ML15014A410

Salem Generating Station Unit 1, Report of Impingement of Shortnose Sturgeon

ML15014A410
Person / Time
Site:	Salem
Issue date:	01/06/2015
From:	Wagner L M Public Service Enterprise Group
To:	Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
LR-E14-0177
Download: ML15014A410 (12)

Text

PSEG Nuclear LLCPO Box 236, Hancocks Bridge, NJ 08038-02360 PSEGLR-E14-0177 EPP 5.4.2 Appendix BMN06205U.S. Nuclear Regulatory CommissionATTN: Document Control DeskWashington, DC 20555-0001CERTIFIED MAILRETURN RECEIPT REQUESTEDARTICLE NUMBER: 7013 2630 0000 0535 8085

SUBJECT:

REPORT OF IMPINGEMENT OF SHORTNOSE STURGEONSALEM GENERATING STATION UNIT NO. IDOCKET NO. 50-272The Nuclear Environmental Event Report, "Report of Impingement of ShortnoseSturgeon" is being submitted pursuant to the requirements of Section 5.4.2 of AppendixB, Environmental Protection Plan, to the Operating License for the Salem GeneratingStation, PSEG Nuclear LLC (PSEG).Please find enclosed a letter and three (3) attachments with further information regardingthis impingement event. This report is in response to one live, and one deceasedshortnose sturgeon collected on December 101h 2014.If you have any questions or require additional information, please do not hesitate tocontact Kenneth Strait, Manager -Biological Programs at (856) 339-3929.Sincerely,Lawrence M. WagnerPlant Manager -SalemPSEG Nuclear LLCAttachments (3)

LR-E1 4-0177Document Control DeskREPORT OF IMPINGEMENT OF SHORTNOSE STURGEONIn accordance with Section 5.4.2 of Appendix B, Environmental Protection Plan, to theOperating License for the Salem Generating Station, PSEG Nuclear LLC (PSEG) herebytransmits notification of a nonroutine event, and documents the occurrence and removalof a shortnose sturgeon (Acipenser brevirostrum) from the Salem Generating Stationcirculating water intake structure trash bars.Consultation pursuant to Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (ESA)between NRC and the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) on the effects of theoperation of Salem Station on threatened and endangered species has been ongoingsince 1979. The most recent revision to the Biological Opinion and Incidental TakeStatement issued in January 1999 exempts the specified annual take of shortnosesturgeon and sea turtles. In advance of relicensing for Salem Station, consultationpursuant to Section 7 of the ESA between NRC and NMFS was reinitiated in 2009. OnApril 6, 2012, the NMFS listed five Distinct Population Segments of Atlantic sturgeon asthreatened or endangered under the ESA. In May 2012, NRC requested consultation onthe effects of the continued operation of Salem Station on Atlantic sturgeon. The NMFSissued a draft Biological Opinion and Incidental Take Statement (ITS) in July 2012 that,when finalized, will authorize a specified incidental take of both Atlantic sturgeon andshortnose sturgeon associated with operation of the Salem Station circulating waterintake system.Pursuant to Section 5.4.2 of the Environmental Protection Plan for Salem Station,nonroutine events which require reporting to other federal agencies shall be reported inaccordance with the other agencies' reporting requirements. Accordingly, enclosedplease find one (1) attachment. Attachment 1 provides the information requested by theNMFS in Appendix II to the current ITS and in Appendix B, Part 2, to the revised draftITS.There are no commitments contained in this letter.Page 2 of 3 4LR-E14-0177Document Control DeskCC: Administrator -Region IU. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission2100 Renaissance Blvd., Suite 100King of Prussia, PA 19406-2713Ms Carleen Sanders, Licensing Project ManagerU. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission11555 Rockville PikeMail Stop 0-4D-3Rockville, MD 20852Ms. Julie CrockerNational Marine Fisheries ServiceProtected Resources DivisionJulie.Crocker@noaa.govMs. Jessica PrudenNational Marine Fisheries ServiceProtected Resources DivisionJessica. Pruden@noaa.govMr. Patrick MulliganBureau of Nuclear EngineeringNew Jersey Department of Environmental ProtectionPatrick. Mulligan@DEP.State. NJ. USMr. Dave JenkinsEndangered and Nongame Species ProgramNew Jersey Department of Environmental ProtectionDave.Jenkins@DEP.State. NJ. USMs. Jeanette BowersDepartment of Fish and WildlifeNew Jersey Department of Environmental ProtectionJeanette.Bowers@DEP.State.NJ.USSalem Commitment CoordinatorMail Code X25USNRC Senior Resident Inspector -SalemMail Code X24Page 3 of 3 ATTACHMENT I (Sturgeon)Observee4 full name: Kenneth Kiem (Environmental Consulting Services. Inc.)Reporter's full name:.iion h KiessSpecies Identification (Key attached): Shortnose sturgeon (Acipenser brevirostrum)Site of Impingement (Unit I or 2, CWS or DWS, Bay #, etc.): PSEG SGS Unit 1; CWI 11ADate animal observed: 12110M2014 rime animal observed: 09.30amDate animal collected: 12110M14 Time animal collected: 09:35amDate rehab facility contacted: Time rehab facility contacted:Date animal picked up: _Time animal picked tip:Environmental conditions at time of observation (i.e., tidal stage, weather):Air temp. -6.0C; Sal. -12.0ppl; sky -overcast; wind -NW; wave -slight; tide -Flood 1 (90.5ft)Date and time of last inspection of screen: 12I1012014 at 0054amWater tenperature ("C) at site and fime of observation,: U.T_Number of pumps operating at time of observation: Unit 1 5 Unit 2 6Average percent of power generating capacity achieved per unit at time of observation:Unit 1 100 Unit 2 100Average percent of power generating capacity achieved per unit over the 48 hours5.555556e-4 days <br />0.0133 hours <br />7.936508e-5 weeks <br />1.8264e-5 months <br /> previous toobrvation: Unit 1 100 Unit 2 100Sturgeon Information,,S$pce hordios sturgeon (Acdt..nser brvkvostum)Fork length (or tal lenk h) 70&nm FL / 771mm TL Weight 2.8 kgcondition Of spcitenndecription of animalAt the te Of retrieVS by Sale Yard CreW, " speCIOe wasive and In good hearth, except for twominor n abrOns observed on t right oWl, just below the lateral row of scutes. ECSl fisheriespersone n 1Wed, oogrwaph, and cheered for tagso, bt no extenal or PIT tags were detecled.Alter processhn, the spee ms released! back to the Delaware River at appox~mately 1 0;00am.Fish D"composed: SLIGHTLY MODERATPLY SEVERELYFish taged: YES record aIl tag numbers. 'rag #photograph attbched! p , h / No(please Wabl tpeclowu, ,( Pe.geograpilcoll/e and vessel Ymine on back o r photograph)

ATTACHMENT I (Sturgeon) continuedPhotographsA left lateral view showing full size and condition of the live shortnose sturgeon, (Acipenserbrevirostrum), retrieved at 09:30am on 12/10/14 by Salem Yard Crew personnel whileconducting routine trash rack cleaning at PSEG Salem Generating Station CWIB (12/10/14).View showing a cdore-up of the left Ode of the head and routrum, Egcept for a fewminor eWrnal abraslons, no major lnjurk§ were observed (12/10/14).

ATTACHMENT I (Sturgeon) continuedPhotographsA dcow-up view which shows detall of the minor abrasons to the surface skin on theright side of the specimen, adjacent to the dorso-lateral row of scutes (12-10-14).

ATTACHMENT I (Sturgeon) continuedDraw wounds, abNormalities, tag locations on diagram and briefly describe belowLRLocation of minor skin abrasionsDescription of fish condition:At the time of initial observation and retrieval by Salem Yard Crew, the specimen was alive and In relativelygood condition, except for two small minor skin abrasions observed on the right side of the body, justbelow the dorso-lateral row of scutes (refer to illustration above). After processing, the specimen wasreleased back to the Delaware River. State of NJ DEP and National Marine Fisheries were contacted Inregards to the incidental take at 10A6am and 10:53am respectively.

ATTACHMENT 1 (Sturgeon)Observe's full nme;, Kenneth Kie (Environmental Consulting Services, Inc.)Reporte's full name. Kenneth KimSpecies Identification (Key attached): Shortnose sturgeon (Acipenser brevirostrum)Site of Impingement (Unit I or 2, CWS or DWS, Bay #, etc.): PSEG SGS Unit 1; CWI -undeterminedDafe animal observed: 1211012014 Time animal observed: 10:15amDate animal collected: 12/1012014 Time animal collected: 10:20amDate rehab facility contacted: Time rehab facility contacted:Date animal picked up: Time animal picked up:Environmental conditions at time of observation (i.x., tidal stage, weather):Air temp. -6.0C; Sal. -13.0ppt; sky -overcast; wind -NW; wave -slight; tide -Flood 2 (91.5ft)Date and time of last insection of screen: 12/1012014 at 00:54amWater temperature (OC) at site and time of observation: 6.00CNumber of pumps opertuing at time ofobervation: Unit 1 5 Unit 2 6Average percent of power generating capacity achieved per unit at time of observation:Unit I 100 Unit 2 100Average pecent of power generating capacity achieved per unit over the 48 bous previous toobservaton Unit 1 100 Unit 2 100Sturgeom Informatso:Species ShoIrtnoe ?strgeeon Vcipenser brev4ros*=u)Fork length (or total length) W7mm FL I 7Orm TL Weight 1 A kgCondition of spocimen/description of animalSpocin was deceased and nfoderately docomposd at the time of the retrieval by Salem Yard Crew.ECSI fishedes technician memumed, photographed, and scanned the specimen for lags. No externaltas or PIT tags were indcated. Due to its poor condition, PSEG Nuclear Environmental Affairs directedthat the speciene be discarded in the Salem CwM detrit asar uponb completion of processing.Fish Decomposed; NO Sl.IGHTLY CM-ODERATEL SEVERELYFish tagged: YEr/S /&( Please record tll lag numbers. Taig #Photograph attached: I NO(please label vpeciex, dale, geographlc sile and vessel nawe on back of photograph)

ATTACHMENT I (Sturgeon) continuedPhotographsView showing the size and condition of the deceased shortnose sturgeon (Acipenserbrevirostrum), retrieved at 10:20am on 12/10/14 by Salem Yard Crew personnel duringroutine trash rack cleaning at the Salem CWIB (12/10/14).This photo provides a close-up of the left side of the head and rostrum. Except for the effectsof moderate decomposition, the specimen did not show evidence of any significant damage(12/10/14).

ATTACHMENT I (Sturgeon) continuedDraw wounds, abnormalities, tag locations on diagram and briefly describe belowLRDescription of fish condition:At the time of ntia observation and collection by Salem Yard Crew, the specimen was deceased. Itrevealed evidence of moderate decomposition, Indicated by foul odor, missing soft tissue, and fragile skin.Based on this condition, It appears that the specimen has been deceased for an extended period of timeand that Its death likely occurred at some other location within the river. State of NJ DEP and NationalMarine Fisheries were contacted In regards to the incidental take at IOA6am and 1053am respectively.

STURGEON DATA COLLECTION FORMFor use in documenting sturgeon injury or mortality incidental to a federal actionOBSERVER'S CONTACT INFORMATIONName: First Douglas Last PottsAgency Affiliation PSEG subcontractor Email dpotts@_ecsi-del.comAddress 100 South Case Street, Middletown, DE 19709Area code/Phone number (302) 378-9881SEC 7 UNIQUE IDENTIFIER (PCTSNo.Assigned by NM FS)DATE REPORTED:Month 12 Day 10Year2014DATE EXAMINED:Month 12 Day 10 Year 2014"--ISPECIES: (check one)l] shortnose sturgeonEl Atlantic sturgeon[I Unidentified AcipenserspeciesCheck "Unidentirsed if uncertain.See reverse side of this form foraid In Identification.CARCASS CONDITION attime examined: (check one)D] I = Fresh dead[ 2 = Moderately decomposed[] 3 = Severely decomposed[] 4 = Dried carcassEl 5 = Skeletal, scutes & cartilageLOCATION FOUND: []Offshore (Atlantic or Gulf beach) gInshore (bay, river, sound, inlet, etc)River/Body of Water Delaware River City Hancocks Bridge State NJDescriptive location (be specific Removed from Circulating Water Intake Structure (CWIS)Intake trash racks, Intake bay 11A, during routine trash rack cleaning at the Salem GeneratingStation, PSEG Nuclear LLC.Latitude 390 27'38.17 N (Dec. Degrees) Longitude 750 32'10.08 W (Dec. Degrees)SEX:9 Undetermined17 Female El MaleHow was sex determined?El NecropsyEl Eggs/milt present when pressedEl BorescopeMEASUREMENTS: Circle unitFork length 66.7 cmTotal length 76.0 cmLength E actual El estimateMouth width (inside lips, see reverse side) Not measuredInterorbital width (see reverse side) Not measuredWeight Z actual EL estimate 1.4 kgTAGS PRESENT? Examined for external tags including fin clips? L] Yes [K No Scanned for PIT tags? 0 Yes [:I NoTag # Tag Type Location of tag on carcassCARCASS DISPOSITION: (check one or more)El =Left where found[D2 = Buried[13 = Collected for necropsy/salvage[D4 = Frozen for later examination05 = Other (describe) At the direction of PSEGEnvironmental Affairs, specimen was discarded In on-site detritus/trash collection basket.Carcass Necropsied? PHOTODOCUMENTATION:I]Yes [ANo Photos/vide taken? [ Yes I- NoDate Necropsied: Disposition of Photos/Video PSEG NuclearEnvlronmental Affairs and NuclearNecropsy Lead: Regulatory Affairs personnel.SAMPLES COLLECTED? LI Yes Z NoSample How preservedDisposition (person, affiliation, use)Comments: The deceased shortnose sturgeon was collected from the Salem Circulating Water Intake Structure during routine trash rack cleanin!on 12110114, at 10:15am. Positive identification was made by Environmental Consulting Services personnel at 10:30am. The specimen wameasured, photograhed, and Inspected for tags, but none were found. The State of New Jersey DEP, Division of Fish and Wildlife, and NationiMarine Fisheries (NMFS) were contacted In regards to the incidental take at 10:46am and 10:53am respectively. Upon completion of processlntPSEG Nuclear Environmental Affairs directed that the specimen be discarded In on-site trash receptacle with other detritus material collectsduring trash rack cleaning.

Draw wounds, abnormalities, tag locations on diagram and briefly describe belowL 'IDescribe any wounds / abnormalities (note tar or oil, gear or debris entanglement, propeller damage, etc.). Please note If nowounds I abnormalities are found.At the time of the Initial observation and retrieval, the condition of the sturgeon was poor. No significant damage(deep cuts, lacerations, abrasions, missing fins, etc.) to the body was observed, however evidence of the advancedstages of decomposition were apparent, Indicating that the specimen has been deceased for an extended period oftime. A cause of death is unknown and most likely occurred at some other location within the river.Submit completed forms (within '24hour- of observation of fish): Mi ,mail to:oInbidcniy fIux'(9"78;-281-9394).-Qiiestions cain be directed ItWoi)NMF'S Protected Reso'ur~ces; Division gt,978-281-9328.Data Access Policy: Upon written request, information submitted to National Marine Fisheries Service (NOAA Fisheries) on this formwill be released to the requestor provided that the requestor credit the collector of the information and NOAA Fisheries. NOAAFisheries will notify the collector that these data have been requested and the intent of their use.