3F0104-03, Special Report 04-01: Results of the Once-Through Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection Conducted During Refueling Outage 13
| ML040350037 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crystal River  |
| Issue date: | 01/27/2004 |
| From: | Annacone M Progress Energy Florida |
| To: | Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| 3F0104-03 | |
| Download: ML040350037 (126) | |
Text
Progress Energy Crystal River Nuclear Plant Docket No. 50-302 Operating Ucense No. DPR-72 Ref: 10 CFR 50.36 January 27, 2004 3F0104-03 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attn: Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555-0001
Subject:
Crystal River Unit 3 - Special Report 04-01: Results of the Once-Through Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection Conducted During Refueling Outage 13
References:
- 1. PEF to NRC letter, 3F1003-07, dated October 31, 2003, Crystal River Unit 3 Special Report 03-01: Once Through Steam Generator (OTSG)
Notifications Required Prior to MODE 4
Contingency Letter of Commitment Regarding License Amendment Request
- 252, Revision 0, Once Through Steam Generator Tube Surveillance Program, Tube Repair Roll (Re-Roll) Process (TAC No. MB 1519)
Dear Sir:
Florida Power Corporation, doing business as Progress Energy Florida, Inc. (PEF), hereby submits Special Report 04-01: Results of the Once-Through Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection Conducted During Refueling Outage 13. This submittal fulfills the requirements of Improved Technical Specification (ITS) 5.7.2.e, which requires submittal of the report to the NRC within 90 days following output breaker closure. Breaker closure for Crystal River Unit 3 (CR-3) was achieved on November 5, 2003.
As required by ITS 5.7.2.e, Special Report 04-01 (Attachment) contains the following information:
- 1.
Number and extent of tubes inspected,
- 2.
Location and percent of wall-thickness penetration for each indication of an imperfection,
- 3.
Location, bobbin coil amplitude, and axial and circumferential extent (if determined) for each first span IGA (Intergranular Attack) indication, and
- 4.
Identification of tubes plugged or repaired and specification of the repair methodology implemented for each tube.
Progress Energy Florida, Inc.
Crystal River Nuclear Plant 15760 V. Powerline Street Crystal River, FL 34428
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Page 2 of 2 3FO104-03 Special Report 04-01 also provides information to fulfill a commitment made in Reference 2 to provide a summary of the evaluation performed to calculate a best-estimate of the leakage expected due to a Large Break Loss-of-Coolant Accident (LBLOCA).
This letter establishes no new regulatory commitments.
If you have any questions regarding this submittal, please contact Mr. Sid Powell, Supervisor, Licensing and Regulatory Programs at (352) 563-4883.
Sincerely, Michael J. Annacone Engineering Manager MJA/lvc
Attachment:
Special Report 04-01: Results of the Once-Through Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection Conducted During Refueling Outage 13 xc:
NRR Project Manager Regional Administrator, Region II Senior Resident Inspector
PROGRESS ENERGY FLORIDA, INC.
CRYSTAL RIVER UNIT 3 DOCKET NUMBER 50-302/LICENSE NUMBER DPR-72 ATTACHMENT SPECIAL REPORT 04-01:
RESULTS OF THE ONCE-THROUGH STEAM GENERATOR TUBE INSERVICE INSPECTION CONDUCTED DURING REFUELING OUTAGE 13 Table of Contents Attachment - Special Report 04-01: Results of the Once-Through Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection Conducted During Refueling Outage 13 Appendix 1 - Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
Appendix 2 - First Span IGA in OTSG-B (Regression Analysis)
Appendix 3 - Tubes Plugged Appendix 4 - Tubes Repaired (Re-Rolled) & In-Service Appendix 5 - Tubes with Tube End Crack (TEC) Remaining In-Service Appendix 6 - OTSG-B, First Span IGA
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attachment 3F0104-03 Page 1 of 7 SPECIAL REPORT 04-01 RESULTS OF THE ONCE-THROUGH STEAM GENERATOR TUBE INSERVICE INSPECTION CONDUCTED DURING REFUELING OUTAGE 13 Introduction Inservice inspection (ISI) of the Crystal River Unit 3 (CR-3) Once-Through Steam Generator (OTSG) tubes was performed during Refueling Outage 13 (13R), October 4 through November 5, 2003. In accordance with Improved Technical Specifications (TS) Section 5.7, Reporting Requirements, Progress Energy is submitting Special Report 04-01. A diagram of an OTSG is attached in Figure 1.
ITS Section 5.7.2.e states:
The complete results of the OTSG tube inservice inspection shall be submitted to the NRC within 90 days after breaker closure following restart. Te report shall include:
- 1. Number and extent of tubes inspected,
- 2. Location and percent of wall-thickness penetration for each indication of an impefection,
- 3. Location, bobbin coil amplitude, and axial and circumferential extent (if determined) for each first span IGA indication, and
- 4. Identification of tubes plugged or repaired and specification of the repair methodology implemented for each tube.
The following information is presented to satisfy ITS Section 5.7.2.e requirements:
- 1. Number and extent of tubes inspected The eddy current testing (ECT) inspection plan and selection of techniques for the OTSG tubes were designed to detect specific degradation mechanisms for each area of the OTSG. The ISI of the OTSG tubes during 13R satisfies the requirements of ITS Section 5.6.2.10.
The EPRI PWR Steam Generator Examination Guidelines, Revision 6, Appendix H, describe the performance demonstration requirements for ECT techniques used for the examination of steam generator tubing and repairs. These criteria were used as the basis for determination of technique qualification.
A review of the qualified technique's essential variables was performed to ensure the application of any qualified technique was applicable to the site-specific conditions and is in compliance with 10 CFR 50, Appendix B, Criteria IX, Control of Special Processes, for qualified nondestructive examination (NDE) techniques. The ECT techniques used at CR-3 during the 13R inspection were adequate for the detection and sizing (where applicable) of the damage mechanisms that are both active and a potential for the OTSGs.
A technique is a category within an NDE method that describes the examination system, inspection requirements and detection capabilities for specific flaw types in sufficient detail to ensure consistent implementation with adequate confidence.
Two ECT
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attachment 3F0104-03 Page 2 of 7 techniques were used to inspect the OTSG tubes as detailed below. ECT techniques are based on the type of probe used for the inspection; bobbin or motorized rotating pancake coil (MRPC).
The bobbin coil was used to examine 100% of the tubes in-service over the entire length of the tube, to the extent practical, in both OTSGs (15,314 tubes in OTSG-A, 14,801 in OTSG-B). Indications identified using bobbin were further characterized using MRPC (containing 0.115 inch pancake coil and a +Point coil). MRPC is qualified to detect primary water stress corrosion cracking (PWSCC) in the tubesheet regions, intergranular attack (IGA), and outside diameter stress corrosion cracking (ODSCC) in the lower tubesheet (LTS) crevice region and sleeved tubes.
MRPC was used to examine the following specific areas in both steam generators:
> 100% upper and lower tube roll transition area
> 34% LTS Crevice in the kidney region
> 34% Tubes in the Lane and Wedge region [upper tubesheet (UTS) and 5th Support Plate)]
> 34% Sleeved Tubes
> 34% Dents identified as of the last inspection
> 100% of Inconel 600 Plugs
> Further characterization of indications identified by the bobbin coil exam 100% of the tubes in B OTSG identified with 1st Span IGA Inspection Summary The bobbin coil inspection resulted in the A and B OTSG being classified with Category C-2 inspection results in accordance with ITS 5.6.2.10. Specific areas inspected with MRPC were calculated independently for categorization to identify if further actions were necessary to determine the extent of degradation. The only expansion sample required was in the lower tubesheet roll transition area based on the discovery of lower tube end indications.
The upper tubesheet (UTS) roll area was identified as a Specific Limited Area (SLA), as defined in the ITS, Section 5.6.2.10.2.d, during the 1997 inspection.
The portion of tube within the clad region in both UTS and LTS were identified as a Specific Limited Area for 13R, as defined in ITS, Section 5.6.2.10.2.d, based on the physical construction of the tube end adjacent to the seal weld heat affected zone.
The degradation mechanism is PWSCC since the indications appear to be inside diameter-initiated and is unique to that area and not random in nature. Absolute determination of the degradation mechanism can only be determined by destructive examination (tube pulls). However, since the indications are near the tube ends, the method of destructive examination would likely corrupt the tube sample.
Therefore, 100% of the tubes in service in the upper and lower tubesheets must be inspected with RPC each 1SI from the tube end as follows: Upper Tube End (UTE) to UTE minus 3 inches and Lower Tube End (LTE) to LTE plus 3 inches. The calculation
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Page 3 of 7 for the overall categorization of the OTSG inspection results did not include the Specific Limited Areas, as specified in ITS Section 5.6.2.10.2.d.
Table 1 OTSG-A Examination
-Tubes
.Number':
-Number
, 1 I 0 i -,;-
.~:'~'-;;"
E xamined Deg aded Defective Bobbin Examination (Special Interest, Through-Wall 15, 314 31 6
Degradation (TWD) 220% - <39%, TWD > 40%)
New Upper Tube End Anomalies [Single Axial Tube End 15,151 0
297*
Anomaly (SAA), Multiple Axial Tube End Anomaly (MAA)]
Upper Tubesheet Roll Area Specific Limited Area 15,151 0
37*
Indications [Single Axial Indication ( SAI), Multiple Axial Indication (MAI), Single Circumferential Indication (SCI), Multiple Circumferential Indication (MCI), Single Volumetric Indication (SVI), Multiple Volumetric Indication (MVI)]
Lower Tubesheet Crevice Region 2,054 0
0 Lower Tube End Anomalies (SAA, MAA) 15,314 0
4*
Lower Tube End Specific Limited Area Indications (
15,314 0
180*
SAI, MAT, SCI, MCI, SVI, MVI)
Total 15,314 31 6
Inspection Results Category C-2
- Consistent with ITS Section 5.6.2.10.2.d, this total was not included for overall categorization of the OTSG for Specific Limited Area.
Table 2 Bbbin j OTSG-B-Examination
-Tues
' Nme Number
, al
,.9.;
- i. --- *Am "- i; - - xamihed':* Degra e d;
efective:-
Bobbin Examination (Special Interest, TWD >20% - c 14,801 24 6
39%,TWDŽ>40__o)
New Upper Tube End Anomalies (SAA, MAA) 14,642 0
237*
Upper Tube Sheet Roll Area Specific Limited Area 14,642 0
87*
Indications (SAI, MAI, SCI, MCI, SVI, MVI)
Lower Tube Sheet Crevice Region 1,387 0
0 Lower Tube End Anomalies(SAA, MAA) 14,801 0
108*
Lower Tube End Specific Limited Area Indications (
14,801 0
11
- SAI, MAI, SCI, MCI, SVI, MVI)
First Span IGA (LTS to l" Support Plate) 178 175**
8 Total 14,801 24 14 Inspection Results Category C-2
- Consistent with ITS Section 5.6.2.10.2.d, this total was not included for overall categorization of the OTSG for Specific Limited area.
- 2. Location and percent of wall-thickness penetration for each indication of an imperfection Percent TWD is only assigned to tube support plate wear indications and OTSG-B first span IGA indications.
A complete list of inspection results for in-service tubes with indications 1% to 39% through-wall in OTSG-A and OTSG-B is provided in Appendix 1
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attachment 3F0104-03 Page 4 of 7 of this Attachment. A complete listing of tubes with first span IGA indications in OTSG-B is provided in Appendix 2.
- 3. Location, bobbin coil amplitude, and axial and circumferential extent (if determined for each first span IGA indication First span IGA is a degradation mechanism specific to OTSG-B. Prior to the 2003 inspection, there were 175 known tubes with first span IGA in service. As a result of this inspection, eight (8) tubes from this population were plugged. Of these eight tubes, five (5) tubes were plugged based on growth greater than 10% through-wall dimension, two (2) were plugged for indications equal to or greater than 40% through-wall dimension, and one (1) was plugged because it did not meet the regression criteria. There are a total of 167 tubes in OTSG-B remaining in-service with first span IGA. Appendix 2 contains the list of tubes in OTSG-B with first span IGA.
CR-3 is also providing additional information regarding first span IGA in OTSG-B in Appendix 6. The additional information includes the axial distribution, percent through-wall (TW) distribution, and percent TW growth distribution of first span IGA in OTSG-B.
- 4. Identification of tubes plugged or repaired and specification of the repair methodology implemented for each tube Tubes identified with unacceptable indications were plugged by using an Alloy 690 plug rolled into both ends of the tube. A complete list of plugged tubes in OTSG-A and OTSG-B is provided in Appendix 3.
Tubes with unacceptable indications in the UTS and LTS were repaired using a repair roll (re-roll) as described in ITS Section 5.6.2.10.1 L.b. A complete list of tubes repaired (in-service) by the re-roll method in OTSG-A and OTSG-B is provided in Appendix 4.
No tubes were sleeved during the 2003 OTSG inspection.
Tubes with axially oriented tube end cracks (TEC) within the Inconel clad region of the primary face of the UTS and LTS were left in-service using the method described in Topical Report BAW-2346P, Revision 0, as approved in License Amendment No. 188 issued October 1, 1999. The through-wall extent is conservatively assumed to be 100%.
Therefore, a leakage value based on tube sheet radial position has been assigned to each TEC to calculate the potential primary-to-secondary leakage in the event of a design basis accident. Other indications of wall loss or cracking are plugged or repaired on detection and are not assigned a percent wall penetration. A complete list of the tubes remaining in service with TEC is provided in Appendix 5.
Secondary Side Pressure Test The primary-to-secondary leakage in the OTSGs was less than five (5) gallons-per-day (gpd) prior to shutdown for 13R. Therefore, a secondary-to-primary leakage pressure test was not performed in the OTSGs. The LTS was monitored for tube leakage during ECT with the OTSGs
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attachment 3F0104-03 Page 5 of 7 full (up to the secondary face of the upper tube sheet). No leakage was identified. Primary-to-secondary leakage after 13R is less than two (2) gpd.
In-Situ Pressure Test During 13R, tubes with indications were evaluated for in-situ pressure and leak testing in accordance with EPRI Report TR-107620-R1, "Steam Generator In-Situ Pressure Test Guidelines," Revision 1. These guidelines utilize sequential screening criteria, i.e., indications that exceed the threshold value for the first screening parameters, are evaluated against the threshold value for the second screening parameter. The screening thresholds (length, depth, and voltage) are reduced to account for uncertainties in the material properties, burst pressure regression parameters, burst pressures relative to the regression, and NDE sizing.
No indications exceeded the screening criteria for in-situ pressure testing. Therefore, no in-situ pressure testing was performed during 13R.
Summary of Best-Estimate Leakage Evaluation Following a Large Break Loss-of-Coolant Accident (LBLOCA)
Following the 13R inspection of the Upper and Lower Tubesheet roll region, the best-estimate leakage following a LBLOCA that could occur from as-found circumferential cracking near the tubesheet rolls has been determined to be 7.41 gpm in OTSG-A and 3.00 gpm in OTSG-B. This estimated leakage has been evaluated and would not exceed the offsite dose limits of 10 CFR 100 and 10 CFR 50.67 when compared to existing assumptions in the FSAR Chapter 14 analysis.
The evaluation demonstrates that the primary-to-secondary leakage following a LBLOCA, as described in Appendix A to Topical Report BAW-2374, Revision 1, is acceptable based on the as-found condition of the steam generators.
Condition Monitoring Assessment The results of the ECT inspection during the 13R OTSG inspection identified the Condition Monitoring (CM) Assessment, relative to leakage integrity, did not meet the performance criteria. The draft CM evaluation concludes that structural requirements were met but the as-found leakage values for Main Steam Line Break exceeded the values projected by the previous inspection (Refueling Outage 12).
The cause for the calculated increased leakage was due to applying a leakage value to the new indications identified in the lower tube ends and to the greater than expected upper tube end cracks.
Conclusion The Operational Assessment (OA) evaluated the degradation mechanisms of the CR-3 OTSG tubes.
The evaluation concluded that the tubes would maintain structural integrity with reasonable assurance throughout fuel Cycle 14. This is based on the inspection results and worst-case Monte Carlo type simulations. Additionally, this was the fourth consecutive 100%
full length bobbin coil and UTS MRPC inspection of the in-service tubes.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attachment 3F0104-03 Page 6 of 7 The bobbin coil inspection resulted in Category C-2 as described in ITS 5.6.2.10. The overall classification for the inspection performed was C-2 for both steam generators. The classification of the Specific Limited Areas inspection in both steam generators was C-3. The SLA calculation was not included in the overall categorization of the OTSGs, as previously discussed.
Therefore, based on inspection results and the OA of the structural and leakage integrity of in-service OTSG tubing, the inspection interval between 13R and 14R will be 24 months.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Page 7 of 7 ONCE-THROUGH STEAM GENERATOR Primary Inlet Nozzle Inspection Opening Upper Hemispherical Head Vent & Level Sensing Connection AFW Header
& Nozzles (7)
Upper Cylindrical Baffle Steam Outlet Nozzle (2)
Upper High Level Sensing Connection (2)
Main Feedwater Risers Lower High Level Sensing Connection (2)
Manway Upper Tubesheet Manway I 11II II II 11II1 1 1 1 1 1I 1 I I I I I I I i I I I I I I I I I I W HIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 11111 11lDIllIIl~lI zII
I 11111111 11111111II1]I II Il I
~
I l~llllit~ullillllll~llll
.4-
'I
,jI I,
i
. `
L~ ~I Wl~~'!ll I 5111!l0111~~~ ~~~11 11!!'111' Downcomer Tubes Lower Cylindrical Baffle Upper Low Level Sensing Connection (2)
Flow Ports Handholes (7)
Lower Low Level Sensing Connection (2)
Drain (4)
Lower Hemispherical Head Primary Outlet Nozzle (2)
Support Skirt 96C129G Primary Drain T
- Ff I III I'M I iIIII III iI IIIl 1 I t 1 1 I1111111 I R I III IIIII lIl PI I I Il l1illlllll]j III11 1I1I 111111!
Li l~Ilill, I LI L Id 11 II ill II I III II I I III I I 0 ill IIIIN III II ITIIIIIIII Nl' l 1 III IIII I1 II II Tube Support Plate Handhole (2 to 8)
Drain (2)
Main Feedwater Nozzles (32)
External Main Feedwater Header Temperature Sensing Connection (2)
Shell Orifice Plate Drain (2)
Temperature Sensing Connection Lower Tubesheet Manway Inspection Opening 4
111111111111Id 9
1 1 I I I I!
! ! P P ! f ! ! ~ V ! 1 1.
t+"llllllLL~LiL=lll1J1wl'lllll1 6 m111,Il 11,`Il~
11
I.
PROGRESS ENERGY FLORIDA, INC.
CRYSTAL RIVER UNIT 3 DOCKET NUMBER 50-302/LICENSE NUMBER DPR-72 ATTACHMENT SPECIAL REPORT 04-01 APPENDIX 1 TUBES LEFT IN-SERVICE WITH THROUGH-WALL INDICATIONS 1%-39%
Appendix Location Acronyms LTS - Lower Tubesheet S - Tube Support Plate
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications % to 39%
Attachment Appendix I OTSG A "Row
.Tube
., Volts.
Degree -
%TW Tube Support TSP Location
.i
... Plate 11 0.32 0
10 12S
+0.68 0.36 105 11 12S
+0.68 1
13 0.24 0
8 11S
+0.81 0.38 138 11 11S
+0.68 2
8 0.8 86 17 12S
+0.66 2
9 0.35 104 10 12S
+0.66 4
28 0.29 0
9 12S
+0.75 0.33 103 8
12S
+0.66 0.26 100 7
08S
+0.72 4
34 0.24 72 8
08S
+0.65 5
34 0.52 74 12 12S
+0.68 5
36 0.4 55 13 12S
+0.67 5
41 0.37 87 9
12S
+0.68 5
45 0.41 0
13 08S
+0.66 0.31 62 8
08S
+0.68 0.3 91 8
12S
+0.65 6
7 0.33 121 9
12S
+0.69 0.34 0
10 12S
+0.68 6
10 0.45 93 13 12S
+0.78 6
25 0.48 142 11 09S
+0.62 6
26 0.41 0
10 BS
-0.72 0.34 0
8 08S
+0.76 0.59 87 17 09S
+0.52 0.47 137 15 BS
+0.00 6
39 0.43 0
10 08S
+0.74 0.21 99 7
08S
+0.72 6
51 0.48 140 15 13S
+0.63 7
21 0.62 110 18 11S
+0.68 7
24 0.64 53 14 07S
-0.75 7
26 0.85 40 18 09S
+0.61 0.78 66 17 08S
+0.61 0.81 77 17 08S
-0.68 0.37 65 9
04S
+0.57 0.67 14 15 04S
-0.70 7
27 0.49 0
15 09S
-0.57 0.49 0
11 08S
-0.73 1.08 0
23 08S
+0.64 0.45 0
10 09S
+0.62 0.36 103 11 07S
-0.73 0.85 88 23 08S
+0.64 0.32 69 10 08S
-0.71 0.52 93 16 09S
-0.73 7
44 0.23 120 8
04S
+0.66 7
52 0.41 58 13 10S
+0.65 Page I o 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%!
OTSGA
.Row-.
Tube Volts
.,Degree
%TW Tube Support
.TSP.Locatlon
- f..-
iPlate 8
21 0.61 96 18 07S
+0.50 8
22 0.31 84 8
07S
+0.57 8
23 0.4 116 12 12S
+0.68 8
25 0.42 0
13 09S
+0.67 0.45 43 14 09S
+0.59 8
27 0.58 82 17 07S
-0.71 8
28 0.72 0
21 07S
+0.69 0.96 0
26 09S
+0.58 0.19 0
6 09S
-0.75 0.18 0
6 07S
-0.72 0.85 81 18 09S
+0.68 0.68 94 15 08S
+0.59 0.77 69 17 07S
+0.68 0.34 84 8
07S
-0.72 0.4 119 10 09S
-0.75 0.35 94 9
08S
-0.75 8
29 0.54 85 16 07S
-0.71 8
30 0.54 0
12 08S
-0.69 0.61 0
14 08S
+0.64 0.38 63 9
07S
+0.63 0.29 118 7
08S
-0.63 0.45 63 11 08S
+0.59 0.56 65 13 07S
-0.57 8
41 0.23 0
7 07S
+0.71 0.54 30 16 07S
+0.65 8
1 46 0.28 0
9 07S
+0.73 0.34 85 9
07S
+0.68 8
51 0.28 0
9 08S
+0.75 0.36 139 12 12S
+0.65 0.26 119 9
08S
+0.72 9
24 0.5 0
11 07S
+0.74 0.32 90 8
07S
+0.70 9
28 0.34 0
8 12S
+0.76 0.51 35 12 12S
+0.68 9
42 0.24 86 6
08S
+0.68 9
53 0.26 104 7
07S
+0.65 9
55 0.35 0
11 03S
+0.76 0.29 100 7
03S
+0.76 9
61 0.3 82 8
12S
+0.56 10 6
0.41 90 12 12S
+0.76 10 7
0.18 114 6
07S
-0.70 0.32 0
9 07S
-0.75 10 8
0.27 91 8
07S
-0.76 0.5 0
15 07S
-0.70 Page 2 ol 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1o to 39%
OTSG A
'Row,-Tube- ;
Volts
!Degree
- %TW Tube Support TSP Location
-P la te _._
10 51 0.27 0
9 07S
+0.73 0.19 90 7
07S
+0.67 10 57 0.36 104 12 07S
+0.67 10 58 0.21 0
7 07S
+0.68 0.27 59 7
07S
+0.68 11 1
0.48 94 14 12S
+0.69 11 2
0.3 0
9 07S
+0.76 0.18 60 6
08S
+0.78 0.26 93 8
07S
+0.82 11 7
0.65 86 17 12S
+0.74 11 8
0.26 106 8
07S
-0.67 0.44 0
13 07S
-0.74 11 11 0.22 107 7
07S
+0.78 11 14 0.3 87 9
08S
+0.80 11 15 0.22 83 7
09S
+0.78 0.22 91 7
08S
+0.74 0.24 91 7
07S
+0.78 1
T 0.45 0
13 08S
+0.72 0.27 0
8 09S
+0.78 0.39 0
11 07S
+0.73 11 24 0.27 105 8
08S
+0.78 0.24 0
8 08S
+0.84 11 58 0.42 46 11 12S
+0.67 11 60 0.36 0
12 12S
+0.70 0.24 93 7
12S
+0.70 12 1
0.38 113 12 09S
-0.65 12 7
0.38 108 12 07S
-0.68 12 9
0.46 0
14 12S
+0.71 0.23 89 8
12S
+0.77 12 10 0.28 0
9 07S
-0.74 0.26 111 9
07S
-0.66 12 14 0.18 0
6 07S
+0.73 0.18 109 6
07S
+0.77 12 18 0.31 109 10 07S
-0.74 0.15 131 5
07S
+0.77 12 28 0.37 106 11 08S
+0.73 12 70 0.81 51 18 10S
+0.63 13 3
0.24 0
8 09S
-0.74 0.28 138 9
09S
-0.77 13 6
0.36 116 11 07S
-0.61 13 7
0.44 0
13 07S
-0.70 0.23 107 8
07S
-0.70 13 9
0.34 63 11 07S
-0.68 13 24 0.24 106 8
07S
+0.83 Page 3 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A
-. Row,-.,-Tube
.:Volts
-, iegree.
._%TW Tube Support TSP Location Row
- .Tue.:
.: :gre-
- . %TW
...Plate 13 59 0.4 0
13 08S
+0.70 0.21 67 6
08S
+0.70 13 61 0.28 0
9 07S
+0.60 0.36 37 9
07S
+0.60 13 69 0.23 0
9 07S
+0.65 0.29 61 8
07S
+0.65 0.39 53 10 08S
+0.60 13 71 0.22 0
7 08S
+0.71 0.21 0
9 09S
-0.74 0.23 59 6
08S
+0.58 0.41 58 11 09S
-0.74 14 1
0.24 60 9
uS
+0.66 14 8
0.47 104 14 07S
-0.70 14 32 0.47 0
15 12S
+0.79 0.37 73 9
12S
+0.66 14 70 0.27 0
9 08S
+0.60 0.23 0
8 07S
+0.65 0.19 78 5
07S
+0.65 0.2 98 6
08S
+0.56 0.31 108 8
los
+0.71 15 8
0.35 0
11 07S
-0.74 0.26 119 9
07S
-0.68 15 30 0.71 107 20 06S
+0.68 15 64 0.37 0
12 07S
-0.77 0.32 114 10 07S
-0.77 15 76 0.52 0
16 10S
+0.65 0.44 111 12 10S
+0.67 16 5
0.33 82 8
07S
-0.70 16 6
0.2 0
6 08S
-0.75 0.22 83 7
08S
-0.70 16 7
0.37 0
11 07S
-0.68 0.25 118 8
07S
-0.61 16 8
0.21 96 7
07S
-0.73 16 9
0.35 27 11 07S
-0.75 16 76 0.26 0
9 08S
+0.65 0.26 118 7
08S
+0.65 16 77 0.51 90 14 09S
-0.70 17 7
0.3 0
9 07S
-0.70 0.33 110 10 07S
-0.68 17 8
0.44 113 13 07S
-0.75 17 9
0.26 0
8 08S
-0.74 0.37 0
11 07S
-0.68 0.29 125 10 07S
-0.70 0.21 69 7
08S
-0.74 Page 4 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSGA t g Row.Tube::
Volts-Degree TubeSupport
.-TSP.Locatlon_,
17 70 0.19 85 6
07S
+0.65 17 75 0.46 65 12 08S
+0.63 18 7
0.28 0
9 07S
-0.66 0.38 107 9
07S
-0.68 18 9
0.3 0
9 07S
-0.65 0.23 0
7 08S
-0.70 0.33 111 11 07S
-0.66 0.2 89 7
08S
-0.72 18 25 0.42 85 14 09S
+0.68 0.52 0
15 09S
+0.71 18 74 0.51 95 14 06S
+0.70 19 3
0.48 79 15 12S
+0.68 19 7
0.22 51 8
12S
+0.73 19 8
0.27 0
8 08S
-0.81 0.25 52 6
08S
-0.82 19 30 0.18 53 7
03S
+0.76 0.42 0
13 03S
+0.72 19 33 0.34 123 11 09S
+0.59 0.13 0
4 09S
+0.58 19 68 0.49 0
15 09S
+0.62 0.38 136 11 09S
+0.62 19 75 0.51 48 13 07S
+0.60 19 76 0.37 133 11 07S
+0.69 19 84 0.26 0
9 08S
-0.76 0.43 146 13 08S
-0.72 20 77 0.4 0
14 07S
+0.58 0.48 0
17 08S
+0.65 0.63 47 15 07S
+0.58 0.43 106 11 08S
+0.65 21 1
0.26 0
8 11S
+0.75 0.23 56 8
lS
+0.68 21 6
0.27 0
8 08S
-0.74 0.28 66 7
08S
-0.80 22 11 0.3 0
9 08S
-0.76 0.31 50 7
08S
-0.82 22 59 0.24 81 5
10S
+0.67 23 8
0.27 0
9 08S
-0.75 0.29 103 7
08S
-0.77 23 86 0.42 0
15 07S
+0.55 0.42 0
15 08S
+0.60 0.76 138 16 08S
+0.60 0.39 95 9
07S
+0.55 24 6
0.22 0
7 08S
-0.74 0.27 61 7
08S
-0.80 Page 5 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A
- r Row Jube
- ,.-,Volts -
- Degree.-
lTube Suport T SP Locaton Tube
.7..
'~~~~~~~~~late.'
24 7
0.23 0
7 08S
-0.75 0.3 111 11 08S
-0.79 0.31 95 11 12S
+0.66 24 8
0.24 0
7 08S
-0.80 0.24 75 6
08S
-0.80 24 51 0.29 68 8
12S
+0.82 24 85 0.28 128 7
07S
+0.69 24 88 0.47 52 9
07S
+0.62 0.38 98 8
08S
-0.72 0.31 89 7
08S
+0.55 24 89 0.39 0
14 07S
+0.65 0.23 0
9 08S
+0.62 0.42 69 11 07S
+0.65 0.3 64 8
08S
+0.62 24 92 0.36 54 8
08S
+0.73 25 7
0.34 118 12 08S
-0.82 25 8
0.29 0
8 08S
-0.77 0.31 52 7
08S
-0.84 25 89 0.45 0
14 08S
+0.62 0.23 67 5
07S
+0.39 0.38 93 8
08S
+0.62 25 90 0.37 0
13 07S
+0.55 0.32 0
12 08S
+0.67 0.33 104 8
07S
+0.55 0.46 113 12 08S
+0.67 25 94 0.43 0
14 08S
-0.75 0.42 126 14 08S
-0.75 26 90 0.46 0
15 07S
+0.66 0.38 0
12 09S
+0.79 0.49 99 12 07S
+0.67 0.78 85 19 08S
+0.46 0.49 74 12 09S
+0.64 26 92 0.31 73 7
09S
-0.80 26 94 0.43 49 10 08S
-0.78 26 95 0.49 98 15 08S
-0.78 26 96 0.8 0
23 08S
-0.72 0.48 91 11 08S
.0.78 26 97 0.78 0
23 08S
.0.79 0.29 106 10 08S
-0.78 27 4
0.38 0
12 OBS
-0.74 0.32 77 9
08S
-0.82 27 93 0.44 113 10 08S
+0.59 27 98 0.4 73 13 08S
-0.78 28 8
0.23 107 7
07S
-0.77 Page 6 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A Row -
-Tube- -
<-,- Volts
. -, Degree eTW.
-Tube Support<,-
TSP Location,,
_ _ _ _._,_.-P la te.:.
28 9
0.3 103 8
07S
-0.77 28 55 0.33 64 8
03S
+0.65 29 98 0.28 116 10 12S
+0.71 29 104 0.58 85 17 11S
+0.73 30 103 0.36 79 8
08S
-0.78 31 11 0.38 104 11 09S
+0.48 31 32 1.06 92 24 los
+0.82 31 49 0.19 52 5
07S
+0.70 32 101 0.39 91 13 04S
+0.64 33 4
0.36 70 10 OBS
-0.73 33 19 0.19 66 5
02S
+0.73 33 104 0.27 72 9
08S
-0.84 34 86 0.35 104 16 15S
+0.58 34 106 0.22 92 8
09S
+0.64 35 7
0.43 0
12 05S
+0.72 0.23 99 7
05S
+0.68 35 11 0.35 88 10 12S
+0.68 35 86 0.37 65 9
03S
+0.67 36 9
0.29 96 8
07S
+0.68 36 73 0.42 105 11 03S
+0.64 36 113 0.36 79 12 02S
-0.80 37 113 1.03 71 20 11S
+0.71 37 114 0.3 113 10 11S
+0.75 38 3
0.31 134 9
08S
-0.77 38 5
0.25 91 8
08S
-0.77 39 8
0.27 0
8 06S
-0.76 0.28 79 8
06S
-0.73 39 93 0.2 0
8 04S
-0.75 0.22 123 9
04S
-0.75 40 7
0.31 98 10 08S
-0.79 40 116 0.3 61 10 08S
+0.70 40 117 0.23 0
9 08S
-0.79 0.31 0
11 08S
+0.65 0.33 116 11 08S
-0.71 41 58 0.33 57 8
03S
+0.63 41 116 0.66 83 16 12S
+0.72 0.61 101 15 1S
-0.71 43 118 0.34 0
11 12S
+0.75 0.28 112 7
12S
+0.74 45 65 0.2 91 7
04S
+0.70 45 115 0.41 52 12 07S
+0.59 46 24 0.64 106 20 03S
+0.70 46 112 0.35 65 12 08S
+0.56 46 114 0.24 77 9
08S
+0.52 Page 7 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A Row Tue ol
Dearee,
%TlW,-.
.Tube Supportj J.~SPLocation late '
47 4
0.27 71 10 1S
+0.64 50 5
0.42 79 13 09S
+0.59 50 117 0.21 0
7 08S
+0.71 0.27 72 8
08S
+0.64 52 5
0.3 120 11 09S
+0.64 52 6
0.64 92 19 09S
+0.64 52 11 0.38 62 13 03S
+0.70 53 5
0.44 55 14 09S
+0.64 53 119 0.33 107 10 08S
+0.61 54 1
0.39 124 17 OBS
-0.79 0.39 0
13 08S
-0.73 54 4
0.24 115 7
09S
+0.64 54 124 0.41 40 12 08S
-0.87 55 96 0.65 68 15 03S
+0.70 55 119 0.37 62 11 08S
+0.69 57 1
0.3 118 14 loS
+0.70 0.69 102 25 10S
-0.68 0.42 146 18 08S
-0.75 0.43 0
13 08S
-0.73 57 2
0.72 96 18 08S
+0.66 57 127 0.84 102 21 10S
+0.64 58 1
0.37 138 16 09S
.0.79 58 6
0.62 65 23 09S
+0.64 0.49 0
16 09S
+0.67 58 128 0.39 42 11 10S
+0.67 59 2
0.65 93 16 08S
+0.68 59 5
0.26 117 13 09S
+0.75 0.25 0
8 09S
+0.65 59 124 0.33 0
11 13S
-0.55 0.27 87 10 13S
-0.62 60 1
0.39 113 17 10S
+0.70 60 4
0.4 99 17 09S
+0.70 0.31 0
11 09S
+0.72 0.44 0
15 09S
-0.75 60 42 0.34 90 8
09S
+0.79 60 84 0.14 108 6
04S
-0.32 60 124 0.27 0
10 08S
+0.60 0.22 117 8
08S
+0.60 61 5
0.25 104 12 07S
-0.75 0.2 88 10 05S
+0.70 0.3 0
9 05S
+0.72 0.58 0
17 07S
-0.69 61 124 0.29 0
10 1S
+0.78 1.02 91 26 10S
+0.00 Page 8 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A
.Row
- Tube,
-:.Volts..
%TWDgree Tube Support-TSP, Location
-~~~~~~
§.~~~P la te 0.26 76 10 11S
+0.66 0.25 114 9
08S
-0.82 62 2
0.28 89 13 loS
+0.43 62 4
0.21 92 11 07S
-0.72 62 7
0.27 98 8
los
+0.73 62 62 0.79 42 15 1S
-0.81 62 124 0.51 107 17 08S
+0.69 62 126 0.39 0
14 07S
-0.78 0.25 75 10 07S
-0.78 62 128 0.42 116 14 08S
-0.80 0.88 89 24 10S
+0.00 63 116 0.24 66 9
07S
-0.83 63
_124 0.43 80 15 07S
-0.71 0.28 91 10 08S
-0.59 63 128 0.31 123 11 08S
-0.84 0.47 77 16 10S
+0.59 64 8
0.2 83 6
los
+0.73 64 9
0.32 119 15 08S
+0.70 0.17 0
5 08S
+0.74 64 61 0.51 49 9
08S
+0.74 0.41 0
13 08S
+0.69 64 114 0.34 90 10 04S
+0.00 65 87 0.43 97 10 04S
+0.66 65 122 0.34 98 12 08S
+0.50 65 128 0.33 0
11 11S
+0.65 0.28 115 10 08S
-0.87 0.33 63 12 11S
+0.64 65 129 0.23 68 7
08s
-0.80 0.62 83 17 10S
+0.77 66 14 0.26 97 8
11S
+0.70 66 17 0.47 89 19 11S
+0.70 0.54 0
16 11S
+0.65 66 126 0.38 79 11 07S
-0.80 66 127 0.4 0
13 15S
-0.95 0.45 94 15 15S
-0.96 66 128 0.27 0
9 07S
+0.63 0.18 66 5
07S
+0.64 0.25 73 7
08S
-0.85 66 130 0.1 96 3
12S
-0.82 67 6
0.22 87 6
1S
+0.75 67 62 0.7 88 13 10S
+0.79 67 118 0.3 0
10 05S
+0.76 0.23 128 9
05S
+0.66 67 129 0.22 0
8 08S
+0.74 Page 9 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A Row-..,.Tube
- olts Degree
/TW
'Tube Support.;
TSP Location
>f
- >:*o^
.,-~-
PIate>
0.42 0
14 08S
-0.65 0.16 0
6 11S
-0.75 0.32 67 9
08S
-0.83 0.53 92 14 10S
+0.60 0.23 97 7
11 S
-0.85 68 3
0.32 102 14 11S
+0.68 68 12 0.42 87 13 11S
+0.61 68 15 0.5 109 19 11S
+0.72 68 16 0.33 80 10 11S
+0.73 68 22 0.4 91 11 12S
+0.70 68 34 0.33 0
10 12S
+0.74 0.25 83 7
12S
+0.78 68 42 0.23 0
8 09S
+0.75 0.24 78 7
09S
+0.81 68 60 0.33 0
11 04S
+0.71 0.48 57 9
04S
+0.74 68 61 0.25 68 4
08S
+0.76 68 73 0.23 0
10 06S
-0.80 0.29 83 7
06S
-0.82 68 127 0.62 0
19 08S
-0.68 68 129 0.43 0
15 09S
+0.68 0.33 91 12 09S
+0.64 0.59 89 19 10S
+0.02 68 130 0.32 0
11 10S
+0.66 0.36 90 10 08S
-0.80 0.32 82 9
10S
+0.46 0.44 90 12 11S
-0.85 69 4
0.86 81 21 1
s
+0.73 69 5
0.4 107 16 11S
+0.72 69 14 0.27 74 8
11S
+0.70 69 129 0.27 0
9 08S
-0.39 0.2 92 8
08S
-0.45 69 131 0.16 0
6 08S
-0.79 0.2 0
8 11S
-0.79 0.26 0
9 12S
-0.80 0.41 115 12 10S
+0.50 0.18 72 5
11S
-0.82 0.34 102 10 12S
-0.83 0.26 80 8
08S
-0.85 70 4
0.58 0
17 11S
+0.67 0.38 123 15 1S
+0.70 70 5
0.46 93 13 11S
+0.70 70 13 0.2 84 6
11S
+0.75 0.18 80 5
10S
+0.68 Page 10 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A
- Row,
-Tube Volts.-.
,Degree
%TW ;.- -Tube.Support TSP Locatlon
~q-5.'I't
-,+,,,,
,,L Plate :- - :
l. ;
70 14 0.36 119 15 11S
+0.72 70 16 0.43 106 17 1S
+0.70 70 30 0.42 83 12 11S
+0.68 70 34 0.19 89 6
07S
+0.76 70 128 0.32 0
11 l0s
-0.75 0.14 0
5 10S
+0.70 0.35 85 10 l0s
-0.80 70 130 0.45 0
15 08S
-0.76 0.29 94 8
08S
-0.85 0.21 106 6
uS
-0.85 71 6
0.5 0
15 1S
+0.67 0.39 118 16 11S
+0.72 71 13 0.39 99 11 1S
+0.63 71 14 0.36 132 15 1S
+0.70 71 17 0.24 85 7
uS
+0.68 71 22 0.42 109 17 11S
+0.66 71 34 0.29 0
9 12S
+0.72 0.37 113 11 12S
+0.78 71 126 0.37 0
12 08S
+0.19 0.13 0
5 08S
+0.81 0.33 76 10 08S
+0.16 71 128 0.46 93 13 l0s
-0.64 0.46 84 13 15S
-0.69 71 129 0.54 87 18 09S
+0.34 0.76 71 22 10S
+0.00 71 130 0.43 96 12 08S
-0.83 72 2
0.18 0
6 14S
+0.66 0.24 70 5
14S
+0.61 72 3
0.56 102 14 12S
+0.70 72 12 0.37 86 15 11S
+0.70 72 13 0.42 81 12 11S
+0.68 72 23 0.21 88 6
07S
+0.64 72 31 0.49 93 11 12S
+0.81 72 38 0.37 102 10 11S
+0.76 72 57 0.49 0
16 10S
+0.70 0.45 94 12 10S
+0.66 72 58 0.74 87 18 11S
+0.75 72 61 0.31 79 9
09S
-0.74 72 91 0.17 88 6
04S
+0.46 72 127 0.3 0
10 07S
+0.75 0.16 0
6 07S
-0.77 0.23 110 7
07S
+0.62 0.69 92 18 10S
-0.67 73 14 0.19 98 5
13S
-0.41 Page I I of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A "Row
- ,Tube Vls
,, Degree,,
%TW Tube Support TSP.Location 0.23 0
7 13S
-0.49 73 20 0.18 94 5
12S
+0.75 73 22 0.35 81 10 11S
+0.70 73 41 0.42 90 12 12S
+0.78 73 57 0.24 94 7
lS
+0.79 73 61 0.43 78 11 07S
+0.72 73 128 0.35 115 11 08S
-0.89 0.46 92 14 09S
+0.43 0.83 89 21 10S
-0.77 74 16 0.19 0
6 11S
+0.65 0.27 68 5
11S
+0.68 74 34 0.28 0 -
9 14S
+0.72 0.23 97 7
14S
+0.78 74 123 0.38 97 12 08S
-0.16 0.36 130 11 11S
+0.00 74 124 0.68 0
21 OBS
-0.62 0.45 117 12 08S
-0.71 0.36 93 10 10S
+0.57 75 16 0.33 0
10 14S
+0.73 0.29 80 6
14S
+0.52 75 29 0.56 99 14 07S
-0.77 75 73 0.46 62 11 07S
-0.80 75 89 0.25 107 7
04S
+0.68 75 123 0.56 88 15 10S
.0.64 0.44 95 12 11S
-0.48 76 122 0.49 95 13 09S
+0.55 76 123 0.3 114 10 11S
+0.00 0.29 56 10 10S
-0.78 0.57 101 18 10S
+0.61 77 6
0.28 62 7
11S
-0.76 0.44 0
15 11S
-0.79 77 17 0.52 91 12 07S
-0.80 77 65 0.24 73 6
09S
+0.72 0.17 97 4
09S
-0.70 77 74 0.48 27 15 07S
-0.80 0.26 0
10 07S
-0.84 77 76 0.51 29 16 07S
-0.72 77 80 0.23 0
8 09S
-0.72 0.5 37 15 04S
+0.54 0.37 45 12 05S
+0.63 0.39 133 13 05S
-0.75 0.44 62 14 04S
-0.67 0.31 44 11 07S
+0.66 0.33 26 11 09S
-0.80 Page 12 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A
-Row
,Tube' ^
- jVoltsl
. Degree ;.
.%TW Tube Support; TSP Location
- .
- > ;::.- '.:-:-P late 77 86 0.4 32 13 04S
+0.60 78 74 0.29 29 10 04S
+0.75 0.29 0
11 04S
+0.75 78 76 0.22 123 8
07S
-0.83 0.22 0
8 07S
-0.83 78 123 0.59 76 18 08S
-0.68 78 125 0.43 0
12 los
-0.61 0.35 95 11 09S
-0.57 0.34 94 11 lOS
-0.66 0.43 82 14 09S
+0.35 79 19 0.27 0
10 04S
+0.66 0.19 80 4
10S
-0.71 0.21 65 5
06S
+0.67 0.22 69 5
04S
+0.59 79 29 0.24 45 5
10S
-0.68 79 32 0.33 0
11 10S
-0.73 0.46 97 15 10 O0.75 79 35 0.3 66 6
lOS
-0.80 79 37 0.36 0
11 09S
-0.75 0.31 111 11 09S
-0.79 79 38 0.16 96 3
10S
-0.77 79 39 0.41 0
12 10S
-0.75 0.51 111 16 10S
-0.77 79 41 0.23 0
7 10S
-0.75 0.4 117 13 10S
-0.79 79 43 0.28 0
8 10S
-0.74 0.36 102 12 10S
-0.75 79 83 0.37 136 12 06S
+0.62 0.23 0
9 06S
+0.68 79 95 0.33 66 11 04S
+0.67 79 128 0.66 93 17 10S
+0.61 0.3 82 9
10S
-0.74 79 129 0.26 0
9 10S
-0.64 0.54 89 16 118
-0.85 0.25 114 lO1S
-0.83 80 2
022 85 12S
+0.70 80 5
0.26 103 6
10S
-0.71 0.33 0
11 l OS
-0.74 80 17 0.15 76 10S
-0.70 80 29 0.36 92 1110S
-0.75 80 35 0.25 0
0 loS
-0.80 0.33
° 1 1 12S
-0.67 0.43 35 1
14 12S
-0.63 0.49 132 16 s108
-0.77 Page 13 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A Row.
Tube Volts Degree.
%TW Tube Support TSP Location Plate:
80 37 0.26 0
10 los
-0.80 0.38 125 13 lOS
-0.81 80 43 0.24 153 9
uS
+0.68 80 55 0.36 0
11 08S
-0.75 0.29 118 10 08S
-0.78 80 66 0.3 96 7
07S
-0.73 80 131 0.43 112 12 1S
-0.80 81 4
0.18 76 5
loS
-0.70 0.19 0
7 loS
-0.68 81 17 0.19 99 5
lOS
-0.70 0.25 0
9 loS
-0.73 81 18 0.32 110 8
loS
-0.73 0.29 0
10 loS
-0.76 81 21 0.31 111 9
10S
-0.75 0.35 0
12 lOS
-0.81 81 22 0.3 116 7
los
-0.79 0.33 112 9
loS
-0.79 81 25 0.27 125 6
los
-0.75 0.42 0
14 loS
-0.75 81 26 0.44 0
15 loS
-0.70 0.29 97 9
loS
-0.73 81 29 0.22 123 5
loS
-0.77 81 30 0.37 101 11 loS
-0.75 81 34 0.46 103 15 10S
-0.77 81 37 0.2 0
7 10S
-0.79 0.38 66 13 10S
-0.75 81 46 0.23 123 5
10S
-0.66 81 48 0.26 101 5
lOS
-0.68 81 51 0.52 100 17 08S
-0.79 81 52 0.23 78 5
loS
-0.66 81 55 0.42 0
12 08S
-0.75 0.33 98 11 08S
-0.76 81 73 0.18 70 4
09S
-0.75 81 130 0.23 0
8 08S
-0.75 0.25 81 8
08S
-0.74 0.21 75 7
09S
+0.67 0.6 97 18 loS
-0.78 0.67 91 20 1S
-0.80 81 131 0.2 0
7 10S
-0.71 0.29 115 8
10S
-0.83 82 13 0.15 77 4
uS
-0.68 0.3 0
10 1S
-0.72 82 19 0.16 119 4
08S
-0.79 0.29 0
10 08S
-0.75 Page 14 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSGA Row Tube Volts
-. Degree,.
1/TW Tube Support TSP Location:
-:______ :-_._.___i_.____, ;>
r f
P ato.
82 43 0.5 97 16 08S
-0.79 82 45 0.26 139 9
OS
+0.70 82 50 0.44 0
13 los
+0.75 0.29 103 6
los
+0.66 82 52 0.36 0
11 1S
+0.67 0.23 66 5
1S
+0.64 82 53 0.29 122 10 loS
+0.74 82 58 0.34 81 8
loS
+0.73 82 60 0.23 81 6
loS
+0.71 82 94 0.24 83 6
04S
+0.66 82 128 0.23 94 7
09S
+0.26 82 129 0.63 91 18 11S
-0.78 83 13 0.42 82 11 1S
-0.72 83 19 0.23 105 6
08S
-0.79 0.21 0
7 08S
-0.78 83 23 0.2 106 6
08S
-0.79 0.2 0
7 OBS
-0.75 83 26 0.37 85 9
08S
-0.75 83 30 0.33 57 8
10S
-0.75 83 53 0.44 96 9
10S
+0.70 83 54 0.37 81 6
10S
+0.73 83 63 0.24 89 5
09S
+0.79 83 67 0.11 87 3
08S
-0.75 83 73 0.34 59 8
08S
-0.77 83 131 0.25 0
8 uS
-0.70 0.36 100 12 11S
-0.78 84 7
0.15 106 4
1S
+0.76 0.26 0
9 1S
+0.66 84 13 0.18 90 5
07S
-0.81 0.24 0
8 07S
-0.77 84 15 0.13 100 4
08S
-0.79 0.24 0
8 08S
-0.73 84 29 0.17 75 5
OBS
-0.81 0.24 0
8 08S
-0.74 84 51 0.69 86 20 10S
-0.72 84 54 0.29 110 6
10S
-0.60 84 56 0.31 84 6
loS
-0.62 84 59 0.3 93 5
10S
+0.72 0.37 95 7
1S
-0.63 84 60 0.35 0
12 10S
+0.64 0.51 0
17 10S
-0.65 0.35 114 7
1S
-0.55 0.19 66 4
1S
+0.75 84 61 0.23 123 4
10S
-0.59 Page 15 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A R
Tube;-..
Volts -
-;Degree -.
lTW
'TubeSupport
'SP Locaton 84 66 0.45 82 10 07S
-0.73 84 82 0.26 113 8
04S
+0.67 85 9
0.51 104 13 08S
-0.78 85 21 0.23 92 5
los
-0.75 85 25 0.2 91 5
los
-0.75 85 27 0.33 114 8
loS
-0.77 85 28 0.31 72 8
loS
-0.77 85 49 0.32 119 11 loS
+0.72 85 50 0.31 77 7
lOS
+0.72 85 57 0.26 0
9 l0S
+0.64 0.2 79 3
l0s
+0.81 85 62 0.46 0
15 loS
-0.66 0.26 86 5
loS
-0.64 85 93 0.34 0
11 04S
+0.74 0.19 85 6
04S
+0.71 86 51 0.49 88 16 loS
-0.72 86 131 0.17 118 5
11S
-0.87 87 26 0.24 0
8 05S
-0.82 0.25 67 6
05S
-0.79 87 35 0.95 95 18 loS
-0.70 87 39 0.29 0
10 09S
-0.75 0.29 102 7
10S
-0.75 0.28 100 7
09S
-0.76 87 122 0.7 81 18 07S
+0.63 87 130 0.17 0
6 1S
-0.18 0.37 0
12 10S
-0.78 0.23 104 7
10S
-0.78 0.26 116 8
uS
-0.09 88 34 0.5 0
17 10S
-0.66 0.45 71 13 1oS
-0.68 88 53 0.83 90 13 09S
+0.80 88 129 0.4 0
13 08S
-0.75 0.39 126 11 08S
-0.76 89 26 0.27 0
9 1OS
-0.75 0.23 74 6
lOS
-0.75 89 73 0.25 74 6
04S
+0.67 89 106 0.29 101 11 05S
-0.80 0.25 0
8 05S
-0.71 89 128 0.26 0
8 07S
-0.72 0.41 92 11 07S
-0.82 90 9
0.28 104 7
OBS
-0.78 90 82 0.37 93 11 04S
+0.70 91 29 0.29 93 8
oS
-0.79 0.27 86 7
oS
-0.75 Page 16 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A
.Row..-
Tube Volts -
Degree XW TubeSupport.
SPLocation,
_ _ ~~~~~~~~~~~~',R P late 92 16 0.36 108 10 06S
+0.70 92 57 0.21 72 4
06S
+0.77 0.14 69 3
05S
-0.70 92 89 0.22 83 6
04S
+0.68 92 92 0.36 58 11 04S
+0.66 92 127 0.68 93 17 04S
+0.70 93 88 0.28 76 7
04S
+0.66 94 6
0.29 0
10 07S
-0.70 0.18 91 5
07S
-0.74 94 46 0.21 95 5
07S
-0.76 94 75 0.45 56 10 04S
+0.60 94 128 0.19 0
7 08S
-0.70 0.31 0
11 04S
+0.75 0.51 70 14 04S
+0.76 0.5 34 13 08S
-0.78 94 129 0.59 95 17 08S
-0.76 0.28 72 9
11S
-0.87 95 2
0.43 0
14 11S
+0.70 0.31 95 7
11S
+0.72 95 6
0.26 123 6
07S
-0.78 0.4 0
14 07S
.0.73 95 63 0.21 103 4
09S
-0.72 95 74 0.28 81 6
04S
+0.66 95 87 0.46 76 13 04S
+0.66 95 122 0.32 133 10 09S
.0.81 0.26 0
10 09S
-0.76 95 123 0.37 121 10 09S
-0.80 95 125 0.81 46 20 04S
+0.69 96 70 0.58 71 13 04S
+0.68 96 123 0.19 144 6
07S
-0.85 96 127 0.35 86 11 10S
-0.76 97 118 0.73 24 18 03S
+0.74 0.23 0
9 03S
+0.71 97 123 0.34 112 11 09S
-0.81 98 99 0.45 101 12 07S
+0.44 0.29 107 9
07S
+0.59 98 125 0.28 55 9
09S
-0.85 99 95 0.26 0
9 04S
+0.75 0.18 96 5
04S
+0.68 101 7
0.18 86 5
07S
-0.79 0.23 0
8 07S
-0.75 101 79 0.49 56 13 04S
+0.71 101 122 0.24 73 8
09S
-0.87 0.27 0
9 09S
-0.73 Page 17 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSGA
^Row
-Tube Volts tDegree
%W Tube Support.
SPL Ion
~ ~~~ ~~~~Plate
.102 20 0.23 106 5
07S
-0.79 0.31 0
9 07S
-0.68 102 121 0.34 0
10 04S
-0.64 0.34 50 9
04S
-0.73 102 123 0.43 50 11 los
-0.74 103 4
0.14 85 4
07S
-0.74 0.19 0
7 07S
-0.81 103 5
0.22 86 6
07S
-0.77 0.25 0
9 07S
-0.91 103 17 0.19 102 5
07S
-0.81 0.21 0
7 07S
-0.73 104 121 0.24 101 7
11S
-0.83 105 5
0.27 103 7
07S
-0.79 105 6
0.16 85 4
07S
-0.81 0.32 0
10 07S
-0.72 105 85 0.42 43 10 15S
+0.80 0.41 31 10 01S
+0.77 105 119 0.24 0
7 14S
+0.74 0.2 0
6 12S
+0.75 0.24 68 7
12S
+0.74 0.22 90 6
14S
+0.82 106 4
0.21 99 6
07S
-0.72 106 7
0.23 109 6
07S
-0.77 106 18 0.21 0
7 07S
-0.74 0.23 113 7
07S
-0.78 106 119 0.35 0
11 lS
+0.65 0.56 86 14 lS
+0.65 0.73 85 17 15S
+0.70 107 15 0.56 106 14 14S
-0.81 107 31 0.18 86 4
03S
+0.70 0.27 44 6
09S
+0.70 108 20 0.25 0
8 07S
-0.75 0.2 96 5
07S
-0.81 108 111 0.26 105 7
04S
-0.77 0.34 0
10 04S
-0.77 109 98 0.33 121 9
07S
-0.79 109 117 0.32 127 9
loS
-0.78 0.29 62 8
14S
+0.78 0.19 72 5
13S
+0.71 111 4
0.21 119 5
08S
+0.79 0.18 0
6 08S
+0.74 111 48 0.16 119 3
05S
-0.83 111 100 0.2 85 5
09S
-0.84 112 93 0.45 98 11 15S
-0.86 Page 18 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A
_Row
-Tube.
Volts lDegree -*. ;
W Tube Support TSP Location
.~~~~~~~~~~
.~~~ Plate 112 94 0.36 0
12 03S
+0.75 0.25 97 7
03S
+0.69 0.2 107 6
07S
-0.84 113 72 0.26 84 6
04S
+0.68 113 91 0.26 98 7
15S
-0.83 113 99 0.23 72 7
15S
-0.86 113 111 0.42 142 10 07S
-0.80 114 39 0.15 0
5 05S
-0.69 0.22 110 7
05S
-0.81 114 80 0.28 72 8
10S
-0.90 114 97 0.28 122 12 15S
-0.82 114 109 0.36 129 10 07S
-0.79 114 114 0.21 0
7 09S
+0.68 115 15 0.15 0
5 05S
-0.74 0.19 105 5
05S
-0.85 115 47 0.2 85 4
05S
-0.78 115 50 0.43 92 10 05S
-0.81 115 63 0.23 122 7
05S
-0.77 115 98 0.33 94 13 09S
-0.80 116 5
0.22 0
7 08S
+0.77 0.14 87 4
08S
+0.74 116 6
0.29 104 7
07S
-0.68 116 85 0.31 74 10 02S
+0.81 117 1
0.23 88 6
08S
+0.83 117 24 0.25 0
8 05S
-0.77 0.27 109 8
05S
-0.77 117 34 0.41 105 12 05S
-0.81 117 92 0.27 83 9
15S
-0.80 118 101 0.36 141 10 07S
-0.86 119 2
0.18 94 5
10S
-0.44 119 3
0.18 86 4
08S
+0.77 119 102 0.24 75 7
14S
-0.84 0.49 71 13 07S
-0.72 119 108 0.2 0
7 10S
-0.78 0.3 127 8
10S
-0.78 120 1
0.36 98 9
08S
+0.85 120 2
0.22 83 5
13S
-0.81 120 107 0.2 0
7 10S
+0.75 0.22 113 6
los
+0.63 121 2
0.21 90 5
08S
+0.68 121 94 0.27 123 8
09S
-0.86 121 105 0.54 30 14 lOS
+0.48 122 1
0.21 54 6
lS
-0.79 122 93 0.13 0
5 15S
-0.78 Page 19 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A
- -Row Tube Volts
,egree
.W l Tube Suppor-TSP Location
.:-~~~~~~~Pate.
0.36 41 11 15S
-0.78 122 103 0.67 143 17 10S
-0.74 0.55 0
17 los
-0.65 122 104 0.49 111 9
09S
+0.61 123 1
0.3 116 8
12S
+0.68 0.54 102 13 11S
-0.77 0.26 98 7
08S
+0.72 123 76 0.13 0
5 15S
-0.72 0.26 88 8
15S
-0.78 123 92 0.11 0
4 15S
-0.78 0.3 125 9
15S
-0.78 123 102 0.37 110 10 los
-0.83 0.51 0
16 10S
-0.63 125 25 0.15 0
5 08S
-0.80 0.27 99 5
08S
-0.84 125 29 0.26 0
10 08S
-0.76 0.48 93 9
08S
-0.75 125 63 0.4 89 11 08S
+0.66 125 75 0.26 74 8
15S
.0.90 125 80 0.93 51 23 04S
+0.68 126 92 0.52 126 10 07S
-0.66 127 60 0.47 96 10 09S
+0.66 127 71 0.37 41 10 09S
+0.69 129 3
0.64 71 15 12S
+0.75 129 77 0.31 0
12 04S
+0.74 0.24 125 5
04S
+0.68 130 87 0.2 0
7 07S
-0.71 0.25 142 9
07S
-0.77 131 72 0.48 140 15 07S
+0.71 0.28 78 9
15S
-0.82 131 84 0.25 122 8
07S
-0.85 132 15 0.17 71 4
14S
.0.83 132 32 0.32 108 7
15S
+0.55 132 64 0.14 87 4
15S
-0.85 133 1
0.19 85 5
10S
-0.72 133 2
0.43 103 9
10S
-0.79 133 3
0.35 91 9
10S
-0.77 133 72 0.32 141 9
15S
-0.88 134 3
0.88 93 20 12S
+0.61 135 71 0.65 98 18 09S
-0.80 135 72 0.4 89 12 09S
+0.69 136 80 0.24 93 8
08S
-0.69 0.23 110 7
08S
-0.69 137 1
0.57 102 14 O9S
+0.72 Page 20 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A Rw Tube Volts
- Dgree b
TW
-Tube Support
.lTSP Location' late 137 11 0.23 90 8
08S
-0.70 138 8
0.33 126 6
09S
.0.81 138 26 0.32 0
10 06S
+0.75 0.3 91 6
06S
+0.70 138 74 0.42 0
13 12S
+0.67 0.27 74 8
12S
+0.67 139 2
0.68 87 14 10S
-0.75 139 4
0.37 0
11 los
-0.69 0.41 128 8
10S
-0.77 139 47 0.32 71 11 09S
+0.69 139 62 0.43 129 12 11S
-0.83 140 2
0.36 94 7
08S
+0.81 0.66 101 12 10S
-0.73 140 3
0.49 89 15 loS
-0.72 141 2
0.99 81 17 loS
-0.68 141 3
0.39 71 12 10S
.0.61 141 47 0.25 0
9 09S
+0.68 0.32 49 9
09S
+0.70 141 64 0.94 118 23 15S
.0.80 143 43 0.27 0
10 07S
-0.65 0.27 110 6
07S
-0.65 143 47 0.31 111 7
07S
-0.81 143 48 0.28 68 7
07S
-0.85 143 50 0.2 0
7 06S
+0.73 0.28 76 7
06S
+0.63 143 57 0.26 106 6
09S
+0.67 144 25 0.25 0
9 07S
-0.67 0.27 119 9
07S
-0.75 145 9
0.2 0
6 09S
-0.77 0.22 101 5
09S
-0.88 145 12 0.21 0
6 07S
-0.72 0.19 0
6 07S
+0.67 0.19 86 6
07S
-0.75 145 16 0.29 0
10 07S
-0.63 0.29 119 8
07S
-0.70 145 25 0.26 0
12 05S
-0.74 0.23 0
9 05S
+0.75 0.19 81 7
05S
-0.77 145 31 0.27 0
10 07S
-0.66 0.23 121 8
07S
-0.79 145 33 0.33 0
12 07S
-0.59 0.26 113 9
07S
-0.77 145 47 0.25 49 6
05S
-0.74 145 52 0.48 81 13 12S
+0.70 Page 21 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A
- ,,Row,
-Tube,.
.volts.,.
'.-,Degree' Tube Support-TSP Location 145 53 0.45 107 10 los
-0.65 146 5
0.26 0
8 09S
+0.66 0.27 104 9
09S
+0.68 146 7
0.25 0
8 07S
-0.74 0.28 0
9 07S
+0.74 0.29 133 9
07S
+0.70 0.31 68 10 08S
-0.72 0.5 105 15 08S
+0.78 146 11 0.24 0
7 07S
-0.75 0.25 95 8
07S
-0.77 146 18 0.36 0
13 08S
-0.60 0.32 104 11 08S
-0.64 146 21 0.39 72 9
07S
-0.66 146 22 0.61 100 18 07S
-0.73 146 25 0.21 96 5
07S
-0.66 146 26 0.42 108 13 07S
-0.81 146 29 0.33 118 7
07S
-0.73 146 34 0.4 96 13 08S
-0.73 146 38 0.25 0
8 07S
-0.74 0.26 116 6
07S
-0.70 146 50 0.55 100 12 loS
-0.74 147 15 0.34 0
12 07S
-0.69 0.34 113 11 07S
-0.75 147 16 0.22 98 5
07S
-0.75 147 30 0.6 82 13 12S
+0.66 147 31 0.46 129 15 08S
-0.68 148 1
0.38 0
11 07S
-0.73 0.43 0
13 08S
-0.71 0.23 123 7
07S
-0.70 0.36 134 10 08S
-0.59 148 3
0.22 0
7 07S
+0.77 0.26 67 6
07S
+0.75 0.62 95 12 11S
+0.64 148 4
0.32 0
9 10S
-0.76 0.26 108 8
10S
-0.77 148 10 0.42 0
15 08S
+0.75 0.19 119 6
08S
+0.72 148 15 0.28 0
10 07S
-0.62 0.29 114 10 07S
-0.72 148 19 0.23 0
8 08S
-0.58 0.19 99 7
08S
-0.66 148 23 0.34 127 11 12S
-0.86 148 36 0.67 0
20 10S
-0.71 0.5 84 11 loS
.0.70 Page 22 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes Left In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG A Row +,
Tube i
V°!o is
< De Tube Support TS Location
-~~~ -
~~~~~~~~p la te 149 3
0.49 0
14 14S-0.76 0.39 118 11 148-0.83 149 6
0.34 0
10 07S
+0.74 0.38 77 8
07S
+0.74 149 8
0.18 0
7 07S
+0.74 0.33 74 7
07S
+0.75 149 10 0.16 0
6 07S
+0.64 0.17 91 4
07S
+0.77 149 11 0.67 84 19 08S
-0.68 149 12 0.37 90 8
10S
+0.59 149 14 0.35 94 8
10S
-0.68 149 15 0.36 111 12 10S
-0.66 0.52 0
17 10S
-0.47 149 19 0.39 115 13 12S
-0.77 0.67 91 19 10S
-0.68 149 20 0.36 110 8
WS
-0.73 149 21 0.52 99 16 10S
-0.73 149 28 0.66 80 14 10S
-0.75 149 34 0.32 91 12 11S
-0.78 0.16 0
7 11S
-0.78 150 7
0.39 96 9
10S
-0.77 150 10 0.32 102 11 10S
-0.77 150 14 0.42 91 13 10S
-0.71 150 15 0.77 0
24 10S
-0.66 0.37 102 8
loS
-0.73 150 16 0.7 91 20 10S
-0.77 150 18 0.53 97 16 10S
-0.62 Page 23 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
.-Row Tube
.;.Volts,;
.Degree
.TW Tube Support
-TSP Location 1
5 0.15 85 3
los
-0.07 1
14 0.12 94 2
09S
+0.72 2
7 0.46 96 8
11S
+0.62 2
9 0.3 126 6
09S
-0.71 0.46 0
7 09S
-0.71 2
10 0.37 90 7
09S
-0.73 2
13 0.29 77 6
09S
-0.78 2
20 0.54 106 10 loS
-0.74 2
21 0.74 104 13 loS
-0.70 2
22 0.45 69 8
los
-0.74 0.56 0
9 los
-0.70 2
23 0.55 128 5
loS
+0.00 0.39 0
6 loS
-0.02 2
25 0.35 85 6
lOS
-0.76 0.17 105 3
11S
-0.82 0.31 54 6
08S
-0.66 0.21 0
4 loS
-0.76 0.24 0
5 08S
-0.77 2
26 0.24 86 5
08S
-0.69 0.34 111 7
loS
-0.69 2
27 0.35 44 7
07S
-0.80 0.26 81 6
09S
+0.67 0.33 97 7
loS
-0.72 3
1 0.41 90 8
07S
+0.65 3
15 0.24 91 5
09S
+0.69 3
19 0.29 66 5
los
-0.76 0.3 0
5 lOS
-0.68 3
21 0.35 50 7
loS
-0.79 3
24 0.52 93 10 10S
-0.79 0.25 77 5
09S
-0.76 3
25 0.72 0
11 loS
-0.63 0.31 0
5 loS
+0.69 0.53 101 11 loS
+0.60 0.34 107 8
10S
-0.76 3
26 0.64 100 12 los
-0.07 3
30 0.26 133 6
08S
+0.46 4
13 0.47 99 9
08S
-0.64 4
16 0.46 105 7
08S
-0.68 4
17 0.42 109 8
09S
+0.65 4
18 0.36 123 5
09S
+0.69 4
19 0.4 104 8
09S
+0.67 4
24 0.63 106 10 09S
-0.77 4
25 0.28 93 5
09S
-0.87 0.3 0
4 09S
-0.74 Page 24 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Row Tub
- e Volts Degree T
Tube Support
. TSP Location,
- ~~':Plate-.~
4 26 0.26 108 4
09S
-0.77 0.32 0
5 09S
-0.70 4
32 0.25 87 5
09S
-0.80 4
34 0.15 89 3
09S
-0.80 4
36 0.18 92 3
09S
-0.80 4
40 0.3 96 6
11S
-0.83 0.26 0
5 11S
-0.71 0.13 127 29 LTS
+9.70 5
5 0.43 45 10 05S
-0.84 5
9 0.37 0
8 07S
-0.81 0.25 103 6
07S
-0.77 5
24 0.22 88 4
08S
-0.74 0.62 0
10 08S
-0.74 5
26 0.27 90 5
07S
+0.67 5
27 0.44 92 10 07S
+0.60 0.22 85 5
08S
-0.85 5
30 0.23 71 4
09S
-0.82 0.25 88 5
08S
-0.78 0.46 0
7 08S
-0.73 0.37 0
08S
+0.66 0.29 0
4 09S
-0.75 5
34 0.24 104 5
08S
-0.80 0.37 0
6 08S
-0.76 5
37 0.22 76 4
09S
-0.85 0.24 54 4
07S
+0.68 0.33 91 6
06S
-0.80 0.2 102 4
07S
-0.85 0.16 0
3 07S
+0.68 0.16 0
3 06S
-0.78 0.15 0
3 07S
-0.73 5
38 0.25 72 6
07S
+0.69 0.87 81 16 09S
-0.85 5
44 0.52 66 11 09S
-0.87 5
46 0.42 38 9
09S
-0.83 0.24 0
5 09S
-0.73 6
7 0.21 0
4 08S
+0.60 0.3 92 6
08S
+0.63 6
9 0.28 0
6 loS
-0.70 0.36 84 7
10S
-0.82 6
17 0.22 94 4
08S
-0.74 0.23 48 4
07S
-0.81 0.33 115 6
09S
-0.87 0.35 0
5 08S
-0.73 0.35 0
5 07S
-0.66 Page 25 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
.Row Tube Volts r
Degree
%TW
-TubeSupport TSP Location.
- -.8. ~.K
.PIa te ;
0.34 0
5 09S
-0.75 6
18 0.21 88 5
OBS
-0.75 0.17 95 4
09S
-0.80 0.32 0
5 09S
-0.74 0.54 0
8 08S
-0.71 6
22 0.4 129 9
09S
+0.58 0.55 0
9 09S
+0.57 6
26 0.32 62 7
12S
-0.84 6
27 0.25 77 5
09S
-0.87 0.27 116 5
08S
+0.41 0.49 0
8 08S
+0.44 0.51 0
8 09S
-0.75 6
28 0.27 69 6
07S
+0.59 0.46 0
7 07S
+0.71 6
36 0.38 97 7
08S
-0.73 6
39 0.28 87 5
09S
-0.85 0.26 78 5
08S
+0.62 0.19 59 3
08S
-0.82 0.24 0
4 09S
-0.66 6
41 0.25 84 5
09S
-0.82 0.25 0
5 09S
-0.67 6
43 0.18 122 3
09S
-0.87 0.33 33 6
07S
-0.83 6
44 0.39 89 8
07S
-0.81 0.73 86 14 09S
-0.83 0.36 0
7 07S
-0.71 6
46 0.67 88 13 08S
-0.78 6
47 0.22 91 4
09S
-0.80 6
49 0.16 92 3
12S
-0.83 0.29 57 5
loS
-0.83 0.65 95 11 09S
-0.80 6
50 0.37 43 8
07S
-0.71 7
10 0.51 93 10 08S
+0.61 7
11 0.43 0
9 08S
-0.80 0.3 78 7
08S
-0.79 7
17 0.23 0
5 09S
-0.73 0.21 94 5
09S
-0.81 7
18 0.22 92 4
08S
-0.78 0.39 0
6 08S
-0.75 7
19 0.25 95 5
08S
-0.74 0.19 64 4
03S
-0.80 7
20 0.86 93 17 07S
+0.55 7
22 0.35 125 8
08S
+0.53 0.4 0
6 08S
+0.54 Page 26 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
,,Row
-ube:
Volts
.,Degre Tube Support TSP Location
_ _ _ _ _ _.. we. s s ;;~t,;;;z
.>,.i' ' v...........
.Plate 7
25 0.29 119 6
08S
-0.78 0.26 0
4 08S
-0.60 7
26 0.44 92 10 12S
-0.85 0.35 124 8
07S
+0.66 0.2 122 4
09S
-0.76 0.23 135 5
09S
+0.02 0.44 0
7 12S
-0.74 0.32 0
5 09S
+0.02 0.41 0
6 098
-0.63 7
28 0.41 78 9
08S
+0.53 7
29 0.19 95 4
09S
+0.67 0.42 86 8
09S
-0.78 0.4 102 8
08S
+0.53 0.44 100 8
07S
+0.67 0.5 112 10 07S
-0.74 0.29 103 6
10S
-0.77 0.34 0
5 10S
+0.74 7
30 1.09 75 21 08S
+0.53 1.06 82 20 09S
-0.78 0.49 76 11 08S
-0.76 0.36 86 8
07S
+0.64 0.47 93 10 07S
-0.78 0.44 82 10 04S
-0.83 0.56 0
9 07S
-0.75 0.32 0
5 07S
+0.68 0.36 0
6 07S
+0.67 7
33 0.14 129 3
02S
+0.23 0.27 0
4 02S
+0.32 7
42 0.25 35 6
07S
+0.67 0.31 67 7
09S
-0.78 7
43 0.34 59 6
09S
-0.82 0.31 86 6
08S
-0.80 0.2 106 4
06S
-0.82 0.21 0
4 09S
-0.80 0.23 0
4 08S
-0.66 0.23 0
4 06S
-0.75 7
44 0.29 134 6
07S
+0.67 7
45 0.29 61 5
09S
-0.84 0.21 0
4 09S
-0.75 7
47 0.46 37 8
09S
-0.82 0.36 0
7 09S
-0.69 7
52 0.33 68 7
09S
-0.76 0.33 75 7
10S
+0.00 7
53 0.4 80 7
13S
-0.80 Page 27 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSGB Row :jTube
- Volts Degree,.
-Tube Support TSP Location
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _P la te 8
4 0.38 72 8
los
.0.76 8
7 0.29 80 6
08S
-0.74 8
10 0.41 0
9 08S
+0.67 0.35 122 8
08S
+0.59 8
15 0.49 89 10 07S
+0.63 8
17 0.19 92 4
09S
-0.77 0.14 92 3
06S
-0.77 8
20 0.37 86 7
08S
-0.68 0.73 0
12 08S
-0.65 0.33 0
5 08S
+0.48 8
31 0.28 87 6
07S
+0.53 0.33 0
5 07S
+0.66 0.25 0
4 07S
-0.69 8
34 0.22 89 4
09S
-0.81 8
36 0.22 85 4
09S
-0.78 8
39 0.23 113 5
09S
-0.85 8
43 0.25 55 6
09S
-0.81 8
46 0.3 64 5
09S
-0.80 0.45 24 8
07S
+0.64 0.36 100 7
07S
-0.78 8
49 0.41 31 8
08S
+0.60 0.24 46 5
08S
-0.83 8
51 0.32 66 7
09S
-0.78 8
52 0.31 84 09S
-0.75 0.26 0
5 09S
-0.68 9
1 0.13 0
3 12S
-0.66 0.31 0
6 12S
+0.66 0.59 36 12 12s
-0.82 0.46 70 9
09S
-0.77 9
2 0.21 101 5
12S
+0.64 9
4 0.43 100 10 09S
-0.79 9
5 0.55 99 11 07S
-0.72 0.57 62
- 11.
09S
-0.86 9
7 0.26 72 6
09S
-0.84 9
I 10 0.26 76 6
09S
-0.77 9
12 0.51 0
11 08S
-0.70 0.42 62 9
08S
-0.82 9
13 0.39 59 8
08S
-0.70 0.39 45 8
06S
-0.70 9
16 0.26 88 5
08S
+0.38 0.18 57 4
06S
-0.70 9
17 0.53 71 11 09S
-0.86 9
18 0.37 48 8
08S
-0.79 9
21 0.24 91 5
08S
+0.25 Page 28 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
- Row ;Tube Volts
.Degree
%TW.
Tube Support
- TSPLocation-
.Plate - 7.
9 38 0.27 121 6
09S
-0.73 0.25 0
4 09S
-0.70 9
46 0.29 81 6
07S
-0.83 9
49 0.3 77 5
09S
-0.87 9
51 0.33 111 6
09S
-0.87 0.21 0
4 09S
-0.70 9
52 0.27 95 6
08S
+0.69 0.33 125 7
09S
-0.78 9
53 0.28 101 5
09S
-0.82 02 0
4 09S
-0.76 9
54 0.4 65 8
09S
-0.78 10 2
0.3 84 7
03S
-0.77 0.41 38 9
09S
-0.77 10 7
0.48 74 10 14S
-0.84 10 12 0.68 86 14 09S
-0.82 10 18 0.32 79 7
09S
-0.82 10 27 0.28 103 5
09S
-0.80 10 35 0.3 80 6
09S
-0.80 10 54 0.23 65 4
08S
-0.77 0.19 0
4 08S
-0.65 11 2
0.41 47 9
los
-0.85 11 9
0.29 73 6
08S
-0.79 11 10 0.28 107 6
08S
.0.82 11 55 0.44 63 8
08S
-0.78 11 57 0.39 85 7
09S
-0.82 0.2 51 4
08S
+0.32 0.22 0
4 OBS
+0.34 11 59 0.49 90 9
09S
+0.64 11 68 0.25 67 4
07S
-0.68 0.18 124 3
13S
-0.75 0.41 0
13S
-0.68 12 1
0.41 121 8
13S
-0.86 0.53 106 10 13S
+0.57 0.43 128 9
08S
-0.81 12 4
0.22 0
4 13S
-0.74 0.33 81 7
09S
-0.84 0.36 70 8
13S
-0.82 12 6
0.36 97 8
09S
.0.82 12 7
0.3 82 6
09S
-0.88 0.21 125 4
08S
-0.86 12 9
0.42 112 8
08S
-0.77 12 37 0.3 119 7
09S
-0.89 0.2 80 5
07S
-0.90 0.18 0
3 09S
-0.73 Page 29 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
.Row ;-Tube.-
--Volts
- Degree.,
%TW Tube Support
- TSP Location
- Nv Plate 12 40 0.28 78 5
07S
-0.78 12 59 0.33 91 6
09S
-0.80 12 66 0.34 95 7
09S
-0.87 0.4 101 8
lS
-0.81 13 1
0.3 0
6 08S
-0.72 0.47 87 11 13S
-0.86 0.3 73 8
08S
-0.77 13 3
0.28 0
6 13S
-0.67 0.25 0
5 09S
-0.73 0.25 113 6
09S
-0.84 0.28 98 6
13S
-0.82 13 9
0.54 86 11 08S
-0.84 0.32 60 7
09S
-0.84 13 10 0.25 63 5
03S
-0.77 13 20 0.49 93 10 07S
-0.81 13 22 0.44 84 9
07S
-0.77 13 27 0.3 76 7
03S
-0.78 13 36 0.21 83 4
08S
-0.80 13 43 0.83 98 17 09S
-0.73 13 70 0.37 147 5
09S
-0.74 13 72 0.23 131 3
09S
-0.77 0.29 0
6 09S
+0.47 13 73 0.53 44 9
09S
-0.77 0.18 130 4
09S
+0.71 13 74 0.21 143 3
07S
+0.72 14 5
0.36 90 7
09S
-0.82 14 6
0.44 0
9 08S
-0.75 0.61 146 13 08S
-0.89 14 7
0.5 68 10 09S
-0.82 14 10 0.38 106 8
08S
.0.82 14 25 0.2 0
4 07S
-0.76 0.27 69 6
07S
- 0.81 0.32 45 7
03S
-0.77 14 26 0.38 80 8
03S
-0.77 14 27 0.56 83 11 07S
-0.79 14 34 0.58 95 11 07S
-0.71 14 67 0.45 121 7
09S
-0.72 14 70 0.46 148 8
09S
-0.84 0.68 39 12 07S
-0.78 0.22 0
4 09S
-0.76 14 72 0.34 64 6
07S
-0.78 14 75 0.87 134 14 15S
-0.75 15 3
0.7 44 15 09S
-0.70 15 5
0.33 0
7 13S
-0.76 Page 30 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
-Row N;.
.Tube
,Volts
- -,Degree
%W r -.Tube Support TSP Location -
~
~Pate i 7 :
0.36 131 8
13S
-0.84 0.31 95 7
08S
-0.87 15 6
0.3 0
6 07S
-0.72 0.34 79 7
07S
-0.77 15 7
0.47 66 10 09S
-0.82
- 15.
8 0.42 33 9
09S
-0.82 15 10 0.46 56 9
08S
-0.84 15 32 0.16 64 3
07S
-0.83 15 35 0.63 101 13 09S
-0.80 15 64 0.6 109 9
09S
-0.74 15 69 0.42 102 8
07S
+0.68 15 70 0.37 120 5
07S
+0.70 15 73 0.34 74 6
09S
-0.86 15 75 0.83 118 14 los
-0.07 0.76 28 13 07S
-0.73 0.43 155 8
09S
+0.66 0.49 73 9
09S
-0.80 16 6
0.48 49 10 09S
-0.82 16 10 0.45 54 9
09S
-0.82 16 22 0.12 107 28 LTS
+6.57 16 32 0.36 87 8
03S
-0.70 16 34 0.27 90 6
03S
-0.75 16 36 0.17 100 4
07S
-0.82 16 38 0.37 91 8
07S
-0.80 16 74 0.24 124 4
09S
-0.82 0.26 0
5 09S
+0.61 0.2 0
4 09S
-0.71 16 76 0.78 59 13 07S
-0.78 16 77 0.37 108 5
09S
+0.64 0.17 87 2
08S
-0.70 0.27 117 4
07S
-0.47 16 80 0.52 82 9
09S
-0.71 17 5
0.39 60 9
09S
-0.87 17 7
0.33 64 7
09S
-0.84 17 28 0.37 71 07S
-0.84 17 45 0.47 96 10 09S
-0.77 17 59 0.37 106 6
12S
-0.75 0.27 0
5 12S
-0.68 17 65 0.36 93 6
09S
-0.75 0.33 0
6 09S
-0.75 17 74 1.04 102 16 07S
-0.78 0.31 124 5
09S
-0.85 17 75 0.34 106 6
09S
-0.72 0.3 0
6 09S
+0.66 Page 31 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSGB Row
,-Tube
-Volts
., Degree -
- -%TW Tube Support -
TSP Location
- ;*. ' ',,,,',.g
' ' P a te -
2.; :-
0.27 0
5 09S
-0.74 17 76 0.45 75 8
09S
-0.85 0.31 0
6 09S
-0.73 17 77 0.24 88 4
09S
-0.82 17 78 0.33 126 6
09S
+0.53 18 4
0.4 0
8 09S
-0.70 0.34 75 8
09S
-0.80 18 8
0.59 62 12 09S
+0.64 18 9
0.31 0
6 09S
-0.70 0.29 74 7
09S
-0.87 18 14 0.25 93 5
08S
-0.79 18 17 0.37 99 8
03S
-0.77 18 21 0.45 78 10 03S
-0.77 18 30 0.17 0
3 09S
-0.72 0.24 95 5
09S
-0.84 18 32 0.22 0
5 1S
-0.74 0.37 84 8
lS
-0.85 18 39 0.25 92 5
09S
-0.80 18 43 0.31 79 7
07S
-0.80 18 47 0.26 102 6
06S
-0.84 18 75 0.47 118 8
09S
-0.74 0.26 48 4
07S
-0.67 0.28 0
5 07S
+0.73 0.26 0
5 09S
-0.74 0.25 0
5 07S
-0.71 18 76 0.34 140 6
07S
+0.59 0.26 78 4
07S
-0.71 18 79 0.2 103 3
09S
+0.59 0.49 100 8
09S
-0.72 19 5
0.38 143 9
09S
-0.80 19 6
0.63 48 14 09S
-0.84 19 7
0.57 42 13 08S
-0.84 0.52 38 12 09S
-0.78 19 8
0.22 80 5
08S
-0.84 19 9
0.42 0
9 OBS
-0.73 0.33 103 7
08S
-0.82 19 11 0.25 0
5 08S
-0.76 0.27 80 6
08S
-0.82 19 18 0.29 59 6
03S
-0.79 19 19 0.46 71 9
07S
-0.75 19 21 0.48 73 10 07S
-0.79 19 28 0.28 92 6
07S
-0.79 19 30 0.57 66 12 07S
-0.77 19 32 0.33 58 7
03S
-0.77 Page 32 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Row Tube Volts Degree
..%TW TubL Suppor PLocation 0.2 95 5
07S
-0.77 19 40 0.31 106 6
09S
-0.82 19 46 0.54 110 12 09S
-0.75 19 78 0.5 50 8
07S
-0.78 0.7 69 11 09S
-0.83 19 79 0.33 87 6
09S
-0.72 19 80 0.56 109 9
09S
-0.85 20 5
0.43 97 10 OBS
-0.86 20 6
0.42 88 10 08S
-0.87 0.36 50 9
09S
-0.78 20 9
0.71 77 15 08S
-0.84 20 10 0.48 73 10 OBS
-0.84 20 75 0.45 75 8
09S
-0.85 20 77 0.45 100 8
09S
-0.80 20 85 0.28 141 4
09S
-0.68 21 4
0.56 52 12 08S
-0.86 21 10 0.34 99 8
08S
-0.82 21 11 0.73 32 16 08S
-0.82 21 37 0.44 105 10 09S
-0.82 21 38 0.54 88 11 09S
-0.83 21 40 0.44 93 9
09S
-0.83 0.27 94 5
07S
-0.78 21 81 0.94 88 16 07S
-0.65 0.26 101 4
07S
+0.56 21 82 0.26 71 4
07S
+0.50 0.44 92 7
09S
-0.82 0.4 0
8 07S
+0.51 21 84 0.22 104 4
09S
-0.82 21 87 0.22 117 4
09S
-0.74 0.4 0
8 09S
-0.70 22 4
0.34 0
7 08S
-0.71 0.32 65 8
08S
-0.82 22 5
0.26 69 6
08S
-0.86 22 6
0.38 0
8 09S
-0.75 0.33 67 8
09S
-0.82 22 35 0.42 83 10 07S
-0.79 22 36 0.34 86 6
09S
-0.81 22 84 0.22 96 4
07S
+0.71 0.3 96 5
09S
-0.82 0.26 0
5 07S
+0.66 22 85 0.29 112 5
08S
+0.24 22 93 0.3 123 5
09S
-0.73 23 5
0.56 53 13 08S
-0.84 23 10 0.37 140 8
08S
-0.86 Page 33 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Row
,Tube -
Volts.
-Degre
.,Tube Support
'-aTSP Location 0.46 0
10 083
-0.75 23 12 0.25 78 6
08S
-0.86 23 36 0.49 71 8
03S
-0.77 23 50 0.38 75 8
07S
-0.80 23 63 0.32 67 5
03S
-0.70 0.31 84 5
05S
-0.66 0.38 0
7 05S
-0.79 0.45 0
9 03S
-0.76 23 83 0.47 97 8
09S
.0.70 23 85 0.3 124 5
09S
-0.74 23 86 0.23 113 4
07S
+0.64 0.35.
92 6
09S
-0.82 0.13 0
3 09S
-0.71 0.25 0
5 07S
+0.67 23 88 0.26 100 5
09S
-0.89 23 91 0.38 25 6
09S
+0.69 0.26 81 4
09S
-0.80 24 4
0.47 79 11 08S
-0.86 24 43 0.36 98 8
03S
-0.70 0.22 131 31 LTS
+39.00 24
-58 0.16 73 3
06S
-0.80 0.17 0
2 06S
-0.73 24 93 0.32 102 5
09S
-0.71 24 95 0.21 0
4 13S
-0.75 0.25 111 4
13S
-0.73 0.23 116 3
07S
-0.66 25 8
0.28 99 6
09S
+0.64 0.43 0
9 09S
+0.56 25 10 1.09 96 22 09S
+0.60 25 14 0.24 113 6
08S
-0.80 25 38 0.64 86 11 09S
-0.77 25 39 0.53 76 12 03S
-0.75 25 86 0.31 103 5
09S
-0.72 0.28 0
5 09S
-0.78 25 92 0.32 98 5
07S
+0.74 26 5
0.29 88 7
09S
-0.77 0.52 166 12 09S
+0.50 26 7
0.31 130 7
08S
-0.79 0.3 130 7
09S
-0.86 26 9
0.49 98 11 09S
+0.64 26 23 0.35 66 6
03S
-0.81 26 26 0.24 74 6
03S
-0.77 0.3 75 7
07S
-0.84 26 93 0.15 102 2
08S
+0.05 Page 34 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B yRow
- Tube Vt
- Degree pTw
¶ e Support'
.TSP Location.:
<'~ ~Plate 26 94 0.27 91 4
07S
+0.73 26 97 0.27 73 4
08S
-0.71 26 98 0.38 36 5
07S
-0.78 27 2
0.16 58 4
03S
-0.77 27 5
0.42 64 10 09S
-0.78 0.32 123 8
09S
+0.57 27 6
0.43 49 10 07S
+0.73 0.29 138 7
08S
+0.64 0.39 83 9
08S
-0.84 27 9
0.33 79 8
08S
-0.86 27 10 0.34 100 8
08S
-0.79 27 21 0.17 65 3
09S
-0.76 0.21 0
4 09S
-0.76 27 32 0.5 77 11 05S
-0.75 27 40 0.31 77 7
03S
-0.77 27 42 0.36 92 8
03S
-0.77 27 45 0.34 64 7
03S
-0.77 27 94 0.58 115 8
08S
+0.60 0.64 84 9
09S
+0.62 27 95 0.56 110 9
08S
+0.64 27 98 0.27 66 4
09S
-0.71 28 4
0.56 86 13 03S
-0.84 28 5
0.36 39 6
07S
-0.66 28 6
0.27 77 7
09S
-0.78 28 13 0.43 61 7
05S
-0.70 28 30 0.41 43 7
03S
-0.79 28 38 0.21 89 4
09S
-0.75 28 94 0.56 82 8
08S
-0.64 0.4 85 6
08S
+0.69 28 96 0.37 0
7 07S
-0.58 0.39 133 6
07S
-0.53 29 6
0.48 102 708S
-0.81 29 7
0.29 101 7
07S
+0.71 29 9
0.37 70 9
08S
-0.82 29 17 0.29 60 4
03S
-0.72 29 42 0.33 81 8
03S
-0.77 29 95 0.3 70 4
08S
-0.75 29 100 0.23 100 4
09S
-0.75 29 101 0.38 75 5
09S
+0.67 30 7
0.24 138 07S
-0.78 0.26 68 4
08S
-0.81 30 9
0.19 54 3
08S
-0.77 30 11 0.23 81 3
08S
-0.75 30 14 0.63 55 14 09S
-0.78 Page 35 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B "Row Tube Volts-.
Degree s.%TW -
Tube Support
.-TSP Location.
30 37 0.3 116 6
09S
-0.83 0.25 0
5 09S
-0.80 30 41 0.48 81 8
03S
-0.75 30 100 0.27 92 4
07S
+0.66 31 5
0.49 67 12 03S
-0.80 31 6
0.3 105 4
07S
+0.75 0.24 70 4
09S
-0.77 31 7
0.43 93 10 08S
-0.83 31 8
0.35 85 5
07S
+0.73 31 12 0.17 86 2
08S
-0.73 31 22 0.41 133 9
07S
-0.81 31 42 1.19 84 18 09S
-0.74 31, 58 0.27 61 7
03S
-0.75 32 6
0.86 77 13 03S
-0.68 32 7
0.27 0
6 08S
-0.75 0.24 109 6
08S
-0.80 32 8
0.2 113 3
08S
-0.73 32 9
0.38 39 9
03S
-0.80 32 11 0.43 59 10 08S
-0.80 32 15 0.74 85 16 09S
-0.73 32 25 0.54 63 9
03S
-0.75 0.59 30 10 09S
-0.81 0.17 0
3 09S
-0.76 32 35 0.64 75 11 09S
-0.77 32 89 0.23 62 6
05S
-0.80 32 106 0.32 113 5
los
+0.21 33 6
0.36 49 08S
-0.72 33 8
0.21 95 3
08S
-0.75 0.43 106 7
07S
+0.75 33 27 0.42 64 7
09S
-0.79 0.28 0
6 09S
-0.65 33 47 0.33 93 8
09S
-0.78 33 70 0.27 77 6
07S
-0.80 34 7
0.36 48 9
09S
-0.78 34 11 0.41 34 10 OBS
-0.80 35 8
0.67 63 14 09S
+0.51 35 20 0.72 70 16 04S
-0.75 35 42 0.85 71 18 09S
-0.79 35 60 0.22 89 5
06S
-0.79 35 108 0.88 78 14 07S
-0.66 36 5
0.28 78 6
09S
+0.58 36 9
0.22 93 5
09S
-0.75 36 10 0.41 76 9
09S
+0.60 36 11 0.27 78 6
08S
-0.80 Page 36 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Rowe :
Tube Volts --
Degree Tube Support
- TSP Location
',.Plate 36 12 0.2 86 4
08S
-0.77 36 19 0.6 91 13 09S
-0.75 0.38 59 8
03S
-0.82 36 36 0.42 111 7
07S
-0.77 36 47 0.8 91 16 07S
-0.77 36 57 0.55 108 8
09S
-0.70 36 64 0.24 85 6
03S
-0.72 36 92 0.29 86 6
03S
-0.79 37 6
0.52 78 11 05S
-0.78 37 8
0.44 103 9
07S
+0.64 37 12 0.51 79 11 09S
-0.78 0.28 57 6
08S
-0.75 37 18 0.43 78 9
03S
-0.73 37 21 0.24 120 5
07S
-0.82 37 48 0.61 86 13 07S
-0.74 37 114 0.37 64 6
09S
-0.73 0.2 90 3
05S
-0.75 38 4
0.34 112 7
09S
+0.53 38 8
0.42 86 9
08S
-0.75 38 10 0.39 103 9
09S
+0.58 38 11 0.35 93 8
08S
-0.75 38 27 0.37 68 7
03S
-0.77 38 38 0.44 96 10 09S
-0.79 38 45 0.38 165 28 LTS
+9.63 0.33 78 6
07S
-0.79 38 62 0.28 73 7
03S
-0.72 38 64 0.18 127
- 32 LTS
+8.05 38 70 0.42 77 10 03S
-0.76 38 75 0.16 127 4
07S
-0.77 39 8
0.61 120 13 07S
+0.68 39 9
0.53 68 11 07S
+0.75 39 11 0.45 61 10 09S
+0.51 39 34 0.42 82 9
09S
-0.79 39 49 0.59 81 12 03S
-0.76 39 52 0.51 75 11 09S
-0.79 39 61 0.62 78 13 09S
-0.75 39 116 0.52 66 8
09S
-0.71 40 5
0.4 122 9
09S
+0.64 40 6
0.38 84 9
09S
-0.73 0.44 0
10 09S
-0.75 40 8
0.42 86 10 07S
+0.68 40 9
0.51 57 11 07S
+0.52 40 35 0.39 61 9
02S
-0.75 40 45 0.19 154 28 LTS
+14.99 Page 37 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSGB
-Row
-Tube Volts Degree > -: %TW Tube Support ;
TSP Location.
-<:w ;.
f,-os..........................
'Plate 0.27 44 29 LTS
+8.41 40 46 0.22 144 31 LTS
+10.17 40 49 0.4 88 9
07S
-0.79 40 52 0.51 80 11 07S
-0.83 40 117 0.19 0
4 13S
+0.66 0.2 0
4 13S
-0.75 0.21 105 3
13S
-0.76 41 4
0.43 52 10 09S
+0.69 41 7
0.4 118 9
07S
+0.62 41 8
0.3 148 7
07S
+0.63 41 11 0.36 59 8
08S
-0.75 41 38 0.88 105 18 09S
-0.75 41 39 0.16 80 27 LTS
+10.94 41 56 0.34 73 8
03S
-0.77 42 7
0.25 86 6
07S
+0.68 42 11 0.5 45 12 03S
-0.70 0.3 43 7
09S
+0.60 42 28 0.38 71 9
09S
-0.75 42 34 0.19 137 28 LTS
+8.83 42 42 0.31 146 32 LTS
+10.62 0.16 86 32 LTS
+7.80 0.09 130 24 LTS
+7.26 42 47 0.1 90 33 LTS
+11.04 42 63 0.15 119 28 LTS
+13.54 0.19 138 25 LTS
+9.11 42 69 0.55 82 11 03S
-0.74 42 113 0.51 47 8
09S
-0.71 43 3
0.49 62 11 09S
+0.64 43 4
0.25 53 6
05S
+0.68 43 6
0.32 68 8
07S
+0.66 43 7
0.56 31 12 09S
-0.77 0.35 89 8
07S
+0.61 43 8
0.31 97 7
09S
-0.77 43 9
0.25 95 6
03S
-0.80 43 19 0.41 84 9
09S
-0.77 43 26 0.63 50 12 07S
-0.79 43 33 0.47 115 10 09S
-0.79 43 44 0.42 75 9
03S
-0.79 43 48 0.08 166 17 LTS
+26.21 0.12 98 27 LTS
+10.74 43 82 0.12 138 29 LTS
+4.26 43 116 0.44 41 6
03S
-0.65 44 1
0.22 0
5 12S
-0.74 0.23 111 6
12S
-0.84 Page 38 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSGB
-Row
. Tube yolts Degree
/,OTW 1, Tube Support TSP Locatlon
~ ~~~~~~~~~late 44 7
0.31 99 7
07S
+0.66 44 8
0.31 126 7
08S
+0.66 0.5 53 1 1 09S
-0.80 44 22 0.41 65 10 03S
-0.75 44 38 0.26 88 4
05S
-0.72 45 3
0.41 84 10 09S
+0.62 45 7
0.6 106 13 07S
+0.66 45 8
0.39 77 9
09S
+0.60 45 35 1.14 88 19 07S
-0.77 45 40 0.3 145 31 LTS
+13.18 0.78 175 31 LTS
+12.41 0.29 154 30 LTS
+8.82 45 48 0.18 131 32 LTS
+13.66 45 49 0.2 137 34 LTS
+13.45 45 54 0.3 48 7
07S
-0.79 0.19 0
4 07S
-0.79 45 55 0.35 84 8
07S
-0.77 45 118 0.18 44 3
07S
-0.73 46 6
0.4 107 9
07S
+0.57 46 7
0.34 86 8
07S
+0.59 46 8
0.41 42 10 09S
+0.55 46 12 0.34 79 8
03S
-0.77 46 41 0.31 122 36 LTS
+8.68 46 48 0.19 80 4
03S
-0.66 0.34 0
7 03S
-0.71 46 49 0.13 100 24 LTS
+14.27 46 52 0.25 76 6
07S
-0.79 46 55 0.35 56 8
03S
-0.77 0.43 0
9 03S
-0.63 46 67 0.54 87 12 07S
-0.77 46 116 0.28 75 4
09S
-0.76 47 3
0.27 30 7
08S
-0.80 47 5
0.37 0
8 07S
+0.63 0.37 112 9
07S
+0.59 47 6
0.28 63 7
09S
-0.82 0.36 78 9
07S
+0.70 0.27 0
6 09S
-0.74 47 7
0.61 92 13 07S
+0.64 47 8
0.31 60 07S
+0.64 0.42 62 10 09S
-0.75 47 10 0.2 104 5
09S
-0.80 0.32 0
7 09S
-0.73 47 38 0.34 81 7
05S
-0.70 47 53 0.41 74 10 07S
-0.83 Page 39 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSGB Row Tube Volts.
Degree
%TW Tube Support TSP Location'
_ ~ ~ ~~~.P la te 47 78 0.34 47 8
06S
+0.69 48 7
0.64 78 14 07S
+0.64 48 9
0.47 0
10 09S
+0.57 0.39 0
8 07S
+0.62 0.31 87 7
07S
+0.66 0.55 44 12 09S
+0.65 48 35 0.36 99 8
09S
-0.82 48 43 0.15 139 28 LTS
+14.75 0.14 129 28 LTS
+12.16 0.19 102 32 LTS
+11.47 0.08 135 23 LTS
+9.32 0.32 160 30 LTS
+8.83 48 61 0.18 154 19 LTS
+7.40 48 64 0.68 28 14 09S
-0.72 48 72 0.11 138 24 LTS
+9.09 49 4
0.28 73 7
08S
+0.64 49 6
0.24 90 6
07S
+0.68 0.25 0
5 07S
+0.71 49 8
0.32 74 8
07S
+0.68 49 52 0.35 58 6
03S
-0.69 0.37 0
8 03S
-0.75 49 56 0.09 133 24 LTS
+11.98 0.16 158 20 LTS
+6.22 49 78 0.33 65 8
12S
-0.48 49 119 0.38 76 6
06S
+0.74 49 121 0.36 55 5
09S
-0.74 50 1
0.54 33 12 04S
+0.64 50 3
0.29 103 7
09S
-0.80 50 4
0.32 111 8
09S
+0.58 50 6
0.26 75 6
09S
+0.67 0.31 25 7
09S
-0.85 50 13 0.57 52 13 03S
-0.73 50 25 0.4 84 9
07S
-0.79 50 37 0.34 115 8
03S
-0.68 51 6
0.32 89 09S
-0.80 51 17 0.36 75 8
07S
-0.79 51 30 0.41 145 35 LTS
+10.58 51 37 0.67 85 12 09S
-0.72 51 50 0.32 71 6
07S
-0.67 51 55 0.23 137 35 LTS
+7.83 51 79 0.32 139 36 LTS
+13.56 0.18 134 32 LTS
+9.84 51 80 0.19 131 31 LTS
+8.62 52 6
0.48 99 11 07S
+0.62 Page 40 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Row Tube ~~:Vot DegeeST Tube Support TSP Location,,
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
-'~~
a te 0.32 36 8
09S
-0.82 0.33 71 7
09S
-0.73 52 7
0.45 111 10 07S
+0.66 0.28 72 7
07S
-0.71 52 8
0.36 35 8
07S
+0.69 52 28 0.46 81 9
07S
-0.74 52 30 0.6 89 11 los
-0.80 52 37 0.05 45 22 LTS
+17.62 0.19 154 28 LTS
+13.85 0.13 62 25 LTS
+13.42 0.13 155 26 LTS
+13.19 52 46 0.44 79 8
07S
-0.77 52 49 0.21 143 28 LTS
+14.72 53 7
0.33 66 8
09S
+0.64 53 26 0.26 69 6
03S
-0.73 53 32 0.38 70 7
07S
-0.77 53 36 0.54 65 12 09S
-0.75 53 44 0.12 128 25 LTS
+11.00 0.18 99 31 LTS
+10.67 0.28 129 35 LTS
+9.70 0.12 127 24 LTS
+8.10 53 57 0.3 66 6
07S
-0.76 53 59 0.29 70 6
07S
-0.78 53 123 0.28 84 3
08S
-0.70 53 124 0.4 65 5
09S
-0.77 54 6
0.45 97 10 07S
+0.68 54 7
0.43 61 9
07S
+0.68 54 28 0.2 72 5
05S
-0.77 54 58 0.37 84 8
09S
-0.80 54 82 0.28 123 36 LTS
+10.77 0.23 146 24 LTS
+9.71 0.1 107 26 LTS
+6.19 54 114 0.29 97 4
07S
-0.82 54 121 0.6 71 7
07S
-0.70 54 124 0.37 74 5
09S
-0.71 55 87 0.33 74 9
11S
+0.67 56 4
0.32 117 7
08S
+0.66 56 21 0.29 103 7
05S
-0.68 56 37 0.18 86 27 LTS
+11.40 0.34 147 32 LTS
+8.64 56 39 0.86 75 17 07S
-0.77 56 45 0.24 135 5
07S
-0.79 56 53 0.2 158 27 LTS
+14.38 0.15 165 24 LTS
+13.46 Page 41 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSGB "Row Tube
-olts Degree
-%TW
. Tube Support TSP Location".
Pla te -
H JP.'
te 0.29 132 33 LTS
+11.52 0.24 143 32 LTS
+5.65 56 78 0.37 78 10 01S
-0.80 56 111 0.3 54 4
07S
-0.72 0.17 0
4 07S
-0.71 56 122 0.56 102 6
07S
-0.73 56 124 0.32 114 4
05S
-0.75 56 127 0.32 82 4
07S
-0.70 57 33 0.22 144 34 LTS
+27.06 0.24 144 29 LTS
+14.22 57 39 0.59 82 13 07S
-0.81 57 89 0.12 120 22 LTS
+10.31 0.1 137 20 LTS
+7.43 0.12 135 25 LTS
+7.23 0.19 128 28 LTS
+6.74 57 122 0.51 80 6
07S
-0.70 57 126 0.6 87 7
07S
-0.73 58 8
0.17 90 3
03S
-0.71 58 33 0.22 52 32 LTS
+15.51 0.11 44 19 LTS
+11.39 0.25 156 30 LTS
+8.90 58 39 0.29 95 6
03S
-0.81 58 71 0.34 60 5
07S
-0.68 58 78 0.32 74 7
07S
-0.71 58 86 0.3 84 7
07S
-0.75 58 89 0.25 132 34 LTS
+5.92 58 101 0.24 100 5
07S
-0.80 58 124 0.33 132 4
08S
-0.70 0.2 0
4 08S
-0.68 58 125 0.36 65 4
07S
-0.71 0.43 102 5
08S
-0.77 0.26 0
6 07S
+0.64 0.14 0
3 07S
-0.76 59 1
0.66 99 14 09S
-0.75 59 5
0.45 50 10 09S
-0.79 59 7
0.28 89 6
07S
+0.66 59 30 0.29 159 32 LTS
+9.85 59 40 0.11 126 29 LTS
+9.30 59 45 0.37 99 8
07S
-0.79 59 56 0.51 76 9
07S
-0.75 59 80 0.2 130 27 LTS
+12.38 59 113 0.61 87 8
07S
-0.74 59 118 0.42 93 5
07S
-0.68 59 121 0.42 42 5
09S
-0.72 Page 42 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Row Tube
.Volts-Degree
%TW Tube Support TSP Locstion,
- t
' ::. ;~-
.. L.
- -~
A
- Plate.
59 122 0.63 77 7
07S
-0.75 0.98 100 11 09S-0.71 60 6
0.22 127 5
03S
-0.73 60 34 0.18 67 31 LTS
+15.66 60 44 0.17 138 26 LTS
+8.34 60 48 0.48 84 11 07S
-0.74 60 52 0.22 51 4
07S
-0.69 60 70 0.24 81 6
05S
+0.66 60 117 0.62 83 7
07S
-0.70 60 119 1.27 91 14 07S
-0.68 60 120 0.35 69 4
03S
-0.69 60 124 0.36 72 5
07S
-0.72 60 126 0.35 85 4
09S
-0.76 0.33 0
7 09S
-0.71 60 127 0.52 32 6
07S
-0.68 0.33 67 4
08S
-0.77 61 1
0.29 115 6
09S
-0.73 61 21 0.34 82 8
03S
-0.70 61 25 0.35 150 34 LTS
+8.09 0.28 133 32 LTS
+6.87 61 27 0.41 66 9
09S
-0.73 0.25 146 36 LTS
+9.94 61 28 0.39 54 9
07S
-0.78 61 42 0.89 80 18 07S
-0.72 61 44 0.37 96 9
. 03S
-0.79 61 46 0.13 141 21 LTS
+8.27 61 50 0.3 56 6
07S
-0.69 61 68 0.19 46 5
05S
+0.68 61 82 0.14 138 20 LTS
+12.29 0.27 131 33 LTS
+8.41 61 88 0.15 113 28 LTS
+6.05 61 124 0.29 125 09S
+0.71 62 6
0.36 0
8 07S
+0.61 0.39 57 9
07S
+0.66 62 13 0.5 71 11 03S
-0.82 62 28 0.09 103 23 LTS
+11.38 0.48 147 33 LTS
+10.60 0.15 138 25 LTS
+9.95 0.22 135 35 LTS
+8.22 62 44 0.1 148 32 LTS
+11.81 0.19 137 25 LTS
+9.74 62 56 0.19 50 4
07S
-0.73 62 58 0.23 68 4
09S
+0.83 62 83 0.32 50 5
02S
+0.81 Page 43 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
-Row Tbe
'Vit~,Degre
-Tub Spot.
TSP Locatio,.
0'
/
'i.
plate 0.27 0
5 02S
+0.80 62 99 0.12 131 29 LTS
+10.14 0.2 133 34 LTS
+9.32 62 103 0.3 92 7
07S
-0.77 62 115 0.32 91 5
14S
-0.85 62 122 0.32 63 5
05S
+0.61 62 127 0.23 0
08S
-0.77 0.19 74 3
08S
-0.71 63 1
0.36 93 8
12S
-0.82 63 7
0.36 0
8 08S
-0.75 0.28 57 7
08S
-0.80 63 12 0.56 66 12 04S
+0.76 63 19 0.43 77 10 03S
-0.75 63 25 0.44 60 10 05S
-0.75 63 26 0.33 170 29 LTS
+27.63 0.15 142 32 LTS
+11.64 63 34 0.82 91 16 07S
-0.70 63 41 0.23 145 30 LTS
+13.75 0.27 129 31 LTS
+12.41 63 69 1.44 85 26 07S
-0.75 63 113 0.29 88 5
04S
+0.68 63 117 0.38 82 7
05S
+0.64 63 124 0.17 49 3
04S
+0.73 63 125 0.41 86 7
08S
-0.75 0.3 100 5
07S
+0.64 64 5
0.46 95 10 09S
-0.78 64 8
0.26 102 6
09S
+0.67 64 34 0.33 0
7 04S
+0.75 0.43 72 9
05S
-0.75 0.3 55 6
04S
+0.68 64 42 0.23 122 34 LTS
+12.05 64 68 0.45 100 10 07S
-0.75 64 77 0.37 74 8
07S
-0.75 64 105 0.21 71 4
14S
-0.79 0.19 0
4 14S
-0.72 64 121 0.45 83 7
04S
+0.77 65 1
0.3 96 7
14S
.0.78 65 8
0.46 28 10 03S
.0.78 65 37 0.26 144 33 LTS
+17.03 0.17 90 30 LTS
+16.51 0.13 146 25 LTS
+12.86 0.16 113 29 LTS
+12.45 0.23 109 30 LTS
+10.58 0.23 86 34 LTS
+8.48 Page 44 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B v Row
. Tube I.-Volts DegreeW
.^
Tube Support.
TSP Location
.:R w
__J
-V_
_Its.,
-grate 0.06 82 12 LTS
+6.95 65 42 0.12 49 23 LTS
+6.72 65 44 0.19 62 28 LTS
+14.34 0.19 132 26 LTS
+11.55 65 50 0.13 117 31 LTS
+13.71 0.1 83 24 LTS
+12.54 0.48 55 11 07S
-0.72 65 52 0.4 54 7
09S
-0.64 0.26 0
5 09S
-0.68 65 71 0.28 25 6
07S
-0.73 0.24 63 5
09S
-0.77 0.13 0
4 09S
-0.71 65 112 0.45 86 7
04S
+0.71 65 113 0.45 83 8
04S
+0.77 65 115 0.58 84 11 04S
+0.86 65 116 0.19 0
4 05S
+0.67 0.24 118 4
05S
+0.70 65 119 1.11 91 21 05S
+0.82 65 121 0.6 85 11 05S
+0.81 65 122 0.58 81 9
05S
+0.70 65 125 0.27 77 4
04S
+0.68 65 127 0.63 84 12 09S
-0.70 0.29 109 5
07S
+0.75 0.35 54 6
078-0.70 0.5 0
10 07S
+0.69 66 1
0.37 0
8 13S
+0.61 0.9 41 18 13S
+0.52 66 4
0.49 46 11 09S
+0.60 66 5
0.42 72 10 09S
-0.75 66 34 0.12 112 29 LTS
+12.61 0.04 80 23 LTS
+8.77 66 37 0.88 92 17 09S
-0.82 66 57 0.22 68 3
07S
-0.66 0.32 0
7 07S
-0.74 66 58 0.55 76 9
07S
-0.70 66 72 0.33 81 8
07S
-0.73 66 106 0.48 94 11 07S
-0.80 66 111 0.65 93 12 05S
+0.66 66 112 0.34 0
8 05S
+0.74 0.27 87 4
05S
+0.75 66 126 0.63 90 10 04S
+0.61 67 5
0.53 85 12 09S
-0.77 67 26 0.23 105 5
09S
+0.74 67 33 0.85 88 17 07S
-0.72 Page 45 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSGB Row
- Tube
.Volts..
Degree -
%T
-Tube Support-.-
TSR Locatlon l
67 38 0.32 71 7
09S
+0.71 67 40 0.49 37 10 09S
+0.69 67 42 0.53 64 11 09S
+0.67 67 47 0.34 98 7
09S
+0.73 67 49 0.29 98 6
09S
-0.68 67 50 0.22 74 37 LTS
+11.94 67 52 0.85 62 14 07S
-0.69 67 54 0.17 73 3
09S
-0.66 67 55 0.75 61 13 09S
+0.81 67 59 0.34 73 5
09S
+0.73 67 62 0.22 78 3
09S
+0.73 0.37 0
8 09S
+0.66 67 64 0.24 57 5
09S
+0.73 0.13 0
6 09S
+0.73 67 70 0.27 75 6
03S
-0.77 67 112 0.45 95 7
05S
+0.70 0.33 88 5
04S
+0.75 67 113 0.36 80 6
04S
+0.88 67 123 0.33 0
8 08S
-0.69 0.39 49 7
08S
-0.68 67 125 0.53 84 10 07S
-0.70 67 126 0.51 0
12 07S
-0.67 0.41 104 6
07S
-0.64 0.5 95 8
09S
+0.73 68 21 1.15 90 21 OBS
-0.79 68 30 0.26 92 6
07S
-0.73 68 33 0.59 86 13 07S
-0.77 68 38 0.17 143 28 LTS
+16.81 0.19 139 28 LTS
+15.53 0.25 147 26 LTS
+13.68 0.24 73 33 LTS
+11.59 0.16 121 28 LTS
+10.08 0.59 44 12 09S
+0.65 68 42 0.83 71 17 09S
+0.69 68 45 0.55 75 11 09S
+0.64 68 47 0.66 107 14 09S
+0.71 68 48 0.72 69 14 09S
+0.69 68 49 0.6 99 13 09S
+0.71 68 50 0.57 114 12 09S
+0.71 0.32 134 7
07S
-0.77 0.35 133 7
09S
-0.68 68 51 0.41 88 9
09S
-0.70 0.66 67 14 09S
+0.69 68 52 0.35 118 7
09S
+0.78 Page 46 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B wRpw
,.Tube V ts Degree..-
TW Tube Support
- TSP Locatlon' 0.45 95 9
09S
-0.70 68 53 0.62 84 11 09S
+0.77 0.41 66 7
09S
-0.60 68 54 0.57 79 10 07S
-0.69 68 56 0.43 85 8
09S
+0.74 68 57 0.3 95 5
09S
+0.69 68 58 0.19 81 3
09S
+0.80 68 59 0.44 88 7
09S
+0.78 0.44 72 7
09S
-0.64 0.31 63 5
07S
-0.68 68 60 0.28 79 4
09S
+0.76 0.32 65 5
09S
-0.64 68 61 0.43 89 7
09S
+0.78 68 62 0.34 90 5
09S
+0.78 0.29 77 5
09S
-0.59 68 63 0.24 83 4
09S
+0.80 68 64 0.48 89 11 09S
+0.69 68 69 0.21 70 5
07S
-0.77 68 99 0.38 67 35 LTS
+11.41 0.36 159 36 LTS
+8.22 68 102 0.26 85 6
07S
-0.75 68 111 0.34 98 6
04S
+0.63 68 125 0.73 88 14 05S
-0.43 68 127 0.38 0
9 07S
-0.47 0.36 129 6
07S
-0.50 68 129 0.43 71 8
09S
-0.71 0.17 130 2
09S
+0.67 69 8
0.44 78 10 12S
-0.77 69 14 0.51 0
11 03S
-0.75 0.35 86 8
03S
-0.77 69 15 0.31 87 7
04S
+0.68 69 17 0.26 85 6
03S
+0.66 0.38 50 9
03S
-0.80 69 40 0.35 84 8
09S
+0.71 69 42 0.3 147 38 LTS
+13.88 69 44 0.47 0
10 09S
+0.68 0.66 37 13 09S
+0.69 69 45 0.81 86 17 09S
+0.73 69 46 0.61 106 12 09S
+0.64 0.31 93 7
07S
-0.79 69 47 0.79 100 16 09S
+0.69 69 48 0.58 86 12 09S
+0.69 0.18 98 4
09S
-0.68 69 49 0.58 27 13 05S
+0.66 Page 47 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
-Row
- ':Tube, Volts Degree
,%TW*.
TubeSupport
-TSP Location
~ ~
~ ~~~~~~~P~~Flate 0.69 51 15 09S
-0.70 0.89 71 18 09S
+0.64 69 50 0.47 86 10 09S
+0.67 0.34 87 7
09S
-0.70 69 51 0.81 77 17 09S
+0.69 0.27 117 6
09S
-0.68 69 52 0.58 53 12 09S
+0.69 0.38 65 8
09S
-0.66 69 53 0.45 90 8
09S
+0.84 0.46 0
10 09S
+0.73 69 54 0.58 88 10 09S
+0.77 1.32 64 21 09S
-0.65 69 55 0.77 81 13 09S
+0.79 0.43 125 8
09S
-0.65 0.29 50 5
04S
+0.76 69 56 1.07 80 17 09S
-0.62 1.03 93 17 07S
-0.64 69 57 0.21 91 3
09S
+0.82 69 58 0.56 91 9
09S
+0.78 0.32 71 5
09S
-0.64 69 59 1.14 78 17 09S
+0.73 0.43 75 7
09S
-0.64 69 60 0.7 86 11 09S
+0.73 0.45 75 7
09S
-0.55 69 61 0.36 83 6
09S
+0.80 69 62 0.39 88 6
09S
+0.78 0.24 84 4
09S
-0.64 69 63 0.27 97 4
09S
+0.76 69 64 0.31 87 7
09S
+0.69 0.23 46 5
04S
+0.73 69 69 0.18 87 4
06S
+0.61 69 70 0.23 67 5
06S
+0.73 0.22 70 5
04S
+0.66 69 72 0.19 79 4
08S
-0.70 0.23 82 5
07S
+0.64 0.32 115 7
11S
-0.55 69 111 0.27 116 4
05S
+0.68 69 116 0.37 121 7
05S
+0.63 69 126 0.5 78 9
09S
-0.55 0.36 83 6
04S
+0.84 0.16 108 2
09S
+0.64 69 128 0.44 118 8
07S
-0.88 70 6
0.4 44 9
07S
-0.86 70 38 0.25 142 36 LTS
+17.80 Page 48 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
,,Row
,Tube.
- z. Volts,.
Degree TW Tube Support
- TSP Location 0.12 127 36 LTS
+15.77 0.17 150 32 LTS
+15.49 0.38 167 32 LTS
+14.15 0.32 77 7
09S
-0.73 70 47 0.69 75 15 09S
+0.66 0.21 154 5
09S
-0.59 70 48 0.75 46 15 09S
-0.75 70 49 0.6 104 13 09S
+0.73 0.39 146 9
09S
-0.70 70 50 0.57 57 12 09S
+0.51 70 52 0.65 71 13 09S
+0.60 0.32 95 7
09S
-0.75 70 53 0.47 71 11 09S
-0.72 0.49 92 11 09S
+0.66 70 54 0.49 76 10 09S
-0.75 70 58 0.3 88 5
09S
+0.76 0.46 82 7
09S
-0.59 0.16 99 33 LTS
+31.04 70 59 0.82 89 13 09S
+0.78 0.41 77 6
09S
-0.61 70 60 0.31 86 5
09S
+0.80 70 61 0.84 95 13 09S
+0.73 0.46 96 7
09S
-0.59 0.19 75 3
07S
-0.68 0.25 0
5 07S
-0.75 70 62 0.55 91 9
09S
+0.80 70 63 0.24 96 6
09S
+0.67 0.17 68 4
09S
-0.73 70 65 0.15 77 4
los
-0.83 70 68 0.7 84 15 07S
-0.77 0.16 69 4
04S
+0.68 70 70 0.16 64 4
09S
-0.80 70 110 0.26 81 4
04S
+0.73 70 111 0.41 90 7
05S
+0.72 0.66 85 12 04S
+0.79 70 128 0.42 123 7
09S
+0.73 71 6
0.22 0
5 03S
-0.75 0.42 35 10 03S
-0.81 71 26 0.55 60 12 07S
+0.70 71 38 0.82 87 16 07S
-0.77 71 42 0.41 0
9 09S
+0.62 0.49 43 10 09S
+0.64 71 43 0.71 77 15 09S
+0.71 71 46 0.64 0
14 09S
+0.67 Page 49 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Row
-Tube
-yolts Degree., 1/TW
-.Tube Support
, TSPLocation'
~~ ~~~~~~~-
plate,
0.47 138 10 09S
+0.64 71 49 0.52 79 12 09S
+0.64 71 50 0.45 62 9
09S
-0.64 71
-51 0.71 71 15 03S
-0.75 0.71 72 15 09S
+0.64 71 54 0.35 75 8
09S
+0.73 71 55 0.81 46 17 07S
-0.77 0.32 76 8
09S
-0.72 71 57 0.2 79 3
09S
+0.73 71 58 0.18 81 3
09S
+0.78 71 59 0.3 86 5
09S
+0.77 71 60 0.29 89 5
09S
-0.61 71 61 0.18 94 3
09S
+0.75 71 62 0.43 95 7
09S
+0.78 71 63 0.24 98 6
09S
+0.69 71 71 0.24 93 6
08S
-0.77 71 82 0.33 51 8
07S
-0.75 0.3 0
6 07S
-0.69 71 86 0.19 79 4
04S
+0.70 0.23 0
4 04S
+0.63 71 95 0.16 112 28 LTS
+7.00 71 111 0.52 0
12 05S
+0.71 0.3 87 5
05S
+0.84 72 2
0.3 74 7
13S
-0.79 72 39 0.64 77 14 12S
+0.68 72 41 0.54 60 12 09S
+0.66 72 43 0.67 50 14 09S
+0.59 72 46 0.66 74 13 07S
-0.84 72 50 0.36 89 8
07S
-0.81 0.39 68 9
09S
+0.66 0.23 0
5 09S
+0.74 72 51 0.36 64 8
09S
+0.67 72 53 0.41 0
9 09S
+0.70 0.59 37 12 09S
+0.62 72 54 0.66 113 13 09S
+0.66 0.51 67 11 09S
-0.70 72 57 0.23 101 4
09S
+0.79 0.44 85 7
09S
-0.65 0.33 73 5
07S
-0.67 72 58 0.55 85 9
09S
+0.73 0.26 100 4
09S
-0.56 72 64 0.32 84 7
los
-0.80 0.21 0
6 los
-0.75 72 65 0.42 91 9
07S
-0.77 Page 50 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B M Row
- -Tube, Volts uDbereo Support TSP Location-72 67 0.51 76 11 03S
-0.75 72 107 0.21 98 3
04S
+0.71 72 129 0.58 84 9
los
-0.52 73 44 0.18 58 27 LTS
+24.16 0.46 0
10 09S
+0.63 0.42 61 9
09S
+0.62 73 46 0.26 137 6
09S
+0.69 73 48 0.4 43 8
09S
+0.64 73 51 0.48 107 11 03S
-0.79 73 53 0.3 51 7
09S
-0.72 0.42 56 10 09S
+0.73 73 56 0.35 0
7 09S
-0.60 0.55 66 11 07S
-0.77 0.55 146 11 09S
-0.68 73 57 0.24 111 4
09S
+0.72 73 58 0.15 96 2
09S
+0.70 0.22 96 3
09S
-0.65 0.41 80 6
07S
-0.74 73 65 0.29 76 7
04S
+0.71 73 67 0.25 102 6
07S
-0.80 73 70 0.25 71 6
09S
-0.80 0.14 0
4 09S
-0.75 73 82 0.42 48 9
07S
+0.68 73 108 0.29 0
6 05S
+0.74 0.34 86 6
05S
+0.72 73 128 0.46 60 8
loS
-0.75 0.33 116 6
09S
+0.77 74 53 0.63 22 13 03S
+0.72 74 64 0.26 60 6
05S
+0.71 74 70 0.2 93 5
07S
-0.77 75 21 0.26 71 07S
-0.83 0.1 0
4 07S
-0.75 75 24 0.34 70 8
04S
+0.68 75 26 0.48 57 11 07S
-0.83 75 51 0.34 103 8
03S
-0.81 75 66 0.3 77 7
loS
-0.78 75 105 0.15 83 2
02S
+0.87 75 123 0.3 0
7 15S
+0.64 0.45 92 7
04S
+0.75 0.25 118 4
15S
+0.65 75 124 0.31 0
7 09S
-0.61 0.33 98 6
09S
-0.70 76 64 0.37 85 8
14S
-0.78 1.13 90 22 07S
-0.80 Page 51 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSGB Row Tube.
SVolts
-Degree
- %W
.'-Tube Support:: :TSP Location 76 65 0.3 85 7
12S
+0.53 76 68 0.45 78 10 07S
-0.75 76 100 0.31 100 7
02S
-0.77 76 119 0.38 107 6
07S
-0.70 0.28 91 4
08S
+0.65 76 120 0.67 74 12 09S
-0.63 0.59 89 11 07S
-0.70 76 121 0.17 0
4 07S
-0.81 0.39 71 6
07S
-0.61 76 123 0.47 137 9
11S
-0.46 77 75 0.36 86 10 08S
-0.79 0.41 0
10 08S
-0.65 77 86 0.15 146 25 LTS
+7.89 77 102 0.54 106 14 15S
-0.72 77 119 0.35 83 9
07S
-0.74 0.47 0
13 07S
-0.74 77 125 0.31 80 8
05S
-0.63 0.71 84 16 11S
-0.74 0.17 83 4
10S
+0.18 0.28 0
8 05S
-0.63 78 8
0.45 82 10 13S
-0.84 78 41 0.18 102 29 LTS
+27.00 78 45 0.25 95 34 LTS
+25.65 78 52 0.23 43 6
03S
-0.79 78 54 0.31 134 7
09S
-0.79 78 71 0.21 100 5
06S
-0.78 78 93 0.43 148 36 LTS
+11.52 78 109 0.38 112 10 07S
-0.78 0.43 0
12 07S
-0.78 78 113 0.24 123 8
058
-0.75 78 123
.1.53 96 30 09S
+0.64 79 10 0.33 28 8
12S
+0.52 79 21 0.8 141 13 07S
-0.77 79 26 0.41 0
13 11S
-0.74 0.57 155 10 11S
-0.84 79 34 0.31 75 7
09S
+0.66 0.26 0
8 09S
+0.71 79 39 0.66 106 14 12S
-0.84 79 40 0.37 104 10 118
-0.75 0.38 88 10 13S
-0.75 0.41 0
12 118
-0.79 79 43 0.2 133 33 LTS
+25.91 79 54 0.23 118 06 los 0.78 0.27 154 7
09S
-0.84 Page 52 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
- Row
.Tube Volts Degree -
T Tube Support.
TSP Loation.
79 55 0.42 143 10 06S
-0.77 79 56 0.49 71 11 09S
-0.77 79 57 0.94 90 20 07S
-0.78 79 61 0.32 60 8
12S
-0.78 0.34 67 8
07S
-0.78 0.26 0
8 12S
-0.74 79 62 0.18 88 5
12S
-0.87 0.14 90 4
09S
+0.60 0.45 82 11 09S
-0.80 79 66 0.38 87 9
07S
.0.82 79 75 0.24 95 6
07S
-0.73 79 92 0.21 138 33 LTS
+14.69 0.2 128 30 LTS
+12.71 79 97 0.34 162 32 LTS
+16.44 0.43 135 36 LTS
+9.46 79 114 0.32 137 9
07S
+0.47 79 123 0.3 120 8
06S
-0.80 79 126 0.54 100 15 07S
-0.72 80 9
0.52 112 9
11S
-0.79 80 35 0.34 74 8
12S
-0.73 80 48 0.19 147 32 LTS
+5.04 80 49 0.29 105 8
09S
+0.65 0.19 0
6 09S
+0.82 80 52 0.23 118 6
09S
+0.69 80 58 0.52 100 12 09S
-0.78 0.8 97 17 07S
-0.73 80 60 0.33 83 8
07S
-0.80 0.27 0
8 07S
-0.64 80 61 0.24 82 6
09S
+0.74 80 62 0.2 97 5
12S
-0.30 0.35 47 9
09S
+0.69 80 65 0.24 79 6
13S
-0.87 0.28 85 7
10S
-0.80 80 70 0.31 78 8
07S
-0.77 80 76 0.34 94 8
07S
-0.71 80 80 0.34 49 8
07S
-0.74 80 99 0.26 131 32 LTS
+14.64 0.17 101 31 LTS
+11.35 0.42 165 31 LTS
+10.24 0.41 160 37 LTS
+7.84 0.17 83 32 LTS
+6.98 80 126 0.44 118 11 07S
-0.71 80 127 0.9 102 22 07S
-0.72 0.35 127 10 07S
+0.72 Page 53 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Row-Tube-
' Volts Degre TW Tube Support TSP Location.
127 8
~~~~Plate 0.26 127 08S
+0.70 80 129 0.29 107 9
05S
-0.56 0.28 0
8 05S
-0.58 81 16 0.47 129 11 09S
-0.76 81 35 0.34 151 8
05S
-0.79 81 41 0.5 137 11 09S
-0.79 81 49 0.34 122 8
09S
+0.75 81 62 0.42 62 10 09S
+0.69 81 64 0.85 93 17 10S
-0.78 81 65 0.72 93 16 los
-0.80 81 75 0.17 109 4
07S
-0.75 81 78 0.23 89 6
09S
-0.79 81 104 0.15 124 32 LTS
+8.48 81 121 0.39 100 11 07S
-0.70 81 122 0.75 109 15 07S
-0.69 81 125 0.62 89 15 03S
-0.50 0.56 105 14 07S
-0.63 81 126 0.29 118 7
04S
-0.68 0.5 125 12 07S
-0.60 0.52 106 13 08S
+0.69 82 6
0.39 119 10 09S
-0.80 82 38 0.39 86 9
09S
-0.75 82 41 0.27 141 7
07S
-0.82 82 49 0.28 106 8
07S
-0.80 82 50 0.54 126 12 07S
-0.70 0.31 69 8
09S
+0.73 82 52 0.48 56 11 06S
-0.79 82 57 0.19 78 5
09s
+0.71 0.28 0
8 09S
+0.82 82 61 0.43 76 10 09S
+0.64 82 64 0.21 79 5
12S
+0.59 82 100 0.27 114 8
06S
-0.81 0.31 0
7 06S
-0.77 82 117 0.31 124 9
07S
-0.75 0.49 0
14 07S
-0.75 82 125 0.45 89 11 08S
+0.63 0.31 48 8
09S
+0.16 83 8
0.26 130 7
09S
-0.74 83 9
0.47 130 8
09S
-0.77 83 11 0.46 36 8
09S
-0.70 83 35 0.66 46 14 03S
-0.79 83 45 0.46 104 11 07S
-0.79 83 49 0.32 85 8
07S
+0.00 0.25 0
8 07S
+0.77 Page 54 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Row Tube Volts Degree W
Tube Support TSP Locatlonw
--Plate -
0.2 0
6 07S
-0.85 83 57 0.35 90 6
07S
-0.70 0.27 79 4
09S
-0.66 83 61 0.24 81 5
07S
-0.67 0.31 81 6
09S
+0.77 83 99 0.36 52 8
06S
-0.78 83 100 0.22 150 28 LTS
+10.95 0.29 144 33 LTS
+7.94 0.1 51 20 LTS
+5.98 83 122 0.32 103 9
07S
-0.75 0.35 0
10 07S
-0.75 83 123 0.4 146 8
07S
-0.71 0.27 0
8 07S
-0.71 83 125 0.37 111 8
07S
-0.59 0.36 0
10 07S
-0.59 83 126 0.39 120 10 07S
-0.63 0.39 0
12 07S
-0.71 83 127 0.41 111 10 07S
-0.71 0.34 120 9
07S
+0.58 83 128 0.27 78 7
04S
-0.69 0.33 101 8
04S
+0.56 83 130 0.58 125 14 09S
-0.74 83 131 0.46 126 11 09S
-0.67 84 27 0.3 47 7
03S
-0.76 84 31 0.26 128 34 LTS
+12.57 84 38 0.28 95 8
09S
-0.73 84 39 0.74 114 16 07S
-0.79 84 47 0.44 50 10 09S
-0.73 0.18 0
6 09S
+0.71 0.14 0
6 09S
+0.75 0.16 0
6 09S
-0.70 84 61 0.36 71 6
09S
+0.78 84 72 0.28 80 6
07S
-0.78 84 75 0.5 83 10 07S
-0.78 84 80 0.35 93 8
05S
-0.60 84 85 0.59 88 15 07S
-0.89 84 93 0.11 129 26 LTS
+14.38 84 98 0.1 140 30 LTS
+16.89 0.12 138 30 LTS
+13.80 0.37 155 32 LTS
+12.23 0.51 169 33 LTS
+11.17 0.27 183 23 LTS
+10.06 0.13 83 26 LTS
+9.19 84 100 0.26 176 37 LTS
+11.25 Page 55 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Row.
l,Tube.
Volts Degree
-%TW
.Tube Support -.
TSP Location r,_______
't 12~.
<-Plate 0.33 149 36 LTS
+8.34 0.37 166 30 LTS
+6.94 84 123 0.65 109 13 08S
+0.67 84 125 0.31 117 6
03S
+0.54 0.57 109 12 08S
+0.78 84 126 0.4 98 11 09S
+0.02 84 128 0.49 98 14 07S
-0.85 85 37 0.41 54 11 07S
-0.75 85 38 0.39 95 9
03S
-0.80 85 43 0.36 72 10 09S
-0.75 0.3 99 8
los
-0.78 0.33 0
10 10S
-0.78 0.28 141 37 LTS
+10.38 85 72 0.39 79 8
06S
-0.73 85 76 0.26 47 5
04S
-0.80 85 90 0.36 76 11 07S
-0.79 85 92 0.13 135 25 LTS
+8.28 85 96 0.28 91 38 LTS
+9.74 85 98 0.24 140 33 LTS
+9.74 85 123 0.33 117 9
08S
+0.70 85 126 0.73 111 17 07S
-0.80 85 127 0.35 103 9
07S
-0.83 0.39 53 10 09S
-0.85 86 6
0.52 0
16 09S
+0.66 0.37 0
12 09S
-0.72 0.56 94 10 09S
+0.62 86 7
0.72 0
21 09S
+0.59 0.4 72 10 09S
+0.63 86 24 0.27 122 37 LTS
+13.00 0.36 156 33 LTS
+9.23 86 25 0.23 91 6
07S
-0.74 86 38 0.56 32 12 09S
-0.71 86 53 0.65 95 14 07S
-0.77 86 76 0.25 70 5
07S
-0.78 0.12 0
4 07S
-0.68 86 85 0.27 99 8
06S
-0.79 0.17 0
4 06S
-0.77 86 104 0.18 93 3
07S
-0.78 86 112 0.36 139 10 02S
-0.81 86 116 0.21 97 6
05S
-0.73 86 124 0.54 104 14 08S
+0.63 0.2 102 6
03S
+0.27 0.4 0
11 03S
+0.27 86 125 0.34 113 7
07S
-0.02 Page 56 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSGB Row
'Tube
.,,,Volts
,Degree
%TW
,Tube Support
!,TSPLocationq
'Plate
- 7j, 86 126 0.51 118 13 07S
-0.11 0.42 107 11 07S
+0.59 0.4 105 11 03S
+0.38 0.28 0
8 03S
+0.38 87 8
0.34 143 09S
-0.75 87 22 0.55 100 10 07S
-0.75 87 39 0.16 109 29 LTS
+12.69 87 40 0.72 91 15 09S
-0.73 87 49 0.73 85 16 06S
-0.77 87 50 0.37 51 10 06S
-0.78 87 53 0.57 88 13 06S
-0.79 87 56 0.18 70 3
07S
-0.69 87 57 0.16 96 2
09S
+0.82 87 67 0.3 92 6
07S
-0.74 87 112 0.36 109 7
07S
+0.50 87 123 0.29 92 8
08S
-0.11 87 125 0.28 125 8
08S
-0.18 88 8
0.46 109 11 07S
-0.82 88 12 0.78 102 17 07S
-0.77 88 19 0.23 100 6
03S
-0.78 88 29 0.62 88 15 07S
-0.81 88 31 0.42 69 10 09S
-0.77 88 34 0.15 130 29 LTS
+15.45 0.22 62 34 LTS
+12.75 88 45 0.22 132 34 LTS
+13.96 88 47 0.47 116 11 09S
-0.75 88 49 0.19 76 5
06S
-0.82 0.18 0
6 06S
-0.89 88 50 0.31 135 9
06S
-0.82 0.22 0
7 06S
-0.85 88 51 0.44 48 10 03S
-0.77 88 53 0.67 62 14 07S
-0.75 88 70 0.46 72 9
06S
-0.80 88 113 0.38 123 8
07S
+0.61 88 123 0.35 132 7
03S
-0.07 0.24 124 5
08S
-0.20 0.29 89 6
08S
+0.25 0.25 144 6
07S
-0.02 0.46 0
14 08S
+0.26 0.36 0
11 07S
+0.12 88 125 0.33 127 07S
-0.76 88 127 0.34 135 09S
-0.76 0.26 0
8 09S
-0.76 88 128 0.52 120 15 07S
-0.78 Page 57 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
-Row
- Tube:
Vots Degree
%TW TubeSupport TSP Location.
,s__
Pla te.
88 129 0.35 122 10 11S
-0.79 89 4
0.34 63 8
10S
+0.49 89 5
0.45 61 11 01S
-0.77 89 33 0.29 141 32 LTS
+9.68 89 39 0.28 139 33 LTS
+14.25 89 49 0.26 106 6
07S
-0.77 89 50 0.41 35 11 09S
-0.73 0.23 0
7 09S
-0.66 89 53 0.36 56 8
07S
-0.77 89 84 0.45 82 13 07S
-0.79 89 89 0.22 168 15 LTS
+11.34 0.12 131 28 LTS
+8.39 0.16 132 28 LTS
+5.83 89 122 0.34 139 7
07S
+0.00 0.32 0
9 07S
+0.00 89 123 0.46 128 12 07S
-0.07 89 126 0.31 126 8
07S
-0.78 0.3 0
9 07S
-0.78 90 5
0.62 45 14 07S
-0.77 90 35 0.29 154 9
07S
-0.78 90 40 0.07 115 16 LTS
+17.73 0.15 127 33 LTS
+15.46 0.19 82 30 LTS
+14.44 0.11 124 27 LTS
+12.22 0.12 78 29 LTS
+11.93 0.28 143 36 LTS
+11.70 0.09 141 18 LTS
+9.86 0.4 149 33 LTS
+8.28 90 41 0.85 79 20 07S
-0.80 90 48 0.36 110 8
07S
-0.77 90 50 0.51 44 11 06S
+0.61 0.53 0
16 06S
+0.77 90 60 0.82 81 14 07S
-0.72 90 65 0.42 83 9
07S
-0.72 90 88 0.23 140 27 LTS
+5.47 90 126 0.27 125 8
07S
-0.79 90 128 0.41 134 10 09S
-0.78 91 6
0.52 75 12 09S
+0.63 91 7
0.53 43 13 09S
+0.64 91 12 0.29 148 7
07S
-0.78 91 41 0.21 78 5
06S
+0.68 91 42 0.3 82 7
lOS
-0.78 91 53 0.28 78 5
13S
+0.89 91 87 0.33 80 10 03S
-0.77 Page 58 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSGB
-Row>
s.Tube
--..Volts: ; ;
-Degree n
%TW-Tube Support
. TSP.Locatlon
- i.,
,t,,.,9,..
P late-'.'n
-i 91 93 0.13 108 32 LTS
+9.44 91 94 0.19 143 33 LTS
+10.92 0.2 134 33 LTS
+8.15 91 96 0.41 31 8
03S
-0.78 91 98 0.24 124 32 LTS
+11.33 0.22 116 33 LTS
+9.12 91 119 0.33 96 8
07S
-0.72 92 17 0.93 105 20 09S
-0.79 92 26 0.28 94 37 LTS
+12.80 0.32 169 34 LTS
+10.78 0.29 153 29 LTS
+7.90 0.07 114 22 LTS
+5.67 92 36 0.73 79 18 07S
-0.75 92 38 0.14 89 4
09S
-0.71 92 39 0.21 132 33 LTS
+10.89 92 40 0.21 52 29 LTS
+14.29 92 43 0.5 150 37 LTS
+5.68 92 60 0.7 90 11 07S
-0.71 92 114 0.4 110 8
07S
-0.76 92 116 0.24 50 5
07S
-0.63 92 120 0.31 136 7
05S
-0.85 0.1 145 2
07S
-0.81 92 124 0.53 42 14 07S
-0.74 92 126 0.52 42 11 09S
-0.79 0.52 100 11 07S
-0.82 93 4
0.71 0
21 09S
+0.66 0.34 132 8
09S
+0.63 93 6
0.47 120 11 09S
+0.56 93 17 0.86 90 19 09S
-0.77 93 31 0.25 77 36 LTS
+12.69 0.19 68 26 LTS
+11.14 93 34 0.29 57 7
07S
-0.79 93 36 0.86 106 17 09S
-0.77 93 40 0.48 68 10 09S
-0.72 93 46 0.21 167 27 LTS
+15.70 0.13 146 26 LTS
+12.05 0.35 160 30 LTS
+10.98 0.19 163 22 LTS
+6.93 93 55 0.35 31 7
07S
-0.74 93 79 0.21 132 35 LTS
+10.65 93 87 0.17 162 20 LTS
+7.55 93 94 0.35 148 37 LTS
+12.63 0.65 170 31 LTS
+7.02 93 116 0.15 131 5
07S
-0.68 Page 59 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
.Row, Tube Volts.
)
"-Degree.
TW '
Tube Support
'TSp Locatn
~
~
~
t Plate 94 7
0.51 52 12 09S
+0.54 94 17 0.4 130 10 15S
+0.80 94 51 0.39 93 11 14S
-0.89 94 56 0.17 83 3
07S
-0.73 94 66 0.34 87 8
07S
-0.70 94 127 0.36 43 9
09S
+0.63 95 1
0.38 93 10 07S
-0.72 95 3
0.41 0
13 09S
+0.65 0.37 79 9
09S
+0.59 95 5
0.55 98 13 07S
-0.77 95 6
0.39 61 9
09S
+0.50 95 20 0.42 0
13 07S
-0.75 0.34 123 8
07S
-0.78 95 21 0.26 88 7
06S
+0.77 95 23 0.49 107 12 07S
-0.81 95 36 0.35 170 27 LTS
+17.94 0.18 135 29 LTS
+14.96 0.19 74 31 LTS
+9.87 95 47 0.11 105 29 LTS
+10.79 95 53 0.41 53 6
12S
-0.87 95 85 0.75 90 19 07S
+0.68 95 90 0.31 107 7
07S
-0.83 0.37 0
9 07S
-0.80 96 4
0.57 86 13 09S
+0.65 96 25 0.26 73 7
15S
+0.88 96 35 0.39 51 11 06S
+0.66 0.38 0
11 06S
+0.69 96 40 0.26 153 34 LTS
+10.21 96 41 0.19 153 25 LTS
+13.21 0.37 145 37 LTS
+11.82 96 44 0.17 54 26 LTS
+9.03 0.13 92 28 LTS
+6.64 96 45 0.17 112 33 LTS
+12.10 96 51 0.63 43 14 06S
+0.61 96 66 0.66 100 14 07S
-0.74
.96 70 0.47 103 11 07S
-0.72 96 91 0.11 142 23 LTS
+11.99 97 3
0.3 55 8
09S
+0.68 0.34 0
11 09S
+0.67 97 5
0.21 85 5
13S
-0.79 0.32 105 8
07S
+0.63 0.2 0
6 13S
-0.77 97 41 0.37 57 9
09S
-0.73 0.27 63 31 LTS
+13.78 Page 60 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Row Tube*
Volts,-;.,
Degree ;
%TW -
Tube Support TSP, Locatlon
- ^,;
V
'.; PIate 0.24 168 30 LTS
+11.66 97 71 0.22 129 6
07S
-0.79 0.11 0
4 07S
-0.86 97 121 0.35 95 10 07S
-0.73 97 123 0.54 35 14 09S
+0.57 98 35 0.17 107 4
07S
-0.82 98 39 0.17 120 26 LTS
+18.12 0.19 132 33 LTS
+15.75 0.2 116 32 LTS
+14.84 0.21 118 37 LTS
+12.27 0.15 71 26 LTS
+6.83 98 42 0.11 59 27 LTS
+14.93 0.24 148 30 LTS
+12.00 98 45 0.12 59 27 LTS
+12.30 98 47 0.09 87 27 LTS
+6.88 0.15 53 24 LTS
+17.12 98 124 0.36 88 8
09S
+0.65 99 1
0.27 78 7
11S
+0.77 99 4
0.51 97 12 09S
+0.63 99 6
0.23 0
7 06S
-0.07 0.2 85 5
06S
-0.13 99 7
0.33 58 8
09S
+0.66 0.37 0
12 09S
+0.70 99 9
0.24 79 6
07S
+0.75 99 41 0.58 83 13 03S
-0.77 0.22 89 32 LTS
+10.45 99 46 0.25 120 7
07S
-0.73 99 106 0.15 100 3
06S
-0.78 99 114 0.15 123 3
07S
-0.79 99 122 0.35 148 8
09S
-0.90 99 123 0.22 20 6
09S
-0.80 99 126 0.59 114 16 07S
+0.27 100 3
0.35 64 9
09S
-0.77 0.37 0
12 09S
-0.75 100 5
0.66 87 15 09S
+0.64 1.07 164 22 07S
-0.79 0.43 0
13 07S
-0.75 100 21 0.43 108 11 07S
-0.79 100 33 0.2 74 30 LTS
+11.07 0.21 86 32 LTS
+10.23 100 36 0.34 150 34 LTS
+7.99 0.31 59 36 LTS
+13.52 100 38 0.19 125 35 LTS
+17.09 0.38 173 34 LTS
+15.17 Page 61 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
,'Row;-
Tube Volts Degree
%TW
.:Tube Support -
- TSP Locationr
'~~~~~
~
~~~~~~Plate 0.11 94 31 LTS
+14.95 100 41 0.43 155 30 LTS
+17.34 0.49 165 36 LTS
+7.99 100 45 0.16 121 32 LTS
+14.79 100 66 0.11 129 29 LTS
+9.91 100 84 0.4 93 11 03S
-0.79 100 92 0.24 159 27 LTS
+9.11 0.18 129 34 LTS
+7.23 100 122 0.28 33 8
07S
-0.61 101 10 0.41 102 10 07S
-0.81 101 24 0.74 76 17 09S
-0.79 101 35 0.43 47 12 07S
-0.82 101 43 0.18 66 29 LTS
+9.19 101 47 0.13 56 25 LTS
+15.17 0.16 167 17 LTS
+11.10 0.17 135 30 LTS
+8.99 101 81 0.19 87 6
07S
-0.82 101 98 0.11 88 21 LTS
+17.47 0.16 143 32 LTS
+13.29 102 41 0.28 149 34 LTS
+16.16 102 43 0.16 130 27 LTS
+13.33 0.24 92 32 LTS
+12.42 0.41 169 31 LTS
+7.83 102 44 0.16 63 27 LTS
+9.59 102 95 0.97 100 22 07S
-0.82 102 111 0.39 114 9
07S
+0.58 102 112 0.3 122 8
07S
-0.66 102 113 0.6 103 13 07S
+0.61 102 115 0.57 118 12 07S
+0.56 102 116 0.34 105 10 07S
-0.65 0.24 84 7
07S
+0.52 0.3 0
9 07S
-0.60 102 119 0.39 119 9
07S
-0.65 103 5
0.48 103 11 09S
+0.61 103 27 0.25 34 6
07S
-0.74 103 36 0.25 143 37 LTS
+10.97 103 37 0.11 119 26 LTS
+23.97 0.29 134 33 LTS
+15.40 0.29 128 37 LTS
+10.14 103 41 0.13 92 25 LTS
+15.78 103 55 0.23 95 5
07S
-0.81 103 94 0.17 108 34 LTS
+5.31 103 97 0.23 88 7
04S
-0.75 103 123 0.28 53 6
07S
-0.76 Page 62 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
,Row
'Tube
,. Volts Degree:
%TW ;
Tube Support
.TSP Location t {b.
+:
P late 104 40 0.09 90 24 LTS
+15.27 0.08 104 25 LTS
+13.19 104 44 0.14 160 26 LTS
+12.41 0.13 53 25 LTS
+11.75 0.13 49 20 LTS
+17.88 104 46 0.47 90 13 07S
-0.79 104 90 0.07 135 27 LTS
+14.24 0.15 106 28 LTS
+12.16 0.2 162 34 LTS
+8.95 104 119 0.27 121 8
08S
+0.59 0.49 0
14 08S
+0.59 104 122 0.82 48 17 10S
+0.59 105 42 0.9 99 18 07S
-0.73 105 44 0.49 87 11 10S
-0.39 105 87 0.31 118 7
07S
-0.81 105 113 0.69 97 17 07S
-0.81 105 120 0.29 104 07S
-0.83 105 122 0.46 122 12 07S
-0.86 106 38 0.63 102 13 07S
-0.79 106 42 0.31 126 37 LTS
+16.36 0.14 68 27 LTS
+14.76 0.24 146 31 LTS
+12.49 0.13 120 28 LTS
+11.46 106 43 0.1 126 26 LTS
+7.01 106 48 0.32 144 34 LTS
+8.90 106 50 0.2 69 32 LTS
+13.63 0.15 53 26 LTS
+10.62 106 61 1.24 96 24 07S
-0.79 106 71 0.32 107 9
07S
-0.84 106 74 0.03 120 23 LTS
+14.55 0.16 127 25 LTS
+9.33 106 92 0.19 96 6
03S
-0.80 106 97 0.37 82 8
02S
-0.84 106 117 0.32 133 9
09S
-0.84 107 23 0.22 121 7
07S
-0.77 107 47 0.18 70 30 LTS
+16.05 0.13 117 31 LTS
+14.13 0.16 117 38 LTS
+11.81 0.28 148 37 LTS
+7.32 107 66 0.1 130 29 LTS
+14.77 0.08 125 21 LTS
+12.20 0.15 142 30 LTS
+7.44 0.09 135 24 LTS
+6.58 107 67 0.39 116 10 07S
-0.77 Page 63 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Row -- l Tube Volts
'Degree
%TW, -
.TubeSupport TSP Location
.2 ~~
A
- ..~~~~Plate.~;
107 116 0.37 107 1 0 07S
-0.86 108 34 0.2 66 32 LTS
+15.09 108 55 0.27 91 7
07S
-0.83 108 74 0.19 148 33 LTS
+13.29 109 46 0.14 144 29 LTS
+12.33 0.18 141 28 LTS
+10.80 0.26 155 28 LTS
+8.43 109 52 0.62 111 14 07S
-0.84 109 84 0.28 102 6
03S
-0.78 0.58 110 12 07S
-0.76 109 100 0.33 104 7
07S
-0.78 0.34 0
8 07S
-0.78 109 117 0.31 128 9
09S
-0.74 0.18 0
6 09S
-0.57 110 24 0.58 101 13 09S
-0.75 110 40 0.29 164 28 LTS
+12.77 110 43 0.17 126 35 LTS
+23.54 110 46 0.2 52 30 LTS
+12.26 110 50 0.19 121 5
07S
-0.81 0.25 0
8 07S
-0.73 110 52 0.17 112 33 LTS
+14.02 0.07 128 23 LTS
+11.39 0.23 134 28 LTS
+10.30 0.19 125 30 LTS
+9.57 110 57 0.31 120 8
07S
-0.79 110 81 0.24 110 5
03S
-0.81 110 85 0.44 69 9
06S
+0.12 111 27 0.3 78 7
07S
-0.82 111 39' 0.12 128 23 LTS
+9.93 111 42 0.25 174 32 LTS
+14.49 0.42 162 34 LTS
+11.58 111 51 0.2 137 34 LTS
+11.30 111 66 0.42 79 10 07S
-0.70 111 71 0.37 105 11 03S
-0.75 0.41 88 12 07S
-0.82 112 26 0.43 98 10 09S
-0.78 112 82 0.41 128 10 07S
-0.78 113 23 0.51 160 12 09S
-0.79 113 44 0.3 171 29 LTS
+12.30 0.28 148 34 LTS
+10.14 0.06 90 18 LTS
+7.80 113 45 0.18 54 31 LTS
+16.87 113 71 0.2 122 6
07S
-0.79 0.22 0
5 07S
-0.78 Page 64 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSGB Row.'
-.Tube,.
Volt8
- Degree,
- %TW
,,,,Tube Support TSP Location
- s
<5 q
x.;.;.;: zPlate 113 94 0.37 132 9
07S
-0.76 113 108 0.31 139 9
07S
-0.77 114 39 0.44 65 10 09S
-0.73 114 41 0.17 144 29 LTS
+9.14 0.18 122 35 LTS
+8.21 114 42 0.09 115 24 LTS
+26.42 0.41 153 34 LTS
+11.65 0.23 172 26 LTS
+8.54 0.23 173 31 LTS
+8.25 0.14 172 24 LTS
+6.93 114 43 0.12 82 24 LTS
+23.58 0.26 168 31 LTS
+11.98 0.34 168 32 LTS
+10.28 0.17 176 28 LTS
+7.23 0.14 147 30 LTS
+6.78 0.04 85 9
LTS
+25.76 114 46 0.14 123 21 LTS
+6.69 114 70 0.44 116 11 07S
-0.76 114 93 0.44 72 12 02S
-0.83 114 109 0.27 70 8
1S
+0.74 114 111 0.34 110 10 09S
+0.48 0.28 0
8 09S
+0.69 115 40 0.52 82 11 07S
-0.86 115 43 0.43 88 12 07S
-0.84 115 57 0.86 99 19 07S
-0.73 115 61 0.57 81 14 03S
-0.81 115 63 0.25 114 6
07S
-0.80 0.19 0
7 07S
-0.73 115 80 0.44 104 12 07S
-0.75 115 87 0.49 95 12 07S
-0.71 115 99 0.31 110 7
07S
-0.76 115 100 0.34 117 8
07S
-0.79 115 109 0.26 103 7
09S
+0.55 0.16 146 5
09S
-0.72 116 25 0.35 24 10 07S
-0.79 116 35 0.52 81 14 07S
-0.75 116 39 0.3 116 9
03S
-0.82 116 43 0.13 134 28 LTS
+7.75 0.08 125 21 LTS
+7.05 0.23 137 35 LTS
+6.69 0.11 137 26 LTS
+6.28 116 49 1.02 93 22 07S
-0.78 116 50 0.27 101 7
07S
-0.83 116 61 0.36 107 10 07S
-0.76 Page 65 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Row Tube Volts ;-:;.'
-Degree
.. _TW.
Tube Support TSP Location" 0,,,
,A,,
'Plate' 116 62 0.23 0
9 07S
-0.75 0.22 116 5
07S
-0.85 116 80 0.37 94 11 07S
-0.77 116 81 0.36 131 9
07S
-0.81 116 92 0.2 66 6
07S
-0.73 0.2 0
5 07S
-0.74 116 100 0.36 135 8
13S
-0.81 116 111 0.29 129 8
los
-0.74 117 40 0.41 105 11 07S
-0.79 117 71 0.4 131 10 07S
-0.79 117 73 0.57 103 15 07S
-0.80 117 82 0.85 110 18 07S
-0.81 118 19 0.54 155 13 07S
-0.76 118 30 0.49 39 13 07S
-0.84 118 41 0.15 110 29 LTS
+9.44 0.24 60 30 LTS
+8.75 0.2 142 30 LTS
+5.81 118 56 0.23 109 6
07S
-0.78 0.24 0
8 07S
-0.75 118 64 0.28 118 7
03S
-0.75 118 66 0.43 90 12 03S
-0.79 0.63 99 16 07S
-0.79 118 76 0.17 115 5
07S
-0.77 0.19 0
07S
-0.81 118 89 0.35 147 9
07S
-0.81 0.37 0
9 07S
-0.87 118 99 0.33 98 9
07S
-0.80 119 12 0.47 140 11 07S
-0.79 119 20 0.35 115 10 09S
-0.81 119 40 0.41 61 11 07S
-0.82 119 48 0.82 100 19 07S
-0.80 119 66 0.4 129 10 07S
-0.76 119 75 0.36 86 10 07S
-0.77 119 79 0.19 110 6
07S
-0.82 0.41 0
10 07S
-0.77 119 80 0.3 127 7
07S
-0.76 120 50 0.23 119 6
07S
-0.83 120 56 0.26 135 7
03S
-0.79 120 63 0.61 92 14 07S
-0.70 120 97 0.32 111 10 07S
-0.86 120 102 0.4 121 10 07S
-0.76 0.23 66 6
09S
+0.58 120 103 0.25 82 8
09S
-0.79 120 105 0.26 99 8
09S
+0.63 Page 66 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
-Row Tube
- Volts, Degree
. %TW
.: Tube Support. :; TSP Location,
~~~~-
p late 121 38 0.36 102 8
07S
-0.76 121 45 0.36 96 9
07S
-0.82 121 48 0.3 108 8
07S
-0.83 121 49 0.22 91 6
07S
-0.83 121 63 0.3 95 8
07S
-0.68 121 64 0.32 152 8
07S
-0.81 121 68 0.46 93 13 07S
-0.77 121 78 0.41 78 12 03S
-0.77 121 91 0.27 125 6
07S
-0.78 121 95 0.24 108 7
08S
+0.61 0.36 0
9 08S
+0.61 122 38 0.61 84 16 07S
-0.77 122 55 0.37 105 10 07S
-0.76 122 56 0.29 120 7
07S
-0.77 122 57 0.25 97 7
07S
-0.76 122 72 0.29 95 8
07S
-0.79 122 102 0.27 124 8
07S
-0.82 123 30 0.45 88 12 07S
-0.82 123 65 0.25 99 5
07S
-0.72 123 70 0.29 117 7
07S
-0.78 0.29 0
7 07S
-0.77 123 74 0.48 99 11 07S
-0.76 123 76 0.39 123 9
07S
-0.78 123 77 0.1 112 26 LTS
+4.44 123 93 0.35 111 7
07S
-0.79 123 102 0.41 113 12 los
-0.84 123 103 0.54 137 13 10S
-0.65 124 17 0.44 90 12 07S
-0.80 124 29 0.24 79 7
06S
-0.82 0.34 100 10 07S
-0.81 0.29 0
9 07S
-0.85 0.28 0
9 06S
-0.85 124 43 0.25 62 7
10S
+0.72 124 45 0.29 125 8
07S
-0.83 124 48 0.39 111 10 07S
-0.79 124 66 0.23 56 5
03S
-0.72 124 70 0.3 123 7
07S
-0.77 0.35 0
8 07S
-0.81 124 71 1.1 89 21 07S
-0.76 124 73 0.37 129 8
07S
-0.78 124 99 0.17 127 6
10S
-0.75 125 34 0.33 128 9
07S
-0.84 125 82 0.33 36 8
07S
-0.85 0.28 0
7 07S
-0.77 Page 67 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Row ;
Jub.
Volts Degree.
.%TW T ube Support.
TSP Location 125 86 0.29 11I 7
07S
-0.81 125 89 0.67 113 14 07S
-0.77 125 92 0.24 106 6
07S
-0.81 0.3 0
7 07S
-0.70 125 98 0.32 101 10 los
-0.82 125 100 0.37 80 11 10S
-0.79 126 2
0.4 44 8
los
-0.60 0.39 77 7
loS
+0.73 0.27 0
9 10S
-0.72 0.31 0
10 los
+0.67 126 13 0.35 62 7
07S
-0.71 126 26 0.4 49 10 15S
-0.77 126 43 0.23 70 6
07S
-0.74 126 53 0.43 119 11 07S
-0.79 126 75 0.28 105 6
07S
-0.77 0.35 0
8 07S
-0.81 126 98 0.38 122 10 lOS
-0.69 0.4 0
12 loS
-0.70 127 3
0.48 82 9
10S
+0.74 0.59 30 11 10S
-0.62 127 31 0.33 72 10 07S
-0.78 127 58 0.62 112 14 07S
-0.79 127 95 0.48 92 14 loS
-0.79 127 96 0.55 95 13 los
-0.76 128 33 0.45 123 12 09S
-0.73 0.22 39 7
07S
-0.80 128 38 0.45 108 11 09S
.0.82 128 53 0.51 109 12 13S
-0.82 128 66 0.46 105 10 07S
-0.78 128 85 0.31 107 7
07S
-0.75 0.39 0
9 07S
-0.73 128 87 0.33 125 7
13S
-0.77 0.16 0
4 13S
-0.76 128 93 0.29 117 9
lOS
-0.81 128 94 0.4 84 10 10S
-0.65 129 2
0.46 89 9
11S
-0.67 129 34 0.7 88 15 07S
-0.82 129 40 0.2 111 5
07S
-0.77 129 41 0.17 102 30 LTS
+21.41 129 52 0.38 114 9
07S
-0.82 129 53 0.5 120 12 09S
-0.81 0.45 75 11 07S
-0.74 129 69 0.48 116 11 07S
-0.78 129 93 0.25 117 8
lOS
-0.70 Page 68 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSGB
.Row Tube
-,Volts,-
Degree -
%TW Tube Support ;-
TSP Location.;
- ~
PIate~ ':
0.13 57 4
los
+0.34 129 94 0.18 106 6
loS
-0.77 130 14 0.57 108 15 09S
-0.85 0.34 113 10 07S
+0.69 0.24 0
8 07S
+0.79 130 19 0.38 26 9
lOS
-0.88 130 23 0.7 95 15 07S
-0.74 130 33 0.29 70 7
07S
-0.79 130 39 0.32 109 8
03S
-0.77 130 47 0.54 111 13 07S
-0.77 130 65 0.41 102 07S
-0.75 0.34 0
8 07S
-0.78 130 71 0.29 120 7
07S
-0.79 0.22 0
5 07S
-0.79 130 91 0.36 142 9
lOS
-0.76 0.37 0
11 los
-0.76 130 92 0.51 90 14 lOS
-0.72 130 93 0.17 80 6
lOS
-0.81 131 3
0.18 141 24 LTS
+37.24 131 50 0.47 120 11 07S
-0.82 131 67 0.42 122 9
07S
-0.76 131 81 0.39 121 9
13S
-0.74 0.29 0
7 13S
-0.77 131 82 0.32 93 7
07S
-0.81 0.39 0
9 07S
-0.78 132 26 0.24 107 6
07S
-0.79 132 30 0.37 88 9
07S
-0.83 132 36 0.38 122 10 07S
-0.79 132 45 0.49 113 12 07S
-0.84 132 48 0.64 104 15 07S
-0.82 132 58 0.52 109 11 07S
-0.77 132 63 0.67 93 14 07S
-0.76 132 72 0.42 94 9
07S
-0.73 0.35 0
8 07S
-0.85 132 74 0.27 92 5
07S
-0.79 0.28 0
7 07S
-0.75 132 76 0.31 115 6
13S
-0.82 132 80 0.29 95 6
07S
-0.75 0.28 0
07S
-0.76 132 84 0.29 98 9
lOS
-0.72 132 85 0.41 124 12 07S
-0.79 133 35 0.4 99 10 07S
-0.79 133 85 0.29 65 7
lOS
-0.74 0.32 0
8 lOS
-0.63 Page 69 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSGB Row Tube Voltss ii.Degre v!
Tube Support TSP.Location 134 7
0.28 0
16 09S
+0.67 0.46 76 9
09S
+0.67 134 29 0.36 113 9
07S
-0.81 134 38 0.44 109 11 07S
-0.82 134 39 0.32 114 8
07S
-0.76 134 45 0.43 57 11 07S
-0.74 134 63 0.46 111 11 07S
-0.77 134 70 0.26 141 7
07S
-0.82 0.27 0
10 07S
-0.75 134 78 0.44 128 11 07S
-0.84 135 2
0.45 86 8
lS
+0.69 0.4 0
13 loS
+0.65 135 29 0.52 97 12 07S
-0.81 135 41 0.41 127 10 07S
-0.74 135 43 0.43 114 11 07S
-0.74 0.36 118 9
09S
-0.83 135 47 0.38 118 10 07S
-0.77 135 81 0.34 114 9
10S
-0.70 136 1
0.51 91 10 WOS
+0.78 136 3
0.7 94 13 los
+0.66 0.45 147 8
1S
-0.73 136 4
0.21 0
13 10S
+0.75 0.2 0
12 10S
.0.65 0.38 60 7
10S
-0.67 0.29 86 6
loS
+0.71 136 13 0.39 146 9
15S
-0.83 136 15 0.2 92 5
15S
-0.83 136 20 0.38 53 10 13S
-0.89 136 28 0.51 28 14 07S
-0.71 0.44 46 12 01S
-0.48 136 32 0.57 113 13 07S
-0.77 136 45 0.74 106 17 07S
-0.77 136 49 0.4 107 10 07S
-0.74 136 73 0.27 128 7
09S
-0.82 0.24 0
6 09S
-0.75 137 1
0.25 122 5
lOS
-0.64 0.4 73 8
10S
+0.67 0.31 0
10 los
-0.69 0.41 0
13 10S
+0.69 137 2
0.22 0
13 los
+0.73 0.17 0
10 loS
-0.68 0.42 84 8
loS
+0.66 137 3
0.27 0
16 loS
-0.62 0.24 0
14 10S
+0.69 Page 70 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Row
--Tube
_Volts
,Degree
- %TW Tube Support TSP Location.
..i-....;,,-,
-: ;Plate 0.34 95 7
10S
-0.67 0.47 98 9
los
+0.76 137 28 0.2 82 5
07S
-0.79 137 57 0.25 132 6
07S
-0.81 0.26 0
6 07S
-0.77 137 74 0.25 135 6
07S
-0.82 0.26 0
07S
-0.74 137 77 0.32 139 7
07S
-0.81 0.32 0
8 07S
-0.71 138 1
0.42 115 8
10S
-0.74 138 2
0.45 57 9
10S
-0.55 0.78 48 14 11S
-0.69 0.61 113 11 10S
+0.69 138 9
0.34 65 10 09S
+0.60 138 20 0.46 63 11 07S
-0.79 138 28 0.26 114 6
07S
-0.86 138 30 0.61 98 14 07S
-0.79 138 63 0.44 124 10 13S
-0.79 139 3
0.42 99 11 10S
+0.57 0.35 0
11 10S
+0.71 139 7
0.31 54 9
05S
-0.83 139 15 0.28 137 8
07S
-0.74 139 21 0.46 84 13 07S
-0.78 139 24 0.15 117 4
07S
-0.79 139 45 0.84 103 19 07S
-0.79 139 74 1.1 112 22 07S
-0.75 0.25 87 13S
+0.66 0.12 0
5 13S
+0.75 140 3
0.27 89 7
10S
+0.64 0.31 66 9
03S
-0.80 0.23 0
10S
-0.91 0.26 0
8 loS
+0.67 0.32 0
9 loS
+0.66 0.33 0
9 loS
-0.73 140 4
0.23 69 loS
+0.58 0.27 0
8 10S
+0.72 140 14 0.23 51 6
07S
-0.73 140 15 1.31 99 26 07S
-0.78 140 21 0.7 93 16 07S
-0.85 140 32 0.38 105 10 07S
-0.74 140 58 0.45 134 10 13S
-0.83 141 3
0.33 51 7
10S
-0.76 141 4
0.58 48 13 10S
+0.59 141 10 0.26 93 6
07S
-0.74 Page 71 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 1 Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
.- Row,,
,.Tuber.
Volts;
-,Degree,;,%TW
.: -TubeSupport
', -TSPLocation.
_ _ _ _ _ _;_ so it-S u~r--
-;t;s P la te d
141 26 0.2 84 5
07S
-0.79 141 29 0.47 117 11 13S
-0.84 141 39 0.28 118 7
07S
-0.80 141 57 0.41 114 11 07S
-0.79 141 59 0.34 139 9
14S
-0.80 0.25 0
6 14S
-0.76 141 61 0.38 67 10 05S
+0.36 142 3
0.44 48 10 los
+0.00 0.4 0
12 10S
+0.63 0.3 0
9 10S
-0.74 142 11 0.33 75 8
07S
-0.79 142 12 0.39 62 8
07S
-0.74 142 14 0.59 106 14 07S
-0.78 142 15 0.33 130 8
07S
-0.77 142 17 0.39 101 9
07S
-0.76 142 25 0.28 96 7
07S
-0.74 142 34 0.35 50 9
08S
-0.59 142 38 0.32 100 8
07S
-0.82 142 40 0.35 128 9
13S
.0.87 142 55 0.4 133 9
09S
.0.86 0.22 0
5 09S
-0.80 142 57 0.32 108 8
07S
-0.83 0.47 0
11 07S
-0.71 142 65 0.16 100 4
08S
-0.82 143 2
0.19 104 2
10S
-0.76 0.46 0
14 10S
-0.76 143 3
0.56 91 13 10S
-0.72 143 15 0.28 52 7
04S
-0.79 143 26 0.16 132 4
07S
-0.85 143 31 0.29 109 7
07S
-0.65 143 60 0.47 149 11 13S
-0.79 0.23 0
6 13S
-0.68 144 2
0.49 32 11 10S
-0.67 144 3
0.5 31 11 10S
-0.74 0.57 22 13 10S
+0.58 144 4
0.33 48 7
12S
-0.82 144 8
0.25 78 4
07S
-0.76 144 9
0.46 116 11 07S
-0.77 144 12 0.91 89 20 07S
-0.76 144 13 0.45 87 11 07S
-0.75 144 15 0.6 83 13 07S
-0.79 144 16 0.57 99 13 07S
-0.76 144 19 0.3 110 6
07S
-0.78 144 22 0.39 113 10 07S
-0.79 Page 72 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B
- Row jub Volts
- DeWree
- YT Tube Support.,
TSP Location 144 23 0.21 145 5
07S
-0.80 144 31 0.24 109 6
07S
-0.74 144 49 0.59 99 14 07S
-0.77 144 50 0.23 104 6
07S
-0.77 0.33 0
8 07S
-0.74 144 51 0.25 104 7
07S
-0.77 0.24 0
6 07S
-0.77 144 56 0.51 115 12 07S
-0.77 144 57 0.64 114 15 07S
-0.73 0.35 142 9
13S
-0.77 145 2
0.4 67 9
10S
-0.75 145 8
0.48 90 11 07S
-0.77 145 10 0.17 126 4
04S
-0.84 0.23 63 6
07S
-0.74 145 12 0.34 82 7
07S
-0.71 145 13 0.39 77 9
07S
-0.77 145 15 0.24 130 6
07S
-0.74 145 21 0.36 114 9
07S
-0.79 145 22 0.33 135 8
13S
-0.86 145 26 0.21 82 6
07S
-0.72 145 28 0.32 105 8
07S
-0.73 145 34 0.49 103 12 07S
-0.89 145 54 0.17 141 4
10S
-0.66 146 6
0.24 53 5
07S
-0.72 146 11 0.23 107 4
07S
-0.78 146 14 0.95 97 19 07S
-0.75 146 16 0.26 118 7
07S
-0.79 146 18 0.31 127 8
07S
-0.83 146 19 0.3 85 8
07S
-0.73 146 24 0.23 119 6
09S
+0.29 0.25 0
9 09S
+0.36 146 26 0.31 70 8
09s
+0.53 0.65 97 15 09S
-0.82 1.01 93 21 08S
-0.82 0.45 73 11 07S
+0.64 0.28 60 7
07S
-0.62 0.25 49 6
08S
+0.59 0.53 0
18 08S
-0.76 0.17 0
7 08S
+0.68 146 30 0.29 82 8
07S
-0.82 146 47 0.47 133 11 07S
-0.77 146 48 0.35 124 9
10S
-0.68 146 49 0.38 98 9
10S
-0.72 146 50 0.21 152 6
10S
-0.66 Page 73 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Row;
-Tube
-,-,Volts
-,Degree l
/
Tube Support -TSP Location
- ~~~~~~~~
~
~~~~~Plate'--'
147 5
0.38 112 8
13S
-0.83 147 12 0.49 111 11 07S
-0.75 147 15 0.44 94 11 07S
-0.74 0.11 146 3
07S
+0.56 147 16 0.19 86 5
07S
+0.63 0.18 76 5
07S
-0.66 147 23 0.32 113 8
07S
-0.70 0.33 123 8
09S
-0.86 0.45 91 11 03S
.0.84 0.24 0
9 07S
-0.77 147 24 0.31 88 8
07S
-0.87 147 32 0.25 108 6
09S
+0.64 147 42 0.21 56 6
los
+0.68 0.28 0
7 loS
+0.77 147 43 0.28 83 7
loS
-0.72 147 44 0.28 119 7
07S
-0.75 0.17 48 5
10S
-0.64 147 45 0.37 137 9
13S
-0.81 148 2
0.28 111 5
09S
-0.81 0.26 113 5
13S
-0.83 0.18 0
6 13S
-0.81 148 17 0.49 101 12 07S
+0.58 148 20 0.57 80 13 10S
+0.65 0.23 153 6
10S
-0.87 148 29 0.2 115 5
09S
+0.54 148 36 0.24 56 6
loS
+0.56 148 37 0.44 98 11 los
+0.64 0.44 0
10 10S
+0.72 148 41 0.2 103 5
10S
-0.75 149 1
0.18 98 2
09S
-0.87 0.23 0
7 09S
-0.86 149 2
0.31 145 7
13S
-0.79 149 5
0.37 42 8
13S
.0.78 0.18 0
6 13S
-0.64 149 7
0.3 136 7
07S
-0.73 0.44 0
13 07S
-0.82 149 11 0.44 106 10 07S
-0.70 149 13 0.92 92 19 10S
+0.56 149 14 0.4 117 11 10S
+0.59 0.22 0
7 1
0S
+0.75 149 15 0.33 75 8
loS
+0.65 0.26 143 6
11S
-0.79 0.16 83 4
09S
+0.52 149 16 0.24 98 7
loS
+0.59 Page 74 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Row
- ,Tube V.olts Degree
.:,TW Tube Support TSP Location 0.32 0
10 10S
+0.73 149 17 0.22 60 6
lS
+0.65 0.22 190 5
loS
-0.70 149 24 0.5 92 13 l0S
+0.61 149 26 0.31 104 9
10S
-0.66 149 27 0.41 103 9
1S
-0.72 0.26 85 6
loS
+0.63 149 28 0.38 113 9
10S
-0.72 0.26 145 6
13S
-0.84 0.22 63 8
10S
-0.70 149 29 0.44 94 10 10S
-0.70 149 30 0.41 71 10 loS
-0.70 0.25 62 6
13S
+0.54 0.68 79 16 10S
+0.67 0.22 0
5 13S
+0.58 149 31 0.57 84 13 10S
-0.72 0.25 88 6
10S
+0.61 149 32 0.26 122 7
10S
-0.77 0.55 80 13 10S
+0.72 150 1
0.84 74 19 10S
+0.69 0.27 62 5
1S
-0.74 150 5
0.22 80 6
10S
-0.75 150 6
0.28 142 7
10S
-0.77 0.16 0
5 10S
-0.74 150 10 0.24 105 6
10S
-0.70 0.37 101 9
loS
+0.61 0.2 0
6 10S
-0.73 0.41 0
12 los
+0.67 150 11 0.24 133 6
10S
-0.73 0.43 108 12 loS
+0.59 0.25 0
8 10S
-0.70 0.26 0
8 1S
+0.71 150 12 0.33 108 8
10S
-0.73 0.33 94 8
loS
+0.61 150 13 0.48 88 13 10S
+0.64 0.23 91 7
10S
-0.78 150 14 0.33 106 8
10S
-0.68 0.28 0
10 10S
-0.68 150 15 0.4 92 11 07S
-0.84 0.37 88 10 10S
+0.61 0.19 79 6
loS
-0.69 150 16 0.24 91 6
10S
-0.72 0.35 0
13 10S
-0.68 150 17 0.24 101 7
10S
-0.77 Page 75 of 76
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix I Tubes In-Service with Through-Wall Indications 1% to 39%
OTSG B Rowv ; eTube Volts -.
Degree i>' /o
- -ube Support
- TSP Location x..'
x~~~~~~~~. Plate
-'~
0.21 111 6
14S
-0.79 150 18 0.42 107 10 WOS
-0.81 0.38 138 9
14S
-0.86 0.08 0
3 14S
-0.78 150 19 0.36 96 10 10S
-0.71 0.26 80 7
WOS
+0.57 150 20 0.43 99 10 loS
-0.68 0.28 66 7
WS
+0.61 150 21 0.42 113 11 lOS
-0.73 0.31 100 8
loS
+0.64 0.27 122 7
14S
-0.77 150 22 0.37 103 9
loS
-0.68 0.2 94 5
WS
+0.59 150 23 0.42 102 11 10S
+0.57 0.29 96 8
10S
-0.68 150 24 0.54 108 12 10S
-0.71 0.24 105 6
11S
-0.70 0.38 92 9
10S
+0.66 0.27 0
9 uS
-0.69 150 25 0.35 119 8
10S
-0.70 0.27 113 6
10S
+0.59 0.32 0
9 loS
+0.60 0.43 0
12 WOS
-0.75 0.47 0
11 10S
-0.70 150 27 0.21 104 5
10S
-0.75 151 2
0.23 80 6
13S
-0.75 0.33 97 9
lOS
-0.77 151 3
0.4 95 9
10S
-0.68 151 4
0.27 85 7
10S
-0.76 151 5
0.29 79 7
10S
-0.68 151 8
0.23 95 6
10S
-0.74 151 9
0.18 103 5
10S
-0.77 151 10 0.45 104 10.
10S
-0.76 0.16 37 4
loS
+0.63 151 11 0.25 110 7
10S
-0.73 151 12 0.53 102 12 loS
-0.73 -
0.19 76 5
10S
+0.61 151 15 0.42 114 10 loS
-0.69 0.52 100 12 loS
+0.61 Page 76 of 76
PROGRESS ENERGY FLORIDA, INC.
CRYSTAL RIVER UNIT 3 DOCKET NUMBER 50-302/LICENSE NUMBER DPR-72 ATTACHMENT SPECIAL REPORT 04-01 APPENDIX 2 FIRST SPAN IGA IN OTSG-B (Regression Analysis)
Appendix Acronyms IGA - Intergranular Attack LTS - Lower Tubesheet OTSG - Once-Through Steam Generator TW - Through-Wall
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 First Span IGA in OTSG-B (Regression Analysis)
Attachment Appendix 2 ColumnS s
e n 2 is eV_ e 4
40 29 9.70 0.13 127 N
0.15 28
-0.02 1
16 22 28 6.57 0.12 107 N
0.09 22 0.03 6
24 43 31 39.00 0.22 131 N
0.18 31 0.04 0
38 45 28 9.63 0.38 165 N
0.33 32 0.05
-4 38 64 32 8.05 0.18 127 N
0.16 28 0.02 4
39 44 19 7.65 0.14 148 Y
0.12 16 0.02 3
23 8.28 0.43 170 Y
0.36 27 0.07
-4 32 6.12 0.28 155 Y
0.26 31 0.02 1
34 16.97 0.18 158 Y
0.20 31
-0.02 3
32 14.65 0.18 130 Y
0.15 34 0.03
-2 24 13.16 0.19 150 Y
0.16 28 0.03
-4 40 45 29 8.41 0.27 44 N
0.19 30 0.08
-1 28 14.99 0.19 154 N
0.13 24 0.06 4
40 46 31 10.17 0.22 144 N
0.21 29 0.01 2
41 39 27 10.94 0.16 80 N
0.16 26 0.00 1
42 34 28 8.83 0.19 137 N
0.19 24 0.00 4
42 42 32 10.62 0.31 146 N
0.22 30 0.09 2
24 7.26 0.09 130 N
0.11 26
-0.02
-2 32 7.80 0.16 86 N
0.16 33 0.00
-1 42 47 33 11.04 0.10 90 N
0.11 26
-0.01 7
42 63 25 9.11 0.19 138 N
0.13 26 0.06
-1 28 13.54 0.15 119 N
0.11 28 0.04 0
43 48 17 26.21 0.08 166 N
0.09 16
-0.01 1
__27 10.74 0.12 98 N
0.09 25 0.03 2
43 49 33 11.87 0.34 168 Y
0.31 29 0.03 4
32 14.46 0.28 147 Y
0.31 33
-0.03
-1 27 8.62 0.10 118 Y
0.08 24 0.02 3
43 82 29 4.26 0.12 138 N
0.07 26 0.05 3
45 40 31 12.41 0.78 175 N
0.45 34 0.33
-3 31 13.18 0.30 145 N
0.21 29 0.09 2
30 8.82 0.29 154 N
0.24 34 0.05
-4 45 48 32 13.66 0.18 131 N
0.13 30 0.05 2
45 49 34 13.45 0.20 137 N
0.16 27 0.04 7
46 41 36 8.68 0.31 122 N
0.27 36 0.04 0
46 49 24 14.27 0.13 100 N
0.16 34
-0.03
-10 48 43 32 11.47 0.19 102 N
0.20 29
-0.01 3
28 12.16 0.14 129 N
0.11 24 0.03 4
28 14.75 0.15 139 N
0.17 26
-0.02 2
30 8.83 0.32 160 N
0.30 29 0.02 1
23 9.32 0.08 135 N
0.08 26 0.00
-3 48 61 19 7.40 0.18 154 N
0.14 21 0.04
-2 48 72 24 9.09 0.11 138 N
0.10 25 0.01
-1 49 56 24 11.98 0.09 133 N
0.09 26 0.00
-2 20 6.22 0.16 158 N
0.11 22 0.05
-2 51 30 35 10.58 0.41 145 N
0.39 35 0.02 0
51 55 35 7.83 0.23 137 N
0.24 36
-0.01
-1 Page 1 of 8
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 2 First Span IGA in OTSG-B (Regression Analysis)
Cret Cu ent
'luggd Peiu rvos ot 0
Row Coumn Oo
'm N
oil De Mgr ees In 203 i
rot r
51 79 36 13.56 0.32 139 N
0.22 36 0.10 0
32 9.84 0.18 134 N
0.21 31
-0.03 1
51 80 31 8.62 0.19 131 N
0.11 27 0.08
- 4 52 37 26 13.19 0.13 155 N
0.10 24 0.03 2
25 13.42 0.13 62 N
0.11 28 0.02
-3 28 13.85 0.19 154 N
0.14 25 0.05 3
22 17.62 0.05 45 N
0.04 26 0.01
-4 52 49 28 14.72 0.21 143 N
0.17 30 0.04
-2 53 44 25 11.00 0.12 128 N
0.11 31 0.01
-6 24 8.10 0.12 127 N
0.09 26 0.03
-2 31 10.67 0.18 99 N
0.14 30 0.04 1
35 9.70 0.28 129 N
0.26 32 0.02 3
54 82 36 10.77 0.28 123 N
0.24 32 0.04 4
26 6.19 0.10 107 N
0.09 22 0.01 4
24 9.71 0.23 146 N
0.16 29 0.07
-5 56 37 27 11.40 0.18 86 N
0.11 25 0.07 2
32 8.64 0.34 147 N
0.27 29 0.07 3
56 53 33 11.52 0.29 132 N
0.32 26
-0.03 7
24 13.46 0.15 165 N
0.07 21 0.08 3
27 14.38 0.20 158 N
0.13 27 0.07 0
32 5.65 0.24 143 N
0.24 32 0.00 0
57 33 29 14.22 0.24 144 N
0.20 27 0.04 2
34 27.06 0.22 144 N
0.23 36
-0.01
-2 57 89 22 10.31 0.12 120 N
0.09 21 0.03 1
28 6.74 0.19 128 N
0.16 27 0.03 1
25 7.23 0.12 135 N
0.11 25 0.01 0
20 7.43 0.10 137 N
0.08 13 0.02 7
58 33 19 11.39 0.11 44 N
0.08 25 0.03
-6 32 15.51 0.22 52 N
0.17 27 0.05 5
30 8.90 0.25 156 N
0.16 30 0.09 0
58 89 34 5.92 0.25 132 N
0.23 34 0.02 0
59 30 32 9.85 0.29 159 N
0.22 25 0.07 7
59 40 29 9.30 0.11 126 N
0.10 23 0.01 6
59 80 27 12.38 0.20 130 N
0.18 29 0.02
-2 60 34 31 15.66 0.18 67 N
0.14 30 0.04 1
60 44 26 8.34 0.17 138 N
0.15 26 0.02 0
61 25 32 6.87 0.28 133 N
0.27 35 0.01
-3
__34 8.09 0.35 150 N
0.31 33 0.04 1
61 27 36 9.94 0.25 146 N
0.13 29 0.12 7
61 46 21 8.27 0.13 141 N
0.09 22 0.04
-1 61 82 20 12.29 0.14 138 N
0.11 23 0.03
-3 33 8.41 0.27 131 N
0.21 32 0.06 1
61 88 28 6.05 0.15 113 N
0.13 27 0.02 1
62 28 33 10.60 0.48 147 N
0.48 35 0.00
-2 25 9.95 0.15 138 N
0.11 28 0.04
-3 35 8.22 0.22 135 N
0.29 36
-0.07
-1 Page 2 of 8
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 First Span IGA in OTSG-B (Regression Analysis)
Attachment Appendix 2 in't I WoWWI Column-M%T I °VoItsIWI I5F6TW4Wj WGroWth~IIGroWthtPl a
4...-. Ta 23 11.38 I 0.09 103 N
0.08 27 0.01
-4 62 44 32 11.81 0.10 148 N
0.07 30 0.03 2
25 9.74 0.19 137 N
0.14 27
--0.05
-2 62 99 29 10.14 0.12 131 N
0.13 27
-0.01 2
34 9.32 0.20 133 N
0.19 35 0.01
-1 63 26 32 11.64 0.15 142 N
0.14 30 0.01 2
29 27.63 0.33 170 N
0.40 28
-0.07 1
63 41 31 12.41 0.27 129 N
0.22 32 0.05
-1 30 13.75 0.23 145 N
0.20 27 0.03 3
64 42 34 12.05 0.23 122 N
0.21 34 0.02 0
65 37 30 10.58 0.23 109 N
0.19 33 0.04
-3 34 8.48 0.23 86 N
0.20 33 0.03 1
12 6.95 0.06 82 N
0.06 10 0.00 2
33 17.03 0.26 144 N
0.19 28 0.07 5
30 16.51 0.17 90 N
0.16 28 0.01 2
29 12.45 0.16 113 N
0.12 29 0.04 0
25 12.86 0.13 146 N
0.12 24 0.01 1
65 42 23 6.72 0.12 49 N
0.07 15 0.05 8
65 44 26 11.55 0.19 132 N
0.14 24 0.05 2
28 14.34 0.19 62 N
0.16 28 0.03 0
65 48 28 7.55 0.11 123 Y
0.11 29 0.00
-1 21 9.25 0.11 44 Y
0.04 19 0.07 2
27 8.96 0.14 87 Y
0.12 32 0.02
-5 18 10.74 0.04 119 Y
0.11 20
-0.07
-2 26 6.04 0.13 120 Y
0.13 27 0.00
-1 36 6.83 0.48 166 Y
0.43 32 0.05 4
13.97 0.04 41 Y
0.06 16
-0.02
-16 65 50 24 12.54 0.10 83 N
0.08 28 0.02
-4 31 13.71 0.13 117 N
0.12 28 0.01 3
66 34 29 12.61 0.12 112 N
0.11 29 0.01 0
23 8.77 0.04 80 N
0.06 27
-0.02
-4 67 50 37 11.94 0.22 74 N
0.20 32 0.02 5
68 38 28 16.81 0.17 143 N
0.16 28 0.01 0
28 15.53 0.19 139 N
0.20 30
-0.01
-2 26 13.68 0.25 147 N
0.21 25 0.04 1
28 10.08 0.16 121 N
0.14 29 0.02
-1 33 11.59 0.24 73 N
0.20 35 0.04
-2 68 99 35 11.41 0.38 67 N
0.30 36 0.08
-1 36 8.22 0.36 159 N
0.43 31
-0.07 5
69 42 38 13.88 0.30 147 N
0.28 28 0.02 10 70 38 36 15.77 0.12 127 N
0.11 36 0.01 0
36 17.80 0.25 142 N
0.26 33
-0.01 3
32 14.15 0.38 167 N
0.18 23 0.20 9
32 15.49 0.17 150 N
0.09 33 0.08
-1 70 58 33 31.04 0.16 99 N
0.15 27 0.01 6
71 95 28 7.00 0.16 112 N
0.11 26 0.05 2
Page 3 of 8
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 First Span IGA in OTSG-B (Regression Analysis)
Attachment Appendix 2 Row Co mn
%1, rrs" moms De Ie FrAr2OS ROMt
'7%.W Gro Gr 73 44 27 24.16 0.18 58 N
0.11 25 0.07 2
77 86 25 7.89 0.15 146 N
0.11 27 0.04
-2 78 41 29 26.06 0.18 102
.l N
31
-2 78 45 34 25.65 0.25 95 N
0.24 28 0.01 6
78 93 36 11.52 0.43 148 N
0.25 37 0.18
-1 78 95 23 11.26 0.15 147 Y
38 9.68 0.21 99 Y
33 8.05 0.25 145 Y
0.22 31 0.03 2
_ 26 7.60 0.14 129 Y
15 15.90 0.11 157 Y
0.14 15
-0.03 0
40 15.41 0.33 140 Y
16 13.90 0.13 134 Y
36 12.61 0.22 139 Y
32 10.42 0.13 135 Y
0.26 28
-0.13 4
21 13.63 0.12 50 Y
17.42 0.30 37 Y
0.30 0
79 43 33 25.91 0.20 133 N
0.18 35 0.02
-2 79 92 30 12.71 0.20 128 N
0.20 34 0.00
-4 33 14.69 0.21 138 N
0.17 35 0.04
-2 79 97 36 9.46 0.43 135 N
0.35 38 0.08
-2 32 16.44 0.34 162 N
0.22 36 0.12
-4 80 48 32 5.04 0.19 147 N
0.17 28 0.02 4
80 99 31 10.24 0.42 165 N
0.30 30 0.12 1
31 11.35 0.17 101 N
0.16 31 0.01 0
32 14.64 0.26 131 N
0.21 34 0.05
-2 32 6.98 0.17 83 N
0.14 32 0.03 0
37 7.84 0.41 160 N
0.33 34 0.08 3
81 104 32 8.48 0.15 124 N
0.11 32 0.04 0
83 100 33 7.94 0.29 144 N
0.20 32 0.09 1
28 10.95 0.22 150 N
0.12 28 0.10 0
20 5.98 0.10 51 N
0.08 19 0.02 1
84 31 34 12.57 0.26 128 N
0.26 34 0.00 0
84 93 26 14.38 0.11 129 N
0.10 29 0.01
-3 84 96 28 11.83 0.21 151 Y
0.14 30 0.07
-2 24 12.37 0.09 143 Y
0.07 22 0.02 2
35 9.11 0.23 114 Y
0.22 34 0.01 1
84 98 26 9.19 0.13 83 N
0.16 30
-0.03
-4 23 10.06 0.27 183 N
0.14 18 0.13 5
33 11.17 0.51 169 N
0.42 35 0.09
-2 32 12.23 0.37 155 N
0.32 30 0.05 2
30 13.80 0.12 138 N
0.11 28 0.01 2
30 16.89 0.10 140 N
0.09 31 0.01
-1 84 100 37 11.25 0.26 176 N
0.15 29 0.11 8
30 6.94 0.37 166 N
0.19 29 0.18 1
36 8.34 0.33 149 N
0.26 35 0.07 1
85 43 37 10.38 0.28 141 N
0.25
- 35 0.03 2
Page 4 of 8
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 First Span IGA in OTSG-B (Regression Analysis)
Attachment Appendix 2 rR'olwIIll "l g I I MOMI MT S1I 5 WI rleeVI r f4RVfiPI IWWI VGrMMI Gi tvih I 85 92 25 8.28 0.13 135 N
0.12 26 0.01
-1 85 96 38 9.74 0.28 91 N
0.23 36 0.05 2
85 98 33 9.74 0.24
.140 N
0.24 34 0.00
-1 86 24 37 13.00 0.27 122 N
0.22 34 0.05 3
33 9.23 0.36 156 N
0.30 34 0.06
-1 87 39 29 12.69 0.16 109 N
0.14 28 0.02 1
88 34 34 12.75 0.22 62 N
0.20 35 0.02
-1 29 15.45 0.15 130 N
0.13 31 0.02
-2 88 45 34 13.96 0.22 132 N
0.20 35 0.02
-1 89 33 32 9.68 0.29 141 N
0.25 34 0.04
-2 89 39 33 14.25 0.28 139 N
0.24 31 0.04 2
89 89 15 11.34 0.22 168 N
0.17 14 0.05 1
28 5.83 0.16 132 N
0.13 28 0.03 0
28 8.39 0.12 131 N
0.19 27
-0.07 1
90 40 16 17.73 0.07 115 N
0.06 25 0.01
-9 29 11.93 0.12 78 N
0.11 29 0.01 0
18 9.86 0.09 141 N
0.08 22 0.01
-4 33 8.28 0.40 149 N
0.33 34 0.07
-1 36 11.70 0.28 143 N
0.20 32 0.08 4
27 12.22 0.11 124 N
0.11 25 0.00 2
33 15.46 0.15 127 N
0.11 27 0.04 6
30 14.44 0.19 82 N
0.17 31 0.02
-1 90 88 27 5.47 0.23 140 N
0.22 26 0.01 1
91 93 32 9.44 0.13 108 N
0.13 31 0.00 1
91 94 33 10.92 0.19 143 N
0.20 31
-0.01 2
33 8.15 0.20 134 N
0.18 32 0.02 1
91 98 33 9.12 0.22 116 N
0.17 32 0.05 1
32 11.33 0.24 124 N
0.22 33 0.02
-1 92 26 29 7.90 0.29 153 N
0.28 27 0.01 2
22 5.67 0.07 114 N
0.07 21 0.00 1
34 10.78 0.32 169 N
0.30 34 0.02 0
37 12.80 0.28 94 N
0.20 34 0.08 3
92 39 33 10.89 0.21 132 N
0.20 32 0.01 1
92 40 29 14.29 0.21 52 N
0.13 29 0.08 0
92 43 37 5.68 0.50 150 N
0.48 35 0.02 2
93 31 26 11.14 0.19 68 N
0.14 27 0.05
-1 36 12.69 0.25 77 N
0.21 34 0.04 2
93 46 27 15.70 0.21 167 N
0.17 25 0.04 2
22 6.93 0.19 163 N
0.19 21 0.00 1
26 12.05 0.13 146 N
0.11 25 0.02 1
30 10.98 0.35 160 N
0.31 30 0.04 0
93 79 35 10.65 0.21 132 N
0.16 35 0.05 0
93 87 20 7.55 0.17 162 N
0.12 13 0.05 7
93 94 37 12.63 0.35 148 N
0.30 37 0.05 0
31 7.02 0.65 170 N
0.56 35 0.09 4
95 36 29 14.96 0.18 135 N
0.19 32
-0.01
-3 Page 5 of 8
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 First Span IGA in OTSG-B (Regression Analysis)
Attachment Appendix 2 S~~~~~~~~urn Curen Prgg-Pr os of i
T Ro Column FI.~S
~
a D
es n203 NM olt Growth "Growthl 27 17.94 0.35 170 N
0.33 25 0.02 2
31 9.87 0.19 74 N
0.17 30 0.02 1
95 45 33 12.56 0.27 142 Y
0.27 32 0.00 1
22 16.58 0.07 81 Y
0.08 24
-0.01
-2 27 11.45 0.15 65 Y
0.11 28 0.04
-1 25 9.43 0.22 163 Y
0.21 23 0.01 2
95 47 29 10.79 0.11 105 N
0.11 26 0.00 3
96 40 34 10.21 0.26 153 N
0.19 35 0.07
-1 96 41 37 11.82 0.37 145 N
0.26 36 0.11 1
25 13.21 0.19 153 N
0.14 23 0.05 2
96 42 40 12.11
.0.32 153 Y
0.35 37
-0.03 3
34 13.13 0.32 163 Y
0.25 30 0.07 4
30 9.54 0.29 158 Y
0.27 30 0.02 0
96 44 28 6.64 0.13 92 N
0.11 26 0.02 2
26 9.03 0.17 54 N
0.14 26 0.03 0
96 45 33 12.10 0.17 112 N
0.20 32
-0.03 1
96 91 23 11.99 0.11 142 N
0.09 20 0.02 3
97 41 30 11.66 0.24 168 N
0.17 30 0.07 0
31 13.78 0.27 63 N
0.21 34 0.06
-3 97 49 30 12.14 0.21 140 Y
0.17 33 0.04
-3 33 15.34 0.25 158 Y
0.22 31 0.03 2
98 39 37 12.27 0.21 118 N
0.15 34 0.06 3
32 14.84 0.20 116 N
0.17 32 0.03 0
33 15.75 0.19 132 N
0.13 30 0.06 3
26 18.12 0.17 120 N
0.10 27 0.07
-1
__26 6.83 0.15 71 N
0.13 30 0.02
-4 98 42 27 14.93 0.11 59 N
0.16 27
-0.05 0
30 12.00 0.24 148 N
0.21 33 0.03
-3 98 45 27 12.30 0.12 59 N
0.08 28 0.04
-1 98 47 27 6.88 0.09 87 N
0.09 22 0.00 5
24 17.12 0.15 53 N
0.16 28
-0.01
-4 99 41 32 10.45 0.22 89 N
0.19 32 0.03 0
100 33 32 10.23 0.21 86 N
0.18 34 0.03
-2 30 11.07 0.20 74 N
0.20 32 0.00
-2 100 36 36 13.52 0.31 59 N
0.28 33 0.03 3
34 7.99 0.34 150 N
0.29 36 0.05
-2 100 38 31 14.95 0.11 94 N
0.11 22 0.00 9
34 15.17 0.38 173 N
0.37 31 0.01 3
35 17.09 0.19 125 N
0.19 33 0.00 2
100 41 30 17.34 0.43 155 N
0.34 36 0.09
-6 36 7.99 0.49 165 N
0.39 34 0.10 2
100 45 32 14.79 0.16 121 N
0.12 31 0.04 1
100 66 29 9.91 0.11 129 N
0.10 23 0.01 6
100 92 34 7.23 0.18 129 N
0.14 26 0.04 8
27 9.11 0.24 159 N
0.25 29
-0.01
-2
- 101 43 29 9.19 0.18 66 0.20 31
-0.02
-2 Page 6 of 8
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Conmission 3F0104-03 First Span IGA in OTSG-B (Regression Analysis)
Attachment Appendix 2 "i~~~~~~.
Ale G s RO Co mn ONW bS.
Iolts 1D&'120 ONfS 0Gr0 t
Gowt.
101 47 17 11.10 0.16 167 N
0.20 26
-0.04
-9 25 15.17 0.13 56 N
0.10 28 0.03
-3 30 8.99 0.17 135 N
0.16 31 0.01
-1 101 98 21 17.47 0.11 88 N
0.09 26 0.02
-5 32 13.29 0.16 143 N
0.13 26 0.03 6
102 41 34 16.16 0.28 149 N
0.30 32
-0.02 2
102 43 27 13.33 0.16 130 N
0.13 27 0.03 0
31 7.83 0.41 169 N
0.34 33 0.07
-2 32 12.42 0.24 92 N
0.20 34 0.04
-2 102 44 27 9.59 0.16 63 N
0.15 29 0.01
-2 103 36 37 10.97 0.25 143 N
0.20 32 0.05 5
103 37 37 10.14 0.29 128 N
0.26 33 0.03 4
33 15.40 0.29 134 N
0.24 33 0.05 0
26 23.97 0.11 119 N
0.13 28
-0.02
-2 103 41 25 15.78 0.13 92 N
0.12 27 0.01
-2 103 94 34 5.31 0.17 108 N
0.15 30 0.02 4
104 40 25 13.19 0.08 104 N
0.09 28
-0.01
-3 24 15.27 0.09 90 N
0.18 31
-0.09
-7 104 44 25 11.75 0.13 53 N
0.05 24 0.08 1
26 12.41 0.14 160 N
0.13 30 0.01
-4 20 17.88 0.13 49 N
0.10 24 0.03
-4 104 90 28 12.16 0.15 106 N
0.13 32 0.02
-4 27 14.24 0.07 135 N
0.09 30
-0.02
-3 34 8.95 0.20 162 N
0.11 33 0.09 1
106 42 37 16.36 0.31 126 N
0.25 34 0.06 3
28 11.46 0.13 120 N
0.09 25 0.04 3
31 12.49 0.24 146 N
0.22 31 0.02 0
27 14.76 0.14 68 N
0.10 28 0.04
-1 106 43 26 7.01 0.10 126 N
0.10 23 0.00 3
106 48 34 8.90 0.32 144 N
0.25 32 0.07 2
106 50 26 10.62 0.15 53 N
0.08 28 0.07
-2 32 13.63 0.20 69 N
0.25 30
-0.05 2
106 74 23 14.55 0.03 120 N
0.05 14
-0.02 9
25 9.33 0.16 127 N
0.13 30 0.03
-5 107 47 38 11.81 0.16 117 N
0.17 31
-0.01 7
31 14.13 0.13 117 N
0.11 29 0.02 2
30 16.05 0.18 70 N
0.17 33 0.01
-3 37 7.32 0.28 148 N
0.26 32 0.02 5
107 66 29 14.77 0.10 130 N
0.06 27 0.04 2
24 6.58 0.09 135 N
0.08 19 0.01 5
30 7.44 0.15 142 N
0.13 24 0.02 6
21 12.20 0.08 125 N
0.08 23 0.00
-2 108 34 32 15.09 0.20 66 N
0.21 29
-0.01 3
108 74 33 13.29 0.19 148 N
0.15 30 0.04 3
109 46 28 10.80 0.18 141 N
0.17 34 0.01
-6
- -29 12.33
-0.14 144 N
0.13 26 0.01 3
Page 7 of 8
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 First Span IGA in OTSG-B (Regression Analysis)
Attachment Appendix 2
-~~~~~C 1
Me Pm qi Row bi in,
%S Vo DeIe 204~Ot~*T
~
Got r
28 8.43 0.26 155 N
0.22 27 0.04 1
110 40 28 12.77 0.29 164 N
0.25 26 0.04 2
.110 43 35 23.54 0.17 126 N
0.17
.. 31 0.00 4
110 46 30 12.26 0.20 52 N
0.09 29 0.11 1
110 52 30 9.57 0.19 125 N
0.15 32 0.04
-2 33 14.02 0.17 112 N
0.14 30 0.03 3
28 10.30 0.23 134 N
0.19 30 0.04
-2 23 11.39 0.07 128 N
0.08 20
-0.01 3
111 39 23 9.93 0.12 128 N
0.14 28
-0.02
-5 111 42 34 11.58 0.42 162 N
0.36 32 0.06 2
32 14.49 0.25 174 N
0.19 35 0.06
-3 111 51 34 11.30 0.20 137 N
0.17 35 0.03
-1 113 44 34 10.14 0.28 148 N
0.23 29 0.05 5
29 12.30 0.30 171 N
0.27 31 0.03
-2 18 7.80 0.06 90 N
0.06 23 0.00
-5 113 45 31 16.87 0.18 54 N
0.15 31 0.03 0
114 41 29 9.14 0.17 144 N
0.12 23 0.05 6
_35 8.21 0.18 122 N
0.19 34
-0.01 1
114 42 34 11.65 0.41 153 N
0.32 34 0.09 0
24 26.42 0.09 115 N
0.10 21
-0.01 3
24 6.93 0.14 172 N
0.07 28 0.07
-4 31 8.25 0.23 173 N
0.20 33 0.03
-2 26 8.54 0.23 172 N
0.29 29
-0.06
-3 114 43 30 6.78 0.14 147 N
0.11 31 0.03
-1 28 7.23 0.17 176 N
0.14 27 0.03 1
9 25.76 0.04 85 N
0.03 14 0.01
-5 24 23.58 0.12 82 N
0.14 28
-0.02
-4
__31 11.98 0.26 168 N
0.21 30 0.05 1
32 10.28 0.34 168 N
0.30 31 0.04 1
114 46 21 6.69 0.14 123 N
0.12 22 0.02
-1 116 43 26 6.28 0.11 137 N
0.09 25 0.02 1
35 6.69 0.23 137 N
0.19 33 0.04 2
21 7.05 0.08 125 N
0.07 27 0.01
-6 28 7.75 0.13 134 N
0.14 28
-0.01 0
118 41 30 5.81 0.20 142 N
0.19 31 0.01
-1 30 8.75 0.24 60 N
0.18 34 0.06
-4 29 9.44 0.15 110 N
0.16 33
-0.01
-4 123 77 26 4.44 0.10 112 N
0.10 26 0.00 0
129 41 30 21.41 0.17 102 N
0.15 32 0.02
-2 131 3
24 37.24 0.18 141 N
0.19 24
-0.01 0
Page 8 of 8
PROGRESS ENERGY FLORIDA, INC.
CRYSTAL RIVER UNIT 3 DOCKET NUMBER 50-302/LICENSE NUMBER DPR-72 ATTACHMENT SPECIAL REPORT 04-01 APPENDIX 3 TUBES PLUGGED Appendix Acronyms OE - Operating Experience SAI - Single Axial Indication MAI - Multiple Axial Indications SCI - Single Circumferential Indication MAA-Multiple Axial Anomaly NDD - Non Detectable Degradation MCI - Multiple Circumferential Indications SVI - Single Volumetric Indication TWD -Through-Wall Dimension OBS - Obstructed NQI - Non Quantifiable Indication MVI - Multiple Volumetric Indications I-Code - Indication Code LTE - Lower Tube End
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3FO104-03 Attachment Appendix 3 Tubes Plugged OTSG-A
- RO.Wi 6TIJB~
REA1§9N Qj_
MiNDi JR MLOCAOJqN J(RO BE 2
26 Pluggable I-Code 0.26 83 SAI 15S
-5.73 520PP Pluggable I-Code 0.31 86 MAI 15S
-7.30 520PP Pluggable I-Code 0.19 85 SAI 15S
-3.28 520PP 2
27 Pluggable I-Code 0.18 100.
SAI 15S -- 7.77 520PP Pluggable I-Code 0.21 101 SAI 15S -6.63 520PP 3
18 Rejected Re-roll 1.57 33 SCI LTE
+0.37 460PP 4
7 Rejected Re-roll 0.93 16 SCI LTE
+0.38 460PP 4
8 Rejected Re-roll 1.49 39 SCI LTE +0.40 460PP 4
25 Rejected Re-roll 1.65 31 SCI LTE +0.39 460PP 4
29 Rejected Re-roll 1.26 20 MCI LTE
+0.37 460PP 5
14 Rejected Re-roll 1.70 33 SCI LTE
+0.39 460PP 8
5 Rejected Re-roll 0.91 29 SCI LTE
+0.44 52OPP 9
59 Preventative for OE 2.54 28 MM UTE
-0.18 520PP 9
60 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 10 60 Rejected Re-roll 0.72 39 SCI LTE
+0.37 460PP 10 61 Rejected Re-roll 2.87 29 MCI LTE
+0.38 520PP 13 1
Rejected Re-roll 1.54 46 SCI LTE
+0.09 52OPP 13 67 Pluggable I-Code 0.21 105 SVI 15S +0.03 520PP 15 5
Rejected Re-roll 1.40 29 SCI LTE
+0.37 460PP 18 5
Rejected Re-roll 1.09 38 SCI LTE
+0.42 52OPP 18 79 Pluggable I-Code 0.17 111 SVI UTE
-4.07 520PP 20 7
Rejected Re-roll 1.38 27 SCI LTE
+0.42 52OPP 21 5
Rejected Re-roll 0.46 16 SCI LTE
+0.35 52OPP 32 105 Rejected Re-roll 0.48 27 SCI LTE
+0.37 520PP 35 3
Rejected Re-roll 1.62 23 SCI LTE
+0.42 520PP 36 4
Rejected Re-roll 0.99 29 SCI LTE
+0.39 52OPP 39 1
Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 39 2
Preventative for OE NDD 51 OUL 40 1
Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 41 1
Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 43 116 Rejected Re-roll 3.84 33 MCI LTE +0.35 520PP 44 117 Rejected Re-roll 2.00 31 SCI LTE
+0.36 520PP 44 118 Rejected Re-roll 0.75 27 SCI LTE
+0.37 520PP 45 119 Rejected Re-rotl 0.71 29 SCI LTE
+0.33 520PP 49 121 Rejected Re-roll 2.23 36 SCt LTE
+0.33 520PP 49 122 Rejected Re-roll 1.13 32 MCI LTE
+0.34 52OPP 50 121 Rejected Re-roll 1.11 28 SCI LTE
+0.37 520PP 50 122 Rejected Re-roll 1.14 23 SCI LTE
+0.40 520PP 56 1
Preventative Wear 0.77 87 TWD 26 12S
+0.59 51OUL 56 3
Preventative Wear 0.94 101 TWD 29 10S +0.70 51OUL 56 5
Preventative Wear 0.84 88 TWD 28 09S
+0.66 SOUL 57 125 Rejected Re-roll 3.66 34 SCI LTE
+0.36 520PP 58 115 Pluggable I-Code 0.58 32 MAI UTE
-3.89 460PP 61 1
Preventative Wear 1.08 97 TWD 31 09S +0.63 51OUL Page 1 of 4
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3FO104-03 Attachment Appendix 3 Tubes Plugged OTSG-A M,1,0;I Jkw~i V LAB I&ROBEj.
63 130 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 64 1
Preventative Wear 0.67 104 TWD 24 06S -0.72 51OUL 64 128 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 65 130 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 70 66 Pluggable I-Code 0.69 19 SCI UTE
-1.13 460PP 71 5
Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 75 22 Obstructed Sleeve OBS USE
-1.18 400PP 75 28 Obstructed Sleeve OBS USE
-0.00 400PP 75 31 Obstructed Sleeve OBS USE
-0.00 400PP 75 33 Obstructed Sleeve OBS USE
-000 400PP 75 95 Pluggable I-Code 0.60 22 MAI UTE
-4.36 460PP 75 96 Pluggable I-Code 1.05 26 MAI UTE
-4.22 460PP 77 50 Pluggable I-Code 0.20 83 SVI UTS
+0.21 520PP 95 128 Rejected Re-roll 1.15 22 SCI LTE
+0.11 520PP 98 124 Rejected Re-roll 1.19 38 SCI LTE
+0.42 520PP 100 123 Rejected Re-roll 0.92 35 MCI LTE
+0.36 520PP 102 2
Rejected Re-roll 0.36 34 SCI LTE
+0.28 520PP 103 3
Rejected Re-roll 1.00 25 SCI LTE
+0.29 520PP 105 3
Rejected Re-roll 0.60 24 SCI LTE
+0.43 520PP 110 3
Pluggable I-Code 0.17 91 SVI 15S
-0.22 460PP 113 114 Rejected Re-roll 1.11 30 MCI LTE
+0.35 520PP 114 112 Rejected Re-roll 2.16 39 MCI LTE
+0.34 520PP 116 110 Rejected Re-roll 2.79 37 SCI LTE
+0.37 520PP 116 111 Rejected Re-roll 1.02 39 SCI LTE
+0.41 520PP 117 106 Rejected Re-roll 1.12 31 SCI LTE
+0.41 520PP 122 4
Rejected Re-roll 0.48 39 SCI LTE
+0.32 520PP 125 96 Rejected Re-roll 1.38 29 MCI LTE
+0.36 520PP 125 97 Rejected Re-roll 1.70 25 SCI LTE
+0.35 520PP 126 3
Rejected Re-roll 0.69 17 SCI LTE
+0.40 520PP 126 97 Rejected Re-roll 2.84 30 SCI LTE
+0.37 520PP 128 91 Rejected Re-roll 0.81 32 SCI LTE
+0.29 520PP 128 92 Rejected Re-roll 1.98 34 SCI LTE
+0.33 520PP 130 90 Rejected Re-roll 1.44 27 SCI LTE
+0.37 520PP 131 88 Rejected Re-roll 1.69 30 SCI LTE
+0.33 520PP 134 2
Rejected Re-roll 1.06 29 SCI LTE
+0.12 520PP 137 4
Rejected Re-roll 0.82 34 SCI LTE
+0.36 52OPP 138 71 Rejected Re-roll 1.67 24 SCI LTE
+0.42 460PP 141 63 Rejected Re-roll 0.69 36 SCI LTE
+0.45 460PP 143 3
Pluggable I-Code 1.21 76 SVI 15S
+0.73 46OPP 143 3
Pluggable I-Code 1.09 37 SCI LTE
+0.44 520PP 143 12 Rejected Re-roll 0.94 33 SC!
LTE
+0.14 520PP 145 48 Rejected Re-roll 0.85 43 SCI LTE
+0.41 460PP 82 Tubes Total in "A" OTSG Page 2 of 4
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 3 Tubes Plugged OTSG-B IRO<WI UB EJ S
FR EAS$N JLL&3J OM MN, tA,%TWj LOCA qNi
- ROBEl-5 1
Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 5
2 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 6
3 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 6
5 Preventative for OE-NDD 51OUL 6
6 Pluggable I-Code 0.27 74 SAI 15S
-5.09 520PP 7
2 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 7
5 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 8
2 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 8
3 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 8
5 Rejected Re-roll 0.20 122 SVI UTE
-4.51 520PP 18 1
Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 18 2
Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 19 1
Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 19 3
Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 20 3
Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 21 89 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 21 90 Preventative for OE NDD 51 OUL 22 90 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 22 92 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 23 92 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 39 44 (1st Span IGA) (>10%
0.18 158 TWD 34 LTS
+16.97 51OHF Growth) 43 49 (lst Span IGA)(>10%
0.10 118 TWD 27 LTS
+8.62 510HF Growth) 46 2
Pluggable I-Code 0.47 59 SVI LTS
+0.00 52OPP 50 82 Pluggable I-Code 0.16 90 SVI UTE
-4.27 460PP 55 93 Pluggable I-Code 0.17 96 SVI UTE
-3.15 460PP 58 84 Pluggable I-Code 0.16 92 SVI UTE
-4.19 460PP 65 48 (1st Span IGA) (NOI 0.04 41 NOI LTS
+13.97 510HF s_43 deg.)
68 1
Preventative for OE NDD 51 OUL 69 2
Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 69 112 Preventative for Wear 2.23 88 TWD 39 04S
+0.77 51OUL 72 31 Pluggable I-Code 1.05 17 SAI UTE
-4.16 460PP 72 34 Pluggable I-Code 0.87 27 SAI UTE
-3.65 460PP 77 9
Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 78 95 (1st Span IGA) (TWD 0.33 40 TWD LTS
+15.41 51OHF
_s40% and NQI) 81 1
Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 81 2
Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 83 1
Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 83 2
Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 84 96 (1st Span IGA) (>10%
0.09 143 TWD 24 LTS
+12.37 510HF Growth) 89 94 Pluggable I-Code 0.13 122 SVI UTE
-2.87 460PP 95 45 (1st Span IGA) (>10%
0.22 163 TWD 25 LTS
+9.43 510HF
_ _ _ _ _ _G row th)
Page 3 of 4
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3FO104-03 Attachment Appendix 3 Tubes Plugged OTSG-B ttR9WF kT.UBEj RE AS90<N 9L~ S LELGk IND; 4,1%.TW1 lL¶CAXIONl FPROBE 96 42 (IstSpanGA)(WD 0.32 153 TWD 40 LTS
+12.11 510HF
- 540% )
97 49 (1st Span IGA) (>10%
0.25 158 1VVD 33 LTS
+15.34 51OHF Growth) 100 123 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 101 94 Pluggable I-Code 0.17 90 SVI UTE
-3.36 46OPP 101 123 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 102 121 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 102 122 Preventative for OE NDD 51OUL 109 2
Pluggable I-Code 0.70 24 MAI UTE
-4.14 460PP 114 1
Pluggable I-Code 0.35 80 SAI 15S
-1.62 520PP 125 81 Pluggable I-Code 0.84 19 SAI UTE
-4.24 460PP 134 66 Rejected Re-roll 1.14 40 MVI UTE
-4.25 520PP 149 33 Pluggable I-Code 0.41 138 SVI UTE
-3.44 460PP 53 Tubes Total in "B" OTSG Page 4 of 4
PROGRESS ENERGY FLORIDA, INC.
CRYSTAL RIVER UNIT 3 DOCKET NUMBER 50-302/LICENSE NUMBER DPR-72 ATTACHMENT SPECIAL REPORT 04-01 APPENDIX 4 TUBES REPAIRED (RE-ROLLED) & IN-SERVICE
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Tubes Repaired (Re-Rolled) & In-Service in OTSG-A Attachment Appendix 4
_CRowtl Columnw Leg.-
1 7
Hot 1
8 Hot 1
9 Hot 2
10 Hot 2
11 Hot 3
8 Cold 3
14 Hot 3
15 Cold 3
17 Cold 3
21 Hot 3
31 Hot 4
13 Cold 4
17 Hot 4
26 Hot 4
37 Hot 5
1 Hot 5
3 Hot 5
9 Cold 5
10 Cold 5
20 Hot 5
l 28 Hot 5
39 Hot Cold 5
40 Hot 5
44 Hot 6
1 Hot 6
42 Cold 6
43 Hot 6
49 Hot 7
2 Hot 7
43 Hot 8
2 Hot 8
52 Hot 8
53 Cold 9
3 Hot 9
47 Hot 10 1
Hot 10 50 Hot 11 1
Hot 11 6
Cold 11 63 Hot 11 64 Cold 12 4
Cold 12 67 Hot Cold
- IRow.,
ColumnM leg 14 71 Hot 15 2
Hot 15 70 Hot 15 71 Hot 15 72 Hot 16 74 Hot 16 77 Hot 16 79 Hot 17 3
Cold 17 6
Cold 18 82 Hot Cold 19 4
Cold 19 79 Hot 19 84 Hot 20 1
Cold 20 73 Hot 20 80 Hot 21 79 Hot 21 84 Hot 21 88 Cold 22 3
Cold 22 90 Cold 22 91 Hot 23 90 Hot 23 91 Cold 23 93 Hot 24 82 Hot 24 91 Hot 24 94 Hot 25 3
Hot 25 4
Cold 25 6
Cold 25 12 Hot 25 92 Hot 25 95 Cold 26 92 Hot 27 51 Hot 27 68 Hot 27 97 Hot 27 98 Hot 28 98 Hot 28 99 Hot 28 100 Hot 28 101 Cold
! Row2 Column Leg 29 103 Hot 30 5
Hot 30 104 Hot 31 105 Hot 32 102 Hot 32 104 Hot 33 105 Cold 33 106 Cold 33 108 Cold 35 105 Hot 35 108 Cold 36 108 Cold 36 110 Hot Cold 36 112 Cold 36 113 Cold 37 111 Cold 37 112 Cold 37 113 Hot 37 114 Cold 38 3
Cold 38 57 Hot 38 113 Cold 38 114 Hot Cold 39 113 Hot Cold 39 114 Cold 40 85 Hot 40 114 Hot 40 116 Hot 40 117 Hot 41 109 Hot 41 114 Hot Cold 41 115 Hot 42 3
Cold 42 111 Hot 42 115 Hot Cold 42 116 Hot 43 43 Hot 43 118 Hot 44 17 Hot 44 116 Cold
..'Rows.C olumn. !4Leg, 45 116 Cold 46 116 Cold 46 117 Hot 47 119 Cold 47 121 Hot 48 3
Cold 48 114 Hot 48 116 Hot 48 119 Hot 48 120 Hot 48 122 Hot 49 1
Hot 49 123 Hot 50 57 Hot 50 120 Cold 51 1
Cold 51 3
Cold 51 120 Cold 51 121 Cold 51 122 Hot Cold 51 123 Hot Cold 52 112 Hot 52 118 Hot 52 122 Cold 53 118 Hot 53 123 Cold 54 40 Hot 55 100 Hot 55 125 Hot 56 108 Cold 56 125 Cold 56 127 Cold 57 80 Hot 59 123 Cold 60 85 Hot 60 127 Hot Cold 62 7
Hot 64 74 Hot 65 73 Hot 69 56 Hot 69 127 Hot 75 112 Hot Page 1 of 4
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Tubes Repaired (Re-Rolled) & In-Service in OTSG-A Attachment Appendix 4
'ow-s Column} jLeg 78 126 Hot 80 102 Hot 80 124 Hot 81 9
Hot 82 3
Hot 84 1
Hot 86 3
Hot 87 1
Cold 87 6
Hot 87 56 Hot 87 94 Hot 92 121 Hot 93 122 Hot 93 124 Hot 95 126 Hot 96 111 Hot 97 125 Hot 101 122 Hot 102 121 Hot Cold 103 123 Hot 104 3
Cold 105 121 Hot 107 3
Cold 108 3
Cold 108 4
Cold 112 1
Cold 112 117 Cold 113 3
Cold 114 1
Hot 114 3
Cold 114 111 Cold 114 113 Hot 114 115 Cold 115 1
Cold 115 111 Hot 115 112 Hot Cold 116 1
Hot 7
Cold 116 109 Cold 118 1
Hot Cold 120 94 Hot 120 106 Hot 1ow.
3CColuol dLeg[
121 3
Cold 121 5
Cold 122 101 Cold 122 103 Hot 123 99 Cold 123 101 Hot 123 102 Hot 125 5
Cold 125 98 Hot Cold 126 1
Cold 126 94 Cold 126 95 Cold 126 96 Cold 127 1
Hot 127 2
Hot 127 94 Cold 127 96 Hot 129 4
Cold 129 91 Cold 130 1
Cold 130 2
Hot 130 4
Cold 130 5
Cold 130 91 Cold 132 82 Cold 133 1
Cold 133 86 Hot 134 1
Hot 134 82 Cold 134 84 Hot 134 85 Cold 135 1
Hot 135 4
Cold 135 78 Cold 135 80 Cold 135 81 Hot 137 77 Hot 138 3
Cold 138 10 Cold 138 75 Hot 139 2
Cold 139 70 Cold 140 1
Cold 140 66 Hot flow Columnl-'
Leg 140 67 Hot 140 69 Hot 140 70 Hot 141 6
Hot 141 64 Hot 142 4
Cold 142 10 Cold 142 52 Hot 142 63 Hot 144 2
Cold 144 7
Cold 144 28 Hot 146 1
Hot 146 43 Hot 146 46 Cold 147 14 Cold 147 42 Cold 147 45 Hot Cold 148 18 Cold 148 28 Cold 148 30 Cold 148 31 Cold 148 39 Hot 149 14 Cold 149 24 Hot 149 27 Cold 149 28 Hot 150 7
Hot 150 20 Hot 151 1
Hot 151 3
Cold 151 7
Cold 151 9
Cold 151 15 Hot Total=288 Tubes Page 2 of 4
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 4 Tubes Repaired (Re-Rolled) & In-Service in OTSG-B
- R ow, COlunt-teg*^
1 3
Hot 1
4 Hot 1
15 Hot 1
16 Hot 2
9 Hot 2
18 Hot 2
25 Hot 3
3 Hot 3
15 Hot 3
17 Hot 4
2 Hot 4
39 Hot 5
8 Hot 5
9 Hot 6
1 Hot 6
51 Hot 7
53 Hot 8
4 Hot 9
4 Hot 9
5 Hot 9
16 Hot 9
57 Hot 9
60 Hot 10 2
Hot 10 20 Hot 11 2
Hot 12 2
Hot 12 5
Hot 12 71 Hot 13 4
Hot 13 6
Hot 13 8
Hot 14 27 Hot 17 1
Hot 17 82 Hot 18 27 Hot 18 81 Hot 19 76 Cold 20 2
Hot 23 94 Hot 24 1
Hot 24 93 Hot 26 4
Hot 26 6
Cold 27 9PO8NO XHret 27 98 Hot 27 99 Hot 30 1
Hot 31 8
Cold 32 68 Hot 32 106 Hot 34 107 Hot 37 91 Hot 37 112 Hot 38 47 Hot 38 88 Hot 38 98 Hot 38 112 Hot 38 114 Hot 39 113 Hot 39 114 Hot 40 116 Hot 41 32 Hot 42 52 Hot 44 3
Hot 44 17 Hot 44 28 Hot 45 119 Hot 46 3
Hot 46 47 Hot 48 3
Hot 48 15 Hot 50 1
Hot 50 123 Hot 51 1
Hot 54 1
Hot 55 122 Hot 55 126 Hot 56 1
Cold 56 8
Cold 56 110 Hot 57 111 Hot 57 126 Hot 58 3
Hot 58 12 Cold 58 81 Hot 58 97 Hot 58 126 Hot 58 127 Hot Row.
ColumM.
eg~
59 21 Hot 59 81 Hot 59 109 Hot 61 115 Hot 62 89 Hot 62 128 Hot 63 129 Hot 64 38 Hot 64 128 Hot 65 94 Hot 66 32 Hot 66 131 Hot 67 9
Hot 67 16 Hot 67 46 Hot 67 130 Hot 68 92 Hot 70 52 Hot 72 130 Hot 73 15 Hot 73 61 Hot 73 87 Hot 73 130 Hot 78 67 Cold 78 126 Hot 80 6
Hot 80 109 Hot 81 10 Hot 81 74 Cold 83 64 Hot 85 62 Cold 85 130 Hot 88 2
Cold 90 2
Hot 90 128 Hot 91 111 Hot 93 109 Hot 94 2
Hot 94 49 Hot 94 52 Hot 94 95 Hot 94 126 Hot 96 97 Hot 97 125 Hot
-13owi;,ColuMn) rleglt 98 97 Hot 99 1
Hot 99 2
Hot 99 51 Hot 99 64 Hot 99 107 Hot 100 33 Hot 101 1
Hot 101 36 Hot 102 42 Hot 103 64 Hot 103 106 Hot 104 44 Hot 104 46 Hot 105 15 Hot 106 14 Hot 106 45 Hot 107 3
Hot 108 3
Hot 108 118 Hot 109 17 Hot 110 2
Hot 110 42 Hot 110 117 Hot 111 1
Hot 111 114 Hot 111 116 Hot 112 90 Hot 114 112 Hot 115 74 Hot 115 112 Hot 116 30 Hot 116 112 Hot 117 108 Hot 120 17 Hot 121 1
Hot 121 2
Hot 121 3
Hot 121 68 Hot 121 83 Hot 122 82 Hot 123 2
Hot 123 104 Hot 124 1
Hot Page 3 of 4
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 4 Tubes Repaired (Re-Rolled) & In-Service in OTSG-B
.tRow' kcolumrni Leg 124 3
Hot 124 8
Hot 124 23 Hot 125 27 Hot 125 97 Hot 127 79 Hot 127 97 Hot 129 92 Hot 130 2
Hot 130 3
Hot 130 64 Hot 130 77 Hot 131 2
Hot 131 3
Hot 131 8
Hot 131 19 Hot 131 70 Hot 131 90 Hot 132 21 Hot 132 53 Hot 132 54 Hot 132 84 Hot 133 2
Hot 133 25 Hot 133 32 Hot 134 1
Hot 134 3
Hot 134 84 Hot 135 4
Hot 136 2
Hot 136 3
Hot 136 80 Hot 136 81 Hot 137 4
Hot 137 25 Cold 137 77 Hot 138 3
Hot 138 4
Hot 138 71 Hot 138 72 Hot 139 3
Hot 139 21 Hot 139 73 Hot 140 5
Hot 140W HGoolutpn WIegX 140 6
Hot 140 21 Hot 140 61 Hot 141 1
Hot 141 2
Hot 141 5
Hot 141 63 Hot 141 65 Hot 141 63 Hot 142 3
Hot 142 4
Hot 142 5
Hot 142 30 Cold 142 62 Hot 143 31 Hot 144 57
- Hot 145 4
Hot 146 4
Hot 146 10 Hot 146 47 Hot 147 1
Hot 147 4
Hot Cold 147 7
Hot 147 38 Hot 147 39 Hot 147 40 Hot 147 44 Hot 147 45 Hot 148 2
Hot 148 3
Hot 148 5
Hot 148 7
Hot 148 32 Hot 148 34 Hot 148 35 Hot 149 3
Hot 149 24 Hot 149 29 Hot 149 30 Hot 149 32 Hot 150 27 Hot 151 2
Hot 151 3
Hot
_*orI CluM,, I i,; ".Leg 151 l
10 l Hot Total=264 Tubes Page 4 of 4
PROGRESS ENERGY FLORIDA, INC.
CRYSTAL RIVER UNIT 3 DOCKET NUMBER 50-302/LICENSE NUMBER DPR-72 ATTACHMENT SPECIAL REPORT 04-01 APPENDIX 5 TUBES WITH TUBE END CRACK (TEC)
REMAINING IN-SERVICE
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 5 Tubes with TEC Remaining In-Service OTSG-A 1
~7 1
8 1
9 2
10 2
11 3
14 3
21 3
31 4
17 4
26 4
37 5
1 5
3 5
20 5
21 5
23 5
24 5
28 5
32 5
33 5
39 5
40 5
44 6
1 6
25 6
27 6
30 6
34 6
36 6
43 6
49 7
2 7
30 7
43 8
2 8
26 8
30 8
52 9
3 9
47 9
54 10 1
10 30 t O*W l
E_'
10 49 10 50 10 56 11 1
11 39 11 57 11 59 11 63 12 45 12 53 12 65 12 67 13 35 13 37 13 39 13 42 13 47 13 48 13 53 13 54 13 55 13 56 13 68 14 45 14 46 14 47 14 54 14 55 14 66 14 67 14 69 14 70 14 71 15 2
15 39 15 40 15 44 15 46 15 67 15 68 15 70 15 71 15 72
~ROW
- -*TUBE' 16 40 16 42 16 46 16 48 16 58 16 70 16 73 16 74 16 77 16 79 17 38 17 41 17 57 17 70 17 71 17 72 17 73 17 74 17 75 17 78 18 16 18 50 18 59 18 60 18 70 18 72 18 74 18 75 18 76 18 78 18 82 19 59 19 62 19 69 19 72 19 73 19 74 19 75 19 76 19 77 19 79 19 84 20 39
'i`%ROWij UBE.Sl 20 40 20 41 20 42 20 59 20 66 20 68 20 73 20 75 20 76 20 77 20 79 20 80 20 85 21 38 21 61 21 62 21 64 21 73 21 74 21 75 21 76 21 77 21 79 21 81 21 83 21 84 21 85 22 8
22 33 22 52 22 63 22 65 22 66 22 72 22 74 22 76 22 78 22 82 22 85 22 86 22 89 22 91 23 50 Page of 13
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 5 Tubes with TEC Remaining In-Service OTSG-A 23O YY~ 5UBE 23 65 23 69 23 76 23 77 23 78 23 79 23 80 23 81 23 85 23 86 23 89 23 90 23 93 24 24 24 53 24 55 24 66 24 68 24 69 24 77 24 79 24 80 24 82 24 83 24 84 24 86 24 90 24 91 24 94 25 13 25 55 25 59 25 66 25 67 25 78 25 79 25 80 25 81 25 85 25 88 25 89 25 90 25 92
'WOWill UFBE~t 26 43 26 46 26 50 26 55 26 68 26 79 26 81 26 82 26 85 26 86 26 87 26 88 26 90 26 92 26 93 27 56 27 57 27 60 27 66 27 68 27 78 27 79 27 82 27 83 27 84 27 86 27 87 27 88 27 90 27 93 27 97 27 98 28 47 28 59 28 61 28 67 28 70 28 75 28 79 28 80 28 83 28 88 28 89 ft.WR (
JUBE*
28 91 28 98 28 99 28 100 29 50 29 54 29 58 29 83 29 93 29 94 29 95 29 97 29 103 30 5
30 13 30 33 30 49 30 51 30 55 30 57 30 59 30 70 30 71 30 72 30 82 30 84 30 89 30 90 30 95 30 96 31 9
31 40 31 43 31 69 31 71 31 86 31 95 31 96 31 105 32 16 32 37 32 48 32 56 32 ROW*
B 32 58 32 59 32 63 32 72 32 83 32 86 32 90 32 91 32 94 32 96 32 97 32 101 32 102 32 104 33 15 33 51 33 65 33 93 33 97 33 100 34 59 34 83 34 90 34 93 34 95 34 96 34 98 34 99 35 60 35 61 35 73 35 74 35 82 35 90 35 95 35 96 35 99 35 105 36 76 36 78 36 86 36 91 36 95 Page 2 of 13
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 5 Tubes with TEC Remaining In-Service OTSG-A S36,,
9 7 TUBE 36 97 36 98 36 99 36 100 36 103 36 104 36 106 36 107 36 109 36 109.
36 110 37 61 37 76 37 83 37 88 37 89 37 94 37 97 37 98 37 99 37 100 37 103 37 106 37 109 37 110 37 113 38 63 38 77 38 84 38 87 38 95 38 96 38 98 38 99 38 100 38 101 38 104 38 105 38 109 38 111 38 114 38 115 39 36 VWOW.. NTUBlE 39 64 39 71 39..
76 39 78 39 89 39 90 39 91 39 99 39 100 39 101 39 103 39 104 39 111 39 113 40 15 40 16 40 58 40 77 40 88 40 94 40 99 40 100 40 101 40 111 40 112 40 113 40 114 40 116 41 53 41 60 41 73 41 77 41 89 41 90 41 91 41 95 41 96 41 98 41 99 41 101 41 103 41 104 41 108 fROWb 8TUBE" 41 109 41 111 41 112 41 114 41 115 42 15 42 69 42 90 42 97 42 101 42 102 42 103 42 104 42 105 42 107 42 111 42 114 42 115 42 116 43 56 43 61 43 62 43 80 43 83 43 88 43 90 43 91 43 92 43 93 43 96 43 98 43 99 43 100 43 101 43 107 43 109 43 112 43 114 43 115 43 118 44 60 44 62 44 65 6-RQWr!I UBE 44 89 44 91 44 93 44 94 44 97 44 100 44 101 44 102 44 103 44 105 44 106 44 107 44 109 44 110 44 114 45 66 45 88 45 90 45 91 45 92 45 93 45 97 45 98 45 99 45 102 45 103 45 104 45 106 45 107 45 108 45 109 45 112 45 114 45 117 46 60 46 66 46 69 46 76 46 77 46 86 46 87 46 88 46 96 Page 3 of 13
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 5 Tubes with TEC Remaining In-Service OTSG-A
- WROW, fTUBE 46 103 46 109 46 113 46 117 47 12 47 62 47 78 47 88 47 92 47 93 47 94 47 98 47 101 47 104 47 105 47 107 47 117 47 119 47 121 48 61 48 63 48 69 48 74 48 90 48 91 48 99 48 110 48 112 48 114 48 116 48 118 48 119 48 120 48 122 49 1
49 51 49 63 49 82 49 88 49 95 49 99 49 100 49 104 9j8cevg WI1JeE9 49 106 49 110 49
.111 49 123 50 58 50 88 50 99 50 110 50 111 50 112 50 115 50 116 50 119 51 24 51 57 51 59 51 76 51 93 51 94 51 95 51 97 51 103 51 107 51 108 51 110 51 111 51 115 51 116 51 118 51 120 51 121 51 122 51 123 52 59 52 62 52 64 52 91 52 101 52 107 52 115 52 117 52 120 53 108 WOW WTU5E 53 115 53 116 53 117 53 118 53 120 53 121 53 122 53 123 54 49 54 92 54 101 54 109 54 113 55 10 55 77 55 83 55 96 55 110 55 125 56 57 56 80 56 108 56 118 57 5
57 7
57 80 57 85 57 87 57 96 57 97 57 112 57 113 57 124 58 7
58 28 58 62 58 74 58 85 58 110 58 111 58 122 58 123 59 19
,s,.3OWO
=WpE 59 48 59 87 59 94 59 97 59 100 59 105 59 109 59 120 59 121 60 65 60 91 60 96 60 97 60 110 60 115 60 118 60 127 61 16 61 54 61 62 61 64 61 81 61 89 62 69 62 94 62 109 63 62 63 100 64 94 64 103 65 24 65 49 65 56 65 59 65 101 66 60 66 62 66 63 66 79 66 95 66 97 66 98 66 102 Page 4 of 13
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 5 Tubes with TEC Remaining In-Service OTSG-A IOWN ILUBE" 66 103 66 109 67 20 67 50 67 54 67 78 67 92 67 97 67 101 67 102 67 103 68 51 68 97 69 55 69 58 69 60 69 62 69 66 69 70 69 71 69 74 69 93 69 103 70 50 70 51 70 55 70 57 70 113 71 51 71 60 71 64 71 91 72 18 72 49 72 50 72 51 72 52 72 57 72 62 72 94 73 24 73 26 73 47
- "ROW#P Wl3JBE 73 53 73 54 73 55 73 60 73 64 74 46 74 49 74 57 74 62 74 64 74 74 75 61 75 63 75 84 75 89 78 30 78 36 78 57 78 67 78 126 79 18 79 29 79 56 79 63 79 64 79 66 79 70 79 71 79 79 79 85 79 92 80 8
80 9
80 13 80 58 80 62 80 64 80 65 80 66 80 67 81 8
81 20 81 38 81 48 81 64 81 67 81 70 81 73 81 102 82 3
82 8
82 10 82 59 82 60 82 63 83 10 83 49 83 50 84 1
84 52 84 73 85 4
85 6
85 8
85 45 85 47 85 48 85 86 86 3
86 9
86 71 86 72 86 73 86 75 87 62 87 70 88 66 89 79 90 46 90 59 91 65 91 70 91 72 91 82 91 83 91 84 R1W' l TUB*
91 85 91 87 91 109 92 61 92 67 92 80 92 114 92 121 92 122 92 123 93 92 93 107 93 108 93 111 93 116 93 117 93 121 93 122 93 124 94 73 94 97 94 98 94 113 94 118 94 122 94 123 94 125 95 66 95 69 95 74 95 82 95 110 95 112 95 117 95 119 95 126 96 56 96 64 96 109 96 115 96 116 97 62 97 66 Page 5 of 13
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3FO104-03 Attachment Appendix 5 Tubes with TEC Remaining In-Service OTSG-A
!POROW-ENUBiW 97 72 97 99 97 109 97 113 97 114 97 116 97 117 97 122 97 125 98 60 98 64 98 66 98 85 98 94 98 114 98 115 98 118 98 120 98 122 98 123 99 72 99 78 99 81 99 97 99 110 99 115 99 116 99 122 99 123 100 9
100 64 100 65 100 74 100 77 100 78 100 80 100 96 100 108 100 109 100 110 100 114 100 117 100 121 VROW EmE 101 96 101 101 101 109 101 112 101 114 101 115 101 120 101 121 101 122 102 70 102 82 102 114 102 115 102 120 102 121 103 102 103 107 103 112 103 113 103 123 104 82 104 101 104 105 105 64 105 114 105 115 105 121 106 53 106 91 106 98 106 101 106 108 107 93 107 103 107 104 107 107 107 108 107 109 107 112 107 115 107 116 108 48 108 93
.ROW llUBE 108 111 108 112
.108 113 109 6
109 25 109 68 109 102 110 98 110 102 111 97 111 99 111 101 112 6
112 42 112 90 112 95 112 99 112 104 112 112 113 107 113 111 114 1
114 85 114 90 114 99 114 104 114 105 114 106 114 108 114 109 114 110 114 111 114 113 115 76 115 102 115 109 115 111 115 112 116 1
116 88 116 92 116 99 116 101 WROW1
'UB 116 105 116 106 116 108 116 109 117 96 118 1
118 96 120 72 120 73 120 79 120 106 121 69 121 71 121 73 121 83 121 96 121 98 122 71 122 79 122 80 122 99 122 103 123 80 123 101 123 102 124 78 124 96 125 95 125 98 126 28 126 72 126 74 126 80 126 87 126 94 127 1
127 2
127 14 127 81 127 92 127 96 128 80 128 89 Page 6 of 13
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 5 Tubes with TEC Remaining In-Service OTSG-A Sf.ROW*j BE..B-128 90 129 34 129 69 129 80 129 90 130 2
130 88 131 19 132 17 132 73 133 5
133 42 133 51 133 59 133 61 133 86 134 1
134 11 134 14 134 59 134 60 134 71 134 80 134 84 135 1
135 56 135 81 137 7
137 11 137 49 137 55 137 73 137 77 138 75 139 38 139 45 139 56 139 57 139 58 139 66 140 9
140 58 140 60 140 65 140 66 140 67 140 69 140 70 141 6
141 53 141 54 141 55 141 56 141 58 141 64 142 30 142 50 142 52 142 63 143 53 144 25 144 46 145 43 146 1
146 43 147 45 148 39 149 24 149 28 150 7
150 20 151 1
151 15 Total= 1105 Tubes Page 7 of 13
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 5 Tubes with TEC Remaining In-Service OTSG-B
'*PROWN SIUBE'l 1
3 1
4 1
15 1
16 2
9 2
18 2
25 3
3 3
15 3
17 4
2 4
25 4
39 5
8 5
9 6
1 6
12 6
34 6
51 7
20 7
34 7
44 7
47 7
53 8
4 8
11 8
12 8
23 9
4 9
5 9
12 9
15 9
16 9
18 9
48 9
57 9
60 10 2
10 15 10 19 10 34 10 49 10 52
'%ROW
!iLB 11 2
11 9
11,.
11 11 12 11 20 11 21 11 23 11 51 12 2
12 5
12 16 12 29 12 36 12 55 12 71 13 4
13 6
13 19 13 20 13 56 14 19 14 20 14 30 14 66 15 8
15 13 15 16 15 19 15 21 15 35 15 45 15 49 15 58 16 11 16 20 16 24 16 25 17 1
17 10 17 13 17 15 17 22 17 25 ROWC7*1'
'%RTUBE 17 26 17 43 17 76 17 82 18 12 18 14 18 16 18 81 19 6
19 12 19 18 19 47 19 60 20 2
20 31 20 55 21 20 21 27 21 50 22 12 22 16 22 28 22 64 22 79 23 16 23 21 23 23 23 94 24 1
24 19 24 33 24 84 24 93 25 5
25 11 25 24 25 28 25 29 25 58 26 4
26 93 26 94 27 6
ROW;
'r 2UBEW 27 10 27 19 27 85 27 95 27 98 27 99 28 4
28 6
28 7
28 30 28 66 28 83 28 95 28 97 29 7
29 94 29 96 29 97 30 1
30 8
30 9
30 12 30 97 31 8
31 9
31 18 31 88 31 97 31 99 32 9
32 12 32 13 32 14 32 38 32 53 32 102 32 106 33 5
33 9
33 13 33 15 33 23 33 26 Page 8 of 13
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 5 Tubes with TEC Remaining In-Service OTSG-B
- ROW0 EfJB.E£ 34 23 34 27 34 28 34 39 34 56 34 107 35 6
35 11 35 61 35 104 35 106 36 102 36 104 36 105 36 107 37 7
37 12 37 103 37 112 38 13 38 104 38 111 38 112 38 114 39 11 39 27 39 31 39 70 39 86 39 108 39 113 39 114 40 15 40 116 41 38 41 46 41 102 41 111 41 113 42 13 42 31 42 54 42 63
,.ROWt^
UBl3 42 106 42 111 43
.14 43 28 43 47 43 107 43 108 43 110 43 111 44 7
44 12 44 14 44 29 44 32 44 109 45 8
45 15 45 29 45 32 45 85 45 119 46 3
46 6
46 14 46 15 46 16 47 14 47 25 47 33 48 3
48 14 48 31 48 34 48 50 48 62 49 9
49 16 49 17 49 23 49 58 49 59 49 62 50 1
-l8Of.,X. '>TUBE 50 6
50 113 50 115 50 120 50 122 50 123 51 1
51 112 51 116 51 117 51 119 51 120 51 122 52 7
52 13 52 30 52 53 52 110 52 111 52 114 52 116 52 120 53 5
53 119 53 120 54 1
54 6
54 16 54 108 54 114 54 115 55 4
55 25 55 47 55 115 55 121 55 122 55 123 55 126 56 5
56 17 56 26 56 53 tOW.',.XBEW 56 55 56 118 56 121 57 5
57 13 57 16 57 71 57 122 57 125 57 126 58 3
58 17 58 114 58 117 58 119 58 120 58 126 59 38 59 113 59 117 59 121 59 122 60 26 60 116 60 122 60 126 60 127 61 121 61 123 62 34 62 123 62 128 63 26 63 37 63 121 64 27 65 69 65 121 66 4
66 9
66 10 66 16 66 50 Page 9 of 13
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 5 Tubes with TEC Remaining In-Service OTSG-B BOwV 6UBE 66 111 66 120 66 131 67 52 67 130 68 26 69 10 69 22 69 54 69 107 70 50 70 52 71 4
71 42 71 43 71 51 71 67 72 39 72 105 72 122 72 130 73 77 73 104 73 130 74 40 74 108 75 53 75 57 75 61 78 34 78 50 78 57 78 126 79 67 80 111 81 85 82 8
82 50 83 126 84 9
84 54 84 59 85 9
85 41 85 53 85 58 85 86 85 130 86 8
86 13 86 55 86 60 87 7
87 107 88 9
88 49 89 7
89 8
89 9
89 21 89 41 90 2
90 7
90 8
90 11 90 13 90 20 90 128 92 7
92 8
92 21 92 24 92 126 93 6
93 7
93 20 93 30 94 2
94 21 94 29 94 49 94 52 94 95 94 126 96 97 97 7
RW-BE-'l 97 8
97 122 98 6
98 7
98 48 98 123 98 124 99 1
99 2
99 5
99 6
99 20 99 51 99 64 99 124 100 5
100 12 100 31 101 1
101 4
101 9
101 36 102 5
102 42 102 106 103 4
103 5
103 31 104 5
104 18 104 44 104 46 105 3
105 4
106 9
106 10 106 45 107 2
107 3
107 10 107 104 108 3
108 10 108 118 109 1
109 13 110 2
110 30 110 34 110 117 111 1
111 12 111 18 111 64 111 114 111 116 112 1
112 2
112 13 113 31 114 12 114 17 114 101 114 112 115 7
115 8
115 12 115 27 115 32 115 40 115 43 115 112 116 9
116 27 116 30 116 92 116 112 117 18 117 25 117 26 117 73 117 77 117 87 117 88 117 89 117 102 Page 10 of 13
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 5 Tubes with TEC Remaining In-Service OTSG-B
.ROW._WU.BEDI 117 103 117 108 118.
17 119 26 119 32 119 33 119 40 119 87 119 88 120 8
120 13 120 26 120 30 120 36 120 65 120 100 121 1
121 2
121 3
121 18 121 23 121 25 121 26 121 28 121 31 121 38 121 87 121 89 122 5
122 12 122 17 122 26 122 29 122 32 122 36 122 38 122 57 122 61 122 76 122 87 122 88 122 89 123 2
,0W,*
TUBE 123 6
123 10 123 11 123 17 123 18 123 22 123 28 123 30 123 37 123 74 123 104 124 1
124 13 124 8
124 16 124 23 124 26 124 29 124 98 125 4
125 6
125 11 125 19 125 23 125 29 125 39 125 69 125 73 125 82 125 83 125 95 125 97 126 10 126 25 126 26 126 30 126 31 126 62.
126 63 126 70 126 71 126 72 126 79
- 0Iow wrTUpEt 126 83 127 10 127 15 127 19 127 24 127 34 127 37 127 62 127 63 127 75 127 79 127 80 127 83 127 85 127 89 127 97 128 6
128 8
128 9
128 10 128 12 128 17 128 18 128 19 128 23 128 24 128 37 128 69 128 78 128 81 128 84 129 6
129 10 129 12 129 20 129 23 129 27 129 29 129 68 129 70 129 76 129 77 129 79 IMOW,*
TUBE+
129 80 129 92
-130 2
130 3
130 5
130 9
130 10 130 22 130 23 130 27 130 28 130 31 130 36 130 40 130 74 130 77 130 78 130 79 131 2
131 3
131 7
131 11 131 14 131 16 131 18 131 20 131 21 131 22 131 23 131 25 131 30 131 35 131 45 131 58 131 63 131 68 131 70 131 74 131 77 131 78 131 84 131 90 132 9
Page 11 of 13
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3FO104-03 Attachment Appendix 5 Tubes with TEC Remaining In-Service OTSG-B
- alRow, TUB,-*
132 13 132 14 132 23 132 26 132 28 132 29 132 30 132 33 132 46 132 55 132 61 132 71 132 73 132 84 133 2
133 8
133 9
133 12 133 13 133 14 133 15 133 16 133 20 133 29 133 44 133 47 133 66 133 72 133 74 133 75 133 76 134 1
134 3
134 7
134 15 134 16 134 18 134 20 134 22 134 25 134 28 134 32 134 40 RFYPW WURBE$k 134 53 134 65 134 72 134 73 134 74 134 84 135 4
135 12 135 13 135 14 135 15 135 16 135 23 135 26 135 27 135 33 135 53 135 59 135 69 135 70 135 72 136 2
136 3
136 4
136 8
136 14 136 19 136 21 136 27 136 40 136 46 136 56 136 61 136 65 136 70 136 71 136 72 136 74 136 75 136 80 137 8
137 9
137 10
,-ROW,.
.TUBE_
137 11 137 14 137 17 137 18 137 24 137 25 137 28 137 29 137 39 137 40 137 66 137 67 137 68 137 69 137 77 138 3
138 6
138 9
138 10 138 11 138 13 138 14 138 16 138 17 138 21 138 23 138 25 138 30 138 31 138 37 138 38 138 63 138 69 138 70 138 71 138 72 139 3
139 7
139 10 139 12 139 13 139 14 139 16 upOW VKUBEj 139 17 139 18 139 22 139 26 139 27 139 30 139 37 139 41 139 43 139 48 139 50 139 64 139 73 140 5
140 6
140 7
140 9
140 10 140 11 140 12 140 15 140 16 140 18 140 19 140 20 140 21 140 22 140 23 140 24 140 33 140 36 140 47 140 48 140 56 140 60 140 63 140 68 141 1
141 2
141 5
141 7
141 9
141 10 Page 12 of 13
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 5 Tubes with TEC Remaining In-Service OTSG-B 141 14 141 17 141 18 141 19 141 27 141 33 141 34 141 35 141 36 141 40 141 49 141 63 141 67 142 3
142 4
142 5
142 12 142 16 142 17 142 18 142 21 142 26 142 27 142 32 142 33 142 34 142 45 142 47 142 49 142 62 143 7
143 11 143 12 143 13 143 14 143 15 143 16 143 18 143 20 143 21 143 24 143 25 143 30 14W3 31BE 143 31 143 32 143 41 143 42 143 44 143 46 143 47 144 11 144 12 144 13 144 14 144 15 144 18 144 22 144 23 144 26 144 27 144 42 144 43 144 57 145 4
145 8
145 10 145 12 145 17 145 19 145 21 145 25 145 26 145 28 145 38 145 43 146 12 146 14 146 18 146 23 146 26 146 29 146 30 146 47 147 4
147 7
147 10 ROW 'fITUBE 147 13 147 16 147 21 147 23 147 33 147 38 147 39 147 40 147 44 147 45 148 5
148 7
148 15 148 17 148 25 148 32 148 34 148 35 149 24 149 29 149 30 149 32 150 27 151 2
151 3
151 10 Total= 972 Tubes Page 13 of 13
PROGRESS ENERGY FLORIDA, INC.
CRYSTAL RIVER UNIT 3 DOCKET NUMBER 50-302/LICENSE NUMBER DPR-72 ATTACHMENT SPECIAL REPORT 04-01 APPENDIX 6 OTSG-B, First Span IGA
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 6 CR3 SG-B 1st Span IGA Return to Service Indication Axial Distribution a.
If 4-M co a
0 0~
C E 0 -
U. 0 CM a
>44.25 44.25 43 42 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 8
6 4
2 1
-I
_______________ p
-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
V
_______________~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I
-U j~J wwA V-M______
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 1
2 4
6 8
10 15 20 25 30 35 1 40 42 1 43 1 44.25 1>44.25 Olnchl RTS I 0 1 0 0
12 44 66 151 34 5
8 1
2 1
0 1 0 1 0 1 I Number of Indications Page 1 of 5
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 6 CR3 SG-B 1st Span IGA Return to Service
%TW Distribution 120 -
100 80 -
k fi a
co.2 60 0
L.0 E
z 40 20 0
IIi 5
10 15 20 25 30 32 34 36 38 39
>39
%TW Page 2 of 5
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 6 CR3 SG-B 1st Span IGA Removed from Service
%TW Distribution 12 10 8
(A
.2 4-o_
C 6
.0 E
z 4
2 I
I
______________I ml I I
0*
1 5
10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
>50
%TW Page 3 of 5
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 6 CR3 SG-B 1st Span IGA Return to Service
%TW Growth Distribution 80 70 60 I
r ' 40-0
.0 E= 30 20 10 0
U
-1
-T
.It I
ii I
I I
I
-20
-10
-8
-6
-4
-2 0
2 4
6 8
10 20
>20 Delta %TW Page 4 of 5
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3F0104-03 Attachment Appendix 6 CR3 SG-B 1st Span IGA Removed from Service
%TW Growth Distribution 10 9
8 7
0, C
=
5 0
3 0
E 4
z I
I
~~~~~~~~-
L go i
, 1101 l
-20
-10
-8
-6
-4
-2 0
2 4
6 8
10 12 14 16 18 20
>20 Delta %/6TW Page 5 of 5