ML17331A727: Difference between revisions
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol) |
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol) |
||
| Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
=Text= | =Text= | ||
{{#Wiki_filter: | {{#Wiki_filter:REGULATORY ENFORMATION DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM(RIOS)ACCESSION NBR:8105290360 DOC~DATE:81/05/26NOTARIZED: | ||
INDIANAIltMICHIGANELECTRICCOMPANYP.O.BOX18BOWLINGGREENSTATIONNEWYORK,N.Y.10004May26,1981AEP:NRC: | NODOCKETFACILi50315OonaldCCookNuclearPowerPlant>Unit1iIndianaK~>OA>50316DonaldC~Cookhucl.earPowerPlant>Unit2PIndiana8-500031.AUTH'AMEAUTHORAFFILIATION HUNTERPR~8'ndiana8MichiganElectricCo~RECIP~NAMERECIPIENT AFFILIATION SUBJFCT:Applicdtion for~amendtoOL<changing AppAofTechSpecs~DISTRIBUTION CODE:AOO'ISCOPIESRECEIVED:LTR J.ENCLSSIZE::.5+T'ITLE.:GeneralDistributionforafterIssuanceofOperatingLicenseRECIPIENT IDCODE/NAME'OTES:ICE:3 cooiesallmaterial~Send3copies-'of al1materialtoICE~W/C4ucl-4l~40~RECIPIENTCOPIESIDCODE/NAME LTTRENCLACTION!VARGAE8~0413.13COPTESLTTRENCL0500031505000316INTERNAL: | ||
D/OIRgHUM FACOSIaE..06OELO11RAOASMTBR11221011OIRPDIVOFLICNRCPDR'20A-E4'SR10GFIQ01111101EXTERNAL'CRS NSIC09.05fe1611LPOR0311wlTOTALNUMBER'FCOPIESREQUIREDLTTR''NCL i | |||
INDIANAIltMICHIGANELECTRICCOMPANYP.O.BOX18BOWLINGGREENSTATIONNEWYORK,N.Y.10004May26,1981AEP:NRC:0372 DonaldC.CookNuclearPlantUnitNos.1and2DocketNos.50-315and50-316LicenseNos.DPR-58andDPR-74TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS CHANGEREQUEST~]g/@a.a.l't'ai',pg tg8U~g~'ibMr.HaroldR.Denton,Director'fficeofNuclearReactorRegulation U.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission Washington, D.C.20555 | |||
==DearMr.Denton:== | ==DearMr.Denton:== | ||
Thisletteranditsattachments requestchangesinseveraloftheAppendix'A'echnical Specifications fortheDonaldC.CookNuclearPlantUnitNos.1and2.Attachment 1isthedescription of'hechanges.Attachment 2containstherevisedTechnical Specification pages.Anumberofthesechangesareeditorial. | |||
Mr.HaroldR.DentonAEP:NRC: | Allchangeshavebeenindicated byaverticallineontherighthandsideofthepage.WerequestthattheNRCfileandprocessthisTechnical Specification changepackageasasingleamendment. | ||
TheseproposedTechnical Specifications havebeenreviewedandapprovedbythePlantNuclearSafetyCoraIIittee. | |||
ChaneNo.7Unit1;Page3/41-15;Section3.1.2.7.and4.1.2.7Unit2;Page3/41-15;SectionD.1.2.7and4.1.2. | Theresultofthesereviewsisthattheseproposedrevisions willnotadversely affectthehealthandsafetyofthepublic.ChangeNos.4,5and6'avebeenreviewedbytheAEPSCNuclearSafetyandDesignReviewCommittee (NSDRC).TheNSDRCconcurswiththePlantPNSRCfindings. | ||
Theremaining changeswillbereviewedatthenextmeetingoftheNSDRCscheduled forJune9,1981. | |||
Mr.HaroldR.DentonAEP:NRC:0372 SeVenproposedTechnical Specification revisions arecontained inthissubmittal; foureditorial innature.ChangeNos.4and7areconsidered tobeClassIIamendments | |||
($1,200feeeach)andchangeNo.6isconsidered tobeaClassII'Iamendment'$ | |||
4,000.00fee).ClassIduplicate feesalsoapplyforchangeNos.4,6and7:.Accordingly, attachedisacheckintheamountof$7,600.00forNRCprocessing oftheaforementioned requests. | |||
Verytrulyyours,VicePresident cc:JohnE.Dolan-ColumbusR.C.CallenG.CharnoffR.M.Jurgensen D.V.Shaller-BridgmanRegionIIIResidentInspector 9CookPlant-Bridgman ATTACHMENT 1TOAEP:NRC:0372 Technical Secification Chan'eDescri'tions | |||
~ChN.1(EC(UnitNo.1-Page3/48-8-Section3.8.2.3.Underthedefinitions ofthetwoD.C.bustrains,thesecondoneshouldbechangedfromABtoCD.Cch¹N.E(EC(UnitHo.2-Pages3/48-9and3/48-10;Section4.8.2.3.2d Initem(d),thetablenumberfor-battery emergency. | |||
loadsmustbechangedto4-.8-1A.Thisrevisionisduetothefactthatcurrently therearetwotablesnumbered"Table4.8.1".~ChN.1(EC(Unit1;Page1-7;Table1.2'.Unit2;Page1-8,Table1.2InTable1.2ofbothunits,frequence notations ofthesurveillance scheduling willbespecified asaspecificnumberofdayswheneverthefrequency isgreaterthan24hours.Thewords"6months"and"18months"willberevisedtoread"184days"and"549days"respectively. | |||
Thisterminology conformstoASMEboilerandpressurevesselcode,SectionIII.ChaneHo.4Unit1;page3/42-2;Section3.2.1Unit2;Page3/42-2;Section3.2.1Aspresently written,Specification 3.2.1requiresthataLicenseeEventReport(LER)besubmitted whenevertheAxialFluxDifference (AFD)exceedsthetargetAFDbymorethan+5%regardless ofthecumuiattve penaltydeviation. | |||
InSection3.2.1ofthebasesitisclearlystatedthattheuseofcontrolrodscan'beexpected, inthemajorityofinstances, tocausetheactualAFDtodifferfromthetargetAFDbymorethan+55.~cc'h 1~~~~ | |||
Itisourunderstanding thattheintentofSpecification 3.2.1istore-quireLERsubmittal onlyinthoseinstances whenthecumulative penaltydeviation exceeds,theallowable valuesspecified intheactionstatement ofthespecification. | |||
However,ourpresent.Specification 3.2.1doesnotreflectthisunderstanding. | |||
Inordertoclarifytherequirements ofthespecification andtominimizesubmittal ofunnecessary LERs,wearere-questingthataSection3.2.l.dbeaddedtotheexistingAFDspecification. | |||
The-revisedTechnical Specification pagesreflectthisproposedchange.Unit2;Page3/4l-ll;Section4.1.2.3Thecentrifugal chargingpumps,when=testedonrecirculation flowduringmodes5and6,,mustdevelopadischarge pressure2390psig.The15psipressuredifference betweendischarge pressures ofthepumpduringModes5and6andduringModes1-4-is-due-to a.difference | |||
.in-the'Volume ControlTank(VCT)pressureinthosemodes.Thiswasreflected intheUnit1Technical Specifications. | |||
earlierandisnowbeingrevisedaccordingly, intheUnit2Technical Specification. | |||
ChaneNo.5Unit1;Page3/46-35;Section4.6.5.6Unit2;Page3/46-44;Section4.6.5.6TheintentoftheCeqfanmotorcurrentsurveillance istocheckfordisengaged driveshafts,brokenfanblades,frozenorbadbearings, andothermalfunctions inthefan-motor systemwhichwouldcauseasignificant deviation fromthenormalmotorload.Ourreviewosurveillance testdataindicates thattheaveragecurrentobservedduringtestsislessthan56amperesandtherangeofdeviations undernormalyetvariableoperating conditions | |||
.isslightlygreaterthan10amperes.Mearetherefore requesting achangetoSpecification 4.6.5.6.b toread:"b.Verifying thatwiththereturnairfandampersclosed,thefanmotorcurrentis56+10A'1PSwhenthefanspeedis880+20RPM.Thisenvelopewouldboundallnormaloperating readingsandensurethattheintentoftheSpecification, todetectaninoperable system,ismet." | |||
ChaneNo.7Unit1;Page3/41-15;Section3.1.2.7.and4.1.2.7Unit2;Page3/41-15;SectionD.1.2.7and4.1.2.7TheTechnical Specifications requiretherefueling waterstoragetankboratedwatersolutiontemperature bemaintained at70oForaboveinUnit1and80oForaboveinUnit2,whenitistobeusedasaboratedwatersourceinModes5and6.Thistemperature canbeverydifficult tomaintainwhenaddingcoolwatertotheRWSTbyblendingfollowing drainingofthetankforrefueling purposes. | |||
Sincethepresentsolutiontemperature limitsarederivedfromemergency corecoolingrequirements, thishightemperature limitshouldonlyapplyinModes1,2,3and4whichiscoveredbyTechnical Specifications 3.1.2.8and3.5.5.Itistherefore requested thattheminimumtem-peraturelimitforModes5and6bereturnedtoitsoriginalvalueof35.oF}} | |||
Revision as of 08:21, 29 June 2018
| ML17331A727 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Cook  |
| Issue date: | 05/26/1981 |
| From: | HUNTER R S INDIANA MICHIGAN POWER CO. (FORMERLY INDIANA & MICHIG |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML17331A728 | List: |
| References | |
| AEP:NRC:0372, AEP:NRC:372, NUDOCS 8105290360 | |
| Download: ML17331A727 (8) | |
Text
REGULATORY ENFORMATION DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM(RIOS)ACCESSION NBR:8105290360 DOC~DATE:81/05/26NOTARIZED:
NODOCKETFACILi50315OonaldCCookNuclearPowerPlant>Unit1iIndianaK~>OA>50316DonaldC~Cookhucl.earPowerPlant>Unit2PIndiana8-500031.AUTH'AMEAUTHORAFFILIATION HUNTERPR~8'ndiana8MichiganElectricCo~RECIP~NAMERECIPIENT AFFILIATION SUBJFCT:Applicdtion for~amendtoOL<changing AppAofTechSpecs~DISTRIBUTION CODE:AOO'ISCOPIESRECEIVED:LTR J.ENCLSSIZE::.5+T'ITLE.:GeneralDistributionforafterIssuanceofOperatingLicenseRECIPIENT IDCODE/NAME'OTES:ICE:3 cooiesallmaterial~Send3copies-'of al1materialtoICE~W/C4ucl-4l~40~RECIPIENTCOPIESIDCODE/NAME LTTRENCLACTION!VARGAE8~0413.13COPTESLTTRENCL0500031505000316INTERNAL:
D/OIRgHUM FACOSIaE..06OELO11RAOASMTBR11221011OIRPDIVOFLICNRCPDR'20A-E4'SR10GFIQ01111101EXTERNAL'CRS NSIC09.05fe1611LPOR0311wlTOTALNUMBER'FCOPIESREQUIREDLTTRNCL i
INDIANAIltMICHIGANELECTRICCOMPANYP.O.BOX18BOWLINGGREENSTATIONNEWYORK,N.Y.10004May26,1981AEP:NRC:0372 DonaldC.CookNuclearPlantUnitNos.1and2DocketNos.50-315and50-316LicenseNos.DPR-58andDPR-74TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS CHANGEREQUEST~]g/@a.a.l't'ai',pg tg8U~g~'ibMr.HaroldR.Denton,Director'fficeofNuclearReactorRegulation U.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission Washington, D.C.20555
DearMr.Denton:
Thisletteranditsattachments requestchangesinseveraloftheAppendix'A'echnical Specifications fortheDonaldC.CookNuclearPlantUnitNos.1and2.Attachment 1isthedescription of'hechanges.Attachment 2containstherevisedTechnical Specification pages.Anumberofthesechangesareeditorial.
Allchangeshavebeenindicated byaverticallineontherighthandsideofthepage.WerequestthattheNRCfileandprocessthisTechnical Specification changepackageasasingleamendment.
TheseproposedTechnical Specifications havebeenreviewedandapprovedbythePlantNuclearSafetyCoraIIittee.
Theresultofthesereviewsisthattheseproposedrevisions willnotadversely affectthehealthandsafetyofthepublic.ChangeNos.4,5and6'avebeenreviewedbytheAEPSCNuclearSafetyandDesignReviewCommittee (NSDRC).TheNSDRCconcurswiththePlantPNSRCfindings.
Theremaining changeswillbereviewedatthenextmeetingoftheNSDRCscheduled forJune9,1981.
Mr.HaroldR.DentonAEP:NRC:0372 SeVenproposedTechnical Specification revisions arecontained inthissubmittal; foureditorial innature.ChangeNos.4and7areconsidered tobeClassIIamendments
($1,200feeeach)andchangeNo.6isconsidered tobeaClassII'Iamendment'$
4,000.00fee).ClassIduplicate feesalsoapplyforchangeNos.4,6and7:.Accordingly, attachedisacheckintheamountof$7,600.00forNRCprocessing oftheaforementioned requests.
Verytrulyyours,VicePresident cc:JohnE.Dolan-ColumbusR.C.CallenG.CharnoffR.M.Jurgensen D.V.Shaller-BridgmanRegionIIIResidentInspector 9CookPlant-Bridgman ATTACHMENT 1TOAEP:NRC:0372 Technical Secification Chan'eDescri'tions
~ChN.1(EC(UnitNo.1-Page3/48-8-Section3.8.2.3.Underthedefinitions ofthetwoD.C.bustrains,thesecondoneshouldbechangedfromABtoCD.Cch¹N.E(EC(UnitHo.2-Pages3/48-9and3/48-10;Section4.8.2.3.2d Initem(d),thetablenumberfor-battery emergency.
loadsmustbechangedto4-.8-1A.Thisrevisionisduetothefactthatcurrently therearetwotablesnumbered"Table4.8.1".~ChN.1(EC(Unit1;Page1-7;Table1.2'.Unit2;Page1-8,Table1.2InTable1.2ofbothunits,frequence notations ofthesurveillance scheduling willbespecified asaspecificnumberofdayswheneverthefrequency isgreaterthan24hours.Thewords"6months"and"18months"willberevisedtoread"184days"and"549days"respectively.
Thisterminology conformstoASMEboilerandpressurevesselcode,SectionIII.ChaneHo.4Unit1;page3/42-2;Section3.2.1Unit2;Page3/42-2;Section3.2.1Aspresently written,Specification 3.2.1requiresthataLicenseeEventReport(LER)besubmitted whenevertheAxialFluxDifference (AFD)exceedsthetargetAFDbymorethan+5%regardless ofthecumuiattve penaltydeviation.
InSection3.2.1ofthebasesitisclearlystatedthattheuseofcontrolrodscan'beexpected, inthemajorityofinstances, tocausetheactualAFDtodifferfromthetargetAFDbymorethan+55.~cc'h 1~~~~
Itisourunderstanding thattheintentofSpecification 3.2.1istore-quireLERsubmittal onlyinthoseinstances whenthecumulative penaltydeviation exceeds,theallowable valuesspecified intheactionstatement ofthespecification.
However,ourpresent.Specification 3.2.1doesnotreflectthisunderstanding.
Inordertoclarifytherequirements ofthespecification andtominimizesubmittal ofunnecessary LERs,wearere-questingthataSection3.2.l.dbeaddedtotheexistingAFDspecification.
The-revisedTechnical Specification pagesreflectthisproposedchange.Unit2;Page3/4l-ll;Section4.1.2.3Thecentrifugal chargingpumps,when=testedonrecirculation flowduringmodes5and6,,mustdevelopadischarge pressure2390psig.The15psipressuredifference betweendischarge pressures ofthepumpduringModes5and6andduringModes1-4-is-due-to a.difference
.in-the'Volume ControlTank(VCT)pressureinthosemodes.Thiswasreflected intheUnit1Technical Specifications.
earlierandisnowbeingrevisedaccordingly, intheUnit2Technical Specification.
ChaneNo.5Unit1;Page3/46-35;Section4.6.5.6Unit2;Page3/46-44;Section4.6.5.6TheintentoftheCeqfanmotorcurrentsurveillance istocheckfordisengaged driveshafts,brokenfanblades,frozenorbadbearings, andothermalfunctions inthefan-motor systemwhichwouldcauseasignificant deviation fromthenormalmotorload.Ourreviewosurveillance testdataindicates thattheaveragecurrentobservedduringtestsislessthan56amperesandtherangeofdeviations undernormalyetvariableoperating conditions
.isslightlygreaterthan10amperes.Mearetherefore requesting achangetoSpecification 4.6.5.6.b toread:"b.Verifying thatwiththereturnairfandampersclosed,thefanmotorcurrentis56+10A'1PSwhenthefanspeedis880+20RPM.Thisenvelopewouldboundallnormaloperating readingsandensurethattheintentoftheSpecification, todetectaninoperable system,ismet."
ChaneNo.7Unit1;Page3/41-15;Section3.1.2.7.and4.1.2.7Unit2;Page3/41-15;SectionD.1.2.7and4.1.2.7TheTechnical Specifications requiretherefueling waterstoragetankboratedwatersolutiontemperature bemaintained at70oForaboveinUnit1and80oForaboveinUnit2,whenitistobeusedasaboratedwatersourceinModes5and6.Thistemperature canbeverydifficult tomaintainwhenaddingcoolwatertotheRWSTbyblendingfollowing drainingofthetankforrefueling purposes.
Sincethepresentsolutiontemperature limitsarederivedfromemergency corecoolingrequirements, thishightemperature limitshouldonlyapplyinModes1,2,3and4whichiscoveredbyTechnical Specifications 3.1.2.8and3.5.5.Itistherefore requested thattheminimumtem-peraturelimitforModes5and6bereturnedtoitsoriginalvalueof35.oF