ML19310A379

Motion to Quash Applicant 800429 Motion to Compel Production of Documents from C Hinderstein & Tx Pirg.No Written Contract or Agreement W/Saxion Exists.Other Info Requested Is Under Third Party Control.Certificate of Svc Encl

ML19310A379
Person / Time
Site:	Allens Creek File:Houston Lighting and Power Company icon.png
Issue date:	06/03/1980
From:	Hinderstein C AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To:	Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
NUDOCS 8006110170
Download: ML19310A379 (4)

Text

. ; r- .m - ;::: .--:-- -

. ~-- ... ;-

Juna 3, 1980 g w r, .

- . : -t , .. ~. ... s j -

.;< ? .F .-

DOCKETED e

2 usuno

" ~ -

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA JUN 61980 * '-

[~ -

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION \s, Omes cf de &&4 S Oceks;& Scate

~

BEFORE'THE TOMIC dAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD p h sy s .q ,\

.In the Matter of 5 S

HOUSTON LIGHTING &. POWER COMPANY $ Docket No. 50-466

. 5 (Allens Creek Nuclear Generating S

- : Station, Unit 1) 5 INTERVENOR CARRO HINDERSTEIN'S MOTION TC QUASH

- APPLICANT'S MOTION TO COMPEL'-THE . PRODUCTION. OF DOCUMENTS

. - . . ;. ; .:. ? . i:: = c.:.:.e: '

wn_ . . -

.  ;-..3 n ari:::.;n Ir=.n:n - - f '- V

. .Inte.rvenor --CARRO-HINDERSTEIN,'. submits the following points

. . _ : . .. _ . ;  :: : r - - : - - -. : 1 - n in opp.osition:to :Appliddnt's Motion to Compel the Production of Documents from Inter.venor_CAPRO.HINDERSTEIN and TEXPIRG sent to Intervenors on April 29, .1980, .as. amended by. letter dated May 20, 1980_e from -Jac_k R. Newman under United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Rul_es.and_ Regula.Cionic714-S:E.R Sf.5-ha(c)-(3).,._(4) , _  !

an d ( 6 );., _. _ _.  ; _. .; . ;;,,7

..  :. . _ ..  ; ; .. - _ :. : i: .:: .--:.

7 m: ~ 1 : -  ;-

--.:: :: ::-.:::: :::.- ::- */.. :: :::::ci '

_ ;:: - ..::::: _ . _ . .:A:.

My contract with Mr. Saxion is by verbal agreement and no written contract or agreement exists. Therefore, Applicant's request for "(1) Copies,of_any contracts,. agreements, or written assignments between Mr. Saxion and Ms. Hind'erstein or TexPirg,"

is an impossibility. Both Mr. Saxion and myself have said, und'er ,

I cath, that I have employed Mr. Saxion as an expert witness. I Intervenor reque'sts that this request be quashed / #' l ' ".

1 II . - . (i.~~ -

Mr. Saxion currently works for Gutierrez, Smouse,'Wilmut ,,_ l

& Associates. He is currently involved in three projects --

go3 )

9 o \

l I

l 1

8 0 o e 3 3,ojyo zg _

..:.p n z.- . .

. . . , .-- . . ~:---- - .-- m ,m; v. ~ >. ' . ~

= -w.

, .- *., J . *- t r*..'.q G ., , *, ,* *'*l

• s. s- * .* * *

?.h*  ; y 'n'g +:. . '

J s *k 4

. L i.*

• 7:.:

. q: . -

. .a.

> ,e . . .- c..- . -

- .-

r r . . *- -' involving the water .a'vailability':in. the Brazos River Basin for  ;.

)..- m-- -

r

. : EG. . . ..vu

5 '

i F -~ the citiles of .+-McGregor, Cleburne, and. Freeport. These works'

-;- n.,

j} ;. .

. : are = ..in.progfess' .' .

, , ,7. . y 7 - .- - ,;

n~o'w witih no" final ~ report. Intervenor requests

, ^: --- - - -

.~

~ that Applicant's request for '.'(3)

~~ ^ Copies of all project reports

.  :.T ' .- :. . '

. .:.  % ..~ .1. . ; -

i listed in .paragraph (2) above that discuss the availability of G- . .. . . . . .- ..

. w .:- ly ;; ... .

water'in thetBrazos River Basin, specifically including reports

. . . . , . .. . - . for the citi,es..of . . . . -

McGregorfand'Cleburne,". be quashed.

As these.

' . . . - . . . ..... . ....v.. ......:..... .:. ..  : e. - . ..., '

... c. .; . '

' p ,M project'5'Jasi]6iiipIEtiid,.;they w'il1~b~e~come "public'~and be avai1~able

- - - +: . - . :- 8 :- - . - .~< -

for inspection.and copying by the' cities that have commissioned-them; n - ~ -- - - - -

.: . ; ; - r. -

r. . . . - - e. -III. ._

i -As. for Applicant's request for "(2)- A list of all projects in~which.Mr. S.axion has participated and in which research was

. dondneted on the availability-of water to municipalities or --

other clients who have employed Mr. Saxion or his firm," -

Mr. Saxion has in.his.first deposition referred to some such projects he was. involved.in. However, some of the information Applicant seeks is .from private ' clients of Mr. Saxion's current or prior firms, and such information~is not disclosable and not--

available to Mr.:Saxion. <The information is under.the control of a third party.and not-in the possession of Mr. Saxion.

, In conclusion, Intervenor CARRO HINDERSTEIN requests that Applicant's Motion to Compel the Projection of Documents from Intervenors CARRO HINDERSTEIN and TEXPIRG as amended by quashed as it applies to the instant Intervenor. Mr. Saxion has in good I

2-

~u - .

3. 3. . :, :,*. .,. .-...a.: .2._u.-_.- . :-, .,-n . .r=.~::-~

- ---. .: * . . ;.1 - . + w - a J - : . 3.. r. ". . .g= . = -

.n-c : . ..

_ ; u ._--  :: .- . . ?. . ... --

i . :zQ *&. , . . . v .. ::s==, - L :Wi. .; . x s .: . . .: *:.: . 2 .1^: *E; Q . .. * *

. ~. '? .. =

a - m. :

.. : nn- -:. .: u-- -

a. g ; ' .

.;. =

; .. - .:  : . w.n., - .. - ,.. ...^ ;.. . .A. - .. u .: . . ...: - .. . . ..m y unc % ;.- .- '-

e..n' .. . " ' !.: - . .. -

. .: .L. . . , . . . . . -. . y. .

7 D

b u.'.

.n_ l faith.'sub'mitied 't'o one- depositiion and will be deposed again ' .

rf.+y;. . dl .- - G ' . ; . -<: , - ..

m a, . . .... , . T ., a ..

-.'~'I

., GtE- U- Juna, 1.751980. .'A6f"f6rtlidr &Teion5"End T requeses for material

.-,... ..m. .

~ ~ _ .

.that_ is"not 16 ~ eiistence or under= the' control of 'a third party

~

C 7 -

x.

ss

=. >- ......, . .

g.3=dh-;- would"Eonstit6te harassm.en[and causs: unreasonable expense to .

-.== ::..= -w .=..w...--.m.=..., -

' * " " l ' N -. .""' F L- ' ' ' ~ ..~~ ~

if ?-. .: .:1:=^ .

c6'mbdt.W . :- . ...- ' -

7. - E -3Y "' ~- ?t

! - ? _.~.M=EC

' 4.2 L'i.: a 1.- " .' . '2?. ~' .

..;. Intervenor woul'd~no'e t that Mr. Saxion'has~sent working

. U- .-T.

.g . . . . . ; , . -

m.  ;;p 4.._.

. - r .-2dc _ , . papers,_ speeches} ,tiistimony, letters', and studies to Applicant -

- .- . __.. .. ..

. u - oe . . -..-. . . m .r,._ T r ..:.. ._.. .

. i . ... . . . . , . . - - - . . ._.

in ~ compliance. wiith.~ i:hilr;,v...

request. - -

.. ,.2 . , . .

". . ~'.

h R. _,

Resp ~ectfully submitted, u- . ,

i. .

e-- -

. I - . .' . l QQ .-

)-

'.n . c., .. 5 . v. ._ .

~~ ~

..; CARRO HINDERSTEIN,.Intervenor j 8739 Link" Terrace'

~ ~ ' '

" ~

. .r : . e Houston, Texas 77025 '

CERTIFICATE OF bERVICE

~~

I hereby certify that true and' correct' copies of the above

~

-and foregoing Intervenor Carro Hinderstein's Motion to Quash

~-

' App 1'icant's Moti6n to Compel the Production of Documents, in the

,above captioned proceeding, were ser.ved on the following by dep~osit in the United States mail postage' pre-paid, this 3rd day of June 1980: -.. ..

Sheldon J. Wolfe, Esq., Chairman Chase R. Stephens Atomic Safetf and Licensing Docketing and Service Section Board Panel..- ~

Office of.the Secretary of U.S. Nuclear Regula~ tory Commission the~ Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission

.. Washington, D.C. 20555 i

Dr. E. Leonard'Che'at'sm ~~ -

Route 3, Box 350A -. Jack R. Newman Watkinsville, Georgia 30677 1025 Connecticut Ave., N.W.

umehincten, D.C. 20036 Mr. Gustave A. Lin~enberger

~

. Atomic Safety.and Licensing ~ ~"~ ~

. . J. Gregory Copeland Board Panel

~

3000 One Shell Plaza U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Houston, Texas 77002 Washington, D.C. 20555

p .**;y . .

- :~.:-} .- . 7 :"'--'}:; -Q ' ~ ~ *

. 2 :- ~-

el

• _ , . r ;, _

2 .? .. . . . -

l .

_ ~ . ...

[ __

_ Richard Lowerre, Esq .Z..' '-- .F. H. Potthoff, III

[ ~As sis tant Attorne9 ' General ~' ' " - --- -~~ 7200 Shady Villa, #110 for the State of Texas --~

Houston, Texas 77080 P. O Box 12548 :-

~

,  != ~

' ' ~

.. J - < Capitol Station -- - - - .

Wayne E. Rentfro

- ~; Austin,._ Texas- 78711 -'t ' ' ' '

P. O. Box 1335

. :- - . - Rosenberg, Texas 77471 Atomic Safety and Licensing.. .

n._. . Board Panel James M. Scott, Jr.

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory' Commission-

~ , ,,

' ~13935 Ivy Mount Washington, D.C. 20555..- r. Sugar Land, Texas 77478

~

o. . .. .,.

.e . .. v- -

4 S teve' Soilinki, 'Esq".' .~ Y'- ". Stephen A. Doggett, Esq.

Stiaff 'Cosns'el ' 2--

C'2 P. O. Box 592 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory _Rosenberg,. Texas 77471 Commission - -' '

Washington, D.C. 20555 '

Bryan L. Baker 1923 Hawthorne John F. Doherty

~

Houston, Texas 77098 4327 Alconbury Street Houston, Texas 77021 J. Morgan Bishop

" ~ ~

' Margaret Bishop D. Marrack . ..

11418 Oak Spring 420 Mulberry Lane -

'Hauscon,. Texas 77043 Bellaire, Texas

• 77401 TexPIRG Brenda McCorkle . _ -- . .At tention : Clarence Johnson 6140 Darnell .

' Executive Director Houston, Texas 77074 Box 237 U.C.

. ;=- -- University of Houston'

_' f~T .- ,

Houston, Texas 77004 N JAd

~

. AAAD __. _

CARRO HINDERSTEIN

. . - . . . . . .