the outer boundary of the low population zone (LPZ). The following sections address the applicability of this guidance to the SNGS Units 1 & 2 MSLB accident analysis.
4.3.1 Modeling of Parent and Daughter Isotopes Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Section 4.1.1), this dose calculation determines the TEDE. TEDE is the sum of the committed effective dose equivalent (CEDE) from inhalation and the deep dose equivalent (DDE) from external exposure. The calculation of these two components of the TEDE considers all radionuclides, including progeny from the decay of parent radionuclides, that are significant with regard to dose consequences and the released radioactivity. These isotopes are listed in Sections 5.3.11 & 5.3.12.
4.3.2 CEDE (Inhalation) Dose Conversion Factors Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9. 1, Section 4.1.2), the exposure-to-CEDE factors for inhalation of radioactive material are derived from the data provided in ICRP Publication 30, "Limits for Intakes of Radionuclides by Workers." This calculation models the CEDE dose conversion factors (DCFs) in the column headed "effective" in Table 2.1 of Federal Guidance Report 1 1, "Limiting Values of Radionuclide Intake and Air Concentration and Dose Conversion Factors for Inhalation, Submersion, and Ingestion" (Ref. 9.7).
4.3.3 Offsite Breathing Rates Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Section 4.1.3), for the first 8 hours9.259259e-5 days <br />0.00222 hours <br />1.322751e-5 weeks <br />3.044e-6 months <br />, the breathing rate of persons offsite is assumed to be 3.5 x 104 cubic meters per second. From 8 to 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> following the accident, the breathing rate is assumed to be 1.8 x 104 cubic meters per second. After that and until the end of the accident, the rate is assumed to be 2.3 x 104 cubic meters per second. These offsite breathing rates are listed in Sections 5.6.3 &
5.6.4.
4.3.4 DDE (Immersion) Dose Conversion Factors Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Section 4.1.4), the DDE is calculated assuming submergence in semi-infinite cloud assumptions with appropriate credit for attenuation by body tissue. The DDE is nominally equivalent to the effective dose equivalent (EDE) from external exposure if the whole body is irradiated uniformly. Since this is a reasonable assumption for submergence exposure situations, EDE is used in lieu of DDE in determining the contribution of external dose to the TEDE. This calculation models the EDE dose INuclear Common Revision 9 X Nuclear Common Revision 9
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 14 of 44 CALC.NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWERIVERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 conversion factors in the column headed "effective" in Table III.1 of Federal Guidance Report 12, "External Exposure to Radionuclides in Air, Water, and Soil" (Ref. 9.8).
4.3.5 Exclusion Area Boundary Dose Acceptance Criteria Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Sections 4.1.5 and 4.4), the TEDE is determined for the most limiting person at the EAB. The maximum EAB TEDE for any two-hour period following the start of the radioactivity release is determined and used in determining compliance with the dose criteria in 10 CFR50.67 (Ref. 9.3). For the MSLB accident the postulated EAB doses should not exceed the criteria established in RG 1.183 Table 6:
EAB Dose Acceptance Criterion (preaccident iodine spike case):
25 Rem TEDE EAB Dose Acceptance Criterion (concurrent iodine spike case):
2.5 Rem TEDE Per RG 1.183 Table 6, the MSLB event release duration is until cold shutdown is established. In this analysis, the MSLB event ends when shutdown cooling is placed into operation at 32 hours3.703704e-4 days <br />0.00889 hours <br />5.291005e-5 weeks <br />1.2176e-5 months <br /> (Reference 9.18).
The RADTRAD Code (Ref. 9.2) used in this analysis determines the maximum two-hour TEDE by calculating the postulated dose for a series of small time increments and performing a "sliding" sum over the increments for successive two-hour periods. The time increments appropriately reflect the progression of the accident to capture the peak dose interval between the start of the event and the end of radioactivity release.
4.3.6 Low Population Zone Outer Boundary Dose Acceptance Criteria Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Sections 4.1.6 and 4.4), the TEDE is determined for the most limiting receptor at the outer boundary of the low population zone (LPZ) and is used in determining compliance with the dose criteria in 10 CFR 50.67 (Ref. 9.3). For the MSLB accident the postulated LPZ doses should not exceed the criteria established in RG 1.183 Table 6:
LPZ Dose Acceptance Criterion (preaccident iodine spike case):
25 Rem TEDE LPZ Dose Acceptance Criterion (concurrent iodine spike case):
2.5 Rem TEDE Per RG 1.183 Table 6, the MSLB event release duration is until cold shutdown is established. In this analysis, the MSLB event ends when shutdown cooling is placed into operation at 32 hours3.703704e-4 days <br />0.00889 hours <br />5.291005e-5 weeks <br />1.2176e-5 months <br /> (Reference 9.18).
4.3.7 Effluent Plume Depletion Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Section 4.1.7), no correction is made for depletion of the effluent plume by deposition on the ground.
4.4 Control Room Offsite Dose Consequences Regulatory Guide 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Section 4.2) provides guidance to be used in determining the total effective dose equivalent (TEDE) for persons located in the control room (CR). The following sections address the I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1 Nuclear Common Revision 9 I
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 15 of 44 CALC.NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWERJVERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 applicability of this guidance to the SNGS Units 1 & 2 MSLB accident analysis. These assumptions are incorporated as design inputs in Sections 5.5.1 through 5.5.17.
4.4.1 Control Room Operator Dose Contributors Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Section 4.2.1), the CR TEDE analysis considers the following sources of radiation that will cause exposure to control room personnel:
- Contamination of the control room atmosphere by the filtered CR ventilation inflow through the CR air intake and by unfiltered inleakage of the radioactive material contained in the post-accident radioactive plume released from the facility,
- Contamination of the control room atmosphere by filtered CR ventilation inflow via the CR air intake and by unfiltered inleakage of airborne radioactive material from areas and structures adjacent to the control room envelope,
- Radiation shine from the external radioactive plume released from the facility (i.e., external airborne cloud shine dose),
- Radiation shine from radioactive material in the reactor containment (i.e., containment shine dose). This form of radiation shine is not applicable to a MSLB accident in which the activity is not released into the containment air space, and
- Radiation shine from radioactive material in systems and components inside or external to the control room envelope (e.g., radioactive material buildup in CR intake and recirculation filters [i.e., CR filter shine dose]).
- Note: The external airborne cloud shine dose and the CR filter shine dose due to a MSLB accident are insignificant compared to those due to a LOCA (see the core release fractions for LOCA and non-LOCA design basis accidents in Tables 1 and 3 of Reference 9.1). Therefore, these direct dose contributions are considered to be insignificant and are not evaluated for a MSLB accident.
4.4.2 Control Room Source Term Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Section 4.2.2), the radioactive material releases and radiation levels used in the control room dose analysis are determined using the same source term, transport, and release assumptions used for determining the EAB and the LPZ TEDE values. These parameters do not result in nonconservative results for the control room.
4.4.3 Control Room Transport Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9. 1, Section 4.2.3), the model used to transport radioactive material into and through the control room is structured to provide suitably conservative estimates of the exposure to control room personnel. The shielding models are not developed to determine radiation dose rates from external sources because their dose contributions are insignificant compared to those from a LOCA (Section 4.4.1).
I uclear Common Revision 9 I
l CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 16 of 44 CALC.NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE IREV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 4.4.4 Control Room Response Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Section 4.2.4), credit for engineered safety features (ESF) that mitigate airborne radioactive material within the control room is assumed. Such features include control room pressurization, and intake and recirculation filtration. Control room isolation is actuated by ESF signals or radiation monitors (RMs). In some cases, the ESF signal is effective only for selected accidents, placing reliance on the RMs for the remaining accidents (see Section 6.7 for CR outside air intake radiation monitor setpoint evaluation). Several aspects of RMs can delay the control room isolation, including the delay for activity to build up to concentrations equivalent to the alarm setpoint and the effects of different radionuclide accident isotopic mixes on monitor response.
4.4.5 Control Room Operator Use of Dose Mitigating Devices Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Section 4.2.5), credit is not taken for the use of personal protective equipment (e.g., protective beta radiation resistant clothing, eye protection, or self-contained breathing apparatus) or prophylactic drugs (i.e., potassium iodide [KI] pills).
4.4.6 Control Room Occupancy Factors and Breathing Rates Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Section 4.2.6), the CR dose receptor for these analyses is the hypothetical maximum exposed individual who is present in the control room for 100% of the time during the first 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> after the event, 60% of the time between 1 and 4 days, and 40% of the time from 4 days to 30 days. For the duration of the event, the breathing rate of this individual should be assumed to be 3.5 x 104 cubic meters per second.
4.4.7 Control Room Dose Conversion Factors Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1, Section 4.2.7), the control room doses are calculated using the offsite dose analysis dose conversion factors identified in RG 1.183 Regulatory Position 4.1 (see above Sections 4.3.2 &
4.3.4). The deep dose equivalent (DDE) from photons is corrected for the difference between finite cloud geometry in the control room and the semi-infinite cloud assumption used in calculating the dose conversion factors. The RADTRAD Code (Ref. 9.2) used in this analysis uses the following expression to correct the semi-infinite cloud dose, DDE., to a finite cloud dose, DDEnnite, where the control room is modeled as a hemisphere that has a volume, V, in cubic feet, equivalent to that of the control room:
DDEfinit, = (DDEO x V0 338) / 1173 4.4.8 Control Room Operator Dose Acceptance Criteria Consistent with RG 1.183 (Ref. 9. 1, Section 4.4), for the MSLB accident the postulated CR doses should not exceed the 5 Rem TEDE criterion established in 10 CFR 50.67 (Ref. 9.3):
CR Dose Acceptance Criterion (preaccident iodine spike case):
5 Rem TEDE CR Dose Acceptance Criterion (concurrent iodine spike case):
5 Rem TEDE Nuclear Common Revision 9
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 17 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/0512004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 5.0 DESIGN INPUTS:
5.1 General Considerations 5.1.1 Applicability of Prior Licensing Basis The implementation of an Alternative Source Term is a significant change to the design basis of the facility and to the assumptions and design inputs used in the analyses. The characteristics of the ASTs and the revised TEDE dose calculation methodology may be incompatible with many of the analysis assumptions and methods currently used in the facility's design basis analyses. The SNGS Units 1 & 2 plant specific design inputs and assumptions used in the current TID-I 4844 analyses were assessed for their validity to represent the as-built condition of the plant and evaluated for their compatibility to meet the AST and TEDE methodology. The analysis in this calculation ensures that analysis assumptions, design inputs, and methods are compatible with the ASTs and the TEDE criteria.
5.1.2 Credit for Engineered Safety Features Credit is taken only for accident mitigation features that are classified as safety-related, are required to be operable by technical specifications, are powered by emergency power sources, and are either automatically actuated or, in limited cases, have actuation requirements explicitly addressed in emergency operating procedures.
5.1.3 Assignment of Numeric Input Values The numeric values that are chosen as inputs to the analyses required by 10 CFR 50.67 (Ref. 9.4) are compatible to AST and TEDE dose criteria and selected with the objective of producing conservative radiological consequences. For conservatism, the limiting values of reactor coolant iodine concentrations listed in the SNGS Units 1 & 2 Technical Specification are used in the analysis.
5.1.4 Meteorology Considerations The control room atmospheric dispersion factors (X/Qs) are developed in Reference 9.5 using the NRC sponsored ARCON96 computer code. The offsite x/Qs were accepted by the staff in previous licensing proceedings.
5.2 Accident-Specific Design Inputs/Assumptions The design inputs/assumptions utilized in the EAB, LPZ, and CR habitability analyses are listed in the following sections. The design inputs are compatible with the AST and TEDE dose criteria, and the assumptions are consistent with those identified in Appendix E of RG 1.183 (Ref. 9.1). The design inputs and assumptions in the following sections represent the as-built design of the plant.
Nuclear Common Revision 9 I I Nuclear Common Revision 9J
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 18 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 Design Input Parameter Value Assigned T
Reference Main Steam Line Break Accident Parameters 5.3 Source Terms 5.3.1 Licensed reactor core power 3,459 MWt 9.6.8 level 5.3.2 Primary Coolant (PC) 1.0 jiCi/gm DE Iodine-131 9.6.1 & 9.6.2 (iodine) specific activity in the Technical Specifications 5.3.3 PC (non-iodine) specific 100 / E-bar 9.6.1 & 9.6.2 activity in the Technical Specifications 5.3.4 Maximum PC (iodine) 60 ptCi/gm DE Iodine-131 at 9.6.7 specific activity permitted by the 100 percent rated thermal power Technical Specifications 5.3.5 Concurrent Iodine Spiking 500 (for a MSLB accident) 9.1, Appendix E, Section 2.2 Factor 5.3.6 Duration of concurrent 8 hours9.259259e-5 days <br />0.00222 hours <br />1.322751e-5 weeks <br />3.044e-6 months <br /> (for a MSLB accident) 9.1, Appendix E, Section 2.2 iodine spike 5.3.7 Secondary coolant (iodine) 0.1 IpCi/gm DE Iodine-131 9.6.6 specific activity in the Technical Specifications 5.3.8 Nominal reactor coolant 12,446 ft3 9.6.3 system (RCS) volume 5.3.9 Total primary-to-secondary 1 gpm 9.6.4 & 9.6.5 leakage through all steam generators (SGs) 5.3.10 Maximum primary-to-500 gallons/day 9.6.4 & 9.6.5 secondary leakage through any one SG 5.3.11 PC iodine activity concentration based on 1% fuel defects 9.11, Table 4 Isotope Activity (.Ci/g)
Isotope Activity (pCi/g)
Isotope Activity (p.Ci/g)
I-131 2.8 I-133 4.2 1-135 2.3 I-132 2.8 1-134 0.57 I
5.3.12 PC noble gas activity based on 1% fuel defects 9.11, Table 4 Isotope Activity (gCi/g)
Isotope Activity (gCilg)
Isotope Activity (glCi/g)
Kr-83M 4.OE-01 Kr-88 3.OE+00 Xe-135M 4.9E-0I Kr-85M 1.7E+00 Xe-131M 2.1E+00 Xe-135 8.5E+00 Kr-85 8.2E+00 Xe-133M 1.7E+01 Xe-138 6.1E-01 Kr-87 l.OE+00 Xe-133 2.6E+02 lNuclearCommon Revision 9l
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET I SHEET 19 of 44 CALC.NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 Design Input Parameter 1 Value Assigned Reference 5.3.13 Steam Generator Dilution 119,233 lbm per UI Model F SG 9.16, pages 7 and 8 Mass 127,646 ibm per U2 Model 51 SG 5.3.14 Fuel Damage No Fuel Failed 9.17, page 4 5.4 Activity Transport Models (Figures 1, 2 & 3) 5.4.1 Steam mass released from 9.24, page 8 faulted SG to the environment Assumed U2 Model 51 SG liquid 0 - 2 hr 128,000 lb mass dryouts in 2 hrs
> 2 hr 0 lb (U2 SG mass is larger than Ul SG mass per Design Input 5.3.13) 5.4.2 PC leakage to faulted SG 0.35 gpm (= 500 gallons/day 9.6.4 & 9.6.5 maximum P-T-S leakage through any one steam generator) 5.4.3 PC leakage to intact SGs 0.65 gpm (= 1 gpm - 0.35 gpm) 9.6.4 & 9.6.5 5.4.4 Primary-to-Secondary leak 32 hours3.703704e-4 days <br />0.00889 hours <br />5.291005e-5 weeks <br />1.2176e-5 months <br /> 9.18, page 4 duration 5.4.5 Steam mass released from 9.24, page 8 intact SGs to the environment 0 - 2 hr 500,000 lbs 2-8 hr 452,000 lbs 8 - 32 hr 2,008,000 lbs 5.4.6 SG liquid iodine partition 100 9.1, Appendix E, Section 5.5.4 coefficient 1 (used in the analysis) 5.5 Control Room Model Parameters (Figure 4) 5.5.1 CR volume 81,420 ft' 9.10, page 33 5.5.2 CR normal flow rate 1,320 cfin (for two air intakes)
Section 6.5 5.5.3 CREACS makeup flow rate 2,200 cfm 9.6.9 5.5.4 CREACS recirc flow rate 8,000 cfm +/- 10% cfm 9.6.10 with one train operating 5,000 cfm (used in analysis)
Section 6.5 5.5.5 CREACS charcoal filter 95%
Section 6.6 efficiency 5.5.6 Delay time for CR 1 minute Assumed pressurization 5.5.7 CREACS HEPA filter 99%
9.6.11 efficiency 95% (used in analysis)
Section 6.6 5.5.8 CR unfiltered inleakage 150 cfm 9.24, Section 3.5.2 5.5.9 CR breathing rate 3.5E-04 ms/sec 9.1, Section 4.2.6 Nuclear Common Revision 9
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 20 of 44 CALC.NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWERIVERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 Design Input Parameter Value Assigned Reference 5.5.10 CR occupancy factors Time (Hr)%
l 9.1, Section 4.2.6 0-24 100 24-96 60 96-720 40 5.5.11 Unit I CR air intake X/Qs for Unit 1 MSSV Set 1 release Time X/Q (sec/nd) 0-2 1.57E-02 9.5, Section 8.1 2-8 1.13E-02 8-24 4.24E-03 24-96 3.08E-03 96-720 2.26E-03 5.5.12 Unit 2 CR air intake X/Qs for Unit 1 MSSV Set 1 release Time X/Q (sec/n 3) 0-2 6.98E-04 9.5, Section 8.1 2-8 5.66E-04 8-24 2.38E-04 24-96 1.65E-04 96-720 1.32E-04 5.5.13 Unit 1 CR air intake x/Qs for Unit 1 Penetration Area Pressure Relief Panel Release Time X/Q (sec/nd) 0-2 5.21E-03 9.5, Section 8.3 2-8 3.54E-03 8-24 1.32E-03 24-96 8.86E-04 96-720 6.80E-04 5.5.14 Unit 2 CR air intake X/Qs for Unit 1 Penetration Area Pressure Relief Panel Release Time X/Q (sec/nd) 0-2 1.96E-03 9.5, Section 8.3
^2:8-1.53E-03 8-24 6.08E-04 24-96 4.23E-04 96-720 3.19E-04 5.5.15 CR allowable dose limit 5 rem TEDE 9.3 5.5.16 CR detector specific 9.12, Table 13 efficiency Xe-133 4.11E7 cpm/lpCi/cc Kr-85 2.51E8 cpml/pCi/cc Nuclear Common Revision 9
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 21 of 44 CALC.NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCRNo. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
0 Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 Design Input Parameter Value Assigned Reference 5.5.17 CR intake monitor 2480 cpm 9.6.16 alarm/trip setpoint 5.6 Site Boundary Release Model Parameters 5.6.1 EAB atmospheric dispersion 1.30E-04 l 9.9, Table 5 factor (X/Q) (sec/m3)
I l
5.6.2 LPZ atmospheric dispersion factors (X/Qs)
Time (Hr)
X/Q (sec/nm)j 9.9, Table 5 0-2 1.86E-05 2-8 7.76E-06 8-24 5.01E-06 24-96 1.94E-06 96-720 4.96E-07 5.6.3 EAB breathing rate (m3/sec) 3.5E-04 9.1, Section 4.1.3 5.6.4 LPZ breathing rates (m3/sec)
Time (Hr)
BR (m3/sec) 9.1, Section 4.1.3 0-8 3.5E-04 8-24 1.8E-04 24-720 2.3E-04 5.6.5 EAB allowable dose limit 9.1, Table 6 Preaccident Iodine Spike Case 25 rem TEDE Concurrent Iodine Spike Case 2.5 rem TEDE 5.6.6 LPZ allowable dose limit 9.1, Table 6 Preaccident Iodine Spike Case 25 rem TEDE Concurrent Iodine Spike Case 2.5 rem TEDE Nuclear Common Revision 9
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET lSHEET 22 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004
6.0 CALCULATIONS
This calculation addresses two cases, a preaccident iodine spiking case and a concurrent iodine spiking case.
Due to the limitations of the RADTRAD code, the MSLB dose consequences for each case are determined by summing together the results from RADTRAD code analyses that separately calculate the dose contributions from the primary-to-secondary (P-T-S) leakage preaccident or concurrent iodine spike iodine activity release, the P-T-S leakage noble gas activity release, and the secondary liquid iodine release. The RADTRAD RFT file SGTRMSLB RFT.txt is interchangeably used for iodine release by setting the iodine release fraction to 1.0 and for noble gas release by setting the noble gas release fraction to 1.0.
6.1 Reactor Coolant & Steam Generator Coolant Mass:
RCS Mass:
RCS water volume = 12,446 ft3 +/- 426 ftO ( Tave of 573 0F (Ref. 9.6.3)
RCS water nominal volume of 12,446 ft3 is used in the analysis, which yields reasonably conservative RCS concentration RCS water density at cooled liquid conditions = 62.4 lb/ft3 (Ref. 9.1, Appendix E, Section 5.2)
RCS water specific volume at 573 0F = 0.02253 ft3/lb (Ref. 9.14, page 182)
RCS water density at 573 0F = 1/0.02253 = 44.39 lb/ft RCS water mass = 12,446 ft3 x 62.4 lb/ft3 x 453.6 g/lbm = 3.523E+08 g used for calculating the RCS activity in Table 4 RCS water mass = 12,446 ft3 x 44.39 lb/ft3 x 453.6 g/lbm = 2.506E+08 g used for calculating the iodine appearance rate in Section 6.2 RCS water mass = 12,446 ft3 x 62.4 lb/ft3 x 453.6 g/lbm = 3.523E+08 g SG Mass:
Reference 9.16, pages 7 and 8, indicates that Salem Unit 1 has Model F steam generators each having a total liquid plus steam mass of 119,233 lbs, and Salem Unit 2 has Model 51 steam generators each having a total mass of 127,646 lbs.
SG Mass For PC Iodine Activity Release:
When evaluating primary-to-secondary (P-T-S) leakage, the use of a smaller secondary dilution mass results in higher secondary activity concentrations, which in turn yield higher P-T-S leakage dose cons-qunrices.
Therefore, the smaller total Unit 1 SG mass of 119,233 lbs is used in evaluating PC iodine releases through the SGs.
Faulted SG volume = 119,233 lb x (1/62.4) ft3/lb =
Intact SGs total volume = 3 x 1,911 ft3 =
I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1 Nuclear Common Revision 9
1 CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 23 of 44 CALC.NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 SG Mass For Secondary Liquid Iodine Activity Release:
When evaluating secondary liquid iodine releases, the larger Unit 2 SG mass is used to maximize the total iodine activity in the secondary liquid, which in turn yields higher secondary liquid release dose consequences.
For conservatism, the total Unit 2 SG liquid plus steam mass is treated as if it were only SG liquid.
Total Intact SGs volume = (3 SGs x 127,646 lb/SG) x (1/62.4) ft3/lb =
Total Intact SGs liquid mass = (3 SGs x 127,646 lb/SG) x 453.6 f/b =
Total Faulted SG volume = (1 SG x 127,646 lb/SG) x (1/62.4) ftlb Total Faulted SG liquid mass = (I SG x 127,646 lb/SG) x 453.6 g/lb =
7 6.2 Iodine Spike Appearance Rate:
Letdown coolant temperature before entering demineralizer = 130 0F (Ref. 9.13, page 4)
Letdown demineralizer decontamination factor (DF) = 10 (Ref. 9.13, page 4)
Specific volume of letdown coolant at 130 0F = 0.016247 ft'A/b (Ref. 9.14, page 185)
RCS mass = 3.523E+08 g (Section 6.1)
Letdown flow rate = 165 gpm (Ref. 9.15)
=165 gal x 1 ft3 x
1 lb x 453.6 g x 1 min
=10,263 g/sec min 7.481 gal 0.016247 ft3 lb 60 sec Specific Activity = Production Rate /Removal Rate (Ref. 9.13, page 4)
Xtotal = Xpurification + Xdecay = [(letdown flow / RCS mass) (1 - I/DF)] + [decay removal rate]
Letdown purification rate = Xpurification = Letdown flow rate/RCS mass (1 - 1/DF)
=
10,263 g x 1
x (1 - 1/10) = 3.686E-05 (sec)-
sec 2.506E+08 g Iodine Appearance Rate = Ai x total = Ai (3.686E-05 secl + Xdecay seCl)
Where Ai = total isotopic iodine activity The isotopic concurrent iodine spike appearance rates are calculated in Table 7 using the isotopic iodine total activity, Xpurification and Xdecay calculated in this section.
6.3 Post-MSLB Release Rates 6.3.1 Faulted SG - Iodine and Noble Gas Release Rate (P-T-S Leakage):
No noble gas hold-up or decay is modeled in the Faulted SG. All RCS mass released to the faulted SG is treated as if it were released directly to the environment.
RCS release rate into faulted SG = 0.35 gpm (= maximum leak rate into any one SG)
RCS specific volume @ 573 0F saturation temp. = 0.02253 ft3/lbm (Ref. 9.14, page 182) 0-32 hr noble gas P-T-S release rate from RCS to environment through dried-out Faulted SG I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1 I Nuclear Common Revision 9 I
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 24 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 l0 Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004
= 0.35 gallon/minute x (62.4 lb/ft3 x 0.02253 ft3/lb) x 1 ft3 = 0.066 cfm of RCS liquid 7.481 gal Iodine partition coefficient = 1.0 (no credit taken for P-T-S leakage iodine retention in the dried-out Faulted SG) 0-32 hr iodine P-T-S release rate from RCS to environment through dried-out Faulted SG
(0.066 cfm of RCS liquid) x (1/1.0) = 0.066 cfm of RCS liquid 0-32 hr iodine P-T-S leakage release from RCS to the environ, via the faulted SG = p 0-32 hr noble gas P-T-S leakage release from RCS to the environ, via the faulted SG
6.3.2 Intact SGs - Iodine Release & Steaming Rates (P-T-S Leakage):
The use of specific volume of the saturated water at average steam temperature yields a higher steaming rate than the use of specific volume of saturated water at the room temperature. Therefore, the specific volume of the saturated water at average steam temperature is used in the following section to calculate the steaming rates:
Total RCS P-T-S leakage = 1 gallon/minute (Refs. 9.6.4 & 9.6.5)
RCS release rate into faulted SG = 0.35 gpm (Section 6.3.1)
RCS release rate into intact SGs = 0.65 gpm (= 1 gpm minus maximum leak rate of 0.35 gpm into faulted SG)
RCS specific volume @ 5730F saturation temp. = 0.02253 ft3/lbm (Ref. 9.14, page 182) 0-32 hr iodine P-T-S leakage rate from RCS to the three intact SGs
= 0.65 gallon/minute x (62.4 lb/ft3 x 0.02253 ft3/lb) x 1 ft3
= 0.122 cfm of RCS liquid 7.481 gal Reactor pressure vessel (RPV) average temperature = 588.4 F (Ref. 9.16, page 7), which is the thermal-hydraulic design value for the Model F steam generator design. The use of RPV temperature is conservative for the SG steaming rate because it yields a hi gher liquid density for the SG Specific volume of SG liquid = 0.02313 ft lb (Ref. 9.14, page 181)
Iodine partition coefficient = 1.0 (no credit taken for P-T-S leakage iodine retention in the Intact SGs liquid)
Total mass of steam released from intact SGs to the environment (0 - 2 hr) = 500,000 lb (Ref. 9.24, page 8)
Intact SGs steaming rate (0 - 2 hr) = 500,000 lb x 0.02313 ft3flb x (1/1.0) = 96.38 cfhi of Intact SGs liquid 120 minutes Total mass of steam released from intact SG to the environment (2 - 8 hr) = 452,000 lb (Ref. 9.24, page 8)
Intat nsse rate (2 - 8 hr) = 452,000 lb x 0.02313 ft3/lb x (1/1.0) = 29.04 cfm of Intact SGs liquid 360 minutes Total mass of steam released from intact SG to the environment (8 - 32 hrs) = 2,008,000 lb (Ref. 9.24, page 8)
Intact SGs steaming rate (8 - 32 hr) = 2,008,000 lb x 0.02313 ft3/lb x (1/1.0) = 32.25 cfm of Intact SGs liquid 1440 minutes 0-32 hr iodine P-T-S leakage from RCS to intact SGs =
0 - 2 hr iodine P-T-S leakage release from intact SGs to the environment =
8 o
tact' 5F 2 - 8 hr iodine P-T-S leakage release from intact SGs to the environment =
- c I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1
t CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 25 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWERNERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 8 - 32 hr iodine P-T-S leakage release from intact SGs to the environment = P: !o nta qqit 6.3.3 Intact SGs -Noble Gas Release Rate (P-T-S Leakage):
No noble gas hold-up or decay is modeled in the Intact SGs. All RCS mass released to the intact SGs is treated as if it were released directly to the environment.
RCS release rate into Intact SGs = 0.65 gpm (Section 6.3.2)
RCS specific volume @ 573 0F saturation temp. = 0.02253 ft3/lbm (Ref. 9.14, page 182) 0-32 hr noble gas P-T-S release rate from RCS to environment through Intact SGs
='0.65 gallon/minute (62.4 lb/ft3 x 0.02253 f 3/lb) x 1 ft3 = 0.122 cfm of RCS liquid 7.481 gal 0-32 hr noble gas P-T-S leakage release from RCS to the environ, via the intact SGs = 2
- I
=
t 6.3.4 Faulted SG - Iodine Release Rate - Secondary Liquid Steam mass released from faulted SG (0 - 2 hrs) = 128,000 lb (Ref. 9.24, page 8)
Steam mass released from faulted SG (2-32 hrs) =0 lb SG Vessel temperature = 588.40F (Ref. 9.16, page 7)
Specific volume of SG liquid = 0.02313 ft3/lb (Ref. 9.14, page 181)
Iodine partition coefficient = 1.0 (no credit taken for secondary liquid iodine retention in faulted SG liquid) 0-2 hr Faulted SG steaming rate = 128,000 lb x 0.02313 t3/lb x (1/1.0) = 24.67 cfm of Faulted SG liquid 120 minutes 0-2 hr iodine release from faulted SG to the environment = P4.-.:7z6 fflte 'uiliqi 2-32 hr iodine release from faulted SG to the environment --
fl i-q uii 6.3.5 Intact SGs - Iodine Release Rate - Secondary Liquid The steaming rates for the secondary liquid iodine releases from the intact steam generators are the intact SGs iodine release rates from Section 6.3.2. An iodine partition coefficient of 1.0 is conservatively applied to the intact steam generators (i.e., no credit taken for secondary liquid iodine retention in the intact SGs liquid):
0 - 2 hr iodine release from all SGs to the environment = 96.38 cfm x (1/1.0) =
3 2 - 8 hr iodine release from all SGs to the environment = 29.04 cfm x (1/1.0) =
8 - 32 hr iodine release from all SGs to the environment = 32.25 cfm x (1/1.0) =
f 6.4 Fuel Activity Release Rate The release rate from the source node - fuel to RCS - is calculated such that 99% of the activity in the fuel is released to the RCS in eight hours. The 1 % of the activity remaining in the fuel is an insignificant dose Nuclear Common Revision 9
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 26 of 44 CALC.NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE IREV:
02/05/2004 0
l I
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 contribution. The volume of the fuel is inconsequential, given that 99% of the activity will be released irrespective of the fuel volume.
A = Ao eXt Where; AO = Initial Activity in Fuel Node A = Final Activity in Fuel Node X = Removal Rate (vol/hr) t = Removal Time (hr) = 8.0 hr Assuming that 99% of activity is released into the environment, A/Ao = 0.01 Therefore, A/Ao = eXt 0.01 = CS%
In (0.01) = - 8X ln(e)
-4.605=-8 X X = - 4.605/-8 = 0.5756 volume/hr Assuming an arbitrary fuel volume of 1,000 cubic feet, the Fuel Release Rate is:
= 0.5756 1/hr x 1,000 ft3 x 1 hr/60 min _ 9.60 ft3/min 6.5 CR Air Flow Rates:
Normal Flow Rate Notes "S" to the Reference 9.19 ventilation drawings provide the outside air flow rates to Zone I from the Unit 1 and Unit 2 air intakes. Zone I is the combined control room envelop. Zone 1 receives only a fraction of the 2,200 cfm of outside air introduced into the building. The fraction is equivalent to the ratio of the Zone 1 (control room pressure boundary) supply air flow rate [8,000 cfm] to the total control area air conditioning system (CAACS) normal airflow rate [32,600 cfm = 2,200 cfm outside air + 30,400 cfm recirculation air)].
Notes "S" provide the following calculation for the amount of outside air to Zone 1:
= (8,000 cfm / 32,600 cfm) x (2,200 cfm) = 540 cfm Per Notes "S", use 600 cfm for Zone 1 During Normal Plant Operation Total Amount of Outside Air Flow Rate From Both Intakes = 2 x 600 cfm = 1,200 cf n Maximum Amount of Outside Air Flow Rate = 1.1 x 1,200 cfm = 1,320 cfm (including 10 percent uncertainty)
CREACS Recirculation Flow Rate With CR Monitors Preferentially Selecting Less Contaminated Air Intake CREACS ventilation flow rate = 8,000 cfm +/- 10% cfm (Ref. 9.6.10)
Minimum CREACS flow rate = 8,000 cfm - (0.10 x 8,000 cfm) = 8,000 cfm - 800 cfm = 7,200 cfm Net CREACS recirculation flow rate = Minimum CREACS flow rate - CREACS makeup flow rate 7,200 cfm - 2,200 cfm (Ref. 9.6.9) = 5,000 cfm INuclear Common Revision 9 l Nuclear Common Revision 9
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 27 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCRNo. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWERIVERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 6.6 CREACS Charcoal/HEPA Filter Efficiencies:
Charcoal Filter In-place penetration testing acceptance criteria for the safety related Charcoal filters are as follows:
CREACS Charcoal Filter - in-laboratory testing methyl iodide penetration < 2.5% (Ref. 9.6.12)
USNRC Generic Letter 99-02 (Ref. 9.20) requires a safety factor of at least 2 to be used to determine the filter efficiencies to be credited in the design basis accident.
Testing methyl iodide penetration (%) = (100% - )/safety factor = (100% - 71)/2 Where il = charcoal filter efficiency to be credited in the analysis CREACS Charcoal Filter 2.5%= (100%-il)/2 5%= (10 0 %-i) i = 100% - 5% = 95%
HEPA Filter HEPA filter efficiency = 99% (Ref. 9.6.11). HEPA filter efficiency of 95% is used in the analysis Safety Grade Filter Efficiency Credited (%)
Filter Aerosol Ee naOrganic CREACS 95 95 95 6.7 CR Outside Air Intake Radiation Monitor Setpoint Evaluation:
CR Detector Specific Efficiencies:
Xe-133 = 4.11E7 cpm/jiCi/cc (Ref. 9.12, Table 13)
Kr-85 = 2.5 1E8 cpm/ntCi/cc (Ref. 9.12, Table 13)
The initial Xe-133 and Kr-85 concentrations at the CR intake for the design basis MSLB are calculated as follows:
Concentration = (RCS activity)/(RCS volume) x (RCS leak rate) x (X/Q)
Faulted SG:
RCS Activity Xe-133 = 9.16E+04 Ci and Kr-85 = 2.889E+03 Ci (Tables 6 & 9)
RCS Volume = 12,446 ft3 (Ref. 9.6.3) 0-2 hour X/Q = 5.2 1E-03 sec/m 3 (Ref. 9.5, Section 8.3)
RCS Leak Rate of Noble Gas isotopes directly to the environment = 0.066 ft3/min (Section 6.3.1)
Xe-133 Concentration at the CR intake
= (9.16E+04 Ci / 12,446 ft3) x (0.066 ft3/min) x (5.21E-03 sec/M3) x (1/60 min/sec)
= 4.22E-05 Ci/m3 = 4.22E-05 [.Ci/cc Kr-85 Concentration at the CR intake
= (2.889E+03 Ci / 12,446 ft3) x (0.066 ft3/min) x (5.21E-03 sec/M3) x (1/60 min/sec)
I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 28 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004
= 1.33E-06 Ci/m 3 = 1.33E-06 gCi/cc Count Rate Xe-133 = 4.22E-05 ptCi/cc x 4.1 1E7 cpm/iCi/cc = 1,734 cpm Count Rate Kr-85 = 1.33E-06 giCi/cc x 2.51E8 cpm/pCi/cc = 333 cpm Intact SGs:
RCS Activity Xe-133 = 9.16E+04 Ci and Kr-85 = 2.889E+03 Ci (Tables 6 & 9) 0-2 hour X/Q = 1.57E-02 sec/m3 (Ref. 9.5, Section 8.1)
RCS Leak Rate of Noble Gas isotopes directly to the environment during first 2 hrs through just one of the three intact SGs = (0.122 ft3/rin) / (3) = 0.0407 ft3/min (Section 6.3.2)
Xe-133 Concentration at the CR intake
= (9.16E+04 Ci / 12,446 ft3) x (0.0407 ft3/min) x (1.52E-02 sec/m3) x (1/60 min/sec)
= 7.59E-05 Ci/m3 = 7.59E-05 jiCi/cc Kr-85 Concentration at the CR intake
= (2.889E+03 Ci / 12,446 ft3) x (0.0407 ft3/min) x (1.52E-02 sec/m3) x (1/60 min/sec)
= 2.39E-06 Ci/m3 = 2.39E-06 piCi/cc Count Rate Xe-133 = 7.59E-05 gCi/cc x 4.1 1E7 cpm/lCi/cc = 3,119 cpm Count Rate Kr-85 = 2.39E-06 [tCi/cc x 2.5 1E8 cpm/pCi/cc = 599 cpm Combined Count Rate of CR Intake Detector
= 1,734 cpm + 333 cpm + 3,119 cpm + 599 cpm
= 5,785 cpm >> CR Monitor Setpoint of 2,480 cpm The Post-MSLB accident concentration at the CR intake exceeds the CR monitor setpoint value of 2,480 cpm, therefore the CR monitor will respond instantaneously.
I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1 Nuclear Common Revision 9 I
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 29 of 44 CALC.NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWERIVERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 7.0 RESULTS
SUMMARY
7.1 The results of the MSLB accident with the preaccident iodine spike are summarized in the following table with the CR monitors preferentially selecting the less contaminated CR air intake:
MSLB Accident - Preaccident Iodine Case TEDE Dose (rem)
Receptor Location Control Room EAB LPZ P-T-S Iodine Release FSG 6.62E-02 2.14E-02 1.O1E-02 SMSLFPID00 (occurs at t = 0)
P-T-S NG Release FSG 2.15E-04 8.77E-05 4.1 lE-05 SMSLFNGOO (occurs at t = 0)
P-T-S Iodine Release ISG 3.62E-02 3.44E-02 1.40E-02 SMSLINPID0O (occurs at t = 8.0 hrs)
P-T-S NG Release ISG 1.52E-04 1.62E-04 7.57E-05 SMSLBNGOO (occurs at t = 0)
Liquid Iodine Release FSG 4.39E-03 7.1OE-03 1.02E-03 SMSFSLIDOO (occurs at t = 0)
Liquid Iodine Release ISG 1.81E-02 3.15E-02 4.79E-03 SMSINSLIDOO (occurs at t = 0)
Total 1.25E-01 9.46E-02 3.OOE-02 Allowable TEDE Limit 5.OOE+00 2.50E+01 2.50E+01 FSG = Faulted SG ISG = Intact SG s
- I I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 30 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE IREV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/ERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 7.2 The results of the MSLB accident with the concurrent iodine spike are summarized in the following table with the CR monitors preferentially selecting the less contaminated CR air intake:
MSLB Accident - Concurrent Iodine Case TEDE Dose (rem)
Receptor Location Control Room EAB LPZ P-T-S Iodine Release FSG 5.32E-01 1.85E-01 7.75E-02 SMSLFCID01 (occurs at t = 5.0 hrs)
P-T-S NG Release FSG 2.15E-04 8.77E-05 4.1 1E-05 SMSLFNGOO (occurs at t = 0)
P-T-S Iodine Release ISG 2.92E-01 3.12E-01 1.05E-01 SMSLINCIDO1 (occurs at t = 8.4 hrs)
P-T-S NG Release ISG 1.52E-04 1.62E-04 7.57E-05 SMSLBNGOO (occurs at t = 0)
Liquid Iodine Release FSG 4.39E-03 7.1OE-03 1.02E-03 SMSFSLIDOO (occurs at t = 0)
Liquid Iodine Release ISG 1.81E-02 3.15E-02 4.79E-03 SMSINSLIDOO (occurs at t = 0)
Total 8.47E-01 5.36E-01 1.88E-01 Allowable TEDE Limit 5.OOE+00 2.50E+00 2.50E+00 FSG = Faulted SG ISG = Intact SG
8.0 CONCLUSION
S:
The results of MSLB accident analyses in Section 7.0 indicate that the EAB, LPZ, and CR doses due to a MSLB accident are within their allowable limits.
I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1 Nu l a Co m nR v s o
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 31 of 44 CALC.NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004
9.0 REFERENCES
- 1.
U.S. NRC Regulatory Guide 1.183, Alternative Radiological Source Terms for Evaluating Design Basis Accidents at Nuclear Power Reactors, July 2000
- 2.
S.L. Humphreys et. al., "RADTRAD: A Simplified Model for Radionuclide Transport and Removal and Dose Estimation," NUREG/CR-6604, USNRC, April 1998
- 3.
10 CFR 50.67, "Accident Source Term"
- 4.
Critical Software Package Identification No. A-0-ZZ-MCS-0225, Rev.0, RADTRAD Computer Code, Version 3.02
- 5.
Calculation No. S-C-ZZ-MDC-1959, Rev. 0, CR x/Qs Using ARCON96 Code - Non-LOCA Releases
- 6.
Salem 1 & 2 Technical Specifications:
- 1.
Specification 3.4.8, Salem Unit 1 Limiting Condition for Operation (LCO) for Reactor Coolant System Specific Activity
- 2.
Specification 3.4.9, Salem Unit 2 LCO for Reactor Coolant System Specific Activity
- 3.
Specification 5.4.2, Salem Unit 1/Unit 2 Reactor Coolant System Volume
- 4.
Specification 3.4.6.2, Salem Unit 1 LCO for Reactor Coolant System Operational Leakage
- 5.
Specification 3.4.7.2, Salem Unit 2 LCO for Reactor Coolant System Operational Leakage
- 6.
Specification 3.7.1.4, Salem Unit I/Unit 2 LCO for Plant System Activity
- 7.
Technical Specification Figure 3.4-1, Salem Unit 1/Unit 2 Dose Equivalent I-131 Primary Coolant Specific Activity Limit
- 8.
Specification 1.25, Salem Unit 1/Unit 2 Rated Thermal Power
- 9.
Specification Surveillance Requirement 4.7.6.l.d.3, Salem Unit 1/Unit 2 CREACS Design Makeup Flow Rate
- 10.
Specification Surveillance Requirement 4.7.6.l.d.1, Salem Unit 1/Unit 2 CREACS Ventilation Flow Rate
- 11.
Specification Surveillance Requirement 4.7.6.1.e, Salem Unit l/Unit 2 HEPA Filter DOP
- 12.
Specification Surveillance Requirement 4.7.6.1.b.3, Salem Unit 1/Unit 2 CREACS Methyl Iodide Penetration
- 13.
Specification 1.10, Salem Unit 1/Unit 2 Dose Equivalent I-131
- 14.
Specification 3.7.6.1, Salem Unit I LCO for Control Room Emergency Air Conditioning System
- 15.
Specification 3.7.6, Salem Unit 2 LCO for Control Room Emergency Air Conditioning System
- 16.
Specification 3.3.3.1 and Table 3.3-6, Salem Unit 1/Unit 2 LCO for Radiation Monitoring Instrumentation Nuclear Common Revision 9 I Nuclear Common Revision 9 l
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 32 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
l Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004
- 7.
Federal Guidance Report 11, EPA-520/1-88-020, Environmental Protection Agency
- 8.
Federal Guidance Report 12, EPA-402-R-93-081, Environmental Protection Agency
- 9.
Vendor Technical Document No. 321035, Rev. 3, Accident X/Q Values at the Salem Generating Station Control Room Fresh Air Intakes, Exclusion Area Boundary and Low Population Zone.
- 10.
CD P534 of Design Change Package (DCP) No. lEC-3505, Rev. 7, Package No. 1, Control Area Air Conditioning System Upgrade
- 11.
Westinghouse Calculation No. RSAC-PSE-800, 04/26/93, Source Term for Salem Margin Recovery
- 12.
Vendor Technical Document No. 311649, Rev 1, Accuracy Analysis of the Sorrento Electronics WRGM, Liquid Effluent, and In-Line Duct Monitors
- 13.
Westinghouse Calculation No. CN-CRA-93-057, Rev. 0, Salem Coolant Activity, Iodine Spike Appearance Rates and Secondary Activity
- 14.
ASME Steam Tables, Sixth Edition
- 15.
Notification No. 20134987, Order 70030162, Operation 0060, Engineering Evaluation Maximum Letdown Flow
- 16.
Nuclear Fuel Section Calculation File No. DS 1.6-0453, Determination of Steam Release Flows for Input to the Radiological Dose Analysis
- 17.
Westinghouse Calculation No. CN-CRA-93-085, Rev. 0, Salem Main Steamline Break
- 18.
Letter FSE/SS-PSE-7561, Salem Units 1 & 2 Maximum RHRS "Cut-In" Time for Termination of Design Basis Event Steam Releases, 3/18/93
- 19.
SNGS Mechanical P&IDs:
- a.
205248, Rev. 44, Sheet 2, Unit I Aux Bldg Control Area Air Conditioning & Ventilation
- b.
205348, Rev. 34, Sheet 2, Unit 2 Aux Bldg Control Area Air Conditioning & Ventilation
- 20.
USNRC Generic Letter 99-02, "Laboratory Testing of Nuclear-Grade Activated Charcoal", June 3, 1999
- 21.
Not Used.
- 22.
Not Used.
- 23.
GE-NE-0000-00 I1-3853-Rl, DRF 0000-0004-6923, Revision 1, Class III, June 2003, GE Nuclear Energy Project Task Report T0807, Coolant Radiation Sources (for Hope Creek Generating Station Extended Power Uprate)
- 24.
SNGS Calculation No. S-C-ZZ-MDC-1987, Rev. 1, Input Parameters for Salem AST Dose CaIcs INuclear Common Revision 9 l Nuclear Common Revision 9 I
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 33 of 44 CALC.NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 10.0 TABLES:
Table 1 Iodine Isotopic Dose Conversion Factors Isotopic Conversion Iodine Dose Factor Dose Isotope Conversion Conversion Factor Factor (Sv/Bq)
(rem/Ci/Sv/Bq)
(rem/Ci)
A B
C=AxB 1-131 2.92E-07 3.70E+12 1.08E+06 I-132 1.74E-09 3.70E+12 6.44E+03 1-133 4.86E-08 3.70E+12 1.80E+05 I-134 2.88E-10 3.70E+12 1.07E+03 1-135 8.46E-09 3.70E+12 3.13E+04 A From Reference 9.7, Page 136 Table 2 Iodine Scaling Factors Preaccident Iodine Spike & Equilibrium Iodine Concentration 1% Failed Fuel Iodine Iodine Dose Product Isotope Activity Conversion Concentration Factor pCi.rem/Ci.g (0C0g)
(rem/Ci)
(rem)
A B
(AxB) 1-131 2.80E+00 1.08E+06 3.02E+06 1-132 2.80E+00 6.44E+03 1.80E+04 1-133 4.20E+00 1.80E+05 7.55E+05 1-134 5.70E-01 1.07E+03 6.08E+02 1-135 2.30E+00 3.13E+04 7.20E+04 Total 3.87E+06 A From Reference 9.11, Table 4; and B from Table 1 l1-131 DEBased on 1% FF Iodine Concentration 3.58E+00
[odine Scaling Factor Based on 1.0 pCi/g DE 1-1311 2.791E-01 INuclear Common Revision 9 I Nuclear Common Revision 9 I
1.
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 34 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/0512004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWERIVERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 Table 3 RCS Iodine Concentration Based on 1.0 iCi/g DE 1-131 1% Failed Fuel Iodine 1.0 pCi/g Iodine Scaling DE 1-131 Isotope Activity Factor Activity Concentration 1.0 pCi/g Concentration (WCitg)
DE 1-131 (tCi/g)
A B
C=AxB I-131 2.80E+00 2.791E-01 7.814E-01 I-132 2.80E+00 2.791E-01 7.814E-01 1-133 4.20E+00 2.791E-01 1.172E+00 I-134 5.70E-01 2.791E-01 1.5911E-01 1-135 2.30E+00 2.791E-01 6.419E-01 A From Reference 9.11, Table 4 B Scaling Factor Based on 1.0 pCi/g DE I-131 From Table 2 Table 4 Total RCS Iodine Activity - Preaccident Iodine Spike Case Tech Spec Reactor Total RCS Activity RCS Coolant 1.0 10C/g 60.0 gCi/g Isotope Activity Mass DE 1-131 DE 1-131 Concentration (WiCtg)
(g)
(Ci)
(Ci)
A B
C=AxB/IE-6 Cx6O 1-131 7.814E-01 3.523E+08 2.753E+02 1.652E+04 1-132 7.814E-01 3.523E+08 2.753E+02 1.652E+04 I-133 1.172E+00 3.523E+08 4.130E+02 2.478E+04 1-134 1.591E-01 3.523E+08 5.604E+01 3.363E+03 1-135 6.419E-01 3.52a+/-Q#._
2.261E+02 1.357E+04 A From Table 3 B Reactor coolant mass from Section 6.1 --
I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1 Nuclear Common Revision 9
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET I
SHEET 35 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/ERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 Table 5 Total RCS Noble Gas Activity - Preaccident Iodine Spike 1% Failed Fuel Noble Gas Primary Total Isotope Activity Coolant Noble Gas Concentration Mass Activity (pCig)
(g)
(Ci)
A B
C=AxB/lE6 Kr-83m 4.OOOE-01 3.523E+08 1.409E+02 Kr-85m 1.700E+00 3.523E+08 5.989E+02 Kr-85 8.200E+00 3.523E+08 2.889E+03 Kr-87 I.OOOE+00 3.523E+08 3.523E+02 Kr-88 3.OOOE+00 3.523E+08 1.057E+03 Xe-131 m 2.100E+00 3.523E+08 7.398E+02 Xe-133m 1.700E+01 3.523E+08 5.989E+03 Xe-133 2.600E+02 3.523E+08 9.160E+04 Xe-135m 4.900E-01 3.523E+08 1.726E+02 Xe-135 8.500E+00 3.523E+08 2.995E+03 Xe-138 6.100E-01 3.523E+08 2.149E+02 A From Reference 9.11, Table 4 B From Section 6.1 I Nuclear Common Revision 9
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 36 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 Table 6 Total Iodine & Noble Gas Activities in RCS Preaccident Iodine Spike Iodine &
RADTRAD Noble Gas Nuclide Isotope Total Inventory Activity File (Ci)
(Ci)
J-131 1.652E+04
.1652E+05 I-132 1.652E+04
.1652E+05 I-133 2.478E+04
.2478E+05 I-134 3.363E+03
.3363E+04 1-135 1.357E+04
.1357E+05 Kr-83m 1.409E+02
.1409E+03 Kr-85m 5.989E+02
.5989E+03 Kr-85 2.889E+03
.2889E+04 Kr-87 3.523E+02
.3523E+03 Kr-88 1.057E+03
.1057E+04 Xe-131m 7.398E+02
.7398E+03 Xe-133m 5.989E+03
.5989E+04 Xe-133 9.160E+04
.9160E+05 Xe-135m 1.726E+02
.1726E+03 Xe-135 2.995E+03
.2995E+04 Xe-138 2.149E+02
.2149E+03 Iodine Activity from Table 4 Noble gas activity from Table 5 INuclear Common Revision 9 I Nuclear Common Revision 9
I I
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 37 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
l Mark Drucker, REVIEWERIVERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 Table 7 Iodine Appearance Rate for Concurrent Iodine Spike 1.0 jxCi/g Letdown Iodine Iodine DE 1-131 Decay Purification Appearance Spike Isotope Iodine Constant Removal Rate Appearance Activity X
Rate Rate (Ci)
(sec)-'
(sec)-'
(Ci/sec)
(Ci/sec)
A B
C D=Ax(B+C)
E=Dx500 1-131 2.753E+02 9.977E-07 3.686E-05 1.042E-02 5.211 1-132 2.753E+02 8.426E-05 3.686E-05 3.334E-02 16.672 1-133 4.130E+02 9.257E-06 3.686E-05 1.904E-02 9.522 1-134 5.604E+01 2.196E-04 3.686E-05 1.437E-02 7.186 1-135 2.261E+02 2.924E-05 3.686E-05 1.495E-02 7.474 Total Appearance Rate (Ci/sec) 46.066 A From Table 4 B From Reference 9.23, Appendix A (X per hr is converted into per sec)
C From Section 6.2 Table 8 Total Iodine Activity In Fuel - Concurrent Iodine Spike Iodine Concurrent Concurrent Spike Iodine Spike Iodine Spike Isotope Appearance Duration Total Rate Iodine Activity (Ci/sec)
(hrs)
(Ci)
A B
AxBx3600 1-131 5.211 8
1.501E+05 1-132 16.672 8
4.802E+05 1-133 9.522 8
2.742E+05 I-134 7.186 8
2.070E+05 1-135 7.474 8
2.152E+05 A From Table 7 B From Reference 9.1, Appendix F, Section 2.2 I Nuclear Common Revision 9 l Nuclear Common Revision 9 I
I I
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 38 of 44 CALC.NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 Table 9 Total Iodine & Noble Gas Activities In Fuel Concurrent Iodine Spike Iodine &
RADTRAD Noble Gas Nuclide Isotope Total Inventory Activity File (Ci)
(Ci) 1-131 1.501E+05
.1501E+06 1-132 4.802E+05
.4802E+06 I-133 2.742E+05
.2742E+06 1-134 2.070E+05
.2070E+06 1-135 2.152E+05
.2152E+06 Kr-83m 1.409E+02
.1409E+03 Kr-85m 5.989E+02
.5989E+03 Kr-85 2.889E+03
.2889E+04 Kr-87 3.523E+02
.3523E+03 Kr-88 1.057E+03
.1057E+04 Xe-131m 7.398E+02
.7398E+03 Xe-133m 5.989E+03
.5989E+04 Xe-133 9.160E+04
.9160E+05 Xe-135m 1.726E+02
.1726E+03 Xe-135 2.995E+03
.2995E+04 Xe-138 2.149E+02
.2149E+03 A - Iodine activity from Table 8 A - Noble gas from Table 6 I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1 I Nuclear Common Revision 9 I
I I
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 39 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE IREV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 Table 10 Secondary Side Iodine Activity - Intact Steam Generators 1.0 liCi/g Tech Spec Coolant Mass Secondary RADTRAD DE 1-131 Secondary In 3 Intact Side Nuclide Isotope Activity Coolant Steam Activity Inventory Concentration Activity Limit Generators File (WCig)
(tCi/g)
(g)
(Ci)
(Ci)
A B
C AxBxC/1E6 I-131 7.814E-01 0.10 1.737E+08 13.574
.1357E+02 1-132 7.814E-01 0.10 1.737E+08 13.574
- 1357E+02 I-133 1.172E+00 0.10 1.737E+08 20.360
.2036E+02 1-134 1.5911E-01 0.10 1.737E+08 2.763
.2763E+01 I-135 6.419E-01 0.10 1.737E+08 11.150
.111 5E+02 A From Table 3 B From Reference 9.6.6 C From Section 6.1 Table 11 Secondary Side Iodine Activity - Faulted Steam Generator 1.0 fpCi/g Tech Spec Coolant Mass Secondary RADTRAD DE 1-131 Secondary In Faulted Side Nuclide Isotope Activity Coolant Steam Activity Inventory Concentration Activity Limit Generator File (1Ci1g)
(WCitg)
(g)
(Ci)
(Ci)
A B
C AxBxC/lE6 1-131 7.814E-01 0.10 5.790E+07 4.525
.4525E+01 1-132 7.814E-01 0.10 5.790E+07 4.525
.4525E+01 1-133 1.172E+00 0.10 5.790E+07 6.787
.6787E+01 1-134 1.591E-01 0.10 5.790E+07 0.9211
.9211E+00 1-135 6.419E-01 0.10 5.790E+07 3.717
.3717E+01 A From Table 3 B From Reference 9.6.6 C From Section 6.1 I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1 Nuclear Common Revision 9
I CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 40 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 11.0 FIGURES:
Figure 1: RADTRAD Nodalization For MSLB Accident with a Preaccident Iodine Spike Release P-T-S Leakage Iodine Release Path Noble Gas Release Path INuclear Common Revision 9 l Nuclear Common Revision 9
I I
I I
- ~
I.CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 41 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCRNo. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05t2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004
~
P--S odne elese
-S Nol Ga ReleaV Via FaultedaSGted SG N
V-iaF aulte SG PIf System 0-8 hrs /9.6 cfm Fuel 0-2 hrs /96.38 cfm M
V=12,446 ft3 E
T i^
T:'sl^
S2-8 h rs 129.04 cfm 1 l f l0-32 hrs / 0.122 cf SIteactml T
V - 5,732 ft3
^; j>R4-z-r;Y
^ ^1 tB.44tifl1-ka z
8-32 hrs 132.25 cfm P-T-S Noble Gas Release via Intact SGs 0-32hrs /0.122 cfm Figure 2: RADTRAD Nodalization For MSLB Accident with a Concurrent Iodine Spike Release P-T-S Leakage Iodine Release Path Noble Gas Release Path II Nueiear Common Revision 9 I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET SHEET 42 of 44 CALC. NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE IREV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 Figure 3: RADTRAD Nodalization For Post-MSLB Secondary Liquid Iodine Release Nuclear Common Revision 9 INuclear Common Revision 9 l
F.I t
CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET ISHEET 43 of 44 CALC.NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/0512004 Figure 4 - RADTRAD Nodalization For CR Response With CR HVAC Intake Radiation Monitors Preferentially Selecting the Less Contaminated Air Intake I Nuclear Common Revision 9 1t I Nuclear Common Revision 9 I
- CALCULATION CONTINUATION SHEET l SHEET 44 of 44 CALC.NO.: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950
REFERENCE:
LCR No. S03-05 Gopal J. Patel, ORIGINATOR, DATE REV:
02/05/2004 0
Mark Drucker, REVIEWER/VERIFIER, DATE 02/05/2004 12.0 AFFECTED DOCUMENTS:
Upon approval of Licensing Change Request LCR S03-05, the following documents will be either voided or revised:
Document to be voided:
Vendor Technical Document No. 322259, Rev. 4, Radiological Dose Consequence at the EAB/LPZ and in Control Room with Modified Control Room Ventilation Design - Main Steam Line Break Accident.
Document To Be Revised:
UFSAR Section 15.4.2 13.0 ATTACHMENTS:
Two Diskette with the following electronic files (1 page):
Calculation No: S-C-ZZ-MDC-1950 OIR1 Comment Resolution Form 2 - Mark Drucker Certification for Design Verification Form-i RCPD Form-i Nuclear Common Revision 9 l
Attachment A H-1-ZZ-MDC-1950, Rev. 0 2 Diskettes With Various Electronic Files A-a--