ML20207N438

Rev 1 to Equipment Environ Qualification Review of Licensee Resolution of Outstanding Issues from NRC Environ Qualification SERs & TMI Action Plan Installed Equipment, Request for Addl Info

ML20207N438
Person / Time
Site:	Davis Besse
Issue date:	04/06/1982
From:	FRANKLIN INSTITUTE
To:	NRC
Shared Package
ML20207N422	List: ML20207N438
References
CON-NRC-03-79-118, CON-NRC-3-79-118, RTR-NUREG-0737, RTR-NUREG-737 RAI-C5257-505, TAC-42508, NUDOCS 8701140217
Download: ML20207N438 (12)

Text

.

,/ ,

REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION EQUIPMENT ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION (EEQ)

REVIEW OF LICENSEES' RESOLUTION OF OUTSTANDING ISSUES FROM NRC EQUIPMENT ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION SAFETY EVALUATION REPORTS (SER) AND TMI ACTION PLAN INSTALLED EQUIPMENT The Toledo Edison Company Davis-Besse Unit 1 NRC Docket No. 50-346 December 22, 1981 NRC TAC No. 42508 Rev., 1, April 6, 1982 l

dl

._ _ Franklin Research Center A Division of The Franklin Institute The Bengmm Franklin Park *ey. Phala . Pa 19103(215)448 1000 l 8701140217 820416 l PDR ADOCK 05000346 l

P pga 1

, , RAI-C5257-505 Rev. 1, April 6, 1982 BACKGROUND Franklin Research Center (FRC) of Philadelphia, Pa. is providing assis-tance to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) for the equipment environmental qualification (EEQ) ' review of operating reactors. - FRC will perform an EEQ review of the Licensee's 90-day response to outstanding issues from the NRC Equipment Environmental Qualification Safety Evaluation Report-(SER) and the installed TMI Action Plan equipment. The review will be limited to safety-related equipment potentially exposed to a harsh environment. The results will be presented in the form of a technical evaluation report for each plant.

This request for additional information (RAI) is the result of an evaluation of the information provided by letters dated October 12, 1981 [1]

and January 30, 1981 [2].* By letter dated March 3, 1982 [5], the Licensee transmitted all of the documents requested and included three additional reports as follows:I }

h J. A. Sears Test Reports Radiation Test of E10 Series Differential Pressure Transmitters of the MCA/RRW Type Foxboro Co., 00 Aug. 1973 T3-1068 (1) h S. Corbett Seismic Qualification Test Report in Dif ferential Pressure Switches Model Numbers 288A and 289A.

Approved Engineering Test La, 26 Apr. 1979 5480-8386(1) h Environmental Qualification Test Summary for Peach Bottom 2 Barton Core Spray Header to Sparger Differential Pressure Indicating Switch General Electric, NSE $79020(1)

• Nunbers in brackets refer to citations found in the list of references.

• • Throughout the text, superscript numbers in parentheses indicate the revision in which the underlined material preceding the superscript was added.

nklin Research Center A DMuon of The FranMa inseue

. L~ .

. RAI-C5257-505 Rev. 1, April 6, 1982

4. Environmental Qualification Test Summary for Quad Cities 1 &~2 Barton Recirculation Loop Pressure Differential Pressure Indicating Switch General Electric NSE $80185(1)

A. FRC REVIEW OF THE LICENSEE'S 90-DAY RESPONSE TO THE NRC EEQ SER INFORMATION REQUESTED DATE RECEIVED BY FRC***

1. In reference to the Licensee's 90-day response [1] to the NRC SER [3], a legible single copy of each of the following qualification documents is requested in order that the FRC evaluation may proceeds

a. Wyle Laboratories Report No. 44354-1 3/11/82 [5] (1)

" Qualification Test Report for Four (4)

NEMA 4 Enclosures," March 8, 1979 (for States, Raychem).

b. Rosemount Test Report ho. 87414, 3/11/82 [5](1)

" Investigation Radiation Requirement, Model 177 HW," 8/16/74

c. Foxboro Company Test Report No. T2-1075, 3/11/82 [5) (1)

" Radiation Test of E10 Series Differential Pressure Transmitter of the Standard Construction Type," August, 1973.

d. Rosemount Test Report No. 12756B Rev. A, 3/11/82 [5) (1)

"Rosemount Modified Model 1152 Pressure Transmitter Environmental Class lA Equipment," 12/5/75.

e. NAM 00 Qualification Report, " Estimation 3/11/82 [5](1) of Qualified Life of EA740-20000 Rev. C, D, or E, Revised 2/27/80.

i l f. Microswitch Engineering Report No. Deleted [5] (1) i LTR-24407, " Preliminary Evaluation of

'LS,' 'HS,' ' CMC,' 'PT,' and ' Series 2' Type Switches Under Electrical Aging, l Environssental Aging, and Seismic Vibration Tests."

i f ***This column will be completed by FRC as the requested information is received.-

nklin Research Center A DMoon of The Franhan insomse

l

' .. l

. = .

l i _

- RAI-C5257-505 -l Rev. 1, April 6, 1982 DATE RECEIVED BY FRC***

g. ITT Barton Report No. R3-288A-1, "IEEE 3/11/82 [5](1) 344-1975 Seismic and Radiation l

Qualification Tests for ITT Barton Differential Pressure Indicating

Switches Models 288A and 289A. )

h. Summary Report No. QSR 027-A-01, BNR 3/11/82 [5](1) '

Equipment Qualification Summary, Barton Model 288 Differential Pressure Switch, 10/2/80.

i. ITT General Controls Engineering Report 3/11/82 [5](1)

No. 721.77.095 ADDENDUM $2,

" Certification of NH90 Series Actuators For 50"C (122*F) Ambient Temperature and 20,000 hour0 days <br />0 hours <br />0 weeks <br />0 months <br /> Usage at 60% Rated Load,"

5/16/81.

j. ITT General Controls Engineering Report 3/11/82 [5](1)

No. 721.77.095 ADDENDUM 95, " Summary of NH90 (Model B) Series Actuator Supplemental Generic Qualification Testing for Class lE Requirements, i Outside Containment," 2/10/80.

k. Letter of 6/4/81 from ASCO to EDS 3/11/82 [5](1) containing materials lists for ASCO coils.

1. Intter of 6/18/81 from ASCO to EDS 3/11/82 [5](1) containing Class A and Class F coil lead wires.

m. Letter of 6/8/81 from ASCO to Toledo 5/11/82 [5](1) l Edison Co. concerning environmental I qualification of ASCO valves.

n. Letter of 9/22/81 from Bailey Meter Co. 3/11/82 [5] (1) to EDS concerning Bailey Meter Materials lists.

o. Letter of 5/21/81 from Barksdale to EDS 3/11/82 [5] (1) containing Non-Metallic Material List for I T2H-M155S Temperature Switch.

p. Letter of 10/30/75 from Boston Insulated 3/11/82 [5] (1)

Wire and Cable Co. to Bechtel concerning ,

IDCA simulation tests of LIW cable. j r nklin Research Center I A Dhesson of The F#enhhn Insuute

.e a .

. RAI-CS257-505 Rev. 1, April 6, 1982 4

DATE RECEIVED BY FRC***

q. Letter of 3/26/81 from Fenwal to EDS ) 3/11/82 [5](1) concerning non-metallic parts in Fenwal 27120-22 Thermoswitch.

c. Letter of 4/21/81 from Foxboro to EDS 3/11/82 [5](1) concerning environmental qualification of Foxboro transmitters.

s. Letter of 4/13/81 from General Dynamics 3/11/82 [5] (1) to EDS concerning Stator Coil Insulation materials for Electro Dynamic Motors.

t. Letter of 3/26/81 from Differential 3/11/82 [5] (1)

Pressure Instruments to EDS concerning non-metallic parts in ITT Barton Pressure Indicating Switches Models 288A and 289A.

, u. Letter of 6/17/81 f rom D.P.I. to EDS 3/11/82 [51(1) concerning materials used in 288 and 289 .

ITT Barton Differential Pressure Switch.

v. Letter of 6/5/81 from Licon to EDS 3/11/82 [5](1) concerning materials in Barton parts Nos.

00068-004-T and 5891-0001-Z.

I w. Letter of 6/19/81 from Kerite to EDS 3/11/82 [ 5] (1)

concerning submergence of Kerite Cable.

3

x. Letter of 4/27/79 from B&W to TECO 3/11/82 [5]II) concerning Limitorque test reports.

y. Letter of 7/28/80 from B&W to Bechtel 3/11/82 [5]III

concerning Limitorque test reports. ,

! i l

z. Letter of 11/5/80 from Limitorque to TECO 3/11/82 [5] (1) concerning Limitorque test reports.

l aa. Letter of 6/1/81 from B&W to TECO 3/11/82 [ 5) (1) i concerning Limitorque test reports.

bb. Letter of 7/13/81 from Bechtel to EDS 3/11/82 [5] (1) concerning Limitorque test reports.

cc. Letter of 7/21/81 from Limitorque to EDS 3/11/82 [5) (1) concerning Limitorque test reports. i I

dd. Letter of 7/7/81 f rom Limitorque to EDS 3/11/82 [5] II)

, concerning Limitorque test reports.

I

?

• j >s

! branklin Research Center 1 A w on ann. n.n.an v.mui.

e - .

• RAI-C5257-505 Rev. 1, April 6, 1982 DATE RECEIVED BY FRC***

ee. Letter of 4/28/81 from Microswitch to EDS 3/11/82 [5]II) containing parts list for Microswitch ILS3.

ff. Letter of 4/28/81 from Microswitch to EDS 3/11/82 [5]III parts list for Microswitch LSD2B-4N.

gg. Letter of 5/1/81 from Okonite to EDS 3/11/82 [5] (1) containing data on EP insulation.

hh. Letter of 9/18/81 from Raychem to EDS 3/11/82 [5] (1) concerning Moisture Resistance of WCSF-N Heat Shrink Tubing.

ii. Letter of 11/10/81 from Rees to Bechtel 3/11/82 [5] (1) containing Rees lists of components and materials lists.

jj. Letter of 3/11/81 f rom Rees to EDS 3/11/82 [5] (1) containing Material List for Pushbutton Switches.

kk. Letter of 4/2/81 from Rees to EDS 3/11/82 [5] (1) containing Material List for Pushbutton Switches.

11. Letter of 7/14/80 from Stanwick to 3/11/82 [5) (1)

Bechtel containing component materials lists and testing documentation for Stanwick Terminal Blocks.

mm. Letter of 2/18/81 from Stanwick to EDS 3/11/82 [5)(1) containing component materials lists and testing data for Stanwick Type G Terminal Block.

nn. Letter of 1/27/78 from States to Yankee 3/11/82 [5) (1)

Atomic Electric concerning States NT and ZWM Terminal Blocks.

oo. Letter or 9/18/80 f rom Southern Company 3/11/82 [5] II) services concerning Wyle Test Report l 44354-1.

f pp. Letter of 2/9/81 f rom States to EDS 3/11/82 [51 (1) concerning States ZWM and NT Terminal Block materials.

c

1. Eh UbA Franklin w a om. n.noaResearch m.ww Cen.ter

i .

e a .

• RAI-C5257-505 Eev. 1, April 6, 1982

> DATE RECEIVED BY FRC***

qq. Letter of 12/9/80 from SOR to TECO 3/11/82 [5](1) containing material lists for non-metallic parts in SOR pressure switches.

tr. Letter of 7/9/81 from SOR to EDS 3/11/82 [5](1) concerning qualification of SOR Pressure Switches.

ss. Letter of 7/20/81 from Westinghouse to 3/11/82 [5](1)

EDS containing environmental

. qualification documentation for Westinghouse Hydrog.n Dilution System Motors.

tt. Letter of 8/15/80 from Toledo Edison Co. 3/11/82 [5] (1) to Babcock and Wilcox concerning HPI and LPI pumps.

uu. Telephone conversation of 7/30/81 between 3/11/82 [5] (1)

F. Levancosti and J. Thompson concerning standard test time for Equipment Qualification Tests.

vv. EDS Calculation 1040-001-038, Arrhenius 3/11/82 [5](1)

Model for Rosemount, Foxboro, and Bailey i Transmitters.

! ww. EDS Calculation 1040-001-040, Low pH 3/11/82 [5]II)

Analysis for Components Tested in a High

[

pH Chemical Spray.

I

! xx. EDS Calculation 1040-001-042, Chemical 3/11/82 [5] III l Spray Analysis of Safety-Related l Components.

I yy. Boston Insulated Wire & Cable Company 3/11/82 [5)(1)

Prototype Test Report No. 73C212, 6/18/73

22. Amphenol SAMS Operation Technical Report 3/11/82 [5) (1) 123-1268, "Special Prototype Radiation, Environmental and Short Circuit Testing of a Type 2 Low Voltage Power Penetration Assembly used on Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station Unit No. 1," 3/12/75.

~., nklin Res,e_ n,. arch Center

, e e

. . RAI-C5257-505 Rev. 1, April 6, 1982 B. FHC REVIIEt OF INSTALLED TMI ACTION PLAN ITEMS INFORMATION REQUESTED DATE RECEIVED BY FRC***

1. The correlation of the installed TMI equipment items with the specific sections of NUREG-0737 [4] is requested.

a. Identification of all TMI Action Plan equipment installed after 1/1/81 is requested.

b. The approximate installation date for the TMI Action Plan equipment items is requested so that the appropriate qualification criteria (NUREG-0588 or DDR Guidelines) can be used in the EEQ evaluation.

2. The qualification documents, e.g., the actual test reports and associated correspondence cited as evidence of qualification listed on the SCEW sheets, for all identified 'IMI Action Plan equipment are requested. [The identification of those reports considered to be proprietary is requested so that proper control of documents can be maintained.)

3. Where the Licensee has a standard Owners' Group position with respect to a NUREG-0737 technical area or has requested extensions of implementation dates, this information is requested in order to incorporate it into the review.

C. INSTRUCTIONS FOR TRANSMITTING INFORMATION REQUESTED

1. The schedule for completion of the FRC assignment requires that the Licensee provide the roquested information within 3 weeks of the date of the RAI.

2. The Licensee may transmit the requested information as follows:

o complete package directly to the NRC project manager or 14 0 O.

i -[E'3 ranklin Research Cen A Dueton of the Fre%2n inetsue.ter

• e

. RAI-C5257-505 Rev. 1, April 6, 1982 o copy of cover letter to NRC project manager and complete package to FRC.

FHC mailing address is as follows:

Mr. Cyril J. Crane Franklin Research Center i The Parkway at Twentieth Street

, Philadelphia, PA 19103 Telephone No. 215/448-1353 Telecopy No. 215/448-1296 Telecopy ConfArmation No. 215/448-1215 4

1 T

i i

l I

I i

l s

.i i

i i

l f

1 i

(

)

x .

U bceuliFranklin 4 w ae m r,. nan m Research Cen.ter

e e e RAI-C5257-505 Rev. 1, April 6, 1982 REFERENCE 3 3

1. R. P. Crouse Letter to J. F. Stolz, NRC.

Subject:

Response to SER for the Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment at Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station Toledo Edison Co., 12-Oct-81 Serial No. 750

2. R. P. Crouse Letter to J. Keppler, NRC.

Subject:

Revision 3 of response to IE Bulletin 79-018 for Davis-Basse Nuclear Power Station Unit 1

'Ibledo Edison, 30-Jan-81 1-184

3. Of fice of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Safety Evaluation Report for Davis-Besse Unit 1 e Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment NHC, 05-Jun-81

4. NUREG-0737, " Clarification of TMI Action Plan Requirements" NRC, November 1980

,5_., R. 1. Crouse Letter to J. F. Stolz, NRC. Subiect: Transmittal of Requested Information Concerning Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment at Davis-Besse Unit 1 Toledo Edison, 03 Mar. 1982 A82-156B W I

i i

p3 Y'

0b OIIFranklin Research Center Atwa a.emrmen m .

9 9

, o

, RAI-C5257-508 Rev. 5, April 7, 1982 REFERENCES

1. E. R. Mathews and C. W. Geisler Letter to J. G. Keppler, NRC.

Subject:

Response to IE Bulletin 79-Olu, Supplement 3 Wisconsin Public Service Corp., 02-Feb-81 NRC-81-15

2. E. R. Mathews and C. A. Schrock Letter to S. A. Varga, NRC. Subject Kewaunee Nuclear Power Plant; Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Elec-trical Equipment Response to NRC SER Wisconsin Public Service Corp., 21-Sep-81 N RC-81-159

3. Of fice of Nuclear Reactor Regulation hafety Evaluation Report for Kewaunee Nuclear Power Plant Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment NRC, 1981

4. E. R. Mathews Letter to J. G. Keppler, NRC. Subjects Kevaunce Nuclear Power Plant, IE Bulletin 7 9-01B, Qualification of Class AE Equipment, with attachments Wisconsin Public Service Corp. 10-Oct-80

5. NUREG-0737, " Clarification of TMI Action Plan Requirements" NRC, November 1980 bz E. R. Ma thews Lotter to S. A. Varga, NRC. Subjects Kewaunee Nuclear Power Plant. . .lligh Energy Line Breaks (llELBs) and Submergence Outside of Containment Wisconsin Public Service Corp., 15-Dec-81 NRC-81-204(1) 73 E. R. Mathews Letter to S. A. Varga, NRC. Subject Kewaunee Nuclear Power Planti Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment -

Heta Done Equipment Qualification Wisconsin Public Service Corp., 02-Nov-81 NRC-81-178(2)

/%

ll$lFrankhn a tw a e n. r.. Resea.rch

. m.w. Center

a

• o r . RAI-C5257-508 Rev. 5, April 7, 1982

. 8. E. R. Mathews l Letter to S. A. Varga, NRC. Subjects Kewaunee Nuclear Power Plantt Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment -

Chemical Spray Wisconsin Public Service Corp., 29-Jan-82 (3) h Postulated Pipe Failure Analysis Wisconsin Public Service Corp.

FSAR App. 10-A(4)

10. E. R. Mathews Letter to S. A. Varga, NRC. Subjects Kewaunee Nuclear Power Plant; Environmental Qualification of Class lE Electrical Equipment Wisconsin Public Service, 26-Feb-82

NRC-82-35, 074-TA-508 (5) i

11. E. R. Mathews

! Letter to S. A. Varga, NRC. Subjects Kewaunee Nuclear Power Plants Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electric Equipment 4 Request for Additional Information Wisconsin Public Service, 18-Mar-82 N RC-82-46 ( 5) 1 i

i I

l l

i i

i k

i

+

1 2

1 4

1. M I

db Atm Franklin Rese.

onw N r,,enm. u arch C.e n.ter

--. ,- - _____ _ -- - ,., _ _ .- _ - - .m _ _ - _ , _ , . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ , _ - - _ - - . _ _ - - _ , , , _ _ , . . -