ML19310A379

Motion to Quash Applicant 800429 Motion to Compel Production of Documents from C Hinderstein & Tx Pirg.No Written Contract or Agreement W/Saxion Exists.Other Info Requested Is Under Third Party Control.Certificate of Svc Encl

ML19310A379
Person / Time
Site:	Allens Creek File:Houston Lighting and Power Company icon.png
Issue date:	06/03/1980
From:	Hinderstein C AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To:	Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
NUDOCS 8006110170
Download: ML19310A379 (4)

Text

. ; r- .m - ;::: .--:-- -

. ~-- ... ;-

Juna 3, 1980 g w r, .

- . : -t , .. ~. ... s j -

.;< ? .F .-

DOCKETED e

-

2

-

usuno

-- '

" ~ -

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

'

JUN 61980 * '-

-

[~ -

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION \s, Omes cf de &&4 S Oceks;& Scate

~

-

"

BEFORE'THE TOMIC dAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD p h sy s .q ,\

.In the Matter of 5

.

S

-

HOUSTON LIGHTING &. POWER COMPANY $ Docket No. 50-466

. 5 (Allens Creek Nuclear Generating S

- : Station, Unit 1) 5

-

INTERVENOR CARRO HINDERSTEIN'S MOTION TC QUASH

- APPLICANT'S MOTION TO COMPEL'-THE . PRODUCTION. OF DOCUMENTS

. - . . ;. ; .:. ? . i:: = c.:.:.e: '

..

wn_ . . -

.  ;-..3 n ari:::.;n Ir=.n:n - - f '- V

. .Inte.rvenor --CARRO-HINDERSTEIN,'. submits the following points

. . _ : . .. _ . ;  :: : r - - : - - -. : 1 - n in opp.osition:to :Appliddnt's Motion to Compel the Production of Documents from Inter.venor_CAPRO.HINDERSTEIN and TEXPIRG sent to

-

. ! : -:::

Intervenors on April 29, .1980, .as. amended by. letter dated May 20, 1980_e from -Jac_k R. Newman under United States Nuclear Regulatory

_.:-

.

-

Commission Rul_es.and_ Regula.Cionic714-S:E.R Sf.5-ha(c)-(3).,._(4) , _  !

. . .

.

-. . .. . . .

- . . . . . . .. .- - - -- . . . . -

.--

-

. . . - - -

. - - - - --

- - -

an d ( 6 );., _. _ _.  ; _. .; . ;;,,7

..  :. . _ ..  ; ; .. - _ :. : i: .:: .--:.

-

.

7 m: ~ 1 : -  ;-

--.:: :: ::-.:::: :::.- ::- */.. :: :::::ci '

-

_ ;:: - ..::::: _ . _ . .:A:.

My contract with Mr. Saxion is by verbal agreement and no written contract or agreement exists. Therefore, Applicant's request for "(1) Copies,of_any contracts,. agreements, or written

-

.-...: ;

assignments between Mr. Saxion and Ms. Hind'erstein or TexPirg,"

is an impossibility. Both Mr. Saxion and myself have said, und'er ,

I cath, that I have employed Mr. Saxion as an expert witness. I

.. -

Intervenor reque'sts that this request be quashed / #' l ' ".

1

!

--

,.

'

-

II . - . (i.~~ -

,

Mr. Saxion currently works for Gutierrez, Smouse,'Wilmut ,,_ l

& Associates. He is currently involved in three projects --

go3 )

9

. .. .-

o \

!

l I

l 1

8 0 o e 3 3,ojyo zg _

-

__ _ _ _.

, ,

-

. . . .

.

..:.p n z.- . .

. . . , .-- . . ~:---- - .-- m ,m; v. ~ >. ' . ~

= -w.

, .- *., J . *- t r*..'.q

G ., , *, ,* *'*l

.,

"

• s. s- * .* * *

% .

, .

?.h*  ; y 'n'g +:. . '

J s *k 4

'

.

. L i.* *

. -

7:.:

• . .. .

.

,

. q: . -

,

.- . - - - -

'

. .. .

• '

..

. .a.

> ,e . . .- c..- . -

- .-

r r . . *- -' involving the water .a'vailability':in. the Brazos River Basin for  ;.

)..- m-- -

.

-

r

. : EG. . . ..vu

. . .

-

-

5 '

i F -~ the citiles of .+-McGregor, Cleburne, and. Freeport. These works'

.

-;- n.,

j} ;. .

. : are = ..in.progfess' .' .

.

. .. .._ , ,

.

, , ,7. . y 7 - .- - ,;

" ' , ,

n~o'w witih no" final ~ report. Intervenor requests

, ^: --- - - -

. .

. .. .

.~

~ that Applicant's request for '.'(3)

'

,

-

~~ ^ Copies of all project reports

-

.  :.T ' .- :. . '

. .:.  % ..~ .1. . ; -

i

_

listed in .paragraph (2) above that discuss the availability of G- . .. . . . . .- ..

. w .:- ly ;; ... .

>

_..

water'in thetBrazos River Basin, specifically including reports

. . . . . . .

-

..

. . . . , . .. . - . for the citi,es..of . . . . -

McGregorfand'Cleburne,". be quashed.

. . - . . ., .. . . .

As these.

. .

' . . . - . . . ..... . ....v.. ......:..... .:. ..  : e. - . ..., '

... c. .; . '

' p ,M

'

- ,

-

project'5'Jasi]6iiipIEtiid,.;they w'il1~b~e~come "public'~and be avai1~able

.,' ..

- - - +: . - . :- 8 :- - . - .~< -

• for inspection.and copying by the' cities that have commissioned-

_. . . . --

. ..

them; n - ~ -- - - - -

.: . ; ; - r. -

- - --

r. . . . - - e. -III. ._

__ ..

i -As. for Applicant's request for "(2)- A list of all projects

'

-

in~which.Mr. S.axion has participated and in which research was

.

. dondneted on the availability-of water to municipalities or --

_ _:

other clients who have employed Mr. Saxion or his firm," -

. __ . . . - -. .

Mr. Saxion has in.his.first deposition referred to some such projects he was. involved.in. However, some of the information Applicant seeks is .from private ' clients of Mr. Saxion's current or prior firms, and such information~is not disclosable and not--

available to Mr.:Saxion. <The information is under.the control of a third party.and not-in the possession of Mr. Saxion.

. . . .: .

, In conclusion, Intervenor CARRO HINDERSTEIN requests that Applicant's Motion to Compel the Projection of Documents from

'

Intervenors CARRO HINDERSTEIN and TEXPIRG as amended by quashed

.. . .. . . . . . .. .

as it applies to the instant Intervenor. Mr. Saxion has in good

,

_.

. . _ , . .  ;,

. -

I

-

2-

.

. . .

~u - .

_ ._

.

-

.

3. 3. . :, :,*. .,. .-...a.: .2._u.-_.- . :-, .,-n . .r=.~::-~

. - -

- ---. .: * . . ;.1 - . + w - a J - : . 3.. r. ". . .g= . = -

.n-

.

-

c : . ..

.-

_ ; u ._--  :: .- . . ?. . ... --

-

-

i . :zQ *&. , . . . v .. ::s==, - L :Wi. .; . x s .: . . .: *:.: . 2 .1^: *E; Q . .. * *

. ~. '? .. =

a - m. :

. .

-

.. : nn- -:. .: u-- -

.- .-

a. g ; ' .

.

.;. =

; .. - .:  : . w.n., - .. - ,.. ...^ ;.. . .A. - .. u .: . . ...: - .. . . ..m y unc % ;.- .- '-

e..n' .. . " ' !.: - . .. -

.

, . - . - . .

. .: .L. . . , . . . . . -. . y. .

7

- - - -

• D

.

b u.'.

'

.n_ l faith.'sub'mitied 't'o one- depositiion and will be deposed again ' .

rf.+y;. . dl .- - G ' . ; . -<: , - ..

.

m a, . . .... , . T ., a ..

..'.......

-

-.'~'I

., GtE- U- Juna, 1.751980. .'A6f"f6rtlidr &Teion5"End T requeses for material

. . - , . ..

.

-

.-,... ..m. .

._

~ ~ _ .

.that_ is"not 16 ~ eiistence or under= the' control of 'a third party

~

C 7 -

-

x.

'

ss

..

=. >- ......, . .

.

. . . .

-

'

g.3=dh-;- would"Eonstit6te harassm.en[and causs: unreasonable expense to .

-.== ::..= -w .=..w...--.m.=..., -

' * " " l ' N -. .""' F L- ' ' ' ~ ..~~ ~

.

.. . ..

,

if ?-. .: .:1:=^ .

c6'mbdt.W . :- . ...- ' -

-

'

7. - E -3Y "' ~- ?t

'

! - ? _.~.M=EC

' 4.2 L'i.: a 1.- " .' . '2?. ~' .

..;. Intervenor woul'd~no'e t that Mr. Saxion'has~sent working

-

. U- .-T.

.g . . . . . ; , . -

.

m.  ;;p 4.._.

-

.

., .. _

'

. - r .-2dc _ , . papers,_ speeches} ,tiistimony, letters', and studies to Applicant -

,

- .- . __.. .. ..

. u - oe . . -..-. . . m .r,._ T r ..:.. ._.. .

.

. i . ... . . . . , . . - - - . . ._.

,

, ,..

• in ~ compliance. wiith.~ i:hilr;,v...

._ _ . ..

request. - -

,

.. ,.2 . , . .

". . ~'.

.

, . ' "

. .

h R. _,

Resp ~ectfully submitted, u- . ,

i. .

- -

-. ,

e-- -

. I - . .' . l

• '

QQ .-

)-

'.n . c., .. 5 . v. ._ .

~~ ~

..; CARRO HINDERSTEIN,.Intervenor j 8739 Link" Terrace'

~ ~ ' '

" ~

. .r : . e Houston, Texas 77025 '

. - .

'

CERTIFICATE OF bERVICE

-

, . _

-

. .

~~

. . -

.. . _ . ..

I hereby certify that true and' correct' copies of the above

~

-and foregoing Intervenor Carro Hinderstein's Motion to Quash

~-

' App 1'icant's Moti6n to Compel the Production of Documents, in the

,above captioned proceeding, were ser.ved on the following by dep~osit in the United States mail postage' pre-paid, this 3rd day of June 1980: -.. ..

. . ._

Sheldon J. Wolfe, Esq., Chairman Chase R. Stephens Atomic Safetf and Licensing Docketing and Service Section Board Panel..- ~

Office of.the Secretary of U.S. Nuclear Regula~ tory Commission the~ Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission

._ .- .

.. Washington, D.C. 20555 i

Dr. E. Leonard'Che'at'sm ~~ -

,

Route 3, Box 350A -. Jack R. Newman Watkinsville, Georgia 30677 1025 Connecticut Ave., N.W.

umehincten, D.C. 20036 Mr. Gustave A. Lin~enberger

~

. Atomic Safety.and Licensing ~ ~"~ ~

. . J. Gregory Copeland Board Panel

~

.

3000 One Shell Plaza U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Houston, Texas 77002 Washington, D.C. 20555

-

. -- - .. . - - - .

. . _ . . _ _ _ _ _ __ ._ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

.

'

p .**;y . .

- :~.:-} .- . 7 :"'--'}:; -Q ' ~ ~ *

. 2 :- ~-

el

• _ , . r ;, _

. .

2 .? .. . . . -

, - - - - -

.

-

,,

,. . _ . , ,.

-.

- - . . , - '-

. -..

l .

-

-"

...

_ ~ . ...

.

. . .

.

_

-.--

,

- - - - _

[ __

' --

.

-

_ Richard Lowerre, Esq .Z..' '-- .F. H. Potthoff, III

[ ~As sis tant Attorne9 ' General ~' ' " - --- -~~ 7200 Shady Villa, #110 for the State of Texas --~

-

Houston, Texas 77080

-

P. O Box 12548 :-

~

,  != ~

' ' ~

.. J - < Capitol Station -- - - - .

Wayne E. Rentfro

- ~; Austin,._ Texas- 78711 -'t ' ' ' '

P. O. Box 1335

-

.:.. ,,

.

. :- - . - Rosenberg, Texas 77471

-

Atomic Safety and Licensing.. .

'

n._. . Board Panel James M. Scott, Jr.

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory' Commission-

~ , ,,

-

' ~13935 Ivy Mount Washington, D.C. 20555..- r. Sugar Land, Texas 77478

~

.

o. . .. .,.

.e . .. v- -

.

4 S teve' Soilinki, 'Esq".' .~ Y'- ". Stephen A. Doggett, Esq.

Stiaff 'Cosns'el ' 2--

'

C'2

-

P. O. Box 592

• U.S. Nuclear Regulatory _Rosenberg,. Texas 77471 Commission - -' '

Washington, D.C. 20555 '

Bryan L. Baker 1923 Hawthorne John F. Doherty

~

Houston, Texas 77098 4327 Alconbury Street Houston, Texas 77021 J. Morgan Bishop

" ~ ~

' Margaret Bishop D. Marrack . ..

11418 Oak Spring 420 Mulberry Lane -

--

'Hauscon,. Texas 77043 Bellaire, Texas *

.

,

77401 TexPIRG Brenda McCorkle . _ -- . .At tention : Clarence Johnson 6140 Darnell .

- - - - ' -

' Executive Director Houston, Texas 77074 Box 237 U.C.

. ;=- -- University of Houston'

_' f~T .- ,

Houston, Texas 77004

. . . . .. ..

.

N JAd

~

. AAAD __. _

CARRO HINDERSTEIN

-

. -.. . . .

_

. .

.

. . . . . . . .

_,

.

'

-

--

.

__

.

-

.

,

.

. . - . . . . . .